Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Conflicts, Clients, and Credits: Ethical Traps in Entertainment Law
Transcript
- 0:03I am David Schrager, the Secretary of the Beverly
- 0:06Hills Bar Association's Entertainment Law Section,
- 0:09and it is my privilege and pleasure to be with
- 0:12you here today. Welcome to our program today
- 0:15entitled Conflicts, Clients, and Credits. Ethical
- 0:18Traps in Entertainment Law, which promises to
- 0:21be an exceptional seminar about a critically
- 0:23important topic for practitioners. Thank you
- 0:27to everyone for attending today. We appreciate
- 0:29your support and your engagement with the bar.
- 0:32And thank you also to the excellent team at the
- 0:34Beverly Hills Bar Association that facilitates
- 0:37these exceptional programs. And it is my honor
- 0:40to now introduce our speakers today, Annie Thompson
- 0:43and Dana Ulysse, who will help us navigate the
- 0:46complicated ethical landscape that can exist
- 0:49for transactional lawyers and indeed all practitioners.
- 0:55Annie Thompson is the chief claims officer for
- 0:58Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company. Ms. Thompson
- 1:00leads the claims department overseeing litigation
- 1:03and pre -litigation strategy and legal analysis
- 1:06of duty. breach, causation, and defenses in claims.
- 1:10She's also responsible for the evaluation of
- 1:13coverage concerns regarding policyholder tenders,
- 1:15and she participates in mediation and settlement
- 1:18negotiations on behalf of policyholders. She
- 1:21previously acted for Lawyers Mutual as director
- 1:23of content and production of live MCLE available
- 1:26to policyholders. And for 10 years prior to being
- 1:30promoted to chief claims officer, Ms. Thompson
- 1:32held the title of claims attorney. She is also
- 1:35a certified specialist in legal malpractice law
- 1:38and is among only about 100 in the state who
- 1:40has achieved this certification. Dana Olise is
- 1:44the chief underwriting officer for Lawyers Mutual
- 1:46Insurance Company. Dana has extensive experience
- 1:49in the legal industry, of course. She had extensive
- 1:51litigation experience in private practice for
- 1:54over a decade. And in 2018, she transitioned
- 1:57into the insurance field and has held the position
- 1:59of underwriting manager at Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 2:02Company. In 2021, however, she was promoted to
- 2:05Chief Underwriting Officer. Dana, I hope I pronounced
- 2:10your last name properly. Please correct me if
- 2:12I didn't get that correct. Of course, just a
- 2:17note myself, coming from a background as a private
- 2:20mediator, I just want to say how fortunate I
- 2:23know we are today to be able to hear from Annie
- 2:26and Dana and to be benefiting from their experience
- 2:29and insight. Entertainment lawyers know that
- 2:32insurance professionals and claims adjusters,
- 2:34they just play such a critical role in how business
- 2:37is done in our industry and how disputes are
- 2:39resolved when things go wrong. These folks can
- 2:42often be the unsung heroes when it comes to these.
- 2:45these types of disputes. They deal with an extraordinary
- 2:48volume of claims. They deal with a wide variety
- 2:51of issues. They can be tremendously high financial
- 2:54stakes. And there are often very competing sets
- 2:57of interests and personalities that they have
- 2:59to navigate. So their skill and expertise is
- 3:02really essential to resolution. And we have two
- 3:04of the best here with us today. So thank you
- 3:07so much, Annie and Dana, for being here and for
- 3:10providing this program to our audience. And with
- 3:12that, I will say, let's get started. And the
- 3:14floor is yours. Thanks, David. And thanks to
- 3:17the Beverly Hills Bar for having us here today.
- 3:20As David said, I'm Dana. And we have Annie with
- 3:23us as well to talk to you today about conflicts,
- 3:26clients, and credits, ethical traps, and entertainment
- 3:28law. Entertainment law presents its own unique
- 3:31conflict challenges given the different overlapping
- 3:34roles that a lawyer can have, such as agent,
- 3:38manager, who they represent, whether it be production
- 3:41companies, talent, studios. and on and on. So
- 3:45today our learning objectives are we want to
- 3:47go over and make sure everybody understands the
- 3:50California conflict of interest roles. We're
- 3:53going to apply ethical principles to the entertainment
- 3:55practice and then go over some hypotheticals
- 3:58of common pitfalls that happen in the entertainment
- 4:01field in conflicts particularly. So along the
- 4:06way we invite you to ask questions. We'll be
- 4:08keeping an eye on it as we go along. And so we're
- 4:12going to kick it over to Annie to get us started
- 4:14with talking about the California Rules of Professional
- 4:18Conduct that we need to know on conflicts. Hi.
- 4:21Good morning, everyone. I'm Annie Thompson. And
- 4:24I thank Beverly Hills Bar Association for that
- 4:28very kind introduction. So one of the reasons
- 4:34this is a shameless plug part of this program
- 4:37is that Lawyers Mutual didn't used to write entertainment
- 4:41lawyers. And now we do. And so one of those things,
- 4:46one of the things available to all of our insureds
- 4:49is a lawyer to lawyer hotline where you can talk
- 4:51to me or someone in my department about a lot
- 4:54of the things that we're going to talk about
- 4:55today. So if you ever want any help or have any
- 5:00questions about our policies, we're here for
- 5:02that. But otherwise, I'm just going to hop in
- 5:05and When I was thinking about doing this program,
- 5:08I was thinking, what is the difference between
- 5:12regular transactional or litigation lawyers in
- 5:16other practice and other lawyers in other practices
- 5:22and entertainment lawyers? And really, the rules
- 5:25are not different for entertainment lawyers at
- 5:28all. Entertainment lawyers are subject to the
- 5:30exact same rules as every other lawyer. However,
- 5:34the nature of the practice leads to more conflicts
- 5:40than other practice areas. And those are the
- 5:42ones that you all should be aware of. And sometimes
- 5:47an entertainment lawyer's value is in the relationships
- 5:51that they have. And those overlapping relationships
- 5:53can form the basis of a lot of the conflicts
- 5:55that we tend to see in these areas. So the types
- 6:00of conflicts, and you'll have in your materials
- 6:04a lot of the ethical rules that apply to this,
- 6:06and I'm going to talk about them as well as we
- 6:08get into this. But the main type of conflict
- 6:12in entertainment practice is multiple representation,
- 6:16which is conflicts between clients. So let's
- 6:20say you're representing both a production company
- 6:23and the talent in contract negotiations. Well,
- 6:27in that case, you need to look at California
- 6:29rule of professional conduct 1 .7. And it says,
- 6:34it's basically the material limitation conflict
- 6:37if a lawyer's ability to advocate is compromised.
- 6:40There's case law on this as well. But the most
- 6:43basic conflict is when a lawyer is representing
- 6:46two clients with differing interests. And the
- 6:49rules say, a lawyer shall not, without informed
- 6:53written consent, and those are very important
- 6:55words, informed written consent, they even have
- 6:58their own definition in the rules of professional
- 7:00conduct. So a lawyer shall not, without informed
- 7:03written consent, represent a client if the representation
- 7:06is directly adverse to another client in the
- 7:08same or separate matter. And you also have to
- 7:14remember that conflicts are not a one -time analysis.
- 7:22Conflicts continue to need to be evaluated throughout
- 7:26the course of your representation, and a blanket
- 7:30conflict waiver in an initial retainer agreement
- 7:34is not going to protect you. So a client consent
- 7:38to conflicted representation is not the end of
- 7:43the analysis, and it isn't enough to protect
- 7:48you. Consent is only valid if the lawyer reasonably
- 7:51believes the conflict will not affect their ability
- 7:54to represent both clients and the representation
- 7:57is not prohibited by law and the representation
- 8:00does not relate to an actual dispute before a
- 8:03tribunal, meaning you can't represent both sides
- 8:06of a dispute. But you have to remember, you are
- 8:10a fiduciary with duties of loyalty and confidentiality
- 8:14and these fiduciary obligations applied to everything
- 8:22you get involved in, whether it's contracts,
- 8:25transactions, any other dispute, whether it's
- 8:29in court or not, it requires you to anticipate
- 8:34conflicts if you are engaged in dual representation.
- 8:39And so while consent from both clients can...
- 8:43Excuse me. Obtained from both clients can be
- 8:46valid where the criteria in subsection D is met
- 8:50conflicts are unwaverable when the party's interests
- 8:54are materially adverse and That that's sort of
- 9:00the situation where When one client desires one
- 9:06thing the other client desires something else
- 9:09and they cannot be they can't coalesce in a way
- 9:17that you feel like you're not putting one, the
- 9:21interest of one client ahead of the other. And
- 9:23that's essentially what you cannot do. And it's
- 9:26designed essentially to prevent dishonest practitioner
- 9:33from engaging in conduct that is conflicted and
- 9:38or fraudulent. but also to preclude the honest
- 9:42practitioner from putting themselves in a position
- 9:45where they may be required to choose between
- 9:47conflicting duties or be led to attempt to reconcile
- 9:51conflicting interests rather than enforce the
- 9:54full extent of the rights of the interests, which
- 9:56they alone should represent, essentially meaning
- 9:59you don't want to be in a position where you're
- 10:03compromising both people's rights so that you
- 10:06can find a compromise that they both can live
- 10:08with. when if they had separate counsel, they'd
- 10:12be fighting for the full extent of what they're
- 10:14entitled to. And that's really the difference
- 10:17is that's how you analyze it in your head. If
- 10:19the clients had separate representation, would
- 10:23their lawyers independently be making different
- 10:25analysis and arguments on their behalf? And that
- 10:29to me is a good way and a good reminder to lawyers
- 10:34as to how to think about conflicts that if I
- 10:37wasn't representing both of these people could
- 10:40stronger arguments be made and could that could
- 10:43benefit them more. If that's the case, the clients
- 10:48need separate counsel. And that is something
- 10:50that I will tell you in this presentation. I'm
- 10:55going to give you a lot of information that I'm
- 10:56going to tell you is best practices. And you're
- 10:59going to tell me without telling me that that's
- 11:02sometimes impractical in the world of entertainment
- 11:05law. So what we're going to talk about is how
- 11:07we can resolve some of these things through conflict
- 11:10waivers, informed consent, disclosures, and whatnot.
- 11:14But I'll also tell you when it is just not feasible,
- 11:19and it puts you personally and your license at
- 11:23risk. Because the state bar does also care about
- 11:27conflicted representation. And a little side
- 11:31note is conflicted representation can subject
- 11:34you to disgorgement of fees, which obviously
- 11:38is not the preferred way to practice law by having
- 11:41your fees taken away from you. So that's really
- 11:44kind of the best practices. So we'll talk about
- 11:48what informed consent is. And informed consent,
- 11:53if you find you're in a situation where you can
- 11:55represent both sides in a negotiation, The informed
- 11:59consent means that the lawyer must provide all
- 12:03reasonably available facts to both parties that
- 12:05would impact the representation. And that requires
- 12:10disclosure of the relevant circumstances, the
- 12:14material risks, and including any actual and
- 12:18reasonably foreseeable adverse consequences.
- 12:22That goes back to what I was saying, is that
- 12:24you can't just have a generic conflict waiver
- 12:27in your fee agreement you need to actually outline
- 12:30what the conflict is. There may be a conflict
- 12:32because you may feel that I am not advocating
- 12:34strong enough for you or you may feel that I
- 12:38am advocating for the other side more and it
- 12:44is foreseeable that you may be unhappy with this
- 12:48result given the fact that there's one attorney
- 12:51representing both parties and you may feel that
- 12:55you are not adequately represented. So you have
- 12:58to advise of those things specifically. A blanket
- 13:02conflict waiver is not going to protect you because
- 13:06informed written consent requires a lot more
- 13:09than just a blanket conflict waiver. So this
- 13:16is sort of the next phase of the bad news of
- 13:21representing two clients is even if proper informed
- 13:24consent Is obtained once an actual conflict arises
- 13:28between the parties. You can't represent either
- 13:31one of them and you can't give them any advice
- 13:34about the conflict, whether it's litigated or
- 13:38not, whether it's transactional, whether it's
- 13:40just a dispute, but the duty of loyalty that
- 13:44a lawyer owes to every client prevents the lawyer
- 13:47from representing any client that's adverse to
- 13:50the other client. So if they are actual conflicts.
- 13:54that arise, then you can't represent anyone.
- 13:59So you should really bear in mind that best practices,
- 14:09in my opinion, is not to do this. Don't represent
- 14:13both sides of a transaction. Don't try to mediate
- 14:17a dispute between two parties who may not be
- 14:23aligned. It's just not good practice. You're
- 14:27going to end up being conflicted out. If you
- 14:30don't conflict yourself out, you may end up in
- 14:32trouble either with malpractice or the state
- 14:35bar. It's just not good practice. But bear in
- 14:41mind also that adversity of client is not solely
- 14:44a condition of actual disputes. When two parties
- 14:46are negotiating a contract, duties and benefits
- 14:49flowing to and from each party also prevent present
- 14:54a conflict. And again, informed consent has to
- 14:58be obtained prior to any dual representation
- 15:02in a negotiation. Again, specifics about the
- 15:07nature of conflicting interests, including bargaining
- 15:09power imbalances, potential pitfalls, and other
- 15:14things. And remember or know for the first time
- 15:19that Communication is not privileged as between
- 15:24co -clients in a subsequent adverse proceeding
- 15:27between them. So if, let's say, you are sued
- 15:33for malpractice, each client is entitled to the
- 15:39whole file. Or if they end up in subsequent disputes,
- 15:44there is no privilege between co -clients. So
- 15:49that is another thing if you've got notes from
- 15:52one client saying, you know, I need Brad to do
- 15:55X Y and Z and then that's produced but you find
- 15:59out that that's adverse to Brad they find out
- 16:01that's adverse to Brad and you've been advocating
- 16:04for that then all then you're also now involved
- 16:07in the dispute which again best practices Don't
- 16:11do that. If you do Your conflict waiver should
- 16:16be as detailed as possible and your informed
- 16:19written consent should have as much information
- 16:22as possible. And it should almost look like something
- 16:26that nobody in their right mind would sign. But
- 16:29if you present that and they have the opportunity
- 16:33to consult with independent legal counsel and
- 16:38determine that this is still what they want,
- 16:40then you will have a valid informed consent conflict
- 16:44waiver. The the risks are high and As someone
- 16:54who's been, you know a lawyer exclusively defending
- 16:57lawyers for 25 years Conflict of interest is
- 17:01one of the main topics of what we see and in
- 17:06your particular practice area the conflicts are
- 17:09you know quadrupled by nature of the relationship
- 17:13and the I forgot where I was. I forgot where
- 17:25I was. I was looking at the Q &As, guys. I'm
- 17:27sorry. I was just going to say, Annie, we actually
- 17:29have a question on directly adverse and whether
- 17:32something is directly adverse. Do you want to
- 17:34take a moment to address that now? Sure. So we
- 17:38have an individual asking if two clients are
- 17:41working on the same feature and one's participation
- 17:44is a deductible as part of negative cost. For
- 17:47example, a bigger salary being an example of
- 17:49a deductible cost and does impacting the other
- 17:52potentially is that considered directly adverse?
- 17:56Well, if two like if assuming like two clients
- 17:59working on the same feature, let's say we're
- 18:02talking about talent. So you've got two. talent
- 18:06to actors or performers or just to to to artists.
- 18:15And one has a larger salary than the other. That's
- 18:23not necessarily directly adverse because salary,
- 18:28for example, is based on a lot of different things
- 18:31and you can negotiate. for one of the artists
- 18:37without impacting the other. And so it's sort
- 18:42of like any business and using salary as this
- 18:49cost, I mean, as this conflict item. I don't
- 18:54believe that that would be a conflict because...
- 18:56Salary negotiations you can effectively negotiate
- 19:00for both of your clients without impacting the
- 19:03other client and that would be one of the situations
- 19:06where I think You should absolutely disclose
- 19:11that you are representing someone else in the
- 19:13same production because You don't if those two
- 19:18people ever get into a dispute. You never want
- 19:21them to go Well, I'm gonna call my lawyer and
- 19:23I'm gonna call my lawyer and they turns out it's
- 19:25the same person You want them to know that you're
- 19:29representing each of them in connection with
- 19:33that particular production. But when it comes
- 19:36to things like salary negotiation, because you're
- 19:38negotiating salary with a third party, and you
- 19:42can advocate for both of them fiercely and get
- 19:49them as close as you want to their goals without
- 19:52impacting the other. It would be different, for
- 19:55example, where these things, if you've got insurance
- 19:59funds and you've got two people in the same car
- 20:02accident negotiating over the same pot of money.
- 20:06That's different in entertainment. Nobody's negotiating
- 20:09over the same pot of money. So in that case,
- 20:12I think you absolutely would be able to handle
- 20:18that with appropriate disclosures. So I hope
- 20:22that Answers the question again. I mean if it's
- 20:26a low budget project, maybe there is only a certain
- 20:30amount of money available and maybe in that situation
- 20:34it could potentially be a conflict depending
- 20:37on the size of the Project and the budget of
- 20:41the project but that's one of those things that
- 20:43in entertainment everything has a different analysis
- 20:47that would in other areas because of the diverse
- 20:51nature of the projects you all work on so the
- 20:57next category of conflicts that I want to talk
- 21:00about is business deals with clients and I'm
- 21:07gonna flip to Dana for a second because Dana
- 21:10as you know our chief underwriting officer this
- 21:13we look for what makes you what makes you risky
- 21:17as an insured in the entertainment field. And
- 21:21I think this is something that Dana would say
- 21:25puts her hackles up and makes Lawyers Mutual
- 21:29very concerned. And that is absolutely correct.
- 21:33So on our application, this is actually something
- 21:35we directly ask about on the underwriting side,
- 21:39whether as a lawyer you are wearing multiple
- 21:43hats, which includes potential business deals
- 21:47with clients. And we do see this more often in
- 21:50the entertainment field with lawyers potentially
- 21:53taking an interest in a film or taking on sort
- 21:58some sort of sponsorship deal where they're kind
- 22:01of investing in a product with their client or
- 22:03something where that client's putting their name
- 22:05on something. And so this is definitely something
- 22:09that, like Annie said, puts a kind of spidey
- 22:13senses go up where we have to ask a lot more
- 22:15questions because we need to make sure that in
- 22:18going and entering these business deals with
- 22:20your client, you're not actually. at creating
- 22:23a conflict between your own interests and your
- 22:26client's interests. And so this is really where
- 22:29this kind of comes up in the conflicts realm
- 22:32and our concerns with potential business deals
- 22:34with clients. So, Annie, then from the claim
- 22:36standpoint, what rules are out there that govern
- 22:39this? Like I said at the beginning, these rules
- 22:45aren't any different than any other lawyer. Think
- 22:48about startups where clients say, I want so many
- 22:52shares in XYZ in exchange for doing your legal
- 22:55documents. It's the same thing and it's the same
- 22:58rules, but the rules about investing with clients
- 23:01are really, really strict. and they do not favor
- 23:07lawyers at all. So that's California rule of
- 23:10professional conduct 1 .8 .1. So it requires
- 23:13written disclosure, fair and reasonable terms,
- 23:16and again, clients informed written consent.
- 23:19And you can be disciplined. There is a case,
- 23:23Beery versus State Bar, where a lawyer was disciplined
- 23:26for entering into an unfair business transaction
- 23:29with a client. So. The rules for transactions
- 23:32between a lawyer and a client are more stringent
- 23:34than anything else. If a lawyer is entering into
- 23:38an agreement with their own client, such as where
- 23:41production counsel seeks an executive producer
- 23:44credit or some kind of kickback, the lawyer has
- 23:49to approach that cautiously. So one, it has to
- 23:52be fair and reasonable. The lawyer may not leverage
- 23:56superior legal knowledge or the client's trust
- 23:58in obtaining better terms for him or herself.
- 24:02The lawyer must tell the client in writing to
- 24:05obtain independent legal advice before entering
- 24:08into the transaction. And you have to give them
- 24:12time to do that. Having somebody sign a document
- 24:17that says you're entitled to independent legal
- 24:19advice. and signing the same day, that's going
- 24:22to be held against you. And so the client has
- 24:25to give informed written consent to the transaction
- 24:28and specifically the nature of the lawyer's involvement
- 24:31and the conflict created thereby, because it
- 24:34is a conflict. Absolutely. And so these can apply
- 24:39to transaction with former clients. And all of
- 24:43these things are fact dependent. but you have
- 24:46to know that the law presumes that the transaction
- 24:49is unfair to the client and the lawyer bears
- 24:52the burden of to overcome that presumption. So
- 24:57it is a rebuttable presumption that this deal
- 25:01is unfair to the client because again, you're
- 25:04a fiduciary. You have duties of loyalty, confidentiality,
- 25:08and you have higher ethical duties. to your clients
- 25:13than you do as an outside investor. So that is
- 25:20kind of a big deal. And I don't recommend lawyers
- 25:25investing in clients' projects. I know sometimes,
- 25:29depending on the size of the project, that's
- 25:31the only way they can afford a lawyer is by a
- 25:34lawyer investing in the startup of this project.
- 25:37You can do it, but you have to be incredibly
- 25:41incredibly careful because the requirements for
- 25:45independent legal advice and written consent
- 25:48are, you know, they are greater than they would
- 25:54otherwise be. When we talk about, you know, you
- 25:57have to tell someone they're entitled to independent
- 25:59legal advice. For example, like if you were disclosing
- 26:03a mistake, you might say you should consult with
- 26:06another lawyer about whether or not you may have
- 26:08a claim against me. You can write that. This
- 26:11is bigger than that. This is before the transaction.
- 26:15You have to provide a writing to the client telling
- 26:18explaining the nature of the conflict created
- 26:21by the transaction and that they should seek
- 26:23independent legal advice. And again, as I said,
- 26:26they must be given a reasonable opportunity to
- 26:29do so before entering into the transaction. At
- 26:32least one decision has condoned a transaction
- 26:35without full informed consent. but only where
- 26:38the client actually hired another lawyer for
- 26:41advice on the transaction. So the better practice
- 26:45would be to ensure that the lawyer entering into
- 26:47the transaction actually makes a complete disclosure,
- 26:51especially if it's not in the lawyer's interest
- 26:54to do so, because that's conflicted representation.
- 26:59And with the presumption that it's unfair to
- 27:01the client, entertainment lawyers really need
- 27:05to be mindful of the fact that these transactions
- 27:10can be very dangerous for you. So alternatives
- 27:14are, if they can secure funding or investment
- 27:18from someone else to pay you, that would be an
- 27:22alternative way to handle this. There are other
- 27:25ways to handle this, but you should in... Every
- 27:30scenario possible, try to get paid in cash dollars
- 27:34rather than investment in a project. Because
- 27:37again, you could end up working for free if the
- 27:39project fails. And I'm a firm believer that no
- 27:43lawyer should work for free. And then you end
- 27:45up in trouble if you want to foreclose on your
- 27:49fees arising out of your investment and you don't
- 27:55want to be adverse to a client. in that situation
- 27:58because you're just going to draw a complaint
- 28:00about the whole situation. And that's like a
- 28:05playbook. That's exactly how it will go. So you
- 28:08will try to enforce your rights because lawyers
- 28:10don't work for free. The client will say, this
- 28:13wasn't fair to me. You're entitled to nothing.
- 28:16And in fact, anything I did give you should be
- 28:18disgorged because conflicted representation is
- 28:21not compensable. And then you are going to draw
- 28:24a complaint. maybe in superior court and maybe
- 28:27with a state bar. None of those things you want.
- 28:33So excuse me. We're going to talk about our next
- 28:41category, which is former clients, which in the
- 28:44entertainment field, I know there's a lot of
- 28:48overlap between the industry can be very small.
- 28:53So you may be asked to represent a new talent
- 28:57agent against a former production company client.
- 29:01And the rules of professional conduct say you
- 29:04can't use confidential information to disadvantage
- 29:08the former client. And I'll get into some of
- 29:10those rules there, but Dana. From an underwriting
- 29:15perspective do we ask about? Conflicts, and what
- 29:18do we what do we want entertainment lawyers to
- 29:20do to make sure that they're a good risk? Absolutely.
- 29:23And this is something just across the board,
- 29:26regardless of whether somebody is an entertainment
- 29:28lawyer or practicing any other area law, it is
- 29:32so important to have a robust conflict system
- 29:35so that nothing falls through the cracks with
- 29:38respect to duties owed to former clients. And
- 29:41so this is something we do ask about on applications.
- 29:44It's something that every firm, whether you're
- 29:47a solo or a large firm, should have in place
- 29:50to be really making sure that duties, because
- 29:54there is a duty still owed to a former client,
- 29:56and there is the potential for conflicts. And
- 29:58so this is really a big factor in risk analysis.
- 30:01And so knowing that, what do you recommend, Annie,
- 30:05from a claim standpoint? Okay, I'm going to get
- 30:08into that, but I'm actually there are a couple
- 30:11of questions on the on the previous topic that
- 30:13I want to handle. Peter Grossman asked if a conflict
- 30:16arises between two clients under what circumstances,
- 30:19if any, can the attorney continue to represent
- 30:21one of the clients in the transaction? And the
- 30:25answer is there are no circumstances under which
- 30:28you can represent one of the clients in the transaction
- 30:31because you are then adverse to a former client
- 30:34and you can't do that. and you have information
- 30:37relative to the transaction for the other side
- 30:41because you were once their counsel. So look
- 30:44at 1 .7 and you'll realize that there is no scenario
- 30:50under which you can continue to represent either
- 30:53of them and then they both need new counsel.
- 30:56I know that's not the answer anyone wants to
- 30:58hear, but it's a good thing for everyone to know.
- 31:02Because it goes back to my advice at the outset
- 31:05where I said, you know Everybody should have
- 31:10separate counsel because that's best practices.
- 31:12This is where you end up because every now and
- 31:16again people argue and then Marla in case you
- 31:21weren't already going to cover this situation
- 31:23a lawyer represents a team where a conflict arises
- 31:27between the two team members. For example, a
- 31:29writing team where one writer is happy to simply
- 31:32write the project while the other writer has
- 31:35other demands such as attachment in another capacity
- 31:37as well as producer actor or attachment of baggage
- 31:41producer and would blow a deal over it. What
- 31:44should the lawyer do? That's really connected
- 31:49to the previous question. If you're representing
- 31:51a team and a conflict arises between two team
- 31:55members, you're in a situation where unless you
- 32:00can find a way to service both interests and
- 32:06because if one person is happy to simply write
- 32:08the project and the other one wants greater accolades
- 32:13or You know titles if the one team member who's
- 32:20happy with writing as is this is all about continuing
- 32:25the the conflict analysis if you talk to the
- 32:30two team members and you've got the one who's
- 32:32happy to go along to get along and doesn't care
- 32:35about the things that the other writer is is
- 32:39doing You can advise and disclose and get a conflict
- 32:46waiver and say to the happy guy, hey, I'm going
- 32:49to go and I'm going to advocate for this, this
- 32:52and this because I also represent that client.
- 32:56But if it's going to blow up the deal to the
- 32:59detriment of the happy client, then you're in
- 33:06a real adverse situation. But if simply advocating
- 33:10doesn't have the potential to blow it up. then
- 33:14I think you can do that with proper disclosures.
- 33:17But again, you see how nuanced this gets. You
- 33:19have to really think about, okay, I can advocate
- 33:23with disclosures because this person isn't asking
- 33:26for anything more, but this person is, and you
- 33:29can advocate for more, but you can't do that
- 33:32to the detriment of the other one, and that detriment
- 33:35would be if the deal's gonna blow up. So it's
- 33:39a pretty nuanced analysis. And again, this is
- 33:42the kind of thing that we do on Hotline is we
- 33:44walk you through these situations and we talk
- 33:47about it and we'll pull out the rules of professional
- 33:49conduct and we'll read them together. So we definitely
- 33:56like to help you in those situations. But because
- 34:01time is going quickly, I'm going to go on to
- 34:04the former clients that we were talking about.
- 34:07you know, representing a new talent against a
- 34:10former production company client. So California
- 34:14rule of professional conduct 1 .9 says you cannot
- 34:18use confidential information to disadvantage
- 34:21a former client. And so if this is this is kind
- 34:27of twofold because your current client needs
- 34:30to know that the other side is a former client
- 34:37so there's sort of the pull your punches rule
- 34:41of professional conduct where you are in a conflicted
- 34:45situation if because this person is a former
- 34:47client you are not going to be as aggressive
- 34:49on behalf of your client as you otherwise would
- 34:51be and then there's also the duty to the former
- 34:56client precluding you from using That information
- 35:07so basically a former a lawyer is represented
- 35:11in a client in a matter may not thereafter represent
- 35:14another client in the same or substantially related
- 35:17matter in which the interests of the former client
- 35:20are materially adverse but if you don't have
- 35:27You know materially similar situations there's
- 35:33nothing precludes you from being adverse to a
- 35:38former client in a completely different transaction.
- 35:43However, that goes to and I believe it is rule
- 35:48one point six. I'm not positive. I did not put
- 35:50that or maybe it's 1 .9. In any event, in the
- 35:58California Rules of Professional Conduct, and
- 35:59I will say, if anybody after this wants a digital
- 36:03copy of the Rules of Professional Conduct, we
- 36:06can send you a PDF to have handy on your desktop
- 36:11to look at whenever you need to reference it,
- 36:14because as often as I talk about these rules,
- 36:17I still need to reference it. But you can...
- 36:22But this requires a disclosure to your current
- 36:27client that that's a former client. And again,
- 36:29I always call that sort of pulling your punches
- 36:31because that client needs to know that you formerly
- 36:35represented them because you don't want an argument
- 36:37later on that you weren't as aggressive as you
- 36:41should have been because that was your former
- 36:42client and you wanted to maintain that relationship.
- 36:45You also need a conflict waiver from the former
- 36:48client. to the representation. So that gets a
- 36:51little dicey. It's a dicey situation. But if
- 36:56a lawyer represented both parties in negotiating
- 37:00a deal, that's a situation where a lawyer can't
- 37:03represent one of those parties in a subsequent
- 37:06dispute over the deal, even if the adverse party
- 37:10is no longer represented by the lawyer. In the
- 37:16introductory example, if a lawyer represents
- 37:19both sides to a directing deal, representing
- 37:22the director only for purposes of the deal, and
- 37:25the director later raises a dispute with the
- 37:27producer on that project, the lawyer may not
- 37:30advise the producer on the subject matter of
- 37:33the dispute without informed consent of the director.
- 37:37Again, informed consent requires that the lawyer
- 37:39fully inform the director in writing, of all
- 37:42reasonably available facts that may affect the
- 37:45director's decision to consent. But what I would
- 37:49say is best practices is not to do that joint
- 37:54representation in the first place. So that's
- 37:58really, you're always going to hear from me the,
- 38:02you know, the black and white just don't do it.
- 38:05Dual representation, conflicted representation,
- 38:08suing former clients. those are all muddy waters.
- 38:12I understand that they sometimes need to occur
- 38:15by virtue of practice areas and whatnot. And
- 38:23our next topic of potential conflicts has to
- 38:31do with prospective clients. And that is California
- 38:35Rural Professional Conduct 1 .18. And so you
- 38:39should just know that you have duties that attach
- 38:42to a consultation, even if there's no formal
- 38:45representation. And you all may know this because
- 38:48I think it may be commonplace for people to consult
- 38:51with you in order to conflict you out later.
- 38:54But that is effective because if an actor shares
- 38:57confidential information in a consultation and
- 39:01a lawyer can't then represent a studio against
- 39:04that actor who consulted them on that issue.
- 39:07So you have duties to prospective clients, even
- 39:11if they don't end up retaining you. So, Annie,
- 39:15backing up just to talking about former clients,
- 39:19we have a really good question here that I'd
- 39:21like you to address. So representation of celebrity
- 39:24clients or smaller companies driven by key individuals
- 39:28can lead to very intimate knowledge of the client's
- 39:31way of thinking, interest strategies, et cetera.
- 39:34Can you be adverse to that client who you know
- 39:36in that way in a transaction? That's not substantially
- 39:39related to anything you've ever represented them
- 39:43in the past That is a good question and that
- 39:48falls under sort of it's what's called the playbook
- 39:52theory is that you can be conflicted out of a
- 39:57case if you have such intimate knowledge of the
- 40:01way that a a person, party, acts, thinks, believes,
- 40:09negotiates. If your knowledge is so intimate
- 40:12that you basically have their playbook, then
- 40:16you cannot represent them in... That matter because
- 40:22you have gained knowledge even if it's not the
- 40:25specific subject matter But if you've gotten
- 40:27close enough to understand and use that information
- 40:31against them because that's exactly what you're
- 40:33gonna do to represent your client Against them
- 40:37is you're gonna use all the information you you
- 40:39learn and know and you're gonna say, you know
- 40:41that You know That actor is known for this that
- 40:46and the other and I know that because I represented
- 40:48him in X, Y, Z. So that playbook exclusion is
- 40:55what will get you in trouble. And no, that is
- 40:59not representation that you should take on. And
- 41:03if anybody wants more information on the playbook
- 41:07concept of conflicts, I can also provide that.
- 41:11But I really want to touch on something that's
- 41:14pretty new. And I don't know that everyone in
- 41:18the entertainment field is aware of this. And
- 41:21this has to do with ethical walls. And the concept
- 41:26of ethical walls was very recently taught as
- 41:30a way to insulate a conflicted lawyer from other
- 41:32lawyers at the same firm. The idea of the ethical
- 41:35wall is to isolate the conflicted lawyer from
- 41:37giving any advice to the adverse client and prevent
- 41:41the conflicted lawyer from sharing confidential
- 41:43information. But rules of professional conduct
- 41:481 .8 .11 and 1 .10 were implemented and that
- 41:56changed the practice. And so they both concern
- 42:02imputation of conflicts with the law firm, but
- 42:04they apply to different situations. 1 .8 .11
- 42:09imputes conflicts described in rules 1 .8 .1
- 42:13through 1 .8 .9 related to current clients to
- 42:17other lawyers in the firm with few exceptions.
- 42:20Rule 1 .10 is the general rule for imputing conflicts
- 42:24of interest, and in California, it permits an
- 42:28ethical screen to avoid imputation when a lawyer
- 42:31moves between firms, but only if the lawyer didn't
- 42:35substantially participate in the prior matter.
- 42:37So these ethical screens used to be used all
- 42:42the time, where sometimes even lawyers in the
- 42:46same firm could represent, but they'd say, we
- 42:47have an ethical wall up, so nobody to protect
- 42:52everybody's interests. And so 1 .8 .11 imputation
- 42:58of current client conflicts ensures that if one
- 43:02lawyer in a firm is prohibited from a certain
- 43:05action with a client, the other lawyers in that
- 43:09firm are also prohibited. And it extends to a
- 43:14prohibition based on a personal conflict to the
- 43:16entire firm. And it didn't used to be that way.
- 43:20It used to be a fact -dependent, substantial
- 43:26relationship analysis where you could go through
- 43:33certain factors and determine if you can do it.
- 43:36But really what 1 .811 does is it says you can't
- 43:41do it. And if a lawyer prohibited from a business
- 43:46transaction with a client under that rule, then
- 43:49another lawyer in the same firm is also prohibited
- 43:52from that same transaction, even if they're not
- 43:54personally involved. The next part of the change
- 43:59in the rules of professional conduct is CRPC
- 44:021 .10, which is imputation of conflicts and ethical
- 44:07screening. And what that does, it's a general
- 44:10rule that determines when conflicts of interest
- 44:13are imputed to other lawyers in the firm. So
- 44:16in California, this rule includes a provision
- 44:18for ethical screening, and it allows a law firm
- 44:21to continue to represent a client, even if a
- 44:24new lawyer joining the firm has a conflict of
- 44:26interest, from a prior firm, but only if certain
- 44:29conditions are met. So this is the situation
- 44:33where you're representing someone, you know,
- 44:37you're representing talent and somebody and you
- 44:45hire someone from an advert from the firm that's
- 44:47adverse to you. The conflict is based on the
- 44:51new lawyer's former client at the previous firm
- 44:54because that conflict was imputed to them as
- 44:56well. and the conflict must be in the same or
- 44:59substantially related matter, but the new lawyer
- 45:02cannot have touched that file. The new lawyer
- 45:05must not have substantially participated in the
- 45:08matter while at the previous firm. That is the
- 45:10only way that you can do an ethical screen now,
- 45:14which is different than it used to be. Ethical
- 45:19screens used to be, again, disfavored but fact
- 45:23dependent and and an analysis that would allow
- 45:30you to have those situations within the firm.
- 45:35But now the rules have gotten a lot stricter
- 45:38with respect to that. We actually have a question
- 45:44which directly relates to that. So then Are you
- 45:47saying that if a lawyer in a firm represents
- 45:49a production company producing the show for a
- 45:51studio, and then another lawyer in the firm represents
- 45:54an actor who's now being hired for the show,
- 45:58is that no longer allowed under the current rules?
- 46:03Well, it depends. It's going to be my answer
- 46:07for everything is it depends. Is this conflicted
- 46:11representation? Presumably, if you're being hired
- 46:18first, the performers being hired for the show
- 46:21and they are negotiating with the production
- 46:25company for salary benefits, kickbacks, whatever
- 46:29it is, you know, rights, executive director rights,
- 46:34whatever it is, then you are negotiating between
- 46:39one client and another. And it used to be that
- 46:42you could do an ethical screen. And in this situation,
- 46:46I would say because the talent and the production
- 46:51company are often at odds with each other. And
- 46:55I think in the negotiation of, say, the talent's
- 47:00contract, the production company wants to pay
- 47:02less and the talent wants to get more. And so
- 47:07I think that's a direct conflict. And I don't
- 47:09think in the same firm you can do that. So I
- 47:12think a robust conflict check like Dana would
- 47:15require if we were writing you would catch that
- 47:18and you say, sorry, we're already representing
- 47:20the production company. We can't take you on
- 47:23as well because that is adverse representation.
- 47:27So a question just came in that I actually think
- 47:29would kind of go along with this. We have an
- 47:32individual asking, what are some best practices
- 47:35when doing client intake to gather the ideal
- 47:38data set to run through the conflict checks to
- 47:40make sure that, for example, a firm's representing
- 47:43an LLC and then later has a potential client
- 47:46maybe in a conflicting position with the individual
- 47:50owner or member of that LLC? So what would you
- 47:53recommend in doing the intake to make sure we
- 47:55have proper conflicts checks in place? That's
- 47:59a really good question. And so best practices
- 48:03when doing client intake to gather data to put
- 48:08in your conflict system would include all members
- 48:14of the LLC. And this actually really dovetails
- 48:18nicely into my next topic, which is conflicts
- 48:21when representing an entity as opposed to an
- 48:25individual. So when you are doing your conflict
- 48:30checks on the representation of an LLC, I would
- 48:37find out who all the members of the LLC are and
- 48:41the LLC itself, and then put all those in your
- 48:45database. And then another potential client who's
- 48:49conflicting with an individual owner member of
- 48:51the LLC, all those owner members names will be
- 48:54listed in your conflict check system. And that
- 48:58was how you will be able to cross reference them.
- 49:02But, you know, so I hope that answers your question.
- 49:05And I'm going to dovetail into conflicts when
- 49:09representing an entity. And that's a perfect
- 49:11example. So thank you, Sharonda. When representing
- 49:15an entity, you represent the entity, not the
- 49:18individuals. And so If a client signing a fee
- 49:22agreement is a business entity and there's additional,
- 49:25you know, there are additional considerations
- 49:27for conflicts. You are obviously communicating
- 49:32with humans and entities can't speak to you.
- 49:34So your entity is being, you know, there's a
- 49:39mouthpiece for the entity, but that mouthpiece
- 49:41for the entity is not your client. Any individual
- 49:46associated with the entity California Rules of
- 49:50Professional Conduct 1 .13a. If a conflict arises
- 49:55between a principal of a client and the entity,
- 49:58and the principal has had communications with
- 50:00the lawyer in the course of representing the
- 50:02entity, those communications can be privileged,
- 50:06but the holder of the privilege is the entity.
- 50:10So it follows that the lawyer cannot represent
- 50:13a principal of the entity in a subsequent or
- 50:16ongoing dispute with the entity. So the lawyer
- 50:20has to act in the best interest of the entity
- 50:24and even report to the entity if the lawyer discovers
- 50:28that a principle of the entity is undertaking
- 50:31or planning conduct against the interests of
- 50:34the entity. So that is a that is a morass of
- 50:42of complication. And so It's sort of like if
- 50:47you're general counsel for a business, you represent
- 50:52the business, not the individual. So think about
- 50:54a law firm. If a law firm has general counsel
- 50:57for the company, somebody's speaking on behalf
- 51:06of the company, but your interest is in protecting
- 51:09the firm. So if the firm is your client that
- 51:14I'm thinking about like outside general counsel
- 51:16not inside so not a member of the firm But if
- 51:19you've got if your firm has outside general counsel
- 51:21their job is to protect the firm if the relationship
- 51:25is with the entity so that gets very complicated
- 51:29because you may get phone calls from you know
- 51:32people within the entity and you've got those
- 51:36communications, but if somebody reports to you
- 51:39that somebody else is trying to undermine the
- 51:41entity, you've got to protect the entity. So
- 51:48that gets to be complicated because you can't
- 51:53reveal client confidences. So you need to make
- 51:55sure who speaks for the entity, what you do,
- 51:59what you don't do. And so, for example, when
- 52:03we were talking before about the LLC and then
- 52:06a dispute, with a member of the LLC that falls
- 52:10into this category of make sure you know who
- 52:14your client is. And that is one of the critical
- 52:18things in any area of practice is make sure you
- 52:21know who your client is. It's very easy in these
- 52:25situations, especially if you've got a small
- 52:29partnership or two individuals. Your retainer
- 52:34agreement needs to say, I am representing the
- 52:37entity and not either of you. And if a conflict
- 52:40arises, I can't represent any of you. So I am
- 52:50going to talk about, real quickly, some of the
- 52:59risks of Serving as an agent manager or producer
- 53:05while also being an attorney You know, I know
- 53:10Dana knows or Dana has told me that we specifically
- 53:13act Ask about this and we do not write people
- 53:16who are agents or managers Because of the conflicting
- 53:20fiduciary duties and the conflicts that it creates
- 53:22so if you are in a situation where you are wearing
- 53:28multiple hats just know that Either your insurance
- 53:33company may not cover you if you've got the policy
- 53:37or you may not get insurance for acting in those
- 53:42rules because those are not legal services per
- 53:44se. So wearing multiple hats is risky. It's dangerous
- 53:49and it borders on being unethical because again,
- 53:52there can be conflicts between your fiduciary
- 53:56obligations in each of those roles. So that's
- 54:00just a good sort of reminder. Let's see. I'm
- 54:07going to answer a couple of questions, and then
- 54:09we're probably pretty close to wrapping up. Nicole,
- 54:14can a lawyer represent a defendant interview
- 54:18and communicate with a former defendant who was
- 54:22dismissed? By a confidential settlement agreement,
- 54:28the former defendant is now in pro -per. I'm
- 54:33not sure I understand the question. I think what's
- 54:38being asked is if there is a lawsuit to defendants,
- 54:41one's dismissed and then goes into pro -per after
- 54:44they're dismissed via a settlement agreement,
- 54:47can the attorney for the other defendant reach
- 54:49out to that individual who is the ex -co -defendant
- 54:52who's now in pro -per? I mean, I guess the question
- 54:59depends on a couple of things. Were you representing
- 55:03that other defendant? And if you were not representing
- 55:12them, and they were in proper now, you absolutely
- 55:18can talk to former parties. You can't, I mean,
- 55:24if they were dismissed by a confidential settlement
- 55:26agreement, you have to do it pursuant to the
- 55:29terms of the settlement agreement. If the settlement
- 55:31agreement indicate, well, do you have a copy
- 55:38of that settlement agreement? Or is that only
- 55:41between the plaintiff and the dismissed defendant?
- 55:44So essentially, you can contact that person.
- 55:47But what that person says to you may be covered
- 55:50by confidentiality, and they may not be able
- 55:53to answer any of your question. But I don't think
- 55:56it is prohibited for a lawyer representing one
- 56:00defendant to contact another defendant that's
- 56:05absolutely permissible. And if they're proper,
- 56:09then you're not in violation of the rule against
- 56:11communicating with represented parties. So I
- 56:14think you're fine to do that, but I think you
- 56:16should be mindful of the fact that if there's
- 56:20a confidential settlement agreement, your answers
- 56:23that you get from that other co -defendant may
- 56:25be very limited. And so, Paul wants to... I hope
- 56:32I answered that question, Nicole. And Paul is
- 56:35asking, elaborate on the issues regarding wearing
- 56:38two hats, lawyer and agent. So, essentially,
- 56:42lawyer and agent are two very different roles.
- 56:46So the lawyer is, you know, as defined in every
- 56:51legal malpractice policy is performing legal
- 56:53services on behalf of the client. And you need
- 56:56to be a lawyer in order to do that role. An agent
- 57:01is not necessarily a lawyer and an agent may
- 57:05use some of their legal acumen in the capacity
- 57:10as an agent. But there are two very different
- 57:13roles and they're usually held by two different
- 57:17people, an agent and a lawyer. Again, some smaller
- 57:22productions and smaller projects can say, hey,
- 57:28can you do both? And there are different obligations
- 57:32for lawyers than for agents. And if you are doing
- 57:37both, there may be conflicted representation
- 57:40because agents get percentages of fees. lawyers
- 57:43are doing allegedly only legal work. And so wearing
- 57:48those two hats is, you know, as I characterize
- 57:52it, can be a situation where you have conflicted
- 57:56fiduciary obligations, because as an agent, you
- 57:59can also be needing to advocate for yourself
- 58:02as an agent, which again, that's basically almost
- 58:06like going into business with your client. And
- 58:09so then all those rules apply and they're construed
- 58:12against you. So you have to think broadly about
- 58:15sort of, how can this get me in trouble? And
- 58:18there are a lot of ways it can. And so I always
- 58:22hate to be the doomsday consultant, but you know,
- 58:25my job is to spot issues and spotting these issues
- 58:29and the potential down the road of what if this
- 58:34goes wrong? And we always have to ask that question.
- 58:36And it's a kind of a sad situation to say, I
- 58:39need to think about my clients as my future adversaries,
- 58:44but in a lot of ways you do. And so if this doesn't
- 58:49go right, what are the potential minefields that
- 58:53I'm stepping into? And that's really how I would
- 58:57ask all of you to look at your relationships
- 59:01at the outset. And that would be a perfect example
- 59:05of if I take on the role of lawyer and agent,
- 59:09what are the potential consequences? of that
- 59:13representation. And down the road, if this relationship
- 59:17sours, where's my liability? And the answer to
- 59:21that is in a lot of places, and it's bigger than
- 59:24you want it to be. Go ahead. I think we're going
- 59:30to say the same thing. We're kind of approaching
- 59:32time here. And so what are the important takeaways
- 59:34you really want people to walk away with having
- 59:37listened to us today? So there's a few. robust
- 59:42conflict checks, as detailed as possible, disclosure
- 59:47and consent, informed written consent required
- 59:50under 1 .7b. Ethical screens know that they are
- 59:54rarely effective in private practice unless the
- 59:57firm is very large, and know that if a conflict
- 1:00:01is unresolvable, rules of professional conduct
- 1:00:041 .16 require withdrawal. So this will tell me
- 1:00:11This leads me to retainer agreements, which in
- 1:00:17some ways could be the beginning of this presentation
- 1:00:19or the end, but anticipate conflicts when drafting
- 1:00:23your retainer agreements. Advance consent for
- 1:00:26certain conflicts, but again, that's limited
- 1:00:29in California, and it needs to be an ongoing
- 1:00:33analysis. So practical guidance, draft a clear
- 1:00:39retainer agreement, with the scope of representation,
- 1:00:42disclaimers, and conflict waivers. Again, avoid
- 1:00:46dual roles. Resist that temptation to be both
- 1:00:49the lawyer and the producer agent. Maintain strict
- 1:00:54confidentiality protocols when handling scripts,
- 1:00:57deals, financials. You are a fiduciary. The fiduciary
- 1:01:01obligation is twofold. It is the duty of loyalty
- 1:01:03and the duty of confidentiality. Strict confidentiality
- 1:01:08is required as a fiduciary and you can't get
- 1:01:11around that So as tempting as it may be to have
- 1:01:15inside knowledge on something Maintain your confidentiality
- 1:01:19and that maintains your reputation and I know
- 1:01:22in entertainment law your reputation is Everything
- 1:01:25and your alliances are everything because this
- 1:01:28is such a relationship based area of law so I
- 1:01:34would always say that when you do have a conflict,
- 1:01:38whether it requires disclosure, whether it's
- 1:01:41entering into business, whether it requires a
- 1:01:45waiver, having in that document a line that says
- 1:01:51you have the right to and should consult with
- 1:01:55independent counsel about the information I have
- 1:01:57just shared with you, that will save you a lot.
- 1:02:02those words in writing are critical and very
- 1:02:06important to your defense down the line. And
- 1:02:10again, it's not required in, you know, a disclosure
- 1:02:14or certain waivers, but it is best practices.
- 1:02:21Standard of care? I don't know, but I'm telling
- 1:02:24you, there are so many cases where protecting
- 1:02:29yourself in an advanced way by going so far as
- 1:02:33to giving advice that is not required of you
- 1:02:37and telling them, hey, look, talk to another
- 1:02:39lawyer. And if this isn't kosher, then we move
- 1:02:42on and we don't do this. That is a really critically
- 1:02:45important thing. And I would include it in all
- 1:02:47of them, in disclosures, in waivers. And certainly,
- 1:02:52you must when you are entering into business
- 1:02:54transactions, that's required. But I would say
- 1:02:58to do it in all of them. And then, you know,
- 1:03:01If your carrier is not Lawyers Mutual, see if
- 1:03:05your carrier has a hotline where they can walk
- 1:03:07you through some of these steps. If you are with
- 1:03:09Lawyers Mutual, call me anytime. We walk through
- 1:03:12all of this. You can stay up to date with the
- 1:03:17State Bar opinions. There is an ethics hotline
- 1:03:20with the California State Bar. From what I understand,
- 1:03:24they don't do exactly as we do. But, you know,
- 1:03:302021 state bar opinion number 205 talks about
- 1:03:34multiple clients and joint representation and
- 1:03:36the importance of informed consent. If you want
- 1:03:38to see some practical type analysis from the
- 1:03:44state bar. So with that, I think we are essentially
- 1:03:51wrapped up. But I would just say. Conflicts are
- 1:03:56heightened in entertainment law because of overlapping
- 1:03:59interests. And that's just a fact of your practice
- 1:04:02area. The main pillars that you need to look
- 1:04:05at are rules of professional conduct 1 .7, 1
- 1:04:09.81, and 1 .9. And your best defense in all of
- 1:04:13these cases are robust conflict checks, disclosures,
- 1:04:17and strict client communication and confidentiality.
- 1:04:21So I will leave you all with that. It has been
- 1:04:26a pleasure to present to all of you today. If
- 1:04:29you want any information about our company or
- 1:04:33the lawyer to lawyer hotline and what we can
- 1:04:36do, we are all happy to talk to you. My information
- 1:04:41is included with the presentation as is Dana's.
- 1:04:46So if you have a claims question or an underwriting
- 1:04:48question, we both remain available to you to
- 1:04:51chat at your convenience. Let me just do a double
- 1:04:56check in the chat. Okay, the rules of professional
- 1:05:01conduct are there. And David, I didn't answer
- 1:05:05your question, but you have direct contact to
- 1:05:08me, so I'll answer that offline.