Latest / The Dillon England Show / The Cost of Voting | Can Socialism Work? | Immigration Meets Economy with Economist Wes Davenport
Transcript
- 0:00There are power dynamics here within this idea of socialism that seems so likely
- 0:06to corrupt the individual in charge that it's an untenable idea.
- 0:11I like to use the example of like the kid game King of the Hill.
- 0:15Well imagine you're playing that on a big stack of gravel, okay? That's the market.
- 0:21That's your market process. Everyone's fighting to get to the top.
- 0:23The moment you get to the top, not only is everyone else trying to knock you
- 0:27down, your footing's unstable too. You can't control a free market because by
- 0:31definition, it's a free market, right?
- 0:34Government likes control. They like controlling things.
- 0:37So if you like controlling things, what is the best form of economic theory
- 0:43that you would want to have? It'd be socialism.
- 0:51Everyone, thank you so much for coming back to the show. I'm excited for this
- 0:55podcast for a couple of reasons. is number one.
- 0:56It is the first time in our brand new studio, which I know I've talked to you
- 1:01guys that it's coming soon, but we finally did it. So that's exciting.
- 1:03Thank you all for the support over the year. I have my buddy Wes here.
- 1:07Wes, our relationship's fun. We were just talking about it off camera.
- 1:10We met on Twitter because we were both diehard Pistons fans.
- 1:15Wes happens to be a producer of a very successful blog, excuse me,
- 1:19podcast called The Pistons Pulse. The blog's not there yet. Vlog's not where you want to go, yeah.
- 1:24But very successful from a sports podcast perspective, and he produces that.
- 1:29He also has his own podcast called The Pin Down that he runs with Blake Silverman.
- 1:34And so he's done a lot of content creation, but his real passion is economics.
- 1:37He has his master's degree from George Mason.
- 1:41Correct me if I gave this wrong. And we met on Twitter because of the Pistons.
- 1:44And then over time, we created a really good relationship.
- 1:48And the way we actually started talking was because I tweeted out something
- 1:52that didn't make sense to me.
- 1:54And then he messaged me on Twitter being like, I might actually have an economic answer for you.
- 1:59And then now you know you're on the show. So welcome, man. Yeah,
- 2:02thank you. Thanks for having me.
- 2:04So for everyone listening, we have not done anything like this before.
- 2:08This is a new kind of mode for us to go to.
- 2:12In the past, it's been all business, but I'd love today to kind of talk about,
- 2:17economics of kind of like a bunch of questions I have.
- 2:20I think economics could be scary for a lot of people, I think,
- 2:23or they just don't care or they don't know how it works.
- 2:25And economics is very important because it kind of runs the country in a way,
- 2:30like at least the theories behind it.
- 2:32So we're going to talk about a lot of fun things today, a lot of potential controversial things today.
- 2:37And controversial, not because we're trying to be, just because when it comes
- 2:41to these belief structures, there are people that will die on both hills.
- 2:45And so I wanted to talk to someone that has a lot more knowledge than I do about
- 2:48these issues, and that happened to be Wes.
- 2:50And Wes drove three hours, two hours and 55, 45? I mean, we could round that up.
- 2:55To be here. And we're glad you're here, man. So I guess the first thing that
- 3:00brought us together was this question. We can just kind of dive in here.
- 3:03So if anyone follows my Twitter, I wouldn't recommend it unless you want to get a lot of political.
- 3:10Pistons and politics are like the two things I tweet. The two Ps.
- 3:13So I was looking at the homelessness of California. Okay.
- 3:17And I was just saying...
- 3:19Why do people in California vote for Gavin Newsom? Because to me,
- 3:23from an outside looking in, I'm like, I wouldn't want to live there right now.
- 3:27Things are crazy expensive. The homelessness is out of control.
- 3:29And so I just put out the question, why do people vote for Gavin Newsom?
- 3:34And then you responded and you were just like, I have an answer.
- 3:38So talk to me about voter economics.
- 3:41Why do people vote the way they vote?
- 3:44And then what's the, yeah, you have a theory on this. So it's a talk to you
- 3:49about this. Well, it's not, it's not my theory.
- 3:51So I want to make sure that that one's clear. This is, this is all coming from
- 3:54what's known as the public choice school of economics.
- 3:57So that is more of the political bent. A lot of economics will get into like
- 4:02institutional type analysis.
- 4:06Public choice is very much why do voters and why do political systems output the things that they do?
- 4:12So in this specific instance, the, the first thing that you got to be aware
- 4:16of when you're analyzing it is to ask the question, does that one vote really matter?
- 4:22Statistically, it doesn't. So in order for a vote to matter,
- 4:25you'd need an election so close that it's going to come down to one vote.
- 4:29And not only that, you'd need that one vote to be your vote.
- 4:33So the odds of that ever happening, even at a really small local election,
- 4:38incredibly small, incredibly low odds.
- 4:41So So practically, you should vote. I'm not telling you not to vote.
- 4:45I think voting is a civic duty and it's a good thing for a lot of people to do.
- 4:49But practically, your vote is not going to be the deciding one.
- 4:52So if you're not voting because you think your vote is going to decide the election,
- 4:57which is the assumption we're going to make here, then why would you vote?
- 5:00There are high costs. It takes a lot of time to get to the polls.
- 5:05It takes a lot of time to research all of these candidates, to have an understanding
- 5:09of where everyone's policy position is. your opinions on it,
- 5:12even just watching the news.
- 5:13That's part of the voting process for actual individual voters.
- 5:17That takes time too. So there is a fairly high cost. You need something.
- 5:22Valuable enough for most people to, you know, exceed that cost.
- 5:26So that's the calculation you're trying to make. Uh, in this case,
- 5:30most, I would expect most public choice theorists would, would lean to saying
- 5:35that there's a social desirability bias.
- 5:38People want to be well-liked amongst their friends. So if you can be voting
- 5:44Democrat in California, where likely most of your friends are Democrats and
- 5:48are very happy with these positions,
- 5:50whether you hold them or not, if you say, hey, I just voted for Gavin Newsom
- 5:55and you get a pat on the back, I can make it all worth it.
- 5:58In reality, you're just trying to be a little bit closer to the people you care about.
- 6:03And that's a pretty rational thing to do. I wouldn't say that it's the wrong approach,
- 6:09but in terms of why people might vote against, quote unquote,
- 6:13quote their self-interest, whatever someone might identify that as,
- 6:16there is a lot of social capital that you can gain.
- 6:19So what would it take then for somebody to say, I know all of my friends,
- 6:26like at what point is the breaking point?
- 6:28Because I feel like at some level, if I'm living in California and I can't safely
- 6:32walk from point A to point B, I'm going to say,
- 6:35you know, I'm not voting with my family, but that is what the theory,
- 6:39the theory is people, people will to their potential own harm and detriment
- 6:46do what's popular. Is that, is that?
- 6:50Sort of. So what I would say is that the weight, the push and pull of this is between your vote,
- 6:59mattering to change that outcome versus the potential feedback you could get
- 7:05from friends, family coworkers, right?
- 7:08So again, if we go all the way, you know, we go back to saying,
- 7:11statistically, my vote's not going to change the outcome.
- 7:14If I accept this, then you're really only doing yourself harm.
- 7:19If you think about it by voting for what you truly want in the end,
- 7:24if you disagree with, you know,
- 7:26Gavin Newsom in this case, right? You're doing yourself more harm because your
- 7:30circle will likely find out that, Hey, you know, I voted against this.
- 7:34They'll be upset with you and you lose some of that social capital.
- 7:38Whereas you flip it and you say, okay, well, you know, it's not likely that
- 7:42I'm going to change this myself by casting my one vote against Gavin Newsom
- 7:47again, in this case, right?
- 7:49Why would I, why does it matter? You know, I stand more to lose personally than
- 7:53the state stands to lose in that general election.
- 7:57Yeah, because we were talking about it at lunch and you kind of mentioned it
- 8:00here. It's where it's like each person's vote actually statistically doesn't matter.
- 8:04Like the way you phrased it was if that your vote is going to be the deciding
- 8:10vote is going to be the probability of zero, pretty much.
- 8:14Like the percentage is not in your favor that your vote is going to actually matter.
- 8:18It's not, of course, to be clear, it's not zero, but it's well under one.
- 8:23Chance. And so in theory, someone's like, well, my vote doesn't matter anyway.
- 8:28So if that's what people believe that their vote doesn't matter,
- 8:31then they're going to do with socially, whatever makes the most sense.
- 8:35Effectively, right? You're venturing into this now space of something called
- 8:40rational irrationality, right?
- 8:42So there's another aspect of this to, you know, why are so many people uninformed voters?
- 8:49Well, because of all of the cost associated with going to actually to the polls
- 8:54to cast your vote, to stay informed.
- 8:57And again, the low probability that you yourself will impact the outcome.
- 9:01It actually makes a lot of sense not to spend the time to do it.
- 9:05Right. So, so with all of these, the tension is not between the outcome that
- 9:11you want or don't want versus the social power, whatever you think that you
- 9:17might be able to get out of voting.
- 9:19The tension is between whatever you might be able to get out of voting positively and,
- 9:25The odds of not voting in that way actually impacting the outcome,
- 9:29which, again, is next to nothing.
- 9:33So democracies don't matter. No, I'm just kidding. Oh, don't go that far.
- 9:37Don't go that far. So it's a hard balance because then if statistically everyone
- 9:42believes their vote doesn't matter, then no one would vote.
- 9:45So there is at some point our votes do matter at some level. Yeah. Right? right?
- 9:51My democracy, like childhood is just being crashed in front of my eyes right now.
- 9:56No, like, but you get the tension, right? Because that's the tension if statistically,
- 10:00but it's still as a whole matters who places like what vote, right?
- 10:06Because if no one voted, and that would be a completely different story.
- 10:09Right. So now we're just going to talk math here for a hot second.
- 10:13So hopefully I don't scare anybody away.
- 10:15But on concept, you individually are a whole lot different than the mass.
- 10:21The mass matters. If a lot of people vote and a lot of people are going to collectively
- 10:26vote for one specific outcome such that that outcome, that's a big deal.
- 10:31That matters quite a bit. You specifically participating in that vote for that
- 10:37outcome won't matter a lot at all.
- 10:39So the practical question for people engaging in politics is how do we craft
- 10:45this large coalition so that we can win elections when we.
- 10:49In the public choice field, you would say you probably know that these people
- 10:53at least have some vague awareness that it's not going to matter too much if I specifically vote.
- 10:59So this is why, you know, you will see a lot of like political events,
- 11:03right? They're not just saying, Hey, come listen to this guy speak as politician.
- 11:06They're saying, Hey, you know, come listen to him speak afterwards.
- 11:09You might get a chance to interact.
- 11:11You'll get food. You'll get drinks. Like there are other things that they're
- 11:15selling to get you in the door to try and motivate you into action, right?
- 11:19It's kind of like, you know, in college, go to this event, you'll get free pizza. Right, right.
- 11:23It's not the event that gets you there. Plan your fitness on Fridays.
- 11:25Right, yeah. Come work out, get free pizza. It's the pizza. Do you remember
- 11:27when they did that? Yeah.
- 11:29Well, so if that's, if I'm a politician, then you have two choices,
- 11:34because this kind of makes sense now with what's happening.
- 11:37You either, if there's a cost to vote, time, learning, right? right?
- 11:43Then there's one of two ways that you can do. You can either make the cost more
- 11:47worth it by doing events, by making it seem more worth your while,
- 11:51or you can lower the cost.
- 11:53Yes. So right now, the left is saying like in-person voting shouldn't have to
- 11:57be a thing. You don't have to bring an ID card.
- 11:59In economic theory, you could argue that what they're trying to do is just lower the cost of voting.
- 12:04Practically, yeah. I would say they are. Okay. That's intriguing.
- 12:07I have my own thoughts on that, but that's not for this podcast.
- 12:09I'm just kidding. So that's interesting. Now, to be clear, too,
- 12:11with that specifically, you're not reducing the cost to zero.
- 12:15There's still time that you have to take filling out the sheet.
- 12:18There's time that you have to take mailing it. And actually,
- 12:21maybe in some cases, if you don't have a mailbox attached to your apartment
- 12:25or you don't have a post office nearby, it may actually be more difficult for
- 12:29you to vote by mail in terms of this cost of time there.
- 12:33That you're taking to actually get that vote in. And remember,
- 12:35all of this costs too, this is technically an opportunity cost, right?
- 12:39So it's not the fact that you're spending the time, it's the fact that this
- 12:42time will be spent on one thing or something else that may be more valuable to you.
- 12:46In business, I mean, this is very similar to like a business,
- 12:50which I've never thought of voting this way at all, or like getting votes.
- 12:52If you had a website store, right, you would want to make it as easy as possible,
- 13:00for people to click and purchase.
- 13:03You want to take the, the, the, all of the steps and the questionnaires and all of the junk out.
- 13:08You want it to be like, that's why Amazon is the king of the buy now button,
- 13:12right? They already have all your information.
- 13:14They've made it too easy to buy, like the cost to buy now,
- 13:18as far as like time and the pain of like, I don't know if anyone's ever gone
- 13:22to a website where you've just, you've gone to where you bought your stuff and
- 13:25then Google didn't save your, your, your, and you like, I don't want to put
- 13:28in my credit card information right now.
- 13:30So you don't do it. same theory right in theory
- 13:33yeah voting if if
- 13:36they if people could in theory make voting easier
- 13:39then they in a sense could get more votes
- 13:42and so like they're just trying to try trying to
- 13:45take down the cost of voting potentially and i would i would add to this that
- 13:51you know practically Practically probably the most consuming aspect of this
- 13:57cost to voting is the cost of getting your awareness and knowledge of certain issues up.
- 14:03So we're dealing with a not insignificant, but a smaller portion of what I would
- 14:10define as the real cost of voting.
- 14:13The time that you would have to spend during the election cycle to be a truly informed voter, right?
- 14:19And make a decision based on all of that information. It's actually quite high.
- 14:23Yeah. It really is. Well, that's hard to do anymore. Either like,
- 14:26how do you dictate truly, you know, informed when it's hard to even believe
- 14:32any of the information that you're actually reading?
- 14:33And is it like... And that's another layer. that's another layer of how do
- 14:37you find fair legit true facts
- 14:40not just facts based off of
- 14:43one party or another that's i can't
- 14:46remember there's a website and i can't remember who promotes it oh graham stefan does
- 14:49i don't know if you know who graham stefan is he's a youtuber very
- 14:52successful but they promote a website where they bring in articles
- 14:56on the left and the right on a topic on the same websites yeah
- 14:59yeah so you'll search whatever topic you're interested immigration whatever
- 15:03there'll be articles from fox and cnn right beside each other and
- 15:05so you can see like the actual like headlines
- 15:09and how they differ um like just cool it's actually i can't remember what it's
- 15:12called maybe i'll put it as a link but that's that's interesting as far as like
- 15:16i never viewed voting that way and i think it makes sense to some degree why
- 15:22like someone like california like in in my mind i'm like even if you vote another
- 15:27democrat it's not gavin like Like, that's how I think about it.
- 15:29But if, A, people don't believe their vote doesn't really matter,
- 15:33and the scope thing, which it doesn't for math.
- 15:38But also socioeconomically with their friends, I mean, do they believe it enough
- 15:44to lose that connection with? That's really the question, right?
- 15:49It's like, are they willing to give up the socio... Do you want more coffee? Sure, yeah, thank you.
- 15:56Or the very, very low percentage that their, that vote actually does accomplish anything.
- 16:01Right. Now, this will probably end up being a theme as we continue talking,
- 16:05but economics as a science, it's a social science.
- 16:08Okay. So really it's a study of human interaction.
- 16:11It's transactions back and forth. So this theory does in large part rest on,
- 16:17on the assumption that people are aware that their vote doesn't matter.
- 16:22You can make an argument both ways on that. I have no good answer.
- 16:27So that's the premise. The premise of this theory is that people going into
- 16:31voting... Because that's the tension, right? That's the tension.
- 16:33The tension is, I know that I can't influence the outcome, so what can I do
- 16:37to still go and vote, right?
- 16:40Because there has to be something that's worth it to me to get out and go vote
- 16:44and be informed about it.
- 16:46But in theory, if everyone did believe that their vote actually mattered,
- 16:49then things might look differently in theory. Correct.
- 16:52And you can make an argument both ways to that. You're telling me that votes
- 16:54don't matter. Votes, definitively, your individual vote doesn't matter.
- 16:59That doesn't help my cause, man. It doesn't.
- 17:02Whether everybody en masse is aware of it, different question.
- 17:06But the individual creates the mass, right?
- 17:09In some ways. So then in that theory, it does matter because you are part of the mass.
- 17:14And without your actual vote, the mass doesn't exist. The mass is a given.
- 17:21We're gonna get it it's a little determinist now right
- 17:24you know there's some deeper philosophical layers here but
- 17:27it takes a little bit too by and large people will vote yeah there will be a
- 17:32lot of them yes so given that reality yeah your vote specifically that's where
- 17:37the theory comes from that makes sense or at least partially that's that's interesting
- 17:41i i think that that's a good segue into where I want to go next,
- 17:45because the beautiful thing about America as a whole is that some of us don't
- 17:52believe it exists anymore. But at one point, we had a democracy.
- 17:55And it was a republic. You know, and people actually could vote and it mattered.
- 17:59I don't know if that's the case anymore, but that's besides the point.
- 18:01But I grew up being taught that capitalism was good, good, healthy,
- 18:10while maybe flawed, the best we have.
- 18:13As I've been growing up, we've had a very big push in America for socialism,
- 18:18bigger push. Worldwide, yeah. And worldwide, yeah, very.
- 18:21I mean, it was already worldwide at some level, but then it kind of seems like
- 18:24it's gone in other countries now. It's just kind of invading us.
- 18:26I mean, obviously Canada ended up being one and right next to us.
- 18:30And as a kid, I remember being like, wow, I really hope America is never socialist
- 18:34because from what I was taught, capitalism is best.
- 18:37And so I'm going into this argument, obviously with, I would like to think it's
- 18:41a decent amount of education because both a college degree and a high school
- 18:46degree. Qualifies. So at least I...
- 18:48Have some level of education on this, but I don't have the actual economics
- 18:52of it because I think a lot of people would be like,
- 18:55well, socialism is bad because of this socioeconomic issue that I'm passionate
- 18:59about, or capitalism does this because, you know, it's not fair to this certain
- 19:04time, you know, whereas if we look at the economics and we look at the math
- 19:07of it, that's what I'm curious about.
- 19:09And so one of the reasons of why I wanted you on the show was I wanted to be
- 19:13like, okay, if we just strip the emotion away from this debate,
- 19:18capitalism versus socialism. And we just said, you know what?
- 19:21We're not going to talk about the, the, you know, people picking them up at
- 19:25why America is the greatest country in the world.
- 19:27And like, you know, like why people, we're not gonna talk about any of the,
- 19:29like the actual case study, like proof of the good or bad, just the pure economics
- 19:34of why one is better than the other.
- 19:37I'm interested to know your thoughts on capitalism versus socialism.
- 19:42And then is there there a better one is there is there a third that i don't
- 19:46know that would be better than in your opinion than then and i know i'm asking
- 19:50very loaded questions and you're like i don't know where to start with all this
- 19:53but that's my question so i guess if we want to talk about,
- 19:58capitalism because i think that's the we are pretty familiar what is capitalism
- 20:02so let's define it for our listeners just to make sure we're all on the same
- 20:07page and then maybe talk about pros pros and cons of capitalism,
- 20:10or do you want to just kind of jump back and forth between both?
- 20:13Like, what do you think would be better?
- 20:15Actually, you know, I was aware of this coming in, but these are two softballs,
- 20:18really. Yeah. Fantastic start.
- 20:20Good. I'm glad I set it up well. You set it up well. Okay.
- 20:24Let's, we can define capitalism and then we can kind of, I guess, go, go from there.
- 20:29So capitalism as a market system is,
- 20:34is effectively just an unregulated market. Okay.
- 20:37So I assume based on how this has started, we'll probably get into this later
- 20:42on, would not argue we're living in a purely capitalistic society.
- 20:46I doubt that many economists would.
- 20:49So if you're going to go a pure capitalism, firms and consumers,
- 20:54no government in the way, very little, if any regulation on top of that,
- 20:59it is just a pure interaction in a market setting.
- 21:01Can I ask you a quick question on that? Of course. Have we ever experienced that in America?
- 21:06I cannot off the top of my head think of any example of a purely capitalism.
- 21:13Now, I think we can segue this and talking about both a little bit because practically,
- 21:20neither has been fully implemented.
- 21:22So I know that there's, you know, sometimes you'll see online,
- 21:25well, socialism truly hasn't been tried. And it's like, well,
- 21:28you know, I can also say capitalism hasn't truly been tried.
- 21:32So let's talk about the theory of why both would or wouldn't work.
- 21:35So with economics, it is a study of a market, right? I said earlier,
- 21:41it's human interaction.
- 21:42So on the theory, I do feel pretty well equipped to talk about either.
- 21:46Okay. So then capitalism is an unregulated market where transactions can happen
- 21:52without any type of intervention and allowing human interaction to just happen
- 21:56and the next thing's just kind of whatever happened without a third party coming
- 22:01in and setting things up.
- 22:03Generally speaking. Okay. Socialism.
- 22:05Let's contrast that. So if that's capitalism, what is socialism?
- 22:09Command and control. So you have a centralized economy.
- 22:12You have a person, could be a few people, doesn't have to be specifically one,
- 22:18but you have basically a central body of control that will be dictating how
- 22:24much of good X goes to firm and consumer YZ, right?
- 22:30And so on down. So if you, if you want to think about it in extremely simplified
- 22:37terms, capitalism is extraordinarily decentralized.
- 22:42Socialism is extraordinarily centralized. Okay. And, and so let's just pretend
- 22:47America was the poster child for capitalism. Okay.
- 22:51Who is the poster child that majority, not some like, you know,
- 22:55random country out there somewhere in the world, but like what would be probably the most popular?
- 22:59Soviet Russia. Okay. would be the most contrast yeah so russia okay so let's
- 23:05talk let's talk let's actually talk socialism first okay the people that are
- 23:10pushing for socialism in the united states,
- 23:13what what's their what's their like what is their pros like why push it what
- 23:17do they look what what are they telling people that we are going to gain if
- 23:21we become more of a socialist country You know,
- 23:23there is a little bit of a utopian-ness that I would argue comes through.
- 23:29Now, I'm maybe a little bit negative on that end of it.
- 23:34But, you know, basically by controlling all of these mechanisms,
- 23:40we'll be able to select better outcomes for everybody in the market.
- 23:46So everybody's going to be better off if we're socialists
- 23:50you know you don't have to work you can just do whatever you know if you want
- 23:54to do something artsy you know you could do this podcast full-time things like
- 23:58that tell me that i might turn socialist but things like that those are generally
- 24:02the the arguments at least that i've heard historically it goes a little all over the place but.
- 24:09So socialism is one person or one group of people controlling things for the
- 24:14masses there at some level. Controlling markets.
- 24:16So Marx was not an economist. He was a philosopher.
- 24:21Socialism is an economic theory, right? So while there are quite a bit of aspects
- 24:26that do lean more into sociology, the meat and potatoes of socialism is economics.
- 24:33So he very much crafted a market system that was controlled, right?
- 24:42So it was a government-forward market system is more or less what socialism
- 24:49is, at least economically speaking.
- 24:51So again, Soviets, that was communism. They implemented some socialism,
- 24:56some not. It wasn't perfect. It was not pure.
- 24:59Marx would not have been happy. Actually, Lenin wouldn't have been happy either with what Stalin did.
- 25:03But in in terms of you know the the tenets of
- 25:06how the system functioned very similar okay and
- 25:09so then if if and by the
- 25:12way is communism and socialism so is is like
- 25:15socialism the economic rules of communism not quite or are they are they two
- 25:20distinct things okay they're two distinct things so marx makes the argument
- 25:25that this is kind of a progress you have capitalism capitalism Capitalism devolves
- 25:31into something you've probably heard of now, late-stage capitalism,
- 25:34where he argues that capitalism breeds basically monopolists.
- 25:39Through that, you're going to remove power and freedom from the masses, the proletariat.
- 25:46The workers are going to rise up, take over and institute a socialist system, which is.
- 25:53Governed by the people that were at the bottom, but practically it's just a
- 25:59set controlled outcome is the goal, right? Of socialism.
- 26:03Of socialism. Now you add on, on top of that, communism is more of a political
- 26:08apparatus, more so than an economic function.
- 26:12So you had like Stalin probably, I guess I don't know for sure,
- 26:17but seemed to believe in socialism.
- 26:21He was part of that movement. communism was the political style that he set
- 26:26up socialism is not political i hope i'm making sense i know this is kind of
- 26:33bouncing back and forth so you're good so then if and this is what we have two
- 26:37hours we can talk about as much as we want this so it's not we're not in a time crunch,
- 26:40so is it then so if socialism is an economic theory of it's a system it's an
- 26:47institution Can you then have a political democracy with a socialist economy?
- 26:54Have you heard of democratic socialists? Or I have.
- 26:58There are a lot of people that advocate for that exact thing.
- 27:01I don't necessarily think it's practical.
- 27:05I think there are our dynamics that are probably untenable there that would ruin the idea.
- 27:11But yeah, there are quite a few people that would advocate for that exact sort
- 27:16of thing. mix of democracy and socialism.
- 27:18And in fact, I was just the other day reading a book written by someone who's
- 27:24a socialist. A friend recommended it to me.
- 27:26Doing a favor of reading it through, even though I haven't enjoyed it all that much.
- 27:29But this author makes the specific argument that socialism is in fact more democratic
- 27:34than capitalism is even with democracy
- 27:37involved because socialism on some level is a product of workers.
- 27:43So it's a little more bottom up, though it ends in central control.
- 27:48That's the argument that he made. Yeah. So this is my question. the
- 27:51thing the thing that's not clicking with my brain with socialism is the
- 27:54theory is always like the people at the bottom get control
- 27:57you know have control now and you know they can you know
- 28:00capitalism creates monopolies right and socialism can tear them down and socialism
- 28:05is there to help the the poor and the the low man and the totem pole right but
- 28:10there's still a group of people laying down the the rules for it to function
- 28:15right practically yeah you know what might help think of unions.
- 28:20I'm not going to say unions are socialists. They're not. They're just a labor group, right?
- 28:25But in terms of the type of effect and outcomes that they strive for,
- 28:32so if you look at the auto workers, right?
- 28:35Just recently, Michigan gets rid of right to work. That means now if you're
- 28:39working in an auto factory, you have to be part of the union.
- 28:42The union, they have quite a a bit of power because of that,
- 28:46both in direct negotiations with firms and with the government.
- 28:51And through that, though the
- 28:53leaders of the UAW are appointed by vote from all of the members, right?
- 29:00They do have complete power over what the union does.
- 29:03So in a way it's somewhat similar because you truly just have the workers.
- 29:09The workers have kind of put forth their talking head and now this is going
- 29:15to be the individual that makes all the decisions for the group.
- 29:18The group still is technically in power. It's being operated by this one individual.
- 29:23Hopefully that makes some sense. 100% sense.
- 29:26So then if I'm a socialist, so let's say like I'm like, okay,
- 29:29this in theory would be amazing for America because capitalism is bad.
- 29:33Yeah. What's the economic reason that it just can't work?
- 29:39Like why could, if you're like in theory, socialism would support the lower
- 29:45man, bring people up, allow everyone to have a more equal lifestyle,
- 29:49blah, blah, blah. Like why can't that work?
- 29:51So you mentioned earlier that we might get into some math. You were hoping to see the statistics.
- 29:57I'm sorry. I don't have math for you on this one. This is going to be just pure theory.
- 30:01So hopefully, you know, if I say something, if I say something that's too far,
- 30:05go ahead and make me re-explain it. But I want to bring up something.
- 30:09It was a period of time in the early 1900s. This was the socialist calculation debate.
- 30:16Not a lot of people know about it, but this was something that purely went on
- 30:19within the field of economics. Sorry, when was this?
- 30:22You just said it before. Early 1900s. 1900s. Okay. Early 1900s. The socialist debate.
- 30:26Calculation debate. So socialism relies what we call calculation.
- 30:32So there's a central person in control. And from this one spot,
- 30:37they need to be deciding who gets how much of what.
- 30:42Economy-wide. Everybody is now under the purview of this individual.
- 30:46The argument is, is there a practical way to make this one person so capable
- 30:53that everybody's better off, that we get better outputs than what a market would decide?
- 30:58Because a market's very scattershot, right?
- 31:00It's very trial and error. There's a lot of really big successes,
- 31:04a lot of really big failures, and you you practically, it's very,
- 31:07very difficult to predict what an outcome is going to be.
- 31:10So if there is a way to calculate a better outcome, it would be better.
- 31:17So this is kind of the crux of the debate.
- 31:20Socialism is pushing centralized calculation, and the people that were arguing
- 31:24against it were pushing decentralized, let it happen because we don't know, we can't calculate.
- 31:31The two kind of big sides of this were Oscar launch, They had F.A.
- 31:35Hayek and Ludwig von Mises.
- 31:37Mises and Hayek were part of the Austrian School of Economics.
- 31:40I actually don't know what school Lange was part of now that I'm thinking about
- 31:45it, but regardless, these are your main characters.
- 31:48Okay. So the two big critiques that we really need to bring up, the first is Mises.
- 31:56Mises brings up price. Okay. So imagine that you are a central planner.
- 32:04You are in charge of the railroads and you want to lay more track.
- 32:08All right. So you need iron, you need iron to lay more track.
- 32:11And this is going to be straight out of a textbook. So I hope this is,
- 32:14I hope this is easy enough for you. Okay. I'm following.
- 32:16I have an IQ of 10, so I should be. No, no, no. You're good.
- 32:18Like I said, I just, I, sometimes you get caught up in your own,
- 32:21in your own world, right? I will stop you. I don't want to go too far.
- 32:23I will pump the brakes if it's bad.
- 32:24Perfect. Okay. So like I said, straight out of a textbook. So you're calculating,
- 32:28speculating you're the central planner.
- 32:30You need to lay track. You need iron.
- 32:33Unbeknownst to you, there has been a big explosion at an iron mine.
- 32:39Iron is now scarce. Just happened. We don't know why.
- 32:43Iron's scarce. So in a market setting, the price of iron is going to go up because
- 32:49there's less. The demand rate, exactly.
- 32:51Right, because there's less. And it's a little bit of a surge price, okay?
- 32:56Iron is now unexpectedly scarce. We will, if we sell iron, we will raise the
- 33:01cost, not because we want more profit, but because by raising the cost,
- 33:05people buy it less, which means I don't run out of iron to sell, okay?
- 33:09So, so price of iron has gone up.
- 33:12We're in a market setting. If you work for the train company,
- 33:15you know, okay, iron just went up. I want to lay more track.
- 33:20Is there a potential alternative to iron that I could use? Is there another metal that might work?
- 33:26Is it, this is the only one, you know, this is the one supply,
- 33:29the one material that I need and I have no other options. Well,
- 33:33in that case, you're probably going to pay the price.
- 33:35But what that price going up does is it
- 33:38communicates to every single buyer of iron that
- 33:42iron is scarce if you can you
- 33:45should probably use something else okay all
- 33:49because the price went up no one knows that there was this big explosion the
- 33:53price just increased randomly so if you you know are using iron for i don't
- 33:58know like like nails or something well maybe you'll use zinc for the next couple
- 34:03of months until that price goes back down, right?
- 34:06That's only because of that one bit, that one price increase.
- 34:10There's no other information communicated to every single firm.
- 34:14Iron's scarce. Adjust if you can. Now take price away. You're a central planner.
- 34:21You have less iron. How do you know who needs iron the most?
- 34:27All of these firms, right? Remember when the price goes up, all of these firms,
- 34:30they make an an internal calculation.
- 34:32They go, okay, can I substitute it for something else or do I still need to use it?
- 34:37If I still need to use it, it means iron's my only option, right?
- 34:42I need the iron. Other people didn't.
- 34:45Does this still make sense? Okay, perfect.
- 34:47So if you take that price away, how do you as a planner know who needs it the most?
- 34:53You can't trust them to tell you. Everyone's going to tell you they need the iron.
- 34:56So how do you know? This is Mises' critique.
- 34:59He says, Because price communicates a lot of information in a market setting
- 35:02that remove the price, you don't know how to allocate things.
- 35:08So here's a clarifying for people.
- 35:10So then in socialism, the pure form of socialism- There's no price.
- 35:15There's no price. That's I think the- Right, yes.
- 35:17In a pure form of socialism, the utopian form that is, I think,
- 35:22and I can- And remember, price is of a market setting, right?
- 35:26So if you are against markets, you want to move past it. There's no bartering or transaction.
- 35:32So then is it just like bartering trading? Like how do transactions happen in
- 35:35a socialist? They don't.
- 35:37So whatever you get and everyone gets the same.
- 35:41Maybe. It's supposed to be, the phrase is, oh shoot, something of his need according
- 35:48to what he gets. Some along those lines.
- 35:50Okay. If you need it, you will have it. That is the promise.
- 35:52And assuming you have the person or peoples in power that will make the right
- 35:57decisions for the masses to make sure everyone's taken care of.
- 35:59Yes. And Mises' critique is that without price, you cannot make that. You don't know.
- 36:04Understood. And I want to add on to that this critique was so effective that
- 36:09all of the economists working on the other side of the socialist calculation
- 36:13debate accepted it as true and started to institute prices into their own theorizing
- 36:19of socialism because there is legitimately no way around this issue.
- 36:23You can't have surveys because you can't trust the people that would send up,
- 36:27you know, send honesty back, right?
- 36:29There's no practical way for you to get the information that a price conveys.
- 36:35And again this was so effective that it changes the entirety
- 36:39of what economists who were studying socialism started to
- 36:42theorize about this was the thing i mean i'd love
- 36:45to be in that room right oh i'd love to be in that room like people on both
- 36:48sides of the aisle you know the socialists are like this is true this is the
- 36:51only way to move forward actually that's a very good point you know not that
- 36:54you brought that up we might want to go back to the drawing board i didn't actually
- 36:57mean what i said you know like i would love to see their faces when he brought
- 36:59up this point The best part is this was a purely – this is why I kind of love
- 37:03this little period so much.
- 37:05This has been a fascination for me during my program.
- 37:08But this is purely academic.
- 37:10They weren't talking. These were through papers.
- 37:13The people, the economists that were thinking that socialism was a great idea,
- 37:19that it was possible, they're publishing papers.
- 37:20Mises reads it all. He writes his own report, sends it back out,
- 37:25and they all read it and they go, whew, good point. Yeah, he's not wrong.
- 37:31But then they respond, right? And they continue on. Well, if anything,
- 37:35what this shows, and this is just a completely sidebar, the importance of just
- 37:38not living in an echo chamber.
- 37:40Absolutely. Like, I think for like what this does, it's funny,
- 37:43I just had breakfast with a guy who.
- 37:48Politically, socioeconomically, in every way, I think we differ.
- 37:52And I don't think there's actually one thing that we would actually agree on.
- 37:55You're talking about our lunch earlier? No, that wasn't that bad. No, I'm just kidding.
- 37:58And so, and so, but I remember just being like, bro, like, I love these because
- 38:01I don't want to live in an echo chamber because like, that's a,
- 38:05I think where you end up believing things are true that actually aren't true in reality.
- 38:09Right. So if like someone lives and all their friends believe in socialism and
- 38:13then they hear this podcast, they might be like, well.
- 38:17He just, Wes actually just made some very good points. And that's the whole
- 38:20point. So I think props to those guys for having the humility to read Mize's,
- 38:26right, paper and say, he has an excellent point.
- 38:30To this day, you will not find, you will find economists that think socialism is possible.
- 38:34You will not find a single economist that says you can do it without any sort of price mechanisms.
- 38:40And so Marx, Karl Marx, was he- That at the time. Right. But he was kind of
- 38:44the main driver of socialism. He created it. Yeah.
- 38:47So he never got to see his baby just get destroyed.
- 38:51If you want to think about it that way, yeah.
- 38:54So that's why I guess my, so the pure form of socialism is impossible.
- 38:58Now there's a new baby, there's now a new form of socialism where they've,
- 39:02they've since this debate of papers, Lange and Mises, right? Or, okay.
- 39:08Now it's like, okay, we, socialism now has price.
- 39:12So then what is now, like now with pricing being involved.
- 39:16Right. with socialism, what's now the difference between, like how does that
- 39:22really function now? So it's still centrally planned.
- 39:25So what these pro, I guess, you know, for lack of a better phrase,
- 39:29they're pro-socialist economists at the time, what they end up starting to push
- 39:33is kind of a mixture of some market actions with a central planner.
- 39:38So you would have a planner that is taking in all sorts of information from
- 39:44all sorts of individual, you know, people that need X, Y, and Z.
- 39:48And then I believe like bureaus that would be, you're running the trains.
- 39:53Okay. They, they know what they need too. So they'd be reporting all of these
- 39:57needs, all these different bureaus for different industry would be reporting
- 40:01all of these needs to the central planner.
- 40:03And then in this case, they would argue the central planner sets prices.
- 40:08Allows the firms to then purchase at the price, the consumers to purchase at
- 40:11the price, whatever they need.
- 40:13So then how would you keep from people with special interests influencing?
- 40:18That's a different, that's a different conversation. So this is another reason
- 40:21why I love this little academic debate that went on back in the day.
- 40:25One of the very first things that Mises and Hayek say,
- 40:29they say, okay, there are power dynamics here within this idea of socialism
- 40:34socialism that seems so likely to corrupt the individual in charge that it's an untenable idea.
- 40:41And the response was, well, we're economists. We're not sociologists.
- 40:47We're not discussing whether power can corrupt people. We're discussing whether
- 40:51this market system could work.
- 40:54And so they have to then take a step back and say, okay, institutionally,
- 40:59what could be the issues? use.
- 41:00And the first thing they come up with is price. Okay.
- 41:03What else did they come? Because my brain wants to run towards everything else.
- 41:08Like my brain wants to run towards, if this is the case, then why are politicians
- 41:13pushing socialism if it just can't work?
- 41:18And so that's where my brain wants to go. But in this debate,
- 41:21was there any other thing?
- 41:22So if prices is number one, socialism can't work because there needs to be price
- 41:27and price conveys information information in a market.
- 41:29Is that a good way to summarize it? I would, yeah. I would summarize it that
- 41:32way. I would have a IQ of 10.
- 41:34You passed, good stuff. And then what else? What else was in that debate kind
- 41:38of like crumble Karl Marx's baby?
- 41:41Okay. So are you familiar with F.A. Hayek?
- 41:44No? Okay. So he was a very well-known economist.
- 41:48He really kind of became, I guess, to his public notoriety in the, excuse me, 40s.
- 41:56Yeah. He writes The Road to Serfdom, which I'm sure some of your listeners probably know what that is.
- 42:02It was a very, very popular book, had a whole book tour at the time.
- 42:05I think that was actually, that might've been in the fifties,
- 42:08but that was a big scathing book of why the Soviet Union isn't working well.
- 42:14Well, regardless, he brings up something known as the knowledge problem.
- 42:19So within a market, you have different types of knowledge.
- 42:25All right. That is actionable. Some of it's delivered by price.
- 42:28Some of it is not. And I want to make sure I say this.
- 42:32Yes. So knowledge can be a decentralized, right?
- 42:37So that's from many, many different areas and that you're ingesting all this
- 42:42information. It can be, you know, it's dispersed, right?
- 42:45So this is, this is the price mechanism. Price disperses knowledge.
- 42:50Okay. And it's also tacit a little bit, which is implied, right?
- 42:56All of these can potentially be measured, but a lot of them can't.
- 43:05So when you're talking about calculation, you need to know, like I said earlier,
- 43:11you need to know how much of what material to spread out.
- 43:14You need to know how much of what good to disperse to these individuals.
- 43:18You need to know everybody's needs. There are some things within this system
- 43:23that kind of by happenstance come about when we're talking about just a market.
- 43:30Market there's a lot of luck involved a lot
- 43:32of trial and error that if you
- 43:35step back and try to actively plan
- 43:39it you're not going to be able to
- 43:42successfully do so now this is the
- 43:44portion of the this is where the debate's left open publicly the you know pro-socialist
- 43:52side actually wins this because the final argument here is hayek's knowledge
- 43:57problem and it's effectively that there are things that happen within a market
- 44:01setting that you can't measure.
- 44:03We're social scientists. We're not physicists.
- 44:06So I can't tell you, for example, what the inflation rate will be at this time
- 44:11next year. I can't, I don't know.
- 44:13No one knows. It's not just my lack of skills in economists.
- 44:17No one could do it. And if anyone is saying that they can, they're trying to
- 44:21sell you something. I don't know. I don't know what they're doing. They're wrong.
- 44:24So this is kind of of the where where
- 44:28it ends you've got people who would support
- 44:32this knowledge problem idea this fact that
- 44:34there are things you could not have foreseen can't control
- 44:37for there's information dispersed that you know you don't have access to if
- 44:43you're the central planner and there are those that disagree but in order in
- 44:48order for socialism to function correctly right and i know that you're You're
- 44:55saying that when it comes to like,
- 44:57I don't, I guess what I'm not quite connecting the dots with that argument is
- 45:02if you, yeah, we don't know what's going to happen. That's fine.
- 45:04But like, that's a problem for both capitalism and socialism, right?
- 45:08Not quite. So let's look at what, what economists kind of, kind of do at least
- 45:14what people think we do. Okay.
- 45:17Calculate equilibrium, right? So where the price level should be in a supply
- 45:21and demand context in an, in an individual market, the information that it takes
- 45:26for me to do that is produced by the market.
- 45:29Okay. Okay. So in order for me to look at an industry and say,
- 45:34all right, here is roughly where the price and demand level ought to be at,
- 45:40at least in so far as I could give you an estimate on that.
- 45:44I need information and knowledge that is produced by the interworkings of this
- 45:51market, of this industry.
- 45:53So if you take away, if you take a step back, This is all retrospective.
- 46:00None of this is predictive.
- 46:02So Hayek's verbiage is it's information X post required X ante.
- 46:10So what this means is I need information in order to accurately plan all of this stuff.
- 46:16I would need information generated after the fact before it ever starts.
- 46:24That's just a logical impossibility yeah right so effectively
- 46:28that's the argument it's this
- 46:30idea that you need x post
- 46:34knowledge x anti which you
- 46:37can't get can't get it's a very common
- 46:39logical fallacy too and what what's what's
- 46:42an example of that like where people like uh just it's
- 46:45a debate term oh really yeah okay yeah yeah that's
- 46:49that's interesting so then when you when you pivot that
- 46:52to talk about capitalism so if socialism
- 46:55in Karl Marx's purest form can't function because
- 46:59there's no price information issues and everything else in which I know you
- 47:04talk about that's also potentially a con for capitalism what is in your mind
- 47:08is capitalism where it's a free market is that the best economic process that
- 47:15is it or or theory or I don't know how else to say that.
- 47:19And then I guess what would be the cons of capitalism? What are the pros of capitalism?
- 47:23We just kind of talked about the issues in that debate. But if we jumped over
- 47:27to capitalism, which I think we kind of talked about socialism,
- 47:32what would you say about capitalism, kind of like we just talked about socialism?
- 47:36What are your thoughts on that?
- 47:37Well, first I want to make clear with the progression there with socialism too,
- 47:42because I think it's important to remember that you have Marx's version of socialism,
- 47:47which is effectively crippled by price theory
- 47:50okay and then you have the adjustment after the fact
- 47:53which involves in bringing in the
- 47:56price mechanism that would be what's popular today yes but that
- 47:59would be where the knowledge problem really exists okay because
- 48:02yes it it exists and in marx's original you know setup for for lack of a better
- 48:09word but hayek is primarily responding to the adjustment thereafter the fact
- 48:14because now if you include price why could it still not work So that's the question.
- 48:18You still don't know what's going to happen.
- 48:20Exactly. So I just want to make sure that was clear for all the listeners.
- 48:23Now for capitalism, yes, I would say it's the best solution.
- 48:29Now all the negatives to it, I would define as short run.
- 48:33So could it lead to really large firms and monopolies? Yes.
- 48:40Is that position incredibly unstable in the long run? Yes, absolutely.
- 48:47So with monopolies, let's pause here. People believe that we need more regulation
- 48:54to stop the monopolies. Right.
- 48:57In theory, does it make economic sense to actually say if we actually had less
- 49:03regulation, monopolies would not last as long?
- 49:06I guess it's my question. Is regulation actually helping monopolies stay in power longer?
- 49:14So, so we got some layers. All right. Was that a good question?
- 49:17That's a very, it's a very good question. It's a very good question.
- 49:19Yeah. I like the question. I just want to, I just want to, there, there are layers to it.
- 49:23So your, your first layer, are there regulations that help monopolies stay in
- 49:27power or at least large firms?
- 49:28Cause we don't outside of like electrical monopolies, right.
- 49:33Which are of course government and stated, right.
- 49:35Outside of those types of examples, there aren't true monopolies right now.
- 49:39There are firms with very large market shares.
- 49:42Define the market however you want. We can get funny with the numbers,
- 49:45but there are very large firms.
- 49:46So are there large firms that are using regulations and pushing for more regulations
- 49:53such that they can stay in power longer? Yes, absolutely.
- 49:57Is it a good idea to regulate monopolies so that they don't pop up more or even large firms? I say no.
- 50:05And it would lean on this idea of markets being more of a process than a steady state of being.
- 50:17There's admittedly some back and forth on this within the different schools
- 50:21of thought and economics, but my position would be to look at,
- 50:25I like to use the example of the kid game, King of the Hill, right? King of the Hill.
- 50:30You're fighting with your friends to To get up on the top of the hill.
- 50:33Well, imagine you're playing that on a big stack of gravel.
- 50:37Okay. That's the market. That's your market process.
- 50:40Everyone's fighting to get to the top. The moment you get to the top,
- 50:43not only is everyone else trying to knock you down, your footing's unstable too.
- 50:47Right? So if you look at like Google right now, who 10 years ago would have
- 50:52thought that chat GPT would be a major competitor to Google in 2024?
- 50:57Right. Well, they are. And it's hurting Google's market share.
- 51:01Hurting their front but you know yeah we wanted to regulate them
- 51:04back then too right right so the the point
- 51:07is once you reach the top not only
- 51:10are you fighting everyone that's below there's also like this
- 51:13other pile of gravel where someone could just jump up and you
- 51:16know body slam you off the top anyway right like it's
- 51:19so unpredictable there was zero regulation for testing creativity you know people
- 51:25like there's always going to be someone with a new idea better idea to potentially
- 51:29essentially topple the person that's currently in charge or the company there's
- 51:31always going to be new innovation now it might not happen 20 years it might
- 51:36take 20 years for that cycle to take place.
- 51:38I mean you look at like you know even like the rock like like people
- 51:41that were huge like the rockefeller family for example like you
- 51:45know like there were times where you had massively successful
- 51:48companies that just aren't anymore and and at that time
- 51:51people were probably like this company's never going anywhere but but
- 51:54it did it did so then now to
- 51:58be clear those that have massive antitrust action
- 52:01against them you know i got to knock them
- 52:04down and split them up i do want to make sure that that's clear too i
- 52:07wonder what would what would have happened if that didn't if that didn't take place
- 52:10right that'd be interesting and that and
- 52:12that would be kind of what what i am arguing if you take
- 52:15away the the ability for companies
- 52:18to help solidify their position through regulation that
- 52:22that's the prerequisite to that which is an issue right
- 52:25now too so i don't think there's an easy answer here you think that at its core
- 52:29it's all about control like the reason so if we strapped up the average politician
- 52:37that's pushing so socialism right to a lie detector test okay and i said and
- 52:44we asked him the question do you believe.
- 52:46Socialism is the best form i'd be curious that
- 52:49a of what their answer would be b i wonder if
- 52:52you can't control a free market
- 52:55because that's by definition it's a free market right government likes
- 52:58control they like controlling things so if
- 53:01you like controlling things what is the best form of economic theory that you
- 53:06would want to have it be socialism because then if you're if government and
- 53:10the theory of socialism is the main guy that sets the prices that sets all the
- 53:14stuff as a government official you'd be like wait a second so either i could
- 53:18be powerless or powerful,
- 53:21what school of thought would i like to attain to do you
- 53:24do you wonder if that's the reason so many people even subconsciously adhere
- 53:29to socialism because as a theory that they want to push because it just gives
- 53:33more power to the government so i thought you were taking this in a slightly
- 53:36different direction and that's
- 53:37where i'm gonna go with it so that's fine we'll just run with it i to me,
- 53:43I think there's something maybe a little deeper going on.
- 53:46Even with people, you know, voters, right? Not, not just politicians.
- 53:50I think this kind of applies to everybody.
- 53:53I've started to split people politically,
- 53:57you know, in my own head canon based on how comfortable you are with the unknown
- 54:04versus how instinctually you want to control it and get an outcome.
- 54:09Because, you know, with a lot of these issues, especially when we're talking
- 54:13about, you know, firms, right? Right. We're directly dealing with the market.
- 54:18This is true with international trade too.
- 54:21If you look at the problem and deep down, we know that we can't practically
- 54:28control the outcome, best we can hope for is to influence it.
- 54:32How comfortable are you letting it be, letting it play out and understanding,
- 54:37you know, we might win, we might lose.
- 54:40I'm going to let it go knowing that that's probably best in the long run.
- 54:43Or does that feeling of unease kind of creep in and I know we can't control
- 54:53it, but gosh, we need to try.
- 54:56You know what I mean? So that's been more my perspective recently on how I've looked.
- 55:02Because, I don't know, I mean, you could make an argument that maybe there's
- 55:06a lot of sinister action going on.
- 55:08And I, I find it easier to take that out and wonder why, if everyone is being
- 55:14more or less truthful, as truthful as you could be in politics.
- 55:18That's a big if though. Yeah, I know. I know. That's a big if.
- 55:21But at the end of the day, you know, people do think there's a lot at stake.
- 55:25So understanding that and weighing that against how powerful that instinct of,
- 55:33gosh, we just, you know, we need this type of outcome.
- 55:36Come i wonder how much that that ends up
- 55:39influencing decision making that's best case scenario
- 55:42if that's what they want is like they're just trying
- 55:45to want what's best for humanity and this is
- 55:48the only way they think it's going to happen if they control it right practically
- 55:50it could lead to the very same situation you had you had outlined i mean obviously
- 55:56you know politicians themselves can get seduced by power right you know there's
- 56:00plenty of history on that but you know in terms of like people that look at
- 56:06like the green regulations, right?
- 56:08We're trying to really push electric cars. We're really trying to cut emissions.
- 56:13And on one hand, you know, would it probably be great if we could like cut short
- 56:20this big problem that's up on our doorstep? Yeah, absolutely.
- 56:24But then at the same time, like, how do you know what you're pushing is going to fix it?
- 56:29Right. And if you let it go, how do you know there wouldn't have been a fix
- 56:32that developed anyway yeah you know what i mean yeah yeah that's a good question i mean.
- 56:39Especially with the electrical, the government's just decided electric is the way.
- 56:43That is the only way. And it very well could be the future, right?
- 56:46I mean, dude, everything's run by coal.
- 56:47I don't see how it's much better, but whatever. Well, I mean, outside of that, right?
- 56:51Practically, electric vehicles, it could be the future of cars. It could.
- 56:55I don't know that. But in a capitalistic society, there would be freedom to
- 57:00have other things to develop.
- 57:02But if you put every incentive program, every tax break, every...
- 57:07And now there's less innovation on other options. Correct.
- 57:09And so with that being said, because that is what is currently happening. Correct.
- 57:15Everyone's releasing an EV.
- 57:17If you had to say America 2024, are we more socialistic or capitalistic?
- 57:24If like on a scale, like 50-50, are we still leaning?
- 57:28Do we still have more capitalism in our genes than we do socialism in America today?
- 57:33Or do we actually potentially have more socialism capitalism and less capitalism,
- 57:37like a 50-50 scale? Like what would be the ratio of like, if you had to put it into a percentage?
- 57:41So when you first brought up this topic, you asked if there was like a third option. Yeah.
- 57:47Kind of is it's called the mixed market economy it's a
- 57:50a honest to goodness attempt to
- 57:53go 50 50 between both options so very
- 57:57common things that would fall under this are
- 58:00public zoos because the zoo is a
- 58:03public private partnership it's in large part funded by
- 58:06the local government but you have an individual firm that is running operating
- 58:11it and doing all the marketing and stuff for it right You could look at a school
- 58:17board that is public soliciting bids to renovate their school.
- 58:23Public-private partnership.
- 58:24So when you get these intermixings between the public side being the government
- 58:30and the private being individual firms, you get this kind of cocktail of a mixed market economy.
- 58:37And I would say that a lot of our systems right now are produced with that in
- 58:43mind. So you see quite a bit of subsidies to industries to try and pop up.
- 58:48And this was obviously big back when housing crisis happened, right?
- 58:51Financial bailouts. Yeah. Financial bailouts to banks. Banks are firms,
- 58:55they're institutions, right?
- 58:57Well, they basically received a massive subsidy from the government.
- 59:01That's a mix. Once these things start getting mixed in together,
- 59:05that's when you get to this third thing called the mixed market economy.
- 59:09And I would say that's where we are. can that function healthily without
- 59:12a bad result in the future i don't
- 59:16think so i guess without like one or the
- 59:19other coming out at the end if that makes sense what i'm saying like socialism
- 59:23like is there a world where this can function and everything kind of be okay
- 59:27or is it always going to yield towards one or the other will win at the end
- 59:32so either socialism will win at the end of of this mixed bag or capitalism will win at the end.
- 59:38Both can't co like can both coexist in any type of like healthy economic manner.
- 59:45It's a good question. I don't think I have a good answer for you.
- 59:49Obviously, Marx himself and quite a few other socialists would argue there's a progression, right?
- 59:54You've got capitalism, you've got late stage capitalism, you've got this middle
- 59:58ground, and then you got socialism that pops out at the end.
- 1:00:02Joseph Schumpeter, actually an economist that I generally like quite a bit,
- 1:00:06but he writes in the book, Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy,
- 1:00:09that as consumers continue
- 1:00:13to be be more and more separated from the actual market
- 1:00:16process right so the actual production of some goods
- 1:00:19the actual act of going to
- 1:00:22a place to purchase things think things
- 1:00:25of that nature as you get more and more separated you are more prone to being
- 1:00:29sympathetic to socialism and then that way you know it is inevitable slippery
- 1:00:34slope argument at some point like that's what those are saying if you i don't
- 1:00:37know if i'd make it but open the water tab of socialism over time it could just
- 1:00:43like the safest play for people who believe in capitalism is to allow no socialism. Maybe.
- 1:00:50Like I said, I don't myself have a very good answer for, for this one.
- 1:00:54I would just say that there are people on both sides of this argument that have
- 1:00:59made that exact argument that you just said.
- 1:01:02There are those that, you know, think that the mixed market economy is a fantastic
- 1:01:06idea and it would just go on in per in perpetuity and be great.
- 1:01:12That's like a utopian world though i right
- 1:01:15like that functioning okay right now is it yeah all
- 1:01:18our metrics are down down as is that a good thing yeah inflation rate is down
- 1:01:24unemployment rate is down i think there are some pretty big long-term concerns
- 1:01:29but you know things are clicking at the moment at at the moment yeah so so it
- 1:01:34works as long as right now we're happy it works hey welcome Welcome to politics.
- 1:01:38So that you actually, this is a good segue. I think we, so I guess if I'm gonna,
- 1:01:42I like trying to summarize on the podcast because like I've always, like if,
- 1:01:47just a side note, but someone said like the key of a good host is a host should
- 1:01:52be able to ask the exact question I as a listener was thinking and then be able
- 1:01:55to summarize it in a way that I can understand in case I miss something, right?
- 1:02:01So socialism can't work.
- 1:02:05Form of socialism that can't work because the pure form of socialism does not allow for price.
- 1:02:09Since the debate in the early 1900s with Hayek and Mises, they have created
- 1:02:16a new form of, an updated form of socialism with price. Within the debate, actually.
- 1:02:20Okay. With price now. Price and socialism can now be happy together with their
- 1:02:24new kind of baby offspring of socialist ideas.
- 1:02:30And so right now the question is, is do we trust a free market more than we
- 1:02:35trust an actual entity to set things?
- 1:02:37That's kind of at the core, that's kind of the debate between capitalism, socialism.
- 1:02:42Is your risk tolerance okay trusting a free market or do you prefer having someone control?
- 1:02:50In terms of whether ordinary people support one or the other,
- 1:02:55I would say that is what's going on in terms of does this mixture of the price
- 1:03:02mechanism into a socialist setting, is that tenable?
- 1:03:07No, because of the knowledge problem. These are both separate from a mixed market
- 1:03:12economy, which is effectively a public-private partnership, which is more of
- 1:03:18what we're seeing today.
- 1:03:19Would Obamacare be an example of that?
- 1:03:23Obamacare was more or less single payer.
- 1:03:26I would lean more that's a socialistic ideal
- 1:03:29though right exactly yeah that's that's where i was heading with that yeah okay
- 1:03:33so it's not even a mixed bag that's just like pure socialism i yeah if it's
- 1:03:38purely if it is something that is solely government provided you can make a
- 1:03:41pretty quick leap to saying it it's potentially socialist okay socialistic,
- 1:03:47you mentioned something briefly because you mentioned inflation and jobs right
- 1:03:52as far as as like currently being happy and numbers looking good.
- 1:03:56I know that recently we just hit, I think a record for the S and P 500.
- 1:03:59So in theory, the economy could look good on paper, right?
- 1:04:03I, well, I mean, it looks good on paper, I guess is what it says.
- 1:04:07I don't think the American family, I don't think America feels that.
- 1:04:10I don't think the average family feels that.
- 1:04:12That's what, that was at a debate that I had with someone else.
- 1:04:14Like I know the average, at least I work with tons of employees every year.
- 1:04:18Every single employee I talk to right now is saying times are hard. Things are tight.
- 1:04:2395% of people, things are hard. I have 170 business owners that I personally currently work with.
- 1:04:28I am adding more to the fold every single month. And almost every single business
- 1:04:33owner says, things are tight, budget's tight, high cost. It's like a rough time to run a business.
- 1:04:39So how can, when you talk to the person in America, they're saying things are tight, it sucks.
- 1:04:48But then you look at the numbers and you hear a politician, like you hear Biden's
- 1:04:54white house secretary chair or whatever her name is, Pierre or whatever,
- 1:04:57be like, our economy has never been stronger.
- 1:04:59And she, and then you have the stats to prove it quickly.
- 1:05:02I'm not saying, I know the stats exist, but I'm just saying,
- 1:05:03but why, why do, does the average American not feel it? Like,
- 1:05:07why does the average American have more debt than they've ever had before?
- 1:05:10Inflation rates being insanely high to where their paycheck doesn't matter as much as it used to.
- 1:05:15Cost of home is being like, how then if our economy is doing so So well,
- 1:05:19why does nobody feel it? So fantastic question.
- 1:05:23It would be a disservice if I did not at first bring up that there is a little
- 1:05:27bit of politicization going on here.
- 1:05:31At least as far as surveys go, if you are a Republican and a Republican is in
- 1:05:37the office of the presidency, you are far more likely to be happy with the way things are going.
- 1:05:43Vice versa is true as well. I don't think that's the full story.
- 1:05:47Sorry, it would just be a disservice if I didn't bring it up. No, I understand.
- 1:05:50But in my question, I am talking, I am like, this is just purely insurance conversations
- 1:05:54I'm having with you. Yeah.
- 1:05:55And by the way, Detroit is significantly more left-leaning. Yes, it is.
- 1:06:00Significantly. So I'm probably talking like 70, 30 Democrats to Republicans.
- 1:06:03And then even the Democrats are saying it's tight. Because politics on their
- 1:06:08brain, I'm not saying like, do you think Joe Biden's doing a great job?
- 1:06:10They would probably say things are tight and I love Joe Biden.
- 1:06:12But my point is like, so I understand your point.
- 1:06:17But like in this, when I've talked to actual people outside of politics,
- 1:06:21just asking them like, hey, how are things right now?
- 1:06:23They're all like, I'm cutting everything I can. Things are tight.
- 1:06:26I don't have savings. Yeah.
- 1:06:27My only point is to get into what I'm about to get into without at least bringing
- 1:06:31up that there is a little bit of a – there is a little bit of partisanship involved.
- 1:06:37Sure. It would be a disservice. That was all. What I would say to practically
- 1:06:41answer your question is the inflation rate.
- 1:06:44The inflation rate is down right now. Okay? It's a rate.
- 1:06:48It's not a set number. number. So when you see the inflation is at,
- 1:06:52you know, 3 point whatever percent, that doesn't mean that, you know,
- 1:06:57since it was at 7 and we're down to 3, that we've actually decreased inflation by 4%.
- 1:07:03That means that inflation is still growing at 3 point whatever percent.
- 1:07:09So practically what this means is,
- 1:07:12yes, everything is a lot more expensive than it was because you start at 2020
- 1:07:1720, right before, you know, all the COVID shutdowns and all of this,
- 1:07:20you had a massive increase in printing from the federal reserve,
- 1:07:24which increases inflation.
- 1:07:26There's a little bit of a delay starts to peak there in late 21,
- 1:07:29early 22 gets up to seven, eight, right? Really, really high.
- 1:07:34And then now it's kind of trickled back down to three as they've stopped and
- 1:07:38halted their printing cycles there at the federal reserve, but it's still positive.
- 1:07:42So your inflation rate is calculated off of a consumer price index,
- 1:07:47which is, you know, we pick a basket of goods that we think most people are
- 1:07:52purchasing and is representative of the time it shifts with whatever point is
- 1:07:56that basket of goods is still a lot more expensive today than it was at this
- 1:08:00time last year and is still even more expensive the year prior.
- 1:08:05It's a, it's a time series thing and it's a rate. So the fact that it's positive
- 1:08:08means that prices are still high. Yeah. So yeah.
- 1:08:12So, And it's not going to go down. Right. That's my question. So...
- 1:08:17Inflation goes up. So the definition of inflation is where maybe I might butcher this definition.
- 1:08:23Basically, the higher the inflation, the less of our dollars worth,
- 1:08:27right? More or less, yeah. Okay.
- 1:08:29So high inflation, bad, unless there's reasons for the high inflation.
- 1:08:32No, high inflation, bad. Okay, cool.
- 1:08:34So let's just say 7% inflation, everything costs more now. Groceries cost more, gas costs more.
- 1:08:40Just to live in America now, you are 7% poorer than you were the previous year,
- 1:08:46or whatever the difference was.
- 1:08:48If it was three to seven, you're now 4% poor or whatever, just by existing.
- 1:08:53When inflation rates go down, do companies, when they price goods,
- 1:08:58do they take an account for that and move their prices back down to match inflation?
- 1:09:04Or because inflation was high, everyone got used to paying a certain things for goods.
- 1:09:09It stays there and their profit margin continues to increase.
- 1:09:14So like if everything is really expensive, we'll get used to paying that.
- 1:09:18Do companies come down with price when it comes to inflation?
- 1:09:21Does that make sense? Or do they just normally keep it there?
- 1:09:25So there are a couple of things that I want to talk about here.
- 1:09:28The quickest one is to, again, it's a rate.
- 1:09:32So the fact that the rate is positive, when it was seven, that means if it was
- 1:09:37seven last month and it's three this month, it means that last month were only
- 1:09:423% more than inflation, right?
- 1:09:45So prices are still on an aggregate, right?
- 1:09:48This isn't, some things are going to be up, some things are going to be down.
- 1:09:52On the average, things are still more expensive and your dollar as opposed to
- 1:09:57the total is less valuable.
- 1:09:59It's constantly going up. So even though inflation rate went down,
- 1:10:04that doesn't necessarily mean that things are inherently cheaper or that your
- 1:10:09dollar is more valuable.
- 1:10:10It's still less valuable than when you last looked just by the
- 1:10:13the three percent so the only way to beat this
- 1:10:17from a is to either get you need a
- 1:10:19negative for prices to go down or for our overall income
- 1:10:22to increase by x percentage right to to match inflation
- 1:10:26uh not quite so so inflation is almost entirely a monetary phenomenon so what
- 1:10:35i mean by that is it is almost entirely derived by how much money is in circulation.
- 1:10:44If there's a lot of money in circulation, your single dollar is worth less than if there's not a lot.
- 1:10:49That's not literally how the calculation is done, but conceptually that's what's going on.
- 1:10:54So when the federal reserve started printing more cash to give,
- 1:10:59you know, help fund the stimulus packages during the the COVID,
- 1:11:02you know, lockdowns, they printed more, which then later on.
- 1:11:07But they knew that this was going to happen.
- 1:11:08Yes. They did it willingly. Yeah. But they just didn't care.
- 1:11:12Why didn't they care? Or not that they didn't care. Why did they, why did they...
- 1:11:16So there's an argument that you can kind of, or oil or gas on a fire, right?
- 1:11:21Like if things are down, if you inject a lot of cash, you'll increase consumption.
- 1:11:26The whole definition of the word stimulus, right?
- 1:11:28Basically. Now that's debatable. There are people on both sides of that within economics, right?
- 1:11:35And within this field, that is not a, you know, set in stone reality.
- 1:11:40When you're in a recession, not, you know, there are those that would say spent,
- 1:11:44but But there are quite a few economists that would say, don't spend it all.
- 1:11:49You need to kind of let it progress through. Let it happen.
- 1:11:52So, yes. Unless we get into politics where it's like, well, we don't want a
- 1:11:55recession to happen on our watch.
- 1:11:57Kick the can. Yeah. The other thing I wanted to bring up, you know,
- 1:12:00because you were talking about prices.
- 1:12:02People, firms rather charge more when inflation is up than when,
- 1:12:08ideally, than when inflation is down.
- 1:12:11But to really dive into, I guess, talking about that, I think we need to discuss what price is.
- 1:12:18And price is not a product of input costs.
- 1:12:23So when, at least economically, when we're looking at a firm,
- 1:12:27a firm does not go down its balance sheet and go, okay, I'm spending this much on labor.
- 1:12:32I'm spending this much for the, you know, the property that we're in.
- 1:12:35I'm spending this much on the machines. And because of all these inputs,
- 1:12:39here's a level of profit percentage above that that I want.
- 1:12:43And that's the price I'm going to charge. That's not how it works.
- 1:12:47Practically what price is, is it is an expression of value from the consumer, right?
- 1:12:53So if you're a firm and you're trying to set a price,
- 1:12:57if you've never bought this product to a market before, What you're doing is
- 1:13:01trying to anticipate the level at which consumers who would buy your product
- 1:13:06would value it at. What the demand is.
- 1:13:10More or less. Right. So price is subjective. It is not a product of input costs.
- 1:13:18Price is purely a function of what people will buy it at and what they value it at.
- 1:13:24So when you say, you know, inflation went up, our prices went up.
- 1:13:30Part of that is driven by the increased costs and the decrease in value of the dollar. Okay.
- 1:13:36Part of it is the other part is that
- 1:13:38there are a lot of people that want that product that
- 1:13:42are willing to pay at that level and that value it at that level so
- 1:13:45it keeps it at that level so it keeps it at that level raise
- 1:13:48it because they know they can get people to the
- 1:13:51right level so you have two kind of conflicting portions of
- 1:13:54this right if you're the firm you need to have a price above
- 1:13:58your level of costs in order
- 1:14:01for you to produce the product at all otherwise it's not
- 1:14:03going to be worth it but if the consumer does not
- 1:14:06value your good above that level of
- 1:14:09input costs you adjust accordingly right well
- 1:14:12you're not going to sell it it's not worth you unless you were lower the price right
- 1:14:15then you could well why would you because you'd take a loss right
- 1:14:18right right so so here so here's where you know it kind
- 1:14:21of comes through at least to me what makes something valuable
- 1:14:25is almost entirely a
- 1:14:28function of what people value it at not necessarily
- 1:14:31the profit margin or the profit margin has anyone ever done done a study on
- 1:14:35the effect of credit cards and cost of goods so do you think that and the reason
- 1:14:41i asked that is question i mean i think everyone you know where i'm going with
- 1:14:45this but if everyone had a debit card credit cards did not exist so you either
- 1:14:50had a good debit card or cash.
- 1:14:51And you saw something when you looked at your bank account well you can't afford
- 1:14:55it so you don't buy it well now people can buy significantly more than their
- 1:14:59means so then that muddies the pool,
- 1:15:03that muddies the pool of what people can actually afford, if that makes sense.
- 1:15:09Because now people are saying, yeah, I can buy that even though they don't actually
- 1:15:13have the real cash to be buying that thing.
- 1:15:15And so then companies still keep things at the same price because people are
- 1:15:20buying it, but then there actually is no money to actually support their purchase
- 1:15:24because it's all now in debt. Well, they still get the money.
- 1:15:27They get the money, but now the consumer's at a loss because now they have debt
- 1:15:31and they're paying interest on it. I don't know.
- 1:15:33I wonder how that would affect our economy if credit cards were thrown away.
- 1:15:36If it would cripple us for a time being because the buying power of the average
- 1:15:40American would go down significantly.
- 1:15:42I suspect that would be the case. Over time would be better for us.
- 1:15:46That was my question. Over time, has credit cards hurt the US economy more than they've helped it?
- 1:15:54Everyone listening i'm sorry i just keep like smacking the side of my microphone,
- 1:16:00anyway i i would say there's a little bit of a moral judgment here not like
- 1:16:04not in the bad way right it sounds like you you want to help people not be in
- 1:16:08debt and again that's a good cause but but practically what then is the the
- 1:16:14policy solution to that sort of idea right if credit credit cards are bad.
- 1:16:19Do we need to take it away because some people misuse it? No, absolutely not.
- 1:16:25Well, I think that was, it was more of a theoretical question.
- 1:16:28Like in theory, has credit cards, if we imagine the US economy without credit
- 1:16:34cards, if credit cards just never existed, I wonder where the average American
- 1:16:37would be financially versus where they're at now.
- 1:16:40If it's actually helped the average American be able to create more businesses
- 1:16:43with credit, you know, like take, or if, I'm just curious I'm curious if that
- 1:16:47study has ever been done on the effect of credit cards.
- 1:16:50I've not seen it. I've not seen it. It may exist.
- 1:16:53I would implore you to go look for it. And if you find it, definitely send it
- 1:16:57to me. I'm open to the idea. It definitely could. I'm agnostic. I have no idea.
- 1:17:02So to wrap up, I mean, we've actually already talked for like an hour and a half, which is insane.
- 1:17:06Yeah, it's great. I want to talk about one more thing. So this is going to get a little political.
- 1:17:10I'm going to try not to make it political, but it is what is happening.
- 1:17:13And I guess I don't know the effect that it could have on the economy.
- 1:17:16Me. So I want to talk about immigration and economics.
- 1:17:20So throughout, obviously we know there's a big immigration.
- 1:17:23You can view it as a problem. I don't care what side of the aisle you are on.
- 1:17:26I'm going to call it a problem because that's how I view it as a problem.
- 1:17:28You have a bunch of people that are currently not US citizens,
- 1:17:31they're not taxpayers coming into the country.
- 1:17:33I think we had like 1.3 million last year in just 2023 coming to the country illegally.
- 1:17:37That's a lot of people. That's a lot of people working jobs.
- 1:17:41That's a lot of people not paying taxes. That's just facts.
- 1:17:45Now, whether that's good or bad, we can argue that on a different podcast.
- 1:17:48But the fact is there's a lot of people that aren't paying taxes that are working jobs.
- 1:17:53Now, potentially working jobs that Americans wouldn't work anyway.
- 1:17:55That's again, beside the point. But the point is that's a lot of people.
- 1:17:59Coming in and, I guess, disrupting what would be a normal taxpayer job. Yes.
- 1:18:06How does that affect the economy? And why, like, yeah, I'll leave it there.
- 1:18:12How does it affect the economy?
- 1:18:14Does it affect the economy? And has it hurt, helped?
- 1:18:18Like, is that something that an economist would be like, that's a problem? I guess is my question.
- 1:18:24I'm going to try and, it's a thought experiment that we're going to do.
- 1:18:27And it's going to be relevant at the end.
- 1:18:29All right. So let's say. Jump in, baby.
- 1:18:33Say there's a firm, opens up a factory in a different country. Okay.
- 1:18:38Right. We're not analyzing this from an American perspective.
- 1:18:41We're analyzing this from the country that it opened up the factory in. Yep.
- 1:18:45There are going to be new jobs that this firm is going to, you know,
- 1:18:49whatever, create, you know, for lack of a better word, even though I don't like
- 1:18:53the terminology there. but there are going to be people that are going to be working these jobs.
- 1:18:58There are going to be a lot of people left behind.
- 1:19:01Is this a net positive for that little country?
- 1:19:05Probably. Probably. So there are people that are going to argue that it's not.
- 1:19:08They're going to say that, well, if you just stayed out of the way,
- 1:19:12everyone would have been better off because we left some people behind when
- 1:19:16we created these slightly higher paying jobs, right?
- 1:19:19So that's going to be an argument. So now we'll go ahead and we'll look at immigration in the United States.
- 1:19:26You have a lot of people that are coming in and working cheap jobs,
- 1:19:32more or less, that otherwise are likely unfilled or are robotic labor of some sort.
- 1:19:39So practically, this is a trade.
- 1:19:43We're trading the money that we're paying them for them to be able to be here,
- 1:19:52have access to things that we have,
- 1:19:55and hopefully they live a better life.
- 1:19:58I don't know if that's a hundred percent, but that's at least the pitch that
- 1:20:02people tend to make. Okay.
- 1:20:05This is a net positive in the same way as that firm going to that other country
- 1:20:10is a net positive for that country because it opens up a lot of other opportunity as well.
- 1:20:16Not strictly in those places that, you know, in those industries,
- 1:20:22but on the side, you know, there are more people now that are not working those jobs.
- 1:20:29They're free to do other things. Now, there are other opportunities that now
- 1:20:32not having this specific job filled by this, you know, by American workers who
- 1:20:39are forced to be charged more, right?
- 1:20:42There are other opportunities that get opened up on the sides,
- 1:20:47even within the same company.
- 1:20:50So it's a trade. Trade's good. Trade's mutually beneficial.
- 1:20:54So most economists are going to say it's good. So to continue the thought experiment. It's good.
- 1:20:58It's good. So is it good to have immigrants or is it good to have illegal immigrants?
- 1:21:05Because to me, that's a big difference. To me, America has always been doing
- 1:21:09the trade of like we've had people come in here legally, working jobs that maybe
- 1:21:13potentially the average American didn't want to work, wouldn't work,
- 1:21:16whatever. Good trade, right?
- 1:21:18Right. So is the trade immigrants or is the trade we are actually willing to
- 1:21:23bend the law to allow people in here illegally so that X, Y, Z can happen?
- 1:21:30Like, or are there more ramifications of them being illegal that actually could hurt the United States?
- 1:21:38You want to talk about the economy? Right. So from just pure,
- 1:21:42from your, because I can have someone else that's not an economist on,
- 1:21:45we can talk about the politics of, like, the safety of Americans.
- 1:21:50And like, that could be a completely, I mean, we could talk about that now if
- 1:21:52you want to, But I think from a pure economic standpoint,
- 1:21:56if America looks at 1.3 million people that are currently non-taxpayer citizens
- 1:22:04entered the United States last year under the Biden administration. Fact. Cool.
- 1:22:11What does that do to my money? If that's where we said, like,
- 1:22:14what does that do to the economy of the United States?
- 1:22:16Helps. Helps. That's the question. So if we're purely going to talk about the economics of this,
- 1:22:23all right, the question that I would pose to you is practically what is different
- 1:22:27between someone that went through all of the proper channels to show up versus
- 1:22:32someone that just migrated over the border to do a farming job?
- 1:22:36They pay taxes. Functionally, what's the difference? They pay taxes.
- 1:22:39Yeah. What do taxes fund?
- 1:22:41Things that hopefully would be less tax increases because there's more people
- 1:22:45paying into them. Sure. Theory.
- 1:22:47So that's what, that would be, that would be the only answer I would have, would be taxes.
- 1:22:50If you had 1.3 million, if tomorrow we could say, hey, we're going to have 1.3
- 1:22:55million people start paying taxes, that's a significantly, that's a significant boost.
- 1:22:59Now, you know, a lot of them wouldn't be tax eligible, right?
- 1:23:01Because they don't make enough? Right.
- 1:23:03We have 400,000. Not as big of a boost as you want.
- 1:23:08Okay. That would be my only, that was my, that was the main thing. so from
- 1:23:11an economics standpoint tax and the benefits going to outweigh the
- 1:23:14cost right if you really look at the production increase
- 1:23:17of this extraordinarily cheap labor that you are
- 1:23:19otherwise not able to access different story if we're less restrictive on going
- 1:23:25overseas and across the borders ourselves with manufacturing opportunities to
- 1:23:30do this right yeah because from a from a pure economic stance sorry it should
- 1:23:34be able to go both ways yeah this is what we're And also,
- 1:23:38even just from a cost of labor, cost of goods, you are now able to pay people
- 1:23:42under what would be legally allowed if they were a legal citizen.
- 1:23:46Right? Hypothetically speaking, because technically you can pay them whatever
- 1:23:49you want. There's no minimum wage. Correct. To an illegal immigrant.
- 1:23:52So then you could be getting significantly more value, hypothetically speaking,
- 1:23:57because of the regulations that are put in.
- 1:23:59Now understand too that this is not only good for the firm, right?
- 1:24:03The cheaper labor, definitely a plus for the firm, but also look at the individual, right? The worker.
- 1:24:10So, you know, a lot of times, this by the way, makes me so popular at parties.
- 1:24:15Look, sweatshops, sweatshops in China, okay? Child labor.
- 1:24:19Yep. those kids are in families that do not earn a lot of money at all.
- 1:24:25The family needs cash.
- 1:24:28Is that kid in a terrible situation?
- 1:24:30Yes. Is it probably a good thing that they're able to work and earn money and
- 1:24:36help their family and hopefully all of them don't starve?
- 1:24:40Absolutely. Yep. It's funny. Side note. And by the way, for the people listening,
- 1:24:44listening, this is a thought exercise of economics only.
- 1:24:47Like I am not at all, if you know me at all, for illegal immigration whatsoever.
- 1:24:52I think you're breaking the law and we can have that conversation at a different point.
- 1:24:55But from an economic theory, sometimes it's good to strip back.
- 1:24:59Like if we're talking pure numbers, that's the goal of this whole podcast is
- 1:25:02what- I appreciate it. So like, what does the economics teach of?
- 1:25:05And like, that's a very interesting thought was, I think a lot of people would
- 1:25:08be like, oh, you know, illegal immigration is killing our economy.
- 1:25:12Well, actually that might not be the case because that's a, that's a cool conversation
- 1:25:15to have. It's good for the people that are working the jobs.
- 1:25:18It's good for the firms that are hiring that jobs out for lower cost labor.
- 1:25:21And it's good for the people generally over time.
- 1:25:24It's not going to be good immediately to the people that have lost the opportunity to have those jobs.
- 1:25:28But over time, because of increased production, because of new innovation,
- 1:25:33they're going to have opportunities that they otherwise wouldn't have had. Yeah.
- 1:25:37It's an entire net positive. Yeah. Take the legal stuff as you will.
- 1:25:41Correct. I'm not speaking to that at all. That is a very interesting thing.
- 1:25:45And again, I'm not saying that because it's a net positive, therefore,
- 1:25:49we should just let it get happening. That is not at all what I'm saying, just to clarify there.
- 1:25:52But from a thought exercise perspective, I mean, that's a very interesting fact
- 1:25:56that it's not killing us from an economy perspective.
- 1:26:01More people would understand that anytime a trade happens, it is inherently
- 1:26:04mutually mutually beneficial.
- 1:26:06Because if you make an argument that it wasn't that one side got robbed,
- 1:26:10you're making a judgment on information that you don't have.
- 1:26:14So the fact that something transpired indicates that at least to the parties
- 1:26:18that negotiated it, they believe it to be mutually beneficial.
- 1:26:22If you start to analyze and operate a lot of things in that way,
- 1:26:26everything from from buying a car to the U.S.
- 1:26:31Trade deficit nationally, right?
- 1:26:33It paints a very, very different picture at that point than what I perceive
- 1:26:38at least to be the traditional quote-unquote narrative. Interesting.
- 1:26:42Yeah, and I guess, yeah, that's a fascinating thing to think through.
- 1:26:47The one thing I was going to say, you mentioned sweatshops and not being popular at parties.
- 1:26:52Because I would not advocate for the minimum wage either, which also makes me just so popular.
- 1:26:56Yeah, no, me either. I mean, I think that's, well, that's anti-capitalism.
- 1:26:59I mean, that's what it is. It's more regulation.
- 1:27:00But so in college, we had a, it was our capstone class.
- 1:27:05Okay. All right. We had this software that was like, so basically like every
- 1:27:10person had to create a shoe company.
- 1:27:13And there was this software that we had. It was like, you're like in groups
- 1:27:15of three or four and you could choose anything you wanted.
- 1:27:19You could choose outsourcing. You could choose the price of the shoe, the quality of the shoe.
- 1:27:23And it was like, everyone was in the same market. So it kind of created its
- 1:27:26own like market conditions for everybody, a really cool thing.
- 1:27:30I think the team that won was actually the dumbest team because they just threw
- 1:27:34in whatever numbers and they got lucky, true story.
- 1:27:37Um, but it was a really, that doesn't tell you what the market process is.
- 1:27:40I don't know. A good lesson in economics, I guess.
- 1:27:43But we decided to outsource our shoes or so, so because it was significantly cheaper.
- 1:27:49And so our professor was like ethically, you know, like, so then he,
- 1:27:52he started talking about the ethics of, of outsourcing and this was in front of the whole class.
- 1:27:57And he's like, Dylan, your team decided to outsource. have
- 1:28:00you considered that you bended your
- 1:28:03ethics to allow child labor and
- 1:28:07i'm like i didn't bend my ethics at all and so
- 1:28:10we had a debate like in front of the whole class on
- 1:28:13why i think in that scenario it's a good thing like for that happened and what
- 1:28:18we actually did is we actually created this huge thing where like because it
- 1:28:21was our company we could do whatever we want so we actually created like schooling
- 1:28:24for the kids oh sure so we actually like and what we did like in in our company
- 1:28:28was the average kid only worked like five hours a day of the actual production.
- 1:28:32And that was still significantly more savings than what we would get to pay an American to do that.
- 1:28:38And then the other three hours, they actually were in school taught by like a teacher.
- 1:28:42And we actually did the actual math of like for whatever it would have cost
- 1:28:47for a line worker here in the United States. This is assuming we didn't have robotics.
- 1:28:51This was like back with it. We didn't have a role. It was people versus salary
- 1:28:55here versus salary there.
- 1:28:57It was still cheaper for us to employ children to work for five hours a week
- 1:29:01with schooling, with safe environments, with all this stuff than it would be to employ one American.
- 1:29:07And it was just actually an interesting thing. So the teacher couldn't get over
- 1:29:12the fact that we were still employing children,
- 1:29:13but the point was it was still better for the company and better for the child
- 1:29:17because we were trying to say, it's like, look, they're going to be way better
- 1:29:19working with us in a safe, healthy environment than they would be because they're
- 1:29:24going to be working either way.
- 1:29:25Like that's I think the one thing. That's the other part of it too.
- 1:29:27Like the people when they get mad is like they will be working somewhere.
- 1:29:31So if you say all of the companies that actually have ethics and the companies
- 1:29:35that actually create good working environments if you force them to pull out
- 1:29:39they are going to work somewhere and they actually might now be working in a
- 1:29:42significantly less good environment,
- 1:29:44than they would have been had you been allowed to stay there.
- 1:29:47Well you know I'll put it this way that I'm,
- 1:29:50He, like I said earlier, the family needs the money.
- 1:29:53Okay. So, you know, we are in a very fortunate position over on this side of the Atlantic ocean.
- 1:30:02The pond. Yeah. Over this side of the pond to sit back and say,
- 1:30:07well, kids shouldn't have to do that. Yeah.
- 1:30:09And for the most part, while this isn't, you know, 100% true,
- 1:30:14but for the most part, kids here don't, don't have to.
- 1:30:18Yeah. And that's lovely. Overseas, that's not always the case, right?
- 1:30:22If the family, you know, you got a family that has three or four kids,
- 1:30:26they're in extreme poverty, and everybody needs to work just to put dinner on the table.
- 1:30:33Like, if you get rid of child labor, you are absolutely... Family.
- 1:30:40Those families, those people, those kids. It's just funny. And it sucks because
- 1:30:43you can't win. Well, it's just a reality.
- 1:30:45I mean, I think that if we wanted to have a... It's a terrible reality.
- 1:30:47You know, if we want to have a utopian debate, then I think we would all agree,
- 1:30:50yeah, like, it'd be great for a kid to be able to go to school. Yeah.
- 1:30:52It'd be great. Yeah, it'd be, but that's not the reality.
- 1:30:56And on a side note, then to punish companies, forcing them to,
- 1:31:01you know, when we talk about American jobs, and that's completely different,
- 1:31:04but like, if you're like, you can't have child labor in other countries,
- 1:31:07well, it's like, those kids will be working somewhere, because they have to.
- 1:31:11That's the reality. We can't change that.
- 1:31:13I'd love to change that. that. So, well, sometimes I think in America,
- 1:31:17it'd be good. It'd be good.
- 1:31:20Also not very popular viewpoint, but I like, what's the stat?
- 1:31:23I don't know if I don't have the actual stat, so don't, you know,
- 1:31:26crucify me in the comment section, but.
- 1:31:29Think like america's like last to develop adults of
- 1:31:32like actual contributing citizens
- 1:31:36to like the whole like
- 1:31:39we're last in the age bracket so like it's like
- 1:31:4225 is the median or 24 is the
- 1:31:45median of actually like people creating
- 1:31:48actually any type of help for the mass
- 1:31:51and like in other other country it'll be like 13 14
- 1:31:55and i don't know i just think that adults the
- 1:31:58what is viewed as adult is very high in the united states
- 1:32:01compared to any other country which i don't
- 1:32:03know if that's a good thing or bad thing but you can make arguments both ways yeah
- 1:32:07there's a bunch of and we also have a bunch of adults that still act
- 1:32:09like babies so i don't know i don't know i don't know what that means you know
- 1:32:12people are complicated we are complicated uh last
- 1:32:16thing i want to go over before we kind of wrap up this podcast and i
- 1:32:18think this has been great i could could talk about this
- 1:32:21stuff forever if me too like we
- 1:32:25could probably have like a four hour just conversation on economics
- 1:32:28and and the the i think
- 1:32:31there's just something powerful to take emotion out of something for a little
- 1:32:35bit which is why i wanted to have you on the podcast because it's very easy
- 1:32:38for me to say capitalism is better because i think it's better right you know
- 1:32:43because i emotionally believe it's better i think also i also believe in the
- 1:32:48depravity of man and so So I think that socialism,
- 1:32:50just by me believing that there's actually not like inherent good in every single
- 1:32:54person, that every person actually is bent is going to be bad.
- 1:32:57Socialism can't work in that situation. Just in my worldview,
- 1:33:01it can't happen. But that's not, that's my worldview. That's what I believe.
- 1:33:05But then if there's actually statistics and numbers and actually like theories
- 1:33:08to back it up, that actually is a good way to think through it as well.
- 1:33:11The one thing I want to talk about to end it was this question.
- 1:33:17In 2024, is there such thing as a free market in America?
- 1:33:24Because I don't know, you've probably heard the statistics. You have BlackRock,
- 1:33:27Vanguard, and there's a third company that owns like 70% of the companies in the S&P 500.
- 1:33:33That's a big topic right now, by the way. A lot of people are now...
- 1:33:37We talked about Larry Fink at lunch.
- 1:33:39We talked about is there one man pulling the strings behind the scenes of the economy?
- 1:33:44Is there three companies that have an influence? Is there a free market?
- 1:33:48So when we invest money into the stock market, can the average American trust
- 1:33:52that a free market is still going on?
- 1:33:54Or is the reality something different that there really is no such thing as
- 1:33:58a free market in America anymore?
- 1:34:00What a good question. I'm good at those. Great. Do you load it?
- 1:34:03I'm sorry. No, you're totally fine. It's a good question.
- 1:34:06It's a very smart one to ask. I would say...
- 1:34:10Things. One, what we talked about earlier, right?
- 1:34:14Where just the presence of large firms does not necessarily mean that something
- 1:34:20has gone wrong in the free market, right?
- 1:34:22It is our king of the hill on a pile of gravel example.
- 1:34:26Just because a company got really big doesn't mean that there is not something unforeseen coming up.
- 1:34:34It doesn't mean that someone below them isn't going to overtake The beauty of
- 1:34:39market processes is that it breeds innovation, especially over the course of time.
- 1:34:45So, you know, you brought up Rockefellers and other really, really large,
- 1:34:50you know, Standard Oil, all these companies in the past.
- 1:34:52Yes, there was antitrust action against them. At the same time,
- 1:34:56you know, you look at iTunes.
- 1:34:58ITunes was supposed to ruin the music industry. And lo and behold,
- 1:35:03here comes Spotify, right?
- 1:35:05Knocks them off their perch. Now you got Apple music, iTunes isn't even really a thing so much anymore.
- 1:35:09You know, eBay was, was a threat at one point.
- 1:35:13I swear, you know, there's always these large companies that pop up and people
- 1:35:19are afraid that they're not going to go anywhere.
- 1:35:21And if the market is allowed to rest and actually be this, this process of innovation
- 1:35:28and, and be this back and forth that takes place over, over a period of time
- 1:35:33in the short run. unsure.
- 1:35:35There might be a near monopoly. There might be an Amazon that runs the show for a bit.
- 1:35:40There might be a Google that's going to have over 90% of the search market,
- 1:35:43which they do right now. Right.
- 1:35:45But again, chat GPT pops up. Who knows what might pop up to compete with Amazon's cloud service?
- 1:35:51Again, AI is a total wild card here. So I would say that first of all, it's a market process.
- 1:35:58A market's not just what we're sitting in right now.
- 1:36:00It grows, it changes, It's unanticipated. It's totally unpredictable.
- 1:36:06Right. And it is a process above anything else.
- 1:36:10So in terms of, can there even be a free market if you have five or six really
- 1:36:16large firms that own a lot of this, you know, the S&P 500, which by the way,
- 1:36:21is just a segment, right? You know, it's not the entire system.
- 1:36:25It's not every firm. It's just a few very, very large funds.
- 1:36:28So could there practically be a free market in that instance?
- 1:36:32Yes. Absolutely, because again, it's a process. It's not stagnant.
- 1:36:37It's ever-changing and it's unpredictable.
- 1:36:39Now, if you're asking currently.
- 1:36:43Do these firms have a lot of influence because politicians listen to them and
- 1:36:49institute regulations that restrict competition from coming up and harm the process of innovation?
- 1:36:57Because, you know, we're not going to have times to really discuss it too much,
- 1:37:00but monopolies are terrible innovators. Yeah.
- 1:37:04Practically they are. are so if you
- 1:37:07have a lot of influence and if you can pay you
- 1:37:10know lobbyists and you can pay to
- 1:37:13charities and exhibit that influence to
- 1:37:16get certain regulatory outcomes to maintain your
- 1:37:19position is that a problem right now absolutely so
- 1:37:24a big yes and a no yeah it's like a yes but in
- 1:37:27theory it could work i think we
- 1:37:31can go full circle here if we have and keep
- 1:37:35in mind the s&p 500 is not the only place to invest obviously like that's
- 1:37:37just one of the you know this there's a thousand other ways that
- 1:37:40you can invest your money i understand yeah i do think that is a big
- 1:37:43concern that's i mean even uh patrick david bett i don't know if
- 1:37:45you know who that is but he started an insurance company he has like probably the
- 1:37:48biggest he's up with rogan not
- 1:37:52as quite as big of a podcast but he has a huge podcast with
- 1:37:55a huge huge huge fan base conservative i
- 1:37:59think by nature but that's one thing that
- 1:38:01he's been talking a lot about and a lot of people are you know
- 1:38:04freaking out about that but i think it's funny because people that are freaking
- 1:38:08out about the black rocks of vanguards like well we have to do something well
- 1:38:11it's like you can't regulate them put them there right because that's exactly
- 1:38:16what you're fighting against you know and so it's uh it's an interesting i I
- 1:38:21guess it's just an interesting problem.
- 1:38:22I want to add this really quickly. This is, this is straight out of Milton Friedman.
- 1:38:26Okay. So if anyone wants to back check and look it up and read some more about
- 1:38:31this sort of idea, what I'm about to say is Milton Friedman,
- 1:38:36economist that was very, very influential,
- 1:38:39especially in conservative circles. But he, he.
- 1:38:43Would remind people that being pro-business is not the same as being pro-market,
- 1:38:48not the same as being pro-capitalism.
- 1:38:50Because capitalism and the free market is a profit and loss system,
- 1:38:56not just a profit system.
- 1:38:57When you set up regulations such that you mitigate losses, such that things
- 1:39:03are too big to fail, bailouts, subsidies, things that get in the way of companies
- 1:39:10falling through the floor.
- 1:39:12When you start to lean into those things, you're no longer practicing free markets.
- 1:39:16You're no longer practicing capitalism.
- 1:39:18You've got a profit system. You're trying to make sure everyone makes profit.
- 1:39:22So I would here like to emphasize that it's a, if a market's going to operate,
- 1:39:27it's a profit and loss system.
- 1:39:29It's a trial. It's an error. It's unexpected.
- 1:39:32It goes on and there are going to be winners, losers, and nothing's going to stay the same.
- 1:39:37So when you start to regulate things yeah everybody
- 1:39:40can't be winners i mean and this this is probably
- 1:39:43a bad analogy but it's even sports right you like there
- 1:39:46has to be a loser there has to be a winner i mean
- 1:39:49in the whole movement where everyone's a winner that's just bullcrap like that doesn't
- 1:39:52no there are winners there are losers in sports
- 1:39:55there and for a market to be functioning healthily there needs to be losers
- 1:39:59just as many as there are winners that's what you're saying if not more losers
- 1:40:04than winners yeah if you think about it the process of innovation is so fraught
- 1:40:09with potential for failure, right?
- 1:40:12So if you have a structure or a market context where there are,
- 1:40:18you know, you're needing to pursue innovation in order to get a leg up,
- 1:40:23in order to overtake and win that, you know, king of the hill game, right?
- 1:40:28There are going to be far more failures than there are successes because it's
- 1:40:33going to be so difficult to reinvent invent the wheel, but someone's going to do it. Yeah.
- 1:40:37Need the one yeah and it unseats everything you just need to let
- 1:40:40the flexibility for people to innovate and let
- 1:40:44that happen and then over time and it might take longer than
- 1:40:47you want and the the monopoly so to
- 1:40:49speak might be in power longer than you wish it would but there
- 1:40:52is someone that's going to take their place if they're as long as you don't get
- 1:40:55in the way yeah and the problem with america right now is
- 1:40:58we have a lot of people getting in the way and you have a lot of bailout i mean the
- 1:41:01that's just the fact at least in my opinion right
- 1:41:04now yeah i'm not a fan of the the subsidies and balance
- 1:41:06yeah but i also don't know how it would be a
- 1:41:09massive change for america to ever go away from
- 1:41:12that it would and we've been this way for a very long time correct
- 1:41:15as well you know this does predate the
- 1:41:18questions we're yeah we're talking this is us that's for
- 1:41:21sure and many of these can be traced back fdr and
- 1:41:24john manor canes actually ancianism is
- 1:41:27a economic thought that we don't have time for but if people want to
- 1:41:30look it up by all means let's do a part two of the the podcast then we
- 1:41:33could talk about like alexander hamilton the banking system and
- 1:41:36how that influenced the free government control yeah
- 1:41:39i don't know if you've heard of that i have not i'll say hi
- 1:41:43again okay yeah and we didn't also talk about crypto and the economy that was
- 1:41:47one thing i was going to talk about but speaking of crypto we do have a podcast
- 1:41:50we were just released on cryptocurrencies if you're into that you can check
- 1:41:52that out well man i appreciate that i think if anything for the listeners just
- 1:41:58living a life where you want to learn if you don't know know, ask dumb questions.
- 1:42:02We talked about that at lunch. Like if you don't know, ask dumb questions.
- 1:42:05There are probably questions that I asked today that Wes was like,
- 1:42:07that's the dumbest thing I've ever heard, but that's okay. Absolutely not.
- 1:42:10Yeah. You can say that. I'll take it later.
- 1:42:12No, no, no. But that's the beauty of having good conversation is asking questions.
- 1:42:17And then like also putting yourself out there, being willing to be wrong,
- 1:42:20being willing to take a loss. And that's how good conversations happen.
- 1:42:24So as people listen to this podcast, this podcast grows, Rose,
- 1:42:27that's what I want this podcast to be shaped on is two people being willing
- 1:42:31to be wrong and actually have good conversation. I think we had that today.
- 1:42:35And so I appreciate you coming on the show. I did want to leave you with an
- 1:42:38opportunity to promote whatever you want to promote. I know you have a cool sub stack.
- 1:42:42I don't know if you want to call it a blog or whatever you want to call it. It is sweet.
- 1:42:45So I'll let you promote that real quick and I'll do a little quick promotion
- 1:42:48for you as well. But go ahead. What do you got going on? What do you want people to know?
- 1:42:51Yeah, absolutely. Well, so as you mentioned at the very beginning here,
- 1:42:53Dylan, I do do a lot lot within the Pistons content creation space.
- 1:42:57So, you know, if you guys are Pistons fans, local to Detroit,
- 1:43:00definitely tune into the Pistons Pulse by the Detroit Free Press.
- 1:43:04I'm a producer on that. And then I also host the pin down from Detroit Bad Boys
- 1:43:08with my co-host Blake Silverman. Both are great.
- 1:43:11You know, we have a lot of fun, even though the team's really bad.
- 1:43:14So, you know, it's a good time as well. If you'd like to follow more of my,
- 1:43:18you know, my thoughts and, you know, musings on current events,
- 1:43:22economic theory, I write a blog on Substack.
- 1:43:25It's called Davenport economics, trying to grow that, just trying to have a
- 1:43:29little bit more of an intellectual space as well, keeping the two separate, of course.
- 1:43:34I have a lot of fun. Would appreciate a subscribe. Obviously got the email list
- 1:43:38and all that. So it's a great time.
- 1:43:40Yeah. If you subscribe, he sends out occasional newsletters.
- 1:43:43What I appreciate about- Try to do weekly.
- 1:43:44Yeah. What I appreciate about it, it's not too much. That's what I was going
- 1:43:47to say. It's actually not too much. It's a good amount, two to four pieces of content a month.
- 1:43:51It's enough to just digest, but it's not enough that just annoys your inbox either.
- 1:43:55So I would definitely recommend everyone listening to the podcast,
- 1:43:58subscribe to his blog on Substack, Davenport Economics.
- 1:44:02It's a cool thing. I've read some things that I'm like, hmm, that's interesting.
- 1:44:06And other things I'm like, that is insane. I'd never thought of it that way.
- 1:44:09And so it's a good mix of everything. Ooh, I want to hear what was what.
- 1:44:11And I love it. So I click it. Every time it comes to my email,
- 1:44:15I'd recommend you guys do the same. I will have a link in the description.
- 1:44:18If you guys want to type in your email, go to your sub stack that they can do that that way. Okay?
- 1:44:23Thank you. I appreciate that. Thank you guys for listening to this episode of the Dylan England Show.
- 1:44:27If you're still with us after two riveting hours of awesome conversation,
- 1:44:31thank you seriously. obviously, please hit that subscribe button, hit that like button.
- 1:44:35Thank you guys for tuning in, and we'll see you guys on the next episode. Thanks, man.
- 1:44:38Music.