Latest / Surrounded / Evan Revisits His Most Viral Debates | Surrounded Follow-Up
Transcript
- 0:00I don't know why there has been this idea
- 0:02that women should want to aspire to work 80 hours a week in order to be on par with men.
- 0:08No offense to Candace,
- 0:10but I think for opponents that I don't necessarily
- 0:13think are like
- 0:15really strong
- 0:17debaters or incredibly confident,
- 0:18the claim that we live in a matriarchy is so silly.
- 0:21I'm here with Evan.
- 0:23Welcome to the Surrounded Follow up.
- 0:25You are a frequent guest on Jubilee's channel.
- 0:28Yeah,
- 0:28thanks for.
- 0:29Having me appreciate it excited to get into it
- 0:31before we kind of dig into the eclipse.
- 0:32I'm just curious,
- 0:33like,
- 0:34uh,
- 0:34how do you kind of see Jubilee as a tool for,
- 0:38for you and your own ideas because
- 0:40of,
- 0:40of all the people I,
- 0:41I can probably remember
- 0:43you on set the furthest back
- 0:46of anybody who
- 0:47kind of has
- 0:48reappears in in the formats today.
- 0:50How is the the channel been useful to you and
- 0:54the goods,
- 0:54the bads?
- 0:55The first video I had done was uh.
- 0:58Ground and it was before Surrounded had had existed
- 1:00yet or like maybe right before it existed yet.
- 1:03I definitely find value in it.
- 1:04It's certainly sharpened my own
- 1:07debate
- 1:08and uh presentation skills.
- 1:10It's helped me elucidate my ideas.
- 1:12Moments like these also give me the opportunity
- 1:15to research and almost like refine a lot of
- 1:19my ideas or talking points or even just knowledge on certain subjects.
- 1:23It's been an enjoyable experience,
- 1:25hence why I keep returning.
- 1:28Well,
- 1:28that's good,
- 1:28that's good.
- 1:29We're,
- 1:29we're obviously uh grateful to have you.
- 1:31What is your background?
- 1:33Do you have background in politics or policy?
- 1:35Cause,
- 1:36you know,
- 1:36of all the people I can
- 1:38You're probably one of the most knowledgeable people um who returns to the show,
- 1:43especially around like foreign policy.
- 1:44You
- 1:45either you're really good at researching and remembering
- 1:48what you
- 1:49gather or you have,
- 1:51you know,
- 1:51more experience that's worth kind of opening up.
- 1:53I do have a bachelor's degree in political science with a minor in philosophy,
- 1:58but outside of that I have no real tangible experience outside of being very
- 2:04having had been very.
- 2:05Politics since a very young age.
- 2:07In fact,
- 2:08uh,
- 2:08it's funny,
- 2:09my,
- 2:09uh,
- 2:09aunt recently just posted an old photo that she found of me getting
- 2:13interviewed in 2016 outside of a Trump rally
- 2:17and I had like a Bernie sign.
- 2:18I,
- 2:19I very much distinctly remember that because it's
- 2:21what I expected to be just like a classic
- 2:24mainstream media interview,
- 2:25just a general interview,
- 2:26and then it ended up turning into like almost like a radio
- 2:30gotcha of uh the,
- 2:31the person trying to grow me and
- 2:33I,
- 2:34I think that experience along with
- 2:37maybe a few other experiences I went and tried
- 2:39to challenge Ben Shapiro at at uh Berkeley where my
- 2:42friends were when he when he visited that college
- 2:44campus at one point I've seen clips of that.
- 2:47I,
- 2:47I also challenged,
- 2:48uh,
- 2:48Dave Rubin back in 2019
- 2:51so I've just been very involved I guess in the online political sphere,
- 2:55you know,
- 2:55being.
- 2:56Very into politics is most of where,
- 2:58where I've got my experience,
- 2:59but
- 3:00you know,
- 3:00uh,
- 3:01having some background of a formal education doesn't,
- 3:04uh,
- 3:04definitely doesn't,
- 3:05uh,
- 3:06hurt either.
- 3:06OK,
- 3:07so let's do choose your own adventure.
- 3:08I've got clips from
- 3:10the episode
- 3:11recently with Dave Rubin.
- 3:13I also have a clip from Exchange You Had with Piers Morgan
- 3:16and Candace Owens,
- 3:17which,
- 3:18which feels like,
- 3:18uh,
- 3:19the place that you wanna start because they're.
- 3:21No,
- 3:21no,
- 3:21no,
- 3:21and we have a Rudy Rockman clip.
- 3:23Let's start with,
- 3:24uh,
- 3:24Dave Rubin since it's fresh.
- 3:27OK.
- 3:27Wokeism did not kick 17 million Americans
- 3:30off of their health insurance through Medicaid.
- 3:32Wokeism didn't start a disastrous war with Iran
- 3:34that has now led to inflation outpacing,
- 3:36uh,
- 3:37wage growth.
- 3:38Wokeism hasn't,
- 3:39uh,
- 3:39ripped up
- 3:40institutions or attempted even
- 3:42to destroy free speech even by your.
- 3:44Standards because
- 3:45uh Ronald Reagan appointed judge
- 3:47uh ruled that the Trump administration was violating
- 3:49the First Amendment by attempting to uh deport,
- 3:52arrest,
- 3:52and detain
- 3:53students and faculty members on college campuses for protesting for Palestine.
- 3:56Um,
- 3:57wokeism
- 3:58to me it doesn't
- 3:59doesn't even have.
- 4:01Uh,
- 4:01remotely as disastrous as a track record as Donald Trump.
- 4:04Well,
- 4:04how would you define wokeism?
- 4:05I guess we should start with,
- 4:06I think wokeism is a pejorative term that's
- 4:08used to describe left wing cultural politics,
- 4:10right?
- 4:11And what do you think left wing cultural politics are?
- 4:13I'd say left wing cultural politics include,
- 4:16uh,
- 4:17just the broad,
- 4:18um,
- 4:19broad attitudes towards social justice,
- 4:21especially for
- 4:22minority groups,
- 4:23um,
- 4:23that have faced,
- 4:24uh,
- 4:24persecution in various ways.
- 4:25OK,
- 4:26so I think the simplest way to define wokeism is
- 4:28basically.
- 4:30Collectivism on steroids and usually as it applies
- 4:33to race
- 4:34and gender meaning that you should be judged based on the color
- 4:38you actually should be judged based on the color of your skin
- 4:40and your sexuality and your gender and a whole bunch
- 4:43of immutable characteristics and depending on where those fall
- 4:46on the left's kind of hierarchy of importance
- 4:49that's kind of how you can parse out where
- 4:51people should be and how important their ideas are
- 4:53so assuming your characterization to be
- 4:56an accurate accurate characterization which I.
- 4:58Don't necessarily take,
- 4:59we're gonna have a lot of trouble
- 5:01getting can you actually demonstrate that wokeism has,
- 5:04for example,
- 5:04skyrocketed inflation out to outpace wage growth the way that
- 5:08Donald Trump's war of aggression on Iran has done?
- 5:11Can you,
- 5:11can you demonstrate that wokeism has violated the First Amendment
- 5:14by arresting students and
- 5:15faculty members on college campuses?
- 5:17So
- 5:18you and Dave sparring right there.
- 5:20Anything come back to mind?
- 5:21Just kind of reliving that clip.
- 5:23What stood out to me was the fact that instead of
- 5:26Immediately addressing with,
- 5:28you know,
- 5:28some of the points that I had brought up which were all,
- 5:31I tried to lay out,
- 5:31lay out very material and specific examples in which,
- 5:36you know,
- 5:36Donald Trump has hurt Americans because
- 5:38his claim was relative
- 5:40of the damage of America of wokeism between wokeism and Donald Trump.
- 5:44And what stood out to me is he immediately sort of pivoted to
- 5:48his definition.
- 5:49And I don't really know how to engage with that necessarily,
- 5:52and to me it almost seemed as though
- 5:55he's so used to speaking
- 5:57with
- 5:58people who agree with him on the Ruben report.
- 6:00He's used to,
- 6:01you know,
- 6:02going down,
- 6:02uh,
- 6:04Sort of dialogues that like a lot,
- 6:05a lot of his audience and the person
- 6:08in front of him is going to nod along to
- 6:10and instead of like hashing out whether or not
- 6:13this definition of wokeism is accurate or whether or not
- 6:16the people that he's characterizing as woke are in the right or in the wrong,
- 6:20tried to get him to give me something substantive back
- 6:23that is at at the very least comparable to the examples that I had brought up.
- 6:27Yeah,
- 6:28I mean this was something that came up when I talked to Mason as well.
- 6:31I
- 6:32I hear what you're saying like,
- 6:33and this was something that was going on in,
- 6:35in his episode
- 6:36quite a bit was like,
- 6:38where's the access of this debate?
- 6:40We jumped around a lot.
- 6:41We jumped around a lot of topics.
- 6:42It was,
- 6:43it was kind of hard to pin down.
- 6:44I think I,
- 6:45of all the episodes I've ever
- 6:47moderated,
- 6:47I maybe got the crankiest during that one because
- 6:49it was just like it was hard to follow.
- 6:51If I'm going to kind of steel man
- 6:53what Dave is saying there.
- 6:55Wokeism is a,
- 6:56it's a fuzzy term,
- 6:58but this idea of like
- 7:00wokeism is essentially
- 7:03judging people
- 7:05partially by the contents of their character
- 7:06but also explicitly by immutable characteristics,
- 7:10race,
- 7:11uh,
- 7:11sexuality,
- 7:12gender,
- 7:13these things that um
- 7:15Maybe
- 7:16historically haven't been as important to contextualize somebody's ideas
- 7:20are now more important.
- 7:21Like if you're a white person,
- 7:22you have to acknowledge your privilege more or we
- 7:25need to acknowledge some of the context in which
- 7:27uh your ideas or your achievements occurred.
- 7:31Do you think that,
- 7:32you know,
- 7:32some of what there's a kernel of truth to what uh Ruben is,
- 7:35is,
- 7:36is saying there
- 7:37when someone like Dave.
- 7:38describes wokeism in that way.
- 7:40I think what they're getting at is
- 7:42they see a lot of maybe people with among the online left describe
- 7:47either
- 7:49black communities in one way,
- 7:50the Asian community in one way,
- 7:53people of color,
- 7:54white people,
- 7:54and they see that language as being
- 7:57racialized or
- 7:59in,
- 7:59in their eyes discriminatory.
- 8:01They almost see
- 8:02The promise of racial justice being one that is color blind,
- 8:05whereas
- 8:06a lot of the left sees racial justice
- 8:09necessarily needing to be
- 8:11anti-racist and addressing
- 8:13racism head on and recognizing that we live in a racialized society.
- 8:17And so I,
- 8:17I think that that is sort of
- 8:19where they're
- 8:21maybe where they're the underlying ideas that they're trying to
- 8:24espouse are coming from.
- 8:26But what I would just say is,
- 8:28you know,
- 8:28even if I were to acknowledge or
- 8:30even accept maybe some of the framing of,
- 8:33of,
- 8:34uh,
- 8:34the positions that they have that yeah,
- 8:36there's probably some
- 8:37weird characterizations of,
- 8:39of race that,
- 8:41you know,
- 8:41maybe
- 8:42some leftist either academics or people online need to rethink.
- 8:46I don't see it as being
- 8:48even remotely as comparable
- 8:50as
- 8:51the.
- 8:52Material harms that Donald Trump's
- 8:55either policies
- 8:57in terms of economics or
- 8:58you know his wars of aggression
- 9:01or uh violations of people's civil liberties in this country
- 9:04have done and it feels
- 9:06to me like the perfect.
- 9:07encapsulation of
- 9:09what the right is so good at,
- 9:10where they're they they're they're so good at weaponizing these
- 9:14these culture war issues
- 9:16to make people not really think about the
- 9:18tangible salient stuff that affects their lives.
- 9:22Yeah,
- 9:22and this comes up.
- 9:23I want to pull up the Pierce Martin clip because this is exactly what you
- 9:26you get into with him and it actually gets a little fiery.
- 9:29It's fun.
- 9:29I hear what you're saying.
- 9:30I mean,
- 9:31even if we think about like the war in Iran,
- 9:33as we speak,
- 9:34you know,
- 9:34it's,
- 9:35it's
- 9:36The ceasefire has ended.
- 9:37It's kind of like sparking,
- 9:39you know,
- 9:39erupting again,
- 9:40and we'll see
- 9:41where it goes,
- 9:42but
- 9:42there was kind of a promise for it to be quick
- 9:44and handled and complete,
- 9:47and yet we see it sort of like
- 9:49bursting up
- 9:50again,
- 9:50and there might be economic consequences to that.
- 9:52So
- 9:54I acknowledge that.
- 9:56For the most part,
- 9:57cultural issues have been.
- 10:00I don't wanna say a complete distraction,
- 10:02but they have been more to the benefit of
- 10:05like the right side of the aisle for politics.
- 10:08But how important,
- 10:09how true,
- 10:11and how much they matter to Americans is kind of like,
- 10:13that's where I
- 10:15I wonder if the left downplays it more than maybe they should,
- 10:19and you and
- 10:19Piers get into that and and get into the data,
- 10:22so let me pull up that clip.
- 10:23Now bringing the sexist in.
- 10:24I don't then there's no problem.
- 10:26Why do you think Imam Khalif is not sure I don't
- 10:28want you to distract from the fact that the election,
- 10:30there is no evidence that people voted based on
- 10:33their opinions on transitivity give it to you.
- 10:35No,
- 10:35wait,
- 10:35no,
- 10:36wait,
- 10:36let me,
- 10:36let me.
- 10:37In a in a Gallup 2024 poll,
- 10:39yes,
- 10:40in a Gallup 2024 poll
- 10:42post-election out of 22 issues,
- 10:44trans,
- 10:45uh,
- 10:45trans issues ranked 22 out of 22.
- 10:48Every in every election in all OCD countries across the world,
- 10:51inflation and the economy,
- 10:53yes,
- 10:53but I just let you go on.
- 10:55No,
- 10:55let me just respond to you.
- 10:57Actually,
- 10:57if you.
- 10:58Read The New York Times the week after the election.
- 11:00I did read The New York Times,
- 11:01then you will remember a deep dive they did into it.
- 11:04Wait a minute,
- 11:05just stop talking.
- 11:05You,
- 11:06you wanna talk all the time.
- 11:07Sorry,
- 11:07sorry.
- 11:07Show me some respect.
- 11:09Sorry.
- 11:09There was a New York Times report into a particular commercial ad,
- 11:13you know,
- 11:13campaign ad that the Trump,
- 11:14uh,
- 11:15side put out,
- 11:16and they originally started it in a few sports arenas,
- 11:18and it got bigger and bigger and bigger.
- 11:19And the ad was basically a 32nd mashup of
- 11:22Kamala Harris endorsing
- 11:24trans athletes in women's sport and in women's spaces and so on and so on.
- 11:28And it ended with Kamala is for they them,
- 11:31Donald Trump is for you.
- 11:32The New York Times
- 11:33said that they believe that move the needle,
- 11:35their reporting
- 11:37by as much as 3 points based on what
- 11:39information.
- 11:40Ask the New York Times.
- 11:41No,
- 11:41that's not you,
- 11:43you understand news agencies
- 11:44aren't conducting,
- 11:45uh,
- 11:45pulling it off the
- 11:46financials.
- 11:47That's.
- 11:47The same article cited the Gallup poll that I just identified where
- 11:51transitions ranked 22 out of 22.
- 11:531 ad moved the needle by 3 points and based on what information polling
- 11:57if you poll people on what issues that they cared about in the in the 2024 election,
- 12:02all of it was centered around economy and inflation.
- 12:04And this is just obvious because this is a global phenomenon.
- 12:07Evan,
- 12:07Evan,
- 12:08and every incumbent party across the world.
- 12:10A lot of a lot of Democrats and and people on the woke left in particular
- 12:14have tried to assure me
- 12:16that absolutely nobody cares
- 12:18about trans athletes in women's sport.
- 12:20People care,
- 12:21the right cares,
- 12:22but let me tell you your median
- 12:23voter cares more about what's in their pocket
- 12:25question for you is and you're doing
- 12:27exactly what I claimed you were doing
- 12:29by using wokeism to distract from my question.
- 12:31Do you think he's,
- 12:32he's falling into the same trap as Dave?
- 12:35Yeah,
- 12:35um,
- 12:36also I looked into,
- 12:38so this is something that I knew
- 12:40Piers had talked about frequently,
- 12:42and I remember trying to look into it
- 12:44at one point before because I remember listening
- 12:47to debates specifically
- 12:49in regards to Pier Piers Morgan debating Iman Khalief and
- 12:52Uh,
- 12:52trans athletes in women's sports and whether or not it swung the 2024 election,
- 12:56etc.
- 12:56I looked into this even more though after this video was aired
- 13:00and
- 13:00what he's citing,
- 13:01it's not the New York Times.
- 13:02The New York Times was obviously reporting on it,
- 13:04but it wasn't their poll.
- 13:05It was a poll conducted by.
- 13:07Future forward,
- 13:08which was,
- 13:09um,
- 13:10I,
- 13:10I,
- 13:10I think it had something to do with
- 13:12uh uh internal polling with the Kamala Harris campaign,
- 13:15but there's no information outside of that.
- 13:17So unless you just wanna accept
- 13:20their results wholesale and ignore.
- 13:23Any other bits of information.
- 13:24There's there's just not enough data to suggest that.
- 13:27Uh,
- 13:28that ad or that trans athletes in women's sports are,
- 13:31are persuading voters in the way that,
- 13:33uh,
- 13:33I think a lot of
- 13:34Republicans,
- 13:35uh,
- 13:35believe it did in the 2024 election.
- 13:37Uh,
- 13:37there's an,
- 13:38there's an article specifically by the Independent
- 13:40that goes into additional research
- 13:42from that,
- 13:42but like my point,
- 13:43and I think
- 13:45what is really central is
- 13:46I don't even necessarily deny that like Americans have
- 13:49quite a few culturally right wing beliefs and they may
- 13:53have.
- 13:54A staunch disagreements with the left on those beliefs,
- 13:57uh,
- 13:57very often,
- 13:58even like Democrats are sometimes characterized as being too far left
- 14:01and usually that's because of
- 14:03culture war stuff.
- 14:04But
- 14:05if you look at the prioritization of issues,
- 14:08Americans most
- 14:10what they care about most is
- 14:11how they're doing in their material lives,
- 14:14you know.
- 14:16And I think it's very easy
- 14:18for them
- 14:18to be distractive
- 14:20because,
- 14:20you know,
- 14:21economics and foreign policy and a lot of these things are,
- 14:23are pretty complicated
- 14:25and that's not to belittle the average American,
- 14:27but it feels,
- 14:28it feels very simple to argue about whether or not
- 14:31a man can be a woman.
- 14:33It feels very
- 14:34Simple to argue of whether or not
- 14:36race should be considered when applying to colleges or universities and so
- 14:42I think that that undue focus
- 14:45ends up,
- 14:45you know,
- 14:46ends up playing into the hands of
- 14:49making that the forefront of our discussion
- 14:52when it really should be about these material issues
- 14:55and then when
- 14:56voters end up voting Republican,
- 14:58they get screwed on all the material issues
- 15:00because Republicans.
- 15:02Ultimately represent
- 15:03more of a capitalist billionaire class than the left.
- 15:07Well,
- 15:07and we're certainly seeing
- 15:08that argument play out right now.
- 15:10I mean,
- 15:10there's a lot of economic populism
- 15:13that seems to be sparking,
- 15:14especially on the left as we see these DSA candidates win,
- 15:18you know,
- 15:18Colorado just had that recent
- 15:19outcome and so that's very interesting to see play out.
- 15:22I feel torn though because I,
- 15:23I see that.
- 15:25There's a vibey truth to what Dave and Piers are saying.
- 15:28Like,
- 15:28I,
- 15:28I looked into it as well.
- 15:30I think the only thing I could find that that offered any
- 15:34definitive data was like AP vote cast.
- 15:36They said that 55%
- 15:38of the voters that they polled
- 15:40said that
- 15:41the left had taken transgender rights too far,
- 15:44but it wasn't ranked as like their top
- 15:46issue like you're saying.
- 15:47And so
- 15:48it is a little tough
- 15:49for me to nail down like how much do these culture war issues matter.
- 15:54When we think about just like the way topics behave online though,
- 15:58anytime we touch the topic of transgender,
- 16:01uh,
- 16:01the transgender debate on Jubilee,
- 16:04it goes mega viral and so.
- 16:07The question in my mind is like,
- 16:09is it just far right people who really
- 16:12can't stand trans people that are clicking on
- 16:14that and that's why it's getting views,
- 16:16or are there a lot of people who don't want to
- 16:18openly talk about it being a big issue to them,
- 16:21but they are very interested and concerned about it,
- 16:24you know.
- 16:25I,
- 16:26I,
- 16:26I like came up around the time that there
- 16:28was this big anti-social justice warrior movement like online
- 16:34with it,
- 16:35yeah,
- 16:36outdated term.
- 16:37But really,
- 16:38but really wokeism is sort of the revival of that.
- 16:41That same concept.
- 16:43It's actually really interesting because
- 16:46it
- 16:47prior to maybe
- 16:482015,
- 16:50trans issues was not
- 16:51a hot button issue.
- 16:52At the time,
- 16:53maybe like racial
- 16:55justice and racial conversations were much more prevalent.
- 16:58Ben Shapiro's most like viral content was often like doing
- 17:01the 1350 talking about
- 17:03uh black crime,
- 17:04etc.
- 17:05but trans issues weren't weren't really that
- 17:08uh big into the forefront.
- 17:10And what's so interesting
- 17:11is
- 17:12looking back,
- 17:13and this is something that I had to almost like remember
- 17:16later in life,
- 17:17but we had a trans man on our lacrosse team.
- 17:20And it was not at all considered
- 17:24even
- 17:24controversial or interesting.
- 17:26Like,
- 17:26I'm sure a few of the guys like made sort of like side comments about it,
- 17:30but nobody even cared to the extent that you would expect people to care
- 17:34or to be a part
- 17:35of,
- 17:36you know,
- 17:36drastic dialogue
- 17:38either in our city,
- 17:39town,
- 17:40or,
- 17:40or what have you.
- 17:41And I think that is Evidence of
- 17:43the conversation being pushed in a way
- 17:45that it's like it's not actually affecting people's lives or
- 17:48take the trans
- 17:49bathroom debate which also came before the trans sports debate.
- 17:53The question was always framed,
- 17:54well,
- 17:55what if someone can exploit the identity of being trans
- 17:59to assault people in bathrooms,
- 18:01but it's like we're making up fictitious.
- 18:04Scenarios of a problem that is not endemic
- 18:08or doesn't exist on any sort of widespread level
- 18:11and yet this conversation
- 18:13feels like
- 18:14it's uh it's it's it's what is you know at the forefront of
- 18:18what people are discussing in politics
- 18:20and
- 18:21my thing is I just don't
- 18:23I don't think it's necessarily like a total
- 18:25conspiracy
- 18:26but I don't think it that's organic either
- 18:29and when someone like.
- 18:30Elon Musk
- 18:31buys buys this
- 18:33platform Twitter and,
- 18:34and Elon Musk,
- 18:35I think this is very relevant because this is
- 18:37relevant to my conversation specifically with peers.
- 18:40When,
- 18:40when Elon Musk buys a platform like Twitter,
- 18:43obviously inflates and boosts his own
- 18:46presence on the platform algorithmically speaking,
- 18:49and then does put undue focus on these culture war issues
- 18:52while at the same time
- 18:53playing a part in the Trump administration.
- 18:55gutting
- 18:57federal agencies that are designed to protect consumers,
- 19:00protect workers,
- 19:01agencies that are,
- 19:02are meant to put a check on capitalists.
- 19:04Literally,
- 19:04the NLRB was investigating Elon Musk's companies like
- 19:08SpaceX
- 19:09and like,
- 19:09but instead,
- 19:10the entire conversation around Elon Musk is whether or
- 19:13not he's correct about his culture war assessments.
- 19:16It's like,
- 19:17that to me is almost
- 19:19the perfect
- 19:20uh succinct.
- 19:21Case of a billionaire
- 19:23pumping
- 19:24the conversation and discourse in America
- 19:27with this culture war nonsense,
- 19:29getting people to demonize trans people
- 19:32while,
- 19:32you know,
- 19:33running away with the money and the scandals and
- 19:36all the things that actually materially affect Americans that
- 19:39Americans should and usually do truly care about.
- 19:42And I agree with you,
- 19:43the conflict of interest that existed while he was running Doge.
- 19:47And,
- 19:48you know,
- 19:48just overseeing so many private companies that were
- 19:51obviously
- 19:52going to be impacted by the decisions he was making
- 19:55with Doge was staggering.
- 19:57So,
- 19:57uh
- 19:58we don't need to,
- 19:59there's nothing really to parse out there,
- 20:00that was just sort of a shocking moment.
- 20:02And the way Doge played out was just like unbelievably
- 20:05chaotic and
- 20:06it's it's unclear what was really achieved there.
- 20:08I will say though,
- 20:09I think it's just important to point out like
- 20:11these culture war issues did,
- 20:14you know,
- 20:14they were already sucking up a lot of oxygen before he even took over Twitter
- 20:18and then maybe on,
- 20:19you know,
- 20:19once he renamed it X and and took it over they became even,
- 20:22even bigger.
- 20:24But the thing,
- 20:25you know,
- 20:25the asterisk that always remains in my mind is like.
- 20:29Yes,
- 20:29these,
- 20:30these issues may play to the advantages
- 20:33of the right,
- 20:34but is the left making
- 20:36a tactical error in simplifying them and downplaying them,
- 20:39even if they're not,
- 20:40they're not widespread,
- 20:41like the,
- 20:42just going back to trans uh issues.
- 20:45Sure,
- 20:45it's a very small sliver of the population.
- 20:48There are
- 20:48going to be small edge cases where something goes wrong.
- 20:52But is the left trying to kind of brush
- 20:54over those things and not like unwind the nuance with
- 20:58average Americans enough
- 21:00so that they feel kind of represented that that was something I really.
- 21:04Got into with Mason,
- 21:05but I don't wanna,
- 21:06I don't want us to go down the same rabbit
- 21:08hole.
- 21:08Well,
- 21:08I think the answer to your question is actually what is
- 21:11happening right now with all of these DSA candidates because,
- 21:16you know,
- 21:16I don't,
- 21:17I'm not,
- 21:17I'm not gonna,
- 21:18I'm not gonna sit here.
- 21:19And say that
- 21:20some of these DSA candidates are getting elected because they believe
- 21:24in in far left things like prison abolition
- 21:27or or what have you that's also not deterring them from winning essentially
- 21:31that's because most of what is bringing.
- 21:34The,
- 21:35uh,
- 21:35a crowd to them
- 21:36is their populist economic platform
- 21:39and so I think it does actually show us that
- 21:41it's not necessarily a tactical error,
- 21:43but we can't,
- 21:44we can't fall into the trap of making it our focus,
- 21:47but we also don't need to sacrifice
- 21:50left-wing principles on these issues
- 21:52to be effective in political strategy.
- 21:55I wanna kind of shift back to the DSA candidates because
- 21:59what I'm hearing from you,
- 22:00and I do think this is an interesting thing to unpack in this moment,
- 22:03is
- 22:03you're saying look.
- 22:05What people voted on was the economy and so is the,
- 22:08if I extend that argument,
- 22:10are you saying the reason
- 22:11Democrats lost this last election
- 22:14was because of some of the errors that Biden made,
- 22:17you know,
- 22:17do you think he miscalculated inflation and
- 22:20or,
- 22:20you know,
- 22:21preventing inflation from getting as bad as it did underneath him?
- 22:24What was it like 9% was maybe like the high water mark?
- 22:27Do you think that was really just the original sin?
- 22:30That's,
- 22:30that's why,
- 22:31uh,
- 22:31the votes shifted.
- 22:32So much more in the other direction.
- 22:34I,
- 22:34I have a very cynical view also of the American people in that
- 22:38I do think that Biden
- 22:41was at the very least a pretty effective president
- 22:44in terms of his domestic economic policy with what he had
- 22:47given a split Senate.
- 22:48And although I'm no fan of Biden,
- 22:50especially in regards to his foreign policy,
- 22:52and
- 22:52as much as I
- 22:54do think that his
- 22:55treatment of Gaza
- 22:57was a,
- 22:58you know,
- 22:58a grave moral failure.
- 23:00And was certainly a red line for me as a voter.
- 23:03I also am not delusional that I don't think
- 23:05that that was what swung the election either.
- 23:07I do think it maybe played a non-trivial role,
- 23:09but
- 23:10I,
- 23:10I,
- 23:10I think that the economy was primary,
- 23:12and inflation is a very salient issue,
- 23:15and inflation was very a global phenomenon.
- 23:17And so I don't think it was necessarily Biden's mistake in how he handled inflation.
- 23:21I think that,
- 23:22uh,
- 23:22largely the Biden administration probably did even better than many
- 23:25was independent,
- 23:26so I mean they were.
- 23:27Sure.
- 23:28Besides the point,
- 23:29I think that,
- 23:30uh,
- 23:30that's not necessarily what his failure was.
- 23:32I think that just given the fact that incumbent parties
- 23:36all across the world lost elections because of inflation,
- 23:39it's
- 23:39sort of a natural consequence and you know,
- 23:41maybe that's just
- 23:43one of the flaws of democracy.
- 23:45One thing that I think the Democratic Party could have done
- 23:48to
- 23:49still given themselves a much better fighting chance
- 23:52is to have had Biden not.
- 23:55Run again.
- 23:56He should have
- 23:56never even decided to run again.
- 23:58I'll agree with you till the end of time on that.
- 24:00That was a
- 24:01huge
- 24:01error.
- 24:02So I,
- 24:03I think that if he never decided to run and if we had a primary
- 24:07and there was a candidate that was able to position themselves
- 24:11as being a change candidate away from the status quo
- 24:14because people were gonna be unhappy with Biden regardless,
- 24:17then Democrats would have had a much better shot
- 24:19at winning the 2024 election,
- 24:21but it was gonna be an uphill battle regardless and.
- 24:25Well,
- 24:25the last thing I'll also say on that is,
- 24:28uh,
- 24:28inflation is so salient and it's just really easy,
- 24:31I think,
- 24:31for people to
- 24:33see the price of goods rise and attribute that to
- 24:36policy,
- 24:37the economy,
- 24:38the world,
- 24:39things external to them,
- 24:41but they don't necessarily attribute that
- 24:44when it's like wage growth.
- 24:45So when they get a new pay raise,
- 24:47they look at that as being something
- 24:50that is attributed.
- 24:51Their personal success and
- 24:53it's not to say that it can't be but of course
- 24:55policy can affect,
- 24:56you know,
- 24:57wage growth or what have you so even if wage growth,
- 24:59which a lot of it did,
- 25:01especially for a lower
- 25:03um income groups in this country
- 25:05outpaced inflation,
- 25:06if they,
- 25:07if they still see the inflation they're going to
- 25:10um attribute those price rises to,
- 25:12uh,
- 25:12you know,
- 25:13bad economic policy or external factors and
- 25:16there's just I think a lot.
- 25:18There's not a lot you can do in that instance aside from
- 25:22maybe provide other forms of uh salient economic policy to
- 25:26where like they're they're getting tangible benefits that they can see
- 25:29the administration is fighting for them as fast and briefly as you can.
- 25:33Do you have any concerns about this wave of DSA candidates?
- 25:36Do you think this economic populism
- 25:39is.
- 25:41Could backfire against Democrats or do you think it's the right direction?
- 25:45I definitely think it's the right direction
- 25:47at this point.
- 25:48I,
- 25:49I,
- 25:50being someone who's been invested in politics for this long and
- 25:53having had the hope of
- 25:55Bernie Sanders potentially
- 25:57beating Hillary Clinton in 2016 and then
- 26:00especially again in 2020,
- 26:01but also like watching so many routine losses,
- 26:05I think this is like.
- 26:07Certainly the the most hopeful I've been since 2019,
- 26:10so I
- 26:11certainly think it's the correct direction and
- 26:14uh we're so far,
- 26:15we're so far away from,
- 26:17you know,
- 26:18the democratic socialist section of the Democratic Party
- 26:21having like too much political power or not
- 26:24doing the right thing with that political power
- 26:26that right now my focus is on getting political power and then,
- 26:30you know,
- 26:30we can discuss
- 26:31criticizing what,
- 26:32what it,
- 26:32how,
- 26:33how we're failing in,
- 26:34in various ways.
- 26:36Yeah,
- 26:36well,
- 26:36the ball is certainly moving in that direction.
- 26:38That's,
- 26:39and I,
- 26:40you know,
- 26:40I'm kind of calling this the,
- 26:41the hot socialist summer,
- 26:42you know,
- 26:43and
- 26:43it's just,
- 26:44it,
- 26:45it,
- 26:45it's been clearly going this direction for some time,
- 26:48so we'll see how it plays out.
- 26:49And
- 26:50what's interesting,
- 26:51I mean,
- 26:51like Zoran's a great case for this.
- 26:54Candidates like him really have an opportunity to,
- 26:58you know,
- 26:59show what they can do in governance.
- 27:01Before
- 27:02the presidential election and we'll kind of see how much
- 27:05of that philosophy is transferred to the presidential ticket based on
- 27:10the wins and losses of some of these candidates as they are in office.
- 27:14So
- 27:14something I'll be debated more in jubilee videos that you appear in.
- 27:19Let's shift to Israel.
- 27:20I'm gonna
- 27:20play a clip.
- 27:21This is between
- 27:22you and Rudy.
- 27:23You,
- 27:23I've seen you debate this topic many times and so you guys kind of get into.
- 27:28The definition of genocide,
- 27:29why it is or is not important to label what's gone on in Gaza as genocide.
- 27:34So I'll play that for you and then you know we can kind of unpack that.
- 27:37I think if the intent was to eliminate the entire population,
- 27:40then it would be a genocide.
- 27:42If the intent is to kill a lot of people in order to do ethnic cleansing,
- 27:45which is another thing
- 27:46which is also problematic,
- 27:47OK,
- 27:48so you're saying
- 27:49ethnic cleansing,
- 27:49not genocide.
- 27:50No,
- 27:50I'm not saying what's going on is ethnic cleansing.
- 27:52I'm saying that there are individual politicians who support the
- 27:55idea of removing Palestinians I'm not talking about individual politicians.
- 27:58Benjamin
- 27:58would be ethnic cleansing,
- 27:59and I'm against
- 28:00that.
- 28:01And you agree that the quote I cited earlier would
- 28:03be it would be the intent for ethnic cleansing,
- 28:05right?
- 28:06The way that you sourced it would be,
- 28:07but I don't think that that's actually what he said.
- 28:10We
- 28:10should,
- 28:10we should fact check it and see the whole entire entire context.
- 28:13If we find,
- 28:14if we find
- 28:14that Israel,
- 28:15if we find that,
- 28:16if we find that Bibi Netanyahu has the intent
- 28:18to remove all the Palestinians from Gaza,
- 28:20I am against it.
- 28:21And you would say that it would be ethnic cleansing.
- 28:24OK,
- 28:24great.
- 28:24So now,
- 28:25now that,
- 28:25now that we're,
- 28:26now that we're agreeing.
- 28:27That there's there's a difference between ethnic cleansing and genocide,
- 28:30and that I'm against both.
- 28:31Let's talk about the claim of it being genocide.
- 28:33Now,
- 28:34when we look at 2.2 million people living in Gaza,
- 28:37and
- 28:38max number is 70,000 by Hamas records,
- 28:40which we know Hamas is constantly lying about how many people are dying,
- 28:43for 70,000 people to have died,
- 28:45also this is in the past two years,
- 28:47there are 5000 people who are dying from natural causes every year,
- 28:50which is also included.
- 28:51The Hamas number,
- 28:52the natural causes are not included.
- 28:54That's false.
- 28:54If natural causes were included.
- 28:56The causes were included.
- 28:58You
- 28:58see excess death among youth and among elderly.
- 29:01You don't see that with the demographic data.
- 29:03The demographic data is actually directly from Hamas Israeli airstrikes.
- 29:07It's directly from Hamas.
- 29:08It's the Gaza Ministry of Health which has been reliable in Hamas.
- 29:11OK,
- 29:11so they've been reliable in every other armed
- 29:14conflict seeks to kill civilians is giving you your
- 29:17information.
- 29:17Why doesn't the Israeli military,
- 29:19if the Israeli military was operating under the laws of war,
- 29:21they would know how many Palestinian civilians have died.
- 29:24Why don't
- 29:25the best place to start.
- 29:26Because this is sort of like the axis of it is why is it so important and why
- 29:31does the debate keep coming back to the definition
- 29:33of genocide and whether or not that has occurred.
- 29:36I think that's a great question,
- 29:38John.
- 29:38I actually may have a different perspective on
- 29:41this and that I almost don't think it's
- 29:43really worth
- 29:45debating genocide with somebody who doesn't even believe
- 29:48what has happened in Gaza is unjust.
- 29:50I,
- 29:51I,
- 29:51I like,
- 29:51I think if you
- 29:52were someone who believes what's happened in Gaza is horrific,
- 29:56unjust,
- 29:56but maybe you're unwilling to
- 29:58Uh,
- 29:59give it the genocide claim,
- 30:01then I think the debate is actually
- 30:03worth having the discussion is worth having because
- 30:05really it's,
- 30:06it's a legal term,
- 30:07it's a historical term,
- 30:08um,
- 30:09it does it,
- 30:09does it reach that threshold?
- 30:11Does it reach that level?
- 30:12And I think that that would be a very interesting conversation,
- 30:14but with someone like Rudy who doesn't
- 30:17maybe believes that there are instances
- 30:19of.
- 30:19Unjust actions or instances of war crimes but doesn't
- 30:23believe that Israel has acted
- 30:25as a matter of policy in a way that is criminal or horrific.
- 30:29I would rather just
- 30:30stick in debate on that
- 30:32and that's part of why I
- 30:34just asked him whether or not he would concede
- 30:36to it being ethnic cleansing or at the very least
- 30:39the quote that I had cited that.
- 30:41The fact check ended up backing me up on
- 30:43was an explicit admission
- 30:45from Benjamin Netanyahu that he has an intent
- 30:48to ethnically cleanse the population because
- 30:50if I can just at the very least have you get you to admit that it's ethnic cleansing,
- 30:54that's a pretty damning admission
- 30:56uh from someone who is here to
- 30:59defend Israel's actions in Gaza.
- 31:02Yeah,
- 31:02and that's really interesting.
- 31:03I actually really like the way you structure that because I
- 31:08My instincts go in the same places
- 31:10whether or not it's genocide is maybe not as important as just being like do you
- 31:15believe that what has gone on there is
- 31:17unjust like instead of getting into the semantic trap
- 31:21just gauging like how are are you horrified or or not
- 31:24horrified by what has happened there because I think there's actually
- 31:27more consensus in that framing.
- 31:29I'm curious about
- 31:31because what where it naturally went right after that.
- 31:35What was interesting is right after that we then shift to the other popular
- 31:38cleavage which is
- 31:40Hamas.
- 31:41This information is coming from Hamas.
- 31:42Hamas,
- 31:43what is the intent of Hamas?
- 31:45They are kind of the governing body of Gaza.
- 31:49If I think about like high profile uh voices on this issue,
- 31:52let's
- 31:53let's talk about Sam Harris.
- 31:56He will kind of over and over again say yes,
- 31:59let's criticize Netanyahu,
- 32:01let's criticize the Israeli government,
- 32:02let's
- 32:03criticize some of the military action that has gone on there.
- 32:06However,
- 32:08The ideology of Hamas and their supporters
- 32:12and sponsors across the world is more concerning
- 32:16than the corruption and moral failures of
- 32:19Israeli leadership,
- 32:20and a lot of people
- 32:22vehemently disagree with him.
- 32:24But I'm,
- 32:25I'm curious like how you,
- 32:27where does your mind go when people,
- 32:29you know,
- 32:30go,
- 32:30what about the radical
- 32:32ideological strain that Hamas represents and what Israel's facing there?
- 32:36My mind goes
- 32:38to just
- 32:39understanding.
- 32:39That Hamas is not is
- 32:42is rather a culmination
- 32:44of decades of occupation and
- 32:46land dispossession and
- 32:49ethnic cleansing and um
- 32:51you know uh brutal
- 32:53either crackdowns or uh
- 32:55or what have you from from.
- 32:57The Israeli state on the Palestinian people,
- 32:59you know,
- 33:00Hamas came into power in
- 33:022006.
- 33:03Israel has been illegally occupying the Gaza Strip and the West Bank since 1967,
- 33:08and really Hamas is also a product of
- 33:12the failure of the Oslo Accords to
- 33:15adequately improve the Palestinians' lives,
- 33:18never mind
- 33:19the fact that,
- 33:20you know,
- 33:20a two-state solution never came out of it,
- 33:22but,
- 33:22uh,
- 33:23Palestinians
- 33:24were.
- 33:25Under worse conditions from,
- 33:27you know,
- 33:271993 when the Oslo Accords were signed,
- 33:29the PA
- 33:31formally recognizes Israel,
- 33:32and then by the time,
- 33:33you know,
- 33:342006
- 33:35is here,
- 33:36there's more settlements in the West Bank.
- 33:38There's tighter restrictions on Palestinian movement.
- 33:40There hasn't been an improvement in the lives of them
- 33:42whatsoever.
- 33:43And then,
- 33:43so,
- 33:44you know,
- 33:44Hamas wins in a plurality in Gaza
- 33:46by this point.
- 33:47And so yeah,
- 33:48I don't blame Palestinian people for maybe wanting an alternative and there's
- 33:52There's fair criticisms to be had about Hamas
- 33:56uh from like maybe an ideological standpoint.
- 33:58I'm not,
- 33:59you know,
- 33:59I'm not an Islamist.
- 34:00I don't share a lot of their views
- 34:03on various things
- 34:04and even from,
- 34:05you know,
- 34:05tactical perspectives or moral perspectives,
- 34:08but I think these are all discussions that need to be had within the context of
- 34:12how
- 34:12to approach liberating Palestine and when you're doing it from the position of
- 34:17you don't even
- 34:18Necessarily put Israel at fault
- 34:21for occupying Palestine.
- 34:23To me,
- 34:23it,
- 34:24it just,
- 34:24it,
- 34:24it feels to me
- 34:26like a,
- 34:26a complete non-starter and then,
- 34:28you know,
- 34:28the whole
- 34:29credibility
- 34:30credibility about uh death tolls like this is something that
- 34:34I find incredibly
- 34:35grotesque and frustrating because it,
- 34:37it is,
- 34:38and it was happening since even the early stages
- 34:40of Israel's um
- 34:43Israel's military actions in Gaza.
- 34:44People were,
- 34:45there was this popular article circulating,
- 34:47circulating around Zionist spaces where they're claiming that
- 34:50Hamas was just outright faking the death tolls.
- 34:52Now that
- 34:53they publish,
- 34:54the Gaza Ministry of Health publishes casualty data,
- 34:56verified deaths,
- 34:58they like Israel has
- 35:01Israel has a record of everyone who lives in Gaza.
- 35:04They have,
- 35:05if they wanted to verify
- 35:07the Gaza Ministry of Health,
- 35:08the Gaza Ministry of Health's claims,
- 35:10they would,
- 35:10and there's
- 35:11other reports that say that,
- 35:12you know,
- 35:13the Gaza Ministry of Health is vindicated in
- 35:15many of their reporting and so.
- 35:17Not to go on a tangent,
- 35:18but like it's just,
- 35:19I,
- 35:20it feels to me,
- 35:21yeah,
- 35:21like such a,
- 35:23a relentless,
- 35:24uh,
- 35:24undue focus when it's like,
- 35:25where is most of the harm coming from?
- 35:26It's coming from
- 35:27Israel's treatment of the Palestinians.
- 35:29So
- 35:30I wanna kinda
- 35:31Zoom out a little bit,
- 35:32think about more of like the domestic,
- 35:34uh,
- 35:34the way this plays out in domestic politics.
- 35:36I've heard people argue that,
- 35:38you know,
- 35:39this is actually one of the
- 35:41biggest fractures in America.
- 35:42Like this,
- 35:43this is becoming one of the,
- 35:44the clearest lines in American politics is,
- 35:46is your stance on
- 35:48Israel and,
- 35:49and the United States' relationship with Israel.
- 35:53I actually wonder though if there's more of a consensus forming.
- 35:56Uh,
- 35:57then.
- 35:59because
- 36:00very recently
- 36:02JD Vance has kind of really changed his tune
- 36:05on Israel and we're seeing
- 36:07sort of this approach to what's going on in Iran
- 36:10becoming much more
- 36:12of a,
- 36:13you know,
- 36:13we're hearing a lot more of frustration with the current administration
- 36:17and Netanyahu
- 36:18and JD Vance,
- 36:19who's obviously going to be one of the
- 36:21The candidates in the next presidential election seems to be kind of
- 36:24distancing himself
- 36:26from
- 36:27that allyship that that used to be,
- 36:30you know,
- 36:31more default.
- 36:32Do you think that there,
- 36:33we might be approaching,
- 36:35you know,
- 36:35an era where both the Democrat and the Republican candidates are,
- 36:39are trying to distance themselves from Israel?
- 36:41Is that where
- 36:42consensus is moving in the US?
- 36:44It's certainly
- 36:46where the consensus is moving among the American people,
- 36:49although I do think
- 36:51the
- 36:51this new right-wing
- 36:53Israel skeptic insurgents,
- 36:56I think is
- 36:57more overblown online than what is actually represented
- 37:01among the American people.
- 37:02I think that a lot of conservatives especially
- 37:05take more of
- 37:06maybe just like a a A bit of an either way view like they,
- 37:10they can be frustrated with
- 37:11Israel,
- 37:12but overall they're gonna
- 37:14back them,
- 37:15especially in the context of,
- 37:16you know,
- 37:17a war against Iran.
- 37:18Like most Republicans
- 37:20still do,
- 37:21you know,
- 37:21support Donald Trump's actions
- 37:23in Iran.
- 37:23Most of them do still say that America doesn't support Israel
- 37:27too much or what have you,
- 37:29whereas it,
- 37:29it's Certainly is a consensus
- 37:32now among
- 37:33Democratic Party voters that that to me is without a doubt.
- 37:36Over 70% of Democratic Party voters
- 37:38believe that Israel committed a genocide in Gaza.
- 37:40An increasing share of people across America do believe that Israel played a role
- 37:45in persuading Donald Trump
- 37:47to get into a war with Iran,
- 37:49which is a very unpopular war,
- 37:50of course,
- 37:51and so.
- 37:53It is,
- 37:53but I think what's really frustrating and
- 37:56what's sort of the moment right now
- 37:58is that
- 37:59the consensus is almost flipped when it comes
- 38:02to the actual representatives who are
- 38:04supposed to represent their constituents is,
- 38:06you know,
- 38:07if you were to pull,
- 38:08you know,
- 38:08the representatives,
- 38:09you're not gonna get.
- 38:1170% of Democrats saying that Israel's committing a genocide.
- 38:15You're not going to get
- 38:16the vast majority of people
- 38:18claiming that the United States supports Israel too much.
- 38:21You might either see a little bit of the status quo
- 38:24or maybe a little bit of rhetorical pushback,
- 38:26but certainly nothing substantive.
- 38:29And you're and is that because you think there's such a strong lobby here,
- 38:33like making sure that that politicians are more
- 38:35cautious about what they say on this issue?
- 38:37Yeah,
- 38:37I think that
- 38:38the lobbying certainly has a role.
- 38:41I do think it's also ideological.
- 38:43I think many of the,
- 38:44you know,
- 38:44boomers in Congress today or even people,
- 38:48uh,
- 38:48within,
- 38:48you know,
- 38:49the Gen X generation,
- 38:50I think that they all.
- 38:52Have you know.
- 38:54Quite frankly,
- 38:55Islamophobic
- 38:57tendencies and just view
- 39:00Israel as an extension of the West and its defense against the Islamic world.
- 39:05So I think that that certainly plays an un-trivial role as well,
- 39:09um,
- 39:09but
- 39:10yeah.
- 39:10I want to move on to just our last clip,
- 39:12but
- 39:13that even came up in the Dave Rubin
- 39:15episode,
- 39:15you know,
- 39:16he
- 39:17There were multiple times where he kind of insinuated that the incompatibility
- 39:22between.
- 39:24The religion
- 39:25of,
- 39:26you know,
- 39:26Islam is a religion and uh Western values,
- 39:29Western culture.
- 39:30You're certainly hearing that come up
- 39:32more and more and more.
- 39:33There's kind of a resurgence of like,
- 39:35have we gone wrong and drifted from
- 39:37Judeo-Christian values and,
- 39:39and is
- 39:40Islam a threat to
- 39:43the health of,
- 39:45you know,
- 39:45the West.
- 39:46I,
- 39:47you're hearing more and more people talk about that,
- 39:49but you're also hearing more and more people,
- 39:50like I said,
- 39:51like Sam Harris,
- 39:52like pointing to
- 39:53Hey,
- 39:54there's a psy op possibly going that is
- 39:56convincing people that Islamophobia is a bigger issue,
- 39:59but there's more of like a credible threat there
- 40:01than
- 40:02smart people want to acknowledge,
- 40:04so.
- 40:04It gets very,
- 40:05very complicated and big.
- 40:07Islamophobia and anti-Muslim bigotry is just so
- 40:10much more accepted in today's politics.
- 40:12I mean,
- 40:13people like Randy Fine say some of the most explicitly
- 40:17outright anti-Muslim stuff all the time.
- 40:19They say Islam doesn't belong in the United States.
- 40:21These are like,
- 40:22you know,
- 40:23representatives.
- 40:23They said
- 40:24if I were to choose between
- 40:25Islam and a dog,
- 40:26I'd choose a dog every time.
- 40:28These are
- 40:29Statements that you could never get away with saying if you just replaced
- 40:33uh Islam with Judaism and for good reason.
- 40:36You shouldn't
- 40:37say any of those statements in regards to Judaism,
- 40:39but it's quite fascinating
- 40:42just how
- 40:43welcoming
- 40:44anti-Muslim bigotry is
- 40:46and uh how accepting it is that it's almost just
- 40:49like on on wholesale that it's just a part of,
- 40:52you know,
- 40:52mainstream.
- 40:54Uh,
- 40:54discourse
- 40:55that we can
- 40:55talk this way,
- 40:56you know.
- 40:57This is gonna
- 40:58come up
- 40:59again
- 40:59in a future
- 41:00episodes,
- 41:00so
- 41:01I'm sure we'll,
- 41:02we'll,
- 41:02we might even talk again about this.
- 41:04The last clip I wanna play for you because you really have done a lot
- 41:08is
- 41:08you and Candace Owens.
- 41:09So we're gonna kind of shift back towards culture war
- 41:12topics and
- 41:13feminism specifically.
- 41:15You would have thought that things would have
- 41:17gotten really heated between you and Candace,
- 41:18but she actually
- 41:20seemed to really like what you said and wanted to to talk more.
- 41:23So I'll I'll play you the clip and I,
- 41:24I just wanna kind of hear what it was like to go toe to toe with her.
- 41:28I don't know why there has been this idea.
- 41:30That women should want to aspire to work 80 hours a week in order to be on par with men.
- 41:36Do you think that interests are innate,
- 41:38or do you think that social interests are innate?
- 41:40So why is it then that for example in the
- 41:421980s only 25% of college graduates were women were.
- 41:45Now the majority of college graduates are women.
- 41:47That shows that because of the way that social pressures have actually changed,
- 41:51women's interests are actually now changing too.
- 41:53A majority,
- 41:53I think,
- 41:54or at least half of,
- 41:55uh,
- 41:56law school graduates are now women.
- 41:57It used to be the case in,
- 41:59for example,
- 41:59a few 100 years ago
- 42:01that a lot of,
- 42:01uh,
- 42:02primary philosophers like Emmanuel Kant,
- 42:04Hegel
- 42:04didn't even believe women could,
- 42:05uh,
- 42:05be reasonable.
- 42:06Now here you are today doing a debate.
- 42:08With me
- 42:09where we're using logic and reason to get to these
- 42:11and nobody here would dismiss the claim that you can't be rational or logical
- 42:16or be uh uh for example a great lawyer
- 42:18because you're a woman,
- 42:19right?
- 42:19So I,
- 42:20I totally agree with you that women,
- 42:22but I think they have actually entered into
- 42:24the workforce I mean entered into college under this
- 42:26external pressure of feeling that if you don't
- 42:28go to college you're going to be a failure
- 42:30and knowing
- 42:30that.
- 42:31Part of the way interests,
- 42:32yes,
- 42:32but we're disagreeing on where the pressure is coming from.
- 42:35Like I think that now the pressure is that if a woman doesn't enter the force,
- 42:38it's there's,
- 42:38there's no longer this idea that,
- 42:40OK,
- 42:40we're gonna come together as a family,
- 42:41whereas there was this reality
- 42:43that there was this understanding that you would have a partner.
- 42:45People were getting married when they were 1819 years old,
- 42:48our grandparents
- 42:49now
- 42:50it's because of feminism,
- 42:51and I'm saying this is actually this is the downside of feminism.
- 42:54Women no longer have that
- 42:56sense.
- 42:56They think that if you,
- 42:57they have to be pressured to go take out a loan to go to college,
- 43:00and then
- 43:01you have the pressure to get,
- 43:02well,
- 43:02they have the same pressures as men because women no longer rely on it for an income.
- 43:06I did like our conversation.
- 43:08I might have to come back to you.
- 43:09Do you think Candace just agree with you because she's biased,
- 43:12uh,
- 43:12and
- 43:13partial towards men,
- 43:14or do you think you were really,
- 43:15uh,
- 43:15making some contact there?
- 43:17I do think I was making some progress.
- 43:21I,
- 43:21I think that I came into that conversation maybe a little bit less combative.
- 43:25I do remember
- 43:27some of the previous discussions being,
- 43:29you know,
- 43:29highly entertaining and
- 43:31I just wasn't.
- 43:33Yeah,
- 43:34exactly,
- 43:35and I wasn't as,
- 43:37I guess,
- 43:37in a combative mood and
- 43:39You know,
- 43:40no offense to Candace,
- 43:42but I think for opponents that I don't necessarily
- 43:45think are like
- 43:46really strong
- 43:48debaters or incredibly confident,
- 43:50like to me the,
- 43:51the claim that we live in a matriarchy is so silly.
- 43:55I,
- 43:55it's,
- 43:55it,
- 43:55it's hard for me to get
- 43:57upset in a way.
- 43:58It,
- 43:58it feels as though I have to explain why that's not
- 44:00the case rather than debate why that's not the case.
- 44:03I'll,
- 44:03I'll,
- 44:04I'll leave it at that,
- 44:04but
- 44:05I do think I was making headway in that
- 44:07she was acknowledging
- 44:09that social pressures do actually
- 44:12change the way that both men and women
- 44:15may be interested in certain fields,
- 44:17you know,
- 44:17I mean,
- 44:18the World Cup is happening right now.
- 44:20I am more interested in soccer than I ever was,
- 44:22and now I kind of want to start.
- 44:24Watching it.
- 44:24If I grew up in Europe,
- 44:25I probably would have already been into it,
- 44:27but
- 44:27because I grew up in the United States,
- 44:29you know,
- 44:29so our environments play a role in just
- 44:32simple things of where and what we're interested in,
- 44:35and I do think that I was making progress,
- 44:38but I was a little disappointed that she didn't pick me at the end.
- 44:40Yeah,
- 44:41I know.
- 44:41I thought she would as well.
- 44:43I actually did a follow up with Candace.
- 44:45It was uh audio only,
- 44:46but people listeners can go back and
- 44:48listen to that.
- 44:49We ended up in a very strange place at the end of our conversation where it wasn't
- 44:54exactly even clear to me if she thought that women should have the right to vote,
- 44:57and this is actually kind of what I wanna hear from you is like,
- 45:00you know,
- 45:01Candice has migrated
- 45:02significantly over her career across the political
- 45:06spectrum.
- 45:06She started out pretty far on the left.
- 45:08I think she might have even been.
- 45:10You know,
- 45:10identified as a progressive and then
- 45:12gradually moved to
- 45:14the right and then became,
- 45:16you know,
- 45:16a,
- 45:17a smash hit for the Daily Wire.
- 45:20Then
- 45:21moved so far maybe into conspiratorial territory that
- 45:25she left the Daily Wire and now she is
- 45:28I don't know if she's
- 45:30the most popular spokesperson for this theory
- 45:33that Erica Kirk,
- 45:35you know,
- 45:35and maybe
- 45:37Israel were behind the assassination,
- 45:40the assassination of Charlie Kirk.
- 45:41I actually don't even know what her stance is,
- 45:43but it's gotten so
- 45:45Extreme that
- 45:48To be honest,
- 45:48I don't even know if we would have her on the show
- 45:51in light of those things.
- 45:53There was some pause already,
- 45:55but.
- 45:57What's going on with Candace?
- 46:00I don't know.
- 46:01It's uh it's actually funny to watch.
- 46:03I mean,
- 46:04even today,
- 46:05there was,
- 46:05she was posting
- 46:07texts of
- 46:09her and Charlie like talking bad about Ben Shapiro,
- 46:12saying,
- 46:12look,
- 46:12Charlie never liked Ben Shapiro.
- 46:14And Ben is saying,
- 46:15if you
- 46:16think Candace is smart,
- 46:17you're a stupid person.
- 46:19He didn't use that language,
- 46:20but
- 46:20we'll say that.
- 46:21And it's like you are the one who hired her.
- 46:24Uh,
- 46:24she was saying crazy stuff even when she was a part of the Daily Wire and a part,
- 46:29she said at one point that,
- 46:30uh,
- 46:31Hitler's issue wasn't
- 46:32his nationalism,
- 46:33it was like that he wanted to go beyond Germany,
- 46:36it was his internationalism.
- 46:38You know that the,
- 46:39so I,
- 46:40she's always to me
- 46:42been very bizarre.
- 46:44She's very charismatic and entertaining,
- 46:46and I think that's what
- 46:48is,
- 46:48you know,
- 46:49captivating,
- 46:49but
- 46:50I,
- 46:51I,
- 46:51I've,
- 46:51I've never taken her to be
- 46:54a serious
- 46:55ideologue if that makes sense.
- 46:57And so,
- 46:58yeah,
- 46:58it,
- 46:59it's also not surprising to me that she's maybe flirted ideas of,
- 47:02yeah,
- 47:02women not being able to vote or what have you.
- 47:05But yeah,
- 47:05now she's on,
- 47:06yeah,
- 47:07a completely different train.
- 47:08The big contradiction of it all was I found her to be utterly
- 47:13Completely pleasant and uh and even like a delight to
- 47:17talk to and work with leading up to
- 47:20recording and just sort of like arranging it
- 47:23like
- 47:24there's there's the charisma you're right like there's some sort of
- 47:28she has some skills and talents that um
- 47:31maybe overindex
- 47:32the rigor and skepticism she has when it comes
- 47:36to.
- 47:37Pulling apart some of these ideas and theories that she,
- 47:40she opens up on her show.
- 47:42But even when I spoke to her,
- 47:43she
- 47:44saw herself
- 47:45and she saw her podcast as a hobby.
- 47:46She didn't really see herself as
- 47:48a leading
- 47:49voice in the political
- 47:51sphere in this country,
- 47:53but her show is one of the most listened to podcasts.
- 47:55So
- 47:56there's all these interesting contradictions that are really hard to unpack.
- 47:59She doesn't even seem to really believe she's doing what she's doing
- 48:02in the way that
- 48:03we think she's doing it.
- 48:05I mean,
- 48:05yeah,
- 48:05that,
- 48:05that also makes sense because I know of a lot of people who
- 48:09started
- 48:10or a lot of like women my age especially
- 48:12who didn't really know of Candace Owens but got into her content following,
- 48:16I believe the Johnny Depp
- 48:18case and trial or the Blake Lively one or
- 48:21some of these other more pop culture
- 48:24trials and then,
- 48:25you know,
- 48:25obviously a big
- 48:26feature of her content right now has been like whether or not the
- 48:29French prime minister has been dating a man or what have you.
- 48:32So it to me,
- 48:33she does seem
- 48:35So on that culture war train to like even,
- 48:39you know,
- 48:39well beyond someone like Dave Rubin
- 48:42and Piers Morgan where it's not even political,
- 48:44it's just sort of
- 48:46reality drama
- 48:48style content that it doesn't surprise.
- 48:50me that
- 48:51she came across as someone who saw
- 48:53what she does is more of
- 48:55a hobby or entertainment rather than like
- 48:58a serious ideological push.
- 49:00I mean,
- 49:00even with this whole Charlie story,
- 49:03it does to me feel like,
- 49:05yeah,
- 49:05it's more about the story itself rather than
- 49:09The underlying political
- 49:12implications of it.
- 49:13You know,
- 49:14I,
- 49:14I,
- 49:14I still really enjoyed,
- 49:15uh,
- 49:16seeing you,
- 49:17uh,
- 49:18debate her in that episode,
- 49:19and I would encourage all the listeners to,
- 49:21to go back and watch it if they haven't.
- 49:23OK,
- 49:23well,
- 49:23Evan,
- 49:24this has been
- 49:25really,
- 49:25really interesting.
- 49:26I,
- 49:27do you have any,
- 49:27uh,
- 49:28ambitions to enter
- 49:30politics explicitly or,
- 49:32or,
- 49:32you know,
- 49:33start your own show?
- 49:33You just,
- 49:34you seem to,
- 49:35to have a pretty strong grasp on,
- 49:37on.
- 49:38All,
- 49:38all of these,
- 49:39these issues.
- 49:40Yeah,
- 49:41I definitely wanna
- 49:42start doing,
- 49:43um,
- 49:44my own show.
- 49:45I,
- 49:45I'm,
- 49:45I'm still trying to figure out what sort of,
- 49:47uh,
- 49:47long form content I wanna do.
- 49:49I've been doing short form content for a while,
- 49:50so I'm gonna
- 49:51continue on that.
- 49:52Um,
- 49:52I don't have any ambitions,
- 49:53at least as of now,
- 49:55to get into public office or get into
- 49:57anything super explicitly political,
- 49:59but certainly I've been enjoying,
- 50:01uh,
- 50:01doing this.
- 50:02Well,
- 50:02great.
- 50:02Maybe we'll have you,
- 50:03uh,
- 50:04debating JD Vance in a future episode.
- 50:08Well,
- 50:08thanks again,
- 50:09Evan.
- 50:09Great seeing you.
- 50:10I'm sure we'll,
- 50:11we'll cross paths again on set,
- 50:12but you have a great rest of your day.
- 50:14Yep,
- 50:15you as well.
- 50:15Thank you.
- 50:16If you want to see more follow up episodes of Surrounded,
- 50:19be sure to like,
- 50:20leave us a positive review,
- 50:21comment if you're watching the video on YouTube.
- 50:24Uh,
- 50:24you can subscribe to Tubbili,
- 50:26Jubilee's second channel.
- 50:27You can also subscribe to Jubilee to see full
- 50:30Surrounded episodes.
- 50:31But however you want to support us,
- 50:33just thank you so much for listening.
- 50:35Remember,
- 50:35you could be wrong,
- 50:37so could I.
- 50:37Keep your mind open
- 50:39until next time.