Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Record Negative Equity, Dealers Optimistic About Service and Parts, Generational Sales Team Conflict
Transcript
- 0:01Oh, man. Okay, yesterday was my birthday. A little slow on the trigger this morning. It's Thursday- [laughs]... March 5th. It's the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul, that's Kyle.
- 0:08Today, we're talking about record negative equity, dealers being optimistic about service and parts, and a generational conflict- People where I go. People really wanna know... on AI in sales process.
- 0:18Where I live, they say ooh when they see me Ooh. We shorties come in threes This is gonna grow. This is a very interesting conversation. Run up in these white T's It is gonna grow. Here's- They be like, "Who is he?"
- 0:23Just so everybody knows- Talkin' to me. Here we go to the third story. Yeah. [laughs] Just so... No, no, no, no.
- 0:26Just so everybody knows, when Paul says, like, he can't get something going because it was his birthday yesterday, he wasn't out drinking. [laughs] He wasn't out late. The man's a dad, and it's fine.
- 0:38Don't, like- Let me tell you, let- Don't put words in the man's mouth... that, that, thank you. Thank you for getting my back on that. [laughs] Let me tell you the real reason.
- 0:44Um, well, uh, the real reason was I've been so behind on communications because so many people have reached out. And so my natural communication flow is I'm trying to catch up on DMs and messages- Yeah...
- 0:55and I'm so appreciative for it. And, um, it's, what a blessing to have that in your life. [laughs] So, um, and also, um, I don't eat a lot of sodium anymore 'cause I'm old now. Yeah. But I ate a lot of sodium last night.
- 1:08Oh, you got crushed yesterday. And so I woke up- Yeah, yeah... I'm like, "I can't believe I used to eat like..." We went to- [laughs]... my favorite restaurant in Syracuse. It's called Rosalie's.
- 1:15That's all I wanted for my birthday was to have a family dinner at Rosalie's, and it was- Aw... amazing. So I'm- That's good... I'm full of joy and happiness. Is that Italian? Very. Of course it is.
- 1:24But, like, but, like, not, like, I won't call it traditional Italian. It's, like, sophisticated Italian, but it's not pretentious. I'm gonna take you. Next time you're in Syracuse, we're going to Rosalie's.
- 1:33Sophisticated, non-pretentious Italian sounds great to me. Yo, you go up, you go down, you go to the bathroom, and they're, like, literally playing, like, like, a learn Italian tape is the bathroom music.
- 1:43[laughs] It's so fun. [laughs] They're like- That's great... [laughs] gento. [laughs] To have little conversations. It's so good. That's great. So good. Oh, man, so much going on today. Uh, so much going on right now.
- 1:53I'm seeing a SOTUCON posts now hit the internet, and you're seeing all these, like- Glistering... Captcha-like, uh, posts, and it's a riot. So, so cool. Because it's the year of the human.
- 2:02The team dialed it in with that. Yeah. It's the year of the human. So how do you verify you're human? Well, the Captcha. The Captcha. [laughs] Let's get Captchas thrown up there.
- 2:07That's exactly right, the relationship between that. If you're coming and you have a ticket and you don't have the Captcha thing, DM one of us. Let us know. We'll get you your Captcha. We'll get it to you.
- 2:15We'll get you your Captcha. Yeah, we gotta get it to you. Yeah, you can go to asotcon.com and check that out. Wanna thank our sponsors today, iPacket.
- 2:22Uh, I think, Kyle, I'm gonna read this one today because we didn't do the little back and forth thing. Go for it. All right. Go for it.
- 2:26Listen, you don't want to be using words like guess, like I guess or I feel, when pricing a vehicle. iPacket starts with OEM-backed build data.
- 2:36That means full options, packages, the actual window sticker, and builds your pricing logic up from there.
- 2:42You can customize the comps, validate the value, check merchandising health before adjusting the price on a I guess or I feel. It's disciplined, transparent. It's how modern dealerships win without racing to the bottom.
- 2:54Visit ipacket.us to learn more. How to- Man, if you've been in the industry a while, you remember, like, you, you feel like the, the used car manager was- [laughs]... kinda like one, in one of those seance modes.
- 3:05You know, it's like, "Oh, what's the pen gonna write?" And then it just, like, writes- [laughs]... a number because that's what the guy feels.
- 3:12I feel like that's, that's what we're overcoming in the industry- Yeah, we are... and not just iPacket, but everybody's doing, you know, everybody's trying to figure that out, so.
- 3:18Yeah, that, dude, that's, that would make a really funny ad. We have to pitch iPacket this ad idea. What a great ad. It's like, "Ah," and then it writes. And then everybody looks- You know, it takes over...
- 3:27he even looks down at the number like he doesn't know what it's gonna be, right? [laughs] One guy's like, "Ah." One guy- That's it... you know, all the confused faces, all the, all the excited faces. That's it.
- 3:35We're calling them today. You know? We, we're pitching you a campaign at iPacket. Oh, what a, what a, what a commercial.
- 3:40By the way, if you didn't know, we never have talked about this on the show, but- We never do that... More Than Cars, we have a full creative shop, and we help- We do...
- 3:45people come up with campaigns and ideas and commercials. It's the ideas. GPT's not coming up with that idea ever. Ever. Ever. Let's talk about some news.
- 3:53A growing number of buyers are rolling serious negative equity into their next vehicle purchase, creating real challenges for dealers trying to structure deals as lingering pandemic era pricing is rippling through the market.
- 4:04Edmunds reporting the average negative equity on trade-ins reached a record 7,214. Goodness. Over $7,000 of negative equity on average in Q4. That's more than $1,000 higher than pre-pandemic levels.
- 4:2029% of new vehicle buyers with trade-in are underwater, up to four percentage points up from a year ago. Nearly 27% carried at least 10,000 in negative equity, making deal structure a lot more complicated.
- 4:34Um, Amade- Amate Kalmar, CEO of auto lender Lendbuzz, says the negative equity issue will likely persist for another 18 months until loans from the high-price inventory shortage era start maturing.
- 4:47Our friend Brian Maz of the California New Car Auto Dealer Association summed it up like this, quote, "Negative equity can be managed up to a point, and at some point, even the most creative dealer can't figure out a way to help their customers get into a new car."
- 5:01Our very own Chris Reeves did a deep dive on this morning's ASOTU daily email, if you don't get it, sotu.com, on how dealers can talk to customers about negative equity and real ownership costs.
- 5:11Little- The deep dive is there. You can go to the link in the show notes and, and check that out. Yeah, or daily.asotu.com. It's, it's one of the first articles there.
- 5:19Uh, this is, this is a, an issue we've known has, going to be coming.
- 5:24Um, the, the beauty of this is, is there are some high day supply manufacturers, and, and you know who you are if you're one of them, that already have incentives that are growing as well.
- 5:34I think we talked about just a week and a half ago, uh, a growing incentive pool on new vehicles.
- 5:40And so we're getting some balance in there we can, where we can find loan rates, uh, that, that match incenti- or, or, uh, loan-to-value rates that match the incentives and the negative equity.
- 5:50But, um, eh, you know, $1,000 on a $30,000 vehicle, 3%, that might bump you out of ty- typical LTV, um, uh, uh, options that, that regular banks might have. Probably checking i- into credit unions.
- 6:06Also, you know-Talking about this upfront in a deal, like understanding the, the customer's trade. The, the customer's trade is one of the, the biggest ideas in their mind, uh, when they're coming to trade that vehicle.
- 6:17So understanding deal structure upfront is extremely important, uh, right now. You know, affordability, it's everything.
- 6:24I mean, it's a huge-- I think it's a huge opportunity for a dealer to be prepared and train their people how to coach someone through a negative equity situation.
- 6:33Like, we talk about scripts and having li- things memorized, but having real coaching scenarios and role-playing through this, I think could make a massive difference at- Mm-hmm... the point of contact with the consumer.
- 6:44Because they know, they probably know. They probably don't know how bad. Nobody knows how bad you're behind. And some people- Sure... have no idea, right?
- 6:52Like, they bought a car, they didn't, weren't really paying attention to what trade values are. Like, they wouldn't. And so being able to say at that moment, "Uh, this is how we're going to get through this," right?
- 7:03"These are the options."
- 7:03And even if that means they can't purchase a new car right there, helping them come up with a plan to the point where they can purchase a car means that you're building massive relationship credibility with that customer.
- 7:13And we talk about retention, and, uh, people go back to people they think are really in it to help them. So a couple opportunities on a couple fronts. That's why we do the deep dives, too. Again- Yeah...
- 7:22that link is in the show notes. Or you go to asotu.com and, uh, just make sure you don't miss that stuff in the emails every morning. Uh, I wanna segue so bad. I can't think of one. There's no segue.
- 7:32Well, no segue today. I'm so sorry. No segue. All right.
- 7:34After a surprising dip late last year, dealer sentiment around service lanes bounced back in Q1, according to Cox Automotive, even as new vehicle sales expectations are flat.
- 7:45The Cox Automotive Dealer Sentimen- Sentiment Index for fixed ops rose 60 to 63 in Q1, up from 61 in Q4. While it's improved, it still trails mid-2025 levels of 65 and 66. Still some work to do.
- 8:00Dealers' expectations for future opportunities jumped to 69, which is up five points. Uh, Cox forecasting flat new vehicle sales around 16 million in 2026. Service lanes likely to become more critical- Yeah...
- 8:13for dealership profitability. Yeah, I mean, [sighs] this is like used cars and service. If you're not good in used cars and service- Heard that combo before... find a way to get good at it.
- 8:26That's, that's your opportunity for transitioning people from low-price entry to new cars and getting life cycle retention back.
- 8:34Um, the-- I-- My opinion on why we've got, uh, a, a little bit more increased excitement around the service conversation is because new cars are waning a lit, a little bit because of the affordability.
- 8:48Um, and so-- And, and even on the EV side, we've seen a new car waning, and, and there's no growth pro- you know, projected by J.D. Power or Cox in new cars. So where do dealers focus? Where they can find profitability.
- 9:01So when you focus on something, you get the opportunity to be optimistic about it. So I think it's just a focus perspective here- Yeah... that we get.
- 9:08And, and you should-- I, I think you should be optimistic about service. There's a lot of manufacturers leaning into service technology, understanding how to give fixed ops a better perspective for the customer.
- 9:19More, more tools that are learning that the life cycle management is much more on the service side than it is on the, on the sales side.
- 9:25So fixed ops as a general whole is just getting much more attention, which, which we've been advocating for over the last three years. And, and I'm glad it's finally getting, uh, the spotlight it needs. Yeah.
- 9:34Our friend Aaron Keating, executive analyst at Cox, said, uh, quote, "We know how many vehicles are in operation in your area. Why are you not capturing them in your service lanes versus independent shops?"
- 9:46So I think back to your point, Kyle, saying an area of focus. Yep. Speaking of a big area of focus right now. What's up? Major area of focus. It's the wrong time. [upbeat music] AI incorporated into your workflow.
- 9:58New report says that generational tension inside sales teams is both getting awkward and expensive.
- 10:03A report from SalesLoft and Clari estimates generational conflict between Boomers, Gen X, and Gen Z is costing companies about $56 billion a year- Wow... in lost productivity as AI adoption reshapes th- how teams work.
- 10:18Nearly 39% of Gen Z sales reps say they'd rather be managed by AI than a human. Oh, my gosh. [laughs] That's nuts. Uh, while some Boomers say they prefer AI over working with Gen Z colleagues.
- 10:29[laughs] They're like, "Don't give me the other generation. Just give me AI-" No, that, that's all just like- "... put that in the middle of it"... listen, AI is better than you.
- 10:35That's what they're both saying right now. Uh, that's, that's all what it is. The tension is pushing talent out.
- 10:4028% of Gen Z reps are job hunting to avoid Boomers, while 19% of Boomers are considering early retirement due to frustrations- This is a riot... with Gen Z.
- 10:49This is just, like, putting, you know, this is just reality of our world. It's always been this way. Uh, yeah.
- 10:56S- CEO Steve Cox of SalesLoft and Clari summed it up this way: "When Boomers hear AI makes you faster, what they really hear is you're too slow." Oh, well, I mean- Dang... that is, that is what they're saying.
- 11:08That is what they're saying. I mean-- And I, I-- And this is actually kind of really r- taking a second to register because, I mean, this is-- this would be basically their grandparents' generation, right? Yeah.
- 11:21Uh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It would be. The Gen X raised Gen Z mostly. Yep. Right? And so [laughs] this is the grandparents.
- 11:26And I-- What, what I see, this is a practical observation, is that I'm noticing a lot of, uh, the Boomer generation
- 11:35feeling very emboldened and powerful because they're embracing AI tech, I think, at a higher rate than older generations typically embrace tech. New tech, yeah. So, so, yes, right, new tech.
- 11:47And so they're feeling emboldened and be like, [tsks] "I'd rather use AI than deal with your crap." And Gen Z is like, "You think you're good at this, but you're actually not. I'm way better at it." And- So funny...
- 11:58I, like, I don't, I don't know that this is new because of AI. No. Right? This has always been there. I think if we just looked at loss of productivity- Get over yourselves and work with people.
- 12:07Learn where they have the-- Learn where someone else has the opportunity to show you a benefit that they've learned because of their area of expertise or worldview. Okay. Right? Gain perspective.
- 12:16Shameless plug for the automotive industry here. Come on. I do not see this happening inside car dealerships and automotive organizations. Nope. We see a lot of- I don't hear it...
- 12:26great interactions between Gen Z and Boomers throughout the auto industry because there's a big focus on mentorship and not replacing one another with technology. I mean, am I wrong? Get in, auto.
- 12:39It's, it's a-- You get in auto. Industry people should fight to join. I don't know. This is a fun show today. [laughs] A fun show. I wasn't expecting this one. Well, thank you so much for being here with us.
- 12:47If you don't get the Asotu daily email, you should, so you don't miss more of this stuff. You can just go to asotu.com, sign up. We'll see you here tomorrow. [upbeat music] Get ready. Get ready. Get ready.
- 12:59And lead the way. Asotu. Get ready. Get ready. Get ready. And lead the way. Asotu.