Latest / The Vegan Report / The Leaky Bucket Trap | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00Hi everyone, this is Ella Wong from Good Growth
- 0:03for The Vegan Report. Today we're exploring a
- 0:06question that's been on our minds. How do we
- 0:09grow the plant -based movement in Asia without
- 0:11falling into the leaky bucket trap? For those
- 0:14of you who might be new to us, Good Growth focuses
- 0:16on research, strategy, and prototyping solutions
- 0:19for sustainable food systems in Asia. We just
- 0:22released our first good growth strategy brief,
- 0:25which we're seeing as a quarterly Intel drop
- 0:27to share actionable insights we're seeing in
- 0:29the field. So before we dive in, a quick reminder
- 0:33to connect with me. My email and social links
- 0:35are in the episode notes. You can find new episodes
- 0:38every Wednesday on this podcast. And if you found
- 0:41this conversation helpful, please share this
- 0:43episode with your community. So let's start with
- 0:46the all protein market. One observation we've
- 0:49seen is a gap between interest and action. In
- 0:53our research, 75 % of those who have not tried
- 0:55plant -based meat in Southeast Asia are willing
- 0:58to try it, but repeat purchases are low. So it
- 1:02makes us wonder, is this a demand or a marketing
- 1:05problem? What we've seen is Western playbooks
- 1:08that focus on abstract values like saving the
- 1:10planet may not resonate in Asia, where food choices
- 1:13are deeply cultural and driven by specific health
- 1:16and cost considerations. But instead of concluding
- 1:21that there's a demand ceiling, we're interested
- 1:23to explore how the movement could apply market
- 1:25research to local campaigns. So some ideas that
- 1:28we come up with that we think are worth exploring
- 1:30include marketing consortiums, where organizations
- 1:34pool resources to hire the same regional experts
- 1:37who may have launched successful campaigns in
- 1:41Asia. Another one is channel testing to see if
- 1:45messengers like healthcare professionals or targeted
- 1:47segment messaging are more effective than broad
- 1:50-based campaigns. And this brings us to Nick's
- 1:53point about growing the movement. We've noticed
- 1:56a pattern where international NGOs scale into
- 1:58new markets but struggle to find a model that
- 2:00works on the ground. We call this the leaky bucket,
- 2:04where resources flow in but we lose credibility
- 2:06and burn out talent because global strategies
- 2:09might conflict with local contexts. So the good
- 2:12news is the movement is starting to update on
- 2:14these lessons. Our take is that we should explore
- 2:17infrastructure that operationalizes contextual
- 2:20knowledge. So this isn't just about hiring locally.
- 2:24It's about building systems to support this local
- 2:26talent. Some soft landing ideas that we think
- 2:30are worth exploring include hosting regional
- 2:34knowledge sharing forums. So maybe using models
- 2:37like fuck up nights, where organizations can
- 2:39openly share failures and what didn't work before,
- 2:43before others commit resources. Or maybe there's
- 2:47contextual onboarding kits, so downloadable resources
- 2:50for priority markets that synthesize desk research,
- 2:54stakeholder maps, and what's been tried before
- 2:56so newcomers don't start from zero. And then
- 3:00there's also mixed methods intelligence gathering.
- 3:02So while we know now that AI is the default research
- 3:05tool for most organizations, which makes a lot
- 3:08of sense, supplementing that desktop research
- 3:10with local insights from advocates and researchers
- 3:13on the ground will provide much more context.
- 3:16We're currently building a platform for this.
- 3:19So DM me if you're interested to know more or
- 3:21join us. Finally, we have to look at how we find
- 3:25resources to grow the movement. Often the default
- 3:28is to build more fellowships or incubators to
- 3:31support young talent or fundraise from within
- 3:34the movement. But in Asia, there is a wealth
- 3:36of resources from other movements that we should
- 3:38consider tapping into. So instead of building
- 3:42from scratch, we believe the movement can build
- 3:44bridges. For example, funding -wise, the top
- 3:4710 institutional funders like Foundations and
- 3:50Corporate Giving in Asia give a total average
- 3:52of 2 billion US dollars annually. and our movement
- 3:55has not tapped into any of these resources. Other
- 3:59local institutional capital can also be found
- 4:01in international schools, chambers of commerce,
- 4:04and religious foundations that may already have
- 4:06mandates for public health, climate, or animal
- 4:09welfare. And in terms of how to engage newer
- 4:12donors, we're very interested in events -based
- 4:15activation, so like shark tank formats or impact
- 4:18tours. which go beyond traditional pitch decks
- 4:21to create experiential, peer -driven engagement
- 4:24for regional donors that might be new to vegan
- 4:28and plant -based advocacy issues. And with talent,
- 4:32we could explore reverse incubation. So recruit
- 4:35proven leaders from climate tech, social impact
- 4:38sector, and train them in animal advocacy to
- 4:40design interventions that make sense locally.
- 4:44We're hoping that this strategy brief becomes
- 4:45a starting point for conversations about what
- 4:47to do in Asia. We're currently working on a series
- 4:50interviewing Asian -based leaders on lessons
- 4:52they've learned from working and expanding in
- 4:55the region, and we'll share that regularly on
- 4:57our socials and newsletters. You can find the
- 5:00full brief at goodgrowth .io or reach out to
- 5:02us at hello at goodgrowth .io with any specific
- 5:06questions. Thank you for listening and thank
- 5:08you for all the work that you do for animals.