Latest / The Vegan Report / When Left & Right Unite for Animals | Ep. 116
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the vegan report. My name is Ryan
- 0:03and today we're getting political. This was a
- 0:07fascinating conversation because We brought together
- 0:11two animal rights advocates from opposite ends
- 0:14of the political spectrum. David Michelle was
- 0:18elected as a Democratic representative in the
- 0:21state of Connecticut. So he comes from the political
- 0:24left. And Liam Gray, on the other hand, is a
- 0:28conservative, a veteran, and the founder of the
- 0:31Animal Protection Think Tank, the Wilberforce
- 0:34Institute. And then we had Sandro Geni, a researcher
- 0:39at the University of Zurich's Psychology Personality
- 0:42Lab who, true to his Swiss heritage, remained
- 0:46impressively neutral, offering thoughtful insights
- 0:50and valuable data throughout the discussion.
- 0:53So, every perspective was represented as we explored
- 0:57how to motivate animal advocates to engage politically
- 1:02at a time when so many feel disillusioned with
- 1:06the political class, why politicians aren't working
- 1:10harder to earn the votes of the millions of vegetarians
- 1:14and vegans out there, and much, much more. David
- 1:18Michel is on Sobstac, so be sure to subscribe
- 1:21to his Sobstac. You can also find his writings
- 1:25as a contributor to the Citi Examiner. Visit
- 1:29the Wilberforce Institute, Liam Gray's organization,
- 1:33and check out their impressive work making the
- 1:35conservative case for animal rights. And be sure
- 1:39to read Sandro Geni's latest study on politics
- 1:42and veganism titled Political Orientation and
- 1:46Attitudes about agricultural reforms around sustainability.
- 1:52He also contributed to the Wednesday Science
- 1:55of Activism episode. Go check it out. You'll
- 2:03find all the links in the episode notes. Lastly,
- 2:08please subscribe to or follow the show, share
- 2:11this episode with the vegans in your life, and
- 2:14leave a 5 -star review. I truly appreciate your
- 2:18support. Thank you. the world of politics, they
- 2:45don't want to hear about it, they don't vote
- 2:47in, you know, for elections, they stay at home.
- 2:52And there's this general apathy towards politics
- 2:56in our society. So I guess my first question
- 2:59for you is, how do we change that? How do we
- 3:03engage people in the political conversation?
- 3:14Well to engage on animal rights in the political
- 3:18realm It's in it's a good great question. I myself
- 3:22was elected so I have a very specific perspective
- 3:26on it But to engage with people in the political
- 3:30world and I was chairing the caucus on Animal
- 3:33Advocacy in Connecticut So I dealt with the games
- 3:37caucus all the way to people who had just don't
- 3:40really think about animal rights and I think
- 3:44it's always with with trying to bring these people
- 3:50in a different setting you have to I think sort
- 3:53of give them a setting like because they're different
- 3:56settings you could talk about animal rights in
- 3:59various ways and also in like you could talk
- 4:03about animal agriculture and you could talk about
- 4:06pets you know livestock wildlife So dealing with
- 4:13farmers as well, et cetera. In Connecticut, they
- 4:16keep coming back with black bear hunting bills
- 4:19to supposedly protect farmers. So I would either
- 4:27immerse myself in their place or I would try
- 4:29to get them in a place where I am, just to have
- 4:33a place to start from and start deconstructing.
- 4:37And for example, the issue with black bears.
- 4:40OK, I'm going to take that one. It's human bear
- 4:45issues when it comes to black bears in Connecticut
- 4:47is linked to bears looking for food and access
- 4:51to food. And so people approach me and say, you
- 4:56know, there are that many say the sightings of
- 4:59bears. There's this and that. And I say, OK,
- 5:03well, where's the science here? What's Well,
- 5:05it's actually something that we can really understand.
- 5:08There's a drought this year, so the bears are
- 5:10more aggressively coming out of their own comfort
- 5:12zone. People are still not using latch bins,
- 5:17right? But people want to feel free to dump their
- 5:21food leftovers in their backyard if they want
- 5:23to. What you're doing is you're also attracting
- 5:28an animal smelling food that you'd also don't
- 5:30want on your property So there's always like
- 5:32this this somewhere. There's always going to
- 5:34be some logic that you can bring in it into the
- 5:37picture you want to shoot a bear for being hungry
- 5:41or You know of threatening some some of the light
- 5:45black bears on attack humans So it's it's like
- 5:48well, why do you say black bears on attack humans?
- 5:50Then you get into those deeper and deeper conversations,
- 5:52but I think it's about setting immersing yourself
- 5:55in their place and trying to see what's their
- 5:57issue, and then deconstructing it and seeing
- 6:00where the logic would bring us. Because usually
- 6:03it will bring us away from violence, typically,
- 6:06in my experience, always. Thank you, David. A
- 6:14lot of what you said there, David, a lot of what
- 6:16we work on is exactly that, kind of talking about
- 6:19issues from... So my organization works on...
- 6:25kind of taking that, yeah, the animal space has
- 6:27been very left coded. And we approach these things
- 6:30from in ways that are kind of more congruent
- 6:32with conservative values or libertarian values.
- 6:35And so a lot of it is just just that approaching
- 6:37these issues from the the readily available rationales
- 6:41that are that are actually congruent with the
- 6:43values that we have. So, yeah, example, there's
- 6:47a large government program in the US to to eradicate
- 6:51one type of owl in order to save another type
- 6:53of owl. It doesn't actually make any sense. It's
- 6:54a big Big government boondoggles spending tons
- 6:56and tons of taxpayer money on it just to kill
- 6:58this one type of owl and most people You know
- 7:00when it comes down to it like owls, right? uh,
- 7:03and so just just talking about that from a Yeah,
- 7:06we're when we talk about this as a giant government
- 7:08program and our solution is to get rid of this
- 7:10program That's something that resonates with
- 7:12the right and it's also just you know, the fact
- 7:14that we're kind of being people of the right
- 7:16ourselves It's yeah, it's not coming from uh
- 7:19someone I mean you mentioned at the beginning
- 7:21of this that uh, yeah how politics is kind of
- 7:23pervasive everywhere And in people, yeah, we
- 7:26have these kind of groupings or try it. Yeah,
- 7:28it's it's a people lean a lot on authenticity
- 7:31now and people coming from the same place as
- 7:33them. So being able to talk from this position
- 7:35and talk from where they're coming from, I think
- 7:36that that gets people more engaged with these
- 7:38issues that wouldn't otherwise be. Thank you,
- 7:42Liam. Sandro. Yeah, I definitely agree with tailoring
- 7:49kind of your messages to. the audience you want
- 7:53to speak to in our research. Like, we're trying
- 7:57a lot to figure out what kind of framings fit
- 8:01with different groups, political groups, people
- 8:05of different values. And I really like the point
- 8:09with the authenticity that maybe it's not enough
- 8:12to just frame the message in the right way is
- 8:15the messenger is not really like matching the
- 8:20audience. So, or sometimes it might also be just
- 8:22very hard for you as an advocate to get into
- 8:27the head of the audience if it's really not your
- 8:31values. And we also, a couple of months ago,
- 8:36we published, me and some other PhD students,
- 8:41we published a commentary on this question. There
- 8:44the question was more like how to engage more
- 8:47conservative people, because we also kind of
- 8:49had this perception of like, okay, a large part
- 8:53of this animal welfare movement is kind of left
- 8:56coded. And we also, so we discussed some arguments
- 9:01that people might come up with or some issues
- 9:06that they see when it's like, okay, maybe we
- 9:10should broaden the scope as a let's say more
- 9:13left -wing organization, you want to broaden
- 9:16your audience. There might also be disadvantages.
- 9:20One is that you don't appear authentic. And it
- 9:23might even be for the people doing the advocacy
- 9:26that it's like, well, this is not really the
- 9:29message I want to share, even though the end
- 9:34goal would be to help animals. And I think there
- 9:37we can all agree and this should be a shared
- 9:40goal, but Yeah, I really like this point of like
- 9:44tailoring it and making also the messenger authentic.
- 9:48I think another thing to engage people more in
- 9:53politics is I mean, this is a way to really have
- 9:58big impact and change the system. And a lot of
- 10:03like research from our perspective and psychology
- 10:07is about this consumer change or like you know,
- 10:12like individual changes and those are hard and
- 10:15like changing your habits is hard. And with politics,
- 10:19you kind of have this big weight, like leverage
- 10:24or change something if it works out, like if
- 10:27you get enough people, of course you have like
- 10:29the problem of collective actions and, and industry
- 10:34that might be Working against you, but yeah,
- 10:38I think also pointing out this idea of like okay
- 10:40together We can really make a big difference
- 10:43that change is the system and maybe you don't
- 10:46have to change so much of your own behavior so
- 10:49yeah, it's if I that last part that's something
- 10:55I've kind of pointed out is that yeah our ask
- 10:58of our audience is is let's stop putting our
- 11:00tax dollars towards yeah, all these these government
- 11:03mechanisms of Uh yeah of herding animals which
- 11:07is a much easier sell then yeah i want to change
- 11:11all these facets of your life that are that have
- 11:13been ingrained in your life for your whole life
- 11:15it's it's a you know that doesn't mean that that's
- 11:18not a worthy never in itself but it's also it's
- 11:20a yeah. Not putting that funding these things
- 11:23is there is a i think a really good start a really
- 11:26good way of starting to to turn back these things.
- 11:28When i was in the animal caucus in the. in the
- 11:32Connecticut legislature. I was the only chair
- 11:38left at some point. I was in a moment of transition.
- 11:40And then I brought in some co -chairs to keep
- 11:45it bipartisan. And actually, we might even have
- 11:51a great victory this year. That's a bipartisan
- 11:53work. Again, it's the... It's hard for me to
- 12:01think of, frankly, I don't typically think of
- 12:05Democrat or Republican more one or the other
- 12:08more or better in terms of environment. This
- 12:13policy is sure with federal and they always violate
- 12:17nature sanctuaries but or the sanctity of nature.
- 12:22But the bipartisanship was very important. in
- 12:26achieving a lot of goals. And it created discussions
- 12:29within their own side, as it also did create
- 12:32discussions within others. I know, for example,
- 12:34the current chair of environment is pro -hunting,
- 12:37and he's a House Democrat chair of environment.
- 12:41But unfortunately, the ranking members from the
- 12:44other side of the aisle are also pro -hunting.
- 12:47So it's not very balanced. And typically, the
- 12:51parties will not necessarily pick the legislators
- 12:54of cognizance. as leaders of those committees,
- 13:01purposely because they are not coming with a
- 13:05set of ideas. I don't think that's actually good,
- 13:08because you want people who have worked during
- 13:11their life and environment to be representing
- 13:14their party in environment. That's the way I
- 13:17see it. Not the opposite, not destruction. I
- 13:22want to talk about bipartisanship and the difference
- 13:26between the left and right. But first, what about
- 13:30what about the cynicism that so many people have
- 13:35right now for the political world? You know,
- 13:38you talk about politics to someone and they'll
- 13:42say all the politicians are a holes, they are
- 13:46all corrupt. We can't do anything politically.
- 13:52The system is rigged against us and the list
- 13:55goes on of reasons not to engage with the political
- 13:59world. What do you make of that cynicism? That
- 14:09sounds like a cynic myself. I think it's pretty
- 14:11well -earned in a lot of cases. You know, I don't
- 14:17think I mean we've seen a lot of this But I think
- 14:18that's I guess I would I would argue is more
- 14:20reason to get engaged and more reason to try
- 14:22to change that I mean, that's you know, that's
- 14:25that's sort of the what you're up against But
- 14:27what's what's the alternative just let the let
- 14:29the crap people keep being corrupt, you know
- 14:31But how to turn back that sentences, I don't
- 14:34know, you know, I think Sandra mentioned was
- 14:38talking about sort of the yeah, the universe
- 14:40versatility is on its message of the messaging
- 14:42and a lot of these cases and and just having
- 14:45the right messenger for them. That's something
- 14:46I've seen a lot. We come at the different issues
- 14:54from, like I mentioned, these different framings
- 14:56and talk about it in ways that are congruent.
- 15:00But if you look at things, there was a post recently
- 15:02that Lewis Ballard did about the Save Our Bacon
- 15:06Act, the SOB Act, which is, if you're not familiar,
- 15:09it's basically just a federal attempt to to override
- 15:14state laws for protecting animals against factory
- 15:17farming practices. But it was notable because
- 15:21it went viral with a lot of conservatives quoting
- 15:25it and commenting on it. And one of the things
- 15:28I noticed with that is even though there's a
- 15:29lot of good conservative framings, conservative
- 15:32ways of talking about that issue that are legitimate
- 15:35and real, we're big on federalism in the states
- 15:40and this is a very anti -federalist You know
- 15:43move and it's there's you know, there's the issues
- 15:46with China and everything else But that's not
- 15:47what the other people that were posting about
- 15:49it. We're talking about it from a cruelty perspective
- 15:51I mean it was a bunch of conservatives that were
- 15:52all saying yeah, we all treat life this way.
- 15:55This isn't Yeah, this isn't this is beneath us.
- 15:58This isn't the way to act and I think that that
- 16:01that speaks to something like when I was at Turning
- 16:04points America fast and we were tabling that
- 16:06our opening question that got people in and talking
- 16:08to us was just do you love animals? I mean everybody
- 16:11says yes to that, you know, and I can't find
- 16:13anybody that likes factory farming and it's not
- 16:15being paid by them so I think there is a universal
- 16:17message here just getting yeah getting breaking
- 16:20away from We have these partisan divides and
- 16:23that make it really hard to communicate across
- 16:25the aisle So I think just having somebody that
- 16:27yes coming from the same place as you talking
- 16:29about these things as well We can start to kind
- 16:31of break past that like That blockage, but yet
- 16:35you have to be careful not to fall for the the
- 16:38political divide between legislators that put
- 16:42on a show frankly and between partisan divide
- 16:46like with the public because in terms of the
- 16:50the public for example on an issue that seems
- 16:52so divisive at this In federal even in states
- 16:55state legislatures is for example health care,
- 16:57right? Like universal of care or Medicare for
- 17:01all is wanted by 70 % of Americans. But then
- 17:09at the state, you have maybe what, 1%, 5 % of
- 17:13legislators are in favor. So the representation
- 17:17is not adequate either. There's huge problems
- 17:20of representation. So we just have to... I'm
- 17:26just careful when I talk about... Between what
- 17:30the public and most of the Republican public
- 17:33is not for federal oversight there for municipal
- 17:36oversight Versus state and federal that's not
- 17:38what's happening currently. So like there's like
- 17:41very it's careful People have to be careful what
- 17:44we really call Republican Democrats Democrats
- 17:47might not have been acting as Democrats for the
- 17:49last 40 years. So There's all these questions,
- 17:53but in terms of what the public is sensitive
- 17:55to is what we always have to focus on. Eventually,
- 17:59the legislators will have to respond. I know
- 18:03a good bill in Connecticut takes five years to
- 18:05happen, but it does happen. And if you do the
- 18:08work and talk and choose your words carefully,
- 18:11because sometimes it's just the words that are
- 18:12triggers, the actions can be the same and the
- 18:16words describe the actions can be very different.
- 18:19And so there's all these nuances to work with
- 18:22and get to a point where it's just normal to
- 18:25do something like pet shops. Stop selling dogs
- 18:27and cats. We know where they come from. They're
- 18:30USDA registered facilities. That's it. Yeah.
- 18:34So let's stop that. Enough. We can't change what
- 18:37the USDA standards are. So then we stop being
- 18:40customers. And everybody, left or right, or actually
- 18:44it's not really left or right, but Republican
- 18:46or Democrat, doesn't really It's still a chance
- 18:50to think. It's that there's a there's a team
- 18:53mentality and that especially at the congressional
- 18:57level, they're very good at tapping into and
- 19:00talking about something that they don't intend
- 19:01to pass anything on or run anything on all year
- 19:04long so that they can come together and pass
- 19:07a giant omnibus bill while everybody's at Thanksgiving.
- 19:10So it's yeah, I think there's there's definitely
- 19:13I think that stuff gets riled up and ratcheted
- 19:17up and it stops becoming about the There's a
- 19:21lot more we have in common if we're able to break
- 19:24past those things. Probably one of the best ways
- 19:26of working on it is bipartisan efforts and more
- 19:30issue -based efforts than being able to go, animals
- 19:34is the perfect example. We all care about animals.
- 19:36Let's do good things for animals regardless of
- 19:39the party origin. Sandro, did you want to add
- 19:44something to this? Yeah, I guess I can give a
- 19:47bit of outside of you or perspective from another
- 19:52political system. Because I would say in Switzerland,
- 19:56where I am from, it seems to me that it's not
- 20:03so polarized. I mean, there's still polarization.
- 20:07I would see that parties are drifting a bit to
- 20:10the extremes and stuff like that. But it's so
- 20:14far going... Like it's pretty moderate. And I
- 20:18think, or like what is often discussed as an
- 20:21explanation for that is that we have a lot of
- 20:24ways to, um, to become active ourselves. So we
- 20:30have a pretty strong direct democracy. Um, so
- 20:34like we vote three to four times a year on like
- 20:38concrete policy issues. And I know that like,
- 20:41in a lot of States in us, that's the same on,
- 20:43I guess, at least at the state level. And I think
- 20:47that helps a lot to really, um, because then
- 20:51it's not so much about like, which party do I
- 20:53vote for, but like, how much do I care about
- 20:56an issue? And then things like, um, voting for
- 21:00on animal issues, which happened in Switzerland
- 21:02a couple of times, um, can be like the discussions
- 21:07can really be about this topic and not so much.
- 21:10Um, yeah, just left, right, or party politics,
- 21:15even though We also have, so like the parties
- 21:18will have an official recommendation, how to
- 21:21vote. And they will also have like, they will
- 21:24engage in the campaigns happening before the
- 21:28vote. So it's not like they stay out of it, but
- 21:32yeah, I guess it helps to get people engaged
- 21:36in politics in general. Even though like I think
- 21:41voter turnout is normally around 50%. It's mostly
- 21:44like the but older people were actually voting.
- 21:48This is an issue. But yeah, I think it helps
- 21:52and maybe makes people less cynical about politics
- 21:58because, yeah. Do you think that's aided by the,
- 22:03it's, and you know better than me on this. So
- 22:06like the, my understanding that was it's very
- 22:08decentralized. The Cantons are all, yeah, not
- 22:13autonomous, but closer to autonomous and more.
- 22:16Do you think that that's a part of why that is
- 22:19why that works that way? Yeah, so a lot of stuff
- 22:24is very, very decentralized and very federal
- 22:28system. Maybe in modern US and not sure whether
- 22:33you can compare it but Yeah, some things that
- 22:36we vote on are on the community level or the
- 22:40states or yeah, cantonal level. But then there's
- 22:42also a lot of stuff on the really on the federal
- 22:45level that we vote on, which would really determine
- 22:49how the whole country works. And there you can
- 22:54run into other kinds of policies, polarization,
- 22:59but kind of cleavages. So what we often have
- 23:01is that, for example, the German speaking part
- 23:05of the country votes more in one way than the
- 23:08French and Italian speaking part, or like there's
- 23:11a difference between the rural areas and the
- 23:15cities. And by adding those kind of other cleavages,
- 23:21maybe also sometimes the left right divide or
- 23:24like party divide gets a bit less important.
- 23:28So maybe this is also a way to take. the narrow
- 23:35focus on party politics away, at least sometimes.
- 23:44I'm going back to the legislature. I guess it's
- 23:46my best examples on this. But one of my nemesis
- 23:50in environment, a Republican, Rep. Dubicki, was
- 23:55still elected. is also in planning and development,
- 24:01which is zoning. That's what we kind of talk
- 24:03in municipal powers and stuff like that. But
- 24:07when it came to supporting pet shops, becoming
- 24:09a municipal power to vote on eliminating, I think
- 24:13he was missing there on the picture. So sometimes
- 24:16even the way that the polarization is on certain
- 24:22issues, it just doesn't. doesn't change the outcomes.
- 24:29So there's a lot to take into consideration,
- 24:32even with the municipal powers. That's a big
- 24:34fight we have in Connecticut, municipal powers.
- 24:36We're not supposed to be a, oh, I forgot the
- 24:41term, a Dillon state rule. We're not a Dillon
- 24:43state rule. So that means that municipalities
- 24:47can pretty much do something, take it under their
- 24:51own will. as long as the state doesn't prescribe
- 24:55that it cannot do so. But we are a very democratic
- 24:59state where it's very much, and I don't see black
- 25:02and white on zoning at all. It depends on the
- 25:06issue, simply enough. And my party, the Democratic
- 25:10Party, is more like state powers, state powers,
- 25:12state powers. And these fights just don't help.
- 25:20I think it's better to have a non -deal and rule
- 25:24state. And I do believe that municipal powers
- 25:27are better in some aspect. And we had a better
- 25:33plastic bag ban bill because of municipal powers
- 25:36and et cetera. So I think here in the U .S. at
- 25:41least it's a big deal actually between Republicans
- 25:46and Democrats, a big back and forth. And it does
- 25:49come in with pet shops, for examples, or hunting
- 25:52and et cetera. Well, let's dive into this whole
- 26:01mess of polarization and divide between left
- 26:05and right. And my first question on that is how
- 26:10much of that divide is real? you know, between
- 26:13left and right, because you hear lots of studies,
- 26:17you know, talking about how people with a college
- 26:20degree or people of a certain age or people from
- 26:24certain locations are more likely to be on the
- 26:28left or on the right. But then when I look what
- 26:32I compare to individuals from different parts
- 26:35of the political spectrum, and I look into what
- 26:39they agree on, I feel like Most people agree
- 26:43on most things on most issues. So how much of
- 26:48that divide is real? How much of it has been
- 26:52created by maybe the political system itself
- 26:55or by other interests, maybe media platforms?
- 27:02Yeah. Yeah, I think it's really easy to get for
- 27:08people now to get into these. Echo chambers,
- 27:12you know, it's ironic that we're more isolated
- 27:16now than we were, you know, prior to all the
- 27:19technological advances that we have currently.
- 27:21You know, I remember as they, yeah, internet
- 27:24was coming out. It was the idea was we were all
- 27:27gonna, you know, it was the communication age.
- 27:29We were all gonna be, you know, where you could
- 27:31talk to people anywhere, but now it feels like
- 27:32people are putting themselves in their circles,
- 27:35you know, and that's assisted by algorithms and
- 27:38whatever else that kind of trapped them there.
- 27:40I find it funny because I go in, you know, it's
- 27:43sort of the eyeball whatever space I go into.
- 27:45Either I'm going into like an animal movement
- 27:47space and I'm the, you know, one of the one of
- 27:51if not the only like person of the right there.
- 27:53And then if I go to somewhere like turning point,
- 27:54you know, me and whoever came came with our organization,
- 27:57only people that are like there for the animals.
- 27:59So it's it's it's always kind of a there's that
- 28:03initial weirdness. But but ultimately, the funny
- 28:06thing is in both cases, you know, the issues
- 28:08we're talking about people. In either either
- 28:10case pretty much agree with us But the funny
- 28:13thing is one of the one of the funny things I
- 28:14find is like talking to You know if I'm in a
- 28:17more left crowd And people will be surprised
- 28:21to find out that I'm conservative or whatever,
- 28:24because I think it's because it's like, well,
- 28:26yeah, you're not a foaming lunatic monster, which
- 28:29is what I would have assumed you were. And I
- 28:31think that probably happens on the other side
- 28:33too. I think part of this is that we've kind
- 28:35of broken off, we've isolated into these spaces.
- 28:38And then like what David was getting at before
- 28:40too, it's the parties drum this up a lot as well.
- 28:42There are meaningful differences. We disagree
- 28:44on a lot of things and some of those things are
- 28:46very profound and serious, but that doesn't necessarily,
- 28:48agreeing on these political issues doesn't mean
- 28:50that we can't, you know, communicate, can't be
- 28:53in the same, you can't talk through things and
- 28:56find compromises and that kind of deal. So that's
- 28:58a, that's a, yeah, it's hard to say what, what
- 29:03depends, I guess what you mean by how real is
- 29:04it, but I do think you're right that there's
- 29:06a, a lot of this is just, you know, exaggerated
- 29:10when you're outside of the individual level.
- 29:17Thank you, Liam. Maybe I can give a bit of perspective
- 29:23of like, what research finds. So it's it's a
- 29:27rather new area. There's not so much data on
- 29:29that. But like some research I've conducted or
- 29:34like I came across. Yeah, literature reviews
- 29:40is that At least in general, you kind of find
- 29:44a polarization, but it's very small compared
- 29:46to other topics that are also much more in the
- 29:50media and people talk about it a lot. And we
- 29:54also don't understand the polarized polarization
- 29:57that much yet. So I guess like we don't or like
- 30:03there's not so much disagreement around whether
- 30:07animal welfare is important. It's maybe more
- 30:10what kind of solutions are right. So like policy
- 30:13preferences might matter a bit more. And then
- 30:19I think another issue that hasn't been studied
- 30:22so much is just how people, how much people know
- 30:26about the issues and in what kind of, I mean,
- 30:31you mentioned it with those bubbles, like what
- 30:34kind of information environments they are. And
- 30:38maybe some people have just a tendency to not
- 30:42hear about the issue or just get the same message
- 30:44always said everything's fine. Or like, I don't
- 30:49know, also whole sentient or what are the cognitive
- 30:56capacities of animals, things like that, that
- 30:59would matter to drive up this need of like, okay,
- 31:02we have to change something for animals. So those
- 31:06things we don't know, the only thing we kind
- 31:08of know is like, you know, asking the people
- 31:11about how important animal welfare issues are
- 31:14to them. And then you can like statistically,
- 31:18you find some effects, you find some differences,
- 31:21but those are all such as like general patterns
- 31:23where you will always find people that are really,
- 31:27um, not fitting into this. And then this is probably
- 31:33something that people don't think about, like
- 31:35that you could just. meet someone who is completely
- 31:38different, who doesn't fit into this pattern,
- 31:41and then they're surprised. Does it matter if
- 31:53somebody is homeless in the street? And a Republican
- 31:59and a Democrat are working both from different,
- 32:02and they're looking at a homeless person. It's
- 32:07not something that any American being Democrat
- 32:10or Republican should accept in having a child
- 32:15in the street or having our elderly and retirees
- 32:18fall to homelessness, just as it matters the
- 32:26same when it comes to an animal being abused.
- 32:32Yeah, does it matter if somebody is left or right
- 32:35or Democrat or Republican or Libertarian? It's
- 32:41I think when we're talking animal rights when
- 32:43you're talking about social justice We're talking
- 32:46about values like values towards sentient life
- 32:50values towards justice and fairness and I don't
- 32:54necessarily attribute it to only my side of the
- 32:57of the aisle Right and I shouldn't there would
- 32:59be a big mistake And just like, I would expect
- 33:05the Republican not to think that because he's
- 33:08a Democrat, this or that. When it comes to values,
- 33:13how we expect that our government should be treating
- 33:18society and where the money should go back to
- 33:22the workers, the ones who are like sweating day
- 33:26and night working in factories in our country.
- 33:29producing American products that are you know
- 33:32like I think we want we want the same thing in
- 33:35essence maybe there's a small fraction of people
- 33:38that wish harm to certain classes of people to
- 33:41certain types of people to certain look of people
- 33:44but I generally tend that's why I keep being
- 33:47hopeful in those days even though I could not
- 33:51you know I get depressed sometimes but it's and
- 33:54it's not only about here inside the U .S. it's
- 33:56about outside the U .S. and our own influence
- 33:58as a country everywhere we're touching and so
- 34:04I've not seen it and it's what makes it difficult
- 34:08today to talk about political sides is I also
- 34:12don't, and maybe that might be seen inconsiderate,
- 34:17I can't see the current leaders as representing
- 34:22one party or the other. I really don't, not based
- 34:25on values, I can't see that. So for me, it's
- 34:29not like Reagan or Obama, it's not the same picture
- 34:34today. We're not looking at the same thing. You
- 34:41know, we're still looking at mostly legislators.
- 34:45And by the way, I was going to say when you started
- 34:47about legislators earlier, I was going to say
- 34:49I'm the first one who says that most legislators
- 34:52are scumbags because I don't think they do the
- 34:56best they can to do their due diligence and in
- 35:00serving and addressing the issues of their constituencies.
- 35:04That being said, there's some people doing it
- 35:07or try, but they usually don't stay too long.
- 35:10So it's hard for me to speak about division.
- 35:15When division is produced by these party politics
- 35:20and by this government, the more you irritate
- 35:25another side or both sides, just the worst, everything
- 35:29goes. Can't resolve things like that. We can't.
- 35:32Now, I also don't necessarily like to talk about
- 35:35common sense because I think it waters down.
- 35:39It worders down the values, but maybe I could
- 35:43get close to that and talk about that. And that's
- 35:46why I was like a bee in a hive in the General
- 35:49Assembly in the House chamber. I was annoying
- 35:52a lot of people, but I was like a bee in a hive.
- 35:54I didn't care which Democrat or Republican. I'm
- 35:57talking about this. This caused this issue. And
- 36:01if we are both agreeing and you're bothered by
- 36:04some of the terms, I'm going to make sure that
- 36:06the terms get changed. That's it. And then we're
- 36:08working towards a resolve. But I think it's,
- 36:13and also, it also comes back to not only parties,
- 36:17but also factions. Like you're an environmentalist
- 36:21and you're talking about energy. And then we
- 36:27have animal rights. And those are like different
- 36:31factions. In the last few years, I think it's
- 36:35been done all across the US and probably across
- 36:37the world is like there's more and more intersectionality
- 36:40between people. So while there's an age of division,
- 36:44there's also an age of intersectionality that
- 36:47also kind of, thank goodness, kind of go against
- 36:51also the divisive state of things. It's the best
- 36:54way I can say it with a French brain. It feels
- 37:01like we need to this is be above my pay grade
- 37:03on on the how of this but I but get you know
- 37:06Being able to not have all these issues filtered
- 37:10through the You know the the parties the political
- 37:14parties on the and the yeah the media and that's
- 37:16very reciprocal thing Would which would lead
- 37:19to a lot a lot of us being able to work together
- 37:21on things there's there's you know a lot of this
- 37:23I think it's your I would strike me you said
- 37:26there was the about the Yeah, we see a homeless
- 37:30person on the street. We see a kid on the street
- 37:31We see yeah these things we we respond as humans
- 37:34to those as human values there that are not it
- 37:36doesn't really matter Yeah, and I actually think
- 37:38the fact that we have different approaches to
- 37:40solving them I mean, that's the there's a value
- 37:42in intellectual diversity, right? like yeah,
- 37:45if you look at all of the there's been a number
- 37:47of There's still ways to go on this but there's
- 37:50a number of um Animal experimentation programs
- 37:52have been cut in the federal government this
- 37:54year, and that happened because it was a new
- 37:56framing that came about. It was, you know, it
- 37:58started being talked about through the lens of
- 37:59government spending, which is, you know, in a
- 38:01left -gutted animal world, there's never the
- 38:03framing that's going to come up because it's
- 38:04just not how people think about things. So when
- 38:06you have people that care about the same things
- 38:07but come at it from a different place, yeah,
- 38:10different solutions will come up, and there's
- 38:12more solutions to come up, more ways of getting
- 38:13this accomplished. So yeah, it's breaking past
- 38:17that and starting to really, to dive into those
- 38:19things that we actually, you know, all really
- 38:21care about, which is... than animals is, yeah,
- 38:24a great one. And to follow on what Liam has said,
- 38:27there's also bad things that are coming out in
- 38:29this government. For example, I'm helping, I
- 38:32just contacted Earthjustice today on behalf of
- 38:35the Paul Watson Foundation to see if they would
- 38:37take additional people in their litigation against
- 38:41the Guard Squad, against removing the protections
- 38:45on marine life in terms of when it relates to
- 38:50drilling in the Gulf. And then I can go back
- 38:56to other presidents. Really bad things also happen
- 39:00and we're gonna let offshore wind happen by pile
- 39:04driving steel pipes into the seafloor. Then maybe
- 39:08we're also shitting ourselves in the foot or
- 39:10pile driving some steel pipe into our feet. Remember
- 39:15Ray and we talked, I think we had a moment on
- 39:18offshore wind, but that question is still going
- 39:21on. Different ways of doing offshore wind. And
- 39:24then you have like really conservation videos
- 39:26that are sponsored by oil and gas industry in
- 39:30favor of the whales. But where are they in favor
- 39:32of the whales when it comes to the oil and gas
- 39:36industry themselves? So that's why we have to
- 39:40really just go by logic and science. and compassion,
- 39:46and values. Focus, focus, focus, focus. I'll
- 39:52never reach out to legislators based on the fact
- 39:54that they're Democrat or Republican. Unless that
- 39:57actually plays in the issue strongly, then I
- 40:01will do that. But say they have more of a word,
- 40:04like sometimes there's more, if it's a very highly
- 40:08Democrat or Republican state, then that party's
- 40:11gonna have more of a say. on bills, obviously,
- 40:13and especially their leadership. So you want
- 40:16to talk to their leadership, not necessarily
- 40:18your side. Can I ask you from your perspective,
- 40:24do you think with your legislators, does it sometimes
- 40:28matter more which state they present, like what
- 40:32kind of industries and sectors are important
- 40:34in a region, so that they will Yeah, in the end,
- 40:41present more the industry to businesses instead
- 40:46of really having a clear political platform.
- 40:52Do you think this happens a lot? Yeah, you're
- 40:57nailing it. Like, it's one of the issues. You
- 41:00have to remember that a majority of legislators
- 41:03are the biggest representation of society in
- 41:06legislators are lawyers. And for example, lawyers
- 41:11that work for pharmaceuticals happen to push
- 41:13for bills that have to do with pharmaceuticals.
- 41:17Or you might have a legislator that has an army
- 41:23base. And then there's gonna be something towards
- 41:25the army and veterans affairs. Sure, that does
- 41:29have a say. But I mean, I represent, I was representing
- 41:33a part of the city of Stanford, which is. corporations,
- 41:36big corporations. I didn't represent one of them.
- 41:40In the country, I've been fighting them. So that's
- 41:42been my, you know. So yes, it does play, yeah.
- 41:48And you know, the power in politics is when it's
- 41:53coming from the people. So the better you can
- 41:57make the representation, then the better you
- 42:00have a system of politics that, of course, is
- 42:02working. But for example, In those cases, like
- 42:06you would want, or in any case, you would want
- 42:09a full representation of society, right? But
- 42:12it's not. You don't have teachers or maybe one
- 42:15or two in our general assembly. You don't have
- 42:20a waiter or waitress that's there, or several.
- 42:24You don't have an office cleaner that's representing,
- 42:29you know, because you can't do it. You have to
- 42:31be able to have a work that you do from home.
- 42:34So just the whole standards around who can be
- 42:37a legislator, that needs to be looked into. That's
- 42:40definitely a big part. And the gerrymandering
- 42:42is very good at confusing who is who. Because
- 42:46if you're in a majority district Democrat, you
- 42:49know that the general election is going to be
- 42:51won by the Democrat. So if I'm a Republican,
- 42:55And I mean a majority district that was designed
- 42:58so it remains a majority Democrat. I don't even
- 43:01get to vote in a primary because they're not
- 43:03open primaries, right? If they were open primaries,
- 43:06that's a different whole different issue and
- 43:08I would be a great world, but they're not open
- 43:10primary. So then I'm going to become a Democrat.
- 43:13So I can have a say as to which one of the two
- 43:16Democrats should become my elected official.
- 43:19So ever like this, we have a lot of issues here.
- 43:21I'm not sure it's the same issues in Switzerland.
- 43:23I don't not in terms of the political representation
- 43:27but i'm sure every country in the world has issues
- 43:29with political representation i think another
- 43:32thing is uh on the non -elected side yeah there's
- 43:36a if you look at um this is one of the reasons
- 43:39to be you know here's here's some of my conservatives
- 43:42will come out it's uh one of the reasons to be
- 43:44dubious about uh regulations, especially federal
- 43:47regulations, is you look at these, you know,
- 43:49the way a lot of federal legislators handle the
- 43:51legislation is they will abdicate those powers.
- 43:54They'll say, you know, we need to regulate this
- 43:57area and this department, you know, will be in
- 44:00charge of doing that, right? And so you're effectively
- 44:02abdicating to these various branches, to these
- 44:05various departments within the executive branch,
- 44:07legislative authority, right? And so, you know,
- 44:11What ends up happening is you have these industry
- 44:13people within those that are unelected, that
- 44:15are in these bureaucracies. One of the best examples
- 44:18is Tom Vilsack was the head of ag under both
- 44:23Obama and Biden. In between, he was working for
- 44:27Big Dairy. He was a Big Dairy lobbyist, effectively.
- 44:30Not officially, but effectively. How can we expect
- 44:36the USDA to be doing regulations that are going
- 44:41to help dairy cows when a person who works for
- 44:42Big Dairy is running the department. I think
- 44:46that's where a lot of cow factory farming ends
- 44:50up being funded by us, by our tax dollars beyond
- 44:54just subsidies. We're doing all the research
- 44:59for CAPOS. We're doing all of the marketing for
- 45:01CAPOS. That's our tax dollars doing that. That
- 45:06doesn't really matter what your legislator is,
- 45:08that's going through these unelected bureaucracies.
- 45:13Yeah, and the executive branches, the agencies
- 45:16are usually appointed by either a Democratic
- 45:17governor or a Republican governor, and it usually
- 45:20doesn't change. They're pretty much all in favor
- 45:22of industry, point blank. Even the environmental
- 45:26protection agencies in Connecticut is horrible,
- 45:29a disaster. Anyway, sorry. They don't like me
- 45:34either, by the way. I want to get back to one
- 45:40of your comment, David, about the numerous intersectionalities
- 45:45of issues. Well, there's the rise of a new kind
- 45:49of voter called the one issue voter. And part
- 45:54of me thinks it's great. I mean, let's focus
- 45:56on the issue and that will get us out of the
- 46:00political divide, you know, whoever represents
- 46:03my interest. Best I will vote for that person,
- 46:06I don't care about political affiliations. But
- 46:10also that person is less concerned about the
- 46:14rest, more issues. Should we wish for one issue
- 46:19voters that are only concerned about animal rights
- 46:22and animal welfare? Or should we wish for less
- 46:28one issue voters and more people including in
- 46:31their list of issues? the animal protection.
- 46:36What do you make of that question? Rayan, how
- 46:39broad is the issue you're talking about? Because
- 46:41if my issue is social justice, then hey, there
- 46:46we go. Because everything as you, we're approaching
- 46:48this from an intersectionality point of view.
- 46:51So one issue voter, like if your animal rights,
- 46:59Mean I passed a resolution at the I don't know
- 47:02if you know that the National Lawyers Guild So
- 47:04now the National Lawyers Guild is like I think
- 47:07the first legal organization In the u .s.. Probably
- 47:10the world that actually incorporates animal rights
- 47:13in their social justice work so So on if we approach
- 47:20this on the basis of Intersectionalities and
- 47:23it should we wish one issue as in animal rights
- 47:26to vote only for people who are pro animal rights
- 47:30Well, just like I explained to non -vegans with
- 47:34the NLG to vote in favor of this is that we're
- 47:37the the advocates are Subjected to the same systems
- 47:42of oppression in all those different issues like
- 47:45so if you're going about homelessness Whatever
- 47:49you do that bothers the powers that be which
- 47:53means the government, and you're pointing out
- 47:55the errors of the government and the crevices
- 47:57where they're leaving some of the voiceless,
- 48:00or even humans that are voiceless, out of the
- 48:03picture. You can't be like you can't be one issue
- 48:09because the other issues affect your issue So
- 48:11it just I don't think it works and I don't think
- 48:14it's a good It's a good approach when we had
- 48:17a time when we act as a matter of fact trying
- 48:19to consolidate forces with others Okay, you want
- 48:23to protect the environment. Well, did you know
- 48:25and then you pop up the conspiracy facts sheet?
- 48:28And say did you know all of this or did you see
- 48:31the smell of money? When we are for the protection
- 48:42and compassion towards sentient life, I mean
- 48:46it's sometimes a conversation between my wife
- 48:48and I, sometimes my wife is fed up with humans.
- 48:51And I'm there fighting both for non -human and
- 48:54human animals, which sometimes is not a good
- 48:58mix. For me, I think it's dangerous to go one
- 49:06issue and to wish for one issue voters, because
- 49:11that also shows that we're just close -minded
- 49:13and that we have this one view. It's like the
- 49:15bad image of the vegan, the vegan who wants to
- 49:18impose. I don't know. I kind of make parallels
- 49:20maybe too easily. That's a good question. I leave
- 49:24you guys take it. Sorry. Thank you, David. I
- 49:29guess I would say I do get a kick when you said
- 49:32that. I get a kick out of the idea of like all
- 49:35the South Carolina Democrats. They're going to
- 49:37have to vote for Nancy Mace because there's like
- 49:40almost I don't even know who's going to run against
- 49:41her for governor. There's almost no way to make
- 49:43them more on animals. So but now I think I think
- 49:49that's a complicated thing. One thing it raises,
- 49:52though, that I, you know, I've brought up kind
- 49:55of since launching Wilberforce is yeah. One problem
- 50:00for single issue voters on animal issues is that
- 50:11neither party is really on their side. It's something
- 50:13I kind of point out to the people on the left
- 50:16in the animal movement. I promise you Wilberforce
- 50:18is a better friend to your issues than the Democratic
- 50:20party is. Because we're actually focused on animals.
- 50:25I do think you see over and over again You know
- 50:29more lip services paid to animals I think on
- 50:31the left I think everyone could probably agree
- 50:32with that like they're they'll talk about it
- 50:34more But they're not really doing much. I would
- 50:36argue they're here worse if not the same it's
- 50:40on animal issues and so it's it's a Yeah, I guess
- 50:44I guess being a single issue voters one thing
- 50:46but it's it's just it's going to fall apart looking
- 50:49at the parties for sure It's always disheartening
- 50:54to see animals always get kicked to it as a secondary
- 50:57or tertiary issue. They'll talk about it until
- 51:02now it's time to actually do something and then
- 51:04it falls by the wayside. I mentioned my wife,
- 51:07and sorry Sandro, I'm just going to say quickly,
- 51:09I love my wife. She would vote only for legislators.
- 51:12She doesn't care their parties. If they're there,
- 51:15if they're going to help animals, that's it.
- 51:17I love her. and for being that way. So I'm not
- 51:21judgmental on it. And that's all I'm saying.
- 51:24For me, it's more difficult because I intertwine
- 51:26everything all the time. I'm complicated. Sandro,
- 51:29sorry, thank you. And I really have a good answer
- 51:32on it. Yeah, I agree that from the perspective
- 51:38of the US system, it's probably pretty unlikely
- 51:43that single issue, like the animal welfare animal
- 51:47rights will be the single issue that both parties
- 51:49focus on. From a European perspective, there
- 51:53is a couple of countries, Switzerland is included
- 51:56kind of more on the, not on the federal level,
- 51:59but on the cantonal level, but also in other
- 52:02countries like the Netherlands, there's kind
- 52:04of this trend of like, there are, are these emerging
- 52:09that are really singles. or almost single issue
- 52:12focused on animals. And you can do this because
- 52:16like their thresholds to be included in the parliament
- 52:20is very low. And yeah, it works because the system
- 52:25allows it. And it seems like from what I've seen
- 52:29is that those parties, they get some percentage
- 52:34of the vote, but obviously not so much because
- 52:38in the end, most of the political discussions
- 52:41are still about other issues. And I guess also
- 52:44if I'm correct, they have to start, even if they
- 52:49start as a single issue party, they have to take
- 52:53positions on other issues. Otherwise they just,
- 52:56I mean, they can't be in the government not taking
- 52:59positions on other issues. So it kind of doesn't
- 53:02work, but what they do, I think is they attract
- 53:06those people that consider themselves a single
- 53:08issue voter for animals. So like David's wife,
- 53:12I guess would vote for those parties, but yeah,
- 53:16I don't know how sustainable it is. And I also,
- 53:21I don't know whether people who are not so interested
- 53:25in animal welfare issues, being those parties
- 53:28are yeah, kind of selfish or kind of detached
- 53:33from the reality because they just focus on one
- 53:35issue. A lot of people will think, okay, there
- 53:39are other issues that are much more important.
- 53:42I don't know. In a research project that we just
- 53:47conducted, it looked a bit like in the Netherlands,
- 53:54we found that there was a lot more discussions
- 53:57about animal welfare issues in the political
- 54:00party programs. And from this party itself, the
- 54:05one focused on animal welfare issues, but also
- 54:08other parties. And it seems like based on some
- 54:13data we already have that this happens in other
- 54:16countries too. And what I could see is that such
- 54:20a single issue party focused on animals will
- 54:23just also push the other parties to talk more
- 54:26about the issue. And there might be a catalyst
- 54:28that helps a lot. I guess having people in the
- 54:32system that just pushed this top page, even though
- 54:35they are not the successful ones, might be a
- 54:37very good thing. But this is the maximum I could
- 54:40see you else like the benefits. I was going to
- 54:44say, I think there's a difference between single
- 54:46shoe voter and single shoe party. And you kind
- 54:48of nailed that there. Because if you're doing
- 54:50a party on this and the immediate critique is,
- 54:54oh, well, you lost it for X candidate. And it's
- 54:57like, well, if this If this size of our voting
- 55:00block is enough for us to sway the results of
- 55:03this election, maybe you should give a damn about
- 55:04our issues. You know, maybe you should be working
- 55:06on these issues. So again, I mean, this is another
- 55:08one, you know, in New York, he has a little while
- 55:14they didn't have a chance, but he was definitely
- 55:15the better on animals than anyone in that race.
- 55:18And, you know, if that was something that was
- 55:21going to. If you had a bunch of single issue
- 55:23voters there, then yeah, they messed up the election
- 55:26for whoever, you know, then that that could be
- 55:28something that would be something that they should
- 55:29then consider like, well, maybe we should actually
- 55:31take this issue set seriously. Let me ask this
- 55:35follow up question, kind of this whole conversation
- 55:38kind of inspired this question, but why aren't
- 55:42political parties considering vegans or vegetarians
- 55:47or animal welfare is an important voting block
- 55:52in most countries, including the US. There are
- 55:57millions of them, millions of us, yet we're not
- 56:01talked about as other voting blocks that are
- 56:05sometimes less important. So they'll say, you
- 56:07know, the Catholics or college educated or, and
- 56:12there are many more vegetarians and vegans and
- 56:15animal welfare. So why aren't we considered more
- 56:19seriously? by political parties during elections.
- 56:24I think my guess on this, and I don't have data
- 56:28to back it up, but I would think it really has
- 56:30to do with the fact that it's become such a specifically
- 56:33left -coded movement. So, yeah, the idea is that
- 56:37even though there's so many people on the right
- 56:39who care deeply about animals who work, who spend
- 56:41their lives working on animals, yeah, if you
- 56:43look at the rescue world, the sanctuary world
- 56:47of the seven units, it's... populated very heavily
- 56:49by conservatives like a lot of baguette conservatives
- 56:51in the U .S. But still the idea is the animal
- 56:54movement, the people who vote on animal issues,
- 56:57that's generally considered to be of the left.
- 57:00And the idea is they're not going to vote anywhere
- 57:01else no matter what. They're always going to
- 57:03vote for Democrats regardless of whether they...
- 57:05So how are Democrats incentivized to work on
- 57:07that if they have those, if they can take those
- 57:09votes for granted? And how are Republicans incentivized
- 57:11if they're not going to vote for them anyway,
- 57:14right? That's kind of part of why I'm... uh why
- 57:17why Wilberforce is doing what it's doing is we're
- 57:19trying to get past that that uh bifurcation and
- 57:23trying to break that that um yeah that this idea
- 57:27that it's only only people on the left are associated
- 57:29with these issues when we it's something we all
- 57:31care about yeah because what you're implying
- 57:37instead right now it's not worth to compete for
- 57:40the for the vegans as a group of um potential
- 57:45voters because it's, it's not, yeah. The politicians
- 57:51themselves are not aware that there's a, that
- 57:54there could be a competition and yeah. I disagree
- 57:59with that point of view. Uh, and that's not because
- 58:02I'm on the left. Uh, I'm, I'm, I'm disagree with
- 58:06that point of view. I think it's so first it
- 58:08depends on the districts. So if I look on a small
- 58:11scale now, I'm going back to Connecticut, sorry.
- 58:14And I'm looking at different voting districts.
- 58:19There are districts where there are more animal
- 58:23liberation people involved in the local politics
- 58:27as well. Enough so that a left or a right wing,
- 58:32here we had Shays, I think his name was Chris
- 58:35Shays, right? Republican. Adored by animal rights
- 58:39people here and even by Democrats. And he was
- 58:43elected. uh and he so and he was also respectful
- 58:47of the cause all i'm trying to say is that the
- 58:51numbers where we are now today represented in
- 58:53society might not be high enough and that's what
- 58:56i'm i'm kind of leaning to to think we're not
- 59:00in high enough numbers so that we can influence
- 59:03a majority of districts elections where where
- 59:09Certain districts certainly can like if any hornish
- 59:12in Connecticut the director of the HSUS her Locality,
- 59:15they know that there's gonna be a lot of people
- 59:18that are following what she's doing And she doesn't
- 59:20care if you're Democrat or Republican if you're
- 59:21gonna vote for animal rights bills that's what
- 59:24we're gonna be pushing for and and so is that
- 59:27single issue not necessarily but And I say it's
- 59:31not necessary because they don't only always
- 59:34look at just that there's always a little bit
- 59:36more the person committed fraud and perjury and
- 59:41went to jail not because they went to jail but
- 59:43because they did commit some pretty serious crimes
- 59:47and violating the public trust then maybe that's
- 59:51not the person you want in place. But I don't
- 59:55think they really necessarily look between Democrat
- 59:57or Republican because frankly, and I really truly
- 1:00:01believe that, and I was involved in politics
- 1:00:02here at least, there's not that much of a difference.
- 1:00:06There's a whole lot of show in front of TV news
- 1:00:08where the minority leader from the Republicans
- 1:00:11at the end of our sessions comes out to the news
- 1:00:13and says, the Democrats didn't let us work on
- 1:00:16the budget, blah, blah, blah. And at the same
- 1:00:18time, the leader of the Democrats goes on his
- 1:00:20other side and all they do is complain, ta -da
- 1:00:23-da, we invited them. and we invited them to,
- 1:00:25but they don't. And it's both doing a show to
- 1:00:29entertain that division, while that's not really
- 1:00:31what happened behind doors, where everybody came
- 1:00:33together and agreed. And there's a majority of
- 1:00:37Democrats and Republicans who vote in favor of
- 1:00:39the budget. So the play Democrat, Republican
- 1:00:42from, and maybe possibly because I did grow up
- 1:00:47in France under a different political system,
- 1:00:49but here to me, there's not that much of a difference
- 1:00:54between Republican and Democrats. I don't see
- 1:00:56those major differences except when it comes
- 1:01:00to, I think the biggest real division maybe on
- 1:01:07immigration. And again, I don't even think so
- 1:01:09because I know as many Democrats as Republicans
- 1:01:12that will say that we need a border, point blank,
- 1:01:15that we need some infrastructure. So I... I'm
- 1:01:20not seeing that big of a deal, Democrat -Republican
- 1:01:23center right to more right. What's the, you know,
- 1:01:29and the leaderships of those two parties work
- 1:01:32hand in hand. Behind doors, they work hand in
- 1:01:36hand and they agree on stuff. So it's like more
- 1:01:39than what they... So again, the... I think that
- 1:01:44we still don't have enough influence. I think
- 1:01:46it's just a matter of numbers. And that's why
- 1:01:48the more we intersect with other advocates on
- 1:01:51other issues, might they be left or right? If
- 1:01:54they're an advocate for conservation, then we
- 1:01:57have a discussion. We can have a discussion.
- 1:01:59If they're a hunter, well, maybe it stops somewhere.
- 1:02:01Because at some point, not understanding the
- 1:02:04three laws of ecology is probably a mistake,
- 1:02:06especially for somebody who calls themselves
- 1:02:08a conservationist. Let's go. Let's go. I think
- 1:02:14it's just a matter of numbers and talking openly,
- 1:02:19not imposing our views, but putting ourselves
- 1:02:21in their setting and see if there's some comfort
- 1:02:25area where we can discuss our view and see if
- 1:02:29maybe actually we kind of agree on the ethics.
- 1:02:33And so maybe we can get to an agreement. I don't
- 1:02:37see the division that's force -fed to the public.
- 1:02:42unless you fall into that, into those rhetorics.
- 1:02:46And if you want to not listen to those rhetorics,
- 1:02:48you have the choice not to, and then you can
- 1:02:50make your own judgment. I don't think on most
- 1:02:54animal rights issues, people that are Democrats
- 1:02:57or Republican might actually be, it could be
- 1:02:59a moderate Republican and a moderate Democrat,
- 1:03:03and they pretty much have the same views. So
- 1:03:05there's a moment where we have to stop on using
- 1:03:10those words and continue feeding the weaponization
- 1:03:14of words which is at a high level today and work
- 1:03:18on issues together and that's it. Again, it's
- 1:03:22about values. It's not about what the party thinks,
- 1:03:25which party thinks what. It's the values and
- 1:03:29most parties should be agreeing. If we had a
- 1:03:32bunch of parties like in Europe, most parties
- 1:03:34should be in agreement with what's the right
- 1:03:37thing to do. That's it. I don't really disagree
- 1:03:40if that wasn't really so where I was getting
- 1:03:42at is more if there's a perception that this
- 1:03:44this This block is only going to vote for one
- 1:03:47way then they're not a competitive block It's
- 1:03:49not something that you feel like you have to
- 1:03:51work for it's maybe a base that you can activate,
- 1:03:54right? But then but then they're right Yeah Republicans
- 1:03:57aren't going to think of that as a right that
- 1:03:59you need to there as a block They need to activate
- 1:04:01if they don't think it's gettable. This is sort
- 1:04:03of where I was going But I but I do agree and
- 1:04:05I and I you know thinking my day job is making
- 1:04:11the case and showing that there's just as many
- 1:04:13people on the right that feel this way, feel
- 1:04:15strongly about it, and kind of just bring them
- 1:04:17to the forefront. Because I think, yeah, it's
- 1:04:19numbers. And we don't get those numbers by limiting
- 1:04:23the base. We get them by expanding it. And I
- 1:04:27know there's a lot of people to share the values
- 1:04:28that I do that put the protection of animals
- 1:04:33at the forefront. And that's, yeah. I think that's
- 1:04:37the key is getting them, getting them to voice
- 1:04:39themselves and get, and make that a major voting
- 1:04:41issue for them. Okay. I, so I asked about, I
- 1:04:48think the perspective of the voter, the person
- 1:04:52on the sideline, but what about getting, being
- 1:04:56part of the game and David, you were very much
- 1:05:00part of that game. You became an elected representative
- 1:05:04in the state of Connecticut. Should we encourage
- 1:05:07more of that? You know, and recently I've been
- 1:05:12invited to fundraiser for Dr. Ami Shah. Have
- 1:05:17you heard of him? And I've seen so many funders
- 1:05:21in the animal rights space supporting his campaign.
- 1:05:24He's openly vegan and pro animal rights. Should
- 1:05:29we feed that momentum and just encourage members
- 1:05:33of our movement to become elected officials.
- 1:05:41Absolutely. I mean, the, uh, the idea of, uh,
- 1:05:44of a democracy that works is when there is discussion
- 1:05:46and when there's contest and, um, and having
- 1:05:52somebody run, encouraging somebody to run, even
- 1:05:55if there's not, if they consider that there's
- 1:05:57not no chance to win considering the settings,
- 1:06:00right? I was talking about gerrymandering and
- 1:06:02et cetera. So even as a third party candidate,
- 1:06:05because once you run, you are bringing your causes
- 1:06:10into the discussion and you might actually impact
- 1:06:13the campaign from your opponents. They might
- 1:06:17have to think about what you're saying and might
- 1:06:19have to adapt. So they capture your base and
- 1:06:21then you are eliminated. But it's good because
- 1:06:25you're serving the cause. So no matter what,
- 1:06:27there's never a failure in running a primary.
- 1:06:30As long as you're outspoken and you bring the
- 1:06:32cause out to the public and knocking on doors,
- 1:06:36then it's going to keep everybody in check. And
- 1:06:39that's the first thing I think that's most important.
- 1:06:42And it expands the conversation. I love that.
- 1:06:46Liam? Yeah, I agree. I think if you know one
- 1:06:55thing is is at least on the Republican side and
- 1:06:58trying to kind of Grow that part of it is that
- 1:07:03there's there's already a lot of people who are
- 1:07:05there that aren't getting Notice for it recognized
- 1:07:07for it. Yeah, I already mentioned Nancy Mase
- 1:07:09earlier and and who's put towards with tons of
- 1:07:13Actually has a list of like animal rights legislation
- 1:07:16That she's done pressure leases on it's just
- 1:07:18it's just something she actually actively runs
- 1:07:20on John Kennedy Louisiana like there's a there's
- 1:07:23a number of Republicans all the animal protection
- 1:07:24caucus like a million talkers and right for Gerald
- 1:07:27like there's there's a ton who just work on our
- 1:07:29grade on animal issues and I think part of it
- 1:07:32is just is finding ways to highlight and and
- 1:07:37talk up and promote the people who are doing
- 1:07:39this and show that it matters and has an impact
- 1:07:41and that people care about it. And then it's
- 1:07:42a reason to vote for them. And I think then you
- 1:07:43can incentivize more to get into, to start taking
- 1:07:47a stand on those issues, even where it maybe
- 1:07:50runs counter to their party or what they perceive
- 1:07:52their voter base as being focused on. Sandro,
- 1:07:59thank you, Liam. Yeah. Well, I guess... It is
- 1:08:05definitely a great idea to inspire more people
- 1:08:10to just get very active in politics if they want
- 1:08:14to promote this issue, which is not really something
- 1:08:17that most advocates would think about. But then
- 1:08:21also the other perspective of like, organizations
- 1:08:26that are trying to have a conversation with already
- 1:08:29established politicians who don't think about
- 1:08:33the issue, or yeah, just don't have it on their
- 1:08:37plate. I think it needs both. If I had to decide
- 1:08:42how to distribute the resources, I wouldn't just
- 1:08:45put all in like having a new generation of politicians.
- 1:08:50Because like, I don't know, I guess it depends
- 1:08:54on the system. But like, yeah, it's not that
- 1:08:58easy. Maybe And we have to change something now
- 1:09:01so we can't wait for a new generation. So we
- 1:09:04have to get also the ones in power on our side
- 1:09:08and yeah. Amazing. So that I think is enough.
- 1:09:17And also I want to be respectful of your time
- 1:09:20again. So did you want to add something before
- 1:09:24I stopped the recording? Wanted to add one thing
- 1:09:30that we might not have touched that is really
- 1:09:32important is war and the impact of war on pets
- 1:09:37in Ukraine or livestock farm animals in Gaza
- 1:09:43or just like So it's like it's something also
- 1:09:48that politicians are behind these are big numbers
- 1:09:51there's huge number if you look up the numbers
- 1:09:53of animals killed by war. It's incredible. It's
- 1:09:57in the hundreds of thousands with cats and dogs
- 1:09:59in Ukraine. And that's again, that's politics
- 1:10:04that are bringing us there. And so I think it's
- 1:10:08an aspect of politics that even in animal rights
- 1:10:11circle, we don't talk too much about war. And
- 1:10:13we should. Because one of our one of our key
- 1:10:16things why we're really annoying as vegans is
- 1:10:19we take the conversation all the way on every
- 1:10:22level and stick stay really really fall on that
- 1:10:26issue and And that's where the intersection at
- 1:10:30least started happening So that's something that's
- 1:10:37that was in Afghanistan 2009 10 and again 13
- 1:10:42and I And I saw horrific things happen to animals
- 1:10:47and it's stuck with me as much as anything else
- 1:10:48that's happened there. So I hear exactly what
- 1:10:51you're saying. I also, I would say though, and
- 1:10:54one of the reasons I think people probably stay
- 1:10:57with it. So I'll put it this way, for Wilberforce,
- 1:11:01we talk about things through sort of a conservative
- 1:11:02lens and kind of the free market framing, pro
- 1:11:05-liberty framing, but we try not to expand out
- 1:11:09of the sheer areas that are, yeah. I don't want
- 1:11:13to say tangential because I see your point. I
- 1:11:14mean, there's animals being heard here. It might
- 1:11:17work better on the left, certainly. Well, I don't
- 1:11:21know. It's interesting. I think the work question
- 1:11:24is an interesting one because I think it's very,
- 1:11:27you know, that's a foreign policy in general.
- 1:11:29I think you get a wide array of answers within
- 1:11:32each political spectrum, right? You can never
- 1:11:36really guess where someone's going to. to fall
- 1:11:38in the hawk -dove spectrum. But I guess maybe
- 1:11:42that's part of it is being, I guess it would
- 1:11:44be being mindful to recognize that you might
- 1:11:47have an ally who is very hawk and you might have
- 1:11:49an ally who's very, very much a doves and you
- 1:11:51might, or probably most of us fall somewhere
- 1:11:53in between, so. Yeah, and Liam, both people in
- 1:11:57the Republican Democratic Party are against the
- 1:12:00war. So there we go again. It's, again, there's
- 1:12:04not... we can we can pretend we have major differences
- 1:12:07but when it comes to you know i think yeah values
- 1:12:12like we you know we have homeless and the rise
- 1:12:16we have animal suffering we have people without
- 1:12:18health care and there's so much money being spent
- 1:12:21somewhere else I think I got myself in trouble
- 1:12:26with this one. I've noticed that presidential
- 1:12:28candidates tend to be very against war and presidents
- 1:12:31have a different view. You're right because that's
- 1:12:36what politicians do. They adapt to their advantage
- 1:12:42with the situation when it comes to elections.
- 1:12:46Then after that, once they're elected, who knows
- 1:12:48if whatever they said. That is definitely a bipartisan
- 1:12:50future. Exactly. Yeah, we've heard lots of veterans
- 1:12:57like yourself, Liam, being very much unsatisfied
- 1:13:01and being outspoken about how unsatisfied they
- 1:13:04are with the current foreign policies and the
- 1:13:08wars. What about you, Sandro? How true is that
- 1:13:13myth that Switzerland is always neutral in times
- 1:13:16of war? like also art conversation in our country
- 1:13:27because like how do you position yourself when
- 1:13:30there's so much going on around the world and
- 1:13:32there's different interpretations of neutrality
- 1:13:36of this like words that seems like pretty clear
- 1:13:40but like different people's different political
- 1:13:44beliefs and have interpreted in a different way,
- 1:13:48how far it should go and how much it means that
- 1:13:50we don't get involved in anything so it's it's
- 1:13:54just it's maybe it's funny from outside but it's
- 1:13:56actually a thing that polarizes right now in
- 1:14:00in switzerland it's like what does neutrality
- 1:14:02mean like and um yeah how should we position
- 1:14:06ourselves as a small country that uh yeah is
- 1:14:12head doesn't have so much power I appreciate
- 1:14:18and respect the military, and I appreciate your
- 1:14:22service, of course, for our country. All the
- 1:14:25best thoughts on this. I just was thinking, I
- 1:14:29hope the interpretation was not made that was,
- 1:14:32yeah. No, no, no. Sandra, I have to ask. I'm
- 1:14:39glad Switzerland is neutral. I think other countries
- 1:14:42are also neutral because who wants to put oil
- 1:14:46on the fire? Sandro, is it true that all Swiss
- 1:14:51citizens get an AR -15 when they have that at
- 1:14:55home or an M4? No. It is required for men with
- 1:15:04Swiss nationality to do military service or something
- 1:15:08else, civil service, if they can't commit to
- 1:15:14military service or other things. Yeah, I think
- 1:15:19this idea or the that every person has a rifle
- 1:15:24at home. I think maybe in the past it was like
- 1:15:27that. But yeah, after military service, you have
- 1:15:30to keep your rifle. And you have to like there's
- 1:15:34specific requirements, how to keep it at home,
- 1:15:37like we don't get ammunition, for example, and
- 1:15:40stuff like that, you have to be very, very, it's
- 1:15:43just very strict about that. But yeah, this is
- 1:15:45something that It's kind of part of this neutrality
- 1:15:51and idea of like, okay, you are also supposed
- 1:15:56to have an army that protects your own country
- 1:16:01because you are not really supposed to depend
- 1:16:06on other countries. Yeah. And what about the
- 1:16:10bunkers? You know, lots of people have been thinking
- 1:16:13about getting a bunker these days. Is it true?
- 1:16:17Yes. Yeah, those are super common. And I think
- 1:16:20for most buildings, if you have a new building,
- 1:16:23you have to make sure you have a bunker. Like
- 1:16:26the apartment building I live in, we have a bunker,
- 1:16:31but it's used as a cellar and it's not really,
- 1:16:35it's kind of the joke of like when war arrives,
- 1:16:40people just have their skis and their wine in
- 1:16:43the cellar and they're not really ready because
- 1:16:45like, yeah, but yeah, There's a lot of, um, a
- 1:16:49lot of bunkers and stuff like that, or like old,
- 1:16:53um, things from the, yeah, from older times still
- 1:16:57in the, in the forest, you can find them. Fascinating.
- 1:17:03I think I was just turned into us asking you
- 1:17:04questions about Switzerland. Yeah. Switzerland
- 1:17:11is beautiful. I visited Zurich once. And I was
- 1:17:15just astonished. You know, it was really, really
- 1:17:18beautiful. So thank you, everyone, for your answers.
- 1:17:23This has been a very insightful conversation.
- 1:17:27I'm truly looking forward to sharing this conversation,
- 1:17:30this episode with my audience. So a big thank
- 1:17:34you for all of your amazing activism and also
- 1:17:39for having taken the time to be a guest on the
- 1:17:43show. Thank you. Thank you, Ryan. Merci. Thank
- 1:17:49you everyone for listening. I kindly invite you
- 1:17:52to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:17:55Let's encourage more people to take action. Again,
- 1:17:59thank you so much for caring and I will see you
- 1:18:02next Tuesday for a new episode.