Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 09/01/26 EPISODE 020: UNCATALOGUED: BANGER OR BUM? - DREAM SPIRITS 18 YEAR BARREL #903
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Yeah. All right, folks, welcome back into the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. We are back with another uncataloged banger or bum. ⁓ if you've ⁓ this is your first time joining, one of us brings a bottle, put it under a bag, we pour it blind, the rest of us get a guess at it. We all talk about it, do we like it? Is it a banger? Is it a bum? Is it just a you know, an average bottle? I think a lot of bottles can be average bottles. ⁓ but Want to welcome back John. He's with us again here. ⁓ got John Carlo, Barsh in the room. Hey. Welcome, fellas. Sir. ⁓ I brought this bottle, and for me, I'm not going to tell you any statistics about it. Nice. I will tell you, I have never tried this bottle. This is a new bourbon to me as well. Wow. ⁓ and so I I'm I'm You just know what it is. I know what it is. I don't know if it's any good or not, though. We're about to find out. So Dive in, see give it just let her fly. Let us know what you think about it. I like the color. Great color. Yeah. Yeah, that is a little amber color. That is copper, amber. That's dark. ⁓ yeah. Eggs. Definitely has definitely got a little vi nice viscosity to it. I like that. I like the color. I like the thickness. I'm trying to discern the aroma. I'm smelling things and I'm not able to put words to it just yet. If that makes any sense. Sure. But normally you're like, ⁓ I smell caramel, I smell this, I smell that. Yeah. minute up. Maybe it's just me. I'm getting fruit off there. I just can't tell what kind of fruit you Yeah, exactly. To me it's darker. Yeah. Like darker fruit notes. Like sometimes you get like a peach or apricot or something like that. To me this is more cherry. Darker cherries or blackberry or something like that. Yeah, I agree. I agree. Yeah. Black like a black cherry or even even like a ⁓ fig or something like that. Fruit leather. Fruit leather. Fruit leather, raisin, like a dehydrated like that. ⁓ that actually explains a lot. Power of suggestion. Power of suggestion, right? Absolutely. And that's why I'm I'm just stuck at first going, I don't know what it is that I'm smelling. But as you guys start talking about darker fruits, I'm like, yeah, there's black cherry, raspberry, maybe vanilla. Getting the vanilla now. To me, it's a darker, like a like a almost like an aged vanilla, barrel aged vanilla or something like that. You know? It's not that bright, bright extract vanilla sweetness. No, this is not French vanilla or some light vanilla that you put in your ice cream. This is much darker, deeper. Yeah. And lastly for me, I get a little bit like ⁓ actual leather leather. Not fruit leather, but like like a leather shoe, leather belt. Well, I cheated, I took I took a sip already and I'm kind of amazed at the legs dripping down the glass on the inside. Yeah, no, that it is viscous. It is very viscous. It did not have a a deep dark well, you go ahead and take a sip and you tell me what you smell and taste. ⁓ It smells good and it tastes even better. Right. I like it. Nice and warm. There's a warmth. There's yep. Mm-hmm. Is that is there like a little bit of a little baking spice, maybe? Yep. Definitely ⁓ that's good. Well, that's good. It just coats. It's super viscous. Tongue. Yeah. In such a nice way. We've all had those bourbons where you get that kind of aftertaste and you sometimes you don't like the aftertaste. This ⁓ I like this. This kind of coated and the taste for me just kinda stayed there. Yeah. It lingers. It didn't change right away. And then when it did, it was great. It lingers in all the right ways. It's really good finish. Yeah, I I would I'm gonna say it was had some proof to it, a little warmth. Definitely a Kentucky hug going down. Sure. But not a like a burn right very very s like a very velvety texture as you swallow it. That's right. A friendly hug. Yeah, friendly honey. From a from a close neighbor. I already took my second little sip, and I want you guys do the same because it's d to me it was different. I don't know why, but that second taste was a little different. I actually liked it even better. ⁓ man. But it tasted very differently on the second sip. I think you warmed the palate up and then your pal then you were ready to do what you were gonna taste. I definitely warmed up. I'm getting the cherry. Dare I say the cherry vanilla? You can say cherry vanilla. That leads me to me almost got a little bit of nuttiness on this too. Like on the front of the palette. Yeah. Like ⁓ not peanut, but like I don't know, like walnut or something like that. What are those bright red cherries that you put on ice cream? Because that's that's not the cherry we're talking about here. We're not talking about this is much darker red cherry like I would put in a Luxardo cherry. The high end. Yeah. This is with a little bit of that syrup. Get a spoonful of that syrup and dump it in too. But as if somebody added some vanilla to that syrup. Ooh. There's for sure vanilla. Yeah. ⁓ yeah. It's kind of and I the more I taste it, the more I taste the vanilla. It's strong for me. Yeah. The vanilla. The cherry vanilla is strong. I see where you now that I if I like really focus and think the cherry vanilla, I'm getting that yeah, I'm hearing that as well. Mm-hmm. I'm tasting that as well. Old to me. It's giving all the old old notes. You think this is a dusty bottle? No, not that old. I'm thinking this is That is aged. So we should should we start with some age guesses? Sure. Where you you think it's old? How much what what age do you think this bottle's coming in at? Do you want me to give you one age or you want to give you a range? I mean, since there's four of us, I'm not gonna guess at it, I know. But you got you three guess at it. Just pick it and I got a I a number that I'm gonna go with. Go ahead. Eighteen. Eighteen, huh? Eighteen years? Okay. Any reason? No. Just a guess. Just tastes old and yummy. Tastes old and yummy. Yeah. No. What do you think, Giancarlo? A lot of say a lot of stuff we have is twelve thirteen all the time. This just to me I'm probably wrong, but I think it's a little bit older. Okay. Fair. I'll split the difference. I was gonna go with fifteen. I was gonna say twelve to fifteen, but I'll s I'll pick fifteen. Fifteen? Okay. Nice. Proof wise. Proof. Where are we thinking at this thing's coming in on proof point? Not too bad. I'm betting it's higher than we think. It may drink below its proof. That's yeah, thank you for put it that way. That's that's what I was thinking. Let's drink below its proof. So what do you think it let's do that? What do you think it drinks like versus what do you think the actual proof is? I think it drinks right around a hundred and it's just over. Okay. Really? Like one ⁓ two, one ⁓ four. I'm thinking one seventeen. One seventeen? Yeah. Okay. That it drinks like or that it is? That it is. I'm thinking it drinks probably like one ⁓ seven. Okay. Yeah, I was gonna say I I wouldn't be surprised if this was a hundred and twenty. Okay. But it drinks more like one ⁓ five to one ten. Okay. Okay. Big big big age there, I They gap on all three. I went older. I went harder and I went Sean Carlos like Unveil it, I want another pore. The cup runneth dry. All right, so we got we got age, we got a proof guess. ⁓ my wife and I like doing this, guessing at how much this bottle sells for. Well if we if we do the formula, right. I'm saying it's about a hundred thirteen years. I'm guessing one fifty to two. One fifty to two hundred. Okay. Are we talking MSRP, retail? What so listen Are we talking Michigan pricing? What are we talking about? 'Cause prices here are different places. Yeah, yeah. So MS we did an MSRP. And if you have a guess at a secondary price, like you can guess at that too. I'm gonna go with one sixty nine ninety nine. So a hundred and seventy bucks on the MSRP for bars. I think this could be a two hundred dollar bottle. Two hundred dollars. Well it could be. Yeah. Okay. It tastes like it could be. Which would be commensurate with my 15-year HD gas. All right. Fair enough. Well, ⁓ before I unveil it, I'll just give you some statistics. Please do. ⁓ you are way off on the price of this bottle. Okay. Ooh. This is a $430 bottle. Whoa. Bars, you're on the nose. 18 year old. ⁓ All right. And you're closest on the proof. I think it's like 122. Okay. So we are drinking. ⁓ Dream. Dream Spirits are off. Eighteen year old Barton juice. Wow. From Pre liquor it was a pre liquor preet liquor's pick in in New York City there. Nice. ⁓ but yeah, Dream Spirits is Professor Off's brand. ⁓ Bardstown, Kentucky, distilled in. Eighteen year what? That's good looking stuff. Exceptional bottle. I was I haven't tried it. I wanted to get it open. So You just did. I no, no. I did well I up until now I hadn't opened it. ⁓ but wanted to get it open because I wanted to put it in some blinds with some other eighteen year old Barton juice that I've got to see kind of on a future episode. Like what's the king of it, right? That's exceptional. It is exceptional. I think I enjoyed it. We never said banger or bum. No. I think we all said it was a banger. It's a banger. ⁓ off before it was a percent. I forgot to completely ⁓ complete that ⁓ episode there. So saying it's a banger, I've got a couple details about it, which are kind of interesting. So ⁓ Dream Spirits, this is an 18-year-old. It is specifically for those that want to know, barrel number nine ⁓ three, a highly coveted age-dated single barrel bourbon. ⁓ to understand this bottle, you have to understand the brand Dream Spirits. It's an independent bottler operated by Prov Sorof. Based out of Washington, DC, they do not distill their own whiskey. Instead, they hunt down exceptional single barrels from major distilleries, bottle them at cask strength, and release them as exclusive store or private group picks. So breakdown on this specific bottle or barrel number nine ⁓ three. ⁓ it is at age stated at 18 years, believed to be a Barton run, closer to 19 years of age, actually. Okay. ⁓ And it was specifically picked by ⁓ a group for pre preet liquors. ⁓ and it is bottled at 122 point four proof. Wow. straight bourbon whiskey, cast strength out of Barton Distillery, 1792, mash bill of seventy four percent corn, eighteen percent rye, eight percent malted barley, and original market value four hundred plus due to the extreme age and and rarity. So in the whiskey community, an eighteen age eighteen year age statement on a single barrel bourbon is incredibly rare. Most of Dream Spirit's eighteen year old releases, including this nine ⁓ three, are sibl sibling and its sibling barrels like nine ⁓ one and nine ten come from a highly celebrated lot of barrels distilled at the historic Barton 1792 facility. Because the bourbon interacts aggressively with the charred new American oak, letting it sit for eighteen years carries a massive risk of the whiskey becoming overly bitter or over oaked. However, this specific run of Barton barrels is highly praised for maintaining rich, thick viscous thick viscosity without turning astringent. In blind tastings among enthusiasts like the degenerate wolf pack, these dream spirits, 18-year-old barrels consistently outperform famous ultra aged benchmark bottles like Calumet 18, which is one of the ones that I've got that I want to compare it against as well. Right. So they're saying on the the the the nose of this thing. Is it's a flavor bomb? So on the nose, deep, funky rickhouse oak, dark heavy, dark cherry, great collithelas, worn leather, rich molasses. You get a distinct scent of old library books and pipe tobacco. There we go. Pipe tobacco. That's what we're smelling. Yes. Old library books. Yeah, the pipe tobacco. Go back and smell it and you smell the pipe tobacco. For sure. Power of suggestion. You've heard it? Yeah. It's there. On the palate, it's viscous and full bodied, initial waves of warm baking spices. John, you called that out. Cinnamon and clove transition into dense caramel, vanilla bean, burnt sugar, and bitter coca cocoa. The eighteen percent rye in the mash bill provides a sharp pop of on the front and mid palate of black pepper. The finish is exceptionally long. The heat lingers warmly alongside the dark fruit skins, sweet chocolate, and powerful waves of deeply toasted oak. Wow. That's a special bottle. So yeah, if you can get yourself one, I ⁓ prelickers.com. That's where I found it and ordered it up. Nice. Had it shipped out here. ⁓ so Dream Spirits. Yeah. ⁓ if you want us to do a pick for you, please reach out. No, we just need to reach out to them. If we want to do a pick with them, we'd love to do a pick with them. We can set it up. They have a a a campus. If you go to do a barrel pick, they got warehouses with all their barrels in it. Yeah. Just shit everywhere. They've got a a house that we you can stay at and bed like a bed and breakfast type setup. I've heard it's amazing. They do a whole like I mean event out of it. So they want it to be a completely different barrel picking experience for the people. So ⁓ that might be something we have to kind of arrange down the road. I just want to pick up on something you said before because this is like what I call Jack Daniels in a charred barrel, right? And they're There's concerns over it going past eighteen I never heard this before, so I'm asking there's concerns of it going beyond eighteen years and spoiling because I thought there were some that had barrels that have been sitting around for like fifty years that make really good whiskey. Yeah, so with American bourbons. So they're because they're going into brand new chart oak versus a scotch or an Irish whiskey that can go into a used barrel and a lot of those tannins have already been pulled out sucked out of it. with a bourbon, get letting it get you know, eighteen, even fourteen years and up, it's a question mark if it's gonna start turning a little astringent on you. Yeah. ⁓ it really depends. A lot of a lot of even Jack Daniels now on their their higher age, like fourteen years, they're moving those to like the basement to try to slow that that the aging process. Without giving it away, I'll just say it's a Taylor Sheridan thing that I was ⁓ looking into and and they were talking about how these barrel again it's made up, it's Taylor Sheridan TV stuff. Right. They had taken it out of the original barrel, put it in a second barrel, and it's now fifty years old and highly valuable. Right. And I was just like, okay, I gotta understand. And when you brought that up with the chore and this going bad, I wanted to try and wrap my head around that 'cause I would have assumed Taylor Sheridan's crew would have done some sort of research on something. Yeah. But it's T V. They put phony stuff out all the time. Yeah, yeah. I think it it really just depends on the liquid that's going into it, right? And the history of it and where you're aging it too. Mm hmm. Right. Right. You know, if you're up in colder climate like Ireland, Scotland, they can let barrels go for sixty years. Okay. Also they're using not brand new barrels. Right. Right. So because bourbon has to use brand new barrels to be a bourbon. ⁓ you get a lot of that oak at a much younger age than some of Irish. Absolutely. You can't overdo it. And that's why, you know, you look at like the Garrison Brothers down in Texas or Detling down in Alabama. Yeah, just the the environments in which those bourbons mature is much, much different than in the northern climates, even Kentucky. So, you know, people say, ⁓ four year, five year age statement on a Garrison Brothers, that can't be good. It absolutely can be delicious. And it is. They taste like they're fifteen years old. They can taste like they are ten, twelve, fifteen plus years. Yeah, that heat that heats pulls all the flavor out of those banks for sure. It's real. I I would So we could do six months around here. Probably. You could do a six two year bourbon here might taste like an eight year bourbon in Kentucky. I don't know how much distilling they're doing and aging here in Arizona, but we could try and find out. Probably not too much. That's right. That's right. ⁓ no, I appreciate you guys coming over. Banger Bum. We found another banger. So if you're interested in getting a bottle of these Dream Spirits now, they do because they're sourcing barrels. Right. I've got a a a Dream Spirits that's a that's a ten year old Booker's. We've got one that's like a well, this one and then I've got another one that's like a nine year in MGP. So it really just depends. Like they've got all kinds of barrels you can go pick from it. ⁓ Yeah, I've got a wild turkey version, I've got a Heaven Hill version that I just picked up 'cause was just at his store, ⁓ not Preet's, but at Prov store on ⁓ P Street about a month ago. ⁓ down DC? Yeah, down DC. That's the trip I'm I need to make and that's a special stop. Let me tell you his store is ⁓ close to your house in terms of his you know collection of whiskeys because DC, unlike most other places in the country, they can buy from ⁓ private collections. So the liquor stores can buy private bottles from private collections and then sell them to the public. Awesome. Yeah wow. Interesting I got some work out there. I'm gonna try to stop by there on one of these next trips. So yeah, you'll be richly rewarded if you do. We'll see. Maybe leave my credit card at home. Yeah. Cash over my way. Thank you all for joining. We'll see you very soon for another episode on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. Cheers. Cheers. Cheers. Cheers.