Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Where is the Gold Card?
Transcript
- 0:00What happens when a, well, a truly radical policy proposal,
- 0:04one designed with these huge ambitions of bringing in
- 0:08trillions, just sort of appears and then almost overnight
- 0:11vanishes? Today, we're doing a deep dive
- 0:13into this really curious case, the enigma of the Trump gold
- 0:16card. So picture this.
- 0:19It's early 2025, and this traumatic plan gets unveiled.
- 0:23It's offering wealthy foreigners permanent US residency, even a
- 0:27path to citizenship. And the price tag?
- 0:30A cool $5,000,000 paid straight to the US Treasury, not an
- 0:33investment. The projections were, well,
- 0:35let's just say ambitious. Talking about selling 1 million
- 0:38or more cards, Trillions in revenue.
- 0:41Yeah, from an immigration policy angle, this was, wow, a radical
- 0:44departure is almost putting it mildly.
- 0:45We're talking about something just fundamentally different
- 0:47from, you know, decades of how the US approached this.
- 0:49It was really framed by supporters as this innovative
- 0:52tool, right? A way to tackle the deficit.
- 0:54Basically, positioning itself is a completely new alternative to
- 0:57the the existing EB5 investor program.
- 0:59But here's where it gets really interesting for us.
- 1:01I think despite this huge announcement, they even had a
- 1:04website, trumpcard.gov. The whole thing just faded away,
- 1:07like almost instantly. Our sources pretty much describe
- 1:11it as effectively stillborn. That's exactly right.
- 1:13And what's so notable about it disappearing is it wasn't killed
- 1:18in Congress. It wasn't struck down by the
- 1:20courts. No, its demise was much quieter.
- 1:23It seems to have been this combination of, well,
- 1:25insurmountable legal hurdles, a real lack of political buy in
- 1:29and frankly, some fundamental economic problems.
- 1:32It just wasn't viable. And that became clear pretty
- 1:35fast. OK.
- 1:36So for you, our listener, our mission today is to kind of pull
- 1:39apart this gold card idea. We want to unpack why it
- 1:41vanished. And you know what?
- 1:43This whole episode told us about the actual limits on executive
- 1:46power and just how complex US governments really is.
- 1:49This deep dive, it's about understanding a policy.
- 1:51That sounded bold maybe, but looking back it was never really
- 1:55viable, legally or practically. OK, right, let's unpack this
- 1:59then. What exactly was this gold card?
- 2:01What was it promising people at its heart?
- 2:03You mentioned that $5,000,000 cover charge.
- 2:06Absolutely. And that $5,000,000 is crucial
- 2:09to understand wasn't an investment like in a business.
- 2:11It was a straight up non refundable payment directly to
- 2:15the treasury. That's totally different from
- 2:17most investor visas where you know you expect to get your
- 2:19capital back, maybe even make a profit.
- 2:21The stated reason was pretty clear.
- 2:23Attract quote wealthy and successful people who the
- 2:27thinking when would boost the economy just by spending and
- 2:31paying taxes here. And one detail our sources
- 2:34picked up, which is fascinating, is it wasn't just for
- 2:36individuals. Corporations could apparently
- 2:38buy these cards too. So, you know, theoretically a
- 2:41big company like Apple could buy cards to get permanent residency
- 2:44for key employees, maybe bypassing the H1B Visa weights.
- 2:47That's that's quite a unique design.
- 2:49It really is. And for that $5,000,000, what
- 2:52you got was pitched as basically green card privileges.
- 2:55Plus the main thing was unlimited residency rights.
- 2:58So functionally the same as being a legal permanent
- 3:00resident, but the process we're supposed to be much much faster
- 3:03and more direct than say family based or employment based green
- 3:06cards. And that promise of a route to
- 3:08citizenship must have been a big draw, right?
- 3:11Suggesting a quicker path to actually becoming AUS citizen,
- 3:14maybe setting it apart from golden visas elsewhere.
- 3:17Definitely part of the pitch, but maybe the most ambitious
- 3:20part and legally the shakiest was this proposed tax break.
- 3:25The plan kind of hinted that gold card holders might not have
- 3:29to pay U.S. Federal income tax on income
- 3:31they earned outside the US. And when you hear that, I mean,
- 3:35that immediately sets off major constitutional alarm bells
- 3:38because that would need a complete overhaul, the wholesale
- 3:40rewriting of the US Internal Revenue Code, something Congress
- 3:44does, not the president. Right.
- 3:46So the main justification pushed by the administration was
- 3:49economics, pure and simple. They sold it as this powerful
- 3:52tool to slash the national debt, massive revenue streams.
- 3:55I think Commerce Secretary Howard Letnick quoted saying
- 3:57200,000 cards could bring in $1 trillion.
- 4:00And President Trump himself talked about selling anywhere
- 4:03from 1 million up to maybe 10 million cards.
- 4:05It's $5 trillion to potentially $50 trillion.
- 4:09I mean to staggering numbers. Oh absolutely staggering and
- 4:12those figures definitely got headlines.
- 4:14The secondary argument was simplification.
- 4:17You know they painted the existing ED-5 program as and I
- 4:20think the quote was full of nonsense, make believe and
- 4:23fraud. So the Gold Card was the clean,
- 4:26simple and way more profitable alternative.
- 4:29But really underneath it all, it represented this big
- 4:31philosophical shift. It was kind of reframing US
- 4:34residency not as something you earn through skills or family or
- 4:38even investment in the traditional sense, but almost
- 4:40like a luxury good you could just buy measuring an
- 4:43immigrant's value primarily by their checkbook.
- 4:45OK, so how did this new idea stack up against what was
- 4:48already on the books? Let's compare it to the EB5
- 4:50program, the one it seemed designed to replace.
- 4:53Well, the biggest difference right off the bat is the money
- 4:55part. EB5 requires an investment.
- 4:58It has to be at risk usually somewhere between $800,000 and
- 5:02about $1.05 million. And you put that into AUS
- 5:05business, the investor expects or at least hopes to get that
- 5:09money back eventually, maybe with a return.
- 5:11The gold card, completely different.
- 5:14That $5,000,000 was a direct payment, non refundable, gone as
- 5:18one source put it, a total loss for investors from the start.
- 5:22So it wasn't about channeling private money into the economy
- 5:25to create jobs anymore, it was just about getting revenue for
- 5:28the government. And that job creation piece is
- 5:30huge, isn't it? EB5 requires that the investment
- 5:33creates or saves at least 10 full time U.S. jobs.
- 5:36That's like the whole point. Exactly, it's fundamental to
- 5:39EB5, the gold card. It explicitly got rid of that
- 5:41requirement. Now, the argument was, oh, these
- 5:44wealthy many people will spend money and indirectly create
- 5:46jobs. But critics jumped on that
- 5:48immediately. They said it cut the direct,
- 5:50measurable link between the money coming in and actual jobs
- 5:53for Americans, calling it, you know, a concierge service for
- 5:56the ultra wealthy that didn't guarantee any US employment
- 5:59impact. Now, to be fair, EB 5 isn't
- 6:01perfect. People criticize it for being
- 6:03slow, bureaucratic, complex. There have been fraud issues.
- 6:07So the gold card was pitched as the solution.
- 6:10Fast, direct and simple. That's true.
- 6:13And that was a smart narrative tactic by the administration
- 6:16portray EB5AS irredeemably broken to make the case for this
- 6:20executive fix. But what's really striking
- 6:22looking back is that this narrative kind of glossed over
- 6:25something important. Congress had just passed the EB5
- 6:28Reform and Integrity Act in 2022.
- 6:31That was a big bipartisan law specifically designed to fix the
- 6:34very problems the administration was highlighting, the fraud, the
- 6:38integrity issues. So the Gold Card wasn't really
- 6:40about improving EB5, it was about replacing it entirely
- 6:43using a totally different mechanism outside of Congress.
- 6:46So yeah, to boil it down, EB5IS law passed by Congress requires
- 6:50investment for jobs, has oversight.
- 6:52Gold Card was a proposed executive move demanding a
- 6:54payment, no job mandate, and designed to bypass Congress.
- 6:57Big differences. OK, but even setting aside the
- 6:59policy differences, was any of this actually legal?
- 7:02Could the president even do this?
- 7:03This is where the Constitution comes in, right?
- 7:05This is really the bedrock issue, the absolute fundamental
- 7:08obstacle, Article 1, Section 8, Clause four of the Constitution.
- 7:11It gives Congress, and only Congress, the power to establish
- 7:15a uniform rule of naturalization.
- 7:17Put simply, Congress makes immigration law.
- 7:20The president enforces the laws. Congress makes creating a whole
- 7:23new way to immigrate, a new visa category.
- 7:26That's a legislative job and legal experts, I mean truly from
- 7:29left, right and center, we're unanimous on this, this lack of
- 7:33a legal basis. Was it basically it's fatal flaw
- 7:35from the GET? Go and our sources really
- 7:36hammered this point. The proposal was a direct hit
- 7:38against the Immigration and Nationality Act, the INA, which
- 7:41is the huge federal law covering all US immigration.
- 7:45Right. It clashed with the INA in at
- 7:47least two major ways. First, the president just can't
- 7:50wave a magic wand and eliminate a visa category Congress created
- 7:53like EB5. That's Congress's turf. 2nd, and
- 7:56this is huge too, the numbers the administration talking about
- 8:00selling 1 million or more cards that would completely demolish
- 8:03the strict annual limits on visas set by Congress.
- 8:06EB5 for example is capped at under 10,000 visas a year.
- 8:10Total immigrant visas are around 421,000 annually.
- 8:13You can't just create a million new slots by executive order.
- 8:16As Jorge Laurie from the American Immigration Council put
- 8:19it very bluntly, it was blatantly illegal.
- 8:22OK, let's circle back to that tax break I do we touched on
- 8:24earlier, the one exempting foreign income.
- 8:26Beyond being controversial, what about the constitutionality
- 8:29there? Oh, there's another complete non
- 8:31starter, legally speaking, the power to lay and collect taxes.
- 8:35That's Article 1 again, exclusively Congress's power.
- 8:38Any change to the tax code, the Internal Revenue Code, needs a
- 8:42law passed by both the House and the Senate and signed by the
- 8:45president. The executive branch simply
- 8:47cannot create a new tax status or exemption by itself.
- 8:51That part of the plan would have faced immediate court challenges
- 8:54plus massive procedural roadblocks in the Senate like it
- 8:57did a bird rule. That rule basically stops
- 8:59unrelated policy changes from being tacked onto budget bills
- 9:03it would have been almost impossible to pass legislatively
- 9:06without huge bipartisan support, which it clearly lacked.
- 9:09Right now there was some chatter, some speculation that
- 9:12maybe they could use the president's parole power to
- 9:14grant some kind of temporary status.
- 9:16Was that a realistic workaround? That was seen as a very, very
- 9:20flimsy legal argument. Parole authority is really meant
- 9:23for individual case by case situations, usually for urgent
- 9:26humanitarian reasons or significant public benefit.
- 9:30It's not designed to create a whole new broad category of
- 9:32immigrants, especially not one based on paying a fee.
- 9:35Now, irony is, the Trump administration itself had
- 9:37previously argued against using parole power so broadly in other
- 9:41immigration contexts. Plus, it raises a really
- 9:43practical question. Would anyone actually pay
- 9:45$5,000,000 for a status? It's temporary, discretionary,
- 9:49and could be revoked fairly easily.
- 9:51It just doesn't offer the security of a real green card
- 9:53authorized by law. Probably not many takers.
- 9:56So at the end of the day, the whole proposal really felt like
- 9:58a test. A test of just how far executive
- 10:00power can be pushed. But the reaction from the legal
- 10:03world was so fast, so unified, from libertarian groups like
- 10:06Cato to pro immigrant groups like the American Immigration
- 10:09Council, it powerfully reinforced those constitutional
- 10:11checks and balances. OK, so legally it seems dead on
- 10:15arrival, but what about the politics?
- 10:17You'd think maybe the president's own party would line
- 10:20up behind a big idea like this, but that didn't quite happen,
- 10:25did it? No, not really.
- 10:27The reaction from key Republicans, especially in the
- 10:29Senate, it was surprisingly muted, lukewarm even.
- 10:35Some seem genuinely caught off guard.
- 10:37Figures like the Senate Majority Leader at the time, John Thune,
- 10:40basically said he was unaware it was moving forward.
- 10:42He called it uncharted territory.
- 10:45That's hardly a ringing endorsement.
- 10:47And Senator Rand Paul was even more direct.
- 10:49He said pretty clearly the gold card with no legislation.
- 10:52This is something I think should go before Congress.
- 10:56That kind of resistance wasn't just about the policy itself, it
- 10:58was about the process. It highlighted this real concern
- 11:01among some Republicans about protecting Congress's role, the
- 11:04separation of powers. That institutional concern
- 11:07created a pretty big political hurdle right within the
- 11:09president's own potential base of support.
- 11:11Meanwhile, on the other side of the aisle, Democrats and
- 11:14immigrant advocates, they weren't holding back.
- 11:16Oh, not at all. The condemnation was immediate
- 11:20and pretty much universal from that side.
- 11:22Yeah, terms like moral failure, A2 tier immigration system,
- 11:27accusations of auctioning off citizenship to the highest
- 11:30bidder. Exactly.
- 11:32You had Representative Rokana saying things like you don't
- 11:35need to have $5,000,000 in your bank account to build a
- 11:38successful company in America, pointing out all the successful
- 11:41immigrants who wouldn't qualify. J Jane Putoria called it a slap
- 11:45in the face to highly skilled workers waiting years, sometimes
- 11:49decades, in the green card backlogs.
- 11:52The narrative was really clear. This plan let the Super rich cut
- 11:56the line while everyone else waited.
- 11:58And critically, as far as we know, no member of Congress,
- 12:01Republican or Democrat, ever actually introduced a bill to
- 12:05create this program. So the president saying early on
- 12:07they weren't asking Congress for legislation, maybe that wasn't
- 12:10as a choice, but kind of an admission that it wouldn't fly
- 12:13politically anyway. That seems very likely in
- 12:15hindsight without anyone willing to champion it legislatively.
- 12:18It was politically stalled before it even started.
- 12:21OK, so legally impossible, politically isolated, but let's
- 12:27just play devil's advocate for a second.
- 12:29Let's say somehow it overcame all that.
- 12:32Would people have actually bought these things?
- 12:34Was there even a market? Well, those projections the
- 12:37administration threw out, selling a million or more,
- 12:39generating trillions. Market analysts pretty much
- 12:42immediately labeled those as fantastical.
- 12:45If you look at the actual numbers globally, there are
- 12:47maybe only about 1.5 million people outside the US who have
- 12:51$5 million or more in assets, and that's excluding their main
- 12:54home. So the pool of potential
- 12:56customers just wasn't big enough to hit those kinds of sales
- 12:59targets. Yeah, the experts who actually
- 13:00work in investment migration, their predictions were way, way
- 13:03lower. They were saying best case
- 13:05scenario, maybe less than 1000 trump cards will be sold.
- 13:08That would generate billions, sure, but not trillions.
- 13:11It would have been, you know, a drop in the bucket for the
- 13:13national debt, not the game changer promise.
- 13:15Those huge sales figures really look more like political talking
- 13:18points than serious market analysis.
- 13:20And just from a financial standpoint it sounds like a
- 13:23terrible deal for the buyer, right?
- 13:25$5,000,000 straight up non refundable, a 100% capital loss
- 13:31as one source called it. Especially when other countries
- 13:33have these golden visa programs where you make an investment you
- 13:36might get back. It sound like a really expensive
- 13:38ticket with no guarantee of return.
- 13:40Exactly. And the price itself was just
- 13:42way out there, $5,000,000. That was at least five times
- 13:45higher than similar residency by investment paths in Europe or
- 13:49other popular destinations. Plus many wealthy individuals
- 13:53who might be interested already qualify for cheaper, often
- 13:56better US immigration options. Things like the EB1A visa for
- 14:00people with extraordinary ability, or the E2 treaty
- 14:03investor visa if their country has a treaty with the US.
- 14:06Those require much less capital outweigh.
- 14:08So fundamentally it looked like an overpriced product in a very
- 14:11competitive global market. And then there's the big
- 14:13elephant in the room for wealthy people globally.
- 14:16US taxes. The US taxes citizens and
- 14:19permanent residents on their worldwide income.
- 14:21That is a huge, huge factor. Unless that illegal tax break on
- 14:25foreign income somehow materialized, which we've
- 14:28established was basically impossible, getting a Gold card
- 14:31meant subjecting yourself to one of the most comprehensive tax
- 14:34systems in the world. For someone whose main goal is
- 14:37preserving wealth, that makes the whole proposition deeply
- 14:41questionable. Why pay $5,000,000 to
- 14:43potentially pay more in taxes long term?
- 14:46And we should probably also mention the security side.
- 14:48Concerns popped up pretty quickly about attracting, you
- 14:51know, dirty money or people with shady backgrounds, even with
- 14:54promises of vetting. Absolutely.
- 14:56That's a common concern with any program like this and the IMF
- 14:59itself has warned about the risks.
- 15:01Plus geopolitically, interest from one of the biggest markets,
- 15:04wealth for Chinese nationals was already cooling towards the US.
- 15:08This was due to rising tensions, safety concerns.
- 15:11Many were looking at places like Singapore or Canada instead.
- 15:14And here's a final kind of paradoxical twist.
- 15:17The Gold Card announcement actually caused a spike in
- 15:19applications for the existing EB5 program.
- 15:22Yeah, it seems investors got worried that EB 5 might be
- 15:24eliminated, so they rushed to get in under the existing,
- 15:27albeit flawed but ultimately more viable, rules.
- 15:30OK, so let's bring it all together.
- 15:32How did the story play out in public and why did it ultimately
- 15:35just is allowed fade from the headlines?
- 15:38Well, the initial news coverage was really shaped by this
- 15:41incredible unity among the experts, legal scholars,
- 15:44immigration lawyers, policy analysts, again, across the
- 15:47political map from Cato to the American Immigration Council,
- 15:51they all basically said the same thing.
- 15:53The president doesn't have the authority.
- 15:55That consensus dominated the early reporting, framing the
- 15:58Gold Card as legally illegitimate right from the
- 16:01start. But Despite that, the
- 16:03administration launched the website trumpcard.gov and they
- 16:06claimed it got what, nearly 70,000 signups?
- 16:10They use that to show popularity.
- 16:11Right, but it's crucial to understand what that website
- 16:14actually was. It was essentially a mailing
- 16:16list, a way to gauge interest, maybe flick contact info.
- 16:20It wasn't a formal application. Signing up had zero legal
- 16:24weight. Experts pretty quickly called it
- 16:26what it was, public relations, political branding.
- 16:29It showed this disconnect between the public facing buzz
- 16:32and the complete lack of any real lawful steps to implement
- 16:36the policy. And so the reason it vanished
- 16:38from the news, the story just ended.
- 16:41Pretty much you could say the narrative arc was complete.
- 16:45As one source put it, there were no bills in Congress to track,
- 16:48no regulations being issued by agencies like USCIS or Treasury,
- 16:52no court cases challenging it because it never got off the
- 16:55ground to be challenged. So the media moved on.
- 16:57The silence wasn't some sign of secret backroom dealing.
- 17:00It was just the natural result of a plan that was essentially
- 17:03dead on arrival. There's nothing left to report.
- 17:06So wrapping this up, what's the key take away for you, our
- 17:09listener? The disappearance of the Trump
- 17:10gold card plan wasn't really a mystery.
- 17:13It was definitive. It was, like, our sources said,
- 17:15Stillborn. Yeah, boils down to that fatal
- 17:18mix of four things we've walked through.
- 17:20One, it was fundamentally unconstitutional to It lacked
- 17:24political support even from key allies.
- 17:27Three, it was economically unappealing and based on
- 17:30unrealistic projections. And four, the narrative
- 17:33surrounding it was immediately 1 of illegitimacy.
- 17:36It seems it never really stood a chance as actual workable
- 17:40policy. It functioned more as maybe a
- 17:42high profile political statement APR move that just slammed into
- 17:46the hard wall of legal and practical reality.
- 17:49Exactly. And it's quiet disappearance
- 17:51really is a powerful illustration of how our system
- 17:54of checks and balances works. Or at least how it's supposed to
- 17:56work. Shows the limits on executive
- 17:58power, especially when it comes to fundamentally rewriting laws
- 18:01about who gets to live here and how the country raises revenue.
- 18:04Which leaves us with a final thought.
- 18:05Perhaps in today's world, with information moving so fast and
- 18:09bold proposals grabbing headlines, how careful do we
- 18:11need to be? How do we distinguish between
- 18:14ambitious political talk and policies that are actually, you
- 18:17know, legally possible and practically achievable?
- 18:20And maybe what other grand ideas are out there, perhaps less
- 18:23visibly running into these same fundamental roadblocks?
- 18:26Something to think about.