Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Blackrock (BLK) Deep Value Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep dive. Today we're taking on a giant
- 0:03BlackRock ticker BLK. Yep, the biggest asset manager
- 0:07on the planet. An absolutely massive $13.46
- 0:10trillion in assets under management.
- 0:12Now our mission put this undisputed heavyweight through
- 0:16the ultimate value investing test.
- 0:18Exactly. We know BlackRock is a well, a
- 0:20truly wonderful company, right? Huge scale, great brand.
- 0:23But the real question, the one Warren Buffett would ask, is, is
- 0:27it available at a wonderful price?
- 0:29That's what we're digging into. That's the core mission.
- 0:32So here's the plan. First, we'll unpack the engine.
- 0:34You know, the business model, the competitive advantages, that
- 0:37economic Moat. How they got so big and stay so
- 0:39profitable. Precisely.
- 0:41Then we had to look at the other side, the headwinds, the risks
- 0:44both short term and the bigger structural ones.
- 0:47Got to be balanced, no company is perfect.
- 0:49And finally, we translate all that into numbers.
- 0:51We'll run it through the Buffett checklist, see where it passes,
- 0:53where it fails, and wrap up with evaluation.
- 0:56Sounds like a plan. Let's get started.
- 0:58OK. Let's start with the momentum,
- 0:59the latest numbers from Q32025 earnings.
- 1:03I mean the scale is just hard to wrap your head around.
- 1:05It really is that new record AUM $13.46 trillion.
- 1:10Yeah, up 17% year over year. Huge jump.
- 1:12And the inflows keep coming, a record $205 billion net client
- 1:16inflows just for that 1/4. It's staggering.
- 1:19How does that massive scale actually turn into reliable
- 1:22revenue? What's the core model?
- 1:24Well, the beauty of it is its stability.
- 1:26Over 80% of their revenue comes from these recurring asset based
- 1:30advisory and administration fees.
- 1:32So basically a tiny percentage cut on that enormous $13
- 1:36trillion pile of assets. Pretty much.
- 1:38Think of it like a toll booth on global capital flows.
- 1:41It's incredibly stable and, crucially, highly scalable.
- 1:44As assets grow, revenues grow almost automatically.
- 1:47And it's not just one type of asset driving this, right.
- 1:49We saw a 25% year over year revenue growth overall.
- 1:52That's impressive diversity. Absolutely.
- 1:54The iShares ETF business is obviously a monster AUM.
- 1:57There's now over $5 trillion alone, but you can't overlook
- 2:00the technology piece that's becoming increasingly critical.
- 2:03Ah yes, Aladdin, let's talk about the Moat.
- 2:05What really protects BlackRock scale is one thing.
- 2:09Scale is definitely number one. Their sheer size gives them
- 2:12dominance nobody else can match. It lets them offer those ultra
- 2:16low fees, especially in iShares ETF's which crushes smaller
- 2:20competitors. While still keeping profits.
- 2:21High exactly, while still maintaining really impressive
- 2:24operating margins. Yeah, often above 40%.
- 2:26Forty. Percent operating margins in an
- 2:28industry where everyone's slashing fees?
- 2:30That sounds, well, almost too good to be true.
- 2:33How do they defend that against rivals like Vanguard always
- 2:36pushing prices down? Yeah, it's a fair question.
- 2:38It comes back to the other parts of the Moat and the stickiness
- 2:41of certain businesses, particularly Aladdin.
- 2:43Their proprietary tech platform. Right.
- 2:46It's their risk management and trading system.
- 2:47It's a huge differentiator. Last quarter, tech services
- 2:51revenue driven by Aladdin was up 16%.
- 2:54OK, but what makes it sticky? Why can't clients just switch to
- 2:57a cheaper competitor system? Because Aladdin isn't just, you
- 3:00know, software you install for the institutions that use it.
- 3:03It's deeply embedded. It's like the central nervous
- 3:06system for their entire investment process and risk
- 3:08management. How many institutions are we
- 3:09talking about? Over 200 external ones, big
- 3:12ones. And get this, they use Aladdin
- 3:15to oversee about $21.6 trillion in outside assets.
- 3:19That's even more than BlackRock manages itself.
- 3:22Wow, so ripping it out. Ripping out Aladdin would be
- 3:25chaos. It's like trying to change the
- 3:27engine of a plane mid flight. You're talking about
- 3:30reengineering your whole risk framework, your trading
- 3:33operations, your reporting, the cost, the disruption, the
- 3:36operational risk. It's astronomical.
- 3:39You're basically locked in. The switching costs are immense.
- 3:41OK, so massive scale, incredibly sticky proprietary tech.
- 3:46What's the third leg of the stool?
- 3:47Brand and trust. This is maybe less tangible, but
- 3:50just as important, especially for attracting those huge
- 3:52institutional mandates, governments, pension funds,
- 3:55sovereign wealth funds. The really big fish.
- 3:57The biggest fish? BlackRock, largely thanks to
- 4:00Larry Fink's leadership over what, 35 years now, they've
- 4:04built this reputation as the default prudent fiduciary, the
- 4:09safe pair of hands. Seen as stewards, not
- 4:11speculator. Precisely.
- 4:12Smaller firms, even really good ones, often just don't get
- 4:15considered for those multi billion dollar mandates because
- 4:18they don't have that decades long track record and ingrained
- 4:20trust. OK, that paints a picture of a
- 4:23pretty formidable fortress, but even the strongest walls face
- 4:27threats. Let's shift gears to the risks.
- 4:30What are the short term headwinds BlackRock is dealing
- 4:33with right now? Well, the most obvious one and
- 4:35it's always there is just market volatility.
- 4:37Because their fees are tied to asset.
- 4:39Values exactly. So if the S&P 500 takes a dive,
- 4:41say 10% and a quarter that directly hits Blackrock's
- 4:44revenue. Rough estimate is usually a high
- 4:47single digit percentage hit to fee revenues for every 10%
- 4:49market drop. Their fate is tied for the
- 4:51market cycle. Makes sense.
- 4:52And what about pressure from within the industry that fee
- 4:55compression you mentioned earlier?
- 4:56Yeah, that hasn't gone away. It's a constant, intense
- 5:00competition, especially from Vanguard in the core ETF space,
- 5:04means they have to keep trimming expense ratios on those big
- 5:07plain vanilla funds. So they have to make it up on
- 5:09volume. They do make it up on volume,
- 5:11but it still puts downward pressure on their overall yield,
- 5:14the average fee they earn across all assets.
- 5:17That metric has ticked down a bit over recent years.
- 5:19They have to run faster just to stay in place sometimes.
- 5:22OK. Market risk.
- 5:23Fee pressure. Now let's talk about something
- 5:26else entirely. The whole ESG situation, that
- 5:29seems like a political minefield.
- 5:31It absolutely is and you know, we have to be careful here.
- 5:33Just report what's happening impartially.
- 5:35Several conservative LED U.S. states, think Texas, Florida,
- 5:39Louisiana have made headlines by announcing divestments.
- 5:42Pulling state money out. Pulling state pension funds?
- 5:44Yeah. The stated reason is an
- 5:46accusation that BlackRock is pushing an ESG environmental
- 5:49social governance agenda, sometimes ahead of maximizing
- 5:53financial returns. How significant are these
- 5:55divestments in dollar terms? Honestly, relative to the $13
- 5:58trillion AUM, they're tiny. Florida's $2 billion pull out,
- 6:03for instance, sounds like a lot, but it's about .015% of
- 6:06Blackrock's total assets. A drop in the ocean numerically
- 6:10of the noise, but the political noise and the reputational
- 6:13challenges are significant. It's something they absolutely
- 6:15have to navigate very carefully to avoid it snowballing or
- 6:19impacting sentiment among other clients.
- 6:21Right. OK, those are the near term
- 6:23waves. What about longer term?
- 6:25Maybe structural risks? Things that could fundamentally
- 6:28change the game for them down a Rd.
- 6:30Well, one potential long term issue is ironically the success
- 6:33of their own core strategy, passive investing.
- 6:37Passive saturation. Yeah, potentially the huge shift
- 6:40from active management to passive index funds fueled Black
- 6:42Rocks growth, especially iShares, for two decades.
- 6:46But that trend might be, you know, maturing.
- 6:48Running out of steam? Perhaps.
- 6:50And the US equity market, for example, indexing is already
- 6:52close to maybe 45% of the market.
- 6:55There's still room to grow globally and in fixed income,
- 6:58but the explosive growth phase from just capturing that passive
- 7:00shift might slow down. So they need other growth
- 7:03engines. Exactly.
- 7:04They'll need to rely more on higher fee areas like private
- 7:06markets, alternative investments, infrastructure and
- 7:10crucially, that Aladdin technology business we talked
- 7:13about. They can't just ride the index
- 7:14way forever. Makes sense.
- 7:15What's the second major long term risk?
- 7:18The second one is more personal. It's succession risk.
- 7:21Larry Fink, founder, CEO, the face of the firm for over 35
- 7:25years. He's 70 now.
- 7:27His eventual departure, and it will happen eventually, is a big
- 7:31question mark. Even with a strong management
- 7:33team. Even with a deep bench, he is
- 7:35BlackRock in many ways. His strategic vision, his
- 7:38relationships, the culture he built.
- 7:41Ensuring A seamless transition that maintains client trust and
- 7:44strategic direction is absolutely critical.
- 7:47Any wobble there could be a significant risk.
- 7:49OK, a lot to consider on the risk side.
- 7:51Let's pivot now and try to quantify all this time to get
- 7:54into the numbers and apply that Buffett checklist.
- 7:56We know it's a great business operationally, revenue doubled,
- 7:59EPS more than doubled from about $20 to over $42.00 in the last
- 8:03decade. But does it meet those really
- 8:06strict value criteria? All right, let's run the tests.
- 8:09And you know, on the financial strength side, BlackRock passes
- 8:12with flying colors. Absolutely.
- 8:13Like free cash? Flow free cash flow consistently
- 8:16positive every single year for the last decade, and not just
- 8:20positive, but strongly positive. FCF margins are typically way up
- 8:24there between 20 and 30%. Buffett wants maybe 5%.
- 8:27BlackRock blows that away. And the balance sheet?
- 8:30Financial firms need solid foundations.
- 8:33Rock solid debt to equity ratio is consistently low for a
- 8:36financial institution, usually around .3 or even lower and they
- 8:40can easily cover their interest payments.
- 8:42Interest coverage is huge, over 10 times operating income.
- 8:45Very little leverage risk here. OK.
- 8:46Strong cash flow, solid balance sheet, profitability metrics.
- 8:51Excellent. Again, gross margins are
- 8:52incredibly high, around 84% and the Net margin, the bottom line
- 8:56profit on every dollar of revenue is consistently strong,
- 8:59typically in the 28% to 32% range.
- 9:02Which tells you. It tells you they have a real
- 9:04pricing power despite the fee pressures we discussed, that
- 9:07Moat is working. It allows them to be highly
- 9:09profitable even at their massive scale.
- 9:11OK, so it aces the financial fortress tests, but the Buffett
- 9:15checklist is notoriously tough. It demands consistency and,
- 9:19crucially, a good price. Where does BlackRock stumble?
- 9:23It stumbles on a couple of key points.
- 9:25First, that strict test of uninterrupted earnings per share
- 9:28growth over 10 years. BlackRock actually fails this
- 9:31one. Really despite the overall
- 9:33growth. Yep, there are minor dips in EPS
- 9:35back in 2016 and again in 2022 tied to those market cycle
- 9:40pullbacks we mentioned. It breaks the perfect 10 year
- 9:42streak that a purist might look for.
- 9:45That market sensitivity bites them on the consistency metric.
- 9:48OK, what else? The big one I imagine is
- 9:50valuation. Valuation.
- 9:52Yeah, this is where it usually fails the classic value test and
- 9:54fails pretty hard. Buffett ideally likes to buy
- 9:57companies with a price to earnings or PE ratio of 15 or
- 10:00less. And BlackRock.
- 10:01BlackRock PE has averaged more like 17 to 18 times earnings
- 10:05over the past decade, and right now it's turning significantly
- 10:08higher, around 23 times earnings.
- 10:10So almost never cheap by that standard.
- 10:12Almost never. You only really see it dip near,
- 10:15say, 12 times earnings during moments of extreme market panic
- 10:19like maybe late 2022. Briefly, it's rarely on sale,
- 10:23OK. Fails EPS consistency fails at
- 10:26PE under 15 test. What about return on equity Roe?
- 10:30That one's close, but technically a slight miss to the
- 10:3310 year average. Roe has been around 13% to 14%.
- 10:37Buffett often looks for 15% or higher consistently.
- 10:40So very good, but just shy of that ideal benchmark.
- 10:44So the numbers really back up the narrative, don't they?
- 10:46It's a fantastic, financially sound, highly profitable
- 10:49company. Truly wonderful company.
- 10:51But the market knows it and consistently prices it at a
- 10:53premium, meaning it's rarely a wonderful price for value
- 10:56investor. Precisely.
- 10:57OK. Let's try to put a finer point
- 10:59on that valuation gap. Let's use a discounted cash flow
- 11:01model, the DCF. We'll use a standard 10%
- 11:04discount rate, which is a typical required return for
- 11:06equity investors. What is a base case scenario
- 11:09suggests for intrinsic value? All right.
- 11:10So if we plug in assumptions for a moderate sort of sustainable
- 11:15free cash flow growth rate, let's say 8% annually, which is
- 11:19pretty close to the historical average through cycles, using
- 11:22that 10% discount rate, the calculated intrinsic value comes
- 11:25out around $600.00 per share. $600.00 per share and the stock
- 11:29is currently trading around $11150.
- 11:31That is a massive difference. That's a huge.
- 11:34Gap So why is the market paying nearly double that baseline
- 11:38intrinsic value estimate? What kind of future growth must
- 11:41investors be baking in to justify today's price?
- 11:44Well, to get the DCF value anywhere near the current $11150
- 11:48price still using that 10% discount rate, you have to shift
- 11:52to a very, very optimistic growth scenario, right?
- 11:55What kind of growth? Like assuming BlackRock can
- 11:57maintain sustained robust double digit free cash flow growth,
- 12:00maybe something like 12% per year consistently for the next
- 12:0310 years. If you assume that, then the
- 12:05intrinsic value calculation does move up significantly, getting
- 12:08you into the ballpark of say, $1200 per share.
- 12:10OK. So the market today seems to be
- 12:13pricing BlackRock right at the absolute peak of a highly
- 12:16optimistic growth forecast. What does that imply for someone
- 12:20looking for a margin of safety? It implies a couple of critical
- 12:24things, really. One possibility is that the
- 12:25market genuinely believes BlackRock can deliver near
- 12:28perfect low teens growth for a full decade, despite the risks
- 12:32we discussed. Which seems ambitious.
- 12:34It does seem ambitious for a company this large.
- 12:36The other, perhaps more likely explanation is that investors
- 12:39are implicitly accepting a much lower required rate of return on
- 12:43BlackRock stock. Maybe they're happy with 6% or
- 12:457% annually, not 10%. Why would they do that?
- 12:48Because of the perceived safety, the wide Moat, the stability,
- 12:51the too big to fail feeling, perhaps they're willing to pay a
- 12:55premium for that perceived quality and durability,
- 12:58effectively accepting lower future returns.
- 13:00So for a value investor demanding, say, a standard 25%
- 13:04margin of safety. They need to buy far, far lower.
- 13:07Based on our $600.00 base case intrinsic value, they'd need a
- 13:11price around $450. Even using the absolute
- 13:14optimistic $1200 value, they'd need $900.
- 13:17It just reinforces the point. At $11150, BlackRock is richly
- 13:22valued and demands near perfection, leaving very little
- 13:24room for error or disappointment.
- 13:26Right. That really crystallizes it.
- 13:27BlackRock. Yeah, An absolutely exceptional,
- 13:29incredibly durable business wide Moat sticky clients generate
- 13:34enormous cash flow. But but the price reflects all
- 13:36of that good news and then some. It requires highly optimistic
- 13:39growth assumptions or forces buyers to accept potentially
- 13:42lower returns than they might get elsewhere.
- 13:43We've covered a massive amount of ground here, trying to
- 13:46distill mountains of data and analysis into the key takeaways
- 13:48for you. And, you know, Speaking of
- 13:50analyzing market conditions and value, if you're interested in
- 13:53tracking the overall market temperature, a useful tool can
- 13:57be monitoring things like the market cap to GDP ratio.
- 14:01Some people call it the Buffett Indicator.
- 14:03There are actually apps that help track this.
- 14:06For instance, if you search the Apple App Store for a Buffett
- 14:08indicator, you can find tools to get daily updates on market
- 14:12levels, which might help in assessing when things look
- 14:14frothy versus when there might be more value around.
- 14:17Good tip. And of course, if you enjoy
- 14:19these kinds of deep dives into specific companies and value
- 14:22investing topics, you can find more by subscribing to our full
- 14:25channel, Deep Value Investing on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
- 14:29Definitely check that out. And just a quick disclaimer, as
- 14:32always, everything we've discussed today is based on
- 14:34public information and is for educational purposes only.
- 14:38It's not investment advice. Please do your own research and
- 14:41due diligence before making any investment decisions.
- 14:44Absolutely essential. OK, so let's leave you with a
- 14:47final provocative thought to chew on.
- 14:49We've established Blackrock's incredible quality, but also its
- 14:53sensitivity to market cycles and its current premium valuation.
- 14:57So if you're an investor truly focused on deep value, are you
- 14:59fundamentally better off patiently waiting, waiting for
- 15:02perhaps a significant market downturn, a real bear market
- 15:05like we saw glimpses of in late 2022 that could knock 50% or
- 15:09more off the stock price to potentially buy this wonderful
- 15:12company at a genuinely wonderful price?
- 15:14Or does the sheer safety and durability of its Moat justify
- 15:18paying today's premium and accepting potentially lower
- 15:20returns for that quality? Quality versus price.
- 15:23The eternal value investing dilemma.
- 15:25We'll leave you to ponder that one.
- 15:26Thanks for diving deep with us today.