Latest / The MaineHealth Podcast / Public Health Grand Rounds hosted by Dr. Dora Anne Mills with guest Michael Osterholm, PhD, MD
Transcript
- 0:00This is Dr. Dora Ann Mills, Senior Advisor for Public Health at MaineHealth.
- 0:07Welcome to our Public Health Grand Rounds, where about every month we explore a relevant
- 0:12public health topic with national and Maine experts.
- 0:17These Grand Rounds are posted to the MaineHealth podcast channel on Podbean and at MaineHealth.org,
- 0:24where you can hear current and past episodes.
- 0:27Please note that guests' opinions are their own.
- 0:32Welcome everybody.
- 0:33This being the era that we live in, I'm actually in Dallas at a conference.
- 0:39Dr. Osterholm is in Minnesota, but heading out somewhere else.
- 0:45That's why we had to have this Grand Rounds at a different time than usual, in part, I
- 0:49think due to the COVID pandemic, we're now used to zooming in from wherever we are.
- 0:53Welcome everybody.
- 0:55My great pleasure to welcome today's speaker to MaineHealth Public Health Grand Rounds.
- 1:01Dr. Michael Osterholm is one of the most respected epidemiologists in the world.
- 1:07He is a Regents Professor and the McKnight Presidential Endowed Chair in Public Health
- 1:11at the University of Minnesota, and the founding director of the Center for Infectious Disease
- 1:17Research and Policy, known as CIDRAP.
- 1:20He has published more than 300 academic papers and abstracts, and has led outbreak investigations
- 1:26of international importance for decades.
- 1:28He has advised heads of state and has been at the forefront of virtually every major
- 1:33infectious disease crisis of the past several decades.
- 1:37Many of you, including myself, know him though from his podcast, Osterholm Update, which
- 1:42has been downloaded by more than 8 million listeners.
- 1:46He is also a New York Times bestselling author, and that brings us to why he's here today.
- 1:52His newest book, The Big One, How We Must Prepare for Future Deadly Pandemics, co-authored
- 1:57by Mark Olshaker, is a 2025 book list editor's choice and winner of several awards.
- 2:05In it, he and his co-author ask, what would happen if a virus had the capacity to infect
- 2:11like COVID, but the ability to kill like MERS or SARS?
- 2:15And they make clear this is not science fiction.
- 2:18We have actually found viruses with that type of characteristics.
- 2:22COVID-19 was devastating, but Dr. Osterholm's message is that it was not the big one, and
- 2:29that is why we have both the obligation and the tools to prepare.
- 2:35But I also just want to, besides welcoming Dr. Michael Osterholm, I also just want to
- 2:41thank him with my deepest gratitude for his now biweekly podcast.
- 2:46But when it was weekly and now even biweekly, it has gotten me through many walks around
- 2:52Back Cove and a lot of settling and calming of whatever nerves might have been happening.
- 2:59So I really appreciate everything you've done the last six some odd years.
- 3:04So thank you very much.
- 3:05I'm going to pass the baton over to you, Dr. Osterholm.
- 3:08Thank you for a great honor to have you join us today.
- 3:11Yeah.
- 3:12Well, thank you very much.
- 3:13It's a real honor to be here with you today, and I'm looking forward to this fireside chat
- 3:17in terms of discussing what the issues are of the day with regard to, I'm sure hantavirus
- 3:23will come up, I suspect.
- 3:25And in addition, of course, just how prepared are we for the future?
- 3:28The other thing that Dory didn't mention, but I just want to emphasize because it's
- 3:32such an important piece, is also our center initiated the Vaccine Integrity Project a
- 3:37year ago, more than a year ago now, because we saw what was going to happen with the vaccine
- 3:42world.
- 3:43And if you want to look any further, look at today's New York Times with a major story
- 3:46from regarding Secretary Kennedy, still very aggressive, but secret moves to basically
- 3:52do in the vaccine world.
- 3:55And so we in the Vaccine Integrity Project are now doing much of the work that the ACIP,
- 4:01the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, used to do.
- 4:04And we're now doing the evidence-based work.
- 4:06We're working with the medical societies, the AMA, any number of public health groups,
- 4:13government groups as such, such as state and local health departments, et cetera, to do
- 4:16whatever we can to not only get the right information out about vaccines, but to make
- 4:22sure that information can result in recommendations from the various medical societies that will
- 4:28be sustainable for the payers.
- 4:30And this is an issue that people often forget, is vaccines can basically not make it into
- 4:35their final destination for a variety of different reasons.
- 4:38And one of them is if nobody will pay for them.
- 4:40And so we're very closely monitoring that issue and working closely with the payers.
- 4:46So with that, I'm wide open here, as we said, this is a fireside chat for you to ask questions,
- 4:53to take it from there, and I'm happy to expound in any and all aspects of that.
- 4:57Thank you.
- 4:58So first, can you first give us an overview of your book and to get into the Vaccine Integrity
- 5:04Project as well?
- 5:05But if you can give us a bit of an overview, and 25, we have bought 25 copies.
- 5:10And so those who are MaineHealth employees who are attending live are going to get randomly
- 5:14chosen to get copies of it.
- 5:16So we're very excited about that.
- 5:18But if you can give us a little, some teasers about your book.
- 5:21Well, thank you, Dora.
- 5:22I'm happy to.
- 5:23Yeah.
- 5:24First of all, let me just say, this is actually my third book.
- 5:27My first one, which was published on 9-11 of 2000, one year to the day exactly before
- 5:319-11, was called Living Cares, What Our Country Needs to Know to Survive the Coming Bioterrorist
- 5:36Catastrophe.
- 5:37And it was all about bioterrorism and the issue of weapons that biologic agents might
- 5:43end up becoming.
- 5:45And I think in the year between 9-11-2000 and 9-11-2001, I bought 18 of the 19 copies
- 5:51that were sold.
- 5:53So it wasn't on anybody's read list, okay?
- 5:57And then, of course, after 9-11, because of anthrax and so forth, it became a New York
- 6:00Times bestseller.
- 6:02I had a somewhat similar situation in 2017.
- 6:07Mark Olshaker and I published a book, Deadliest Enemies, Our War Against Killer Germs.
- 6:11And I tried to lay out, wake up world, we have some huge challenges coming down the
- 6:15pike, none the least of which, of course, would be the pandemic potential agents, those
- 6:19that actually could cause a global pandemic.
- 6:22And we actually had three chapters that were a scenario, in a sense, of what an influenza
- 6:28pandemic would look like.
- 6:29But it played out almost identical to what ended up happening with COVID.
- 6:34In addition to that, we actually had one whole chapter.
- 6:37The title of it was SARS, MERS, the harbinger of things to come, in which we said, you need
- 6:42to be mindful of the coronaviruses too, okay?
- 6:45And at the time, again, this book sold a few more copies than the first one did, but still
- 6:50not a lot.
- 6:51And then, of course, 9-11, or then we saw the pandemic happen, it became a year-time
- 6:56bestseller.
- 6:57So my goal is to do whatever the hell I can to make sure this book does not, the new one,
- 7:00become a bestseller, okay?
- 7:02Because if it does, that probably signals not a real good situation.
- 7:06But in this book, what I tried to do is, because I really was on the front lines of a lot of
- 7:11the issues around the pandemic, our group at CIDRAP, I think, was the very first group
- 7:16in the world to say, it's going to be a pandemic.
- 7:19We did that in early January of 2020.
- 7:24At that point, we based it on our extensive network of contacts around the world, and
- 7:27we could see how rapidly this virus was transmitting.
- 7:31Initially, when I realized it was a coronavirus in that first week, I actually breathed a
- 7:36little bit easier, because we had worked with previous coronaviruses, SARS and MERS, which
- 7:42were surely dangerous, but did not have sustainability to become pandemic agents.
- 7:46They just did not have enough people who were shedding the virus at levels that would
- 7:51spread it quickly around the world.
- 7:53And so my first thought was, well, we hopefully can control this one like we did SARS or MERS.
- 7:58Well, within days, we realized, no, this was acting much more like a flu virus, and it
- 8:02had all the makings of being a pandemic virus.
- 8:05And so on January 20th, we actually put out a statement from our center saying, this is
- 8:11the next pandemic, get on with it.
- 8:13And it still took two more months for the world to really understand what was happening.
- 8:18Also at that time, you know, we began to put out other messages that I felt like we were
- 8:23kind of running willy-nilly.
- 8:25We didn't really have a plan.
- 8:26We didn't really understand what we were talking about.
- 8:28We had such conflicting information out there.
- 8:31And I wrote an op-ed piece in the Washington Post in that time period and said, whatever
- 8:38you do, don't do lockdowns.
- 8:39They're not going to work.
- 8:41And at that point, people, wait, aren't you a public health guy?
- 8:44Well, the problem was is that we recognized early on that this was going to last for years
- 8:50and years.
- 8:51In fact, I was on Joe Rogan's podcast on March 10th, and I said, I thought that there could
- 8:56be 800,000 deaths in the next 18 months, not just the next couple of weeks or few months,
- 9:01but 18 months.
- 9:02And actually, 18 months later, we were 790,000 deaths.
- 9:07So, you know, and the reason that was important is because if you respond to something like
- 9:11a hurricane, it's really, really bad, but you go into recovery quite quickly, okay?
- 9:17And so at that point, you can move on.
- 9:19I saw with this pandemic that that was never going to happen.
- 9:22This was going to last quite a while.
- 9:25And therefore, a lockdown would only work if you could sustain it over time.
- 9:29And let me give you an example of how it didn't work in China.
- 9:33There they actually had areas of the country where they literally were really locked down
- 9:36for more than 18 months, meaning you couldn't leave your house, food was delivered to you,
- 9:40drugs were delivered to you, et cetera.
- 9:42I mean, it was locked up.
- 9:43But guess what?
- 9:44Under the social and cultural pressures, they went ahead and released those people from
- 9:49these lockdowns, but they never vaccinated them.
- 9:53And then the next months after that happened, millions of Chinese died.
- 9:57So, you know, whether you die in the first six months or the second six months or the
- 10:01third six months or the fourth six months, you're still pretty dead at the end.
- 10:05And so what we needed to do is how could we sustain ourselves long term?
- 10:09And so what we proposed, and this is discussed in the book, and this kind of sets the framework
- 10:14for the rest of what we'll talk about, is what we needed to do is think about it very
- 10:18differently.
- 10:19We need to think about it like snow days.
- 10:20Now you're from Maine.
- 10:21You understand snow days.
- 10:22We understand snow days here in Minnesota, OK?
- 10:25What was the one thing we had early in the pandemic that could help us like nothing else?
- 10:31It wasn't vaccine.
- 10:33It wasn't drugs.
- 10:34It was, in fact, good medical care.
- 10:37And if your hospital is running at 140% capacity with beds in the hallways and the parking
- 10:42garage stalls and the garage, et cetera, you are not getting good medical care.
- 10:47So we had proposed what we should do is actually put out every day the census level in your
- 10:52hospital for the whole, all the world to see.
- 10:56And everybody would know, oh my God, they're at 140, 150% capacity.
- 11:00This is not a time I want to get COVID.
- 11:03And if that had happened, people could have made their own decisions about what to do
- 11:06or not to do.
- 11:07But they now would have been informed.
- 11:08You know, do I want to go out and drive on a highway tonight where nine out of 10 people
- 11:13on the highway are drunk?
- 11:14I probably would decide not to, OK?
- 11:17Well, if I knew that I also didn't want to go to a hospital where I wasn't going to get
- 11:21good care, would I reconsider some of the things I was doing?
- 11:24On top of that, of the states in the United States that enacted some kind of lockdowns,
- 11:30which initially there were 47 of them that did, they really didn't mean much.
- 11:35Why?
- 11:36Because they were like state of Minnesota, where in fact, we had a lockdown here, but
- 11:40only for non-essential personnel.
- 11:43And guess what?
- 11:4482% of our workforce was considered essential.
- 11:47Now come on, is that a lockdown?
- 11:49And so we led people to believe we did a lot more with these lockdowns.
- 11:52And people who criticize the economic impact of the lockdowns are just dead wrong, because
- 11:57we didn't really have lockdowns.
- 11:59What happened was the economy went to hell, because people were frightened.
- 12:03People were scared.
- 12:05People didn't go and buy things.
- 12:06People stayed home.
- 12:08And what we didn't do is give a long-term view.
- 12:10How are we going to get through this for 18 or 36 months?
- 12:13What are we going to do?
- 12:14What does this mean?
- 12:16And so what this book is really all about, and I don't give anybody a free pass, including
- 12:23public health, OK?
- 12:24Because there are a lot of things we could have done differently.
- 12:27I look at the issues around communications.
- 12:30We had so many self-described experts on COVID who were on TV every night talking, and I'll
- 12:35put myself in that category, that basically, though, much of what they had to say was wrong.
- 12:42And so the public was getting whiplashed and confused.
- 12:44And I actually cite examples of that in the book and say, what can we do?
- 12:49What must we do in the future to have a more clear message?
- 12:51Well, it's deja vu all over again right now with coronavirus.
- 12:55We got all the same problems again.
- 12:56We got all these experts out there talking, and I don't think many of them are qualified
- 13:02to do so.
- 13:03But that's what the media is appointing or anointing as the people that you should be
- 13:07listening to us.
- 13:08Why?
- 13:09Because they're on our station or whatever.
- 13:10And in fact, last week, I come from a small Iowa farm town boy, OK?
- 13:17So to me, I don't get too riled about too many things.
- 13:21But when I saw one of the major networks last week commenting about how the virus had now
- 13:27spread to three additional countries, when, in fact, all it was was people were air-vacced
- 13:31from the ship to three different countries for hospitalization, there was no transmission
- 13:35there at all.
- 13:36But if I was in the public and I heard that, I would go, wow, that's really bad.
- 13:41This thing's spreading.
- 13:43So this book gets into that.
- 13:44We also talk about the issue of respiratory protection.
- 13:48We blew the respiratory protection issue over and over again.
- 13:51All the plexiglass, all the six-foot things meant nothing, absolutely nothing.
- 13:56This was an aerosol.
- 13:57Do you want to know what an aerosol is like?
- 13:59Imagine you're walking down the street today and all of a sudden you smell cigarette smoke
- 14:02and you look upwind 35 feet and there's somebody smoking.
- 14:06That's an aerosol.
- 14:07Let me give you an idea of just how airborne transmission can occur.
- 14:12One of the outbreaks that I worked up in my days at the state health department was a
- 14:15measles outbreak that occurred in Minnesota associated with the Special Olympics that
- 14:20year.
- 14:21The World Special Olympics were held in Minneapolis.
- 14:23And in the opening night ceremony in what was then the Hubert Humphrey Metrodome, there
- 14:28were 67,000 fans in the stands.
- 14:31Most of them were local people who had come to see the opening night ceremony, but had
- 14:34no real contact with the games.
- 14:36The players, the coaches, the support staff all walked in from a right field, big large
- 14:42door, and marched in towards the infield and then up third base out to left field.
- 14:47And eventually they all cycled and they filled the entire ground level of the stadium.
- 14:53All the infield, outfield, et cetera, okay?
- 14:56There was by chance a young boy from Argentina who was just breaking with measles.
- 15:02And we had not had indigenous measles in Minnesota in the previous five years.
- 15:06He sat on home plate that night, literally.
- 15:08It was right where he, the A's team stood, Argentina.
- 15:12And it turned out that the air system for that large dome, the air came out from behind
- 15:17home plate, pushed out.
- 15:19And then actually, no one really knew this, by the time it hit home plate, it bounced.
- 15:26And the exit for the air, the outtake, was actually at 420 feet up in the upper right
- 15:35field bleacher area, where at the time Mark McGuire couldn't hit a home run on steroids.
- 15:42And it turned out there was cases that occurred only in that opening night session.
- 15:46And none of them knew each other.
- 15:48But guess what?
- 15:49They all sat in that same section right underneath the outtake van.
- 15:52And everyone who had not previously had measles or who had previously not been vaccinated
- 15:58got infected.
- 15:59Now, look at, that's an airborne transmission.
- 16:02So one of the things we hit heavy on was the importance of understanding airborne, why
- 16:08N95 respirators were important.
- 16:11Some of the most challenging moments I had during the pandemic was when I would visit
- 16:15a hospital for work.
- 16:17And I'd walk in the front door, and they would see me in my N95 face-fitted respirator.
- 16:22And they'd say, I'm sorry, you need to take that off and put on a surgical mask.
- 16:25That's what we do here at this hospital.
- 16:27Oh my God!
- 16:28You know?
- 16:29I mean, it was frustrating.
- 16:32And so that's another example of where we had very poor communication.
- 16:36We had the data to show how important N95 respirators were and what they could do to
- 16:40reduce transmission.
- 16:42I could go down the list.
- 16:43Let me just give you one last one on communication.
- 16:47I was actually on the Biden-Harris transition team on COVID and continued to advise the
- 16:51administration substantially during the course of the pandemic.
- 16:54I'm not sure my advice was helpful.
- 16:57But when the vaccine data first came out in the end of 2020, it was really remarkable
- 17:05that we were able to bring forward two vaccines, both using mRNA technology, that had 95 to
- 17:1297 percent protection.
- 17:14And everybody was shouting from the rooftops, here it is, here it is, here it is, get the vaccine.
- 17:18Well, I had worked on both SARS and MERS in my previous life and recognized right up front
- 17:26that one of the challenges we have with coronavirus is waning immunity.
- 17:30And that's been true whether it's the cold-like coronaviruses or whether, in fact, it's SARS
- 17:38or MERS.
- 17:39And so I had suggested at the time that rather than just put out 95, 97 percent protection,
- 17:45let's keep these cohorts that were enrolled to give us the data that we had and now realize
- 17:51we had to vaccinate the placebos, okay?
- 17:53So they, in fact, we didn't want to leave them unprotected.
- 17:56But let's follow each month out after vaccination and give the rate of protection.
- 18:01So 95, 97 percent, day zero.
- 18:05Day 60, 88 percent, 86 percent.
- 18:10And if we had done that and said to the public, we don't know if we're going to need a booster
- 18:14or not.
- 18:15We know with coronaviruses, there is waning immunity.
- 18:18We'll keep you posted.
- 18:19Every month, we'll post for you what the results are of that cohort we're following to see
- 18:24how, what protection.
- 18:25So rather than waiting until Barnstable on the Cape in the summer of 2021, when so many
- 18:33people all got infected in the Fourth of July party, when, in fact, they had been vaccinated
- 18:38six months before, it left people irate.
- 18:41You lied to us.
- 18:42You told us this is going to protect us, 95, 97 percent.
- 18:46And nobody lied.
- 18:48Nobody did.
- 18:49We just hadn't thought through enough to understand what could this mean for a public message.
- 18:53What are the things we should be thinking about in terms of just how well these vaccines
- 18:58protect over time and giving the public the information so they could know?
- 19:03And we could say, if we get down to 50 or 60 percent, we're probably going to recommend
- 19:06a booster and let the public know that.
- 19:09Think how different the response would have been to vaccines and how well they work.
- 19:14So that's more of all the kinds of things I tried to cover in the book.
- 19:17And the thing I would just leave you with is that I was part of a group that tried very,
- 19:22very hard to get the federal government to do a hot wash, a real review of what happened
- 19:28with COVID, not to blame.
- 19:30You know, right after 9-11, Secretary Tommy Thompson, HHS, asked me to come and help out
- 19:35with the terrorism on the bio issues with anthrax.
- 19:39And so for three years from 9-11, for three years, I was at HHS halftime and at Minnesota
- 19:44halftime.
- 19:46And I was there for the early days of the 9-11 commission, led by a prominent Democrat
- 19:52and Republican.
- 19:53It was the most nonpartisan, absolutely to-the-point review I've ever seen.
- 19:58It was outstanding.
- 20:00And the recommendations they made, the conclusions they arrived at were all just really remarkable.
- 20:06And we were so hoping we could have a 9-11-like commission for COVID, where, you know, no
- 20:11finger pointing, no more of this, where did the virus come from?
- 20:14We're never going to know where the hell the virus came from.
- 20:17It could have been a lab leak.
- 20:18It could have been, in fact, a spillover.
- 20:20I tend to favor spillover, but I'm first to acknowledge it could be a lab leak.
- 20:26And in that sense, basically, we need to move on.
- 20:30We're just stuck on that.
- 20:32We're not having any productive discussions about what we really need to do to prepare
- 20:35our vaccines, our drugs, our stockpiles, messaging.
- 20:38I mean, the messaging is an example right now.
- 20:41It's a mess with the whole issue with the coronavirus.
- 20:45So I hope that sort of gives you a little bit of an overview of what the book's about.
- 20:50You know, I don't, you know, I don't hold back on anyone, and I surely give a lot of
- 20:55credit, too, to a lot that did so much.
- 20:57So with that, I'm happy to take any other questions or comments, too.
- 21:01Or, Dora, if you have anything, feel free.
- 21:03Sure.
- 21:04Thank you so much, Dr. Osterholm.
- 21:06Yes, I do remember those early days, particularly where, when we did not have testing, did not
- 21:12have adequate PPE, even in our hospitals.
- 21:15And so even in Maine, we had, you know, some slowing down of things.
- 21:18We had like snow days, as you mentioned, for a while.
- 21:21But I want, there are a lot of people on this call who actually worked very hard to open
- 21:26Maine up sooner than later, including Laura Blaisdell, whom I think, Dr. Laura Blaisdell, whom I
- 21:32think you know.
- 21:33Laura's one of my former students and one of the people I'm most proud to have ever
- 21:36been associated with.
- 21:37Yes, and she actually was instrumental in making sure that our youth camps, our overnight
- 21:43youth camps, which are a big economic driver in Maine in the summertime.
- 21:49We have students, kids who come from all over the world, usually, back then it was around
- 21:52the country, to spend their summers in Maine.
- 21:56And she and others worked very hard to make sure that that still could happen that summer
- 22:00of 2020, as an example.
- 22:03And our schools opened up fully and, you know, starting in August and the like.
- 22:07But anyway, I think Emer, Emer Smith, I saw your hand raised a minute ago.
- 22:13Emer, are you there?
- 22:15Can you unmute?
- 22:16I see her.
- 22:17I am.
- 22:18Yes.
- 22:19Yeah, it's Emer.
- 22:20You got it right.
- 22:21Thank you, Emer.
- 22:22And I know Emer, she works at Maine CDC, I think still, and our state public health
- 22:24agency.
- 22:25So thank you for your work.
- 22:27Hi there.
- 22:28Hi.
- 22:29I'm a infectious disease field epidemiologist, one of seven in the state that investigate
- 22:34a lot of different things at a lot of different times.
- 22:37And I was involved in the COVID response when it started happening and continues to happen.
- 22:42So I guess my question is really about communication, because I feel like a lot of people either
- 22:48wildly overestimate their risk for infection, or wildly underestimate their risk for infection.
- 22:54And they feel like, you know, they are very confident that they're invincible, I guess.
- 22:59I mean, how do we thread that line between people who are worried well, versus people
- 23:04who think that they're not going to die ever.
- 23:07And like, you know, being respectful of everybody while trying to get them to focus on the shared
- 23:13point and goal?
- 23:14Well, first of all, let me say thank you to you for the work you do having been the epidemiologist
- 23:20and overseeing infectious disease at Minnesota for 25 years, besides my time at the university.
- 23:25I have a very warm soft spot for public health field investigators such as yourself, okay?
- 23:31That's where the rubber really hits the road.
- 23:35What you've hit upon is the conundrum we're all having right now, how to communicate.
- 23:40And the fact of the matter is, there's not one way in that there's not one issue of why
- 23:45people do or don't believe what you're saying or how you're saying it.
- 23:51And we're actually quite involved right now on a major research effort on social media
- 23:55to understand the influence that it has.
- 23:57And how does that convince people to go yes, no, whatever.
- 24:02And that's a huge challenge.
- 24:04So I think one of the areas we have to acknowledge is we weren't good at communication.
- 24:08And I'm not sure that it's going to be an easy thing to solve ever when you have so
- 24:13many different voices and people have the freedom to have it.
- 24:16And today with the electronic world that we live in, anybody can become a voice.
- 24:23Dora has commented about my podcast.
- 24:24What the hell gives me a right to have a podcast and have all these people come and listen?
- 24:29I may be providing them junk, others do.
- 24:34And so I think that one of the challenges we have also is how do we come upon that issue?
- 24:40Now let me just say, we're trying to address that in one way with the VIP program, the
- 24:45Human Integrity Project.
- 24:47Not only are we doing the evidence-based review, and let me just give you an example.
- 24:50We just published last week an update dated piece on HPV.
- 24:57And HPV had been covered by the ACIP some 18 months before when it was still the old
- 25:02ACIP.
- 25:04And so our update was from that point 18 months ago until now.
- 25:08We had to review 7,800 papers that had been published in that time period on HPV.
- 25:14So imagine if you're talking about updating a vaccine for five years or seven years.
- 25:19And so that really raises a lot of questions about what do we know or not know.
- 25:24But what we're doing at VIP is we have a major communication arm with the science.
- 25:28So we're providing the evidence to the medical societies for them to make recommendations.
- 25:33We're not making recommendations.
- 25:35These used to be done by ACIP, but now the medical societies really are taking responsibility.
- 25:39So for example, AAP, all these other groups are involved.
- 25:45And what's important about that is it's not just getting the information to them, but
- 25:49to the public.
- 25:50And so we have a major initiative with the NBioScience folks and the collective EPI folks
- 25:56right now to basically enhance whenever we put things out, what can we do?
- 26:02And a good example is all of the information systems that we're putting out right now around
- 26:08these vaccines, we actually have a tool with each one that you can go in and have access
- 26:14to all the information we did.
- 26:17All the papers, everything are there.
- 26:19So anybody can go and do it and look at it, and it's not some black box that somebody
- 26:24told you this is what the results are.
- 26:26You can go do it yourself.
- 26:28So that kind of transparency is important.
- 26:30But we're also working right now with the clinical and public health communities to
- 26:34figure out what kind of materials can we provide?
- 26:36What are the things we can help the practicing epidemiologist or clinician deal with in
- 26:42terms of information for the clients?
- 26:46And I might add that one of the things that gives you a sense of just where we're at,
- 26:51we're seeing a major spike right now in the reluctance, if not the outright refusal, for
- 26:57many owners of dogs and cats to no longer vaccinate their pets for rabies.
- 27:03They want to decide.
- 27:04So it's not even just about human medicine.
- 27:06I mean, it's this kind of anti-don't tell me what to do kind of stuff, when in fact
- 27:11all we're trying to do is relay this is what we know.
- 27:15We don't need a lot more science to understand, you know, if you don't put a stop sign in
- 27:20a crossing on a freeway, you're going to probably have some accidents, okay?
- 27:24We don't need more data on that.
- 27:25That probably is what's going to happen.
- 27:26And somehow we've got to be able to understand how to communicate why those stop signs are
- 27:31really important or the green lights are important, and we haven't.
- 27:34So I wish I had better information for you, and to say that your point's really well taken,
- 27:40and we clearly, clearly know that that's a huge issue.
- 27:44And today in the, I would just also say, in this world of healthcare cost containment,
- 27:50clinicians don't get paid to have an hour-long conversation with the mom coming in or the
- 27:54dad coming in with the newborn child.
- 27:57And so from that standpoint also, it makes it much harder to be a clinician today, a
- 28:02public health worker, a vaccinator, because, in fact, you could spend all day talking to
- 28:09just several clients, and that's it.
- 28:12I welcome your feedback on that.
- 28:14Yeah, no, I was thinking to myself, I'm like, who, we always kind of fall back on, like,
- 28:20trusted gatekeepers, but, like, trying to identify who those gatekeepers are may be
- 28:24a little bit easier in a state that's as small as Maine, and yet, like, you know, the information
- 28:29overload that just comes from, you know, all the available resources that are out there.
- 28:34I mean, we appeal to, like, you know, authority from based on, like, oh, we've done the research,
- 28:39but we also have to deal with people who feel that their research is better or more accurate
- 28:44or more reliable or...
- 28:46Yeah, yeah.
- 28:47Yeah.
- 28:48You know, I think the other thing that's a challenge right now, you know, I have served
- 28:54every presidential administration from Ronald Reagan up and through Biden.
- 28:57Even during Trump one, I was a science envoy for the State Department helping the world
- 29:01get better for a pandemic in 2016-17, and, you know, I...
- 29:08No one could tell you my partisan politics.
- 29:10I'm here just to call balls and strikes.
- 29:12That's my job.
- 29:13You know, when I was at the State Health Department, I served two Republican governors, two Democratic
- 29:17governors, and we affectionately say, with Jesse Ventura, one independent rassler, and
- 29:21for those that don't know that, and so, in effect, the same thing there, you know.
- 29:26Everything's partisan.
- 29:27It's just called balls and strikes, but today, you can't help.
- 29:31You can say yes or no.
- 29:33You can say up or down.
- 29:34You can say yes, maybe, may, no, maybe, and you get in trouble, because somebody will
- 29:39take that as a point of political disagreement, and, I mean, look at your own state of Maine
- 29:45right now and the politics that are happening there.
- 29:48You know, it's a challenge, and so, I think one of the other things we have to understand
- 29:52is, in public health, we can't divorce ourselves from the reality of what's happening in our
- 29:57world, but, at the same time, we've got to live in that world, and we've got to fight
- 30:00those bugs, and those germs don't give a damn what's going on among a bunch of humans, and
- 30:04so, I think that's what's really, really important, also, is we've got to keep doing our job,
- 30:09you know, when, in fact, it's not necessarily easy to do, so thank you again.
- 30:14Thank you.
- 30:15And thank you.
- 30:16We've got a couple of questions in the chat, and also, Sharon McHale's got her hand raised,
- 30:21but on the chat, there are two kind of questions that are related, I believe.
- 30:25One of them from Mark Agger says, you know, comparison to lockdowns, was there an overall
- 30:30value in social isolation for the general public?
- 30:33Did we get this right?
- 30:34And then, kind of a corollary to that, Michelle Melio says she's in a senior center at the
- 30:43time of COVID, so she's working in a rural area, and they shut down, you know, for basically
- 30:48a year, and she saw a lot of seniors who died, who were in the senior center, who died
- 30:57of COVID.
- 30:58She also saw a lot of them die of lack of care, because they were too afraid to go out
- 31:02and go to the hospital, or go to the provider's office to get care, and I also would just
- 31:09balance that with the fact that we also saw early on, several nursing homes get literally
- 31:14almost just wiped out with massive COVID deaths that just ran through horribly, tragically.
- 31:21So, what would, you know, let me take a stab at that, and I would also add that, unfortunately,
- 31:28I think it's hard to define this, but I think a lot of people in long-term care died of
- 31:34a broken heart and loneliness, and that was hard.
- 31:37That was very hard for that long a time, to only be at the window and touching someone
- 31:42through the glass kind of thing, but, you know, what were the options?
- 31:46You know, one of the challenges we had was, again, putting the kind of information that
- 31:52we had access to into public policy.
- 31:55Let me give you an example, and I was an outlier on this one, for sure.
- 32:00Early on, the conclusion was that this virus was not hard on kids.
- 32:05You know, there was 199 deaths in the first year, but if you did an actual age-specific
- 32:10attack rate, a death rate, it was much lower than everybody else.
- 32:14Well, that's when we had the ancestral and alpha strains present, but when Delta came
- 32:19along and then Omicron, that changed completely.
- 32:23We had 199 deaths in this country in kids in the first year.
- 32:27The second two years, we had over 1,500 deaths in kids, 88 to 89% of the deaths to COVID
- 32:35in the first three years occurred in year two and three, and we didn't adjust to that.
- 32:39We kept living our life like we were in the first year, and, you know, there was surely
- 32:45a situation in the first year we might have argued it wasn't as important in prevention
- 32:51to actually close schools, but when we got into year two and three, in some cases, when
- 32:55people were saying, oh, don't worry, it's not a problem, we had a lot of kids dying,
- 33:00and so I think that one of the challenges we had was just interpreting the science into
- 33:05public policy and preparing to have the public understand what's different.
- 33:10You know, I wrote an op-ed piece in the New York Times when we saw Omicron emerge in New
- 33:16York and the mayor kept saying, oh, it's perfectly safe, send them to school, but we actually
- 33:20surveyed schools for which they had no teachers.
- 33:23They had a janitor in a study hall taking care of the kids because there was nobody
- 33:27else there.
- 33:28That's not kind of school conducive learning, okay, on top of transmission.
- 33:33The next thing was we do not have good respiratory protection for kids.
- 33:38There is no N95s for kids.
- 33:41One of the things that we would have wanted to come out of this commission if we'd had
- 33:45one is we need to accelerate a program for much better respiratory protection for kids.
- 33:50So you know, my grandkids all eventually all caught COVID, and they would go to school
- 33:55with their basically surgical mask on, which provided very little protection at all.
- 34:00They go to lunch, and for 45 minutes a day, they had permission to take their mask off
- 34:05in this large room with everybody else, which is like the virus is going to wait until you
- 34:09come back to your classroom before it's going to hit you.
- 34:11I mean, we were illogical in a lot of things like that.
- 34:14So I think the challenge we have is how do we come up with rational policies that aren't
- 34:20perfect, that are not going to solve all the problems, and how do you avoid getting hit
- 34:26for three to four years?
- 34:28You know, all I can say is the further we got into the pandemic, the more tools we had,
- 34:33the more drugs we had.
- 34:35You know, if you've been following the Pax Lovid story, I think it's fascinating.
- 34:39You know, in the early days of Pax Lovid, there was really good level of protection
- 34:44against serious illness, hospitalizations, and deaths, particularly in older people and
- 34:48in undercompromised people.
- 34:50In a recent study, showed no benefit at all from Pax Lovid.
- 34:54And people say, what?
- 34:55It doesn't work.
- 34:56You know, what happened is severe illnesses have been disappearing on their own because
- 35:01of the population-based immunity.
- 35:04And it wasn't the Pax Lovid that didn't work, it's just that in the placebo group, basically,
- 35:09there was no severe COVID, period.
- 35:12You know, we're right now at the lowest level of COVID circulation in our community since
- 35:162020, which, by the way, I'll give you good news also, it's the lowest level we've seen
- 35:22for RSV and flu in a very similar way.
- 35:25This is by far the lowest respiratory virus level of circulation we've seen, literally
- 35:29dating back to 2018.
- 35:31So just for all of you, that's good news.
- 35:34So I think the challenge we have is, and this is a great question for that, is how do we
- 35:40also communicate changing policies based on new updated information?
- 35:46And if you don't remember anything else I say in this entire session today, you just
- 35:50can skip everything else out.
- 35:52Just remember, science is not truth.
- 35:54It is not truth.
- 35:56Science is the pursuit of truth.
- 35:58And I can't tell you how many days I wake up in the morning, sit on the bed for a second
- 36:03and say to myself, boy, I wish I could know today what I'm going to know six months from
- 36:06now.
- 36:07Wouldn't that be something?
- 36:09And I think we have to help the public understand that point of view, that, you know, we are
- 36:13going to be learning.
- 36:14That's not a fault.
- 36:16That's not something's wrong.
- 36:17But if we end up updating our information, it's what you want.
- 36:21You know, it's like, I mean, what would you do if you didn't update your computer with
- 36:26new additional software when, you know, they have security glitches and so forth?
- 36:31You want that.
- 36:32Okay.
- 36:33It didn't mean that the computer you had six months ago is wrong or that, you know, it
- 36:37cheated you or didn't tell you the truth.
- 36:39It's just we now have updated information that that computer now has to have.
- 36:43So I think that at this point, I would just say that we need to do a much better job and
- 36:50this is where we need to have public health have this kind of discussion.
- 36:53So the fact, mere fact, you're having me here today, you know, as crazy as I am, you know,
- 36:58thank you.
- 36:59You know, you're giving the opportunity for at least another point of view to come forward.
- 37:05We appreciate it a lot.
- 37:06I want to go to a couple of great questions in the chat, but I first want to go to Sharon
- 37:10McDonnell, Dr. Sharon McDonnell, who's a physician and a nurse and a public health
- 37:15epidemiologist.
- 37:16Used to work at CDC, but we're grateful, and Vermont, we're grateful to have her in Maine
- 37:21now.
- 37:22So, Sharon?
- 37:23Yeah.
- 37:24Hi.
- 37:25Hi.
- 37:26I have Gib Parrish with me as well.
- 37:27We're calling from Quebec, Canada for a vacation.
- 37:31I guess two things.
- 37:32One is the input channels for communication from communities.
- 37:37I spent two years in Liberia with Ebola, and they had much better pillars of communication
- 37:45and social marketing.
- 37:47And I felt like this was really a problem for, you know, how is the community getting
- 37:51information, using community health workers to get it back out.
- 37:55And this, the COVID pandemic in the U.S. and even in Maine, we didn't have enough input
- 38:03coming from communities to turn it back around into messaging.
- 38:08So that is something that I felt is really important going forward, to get an active
- 38:13two-way channel.
- 38:14The other, we've got community-based wastewater surveillance in our small town in Maine.
- 38:20And it's, you know, the labs change, and it's hard to compare over time, but I feel like
- 38:25that is one way that we engage our community in what's happening.
- 38:30It's not perfect, but I would love your comments on wastewater surveillance.
- 38:34Yeah.
- 38:35Well, first of all, thank you for what you've done, and your point is spot on.
- 38:40We do need much better ways of moving information up and down the communication chain.
- 38:45The problem we have with that is there's a lot of huge speed bumps, in some cases just
- 38:49huge holes in the road, because, for example, with a private media source that can provide
- 38:55whatever they want, whenever they want, whatever point of view they have, you know, Fox News
- 38:59versus MSNOW versus, you know, CNN, really, that's a challenge.
- 39:05I mean, when you think about it, if you add up the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times,
- 39:09the Washington Post, CNN, and MSNOW, they have a combined number of readers or watchers
- 39:18at about 14 million.
- 39:21Fox News itself is about 10 million, okay?
- 39:24Which you say to yourself, now, wait, that's only 25 million.
- 39:27We have 350 million people in this country.
- 39:29How the hell do the rest of the people get in their news?
- 39:31What do they get in it?
- 39:32Where from?
- 39:33It's social media.
- 39:35Well, we don't really understand social media very well at all.
- 39:39And so your point's really well taken, and I think what you emphasized isn't nearly emphasized
- 39:44enough that it's information going up the chain and down the chain.
- 39:48It's got to be simultaneous.
- 39:50It can't be all one way, and then, oh, by the way, occasionally we'll do the download,
- 39:54okay?
- 39:55So you're right about that, and I hope you keep pushing that, okay?
- 39:59Because it's a very important message, and that's one of the things we're looking at
- 40:02carefully right now with our social media studies that we're doing is that very issue.
- 40:06As far as wastewater, I think the wastewater surveillance that came out of the COVID pandemic
- 40:12and now being widely applied is one of the most amazing stories that I have ever been
- 40:17associated with in public health.
- 40:19We have had, right here in Minnesota, there's a new report today that just came out in New
- 40:26Mexico.
- 40:27There's one that just came out.
- 40:28Well, there's several.
- 40:29Chicago just had one last week, a report.
- 40:33We had a case of measles here.
- 40:35We had a hit in our wastewater in Rochester, Minnesota this past October.
- 40:41No cases were at all known at the time, okay?
- 40:45Well, two days later, a child who had been in the Mayo Clinic and misdiagnosed was in
- 40:50fact a measles case, and his onset corresponded exactly with the waste.
- 40:55Well, then two weeks later, there was another bump in the wastewater system.
- 40:59His two sibs came down with measles, and they picked it up in the wastewater before they
- 41:03actually diagnosed it.
- 41:05Now, Rochester has a catchment of 140,000 people.
- 41:10How the hell with dilution did you pick that up?
- 41:16I mean, we're seeing that now repeatedly happening.
- 41:18And so, you know, I was just at a meeting in D.C. with CDC where all their funds were
- 41:24being cut for wastewater work.
- 41:27It's the worst decision that could possibly be made, because I think wastewater is a sentinel
- 41:33that could be used for a lot of things.
- 41:35So, I like to think of myself as being in that first row of supporters for wastewater,
- 41:42and I'll do whatever I can, because I think it helps us with our job a lot.
- 41:46If you see a signal right now on measles in your community, and somebody says there are
- 41:50no cases, you know there are, okay?
- 41:53And you've got to find them.
- 41:54And the fact that you could even see the difference between two kids versus one kid and the amount
- 41:59that was in the wastewater stream, I mean, that just blows me away.
- 42:03I mean, that's like, okay, we're going to have our next outpost for public health on
- 42:07Mars, you know?
- 42:08It's kind of that thing.
- 42:10So, I don't know if that jives with what you're seeing or thinking, but I think it's really
- 42:14an important point.
- 42:15Thank you.
- 42:16Thank you.
- 42:17Thank you so much, Sharon and Gibb, too, for your work in Maine as well as many other places.
- 42:22So, we have several questions in the chat.
- 42:25I don't think we have others who have raised their hands yet to go off mute, but if you
- 42:29do, please raise your electronic hand.
- 42:31So, maybe we can do these somewhat quickly.
- 42:34So, Lonnie Graham, who's a public health physician and my predecessor running the state public
- 42:38health agency, she says, the public has developed a pretty strong anti-science perspective and
- 42:45in addition, an anti-government bias.
- 42:48How would you advise our next governor of Maine to combat that?
- 42:51And I realize that's a big question for a short answer, but we do have a gubernatorial
- 42:56race since our current governor's term is limited.
- 43:00So in short, what would your advice be?
- 43:03Well, you know, at the same time as answering this, I'm going to take on peace and war,
- 43:08health, economic conditions, and who's going to land on the moon next, okay?
- 43:13I mean, this is a challenge beyond a challenge, and I say that with a smile, but I'm very
- 43:18serious about it.
- 43:19I think the most important thing that you can do is just be honest and be humble and
- 43:27say, this is what we know, this is what we don't know, this is how we're learning it,
- 43:30this is what we're going to go.
- 43:31You know, I've been asked all week on the hantavirus issue, and I've been saying, well,
- 43:35this is what we know about hantavirus.
- 43:36You know, I'm very aware of the studies in Argentina, et cetera.
- 43:39I was on the sail program team that looked at cruise ships during the pandemic.
- 43:44I learned a hell of a lot about ventilation and what it means to have swapping air on
- 43:49a ship, particularly one like this that basically was made for cold weather, not warm weather.
- 43:54I can tell you when they were in the Antarctic two weeks before, there were not a lot of
- 43:58people drinking martinis out on the deck, okay?
- 44:01That wasn't the case.
- 44:02And so what does that mean in terms of the potential for internal air movement and transmission?
- 44:10And so I think we just have to tell people we're learning this, and this is what we're
- 44:13learning, but that you then give them feedback every day.
- 44:16Now CDC obviously has not done well from a public standpoint with this one, with their
- 44:23first Han alert only just a couple of days ago.
- 44:26On the other hand, I will tell you, I know for a fact, and the state public health folks
- 44:31know this, they have been meeting daily with state public health folks in this country,
- 44:36and there's been tremendous coordination between CDC and the state health folks.
- 44:41So it's not all a lost issue, but the bottom line message is we've got to have a better
- 44:47way and an understood way to communicate, you know, who speaks for what and how do they
- 44:53speak.
- 44:54And, you know, frankly, when you're dealing with the Secretary of Health and Human Services
- 44:58that lies and lies and lies about vaccines, how can you believe anything?
- 45:03You know, when the Biden administration was there, and again, this is balls and strikes,
- 45:09this isn't partisan, CDC had one senior political appointee person from Washington, D.C. in
- 45:16the director's office, and they helped coordinate things going on between D.C. and Atlanta.
- 45:22Right now there are 16 political appointee non-scientists leading CDC, and I can tell
- 45:30you that there is not the same sense of science review and information validation that's occurring
- 45:39here.
- 45:40You know, you saw just recently how one of the major studies that CDC was putting out
- 45:44on using test negative design for understanding, you know, the whole COVID vaccine effectiveness,
- 45:53how they blocked that, while having not blocked just two weeks before an MMWR with influenza,
- 45:59which showed also very, you know, helpful results.
- 46:02So, you know, when you have an administration that's doing that, first of all, all of us
- 46:07in science, we've never really been here before, I mean, we've had disagreements over different
- 46:12program areas and so forth in public health, but I think it's been what I would consider
- 46:16to be friendly, fire, working with each other, okay?
- 46:20This is so different.
- 46:21I mean, this one is, you know, it's just out and outright lies.
- 46:26And I've never said that before about anyone in the political world, you know, that kind
- 46:30of thing.
- 46:31So I don't know how to answer the question of communication in a better way, but we definitely
- 46:35have to understand that that's a huge challenge for us.
- 46:39And so my bottom line message, when in doubt, just tell the truth.
- 46:44Thank you.
- 46:45And Deb Hagler, I'm sorry, I skipped over your question.
- 46:48She asked about how, can you discuss how you think our surveillance systems could improve?
- 46:53And you've talked a little bit about that in terms of the wastewater surveillance.
- 46:59Any other ideas?
- 47:00Yeah.
- 47:01Well, you know, and I cover a lot of that in the book, because this is a huge area.
- 47:04You know, I cut my teeth in public health on surveillance.
- 47:07A lot of our work at Minnesota was based on statewide surveillance that was active and
- 47:13very participatory.
- 47:15You know, I often felt guilty that we had so many of the infection control practitioners
- 47:21in Minnesota should have been getting paid on the state health department dime, okay?
- 47:25Because they were so instrumental in doing the day-to-day surveillance at the hospital
- 47:30level, giving us the kind of information we needed, and even at the community level, non-hospitalized
- 47:34in clinics.
- 47:35So I can't say enough about how important surveillance is.
- 47:39I think what we have to do, though, is take on a new way of looking at surveillance.
- 47:44It's not going to be the old way.
- 47:46I keep hoping that one day we're going to all be having discussions about how to build
- 47:50back public health better, you know, after destruction has happened.
- 47:56What can we do differently?
- 47:57We don't want to go back to the old system.
- 47:59I think between electronic medical records, the information sharing, laboratories tied
- 48:06in, I think all of that plays a key role.
- 48:09I think the issue with wastewater is important.
- 48:13And we may find that there are other aspects of community-wide ascertainment that we just
- 48:18haven't thought of yet.
- 48:19What's in the air?
- 48:20You know, the BioWatch program tried to get at that, but that was a rather challenged
- 48:25project, a challenged activity.
- 48:27But what are the other ways that we can know if we've had hits or that we have activity
- 48:31going on?
- 48:32And so I would like to see in the next round of whoever is going to come in and take over
- 48:37again, you know, that we don't just try to go back at the issue of this is the way we
- 48:44did it before.
- 48:45Because I think surveillance is so absolutely critical.
- 48:48And just along those lines, too, Imer puts in the chat, and this is a good point for
- 48:53rural states like Maine and Minnesota probably too, over half of Mainers get their water
- 49:00at home from a private well.
- 49:02So the wastewater surveillance is so important, as you said, and as I know you've noted on
- 49:08your podcasts and your books, that there's no perfect surveillance.
- 49:11So wastewater surveillance is important, but just in terms of rural areas, the public also
- 49:15needs to know that we're not capturing the over half of the people who get their water
- 49:19from a private well.
- 49:21And along those lines...
- 49:22And, Dora, can I just comment on that?
- 49:23Yes, yes.
- 49:24I think that's too...
- 49:25Thank you.
- 49:26I'm glad you raised that, because I come from rural Iowa, same thing, okay?
- 49:30And I think that's a very important observation, and that's another example where then we have
- 49:34to take into account, well, if we can't collect all this, what can we collect?
- 49:37Where can we collect it, and how do we collect it?
- 49:40And I think that that's a really important point.
- 49:43So nothing's going to be a magic bullet.
- 49:46Nothing is going to basically change the animal into the next queen or king, okay?
- 49:54So I think at this point, all I would say is that, yeah, that's a downside, but you
- 49:59can pick up a lot from the systems that do exist, and then from that, learn what does
- 50:05that mean for those people who are on private systems.
- 50:08Yeah.
- 50:09And I'm just going to go quickly to a question from Steve Trockman, and then I want to go
- 50:13back so we end with Hantavirus, because I know there are people who have asked questions
- 50:17about Hantavirus.
- 50:18But while we're still on surveillance, Steve asks about social media monitoring.
- 50:23Is that still a reliable syndromic surveillance source?
- 50:27Yeah.
- 50:28You know, that is a problem, and, you know, our group at Minnesota actually pioneered
- 50:33this very program for foodborne disease and looking at gastrointestinal illnesses.
- 50:38And you know, people may not be aware of this, but at any one time, about 3% of the U.S.
- 50:42population has diarrhea.
- 50:45Any one time, 8 to 10% of the population has a respiratory ailment, whether it could be
- 50:49anything from pollen to a real viral infection.
- 50:53And so oftentimes, the signals that come in may be real but may not be.
- 50:59So the sensitivity and specificity is really not that clear yet.
- 51:03If you suddenly see a major uptick in certain things like diarrheas or respiratory illnesses,
- 51:11that may surely be an early alert that you need to look into it further.
- 51:15And to me, I almost count that much like we do VAERS and others where, you know, what
- 51:20is happening with vaccine recipients?
- 51:22Is there a signal there that should get us to look at a more advanced system?
- 51:27And so I think that's also where we need to quickly turn on the kind of contacts that
- 51:32we have with those with electronic medical record capabilities.
- 51:37And are we seeing anything that would suggest an increase that way?
- 51:41And so I think that that is surely doable, but it's going to take more support information.
- 51:46If you do get a signal, what does it mean?
- 51:49And what you don't want to have happen is, you know, 25 new signals, but you can't explain
- 51:54any of them or at least understand what's going on, then people will doubt the system
- 51:59and that'll be a challenge.
- 52:01So getting on to Hantavirus, because I know we've had several questions asked about it
- 52:05and this sort of issue du jour, so Jennifer asked about, you know, some of the passengers
- 52:10from the cruise ship have been difficult to trace because they got off the ship early.
- 52:16Is Hantavirus a pandemic concern?
- 52:19And I think a corollary to that is what did you see in early 2020 about COVID that made
- 52:27you feel it was going to be a pandemic versus perhaps Hantavirus?
- 52:32What kind of the difference in characteristics?
- 52:34Yeah, a lot of what was driving us with 2020 was in fact the number of cases of what appeared
- 52:42to be asymptomatic transmission.
- 52:44For example, we had contacts in Hong Kong where people who had been in Wuhan flew back
- 52:50to Hong Kong well, they had contact with people on the day they returned, they then got sick
- 52:57a day later, and then the people who they had contact with got sick three days later.
- 53:03And so basically, we began to get more and more evidence of person-to-person asymptomatic
- 53:09transmission, and it was pretty dynamic.
- 53:11So that's what led us to say, this is very different, okay?
- 53:15I think right now with Hantavirus, I'm one of those out there saying this is not going
- 53:19to be a pandemic virus ever.
- 53:21You know, I've worked with these viruses, and clearly it's a challenge in terms of this
- 53:27particular strain.
- 53:28As you know, the Andy strain is the one that has the potential to be a respiratory transmitted
- 53:34agent airborne.
- 53:36But at the same time, we've had many, many experiences in Argentina where this is the
- 53:43most heavily hit, and where there was no transmission.
- 53:47You know, we had the MMWR, a woman from Delaware who became ill in Argentina, flew home on
- 53:53the plane ill, got to Delaware, wasn't diagnosed with Hantavirus Andy strain until after they'd
- 54:00returned.
- 54:01Very intensive follow-up, 50-some people after she returned, not one of them was infected,
- 54:07including people who sat next to her for hours, okay, on the plane.
- 54:11So we do see a situation, I think it's much more akin to SARS and MERS, where we have
- 54:19individuals for some reason who are super spreaders.
- 54:21I was involved with working up the outbreak at Samsung Medical Center in Seoul, Korea,
- 54:27where we had one individual who came back from the Middle East with MERS, was hospitalized,
- 54:32actually was in an emergency room, sat in a waiting room for hours, and transmitted
- 54:38to 100-and-some people, okay?
- 54:40We've had outbreaks with MERS where we've had a couple of cases, and we've had a lot
- 54:45of patients where nobody got infected.
- 54:47I worked up a lot of work on the Arabian Peninsula, Abu Dhabi, and the same thing was there.
- 54:53So I think the vast majority of people who develop Hantavirus Andy strain do not transmit.
- 55:01And there's something about a super spreader where we know, and we do have some data on
- 55:05viremia levels, that the higher the viremia level is more likely, possibly, and this is
- 55:09the data that the folks in Argentina have developed.
- 55:13And so I think that you could see a lot of one-off cases with one super spreader, doesn't
- 55:21mean that that will then transmit to the next one.
- 55:23Also, they're making a lot right now out of the New England Journal paper about an outbreak
- 55:27where someone who was symptomatic transmitted, and they're drawing lines to where people
- 55:32sat, but they don't want to talk about air dispersion.
- 55:36And so again, I come back to what I talked about before.
- 55:39It's not necessarily where you sat, it's who's air were you breathing, okay?
- 55:44And we see that often happen in settings like I gave you with measles and smoke and so forth.
- 55:49And so I don't see anything right now that would change that.
- 55:52I'm making a prediction that within the next week or two, this will be largely behind us.
- 55:58I hope that helps.
- 55:59And unfortunately, I am going to have to go on a second year because I have to catch a
- 56:02plane.
- 56:03Isn't that a stupid thing to say to catch a plane?
- 56:05What the hell would I do if I caught a plane?
- 56:07Would I just grab it?
- 56:08What would I do?
- 56:09You know?
- 56:10Well, it's been great to meet with you all.
- 56:12I hope this has been helpful, and I appreciate you accommodating the time change.
- 56:16It's been wonderful.
- 56:17We've had a lot of comments starting to flow in about how grateful people are.
- 56:20And believe me, I'm extremely grateful for your presence today with us, and thank you
- 56:25very much.
- 56:26The floor is on.
- 56:27I have to say hi.
- 56:28Okay?
- 56:29Yes, yes, yes.
- 56:30And if you want to learn more, please go to his podcast, the CIDRAP podcast, the Osterholm
- 56:37podcast, Osterholm Update.
- 56:40I know I get it through Apple, through the podcast.
- 56:43And then also the big one, the book, the new book that's out.
- 56:47Your main health employee and you're attending live, we will be giving out 25 of those.
- 56:51So please also join us next week on May 19th, Tuesday, back to our normal time of noontime.
- 56:59We have Dr. David Higgins from Colorado, who's going to be talking with us about how tips
- 57:04and tools for addressing vaccine hesitancy among vaccine-hesitant communities, as well
- 57:10as families.
- 57:11Can I say we're working with David, and he is brilliant.
- 57:16You've got the absolute perfect speaker.
- 57:18He's outstanding.
- 57:19And I know we didn't really get to the Vaccine Integrity Project much, except early on, and
- 57:23I want to thank you deeply for all that tremendous work you've done on that, which has been extremely
- 57:29helpful for everyone across the country.
- 57:30Well, can I just say one last thing in the motto at CIDRAP right now, is we will bend,
- 57:35and we will bend, but we will not break.
- 57:37We will not break.
- 57:38So whatever this administration throws at us, we're there.
- 57:42Well, thank you so much for giving up all these years.
- 57:45Thank you.
- 57:46Take care.
- 57:47Bye-bye.
- 57:48Thank you for listening.
- 57:49And we look forward to connecting with you again at MaineHealth's Public Health Grand
- 57:53Rounds, where we explore a timely public health topic with national and Maine experts.
- 57:59These Grand Rounds are posted to the MaineHealth podcast channel on PodBeam and at MaineHealth.org,
- 58:06where you can hear current and past episodes.
- 58:09See you next time.