Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Boy Who Stayed Behind | The Leaked Call and Autopsy Rocking the Nolan Wells Case
Transcript
- Nicholle: This episode covers the death of an 18 year old, the discovery of a body in water, disputed in In-Person: Separate five year one. Disputed. Nicholle: graphic audio recordings, and an active investigation with unresolved racial tension. No individual named in this episode has been charged with a crime and several claims discussed, particularly around a leaked emergency call are disputed, unverified, and still under investigation. We name people only as they've been named in public reporting and we ask you to hold every In-Person: And an active investigation with unresolved racial tension. No individual named in this episode has been charged with a crime, and several claims discussed, particularly around elite emergency call, are disputed, unverified, and still under investigation. We name people only as they've been named in public reporting, and we ask you to hold every theory loosely. Please take care while listening. Nicholle: Please take care while listening. In-Person: It's four thirty one in the afternoon on the fourth of July And a boat is limping away from a barrier island ten miles off the Mississippi coast. Not fast. Not normal. GPS records will later show it's crawling less than five knots for almost three miles before it suddenly jumps to over thirty. Somewhere in that stretch of water, a phone call is being made. A young man's voice asking for help. A sinking boat. a bilge pump that won't work, a dispatcher who can't get a straight answer to a simple question. And on that island behind them, getting smaller in the wake, is a young man who was last seen alive around three o'clock that afternoon, talking to a girl at the north end of the beach. He will not be on a boat when it reaches shore that evening. His mother will report him missing before midnight In less than forty eight hours, a National Park Service ranger walking the marsh at the edge of that same island will find his body face down in the water. His name is Nolan Xavier Wells, eighteen years old, a wide receiver, about to start his freshman season at a community college in Mississippi, and almost three weeks after his body was found, we still don't have a cause of death. Nicholle: Hey In-Person: What we have instead is a leaked phone call the internet says is damning, an independent autopsy that couldn't rule out foul play, a sheriff's department that says there's nothing to see here, and a family that has been begging in public for someone to just tell them what happened to their son. Hey everybody, welcome back to Coffee and Carn with Mom. I'm Zaley. Nicholle: And I'm Nicole and Zayley I have to say out of everything we've covered on this show, this is one of the first cases where the story is still actively moving while we're recording. We are not telling you the ending today because there isn't one yet. That's exactly right. And I want to say that upfront because you're going to hear us before a leg, before we end this meeting, more in this episode than almost any other we've done. This case is called... In-Person: That's exactly right. And I wanna say that up front because you're going to hear us use the words alleged, reportedly and disputed, more in this episode than almost any other we've done. This case is called Nicholle: No into In-Person: Nolan Wells online, but you'll also see it as Noah Wells. That misspelling took off early on social media and it stuck. this is the same case. Today we're calling him by his real name Nolan Xavier Wells. Nicholle: Ocean Springs, Mississippi sits right on the Gulf Coast across the bay from Biloxi. It's the kind of small coastal town where everybody roughly knows everybody and where a Fourth of July boat trip to a barrier island isn't some big production. It's just what you do. Horn Island is part of the Gulf Islands National Seashore. It's remote, undeveloped, about 10 miles offshore. No stores, bathrooms, no cell towers to speak of. In-Person: Just what you do. Horn Island is part of the Gulf Islands National Seashore. It's remote, undeveloped, about 10 miles offshore, no stores, bathrooms, no cell towers to speak of, just sand, marsh, and water on every side. It's popular exactly because it's empty. Nicholle: just sand, marsh, and water on every side. It's popular exactly because it's empty. Nolan Wells grew up in Ocean Springs. He just graduated high school and was about to head to Southwest Mississippi Community College to play wide receiver. Friends and family describe him as a strong swimmer and athlete, somebody with his whole life about to start. On July 4th, 2026, he went out to Horn Island with three friends from high school. In-Person: Nolan Wells grew up in Ocean Springs. He just graduated high school and was about to head to Southwest Mississippi Community College to play wide receiver. Friends and family describe him as a strong swimmer and athlete, somebody with his whole life about to start. On July 4, 2026, he went out to Horn Island with three friends from high school, Nicholle: all of them white, for a Fourth of July trip. That detail, that Nolan was the only black teenager in the group, In-Person: all of them white, for a 4th of July trip. That detailed that Nolan was the only black teenager in the Nicholle: is going to matter a lot as this story unfolds. And we're not going to pretend it doesn't. never came home. By the time his body was discovered today's day, this had already become one of the most watched, most argued about cases in the country. Split almost evenly between people who see a tragic drowning and people In-Person: Is going to matter a lot as this story unfolds. And we're not going to pretend it doesn't. He never came home. By the time his body was discovered, two days later, this had already become one of the most watched, most argued about cases in the country, split almost evenly between people who see a tragic drowning and people who see something covered up. Attorney Ben Crump, the family, the NAACP. Nancy Grace, TMZ, CNN, everybody's in this story now. And in the last week alone, a leaked phone call has poured gasoline on all of it. So let's start where it actually starts, not with the leaked audio, not with the press conferences, with four teenagers, a boat and a holiday. According to a Mississippi Department of Marine Resources Marine Patrol report, the same GPS records that are now at the center of this whole case, the boat left the dock on El Camino Railroad at nine fifty six that morning. It belonged to the grandparents Nicholle: The boat left with us on El Camino railroad at 9.56 that morning. It belonged to the grandparents. In-Person: of one of Nolan's friends. Four boys, one boat, headed out to Horn Island for the day. Nicholle: They In-Person: They arrived at eleven fourteen AM and then for the next five hours from eleven fifteen to four hundred thirty in the afternoon, the GPS shows the boat sitting completely still, anchored, a normal beach day, swimming, partying, being eighteen on the fourth of July. Investigators say Nolan was last seen alive around three PM on the north end of the island talking to a girl. Nicholle: arrived at 1114 a.m. and then for the next five hours from 1115 to 430 in the afternoon, the GPS shows the boat sitting completely still anchored. A normal beach day, swimming, partying, being 18 on the 4th of July. Investigators say Nolan was last seen alive around 3 p.m. on the north end of the island, talking to a girl. In-Person: That's the last confirmed sighting anyone has been able to pin down. Not from his friend's initial accounts, not from anything official since. Three o'clock, a conversation on a beach, and then according to what friends later told investigators, at some point after that the group decided to head back to the mainland and Nolan didn't go with them. Nicholle: Sheriff John Ledbetter told ABC News what the friend's account was. They left Horn Island and went back without note. From what we understood, he chose to stay there. The story as it was first told is that Nolan wanted to find another ride back later, so he let his friends leave without him. It's the kind of decision that sounds almost unremarkable on a beach in the daytime. Stay a little longer, catch a ride later, and unthinkable in hindsight on a remote island with no cell service as the sun starts going down. But here's the detail that doesn't fit neatly into he chose to stay. At 4.31 PM, one minute after the GPS shows the boat leaving Horn Island, In-Person: Stay the little stay a little longer. Catch you right like and unthinkable in hindsight on a remote island with no self service as the sun starts going down. But here's the detail that doesn't fit neatly into he chose to stay. At 4 31 PM, one minute after the GPS shows the boat leaving Horn Island, Nicholle: Somebody on that boat made an emergency call saying the vessel was sinking In-Person: somebody on that boat made an emergency call saying the vessel was sinking. Nicholle: and that's where the story stops being a simple beach day and starts being the case being the entire country is arguing about. In-Person: and that's where the story stops being a simple beach day and starts being the case the the entire country is arguing about. Okay. And we can double back to my statement later, but I have got to put this out there. I know a many of young black men and old black men. Okay, and I don't know of of a shade. I don't know one of them that would go to an island and not leave on the same vessel in which they arrived in and just be like, I'ma find a ride later with no cell service. How I'm finding a ride? How I'm gonna get the Nicholle: I don't know one of them that would go to an island and not leave on the same vessel in which they arrived in and just be like, I'm gonna find the ride later. Right. With no cell service. I'm finding the ride. We're on an island. In-Person: Did you leave a flare gun? Is there a messenger pigeon that's assigned to this island or like Nicholle: I can't get over. And I feel like these I don't know if these kids come from far around, but I mean, he could probably find her later at another point if it was if if that's what it was. it already. Yeah. It gets dicey. In-Person: That just that doesn't sound they don't sound right to me. Maybe it's dice. Nicholle: For weeks the public only knew fragments of what happened on that boat as it left the island. Then piece by piece, the actual audio started to surface. The first piece came out around July 16th through NBC News and Newsweek. Then CBS became more and TMZ published a fuller version on July 24th. And here's the thing people need to understand right away. This wasn't a call to 911. In-Person: came out around July 16th through NBC News and Newsbeat, then CBS Cain War, and TMZ published a fuller version on July 24th. And here's the thing people need to understand right away. This wasn't a call to 911. Nicholle: It was a call to CTO, a private towing and marine assistance company, a dispatcher reportedly named Vicki, picked up. In-Person: It was a call to CETO, a private touring and marine assistance company, a dispatcher reportedly named Vicky, picked up Nicholle: And this is close to word for word what was recorded. In-Person: and this is close to word for word what was reported. Nicholle: CTO assistance, this is Vicki speaking. How can I help you? In-Person: C tour instance. This is bigly speaking. How can I help you? Nicholle: Hey, we're at the west tip of Horn and our build pumps stopped working. Can y'all please come? In-Person: Hey, we're at the west tip of Horn and our bilge pump stopped working. Can y'all please come? From there the call gets strange fast. The dispatcher asked for membership information. Nicholle: and In-Person: Standard for towing service and the caller doesn't seem to know it or have it. He gives GPS coordinates instead. Then the dispatcher asks, How many dolts are on board? The caller says zero adults are on board. Nobody here is over the age of twenty-one, which understandably confuses the dispatcher. She has to clarify that she's not asking about legal adulthood. She's asking if there are living, breathing people on the boat who need help. The caller answers that everyone's accounted for, everyone's fine. At another point in the call, he says the boat is in thirty one feet of water and he wants it unsank and towed back to shore. Then it gets weirder still. The sea tow dispatcher relays the situation to the actual tow boat captain, telling him the kids on board sound panicked, Nicholle: and the captain called back and says that he just spoken to the boat operator's grandfather, man named Jerry, who told him the situation had already been handled and that they didn't actually need help. In-Person: And the captain calls back and says that he'd just spoken to the boat operator's grandfather, a man named Jerry Atkerson, who told him the situation had already been handled and that they didn't actually need help after all. Moments earlier, these same teenagers had been telling a dispatcher their boat was sinking and they needed rescue. Now suddenly everything is fine. Nicholle: obviously has been on the phone with the grandfather while all of this was happening. But that means that he's also talking to In-Person: the captain obviously had to have been on the phone with the grandfather while all of this was happening. What but that means that he's also talking to somebody. Somebody knows the situation on the boat. Whether it's somebody else in the room with the grandfather who's actually on the phone, relaying it to the grandfather who's talking to the captain, but there are other people involved. Because there's no way that you know exactly what is happening to tell the captain as they're on the phone with the dispatcher at the same time. Nicholle: And it's crazy because you would think if he knew it then he would if he knew they were calling the toll But then he knew they call because In-Person: They would have told them no, rather than call in the captain. Nicholle: he called the captain to stay don't worry about it we've got to handle In-Person: Right, so that right, so somebody had to have called after he was already on the phone with the dispatcher. Nicholle: Yeah Yeah, In-Person: It's somehow in simultaneous communication for you to know exactly what's happening at the same time and then you're telling the captain at the same time he's talking to dispatch everything is handled. Yeah. Somebody had to have called at while he after he called them. Otherwise, if it was handled, they wouldn't have called the grandpa would have just said, Don't worry about it, I got it. Nicholle: That's the only way that makes sense. In-Person: That's the only way that makes sense to me. Nicholle: Right, right, And that's just the first version of the audio that came out. On July 25th and 26th, a longer, unedited version started circulating. And this is where the internet lost its mind. According to multiple online creators who've listened closely to the full recording, there's background audio captured while the caller was on hold before the dispatcher even answered. Because CTO calls, like a lot of business lines, can start recording while you're waiting for someone to pick up. And in the background audio, several voices can allegedly be heard. In-Person: in the background audio several voices can allegedly be heard Nicholle: I wanna be very careful here because In-Person: want to be very careful here because Nicholle: This is the most explosive claim in the entire case. And it has not been confirmed by any law enforcement agency. In-Person: This is the most explosive claim in the entire case, and it has not been confirmed by any law enforcement agent. Nicholle: It comes from independent YouTube creators and commentators, not from the sheriff's office, not from the In-Person: It comes from independent YouTube creators and commentators, not from the sheriff's office, not from the Nicholle: coroner, and not from Ben Front's legal team making an official claim in a press conference. In-Person: Legal team making an official claim in a press conference. Nicholle: If it's real and if those words are being said about Nolan, it would mean he was on a boat, alive or dead, at a moment when the official story says he'd already been left behind on the island. This is an enormous gift. And we have listened to this 911 call on YouTube. In-Person: If it's real and if those words are being said about Nolan, it would mean he was on a boat, alive or dead, at a moment when the official story says he'd already been left behind on the island. This is an enormous if. And we have listened to this 911 call on YouTube. Nicholle: and I can't say what happened on the boat. I have no In-Person: And I can't say what happened on the boat. I have no idea what happened. Nicholle: What happened on the boat, but somebody is trying to cover something. Whether it was an accident, whether it was a fight, somebody's covering something up because, like Zay mentioned, there's no way that the grandfather had already was already speaking to the the tow captain when he's on the phone with the dispatch lady at the same time at the same time. In-Person: But somebody is trying to cover something up. Whether it was an accident, whether it was a fight, somebody's covering something up because like as they mentioned, there's no way that the grandfather had already was already speaking to the the tow captain when he's on the phone with the dispatch lady. At the same time. They're both talking to these people at the same time. and there's a timeline wrinkle that makes people even more suspicious. The GPS shows the boat didn't leave Horn Island Nicholle: a there's a timeline wrinkle that makes people even more suspicious. The GPS show, the boat didn't leave Horn Island. In-Person: until four thirty one. But during that roughly eight minute call, the caller describes the boat is already being in thirty one feet of water. Away from the island taking on water. Some commentators say that's consistent, the GPS mark could be the first recorded movement, not the exact second they pushed off. Others say the timeline doesn't add up at all and that's exactly the kind of discrepancy that makes people distrust the official account. Either way, a distress call, a sudden never mind, we're fine, and now a disputed recording that some people are calling an alibi call and others are calling Nicholle: Either way, a distress call, a sudden never mind, we're fine, and now a disputed reporting that some people are calling an alibi call and others are calling nothing more than four scared drug teenagers panicking about thinking vote. We genuinely don't know which one it is yet. But it's the single biggest reason this case has to close the way it has. Yeah, 'cause that's all definitely suspicious. Definitely, definitely. You could tell something is going In-Person: Nothing more than four scared drunk teenagers panicking about a sinking boat. We genuinely don't know which one it is yet. But it's the single biggest reason this case has exploded the way it has. Yeah, 'cause that call was definitely suspicious. Definitely, definitely. You could tell something. Nicholle: on there. Whatever happened on that boat, here's what we know for certain. It made it back to the mainland by 5 44 In-Person: Whatever happened on that boat, here's what we know for certain. It made it back to the mainland by 544. Nicholle: p.m. Nolan was not on it, and for the rest of that evening, as the sun went down over the Gulf, nobody seems to have raised much alarm. It wasn't until close to midnight after a phone call from one of the friends that Nolan's mother, Christine Wells Wandsley, called to report her son missing. Think about that gap. In-Person: of that evening as the sun went down over the Gulf, nobody seems to have raised much alarm. It wasn't until close to midnight after a phone call from one of the friends that Nolan's mother, Christine Wells Wandsley, called to report her son missing. Think about that gap. Nicholle: from roughly four thirty in the afternoon when the boat left to nearly midnight when a missing person report was finally filed. In-Person: from roughly 4:30 in the afternoon when the boat left to nearly midnight when a missing person report was finally filed. Nicholle: That's more than seven hours where an eighteen year old was alone on a remote, unpopulated island with no way to call anyone and apparently no urgency from the people who left him there. Disgusting. Warm. And so depth for the parents. Yeah. In-Person: That's more than seven hours where an eighteen year old was alone on a remote, unpopulated island with no way to call anyone and apparently no urgency from the people who left him there. Just disgusting one. And so devastating for the the parents. Nicholle: Once the report came in, the response was fast and large. The Jackson County Sheriff's Office launched a search that pulled in the U.S. Coast Guard, the Mississippi Department of Marine Resources, Gulf Islands, National Seashore Park Rangers, and eventually the United Cajun Navy In-Person: Once the report came in, the response was fast and large. The Jackson County Sheriff's Office launched a search that pulled in the US Coast Guard, the Mississippi Department of Marine Resources, Gulf Islands, National Seashore Park Rangers, and eventually the United Cajun Navy, a volunteer search and rescue group Nicholle: volunteer search and rescue group In-Person: that's become a fixture in Gulf Coast disappearances. For a day and a half they searched the island and the surrounding waters. Then on Monday morning, July sixth, between roughly eight thirty and nine AM, a National Park Service Ranger found a body in the marsh at the edge of the island's northwestern tip. Nicholle: That's become a fixture involved close disappearance. For a day and a half they searched the island and the surrounding waters. Then on Monday morning, july sixth, between roughly 8 30 and 9 AM, a National Park Service Ranger found a body in the marsh at the edge of the island north western pit. Face down in the water, Jackson County Coroner Bruce Lynn told C N that the swimsuit on the body matched. In-Person: Face down in the water, Jackson County coroner Bruce Lind told CNN that the swimsuit on the body matched the one in the last photograph anyone had of Nolan. Dental records would later confirm what everyone already feared. It was Nolan Wells. His mother had said hours before the body was confirmed, we pray our son is alive and safe. And instead, less than forty eight hours after he was last seen, laughing on the beach, Nolan Wells was gone. Nicholle: in the last photograph anyone had a known. Dental records would later confirm what everyone already figured. It was known what. His mother had said, hours before the body was confirmed, we pray our son is alive and safe. And instead, less than forty-eight hours after he was last seen, laughing on a beach, Nolan Wells was gone. So here's where this case starts to split the country into almost immediately. Sheriff John Ledbatter said publicly In-Person: So here's where this case starts to split the country in two almost immediately. Sheriff John Ledbetter said publicly Nicholle: That his offer did it suspect file play. He said that this looks like an accidental drowning In-Person: that his office didn't suspect foul play. He said that this looks like an accidental drowning You know if it was a accidental drowning, why didn't nobody say anything? Anywho, his exact words to ABC News, there's no information that we have right now that would lead us to believe that a crime has occurred. Nicholle: if it was an accidental drowning, why did nobody say anything or anything? His exact words to ABC News, there's no information that we have right now that would lead us to believe that a crime has occurred. Coroner Bruce Lynch In-Person: Coroner Bruce Lind said there were no immediate obvious signs of trauma on the body, but because of the condition Nolan's body was found in, he still requested a full autopsy from the state medical examiner's office. Very professional, we appreciate that. Nicholle: Said there were no immediate obvious signs of trauma on the body, but because of the condition, no one's body was founded. He still requested a full autopsy from the state medical examiner's office for his prejudice to agree with that. Thank you. In-Person: Specifically to check for any signs of foul play or trauma that weren't visible on the surface, Nicholle: specifically to check for any signs of foul play or trauma that weren't visible on the surface. In-Person: which is what you're supposed to do. Good job, Corporate Nart. So even in that first calmer version of events, a drowning, no suspected crime, there was already a hedge built in. Nobody was ruling anything out completely, but the headline that traveled fastest, especially in logo coverage, was simple. Nicholle: Which is what you're supposed to do. Good job, former nurse. So even in that first calmer version of events, the drowning of suspected crimes, there was already a hedge building. Nobody was ruling anything else, but headlines that traveled fast, especially in local coverage, was simple. No foul place, appearing case in the ground. In-Person: No foul play suspected apparent accidental drowning, which mind blowing. Nicholle: And almost immediately that conclusion ran headfirst into a very different set of facts circulating online. There was a video described by multiple outlets as showing what looked like an altercation on the island that evening In-Person: And almost immediately that conclusion ran headfirst into a very different set of facts circulating online. There was a video described by multiple outlets as showing what looked like an altercation on the island that evening. Nicholle: that started spreading on social media. Being front referenced it directly in a CNN interview. In-Person: That started spreading on social media. Bing Prump referenced it directly in a CNN interview, saying investigators hadn't explained why they weren't treating that footage as significant. And there was a deeper, more uncomfortable fact sitting underneath everything. A black 18-year-old had gone into the water and not come out. Nicholle: saying investigators hadn't explained why they weren't treating that footage as significant. And there was a deeper, more uncomfortable fact sitting underneath everything. A black eighteen year old had gone into the water and not come out on a trip with three white friends in a state with, as CNN put it, a complicated racial history. A sheriff saying no foul play without walking through his reasoning. In-Person: On a trip with three white friends in the state with, as CNN put it, a complicated racial history. A sheriff saying no foul play without walking through his reasoning a sheriff saying no foul play without walking through his reasoning in that context was never going to be received as neutral. it was going to be received as a decision already made. Within days, the calm procedural version Nicholle: A sheriff saying no foul play without walking through his reasoning in that context was never going to be received as neutral. it was going to be received as the decision already made. Within days, the calm procedural version of this story, In-Person: my god. Kid drowned, tragic accident, nothing more to see, was gone. What replaced it was a full blown national story about race, trust, and whether Mississippi law enforcement was given this case the scrutiny Nicholle: Kid drowned, tragic accident, nothing more to see, was gone. What replaced it was a full-blown national story about race, trust, and whether Mississippi law enforcement was given this case scrutiny, a young man's death deserved. In-Person: a young man's death deserved. Nicholle: On July 7th, one day after Nolan's body was confirmed, his family retained civil rights attorney Ben Crumb, the same attorney behind the Trayvon Martin. In-Person: On July 7th, one day after Nolan's body was confirmed, his family retained civil rights attorney Ben Crump, the same attorney behind the Trayvon Martin, George Floyd, and Breonna Taylor cases. In the retention announcement, Crump said the family was calling for a thorough and transparent investigation into how Nolan died. Nicholle: George Floyd and Breonna Taylor cases. In the retention announcement, Crump said the family was calling for a thorough and transparent investigation into how Nolan died, and that his team would conduct an independent review of the circumstances of Nolan's death and push for the release of all records, witness accounts, and autopsy times. In-Person: And that his team would conduct an independent review of the circumstances of Nolan's death and push for the release of all records, witness accounts, and autopsy findings. Nicholle: Two days later in an interview with ABC News' Lindsay Davis, Trump laid out the family's frustration directly. The fact that they continue to tell the family they don't see any evidence of any foul play, even though you have students who recorded and then cutting to the heart of it, all we know is Nolan is dead. Not how, not why, just that he's gone. In-Person: Two days later in an interview with ABC News' Lindsay Davis, Prump laid out the family's frustration directly. The fact that they continue to tell the family they don't see any evidence of any foul play, even though you have students who recorded, and then cutting to the heart of it, all we know is Nolan is dead. Not how, not why, just that he's gone. I thought I was saying. And nobody in authority seemed to be treating that as urgently as the family needed them to. Which is horrible. So the family did something dramatic. They arranged for Nolan's body to be flown from Mississippi to Washington Nicholle: And nobody in authority seemed to be treating that as urgently as the family needed them to. So the family did something dramatic. They arranged for Nolan's body to be flown from Mississippi to Washington. In-Person: D C. Specifically so a forensic pathologist with zero ties to Mississippi law enforcement could perform a second fully independent autopsy. Okay, sh hats off to you. Nicholle: Specifically so forensic pathologists with zero ties to Mississippi law enforcement to perform a second fully independent autopsy. Okay. In-Person: Crump explained the reasoning bluntly at a press conference. This situation isn't adding up. That's why at the family's request we had an independent autopsy conducted. We arranged for his body to be transported from Mississippi to Washington, DC, so that the examination could be performed by a doctor with no ties to Mississippi law enforcement, which is horrible. Smart but horrible that they even had to do that. Nicholle: explain the reasoning bluntly at a press conference. This situation isn't enough. That's why at the family's request we had an independent autopsy industry. We arranged for his body to be transported from Mississippi to Washington DC so that the examination could be performed by a doctor with no signs of Mississippi lawn. Smart but horrible that they have to do that. Yeah. That triple loan tells you how little trust the family had left. In-Person: That trip alone tells you how little trust the family had left in local process. and two names came up that you wouldn't expect in a small town Mississippi drowning case. Colin Kaepernick helped fund the independent autopsy. Tyler Perry helped cover funeral expenses. Nicholle: And two names came up that you wouldn't expect in a small town, Mississippi, Johnny Bay. Colin Affrican. Helped fund the independent arch property. I have a parent In-Person: Within a week a local tragedy had become a cause that reached from Ocean Springs Nicholle: Within the week, a local tragedy has become a call that reached from Ocean Springs. In-Person: all the way to the NAACP's national stage. Nicholle: We're not going to dance around this because it's the engine drive you have. In-Person: We're not gonna dance around this because it's the engine driving half of the story. Nolan Wells was the only black teenager in a group of white friends from Ocean Springs High School. He went into the water, he didn't come out, and within days, that fact alone had turned this into a into a referendum on race in America in twenty twenty six. Nicholle: Nolan Wells was the only black teenager in a group of white friends from Ocean Springs High School. He went into the water, he didn't come out. And within days, that fact alone had turned this into a referendum into a referendum on race in America in twenty twenty-six, with some commentators drawing direct, explicit comparisons to Emmett Till and others accusing the family and the NAACP of racializing what they insist is a straightforward. In-Person: With some commentators drawing direct, explicit comparisons to Emmettil and others accusing the family and the NAACP of racializing what they insist is a straightforward accident Nicholle: I In-Person: CNN reported that images of Wells with his friends have sparked discussions about race relations in America and that observers online Nicholle: Okay. CNN reported that images of Wells with his friends have sparked discussions about race relations in America and that observers online In-Person: had zeroed in on exactly who was and wasn't in those fourth of July photos because you know the internet and the people and we do our job. The Lord's internet. You put it on there, we gonna figure it out. I don't even know why you come Nicholle: had zeroed in on exactly who was and wasn't in those fourth of July photos. 'Cause you know. The internet didn't be the Lord's internet. The Lord's Internet. You put it on there, we're gonna figure it out. Somebody's gonna figure it out. Meanwhile, in Ocean Springs, where Nolan went to high school, peaceful demonstrators gathered calling for a transparent investigation. A parent of one of Nolan's friends and a local NAACP leader In-Person: Meanwhile, in Ocean Springs, where Nolan went to high school, peaceful demonstrators gathered calling for a transparent investigation. A parent of one of Nolan's friends and a local NAACP leader publicly pushed back against what they called runaway social media speculations while also acknowledging the sheer volume of tips, calls and theories pouring into the sheriff's office. Nicholle: publicly pushed back against what they call runaway social media speculation, while also acknowledging the sheer volume of tips, calls, and theories pouring into the sheriff hall. This is the part of the case that's genuinely impossible to separate from the facts. Because the facts and the social context are tangled together. In-Person: This is the part of the case that's genuinely impossible to separate from the facts because the facts and the social context are tangled together. On one side, a sheriff's department that said no foul play early without a completed autopsy in a case involving a black teenager who died on the tree Nicholle: On one side a sheriff's department that said no foul play early without a completed autopsy in a case involving a black teenager who died on a trip with white friends. On one side, a sheriff's department that said no foul play early, without a completed autopsy, in a case involving In-Person: On one side, a sheriff's department that said no foul play early without a completed autopsy in a case involving Nicholle: a black teenager who died on a trip with white friends, a pattern with an ugly history in the South that makes people understandably slow to trust a quick official answer. On the other side, no confirmed evidence as of today that this was anything other than a tragic accident. In-Person: History in the South that makes people understandably slow to trust a quick official answer. On the other side, no confirmed evidence as of today that this was anything other than a tragic accident. And a real risk that speculation, understandably fueled by that history, gets ahead of what investigators can actually prove. Nicholle: And a real risk that speculation, understandably, fueled by that history, gets ahead of what investigators can actually prove. Both of those things can be true at once. The skepticism can be earned by history and the specific facts of this specific case can still eventually turn out to be an accident. That tension between justified distrust and unproven accusation is the air that this entire case has been breathing in In-Person: Both of those things can be true at once. The skepticism can be earned by history and the specific facts of this specific case can still eventually turn out to be an accident. That tension between justified distrust and unproven accusation is the air that this entire case has been breathing in. Nicholle: for three weeks. In-Person: On july twenty second, at the NAACP's 117th National Convention in Chicago, Ben Crump stood alongside Nolan's parents, his mother Christine Wells Wandsley and his father, Elmore Wandsley, and announced the preliminary findings of the independent autopsy. Nicholle: On July 22nd, at the NAACP's 117th National Convention in Chicago, Ben Crump stood alongside Nolan's parents, his mother, Christine Wells-Wandsley, and his father, Elmore Wandsley, and announced the preliminary findings of the independent autopsy. In-Person: The pathologist, Dr. Roger A. Mitchell, Jr., had performed the second examination on July 10th, four days after Nolan's body Nicholle: The pathologist, Dr. Roger A. Mitchell, Jr. had performed the second examination on july tenth, four days after Nolan's body In-Person: was recovered and delivered his written report on july nineteenth. Nicholle: was recovered, and delivered his written report on july nineteenth. The headline finding, and I want to say this clearly because it's the most misunderstood detail in this entire case. Cause of death undetermined, pending investigation. Manner of death undetermined, pending investigation. That is not the same as murder. It's not the same as no foul play either. It means exactly what it says. The doctor cannot determine from the body alone In-Person: The headline finding, and I want to say this clearly because it's the most misunderstood detail in this entire case. Cause of death undetermined pending investigation. Manner of death undetermined pending investigation. That is not the same as murder. It's not the same as no foul play either. It means exactly what it says. The doctor cannot determine from the body alone Nicholle: how Nolan died. In-Person: But there was one specific significant detail buried in Doctor Mitchell's report. During the dissection of the back of Nolan's head, he found what the report described as a vocal area of red discoloration in the soft tissue overlying occipital bone, Nicholle: There was one specific significant detail varied in Dr. Mitchell's report. During the dissection of the back of Melan's head, he that the report described as a vocal area of red discoloration in the false tissue overline occipital bulb. In-Person: the base of the skull. Nicholle: the base of the skull, measuring roughly twelve by eight centimeters. There were no lacerations on the pin above it and no fractures in the in the skull underneath. On its own that finally gets the composition. In-Person: Measuring roughly twelve by eight centimeters. There were no lacerations on the skin above it and no fractures in the s in the skull underneath it. On its own, that finding is inconclusive. Nicholle: It could be from decomposition. It could be from something else in In-Person: It could be from decomposition. It could be from something else entirely. Nicholle: And Dr. Mitchell said as much, but he also wrote that he couldn't rule it out as significant and flagged it specifically for further investigation. Then there's the limitation that made headlines almost as much as the finding itself. The report noted that the trachea, the large part leads, the thyroid corn In-Person: And Dr. Mitchell said as much. But he also wrote that he couldn't rule it out as significant and flagged it specifically for further investigation. Then there's the limitation that made headlines almost as much as the finding itself. The report noted that the trachea, the larnix cartilage, the thyroid horn Nicholle: and the height of the bone, all structures at the front and base of the neck, all structures. In-Person: And the hyoid bone, all structures at the front and base of the neck, all structures you'd examine closely if you were checking for strangulation or a neck injury were not sent along with the body when it arrived for the second autopsy. First of all, excuse the fuck out of me. I beg your pardon? That's what I said when I heard that. Come again? Like did you think we're gonna notice? Can we what'd you do with rewind and excuse Nicholle: You'd examine closely if you're protecting for triangulation or neck and or not. This along with the body when it arrives for the second eye. First of all, it's the fuck out of the eye back and forth. That's what I said when I heard that. Come again? Like did you think we're gonna notice? And we what did you do with it? Rewind beginning two. In-Person: me? They've been retained during the state's initial examination. How can you retain a part of the body that's supposed to you okay. Where'd you retain it? Yeah. And why you didn't send it when you sent the body? 'Cause we can't make a determination without without it. Nicholle: They've been retained the sparing the state's initial examination. How can you retain a part of the body that's supposed to be okay? Where'd you retain it? Yeah. And why you didn't send any body? Because we can't make a determination without without that. Dr. Mitchell noted that retaining that issue is actually standard forensic practice, not automatically suspicious. But admit the independent pathologists could not fully In-Person: Doctor Mitchell noted that retaining that tissue is actually standard forensic practice. It's not automatically suspicious, but it meant the independent pathologist could not fully examine the neck, and because of that, in his own words, he cannot rule out injury to the neck as a contributing factor or a cause of death. Doctor Mitchell listed seven specific outstanding questions in his report. How Nolan entered the water in the Nicholle: Because that, in his own words, he cannot roll out injury to the neck as a contributing factor or a cause of death. Dr. Mitchell listed seven specific outstanding questions in his report. How Nolan entered the water in the first place, whether there was water in his airway consistent with drowning, whether he had a brain bleed, whether he was conscious or unconscious when he went into the water, whether he entered the water by force, what was found in his stomach. In-Person: whether there was water in his airway consistent with drowning, whether he had a brain bleed, whether he was conscious or unconscious when he went into the water, whether he entered the water by force, what was found in his stomach, and what was the toxicology result Nicholle: And what was the toxicology result, And what the toxicology results would eventually show. As of this reporting, we still don't have answers to most of those questions because the state's own toxicology results, which the entire case is waiting on, still haven't been released. And that's the sentence Dr. Mitchell chose to close on, In-Person: And what the toxicology results would eventually show. As of this recording, we still don't have answers to most of those questions, because the state's own toxicology results, which the entire case is waiting on, still haven't been released. And that's the sentence Dr. Mitchell chose to pose on, the one Ben Crump has repeated at nearly every public appearance since. Nicholle: The one Ben Crump has repeated at nearly every public appearance since. In-Person: this pathologist cannot rule out if any intervening non-accidental factors contributed to or caused the death of Nolan Wells. Translated out of legal language, he can't rule out foul play. Not that he found it, that he can't rule it out. That distinction matters enormously, and it's the exact space this entire case has been living in for weeks. Nicholle: This pathologist cannot rule out if any intervening non-accidental factors contributed to or caused the death of Nolan Wells. Translated out of legal language, he can't rule out foul play. Not that he found it, that he can't rule it out. That distinction matters enormously, and it's the exact space this entire case has been living in for weeks. So where does this leave us as of this report? On July 19th, the family and Ben Trump met with the Jackson. In-Person: So where does this leave us as of this recording? On July nineteenth, the family and Ben Crump met with the Jackson County District Attorney. Two concrete things came out of that meeting. First, once the investigation is complete, this case will go to a grand jury, which to be fair is standard procedure in Jackson County for any unnatural or suspicious death not necessarily a sign of pending charges. Second Nicholle: District Attorney. Two concrete things came out of that meeting. First, once the investigation is complete, this case will go to a grand jury, which to be fair is standard procedure in Jackson County for any unnatural or suspicious death, not necessarily designed Second, there will be a mutual forensic inspection of no cell phones with experts from both the family side and law enforcement present at the same time. In-Person: There will be a mutual forensic inspection of Nolan's cell phone with experts from both the family side and law enforcement present at the same time. looking at the same data simultaneously. Nicholle: looking at the same data cycle change response In-Person: A response to swirling online claims amplified on shows like Nancy Grace's that the phone contents may have been altered or deleted after his death. That claim, like the background audio and the CETO call, remains unconfirmed and disputed. Nolan was laid to rest at Center Point Church in Ocean Springs Nicholle: to swirling online claims amplified on shows like Nancy Grace that the phone contents may have been altered or deleted after death. That claim, like the background audio and so calls me unconfirmed in dispute. Notable was laid to rest at Center Point Church in Ocean Spring. In-Person: in a homegoing celebration attended by his family, friends, and community and Nicholle: Nancy Grace devoted a full hour of her show to lose the case just hours after that panel walking through what she characterized as Mississippi authorities mishandling the investigation. And as of today, July twenty sixth, the single biggest open question in this entire case is the same one it's been since July seventh. In-Person: Nancy Grace devoted a full hour of her show to the case just hours after that funeral, walking through what she characterized as Mississippi authorities mishandling the investigation. And as of today, July twenty sixth, the single biggest open question in this entire case is the same one it's been since July seventh. Nicholle: What did the Mississippi State Medical Examiner's Office find in its own official autopsy? that report still has not been released publicly. Coroner Bruce Lynn confirmed as recently as this past week In-Person: What did the Mississippi State Medical examiner's office find in its own official autopsy? that report still has not been released publicly. Coroner Bruce Lynn confirmed as recently as this past week Nicholle: that the state's report isn't finished because they're still waiting on toxicology results. The same test that per forensic pathology. In-Person: That the state's report isn't finished because they're still waiting on toxicology results. The same test that per forensic pathologist who've spoken to CNN can routinely take two to three weeks or longer to come back. So here's where we actually are: no official cause of death, no toxicology results, no charges, elite emergency call Nicholle: Who've spoken to CNN can routinely take two to three weeks or longer to come back. So here's where we actually are: no official cause of death, no toxicology results, no charges, elite emergency call, whose most explosive claims, Nolan's name being shouted, someone asking if he's dead. In-Person: Explosive claims, Nolan's name being shouted, someone asking if he's dead, have not been confirmed. Nicholle: Have not been confirmed by any law enforcement agency and exist right now as an internet driven disputed interpretation of a report. A grand jury that hasn't happened yet on a case the DA hasn't finished investigating. And the family that after three weeks of press conferences and independent autopsy and a national platform at the NAACP convention is still saying the exact same thing they said on day one. They just want to know what happened to their son. In-Person: This right now as an internet driven disputed interpretation of a recording. A grand jury that hasn't happened yet on a case the DA hasn't finished investigating, and the family that after three weeks of press conferences and independent autopsy and a national platform at the NAACP convention is still saying the exact same thing they said on day one. They just want to know what happened to their son. Okay. So let's get into the theories. Theory one, this was exactly what it looks like on paper, a tragic accidental drowning. A strong swimmer Nicholle: Okay. Okay. So let's get into the theory. Theory one is what exactly what it looks like on paper. A tragedy accident around. A strong swimmer. In-Person: alone on a remote island as the sun went down with no cell surface went into the water at some point and didn't come back out. No witnesses, no violence needed to explain it. This is the sheriff's stated position from day one And it's also statistically the most common explanation anytime a body is recovered from open water after a beach day. The evidence for it, no confirmed physical trauma consistent with an assault, a body recovered from the water near where he was last seen, an environment remote island, no lights, uneven footing near the shoreline at dusk, where accidental drowning is genuinely common. Against it, the independent pathologist occipital finding. Nicholle: open water after reaching. The evidence for it, no confirmed physical trauma consistent within the soul, a body recovered with the water near where he was last seen, an environment with remote islands, no place, an even footing near the shoreline and dust, where accidental drowning is genuinely common. Against it, the independent pathologist obcipital finding the missing neck structure would be insane. In-Person: The missing neck structure, which is insane, because how do you not have a neck structure? Clearly, that is preventing a full exam. And then the sheer number of unanswered behavioral questions, like why was he left alone for seven plus hours before anyone called for help if that is what happened? And what actually happened on that boat as it limped away because it didn't just Nicholle: Because how do you not have the connection clearly that is preventing the forex and then the sheer number of unanswered behavioral questions, like why was he left alone for seven plus hours before he wants to call for help if that isn't what happened? And what actually happened on that boat as it looked away because it didn't be speeding In-Person: speed out of there, it took a while for them to get out of there. So clearly they weren't drowning if it was moving. Right. Nicholle: out and wanted for them to get out of it. Clearly they weren't drowning because it was moving. Right. In-Person: And then I know that there were saying Nicholle: And then I know that there were saying someone was saying that it is normal for them to remove those structures, but they would also have taken pictures, samples, things that they could send to that next pathologist, even if that is something that they send. So it doesn't help them by not giving that information. And then we have theory two. Something happened on the island or on the boat and In-Person: pictures but they would also have taken pictures, samples, things that they could send to that next pathologist, even if that is something that they send. Right. So it doesn't help them that there's there's none of that. Yeah. And then we have theory two something happened on the island or on the boat and Nicholle: what followed was a cover up, not a crime scene. This In-Person: This is the theory implied by the leaked audio, by the altercation video Ben Crump has referenced, and by the GPS timeline oddities. Under this theory, whatever put Nolan in the water, an accident, a fight that went too far, panic after an injury, the friend's subsequent behavior, the confusing distress call, the sudden never mind, we're fine, the alleged background voices, and the seven-hour gap before anyone reports. Nicholle: Theory implied by the leaked audio, by the altercation video Bing Crump has referenced, and by the GPS timeline audience. Under this theory, whatever put Nolan in the water, an accident, a fight that went too far, panic after an injury, the friend's subsequent behavior, the confusing distress call, the sudden nevermind, we're fine, the alleged background voices, and the seven-hour gap before anyone reported him missing. In-Person: Reflects fear and self-protection more than malice. Evidence for it. The disputed audio, the timeline gap, the altercation footage Crump has cited. Against it, none of that has been authenticated by law enforcement. The Is He Dead audio interpretation comes entirely from independent online creators. And we have zero confirmed evidence Nicholle: Reflects fear and self-protection more than malice. Evidence for it, the disputed audio, the timeline gap, the altercation footage Crump has cited. Against it, none of that has been authenticated by law enforcement. The Is He Dead audio interpretation comes entirely from independent online creators. And we have zero confirmed evidence. In-Person: placing Nolan back on that. Nicholle: Placing Nolan back on that boat after he was last seen on the beach at 3 p.m. But I do want to say that we have listened to that call. And although they do put the subtitles up so that you can understand parts of it, we listened to it without looking at the screen. So some of the things In-Person: On the beach at 3 p.m. But I do want to say that we have listened to that call. And although they do put the subtitles up so that you can understand parts of it, we listen to it without looking at the screen. So some of the things Nicholle: we didn't hear the same as what some of the commentators are saying. In-Person: we didn't hear the same as what some of the commentators are saying. What we heard we could definitely hear dragging. We heard them hollering his name. Is is he dead? that you can hear those things if you go listen to it and you can even listen to it without those subtitles 'cause it's a brain thing that your brain will hear what you somebody tells you it is. But you can definitely hear them all most of those things being said that you're hearing in those videos. Yeah, so even though Nicholle: What we heard we could definitely hear dragon. We heard them hollering his name. Is is he dead? that you can hear those things if you go listen to it and you can even listen to it without those subtitles because it's a brain thing that your brain will hear what you somebody tells you it is. But you can definitely hear them all most of those things being said that you're hearing in those videos. Yeah, so even though the officials haven't spoken on it, I don't feel like they haven't spoken on it because In-Person: The officials haven't spoken on it. I don't feel like they haven't spoken on it because it's not true. I feel like they haven't spoken on it one because it's an open investigation, so I can't speak on it, which is the smartest move on everybody's half. Everybody involved not speaking on it. But go and listen for yourself. Listen back to what we put in here or go onto YouTube. Listen to if you can find the ones that are slowed down, I would listen to the ones that are slowed down because what you can hear Nicholle: True, I feel like they haven't spoken on it one because it's a cut and open investigation so I can't speak on it. Which is the smartest move on everybody's head. Everybody involved not speaking on it. But go and listen for yourself. Listen back to what we put in here or go on to YouTube. Listen to if you can find the ones that are slowed down, I would listen to the ones that are slowed down because what you can hear In-Person: Is insane. It's insane. Something definitely happened. You hear them calling Nolan's name. Nicholle: is insane. It's insane. Something definitely happened. You hear them calling no one's name. In-Person: You heard, my God, Nolan. somebody else saying, Check his chest. Somebody else saying, Get the fuck up, man. Get the fuck up. You can hear and then at one point you heard something like drop him in the water, put him in the water, or something like that. Mm-hmm. Now that's what we're saying. That's why we're saying it's not official. Yeah, like But you can hear something Nicholle: You heard, my God, no lane. somebody else saying, Check his check, somebody else saying, Get the fuck up, Mary, get the fuck up in here And then at one point you heard something like Drop in the water, put in the water or something like that. Mm-hmm. Now that's what we're saying. That's why we're saying Yeah, like that part. That one part we she was hearing that and I was like I c I can hear water In-Person: while one part we she was hearing that and I was like, I can I can hear water. Nicholle: but I can't really tell. The other parts we both heard and we weren't looking at that. So there's something I I don't know what it is, but there's something going on. Yeah, it's definitely something. But theory three, this is a racially charged case where the facts, whatever they turn out to be, are being filtered through and possibly distorted by a justified historical mistrust of Mississippi Law enforcement. In-Person: Can't really tell what he says before the we both heard and we weren't looking at that. So there's something. I I don't know what it is, but there's something going on. Yes, definitely something fishy. But theory three, this is a racially charged case where the facts, whatever they turn out to be, are being filtered through and possibly distorted by a justified historical mistrust of Mississippi law enforcement. Nicholle: Under this reading, the sheriff's early meet In-Person: Under this reading, the sheriff's early Nicholle: no foul plate statement wasn't a cover-up. It was simply premature and home death. And the explosion of viral theories is less about specific evidence, more about the community and the country crime by history to expect the worst from a quick official answer in a case like this, which includes him channel. In-Person: No foul play statement wasn't a cover up. It was simply premature and tone deaf and the explosion of viral theories is less about specific evidence and more about a community and a country primed by history to expect the worst from a quick official answer in a case like this, which is completely understandable. Evidence for it, the early hedge free no foul play statement made before toxicology or for autopsy, which no police officer should ever do. The documented history that makes that kind of quick dismissal land so badly and the fact that even the most viral evidence, the audio, the altercation clip, remains unauthenticated months into national coverage. Against it, dismissing all Nicholle: the early history no foul play statement made before toxicology or for our country, with no police officers or evidence known. The documented history that makes that kind of quick dismissal and so badly. And the fact that even the most viral evidence, the audio, the publication clip, remains unauthenticated once into national coverage. Against it, dismissing all of the disputed evidence as just speculation on In-Person: all of the disputed evidence as just speculation also risk ignoring real documented inconsistencies in the friend's timelines that deserve scrutiny regardless of anyone's race. And definitely them disregarding the dis the video of them arguing on the island because he was surrounded by and I'm sure it was the group of friends and whoever else was like immediately with them. Nicholle: And definitely they're disregarding the video of them arguing on the island because he was surrounded by and I'm sure it was the group of friends and whoever else was like immediately with him and he was arguing with one of the people that he came with. So they're around him. In-Person: And he was arguing with one of the people that he came with. So they're around him. It Nicholle: It looks like they're probably trying to break the fight up. And that's why I saying when you listen to the call, it sounds like one person's super pissed off and everybody else is shook. Right. But you know, there was, I saw today that there was In-Person: looks like they're probably trying to break the fight up. And that's why I was saying when you listen to the call it sounds like one person is super pissed off and everybody else is shook. Right. But you know, there was I saw today that there was Nicholle: one of Nolan's friends who's not white. And he was saying that was actually him in the video, in the altercation. He was like, that wasn't Nolan. That was me. In-Person: Mhm. And he was saying that was actually him in the video in the altercation. He was like, That wasn't Nolan. Mm-hmm. That was me. Okay. So I don't know. That's why so much of this is, we don't know because that was what they were saying. Yeah, he could have been there. He could have been the one breaking it up. But either way you see that he's there on the island with all of these people. So Nicholle: Don't know that's why so much of this is we don't know because that was what they were saying that's no Yeah In-Person: Them not using that or even using the audio clip of the call as insane because it's way too much information on that call for you to just be like, yeah, this is a drowning. What? Right, and that you haven't. You know, they we keep talking about Nicholle: Right and that you haven't you know, they we keep talking about how the Call is not or what we're hearing on the cause not authenticated, but why haven't you started doing that? Maybe so yeah And then we have 34 In-Person: Hearing on the call is not authenticated, but why haven't you started doing that? Or maybe the reason why they're not speaking on it is because they have sent it and you know it takes a while, especially if they're gonna slow it down and clean it up and do all of that. We wanna hear good, good audio when this starts. Yeah. And then we have their Nicholle: and honestly the one we can state with total confidence we don't have enough yet. No state autopsy, no toxicology, no authenticated version of the looped audio's most explosive claims, no results from the mutual cell phone inspection. Every single theory above is built right now on an incomplete foundation. And anyone online telling you with certainty that they know exactly what happened to Nolan Wells is telling you more. In-Person: No state autopsy, no toxicology, no authenticated version of the leaked audio's most explosive claims, no results from the mutual cell phone inspect inspection. Every single theory above is built right now on an incomplete foundation. And anyone online telling you with certainty that they know exactly what happened to Nolan Wells is telling you more. than the actual evidence currently supports and that is true. Unless they were there. Right. Unless they were on that boat or they were next to those people and heard something. Because you hear a lot of that, when we were watching it with your dad, like those people on YouTube, we won't name anybody on there, but they're very much like that's what this is. It's this and it's that and that's what I don't I I feel like some somebody's doing something. But I think it's too early. Nicholle: than the actual evidence currently supports. And that is true. Unless they were on that boat or they were next to those people and heard something. Because you hear a lot of When we were watching it with your dad, those people on YouTube, we won't name anybody on there, but they're very much like, that's what this is. It's this and it's that. And that's what I don't, I feel like somebody's doing something. But I think it's too early In-Person: To say exactly what. Whether it was Nicholle: to do that. In-Person: an accident or not an accident, we're not speaking on. But the covering something up, it's definitely some kind of cover up, whether it would be for benefit of the case, or you're just covering this up because it was all these white kids and a black kid came up dead. one of the kids' mom is a judge. Yep. And so we were talking about that and they Nicholle: And One of the kids mom is a judge. Yep. And so we were talking about that and they were on the same, YouTube channel talking about In-Person: the same, YouTube channel talking about how she was saying, she was making statements. They didn't really I didn't hear what exactly she was saying, but somewhere in there she mentioned that she was a judge and she made comments on the case because her son was one of the I I believe her son was the one on the phone. The one that did the interview 'cause there's one that did has done it at least one interview. Nicholle: how she was saying, she was making statements. They didn't really, I didn't hear what exactly she was saying, but somewhere in there, she mentioned that she was the judge and she made comments on the case because her son was one of the, I believe her son was the one on the phone, the one that did the interview, because there's one that has done at least one interview. In-Person: That's the one whose mom is the judge. And you know, they were talking about how she's not supposed to do that. So Nicholle: Yeah, there's the judge. And you know, they were talking about how she's not supposed to do that. So, In-Person: I think that we it's a lot of it is this when people don't know. And I bring up the mom because yes, no, if she's a judge, she shouldn't have done Shouldn't have said anything. But we also have to look at the fact that whoever she is and whatever position she holds, that's her child that's involved in that. And because we don't know exactly what happened on the boat Nicholle: I think that we, it's a lot of, it is this when people don't know. And I bring up the mom because yes, no, if she's the judge, she shouldn't have done that. But we also have to look at the fact that whoever she is and whatever position she holds, that's her child that's involved in that. And because we don't know exactly what happened on the boat, I understand her trying to defend her son. In-Person: I understand her trying to defend her son. That's what a mom does. And if it was my kid I wouldn't give two hoots what who what the hell job yeah. I had. I'm gonna do what I need to do. Okay, where do you land as far as like where's your official theory for this? So I do think that we we can't dismiss the occipital finding from Nicholle: what a mom does. And if it was my kid, wouldn't give to hoots what the hell job I had. I'm going to do what I need to do. So I do think that we can't dismiss the occipital finding from the autopsy, even though they say it could be from decomposition. In-Person: Even though they say it could be from decomposition, Nicholle: It could we don't know what is firm because we don't know enough faction and why an independent credentialed forensic pathologist explicitly refused to close the door on file play In-Person: it could be. We we don't know what is from because we don't know enough facts yet. and why an independent credentialed forensic pathologist explicitly refused to close the door on file play. Nicholle: I believe that something something happened on that boat Because you if you listen to the if they were on the boat when they made the call then something happened on that boat In-Person: I believe that something something happened on that boat. Because you if you listen to the if they were on the boat when they made the call, then something happened on that boat. the panic, it especially in the girls' voices that you can hear in the background. So I think whatever was happening, they at least weren't expecting it. So I don't know if it was an accident, if there was a fight, but something happened on that boat and people are covering it up. Yeah, I definitely agree with that. Nicholle: especially in the girls voices that you can hear in the background. So I think whatever was happening, they at least weren't expecting it. So don't know if it was an accident, if there was a fight, but something happened on that boat and people are covering it up. Yeah, I definitely agree with that. It is the timing of everything, OK? Because when you listen to the call, you hear the kid when everything is happening in the background, something had to have just immediately. In-Person: It is the timing of everything. Okay, because when you listen to the call, you hear the kid when everything is happening in the background, something had to have just immediately happened. Right. Immediately. So this kid decided to call the tow people. Maybe thinking that it was something going on with the boat. And somebody else decided to go. Jerry Atkinson at the same time. Right. Okay. Nicholle: Right. In-Person: They're speaking to different people, two kids on this boat are talking to two people at the same time. While and I don't know how that works because how can the grandfather be on the phone with the captain at the same time this kid is on the phone with this the dispatcher from the tow? Nicholle: How can the grandfather be on the phone with the captain at the same time this kid is on the phone with the dispatcher from the Toll's In-Person: Telling them what's going on at the same time, 'cause the officer said I literally just got off the phone with him. So that means you were talking to him while I was speaking to this child. So somebody else was talking to the grandfather. I had to have called him at least ahead of this to tell him what was going Nicholle: telling them what's going on at the same time? Because the officer said I literally just got off the phone with him. So that means you were talking to him while I was speaking to this child. somebody else was talking to the grandfather. I had to have called him at least ahead of this to tell him what was going on. In-Person: on. But what doesn't get me is if they did call beforehand, I don't feel like the kid would have called the dispatcher at all. Nicholle: But what does it give me is if they did call before him, I don't feel like the kid would have called at this time. So In-Person: So they had to have been on the phone at the same time. And if you listen at some point it sounds like the voices on the phone switches, like it's one kid and then it's another kid. And you hear them him stop. He stopped talking. Nicholle: they had to have been on the phone at the same time. And if you listen, at some point it sounds like the voices on the phone switches. Like it's one kid and then it's another kid. And you hear them, him stop? Because she asked the question, they stopped talking. In-Person: You hear somebody say something and then he says hello and then it's different. It's like monotone. And it's not just like a like are you there like it was before. It's hello. So Nicholle: You hear somebody say something I couldn't really understand it and then it's different. It's like monotone. In-Person: to me It's a different kid. So what that tells me is probably what happened was that's the kid who called the grandfather. He's telling him what's happening, whatever, whatever, whatever. And then they switch phones. And now this kid finishes telling the dispatcher all of the information while the the other kid is talking to the grandfather, verifying the information, so the grandfather or whoever can cover it up. Yeah. And Nicholle: It In-Person: It might not have been the grandfather they were talking to. It could have been one of the dads or something like that. And the they called the grandfather and he decided to handle the captain. Otherwise they wouldn't have called at all. They would have just let their people handle it. So Nicholle: might not have been the grandfather they were talking to. It could have been one of the dads. Right, was somebody called the they called the grandfather when he decided to handle the captain. Otherwise, they wouldn't have called at all. would have just let their people handle Yeah. So. In-Person: it's too it's too weird. It's too much happening. It's too much unknown. But I definitely feel like something happened to that boy, whether it be an accident or not an accident. And like I said earlier, one of the kids in the call, when you listen, the call the kid on the call, he sounds drunk, he sounds messed up. But Nicholle: it's too it's too weird too much happening it's too much unknown but I definitely feel like something happened to that boy whether it be an accident or not an accident and like I said earlier one of the kids in the call when you listen the call the kid on the call he sounds drunk he sounds messed up but for everybody else in the background you can hear the like shock or like oh my god of the situation and this kid just sounds pissed off the whole call the whole call very irritated very frustrated In-Person: For everybody else in the background, you can hear the like shock or like my god of the situation and this kid just sounds pissed off. Of the whole call. The whole call. Very irritated, very frustrated. It's no like you would react if something dis distraught is happening as everybody else's voice is giving in the background and you're the only upset one. So something happened, whether it was an accident or not an accident and Nicholle: This was a fault to cover it up. Like the alibi fault is what they were saying and I agree with that. Because it doesn't even when they're giving the information to the dispatcher about the boat sinking and In-Person: This was a call to cover it up, like a alibi call is what they were saying and I agree with that. Mm-hmm. Because it doesn't even when they're giving the information to the dispatcher about the boat seeking sinking. And she's asking questions. He really couldn't say nothing. He's answering the questions. It's like, When the other kid gets on at the end, he's like, Yeah, we're definitely taking on water. She asked something specific and he doesn't answer it. He's not being rude like the first time. Nicholle: she's asking questions even when he's answering the questions it's like when the other kid gets on it and he's like yeah we're definitely taking on water she asked something specific and he doesn't answer it he's not being rude like the first In-Person: But he just kinda They're still not answering the direct. Mm-hmm while she's talking to the captain about the kids. Yeah, I agree. I agree. Read Nicholle: But he just kind of, and you can tell that this dispatcher is used to talking to rich, naughty kids because she's very patient and even compassionate while she's talking to the captain about the kids. In-Person: And also, I definitely feel like the family was right to fight for the full truth. And I think Ben Crump forcing a second autopsy is the reason we even know about the occipital finding occipital finding at all Nicholle: And also, I definitely feel like the family was right to fight for the full truth. And I think Ben's front forcing a second autopsy is the reason we even know about occipital fighting at all. In-Person: because they would not have just brought that out, especially if they just dismissed it with no foul play and case closed. So that's amazing. They definitely should have did that smart decision. I think that's awesome on there. their account for them but also for the case 'cause it's definitely going in the grand jury and we'll be keeping you up posted on that one. Nicholle: We will. We will. So if we're being honest about where this actually leaves us, an 18-year-old is dead. A family is still waiting on answers three weeks later, we don't get to close it out the way we usually do. There's no verdict here. No confirmed villain, no confession, no closed file. In-Person: There's no verdict here, no confirmed villain, no confession, no closed file. Nicholle: What there is is a mother who spent three weeks standing in front of cameras at press conferences at an NAACP convention saying the same sentence over and over. We just want to know what happened to our son. In-Person: What there is is a mother who spent three weeks standing in front of cameras, at press conferences, at an NAACP convention saying the same sentence over and over. We just want to know what happened to our son Which is heartbreaking to think about. Being a mom of three boys, I can't imagine. And I also keep thinking about that seven hour gap about him being alone on the island with no way to call anybody while for whatever was actually happening on that boat, nobody came back for him. So whether that gap is explained by panic, miscommunication or something darker, or by nothing more than a group of teenagers who genuinely believe they catch another ride. Nicholle: Wow. Ever was actually happening on that boat. Nobody came back. So whether that gap is explained by panics, miscommunication or something darker or by nothing more than a group of teenagers who genuinely believe they catch another ride. It's the image that's staying. Boiling on these kids are and he's waiting for somebody to come and get In-Person: It's the image that's staying with me, a boy alone on a beach, it's getting dark, and he's waiting for somebody to come and get him. Nicholle: him. That just gave me chills. I can't imagine being his parents. Our hearts go out to his parents. don't, if this is horrible, whatever happened that they're having to do all of this to get the information that they need, right? To have to fight like this, to get answers. In-Person: Yes. We they do. Whatever happened that they're having to do all of this to get the information. Your son definitely deserves justice. You deserve justice. You deserve to know whether it was a accident or whatever. You d it it's not okay for a parent to not know what happened to their child. Okay. We'll be following this case at Nicholle: Okay, We'll be following this case as the state autopsy, the toxicology results and the grand jury process move forward. And if there is a real update, we will absolutely come back to it. Until then, we're going to do what we ask everyone arguing about this case to do. Hold all the theories loosely and wait for the actual evidence. In-Person: We'll be following this case as the state autopsy, the toxicology results, and the grand jury process move forward. And if there is a real update, we will absolutely come back to it. Until then, do what we ask everyone arguing about this case to do. Hold all the theories loosely and wait for the actual evidence. Nicholle: Thank you guys for being here with us. If this one moved you or frustrated you because it should. You should please leave us a review. Share it with somebody who can handle case without the clean ending and surprise so you don't miss the next one. And tell us what you're drinking while you listen. Coffee, tea, something stronger. We don't go. Tag us or drop it in the comments. In-Person: Yes, please. And thank you guys for being here with us, you co-conspirators. If this one moved you or frustrated you, because it should, you should please leave us a review, share it with somebody who can handle a case without a clean ending, and subscribe so you don't miss the next one. And tell us what you're drinking while you listen. Coffee, tea, something stronger, we don't judge. Tag us or drop it in the comments. Nicholle: Send us your cases and send us your read on this. We read everything. We'll be back soon. Until next time. In-Person: Everything. We'll be back soon. Until next time. Peace. Nicholle: Peace!