Latest / The Academic Boardroom Podcast / Is Higher Education Immune to Colorism?
Transcript
- Anyone who spent any amount of time at like elite institutions of higher education can see that there's a disproportionate amount of light skinned people, mixed race people, people adopted by white parents, etc.. So I think that the many ways that whiteness works its way into black experiences is highly salient in higher education. Just like other forms of discrimination around colorism, terms of employment and who seems like they would be a good fit, who feels familiar, who's easy to get along with, you know, for black folks who've been around more white people and are used to being around white people is an advantage in predominantly white environments. [Theme Music] Welcome to the table. You tuned in to the academic boardroom with doctor J and doctor E, pull up a chair. Higher learning, higher stakes. Welcome back to The Academic Boardroom where we sit down with powerbrokers shaping the future of education. I'm your host, Dr. Eli Joseph. And joining me is my colleague and partner in crime, Dr. Janice Gassam Asare. Today we are joined by Dr. Maggie Hunter, who is the professor of sociology and strategic advisor to the Dean for faculty DEI Initiatives at Santa Clara University, a leading expert on colorism, Dr. Hunter's research on skin tone bias has been featured on the Oprah Winfrey Network documentary Like Girls in the classroom. She champions hands on community engaged learning, mentoring student teams, studying Gen Z activism while teaching dynamic courses like social movements and Body politics. Dr. Hunter, welcome to the boardroom. It's great to be here. I appreciate the invitation. Of course. It's so wonderful to have you here. You have such an extensive and really interesting background. But the first question that I think doctor E and I are really curious about is like, how did you get into the work that you're doing now? You're, as doctor E mentioned, one of the leading researchers on colorism, but how did you get into this work or what drew you specifically to this work? I would say, like many sociological topics, it grew out of my own personal experience. So I'm a mixed-race person, black and white. I grew up in the Midwest in a very black and white context, and I think from an early age I was really attuned to status by skin tone. In my school, in the community, in the mass media, all of it. And so I think I sort of always had some questions and maybe nagging issues I wanted to explore around that. And then I did a little bit of that as an undergrad in my undergraduate research work. But I really dove in more deeply. As a graduate student in sociology. I knew I was interested in race in general, and I kind of stumbled into an ongoing project on colorism that was comparing black experiences and Chicano experiences with colorism, and that basically got the ball rolling for what became a sort of career long research question. So I was looking at you have a really extensive background, and if anyone is interested, they can like check out your Google Scholar page. But I saw so I saw that one of the studies that you actually published last year was on student belonging at HBCUs. So I was really curious about like, what some of the main findings of that particular study was because we may have some listeners that either plan to attend HBCUs or want to attend an HBCU, or they teach at an HBCU. So what were some of the findings from that research study? So this was a team project that I worked on with three colleagues, two of whom are at Morehouse, and we are all in now various parts of higher ed administration. So for me, I'd say over the past decade, being in these different leadership roles has led me to ask some interesting questions. I think about race and higher ed. So one of the things I was interested in and so was this team. There's a lot of discussion about belonging now in higher ed, and sometimes we can discuss this later, but sometimes those questions of belonging are used to do an end run around questions about race. But that's not the case in this situation here. What we were interested in is what is belonging look like on an HBCU campus. Because usually when belonging is studied, it's the focus is like on a predominantly white university. How do students of color sort of make space for themselves, get connected, build community, and thrive? But in an HBCU situation, you have a much more. It's not a homogenous environment, but there are obviously many, many more black students. But of course there's a lot of diversity within that community. So we still wanted to ask about belonging and how does it operate in this kind of unique context. So we did some focus groups with students and what we found, and I think this is also unique to a lot of HBC use, is that there's a lot of sort of and I don't know if either of you are HBCU alumni. So you can jump in if that's the case. But there's a lot of like, ritualized, university culture at these institutions, and that is actually very helpful for building belonging. So like every year everyone participates in certain kinds of things and it becomes a part of being a part of the community. So what we found is that there was a lot of trepidation among people coming into a new environment, just like at most universities. But there are all of these sort of highly structured and ritualized things to participate in. Homecoming would be a good example that gay people, a way to immediately connect. And then the way people formed belonging obviously wasn't as connected to race. So that's a part of it, of course, but is also connected to all these other things. So a lot of people who had been in other educational environments where race is sort of this salient identity that stands out for them because they're in a minority in this situation. They get to be more their full selves, and so they get to connect in all kinds of other ways region, area of academic interest, religion, politics, etc.. So what we found is that people came in waiting to see how things would go participating and some of these sort of structured activities feeling a sense of belonging. But then also and this is, I think, another part of the HBCUs experience then becoming active participants in building belonging for others. So even within the focus groups that we did, people started reaching out to each other. Oh, you're struggling with that. Hold on. Afterwards, stay on this call and let me hook you up with this person who can help you with that problem. So there was a lot of, I think, sense of responsibility as a part of this university community to also build belonging for other students. I can imagine that it can also translate over after school. Right? So at the graduation, I'm pretty sure they carry the students. They carry along the same characteristics of helping others, being an asset, being sponsors and being mentors to others, whether it's their alumni network or out there in the world when they're interacting with other right? Definitely. And I think, I mean, a lot of the HBCUs, part of their sort of culture of the institution is a sense of community service. So that's also part of it sort of getting acculturated. And then also, I think for many schools, this is true for some other universities too, and also including HBCUs. The alumni network is strong, and that feeling of connection persists long after people leave. What's interesting also is that all of this is done in a setting with a fair amount of resource constraint, because most HBCUs do not have a lot of resources. And even though we were at one of the most elite, which was Morehouse, where we were interviewing people, even still, I mean, Morehouse still struggles with funding also. So I think it's interesting to and part of what we were hoping people would see from this study is ways to apply it. Even outside of the HBCUs context. There's many, many universities in excessive resource constraint. So we're just, I think, trying to show there's a lot of ways to build belonging and help students connect with the institution that don't necessarily require these massive infusions of cash. I have a question. Was it done pre-COVID or during Covid? After Covid? It was. Yeah, yeah. Well, after but. Some most of the students we interviewed spent like their first year remote or a high school year remote. So they were still feeling the close effects, but it was after the worst of it. I'm curious, you know, your research, a lot of your research focuses on colorism. How do you see colorism showing up within academic institutions among like faculty and staff and administration? Because I've read different things, I've heard different things. But I want to know, like from your research standpoint, what have you seen as far as how colors and serves up amongst university faculty and staff and administration? That's a good question. I don't I haven't actually done a paper on that. Maybe that should be next up in my Q, but I think anyone who's spent and this probably applies to you also, anyone who spent any amount of time at like elite institutions of higher education can see that there's a disproportionate amount of light skinned people, mixed race people, people adopted by white parents, etc.. So I think that the many ways that whiteness works its way into black experiences is highly salient in higher education. I mean, just like other forms of discrimination around colorism, in terms of employment and who seems like they would be a good fit, or I was doing air quotes for the listening audience or who. Feels familiar, who's easy to get along with, you know, for for black folks who've been around more white people and are used to being around white people is an advantage in predominantly white environments. Yeah, I can just speak anecdotally. I don't know, doctor, about your experiences, but I know that when I in most of the universities that I've worked in, when I see other black professors, they're usually lighter skinned. So I have noticed that. And that's something that I think as the public, as there is more discourse around color ism online, that's something that I see being brought up because, you know, colors and shows up a lot in the workplace. But specifically, I have anecdotally just seeing, you know, in higher education, for example, I was working in a business school in Connecticut and there were only three faculty, only three black faculty in the business school, and all of us were light skinned myself into black men. And I just found that to be really, really interesting. The other black professors outside of doctor E that I know, the lighter skinned black women. So it's just it's a really fascinating thing. So I, you know, I'm sure that when you do, whenever you do decide to do that research, it'll probably just affirm what a lot of people have been saying online for a while now. Yeah, I think so. I mean, I think that higher ed is not immune from the kinds of discrimination that's happening in all of these other spaces. Yeah. I'm curious. And doctor, even I'll give you the mic. I'm really curious, like how you've seen as somebody who studies colorism, I don't know if after you started studying colorism, it became like the red car effect where you started seeing it becoming more prominent. But how have you seen colors and manifest in your own life? Because I think as somebody who does this research or maybe very keenly aware of colorism, how it impacts you, how it shows up in your life. So how have you seen it show up in your life? Constantly for sure, I think, I guess I feel like, I sense that people sometimes try to forget that I'm black, both in my professional life and personal life, and that especially if they're uncomfortable. So. And then when something happens that reminds them, it's like a little like a hiccup, right? A little a little hiccup. I think in the context of the university. I feel like other leaders or administrators turn to me to ask about various whatever the racial or political issue of the moment is that we're dealing with on campus, assuming that I'll be a. Easy person to talk to about it. And I don't think that that is always what they get. But I think the assumption is because I'm light skinned and maybe because I'm mixed, that I'll, I'll be easy to talk to about it. And I think it makes it hard sometimes also to. Express the kind of anger that I share over all these things, just like everyone else. But on the other hand, it does give me access to spaces and to people to talk to about things who otherwise have a hard time listening. So I try to take that privilege seriously, but I'm not under illusions about the way that also reinforces disadvantage for people who have darker skin. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. I think it's good that you acknowledge and that you're doing research around this because like you said, a lot of what I've seen and I'm sure you've seen this to a lot of specifically black women who are more Melanie, who talk about colorism are often silenced or they are not listened to. And so I do think that there needs to be more people who benefit from this system of colorism, talking about it and researching it and doing the things that you're doing. Doctor E, I want to pass it to you because I know I'm dominating. I have so many more questions, but I don't want to be to overtake the conversation too much. I was going to piggyback and share my experiences as well. You know, I stumbled into academia by accident. So, for example, I spent my time on Wall Street. I, I only lasted six months because I couldn't take the, you know, micromanagement. So I said to myself, let me just go back to school and pursue a doctorate. But I realized that, yeah, you need some teaching experience as well as research. So when I was applying, I remember applying to a school in Manhattan, Marymount Manhattan College, and I, was able to get that job by accident because the a tenured professor who I believe was was an Indian descent. He was injured. I believe he broke his hip. So I, I just happened to be there, you know, emergency. We need to get you in and start teaching right away. And that's fine with me. I had no issues, as you know, when it comes to that experience. But when I was able to navigate from Mario Mountain College to my alma mater, Queens College, from Queens College to Columbia University, Columbia University, NYU, UCLA, Dartmouth College, where I'm doing some program as well. So I was able to get those roles by accident. You know, someone dropped out last minute. We need someone to come in a safe to fill in the void and basically save the day and salvage the situation. So that's and I think that has nothing to do with race. Based on my experience, however, I wanted to talk to you guys about names. Sometimes names can be discriminate a form of a discriminating factor here. Sometimes when they look at my name, my name is short Eli, Eli, Joseph. But my full name is Elisee. It's a French name. So when they look at it, they have some preconceived notion until I show up and they're like, oh, I did not be. I thought, your name, you live like a Tyrone or a Michael. So names can also play a role in terms of how people, especially in academia, will receive roles. I'm not sure if you guys will agree or you know, or you guys may have some some other suggestions, but I think sometimes names can play a factor into how people can be treated. There's a lot of research on that showing that, you know, people who have more recognizably black names get less callbacks, less interviews, etc. over and over and over and over again. Or even. Maybe their name is not recognizably black, but their address is in a black neighborhood. Same. So there's been a lot of, big studies about that. So it's really interesting. I agree 100% matters a lot in terms of getting access for sure. Yeah, I worked with I was consulting with a company and yeah, I agree with you, Doctor Maggie, where there's so many studies specifically with like black sounding names. But I remember reading a study that they did in Sweden with like, Swedish sounding names and Arabic sounding or Arab sounding names, and they found the same thing where people with more Arab sounding names got less callbacks on their resumes. But I remember I was consulting for this company, and I told them that they should adopt like an anonymous resume system because of name bias and name discrimination. And the HR manager told me, well, we actually like to see the names because we try to get priority. If we see someone has like a Hispanic sounding name or a black sounding name. And I thought that that was really, really interesting because it was kind of like the reverse, because, you know, people say, okay, name bias is a thing. Well, to address that, we anonymize resumes. So we can't see the name or zip code or any demographic identifiers. So I thought that that was super interesting that they were like, no, we're specifically looking for. But I think that that's like murky because there are a lot of black people who don't have black, black sounding names. There are, you know, there is I think the guy who runs the who does something with the fed. Eli. Right. His name is Tyrone, or he has a black name. I'm forgetting his exact positioning. Trump was trying to get him out or get him ousted. And he's out. Yeah, he's out I think. Yeah, yeah. Is it? His name's not Tyler. It's something. And I was like, wait, is this a black man? And I remember when I first looked him up, I was like, no, that's definitely so it's like it's tricky when you when you set off of that because there isn't like a, like, you know, there isn't a one size fits all. I just saw a TikTok about a girl who said that. I think her last name was Li Li. She's a black woman and she was applying for a job, and they brought her in for the interview, but said she wasn't a good fit for the culture and the the demographic of the employees and the managers interviewing her were mostly East Asian, and so they asked her if she had anyone she knew that might be qualified like her. And so she tapped on her friend, who was also East Asian. He ended up getting the job, and it confirmed to her that they had only brought her into the interview because they thought she was also East Asian. When they saw she was black, it was like, oh, we don't know if you'll fit the culture. So I do think to to go back to, you know, your question, doctor, that that's a a very real issue. Doctor. Maggie, I had a question for you. So for the listeners who have followed your work, maybe watched the the documentary on the own channel, like girls who are like, I've been shouting from the rooftops, the color is a thing, but people don't want to listen. I think there's one of two rebuttals that come up when people bring up colorism conversations, especially Darker skin people is like, you're being divisive, right? So I see that a lot where people say, well, we're all black, so there's no point in stratifying us and and trying to differentiate. And then I also hear this weird thing where people say color ism goes both ways. And because you may be like, I may be a light skinned person who was called light bright or Mello Yello. That is a form of colorism and not the systemic sorts of harms that darker skinned people experience. Have you like, based on your research and all the work you've done? Do you have any suggestions for how people can sort of like, rebut the rebuttal? You know, because these are common things or people, you know, I follow colorism conversations in the media and celebrity might say, you know, I don't know if you followed, but if you ever watched the show, Martin, the actors who played Pam, she went on a podcast and said something about how colorism wasn't an issue, and people pushed back and said it is an issue, even if maybe for you individually, you didn't see it or experience it. So I try to follow a lot of these conversations. But do you have any thoughts on how people can approach the conversation? Because there is within the black community, people can kind of try to come up with these rebuttals. Yeah, I actually have strong feelings and a lot of thoughts about this topic. And maybe I should start since you brought up Light Girls framing it in that context. So I was asked to be like, you know, expert on light girls and speak a little bit to the history of colorism. But that team, that director and creative team did a previous film called Dark Girls and Dark Girls, in my opinion, was a more thorough exploration of colorism. It was told about, interviewed a lot of everyday people, and it explored the penalties essentially for darker skin across a range of different fields, but particularly in interpersonal relationships. Like girls. I think they were conceiving of it as a kind of other half of the story, kind of like you just described, which I understand but don't actually sociologically agree with because and I think you're alluding to this maybe in the way you phrase the question to have. And I'm and I don't want to minimize it too much, but I'll just start out by saying, like, to have your feelings hurt is not the same as losing out on money, job, and educational opportunities. And I don't want to minimize having one's feelings hurt because that can be painful. And like girls in that film, it wasn't my my part was sort of like historical context. They interviewed a lot of like, celebrities, actually, who were light skinned about their experiences, and some of them told sort of extreme stories of being astrocyte or bullied or whatever because they were light. And I think that that happens, obviously, when I did interviews with people, light skinned women also shared those kinds of things. But there is a kind of. Both sides in it that I don't think fits what's actually happening. Yes, it can be painful to be called, like you're not really black, you aren't really part of it, the group, etc., etc. but it doesn't have the same kind of material impact on people's lives. And honestly, the emotional tolls of. The same kind of teasing for darker skinned people, I think is much, much, much more profound. So I don't feel too comfortable with the kind of. People trying to make it a symmetrical experience. I don't want to say there's nothing happening for light skinned people. Of course there can be challenges, but overall, I think the big story is that discrimination against darker skinned people. Yeah. And in your research, I know you've looked at not just the black community, but it's something, you know, looks at the Chicano community you looked at, you know, it's not something that just happens in the US. And I would even argue in, you know, my parents are West African and it's very pervasive in West Africa. Maybe doctor E, I'm not sure if, like in Haiti, bleaching creams are big, but they're really big in Cameroon and Nigeria and in Ghana, I think Ghana band banned them, but they're really big. And so I think it's it's a really pervasive issue. But I hear within the black community, you know, one of the things I also hear people say is, well, white people see us all as the same. They can't tell one person from another. So why are we doing this? Like crabs? And I see people say this crabs in a bucket or crabs in a barrel mentality by trying to tear each other apart. Right? But that's actually not true because white people do distinguish between us, which is why lighter skinned people have better jobs, more income, more education attainment, lighter prison sentences, etc., etc., etc. so I think that's a really like a real misunderstanding of what's actually happening. And it's a kind of 1970s understanding of it. And what I mean is, like, I think back in the day, we saw, like Ebony magazine would run a cover story on color and people would be like, oh, why are you putting our dirty laundry out like that? But that is a that was an older way of seeing it and seeing it as something just internal to the black community. But in fact, it's, as you said, global phenomenon of which we participate. So, yeah, that that is a real misunderstanding. And also, interestingly, a researcher from Harvard who's I think a political scientist, she did a really interesting study about political attitudes and skin tone among African Americans. And she found her argument was basically, if lighter skinned people are having such different sociological experiences, more money, more integrated neighborhoods, more educational attainment, etc., then darker skinned black folks, then it would stand to reason that they would have different political attitudes as well. But we actually don't. Our political attitudes as black people are very similar, but our experiences of blackness are actually quite different, right? So, and I'm not saying whites can people don't experience discrimination. Obviously they do. But it's different, right? It's different because they're getting a little bit more access to some of the resources in the country. So there's just some interesting things there. I think about what it is to be black in the United States. So maybe, as you were saying earlier, white people do not see us all in the same way, but we see the country in a very similar way. Interesting. I was wondering how much social media plays a role in terms of the narrative, how we narrate this distinction, because sometimes he you mentioned 1970 and and how we may think, you know, the white people or the black people may perceive to see each other. But now social media has amplified everything. You know, there's just a we talk a lot in, in detail J that, you know, light skinned women or light skinned people may can get away with fabricating some things and just because they look appealing or, you know, beautiful, they they can be able to escape and, you know, escape some of the accountability that they may have compared to that of a black person who may have done the same thing, who may have committed fraud, or who may have, you know, have some, you know, false falsified documents. So I think and I was wondering if there should be some, some documents or research on how social media plays a role in amplifying, you know, the distinction between how darker skinned people get treated compared to light skinned. Yeah, that's a really interesting question. I don't I'm sure someone is doing something on that. I'm not sure myself. But I do know there's been a lot of research on criminal justice sentencing. So kind of along the lines of what you're saying, like having to have consequences for things that you've done. There's a lot of research, actually, on both school discipline and criminal justice sentencing. And they all point to the same thing, which is that the darker skin and some of it is also on facial features, like the more sort of black facial features you have, the worse your sentences are like, the longer and the harsher your school discipline is like more likely to be expelled rather than suspended or just chastised or whatever. So I agree with you that that skin tone definitely plays a role in who's seen as like a victim versus a perpetrator and all that kind of thing. And I don't know, Doctor Maggie, if you've done I can't remember if I saw your research, but how does it show up or how do you see it show up in I, I, you know, I feel like just based on the research that's going to show up in the, the classroom, like within universities, and it's not something that I was really paying attention to back when I was in undergrad, you know, where I there were more I didn't go to an HBCU, but I went to school in Virginia, and there were two neighboring HBCUs where we would all kind of come together and do things. So it was like a UI into how use I didn't really notice it. But in graduate school and in my doctoral program, I was like one of the only black people, so there wasn't even a thing. But I imagine that in undergrad it shows up a lot in the classroom for students, where maybe there are there's a lighter skinned student and a darker skinned student. And the differential treatment, I guess that it's probably less pronounced because there's maybe far fewer than at an HBCU where it's just very like. And I think of movies like School Days, where I think it was very, you know, it was very specific to like the sororities and the fraternities and, and it was very it was more pronounced. But I wonder, have you done any research in the classroom specifically looking at student treatment and how color is a may show up for students within higher education? I have not done any in higher ed, but I have supervised some student research over the years and they're pretty interested in like who is invited to participate in the white Greek system that are people of color, for example. And so there's a lot of and so I don't have, like. You know. Strong research to, to share. But I think anecdotally, there's definitely something happening in the classroom and, and outside the classroom. But on campus that is really showing privilege in terms of like access to opportunities and that kind of thing for lighter skinned black folks and lighter skinned people of other groups, also other people of color. I think one of the studies I've always wanted to do, but haven't done yet is I'm interested also in how. Whiteness because, I mean, arguably the whole skin tone thing is sort of like proximity to whiteness. But I think it's also interesting to think about proximity to whiteness outside of phenotype, but thinking about it in terms of like, white parents. So I'm curious. I would love to do or have or see someone else do a study where maybe like in a K through 12 setting, they investigate how different kinds of black students fare when their black parent comes in to advocate on their behalf, versus a white parent coming in to advocate on their behalf. There's a lot of research on the power of white women, especially in settings that have to do with children. So I just think it would be really interesting to see that aspect of whiteness intervening in black lives as well. Yeah, I think that would be really interesting. Like whether the child is adopted or they're biracial and how like what role? Because I imagine that having a white person advocating for you would make you more listen to by teachers, maybe discipline less. So that would be really interesting. Also the teachers to the teachers, the administrators, the principals, vice principals, you know, the assistant principal. Sorry, that can also play a role in terms of leadership in comparison to in how they may not treat, how they may interact with darker skinned children compared to skin children as well. Yeah. Doctor. Maggie, you were saying that there's research about discipline, right? I feel like there's probably a lot of research on that, maybe specifically with black boys and how if they're darker skinned, they may be suspended, more disciplined, more than their lighter skinned counterparts. And I think just black boys in general are are more likely to experience that. I'm Doctor Maggie, I'm really curious. Like, I know you also do dye consulting. How do you sort of bring these conversations up in the work that you do with corporations? Because I think it's still one of those things that maybe more abstract for people from a workplace context, like doctor Eve is talking about social media, right? We see these conversations happening in social media, but I don't know if people quite fully understand how colorism shows up in the workplace unless they are directly impacted by it. So how do you bring up these conversations when you do the work that you do within corporations? Most of the dye consulting work that I do is in universities and tends to be around not so much colorism, but managing issues of either faculty and student diversity or managing racial incidents that blow up, because that's sort of well, as you both know, you're in higher ed, regular part of life in higher education. That's just how things go. And so that sort of more of the focus of the things that I do there. And I think for me, one of the things I tried to talk a lot about is, you know, at universities, among the sort of group of leaders broadly defined on any campus, they're usually always a couple of people of color, often black, though not always or very outspoken, who are always sort of needling the leadership about, like, what they're doing and telling them that they're doing something wrong, which is often true. And I think that typically presidents, provost, deans, etc. tend to push those people to the margins and see them as causing problems, stirring things up hard to deal with, etc. but my experience is that though they might be hard to deal with, they are often correct with their assessment of what they think is actually happening and their suggestions of how you might try to handle whatever is happening. And so one of the things I try to do is help leaders think about how to bring people in who they might see as quote unquote difficult, but who might actually help them get ahead of something or help it from getting worse and worse and worse if they bring them in early, instead of letting everything blow up and then waiting to talk to that person three weeks later, while now the whole campus is like in some kind of crisis. So I, I mean, part of that is, you know, maybe going back to the original question we started with, which is like, what is my role and how do I see myself on campus? But I try to help leaders who are often white, think about listening a little bit more to people of color and maybe getting trying to understand why they're mad and be able to hear what they're actually saying. Do you think tenure also plays a role in some of that dynamic from how, you know, like how certain roles are being allocated and or, you know, certain faculty members are pursuing and actually getting these roles? I wonder if they have resource on that, like to look at every black faculty member who's earned tenure and whether there is like, I just wonder. That's really fascinating. And you push back from those who may have not gotten tenure. And, you know, obviously the reaction it can blow up sometimes where, you know, you have some people that were not granted tenure. And and now it's a big problem. And all of a sudden it's basically how do we try to salvage the situation. I wonder if that there are some research data or data about that. That's a good question. I mean, there's definitely a lot of research about who gets tenure and who doesn't. And not just tenure, but like promotion all the way up. And it won't surprise you to know that black people have lower rates of promotion and tenure and promotion all the way through. There are more black faculty in various kinds of adjunct roles than tenured roles, more at associate professor rather than full, etc.. Yeah. I think when someone is denied tenure, it's definitely. Cause for concern and at least investigation. The problem is that a lot of places, those processes are pretty closed, and so it can be hard to learn much about what actually happened, and it can make it hard then the community to sort of appeal on someone's behalf, even informally. But that's part of the kind of gatekeeping of higher ed, which is to do a lot of things behind closed doors. Yeah, I imagine that there is probably research because I think, you know, based on the research, lighter skinned people just in general are lighter skinned black people. And I feel like of any ethnicity are more likely to be hired. So I think that starting out, there's probably already going to be more light skinned black people at whatever levels. And then when it comes to advancement, because so few black faculty are actually able to advance that, I just don't envision, I'm sure if somebody has research on that out, it would indicate that, you know, there's clear like racial or color skin tone stratification when it comes to who's granted, who's granted tenure. And I also, you know, I'm one area that's similar but not quite that I'm really fascinated by is like hair discrimination, you know, when whether that also plays a role in both aspects, like students who show up with certain hairstyles. Because I know when I was in undergrad, I never even in my PhD program. I never really wanted to wear certain styles. And then when I became a faculty member, I still was like nervous. But I felt a little bit more freedom. And I would get feedback from students at mostly white universities when I would change my hairstyle, when I would wear my hair straight before I cut my hair, and students would be like, I love your hair, you know? And just even in like I do wonder, like when it comes to student evaluations, if a faculty member has like a big afro versus one who has braids or who has straight hair and they're all black, same skin tone. Whether hairstyle will play a role in perceptions. But I think that all that kind of goes back to what you were saying, Doctor Maggie, about, like, I don't know if it's I think skin tone definitely plays a huge role, but I wonder if also like where you went to school, who you know, whether you know, whether it's an HBCU or not. Are you if I'm an AK or if I'm a Delta, if the it's I think there's so many factors that play into it. But I would I would guess if someone has done research, it would indicate that it's mostly lighter skin or predominantly lighter skinned people who've advanced within the university system, because I just think there's more lighter skin people even starting out within higher education. Yeah, I agree, and I think the other piece that affects things a lot is the kind of research that you do. So if you're a black faculty member and you study, I don't know, something in mechanical engineering that's pretty highly technical. That's a different situation than if you're a black faculty member in public health studying black women's mortality in childbirth. And you're involved in community engaged research, where you're working with different black community organizations around birthing, I mean, that's a very different kind of research profile that has a lot more opportunities for white people who are or others who are uncomfortable to take out their discomfort in the process. Yeah. Yeah, I've I think I've exhausted all I've had. So, you know, I've exhausted all my questions. One question. Yeah, I have one final question. And I like to throw these type of questions out to all of my guests here. But it's different for this episode. My question to you, Doctor Maggie, is what keeps you optimistic despite the challenges that 1st May face in academia. What keeps you optimistic with all that's going on today? I work at a university. That is, I guess you would call medium sized. So I have small classes. I know my colleagues well, and consequently I really get to know my students. And I really have gotten to know a lot of my colleagues and the daily work of what we actually do with most of our time, either teaching our students and mentoring our students, or doing research, and especially a lot of community, engaged work. That reminds me of what we're actually supposed to be doing. And that gives me a lot of not just personal joy, but like. Hope that, like, this is the main thing. Like, you know, I thought we might talk more about AI, for example. And one of the things that I think AI is robbing universities of is a human connection, that that learning is best done in community. And when I'm with 25 of my students and we're talking about something difficult and they're starting out the conversation, tiptoeing a little bit around each other, and then someone takes a little bit of a risk and share something sort of personal or takes an intellectual risk, and then someone else does and the conversation really gets going. Like, that is the magic of real learning together. And I feel like it only really can happen together, and that I feel a lot of respect for my students. I feel like we're in good hands with the young adults who are coming up. I feel like they have a really clear sense of social justice. They have a healthy skepticism of things they should be skeptical of. I feel optimistic about what they're going to contribute, and I feel like it's been a gift to be in this profession for those reasons. I love that. I love that, especially given the work that you do, it's really easy to become dejected and to feel like, is this? I sometimes feel like, is this making an impact? Our these systems actually going to change? So I think that that's a great framing to the listeners, to myself, to Dr. Eli, about how to say optimistic, especially during times like these. Dr. Maggie, we appreciate you for joining Thank you so much for all your insights. It was so wonderful to meet you. I hope the listeners enjoy this episode because I definitely enjoyed talking to you. Oh, I enjoyed the conversation so much. Thank you. This is the ballroom and we're signing out right now. [Theme Music] of a scholar and a business minded soul. We at the academic forum. Yeah, we keeping it 100. If you're looking for the truth. Well, you finally found it. Take a seat at the head. Let the dialog flow. It's a masterclass. Five. If you did it now you know.