Latest / Wellness For Real at Any Age / Why Overly Restrictive Diets Always Fail & What To Do Instead For Quicker, Lasting Weight Loss
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to weight loss and wellness.
- 0:06For real, the podcast, where people like, you get the
- 0:09Practical Solutions and support you need to permanently lose the
- 0:14physical and mental weight, so you can feel better and live the
- 0:17life you want in the body and mind you want.
- 0:21If you're looking to overcome your stress eating over eating,
- 0:24binging behaviors and move to a place of Freedom with food and
- 0:29your body. You're in the right place.
- 0:35Just a reminder that this podcast represents my own
- 0:38opinions, the content here should not be taken as medical
- 0:42advice. The content here is for
- 0:44educational and informational purposes.
- 0:47Only please consult your doctor or health care.
- 0:49Professional for any individual medical questions.
- 0:53You may have. Hello, friends and welcome.
- 0:55I'm glad you're here today and thanks for listening.
- 0:59We are talking all about restriction today.
- 1:02When it comes to dieting. Eating and how over restriction
- 1:07will always fail when it comes to weight loss and other health
- 1:12issues that go along with restriction and I'm going to
- 1:15talk about ways, you can make sure to stay away from the
- 1:19dieting trap, that leads to regaining the weight you've lost
- 1:22or the inability to drop weight. The psychological issues, the
- 1:27other issues, physical issues, that can happen like thyroid
- 1:31issues. Hormone dysregulation.
- 1:33I'm going to give you some tickle strategies to make sure
- 1:36that you are creating a sustainable way to lose weight
- 1:40and to stay at that weight. Or if you're currently wanting
- 1:44to stay at your weight, a sustainable weight way to stay
- 1:48there, where you feel your best and healthy.
- 1:52So let's talk about a little bit about restriction, and exactly
- 1:58what it is and we need to kind of start by talking about the
- 2:03the concept, the idea. That we all have some sort of
- 2:07relationship with food, right? So, typically we would Define
- 2:11our relationship with food as either healthy or maybe not so
- 2:15healthy. And this relationship for those
- 2:18of us with a not. So, healthy relationship with
- 2:20food is very complicated for many of us for most people.
- 2:24In fact, I mean, not all but many, many many in this day and
- 2:28age and food is not anymore, just what sustains us physically
- 2:32food nowadays in our Fireman and culture is also very
- 2:37psychological and obviously being a mental health therapist,
- 2:41this is right up my alley. And so we can use food for
- 2:45comfort for control to change our state of feeling to change
- 2:50the sensations. In our bodies to distract, we
- 2:53can use it to connect socially with others to commune so.
- 2:57And so, those are not all negative things, right?
- 3:00Some are, but some aren't so many ask, there are many, many
- 3:04aspects to our Ship with food. And so how do we create this?
- 3:08Very healthy long-term relationship, with food with,
- 3:11with the foods we enjoy with the foods that we might crave that
- 3:15were maybe part of our upbringing that are nourishing
- 3:18for our bodies and Minds. So balance becomes really
- 3:21important here, and we're going to talk more about that and how
- 3:26to really figure out if you are in that restriction type space,
- 3:30which is always going to self-sabotage you and your
- 3:33goals, your relationship, your Your healthy relationship with
- 3:37your body with yourself. And then, you know, how can we
- 3:41move through that? How can we process through that?
- 3:43How can we start to change that? I hope you are finding something
- 3:47useful from these episodes and this podcast.
- 3:50And if so please share it with someone else in your life you
- 3:53feel. It could benefit this podcast,
- 3:56is also now monetize. So if you really feel, you are
- 4:00getting a lot from it and want to help keep it going, please go
- 4:04to the Sold show notes. You can just scroll down from
- 4:08wherever you're listening, you'll see a description of the
- 4:10episode and then you will see it, says support this podcast
- 4:16and then there's a link, you can click on, you can click on that
- 4:19link and that's where you can support the podcast, even the
- 4:25smallest donation. Like 99 Cents helps to keep me
- 4:29producing the podcast. And to, those of you who have
- 4:33donated, I really We appreciate the support.
- 4:37I really do appreciate all of you listening and sharing the
- 4:40space with me again, just very thankful for all of you.
- 4:44If you are someone who in the past or currently has really
- 4:49restricted in order to try to drop weight and I'm not talking
- 4:54about the guidelines that we set in place when we are trying to
- 4:59lose weight or, you know, kind of gained a healthy relationship
- 5:04with food You know, we if we're trying to lose weight, we do
- 5:10need some guidelines around food, you know, I'm talking here
- 5:14about overly restricting, to get down to a specific way and you
- 5:19know how once you're there, it becomes incredibly difficult to
- 5:23stay there. And almost everyone who has
- 5:26overly restricted to lose that weight, gains that weight back,
- 5:32plus some more and and has to try to lose it all over.
- 5:35Again, it's kind of that whole thing.
- 5:36We always talk about if you've yo-yo dieted, right?
- 5:39The problem is, is that over time of doing that losing
- 5:43gaining losing gaining, our metabolism is working
- 5:47differently, typically slower. And so now you get to this place
- 5:51where you have to continue to eat even less and less in order
- 5:54to lose any weight at all. And the cycle just sort of
- 5:57continues, its really, no wind. So here's how I've just got a
- 6:01list, a things. Here's how to know if you are
- 6:04over. Restricting.
- 6:06So, so pay attention. If any of these hit home, it's a
- 6:09clue, that you are overly restricting and something really
- 6:12needs to change, or you're not going to be able to keep this
- 6:16sustainable weight loss going. You're not going to be able to
- 6:19sustain it at maintenance. So first one, if you are feeling
- 6:22fear around trusting yourself around certain foods or food
- 6:27groups. So it's kind of like you know I
- 6:32can't have a car because if I have a car but I'm going to
- 6:34overeat. It or I can never have
- 6:36chocolate, because if I eat chocolate, you know, it's just I
- 6:40just go crazy. It's all down there Hill from
- 6:42there. So really sensing that fear
- 6:44around certain foods, not being able to trust yourself around
- 6:47certain foods. Second one would be refusing to
- 6:50eat certain foods and unless, of course, if you had an allergy or
- 6:54an intolerance right, but besides that refusing to eat
- 6:57things, you would actually like to eat, but just won't next one,
- 7:01labeling food as good or bad. This is Huge, if you notice,
- 7:07when you describe food, you're describing it as good or bad.
- 7:11This is a clue that you might be overly restricting.
- 7:14And I would really suggest if you think this is you go to
- 7:17episode 55. It's called dichotomous thinking
- 7:20overeating, binging and psychological flexibility.
- 7:23To learn more about this kind of thinking, this black-and-white
- 7:26thinking also called dichotomous thinking and how to change it
- 7:30because if you are caught in the habit, thinking pattern of black
- 7:34and white thinking, You will always self-sabotage eventually,
- 7:39okay? Other one would be social
- 7:41withdrawal if you want to bow out a social engagements because
- 7:44you don't want to be at events where food is present because
- 7:47the availability of food at these events park, a lot of
- 7:50anxiety or fear and feelings of being out of control or you
- 7:54don't want to eat in front of others, that would be another
- 7:56sign that you're overly restricting.
- 8:00Another one, if you're fasting or you're going low carb, or
- 8:04keto, or Low calorie, you know, following the newest fad diet
- 8:08and you are feeling hungrier and hungrier or start to experience
- 8:12the things that I just listed above, you're probably
- 8:15restricting too much. Another one, if you find
- 8:18yourself dieting and then get to a place where you give in and
- 8:22you weigh over eat, kind of says uncomfortable level.
- 8:27You may even start to binge, this would be a clue a big one
- 8:33that you are over restricted. Eating and just a side note,
- 8:36binge eating disorder. There's an actual DSM-5 criteria
- 8:40for that. So you know, there's just
- 8:44specifics that that kind of go on that that differentiate
- 8:48between overeating and binge eating.
- 8:51Both of them are signs that. You're restricting too much.
- 8:54If you are experiencing experiencing true, binge eating
- 8:58disorder. I just want to throw in.
- 8:59Definitely make an appointment with your doctor or mental
- 9:03health, professional for Help with that because that, that
- 9:06becomes a cycle, that gets pretty difficult to break
- 9:10without some intervention there. Other signs, you may be overly
- 9:13restricting. Your food intake are feeling
- 9:17tired, all the time, your gym, performance or athletic
- 9:20performance is suffering. You're crabby.
- 9:23You have no patience. You have a really low mood or
- 9:25you have mood swings. There is an interesting study,
- 9:29I've talked about it before, but just to hit home, there's one
- 9:33study called the milkshake study.
- 9:35This was by Herman at all, and that was back in 1975, but it's
- 9:39been repeated over and over and over again.
- 9:41And the subjects were randomized to consume zero one or two
- 9:45milkshakes. And this was after they had
- 9:47consumed a meal, so they were all going to consume a meal,
- 9:50then some of them were going to have no milkshakes.
- 9:52Some of them were going to have one.
- 9:54Some of them were going to have two milkshakes about two hours
- 9:56afterwards and then after that, they were given access to as
- 10:01much ice cream as they wanted. Now, before the study started,
- 10:04they were all We'll give and questionnaires to determine who
- 10:07held more restrictive, thoughts and behaviors around food, who
- 10:11was more restrictive in general around their diets.
- 10:13Okay, so they all ate a meal and then a couple hours later, they
- 10:18either had no milk. Shake another group had one
- 10:21milkshake and another group had two milkshakes.
- 10:24And then they were given more ice cream to eat as much as they
- 10:27wanted. It was given ad lib.
- 10:29So the group who was identified from the beginning, the people
- 10:32who are identified as being More restrictive in their dieting,
- 10:36behaviors, and thoughts consumed.
- 10:38Almost twice the amount of ice cream after having the two
- 10:43milkshakes compared to the group who had the meal and zero
- 10:47milkshakes. So those who practiced more
- 10:50restrictive Tendencies with food and within their thoughts about
- 10:54food within their diet, ate way more ice cream after the meal
- 10:58and two milkshakes. So those who had restricted
- 11:01their diets, the restrictive Behavior.
- 11:03Drove them to Indulge and binge on the food, they had been
- 11:07restricting or emitting out of their long-term dieting, eating
- 11:11plan. So, the thinking pattern is
- 11:13something like this, and sorry, now my cat is playing.
- 11:16Of course, forgive forgive the background noise.
- 11:21The thinking powder goes something like this.
- 11:23I already slipped up a little. I ate the thing.
- 11:25I promised myself, I wouldn't eat or said, I wouldn't eat or I
- 11:29was restricting, I ate the thing off my plan, so I already messed
- 11:33up. So, I might as well, eat more
- 11:34and more. I've heard clients, tell me, and
- 11:36of course, this was me struggled with this pattern for so long
- 11:41that our brain thinks things. Like, I might as well get it out
- 11:43of my system or well, the day is wrapped.
- 11:46So I might as well eat what I want.
- 11:48I'll just start again tomorrow. These are the thoughts that come
- 11:51from overly restricting. So then most of us will overeat
- 11:55even more. Like, in the study I told you
- 11:57about and many will binge at this point, or really, really
- 12:00overeat at this point point. And then, I'm sure many of you
- 12:04get this The feeling start up after the binge or after the
- 12:07overeating of Shame of guilt. And so now to appease that
- 12:12feeling to get rid of those feelings, the shame and guilt.
- 12:16You know, we try to make up for it and and we start to restrict
- 12:19again and get back to losing weight.
- 12:21So then they are overly restrictive again, to make up
- 12:25for it. Oh my goodness.
- 12:27Sorry. And you know, by now it happens,
- 12:30you know, or in that cycle again for strict overeat, restrict
- 12:34binge Restrict overeat, we're strict overeat.
- 12:37And for many of us, this cycle repeats for years.
- 12:41And if you have been part of this cycle, which I know many of
- 12:46you listening, have you understand?
- 12:48It is literally exhausting physically emotionally mentally,
- 12:54this cycle, due to restriction, as well as overly restriction.
- 12:59Re-stick restricting itself, the consequences are profound and
- 13:04they Include physical consequences as well.
- 13:07I mean, really major thyroid issues come from over
- 13:10restriction. That's my own personal Journey
- 13:13that I continue to be on a lot of hormone imbalance can happen.
- 13:17Chronic fatigue hair loss muscle loss.
- 13:19There's just so many more even physical issues that come up
- 13:23from over restriction of food. There can also be big social and
- 13:27relationship consequences as well because a lot of times, you
- 13:31know, our social interaction, we do a lot of communing Over food.
- 13:35And so if there's over restriction, we often will avoid
- 13:39those interactions so it can really create some relationship
- 13:42consequences. And there are also obviously
- 13:45emotional and mental, big, big consequences of over restriction
- 13:49or even thinking thoughts of restriction.
- 13:53And so these come down to things like moodiness depressive
- 13:56symptoms, are heightened, anxiety, symptoms are
- 13:58heightened. There's a low tolerance for
- 14:01anything, right? So like no patience overly.
- 14:05Really creates a really big life consequences I do again.
- 14:11Just one little caveat add in here that anorexia, which is
- 14:15diagnosed. A diagnosable disorder is, of
- 14:17course, one of the deadliest mental health disorders and, you
- 14:21know, is, you know, this whole other extreme on the continuant
- 14:27Continuum of restriction. And so, you know, if anyone is
- 14:32listening and you think that this is you Like your way on
- 14:36that, really scary side of restriction.
- 14:39Please call your doctor or medical professional and get
- 14:41some help for this. It's a really slippery slope to
- 14:44go down and you do really need help from professionals to get
- 14:48out of that, that behavior. Okay, so back to not the
- 14:53clinical disorders, but more to being just simply that overly
- 14:57restrictive. Dieter how do we solve for this?
- 15:00And how do we make sure that That if we're using guidelines
- 15:06with food to lose weight or for health purposes, how to make
- 15:10sure we're not overly restricting or if you're already
- 15:14in that restrict to overeat binge, then restrict overeat,
- 15:17then cycle how to start to break free of it.
- 15:20So the really big first step is planning and, you know, I work
- 15:26with my clients dealing with this all the time we work on
- 15:31strategies and methods and ways of How to shift our thinking and
- 15:35thoughts in order to implement these behaviors, the things that
- 15:38we really need to do in order to allow the food.
- 15:43The foods that we love the foods, we enjoy into their diet
- 15:48or Weight Loss plan into their way of eating lifestyle.
- 15:52And this really means making a plan that includes your favorite
- 15:56foods into your eating plan. If I have a client trying to
- 15:59lose weight with me and in the assessment, I use for potential
- 16:02clients, they tell me they Adore, chocolate.
- 16:04The chocolate goes on their plan on purpose.
- 16:07Now, they are trying to lose weight.
- 16:10So, do I, you know, am I telling them eat all the chocolate you
- 16:13want? Absolutely not we all know.
- 16:15We cannot lose weight. If we are eating all the
- 16:17chocolate ice cream chips cookies.
- 16:19But it does mean it's included a few days a week or maybe in a
- 16:23limited amount every single day. And now, you may say, oh my
- 16:27gosh, if I do that, I'll just go overboard.
- 16:29And I understand that, and we have methods and strategies and
- 16:32ways that we work through. That we work on creating a
- 16:35relationship with chocolate to where it can be enjoyed without
- 16:39overeating. It now for some of us and I
- 16:42sometimes fall into this place with chocolate, that's, and I'm
- 16:45using that example because that's the one for me.
- 16:47It seems to be one for a lot of people, but, you know, do I
- 16:51include chocolate in my diet every day?
- 16:53No. Because there are still certain
- 16:55times in my life when I do that. It's especially when there are
- 16:57high stress times in my life, things like that, just different
- 17:01seasons in my life, where it Trigger me and and it will make
- 17:06me want to consume it over and over and all I'm doing thinking
- 17:08about it. So I don't have chocolate in my
- 17:12diet, every single day, in my way of eating every single day,
- 17:15but it is allowed my way of thinking around chocolate, is
- 17:19that if I really, really want it, I can have it.
- 17:21I can go get it, I can go to the store, I can have it if I want
- 17:24it and just shifting my thoughts around, it makes it less
- 17:30stressful, right? Feel less restrictive.
- 17:32So So it's the idea here that you may have a food.
- 17:37This is real that triggers you to overeat.
- 17:40So we're not just going to make you have that every day.
- 17:42There are steps and strategies to slowly work into that space
- 17:46of. How do we not feel fear around a
- 17:48certain food or that if we do have it?
- 17:50Like if I go out to dinner and I do have some chocolate, how it
- 17:53doesn't turn into then overeating later that night or
- 17:57the next day or days of overeating because I ate the
- 17:59chocolate and now that's all I want.
- 18:01So there are strategies and ways.
- 18:03To deal with that. One of the strategies, though
- 18:08would also be that we start to plan this chocolate in
- 18:11eventually after doing some thought work around it.
- 18:14And what happens is when that chocolate is planned in every
- 18:17day, clients will eventually find.
- 18:19They don't want it as often or if at all, and I have had that
- 18:23happen personally in different seasons.
- 18:26You know, it also the cravings for certain things, the desires
- 18:32for processed food, you know? Of that once we start increasing
- 18:37their quality of foods and they start kind of lessening some of
- 18:41that process food. Some of those things doing those
- 18:44things really does change our cravings and taste buds and what
- 18:46we desire in food. But my point is, including the
- 18:51thing in your eventual. Way of eating is really
- 18:54important. You're going to end up eating
- 18:56less of it than you would if you were completely restricting.
- 18:59It and also to the point I mentioned before how you're
- 19:03thinking about Bout it. So think of how this works.
- 19:07Another example, you restrict cookies, you say I can't have
- 19:10the cookies. I love if I want to lose weight
- 19:13but eventually you given it's a hard day.
- 19:16You've been restricting too much.
- 19:18So simply you are just really, really hungry and your brain
- 19:21urges, you know, throws up the urges so strong, like we're
- 19:23starving. You need to eat all the cookies
- 19:25and this this one over eat. This one sort of binge is almost
- 19:31always going to be more An amount and energy.
- 19:35So in calories that then if you had decided to be more open and
- 19:39curious and relaxed around this food and set up some more
- 19:42relaxed guidelines around this cookie.
- 19:44So, things like this week, I'm going to practice a guideline of
- 19:48eating one cookie every day, instead of 15 on the weekend,
- 19:52okay? So right there, think about
- 19:53that. You practice having one cookie
- 19:55every day, instead of 15 on a weekend, again, practice this is
- 19:58practice or eight, but if you do that one cookie every day,
- 20:03instead of the butler, a binge of 15 on the weekend.
- 20:05You're going to have seven cookies in that week versus 15.
- 20:09Okay? Right there.
- 20:10We've saved a bunch of energy, okay?
- 20:13Or okay? Or this week, I'm going to
- 20:15practice eating three cookies only on Friday Saturday Sunday,
- 20:20instead of the whole sleeve of Oreos.
- 20:21I typically eat every Friday night so you can see from these
- 20:25examples within one week's time, you've eaten lesson energy of
- 20:29cookies, by still having the three cookies, three days a week
- 20:32versus the ovary Of a whole sleeve sleeve of cookies once a
- 20:35week because you're like white knuckling through the week.
- 20:37Trying not to eat the cookies. My point is planning these Foods
- 20:41into your eating plan with responsible guidelines around
- 20:45them will actually bring you quicker weight loss and weight
- 20:49loss that last over time because you are creating a lifestyle
- 20:55around food. You are creating a lifestyle
- 20:58around food over time, that is not restrictive so that you can
- 21:02maintain in. Enjoying your way of eating, and
- 21:06being in the body want to be to be in.
- 21:09You really need to make sure that you are also eating enough
- 21:12throughout the day and making sure you are not having those
- 21:17Behavioral or thought patterns of restriction.
- 21:20Remember again, even thoughts around food that are
- 21:24restrictive, lead to overeating, and just for more on how to
- 21:30unwind thoughts of restriction around food, so you can lose
- 21:33weight. Quicker and stay there for life
- 21:35or, you know, you're on the other side of the coin here.
- 21:38You know, you should not be losing any more weight but you
- 21:42find yourself with lots of restriction thoughts around food
- 21:45and you're miserable with food in that relationship and want to
- 21:48find a healthier more peaceful relationship with food.
- 21:51Go back and look through other episodes episode titles in this
- 21:55podcast that align with you. I have tons of episodes with
- 21:58really practical strategies on how to start to change this kind
- 22:02of mentality, See the sort of restrictive mentality around
- 22:06food. Again, remember, it's not just
- 22:09the Restriction behaviourally of food itself.
- 22:11It's how you are thinking about food, if you have restriction
- 22:15thoughts, this same pattern. The same self-sabotage will keep
- 22:20coming up. There are many other ways to
- 22:24work on this issue and I have seen many different strategies
- 22:27work for different people to truly heal their relationship
- 22:31with food to get into That healthy body that they want to
- 22:35be living in and doing it. This is the most important part
- 22:39doing it in a way that becomes this easygoing enjoyable
- 22:44lifestyle for them. For life, do not discount, your
- 22:47ability to change your relationship with food.
- 22:50And with yourself, there are ways to do it at anytime in
- 22:54life, no matter your circumstance, your age, your
- 22:57gender, Etc. All right.
- 22:59Going to wrap it up there. Thanks for listening, and if you
- 23:02found anything useful, please. Please pass it along to someone
- 23:05else who might benefit or post it on your social media.
- 23:08All those things help to keep me sending out a new episode every
- 23:13week. Again, you can head over to my
- 23:14website, Heather heinens.com, 8, high end but it's spelled heyy
- 23:20and Iain. So Heather heinens.com.
- 23:23And there's lots of other things over there.
- 23:26You can sign up for my free monthly newsletter on all
- 23:28things. Well being, you know, I include
- 23:31tips and tricks for optimal physical mental It'll emotional
- 23:34health things. I'm kind of musing on thinking
- 23:36about there's recipes, discount codes with companies that I like
- 23:40or use things like that. Thanks again.
- 23:42And we are going to talk soon. Did you know you can find a lot
- 23:51more help from me on my website. Go to Heather.
- 23:54Heinens.com, Heinen is spelled heyy any n and get in touch with
- 24:00questions on all things. I offer like online courses, for
- 24:03overeating, weight loss, goal attainment, and also my coaching
- 24:08and counseling services.