Latest / Keen On America / Whoosh! That Really Was a Week in Tech: Winner-Take-All AI and the $1 Trillion Selloff
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, my name is Andrew Keen.
- 0:02Welcome to Keen on America, the daily show about everything that matters with the
- 0:07world's leading commentators and thinkers.
- 0:30Hello everybody.
- 0:31It is Saturday the 7th of February.
- 0:33I am talking to, as always, from San Francisco.
- 0:36Tomorrow is the Super Bowl, the annual American.
- 0:41Celebration of all things football.
- 0:44Um, one piece in the Financial Times talks about how the NFL became
- 0:50America's true national pastime.
- 0:52It's the one thing that brings Americans together, and of course
- 0:55it's taking place tomorrow in Silicon Valley and the heart of San Jose.
- 1:01But as it happens, uh, the.
- 1:04Super Bowl is not bringing Silicon Valley together.
- 1:08In fact, it's dividing them.
- 1:09That's been the big story of the week out here.
- 1:12Anthropic have a big ad about the absence of advertising in their
- 1:17product, and Sam Altman has lashed out.
- 1:20Keith, I know you are a keen observer of all things ChatGPT and Anthropic.
- 1:26What should we make of this latest, um, spat between Altman
- 1:33and Anthropic; Dario Amodei
- 1:37well, the, the, the joke on the streets here is, um, of course
- 1:41Anthropic doesn't have ads.
- 1:43Because it doesn't have consumers.
- 1:46Um, and so ads would play no role for it.
- 1:48Whereas OpenAI has hundreds of millions of consumers, many of
- 1:53whom use the service for free.
- 1:55So ads make sense, but the, the more serious point underneath
- 2:00that, um, pushback is to do with the content of Amodei's ads are
- 2:07basically fundamentally dishonest.
- 2:09Uh, and deceitful.
- 2:11Uh, he's making the point that OpenAI plans to have the AI tell you different
- 2:17things based on what it's trying to sell you, which is just not true.
- 2:21Um, and, but it's,
- 2:22when was the last time Keith, you ever saw an honest ad? By definition, those
- 2:25are ads by definition at dishonest, so I don't know why we should object to that.
- 2:30Um, uh, uh, Altman had an interesting ex-post.
- 2:35Uh, he acknowledges that the philanthropic ad. Is funny and it made him laugh, but
- 2:41he says, and and it's interesting that the way he frames it, he suggests that
- 2:47most people can't afford anthropic.
- 2:49It's too expensive.
- 2:50Only wealthy people use Anthropic and therefore the OpenAI.
- 2:55Advertising model is actually suited for less well off people.
- 2:59It's an old argument.
- 3:00It was made back in the Web 2.0.
- 3:02Age as well.
- 3:04Yeah.
- 3:04Look, I've, I, I've advocated for, um, not ads.
- 3:08I don't like the word ads 'cause it conjuress up exactly
- 3:11what, uh, Amodei is implying.
- 3:15Uh, but paid links, a paid, a paid link.
- 3:19Uh, if relevant to the context can be a helpful thing.
- 3:22And I, I see that more and more actually in places like Instagram
- 3:26where the ads are relevant to something I'm kind of interested in
- 3:30and I don't object to them as much.
- 3:32So I think, I think there's a smart way for Altman to be right and I
- 3:37think for sure am day has done.
- 3:39It is a good marketing move by him, don't get me wrong, but it's.
- 3:43And you're right, ads are doula.
- 3:46Um, but it isn't like the Apple 1984 ad, which was.
- 3:52Truly symbolizing, um, a shift and a change in Apple's position in the world.
- 3:58Thi this is just, um, childish.
- 4:01I mean, it's like playground stuff, so it doesn't, it doesn't really, uh, you
- 4:06don't draw the conclusion that Anthropic is breaking through to a, to a new,
- 4:11oh, they're coming back.
- 4:12I hadn't thought of the, uh, the Apple 84 ad, but the anthro, uh,
- 4:15the Apple 84 ad was very much.
- 4:18Directed against IBM and their model.
- 4:20So it was equally childish in the sense that they were bashing their rival.
- 4:25Yeah, it, it, it was childish, but.
- 4:27Luckily for Apple, it reinforced a true theme in the real world, whereas no one
- 4:34in the real world thinks that Anthropic is looking out for the interest of consumers,
- 4:39'cause it isn't a consumer company.
- 4:41It's
- 4:41just, well, I use it.
- 4:41I'm a consumer.
- 4:43I'm not sure that's an entirely true.
- 4:44Um, Altman's been ridiculed, uh, according to the BBC, at least for
- 4:51what they call his online tantrum.
- 4:53Do you think it reached a nerve?
- 4:54Uh, Altman's usually a fairly smart, self-controlled guy.
- 4:58Why, why did he respond so angrily?
- 5:01Well, it goes to the roots of his personality.
- 5:04I mean, Al Altman is, um, you know, a somewhat deceitful and devious person
- 5:11himself, probably more so than Amodei.
- 5:14And when you get under his skin, a bit like Trump.
- 5:18He reacts and, and, and that's what happened there.
- 5:21Um, you know, if you look at the other player, uh, Demis, uh,
- 5:26Hassabis
- 5:28um, of the three, he's the most, you know, uh, I'd say fundamentally,
- 5:36intellectually honest of the three.
- 5:38Well, it's interesting you put him in their company.
- 5:40He is, of course not the CEO of Google, although he runs.
- 5:44DeepMind, he's the Google AI chief.
- 5:47I wonder, Keith, whether one could argue that.
- 5:51Altman was already irritated enough this week.
- 5:53Anthropic's had a remarkable week, uh, a breakout moment according to the
- 5:58FT with the launch of, um, their new, uh, version of, uh, of, of Claude,
- 6:06which has really riled the markets.
- 6:08How big a week has it been, do you think, for Anthropic?
- 6:11And do you think that's the real reason why Altman has lashed out?
- 6:15Well, look, j just to frame it, uh, I think the answer to that is no.
- 6:19Because literally the day after that, anthropic Launch ChatGPT launched
- 6:26version 5.3 of of its, um, modeled, which was a very similar leap.
- 6:36The Anthropic one, and indeed yesterday I spent most of yesterday
- 6:39playing with both of them, and I'm an anthropic user, as you know.
- 6:43We talked about, are you a
- 6:43consumer?
- 6:44Keith?
- 6:45Never.
- 6:46Nevermind whether I'm a consumer, but I am now a convert to OpenAI.
- 6:49I used OpenAI to do the You
- 6:51But you've always been a convert.
- 6:53No, I've used Anthropic forever.
- 6:55I don't, I don't use OpenAI um, uh, because I see it as a consumer app.
- 7:00I'm, uh, and I'm using it for real use cases in my work.
- 7:04But yesterday I switched to OpenAI because the, the new is called, uh, OpenAI Codex,
- 7:10which is an app that runs on the Mac.
- 7:12Uh, not to be confused with the codex they've had for months.
- 7:16And it is, it is, um, it and Anthropic, and this is both of them.
- 7:21Uh, so this is the big story.
- 7:23Both of them have introduced, um, the ability for the interface, the chat
- 7:29interface to launch multiple workers, if you will, or agents in their language.
- 7:35So if you give it a task that has multiple skills.
- 7:38It will spin up an agent for each of those skills and they'll
- 7:41collaborate with each other.
- 7:43In the case of Anthropic, they literally talk to each other.
- 7:47In the case of OpenAI, there's a, a, a kind of a boss agent that each of
- 7:51the other agents talk to one-on-one, but they're all collaborating on
- 7:55your job and the outcome of the job.
- 7:58And it can take, you know, anywhere for depending on the complexity
- 8:01of the job, anywhere between 10 and 15 minutes to complete.
- 8:06And it replaces.
- 8:09Software.
- 8:10You know, you don't, you don't really use software anymore.
- 8:12You use
- 8:13Yeah, I mean, that's the headline.
- 8:14Keith, say it again?
- 8:15It replaces software.
- 8:16I mean, that's a massive statement.
- 8:18You've been hinting at this now for months, but it, this seems to be the
- 8:22week where the promise of replacing software has become a reality with
- 8:29the launch of Claude Opus 4.6 and of course the new ChatGPT, uh, a lot of
- 8:35the headlines this week have been about.
- 8:38And, and this one is about Anthropic Anthropic triggering
- 8:42a a trillion dollar sell off.
- 8:44When we talk about replacing software, it means that software companies are in
- 8:50suddenly being dramatically hit on the markets and, and in every other sense.
- 8:55Yeah.
- 8:56I mean, if we define software as.
- 8:59Take my Creator automation.ai, which I built for myself with AI.
- 9:05I didn't use it this week because the OpenAI agents were better than
- 9:09my software, and, and that's me grandfathering my own software, or
- 9:15that's the wrong word, isn't it?
- 9:16Retiring my own software, which was custom built for my use case, and OpenAI now
- 9:22does a better job than my software, and by the way, saves me about two hours.
- 9:27That otherwise I would've had to use the other.
- 9:30The other one is Claude Bart, which has now been renamed to Open Claw.
- 9:35Yeah.
- 9:35You've got, uh, you, you quote in your post of the week, um, om
- 9:41who says Open Claw is ht, HAWT.
- 9:46Well, and OOII, I put it to work on my newsletter as well.
- 9:51Two, I, I actually produced two copies of my newsletter.
- 9:53One with OpenAI, uh, and one with Openclaw and, uh, actually a third one with Claude
- 10:00and Claude didn't, wasn't very good.
- 10:04Um, for my use case, it's probably good.
- 10:06Uh, other things, it's very good in Excel, for example, if you use the
- 10:10Claude Plug into Excel, it's fantastic.
- 10:13Um, but, um, both Open Claw and OpenAI did a actually a really, really good job.
- 10:18Now, the nice thing about Open Claw is, um, I can embed its persona in a telegram.
- 10:26Uh, uh, account and I can talk to it and ask it to do things from anywhere in the
- 10:32world, and it's running on my computer at home and will carry out my tasks.
- 10:37So when, when you put it all together this week was a massive shift in how you use
- 10:44AI and how productive it can be for you,
- 10:47right?
- 10:48And, and let's talk about the impact on the rest of the market.
- 10:51As I said, um.
- 10:53Some people believe that this latest version of Anthropic's Claude triggered
- 10:58a trillion dollar se sell off.
- 10:59What will it mean to companies like.
- 11:01Adobe middle market companies look at the stock price.
- 11:04It's dramatically collapsed over the last few days, and, and they're not alone.
- 11:09The same has happened with PayPal and many other software companies.
- 11:12Yeah, Salesforce.
- 11:14Um, uh,
- 11:15yeah, and Salesforce used to be a cutting edge company.
- 11:17Now it appears more and more archaic.
- 11:19Workday, I noticed that Workday, um, all, all, all of these companies have had
- 11:24massive reductions in their share price.
- 11:27I mean, in a way, Google is lucky to be in the AI game.
- 11:30If it wasn't, it would've had a similar.
- 11:33Reduction based on workspaces and, and, and, um, you know,
- 11:37Google Docs and all that stuff.
- 11:39So, so ba basically what's happened is the stock market has moved away from software
- 11:46companies and SaaS companies as well.
- 11:49It, it, it can't yet move towards AI companies because they're not listed yet.
- 11:53They, they probably,
- 11:54well, Google is.
- 11:55Google is, but actually Google had a bit of a drop this week as well.
- 11:59'cause it's a hybrid.
- 12:01Um, and, uh, and you know, I don't believe it will stay a hybrid.
- 12:05I think it's gonna go the whole way and become an AI company.
- 12:08Uh, unlike saying Microsoft, which had a huge hit this week
- 12:11because it's deemed to not be an AI
- 12:13company.
- 12:14And, and Amazon, Amazon had a terrible week.
- 12:16I mean, just to put things in perspective, um, Google, Google's
- 12:21numbers came out this week.
- 12:22They beat.
- 12:24Expectations dramatically.
- 12:26And yet, uh, the stock declined even though they committed $185 billion
- 12:31this year to investment in AI.
- 12:33So it does reflect the complete shift in, in the way the markets are viewing
- 12:40tech companies and their valuations.
- 12:42Yeah.
- 12:43Yeah.
- 12:43Although I, you know, I, I think we should say out loud.
- 12:46Google are doing the right thing by doing that and Oh,
- 12:49absolutely.
- 12:49And Amazon, I think, committed $200 billion and, and their, their,
- 12:54their stock, uh, lost about 10%.
- 12:58And, and Microsoft, of course, um, is increasingly looking of all
- 13:04these tech giants the least able to, uh, embrace AI, or at least as
- 13:12well, it, it's become a utility in the AI world, a bit like Oracle, Microsoft.
- 13:17It, it isn't a player except at the infrastructure layer.
- 13:21And it, it will be able to charge a rent for that infrastructure
- 13:24through Azure as it does to OpenAI.
- 13:27But it, it isn't gonna be the company that transforms our experience.
- 13:31Right.
- 13:31And they're, they're cloud numbers.
- 13:33Uh, in, if not in crisis, certainly in decline, especially compared to
- 13:39to, to glue to Google's cloud numbers.
- 13:41So even on that front, they're not succeeding.
- 13:43The other thing to bring into this, 'cause I think it's part of it, is
- 13:47the merger between SpaceX and XAI.
- 13:50Yeah, I was gonna bring that up.
- 13:52I mean, Elon Musk as.
- 13:55Regular viewers, listeners to the show, knowing our conversations.
- 13:58I'm not a big fan, but you have to admire, I mean, he thinks very clearly on this.
- 14:03And according to The Economist, he's betting his business empire on
- 14:07AI by merging XAI, uh, and SpaceX.
- 14:11So he's, he's part of this dramatic week, isn't he?
- 14:15Yeah.
- 14:15I mean, I think if you measure the effectiveness of the CEOs
- 14:20in, uh, or leaders in this space, he's the most definitive.
- 14:25You know, he says, this is what's gonna happen, here's what I'm gonna do.
- 14:29He then does it, and you know, in his case, he, it's, um, audacious.
- 14:34He wants to put apparently a million satellites into orbit,
- 14:38which are effectively data centers for AI processing, using the
- 14:42power of the sun to, to fuel 'em.
- 14:45And, you know, there's no doubt even that's a huge audacious goal.
- 14:50He reckons by 36 months from now.
- 14:53Most of the power needed to run data centers and AI will be in space.
- 14:58Um, who we'll see.
- 14:59Yeah.
- 14:59Which is interesting because Google this week came out with more
- 15:03initiatives about their AI energy race, investing in earth bound energy.
- 15:09So that's gonna be an interesting story.
- 15:12Keith, a couple of months ago we did a show on AI.
- 15:16It seems every week we do a show on AI.
- 15:18We talked to, or you argued that the AI race is a myth and I. Argued
- 15:23that it's a bit of a wacky race every week there's a new leader.
- 15:27Has anything changed this week in terms of the order?
- 15:31We have Google, we have Microsoft, we have OpenAI, we have Anthropic, we have XAI.
- 15:38Has anything dramatically changed or is it just that AI is moving
- 15:43ahead of the rest of the tech world?
- 15:46Uh, AI is moving ahead.
- 15:48Um.
- 15:49It's, we, it's easy to forget this, but the first player who stepped up to this
- 15:54new level of functionality was Kimi.
- 15:57K 2.5 is the version, which is a Chinese, uh, system that started this
- 16:05concept called agents swarms to, uh, put a swarm of agents against a task.
- 16:11That was three weeks ago, I think.
- 16:13So the last three weeks have seen Kimmy.
- 16:16OpenAI and, and anthropic leapfrog Google actually.
- 16:21So Gemini now is a generation behind again and no doubt is
- 16:26already working on not being.
- 16:27So it is like the wacky race.
- 16:28It's every episode or every week it seems to be a new leader.
- 16:31One pulls ahead, one falls behind.
- 16:34Is there a dick dastardly here?
- 16:35Is it, I mean, for me, of course it's Musk.
- 16:38Uh, for others it's Altman some.
- 16:40It's Dario Amdis.
- 16:42It does it really depend on one's own perspective.
- 16:47I vaguely watched that show when I was a kid, but I can't, uh, I haven't
- 16:51got your ability to link it to what's going on, so, so I don't know who
- 16:56is Dick dastardly in this context.
- 16:58The, the bad guy chasing down all everyone else and cheating is probably Amodei.
- 17:05If there is one, because he's, he's just using marketing and lying to
- 17:10try to look better when he, when he actually isn't any better.
- 17:14In other words, he's as bad as everybody else.
- 17:17Yeah.
- 17:19And the focus of your editorial this week is that the CEOs are not growing up, but
- 17:24does that reflect again, the reality of our AI age or however smart AI becomes
- 17:29and it's becoming smarter and smarter.
- 17:31It's not making humans any smarter.
- 17:33It doesn't make Elon Musk or Sam Aman or Dario Amodei, and we just accept
- 17:39that, that however smart AI becomes, we're always gonna be a bit dimwitted.
- 17:43We're always gonna watch.
- 17:45Stick dastardly and wacky races.
- 17:48Yeah.
- 17:48I, I, I don't think
- 17:49exactly you of course, who, who, who was always mature.
- 17:52Were you, what were you doing when you, what were, you were watching?
- 17:54Six, uh, uh, when you were six Keith, uh, Shakespeare
- 17:58when I was six.
- 18:00You missed wacky races.
- 18:02How?
- 18:03I was six in 1960, so I think I was probably watching top of the pops.
- 18:07Uh, so you did have a little bit of triviality.
- 18:10You weren't always an adult or as much of an adult as you are now.
- 18:13I,
- 18:14I certainly wasn't, but, you know, but I, I, I, uh, I, we lost
- 18:19the thread there a little bit when you asked me that question.
- 18:22I was, I, I had it all teed up and now it's gone.
- 18:25So.
- 18:25Okay.
- 18:25Well, let me tee you up again.
- 18:27Um.
- 18:29Are, are we dealing with these weirdly paradoxical realities that on the
- 18:33one hand, AI is becoming smarter and smarter and on the other hand
- 18:36we it's becoming dumber and dumber.
- 18:39Yeah.
- 18:39I've got it back.
- 18:40So, look, I I, I don't think we should be measuring AI's impact on whether
- 18:44it makes individual human smarter.
- 18:47Um, I, I, I think we, we are as smart as we are, we're all different.
- 18:52What it does is it makes us.
- 18:54Leverage tools to get more done, hopefully done better.
- 19:01Uh, not always true.
- 19:02Sometimes it gets done worse, hence the slop word.
- 19:06Um, and it doesn't make us smarter.
- 19:09It just makes us better at using our smarts to get things done.
- 19:13And, and I think if it can achieve that, that's huge.
- 19:16But then why'd you write this editorial about AI growing up and the CEOs aren't?
- 19:21Well, so that is to do with two things.
- 19:23Uh, let's take AI growing up.
- 19:26This, this leapfrog from a single chat interface with a single AI to AI that
- 19:33can carry out work using multiple AI agents that it manages is, is a huge
- 19:40change in what AI can do and how fast it can do it, and how well it can do it.
- 19:45That's the AI growing up bit, the CEO's not growing up, is the mud
- 19:49fight between Altman and Amodei.
- 19:53Um, basically when Amodei talks about adolescence in, in terms of the tech,
- 19:59it's ironic 'cause he's displaying adolescence in his use of advertising.
- 20:03And Altman is equally in his response showing adolescence when all of them
- 20:08have got better things to be doing, they, they're actually contributing massively.
- 20:13But having this side fight as they do it, that that's the CEO's not growing up bit.
- 20:20But, so what does that tell us that, are you optimistic that these people
- 20:24can become a little bit more mature or is that just the nature of things?
- 20:29They totally can.
- 20:29Yeah.
- 20:30I mean, I, all of every entrepreneur, and I'll include myself in this, in
- 20:36the, you know, in their learning phase.
- 20:38When they, having their ass handed to them in all kinds of ways, uh, react,
- 20:44um, based on their past experience, you know, either better or worse.
- 20:49I, I had some when I was doing real names, roughly at their age.
- 20:53Uh, I remember thinking I could beat Microsoft in a fight.
- 20:57And I, I really thought I could.
- 21:00Um, and I didn't.
- 21:01I lost and had my ass handed to me.
- 21:03And over time you learn that not everything is under your control.
- 21:08And that is a maturing learning curve.
- 21:11They'll, they'll all get there, um, because the world won't be
- 21:15kind to them unless they go there.
- 21:18Well, one thing for sure is they've all got jobs and it was an, an
- 21:21interesting, another interesting.
- 21:23Piece of this week's news, there's so many interesting stories this week,
- 21:27is that US job openings dropped to a five year low, uh, in December, 2025.
- 21:34More and more pessimism on the job front.
- 21:37One big piece, at least of media news was that the Washington Post.
- 21:42Uh, essentially committed suicide, at least according to the Atlantic.
- 21:47Is this an important week in terms, again, you've talked about
- 21:50swarms and bots and smart ais.
- 21:54Is this an important week or will it be seen Keith as an important week when it
- 21:57comes to what more and more people are believing to be a crisis of human labor?
- 22:05I think it is the starting point of that.
- 22:08Uh, and most of these things are overreactions, uh, based on
- 22:13a misunderstanding of timing.
- 22:16I don't, I don't think timing suggests that.
- 22:19You know, anytime soon, meaning the next few months, you're gonna see
- 22:24a huge change in the job market.
- 22:26Um, I, you know, so I think the answer is there's always an
- 22:31emotionally overreaction and the stock market is the extreme of that.
- 22:34'cause it reprices things very early once it sees a trend.
- 22:39So there is truth in the reactions, but timing wise, probably an overreaction.
- 22:46Coming back to my favorite television program, wacky Races.
- 22:50It is made up of all sorts of interesting teams.
- 22:53Uh, and in terms of the AI wacky races, I mean, obviously we think
- 22:56of Anthropic and OpenAI and Google, Microsoft, Amazon XAI, but I know
- 23:03for you it's a more complicated race.
- 23:07The VCs are also participating, and in this week's editorial you imply that.
- 23:14They're not doing very well, but they're certainly not leading
- 23:17the pack when it comes to the AI race and this crisis of software.
- 23:22Can we talk, Keith, also maybe last week about the crisis of
- 23:25traditional venture capital as well?
- 23:29Well, the, the crisis is, uh, what you could think of as.
- 23:34Um, a, a massive concentration of capital into a small number of hands.
- 23:39In venture capital, most of the money being raised and deployed is
- 23:43coming through about five funds.
- 23:46Um, those five funds, uh, sucking the air out of the room.
- 23:52So the, the, the venture ecosystem thrives due to seed investors.
- 23:58Who find these companies before anyone even knows they exist, and
- 24:02the seed investors are being starved of oxygen and many are threatened.
- 24:08With being viable.
- 24:10And there's a lot of writing this week about that.
- 24:13Uh, three, three very good pieces.
- 24:15One from Beza Clarks and one from Dan Gray.
- 24:18And, um, I'm blanking on who the third one is.
- 24:22Um, and, and they all, uh, naval gazing about the impact of this
- 24:28structural shift in capital.
- 24:31For innovation.
- 24:32And I think that's, that's a reasonable concern.
- 24:35I do, I I do think that, um, really, really good angels and
- 24:39seed investors will still thrive.
- 24:42But, um, anyone in the middle is, is threatened.
- 24:46Yeah.
- 24:46And it, it, this is part of this crisis.
- 24:50It's the middle market companies like Adobe is in crisis.
- 24:54Um, it's the five or six.
- 24:57AI companies that are dominating everything, whether they're private,
- 25:01privately owned or publicly owned.
- 25:03There'd probably be two IPOs, anthropic and OpenAI this year.
- 25:08So what's happening with Venture is a mirror and a cause, or perhaps a
- 25:13cause and a consequence of what's happening more broadly in tech.
- 25:18Is that fair?
- 25:19I mean, it's a, it's a winner take all economy in every sense.
- 25:22Yeah.
- 25:22Whether you are an investor, whether you are a developer, whether.
- 25:26Um, whether you are an ex, uh, you are an AI company
- 25:32Yeah.
- 25:32And there's some public companies in there as well.
- 25:34And Palantir's results this week were spectacular.
- 25:39Um, it did actually suffer, um, a, a big rise and then a big drop in it.
- 25:43Share price.
- 25:45Over two days.
- 25:46Um, you think of and Unreal, who's the AI in?
- 25:50Yeah.
- 25:50And these are smart defense.
- 25:53Yeah.
- 25:53Smart military software companies.
- 25:57So the, the, the, you know, the s and p 510 years from now is not going
- 26:01to look anything like it does today.
- 26:03And if you're an investor, you want to be putting money into the future
- 26:07s and p 500, not the current one.
- 26:11One company we haven't mentioned actually is, is, is Facebook,
- 26:14are they a loser in this?
- 26:15Are they They are.
- 26:17Are they a foot?
- 26:18No.
- 26:18Now in, in, in, in, uh, in the wacky racist, do they even have a team in this?
- 26:25Well, look, they're a fantastic company.
- 26:27They're revenues announced last week were huge, but their stock
- 26:31price has not gone up because in the AI race, Theran also ran.
- 26:36Trying to figure it out.
- 26:38They, they have a brand new team in place, building brand new platform to
- 26:42replace, uh, the LAMA platform that they've had for the last few years.
- 26:46There's a big internal debate about open source versus closed source models,
- 26:53but with the amount of money they've got, and, you know, time is on their
- 26:58side, they'll probably figure it out.
- 27:00I don't think they'll, I think they'll be a survivor, but
- 27:03they're a laggard right now.
- 27:05Um, you sidestep the Washington Post question.
- 27:09Are you concerned that America no longer really has, it seems a, uh, a viable
- 27:15newspaper in its capital, especially in its rather precarious political
- 27:20state in, uh, in February, 2026?
- 27:25You know, I, I, I think the Washington Post has been challenged for, at, at
- 27:30least 10 years since, um, Kathy Graham.
- 27:35Um, moved on from it.
- 27:37I think, I think it's, it's challenge for a few reasons, but
- 27:41the first is it tied, its mast.
- 27:44To the Biden administration and ended up taken the wrong side of most
- 27:47discussions and became irrelevant in a similar way to the New York Times
- 27:54by, by abandoning the, you know, the, the, um, being the source of truth
- 27:59and becoming a co, uh, a combatant, if you will, in the political wars.
- 28:04And, and so I think America lost.
- 28:09A news business, um, CNN tried to survive by being independent,
- 28:15uh, against M-S-N-B-C and Fox.
- 28:18But I think across the entire traditional media, you've had this partisan
- 28:23bifurcation of media and they're all gonna be losers because of it.
- 28:27'cause most normal people want to make their own opinion from good journalism,
- 28:33and that hasn't been available.
- 28:36But there's less and less journalism.
- 28:38I mean, that, isn't that the point of the crisis at the Post?
- 28:42Is there, and I mean, whether you like normal or not, they're capable
- 28:45of, of high quality journalism.
- 28:47It's, it, it's um, I call it boogieman journalism.
- 28:53It's like.
- 28:54Every couple of weeks.
- 28:55There's a new boogieman this week.
- 28:57Is Jeffrey Epstein that distract?
- 29:00Well, he might legitimate.
- 29:01I mean, there, there are certain legitimate boogieman and, uh,
- 29:04Jeffrey Epstein seems to be one
- 29:06that, well, he, of course he is one, but for the entire media to get distracted
- 29:11from big issues by focusing only on this boogeyman and trying to un undermine,
- 29:17uh, Trump, only because of his.
- 29:19Possible associations, or likely associations means that the entire
- 29:25narrative driven by the media's desire to sell clicks or, or papers or
- 29:31news or TV channels gets distracted.
- 29:34You know, before it was Russia interfering the election as the boogeyman.
- 29:38There's always a boogeyman.
- 29:39It's always about the media driving attention, and none of it is about what's
- 29:43really going on, which is so frustrating.
- 29:47What you call this attention economy is an advertising economy.
- 29:51And does that mean that maybe Dario Amid dies onto something by suggesting
- 29:57that when you insert ads into AI, you're only compounding attention
- 30:03and trivialization on all the other things that have gone wrong?
- 30:06I'm, you know, I'm definitely against.
- 30:09What we would think of as ads in AI.
- 30:12Um, for, for, so
- 30:13you're in Amides Camp
- 30:15for good reason, even if
- 30:16you don't like it.
- 30:16Uh, well, no, no, no.
- 30:19Because I do know that OpenAI has also said it's against that, and
- 30:23that it has no intention of putting what we all think of as ads in AI.
- 30:28But it is thinking of working with, um, you know, if you think about the
- 30:33world, the digital world, everything that there is available to sell, read.
- 30:38Buy has a link.
- 30:40And so we live in a place where in order to have your ideas, products.
- 30:48Services surfaced in any conversation with AI.
- 30:53It has to take the form of a link.
- 30:55And, you know, Amodei has links, uh, perplexity has links open, AI has links,
- 31:02and now they're saying, you know, you can pay us to put your link there in our free
- 31:07service if and only if it's relevant.
- 31:11To what the user is looking for.
- 31:13I think that's okay.
- 31:15I don't, I don't, but
- 31:15that's not the, in to, to borrow a word from Corey Doc, that's not the ification
- 31:22of AI or the beginnings of its ification.
- 31:24I, I, I, I don't think there's any intent.
- 31:28And, and it would be counter to OpenAI's economic future.
- 31:33There is no intent to interfere with the AI itself and what it
- 31:38says does thinks, um, at all.
- 31:41So that's where the Amida ad is.
- 31:43Just, you know, uh, leveraging a, a nuance to try to depict
- 31:49something that isn't gonna happen.
- 31:52Well, there is other news outside AI.
- 31:54My tech company of the week is Spotify.
- 31:57I'm not always my favorite company.
- 31:59But then news this week was that when you buy a physical book now and
- 32:03they've done a deal with bookstore, um, you'll also get the audio book.
- 32:08It's always been one of my.
- 32:10Irritations that you, on Amazon, at least an audible, if you buy the the audio book,
- 32:16you still have to buy the physical book.
- 32:17So that's still innovation.
- 32:19Keith, I don't know whether you are a, a reader of physical books or a listener
- 32:24to audio books, but this is good news.
- 32:26Spotify is still innovating.
- 32:28Yeah.
- 32:28If you look at this behind my head, it's books and there's a whole
- 32:32wall of them to my right here.
- 32:33So I do read physical books.
- 32:35Um, I, you know, that is innovation, but with a. Small.
- 32:40I, I would say, um, and it, it's smart as well.
- 32:44It's smart because I think the consumer will much prefer getting
- 32:48both in a single purchase.
- 32:50So I think I, I do think that's smart.
- 32:53Um,
- 32:53but in the name of democracy, I gotta be fair and give you the last
- 32:57word with your startup of the week.
- 33:00This is a startup that raised $20 million from Sequoia to build the.
- 33:05Cursor of CRM sounds rather boring.
- 33:08Tell me about this company.
- 33:11Well, we all know that.
- 33:12Uh, what CRM is?
- 33:15Customer relationship management.
- 33:16Probably not Everyone knows what Cursor is.
- 33:18Cursor is, um, a, a rapper, um, uh, not, not a singer, um, a rapper
- 33:25as in paper, uh, around a rapper
- 33:28with a w
- 33:29around, um, using AI to write code.
- 33:32Um, or perform other tasks.
- 33:35And, um, this, this is an AI wrapper around your customer
- 33:40list and your prospects list.
- 33:42Um, I dunno if it's any good, but the investors, what's it called?
- 33:46The investors who invested in it, certainly think, what's
- 33:48its name?
- 33:50The, the name of the company?
- 33:52Yeah.
- 33:53Didn't you say the name of the company already?
- 33:56No.
- 33:57It's your start of the week.
- 33:58It's your company, not mine.
- 33:59Start of the week is, um.
- 34:03Up.
- 34:04I think it's, uh, upstart, I think it's called.
- 34:07Oh, wow.
- 34:07That's so interesting.
- 34:08We're not quite sure of their name, but they are at least RA rapper, the cursor.
- 34:14They're,
- 34:16but I will say, uh, before we go, Andrew, that I think the poster of
- 34:19the week is the most illustrative.
- 34:21It's from O Malick and Om, you know, you know, when we talk
- 34:25about music, we talk about music distribution, going from the radio.
- 34:30To vi and vinyl to cassettes, then to CDs, and then to streaming,
- 34:37and then back to vinyl.
- 34:38And what, what Omar's done is applied that same evolutionary
- 34:42scale, if you will, to software.
- 34:45And in his piece, he talks about, you know, the different eras of software,
- 34:52uh, distribution from, I remember when I started Easy Net, we put a cd.
- 34:58Cell a tape to the cover of the internet magazine and we also
- 35:02gave the CD to Compact to put in the box when he bought a laptop.
- 35:06And software distribution was really hard.
- 35:08Then Mobile came along and suddenly there were two app stores and
- 35:13you could ship software to the whole world in five minutes.
- 35:16And, and, and it took the form of, uh, app stores and then there was sas.
- 35:23Which is the cloud version of software for enterprises, mainly through subscriptions
- 35:28or buying enterprise software.
- 35:30And what OM is pointing out is that software is now gonna be built
- 35:33by users for their own purposes.
- 35:36And it, it'll be self-made, uh, and I think it is pieces very
- 35:41thoughtful and really good.
- 35:43Yeah, software then becomes free in every sense, metaphorical,
- 35:47perhaps, and otherwise, although someone's gonna profit from it.
- 35:50Uh, one other sector that's getting a lot of attention in the the Super
- 35:55Bowl week is the prediction market.
- 35:57The way in which, uh.
- 35:59Betting has become ubiquitous.
- 36:01Maybe we can talk about that another week.
- 36:02But let's add where we began, Keith, with the Super Bowl,
- 36:06not far from you in Palo Alto.
- 36:08In San Jose.
- 36:09Uh, who's gonna win between Seattle?
- 36:11Do you have any sense between Seattle and New England?
- 36:14I.
- 36:15Anyone who listens to my opinion about football is, um, is a beautiful,
- 36:18maybe Manchester United will win.
- 36:20They did win today.
- 36:21Andrew, against your team?
- 36:22Yeah.
- 36:23I, I am not really aware of that.
- 36:24Well, uh, this was the week that broke the software business.
- 36:30I hope next week it'll be equally dramatic.
- 36:32Keith, uh, we, we need You, or, that was the weak newsletter.
- 36:36It keeps us up to date with a fascinatingly.
- 36:41Dramatic changing world.
- 36:43So, uh, we'll talk again next week.
- 36:45Thank you so much.
- 36:46You're welcome.
- 36:46Bye everyone.