Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E001: The Power of Open Protocols with Matt Odell
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:09Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:12management platform built on multi institution custody,
- 0:16leveraging our partnerships with industry veterans, Bit Go and
- 0:19Coin Cover on ramps. Multi Institution Custody is a
- 0:23segregated vault requiring two of three institutions at any
- 0:26point in time to sign once a client's unique permissions have
- 0:30been met. Our industry leading best in
- 0:32class approach to custody helps individuals and institutions
- 0:36secure new and existing Bitcoin positions.
- 0:39All keys are held in deep cold storage and kept 100% offline.
- 0:44Managed with institutional grade security best practices.
- 0:48The custody solution eliminates single points of failure and
- 0:52reduces counterparty risks. Ensuring maximum security and
- 0:55Peace of Mind on Ramp's suite of products includes our custody
- 0:59offering, a spot Bitcoin fund, private wealth services and
- 1:02inheritance planning, and managed wealth for advisors.
- 1:05Whether you're new to Bitcoin or a veteran in the space, we would
- 1:09love to connect with you. To understand your needs and how
- 1:11we can serve you, please visit our website at on
- 1:14rampbitcoin.com where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:17connect directly with our team. It all comes down to computers.
- 1:23Communicating the information superhighway can be a confusing
- 1:28mix of on ramps and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 1:34gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 1:36Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 1:40OK, this is actually foundational.
- 1:42Technology. What the Internet of Money does
- 1:45is it creates a single network which can do a microtransaction
- 1:51to a giga transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 1:57of the major forces for reducing the role of gun The one thing
- 2:02that's missing that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 2:12And we are live. Welcome to the first episode of
- 2:16Final Settlement. This is a new podcast coming
- 2:19from the On Ramp media umbrella. You might be familiar with the
- 2:23last Trade, the podcast that we started in May of last year.
- 2:28We are expanding the suite of podcasts here at On Ramp
- 2:32building some complimentary shows that will look at Bitcoin
- 2:36at you know from a bit of a different lens than what the
- 2:39last trade has has historically been, which is you know
- 2:42primarily the intersection of Bitcoin and traditional finance,
- 2:47the global macro context and and really Bitcoin as a financial
- 2:52instrument. The purpose of final Settlement
- 2:55is really to go beyond the digital gold thesis and really
- 2:59look at Bitcoin as a piece of technology and understand the
- 3:03protocol layer and the various forms of utility that that are
- 3:08being leveraged in the real world.
- 3:10People building on top of Bitcoin and using this open
- 3:13source protocol to better society in in various ways.
- 3:17And so this podcast is going to be every two weeks and you'll
- 3:21still get the last trade every Friday, so no worries there.
- 3:25But really just trying to build a more comprehensive approach to
- 3:30education generally and and really helping investors in our
- 3:33audience build their thesis on Bitcoin beyond just Bitcoin as a
- 3:39financial instrument or a number on a screen.
- 3:41There's a lot more meat to cover as you go down the rabbit hole.
- 3:44So that'll be that'll be sort of the goal of the show.
- 3:47My name is Brian Cabellos I'm the head of strategy and
- 3:50research here at on RAMP Co hosting final settlement with me
- 3:54will be Michael Tanguma, Co Founder and CEO of On RAMP and
- 3:58our first guest Mr. Matt O'dell. Super pumped to have you on.
- 4:03Could think of knowing better to to start this podcast then Matt.
- 4:08He's been you know, contributing to Bitcoin space for several
- 4:11years in a number of ways. Wears many hats.
- 4:13But Matt, thanks for coming. On Yeah, I literally wear many
- 4:17hats. Thanks for having me look at
- 4:21looking forward to it. It's it's almost become a joke
- 4:26like oh what do we need Another Bitcoin podcast.
- 4:28But the more education the better.
- 4:30It's an important topic. Absolutely.
- 4:33I'm just glad Matt's our first because we can say, you know, we
- 4:36were talking about when do we get them on the last trade and
- 4:38now we could say we started a whole podcast to have that.
- 4:42We were waiting. Invited me on the last trade.
- 4:46That's this is like the this is even better.
- 4:49It's a whole brand new pod. First episode we will find.
- 4:52I accidentally joined the tail end of one of them, but.
- 4:55That's right. That's true.
- 4:56I technically was not a guest. I thought about it around the
- 5:00ETF. When the ETF gets announced so
- 5:02you can scream at everyone about how it's not Bitcoin.
- 5:04But I don't know if that'd be appropriate for that audience.
- 5:06But maybe we'll. Well, it's funny on the ETF
- 5:09side, I mean, I know I we're, I, we're not supposed to talk about
- 5:12this is like a last trade topic. But I mean, it's just funny on
- 5:15the ETF side that my role has almost been the opposite.
- 5:20You know, the ETF is not Bitcoin, it's an IOU.
- 5:23You should learn how to hold your own Bitcoin.
- 5:25You should learn how to use it as freedom money.
- 5:27But the ETFs are incredibly bullish.
- 5:29Like they willing, they will increase the purchasing power of
- 5:32Bitcoin tremendously by exposing it to a new market.
- 5:36And also all these companies can do it without permission.
- 5:38That's the whole point of Bitcoin.
- 5:40So I think you know the ETFs aren't priced in.
- 5:43I think it's impossible for them to be priced in because the
- 5:46suits can't hold their own private keys.
- 5:49They lack the personal responsibility and the chops to
- 5:51do it. So they they need a new
- 5:54custodial wallet product in order to to get exposure to
- 5:58Bitcoin, and that's what the ETFs are.
- 5:59They're simply just a custodial wallet for suits.
- 6:02And it it also just sort of amplifies what we always think
- 6:06about, which is like education and and really awareness are
- 6:10what tips the scales of adoption over the long term, right.
- 6:13And so whether it's an inferior product or not like it'll force
- 6:17people to think about Bitcoin more so than they previously
- 6:20would have once these things exist but so have a bunch of
- 6:28things want to get to. But Matt I'm curious.
- 6:32You know I've, I personally have learned a ton from you over the
- 6:35years on RHR sealed dispatch thousands of hours of pods.
- 6:42But I don't think I can recall like your actual Bitcoin origin
- 6:46story. Like what did you what were you
- 6:48doing before Bitcoin? Did you have any sort of like
- 6:51predispositions or or past experiences that led you to to
- 6:55find Bitcoin and and dig deeper? I'm just curious, you know, what
- 6:58was that origin story like and what what stood out to you and
- 7:01and caused you to think more deeply about it?
- 7:05Yeah, I mean, I don't really talk about my previous
- 7:07professional Fiat life much, but the the TLDR, the quick summary
- 7:16is that I was a, you know, disenfranchised youth.
- 7:20I didn't have much hope. Like, I I grew up through the
- 7:232008 financial collapse. I saw that there were no adults
- 7:27in the room. No one had any idea what was
- 7:29going on. But everyone just acts super
- 7:31confident on CNBC while they're just fucking yoloing it and
- 7:35winging it. And then I was like, OK, so you
- 7:38can't trust the banks, but at least we got the, the tech
- 7:41companies. Like, you know, Google's don't
- 7:44do evil is their is is their slogan.
- 7:46Like of course they got our back.
- 7:48And then Snowden came out in 2013.
- 7:51And Snowden was like all the all the major tech companies are
- 7:55complicit in mass surveillance and control.
- 7:58And at that point, I I had, I discovered Bitcoin right right
- 8:02around. I discovered Bitcoin right
- 8:04before Snowden's leaks. So it was it was this
- 8:07culmination of you can't trust the financial system.
- 8:11You can't you can't trust big tech.
- 8:15So what it what is the solution? The solution is free in open
- 8:17source software. It's it's it's freedom tech and
- 8:20Bitcoin fits squarely in that, in that hole.
- 8:24Yeah, No, it's it's interesting because I think that's that's
- 8:27part of the reason I think you're the the perfect first
- 8:29guest for the show because you actually did come at it first
- 8:33from a technology perspective. Whereas I think, you know, there
- 8:36is a proclivity at least in sort of the institutional realm, the
- 8:39traditional finance world and even just sort of casual
- 8:43onlookers of Bitcoin to think of it first and foremost as just
- 8:47another asset, you know, similar to a stock or a bond or other
- 8:51precious metal and not really think of it as as a technology
- 8:551st. And so I think you know from a
- 8:58very high level, like you know, a fundamental perspective, you
- 9:01know, most people don't even know, you know, that there is a
- 9:04distinction between Bitcoin the asset and Bitcoin the network,
- 9:06right. And so it's, it's, it's
- 9:08fascinating that you came at it first from a network
- 9:10perspective. But I think the reality is most
- 9:13people are coming at it from an asset perspective, which is
- 9:16fine. You know, the digital gold
- 9:17thesis is important, but I think in order to sort of strengthen
- 9:21people's conviction over time, you need to understand this more
- 9:25fully in a in a more comprehensive level and and
- 9:27understand that this is an open source piece of software.
- 9:30And I think, you know, that's something that you've spent a
- 9:33lot of time thinking about. And and I'm curious your
- 9:36thoughts just around, you know, why is it so, why is it so
- 9:38important and critical that Bitcoin is built on this
- 9:41foundation of free and open source software?
- 9:44And how does that sort of what are the implications of that
- 9:47generally speaking? And and why does that make it
- 9:49very different? Why does that make the asset
- 9:51that is governed by the protocol much different than any other
- 9:55assets that someone could invest in?
- 9:58I mean, the open source software is a foundational building block
- 10:02that this is all built on top of.
- 10:04Because the the problem is the problem isn't a technical
- 10:08problem. The problem is a human problem.
- 10:11The the the the issue we face in society is that all of our
- 10:15institutions require insane amounts of trust in centralized
- 10:19entities. Individuals, companies,
- 10:21governments, and those entities inevitably get corrupted.
- 10:25It doesn't matter. You know how how good of a
- 10:29person you are or how well meaning you are at first.
- 10:32Like if you get big enough and you become, you know, you become
- 10:35the juggernaut that Google is, It doesn't even matter if you
- 10:38want to be evil. You have no choice.
- 10:40You get a gun pointed to your head and you're forced to do it.
- 10:44So the beauty of open source software is, as it is at its
- 10:48core, not controlled by an entity.
- 10:50It's not controlled by an individual.
- 10:51It's free and available to the public.
- 10:53They can modify it, they can ship it, they can monetize it,
- 10:57they can do whatever the hell they want to do with it without
- 10:59permission. So open source software is is
- 11:03absolutely beautiful in that regard.
- 11:04It's it's almost viral in nature where you don't you know, a
- 11:08person the person who created the software could die.
- 11:11I mean we have no idea who Satoshi is.
- 11:14He completely disappeared and people can take where where he
- 11:17left off and continue on. You know you can throw someone
- 11:20in jail for being an open source contributor, which is absolutely
- 11:24insane. Particularly in America where we
- 11:27have at least we're supposed to have constitutional protections
- 11:31on free speech. But it doesn't matter if you
- 11:33throw the lead developer in jail because the the software is is
- 11:37is code and it's available to everybody.
- 11:40So that that's that's key, that's key to this whole, this
- 11:44this whole mission, this whole movement.
- 11:47And it's key to every Bitcoin holder.
- 11:48Because at the end of the day, you can't have wealth without
- 11:52freedom. If if it requires someone's
- 11:56permission to spend your Bitcoin, then it's not your
- 12:00Bitcoin, because they can stop you from spending it at will.
- 12:04They can seize your money at will.
- 12:06It defeats the whole entire purpose of the thing.
- 12:08So I think there's a bit of a disconnect right now where where
- 12:13people think that they can be separated, that this idea of
- 12:17store of value or Bitcoin as a financial asset is different
- 12:21than Bitcoin as P2P cash. And it's just not the case,
- 12:25because it doesn't matter what price Bitcoin goes to, if you
- 12:28have to go ask Blackrock's permission to spend it, then you
- 12:32fucked up the whole thing like they they'll.
- 12:34And it it doesn't, BlackRock doesn't have to be evil.
- 12:37They can. They can literally just have a
- 12:38gun pointed to their head and say, you know, Michael can't
- 12:41spend his Bitcoin, stop him from spending it, He's on the
- 12:44terrorist watch list. So I'm done.
- 12:46Yeah, that's a really good point because I think you know from
- 12:50that perspective it's like that is that's really the core value
- 12:54prop of this thing, right. Like yes, the, the scarcity, the
- 12:57immutability are important, but it is the fact that it is this
- 13:01open network that is accessible to everyone and uncensorable.
- 13:04And I think we need to get to the point where people are are
- 13:08building a more comprehensive thesis on this thing outside of
- 13:12number go up. This is a, you know, I have
- 13:15exposure to this this thing that is you know going up in value.
- 13:20It's much more than that. And I'm curious, you know, I
- 13:24think there's also some issue related to sort of, you know,
- 13:29the the notion of something being truly open source and
- 13:32permission less that sort of lends lends itself not only to a
- 13:36system being more robust and resilient, but also, you know,
- 13:40maintaining some elements of of true decentralization.
- 13:43And I sort of hate the word decentralization because it's
- 13:46wildly overused and particularly in the crypto space where it's
- 13:49or the, you know, the broader digital asset space where you
- 13:53know it's really, you know, decentralized in name and
- 13:56marketing only. So I'm curious your thoughts
- 13:59around, you know, what about Bitcoin and its foundations from
- 14:03a network perspective make it truly decentralized and allow it
- 14:07to remain so over time versus you know, some of these other
- 14:10quote UN quote protocols that market themselves as
- 14:13decentralized but may not be so. Well, personally I like the term
- 14:19distributed protocol, but either way we're talking about the same
- 14:24thing. The idea that the idea that no
- 14:29individual or entity has control over Bitcoin and can change
- 14:32Bitcoin, which ironically has has been considered by the quote
- 14:39UN quote crypto people and the overwhelming majority part of
- 14:43this industry has has considered it a negative with Bitcoin that
- 14:47it's that it's hard to change by default, that there's not a
- 14:49centralized entity in control, but that is the key value prop.
- 14:54The key value prop is that it's incredibly difficult to change
- 14:58and that is very rare in terms of digital tools, digital
- 15:01services usually it's it's it's the opposite right where Tim
- 15:05Apple can just issue an update and everyone just updates.
- 15:09So it's it's fundamentally different in that respect that
- 15:13it's not controlled. But but yeah I I it's it's a
- 15:18little bit interesting because it's hard to objectively measure
- 15:24distribution or decentralization.
- 15:26You really don't know until it's too late.
- 15:30Like it it it's very easy to tell when something is too
- 15:33centralized because it it gets stomped on, right.
- 15:38A gun gets put to someone's head and something gets changed,
- 15:40something gets robbed. But usually you don't.
- 15:42You don't the the majority of people don't realize that till
- 15:45after the fact. So one of the things I always
- 15:47say to Bitcoin particularly less technical people, right?
- 15:50Like if you're technical you can look at the code you can look at
- 15:53all the different get commits and and see how the the project
- 15:57has changed over time and and do your own verification and
- 16:00analysis. And that's one of the beauties
- 16:01of open source software is that you can see everything that's
- 16:04happening and you can verify it yourself.
- 16:06But if you're not technical the single easiest way to to solve
- 16:10this problem is is time right? And the number one thing you'll
- 16:14hear a non-technical person say is, Oh well, you say there's
- 16:19only 21 million Bitcoin, but humans always make promises they
- 16:23don't keep. There's no way they're going to
- 16:25keep the 21 million cap. OK, well, I'm pretty sure the
- 16:31way Bitcoin is set up that that 21 million cap will never get
- 16:34fucking changed. It is not going to fucking
- 16:36happen. But if if if you don't have the
- 16:39capability of doing that, then time time solves that for you.
- 16:43With time comes the ability to assess this in a more personal
- 16:50way, right? If if if you're watching Bitcoin
- 16:53for five years, six years, and the 21 million cap doesn't
- 16:56change, it's way less likely that it'll change in the next
- 16:58five years. You watch it for 10 years.
- 17:00It's way less likely it's going to change in the next 10 years.
- 17:02So for most people, it's going to take time to realize that
- 17:06that the way the way the system was designed, it was, it was
- 17:09designed to be incredibly resistant to change.
- 17:13But the the core thing that I would like listeners to take
- 17:16away from this is that that is the value prop.
- 17:19Because if you can change something easily, you can change
- 17:23it for the worst easily. And it's important that if we
- 17:27are building the bedrock of a global censorship resistant,
- 17:32permissionless financial system that it has the stability of not
- 17:37being manipulated super easily and that most people that flies
- 17:42right over their head. That's the key, the the the key
- 17:44value prop is, it is the the thing that holds it all together
- 17:48is that you would you essentially need a overwhelming
- 17:52majority of individual stakeholders of Bitcoin.
- 17:56This is not a vote. This isn't no votes happening to
- 18:00to agree with any kind of substantial change, and that
- 18:04just doesn't happen in practice unless there's massive
- 18:07motivation for something to happen.
- 18:09And something like the 21 million cap is a perfect example
- 18:12of the stakeholders have. It's against their financial
- 18:14interests to dilute the supply of their own, of their own asset
- 18:19that they just potentially own significant, that they own
- 18:24significant amounts of. I find I find the technology
- 18:27aspect interesting because it it keeps people away from the asset
- 18:32in two different completely opposite spectrums like and.
- 18:35We can start with either one first, like for the gold, for
- 18:37gold individuals or individuals that need to touch things.
- 18:40The technical aspect, you have all the concepts or primitives
- 18:43of gold without the physical nature and then on the other
- 18:46side of it you have all the aspects of gold except for it's
- 18:49not fast enough or it doesn't do what it is for the tech side.
- 18:52So both sides of the camps are the ones that like you never
- 18:55look at it and they're like this is too slow or this is this
- 18:57isn't fast enough versus like it has this like natural sweet
- 19:01spot. And and it's just like continues
- 19:04and I don't know what that lens of the world is that somebody
- 19:07looks at it and they look and they're like OK this makes
- 19:09sense. But we all see this and we have
- 19:11discussions and it's like every whether it's the touch points or
- 19:14the adoption phases. Everybody slowly starts to
- 19:16realize, oh, this was exactly how it was supposed to be.
- 19:19Not. It's just, they're just enough,
- 19:21right? These keys, these private keys
- 19:23live in the real world, so you can actually make a tangible
- 19:25aspect to it. And it also has speed.
- 19:27And you can talk about multiple layers that start to play into
- 19:30how you can compete with all the other cryptocurrencies.
- 19:32But at the same time, it it doesn't fit in the bucket that
- 19:36everybody naturally wanted to fit in.
- 19:38And that's why it's so hard for individuals to accept or like
- 19:40wrap their heads around it because it just doesn't map to
- 19:42the real world all the way down to like what Matt alluded to in
- 19:46the like natural order of Facebook.
- 19:48And Google doesn't wrap in a bow of like, you have an owner, you
- 19:50have somebody that can just turn it off and like, you can call.
- 19:53And so people are, we're still trying to figure out how do we
- 19:55actually, like, get these primitives to individuals.
- 19:57And that's where, like pods like this exist to be able to, like,
- 20:00figure out what are the mental models to get people to
- 20:02understand it, figure out how to build and invest.
- 20:05Yeah. And it's a good point around,
- 20:08you know, this sort of extreme resistance to change is very
- 20:14unique in the broader technology space, software space.
- 20:18And I think that's part of the disconnect between Bitcoin and
- 20:22all these other altcoin protocols is that they're one,
- 20:27they're optimizing for different things, right?
- 20:29Like if you're building a new form of money, it should be
- 20:33resistant to change, right? You want to have a, you know,
- 20:38transparent and knowable monetary policy for that new
- 20:41form of money, all these other things, you know, sometimes they
- 20:44they market themselves as ultrasound money, but like the
- 20:46reality is that they're they're optimizing for other things
- 20:49right on the base layer in most, in most instances.
- 20:53And so you can optimize for those things in Bitcoin as
- 20:56Michael alluded to. But it happens above the base
- 20:59layer and we can get into that more later in the convo.
- 21:02But I guess one sort of more high level question, we don't
- 21:07have to get too in the weeds of it.
- 21:08But you sort of alluded to this, Matt, in terms of like how
- 21:11things actually do change on Bitcoin.
- 21:13Because I think that generally speaking that's like again such
- 21:17a foreign concept of people. It's like oh, you're telling me
- 21:19this thing that is super scarce will never change, but actually
- 21:23technically anyone can change it.
- 21:24So it's it's it is it is hard for people to grasp, but that
- 21:27can be the reality. So maybe just some color on like
- 21:31how do changes actually get made in Bitcoin, what are some things
- 21:33that you know past examples that everyone was on board with that
- 21:38we're we're able to get through and some some opposite examples
- 21:41as well. So I mean, when you're talking
- 21:45about Bitcoin changes, right, Bitcoin, you know at at the
- 21:51core, Bitcoin is a is is a piece of software that people are
- 21:54running on their computers, right?
- 21:57First things first, there's no auto updates.
- 22:01So auto updates are a security hole.
- 22:04If if a single developer somewhere has access to the
- 22:08ability to auto update people, they can auto update them to a a
- 22:12a malicious piece of software. So the number one core
- 22:17protection is if you want to change, like if you want to run
- 22:22a change to Bitcoin, you have to go manually install the new
- 22:25version of the software and install it on your computer.
- 22:28The second thing to keep in mind is there's two different baskets
- 22:34of of changes, right? One is is consensus level code.
- 22:40So this is the rules that each Bitcoin node, when you're
- 22:45running the Bitcoin a Bitcoin node is simply just running
- 22:47Bitcoin software on your computer.
- 22:50These Bitcoin nodes, their their main role is to enforce the
- 22:55rules of the network. Any of those rules we consider
- 22:59those consensus rules, those are consensus changes.
- 23:04So what does that mean? So, so your node is by running
- 23:07your own node, you're verifying the rules of the network on your
- 23:11own and you're also able to broadcast the network without
- 23:16permission and you're able to verify all receipts, right?
- 23:21So you if you're running a Bitcoin node, it's it's almost
- 23:23like you're running a a gold bar verification service right?
- 23:27Where every time you receive gold it's automatically verified
- 23:32that that gold is not counterfeit.
- 23:35Which is why it's incredibly important that people can easily
- 23:38run their own nodes and and people should use their own
- 23:40nodes if if they are technically capable of it.
- 23:44It's way easier than people think it is.
- 23:46But the most important thing is that it's easy and accessible
- 23:49for people to do it. Not necessarily that everyone
- 23:51does it. We're realistic, everyone's not
- 23:52going to do it but if enough people are doing it then it
- 23:56makes it resistant. So on the consensus change side,
- 24:00anyone can take Bitcoin code, they can take the Bitcoin
- 24:03software, they can change it however the hell they want
- 24:05without permission. No one can stop them.
- 24:07If they change something on the consensus level and then they
- 24:11run that software, the other Bitcoin nodes will reject them.
- 24:15They're they're essentially on a different version of Bitcoin.
- 24:20So consensus level changes are incredibly difficult to to
- 24:26implement that scale because you need buy in from the other
- 24:30people that are running notes. The thousands of people around
- 24:33the world running notes all need to update to the new software.
- 24:36Otherwise you're running on your own essentially counterfeit
- 24:40Bitcoin network right where no one's deeming those Bitcoin
- 24:44valid Bitcoin because they're it, it does not agree with their
- 24:47notes rules. And then you have non consensus
- 24:50changes, and non consensus changes can deal with stuff like
- 24:54mem pool policy in terms of Bitcoin waiting, like the the
- 24:58waiting list to get into Bitcoin block, stuff like that.
- 25:00Those changes you can just implement on the fly, you can
- 25:04run it on your own node and the other nodes will still
- 25:07communicate with you, but you might have a slightly different
- 25:09view of the network. Or maybe you have a different
- 25:11interface on how you, how you interact with the network,
- 25:14different kind of user facing things that don't affect the
- 25:17rest of the network. But if they affect the rest of
- 25:20the network, we consider those consensus changes and those are
- 25:24way, way, way, way more difficult to get through.
- 25:27And the activation method for those kind of things is not very
- 25:33clear cut. They've been activated in many
- 25:35different ways. Sometimes, you know, in the
- 25:39early days, a lot of times it was like, oh, if the miners hit
- 25:42a certain threshold, then we'll do it.
- 25:44And it's gotten significantly harder over time.
- 25:47In 2017, a large portion of the miners decided they wanted to to
- 25:53attack the network and and try and push forward their own
- 25:57consensus change. And as a result, a lot of those
- 26:00activation methods have changed. And the only real major
- 26:03activation on the consensus level we've had since then is
- 26:06Taproot, and it happened to be relatively uncontroversial and
- 26:11it kind of just got pushed through.
- 26:13But I don't expect other activations to happen that way.
- 26:17It's more of an art than a science.
- 26:19Also, you don't really on the consensus level, you don't
- 26:21really know if if you've you've hit the, you know this
- 26:27ridiculous threshold of like 95% plus you don't really know until
- 26:32afterwards if you hit it. So everything is is about trying
- 26:36to reduce any kind of user risk. In that scenario if you have a
- 26:42consensus change that like let's say half the network decides to
- 26:46go one way and half the network doesn't, you have something
- 26:48called a fork. And what that means is your
- 26:52blockchain, right? The Bitcoin blockchain that
- 26:54holds all the record of of all of our transactions publicly
- 26:58forever, right? It'll have a shared history but
- 27:01when that consensus change happens, the the history will
- 27:04fork and and from that point forward it will have a different
- 27:08Ledger, right, a different path forward.
- 27:11So if a fork does happen which we we had one that was a minor
- 27:17fork in 2017 Bitcoin Cash that that relatively quickly resolved
- 27:21itself because most of the market was was on on on the main
- 27:27chain of Bitcoin and and a subset of the market was on
- 27:30Bitcoin Cash. But if you have a fork in that
- 27:32situation an existing holder essentially has the equivalent
- 27:36amount of Bitcoin on both sides. So the beauty of that and I
- 27:41think not enough people appreciate that.
- 27:42The beauty of that is if someone were to trying a malicious actor
- 27:46was going to try and force through some kind of consensus
- 27:48change and got like 40% of the network or 60% of the network to
- 27:51go along with it, the average person could do nothing.
- 27:56And whichever whichever chain turned out to dominate, they
- 28:00would still have the equivalent amount on it.
- 28:02Now if you want to be a gambler, you can go on to the markets and
- 28:05you can sell one side for the other side.
- 28:08And you know, that's the beauty of free markets, right, And the
- 28:11markets kind of pricing, which side is better or which side has
- 28:15more market demand, I guess, and it kind of just works itself
- 28:19out. But if you're the average user,
- 28:20you can just sit there and do nothing and you get equivalent.
- 28:23Now this is really important though in the age of ETFs is if
- 28:27you're using a custodial wallet or an ETF, which is just a fancy
- 28:32custodial wallet for suits, you are trusting the custodian with
- 28:36that decision. You, you have no choice on the
- 28:39matter. But if you're holding self
- 28:40custody Bitcoin, you're holding your keys yourself.
- 28:42Maybe you're using a hardware wallet, you know, maybe using
- 28:46collaborative multi sig you at that point you're getting
- 28:50equivalent to both sides and you can choose now because of the
- 28:53messiness of of of consensus change, potential consensus
- 28:59change forks. What we've normally see in
- 29:02Bitcoin in terms of these changes is something called a
- 29:06soft fork versus a hard fork. And with a soft fork, what
- 29:09happens is new clients might see the new thing.
- 29:14If you're running a new version of Bitcoin, you might see the
- 29:16new thing. But if you're running an old
- 29:18version of Bitcoin, it still works, it's still compatible
- 29:22with everything else, and it just is missing a subset of of
- 29:27transactions. It doesn't doesn't doesn't see
- 29:29the new shit, but you can still run the old one and be
- 29:32completely fine, and everything will still work together.
- 29:35And then the hard fork is everyone actually needs to
- 29:37update to the newest software. So hard forks are incredibly
- 29:41unlikely. Soft forks are a lot more
- 29:44likely. But both types of changes when
- 29:48it comes to changing actual consensus rules of the network.
- 29:51The rules that these nodes enforce are very, very rare and
- 29:55very, very difficult. And it's a combination of like
- 29:58art, politics, and just like sheer momentum like I, I.
- 30:03The only way you really have these changes, especially going
- 30:06forward, is if there is incredibly strong motivation
- 30:11among participants to enact this change.
- 30:14And that is basically this beautiful check we have on
- 30:19changes on Bitcoin is that it? It needs to have like an
- 30:22absolute massive amount of demand for that change, for that
- 30:25change to actually have. So that was an incredible recap.
- 30:29I think, one, appreciate you running through that because I
- 30:32think that's going to go down as we push people back to listening
- 30:35to understanding the fork. But so to go a little deeper on
- 30:39that going backwards for anybody that's not familiar, this is
- 30:43really where credible monetary policy comes into play.
- 30:45And Etherium had the Was it parody hack in Was it 1414?
- 30:52Something like that. 14 or 15 where they rolled back the chain
- 30:55and forked to roll back from the hack versus.
- 30:57Well, it wasn't just the parody. They had the Dow hack.
- 31:00To the Dow, yeah. It's the Dow, yeah.
- 31:03I think parody. They said fuck you to parody and
- 31:06didn't rollback. Parody, but they.
- 31:07Rolled back. It was a Dow hack that they
- 31:09rolled back effectively, you know, moving the coins back into
- 31:13the existing wallet. Which hacker?
- 31:15The hacker stole Ethereum and then they forked it.
- 31:18They did a hard fork, so consensus breaking change.
- 31:22Everyone had an update to the new software and the new
- 31:24software stated that the hacker did not actually own own the
- 31:27Ethereum and and it returned it back to the previous owners.
- 31:32And then at that point there was another the existing chain over
- 31:36the hackers still had it. They they called it Ethereum
- 31:39Classic. And you had like this little
- 31:42glimpse into how you would market a malicious fork, right
- 31:45where you you have the fork retain the name Ethereum and
- 31:50then you have the one that wasn't a fork, that was the
- 31:52existing chain. You call that classic and you
- 31:55kind of just throw it under the bus.
- 31:57And I think that's important to point out one because of
- 31:59monetary policy, it's not just a name only.
- 32:02When you think about decentralization that was
- 32:04obviously not decentralized or distributed even properly if you
- 32:07can roll that back. And it reminds me of whatever
- 32:10happened with CZ initially with the safe SAFU and he like
- 32:14referenced that he could roll back the chain and they're like,
- 32:15Oh yeah, try it. It's like this idea, you can say
- 32:18it, but to be able to effectively do it on the
- 32:19Bitcoin. Protocol CZ of Binance had some
- 32:22Bitcoin hacked and he like tried to play games and he couldn't
- 32:26get it back right. Final settlement, final name of
- 32:29the podcast you like. It comes down to the fact that a
- 32:32centralized centralized entity does not have control, right.
- 32:35All this stuff comes back to that.
- 32:37And I, Brian mentioned earlier, I think a better, more recent
- 32:40example because it's easy for people.
- 32:42The old examples, people always just brush under, right?
- 32:45Like I was telling people to don't like custodial risk is a
- 32:49real thing. Not your keys, not your coins.
- 32:51And people are calling me a fudder right?
- 32:53They were like Mount Cox was 10 years ago.
- 32:56That's ridiculous. Why do you hate people like my,
- 32:58my my family relies on the yield I get from Block Fi and FTX and
- 33:03Celsius and they all got fucking rugged right?
- 33:06And now they have a new lesson on why they should hold self
- 33:09custody and learn how to hold Bitcoin themselves.
- 33:12But in 10 years, like, if there's not another major rug,
- 33:15like people are going to say in the same thing like, oh, FTX was
- 33:17a decade ago, like BlackRock is responsible now.
- 33:20And then BlackRock rocks and then people will realize again.
- 33:23So the older examples are a little unfortunate, a little bit
- 33:26less effective. But we have a new example with
- 33:28Ethereum, which is this idea of ultrasound money that they like,
- 33:32like 10 people in the room decided they were going to
- 33:34change the inflation rate of Ethereum and then they changed
- 33:37it to be less than Bitcoin. And they were like, oh, we're a
- 33:40better store of value in the Bitcoin.
- 33:42But they don't realize the cell phone that if they can change
- 33:47the the they can change the the monetary supply at a whim, they
- 33:51can change it in the opposite direction.
- 33:53And that's why it's not ultrasound, right, that you
- 33:56can't you can't have a you can't have a sound protocol.
- 33:59You can't have a hard protocol. You can't have a protocol that
- 34:02is censorship resistant and permission list if there are
- 34:05centralized entities in control because they can change it at
- 34:07will. So real quick because I know
- 34:10Brown's the transition, but it's an important facet that I kind
- 34:13of want to put you on the spot Matt on to be most relevant the
- 34:17ETF. So if we if we're realistic, I
- 34:19think like you know we look at 3510 year time frame that is a
- 34:23realistic like vector where we can think about forks and what
- 34:27happens. I think there's two components
- 34:28Matt alluded to. One, most investors coming in
- 34:31don't necessarily know Bitcoin is is a digital bare asset at
- 34:35the end of the day. And then you can actually take
- 34:36delivery of that. And independent if you're not
- 34:38ready to take delivery right off the bat, you always want that
- 34:40optionality. And we've seen that with GBTC
- 34:43and that's effectively what we. I think all agree here is going
- 34:45to happen where somebody wakes up, gets educated and they're
- 34:47like hey I want my Bitcoin, like Oh yeah, you know screw off.
- 34:50You can maybe get your dollars at best.
- 34:53Yeah. And pay cap gains.
- 34:54So then taking that to the dominant chain and working out
- 34:58like because I'm actually generally curious on like and I
- 35:00know it's more of science than art or more of arts and science.
- 35:04But with the B cash fork, was the general consensus that most
- 35:11that were forking for B cash like sold their Bitcoin or did
- 35:15they hedge? And then how would that, like
- 35:18how did that chain work out from like hash rate like help us walk
- 35:22through that And then what that would potentially look, if you
- 35:24can with like the ETF because that would be a similar format
- 35:27for like green coin or whatever that would look like from a just
- 35:30game theory perspective of you have enough, you have enough
- 35:33ETFs that are all saying, hey this isn't like you know
- 35:35conducive to ESG anymore that that's been discussed.
- 35:39It's part of these, you know, S1 docs when it comes to like
- 35:42chains and consensus and who ultimately bears a
- 35:44responsibility or or ability to determine which chain is
- 35:48dominant. So just like help us walk
- 35:50through what happened with B cash and then where you could
- 35:52see that or how it would play out.
- 35:53Not how it would play out, but effectively like what the vector
- 35:56would be with an ETF like this. I believe there was a book,
- 36:04yeah, there was a book by the guy behind Bit Mix Research,
- 36:10Block Size, the block size Ward, which everyone.
- 36:13If you're new to Bitcoin, you should read 'cause it was crazy
- 36:16time and it goes into, it goes into everything, and he does a
- 36:22really good job of of capturing all the different perspectives.
- 36:29And it's it's important because humans, it's a human thing,
- 36:31right? Winners write history.
- 36:35I think he did a very ethical job of being a winner writing
- 36:37that history and I think it it it does capture as much of the
- 36:41other perspective as possible in an objective way.
- 36:45But anyway with with B cash it was a very interesting scenario.
- 36:50First of all we were very immature in terms of Bitcoin as
- 36:55a as a network we were very very early on and and and what was
- 37:00the result of that. The result was bit main Chinese
- 37:05mining ASIC manufacturer. They make the mining computers
- 37:09#1 manufacturer in the world had almost no competition at the
- 37:14time. They were making you know 80%
- 37:17plus of of mining ASICS. Also a lot of those ASICS were
- 37:21then were were mining in China and they had the largest pool
- 37:26Ant pool, the largest mining pool.
- 37:28So when you're a miner, if you mine by yourself it there's a
- 37:33lot of variants. You might not get paid for
- 37:35months, days, years, a long period of time.
- 37:39So. So people pool their mining
- 37:42resources together and they get paid way more frequently.
- 37:45So a lot of people use mining pools, but the mining pool
- 37:48operator has a lot of control. They can choose which
- 37:51transactions get mined and in the case of a fork, they can
- 37:53choose which fork they want to mine.
- 37:56So and Poole had a lot of power and Jihan Wu the the founder of
- 38:02of Bit main Co founder of bit Main had a lot of indirect
- 38:05power. It was like hard to measure, but
- 38:08you know, like his buddies in the room who were all buying
- 38:11ASICS from him probably accounted for 75% of the global
- 38:14hash rate or something crazy like that, right?
- 38:1675% of miners were like on a first name basis with Dionne and
- 38:21if he wanted something done, he could be like if you don't do
- 38:24it, I'm not going to give you any more miners, right?
- 38:26He was their sugar daddy. He was the godfather and he was
- 38:31pro this change called SegWit 2X which was this idea of we
- 38:35package a a soft fork consensus changed a segue and we and we
- 38:43package it with a hard fork increase of of the amount of of
- 38:48block space that you could have in Bitcoin.
- 38:51So 2X the, you have the segue part and the 2X part was like,
- 38:55let's double the size of of a Bitcoin block and a whole
- 39:00consortium of suits in in Bitcoin at the time.
- 39:05And they were immature suits, right?
- 39:06Like they were mostly led by Barry Silbert who owes billions
- 39:09of dollars to people right now. These these aren't like your
- 39:13classic Wall Street suits. They were like orange suits.
- 39:16They were like Bitcoin suits. They were like we own all the
- 39:20companies in Bitcoin. We also want segment 2X.
- 39:25So there was like some kind of like loose agreement that
- 39:27happened. Most of most of the independent
- 39:30community did not want to increase the block size.
- 39:34And there was like kind of like this handshake agreement that
- 39:37SegWit 2X will implement in the fall.
- 39:41But in the meantime, we'll add SegWit.
- 39:44Now this is great. The grand compromise, we'll add
- 39:47SegWit now we'll add, that's a soft fork.
- 39:49It doesn't, it's not going to, you know, break, break the
- 39:51consensus rules of the chain. If you're running an older
- 39:53client, you're still fine it it adds like a de facto block size
- 39:59increase because it discounts The Witness.
- 40:01So you can have blocks up to 4 megabytes instead of the one MB.
- 40:05But it's a soft fork. And then in the fall you know
- 40:09we'll we'll we'll do the 2X part.
- 40:13Gian was like, these guys are just fucking with the suits.
- 40:17There's no shot in hell they're going to do this.
- 40:19So at the same time that Segway got implemented he for did a
- 40:22hard fork for be cash and I think it was like 8X to block
- 40:26size or something. It was like his hedge and he
- 40:31just really never had the balls to put the majority of hash on
- 40:35to be cash. Like he I think he could have
- 40:38made a couple calls and and done it but the like the actual game
- 40:42theory incentives of Bitcoin worked like his whole livelihood
- 40:46was based on Bitcoin. Like if he killed the golden
- 40:49goose he would have been absolutely fucked so he never
- 40:52did it. Like if you go back and you look
- 40:54at the hash rate differences and there's a big issue like if you
- 40:57have for a long extended period of time 2 chains using the same
- 41:02hashing algorithm shot 256, the miners on the the majority side
- 41:08can go and attack the other side and just do utter mayhem right?
- 41:14Like if you have like 10% of the mining hash, so really you you,
- 41:18you, you don't, you don't want to be in a situation where you
- 41:21have a chain that is secured by the same hashing algorithm as
- 41:24another chain that has significantly more hash than
- 41:26you. So yeah, I'm getting a little
- 41:29bit lost in the weeds, but B, cash never really had any kind
- 41:33of critical support. Now, I know of a lot of
- 41:37bitcoiners that sold their Bitcoin cash early on and
- 41:40throughout the whole process four more Bitcoin and had
- 41:44conviction in it. I assume a lot of the B cashers
- 41:48did the same thing in the opposite way.
- 41:50Some of the more notable ones clearly didn't because they're
- 41:53still financially solvent now because B cash is worth fucking
- 41:57nothing and a lot of participants just completely sat
- 42:01it out. Like if you were an uneducated
- 42:02participant, that was probably the safest decision for you to
- 42:05make. It's just completely stood it
- 42:06out. Now the interesting thing on the
- 42:08ETF side is in the beginning Coinbase who is pro Bitcoin 2X
- 42:15refused to give people their B cash.
- 42:18They hesitated for a while and there was a bunch of other
- 42:22custodians that did similar and I think it was a learning
- 42:25experience for a lot of people on on not your keys, not your
- 42:28coins. And I I could 100% see
- 42:30similarities happen in, in ETF world where a Black Rock is like
- 42:36we're not going to honor this fork and we're not going to give
- 42:39you the equivalent amount of Bitcoin for like on this port.
- 42:45And there is an argument on the custodian side that it can be a
- 42:48little bit ridiculous like me, you and Brian can go fork
- 42:52Bitcoin and call it, you know, Bitcoin on RAMP or Bitcoin
- 42:56Brian, right. We can like create it.
- 42:57We can create a chain called Bitcoin Brian.
- 43:00Like, it's ridiculous for BlackRock to redeem to 10
- 43:03million people Bitcoin Brian, just because the three of us
- 43:07decided to fork. Like, there should be like from
- 43:09a custodian side, right? There should be some kind of,
- 43:11like critical mass where like then they'd decide, like, OK,
- 43:15like this thing actually has market value.
- 43:16Like I should give you, I should give you, you know, your
- 43:20equivalent amount of money that you're due.
- 43:23But the way all these ETFs are written, it's just like
- 43:26completely up to their discretion, which makes sense,
- 43:28like if they had lawyers write it like it doesn't make sense.
- 43:31Like I would like. There's no objective measurement
- 43:34where a fork has merit and a fork doesn't because we can make
- 43:38Bitcoin, Brian and then Michael can buy like one SAT for me for
- 43:42a billion dollars and then the things got like a ridiculous
- 43:45market cap. So like you can't use that
- 43:47market cap as the obviously I'm being extreme there, right.
- 43:50But you can't use market cap as the as the rule there.
- 43:53So all these ETFs have it written that they can just
- 43:54decide which is real Bitcoin to which is not.
- 43:58And I think that would just be part of the learning experience.
- 44:01Like people will get rugged. People like the the history of
- 44:05Bitcoin custodians is them either getting pressured by
- 44:09governments and rugging people fucking something else, fucking
- 44:14something up and people getting rugged unintentionally, or a
- 44:17government pointing a gun to their head and people getting
- 44:20rugged. And in every situation there are
- 44:23thousands, hundreds of thousands, 10s of thousands.
- 44:26I don't know how many people that learn their lesson and
- 44:28they're like, OK, I need to learn how to hold this thing
- 44:30securely myself because I trusted third parties or
- 44:33security holes and if I have to trust someone else to hold my
- 44:36Bitcoin, they will probably fuck me over eventually.
- 44:41Yep, there will be many more learnings going forward because
- 44:44the take away most likely one thing.
- 44:47I wonder how many go ahead, Brian.
- 44:49Like I wonder how many participants like are in
- 44:52Bitcoin. How many people hold Bitcoin
- 44:54right now that just didn't exist during the 2017 Ford.
- 44:58It's a lot of people. It's a lot of people and you
- 45:02know, I think these, in a lot of ways like Bitcoin is just going
- 45:06to be. I've been active in this space
- 45:09for over a decade now. It's just eternal September.
- 45:14Like it's just going to be over and over again.
- 45:16We're just going to learn the same lessons, but it's going to
- 45:18be new people learning the lessons and it's going to be a
- 45:20slight twist, right? Like the difference between FTX
- 45:23and Gox isn't really that much. It's it's like different aspects
- 45:28of a Ponzi scheme. It's fun.
- 45:31People learn it in their own way, at their own time.
- 45:34It's funny you bring up that question about how many people
- 45:38are in that weren't around in 17, because I I think the other
- 45:41side of that is how many people were around in 17 that aren't
- 45:43around now? And this idea behind a lot of
- 45:46the stuff we work on and cumulatively as a group in own
- 45:49respects of like there's this idea.
- 45:51I don't obviously have hard numbers, but I feel like over
- 45:5350% of people that have come into Bitcoin since its inception
- 45:57do not hold any Bitcoin anymore. And whether it's because they
- 46:00got shaken out, you know they sold too early, they were
- 46:03hacked, they left it on FTX or block fired Genesis.
- 46:06It's like this idea that this thing is so foreign to everyone
- 46:09that they can't unless they go down and really understand what
- 46:11they're doing and how they think about it.
- 46:13They just ultimately, and to your point like last year it
- 46:16seems already, you know FTX was only 1212 months ago and people
- 46:20don't even talk about it. Seems like it's all it's good.
- 46:22And like that was a scary part of a lot of what we're doing
- 46:25here is my concern. I don't know if I share this
- 46:28with you. That was the behind a lot of
- 46:30this stuff was seeing Wall Street come in and realizing
- 46:33that they were using the same stuff that existed in 2022 and
- 46:36everything blew up and then we're going to get orders of
- 46:38magnitude more carnage in like 2028 in my mind was 2026 or
- 46:432028. They were just going to blow it
- 46:45all up again and it was like shit, well, these guys weren't
- 46:47the smartest guys in the room. When we think about you know
- 46:49Silver, I was like why couldn't we have a lot of learning based
- 46:51on all the things we've done And I know it's not full you know
- 46:55obviously the self custody. But there's this idea of like
- 46:57you mentioned it earlier and I think it's key is distributed
- 47:00like there is no pure or perfect you know decentralization but
- 47:06there's enough where and we don't know what it is yet but of
- 47:08distribution where the game theory starts to shift.
- 47:10I'm like a, does it make sense where if you don't have to trust
- 47:13a single entity, how many can you trust?
- 47:15Where it kind of starts to look more like a traditional firm
- 47:18that you're used to, that we've historically used for thousands
- 47:21of years while you can also still bet.
- 47:22And then it comes more to like trust in people, get rugged and
- 47:26then you don't trust them to sign or trust them to be your
- 47:28partner. Because I think that's more of
- 47:30like what we've seen over time, you know?
- 47:31So yeah, the distribution I think is key because and that's
- 47:35another part of kind of joke around with like the difference
- 47:38between Bitcoin and gold is not the like digital nature of it.
- 47:42It's the, it's multi sig. It's the fact that like you can
- 47:45actually put it in in multiple locations or you can have
- 47:47multiple entities participate and it's transparent because
- 47:50that's ultimately where gold really failed was the
- 47:52centralization of like entities and all the like, you know,
- 47:55good. I mean, try and take custody of
- 47:59gold. Like what?
- 48:00You're going to just take 2 tons of gold custody.
- 48:03Like, how the hell are you going to handle that?
- 48:05You're going to put it on a plane.
- 48:06Is it going to be like vans with guys with fucking guns like
- 48:10bringing it over to you and then when when you get it where do
- 48:12you put it? With Bitcoin you can just it's
- 48:16it's so easy to take self custody and that's what people
- 48:18don't realize the the like the games will still be played.
- 48:27We don't we haven't solved that like there will be paper Bitcoin
- 48:30games. There'll be Ponzi schemes.
- 48:33There'll be blow UPS. There'll be leverage.
- 48:35There'll be degens. Everyone's a humans are degens.
- 48:39They're inherently degens. It's the reality of the
- 48:42situation. There's a reason why the
- 48:46government and the US government has maintained A legalized
- 48:50monopoly on lotteries just because they make a shit ton of
- 48:53fucking money. Because people just want to
- 48:55scratch off a fucking card for $5 and potentially win 10,000 a
- 48:59week for life. You know people are are degens
- 49:02and as a result free markets are naturally volatile short term
- 49:08and and and for people that can that can scare the shit out of
- 49:12them with Bitcoin. Because it if if you've been
- 49:15coddled in your pretend free markets that are the US
- 49:19financial system that aren't actually free, that have circuit
- 49:23Breakers that have all these different centralized
- 49:26manipulations that are that are designed to try and stop
- 49:29downward volatility specifically people quote UN quote losing
- 49:33money. It is hard for people to fathom.
- 49:37But in a proper free market what happens is D genes will get
- 49:42wiped out. They will get wrecked.
- 49:44There'll be some short term pain for people that rely on Bitcoin
- 49:47as as their main asset that you know that their main savings
- 49:51that they're spending from when necessary but ultimately the
- 49:57market will market demand will will bring it back to its to its
- 50:01fair purchasing power right. Like the fair purchasing power
- 50:05price and and and the way I look at Bitcoin is it's a it's it's
- 50:09the most scarce asset we've ever seen.
- 50:11And so with adoption purchasing power should naturally increase
- 50:15and you can measure that purchasing power in dollars
- 50:18right. Like I'm a weird person right?
- 50:19Because there's there's like a whole subset of bitcoins that
- 50:22are like I'm in it for the tech and there's a whole subset of
- 50:24bitcoins and I'm I'm in it for the riches.
- 50:26I'm in it for both. Like I'm in it for the freedom.
- 50:28But I like to get wealthy along the way.
- 50:30Like I'm not going to keep my savings in something I think is
- 50:32going to erode value over time. And and Bitcoin is this
- 50:37beautiful free market where it just because it doesn't require
- 50:42permission, because it doesn't have centralized entities in
- 50:45control that just that works itself out.
- 50:48But humans are the market participants.
- 50:51So it will be volatile. You know it, it it it will take
- 50:55those tendencies from its participants and reflect them in
- 50:59the market. Yeah I think that's good.
- 51:01That's a key part of this pod and and specifically around why
- 51:05like the volatility scares so many people.
- 51:06So will they start looking at the technology.
- 51:08It's like well what can the technology because I don't want
- 51:09nothing to do with the volatility.
- 51:11You met your final settlement. It it made me think of a try to
- 51:14final settle a billion dollars worth of gold across the Red Sea
- 51:17right now and you're you're just like does not work.
- 51:22I mean, Russia, I forget when it happened.
- 51:24It was like within the last two years or whatever, it was like
- 51:26super memorable. But like Russia had like a plane
- 51:28full of gold that, like, the gold fell out of the plane
- 51:31midway. And like, people just have like
- 51:32gold bars, like falling on their heads.
- 51:34Like it's a real problem. It's it's it's a real fucking
- 51:37thing. And that's why we have so much
- 51:41paper gold, because it's way easier to buy GLD on TD
- 51:44Ameritrade or Charles Schwab than it is to take substantial
- 51:48custody of gold. And it doesn't count if your
- 51:52uncle has, you know, 5 Krugerrands like it just doesn't
- 51:57move the market in the way that someone can take easy self
- 52:00custody of a billion dollars with Bitcoin.
- 52:02It's just a whole different ball game.
- 52:03Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 52:06exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 52:08about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 52:12allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 52:16We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 52:20Yep, you mentioned digens and that reminded me of what I
- 52:23wanted to go back to was when you were talking earlier, you
- 52:27mentioned one of the more recent meaningful upgrades to Bitcoin
- 52:32was Taproot a few years back. And years later.
- 52:38There are some basically externalities, positive negative
- 52:44of that upgrade that are now being leveraged for people to
- 52:48basically at a very high level, somewhat somewhat bring NFTS.
- 52:52So you know, something that was originated on Bitcoin back in
- 52:56the day, but then really gained a lot of hype on all these other
- 53:00crypto networks. But bring NFTS to Bitcoin again
- 53:04in a way that basically, you know there's arguments.
- 53:09There's different cohorts of bitcoiners that that view this
- 53:11topic from different perspectives and I'm curious to
- 53:14get your thoughts on it. Generally speaking, you know are
- 53:19ordinals and inscriptions an attack on Bitcoin?
- 53:23I I don't see it that way. I think generally they these
- 53:27represent valid transactions that will ultimately be priced
- 53:30out in the future. But there is, you know there's
- 53:34past 12 months have been sort of this has been the topic du jour
- 53:38of sort of Bitcoin development, Bitcoin community in terms of,
- 53:43you know in some ways it's it's the argument is really it's
- 53:48related to sort of like the ossification versus innovation
- 53:51camps generally speaking, right. Like do we want to try to bring
- 53:56all these other things and and forms of functionality to the
- 53:59base layer in a way that could you know basically clog the
- 54:03chain or or compromise in other ways.
- 54:05And it also come back to like assessing trade-offs, right,
- 54:08generally speaking, which is something you talk a lot about
- 54:10Matt, and trying to think about, you know from a very adversarial
- 54:14perspective like what are the possible externalities of any
- 54:17change that you make to Bitcoin. So what are your thoughts
- 54:19generally on all of that? You know, this change that
- 54:22occurred years ago but is now sort of come back up as a topic
- 54:26of discussion because of how people are leveraging it?
- 54:29So first of all, it's a misconception that taproot
- 54:34enables all this stuff. You can do different, a little
- 54:39bit more efficient from a cost perspective things with Taproot,
- 54:42but you can do these things regardless.
- 54:45There's also a misconception that NFTS are the main the main
- 54:53driver of these things. It's it's mostly been these like
- 54:56SCAM tokens, like these MEME tokens.
- 54:59I think the biggest one is called Orti, which are like
- 55:02they. Have are functionless tokens.
- 55:04They have zero utility. They're basically the NFTS
- 55:07without art. Like they're collectible, right?
- 55:09Like, yeah, exactly. They're text NFTS.
- 55:13Look, if you have a Bitcoin transaction and it's valid by
- 55:17the rules of the network of the nodes that are running and you
- 55:22pay a a market rate transaction fee, it will get confirmed by
- 55:27the network. It is a valid transaction as far
- 55:29as the network's concerned. Now people that are smarter than
- 55:32me, specifically Andrew Polstra who's a fucking legend I was he
- 55:38was my guest for the single best interview I ever did in Austin
- 55:42at Bitcoin Commons where we had 1/2 an hour on his history and
- 55:45open source and I asked him what is your history and open source?
- 55:49And then he talked for 1/2 an hour and gave us a perfect like
- 55:52rundown of everything then turned back to me.
- 55:54I was like, we're done. It's like it's over.
- 55:56Like that's the interview. I literally just asked one
- 55:57question, but the guy's a fucking legend.
- 56:01He does not think there's a way to stop people on a technical
- 56:05level for making these transactions.
- 56:07So I think that whole argument, this whole idea that like we
- 56:12should even be wasting time thinking about it is, is from
- 56:16the incorrect premise. Because if poster doesn't think
- 56:19it's possible to do it, then I'm like, I'm going to defer to him
- 56:24on that. But regardless, we have Mononat
- 56:28from mempool space. He's one of the main guys on the
- 56:33team over there and he did an analysis of this year.
- 56:36This year there was so. So Bitcoin miners get paid a
- 56:40subsidy and that subsidy has halvings Every four years it
- 56:45splits in half, right? Right now they get paid 6.25
- 56:49Bitcoin per block and then somewhere in the spring.
- 56:52It's based on blocks, not on actual like Gregorian calendar
- 56:57or whatever. It's made-up bullshit.
- 57:00It's based on blocks. It's somewhere in the spring,
- 57:02right? And then it's going to drop to
- 57:043.125 subsidies. So this is this is bitcoins
- 57:08built in system to regulate monetary supply, right?
- 57:11So new Bitcoin that get issued get HAP.
- 57:13But Bitcoin miners also receive fees and the fees are a pure
- 57:17free market without permission. And they are they are simply
- 57:22handled on a supply demand basis.
- 57:24You have a fixed supply of block space available and as more
- 57:30Bitcoin transactions are being sent you have to pay a higher
- 57:32fee. Otherwise miners will be
- 57:34unlikely to confirm that. Miners can confirm whatever
- 57:36transactions they want to confirm, but usually they
- 57:39confirm the highest fee transactions first because they
- 57:41make more money. So we had 23,431 Bitcoin were
- 57:46paid in minor fees this year. Fucking massive number.
- 57:51And according to his analysis, 63.8% were quote, UN quote
- 57:55normal Bitcoin transactions, just regular Bitcoin
- 57:57transactions. The NFTS were 2.4% and these
- 58:02scam tokens were 27.9%. So the majority is these scam
- 58:06tokens. Now, when you're thinking about
- 58:09inscriptions, inscriptions are are real.
- 58:15They're real. Like you can do a valid Bitcoin
- 58:17transaction and you can inscribe data along with it in the
- 58:20blockchain that is there for everyone who's running Bitcoin
- 58:24software, it's in their Ledger. Those could be jpegs, those
- 58:28could be texts, whatever. Now they've married them with
- 58:31something called ordinals, which is a separate from the chain
- 58:35theory. And that's how they say you can
- 58:37transfer the inscriptions, but inscriptions are real.
- 58:40You can't transfer the inscriptions like the.
- 58:42The Bitcoin protocol doesn't let you transfer the JPEG from 1
- 58:45address to another address. It's just in the fucking Ledger,
- 58:48right? Or the text of the token, right?
- 58:50It says the already token. You own #2 of 1000 or whatever.
- 58:54It's just like a little simple Jason text.
- 58:57There's no way to actually transfer them in the mechanism.
- 59:01So I think this will become, I mean, first of all, besides the
- 59:03fact that I don't think these things really have collectible
- 59:06value, I think the fact that you can't transfer them will become
- 59:09apparent to people. Because look, at the end of the
- 59:11day, people, humans like collectibles, especially bit
- 59:13corners, most bit corners. Like if you go back, we had some
- 59:17like ridiculous collectibles that we were like obsessed with
- 59:22before Bitcoin existed. I know my family, my family got
- 59:24wrecked on Beanie Babies. I was like a big baseball cards
- 59:27guy, all centralized bullshit collectibles.
- 59:30I have like all I have like a sign shack, you know,
- 59:33basketball. I got, you know, I got Pete
- 59:36Rose. I got David Cohn.
- 59:38Like I got all I got all my like baseball collectibles,
- 59:41basketball collectibles. It's all bullshit compared to
- 59:43Bitcoin. Like Bitcoin is, is, is just
- 59:46what I should have the entire my entire net worth in.
- 59:49And I have the majority of my net worth in.
- 59:51But anyway, my point is I'm, I'm, I'm going.
- 59:54I'm going past the point People like collectibles.
- 59:57I'm not saying, you know, you could do whatever collectibles
- 1:00:00you want. I don't think they compete with
- 1:00:01Bitcoin. But I think the market will
- 1:00:03start to realize eventually that you can't transfer these things
- 1:00:06between each other. And that's all bullshit.
- 1:00:08It's just a centralized system that's bolted on top that
- 1:00:11they're just assuming like, oh, I transferred this, I
- 1:00:13transferred that. But the actual inscription part
- 1:00:16is kind of interesting because you can, you can do things like
- 1:00:21inscribe banned books, right? You can inscribe.
- 1:00:25And and that might actually have like a significant financial
- 1:00:28worth in the future, like someone just just to get the
- 1:00:31information out there might be willing to pay for it even
- 1:00:34though they don't think it has any kind of collectible value or
- 1:00:36something like that. But regardless, we can't stop
- 1:00:39it. You can't transfer them.
- 1:00:42And as a result, the Bitcoin fee market is working as designed.
- 1:00:49So, like when you're when you're, when when, when you,
- 1:00:53when you do e-mail, right. The big issue with all these
- 1:00:58things, all kind of communication networks are spam,
- 1:01:01right? So it's what is spam.
- 1:01:03Spam is something you don't want, right?
- 1:01:05It's, it's, it's there's no objective definition of spam.
- 1:01:10But spam is something that you as an individual subjectively do
- 1:01:14not appreciate getting right. And with e-mail, the way we
- 1:01:18handle spam is we have centralized services like Google
- 1:01:22and their cohort decide what they're blacklisting and what
- 1:01:26they're not, and they're making decisions based on it.
- 1:01:28And obviously that's inherently able to corrupt, right?
- 1:01:31We can inherently corrupt that. So we can get a gun to their
- 1:01:33head and say this mail registrar should always be declared as
- 1:01:36spam. And then it doesn't matter how
- 1:01:38much you care about freedom. If you're trying to e-mail
- 1:01:40someone on Gmail, it's going to go straight to the spam folder
- 1:01:44on on websites, we have something called deny
- 1:01:47distributed denial of service attacks, DDDOSS.
- 1:01:51And that's like you just hit a website from a bunch of
- 1:01:53different computers. Often times bot Nets and you,
- 1:01:56you bring it to its knees. And how do they handle that?
- 1:01:59A lot of times through centralized services like
- 1:02:00Cloudflare that are sitting in the middle and they're saying
- 1:02:03that IP address is a bad IP address, That IP address is a
- 1:02:06bad address. We're not going to give them the
- 1:02:07website, but we'll give this other guy the website because
- 1:02:10he's KYC on Comcast and we know he's a good dude.
- 1:02:13Can't have that in Bitcoin either.
- 1:02:15So what does Bitcoin do? We have this scarce block space.
- 1:02:18And why is the block space scarce?
- 1:02:19Because every node needs to store and validate that
- 1:02:22information, and so it adds real cost to running a node.
- 1:02:25And it's important that everyone can run their own node.
- 1:02:27So what do we do? We have a dynamic free market
- 1:02:30where if you send a Bitcoin transaction, it has to be valid
- 1:02:34by the consensus rules #1. That's what inscriptions are.
- 1:02:38It's a fact, regardless of how you feel about them, Valid by
- 1:02:43Bitcoin consensus rules and a fee that is acceptable to a
- 1:02:47minor to to mine that transaction.
- 1:02:50So you end up in a situation where the real argument is if
- 1:02:53someone I don't like is flooding the Bitcoin network with
- 1:02:56transactions and it's crowding out people I like from sending
- 1:02:59Bitcoin transactions, is that a problem?
- 1:03:02Yeah, it is a problem. And and Bitcoin transaction fees
- 1:03:06are designed to mitigate that problem.
- 1:03:07Because if you if, if if we forget about inscriptions
- 1:03:11altogether, let's pretend the US government decides they don't
- 1:03:13want us to use Bitcoin. They're not using inscriptions.
- 1:03:17They're just sending Bitcoin transactions back and forth
- 1:03:19between each other at a high fee to try and stop Bitcoiners from
- 1:03:23transacting. That's a real attack method,
- 1:03:26right? That's a that's a potential
- 1:03:28attack vector that Bitcoiners have talked about in the past.
- 1:03:32They would have to spend billions of dollars in Bitcoin
- 1:03:34mining fees to miners. They would have to buy the
- 1:03:37Bitcoin. They would have to spend it to
- 1:03:40minors. They would have to essentially
- 1:03:42take existing supply off the market when they bought it,
- 1:03:45increasing the purchasing power of Bitcoin.
- 1:03:47And then they'd have to repeat that year after year after year
- 1:03:51for increasingly larger amounts of Fiat.
- 1:03:54Because it's all denominated in Bitcoin.
- 1:03:56It is the best incentive mechanism ever.
- 1:03:58It's like, literally to attack it.
- 1:04:00They have to feed the Ponzi. It is the most insane fucking
- 1:04:03system. And it works.
- 1:04:05So the result is at the end of the day, right now, maybe you're
- 1:04:09crowded out, you know, maybe fees are too high for you and
- 1:04:13you're an African and you know you're making $5 a day and it's
- 1:04:17just too expensive for you. But ultimately, and that sucks,
- 1:04:22and hopefully we'll have tools available to people that they'll
- 1:04:25be able to efficiently use Bitcoin at smaller amounts and
- 1:04:28different trade off balances like all this different stuff,
- 1:04:31collaborative multi sig, vitamin, stuff like that.
- 1:04:35Maybe responsible custodial solutions like these.
- 1:04:38These tools don't get built out unless there's fee pressure.
- 1:04:40But ultimately the malicious entity will run out of money
- 1:04:43eventually. And in the meantime, they
- 1:04:45increase the purchasing power of Bitcoin and they provide direct
- 1:04:49funding to mining infrastructure.
- 1:04:51And that's how the whole system is designed and how it works.
- 1:04:54And it's it's working fucking beautifully right now.
- 1:04:56It's a it's funny, you tied it back all the way to the game
- 1:05:01theory and the incentive working how it's supposed to because it
- 1:05:06was something I was going to reference.
- 1:05:07You like tied it. Exactly.
- 1:05:09It's different camps, but same argument around ETF and is it
- 1:05:13good or bad for Bitcoin or inscription?
- 1:05:15Is it good or bad? It's literally the same thing.
- 1:05:16It's like they're valid transactions and you have to
- 1:05:19participate in the network. And then on the other side of
- 1:05:21that everybody benefits. Even though a short term certain
- 1:05:25people think, you know may get rugged and all the things
- 1:05:27associated they need to buy the Bitcoin, they have to take it
- 1:05:29off the market. It's the exact same
- 1:05:32conversation. It's fucking beautiful.
- 1:05:36Beautiful. Incentives.
- 1:05:37And it's just like, yeah, there's just like this like non
- 1:05:39practical sense of an individual that is like it's like the same
- 1:05:42thought of like coming in, I'm here to fix Bitcoin.
- 1:05:44It's like this isn't a fair transaction or this isn't a
- 1:05:47fairway to custody the Bitcoin. It's like there isn't, there's a
- 1:05:49sub like your version of spam being subjective.
- 1:05:52Like it is subjective. It's like what is the
- 1:05:54subjective, the objective way to use Bitcoin?
- 1:05:57Yeah, I mean like if you look at the math right now today, the
- 1:06:00math is if the US government or anyone else wanted to like peg
- 1:06:05fee rates at 200 stats per byte, right?
- 1:06:08Like if you go to mempool dot space right now, the next block
- 1:06:11fee is like probably like 7080 cents per byte, maybe $0.90 per
- 1:06:15byte. If the US government wanted to
- 1:06:18peg it at 200 cents per byte, it's like 8 to $12 billion
- 1:06:23because it's in Bitcoin terms. So it it depends where Bitcoin's
- 1:06:26moving and and whatnot and they have to actually buy the Bitcoin
- 1:06:29and that's just one year. And by buying the Bitcoin, it's
- 1:06:32increasing the purchasing power of Bitcoin.
- 1:06:35So my answer to them is attack us.
- 1:06:39That would be wonderful. I can, you know, I'll, I'll,
- 1:06:43I'll stop making the Bitcoin transactions that I don't
- 1:06:46absolutely need to make. I'll continue to make the ones
- 1:06:48that I absolutely need to make and I'll wait you out.
- 1:06:54Beautiful, beautiful incentives. We've talked a lot about
- 1:06:59development, how it works, consensus.
- 1:07:02I think what I'd be curious to hear from you, Matt, is what
- 1:07:07sort of what you know, what excites you going forward in the
- 1:07:10development space, certain projects, whether it be related
- 1:07:15to the build out of the Lightning Network, things like
- 1:07:18Noster, different initiatives like fediments.
- 1:07:22What are you most excited about sort of heading into the New
- 1:07:24Year from a development perspective and and why?
- 1:07:31Well, I mean, I'm, I'm really incredible.
- 1:07:33I'm really excited about Noster. It's not Bitcoin specific.
- 1:07:39The idea of of Noster is a a censorship resistant,
- 1:07:43permissionless, interoperable communication protocol.
- 1:07:48And it's just really complimentary to Bitcoin because
- 1:07:51you have a censorship resistant, permissionless, interoperable
- 1:07:54money and then you have the equivalent on communications and
- 1:07:59then all of a sudden wallets can communicate with each other.
- 1:08:01You can have freedom aspects, like a freedom Venmo, you know,
- 1:08:05you can have a freedom Twitter that has Bitcoin integrated.
- 1:08:08Like there's all these different cool, complementary aspects of
- 1:08:11it. And it's also based on this idea
- 1:08:13of freedom tech. And it's completely open source.
- 1:08:16Yep. Markings back to what what we
- 1:08:18started the conversation with in terms of like the actual
- 1:08:21advantages of building things that are open source and
- 1:08:23interoperable and also is a perfect example of that.
- 1:08:27Maybe you could go into a bit more detail in terms of like how
- 1:08:30it actually works, how some of the sort of fundamental
- 1:08:33architecture is similar to Bitcoin with, you know, public
- 1:08:35and private keys and you know, maybe some some applications
- 1:08:42that you think have gotten some decent traction thus far and
- 1:08:45where you think things are headed.
- 1:08:47Well, The thing is, Nasser's incredibly early and like I
- 1:08:49said, it's not necessarily Bitcoin specific.
- 1:08:52I think it's just it's it's to me it's this compelling freedom
- 1:08:56tech stack that I haven't, I haven't been this excited about
- 1:09:00since I discovered Bitcoin. And so it it has all these
- 1:09:04similarities to Bitcoin. It is also very different from
- 1:09:06Bitcoin. The whole idea of the consensus
- 1:09:09rules and stuff that we're talking about bit with Bitcoin
- 1:09:11doesn't exist with Noster because you don't have this you
- 1:09:14know, omnibus financial Ledger like a blockchain.
- 1:09:18It's like different clients can implement what they want to
- 1:09:21implement and like worst comes to worst they can't communicate
- 1:09:23with each other and like the world doesn't end.
- 1:09:24You don't like lose your life savings.
- 1:09:26You know, like a government doesn't lose their entire
- 1:09:30central bank treasury because you like did a consensus change
- 1:09:33so. So you're able to, you know,
- 1:09:36iterate and and innovate quicker.
- 1:09:38But at the same time, to me it feels like maybe what Bitcoin
- 1:09:42probably felt like in the early days of Bitcoin, but I didn't
- 1:09:46get to be there for that and I get to be there for Noster and
- 1:09:48it's super fucking cool. And the potential is really
- 1:09:50huge. And I think basically every
- 1:09:52Bitcoin company becomes a Noster company.
- 1:09:54Every Noster company has a Bitcoin.
- 1:09:56I think every company becomes a Bitcoin company, period.
- 1:09:59And I think they also probably become noster companies, just
- 1:10:02like every company has an e-mail strategy because you just can't
- 1:10:05run a business without an e-mail strategy.
- 1:10:07It's like you don't, it's not like, oh, this is a credit card
- 1:10:09business. And it's like they accept credit
- 1:10:11cards, they have to accept credit cards, they have to
- 1:10:13accept Bitcoin, they have to communicate via Noster.
- 1:10:15Like it'll just be the standard protocols on the Bitcoin side.
- 1:10:19I don't want to get too far into Noster because it's it's a
- 1:10:22little bit of a a rabbit hole. But on the Bitcoin?
- 1:10:25Yeah, go on. I think an important part about
- 1:10:28Noster, independent of Noster, what Matt's alluding to is I I
- 1:10:31think and this is a different conversation, like Noster really
- 1:10:35can exist from a long term perspective without Bitcoin from
- 1:10:38like a censorship from like running relays and the ability
- 1:10:41like to run certain servers. That potentially could.
- 1:10:44Because at the end of the day, like there's economics tied to
- 1:10:46it and to be able to pay somebody for it if you get shut
- 1:10:49off via like your credit card. How do you?
- 1:10:51The only thing is the only thing is yes, I, I on a technical
- 1:10:55basis, yes Noster could exist without Bitcoin.
- 1:10:58But we are living in a new paradigm now where open source
- 1:11:03software is much easier to monetize.
- 1:11:07If you have a programmable money that that has final settlement
- 1:11:11without a trusted third party like Bitcoin changes the whole
- 1:11:15dynamic not just for Noster, but any freedom software.
- 1:11:19Because historically, if you were running an open source
- 1:11:22project and you wanted to try and ethically monetize it, you
- 1:11:26had to. You had to get a credit card
- 1:11:28processor, you had to bring trusted third parties into it.
- 1:11:30Maybe you're doing some KYC elements, you have to collect
- 1:11:33billing addresses, you have this whole fucking burden.
- 1:11:36Maybe you have to start a company, do all this other
- 1:11:37stuff. The perfect example is something
- 1:11:39like Sparrow wallet, right? Doesn't have any Noster
- 1:11:42integration. Completely separate Noster.
- 1:11:43It's a Bitcoin wallet Best Bitcoin wallet available and and
- 1:11:49the lead developer is this guy called Craig Raw.
- 1:11:51He's from South Africa, doesn't have a company, did not you know
- 1:11:57did not create a corporate entity, does not integrate with
- 1:12:01Square or any kind of payment processors and he just he has
- 1:12:05reoccurring Bitcoin revenue that supports the project right and
- 1:12:09people are able to just pay him Bitcoin.
- 1:12:10As for coin join fees in his particular situation, but
- 1:12:13they're able to pay him Bitcoin for a service they want and he's
- 1:12:16able to monetize that across the entire globe for his open source
- 1:12:20software. And if you want to fork his
- 1:12:22software and do whatever you want because it's open source,
- 1:12:24you can do that but but you won't be able to collect the
- 1:12:28fees that he collects, right, because the fees are attached to
- 1:12:31to a network effect in terms of liquidity of users.
- 1:12:34So, so this is something specifically that we've been
- 1:12:37watching very closely at 10:31 and open SAS is this idea of
- 1:12:41monetizable open source projects and they're monetized with
- 1:12:44Bitcoin. And I think Noster greatly
- 1:12:46benefits from that aspect. Things like relays, things like
- 1:12:49clients, they can monetize using Bitcoin and and and they don't
- 1:12:54have to integrate with the traditional financial system and
- 1:12:56all the trusted third parties that come with it, if that makes
- 1:12:58sense. No, it makes complete sense and
- 1:13:00that's kind of where I wanted just at least a tie back.
- 1:13:03Well, we before we go directly to Bitcoin and and Matt's
- 1:13:05thoughts there, you alluded to very beginning like your journey
- 1:13:09and the the loss of trust in financial institutions and
- 1:13:11intermediaries, which I think most that have like looked at
- 1:13:13Bitcoin can understand why there's value.
- 1:13:16But then you reference post that looking at like the
- 1:13:19conglomerates that require trust and centralization and there's
- 1:13:23this realization that exists for a reason and we all know of like
- 1:13:29up or we may have know like operation choke point.
- 1:13:31In these like aspects of like the central points, whether it's
- 1:13:33a tech stack or financial service stack where the money
- 1:13:36starts to like, well you can't stop certain aspects, you can
- 1:13:39stop the money flows which effectively second, third order
- 1:13:42effects stop the actual actions. And it kind of dawned on me and
- 1:13:46so and this is part of like what we want to do here in the pod.
- 1:13:48And like hopefully we get, you know, you back on and other
- 1:13:51individuals where it's like when you start to squint and you look
- 1:13:54at the disruptive technologies, you can start to realize that
- 1:13:57it's not the incumbents like they will be left completely
- 1:14:00behind because these are meant to like fundamentally disrupt
- 1:14:03their models. And so Bitcoin's an easy example
- 1:14:06of that. But then Bitcoin actually under
- 1:14:08like pins everything else that disrupts everything past that
- 1:14:12because you can't stop it. And so like, NOSTER is just this
- 1:14:14first example and you need like speech to be able to like
- 1:14:18actually do these things. And that's why I fall in this
- 1:14:19like middle camp versus some of our other friends that may not
- 1:14:22find it valuable. It's like, you know, you
- 1:14:23actually have to be able to coordinate in in like discuss.
- 1:14:27But this is like where the AI thing comes into play, too,
- 1:14:29because these things are so disruptive that you'll
- 1:14:31ultimately try to stop them. But then you need the money to
- 1:14:34keep the juice running, whether it's the power or the servers or
- 1:14:38all the other things associated. And that's how this whole thing,
- 1:14:42you know, when we come down to final Storm is like, how do we
- 1:14:44actually ideate and see the reality of how this thing
- 1:14:46changes almost everything? And then what are the practical
- 1:14:48use cases? Because we're not even, like,
- 1:14:50we're not even at the ball game yet.
- 1:14:51We're like, showing up. We're still like, if you're in
- 1:14:53Texas, you know, you have your roadie and you're driving to the
- 1:14:55Cowboy Stadium just to start. Like, the national anthem hasn't
- 1:14:58even begun. Matt Odell still singing in the
- 1:15:00back of the truck with his shirt off.
- 1:15:02And it's it's. Just tailgating.
- 1:15:05We're still tailgating. We haven't gotten.
- 1:15:08No, I mean, you're absolutely correct.
- 1:15:11I mean Noster is particularly a special beast because like it's
- 1:15:17the brainchild of Bitcoin developers like Bitcoin
- 1:15:20developers like Fiat Jaffe, Willis, Cesarean, like Kooks.
- 1:15:24Like they they like set up the basis of of like Fiat Jaffe
- 1:15:29published the original spec like it's it was bit corners that
- 1:15:32created it. But yeah I mean IA 100% agree
- 1:15:36and I would just say to people like look noster's really early.
- 1:15:39I think it's something you should pay attention to.
- 1:15:43You know the the the the main product that exists right now
- 1:15:47that uses Noster is is basically a censorship resistant
- 1:15:51alternative to Twitter where where or Facebook where like
- 1:15:54Elon can't stop you. Zuck can't stop you.
- 1:15:57Anyone holding a gun to either of their heads can't stop you.
- 1:16:00The easiest way to interact with that is an app called Primal.
- 1:16:03You can search it on your your App Store PRIMAL primal and yeah
- 1:16:10it it'll look it looks like Twitter it's just hard to censor
- 1:16:14and you can just post whatever the fuck you want and no one can
- 1:16:16stop you. And I I I think I think people
- 1:16:20will start to realize the implications there.
- 1:16:21I mean I'm also like I think Mutiny wallet is like way on the
- 1:16:25forefront of it. Mutiny wallet.
- 1:16:28Right now you can run a you essentially have a full
- 1:16:32Lightning node in your browser of any phone you just type in
- 1:16:37munitywallet.com. They didn't have to integrate
- 1:16:40with the traditional financial system because it's a Bitcoin
- 1:16:42wallet, and they didn't have to integrate with a social network
- 1:16:46graph like the Venmo API or the Twitter API or the Facebook API
- 1:16:51because they just integrated with Noster.
- 1:16:53So they're essentially building freedom Venmo, and they're
- 1:16:56building it on two open source stacks, Bitcoin and Noster.
- 1:17:00And so for the average person, like, it won't hit them until
- 1:17:04like V5, right where it's like super polished.
- 1:17:08Everything seems exactly the same as their their surveilled
- 1:17:12and controlled alternatives, but it's actually based on freedom
- 1:17:16technology and they get all the benefits of that.
- 1:17:19And they don't even necessarily, for a lot of people in the
- 1:17:22beginning won't realize the freedom benefits.
- 1:17:23They just realize the lack of friction where they don't have
- 1:17:27to through the KYC process. They don't have to confirm 2
- 1:17:30deposits in their bank account. They don't have to, you know,
- 1:17:32like, oh, you deposited $0.23 in my bank account on whatever, you
- 1:17:35know, like all that friction that comes with the traditional
- 1:17:37financial system, they just won't have to deal with and the
- 1:17:42traditional communication networks.
- 1:17:43And that's where it all starts to come together.
- 1:17:45And like you said, we're we're tailgating like it's it is so
- 1:17:49fucking it's it's a meme because it's based in reality.
- 1:17:52Like good memes are based in reality.
- 1:17:54And like, I cannot, I cannot overstate how early we are in
- 1:17:59both Bitcoin Noster. Like all this shit.
- 1:18:02Like people are are sleeping on it and we can just scream it
- 1:18:06from the rooftops. All this alpha, I can just
- 1:18:08scream it from the rooftops. No one executes, no one pays
- 1:18:11attention. I'm going to be screaming it for
- 1:18:12like, next. Four years.
- 1:18:14Five years, 10 years. I've this joke I've been saying
- 1:18:17and it's just been like I'm sure you know this.
- 1:18:19You just been looking at you yourself know this and anybody
- 1:18:22that's on the space. If you generally have a good
- 1:18:24idea in the real world it's probably a bad idea.
- 1:18:27Like it's already been thought of and it just wasn't good.
- 1:18:29Like it just actually wasn't a good idea.
- 1:18:31Couldn't make money couldn't do it.
- 1:18:32But in Bitcoin, like if you look at something you're like it
- 1:18:34should exist or why isn't this exist?
- 1:18:36It's probably or most likely is a good idea and just somebody
- 1:18:38hasn't done it yet because they just.
- 1:18:40Haven't executed. We're still so early yet.
- 1:18:42And this idea of like the guys that know Bitcoin developing
- 1:18:46Noster, you can actually start to see like there's a certain
- 1:18:49lens and has nothing to do with ideology, has to do with like
- 1:18:53understanding and practice how systems need to be built from a
- 1:18:56resiliency standpoint. Where then you start in like a
- 1:18:59redundancy standpoint where you start to think about like, you
- 1:19:03know, you reference Noster and is it just, you know,
- 1:19:04distributed enough? It's like, no, it's just
- 1:19:06distributed enough to do what it needs to do.
- 1:19:07And then the game theory around if you take something around, it
- 1:19:10doesn't kill it. It's just the next thing that
- 1:19:12can exist. And that's the whole idea
- 1:19:14doesn't like everybody's mental model starts to map to like
- 1:19:16Bitcoin or other things. It's just, it's just maps to the
- 1:19:19use case that's needed. You also, you also mentioned AI
- 1:19:24and so I I don't want to miss the opportunity to say 3
- 1:19:27buzzwords together. I believe the future is Noster
- 1:19:33AI and Bitcoin combined where the AI communicates with people
- 1:19:38and other AI bots using Noster and all the payments are handled
- 1:19:41with Bitcoin and I think people will start to realize the
- 1:19:45issues, it'll become overly apparent, the issues with
- 1:19:49centralized entities running these AI models because of how
- 1:19:53crippled they will become due to regulations and and if you use a
- 1:19:58freedom focused one, you're not necessarily doing it for the
- 1:20:02freedom, you're just doing it because you get better results
- 1:20:04that are not biased because they don't have a bunch of woke
- 1:20:08regulators that are deciding what your results are on your AI
- 1:20:11search. Can you actually plug MV KS deal
- 1:20:15just because they just launched and just a breakdown like what
- 1:20:18that's a visa? I feel like that's partially an
- 1:20:20example of it. Yeah, so MVK has a service
- 1:20:22called Unleashed dot Chat which runs open source AI models in
- 1:20:29your browser locally. Well, the models are run on a,
- 1:20:34you know like a cloud server, but but all your history is is
- 1:20:38held locally. So it's it's designed to be more
- 1:20:41private than like the chat, GP, TS and stuff like that and you
- 1:20:45simply pay Bitcoin to use it. I would call that you know MVP
- 1:20:51one a minimum viable product, one of of what we could see here
- 1:20:58at the basis, like it's centralized, obviously it's just
- 1:21:02completely centralized, but centralized things are easier to
- 1:21:05use. So if regulators don't come in
- 1:21:07and say like you can't do this, like it makes sense and it feels
- 1:21:10a very easy niche. And it's a perfect example of
- 1:21:12Bitcoin allowing people to monetize ethically because they
- 1:21:15don't have to take private information, right?
- 1:21:17Like if you use something like ChatGPT, even if they're not
- 1:21:21surveilling all of your searches and everything which they are
- 1:21:24in, like building their models against it, at the very least
- 1:21:27they have your credit card and billing information attached to
- 1:21:30you, right? Because you can't just pay in
- 1:21:31Bitcoin now on the Noster side. And and so he does have some
- 1:21:35Noster integration where he takes every single Noster post
- 1:21:38that has ever existed and he put it into the into his AI model.
- 1:21:44So you can search through the history of Noster, right.
- 1:21:47And this is another situation where like open systems win,
- 1:21:50right? Because all these all these big
- 1:21:52tech companies are doing the opposite.
- 1:21:54They're closing the silos. I don't know if you've realized,
- 1:21:56like if you try and click a Reddit link they like almost
- 1:21:58always ask you to sign in if it's anything good, if they rate
- 1:22:01it like over 18. Plus you have to sign it.
- 1:22:04If you click a Twitter link, you can't see any of the replies or
- 1:22:06anything unless you sign in, right?
- 1:22:08LinkedIn has been doing it for ages.
- 1:22:10Instagram has been doing it for a long time.
- 1:22:12They're all closing up their ship because they know that the
- 1:22:15users are their product, even though the users think they're
- 1:22:17their customer and they want to protect the product at all costs
- 1:22:21and they want to charge you for API access if you want to use
- 1:22:23it. Noster is not that case.
- 1:22:25You don't have to pay for an API.
- 1:22:27So everyone who's using Noster is contributing to this global
- 1:22:31open database of signed cryptographic posts.
- 1:22:35And he just uploaded it all without permission to his to his
- 1:22:40open source large language model LLM.
- 1:22:44And as a result you can search through all the Noster posts.
- 1:22:47But when I say Noster AI and Bitcoin, what I imagine, and
- 1:22:52this is what Pablo's been working on.
- 1:22:55Pablo is this Pablo 7 ZS like this ridiculous prolific Bitcoin
- 1:23:00and Noster developer is this idea he calls it DVMS data
- 1:23:04vending machines. And it's like this idea of a
- 1:23:06marketplace of AI boss right, that are competing on a free
- 1:23:10market in terms of price, reliability, output.
- 1:23:14Like how how good the results are and they can work together
- 1:23:18communicating via Noster and they can bid against each other
- 1:23:21via Noster and you pay them with Bitcoin.
- 1:23:23So like there's a situation where instead of paying one
- 1:23:27large model to do the whole thing you need to do.
- 1:23:30Let's say you need to look at a picture, you need to figure out
- 1:23:33who the people are in the picture, then you need to write
- 1:23:36a bio about them and then you need to submit the bio as a
- 1:23:40noster post. You could have three different
- 1:23:42AIS do that and they can all pay each other in between with
- 1:23:45Bitcoin. All communicate with Noster and
- 1:23:47you can get the best price and the best output and it for the
- 1:23:50user. We're still a ways off from
- 1:23:52this, but from the user it should be a nice clean flow
- 1:23:54right? Where they don't realize they're
- 1:23:56like, I just need this thing and I need it to be the best it can
- 1:23:58possibly be and I'm willing to pay market rate and the whole
- 1:24:01thing just happens and that's fucking crazy, right Then.
- 1:24:05Then we're in a whole new ball game and it's it's reliant on
- 1:24:09these open systems all being able to interact with each
- 1:24:11other, if that makes any sense. Yeah it makes sense.
- 1:24:15One thing just Brian knew about a transition is what's exciting
- 1:24:18about this. And it it just dawned on me,
- 1:24:20Matt, like this is really inevitable.
- 1:24:24And while it sounds crazy, it's like it's just as inevitable as
- 1:24:27we feel about Bitcoin. And like it's essentially
- 1:24:29because of the alternative. It has to be inevitable
- 1:24:33basically, because the alternative is like the systems
- 1:24:35you reference closing like that's the nice version of like
- 1:24:37systems starting to close and and it really hit me with.
- 1:24:40Digital slavery as the alternative?
- 1:24:42Yeah, yeah, I mean it's exactly right.
- 1:24:44And like this, this AI like large the LLMS along with the
- 1:24:48neural Nets, when they get like good enough people and like
- 1:24:51nation states are going to freak out just like they're gonna
- 1:24:53freak out about like censorship resistant money.
- 1:24:55It's it's a very similar concept And and then they have to and so
- 1:24:59then you need something to have to like coat inside together and
- 1:25:02start to move together the same way.
- 1:25:03Like to be able to speak freely you're going to need a version
- 1:25:06of that. And so it's just a natural order
- 1:25:08of how like we move into a transition to a new age.
- 1:25:12And it's just a weird thing, because I hadn't thought about
- 1:25:14it in that same way of like Bitcoin the past six years is
- 1:25:16felt inevitable, but this all feels inevitable as like this
- 1:25:19starts to interweave with each other.
- 1:25:21There's no alternative because there just can't be another
- 1:25:23alternative. Yeah no it's super fascinating
- 1:25:26and and open systems win. I, I, I, I totally agree with
- 1:25:32that. But I, Matt can you elaborate on
- 1:25:35because I think we need to be wary of you know basically the
- 1:25:41there's going to be other attempts at doing these types of
- 1:25:44things with the the broader crypto space, right.
- 1:25:48And we've already seen some of this to to some extent.
- 1:25:50But why elaborate for for the listeners on why again building
- 1:25:55on open interoperable systems that are you know based on a
- 1:25:59solid foundation of a monetary unit that that can be ubiquitous
- 1:26:03within these connected protocols.
- 1:26:05Why is that the better route than having these disparate
- 1:26:09systems of crypto tokens which may garner more attention early?
- 1:26:13Because it's like just greed and grift of people thinking that
- 1:26:17they can be early to these things and and be profitable.
- 1:26:20By participating in these quote UN quote open systems that are
- 1:26:25enabling different things with AI or or decentralized
- 1:26:27communications, whatever it may be elaborate on why it it has to
- 1:26:32be built on something like Bitcoin.
- 1:26:34Yeah, so I mean look if the open systems that will win, they win
- 1:26:43because they they win. They win because humans can't
- 1:26:47help themselves and they they destroy the the systems that
- 1:26:51require trust. Like if if you can, if you can
- 1:26:57make a payment on PayPal around the world.
- 1:27:00Let's forget the debasement aspect of the dollar and that,
- 1:27:03like you can't really self custody a dollar because they
- 1:27:05can just debase you at will. We'll just forget about that for
- 1:27:09a second. But let's say you can just send
- 1:27:11money around the world with PayPal without KYC.
- 1:27:15They can't block you, they don't seize your money.
- 1:27:17You never get rugged. The value prop of Bitcoin goes
- 1:27:20down because a centralized alternative that is cheaper and
- 1:27:24faster works and gets the job done well enough that you you
- 1:27:29don't need something like that. If Elon for some reason is like
- 1:27:33a God among men and doesn't censor anybody and is able to
- 1:27:37stop, you know regulators with guns telling him that he needs
- 1:27:40to ban Alex Jones, then Noster has less use cases, right?
- 1:27:45Because you can just use the centralized alternative that is
- 1:27:48cheaper and faster and prettier and you don't have to use, you
- 1:27:52don't have to use the freedom alternative.
- 1:27:54But the reality is humans can't help themselves.
- 1:27:57Like if you have a centralized third party, they will either
- 1:27:59get greedy or someone who has power over them will get greedy
- 1:28:03and it destroys those systems. And I think they get out
- 1:28:06competed by the systems that don't require permission.
- 1:28:10And I I see that with Noster and I see that with Bitcoin and I
- 1:28:13would push back against the idea of inevitably, inevitably,
- 1:28:17inevitably, inevitably I would push back on that idea because
- 1:28:22it it does create complacency to a degree.
- 1:28:25And at the end of the day these things are easy to think of as
- 1:28:27tech projects but they're movements of individuals.
- 1:28:30It's it's it's individuals deciding that that they wanted
- 1:28:33to better their lives and push this thing forward and and we
- 1:28:37need people to stand up like people need to stand up and push
- 1:28:40forward. Now I think we have the momentum
- 1:28:42on the Bitcoin side. I'm pretty sure like I'm I have
- 1:28:46incredible conviction on Bitcoin on the Noster side.
- 1:28:50It's still very nascent and early and I have less so
- 1:28:54conviction on that regard. But I I think people shouldn't
- 1:28:56get complacent. And in both of these cases, when
- 1:29:00you have open systems and I'll bring it back to the original
- 1:29:02question, which was like one of my most excited about in Bitcoin
- 1:29:06is when you have these open permission list systems.
- 1:29:08Which by the way, two of the things that make Noster and
- 1:29:12Bitcoin similar is they had a benevolent, benevolent creator
- 1:29:17that didn't want fame and control.
- 1:29:20And I I think that is underrated and it's very uncommon.
- 1:29:24I I don't think America would be in the place it was in today if
- 1:29:27if George Washington decided that he wanted to do 3 terms or
- 1:29:31four terms or five terms and become king.
- 1:29:33Right? Like it actually.
- 1:29:34Like the history of America comes down to like one dude
- 1:29:37sitting in his parlor like drinking tea and like talking to
- 1:29:42his boys and was like, I probably shouldn't do that,
- 1:29:44right? Like I could do it.
- 1:29:46Like I, you know, like if Dan Held was in charge at that
- 1:29:49point, like we might be in a completely different situation.
- 1:29:53So like, I think people discount that, right?
- 1:29:55And Fiat Jaf deserves a lot of credit in that regard.
- 1:29:57Like he never wanted personal fame, he never wanted personal
- 1:30:00control. Same with Satoshi.
- 1:30:01And that's very hard to recreate.
- 1:30:03Like you need, you need people that are willing to do that.
- 1:30:05The original creator needs to do that.
- 1:30:06And it goes against natural human desires and wills like
- 1:30:10emotion to to control things. But when you're talking about
- 1:30:14these open, permissionless networks that are not controlled
- 1:30:16by people, the only way they improve and innovate is with
- 1:30:19pressure with market pressure with.
- 1:30:21With with like iron sharpens iron.
- 1:30:24Like you need pain before there's actually market demand
- 1:30:28to improve things in these open systems, nonstar, super nascent,
- 1:30:34there's going to be all these different pain points.
- 1:30:36And as we hit those pain points the the the hope is that open
- 1:30:40source contributors around the world will build tools and
- 1:30:43improvements that that will get us past those points.
- 1:30:46Now, with Bitcoin, we've gotten through a lot of the pain
- 1:30:49points, but one of the big ones is box space is scarce.
- 1:30:53With adoption, transaction fees should should increase, right?
- 1:30:59Humans increase. Humans have a tendency to
- 1:31:02increase exponentially. We grow very fast, We have lots
- 1:31:06of children. Our production increases, right?
- 1:31:10Our GDP increases. All these things increase.
- 1:31:13Block space does not increase. So as people transact more in
- 1:31:19Bitcoin, regardless of their degens or not, transaction fees
- 1:31:23should increase because there's more people transacting and
- 1:31:28there's the same amount of block space.
- 1:31:30And we just have not been in this environment for very long.
- 1:31:35So we should see substantial improvements in terms of the
- 1:31:37tools and services that are built on top of Bitcoin in terms
- 1:31:40of handling high fee environments.
- 1:31:42And the big one that has been championed for years in Bitcoin
- 1:31:45circles has been Lightning. The Lightning Network.
- 1:31:48This idea of of of basically an interoperable protocol of
- 1:31:52batched Bitcoin payments. I can make a single on chain
- 1:31:54transaction to open a lightning channel and then I can send
- 1:31:5710,020 thousand 30,000 Bitcoin transactions through lightning
- 1:32:01without trusting a third party. And then I can close that
- 1:32:04Channel and it's only two Bitcoin transactions on chain.
- 1:32:07I'm only paying my transaction fee twice, but I'm able to send
- 1:32:1110,020 thousand, 30,040 thousand transactions to that Channel
- 1:32:14before I close it. It has been herald as a way to
- 1:32:19be more efficient with your transaction fee burden and it
- 1:32:22is, but it has not been built to the point where it it is very
- 1:32:30it, it has issues in a high fee environment, which is insane,
- 1:32:34right, because that is like almost exactly what it's trying
- 1:32:37to solve for. But it hasn't existed in a high
- 1:32:40fee environment. So it's kind of it's it's to be
- 1:32:43expected. So with this, yeah.
- 1:32:45So with this pressure, we're seeing this pressure.
- 1:32:48The tools should get better, the layer two should get better, all
- 1:32:52these different toolings on the sides.
- 1:32:53The businesses should interact with Bitcoin in a more efficient
- 1:32:56way because because at the end of the day they have the best
- 1:32:59incentive ever, it will cost them more not to, and they have
- 1:33:03to figure out how to do it in the most cost effective way
- 1:33:05possible, otherwise they will lose money.
- 1:33:08So if you asked me two years ago what was I most excited about
- 1:33:11with Bitcoin, I probably would have said the Fetamine project
- 1:33:15and people thought I was fucking crazy.
- 1:33:17You know, like that's a custodian.
- 1:33:19Oh, but it's a multi sync custodian.
- 1:33:21I don't care Matt, Not your keys, not your coins.
- 1:33:23Oh but the multi sync custodian can't see your transactions.
- 1:33:27Yeah, I don't care. Matt is still a custodian.
- 1:33:29It's like OK, but it's interoperable with the Lightning
- 1:33:31network between other multi sync custodians and all of a sudden
- 1:33:35two years later you start to see why a project like Fetterman
- 1:33:37should exist. It should exist because people
- 1:33:40need to be able to use the chain more efficiently.
- 1:33:43And if you have a low value transactions that you're that
- 1:33:46you're trying to save low value amounts in terms of stats, in
- 1:33:50terms of Bitcoin or transact in low value amounts.
- 1:33:54You're going to have to figure out ways to share UTXOS with
- 1:33:56other people. You're going to have to figure
- 1:33:58out, you know clever good trade off mechanisms to do this on a
- 1:34:03higher layer above Bitcoin. And so, so I'm I'm excited about
- 1:34:08Fetamine. I'm excited about Lightning
- 1:34:10innovation. I'm excited about things like
- 1:34:12state chains. I think there's going to be
- 1:34:14really compelling innovation in terms of efficiently using
- 1:34:20Bitcoin in a relatively secure and private way in a sustained
- 1:34:25high fee environment and it was never going to happen unless we
- 1:34:28had one. Right.
- 1:34:30That's a great point and nice transition to something else I
- 1:34:34wanted to talk about which you you mentioned earlier in the
- 1:34:37call, but your work with Opensats starting up that maybe
- 1:34:43tell the listeners a little bit about what that is and why it's
- 1:34:45important. Generally speaking, you know,
- 1:34:47related to what we just talked about in terms of tools being
- 1:34:51built, when the pressure's there and who's going to go build it.
- 1:34:55He's open source contributors. So maybe shed a little light on
- 1:34:58on what you've been doing there? Yeah, so I mean Opensats is a
- 1:35:02501C3 that I Co founded with this guy Ben Price.
- 1:35:09He's the founder of the Bitcoin company.
- 1:35:13Great company, does not run Bitcoin.
- 1:35:16I disagree with the name of his company, but he did.
- 1:35:18His lawyers also disagreed because he can't get it
- 1:35:20trademarked or anything. He has horrible SEO because if
- 1:35:23you search the Bitcoin company there's like thousands of
- 1:35:25companies come up. But anyway, that was his
- 1:35:26prerogative. He came to me and he was like,
- 1:35:29let's let's start this 501C3 that supports open source
- 1:35:32contributors. I said that sounds like a lot of
- 1:35:33paperwork. He's like, yeah, but it's
- 1:35:35needed. I was like, well, if you take
- 1:35:37care of the majority of the paperwork, like I'll help you
- 1:35:39build a board and and and do all the other good things.
- 1:35:43But like I just don't want to deal with paperwork.
- 1:35:45Fast forward to today, we have a great board.
- 1:35:49We have nine people on our board, all great bit corners
- 1:35:53that have strong reputations of the space and what we do is we
- 1:36:00accept donations. You get a tax deduction if
- 1:36:02you're in America, if you want, or you can donate it anonymously
- 1:36:05with Bitcoin. If you donate via credit card or
- 1:36:10wire, we automatically convert it into Bitcoin.
- 1:36:12All grants are paid out in Bitcoin.
- 1:36:15We take zero cut whatsoever. A lot of these charities will
- 1:36:18take 1020. Thirty 40% For operations we
- 1:36:21take zero cut 100% gets passed through to open source
- 1:36:23contributors. We have a separate operations
- 1:36:26fund that pays for a few few full time employees that you can
- 1:36:30donate to separately if you want to support our operations.
- 1:36:33And that's how we're able to to, you know, execute efficiently,
- 1:36:39but also an ethical way. And it's relatively simple.
- 1:36:42You apply for a grant@opensets.org.
- 1:36:45Our nine person board reviews it, we debate it, we argue about
- 1:36:49it, And then if you get five of nine votes, you get approved.
- 1:36:53And the reason we have a nine person board is to reduce
- 1:36:56corruption and bias. If you if you want to attempt to
- 1:37:00block someone, you need to get 5.
- 1:37:03You need to get four other people to join you, to block
- 1:37:05someone in a corrupt way. If you want to get something
- 1:37:08pushed through, you need to get four other people corrupted to
- 1:37:10push through something. So we naturally built it in a
- 1:37:14way that obviously it's still centralized, but trying to
- 1:37:17distribute those roles a little bit, right?
- 1:37:19Reduce the pressure on any individual.
- 1:37:20And I'll tell you, in the beginning people thought we were
- 1:37:22fucking crazy because you have a nine person board.
- 1:37:25There's a lot more friction to run that organization, right?
- 1:37:29You can't just like push changes through and change all this
- 1:37:31other stuff. But like Bitcoin, it was a
- 1:37:33feature, not a bug. And now that we have millions of
- 1:37:36dollars we deployed, we allocated over $7,000,000 to
- 1:37:41open source contributors this year.
- 1:37:42That's a lot of money, and there's a lot of great
- 1:37:45conspiracy theories where I'm like the head of the Illuminati
- 1:37:47or whatever, and we designed it so that I'm not like that is the
- 1:37:50point. So if you have large tax gains,
- 1:37:53I know this is coming out like the first week of 2024 but this
- 1:37:57is going to be a ball or year. You're going to have very large
- 1:38:00tax gains. Potentially consider donating to
- 1:38:02open SAT's and and get your tax deduction.
- 1:38:04If you're an open source contributor, consider applying
- 1:38:08and and why why is this important?
- 1:38:09This is important because these open source contributors around
- 1:38:12the world are making this movement possible and they're
- 1:38:14often not compensated whatsoever.
- 1:38:17It's it's usually a side hustle. It's something they're doing on
- 1:38:20the side. They work there 9:00 to 5:00 or
- 1:38:22they're, you know, they're 7 to 10, you know, like insane hours
- 1:38:27at their at their normal job. And then they come and they do
- 1:38:29their open source, almost charitable work.
- 1:38:32It's it's available to the public.
- 1:38:33It's free. Anyone can modify it.
- 1:38:36It's often times hard to monetize and we want to speed up
- 1:38:40this process. We want to speed up the process
- 1:38:43because we don't need freedom yesterday, we need freedom
- 1:38:46today. And and the stakes are quite
- 1:38:49high. The stakes are quite high at the
- 1:38:51end of the day. Like if we fuck this up, like
- 1:38:52our children, their children, they're digital slaves.
- 1:38:56They live in a complete dystopia like we need to make this shit
- 1:38:59happen. And if it's not us, then who's
- 1:39:01it going to fucking be? So it's important that there are
- 1:39:04these organizations and there's other ones that are doing
- 1:39:07similar work. I like to think we're
- 1:39:08particularly unique in our scope and our scale but but giving
- 1:39:15giving these people the ability to to say no, I want to work
- 1:39:18full time on Bitcoin. I want to work full time on
- 1:39:21Noster. I want to work full time on
- 1:39:22freedom tech and have a a relatively you know secure and
- 1:39:28sustainable salary right. So like sometimes we'll do one
- 1:39:32off grants, but also we have this idea, this long term
- 1:39:35support program where like Bitcoin core contributors like
- 1:39:39people that are working on like the core foundational code that
- 1:39:44runs the Bitcoin network. We provide them two year grants
- 1:39:48where where they know their monthly salary in dollar or euro
- 1:39:52terms, not in Bitcoin terms, dollar or euro terms because
- 1:39:55that's what their rent is in, that's what they're paying for
- 1:39:58diapers in, that's what they're paying for food for their
- 1:40:00family. And and if they're going to
- 1:40:02leave Google, Amazon, Facebook, Twitter and focus on Bitcoin we
- 1:40:07need to provide them a competitive, competitive, safe,
- 1:40:10safe compensation for that right.
- 1:40:12And it speeds up the whole process.
- 1:40:14Like, I don't think it's necessarily I, I, I, I I would.
- 1:40:18I would hesitate to say it's required for this movement to
- 1:40:20happen, but we speed it up. And anyone who's building on top
- 1:40:25of these open source protocols, their company will benefit if
- 1:40:29they support these initiatives. Like if you are running an ETF,
- 1:40:34you should be donating a portion of your fees to to open source
- 1:40:37contributors. They are a requirement for your
- 1:40:39business to function and and you will benefit significantly
- 1:40:42indirectly over the next 10 years if you do support this.
- 1:40:45If you are running Coinbase, you are building on top of these
- 1:40:49people, you you should support them.
- 1:40:51It is in your best interest to support them and we will make it
- 1:40:53as easy for you as possible. Whether you want to send U.S.
- 1:40:56dollars, whether you want to send us Bitcoin, you don't have
- 1:40:59to do any of the hard work. We'll evaluate the projects,
- 1:41:01we'll stay on top of them, we'll decide if they get renewed or
- 1:41:03not. And to us it's it's almost a
- 1:41:06full time job for us and in this in the classic state of open
- 1:41:10source, none of us get paid for it.
- 1:41:12So we're all doing this you know pro bono or whatever and not pro
- 1:41:16bono because we're not fucking lawyers, but you know we're
- 1:41:19doing it. No cut, no salary to ourselves
- 1:41:23because I mean I think first of all because it's an important
- 1:41:25mission, but I think also like partially selfishly because I I
- 1:41:29want there needs to be freedom in the world and and it's
- 1:41:31actually valuable if you would think about it from a long term
- 1:41:35horizon, if you think about it in a low time preference way
- 1:41:38like it's valuable to to all of us to support these open source
- 1:41:44ecosystems. Yeah, and I think me and Matt
- 1:41:47have been friends for some time now.
- 1:41:49And I think partially we've really appreciated Matt's
- 1:41:53friendship and him just giving back to the space.
- 1:41:55It's very commendable to realize these things.
- 1:41:57The very first principle, like what you're describing reminds
- 1:42:00me of, like who will build the roads where people forgot about,
- 1:42:04like the resilience of humans? Or like if we look at it from an
- 1:42:07investment aspect of the the network, it's like who will?
- 1:42:10Who will fix the code? It's like, who will?
- 1:42:11Ship the code. Yeah, like.
- 1:42:13We will like, we will partner ourselves because that's what
- 1:42:16humans did and do when there's like meaning and things behind
- 1:42:20it. And this ties into like the
- 1:42:22aspect of Bitcoin and its resiliency to it and then when
- 1:42:26you kind of tie in and not to go down that rabbit hole, but it is
- 1:42:29relevant when you think about all coins and you know pre mines
- 1:42:33and all the things associated, it's like we need to figure out
- 1:42:35development. We got to figure it out.
- 1:42:37It's like this is completely different.
- 1:42:39It's completely opposite. Dev funds and.
- 1:42:42Dev taxes and we'll say that's why we had to like pre mine and
- 1:42:44that's why we had to get the tokens and why you had to put
- 1:42:46$10 million in this and all the things associated.
- 1:42:49And so I just think it's very important to just realize and
- 1:42:53highlight like this is how society generally worked for
- 1:42:56hundreds and thousands of years is like you create capital, you
- 1:43:00benefit from the capital you give back because it actually
- 1:43:02benefits you as a society versus like raping and pillaging the
- 1:43:06the the city center that like basically you live in the muck.
- 1:43:09And that's kind of what we're we've experienced whether it's
- 1:43:11in digital or like meet space. So it's very cool to see you
- 1:43:14doing that. I know you've been picking up a
- 1:43:15lot of traction. You've been getting some some
- 1:43:17very interesting phone calls on the open sat side and hopefully
- 1:43:19that like you said continues into the bull market and it's
- 1:43:22the best year for you guys. Dude, the momentum on open open
- 1:43:26Sats is the I can sleep well at night because Open Sats, man.
- 1:43:30Like, it's to me, it's. I think people are going to look
- 1:43:34back on this stage of Open Sats and just be like, wow, like it
- 1:43:38turned into a fucking juggernaut for good.
- 1:43:41So I'm incredibly excited about open sets to bring it back to
- 1:43:44the token part of Brian's question that I just didn't
- 1:43:47answer at all. Like you're repeating crypto
- 1:43:49tokens. Like, the way I look at all this
- 1:43:51shit is very simple in a free market.
- 1:43:54In a proper free market where there aren't legal tender laws,
- 1:43:58where they're saying you have to use this money, you have to
- 1:44:01trade it this way, you have to do this here's, you know, brutal
- 1:44:04tax, regulation, all this other shit.
- 1:44:06If you if you do forex in a certain way or whatever, in a
- 1:44:09proper free market, monies compete against each other and
- 1:44:14the best money will win. The hardest money will win.
- 1:44:17And Bitcoin is is the hardest money ever in humanity.
- 1:44:23And it's going to win. I, I I believe it's going to
- 1:44:26win. I, I, I, I crunched the numbers,
- 1:44:30I did my own research and I believe it's going to win.
- 1:44:32And as a result I have incredible conviction that shit.
- 1:44:36Coins, crypto tokens, the US dollar, the Euro, whatever
- 1:44:40bricks comes out with in their future currency, gold, real
- 1:44:43estate as a store of value are no competition to Bitcoin and
- 1:44:47the market will prove that out over time.
- 1:44:50They are not a threat to Bitcoin, they're a threat to the
- 1:44:52users that speculate on them, right?
- 1:44:55So. So I don't pretend that, you
- 1:44:57know, like if if if you have some new scam token that comes
- 1:45:02out, like absolutely it it can be a malicious scam token.
- 1:45:05It is and it's a threat to the users who decide to purchase it
- 1:45:08thinking that they're going to get rich quick.
- 1:45:10But it's not a threat to Bitcoin.
- 1:45:12And and so I I sleep well at night on on in that regard.
- 1:45:16I don't try. And yeah, I mean you will just
- 1:45:21you will die a miserable life if for the rest of your life you
- 1:45:25try and call out all the scams and tokens and everything else
- 1:45:29in this space, it's it's much easier to just go into your
- 1:45:33bitcoins Zen and realize it's not a threat to Bitcoin and
- 1:45:38accept the unfortunate reality that that people that don't want
- 1:45:40to accept personal responsibility will fall for get
- 1:45:43rich quick schemes forever. Bitcoins Zen in 2024.
- 1:45:48It's a It's a nice, nice motto. Things to get sets.
- 1:45:51Yep, exactly. Unless you're going to get crazy
- 1:45:54once you're following that on Noster, then it's there's, it's
- 1:45:57it's even less than the Caps have come back so that.
- 1:46:01I'm not the Caps doesn't mean I'm shouting.
- 1:46:03I'm just speaking clearly. That's all the.
- 1:46:07Caps like the Cramer. Enunciating.
- 1:46:10The caps are scary, though, because you remind me of like
- 1:46:12the Cramer. They're like the reverse.
- 1:46:13The reverse if you're bullish and then it just it all starts
- 1:46:17crumbling, you got sand. Well, I mean, it's easy for
- 1:46:20people to cherry pick. I've been bullish at every
- 1:46:22single Bitcoin top, but I've also been bullish on every
- 1:46:24single Bitcoin bottom. So.
- 1:46:27Consistent. Nothing else.
- 1:46:28Yeah, very consistent. Well, this has been this has
- 1:46:33been awesome Matt. I think being mindful of your
- 1:46:35time we can probably wrap here, but super, super excited to get
- 1:46:39this this pot off the ground and again, couldn't think of anyone
- 1:46:43better than you to to help us launch it.
- 1:46:44So appreciate it man. It was a fun rip.
- 1:46:48Appreciate you guys. Yeah, appreciate.
- 1:46:50Appreciate coming on. I think we're going to try to
- 1:46:52make the the future ones nice and tight.
- 1:46:55But this one, we felt we got it. We had to go go for it and get
- 1:46:58Matt's background, some of the early stories and then tying
- 1:47:01into what's happening now and what we're looking forward to.
- 1:47:03So appreciate everybody tuning in.
- 1:47:05Yep, appreciate tuning in. See you guys in a couple weeks
- 1:47:10later. Thanks.