Latest / Before you say yes / Ep 5. Debt doesn't care who walks away: Before you say yes to getting into debt together
Transcript
- 0:02Before you say yes, have an honest and transparent conversation about everything to do with your finances and your partner's finances.
- 0:13Before you say yes, I would say to people, stop and think about what you want, what it is that you deserve and make sure that you're protected.
- 0:21Thank you.
- 0:22I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick, former senior bank executive, now working with companies, governments and regulators around the world to change the way financial products are designed.
- 0:32This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask before you share your money, your accounts and your digital life with someone you love.
- 0:43So before you say yes to getting into debt with someone else, listen to this.
- 0:49Most of us have signed up for debt at some stage in our life, a credit card, a car loan, a buy now pay later account, a mortgage.
- 0:58When we sign up on our own, it's straightforward because we're responsible for paying it back.
- 1:04But have you ever stopped to think about what shared debt actually means and who's responsible for it if your relationship ends or your circumstances change?
- 1:15David Koch, Kochie, to most of us, has been helping Australians make sense of their money for decades.
- 1:22He's a financial commentator.
- 1:23He's been married to Lib for 47 years.
- 1:26He's a dad of four and a grandfather of 10.
- 1:30Most couples end up sharing money, a joint account.
- 1:34They might have a mortgage.
- 1:37They might have a car together.
- 1:39But they don't always think about it or talk about it together before they fall into it.
- 1:46So I'm really interested.
- 1:47It's not very romantic, is it, to talk about money when you're in love with somebody and all of that.
- 1:53But it's a question you've got to have.
- 1:55Yeah.
- 1:55So how do we make it romantic?
- 1:58Okay.
- 1:58Okay.
- 1:59And it's all about getting life in order before you get into a long-term relationship.
- 2:09And particularly if you're going to share financial commitments and things like that.
- 2:15And you've got to talk about it.
- 2:17I reckon because you're a team.
- 2:21You're a team in life.
- 2:23You're a team in finance.
- 2:25You're a team in love.
- 2:26You're a team in love.
- 2:27And with money, you've got to work as a team, always.
- 2:30And I always say to people, once a month,
- 2:35spend 15 minutes, I call it love money.
- 2:40It's a love money session where you love your money.
- 2:43And you sit down, it's only half an episode of Home and Away.
- 2:47So in the overall scheme of things, it's not a lot of time.
- 2:50Liv and I usually get cheese and biscuits.
- 2:53I open a bottle of red and inevitably last longer than 15 minutes.
- 2:59but just talk about your money.
- 3:01Not going through credit card statements and going, why'd you buy this?
- 3:03Why'd you buy that?
- 3:05It is, hey, anything worrying you.
- 3:08Anything that you need to know.
- 3:12So how do you start that, step into that conversation if it feels uncomfortable at first?
- 3:18Yeah.
- 3:19Look, it's, I think it's almost you're compatible in love, interests, friends, that sort of stuff.
- 3:28It's almost putting it in that bucket and saying, okay, let's talk about are we compatible financially?
- 3:37Are you a good saver or are you a spender?
- 3:40You know, those little things can, after a while, irritate you if you're not on the same page or you're not aware.
- 3:50oh, can't believe they go shopping for this and that, while the other partner just loves to see their account balance go up in their savings account.
- 4:00Got to talk about those sort of things because...
- 4:04Breakups, divorces, you know, 50% of them are because of financial stress or financial incompatibility.
- 4:14And so right from the very start, you've got just in a fun way, cheese and crackers, glass of wine, oh, you're savor or what do you do?
- 4:24Do you set yourself financial goals?
- 4:27And I've got a lead as one partner if you want to open the subject.
- 4:32Oh, I love to save.
- 4:34You know, this is my financial goal.
- 4:36And just ease into it rather than say, do you have any credit card debt?
- 4:40How many credit cards do you have?
- 4:42That comes further down the line.
- 4:44But the icebreaker is, oh, what are your goals?
- 4:48But any little warning flags of...
- 4:53money that disappears or they want to control their money very secretively or, worst case, they want to then control yours because you're a team.
- 5:07They're real red flags for me.
- 5:10Everyone's just got to be so transparent.
- 5:12There should be no money issue at all that shouldn't be talked about.
- 5:22oh, don't you trust me, well, then you've got to be thinking in your own mind, well, maybe I shouldn't.
- 5:30Don't you love me?
- 5:32Don't you trust me?
- 5:34It's not about that.
- 5:36It's about being honest and protecting yourself.
- 5:43The red flags Kochie describes rarely announce themselves.
- 5:47We often fall into financial arrangements at the start of a relationship when we're madly in love, even when our spidey senses are tingling.
- 5:57Simone Weston is an executive leader, keynote speaker and women's advocate that has survived domestic violence and financial abuse.
- 6:08I had set myself up with safeguards, or so I thought, around the banking, but I had
- 6:15Prior to coming into our relationship, a credit card existed that he had as part of his family.
- 6:19They had different account holders.
- 6:22And when we got into our relationship, I had the safeguards around the banks.
- 6:27But he said to me, like, it makes sense for us to put it on that card because we get all these amazing benefits from it.
- 6:36And at the time, my body said, no, I didn't like it.
- 6:40I didn't like that I didn't have my own account.
- 6:42I like my own card.
- 6:44And I asked to get my own card.
- 6:45And it was like, no, you can't do that.
- 6:47And so in the beginning, I was getting the statements and saying,
- 6:53He was paying the bills and it's kind of like that visibility versus control gap.
- 6:57I didn't notice the gap until the relationship deteriorated and then he stopped giving me the statements.
- 7:05For a woman who thought she was going into it quite intelligently and protected, that one decision cost me everything.
- 7:13And I lost visibility.
- 7:15I lost control of where the money was going.
- 7:18And he had complete control.
- 7:20We got some financial advice and they were asking questions that I'd been really curious about for a long time because I didn't have visibility.
- 7:27And so when you don't have visibility, the story to me was we need to be really financially prudent.
- 7:33There isn't a lot of money.
- 7:34You need to not spend.
- 7:35And so I wasn't really living much of a life.
- 7:39And then when we had this conversation, I realised he was living like a king and I was living like a pauper.
- 7:46You speak about power and you teach people about power.
- 7:50What do you mean when you say structural power?
- 7:53Every system, like the banks, the telcos, the energy providers have been set up and structured to have a named authority on the account.
- 8:01Yeah.
- 8:02If you are the named account holder, you have structural power, you have power in that system.
- 8:07And so you can call them, you can ask questions, you can make changes, you can act.
- 8:14If you are not the authorised account holder, even if you use it every single day, your life runs through it, you don't exist.
- 8:20You have zero power in that system.
- 8:22And so why this matters is, in a healthy relationship, it doesn't necessarily, but
- 8:28The person whose name on the account holds the power.
- 8:31And so if they choose to use it against you, they can block you, they can freeze you, they have control.
- 8:37And so they can really use it against you.
- 8:40In a healthy relationship, you don't notice it, but a system, structural power, can't
- 8:45doesn't know if a relationship is healthy or not.
- 8:48It just cares about the named account holder.
- 8:51And that's why it is so important for people to understand the structural power, the systems power, but particularly in this context, their name that is on the accounts, because it will either give them permission to act or not.
- 9:04When did you come to an understanding about that structural power?
- 9:09When it was too late.
- 9:12When I realised, like, I don't exist in the system.
- 9:15And so I kind of...
- 9:18I found myself in a position where I was like, I'm really educated and I thought I was going into it eyes wide open.
- 9:24I really wasn't as blind to this as some people are, but I actually was around structural power.
- 9:31This deceit is what Kochie calls financial infidelity.
- 9:37You're cheating.
- 9:38If you've got secret credit cards
- 9:41that only you know about or debts that only you know about, then you've got to declare it.
- 9:50And particularly in this day and age of going to the bank of mum and dad, if you want to get help getting into property, I always say to mum and dad, be a bank.
- 10:07Never give the money, lend the money, because if your child's partner walks out, I'd rather them walk out with half of a debt to me than half an asset that they're just going to take away.
- 10:26So it is a big responsibility and you'll be amazed, absolutely amazed,
- 10:34how many people fall for the traps and find themselves in all sorts of problems.
- 10:40We hear the term joint account all the time and you've talked about that, but what do people think it means and what does it actually mean?
- 10:47Okay, I think joint accounts, joint loans, the whole thing, everybody goes, oh, it's joint, it's fair, I'm responsible or am entitled to.
- 11:0250% of the joint savings account or I'm responsible for half the joint debt on a credit card or a mortgage.
- 11:13But what it really means is, no, no, no, no, you are responsible for the entire debt if your partner walks out and won't pay their share.
- 11:24And with your joint savings account, you're responsible for the entire debt.
- 11:29you are responsible for the entire balance as your partner is.
- 11:34Now, in a joint savings account,
- 11:39Your partner's just not limited to taking out their half of the joint.
- 11:43They're entitled to take a whole lot.
- 11:46And there have been lots of stories where a partner has walked out and said, see you later, and the other partner has gone to their joint savings account and it has been cleaned out.
- 11:57Yeah.
- 11:57So, yeah, joint is you.
- 12:01This is going into what I've been calling my feminerd territory because I love reading terms and conditions.
- 12:09Catherine, you are a very special person.
- 12:11If you love reading terms and conditions.
- 12:14You know, we know it's really weird.
- 12:15You're a nerd.
- 12:16I am a nerd.
- 12:17I like to say I'm a feminerd.
- 12:19I think there's a hashtag.
- 12:21But I've been trying to explain to people if you take a look, say in your mortgage or any other account where there's a debt,
- 12:28There's that expression joint and several liability, and it's exactly like you've talked about.
- 12:33It doesn't mean you're only on the hook for 50%.
- 12:35You're actually on the hook for the whole 100%.
- 12:38Why do you think people don't quite understand that?
- 12:40Is it the banks are not telling us enough about it, or is it we go in a little bit blindly?
- 12:47I think we go in a bit blindly.
- 12:50Reading terms and conditions is...
- 12:52Boring.
- 12:53Boring and can take a fair bit of time.
- 12:57They should be advised with the lender, and the lender often says you need to get your own independent advice to each of the borrowers.
- 13:09I reckon that rarely ever happens.
- 13:12Now with...
- 13:14With AI, and if you subscribe to Claude or one of those, you can put the terms and conditions into Claude and say, what do I need to watch out for in these terms and conditions?
- 13:26And Claude very quickly puts it through.
- 13:28So I think AI is going to be an absolute boom for financial literacy and risk management in financials.
- 13:37But you've got to be aware of all.
- 13:39And a lot of people say to me, I have this saying,
- 13:44You can delegate some financial responsibility to the other member of the team.
- 13:50Like I delegate the household budget to Libb.
- 13:53but you can never surrender responsibility.
- 13:57And you've always got to be aware there is no excuse.
- 14:01None of this, I find it too complicated, I'm not interested, it takes too much time, whatever.
- 14:07I don't care.
- 14:08It's your money.
- 14:10You've got to spend a bit of time looking at it and understanding what you're in for because it will pay off into the future.
- 14:19And then what about as you're moving through life and you've got some of those other things that are happening?
- 14:25We don't always talk also about the things that might go wrong.
- 14:29So when you're doing the planning, so you're walking in, it's all hunky-dory, but what about when life happens?
- 14:36And life does happen, and particularly when.
- 14:38If you're part of a small business, that's another layer of responsibility.
- 14:46I've had family businesses virtually lived in my whole married life.
- 14:52And it is if you're a director of a small business, if you're a
- 14:58in a relationship with a tradie or married to a tradie and you're a director of their small business, it is understanding your responsibilities there.
- 15:11The golden rule is you never sign anything, never sign anything until you understand it and it's explained to you.
- 15:19Never.
- 15:21If you're in a relationship where, and I know it can be really easy because life's...
- 15:28very busy for everyone, hey, can you just sign this for the accountant?
- 15:32Well, no, you stop.
- 15:35Even though you're busy, you stop and go, I'm not going to sign it now.
- 15:40Let's set that aside where in tonight or in two days' time or when we catch up for our monthly, talking about money, you explain to me what I'm signing.
- 15:53Yeah.
- 15:54And leave the document with me so I can read it.
- 15:57And let's talk about it.
- 15:59And you tell me why it's so important.
- 16:00I need it.
- 16:01And, you know, it could be an ASIC document.
- 16:03It could be anything.
- 16:06It could be administrative bureaucratic.
- 16:10And the answer's pretty simple to give you.
- 16:13But it could be something different as well.
- 16:14It could be, hey, you're guaranteed for an overdraft that we're going in for the bank, understanding what that means for you.
- 16:25Sue Fraser has spent more than 30 years as a financial counsellor.
- 16:29She has sat across from people when the emotional realities of relationships collide with the fine print.
- 16:36And she'll tell you most of them didn't see it coming, not because they weren't paying attention, but because nobody told them what they'd actually agreed to.
- 16:47I mean, I used to see lots of young people going into mortgages or even for guarantors for other people in terms of money, and they almost always end in disaster because they didn't understand the consequence of what it was that they were signing.
- 17:02No one believes that they could lose their own house because they guaranteed someone else's loan.
- 17:08But if that was explained to them in an honest and open way, then you might have a different conversation and you might decide not to proceed.
- 17:15And I've had a lot of conversations with people about, so this contract could be joint and several liability.
- 17:23Do you know what that means?
- 17:25And most people think it means, oh, it's a 50-50 loan.
- 17:30Tell me, what is joint and severally liability?
- 17:33And tell me some other areas that we should be looking for as well in understanding what is that legal construct.
- 17:40If someone has a contract where it's jointly and severally liable, it means that if they can't get the money from me, they'll get it from you.
- 17:48Right.
- 17:49So that if I'm out of the picture, 100% of that debt will come to you and you'll be pursued for that.
- 17:55If people are starting to move in together, they're starting to share bills, sign a lease, open a joint account, maybe even start thinking about saving for really big expenses like a car or a home.
- 18:08What are they really agreeing to, whether they realise it or not?
- 18:15They're usually not agreeing to much in a voluntary informed capacity.
- 18:20You know, someone will have a credit card or get a credit card and there'll be a second card off that, but not understanding the financial and legal obligations that sit with it.
- 18:29When we buy a car together or when we buy a home together,
- 18:33You know, how that contract's structured is really important.
- 18:36And most people buy as joint owners.
- 18:40Some younger people are now buying as tenants in common, which means that if we have a house together and I conk out, my half can be willed to whoever I want it to be.
- 18:49Now, that might create a problem for you if I leave my half to someone who you might not get on with or don't think that's appropriate.
- 18:56But they're the discussions that need to happen.
- 18:59It's about how do we protect ourselves, but how do we protect each other?
- 19:03It's not always a one-way street.
- 19:06It's about being really clear about what it is that we've agreed to and understanding what the ramifications are.
- 19:12Kochie's been talking about this for a long time.
- 19:16In 2004, he wrote a book with his wife, Lib, about money and relationships.
- 19:21What would you say if you were going to write the book now
- 19:26instead of it being the 10 things you do before you get emotional after they leave, what about the 10 things you do as you're right in the throes of emotion?
- 19:35Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 19:36Or the 10 things you do when you're about to commit to a long-term relationship.
- 19:41Yeah.
- 19:41What would be on that list?
- 19:42Okay.
- 19:43Oh, it would be having the conversation.
- 19:46It would be setting the ground rules of how our money is going to be managed.
- 19:52It might be a joint account and kick off in the early stages of a relationship while you're building that trust because you really don't know someone unless you've lived with them for a fair amount of time, I don't think,
- 20:13the short-term romance will go and you become friends and you become partners and you become a team.
- 20:19That's a big step forward and that's where it all, you get to really know the person going forward.
- 20:26So it is, okay.
- 20:28How do we sort out our banking?
- 20:30How do we sort out the income we both earn?
- 20:33How do we divvy it up?
- 20:35What are the financial goals?
- 20:36What are each of our responsibilities in terms of managing different parts of the household budget or just our financial relationship?
- 20:45And getting that all done quickly, our estate planning, what are we going to do with wills?
- 20:51Insurances, do we add each other as beneficiaries?
- 20:55Do you become my designated beneficiary on my super?
- 20:59You know, absolutely.
- 21:00Today, that's a big commitment.
- 21:02That's a big sign of a relationship.
- 21:05So it's all of those issues I think you need to discuss.
- 21:11And that's just part of having a healthy relationship.
- 21:14It shouldn't be intimidating.
- 21:16So I think what I'm really taking away from this conversation is eyes wide open and the curiosity to have the conversation together.
- 21:25And you're not loving your partner.
- 21:27You're not.
- 21:29distrusting them, and they shouldn't take it that way either.
- 21:34It is you want to satisfy yourself.
- 21:39You want to understand what you want to be involved in.
- 21:43in the financial side of the relationship.
- 21:45And you should be because it's your money.
- 21:48It's your commitment.
- 21:49It's your risk in terms of any loans that you might have.
- 21:57And that's just part of a healthy relationship.
- 22:01People that say to me, oh, I'm really uncomfortable talking about it.
- 22:05Why?
- 22:05You know?
- 22:06We'll talk about our family.
- 22:08We talk about our sex lives with each other.
- 22:11All that.
- 22:11Why can't you talk about money?
- 22:14It's just part of life.
- 22:15It's part of a relationship.
- 22:17But everyone goes this taboo thing, oh, I don't want to upset anybody or think that I don't trust them.
- 22:25No, you're just protecting yourself.
- 22:29So what about when the team does it really well?
- 22:32How does that feel?
- 22:33I know.
- 22:34We've been sounding very serious, haven't we, with all of the pitfalls you've got to watch out for.
- 22:40But if you're working well as a team financially, you're not going to be able to do it.
- 22:44It's just a wonderful experience.
- 22:47So all that financial stress lifts off your shoulders because you're talking to someone about it.
- 22:53You're sharing issues.
- 22:54You're sharing goals.
- 22:56You're achieving goals because you're on the same financial page.
- 23:00So it can be a wonderful, liberating experience when you get it right, and so many people do.
- 23:10My takeaway from Kochie, Simone and Sue.
- 23:14Debt you share isn't half-half.
- 23:17Joint doesn't mean your home loan is split down the middle.
- 23:20The law doesn't see halves.
- 23:22And when you're madly in love at the start of a relationship, you might not either.
- 23:27So before you say yes to sharing debt with someone, do this.
- 23:32Understand what joint actually means.
- 23:34Joint doesn't always mean equal.
- 23:37On a loan with joint and several liability, the most common lending to consumers, you're not on the hook for half.
- 23:45You're on the hook for all of it.
- 23:47If your partner stops paying or walks away, the lender can come to you for the entire debt plus interest.
- 23:56And a joint savings account works the same way in reverse.
- 24:00Either of you can withdraw the whole balance anytime without the other's permission.
- 24:05There are plenty of stories of an account being emptied the day a relationship ended.
- 24:11Know which accounts you're on and what that exposes you to.
- 24:15There's a difference between the asset and the debt.
- 24:18They're two different legal questions.
- 24:21Joint tenants and tenants in common are about the asset.
- 24:25Who owns what share of the property and what can happen to it?
- 24:30You can choose this.
- 24:32Joint and several liability is about the debt.
- 24:36Who's on the hook if it doesn't get paid?
- 24:39And there are other debt structures too where liability is split differently.
- 24:44They're more commonly used in business.
- 24:46You should check which structure applies and what it means for you personally.
- 24:52Have visibility always.
- 24:55Make sure statements and account communications come directly to you as well as your partner.
- 25:00You can delegate the day-to-day management of your finances, but don't surrender responsibility.
- 25:07It's too complicated is not a reason to look away.
- 25:12It's your money.
- 25:13It's your risk.
- 25:15Never sign anything until you understand it.
- 25:18Not for an accountant, not for a lender, not for a partner, not for anyone who says it's urgent.
- 25:24Just stop.
- 25:26Ask what you're signing.
- 25:27Ask for the document.
- 25:29Read it.
- 25:30And if it can't be explained to you clearly, that's a reason to pause, not to hurry up.
- 25:36Understand what guarantor really means before you agree to it.
- 25:41If you guarantee someone else's loan, including your child's mortgage, you could be made to repay the whole loan if they don't.
- 25:50And if you've put up your own home as the security, the lender can sell it to recover the debt.
- 25:57When your next joint statement lands in your inbox or your mailbox, stop and ask yourself the question,
- 26:03Do I still know what I've agreed to?
- 26:05Because love shouldn't cost you freedom.