Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / New Statement of Decision Statute and Rules: Tips To Prevent Mistakes
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to New Statement of
- 0:07Decision Statute and Rules, Tips to Prevent Mistakes.
- 0:11I'm Ola Policastro, Director of Education and
- 0:14Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:16Association. And today, I am delighted to introduce
- 0:18our speaker, Claudia Ribbett. Claudia is a partner
- 0:22at Ribbon & Silver and counsel at Complex Appellate
- 0:25Litigation Group, LLP. She's one of only a handful
- 0:28of attorneys in California certified as a specialist
- 0:31in both appellate law and family law. Her practice
- 0:34focuses on complex dissolution matters, including
- 0:37asset division, business valuation, child custody,
- 0:40and spousal support with substantial experience
- 0:42before the California Court of Appeals. Claudia
- 0:45is a fellow of the American Academy of Matrimonial
- 0:48Lawyers and in the International Academy of Family
- 0:51Lawyers and has been recognized as a super lawyer
- 0:54for many years. We're so excited to have her
- 0:56with us today. So I'm now going to turn it over
- 0:58to her. Thank you, guys. I'm actually one of
- 1:01maybe 12 now lawyers who's dual certified in
- 1:04the state of California and also another Academy
- 1:08took me in the. California Academy of Appellate
- 1:11Lawyers. Oops, I get very small now. This discussion
- 1:19of statements of decision isn't the hottest and
- 1:22sexiest topic in the world, but it has gotten
- 1:25much or will get in January of 2027, thank God,
- 1:30much, much easier because I used to say that
- 1:34the rule for statements of decision CRC 3 .1590
- 1:39was Kafkaesque or Byzantine and Nobody could
- 1:44understand it and I used to have a complete copy
- 1:49plastered on my wall and I would look at it even
- 1:52at In my level of experience multiple times a
- 1:57week. It's gotten much easier I don't mean to
- 2:00be simplistic, but I will go back for just a
- 2:02second to say, what is a statement of decision?
- 2:06Can you move the slide? A statement of decision
- 2:09is the court's factual and legal basis for its
- 2:13decision on anything that's controverted as an
- 2:16issue at trial. It is not an order of the court.
- 2:19It's not an appealable judgment. It's going to
- 2:22become much easier under the new rules to figure
- 2:25out what is an appealable judgment or what isn't.
- 2:29Several times a month, someone will ask me whether
- 2:32they need to appeal from a statement of decision,
- 2:35and the answer is 99 .9 % of the time, no. So,
- 2:41just remember that after a court has issued a
- 2:44final statement of decision, either now until
- 2:47January or under the new rules and new statute,
- 2:51ask the court to issue its final judgment if
- 2:55for some bizarre reason the court hasn't done
- 2:58so. So, next slide please. When do you get a
- 3:03statement of decision? You get a statement of
- 3:05decision in any non -jury proceeding, which is
- 3:08always us, where a question of fact is being
- 3:11determined. It's generally not required for a
- 3:14motion or an RFO, even if an evidentiary hearing
- 3:18is held. One of the exceptions, which is not
- 3:26on the next slide, is a DV case, but it is my
- 3:34judgment and advice that if you're holding a
- 3:37large DV hearing, a small DV hearing, any kind
- 3:40of domestic violence protection order hearing,
- 3:42ask for a statement of decision. arena entitled
- 3:54to a statement of decision. When you have a bifurcated
- 3:57issue tried to the court, what is the date of
- 4:02separation, whether a premarital agreement is
- 4:05valid or invalid, and you're holding a hearing
- 4:07on this issue with witnesses under CRC 3 .1591,
- 4:13which we'll talk about a little bit later because
- 4:16it too has some small modifications or will have
- 4:19some small modifications when you have a bifurcated
- 4:23issue to be tried to the court or that's being
- 4:25tried by the court. You are entitled to a statement
- 4:29of decision. We can talk some other time in some
- 4:32other place What you do if you want an immediate
- 4:35appeal from a bifurcated issue that is the subject
- 4:39of a separate Order for bifurcation that is not
- 4:43the subject of today, but that also has its own
- 4:46kind of complicated rules So equitable claims
- 4:49try to a bench trial We don't really need to
- 4:51worry about that at the moment because all of
- 4:54our cases are equitable Claims tried to a bench
- 4:58trial. Custody determinations under Family Code
- 5:02Section 3022 .3 and cases including In Ray Rose
- 5:08G are 100 % of the time entitled to a statement
- 5:13of decision. So if you have a small, large, medium
- 5:17size child custody trial, You asked for statement
- 5:21of decision under 3022 .3 and you're going to
- 5:24get one or better get one or should get one.
- 5:28Next slide please goes into the important question
- 5:32which probably all know about but I'm going to
- 5:35take a moment to remind us is why do you need
- 5:39a statement of decision? You need a statement
- 5:42of decision because of the doctrine of implied
- 5:44findings. In the absence of one, the appellate
- 5:48court is going to presume that the trial court
- 5:51made each and every factual finding necessary
- 5:55to determine or rather to support the judgment
- 5:57for which substantial evidence exists in the
- 6:01record. That means if you didn't ask for a statement
- 6:04of decision and didn't ask for the court to lay
- 6:07out every single factual finding that it made,
- 6:11the Court of Appeal is going to presume that
- 6:14such a factual finding was made. Sometimes it
- 6:17wasn't made and sometimes you need to ask the
- 6:21court to tell you what it's doing, what it's
- 6:23saying, and what it's making because otherwise
- 6:27all necessary findings of ultimate fact in your
- 6:32trial are going to be implied, meaning the court
- 6:35of appeals is going to say, I'm implying them,
- 6:38and the only issue on appeal is whether the implied
- 6:41findings are supported by substantial evidence.
- 6:44And that's a much more narrow standard of review
- 6:47and a very difficult burden or rather standard
- 6:52of review to get a reversal on appeal. So next
- 6:56slide. Here's an example. It comes from negligence
- 7:01cases, which we are not dealing with, but it's
- 7:04kind of an easy, non -specific way to explain
- 7:07it. In a negligence action, a court has to find
- 7:10there was a duty of caro to somebody. It was
- 7:13a breach of that duty. The breach of that duty
- 7:16was the cause of an injury, and the victim incurred
- 7:19damages. If the court finds the defendant negligent,
- 7:24but doesn't issue a statement of decision, The
- 7:27court of appeal is going to assume that the trial
- 7:31judge found each and every one of those ultimate
- 7:34facts to be true. There was a duty. There was
- 7:37a breach. There was a breach of the duty of care
- 7:40and the victim incurred damages. So you can imagine
- 7:44and say in a custody case, If you don't ask for
- 7:51a statement of decision on whether one parent
- 7:53was withholding the child or one parent was likelier
- 7:57than the other parent to provide for close and
- 8:00continuous contact between the child and the
- 8:03parent and the judge finds that one parent should
- 8:06have primary physical custody, the court's gonna
- 8:08find everything else that you may not believe
- 8:11was tried in the case in order to support that
- 8:14judgment. So it's important not only to ask for
- 8:18statement of decision, but to be very mindful
- 8:21and careful about what you're asking or how you're
- 8:24asking for a statement of decision, which we'll
- 8:27talk about a little bit going forward. And I'm
- 8:31not here to seed my own bed, so to speak, but
- 8:33I'm happy to help people in post trial. areas
- 8:40including drafting requests for statement of
- 8:42decision. I do maybe 40 percent of my, 100 percent
- 8:46of my appellate work is helping trial lawyers
- 8:49at all stages of the proceedings because I am
- 8:52a trial lawyer, I was a trial lawyer, I'm mostly
- 8:54now an appellate lawyer and I like helping and
- 8:58I and I can help. I also answer the phone, sometimes
- 9:03just give you an answer, not on a fact -specific
- 9:06question, but some general question. If you have
- 9:09a quickie question to ask me, I will certainly
- 9:12answer the question. So next slide, please. So
- 9:17the statement of decision process is two -step.
- 9:21First, you have to ask for a statement of decision.
- 9:24and then once the court issues a statement of
- 9:26decision, a party must bring omissions or ambiguities
- 9:30to the court's attention before entry of judgment
- 9:34or in conjunction with post -trial motions. This
- 9:38is exactly how one can mess up in failing to
- 9:42preserve the record for appeal at the trial court
- 9:45level. Namely, you ask for a statement of decision
- 9:48and the court produces something that isn't full
- 9:53enough or isn't complete enough or makes material
- 9:56or even immaterial errors that you want corrected
- 10:00and you fail to bring it to the court's attention
- 10:02before the judge issues a judgment or rules on
- 10:07a motion for a new trial or a motion to vacate
- 10:10or to set aside or any other post -trial motion.
- 10:14You have just waived your probably largely or
- 10:19likeliest, waived your argument on appeal. So
- 10:23waiver is a bad word and one that I try to avoid
- 10:26for my clients and myself at all costs. So next
- 10:31slide please. So before I go into the good news,
- 10:40I want to talk about the old news, which is the
- 10:42current news. So we're in June, almost July.
- 10:45We have whatever many months left. The current
- 10:48rules are so convoluted, as I mentioned before,
- 10:52that first, the court announces a tentative decision.
- 10:57It can be theoretically as easy as I find that
- 11:02mom should have primary physical custody. Step
- 11:05two. is issuance of a proposed statement of decision.
- 11:10And after the tentative decision, a tentative
- 11:15decision is not a statement of decision. It's
- 11:17not a proposed statement of decision. After a
- 11:20tentative decision, the court can change its
- 11:23mind at any time. And you are to ask the court
- 11:26after a tentative decision for a statement of
- 11:28decision to include. And you put a whole bunch
- 11:32of requests in your statement of decision request.
- 11:36The rules are so convoluted now that it's sometimes
- 11:39difficult to figure out how you get from this
- 11:43oral or written tentative decision to the proposed
- 11:46statement of decision, and you can pull your
- 11:49hair out. After the judge issues or orders a
- 11:53party to issue a proposed statement of decision,
- 11:59parties currently are given an opportunity to
- 12:02object. to the proposed statement of decision
- 12:05and then the court issues its final statement
- 12:08of decision, which people try to object to. There's
- 12:12no grounds for that under CRC 3 .1590. People
- 12:17do it anyway, but people shouldn't do it. They
- 12:20do it. And then a judge issues a judgment or
- 12:24order and you can oppose that too. This slide
- 12:27has a typo in it. It says that on October, well,
- 12:32the first Bullet point is fine. Governor Newsom
- 12:35signed into law AB 515, which totally changed.
- 12:40Code of Civil Procedure 632, which is our Statement
- 12:44of Decision Statute, and 664, which is our Entry
- 12:48of Judgment Statute. But the next bullet point
- 12:51has a typo. It says, although the Rules of Court
- 12:543 .5190 haven't been amended, the Judicial Council
- 12:58was directed to do it. It's 3 .1590, and the
- 13:02Judicial Council is doing it. I was just participating
- 13:07with the Bay Area Bar Association in sending
- 13:12the Judicial Council our comments to the proposed
- 13:16new rules 3 .1590, which I absolutely will talk
- 13:21about later because they are not as... Kafka
- 13:26-esque, but they require a little bit close scrutiny.
- 13:29They aren't final. It's going to be a whole lot
- 13:32easier, but I'll talk about what it looks like
- 13:35they're going to be when they come out. Next
- 13:38slide, please. So under the current rules, as
- 13:45I mentioned, a party has to request a statement
- 13:48of decision within 10 days of the announcement
- 13:51of the tentative decision, or, and this is where
- 13:54people do get stuck and make make errors if a
- 13:57trial is less than one day before submission.
- 14:01And there's that typo. Again, I don't know how
- 14:03that keeps coming up. I must be slight dyslexia,
- 14:06which I didn't know that I had. It's 3 .1590
- 14:10DNN. So a court issues a tentative decision or
- 14:15orally announces one. And then within 10 days,
- 14:18you're supposed to ask for a statement of decision.
- 14:21What is going to change? This is the biggest
- 14:24problem or the biggest, this is the newest news
- 14:27and the biggest change and one that is the subject
- 14:31of a lot of cross discussions in my law firm
- 14:35and among family law appellate lawyers in general,
- 14:39which is that under the new law, All requests
- 14:43for statement of decision have to be made prior
- 14:45to the submission of the matter for decision,
- 14:48regardless of the length of the trial. That means
- 14:51when you're exhausted and you've made sure that
- 14:54all your exhibits are in evidence and you want
- 14:57to go home, you need to remember to ask for a
- 15:01statement of decision before the court says so
- 15:03submitted or the matter is submitted. You need
- 15:06to read the new statute. I'm going to talk about
- 15:09it a little bit later. There's, again, close
- 15:13scrutiny because it's a real toughie. And what's
- 15:17the toughie? Well, how do you know what you want
- 15:19to ask for if you don't know if you've won or
- 15:21lost? looked like you were going to win or you
- 15:31knew you were going to win because the court
- 15:33issued a tentative decision in your favor, there
- 15:37would be a valid question as to whether you even
- 15:40wanted a statement of decision. Because if all
- 15:43presumptions are read to support the judgment
- 15:46and you are the absolute drop dead winner, then
- 15:50why would you want the court to make it easier
- 15:52for the other side to appeal? You wouldn't. You
- 15:55just might not want to do that. You might want
- 15:58to keep mum and not say a word about wanting
- 16:01a statement of decision or further... findings
- 16:05of fact and conclusions of law that a statement
- 16:07of decision provides. You don't have that luxury
- 16:11anymore under the new rule. If you don't ask
- 16:14for a statement of decision before the matter
- 16:16is submitted, and obviously, by definition, before
- 16:20you get a ruling, then you're SOL for getting
- 16:23a statement of decision, and there is not one
- 16:26of us 12 dual -certified lawyers who's gonna
- 16:29wanna let that happen. the prior currently and
- 16:36until the law changes, if I thought that I was
- 16:40going to be in a short trial or if I'm helping
- 16:43somebody who's going to be in a short trial and
- 16:45you don't know if it's less than one day and
- 16:47you need to provide a request for statement of
- 16:50decision before submission, I would draft a very
- 16:54simple document entitled Petitioner or Respondents
- 16:59Request for Statement of Decision and you can
- 17:02make it kind of very broad and maybe leave some
- 17:05space in between your paragraphs. So as you're
- 17:08sitting there at the hearing, you can maybe interlineate
- 17:12in a handwritten manner and then file up with
- 17:15the bailiff a request for a statement of decision
- 17:18on custody, division of property, breach of fiduciary
- 17:22duty, whatever the trial happens to be dealing
- 17:25with. And maybe the same thing will be correct
- 17:28now. You'll go to court even if it's a eight
- 17:32week trial and you'll have a very bland request
- 17:36for a statement of decision, which you may or
- 17:39may not be able to amend later asking for what
- 17:43you want, which is a statement of decision on
- 17:46whatever you just tried in the hearing or in
- 17:49the trial, and that's going to be tough. I think
- 17:52it's going to be the subject of some decisions
- 17:55in the Court of Appeal, certainly some discussion
- 17:59among bench officers, and we'll see how it plays
- 18:02out. As I say to people sometimes, I'm kind of
- 18:06driving ahead of my lights here because I don't
- 18:08really know how it's gonna play out. I just know
- 18:10that it's gonna be an interesting problem that
- 18:13requires close scrutiny. Next slide, please.
- 18:18What does a statement of decision have to...
- 18:21asked for. It has to ask for those controverted
- 18:24issues as to which the party is requesting a
- 18:27statement of decision, and that is true now and
- 18:31it's going to be true also in January. It doesn't
- 18:34have to be a detailed list of questions. It's
- 18:37sufficient if the request states the specific
- 18:39issue, e .g. was the defendant negligent, e .g.
- 18:43was the wife withholding the child, and the factual
- 18:47issues and controversy. Judges historically pushed
- 18:52back at detailed lists of questions and there
- 18:56are cases that say exactly that, that the trial
- 19:00judge doesn't have to ask, excuse me, answer
- 19:02interrogatory questions. So you need to walk
- 19:06a fine line between covering yourself and pissing
- 19:10off the judge so much that she or he doesn't
- 19:14give you what what you want him or her to give
- 19:16her or him to give you. I used to give a talk
- 19:19that said the most important thing you could
- 19:22do as a trial lawyer with your appellate lawyer
- 19:26is win. So your appellate lawyer wants to be
- 19:29the respondent's lawyer, not the appellant's
- 19:31lawyer, although of course I'll do both. So if
- 19:35you're going to win, if you look like you're
- 19:36going to win, hang in there and don't piss the
- 19:39judge off. Next slide, please. As I said, and
- 19:45we'll probably say another time during this conversation,
- 19:49under the current rules, the court has to first
- 19:51announce a tentative decision. And then there's
- 19:54a complicated process for issuance of proposed
- 19:58and then final statement of decision. That's
- 20:01got that silly typo again. And I said, hooray,
- 20:04all of that's eliminated under the new law. And
- 20:06that is a really big hooray. So the next slide
- 20:10gives us what we. have to do in the future, which
- 20:13is imminent, and we ought to get used to it now.
- 20:17In the future, when a party requests a statement
- 20:20of decision, the court must issue a written statement
- 20:24of decision, or if the trial is less than...
- 20:27Whoa, wait a minute. This is wrong. This is the
- 20:30old rule. I just made a terrible mistake. Nope,
- 20:33I didn't make a mistake. In the future, when
- 20:35a party requests a statement of decision, the
- 20:38court issues a written tentative, or if the...
- 20:40trial is less than one day, the court can make
- 20:42an oral statement of decision, or the court can
- 20:45order a party or parties to prepare a draft.
- 20:49But even if a party prepares a draft, the court
- 20:52has to issue the statement of decision. And although
- 20:55the term proposed statement of decision is a
- 20:59matter of past history or will be a matter of
- 21:03past history. The statement of decision is final
- 21:06upon issuance but still subject to modification
- 21:11before the judgment by way of objections or if
- 21:17the judge wakes up in the middle of the night
- 21:19and decides that she or he has done something
- 21:21wrong and she or he wants to change it because
- 21:24she or he always has the right to do it under
- 21:27LeFrancois versus Goyle and can wake up and say,
- 21:30oops, I made a mistake. I'm changing it. I'm
- 21:32changing my decision because a judgment has not
- 21:35yet issued. New slide, please. So, a detailed
- 21:45discussion of evidentiary facts doesn't have
- 21:49to be made. The court only has to talk about
- 21:52ultimate facts. So long as the statement of decision
- 21:55disposes of basic material issues in the case,
- 21:59it's going to be okay. Next slide. Okay, this
- 22:04is important. This is where I do a lot of my
- 22:06work. To avoid the doctrine of implied findings,
- 22:10a party has to object. to any omissions or ambiguities
- 22:15or errors in the court's factual findings and
- 22:18statement of decision. Do not simply disagree
- 22:22and say the court got it wrong, and don't try
- 22:26to re -argue the merits of the court's decision.
- 22:29When I help people do objections to the statement
- 22:32of decision because the court inadvertently got
- 22:35something wrong, I will refer the court to the
- 22:40piece of evidence either an exhibit or some testimony,
- 22:45hopefully with a transcript, with citations,
- 22:48so the court can say, she's right, I did this
- 22:52particular thing incorrectly, I'm going to change
- 22:55this, and I'm going to uphold the objection to
- 22:59the statement of decision. It doesn't happen
- 23:01a lot because it's very difficult to get anybody,
- 23:04judges, spouses, friends, children, to agree
- 23:10that they made an error or to change their mind,
- 23:13it's human nature. But the best thing you can
- 23:16do is gingerly and respectfully point out where
- 23:20the evidence is incorrect. And I often, when
- 23:24I am objecting to the statement of decision,
- 23:26not only do that, but also provide a proposed
- 23:31alternative. Instead of saying X, why don't you
- 23:35say Y? And the court can ask for parties briefs
- 23:40on statements of decision in Word. I know several
- 23:43bench officers in Los Angeles County do that.
- 23:47And then the judge can pick and choose cut and
- 23:50paste from people's drafts and save a lot of
- 23:55work and time, which is obviously good for the
- 23:57court and good for your client. Next slide. Under
- 24:03the old rules and until January, a party may
- 24:07object to the proposed statement of decision
- 24:09within 15 days after it's been served. So there
- 24:13was a 10 -day request for a statement of decision,
- 24:1615 -day request for objections, then another
- 24:20number of days for the judgment, and then final
- 24:23judgment after that. That's gotten much easier,
- 24:27thank God, under the new law. Objections have
- 24:30to be served and filed within 10 days after the
- 24:33statement of decision has been served by the
- 24:35court. Period. End of discussion. And if no objections
- 24:39are served, the statement of decision becomes
- 24:41final. And like with orders and judgments now,
- 24:47I predict that our bench officers are going to
- 24:49say exactly that. If no objections are served
- 24:52within 10 days, this proposed statement of decision
- 24:55is going to become the final statement of decision.
- 24:59of the court. So correct errors, don't raise
- 25:07the specter of waiver of an issue relating to
- 25:12the sufficiency of evidence by failing to object
- 25:16to something in the statement of decision that's
- 25:18incorrect, because the statement of decision
- 25:21does absolutely give rise to implied findings.
- 25:25And if you haven't objected, it's going to be
- 25:27a problem. Next slide, please. So under the old
- 25:37rules, the court is required to prepare a proposed
- 25:41judgment along with its proposed statement of
- 25:44decision subject to objections. Under the new
- 25:48law, the court may, doesn't say must, prepare
- 25:51and serve a proposed judgment before or after
- 25:55the statement of decision is final. And if so,
- 25:58any party may object to that proposed judgment
- 26:03within 10 days. So you can see that it's really
- 26:08important to read the language of Code of Civil
- 26:14Procedure Section 632 because it lays out exactly
- 26:18the time frame and how you're supposed to...
- 26:21paint by numbers, cross your T's and dot your
- 26:24I's. The proposed rules, which we'll talk about
- 26:28in a bit, may make it easier to follow CCP 632,
- 26:33but 632 is the legislation, it's the statute,
- 26:39it is the basis for which the new rules are going
- 26:43to be issued, and you should look at 632 really
- 26:47carefully sometime in the next six months. So
- 26:51next slide, please. I'm just going to take a
- 26:54sip of water. Entry of judgment. Under existing
- 27:01Code of Civil Procedure at 664, judgment has
- 27:06to be entered by the clerk immediately upon the
- 27:09filing of the court's decision. Under the new
- 27:13law, judgment must be entered within 30 days
- 27:16after the statement of decision becomes final.
- 27:19or 30 days after the filing of the court's decision
- 27:22if no statement of decision is requested. Pretty
- 27:27simple. So in addition to reading Code of Civil
- 27:30Procedure 663, please read Code of Civil Procedure
- 27:34664, which I didn't print here in a slide because
- 27:38it's easy for you. to read it as for me to read
- 27:42it out loud, which of course is not interesting
- 27:45to anybody. So just to summarize again, under
- 27:48the old rules, proposed judgments were issued
- 27:51at the same time as proposed statements of decision.
- 27:55And it was so complicated because... The judgment
- 27:58and final statement of decision were ultimately
- 28:01required to be issued within 50 days after the
- 28:05announcement or service of the tentative decision
- 28:08or if a hearing was held on objections within
- 28:1110 days of the objections. And if you're not
- 28:14pulling your hair out now, you can imagine that
- 28:17we all are pulling our hair out trying to draft
- 28:21out or chart out, raff out, I guess is the way
- 28:24to put it, who needs to produce what by when
- 28:27and how do you object if the court doesn't do
- 28:30it right. It can be very time consuming. So before
- 28:37I go to the next slide, I want to take a moment
- 28:39to ask the following question and answer it.
- 28:42What happens if the court doesn't issue a statement
- 28:46of decision that you properly requested? Back
- 28:50in the old days, a long line of cases held and
- 28:53I would argue that if counsel properly requests,
- 28:57timely that means generally, a statement of decision
- 29:00and a court fails to issue one, that is reversible
- 29:05error. Well, in Let's see, 2017, which seems
- 29:11recent to me, but it's really not. The Supreme
- 29:14Court of the State of California in a case called
- 29:18FP versus Monnier held that, no, no, no, no,
- 29:22no. A trial court's error in failing to issue
- 29:26a statement of decision is not reversible per
- 29:29se. evaluate whether the error was harmless or
- 29:36plain error. If it was harmless error, because
- 29:38who cares? No harm, no foul. You have to argue
- 29:45what? You have to argue both that you were entitled
- 29:48to a statement of decision and that you were
- 29:51prejudiced from the denial of the statement of
- 29:54decision, which means basically that something
- 29:59has really gone wrong because the statement of
- 30:01decision wasn't issued. How do you show that?
- 30:04Well, you can read Monnier. Text me or email
- 30:09me and I'll give you the site. How does Monnier
- 30:13instructs that if one or more issues in the proposed
- 30:17statement of decision or rather request a statement
- 30:20of decision was left unaddressed by the trial
- 30:23court, The more you ask for, the more difficult
- 30:27it may be to find harmless error. So you want
- 30:31to ask specifically in a statement of decision
- 30:35for what you want. and then you're going to argue
- 30:39that the court had enough opportunities to tell
- 30:44us what it was doing that its failure to do so
- 30:47was plain error. It's a hard argument to make
- 30:51just from the failure to issue a statement of
- 30:54decision, but it bears thinking about if you're
- 30:58on appeal or if your client is thinking about
- 31:00appeal. Now the one exception to this FP versus
- 31:05Marnier Holding, which is that you have to show
- 31:08plain error, not just that the statement of decision
- 31:11wasn't entered, is when you have a custody trial,
- 31:15a child custody matter. The exception is if a
- 31:19judge fails to issue a statement of decision
- 31:22in a trial of a child custody issue, that's deemed
- 31:26always prejudicial and reversible. And this site
- 31:30I will give you, it's City and County of San
- 31:33Francisco. versus H .H. City and County of San
- 31:37Francisco versus H .H. It's a 2022 case, and
- 31:43it is at 76 Cal App 5th, 531, 76 Cal App 5th,
- 31:49531. So you say to the court, you issue, please,
- 31:54a statement of decision. You're mandated to,
- 31:56under family code 3022 .3. Did I get that right?
- 32:02point something, point three, I think. And if
- 32:04the trial judge says, no, so sad, too bad, I'm
- 32:08not going to do it, then you have an argument
- 32:13for reversal. Of course, you'd rather win than
- 32:17be in the Court of Appeal. OK, next slide, please.
- 32:26So these next slides are not written in stone,
- 32:33they are proposed. It says on every slide from
- 32:37here on out, proposed rewrite. And I do want
- 32:40to say something before I go any further, which
- 32:43is that in the future, there's going to be a
- 32:50Judicial Council form. It's going to look kind
- 32:53of like this. I'm trying to do this. I'm not
- 32:57putting this on a slide because it's fake. I
- 32:59mean, it is a proposed judicial counsel forum.
- 33:02It's going to be entitled Request for Statement
- 33:04of Decision. And that may help you. And it's
- 33:07certainly what you will potentially bring into
- 33:10the courtroom when you go to any trial you think
- 33:13is going to end that day. Cause trial or a long
- 33:18cause trial. It's been ten weeks. You'll bring
- 33:21it and It's this is one page It's got space here,
- 33:26but you could of course add to it and you propose
- 33:29I mean, excuse me You present this to the bailiff
- 33:32and tell the court to file it There's also interestingly
- 33:35going to be a statement of decision information
- 33:38sheet. It's called a Civil 175 info civil 175
- 33:44info again I'm not putting a slide up about this
- 33:47because there it's just totally not Finalized
- 33:51yet, but the statement of decision information
- 33:54sheet has four pages. I was about to count then
- 33:57I see it says one of four It's like two of four
- 34:00so it'll tell you What's the statement of decision?
- 34:04When can I ask for one? Why do I ask for one?
- 34:08Is the court required to issue one if a party
- 34:10asks? When is the deadline? This is a really,
- 34:13really, really, really good thing. Is it going
- 34:15to do away with you? Do away with you? No. Is
- 34:19it going to do away with me? Probably not. Hopefully
- 34:22not. Because it's just a piece of paper with
- 34:27some answers that the Judicial Council is going
- 34:29to draft up. It's not the be all and end all,
- 34:34but it sure is better than nothing. And this
- 34:36is the first time we're going to have anything
- 34:38like this for pro se litigants, pro pro litigants,
- 34:42for any of us who are trial lawyers who look
- 34:46at the word statement of decision and want to
- 34:48put a cross up, or for appellate lawyers. Because
- 34:53I would say, I don't know, 10 % of my work. Fully
- 34:5910 % of my work is involved with answering questions
- 35:03about Statement of Decision, drafting requests
- 35:06for Statement of Decision, objecting to Statement
- 35:08of Decision, or drafting with a trial or Statements
- 35:11of Decision. So this Statement of Decision information
- 35:16sheet is going to be a great thing. Those of
- 35:20us who practice substantially in this field are
- 35:23hand in glove rolling up our sleeves and giving
- 35:26the Judicial Council of the State of California
- 35:29as much help and input as it requests and it
- 35:32wants and in addition to a piece of paper judicial
- 35:37council form for a Request for statement of decision.
- 35:43There's also going to be a piece of paper entitled
- 35:46objection to a statement of decision. I don't
- 35:48know if I'm doing this right, but this is also
- 35:50one page, which is of course ridiculous because
- 35:53the statement of decision that has been drafted
- 35:55by the judge or by you or your opponent is going
- 35:58to be, you know, 35 pages. And this one piece
- 36:02of paper isn't going to do it, but it'll certainly
- 36:05get you started. It says, you know, please see
- 36:08attachment two and attachment two is going to
- 36:10be a whole bunch of pages But at least there's
- 36:13a form now and at least there's a thought, you
- 36:15know something that you can wrap on to You know
- 36:20statements of decision are complicated the one
- 36:23Statement of decision that I can recall as I'm
- 36:26sitting here and maybe the bench officer who
- 36:29issued it may hear this this webinar someday
- 36:33was in the No, Lappi v. Superior Court, Lappi,
- 36:38L -A -P -P -E, is the case that was decided on
- 36:41a petition for it of mandate by me, by my side,
- 36:45that holds that declarations of disclosure are
- 36:49not done and exchanged for mediation. They're
- 36:52done because without them, you can't get divorced.
- 36:55So they're not privileged from disclosure and
- 36:58a subsequent action by the... Evidence code provision
- 37:03on mediation confidentiality. Evidence code 1119.
- 37:09Declarations of disclosure are necessary in order
- 37:11to get divorced full stop. And if you're moving
- 37:14post judgment or to set aside a judgment and
- 37:17you want to see the lies that were made in a
- 37:20prior declaration of disclosure and you asked
- 37:23for it in a request for discovery, you're entitled
- 37:27to get it. In that Lappy case, a judicial officer
- 37:31was on the bench, of course, but also on the
- 37:34fence as to whether I was right or I was wrong,
- 37:38and issued a 34 -page statement of decision that
- 37:41was both factual and legal that laid out this
- 37:46person's point of view that declarations of disclosure
- 37:50were actually barred by the Evidence code mediation
- 37:54confidentiality doctrine from disclosure And
- 37:57so when you're objecting when I objected to that
- 38:00statement of decision It took me I don't know
- 38:03the better part of a week or the better part
- 38:05of several days to get this done I don't mean
- 38:07a week, you know day in and day out, but it was
- 38:10it was tough. So a one -page Objection to propose
- 38:15statement of decision Judicial Council form is
- 38:19not likely to carry the day But it's a start.
- 38:25And let me see if I want to say anything else
- 38:27about the Statement of Decision Information sheet.
- 38:36It's got great questions. I mean, I don't know
- 38:38if this is what's going to ultimately be emblazoned
- 38:42in paper that we get to look at. But in addition
- 38:46to the questions that I asked, I mean, enunciated
- 38:49to you a few minutes ago, can the deadline be
- 38:52changed to ask for a statement of decision? What
- 38:56happens if the request isn't made on time? How
- 38:59can you ask for a statement of decision? What
- 39:01are examples of the kinds of questions that a
- 39:05party can list in a request for a statement of
- 39:07decision? And there are even examples here, like,
- 39:12for example, what is the basis for concluding
- 39:14that? Does blankety blank statute apply? If not,
- 39:17why not? Did petitioner establish by a preponderance
- 39:21of the evidence that? What are the court's reasons
- 39:25for granting or denying the child custody orders
- 39:28requested by petitioner? This is very helpful.
- 39:33Does the court find the respondent told the truth
- 39:35about searching for a job? If not, why not? You
- 39:39know, the more you get into this, the more a
- 39:41judge is going to bristle that you're asking
- 39:43for interrogatory type questions, but judges
- 39:47are smart people and they know that if you've
- 39:49asked for the really seminal and important issues
- 39:53in the case, they're going to give you what you
- 39:55want. Can a party request that issues be included
- 40:00in a statement of decision? after a different
- 40:03party has filed and served a request for one.
- 40:06The answer now prior to January 2027 and after
- 40:10is yes. Before the matter is submitted for decision,
- 40:14the other party can say, wait, wait, wait, my
- 40:17opponent, my honored person, my colleague, as
- 40:21we used to say in Boston, my sister at the bar,
- 40:23my brother at the bar didn't ask for blankety,
- 40:25blankety, blankety. I would like you to ask for
- 40:27that. Who prepares the statement of decision
- 40:31after one is requested? How much time does the
- 40:35party have to serve and file it? What happens
- 40:38if the party's ordered to draft one and doesn't
- 40:40prepare it on time? If I read these, you'll go
- 40:42to sleep, so I'm not going to continue to read
- 40:45it, but it's great stuff. Okay, so to this slide,
- 40:52the proposed rewrite to subdivision A and B say
- 40:56the following. Subdivision A specifies the request
- 41:00must be made under 632 and may be made on the
- 41:08proposed new form request for statement of decision.
- 41:12It has to follow the requirements of CCP 632,
- 41:17which is why I asked you to read it. Subdivision
- 41:21B lays out the timelines. 90 days for the court
- 41:25to prepare one, 30 days for a party to prepare
- 41:28a draft, with the court being able to change
- 41:30the time frames, clarifies the court has to serve
- 41:34a statement of decision after a party prepares
- 41:37a draft, since the time frames that we'll talk
- 41:41about in a minute start once for objections,
- 41:45happens once after the court serves the draft.
- 41:49And the clot... committee sought specific comments
- 41:55on whether the rule should include a time frame
- 41:57for the court to prepare a statement of decision
- 42:00as proposed in paragraph B1, and if so, whether
- 42:04it should instead apply to the court's issuance,
- 42:07regardless of whether the statement was initially
- 42:09prepared by the court or the draft, and people
- 42:12are talking about that right, left, and center
- 42:14now. The operative goal is to give the court
- 42:20a lot of flexibility, but not to be so flexible
- 42:24that we members of the bar don't know what we
- 42:29have to do and when we have to do it. Would you
- 42:31kindly go to the next slide? Subdivision C involves
- 42:38preparation of an accompanying judgment. The
- 42:41committee proposed an advisory committee that
- 42:44refers to rule 2 .900, which specifies when a
- 42:49cause is deemed submitted. Just go to CRC 2 .900
- 42:55and look at it. The comment is intended to assist
- 42:59courts and litigants interpreting the timeframes
- 43:01under 632. We will hopefully get 3 .1590C that
- 43:10talks about when the accompanying judgment specifically
- 43:13has to be written so long as it follows the language
- 43:17in 632. Subdivision D will cover objections to
- 43:21the statement of decision or proposed judgment
- 43:24and will address a new form for those objections,
- 43:28which I've just made reference to, but a one
- 43:31-page judicial counsel form does not It's not
- 43:36going to cover the field, so I'm not sure it's
- 43:38going to really make that much of a difference,
- 43:40except that it's a good place to start. Next
- 43:43slide, please. So under the proposed rewrite,
- 43:48subdivision E of the new rule, the court signs
- 43:51and files the judgment. Issue raised. Here's
- 43:54an issue. is prepared after the statement of
- 43:58decision becomes final and there are objections
- 44:01to the proposed judgment, which we know we do
- 44:03all the time. We are constantly making objections
- 44:07to the proposed judgment or filing them. The
- 44:10court may have very little time to consider and
- 44:12rule on those objections before the judgment
- 44:15has to be signed and filed so that So in light
- 44:22of that potentially short time frame, the committee
- 44:25was seeking specific comment on whether it would
- 44:27be helpful to include a 30 -day statutory time
- 44:31frame in the rule or note that the time frame
- 44:33is advisory and the court can do what it wants,
- 44:36et cetera. I think I'm getting a little bit into
- 44:39the weeds for which I apologize, but I'm excited
- 44:43and I guess... a little geeky about it because
- 44:47the old 3 .1590 was basically unfollowable if
- 44:52there's such a word and this hopefully ultimately
- 44:55when it's finally drafted will be much easier
- 44:58to follow. Next slide please. Subdivision F will
- 45:07include allowing the court to extend time frames
- 45:10for good cause permits shortening of timeframes
- 45:14in actions under the family code? Oops, God forbid.
- 45:17Okay, fine. I mean, I have often asked my trial
- 45:22court colleagues with whom I am consulting that
- 45:26to please go in ex parte or in shortened time
- 45:30to ask the court for additional time on statement
- 45:34of decision rules, because it can be very, very
- 45:37difficult to get this all done in a timely basis.
- 45:42Some judges allow post -trial statement of decision
- 45:45discussions to occur via email. I think that's
- 45:49becoming less and less an option and more and
- 45:52more verboten. But if you want more time, you
- 45:55can get it now under Subdivision M, in the future
- 45:59under Subdivision F, and it would really, really,
- 46:02really be a good idea to ask for more time if
- 46:06you need more time. There is a second rule, 3
- 46:15.1591, which is the rule that you have to follow
- 46:19if you're in a bifurcated hearing, which we talked
- 46:23about a little while ago. When you're in a bifurcated
- 46:27hearing and you go right to 15 .91 as it exists
- 46:32now and as it will exist in the future to ask
- 46:35the court for statement of decision pursuant
- 46:37to it rather than to 3 .1590 or perhaps cite
- 46:41both rules of court, the new 3 .1591 is going
- 46:46to specify how the procedure will apply. I'm
- 46:51sorry, let me say that over again. How the rules
- 46:54in 3 .1590 will apply in a bifurcated proceeding
- 46:58and the committee believes guides is still needed
- 47:01because we need to make very or they need to
- 47:05make very clear that any rule that gets written
- 47:09or rewritten is in strict compliance with CCP
- 47:15632 and of course for judgments 664. Next slide.
- 47:23Up there is no next slide. And I'm 10 minutes
- 47:25early, which I was told not to do. So I was asked
- 47:29to give any kind of, there's some questions and
- 47:35answers here. So what is the, I mean, this is
- 47:39interesting. So what is the authority to ask
- 47:41for a statement of decision in domestic violence?
- 47:45I would say that there isn't a specific rule.
- 47:49I'm not sure as I sit here that there is a case
- 47:52that says that. However, if you look at some
- 47:56domestic violence restraining order appellate
- 47:59decisions, you'll see the word statement of decision
- 48:02in there somewhere. The authority to ask for
- 48:06a statement of decision in domestic violence
- 48:08hearings is that it is an evidentiary hearing
- 48:12on an issue of fact. and it most of the time
- 48:16will deal with custody issues which will implicate
- 48:20the mandatory right under Rose and the statute
- 48:23that I cited to get a statement of decision where
- 48:27custody issues are being ruled upon or are an
- 48:31issue. And even if you don't have a custody issue
- 48:33yet, because you don't have a presumption against
- 48:37joint custody because of a finding of a domestic
- 48:40violence action, you have an evidentiary hearing
- 48:44on an issue of fact that is important to both
- 48:49parties and will guide the rights of both parties
- 48:53in futuro not only for three years but potentially
- 48:56five years and it should behoove the court to
- 48:59issue a statement of decision on this important
- 49:02matter as it does for matters that are far less
- 49:05important than how people are restrained or kicked
- 49:08out of their homes or deal with their custody
- 49:10matters. I'm going to answer the third question
- 49:15first because I don't know the answer to that.
- 49:19Do SLAP motions do or don't require? I don't
- 49:22know the answer to that. I would be guessing
- 49:25that they don't because they're motions, they're
- 49:28not evidentiary hearings. I don't do SLAP motions,
- 49:33and so I'm not the best person to answer that
- 49:35question. And so ask somebody else. I mean, ask
- 49:38somebody who does SLAP motions. Okay, the next
- 49:41question is, the judge gives his or her tentative
- 49:47ruling. The loser asks for a statement of decision.
- 49:53The judge asks the winner to draft the statement
- 49:55of decision. How do you get the judge to not
- 49:59sign the winner's draft? Is the loser's only
- 50:03hope that the winner doesn't do a good job in
- 50:06drafting the statement of decision? No. What's
- 50:10important is to object. The loser, excuse me,
- 50:16the winner has been asked to draft a statement
- 50:18of decision and you get statutory CRC 3 .1590
- 50:24time to object and you should take that very
- 50:28seriously and perhaps follow the roadmap that
- 50:31I gave you which is to take out all of the the
- 50:35transcripts and all of the exhibits and any declarations
- 50:40or other pleadings that were admitted into evidence
- 50:43and show the judge where what the winner has
- 50:46said was incorrect. Now the winner is not likely
- 50:50to make an error or may not make an error as
- 50:53to the evidence and sure you've got a problem
- 50:57here because you can't ask the judge simply to
- 51:00change her or his mind. You can't say, well,
- 51:03I want to be the winner now. I don't want to
- 51:05be the loser. But if there is a genuine issue
- 51:08of law that the judge got wrong, the judge misinterpreted
- 51:14la musée, didn't follow the la musée factors,
- 51:19or didn't apply them in a way that is appropriate
- 51:24under the cases interpreting la musée, then it's
- 51:30incumbent upon you to point that out. It's important
- 51:34because, among other reasons, a standard of review
- 51:38based on the judge getting the law wrong is a
- 51:42much easier case to win on appeal, of course,
- 51:45because you get a de novo standard of review
- 51:48because the courts of appeal think the trial
- 51:51judges are in a better position to evaluate whether
- 51:54someone was lying or telling the truth. Credibility
- 51:57of the witness is not the purview of the court
- 52:00of appeal, but deciding what the law is. is the
- 52:05purview of the Court of Appeal. And the Court
- 52:07of Appeal wants to give guidance to all eight
- 52:12divisions of the second appellate district and
- 52:15maybe even all appellate districts in the state
- 52:18of California. Although, and I'm talking in other
- 52:22areas that aren't the subject of this, but other
- 52:26appellate districts do not have to follow the
- 52:30second appellate district. district is meant
- 52:34to follow its own cases and decisions, but other
- 52:38districts don't have to. Although that is a very
- 52:41complex issue and I may have oversimplified it
- 52:44and it might be the subject for a whole different,
- 52:49any other questions because we have time and
- 52:53I don't want to cheat you out of any of the time
- 52:56that you're entitled to. Anybody have anything
- 52:59they want to say? Let's see, I'm actually checking
- 53:06the help desk right now. Let's see. I tried to
- 53:13be as slow as possible. There's just so much
- 53:17you could say about 3 .1590. And Susie said to
- 53:21me, do you have any stories to tell about statements
- 53:26of decision? I told one story about the LAPI
- 53:28statement of decision. I helped a law firm a
- 53:34couple of years ago in a case that involved five
- 53:37trials, one client, five trials, five statements
- 53:43of decision, five judgments, hundreds of thousands
- 53:47of pages of transcripts, and the statement of
- 53:51decision process in that case took a whole lot
- 53:56of time and effort. So the goal of these new
- 54:00rules, both the statute and the California rule
- 54:04of court is to make it less expensive and less
- 54:08onerous for people to get this done, which as
- 54:10I said, I don't think will end up causing me
- 54:14to lose a job or be out of work, but I think
- 54:18it will help. A big problem, which wasn't asked
- 54:22of me, but I'm going to sort of talk about it
- 54:24anyway, is AI. So we all get comments from our
- 54:33clients that are AI generated. They are all not
- 54:37to be relied upon naturally. We don't. The courts
- 54:40of appeal are not allowed to do generative AI.
- 54:44I am not allowed in my appellate practice to
- 54:47do generative AI. That is not to say, however,
- 54:50that AI would not be helpful in taking a 10 -day
- 54:54set of transcripts and putting the transcripts
- 54:58into your into your file and using Copilot, asking
- 55:03Copilot to summarize all 10 days of the transcripts
- 55:08because that will ultimately end up helping you
- 55:11and your appellate lawyer in understanding at
- 55:14least what went on. I would never, ever say to
- 55:18AI, Not yet, anyway, and probably never. My managing
- 55:23partners listening to this, I'll get my head
- 55:25handed to me. But maybe in the future, I might
- 55:28ask AI to draft a statement of decision, but
- 55:31I doubt it. I think the most I would ask AI to
- 55:35do is organize the exhibits, the testimony, and
- 55:39summarize the evidence. on X or Y subject for
- 55:44me so that I can get into the statement of decision
- 55:48and draft it. It would be helpful and objective
- 55:52to a statement of decision to take your opponent's
- 55:56statement of decision draft that's been filed
- 55:58up at the court, stick it into your computer
- 56:01and... Stick the transcripts in simultaneously
- 56:05and ask copilot if and only if you have one of
- 56:08those safe Copilot versions that don't go into
- 56:11the cloud to please tell you where the proposed
- 56:17statement of decision made a mistake based upon
- 56:20all of the evidence in the transcript that you've
- 56:23loaded in I mean, I think I Think AI will end
- 56:27up helping us, but it's certainly not going to
- 56:29do away with us, although in one American Academy
- 56:35of Matrimonial Lawyers webinar, somebody said
- 56:39AI is not going to do away with your job, but
- 56:42it won't replace you. But if you don't add a
- 56:48do AI, I can't remember now how clever it was.
- 56:52AI will not do away with your job. Something
- 56:55like it'll do away with your work. I don't remember.
- 56:58I'm not being making much sense here. This is
- 57:00not a good way to end Again, I mean I just want
- 57:03to say I'm willing to help This a I want to sort
- 57:08of go back to AI for a second. It's it's a really
- 57:11interesting issue. I mean I get AI emails from
- 57:16people, prospective clients all the time now,
- 57:19telling me why their appeal is great and they've
- 57:22put the issue through AI and AI is telling them
- 57:26A, B, and C. Very dangerous to rely on it. Our
- 57:29law firm is telling each of us each and every
- 57:33published decision that's come down about people
- 57:36who are sanctioned, not only for hallucinating
- 57:39about cases that don't exist, but also more importantly
- 57:42or as importantly for incorrectly citing cases.
- 57:48So it's just something to be mindful and careful
- 57:52of in the future. And I think I really am done
- 57:55unless Susie wants me to answer any more questions.
- 58:00Is there anything else? It does look like we
- 58:03do have a few questions left in the Q &A, some
- 58:06new ones, if you'd like to take the time to answer.
- 58:08Sure, I'm happy to. Where are they? So it looks
- 58:12like there's what happens when judges refuse
- 58:17to rule on objections to statement of decisions.
- 58:24That's a good question. I mean, they have to.
- 58:27They are meant to. You can't not do it. I have
- 58:32asked my trial lawyers to go call the department,
- 58:37politely to ask. I'm trying to remember if I've
- 58:42ever asked or if I had the trial or a file something
- 58:46that says request for hearing on objection statement
- 58:51of decision. By the way, that is something that
- 58:54we didn't discuss today. always ask for hearing
- 58:58on objections to the statement of decision because
- 59:00it's my historical belief in life that looking
- 59:04somebody in the eye and explaining something
- 59:07openly and honestly to a bench officer makes
- 59:12a lot more sense than having that person read
- 59:15the four millionth piece of paper that's come
- 59:17across his or her desk that day. Judges do not
- 59:21have to give. hearings on objections is a statement
- 59:24of decision. They may do it in long -cause trials
- 59:27where they too find oral argument a little bit
- 59:31more helpful than just kind of reading 25, 35,
- 59:3545 pages of an objection. But I think the shortest
- 59:39answer to what happens if they don't rule on
- 59:42objections is to have both sides call the court,
- 59:48call the department and ask. Assuming party properly
- 59:55requests a credibility finding, but the court
- 59:58fails to make a credibility finding. I don't
- 1:00:01know the answer to whether it's reversible error
- 1:00:03without knowing what's in the case. What was
- 1:00:08the evidence? What did the parties talk about?
- 1:00:14No, probably not. Reversible error usually means
- 1:00:19It's such plain error that the party didn't get
- 1:00:22a fair trial. And I'm not sure that failing to
- 1:00:26make a credibility finding when one is merely
- 1:00:28requested is a plain error. It is the court's
- 1:00:34purview to find somebody truthful or not truthful.
- 1:00:37And they do that not only by saying, in the record,
- 1:00:40I find you more credible than the other side.
- 1:00:43They do it by the way they rule. They do it by
- 1:00:45how they rule. what they say in their ultimate
- 1:00:49decision. Anything else Suzy? It looks like we
- 1:00:57have we have one more question. The other two
- 1:01:01are comments but towards the bottom we have for
- 1:01:03a motion are there strategic considerations with
- 1:01:06making a request for a statement of decision
- 1:01:08with the notice of motion or later but before
- 1:01:11the hearing or ruling? I wouldn't do it with
- 1:01:15emotion. The courts get annoyed by what they
- 1:01:17think is boilerplate. Doing it in your petition
- 1:01:20for dissolution or your response to the petition
- 1:01:25for dissolution is really almost meaningless
- 1:01:29because it isn't helpful. It's not doing anything.
- 1:01:33I would do it if you have a full -on evidentiary
- 1:01:36hearing on an issue of custody or DV of such
- 1:01:41importance that you believe that justice will
- 1:01:45be served by having the court give better, clearer
- 1:01:50indications of how it's ruling and why it's ruling.
- 1:01:53I would do it before the submission of the motion
- 1:01:58to the court. By the way, this issue about what's
- 1:02:02the authority for DV statements of decision is
- 1:02:06the subject of some banter between me and one
- 1:02:09of my colleagues in the Complex Appellate Litigation
- 1:02:12Group. And that means that there isn't a 100
- 1:02:15% clear answer. But stay tuned. I think there
- 1:02:18will be in the near term. And if I learn anything
- 1:02:22that tells me differently, I'll try to remember
- 1:02:25who asked the question and post a response to
- 1:02:27that person. OK. Thank you so much for listening
- 1:02:32to me, especially when I made mistakes. I greatly
- 1:02:36appreciate it, and I'm grateful to be here. Alrighty,
- 1:02:40this concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 1:02:42so much, Claudia, for your time and an excellent
- 1:02:45presentation today, and thank you so much to
- 1:02:47our audience for joining us. Have a great day,
- 1:02:49everybody.