Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Special Episode: Supporting Employees Through Wildfire Disasters: Legal Guidance for Employers
Transcript
- 0:00This program and the associated written materials are provided for informational purposes only
- 0:04and are not intended and must not be taken as legal advice on any particular set of facts
- 0:10or circumstances. You should not act or refrain from acting on the basis of any content included
- 0:15in this program without seeking legal or other professional advice on your specific matter.
- 0:20This program contains general information and may not reflect current legal developments
- 0:24or address your specific situation. This program and the associated written materials
- 0:29are not intended as a solicitation.
- 0:34My name is Mary Hevner. I'm joined by my colleagues Steve Johnson and Anna Michela,
- 0:40and we've been asked by the Beverly Hills Bar Association to explain some of the tax rules
- 0:47that employers can use and charities and employers' sponsored charities can use
- 0:53to assist employees who are affected by disasters. Certainly, pre-eminent among them right now is the
- 1:01well-centralist wildfires that were, a lot of us have friends and colleagues or a firm has an office
- 1:08in and it has a lot of employees who are also affected, so we're delighted to be able to help
- 1:14here. I was going to explain a little bit of the background regarding some of the tax rules
- 1:20that are applicable, and I'm going to let Steve and Anna do a lot of this discussion with respect
- 1:25to the individual slides. So, if you start with the first slide, I'll explain some of the tax
- 1:30background here supporting these various changes. We're going to discuss a code section that allows
- 1:37employers to provide relief payments to any people. It doesn't have to be limited to employees. It
- 1:44can be anyone who's affected by a qualified disaster, and that means a flood, a tornado,
- 1:51COVID, any particular disaster that's been recognized in the presidential declaration
- 1:57as being a disaster that amounts to something that would qualify for a lot of different tax
- 2:05reliefs. It takes the presidential declaration to have a qualified disaster. If you have one,
- 2:10you can use section 139. We're going to discuss leave donation programs, and I'll explain in a
- 2:18minute how those work, and we're also going to discuss relief through tax exempt organizations,
- 2:23and many instances, large employers will set up foundations that may be able to help employees.
- 2:29I'm going to spend a minute before we discuss the details of the current rules on this concept of
- 2:34leave donations. There is an extremely longstanding rule in the tax law indicating that any worker
- 2:43an employee in independent contract or anyone who earns money, but then wants to say, oh,
- 2:48don't pay me, pay someone else. Don't pay me, pay for my children's education. Don't pay me,
- 2:55pay something for my mother who needs money. Don't pay me, pay a church. Don't pay me,
- 3:01pay someone else. If an individual requests those kinds of transfers of compensation under the very
- 3:09longstanding tax law, all of those contributions are still taxed to the person who performs the
- 3:16services. Those rules were changed to a limited extent in 1990 when the Internal Revenue Service
- 3:23developed a rule allowing employees to donate their leave and have employers set up leave banks
- 3:30to assist employees who were suffering from medical emergencies. It's a very limited exception.
- 3:38It was expressed by the IRS in a revenue ruling issued in 1990. It was an odd revenue ruling because
- 3:45it did fly in the face of all these assignment of income rules, but the IRS developed it in
- 3:50recognition that the federal government, indeed nearly all the federal government agencies,
- 3:55operated these kinds of leave donation programs. And the Commissioner of Internal Revenue at the
- 4:00time believed it was unfair to have rules that the federal government could follow and that
- 4:04private sector people could not follow. So you've had a rule in place since the 1990s that permits
- 4:10very limited programs whereby companies can have employees assign back their vacation days and have
- 4:18those vacation days be transferred out to people who were in need of vacation because either they're
- 4:24suffering from medical emergency or someone in their immediate family has such an emergency.
- 4:29So those rules were in turn expanded dramatically. First after 9-11,
- 4:35my name and revenue rules that we're going to be discussing today. So that's just the three
- 4:40things we're going to be discussing. And we're going to the next slide and I'll let my compatriots
- 4:46explain some of the rules that can help people to be listening today. I'll take over with code
- 4:54section 139, it covers qualified disaster relief payments. This is a heavy lifting payroll tax
- 5:01exclusion. It's got very specific requirements in order to be triggered, which we'll get to you
- 5:06shortly. But the great thing about the 139 exclusion is that when it applies an employer or
- 5:14quite honestly anyone or any entity can provide disaster relief assistance on a completely
- 5:21non-taxable basis for federal purposes. The law in terms of how it applies for state purposes depends
- 5:28on the state. But it also has the benefits of being deductible to the paying employer unlike
- 5:35many other types of payments for personal expenses. The statute itself came into existence shortly
- 5:46after the September 11th terrorist attacks in which Congress wanted employers and the
- 5:53general public to be able to make contributions to those affected and to do so to cover living
- 5:58expenses that were attributable to the terrorist attacks and receive those payments on a non-taxable
- 6:06basis to the recipient and then also to be able to deduct those payments from an income tax
- 6:11perspective of the payor. The next slide I think has the requirements.
- 6:22The requirements require number one that there be a qualified disaster which is a
- 6:28presentially declared emergency. It has to be announced in accordance with the Robert T. Stafford
- 6:35Emergency Act but essentially it's whenever the President of the United States
- 6:43authorizes FEMA and other government agencies to act under the emergency authority powers
- 6:50the President has. In this case with respect to the Southern California wildfires,
- 6:56former President Biden declared several counties around Los Angeles to be covered within the
- 7:05President's emergency powers. And so essentially the first requirement of Section 139 was triggered
- 7:12as of January 8th and continues to exist today. I believe that the areas that were covered have
- 7:20expanded since by virtue of declarations that FEMA have made underneath that Presidential Declaration
- 7:26of Emergency Authority but that can be figured out by going to the FEMA website which lists
- 7:32counties that are affected. The second requirement under Section 139 is that the assistance is
- 7:40intended to cover out-of-pocket personal living expenses of the recipient. Importantly here is
- 7:49that their personal expenses so they're not business expenses that would otherwise be reimbursed on a
- 7:55non-taxable basis under the working condition fringe rules which Ann will talk about shortly
- 8:01but they're intended to cover personal expenses. They have to be out-of-pocket so it can't be an
- 8:06expense that's otherwise reimbursed by insurance or by some other relief agency. But in terms of
- 8:15what the personal living expenses can be as long as the assistance is intended to be attributable to
- 8:23sort of unforeseen additional expenses that were related to the natural disaster
- 8:30then they can qualify. These can be from everything from food to shelter to clothing to medical
- 8:37to transportation. The assistance can't be extravagant, it can't be lavish, it's supposed to be
- 8:48reasonable under the circumstances so both in terms of the amount, the length of time that
- 8:57the assistance may be provided, those all should be in some form benchmarked to what
- 9:02actual cost or benchmarked to add or under what actual costs are expected to be. And then the last
- 9:08requirement is that the assistance can't be intended to be a wage replacement. And what does
- 9:12that mean? That means that if I make $100 a week just normal times, my regular wages are $100 a week,
- 9:22my employer can't, I'm in an infected area, my employer can't say well we're going to pay you
- 9:27$60 in taxable wages and we're going to convert $40 that we would otherwise pay you into a $139
- 9:35payment because that would violate the the rules. So the employer could continue to pay $100 and then
- 9:40pay an additional $40 on a non-taxable basis but you can't basically recharacterize wages for
- 9:46taxable wages for a $139 payment. Next slide please. Here we are. The IRS has had limited
- 9:54guidance as to what qualifies under $139 but I think the heavy lifting here is is figuring out
- 10:02how to ensure that the assistance is intended to cover out-of-pocket expenses that are
- 10:08attributable to the disaster. So for instance it would be a stretch to say that I live in
- 10:17you know balsades and my house was fine but I had other completely unrelated expenses
- 10:29that had nothing to do with with the wildfire. I have expenses due to a car accident that I was
- 10:38then not related to the wildfire or escaping from the wildfire. Those certainly wouldn't
- 10:43wouldn't wouldn't fly but I think because of the way the statute's written and there are no regulations
- 10:48under the statute the nexus between a qualifying expense and the assistance is relatively open
- 10:55ended. I had a situation for a client that was located in a county affected by a hurricane in
- 11:05the southeast United States and they put parameters around that anyone that works in
- 11:10an affected county or lives in an affected county will get some basic stipend to help them cover
- 11:16transportation expenses, food or shelter as much as they had to evacuate because of the storm.
- 11:24That was a pretty basic policy but beyond that I said if you have one-off questions we can discuss
- 11:31them and there was a situation where the client had a low-level sort of hourly employee who had
- 11:38a child who worked in the northeast but he had a child that was in school in an affected county
- 11:44in I think it was Florida and they wanted to know if they could get assistance from their
- 11:48employer to help evacuate their child from college to come home while their school was closed.
- 11:53There was an interesting question and I only tell the story here because I think it really kind of
- 11:57illustrates the point that that was a personal expense of the employee
- 12:01attributable to a hurricane that closed the employee's child's school and so in that sense
- 12:07it's not completely limited to the list of items here but also you know like with anything
- 12:14what's the expression that pigs get fat and hogs get slaughtered. I think coming at this from an
- 12:19employer's perspective with an attempt at being reasonable without being too excessive and with
- 12:27having some attempt to comply with the statute in terms of the requirements in employee communications
- 12:33and making sure that it's not just a cash grab free giveaway and really is instead intended to
- 12:39cover expenses that are you know very likely to be incurred. I think those are all hallmarks of a
- 12:47139 type of a program that can allow an employer to get assistance out pretty quickly.
- 12:53One other example Steve that we had when COVID was the kind of qualified disaster that had been
- 12:59recognized as such we had a client who had an employee called up and said that during the COVID
- 13:06emergency just before the emergency he purchased a new home that had never gotten any furniture for it
- 13:12and he asked for $350,000 to furnish his house. I mean and we said no I mean that's not an expense
- 13:19as you know we will cover it I mean you may need to go home and live in a house but the fact you
- 13:24don't have any any furniture is not something that's a COVID expense. So you do have to be a little
- 13:29careful but there's not a lot of checking. One other point I should make too is that since 1987
- 13:36as another rule under the tax code it's not possible for an employer to make the gift to an
- 13:42employee. So our employer cannot say look we're just trying to be generous to employees and maybe
- 13:47there are things we can't give under 139 we will just make gifts to employees who are really hurting
- 13:53can't do that either under the code you're just not allowed to make the gift to an employee. So
- 13:57there was one reason that 139 was needed I mean it does have generous rules but you do have to
- 14:02be a little bit careful about what you're handing out. Yeah a few other points to make. As I mentioned
- 14:10qualifying 139 payment is exempt from federal income tax withholding social security tax
- 14:17Medicare tax and federal employment tax. In California 139 qualifying payments are exempt
- 14:25from state personal income tax and therefore exempt from personal state personal income tax
- 14:31withholding but according to the California EDD 139 payments are still subject to state level
- 14:39unemployment taxes and for short-term disability insurance payments.
- 14:44And that would that would be of course Steve if they came from the employer. I mean if an employee
- 14:51happens to be getting funds from another source like a charity or something like that I don't
- 14:56I'm not sure how the EDD can say that you have any kind of employment taxes related to it but
- 15:03certainly if an employer is handing out this the employer has to be careful to value what's being
- 15:08handed out and then apply these California taxes. Most other states don't do that but California is
- 15:14all different. I agree a couple other points the section 139 does not have any anti-discrimination
- 15:23standard that would prohibit making payments in favor of highly compensated employees to the detriment
- 15:31of non-highly compensated employees. That rule doesn't exist. That said I will tell you I've been
- 15:37in plenty of meetings with our Labor and Employment colleagues that show real concern about an
- 15:43employer adopting an assistance program that disproportionately benefits certain groups of
- 15:50employees whether it's within the same sort of pay range or even if it benefits higher end you
- 15:57know executives to the detriment of lower end and I think the reason is that that's potential
- 16:02potentially it's just bad it's a bad optic but also I think there's worry that it could open up the
- 16:07the paying employer to some kind of a discrimination type of a claim. The last couple points I have
- 16:14on section 139 payments I think it's still important to keep good records in terms of how an employer
- 16:21sets the amount how are you benchmarking you know and I'm out here to say if the hire consultants
- 16:27or experts to come in and say you know how do we justify $500 payment or $1,000 payment or whatever
- 16:34it might be but I like to think of it in terms of has anybody done any kind of basic research about
- 16:41you know what a reasonable price is to get a hotel room for a week you know 100 miles away
- 16:48or has anybody looked at what it would cost to you know just benchmark basic you know a basic
- 16:55change of clothes or a wardrobe not a full wardrobe but basic amenities what are the prices of you
- 17:03know car rentals look like in the meantime. Child care certainly so I think there's a lot of ways to
- 17:09get there it doesn't have to be specific to any actual expense I think as long as it's you know
- 17:16generally in line with what expected personal living expenses are going to be. The other the
- 17:23last point I'll make is that in my experience in situations where employees are affected by natural
- 17:30disasters oftentimes what they need is cash and they need it quick and so the idea about gift cards
- 17:37or we'll have an application process submit receipts quite honestly in the wake of you know a disaster
- 17:47oftentimes the best thing an employer can do is pump money into you know affected employees bank
- 17:52accounts through the payroll process essentially so direct deposit into you know employee checking
- 17:57accounts if that's done while it gets money there quick more quickly employers need to be aware and
- 18:04be mindful of how those payments are coded for payroll tax purposes so they don't inadvertently
- 18:10get lumped in with taxable wages or they don't inadvertently fail to get picked up for state
- 18:18level taxes that may apply. We go to the next slide it pretty much said all I have to say
- 18:24about about 139 and and I can turn it over to
- 18:32So working condition fringe benefits are not limited to disasters but they're very useful
- 18:39and so far as employers are trying to help their employees also to get back to work.
- 18:48These are essentially this can be cash payments or reimbursements for property or services that
- 18:58could be deducted as a business expense essentially and during COVID when people were forced to work
- 19:07from home we advised employers on how they could help employees get you know extra computer equipment
- 19:15you know maybe they didn't have to work at home and didn't even have a desk and so on so here
- 19:24in the context of a wildfire we have some folks if they lost their house they might need access to
- 19:30a temporary workspace they may need that office equipment they may need new computers or accessories
- 19:39they may need cell service or internet service only the part of of whatever expense that is
- 19:47it's attributable to business use can be excludable from employee income which means it wouldn't be
- 19:55subject to income tax and FICA I think it's safe to assume in in the circumstances that
- 20:02I've seen on the news that if if people have lost access to their homes and to these materials
- 20:09this these items could be considered 100% business use. On the next slide so that was the last slide
- 20:18if you can move what's also helpful to know about the working condition fringe is that this is not
- 20:22limited to W2 employees there it's a broader list of workers who can receive a working condition
- 20:34fringe it's not only your current employees it's your partners it's your board members and it's your
- 20:39independent contractors. And by the way it's not it's not a term that we made up it's actually in
- 20:45the internal revenue group that the benefits that a company gives to individuals working for it or
- 20:52a partnership gives any entity gives to service providers can be a working condition fringe if
- 20:57you need to test for exclusions that are outlined in the code in the reg. It just is not a commonly
- 21:04recognized term you don't see it in the news it's not something Siri even might know but it is
- 21:10simply an internal revenue code and provides an exclusion from income and health services and payroll
- 21:15taxes. Steve do you have anything else to add on working condition franches we went over these
- 21:21we went over these expenses this this is a circumstance where you would want your employees to
- 21:26keep to keep records of receipts but I also had a conversation with an employer last week
- 21:34whose IT department for example was prepared to send out packages of computer related equipment
- 21:42and so on because getting supplies in the affected area might be difficult. I would just simply add
- 21:52that the 139 qualified assistance exclusion and the 132A3 working condition fringe exclusion fit
- 22:02sort of neatly together in that 139 covers out-of-pocket personal expenses whereas the working
- 22:09condition fringe covers out-of-pocket business expenses and so they they don't have any potential
- 22:17for overlap and yet there still are two separate ways in which an employer can provide some kind
- 22:23of an assistant can provide assistance in in light of you know a natural disaster. Note that the
- 22:30working condition fringe doesn't just apply to natural disasters though it just happens to potentially
- 22:36be relevant right now as companies like Anna said are scrambling to get you know materials and supplies
- 22:43to employees who otherwise aren't able to come into the office or access them from home.
- 22:54So I just to pause to let our audience know that there is you do have the capacity to ask questions
- 23:02in the Q&A. I don't see any yet. And sort of just add that anyone in the audience can reach out to
- 23:12the BAR Association with questions and they will forward them to us or look for Mary Hevner,
- 23:18Anna Pomekall, or Stephen Johnson at Morgan Lewis. You can find our email addresses online
- 23:24on the firm's website and feel free to send any questions you may have about this presentation
- 23:29as well. Next slide.
- 23:36Andy you're on mute. Do you I think no you're not on mute. Andy you want to pick up where you left
- 23:40off with respect to leave donations. Yeah this was this was the revenue ruling I mentioned at the start
- 23:47that the IRS since 1990 has had this odd exception from the general rules prohibiting people from
- 23:53assigning income and avoiding tax on that assigned income. Starting 1990 the IRS allowed employees
- 24:01to deposit their annual leave and a leave bank and then the employer would hand the amounts out
- 24:07to employees who suffer medical emergencies. You have to be careful because it needs to be a medical
- 24:12condition of the employee or a family member of the employee that's going to require the employee
- 24:17to take a prolonged absence from from the job and is obviously in that event would have a substantial
- 24:24loss of income to any employees that don't have paid vacation days and paid PTO left. So in that
- 24:31kind of a situation the employer can accumulate leave in a leave bank and then hand out additional
- 24:37leave days paid leave days to employees who need to take paid leave. Employees can apply to the
- 24:43employer for the donated leave. Individual employees aren't supposed to select the recipients.
- 24:50So you as an employer are not supposed to say well I'll give my leave days but only if you're
- 24:55going to give it to my friend here you have to have the leave collected for employees and then
- 25:01leave it up to the employer to distribute the leave as the employer sees fit. And the employer can
- 25:07set rules as to the amount of days and PTO days that can be donated and rules on how leave could
- 25:12be granted. For example if you have a top executive who's paid an enormous amount translated hourly
- 25:19rates or daily rates you may need to have the leave bank adjust what's happening so that the
- 25:25leave days may be worth more when we're in a top executive contributes leave days. Not all companies
- 25:31do it but it's certainly something that can be done if the employer decides to make adjustments
- 25:37and changes and leave days that are donated. And additional paid leave for the recipient is paid
- 25:45out that the employee's normal rate of compensation because it is handed out as a PTO deck. So and
- 25:50when received by the employee would be a simply additional compensation. So it's not taxed to
- 25:57the person who surrendered the leave under Rev. Rule 90-29. It is taxed to the employees who
- 26:04receive the leave days. That's sort of a general overview of the revenue ruling. There are numbers
- 26:10of work called private letter rulings that the IRS has issued with under this revenue ruling 90-29.
- 26:17I'd say two-thirds of them are bad news for the companies about the ruling. The IRS says no, no,
- 26:23you didn't meet the rules. No, you've allowed the leave to be taken by people who don't have medical
- 26:28emergencies. No, you've allowed the leave to be handed out to people who really don't qualify. So
- 26:33you need to be very careful because this is something that the IRS does monitor and they have upon
- 26:40at least a dozen occasions issued rulings that have warned employers not to set up the leave
- 26:45banks in a way that operate in too generous a fashion. Next slide.
- 26:54And now we're going to talk about the employer deposits into an employer-sponsored leave bank.
- 27:00This is a different revenue ruling. This is one that was followed in a series of very short IRS
- 27:09notices. After 9-11, for example, the then the IRS formalized the guidance and issued notice
- 27:162006-59 that provides different rules than those that apply under the 1990 revenue ruling because
- 27:25they allow the leave to be donated not just for medical emergencies but for employees who
- 27:30have severe hardships on account of a disaster, particularly on account of a presidentially
- 27:36recognized disaster where the employee has to be absent from work. So unlike all the prior
- 27:41discussion of employer donations that go for personal expenses, this is a program that allows
- 27:47employers to let employees donate leave to each other in the wake of a disaster. And then again,
- 27:54the donors of the leave are not taxed on the leave they donate and the recipients believe
- 28:00are taxed on the leave they donate but it's not it works or it's not taxed twice which is terrific.
- 28:09The donate that recipient a leave is subject to income tax withholding and fight the tax
- 28:13on the donated leave but the donor doesn't have any tax. If you don't have a presidentially
- 28:20declared national disaster or if you don't have a medical emergency, you need to be careful because
- 28:26these leave leave donation programs don't work. Next slide and I think Steve, you or Anna are
- 28:33going to take over here for some of the caveats so I'm not the only one talking.
- 28:39I'm not aware of that but certainly I can.
- 28:45The couple points I want to make, and Hanny, help me remember it's relatively rare for the IRS to
- 28:54give guidance that says the donating employee can actually claim a charitable contribution for
- 29:01the leave. That's just kind of depends on administrative prerogative. There's any kind
- 29:08of standard that says it kicks in and it has to happen at any certain point as I understand the
- 29:12rules. Are you aware of what the substantiation rules are in instances when the IRS has recognized
- 29:21the ability for donating employees to be able to claim a charitable contribution deduction?
- 29:27And it's actually not a leave donation, Steve. I mean, I think we're first talking about leave.
- 29:32If you're donating your annual leave and you have annual leave to donate then it works pretty well
- 29:37because the donor doesn't have FICA and the donor does. What the IRS has done in the case of various
- 29:46individual disasters and it's done this a couple of dozen times to let people just write checks
- 29:54and write checks and contribute to the charity. It's enormously helpful when the IRS has allowed
- 30:01these kinds of charitable donations of cash because not everyone has the PTO to donate
- 30:07and not all people want to necessarily donate their PTO. They're happy to dig in, write a check
- 30:12from their checkbook, but they don't want to necessarily give up PTO. So on the occasions
- 30:17when the IRS has announced charitable donation programs and they have not done it for the
- 30:23California wildfires, but when they do announce it, it allows people just to take out their
- 30:28checkbook and write a check and give the check to a charity and assuming that the charity is then
- 30:33in turn helping people afflicted by the national disaster, the donor gets a charitable deduction,
- 30:38which is terrific. And in the case where somebody's writing a check and they're actually donating
- 30:46your leave, they're going to not be taxed on the leave and there's a real incentive to try to
- 30:53give away your income and assign your income because then you get the FICA tax break as well.
- 30:57They just haven't done it here. I was tremendously hopeful that Biden would, in one of his last
- 31:03acts announced that you could have these kinds of charitable donations to charities, but it wasn't
- 31:09done by the IRS before Biden left and I frankly think with all the other stuff facing the Trump
- 31:15administration, it's not too likely that he's going to announce a charitable donation program
- 31:19at this point. There had not been one announced by the Trump administration for any California
- 31:24wildfire or flood during the Trump administration. And I doubt that in the early days of the Trump,
- 31:31new Trump administration is going to be a big announcement that's going to allow these kinds
- 31:36of charitable donations. But for the leave donation programs, you have to have PTO to be able to
- 31:42donate it. The other problem, and I'll start with the slides, is that the employer has to track
- 31:48the donations if a tremendous amount of PTO is donated and it isn't used. In my experience,
- 31:55it's extremely unusual for an employer to collect these PTO donations and have them not be used.
- 32:02Most employers keep the period for distributing the donated leave open for relatively long periods
- 32:12of time. So there isn't a big need for an employer to track and then return the PTO leave to the
- 32:18individual donors in proportion to the leave that they donated. It's certainly a requirement that
- 32:23that be done. And notice 2006-59, but I haven't seen that happen. Even though we have seen
- 32:30tremendous amounts of PTO be donated, in situations like the one that's unfortunately
- 32:37afflicting Los Angeles, there are a tremendous number of people who need to leave as well.
- 32:44So I doubt at this point that you're going to have a situation where the leave remains unused,
- 32:49you have to be returned to the donors. The idea of having...
- 32:55On that point, I would presume that companies that do operate leave banks
- 33:01have them open-ended to say you can donate for medical purposes as necessary or as needs arise,
- 33:10or for natural disaster as needs arise. And it's not limited to this disaster or to this period
- 33:18of time. They tend to be literally banks that are there until they're utilized.
- 33:24And that's a fine large way. You don't see any companies turning around and returning the leave
- 33:28to the donors. How common is employer matching for leave donations? For every hour that somebody
- 33:37donates of their leave, the employer will match in like-kind whenever that hourly rate would have been
- 33:45to the bank or to some other charity, some other way to get assistance out into the affected community.
- 33:54Is it relatively common? I think most employers will just as with any matching program,
- 34:00they'll put limits on the match. They'll say for the first day you give or two days you give,
- 34:05we'll do a match. It usually doesn't extend beyond that. I think employers also wanted to see how
- 34:10many people were going to be donating PTO. But I certainly have seen it. I've also seen it coupled
- 34:17with a cap on how much is being matched. Right. Because I guess for related, the employer still
- 34:26gets to claim an income tax deduction for the leave when it's utilized because it's essentially a
- 34:32taxable wage expense. But I would presume that- Yeah. If people came to the same deduction for the
- 34:39instances where the IRS has allowed the tax to be given to charity, I mean, the employee isn't
- 34:45taxed on the donation. It isn't taxed on the donation, but the employer is going to get an
- 34:50actual deduction. They didn't even limit it to a charitable deduction. In the instances where
- 34:54they've allowed these contributions to charity, we just haven't seen it for these wildfires.
- 34:59They've limited their relief only to donations to these leave programs. And that's it without
- 35:05talking specifically about cash contributions to charity. I think luckily for everyone, the
- 35:10Code Section 139 Exclusion coupled with the Working Judition Fringe means that the recipient may
- 35:17not necessarily be taxed on a lot that's handed out. The other benefit of cash contributions to
- 35:23charities, the charities can give subsistence funds. They can just hand out money to people who
- 35:30are in need of it without necessarily meeting the conditions of 139 or the Working Judition Fringe.
- 35:35We just haven't seen any announcement from the IRS. And I don't think we're going to see
- 35:42when here if it's going to allow these kinds of leave donations to charities.
- 35:46If I can interject, we have a relevant question in the comments. The question is,
- 35:53does the Working Condition Fringe benefit apply to volunteers? Yeah, it does. They actually
- 36:04work for that fund because they, it's pretty clear the volunteers didn't have any profit motive.
- 36:10But there's a specific regulation, I think it's 1.132-R that recognizes that volunteers are able
- 36:16to get working condition fringes. Do IRS spend quite a deal of time on that in 1986 and 2007
- 36:23when it was developing these regulations? It's 1.132-5R and you're right. Oh, sorry,
- 36:305R. That's the working condition. I'll have to 5 out. Yeah, regulation. I got your R right though.
- 36:37And so we have a second question that asks if only some employees are affected,
- 36:44can you only help them? And so in both under 1.39 and for the leave donation program,
- 36:55you'll want to make sure that someone is receiving funds because they've suffered
- 37:01some sort of a hardship or incurred expenses, unexpected expenses with respect to the specific
- 37:06disaster. And that may not be everybody in your workforce, of course.
- 37:10And so getting some kind of a written statement at some point that certifies to that would make
- 37:18sense. Well, I'm just trying to right size the assistance, right? You don't want to say everyone
- 37:22in our national company gets a 1.39 payment because of wildfires in California,
- 37:30including employees in Massachusetts. That makes no sense. But right sizing into where we say
- 37:37all employees within the affected account, within the counties that are identified in the
- 37:43emergency presidential emergency order as a starting point. But then further,
- 37:48you have to have some sort of proof that you were affected by.
- 37:54It could be even more granular in terms of by address or by providing some kind of certification,
- 38:01proof of actual incurring an expense. So there are ways that certainly it could be
- 38:06made to be smaller. But you don't want it to be like Goldilocks and the three bears, right?
- 38:14You don't want it to be too big or too small because then you've provided assistance to people
- 38:18who don't need the assistance. So they have a windfall or you've not helped people that
- 38:24were otherwise in a position to need the help in the first place.
- 38:29And relevant to your point, we had an employer ask some questions last week.
- 38:34Do they have to give the same type of help to everybody? And the answer is no, based on what
- 38:41we just described. And then how can they modify their plan very quickly? And their plan had been
- 38:48drafted years ago and set a dollar amount that for rent assistance, for example, that I'm sure was
- 38:57out of date in terms of what the market demands right now and had listed in that plan. And they,
- 39:09instead of revamping the whole thing, added language to say if you have individual, if
- 39:15you have requests specific, you know, to your situation, please, please let us know.
- 39:20To this point, I will clarify that under section 139 and under the 132 working condition fringe
- 39:29rules, there's no requirement for a written plan. There are other code exclusions that do impose a
- 39:36writing requirement. 139 and the working condition fringe do not. For reasons that we've explained,
- 39:42you know, to avoid confusion, to avoid abuse, to have, you know, basically be documenting for
- 39:49potential audit defense file. There are certainly reasons why putting a policy in writing makes a
- 39:55whole lot of sense. But whether or not there was, you know, an outdated plan that was in writing
- 40:01doesn't affect, doesn't affect technical eligibility or availability rather of either of
- 40:08these exclusions. I mean, mindful kind of where we're on time. Do we want to maybe move forward to
- 40:16the next slide?
- 40:20Handy, do you want to go with?
- 40:24Well, I mean, again, this is another thing that many companies do, to set up their own private
- 40:30foundations or even public foundations. A lot of companies also work straight
- 40:35really through charitable organizations by making donations to charity. So they announce to their
- 40:40employees that they're willing to collect the monies and to donate to charity. This is more
- 40:45commonly an area where employer will also match donations to charity. I've seen that happen more
- 40:51often than with donations of leave days. If you're going to set up your own charitable organization,
- 40:57you have to have a cost of beneficiaries that large and upper in depth and enough to constitute
- 41:02a charitable class. Frankly, I think for employers in the Los Angeles area, it's very likely,
- 41:09unfortunately, that they're going to have a class of people that are going to be large enough to
- 41:13be a charitable class. Also going to meet the second condition, that you have to select the
- 41:17recipients based upon an objective determination of need. As Steve said earlier, you can't just
- 41:22throw out money. You have to be sure that somebody really did lose the entire house or have a house
- 41:28nearly destroyed in order to be able to hand out the charitable funds. You have to also be sure
- 41:36that the benefit of the employer is incidental. Most of these foundations are run through independent
- 41:42selection committees that make sure that the money is going out to deserving recipients for
- 41:47deserving reasons. Next slide. As I said before, the charity usually solicits contributions to
- 41:56employees. The board often includes rank and file employees. The other point is that it's very
- 42:02common for employers to add matching contributions to incentivize employees to be here. It's going
- 42:08to happen a lot. Next slide. Also because of the technical requirements that Haney just mentioned,
- 42:16going the employer charity route is not preferable when section 139 is otherwise available because
- 42:28there's as many strings. I'll also say when it comes to charities, there are some concerns that
- 42:37our tax exempt colleagues are always concerned about to make sure that there isn't any potential
- 42:43for private enurement that the charity is paying out in favor of certain selects,
- 42:51employees, or executives. I have been witness on email traffic that based on where the
- 42:58wildfire started and that they were often in more affluent areas, more affluent suburbs of Los
- 43:05Angeles, that there were charities that are coming to charities in place that were worried about
- 43:11providing assistance through their charity because of how it could disproportionately affect
- 43:17the sort of the, you know, top or top upper management and executives more so than lower
- 43:25level employees who may be in different parts of the city. I think at this point in where the
- 43:29wildfires have spread, I don't know that's quite as much a concern, but certainly another thing to
- 43:33be mindful of when going the foundation route. Also a foundation can't be stood up overnight.
- 43:39That's been another problem too. We've had clients that would consider going the foundation route,
- 43:44but it's one of those situations where if the foundation isn't already in place, isn't already
- 43:51established, doesn't already have the tax exempt blessing from the IRS and state departments of
- 43:56revenue, it's not something you can do overnight to then be able to start providing assistance
- 44:02through a foundation. So it takes some foresight and some planning. That said, I get a sense that
- 44:09there are a number of companies now that found that they did not have a company charity in place
- 44:16and are looking at the wildfires as an opportunity to be prepared the next time there is some kind
- 44:20of natural disaster. Next slide.
- 44:23Here's where we are. Here's how you find us.
- 44:33All right. And then maybe we just give a moment or two for attendees to submit any questions.
- 44:38Please use the Q&A function.
- 44:47In the meantime, I do want to say that we're very grateful to the Bar Association for giving us
- 44:52this opportunity to speak today and that we sincerely send our sympathies and our support to
- 44:59everyone who's been affected by these horrible wildfires.
- 45:07All right. I don't see any questions in the Q&A for our attendees. If you have any questions
- 45:13after the webinar is concluded, their contact information is available in the packets.
- 45:18Please check the Zoom chat if you haven't received the packet or feel free to reach out to us at
- 45:22help.bhb.org. Thank you so much for your time today.
- 45:27Thank you. Thanks, Anne. Thanks, Steve.
- 45:31This program and the associated written materials are provided for informational purposes only and
- 45:36are not intended and must not be taken as legal advice on any particular set of facts or circumstances.
- 45:43You should not act or refrain from acting on the basis of any content included in this program
- 45:48without seeking legal or other professional advice on your specific matter.
- 45:52This program contains general information and may not reflect current legal developments
- 45:56or address your specific situation. This program and the associated written materials
- 46:01are not intended as a solicitation.