Latest / CXOTalk / Securing Critical Infrastructure: Precision AI for OT Environments | #865
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to CXO Talk. I'm Michael Krigsman, and we're
- 0:04discussing how AI can protect operational technology and
- 0:09critical infrastructure. We're speaking with Anand Oswal
- 0:14from Palo Alto Networks. Palo Alto Network is a leading
- 0:17cybersecurity company in the world.
- 0:20Our mission is to make everyday more safer than the day before.
- 0:23At Palo Alto Networks, I'm the SVP and general manager of
- 0:27Network security. Anon, we're talking about
- 0:29operational technology, OT and information technology IT.
- 0:35Give us some background here. We think of operational
- 0:38technology, think of factory flows, manufacturing facilities,
- 0:42think of utility, oil and gas mining.
- 0:45These environments have high value assets and there's a big
- 0:49difference between IT environments and OT
- 0:52environments. First, IT environments typically
- 0:55are usually always connected. OT environments are trying to
- 0:58get connected now, but they're also mission critical in nature.
- 1:01If an OT asset goes down, it can mean a big downtime for a
- 1:05factory floor, for a utility network, etcetera.
- 1:08At the same time, we're seeing over 70% of industrial
- 1:12organizations were victims of cyber attacks.
- 1:15Just in the last year, one in four organizations had to shut
- 1:19down their operations for a small amount of time.
- 1:21Anon there is a convergence between OT and IT systems.
- 1:29What's going on there? As OT environments are getting
- 1:32more and more digitized, the IT and OT environments are
- 1:35converging so that you can have consistent visibility across the
- 1:39entire infrastructure. At the same time, you're seeing
- 1:43over 3/4 of all threats on OT networks originated from the IT
- 1:49side and then percolated on to the OT environments.
- 1:53You can have these two disjoint environments operate in silos
- 1:57forever. They're converging.
- 1:58Digitization is being all these things together.
- 2:00You want to have a consistent architecture across IT and OT
- 2:06with all the controls you want which are unique to OT.
- 2:08Now digitization is amazing thing.
- 2:10It brings new opportunities, new capabilities for these factory
- 2:13floors, for these manufacturing facilities, but also brings in
- 2:17an increase attack surface. How does this increase the
- 2:22attack surface as you just mentioned?
- 2:24As you get more and more digitized, as more and more
- 2:27things get connected, the attack surface increases.
- 2:30In the past, these organizations were completely air gap or not
- 2:33connected to the outside world. As these are getting connected
- 2:37now, what's happening is that the attack surface increases.
- 2:40Also these systems or the organizations have very legacy
- 2:44and complex systems, flat layer to networks.
- 2:46Their assets have not been patched periodically.
- 2:49They are very old assets. The variety of different systems
- 2:52and stacks that have been used from last 123 decades at times.
- 2:56So modernization was not possible.
- 2:59Patching of these assets is not happening very frequently and
- 3:02now people are exploiting as these get connected.
- 3:05Can you give us some examples of exposed OT critical
- 3:11infrastructure that's therefore open to attack?
- 3:14Over 3/4 of these attacks the originate from the IT side.
- 3:19So you have infiltrated into your IT systems and then you're
- 3:22going into your OT environments. And these could be things like
- 3:26remote code execution, command and control attacks, software
- 3:29exploits happening on specific old systems.
- 3:32A variety of different attacks are happening now.
- 3:34Not all attacks of course are happening from IT and going to
- 3:37OT. There are attacks are happening
- 3:38on OT alone, but a large majority of them are are
- 3:42initially happening on the IT side and then they are going to
- 3:45move on to the OT environments. OT systems do have unique
- 3:49attributes as you were describing.
- 3:52What about traditional conventional approaches to
- 3:55security, firewalls and so forth?
- 3:57Securing the OT environments is a top, top priority.
- 4:01Most of the customers I talk to in the OT environments, whether
- 4:04the customers are manufacturing in utility, in oil and gas, in
- 4:07food production, etcetera, recognize the problem.
- 4:10They understand it's not easy because they have these legacy
- 4:14environments. They're complex, they're flat
- 4:17layered to environments. Some of them are getting
- 4:19connected and the connectivity varies.
- 4:21Some are getting connected a traditional way, some are
- 4:23getting connected directly over 5G bespoke.
- 4:26You want to give access to these factory flows and assets from
- 4:30outside. You want to ensure that you're
- 4:32giving them the least privileged access and they can only do what
- 4:36you what you want them to do. So all those environments are
- 4:39unique for OT environments. Now, the way to go about this
- 4:43holistically is on the principles of 0 trust security.
- 4:47There's power through AI visibility.
- 4:50If you think of visibility, it's not about manually understanding
- 4:54what your assets are in the environment.
- 4:56It's next to impossible to do that because you have new
- 4:59assets. I want to be able to understand
- 5:01through machine learning, what's the device, what's the type,
- 5:04what's the make, what's the model?
- 5:06What is it talking to? What is it not doing?
- 5:08What is supposed to do so I can baseline those things.
- 5:11Second, your rules for segmentation or or should also
- 5:15be machine learning power or AI, AI powered because these rules
- 5:19will may change and you have new devices coming on, which devices
- 5:24have access to which group? What's the policies you set for
- 5:26them? They cannot be done manually.
- 5:28Look, majority of breaches happen when things are
- 5:31configured manually. Once you do that, the third is
- 5:35that how do you secure all of the connections outside and
- 5:38coming from the outside world? That only happens to the power
- 5:41of what I call as precision AIA combination of machine learning,
- 5:45deep learning infused with large language models.
- 5:48Because the traditional approaches of security which are
- 5:51based on a signature or a database is not sufficient.
- 5:55Attackers are more and more sophisticated, so you cannot
- 5:58rely only on that. The only way to solve problems
- 6:01for the new world will be AI driven through your machine
- 6:04learning and deep learning models.
- 6:06You mentioned precision AI to support security on OT devices
- 6:13and environments. Can you elaborate on that?
- 6:17So if you think of a signature, it's like, you know, I had a
- 6:20given device or a person infected with a given threat.
- 6:23I understand what it is. I built a signature and then I
- 6:27give a content update on my network enforcement point so
- 6:30that nobody else is affected by the same threat that the first
- 6:34person was. In my view, that's reactive.
- 6:38It used to take us seven days to give a content, then 24 hours
- 6:41and 8 hours, and sometimes it's now it's in a matter of minutes,
- 6:44but it's still reactive. If you want to stop new threats,
- 6:48threats that that you've seen before, but also threats that
- 6:51you've never seen before, what I call as day 0 threats, then you
- 6:54need to not depend only on the signature and databases.
- 6:57You got to look at things in line in real time.
- 7:01That happens with deep learning across both structure and
- 7:04unstructured data. We were able to understand
- 7:06what's going on and protect you from threats that you've never
- 7:10seen before. And that's the power of
- 7:13precision AI, where we taking what we did with machine
- 7:15learning, we added these deep learning models and we'll infuse
- 7:19that in the last two years with all the variation that we can
- 7:21get with large language models. So combination of these three
- 7:24techniques is what we call precision AI.
- 7:26And of course, you're dealing with threat actors who have
- 7:28become very sophisticated in the use of AI and machine learning
- 7:33on their side as well. Cyber security is the only
- 7:36industry that has an active adversary.
- 7:38Our job is to be right every single time.
- 7:41The attacker's job is to be right once.
- 7:44And the amount of effort that we put into researching all of
- 7:47these various threats, models, new techniques in AI is to
- 7:51always stay ahead of the adversary and that's what we do
- 7:55with position AI. We are now stopping at Palo Alto
- 7:57Networks over 12 billion attacks every single day, and two and a
- 8:02half million of those are net new attacks that nobody has ever
- 8:06seen before. That's only possible because we
- 8:09have 4400 machine learning deep learning models running on the
- 8:12platform that is looking at these things in line in real
- 8:16time, protecting you from threats that you've seen in the
- 8:18past and threats that you've never seen before.
- 8:21Now, many of these OT systems are in legacy environments.
- 8:26They're not patched, they're a whole host of issues.
- 8:29How do you manage that? You need to have something where
- 8:33you can do what I call virtual patching where you can.
- 8:36You can build signatures of what you want, what is happening on
- 8:39the endpoints and block them on the network side because they're
- 8:42easier to patch it centrally because it's hard to update
- 8:44these devices periodically and in some cases it's not possible.
- 8:48Why is virtual patching so important?
- 8:51See Virtual Patching helps us now solve the problem where I'm
- 8:55not able to patch my endpoints with vulnerability and CVS that
- 8:58I see, but I'm having a network solution to to still make sure
- 9:03that I'm not affected by that situation.
- 9:05So I'm I'm basically solving it more creatively.
- 9:07These environments are mission critical and very often must run
- 9:14continuously. How can organizations integrate
- 9:20these kinds of solutions without causing disruption to their
- 9:25environment? If you're using OT, stick it in
- 9:28a factory floor. You can't stop production in a
- 9:31factory floor. If you're using in a utility or
- 9:35oil and gas environment, you can't stop what's happening with
- 9:38your utility and your oil and gas environment.
- 9:40So it's very important that you build your OT solutions keeping
- 9:45in mind high availability, keeping in mind how do you
- 9:48ensure that from an operational perspective they continue to
- 9:52run. Remote access is critical for
- 9:56these kinds of environments. How do you enable remote access
- 10:00while providing security? Over 50% of organizations today,
- 10:05Michael, are having technicians, contractors or employees access
- 10:11these high value critical assets remotely.
- 10:14And for that, you want to make sure that a, you're using the
- 10:17right privileges for what they have access to.
- 10:20When they get access to the system.
- 10:21They are accessed ideally from a secure enterprise browser where
- 10:24you can do just in time recording, you can look at the
- 10:27activity, you can log all things that they are doing because
- 10:29these are very critical assets. So you want to make sure that
- 10:31you are designing the solutions with least privilege of what the
- 10:37contractor, the employee, the technician accesses.
- 10:41But also ensure that you have a full ordered log of every single
- 10:44activity done by the user. Anon, you've mentioned zero
- 10:48trust several times. How does that come into play in
- 10:52this remote access scenario? It is one of the most abuse
- 10:56words in cybersecurity. You think of 0 trust.
- 10:59It means no notion of implied trust.
- 11:02So I want to understand in this case who the device or the asset
- 11:06is. Is this something that I
- 11:07understand and it's assigned to my OT environment?
- 11:11Then you want to know who is this asset talking to, talking
- 11:16to systems inside the organization and talking to
- 11:19things in the outside world? Who can access these systems
- 11:23from the outside for the example we talked about for remote
- 11:26access? And when you allow this
- 11:28connection, how do you ensure that this connection, whether it
- 11:32is from the asset to the outside world or the reverse is
- 11:35monitored for all threats, vulnerabilities, command control
- 11:39connections and so on, so forth? And four, how do you manage the
- 11:43entire life cycle of this assets?
- 11:46All this in construct helps us define zero trust for OT
- 11:50environments where we have no notion implied trust, we have
- 11:53least privilege access and I'm monitoring every single
- 11:56connection and flow from the asset or to the asset.
- 12:00I know in factory floors and other OT environments are very
- 12:06harsh. There's humidity issues, there's
- 12:09temperature. How do you handle that aspect?
- 12:13They are harsh environments. Sometimes these environments
- 12:16have vibration temperature control and you think of other
- 12:20OT environments, they could be outdoor Michael, like like your
- 12:23utility, your mining, your oil and gas which could have you
- 12:27know have to operate in temperatures which are very hot
- 12:30or really, really cold. So for those environments we
- 12:33have what we call ruggedized firewalls.
- 12:36These are network enforcement points which have all of the all
- 12:39of the ability to wither all the harsh environments, whether it's
- 12:43temperature, whether it is rain, whether it is vibration, whether
- 12:47it is sand and so on and so forth.
- 12:49And these are enforcement points.
- 12:50These are enforcement point, or these are sensors on the network
- 12:53that help identify who the devices are on the environment,
- 12:57but also help protect from threats, command control
- 13:00connections, software exploits, so on and so forth.
- 13:04And on the regulations around cybersecurity reporting are
- 13:11evolving. Can you tell us about that?
- 13:14What's going on there? Within 72 hours if you are
- 13:18having a attack you got to have you have to report that.
- 13:20For ransomware you have 24 hours to report that.
- 13:23So these are environment that are happening and this is quite
- 13:25broad. It affects large sector of
- 13:29organizations, including OT environments and that is what
- 13:33the rules and regulations are. The best thing that we are
- 13:37advising our customers is that make sure that you're building
- 13:40these systems which are highly secure so that you have the
- 13:44capability then to protect yourself from these threats.
- 13:47Do you have advice on how organizations can maintain
- 13:51operational efficiency while maintaining compliance with
- 13:57these new regulations? Most of these environments are
- 14:00highly regulated. Most of these environments have
- 14:02to do have a lot of things around audits and trails and
- 14:05logs and a lot of time is spent including this audit log
- 14:08reports. What we do with our solution of
- 14:11OT security in addition to the things I talked about which is
- 14:14visibility, segmentation and policy control, zero trust
- 14:19access and security on an ongoing basis, we also help them
- 14:22automate all the audit information because now we have
- 14:25full visibility into every individual asset in the
- 14:28organization. We know the make the model, the
- 14:31version, the vulnerabilities associated with it and we can
- 14:34now automate so as report creation from audit perspective
- 14:37and help them be more proactive in how you remediate form these
- 14:42vulnerabilities either by patching the endpoints, by
- 14:45having solutions like guided virtual patching or support on
- 14:49the network enforcement point for security threats.
- 14:52So given the complexity around these OT environments and the
- 14:59ever evolving nature of security threats, automation is the key.
- 15:07Automation and your security and your visibility needs to be
- 15:10powered by AI. You cannot do these things
- 15:12manually. AI and machine learning have
- 15:16been core themes you've touched on during our discussion.
- 15:21Why is it so important in these converged OTIT environments?
- 15:28We're talking of OT environments and IT enviros merging.
- 15:31You're talking of two systems coming together.
- 15:33We're talking of complexity, of variety of different things on
- 15:36the OT environment, many of them that can't be patched, many of
- 15:39them having vulnerabilities. And then you have to have all
- 15:42the segmentation rules and policies.
- 15:45All of this has to be powered through AI and machine learning.
- 15:48You got to be able to have full visibility.
- 15:50You got to do it on structure unstructured data.
- 15:52You got to have your segmentation rules and policies
- 15:54automatically created. But now as these assets get
- 15:58connected, you have to use the power of machine learning, deep
- 16:01learning, LLMS, what we call precision AI to secure every
- 16:05single connection across every single possible threat vector
- 16:09with this command control connections and software
- 16:11exploits and phishing attacks or malware or OT specific threats.
- 16:16All of this needs to be done to the power of AI so you can stop
- 16:20and prevent both known as well as unknown threats in real time,
- 16:26reducing any of the downtime of the assets and have full life
- 16:30cycle manageability across the entire life cycle of the OT
- 16:33assets for the factory floor of the plant.
- 16:36Anon, great talking with you. Thank you so much.
- 16:38Michael, always a pleasure. Thank you so much.