Latest / FE exam in the car / The Dark Side of Fandom: Parasocial Bonds, Infamy, and the Ted Bundy Effect
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker 1: Welcome back. Everybody.
- 0:03Speaker 2: Today's story is hybrivestophilia. It's an uncomfortable psychological territory that
- 0:09we're going to be entering that many people find disturbing, confusing,
- 0:13or even uncomprehensible.
- 0:16Speaker 1: And I get it. It is. Let's stick with me.
- 0:19Speaker 2: The question is why do some individuals become attracted to
- 0:23violent killers?
- 0:25Speaker 1: Why do serial killers receive love letters?
- 0:29Speaker 2: Why do convicted murderers develop fan bases, Why did women
- 0:33attend the trials of ten Bundy like they were celebrity appearances,
- 0:38and why decades later do social media users still romanticize
- 0:43offenders like Richard Ramirez, Jeffrey Dahmer or Charles Manson. It's
- 0:50a bizarre concept, really, And I remember tell asking students
- 0:55about this, who was Ted Bundy?
- 0:57Speaker 1: Everybody knew? Who was Jeffrey Dahmer?
- 1:00Speaker 2: Everybody knew, But when I asked him about Gerald Ford,
- 1:04almost nobody knew. About half the class didn't know he
- 1:06was president at one point, Jimmy Carter about two thirds,
- 1:11but almost everybody ninety percent plus new Ted Mundy. The
- 1:17phenomenon of being attracted Women attracted to these serial killers
- 1:21is called high brestophelia. High brestophelia is hy bris t.
- 1:27Speaker 1: Phi l i A.
- 1:29Speaker 2: More informally, people sometimes call it the Ted Bundy effect.
- 1:33I have to say it's easier to spell and say.
- 1:36Today we're going to unpack this phenomenon carefully and scientifically,
- 1:40not sensationally, because beneath the headlines and internet fascination, why
- 1:45is something psychologically important? Human beings are not attracted only
- 1:50to kindness, safety, and stability. Sometimes attraction becomes entangled with fear, power, danger, trauma, dominance, fantasy,
- 2:02or the illusion of emotional rescue, and when that happens,
- 2:07the result can become psychologically and socially dangerous. Before we begin,
- 2:14it's an important clarification. Being interested in true crime does
- 2:17not mean someone has hypristophelia or the Ted Bundy effect.
- 2:21Millions of people consume the true crime content out of curiosity, education,
- 2:26or attempts to understand human behavior. Hybrivestophelia specifically involves emotional, romantic,
- 2:32or sexual attraction to the defender. That distinction matters for
- 2:36those who are interested in true crime. We've spoken about
- 2:40this before.
- 2:41Speaker 1: A lot of it is kind.
- 2:41Speaker 2: Of a way to access our shadow, the things that
- 2:44we are not happy about that we think about or
- 2:47do in a safer way, right in a world that
- 2:50we would never be a part of.
- 2:52Speaker 1: But we can see it in a safe in a
- 2:54safe distance. So let's go back.
- 2:59Speaker 2: So the term hybristophilia come from well I was introduced
- 3:03by John Money, a sexologist in the eighties. The words
- 3:07arise from the Greek term hohobessen, meaning to commit an
- 3:10outrage against someone, and of course phelia is attraction, So
- 3:15clinically speaking, hypristophilia refers to sexual romantic attraction toward individuals
- 3:20known to have committed serious crimes, often violent crimes kidnapping,
- 3:27sexual assault, armed robbery, terrorism. In some cases, the crime
- 3:33itself becomes psychologically central to the attraction. Now clinically this
- 3:39is often discussed as a type of paraphilic interest, though
- 3:43the research remains limited and debated. Psychologists sometimes divide hypristophelia
- 3:49into two categories. Passive this is the more common form.
- 3:53The individual is attracted to the criminal but does not
- 3:56participate in crime themselves. This may involve writing prisonly letters,
- 4:00visiting inmates, marrying and incarcerated offenders, fantasizing about dangerous criminals,
- 4:06or idealizing violent offenders emotionally. Now, the more rarer and
- 4:11more dangerous kind is the active hybristophilia. Here, the attraction
- 4:17involves direct participation and criminal behavior. Examples might include assisting crimes,
- 4:23helping conceal evidence, aiding escape, or becoming sexually aroused through
- 4:27involvement in violence itself. Now, importantly, not all admirers of
- 4:32criminals meet clinical criteria for periphilia. You may even think
- 4:37about Bonnie and Clyde here. Some are motivated by fame, attraction,
- 4:43anti authority, IDs, sensation seeking, getting back up society, loneliness,
- 4:49unresolved attachment needs. Human motivation is complex and multi factorial,
- 4:54basically meaning there's a lot of factors involved, and forensic psychology.
- 5:00He repeatedly and reminds us that behavior almost never emerges
- 5:02from one single cause. One of the biggest misconceptions about
- 5:06high bristophelia is that it's simply about physical attraction.
- 5:10Speaker 1: It usually isn't.
- 5:12Speaker 2: The attraction often involves symbolic psychological meanings, power, danger, dominance, notoriety,
- 5:21emotional intensity, or fantasy based identity formation. Sometimes a criminal
- 5:27becomes psychologically transformed into a fantasy object rather than perceived
- 5:32realistically and Once fantasy overwrides reality, critical judgment can deteriorate dramatically,
- 5:39and fantasy is one of these defense mechanisms. If you
- 5:42look at the psychodynamic world, well, the person who lives
- 5:45obviously not in reality, somewhere that they believe is safer.
- 5:49Speaker 1: It's a defense mechanism. Exactly what it means.
- 5:51Speaker 2: It's a mechanism to defend and protect your inner self.
- 5:56No offender symbolizes phenomenon more than Ted Bundy. Bundy was
- 6:01convicted of multiple murders during the nineteen seventies.
- 6:04Speaker 1: I think over thirty five.
- 6:06Speaker 2: But what shocked many observers wasn't only the brutality of
- 6:09his crimes. It was the admiration he received. Yes, Bundy
- 6:14was an attractive man, and maybe that's part of the
- 6:18reason women packed courtrooms during his trials. Some reportedly cried
- 6:22when he was convicted. Others described him as charming, intelligent, misunderstood,
- 6:27or attractive.
- 6:28Speaker 1: And he was a lot of these things.
- 6:30Speaker 2: Oddly enough, if you could separate that from his obviously
- 6:32heinous behavior, the horrific things he did. He received hundreds
- 6:38of romantic letters while incarcerated.
- 6:41Speaker 1: Eventually he actually.
- 6:42Speaker 2: Married a long time supporter, Carol Ann Boone during trial proceedings.
- 6:48She later gave birth to a child believed to be
- 6:51followed by Bundy. From a forensic psychology standpoint, Bundy represented
- 6:57a uniquely dangerous psychological packet. He possessed superficial charm, manipulative
- 7:05social intelligence, confidence, emotional mimicry, and what psychopathy researchers call
- 7:12impression management. So what is impression management? Well, impression management
- 7:24is a psychological process by which individuals consciously or unconsciously
- 7:28attempt to control how they are perceived by others. Who
- 7:31draws from Irving Goffman's framework dramatical journal framework where social
- 7:37life is understood as a performance. You remember Shakespeare even
- 7:39said it right, Remember we are all actors in the
- 7:42stage of the world. I'm paraphrasing and probably didn't do
- 7:44a good job. Back to Goffman's framework, social life is
- 7:48understood as a performance and the stealth is strategically presented
- 7:51depending on the audience and context. Basically, as Young put
- 7:54it is a persona the more core mechanisms including gratiation,
- 7:59cultivating like a ability through charm, flattery and warmth, self promotion,
- 8:04emphasizing competence and intelligence, which we saw with Bundy a
- 8:07lot both of these, exemplification projecting moral virtue or integrity,
- 8:13intimidation using dominance or threat to establish control. This is
- 8:16less relevant in Bundy's case in regards to the general
- 8:18public supplication, performing vulnerability or helplessness to elicit sympathy, which
- 8:23he did. Bundany's arguably the most instructive forensic example of
- 8:27pathological impression management. His effectiveness was rooted in several convergent factors.
- 8:32He cultivated a persona of conventionality. Bundy was handsome, well spoken,
- 8:38politically connected, and enrolled in law school.
- 8:41Speaker 1: He looked like the person anyone would.
- 8:43Speaker 2: Suspect, and he knew it that surface presentation was not
- 8:46incidental but weaponized. He used feigned helplessness as a predatory tactic,
- 8:53often approaching victims while wearing a fake caste or sling
- 8:56and asking for assistance. This inverted the perceived threat dynamic entirely.
- 9:01He positioned himself as the vulnerable party, activating the victim's
- 9:05pro social instincts. In his trials, he represented himself using
- 9:10the courtrooms another stage. He was charming to the judge,
- 9:13flirtatious with female observers, and composed under pressure. He understood
- 9:18the competent legal performance with signal sanity, intelligence, and control
- 9:23to the jury and the media. So we continue on.
- 9:32Psychopathic offenders are often not socially awkward monsters, and neither
- 9:36was Bundy. Some are highly skilled at appearing charismatic. In fact,
- 9:39one of the defining features of psychopathy is the ability
- 9:42to mimic emotional normo normalcy convincingly. Bundy understood social presentation
- 9:49extraordinarily well, and media amplified it. Televised trials transformed him into.
- 9:56Speaker 1: A cultural spectacle.
- 9:58Speaker 2: You could say this is important psychologically because repeated media
- 10:04exposure creates familiarity, and familiarity can create perceived intimacy. Psychologists
- 10:10call this parasocial relationship. It's a one sided emotional bond
- 10:15form with someone who does not actually know you. Celebrities
- 10:19generate parasocial attachment all the time, but notorious criminals can
- 10:24generate it too, especially when media reportedly repeatedly focuses on appearance, charm, intelligence,
- 10:32or emotional backstory. Bondy wasn't alone. Ramier is married a
- 10:38supporter while on death row. Charles Manson maintained devoted followers
- 10:42decades after orchestrating murders even had some making money off
- 10:46his shirts and pictures. Faces Jeffrey Dahmer continued receiving admiration
- 10:51and other details of cannibalism and murder after the details
- 10:55of cannibalism and murder became public. More recently, act like
- 11:00Chris Walltz have received romantic support from strangers online. The
- 11:04pattern repeats across generations, and every generation think it's uniquely shocking,
- 11:09but psychologically the mechanisms remain surprisingly consistent. One of the
- 11:15strongest theoretical frameworks for understanding the ted Mundy effect comes
- 11:20from attachment theory. Attachment theory proposes that early relationships shape
- 11:24later emotional expectations. Children exposed to instability, neglect, unpredictability, abuse,
- 11:31or inconsistent caregiving may develop insecure attachment styles. Some individuals
- 11:37grow up associating love with emotional volatility. Intensity becomes confused
- 11:43with intimacy, danger becomes confused with passion. Fear becomes intertwined
- 11:48with attachment, and this is clinically important because many violent
- 11:54offenders initially present themselves as emotionally intense, dominant, protective, or
- 12:01psychologically consuming. For someone with unresolved detachment wounds, the intensity
- 12:08can feel emotionally magnetic, doesn't feel safe. It's definitely not healthy,
- 12:14but psychologically familiar, and familiarity often feels compelling. Psychodynamic psychology
- 12:21sometimes describes us as repetition compulsion, the unconscious tendency to
- 12:26recreate unresolved emotional dynamics. A person repeatedly drawn toward dangerous
- 12:32partners may unconsciously be attempting to master earlier emotional wounds.
- 12:38In other words, if I can finally make this dangerous
- 12:40personal love me, maybe I can heal something unresolved inside myself. Now,
- 12:45to be clear, this does not mean everyone attracted to
- 12:48criminals has trauma, nor does trauma automatically produce maladaptive attraction.
- 12:54Most trauma survivors, the overwhelming majority, never develop hybristophelia, but
- 13:00clinically unresolved trauma parents can increase vulnerability to dangerous relational dynamics,
- 13:06especially when it's combined with low self esteem, identity diffusion, loneliness,
- 13:12dependency needs, or emotional deprivation, and many offenders will exploit
- 13:17this intentionally. Highly psychopathic individuals are often exceptionally skilled at
- 13:23identifying emotional vulnerabilities. Unfortunately, they have pretty high emotional intelligence.
- 13:28They can read people really well. They marror needs very
- 13:32well as too, they create illusions of intimacy. They can
- 13:36alternate affection with emotional manipulation, and for psychologically vulnerable individuals,
- 13:41interment intermittent reinforcement can create powerful attachment bonds the same
- 13:48conditioning principles observed in abusive relationships. Take a break for
- 13:54a second, folks, and hey, don't forget to share and
- 13:56subscribe this podcast if you're enjoying it. You can also
- 13:58catch some of our other ones, Old Cases Solved, where
- 14:02we highlight cases that have been solved recently, Cold cases.
- 14:06Speaker 1: We just did an episode on one that was solved.
- 14:08Speaker 2: There was a forty year old murder, hopefully providing hope
- 14:11and to those who have lost someone due to a
- 14:15heinous crime or a murder. Also, you can catch some
- 14:20of our other podcasts, Stories of Special Forces Operators and Spycraft,
- 14:25where we talk about espionage stories current in the past
- 14:29the Special Forces. We have a lot of interviews with
- 14:31Special Forces operators as well as insight and psychologically about
- 14:36how they operate. Back to our episode, one of the
- 14:40darker realities in forensic settings is this some violent offenders
- 14:44become more attractive because they're feared. Fear and arousal activate
- 14:48overlapping physiological systems.
- 14:50Speaker 1: We've seen this if you remember the study with people going.
- 14:53Speaker 2: Across the bridge and they had people asking them how attractive.
- 14:58Speaker 1: They were, and they were rating them.
- 15:00Speaker 2: When they moved the bridge and shook it, the individual's
- 15:04heightened arousal made the people score higher on one to
- 15:08ten scale. For some individuals like this, danger itself becomes
- 15:12eroticized psychologically, again not common, but clinically documented. Another major
- 15:20psychological components where clinicians sometimes can formally call the savior fantasy.
- 15:26The belief often sounds like everyone misunderstands him. I see
- 15:30the real person underneath. He would never hurt me. I
- 15:34can change him. This dynamic appears frequently an abusive relationships,
- 15:38generally not just criminal attraction. We see this a lot
- 15:41of intimate partner violence. The partner becomes psychologically framed as wounded, misunderstood,
- 15:47or emotionally damaged or secretly redeemable. The relationship then provides
- 15:52the admirer with a sense of purpose the uniqueness, emotional importance,
- 15:56or identity psychodynamic terms. The individual may derive self worth
- 16:00through rescuing the criminal becomes less a person and more
- 16:04psychological project Now, prison settings intensify the fantasy formation dramatically.
- 16:12But why Because real world intimacy is limited. Most interactions
- 16:17occur through what letters, phone calls, control visits, fantasy imagination.
- 16:23The offender controls the narrative, and without ordinary day to
- 16:27day relationship stressors, well idealization can flourish. The admirer sees fragments,
- 16:34not the full personality. This creates fertile ground for projection.
- 16:39People project fantasies onto the offender strength, sensitivity, intelligence, vulnerability,
- 16:47and misunderstood brilliance. Meanwhile, the actual violence becomes psychologically minimized
- 16:54or compartmentalized.
- 16:56Speaker 1: This cognitive process is called splitting.
- 16:58Speaker 2: The offender becomes psychologically divided into a monster everyone talks
- 17:03about versus the special person only I truly understand, And
- 17:08once someone emotionally commits to that narrative, contradictory evidence often
- 17:13gets rationalized away. That's where cognitive distortions become critically important. Denial, rationalization,
- 17:24or some of the defense mechanisms we call idealization fantasy.
- 17:31What role does social media play in all this? And media,
- 17:35unfortunately not a good one. Modern media has dramatically amplified
- 17:39the hyperstophilic tendencies, especially social media platforms like TikTok or Instagram, Reddit, Tumblr,
- 17:48and YouTube, have created ecosystems where criminal offenders can become asynthesized, romanticized,
- 17:54even edited clips attractive actors, dramatic music, courtroom footage. The
- 18:02fender becomes transformed into a symbolic character rather than a
- 18:06human being responsible for heinous crimes and real suffering. This
- 18:12creates moral and psychological distortion for the audience. For example,
- 18:17after the Netflix series on Jeffrey Dahmer was released, social
- 18:21media became flooded with romanticized edits of the killer. Many
- 18:26victim families publicly criticize this phenomenon because from their perspective,
- 18:31and it's true, their levels were being erased while the
- 18:33offender became entertainment and we see that constantly. This raises
- 18:39major ethical concerns through crime media occupies a difficult psychological space.
- 18:45On one hand, education awareness an investigative journalism can provide
- 18:50a legitimate public value.
- 18:53Speaker 1: On the other, repetitive.
- 18:55Speaker 2: Sensationalism can unintentionally glorify offenders, especially when attractiveness is emphasized,
- 19:05trauma histories are overhumanized, or violence becomes stylized entertainment. There's
- 19:10also something psychologically seductive about proximity to notoriety. Some individuals
- 19:16feel psychologically elevated through association with infamous figures, almost like
- 19:21proximity to power, even destructive power. And historically society is
- 19:26often confused notoriety with importance, and that confusion matters. One
- 19:33of the most dangerous outcomes occurs when empathy becomes detached
- 19:36from accountability. I think the new book that just came
- 19:41out might represent this interestingly enough, Gadsad's book Suicidal Empathy
- 19:47Understanding Why someone became violent psychologically valuable, but understanding should
- 19:53never become romanticization. Forensic psychology aims to explain behavior.
- 19:59Speaker 1: And not excuse.
- 20:01Speaker 2: Again, I don't get anything for the promo because suicidal
- 20:05empathy is an interesting ones.
- 20:06Speaker 1: I believe one of the chapters dealt with this concept.
- 20:12Speaker 2: So what does Hybristophelia ultimately teach us in the end? Well,
- 20:18it teaches us something uncomfortable. Human attraction is not always rational.
- 20:27People are sometimes drawn toward intensity instead of stability, dominance
- 20:33instead of safety, fantasy instead of reality, emotional chaos instead
- 20:41of emotional health, and modern media ecosystems can magnify those vulnerabilities.
- 20:49From a forensic psychology perspective, hybristophilia sits at the intersection
- 20:53of several components, one being attachment pathology, trauma dynamics, paris
- 21:02social bonding. As we explained earlier, sensation seeking, cognitive distortions,
- 21:08not looking at reality the way it is, just like
- 21:10fantasy formation and cultural storytelling. But we should also avoid
- 21:16simplistic judgment. Many individuals involved in these dynamics are psychologically
- 21:22vulnerable rather than malicious. Some are profoundly lonely, some are
- 21:28trauma survivors, some are searching for identity, some are captivated
- 21:33by danger and power, and some become psychologically consumed by
- 21:38fantasy narratives that gradually detach from reality. At the same time,
- 21:43violent offenders frequently exploit these vulnerabilities, particularly the psychopath. The
- 21:49psychopath offenders skilled or skilled the manipulation as I mentioned earlier,
- 21:54and that reality cannot be ignored. The broader lesson here
- 21:58may be this. Human beings often crave meaning, intensity, and
- 22:03emotional significance, and when those needs go unmet in healthy ways,
- 22:09well many times they can attach themselves to dangerous people
- 22:13and dangerous narratives, which is why psychological literacy matters. Understanding
- 22:20manipulation matters, Understanding attachment patterns matters, Understanding how media shapes
- 22:28perception matters, because once fantasy overwhelms critical thinking, risk assessment deteriorates.
- 22:38In forensic psychology, deteriorating risk assessment can have devastating consequences. Well,
- 22:45hopefully you enjoyed today's podcast episode on this rare phenomena
- 22:51of what's happening here in hybristophilia, And as a little
- 22:55bit of a bonus, let's look at some of the
- 22:58data in regards to the endivid's very limited research on it,
- 23:02because it's considered still relatively rare and it is understudied.
- 23:08It is reported mostly in women, more so than men.
- 23:10Often focused on male offenders, frequently associated with high profile
- 23:15violent criminals such as serial killers or notorious gangsters. Common
- 23:21demographic patterns found than research where gender. Most cases documented
- 23:25involve women attracted male defenders, especially offenders proceed as dominant, dangerous, charismatic,
- 23:31famous right they can attach their own identity to this
- 23:33famous person. Research is repeatedly note that female attraction to
- 23:37male violent offenders is far more commonly documented than the reverse. However,
- 23:43male hyprostophelia does exist. One forensic paper described men becoming
- 23:48sexually emotionally attached to a female serial killer in assisting.
- 23:51Speaker 1: Her crimes age.
- 23:53Speaker 2: When you look at this population the sample, modern online
- 23:57studies suggests a phenomenon is increasingly invisible among late adolescents,
- 24:01young adults, and gen Z social media users.
- 24:07Speaker 1: Education.
- 24:07Speaker 2: One of the interesting findings is that hybristophelia is not
- 24:10limited to one social class. Some are educated, some held
- 24:14stable employment, some had trauma histories, although these are not
- 24:17fit obvious clinical stereotypes. Several studies in forensic theories suggest
- 24:22higher rates of childhood and stability, abusive relationships, and trauma exposure,
- 24:27but it is important to understand these are risk correlations
- 24:30not in universal findings, and that many people with trauma
- 24:33histories do not develop the hyperstic hybrostophilic interests.
- 24:37Speaker 1: Actually the majority don't.
- 24:40Speaker 2: Researchers frequently described recurring themes we talked about earlier. The
- 24:45data is pretty weak on the prevalence. We don't have
- 24:47a universal accepted prevalence rate for it. Most studies use
- 24:51prison pen pals, courtroom fan communities, online forums, things of
- 24:55that nature, and the attraction to bad boys is not
- 25:00is not the same as attraction to serial murderers, so
- 25:06there's different degrees of it as well. That as we
- 25:09talked about passive and aggressive or active. So hopefully you've
- 25:15enjoyed this podcast. If we found the episode valuable, please subscribe,
- 25:19leave a review, hit the like button, share it with others,
- 25:23and as always, stay curious, stay psychologically aware, and never
- 25:27underestimate the complexity of human behavior.