Latest / Bloomberg Law / Judges Skeptical of Trump's Immunity Claim
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:11Speaker 2: Could a president order Seal Team six to assassinate a
- 0:14Speaker 2: political rival? That's an official act? In order to Seal
- 0:17Speaker 2: Team six.
- 0:19Speaker 1: He would have to be and would speedily be, you know,
- 0:21Speaker 1: uh uh impeached and convicted before the criminal.
- 0:25Speaker 2: But if you weren't, there would be no criminal prosecution,
- 0:27Speaker 2: no criminal liability for that.
- 0:29Speaker 1: What the founders were concerned about was not I asked
- 0:32Speaker 1: you a.
- 0:32Speaker 2: Yes, yes or no question. Could a president who ordered
- 0:36Speaker 2: Seal Team six to assassinate a political rival who was
- 0:39Speaker 2: not impeached, would he be subject to criminal prosecution.
- 0:44Speaker 1: If he were impeached and convicted first? So your answer
- 0:47Speaker 1: is is that My answer is qualified. Yes, there's a
- 0:50Speaker 1: political process that have to occur on it.
- 0:52Speaker 3: And that question, pressed repeatedly by Judge Florence Pan, was
- 0:57Speaker 3: just one of the tough questions that Donald Trump lawyer
- 1:00Speaker 3: faced at the DC Appellate Court today. All three judges
- 1:04Speaker 3: on the panel seem skeptical of Trump's claim that he's
- 1:07Speaker 3: immune from criminal prosecution for trying to overturn the twenty
- 1:11Speaker 3: twenty election because he was president at the time.
- 1:14Speaker 1: Thank's the notion that criminal community for a president doesn't
- 1:17Speaker 1: exist as a shocking holding. It would authorize, for example,
- 1:20Speaker 1: the indictment of President Biden in the Western District of
- 1:22Speaker 1: Texas after he leaves office for mismanaging the border allegedly.
- 1:26Speaker 3: Trump's attorney John Sower argued that a president can only
- 1:30Speaker 3: be criminally prosecuted after Congress has voted to both impeach
- 1:35Speaker 3: and convict him on similar charges. Judge Michelle Chiles didn't
- 1:39Speaker 3: find that argument particularly convincing.
- 1:42Speaker 4: But not everybody goes through that process, and of course
- 1:45Speaker 4: it's limited to the certain actors in that regard, but
- 1:47Speaker 4: not everybody has to go through that process. Prosecutors later
- 1:51Speaker 4: on can come into information and evidence after they've investigated,
- 1:55Speaker 4: to make their determinations about what they'd like to criminally prosecute.
- 1:59Speaker 4: So you're not always fine to whatever would be in
- 2:01Speaker 4: the impeachment judgment clause.
- 2:03Speaker 1: Whatever the practice has been with respect to support and officers,
- 2:06Speaker 1: the form the founding generation as clear as you cannot
- 2:09Speaker 1: do that respect to the beast.
- 2:10Speaker 3: My guest is Michael Gerhard, a professor at the University
- 2:13Speaker 3: of North Carolina Law School and an expert on impeachment.
- 2:17Speaker 3: In fact, his new book is called The Law of
- 2:20Speaker 3: Presidential Impeachment. It seemed like the focus of the argument
- 2:25Speaker 3: for Trump's lawyer was that under the Constitution's impeachment clause,
- 2:31Speaker 3: a president can't be prosecuted unless he's first impeached and
- 2:35Speaker 3: convicted over the same charges. Tell me about that argument
- 2:40Speaker 3: and what you think of it.
- 2:42Speaker 5: It's really dumb as it's not a good argument. There
- 2:45Speaker 5: are three judges in the late nineteen eighties that all
- 2:48Speaker 5: faced impeachment, and all three were actually tried criminally before
- 2:55Speaker 5: they were impeached, and they raised that argument back in
- 2:59Speaker 5: the late ninety eight and courts rejected. There's no constitutional
- 3:04Speaker 5: requirement that impeachment proceede a criminal investigation. Whether a criminal
- 3:09Speaker 5: investigation proceed an impeachment, their separate proceedings just as simple.
- 3:13Speaker 3: So then where did they get that argument? Did they
- 3:16Speaker 3: make it up out of whole cloth?
- 3:19Speaker 5: I think they largely made it up. I think it's
- 3:22Speaker 5: designed in part to delay things. That's first. Secondly, I
- 3:28Speaker 5: think it is probably and this might be the best
- 3:33Speaker 5: characterization of it. It might be loosely based on some
- 3:38Speaker 5: constitutional language that seems to leave an inference after an
- 3:45Speaker 5: impeachment that officials could still remain liable at law, but
- 3:51Speaker 5: that's not a command. That's just basically suggesting that after
- 3:57Speaker 5: impeachment there could be separately go proceeding. But I would
- 4:03Speaker 5: also maybe suggest third that I think it's just another
- 4:07Speaker 5: variation of Trump's arguments, which date back to his presidency,
- 4:12Speaker 5: that he currently no other president, but he at least
- 4:14Speaker 5: is above the law.
- 4:16Speaker 3: That led to some really startling hypotheticals. Judge Florence Pan
- 4:22Speaker 3: asked if a president ordered Seal Team six to assassinate
- 4:26Speaker 3: a political rival, could he be criminally prosecuted? And Trump's
- 4:30Speaker 3: lawyer seemed reluctant. Over and over again. She tried to
- 4:34Speaker 3: press him yes or no, Yes or no. He seemed
- 4:37Speaker 3: reluctant to even make a concession there.
- 4:41Speaker 5: Well, I think that he was, in a sense, arguing
- 4:44Speaker 5: from a corner. So he's already backed in, and I
- 4:48Speaker 5: think he thought maybe his best option was just to
- 4:52Speaker 5: take a hard line. But I think that question, among others,
- 4:57Speaker 5: sort of underscores the absurdity of Trump's argument.
- 5:00Speaker 3: Did you see any inkling that any of the judges
- 5:03Speaker 3: were buying that particular argument.
- 5:06Speaker 5: I did not, but that may not mean very much.
- 5:09Speaker 5: There's not always a complete overlap between what happens in
- 5:14Speaker 5: a oral argument and what comes out of an opinion.
- 5:16Speaker 5: So you know, lawyers tend to take with a grain
- 5:19Speaker 5: of salt all the questioning in oral argument because boris
- 5:22Speaker 5: understand it may not necessarily to or predicted exactly what
- 5:25Speaker 5: the opinion might look like. But I think before there
- 5:29Speaker 5: was any argument that I and other scholars to short
- 5:33Speaker 5: study this area thought Trump's arguments was probably at best
- 5:38Speaker 5: a week. It's not absurd, and I think that the
- 5:41Speaker 5: judges at least appear to have so far taken the
- 5:46Speaker 5: stimular sort of approach.
- 5:48Speaker 3: So before the argument, I had understood, well, did the
- 5:53Speaker 3: lawyer concede that then Trump does not that if his
- 5:58Speaker 3: premise is correct about the impeachment clause, that Trump does
- 6:02Speaker 3: not have absolute presidential immunity.
- 6:05Speaker 6: Was that conceded by him at all? I couldn't tell.
- 6:11Speaker 5: I don't know that the lawyer made any such concession.
- 6:14Speaker 5: But the lawyer's arguments, if you kind of think about them,
- 6:18Speaker 5: practically speaking, the lawyer's arguments in this oral argument today
- 6:22Speaker 5: is the same as they were all throughout Trump's presidency,
- 6:25Speaker 5: and that is that Donald Trump is somehow above the wall.
- 6:28Speaker 5: But there's no way to hold Donald Trump accountable for anything.
- 6:31Speaker 3: Well, I expected more discussion of whether Trump's actions on
- 6:36Speaker 3: January sixth were part of his official duties or discretionary.
- 6:41Speaker 3: What did you hear about that particular issue?
- 6:44Speaker 5: Now, I was a little surprised that that was impressed
- 6:48Speaker 5: more so by Trump's lawyers, not because there was a
- 6:50Speaker 5: good argument, but just because it's an argument that could
- 6:52Speaker 5: make So I think that I don't want to read
- 6:58Speaker 5: too much in the silence is you know on either side,
- 7:02Speaker 5: but it strikes me as possible that Trump's lawyers may
- 7:08Speaker 5: have recognized that they'd have to draw a line at
- 7:14Speaker 5: some point about where official duties end. They can't argue
- 7:19Speaker 5: that official duties are boundless because the Speedwar has rejected
- 7:23Speaker 5: that in more than one and I think that Trump
- 7:27Speaker 5: lawyers probably were reluctant their fortune engage with this issue
- 7:30Speaker 5: because they don't want to draw that line.
- 7:33Speaker 3: There was one thing that I think one or two
- 7:36Speaker 3: of the judges picked up on. Judge Karen Henderson express
- 7:39Speaker 3: concern that a ruling saying the president doesn't have immunity
- 7:43Speaker 3: would lead to politically driven prosecutions of future presidents.
- 7:47Speaker 4: How do we write an opinion that would stop the
- 7:51Speaker 4: flood dates.
- 7:54Speaker 7: Your predecessors, in their ollc opinions, recognized that aliability would
- 8:01Speaker 7: be unavoidably political.
- 8:04Speaker 6: What side had the better of that argument?
- 8:07Speaker 5: Well, I think that question really has been answered already
- 8:11Speaker 5: by the United States Supreme Court. They answered it in
- 8:13Speaker 5: case called Trump versus Vans And in that Supreme Court case,
- 8:17Speaker 5: the Supreme Court ruled that a president in Trump's case,
- 8:21Speaker 5: then a sitting president may be subject to state criminal prosecution.
- 8:26Speaker 5: Trump tried to argue in that case, oh, the president
- 8:29Speaker 5: could then be subject to all sorts of partisan prosecutions,
- 8:32Speaker 5: and Spreme Court rejected that because the Court said, they're
- 8:35Speaker 5: all sorts of stafeguards against that. So it's not really
- 8:40Speaker 5: going to be a real or practical concern because if
- 8:43Speaker 5: that's the motivation, Again, if it's in federal court, set
- 8:48Speaker 5: of judges could obviously try to not just look behind it,
- 8:50Speaker 5: but so could state judges, And ultimately, a state prosecution
- 8:54Speaker 5: of somebody, let's say, who used to be president is
- 8:57Speaker 5: still possibly appealable to the United States Supreme Court, which
- 9:00Speaker 5: is a whole other stateguard that could exist. So there's
- 9:03Speaker 5: no reason to think that the possibility of a prostitution used.
- 9:07Speaker 5: This may never be across the teacher.
- 9:10Speaker 1: Well.
- 9:10Speaker 3: Trump suggested on Monday that if the court doesn't rule
- 9:13Speaker 3: in his favor and he wins the presidential election, he'd
- 9:16Speaker 3: have Joe Biden indicted. So we'll see what happens there.
- 9:21Speaker 5: Not a good thing, I think, because presidents shouldn't be
- 9:24Speaker 5: making that decision here.
- 9:25Speaker 6: Stay right there.
- 9:26Speaker 3: Michael will discuss more about the contours of any decision
- 9:29Speaker 3: coming up next. And Donald Trump was actually in the
- 9:34Speaker 3: courtroom for the oral arguments and had some comments afterwards.
- 9:38Speaker 7: And I think we're doing very well. I think it's
- 9:40Speaker 7: very unfair when a opponent, a political opponent, is prosecuted
- 9:46Speaker 7: by the DOJ, by Biden's DOJ. So they're losing in
- 9:51Speaker 7: every ball, they're losing in almost every Demographic numbers came
- 9:57Speaker 7: out today that are very mind boggling if you happen
- 10:02Speaker 7: to be Joe Biden. And I think they feel this
- 10:06Speaker 7: is the way they're going to try and win, and
- 10:08Speaker 7: that's not the way it goes. That will be bedlam
- 10:10Speaker 7: in the country. It's a very bad thing. It's a
- 10:12Speaker 7: very bad precedent. As we said, it's the opening of
- 10:15Speaker 7: a Pandora's box. And that's that's a very sad thing
- 10:18Speaker 7: that's happened with this whole situation.
- 10:22Speaker 6: I'm Jim Gross when you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 10:28Speaker 8: Never in our nation's history until this case, as a
- 10:32Speaker 8: president claimed that immunity from criminal prosecution extends beyond his
- 10:36Speaker 8: time office. The president has a unique constitutional role, but
- 10:41Speaker 8: he is not above the law. Separation of powers principles,
- 10:45Speaker 8: constitutional texts, history, precedent, and other immunity doctrines all point
- 10:51Speaker 8: to the conclusion that a former president enjoys no immunity
- 10:54Speaker 8: from criminal prosecution.
- 10:56Speaker 3: James Pierce, a lawyer working with Special counsel Jack Smith,
- 11:00Speaker 3: explained to the d C. Appellate Court today why former
- 11:03Speaker 3: President Donald Trump is not immune from prosecution for his
- 11:07Speaker 3: attempt to overturn the twenty twenty election. In his final
- 11:11Speaker 3: days as president, Trump was in the pack courtroom listening,
- 11:14Speaker 3: even though he was not required to be there. The
- 11:17Speaker 3: panel of three judges, two Biden appointees and one George W.
- 11:21Speaker 3: Bush appointee, appeared very skeptical about Trump's claim that he
- 11:25Speaker 3: has presidential immunity from the criminal charges brought by the
- 11:29Speaker 3: Special Council and his attorney, John Sower, appeared to be
- 11:33Speaker 3: caught by the judges questions several times, particularly when judges
- 11:38Speaker 3: Karen Henderson and Florence Pann noted that the lawyer who
- 11:41Speaker 3: represented Trump during his twenty twenty one impeachment trial had
- 11:46Speaker 3: in fact suggested that he could later face criminal prosecution.
- 11:50Speaker 4: He did not say that.
- 11:51Speaker 1: Could never be raised immunity defense. It's that criminal process
- 11:54Speaker 1: could going.
- 11:55Speaker 2: There's a quote in the congressal record in which your council,
- 11:58Speaker 2: I'm sorry, your client sets through cal No former officeholder
- 12:02Speaker 2: is immune from investigation.
- 12:04Speaker 1: Investigation, is what There's no issue. Well, that may be
- 12:08Speaker 1: true of subbortinate officers, but as to the principal officer
- 12:11Speaker 1: of the president, he is immune unless he is impeachent
- 12:13Speaker 1: connected ay, and it comes back to the point way he.
- 12:15Speaker 2: Was president at the time, and his position was that
- 12:18Speaker 2: no former officeholder is immune. And in fact, the argument was,
- 12:25Speaker 2: there's no need to vote for impeachment because we have
- 12:28Speaker 2: this backstop, which is criminal prosecution. And it seems that
- 12:32Speaker 2: many senators relied on that voting to a quit.
- 12:36Speaker 3: Trump is trying to get the panel to reverse a
- 12:38Speaker 3: ruling by federal trial judge Tanya Chutkin, who rejected Trump's
- 12:42Speaker 3: immunity defense and suggested he was seeking the power of
- 12:46Speaker 3: a monarch. I've been talking to Michael Gerhard, a professor
- 12:49Speaker 3: at the University of North Carolina Law School. So the
- 12:53Speaker 3: Special Council and Judge Michelle Child pointed to the fact
- 12:57Speaker 3: that Richard Nixon was pardoned upon leaving office to show
- 13:01Speaker 3: that it's been assumed that presidents can be prosecuted after
- 13:06Speaker 3: leaving office.
- 13:07Speaker 6: Is that much of a legal argument, though, I think.
- 13:09Speaker 5: It's a perfectly good argument, because what it's doing is
- 13:13Speaker 5: is trying to ensure that whatever the court does now
- 13:15Speaker 5: is going to make sense of the whole system as
- 13:18Speaker 5: we've understood it up untown now. And so the pardon
- 13:21Speaker 5: of Nixon presumed that Nixon could be criminally prosecuted for
- 13:26Speaker 5: things he had done as president. That presumption cuts directly
- 13:30Speaker 5: against Trump's arguments right now, and by the way, that's
- 13:33Speaker 5: not from a democratic president.
- 13:36Speaker 3: There was a question at the beginning of jurisdiction, and
- 13:39Speaker 3: it wasn't raised by either of the parties, and it
- 13:42Speaker 3: seemed like neither of the parties wanted to endorse it.
- 13:45Speaker 3: But it was by an amiicus brief that Trump doesn't
- 13:48Speaker 3: have the right to make the request before trial. What's
- 13:51Speaker 3: known as an interlocutory appeal. Would you explain that and
- 13:54Speaker 3: where you think they came.
- 13:55Speaker 6: Out on that.
- 13:56Speaker 5: Sure, Well, a jurisdictional issue has to do with not
- 14:00Speaker 5: court or a court has the power to do something.
- 14:03Speaker 5: So a jurisdictional issue may be raised at any time,
- 14:07Speaker 5: and it may be raised by the court itself. Court
- 14:09Speaker 5: doesn't have to rely on the parties to a case,
- 14:11Speaker 5: because the court's always going to be concerned with do
- 14:13Speaker 5: we have the power to decide this case or even
- 14:16Speaker 5: hear this case? And an interlocuatory appeal is an appeal
- 14:22Speaker 5: that could be made before the end of the case.
- 14:26Speaker 5: So an appeal could be made to some higher court
- 14:29Speaker 5: based on some concerns, and they may be so excuse
- 14:32Speaker 5: that it could be raised before there's actually been a trial,
- 14:36Speaker 5: or before there's even been conviction, or the case is
- 14:39Speaker 5: not yet over. I think the court was reasonable in
- 14:43Speaker 5: raising this question. The fact that either side could really
- 14:47Speaker 5: address it well might suggest that either side has thought
- 14:50Speaker 5: about it very much. But what is clear is that
- 14:54Speaker 5: Trump is trying to raise this now before he's he's
- 14:57Speaker 5: gone to trial, much less having been convicted, and so
- 15:01Speaker 5: that raises a question, least in my mind, not so
- 15:03Speaker 5: much about whether there should be an intelocatory appeal that
- 15:06Speaker 5: is a special appeal right now, but what we call
- 15:09Speaker 5: a rightness issue, is the issue really right as a
- 15:12Speaker 5: mature to the point where a court suard decided in
- 15:15Speaker 5: rightness and they also become a concern for a colored
- 15:17Speaker 5: cord as well.
- 15:19Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, so there are a lot of things
- 15:20Speaker 3: that the appellate court could do. They could say they
- 15:23Speaker 3: don't have jurisdiction at this point. I mean, they could
- 15:27Speaker 3: go just based on the Constitution's impeachment clause and Trump's
- 15:32Speaker 3: argument there.
- 15:33Speaker 5: Yes, I mean, of course they could craft this anyway
- 15:37Speaker 5: they like. I think generally speaking, it has long been
- 15:41Speaker 5: understood and I would even argue well settled that there's
- 15:43Speaker 5: no what we'll call a double the jeopardy problem with
- 15:46Speaker 5: having an impeachment on the one hand and a criminal
- 15:49Speaker 5: process on the other. They are two separate proceedings, and
- 15:52Speaker 5: an impeachment proceeding is not a criminal proceeding. So the
- 15:56Speaker 5: double jeopardy clause mean you can't bring two criminal prosecutions
- 15:59Speaker 5: for the same in this conduct doesn't apply because it's
- 16:02Speaker 5: not a criminal process. Beyond that I think that the
- 16:06Speaker 5: court has to be thinking, among other things, about what
- 16:09Speaker 5: kind of precedent are we going to establish here? And
- 16:13Speaker 5: if I had to guess, my guess would be that
- 16:15Speaker 5: the Court's going to not want to establish a precedent
- 16:18Speaker 5: that makes it easier for presidents to be above the wall.
- 16:21Speaker 5: The bottom line is Trump's going to face criminal trial,
- 16:24Speaker 5: and you can't avoid that.
- 16:25Speaker 3: What's the best argument of all the arguments Trump made?
- 16:29Speaker 3: What's the best of them?
- 16:31Speaker 5: I confess I'm not sure any of them are any good.
- 16:33Speaker 5: And I mean it seriously. I mean, I've studied this
- 16:35Speaker 5: for decades. I think these arguments are They've all been
- 16:39Speaker 5: raised to some extent in the past, all have been
- 16:42Speaker 5: rejected or found the lack of credibility by historians. So
- 16:45Speaker 5: I confess I could think of one.
- 16:48Speaker 3: And so Trump's lawyer asked for a stay of the
- 16:51Speaker 3: opinion so that they can appeal. So if they appeal
- 16:54Speaker 3: to the full DC Circuit as for an on bank hearing,
- 16:57Speaker 3: do you think the DC Circuit would.
- 16:59Speaker 6: Take on bank?
- 17:01Speaker 5: Well, you don't know the answer. I'm not sure why
- 17:04Speaker 5: the full DC Circuit needs to hear this. I think
- 17:06Speaker 5: that's another move by Trump's lawyers to delay everything, sort
- 17:10Speaker 5: of to throw a lot of legal process and the
- 17:13Speaker 5: proceedings against him as a way to kind of delay
- 17:15Speaker 5: them in the hopes I suppose that Trump will win
- 17:18Speaker 5: the presidency and pardon themselves, or that one of his
- 17:21Speaker 5: bacoltes will win the presidency and pardon him. But the courts,
- 17:24Speaker 5: I think, are aware of the possibilities that they're being
- 17:27Speaker 5: used here, and generally speaking, courts don't like to be
- 17:30Speaker 5: used in that manner.
- 17:31Speaker 3: Everyone assumes that this is going to be appealed to
- 17:34Speaker 3: the Supreme Court no matter what happens, and a lot
- 17:37Speaker 3: of legal experts are predicting that the court will take
- 17:40Speaker 3: the case.
- 17:41Speaker 6: But is that necessarily true.
- 17:44Speaker 5: No. Let's say, for example, this current panel concludes that
- 17:49Speaker 5: none of Trump's arguments are credible, and the court rejects
- 17:52Speaker 5: all of them. The Supreme Court could simply reject any
- 17:56Speaker 5: appeal based in part on the justices considering there's no
- 18:00Speaker 5: real issue here and we have to decide because what
- 18:04Speaker 5: the panel would have concluded is consistent with whatever courts
- 18:08Speaker 5: have said before. So there's no compelling reason why the
- 18:13Speaker 5: US sping Court needs to get needs to intervenient at
- 18:15Speaker 5: this point. The other thing I might just raise at
- 18:18Speaker 5: this point is to just make note of the fact
- 18:21Speaker 5: that Trump is still trying to argue that as a
- 18:24Speaker 5: former president he has some kind of special community. The
- 18:28Speaker 5: sitting president may not be immune to criminal process that
- 18:32Speaker 5: was decided by the USPN Court. When Trump is president,
- 18:35Speaker 5: it's Trump versus Advanced. So as a former president, Donald
- 18:39Speaker 5: Trump's making these are quite long reaches claiming for a
- 18:44Speaker 5: former president immunity that, by the way, no sitting president
- 18:48Speaker 5: has ever had, and that just increases the odds. I
- 18:51Speaker 5: think that courts will reject his.
- 18:52Speaker 3: Claim, and the decision from the panel of the DC
- 18:56Speaker 3: Circuit could come at any time. Thanks so much, Michael.
- 19:00Speaker 3: That's Michael Gerhard, a professor with the University of North
- 19:03Speaker 3: Carolina Law School. His new book is entitled The Law
- 19:07Speaker 3: of Presidential Impeachment. Coming up next on the Bloomberg Lan Show.
- 19:11Speaker 3: Do you know what it takes to get on the
- 19:12Speaker 3: no Fly list and what it takes to get off?
- 19:15Speaker 3: Those questions were explored at the Supreme Court. I'm June Grasso,
- 19:19Speaker 3: and this is Bloomberg. This week, the Supreme Court sought
- 19:23Speaker 3: to untangle whether an Oregon man can proceed with a
- 19:26Speaker 3: lawsuit against the FBI for placing him on its no
- 19:29Speaker 3: fly list before removing him and then calling the matter moot.
- 19:34Speaker 3: The justices heard arguments in the case of Jonas Fikre,
- 19:37Speaker 3: a US citizen who sued the government over his placement
- 19:40Speaker 3: on the list. Fikree says he learned he was on
- 19:43Speaker 3: the list in twenty ten while traveling to Sudan, after
- 19:47Speaker 3: FBI agents approached him asking about his association with a
- 19:51Speaker 3: particular mosque in Portland. Joining me is Hinna Shamsi, director
- 19:55Speaker 3: of the acl u'sed National Security Project, the ACLU f Wild,
- 20:00Speaker 3: then amikas brief in the case. So start out by
- 20:04Speaker 3: telling us what happened to Jonas kra Well.
- 20:08Speaker 9: Yonis Sicra is a US citizen who discovered that he
- 20:12Speaker 9: was on the no fly list in twenty ten, and
- 20:15Speaker 9: he then filed a lawsuit saying that the government wrongly
- 20:19Speaker 9: placed him on the list in violation of his constitutionally
- 20:24Speaker 9: protected right to travel, and that the procedures that the
- 20:28Speaker 9: government used to place him on the list violated fundamental
- 20:31Speaker 9: due process. So the case moved forward, and the government
- 20:36Speaker 9: then removed him from the list in twenty sixteen, and
- 20:40Speaker 9: since then, it is argued that his lawsuit could not
- 20:44Speaker 9: go forward because it was moot there was no live
- 20:48Speaker 9: case or controversy to be adjudicated. Mister Ficra then appealed
- 20:52Speaker 9: from a district court judgment in the government's favor, and
- 20:57Speaker 9: the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals twice shoed decisions in
- 21:01Speaker 9: mister vickras favor, rejecting the government's attempts to end the case.
- 21:06Speaker 9: And that's when the government appealed to the Supreme Court,
- 21:09Speaker 9: and that's the argument that the court heard.
- 21:12Speaker 3: Does the FBI frequently refuse to tell someone why they've
- 21:16Speaker 3: been placed on the no fly list or why they've
- 21:20Speaker 3: been taken off the list?
- 21:21Speaker 9: Absolutely, you know, And this is one of our fundamental
- 21:27Speaker 9: problems with the no flylist and why we've been working
- 21:31Speaker 9: on litigating these issues for about twenty years, which is
- 21:35Speaker 9: that the no fly list program potentially operates in a
- 21:39Speaker 9: black box of executive branch discretion and secrecy. The government
- 21:45Speaker 9: refuses usually to tell people the full reasons and most
- 21:51Speaker 9: often any reason for placing people on the no fly list,
- 21:57Speaker 9: and so for decades and other rights groups have documented
- 22:02Speaker 9: the secrecy and unfairness of this program, and it's devastating
- 22:08Speaker 9: consequences for people's lives, yet it remains a black box.
- 22:13Speaker 9: Let me be more specific, Americans who are on the
- 22:16Speaker 9: no fly list and West often left in the dark
- 22:19Speaker 9: about why they've been placed on the list. They're not
- 22:22Speaker 9: given any meaningful explanation when they are removed, if they
- 22:27Speaker 9: are removed, or any guarantee against being wrongfully placed on
- 22:32Speaker 9: the list in the future. And the issue before the
- 22:35Speaker 9: court was whether mister Sikra's case could go forward after
- 22:41Speaker 9: he had been removed.
- 22:43Speaker 3: Does mister fire know why he was put on the list?
- 22:48Speaker 9: He does not have the reasons, all the reasons that
- 22:51Speaker 9: he was put on the list. You know, in the
- 22:53Speaker 9: argument that took place on Monday, the government repeatedly said, well,
- 22:58Speaker 9: we've provided a reason, you know, we've explained the criteria
- 23:03Speaker 9: for placement on the no fly list that was applied
- 23:06Speaker 9: to him. But here's the problem. What that means is
- 23:10Speaker 9: that the government has disclosed what standard it uses to
- 23:14Speaker 9: place people on the no fly list. And we can
- 23:16Speaker 9: talk about why that standard is vague and broad and
- 23:20Speaker 9: deeply problematic, but it hasn't disclosed the reasons that it
- 23:24Speaker 9: thinks mister Fikra satisfied that standard. So mister Figray doesn't
- 23:31Speaker 9: know what he's alleged to have done wrong in the
- 23:34Speaker 9: first place, and how he can, as he argued to
- 23:38Speaker 9: the court, you know, know what to do in order
- 23:41Speaker 9: not to be placed on the no fly list again
- 23:43Speaker 9: in the future.
- 23:45Speaker 3: It seemed as if several of the justices cross ideological lines,
- 23:50Speaker 3: were sympathetic to mister Fikra. Justice Brett Kavanaugh said, that's
- 23:55Speaker 3: a complete wild card.
- 23:57Speaker 6: A return to the.
- 23:58Speaker 3: List still depends on the FBI's assessment of someone's activity
- 24:02Speaker 3: based on a multi factor security threat threshold. We're in
- 24:06Speaker 3: the dark, and Justice Sonya Sotomayor said, how can someone
- 24:10Speaker 3: tell you that they're not going to engage in a
- 24:12Speaker 3: terrorist activity if they don't know what terrorist activity you
- 24:16Speaker 3: claim they did?
- 24:17Speaker 6: So Catch twenty two.
- 24:19Speaker 9: It is a real catch twenty two and it was
- 24:22Speaker 9: a concern. You know, the discretion as well as the
- 24:25Speaker 9: secrecy is something that the justices, and I think a
- 24:29Speaker 9: lot of the justices across the spectrum were troubled by
- 24:34Speaker 9: or expressed concern about, because, as often happens, courts as
- 24:39Speaker 9: well as the people who are impacted by the placement,
- 24:42Speaker 9: are left in the dark in this black box of
- 24:44Speaker 9: a program, just.
- 24:46Speaker 3: As Elena Kagan suggested that the government should be required
- 24:50Speaker 3: to go before a judge in private to explain why
- 24:54Speaker 3: someone had been placed on the no fly list and
- 24:57Speaker 3: why they've been removed from the list and what they
- 25:00Speaker 3: would not be returned to the list, and Justice course
- 25:03Speaker 3: it seemed to agree with that. Is that a possible
- 25:06Speaker 3: solution here?
- 25:08Speaker 9: Well, you know, I want to start with what justice
- 25:11Speaker 9: the Gorsich said, which is that you know, normally in
- 25:16Speaker 9: our legal system, we have a right to know what
- 25:20Speaker 9: evidence the government has against us, and Justice Gorsic rightly said,
- 25:25Speaker 9: that's due process, that's a pillar of our democracy. And
- 25:30Speaker 9: why is it? I think he asked that an American
- 25:33Speaker 9: citizen who's been denied a right and evidence, why shouldn't
- 25:39Speaker 9: he be able to determine what's at state? So, you know,
- 25:43Speaker 9: one of the factors in one of the alternatives proposed
- 25:47Speaker 9: during the argument in court was that the government could
- 25:51Speaker 9: provide its reasons to judge in camera, meaning you know,
- 25:58Speaker 9: in continued secrecy a judge to make a determination, and
- 26:02Speaker 9: that would certainly be better than what exists now or
- 26:07Speaker 9: what mister Fickray was facing, which is not being able
- 26:10Speaker 9: to have any kind of meaningful guarantee that the government
- 26:17Speaker 9: would not place him on the list wrongly again in
- 26:22Speaker 9: the future. I think we should still pause and think
- 26:25Speaker 9: about what that might mean though that the government tells
- 26:28Speaker 9: a judge. But if your person who has been left
- 26:32Speaker 9: in the dark about why you've been placed on the
- 26:36Speaker 9: list in the first place, why you've been denied as
- 26:39Speaker 9: some of my clients have the right to travel to
- 26:44Speaker 9: be with their loved ones on their sick beds, to
- 26:46Speaker 9: attend funerals or weddings or graduations, you know, surely more
- 26:51Speaker 9: is required to the person impacted themselves. But let's see
- 26:56Speaker 9: how the court rules.
- 26:58Speaker 6: So the FBI's position is that this is moot. Is
- 27:01Speaker 6: that right?
- 27:02Speaker 9: The FBI's position was that they have told mister Fikra
- 27:08Speaker 9: that he would not be placed on the list again
- 27:13Speaker 9: quote based on currently available information, and that that is
- 27:17Speaker 9: enough to end his case. And what mister Fickra was
- 27:20Speaker 9: arguing was that that isn't enough. That when the government
- 27:25Speaker 9: acts as it did here, which is that it voluntarily
- 27:29Speaker 9: takes someone off the list, the case is not moot
- 27:35Speaker 9: because the standard the government has to meet is to
- 27:39Speaker 9: make it absolutely clear that the allegedly wrongful behavior won't
- 27:44Speaker 9: happen again, and mister Fikra argued that the government hasn't
- 27:49Speaker 9: repudiated its decision to put him on the list, and
- 27:52Speaker 9: it remained free to return him to the list for
- 27:55Speaker 9: the same reasons and using the same procedures that mister
- 27:59Speaker 9: Fra ledges were unlawful. So, in essence, mister Fickray was
- 28:04Speaker 9: asking for his case to go forward so he could
- 28:07Speaker 9: have his day in court.
- 28:09Speaker 3: The Chief Justice suggested that the government's promise might be enough.
- 28:14Speaker 3: Did you get a feel from the justices about what
- 28:19Speaker 3: they might do here?
- 28:20Speaker 9: Well? I think what leaves me cautiously optimistic about the
- 28:23Speaker 9: argument is that most of the justices understood that a
- 28:29Speaker 9: system in which a person does not know the government's
- 28:33Speaker 9: reasons for placing them on the list or taking them off,
- 28:36Speaker 9: it that there's not really a guarantee here against the
- 28:40Speaker 9: kind of wrongful conduct that is being challenged occurring.
- 28:44Speaker 3: Is this the first time the no fly list has
- 28:46Speaker 3: come before the justices.
- 28:48Speaker 9: It's not the first time that a no flylist related
- 28:51Speaker 9: issue has come before the justices. There was a previous
- 28:55Speaker 9: case about whether an individual who alleged that he was
- 28:58Speaker 9: placed on the no fly list after he refused to
- 29:01Speaker 9: become an informant, whether he consued to retain damages under
- 29:06Speaker 9: the Religious Freedom Restoration Act because he said that, you know,
- 29:10Speaker 9: he refused to become an informant because to have become
- 29:13Speaker 9: an informant would have gone against his religious beliefs. You know,
- 29:17Speaker 9: it's important to know that the issue in the case
- 29:21Speaker 9: was whether mister Fikray's constitutional claims could go forward. The
- 29:29Speaker 9: issue was not the lawfulness of the government's no flylist
- 29:33Speaker 9: placement and administrative redress process. The Court has never actually
- 29:40Speaker 9: ruled on the lawfulness of the no flylist placement and
- 29:43Speaker 9: redress process, but the lawfulness of the government's no fly
- 29:50Speaker 9: list program itself, whether the decision to place people on
- 29:54Speaker 9: the list, or the constitutionality of the administrative redress process
- 29:59Speaker 9: the government provides. None of that was before the court,
- 30:04Speaker 9: but to understand whether the case was neot or not,
- 30:08Speaker 9: it was necessary for the Court to consider what the
- 30:12Speaker 9: program is, and as we argued in our Friend of
- 30:16Speaker 9: the Court brief that we submitted to the court, it
- 30:19Speaker 9: was necessary to understand government discretion and the secrecy that
- 30:24Speaker 9: the government asserts in making its decisions. So we identified
- 30:31Speaker 9: in fact, you know, we comb through federal court dockets,
- 30:34Speaker 9: and we identified forty US citizens and residents who had
- 30:38Speaker 9: challenged their placement on no fly list in court, and
- 30:42Speaker 9: we found that the government kept secret the full reasons
- 30:46Speaker 9: or any reason for placing each of them on the list.
- 30:50Speaker 9: And we argued that from what is publicly known, the
- 30:55Speaker 9: government removed about seventy percent of those people from the
- 31:00Speaker 9: list during litigation, and many of the removals occurred just
- 31:05Speaker 9: before court imposed deadlines or while awaiting court rulings. So,
- 31:11Speaker 9: in essence, the government can take people off the list
- 31:16Speaker 9: and prevent their challenges to placement or the process from
- 31:22Speaker 9: being heard, and we wanted the court to take that
- 31:24Speaker 9: into account in making its determination in mister Fikra's case.
- 31:29Speaker 3: Let me ask you a general question. So someone gets
- 31:32Speaker 3: placed on the no fly list and they don't know why,
- 31:36Speaker 3: who do they sue to try to find out or
- 31:38Speaker 3: try to get off the list.
- 31:40Speaker 9: So when people are placed on the no fly list,
- 31:45Speaker 9: they can avail themselves of a process called DHS trip
- 31:51Speaker 9: It's through DHS and what that requires is that you
- 31:57Speaker 9: submit information to Dhryes saying I think I'm on the
- 32:02Speaker 9: no fly list and I'm wrongly on the no fly list,
- 32:05Speaker 9: and the government will review this information, and if you're
- 32:10Speaker 9: a US citizen or a lawful permanent resident, it will,
- 32:14Speaker 9: after a couple of different stages, tell you if you're
- 32:19Speaker 9: on the no flylist. It will tell you what standard
- 32:22Speaker 9: it used to place you on the no fly list,
- 32:26Speaker 9: and it can but as we found, most often does
- 32:31Speaker 9: not provide you with a summary of the reasons or
- 32:38Speaker 9: a reason. But most often, we've found that the government
- 32:42Speaker 9: does not provide all or even most often any reason
- 32:48Speaker 9: for placing people on the list. So that's often when
- 32:52Speaker 9: people sue to compel constitutional due process us to find
- 33:01Speaker 9: out why they've been placed on the list and to
- 33:05Speaker 9: seek a meaningful process through the court to remove themselves.
- 33:09Speaker 3: It'll be interesting to see how far the Supreme Court
- 33:11Speaker 3: goes here.
- 33:12Speaker 6: Thanks so much for being on the show.
- 33:14Speaker 3: That's Hannah Shamsey, director of the acl USED National Security Project,
- 33:19Speaker 3: And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 33:22Speaker 3: Remember you can always get the latest legal news by
- 33:24Speaker 3: subscribing and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 33:28Speaker 3: and at Bloomberg dot com slash podcast Slash Law. I'm
- 33:32Speaker 3: June Grosso and this is Bloomberg