Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E077: The Institutional Case for Bitcoin with Daniel Batten & Samuel Roberts
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK.
- 0:27I say when we sell. All right, everyone, welcome
- 0:34back to the last trade. This week we have my Co host
- 0:37Michael Tanguma and Brian Cabela's and we're joined by Sam
- 0:41Roberts and Daniel Batten. Gentlemen, nice to see you all.
- 0:45How are you all doing today, Sam?
- 0:46Daniel, thanks for joining us. And welcome.
- 0:50Doing great. Good to be here.
- 0:53Excellent. Well, Daniel, Sam, how about the
- 0:56best place for us to start would just be to get the audience a
- 0:58little bit more familiar with both of your backgrounds.
- 1:01Sam, you have been on the show before, but it has been some
- 1:04time and and Daniel, this is a first time appearance for you.
- 1:07So Daniel, why don't I hand it over to you if you just want to
- 1:10share more about your background, what you're focusing
- 1:13on these days and and how you got into Bitcoin, and then Sam
- 1:16will let you do the same. I've been focusing mainly on the
- 1:21overlap between Bitcoin and ESG. So it's environmental and social
- 1:26benefits, ES benefits for the last two years.
- 1:30How I got into that was I was running a impact investment fund
- 1:34and then a climate tech investment fund, and the
- 1:38opportunity to look at Bitcoin came across my desk and I
- 1:42initially didn't think the person was serious, but I had a
- 1:44second look at it and end up doing due diligence.
- 1:46And that led to me to realize that she had some really
- 1:49positive ESG attributes and that's led to the work I do
- 1:52today. I came at it from a very
- 1:58different direction. So I came at it from a very much
- 2:01an institutional investment point of view, although I was
- 2:07first learning about Bitcoin some years before that on a
- 2:11personal level, because I just found it interesting.
- 2:14What is this strange Internet money?
- 2:16How does it work? And then it was about 2 1/2
- 2:20years ago that with the confiscation of or freezing of
- 2:25Russia's assets, realised that actually that's a bit of an
- 2:29inflection point. And therefore institutions need
- 2:32to be more aware of Bitcoin and also potentially investing.
- 2:38And we'll get into some of this detail, I'm sure as we go.
- 2:41But it was, it's all very well saying the institutions should
- 2:46think more about buying Bitcoin, but how do they do it in
- 2:49practice? So that's, that's very much,
- 2:52yeah. That institutional side was
- 2:54where we came from. Excellent.
- 2:58Well, appreciate both of the backgrounds.
- 2:59And to your point, we certainly will be getting more in the
- 3:03weeds there. And maybe before we do, I'd be
- 3:05curious to hear from either Sam or you, Daniel, just how maybe
- 3:11how is your personal thinking evolved on Bitcoin since you
- 3:14first came across it and where you are today.
- 3:16I'm sure that will really shape the discussion around your
- 3:19professional work. But maybe what's most exciting
- 3:22to you today and how are things change for the two of you over
- 3:24the past couple years? When I first encountered
- 3:28Bitcoin, I honestly wasn't that interested in it.
- 3:31I didn't see how it solved any particular problems.
- 3:34I couldn't see its use or value and I think that's an affliction
- 3:39that a lot of people have coming from the West.
- 3:41When we have what looks like good banking rails, we don't
- 3:44tend to get de platformed. Although as Sam mentioned
- 3:48recently, what happened with the freezing of Russia assets?
- 3:51Now you can, but at the time that wasn't really a
- 3:53consideration to me. That freezing of Russian assets
- 3:56did open my mind considerably, but the more I researched it,
- 4:00the more I realized that Bitcoin solves some fairly fundamental
- 4:04problems in terms of freedom from hyperinflation, freedom
- 4:10from the ability for third parties to be able to freeze
- 4:15asset transactions, and freedom to be able to live in a country
- 4:20which may not have a set of rulers who play nice.
- 4:26In other words, if you say the wrong thing, do the wrong thing,
- 4:29the financial system can be weaponized against you.
- 4:31So I started to see how both in the West but also in the global
- 4:36S, how Bitcoin provided a form of freedom money that was
- 4:40extremely interesting to me. And then at the same time,
- 4:44Bitcoin mining, the more I researched, I could see that it
- 4:47solved a lot of energy problems as well, and particularly energy
- 4:51transition problems and grid stabilization problems.
- 4:55So I became fascinated both in Bitcoin mining first and then
- 4:59literally Bitcoin itself as an asset.
- 5:05Oh, this, this is great because we're coming at this from
- 5:07completely from directions. So I think it's very
- 5:09complementary. So my background was more coming
- 5:14through sort of learning about Austrian economics following the
- 5:19global financial crisis, which led me to gold and the benefits
- 5:24of the sound money on, well, actually the environment, but
- 5:29society generally. And that's what that's what I
- 5:32came through. And then when I first found
- 5:35Bitcoin, it was like, well, yeah, but it probably won't,
- 5:38won't survive or won't, won't work as well as it's intended.
- 5:43And so for me, the journey was, with some ebbing and flowing
- 5:47along the way, was to realise that Bitcoin is here to stay and
- 5:56to succeed, all it needs to do is to survive because everything
- 6:02else will then follow in its wake.
- 6:05So that was, yeah. So that's that's where it came
- 6:10from. Are you ready to secure your
- 6:12future with Bitcoin? At Onramp, we're revolutionizing
- 6:15how you can save for retirement. Onramp has just launched the
- 6:18industry's first Bitcoin IRA product with multi institution
- 6:21custody, designed to give you unparalleled security,
- 6:24transparency and Peace of Mind. With Onramp, you can verify your
- 6:28assets on chain and protect them with the support of three
- 6:31independent institutions, reducing risks and enhancing
- 6:34security. At Onramp, we believe that
- 6:37Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 6:40The hard part is securing it right.
- 6:42There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 6:44exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 6:47arrangement. Onramp solves for these
- 6:49concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 6:52solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 6:55ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 6:58possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 7:01your family is protected as well.
- 7:03On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 7:06whether for your whole stack or for part of it, as a complement
- 7:09to your existing self custody setup.
- 7:11For more information about our services as well as our new
- 7:14Bitcoin IRA product. Check.
- 7:16Us out at on rampbitcoin.com. You bring up a good point, Sam,
- 7:19in that I think a lot of the reason and rationale why, you
- 7:25know, a lot of institutional allocators and even some high
- 7:27net worth, but just generally large pools of capital have have
- 7:31remained on the sidelines is because there is this element of
- 7:34Bitcoin. And, and you know, this has been
- 7:37said before, but it feels good too, too good to be true, right?
- 7:39When you first hear this, you know, digital sound money, hard
- 7:43capped, similar to gold, but improves upon gold in all these
- 7:46ways, there is this general sort of gut reaction to like that
- 7:50that can't be there. There's no way that this is
- 7:52going to work. So I'm curious, like when you
- 7:55had that first initial response, what were the next steps you
- 7:58needed to take to effectively, you know, codify and form a real
- 8:03thesis around the robustness of the network, why it will persist
- 8:08And just getting your arms around, you know, it, while it
- 8:11may seem too good to be true on the surface, there's all these
- 8:14fundamental dynamics which actually allow it to be, you
- 8:18know, this, this ultimate sort of network of trust in the sense
- 8:22that you don't have to trust any other entities that are using
- 8:25it, but you can trust that it's, it's sound and it's transparent.
- 8:29And we know the monetary policy that that is always a journey
- 8:33for everyone. But I'm curious what specific
- 8:35steps you took as an allocator to say OK, I, I I need to know
- 8:39more about this. I need to test me on conviction
- 8:41here and get up to speed. Well, the main thing was time,
- 8:47actually just spending time on it.
- 8:49And when there's, you know, a million things to do, it's
- 8:53difficult to know what to spend time on.
- 8:55And then at some point I realized, oh, I need to spend
- 8:59some time on this or, you know, got naturally drawn in.
- 9:02And then you find one thing and then another thing and then at
- 9:05least you another thing and you learn more and more.
- 9:08And I don't think this is a unique journey by any means, but
- 9:12you still get dragged in and suddenly find yourself, you
- 9:17know, however many hundreds of hours deep and realise that
- 9:21there is something to this. So I think that's what we see
- 9:27quite often in in my industry is where people just simply haven't
- 9:30spent the time to understand it. And if they did, then I think
- 9:36they'd be having similar thoughts, at least some of them.
- 9:41And it was probably, there's probably a couple of other
- 9:45things which which helped, which were probably, I mean, it's
- 9:49probably about three, 3 1/2 years ago now for me in my
- 9:53journey. And it was understanding in more
- 9:58detail why gold has failed us as a sound money and also
- 10:05understanding why cryptocurrencies generally are
- 10:09not some money and not the army. They're not money really, but
- 10:14they're why they're not the answer to these.
- 10:17And that. Then that then pulls in things
- 10:21like the benefits of using lots of energy to maintain the
- 10:25network, the benefits of proof of work, along with lots of
- 10:28other things, the benefits of it being permissionless.
- 10:33So both those things, when we think about them in the
- 10:35environmental and the social context, sort of I think get to
- 10:41the nub of why they're so useful.
- 10:42And then you start thinking of what it could be used in this
- 10:45area or that area or for this to help this problem or that
- 10:48problem. And and then you can get carried
- 10:51away and end up with a very long list.
- 10:54Yeah, this is to throw a couple things out there that were said.
- 10:57So part of this discussion and, and having Daniel and Sam join
- 11:01is then use of the first UK pensions allocating the Bitcoin
- 11:05that Sam Participator was a very heavily involved with, and then
- 11:09Daniel's interest in that area of the market.
- 11:12But we couldn't have scripted better your, your different
- 11:15journeys to come to this asset class, which are very emblematic
- 11:18of like effectively everyone that it's very multidisciplinary
- 11:21and we all have different frames of reference.
- 11:24And Sam, something you shared is, is after having thousands of
- 11:27conversations with individuals about Bitcoin and when they came
- 11:30in that reference of time in 2020 as the big moment that they
- 11:36really recognize what was happening here and took whatever
- 11:39was a small allocation and increased it to a material
- 11:41allocation. And it wasn't necessarily the
- 11:43function of the amount of capital that was printed.
- 11:45It was the fact that they had so much time off the rat race.
- 11:48Because to your point, everyone is so busy doing all these other
- 11:50things that they don't ever actually have the time to take a
- 11:52step back and look at this for what it is.
- 11:55And once you see it, you, it's like everything, you know,
- 11:57everyone that's come down this journey, you can't Unsee it.
- 12:00And so it's a real big component of where, you know, Brian has
- 12:04been so integral and coming from the private banking sector and
- 12:07then leading institutional research at Coinbase and taking
- 12:09leadership here of, of creating this research.
- 12:12Because at the end of the day, like nobody can get to the end
- 12:14state of our products or how do you allocate in the right way
- 12:18unless the research is there because the education is so
- 12:20asymmetric and there's, we're still so early in this
- 12:23monetization of Bitcoin that unless that is done for the in
- 12:27the right way, this is where the past 15 years have shown losses
- 12:31that have occurred because your counterparty is, is effectively
- 12:34where the outfit is right. And if you don't have the right
- 12:36counterparty, you basically might be holding A0 on a long
- 12:40enough time horizon. And nobody can get that coming
- 12:43from a traditional world unless they, they're educated properly.
- 12:46And that takes time. Yeah, one, one thing I'd add as
- 12:49well, Sam, to the points that you made and ties into what
- 12:51Michael just described as well is time is incredibly important
- 12:55in the investment management world, right?
- 12:58A track, having a track record of a strategy is ultimately how
- 13:02you build credibility and demonstrate your acumen at
- 13:06managing money in the space. And Bitcoin's a little bit
- 13:09different, right, Because we at On Ramp and with your work at
- 13:13Cartwright and how we view the market is Bitcoin is the market
- 13:16and the alpha is in the beta in the sense that you want to have
- 13:19exposure to Bitcoin. So it's a bit different in the
- 13:22sense that the way you can think about it as an allocator is
- 13:26you're measuring Bitcoin's track record as an asset versus
- 13:30measuring a manager's track record trying to invest in other
- 13:33Bitcoin and crypto assets, right?
- 13:35And as it relates to Bitcoin's track record, it's incredibly
- 13:38impressive. It's 15 years, about to be 16
- 13:41years since the network first went live in 2009.
- 13:44And it's monetized from not having a price 16 years ago to
- 13:48be nearly a $2 trillion asset as of the all time highs last week.
- 13:52So I think that track record is really what investors should be
- 13:55paying attention to and should be asking the questions about
- 13:58why, why has this happened over the 15 years?
- 14:01Will it persist going forward and, and what might change,
- 14:05right. So that's that's how I at least
- 14:06think about it as it relates to time in the market is Bitcoin
- 14:09has almost two decades now of a track record and it is the best
- 14:12performing asset that we've ever seen.
- 14:16Yeah. And there's those things that we
- 14:20need to sort of explain and give training on to trustees that are
- 14:24interested. And you're right, some of that
- 14:28is to do with if it's gone up a lot in the past, does that mean
- 14:33it's going to go, you know, down or sideways in the future?
- 14:37And so it's thinking about things like the the fixed supply
- 14:43compared to the increasing supply of the number in which
- 14:47it's denominated, whether it's pounds sterling or whether it's
- 14:51dollars or whatever. So that's part of it.
- 14:54And other part is the total addressable market and
- 14:58understanding where it could have the the concepts of the
- 15:03black hole of Bitcoin sucking out the monetary premium from
- 15:07other asset classes. And guess what, pension schemes
- 15:11invest in equities and property and bonds and cash.
- 15:16And so those are the asset classes that are at risk from
- 15:21Bitcoin becoming a global money. So there in some senses you
- 15:28could say that from an institutional investment point
- 15:31of view, Bitcoin is a hedge against Bitcoin succeeding.
- 15:36But that and you don't need much.
- 15:38You know you need a small allocation to to enable that.
- 15:43It might be worth unpacking as well the idea of a monetary
- 15:46premium, right? Because at least in my case,
- 15:50before coming to Bitcoin and reading some, some work in the
- 15:53space, I think Parker Lewis being one, one person who's
- 15:57really explained this well, is what is the idea of a monetary
- 16:01premium? Because if you're sitting in the
- 16:02traditional investment world, you're allocating to asset
- 16:05classes and specifically in the Western world, right?
- 16:08If we focus on the, you know, North America, Europe, UK,
- 16:11etcetera, we've been fairly privileged as of the past 100
- 16:15years or so with somewhat or fairly stable monetary policy
- 16:21when you compare it to other parts of the world.
- 16:23So I think in many senses we haven't had to go back to first
- 16:28principles as much as people who've been outside of the West.
- 16:31And there's this unspoken recognition as relates to
- 16:35capital allocation that you invest in assets, right, because
- 16:40you need to get a certain return.
- 16:42And the idea is why do you need to get a certain return?
- 16:44Well, it's because you need to outpace inflation.
- 16:47And so this idea of monetary premium, I think is often
- 16:52discussed but usually not explained at least fully in the
- 16:55sense that investors are. And this is how I understand it.
- 16:58Would be curious to hear any differences.
- 16:59But investors allocate capital to asset classes like equities
- 17:03or real estate and they assign a premium above the utility value.
- 17:07So for equities, you're looking at fundamental metrics related
- 17:10to cash flows of the business. And then likewise with real
- 17:12estate, you may be looking at where it's located,
- 17:15demographics, cash flows, etcetera.
- 17:18But then there's this market that exists above that utility
- 17:20value and that's effectively what the monetary premium is,
- 17:24where people are allocating capital into those markets
- 17:27because they don't want to have a reduction in their purchasing
- 17:30power over time. Is there anything that any of
- 17:33you would add to that? I think that's well said.
- 17:38Yeah. If you look at gold, for
- 17:40example, a lot of people say, well, gold has utility value and
- 17:43that's why it has a price. But the reality is that the
- 17:45industrial use case for gold, for gold drives very little of
- 17:49its actual value. And if gold no longer existed as
- 17:53a store of value, then the price of gold would crash to a
- 17:57fraction of what it is. And people have postulated that
- 17:59the utility value is roughly between 1/6 and 110th its
- 18:04current price. So that additional value which
- 18:07gold trades at is because of supply demand dynamics in the
- 18:11marketplace where there's so much supplied and inflates by
- 18:14roughly 2% every year. We don't know exactly how much
- 18:17because it's not fully transparent, but that's how much
- 18:19new gold is mined and sent into the gold network, if you will,
- 18:23every year. And then there's supply and
- 18:27those supply demand dynamics dictate how much it's worth.
- 18:29And it's the same with real estate as well.
- 18:32I know people who have, you know, upwards of 10 properties.
- 18:35They don't live in 10 properties.
- 18:36They live in two of them. But why do they own the
- 18:38additional eight? Well, it's because they need
- 18:40somewhere to store their money. And as you said, they need
- 18:42somewhere to outpace inflation. I would say not just inflation,
- 18:45but actually outpace the growth of new dollars that have been
- 18:50printed, which is it's a higher bar to have to rise above.
- 18:54So unless they invest in real estate or equities, they're not
- 18:57going to outpace that. So most of the value you see in
- 19:00the stock market or in the real estate market or in gold is
- 19:03because of the monetary premium, because people are looking for
- 19:06somewhere to store their value. And Sam made a really great
- 19:08point, which is that we've had this concept that Bitcoin is
- 19:12risky, so therefore I shouldn't invest.
- 19:14Well, it's actually flipped on its head now.
- 19:16It's high risk not to invest in Bitcoin because where's the
- 19:20money going to come from that pours into bitcoins?
- 19:23It's not going to come out of nowhere.
- 19:24It's going to come out of traditional instruments, It's
- 19:26going to come out of equities, it's going to come out of gold
- 19:28and it's going to come out of real estate and to a lesser
- 19:30extent from bonds. So all of those, as the monetary
- 19:33premium gets sucked out of those things, we can reasonably expect
- 19:37all other things being an equilibrium that although
- 19:39they'll have a downward impact on price of those assets.
- 19:42So if you're a pension fund or a sovereign fund and you hold
- 19:45predominantly equities, bonds, real estate, gold, then you're
- 19:49suddenly at risk. And so Sam said, it's a
- 19:52brilliant comment. I've never heard anyone say it
- 19:54before, but holding Bitcoin is actually a hedge against Bitcoin
- 19:58succeeding because it's a hedge against the value of all those
- 20:02other assets which you have invested in going down in value.
- 20:08Yeah. It's highly agree.
- 20:10Quick point now I was going to add Michael.
- 20:12So it was to do with we did some analysis on looking back over
- 20:19100 a 150 years and we looked at the relative valuations of those
- 20:25key different asset classes compared to what might be
- 20:28considered their intrinsic value, so or their utility
- 20:31value, I should say. So, so for example, we were
- 20:35looking at the property real estate prices compared to a
- 20:39multiple of salary. We compared equities, we're
- 20:42looking at Cape ratios there. And if the Munchu premiums only
- 20:49built up over the past, let's say 50 years or so, then very
- 20:54approximately around half of those asset classes could be
- 20:59monthly premium. Now no one actually knows what
- 21:01the monthly premium is. All we have is the total price,
- 21:04but there's a chance that it's around 50%.
- 21:08And so if you add together equity markets, real estate
- 21:14markets, bond markets, gold and cash, you get to roughly $900
- 21:20trillion equivalent. And if you take half of that,
- 21:25that's 450 trillion. So then you can do the maths on
- 21:29that to say, well, if, and it is an if because I don't expect all
- 21:34of these other things to go to 0 monetary premium anytime soon,
- 21:39then you can divide that 450 trillion by 21 million to see
- 21:42what Bitcoin price might be. Now we're a long way from there.
- 21:46So I'd want to be taking some pretty hefty margins off that
- 21:50number to be prudent. But it gives you an idea that
- 21:55there's a if Bitcoin succeeds, then we're a long, long way from
- 22:00the potential price it could reach.
- 22:02And of course, that's before any further devaluation of the
- 22:06dollar, the #, the euro, et cetera.
- 22:09Yeah, And there's one very visceral and tangible thing to
- 22:14call out where because a lot of times the numbers get very
- 22:16ephemeral and lofty when we talk about trillions and market caps.
- 22:19But to Daniel's point, like a Bitcoin has been an emergent
- 22:23phenomenon from the retail sector.
- 22:25And to this point, there's ten, you know, his friend that has 10
- 22:29properties. When we see real estate
- 22:31investors get in, the thing that they notion this is a proxy for
- 22:34everything downstream of it is Bitcoin doesn't call me at 2:00
- 22:38AM on Saturday mornings with a leaky with a leaky pipe, right?
- 22:42And so it's this understanding of it, that monetary premium
- 22:45that taking out. That's what individuals at the
- 22:47very emergent side have been allocating from gold to equities
- 22:51all across the board because they look at a superior monetary
- 22:53properties. And now we're just naturally
- 22:55seeing that start to move up to larger pools of capital.
- 22:59But it's still to Sam's point, still very early.
- 23:02You have to not only be able to, it's not one person you're
- 23:06describing and has to get educated.
- 23:08Now committees have to get educated and large institutions
- 23:10have to move their ship. And so it takes time.
- 23:13But that's to that direct point that this has been happening at
- 23:16a micro level since Bitcoin's inception, and now it's just
- 23:19getting into larger pools of capital.
- 23:22And so as it relates to those larger pools of capital, maybe
- 23:26we should talk a bit about why institutions are adopting
- 23:29Bitcoin and should be adopting Bitcoin.
- 23:31And I would be keen to hear if you think there is a
- 23:34recognition, Sam, to your point and and Daniel, as you emphasize
- 23:39that Bitcoin is a hedge against Bitcoin succeeding.
- 23:42And do you think that some of the ideas that we've discussed
- 23:44in the past 20 minutes or so are in line with how institutions
- 23:48are thinking about Bitcoin? Or maybe should we take it,
- 23:52should we take a step back? And are there other ways that
- 23:55you're seeing just from your respective roles within the
- 23:57institutional space? Are you seeing other ways that
- 24:00endowments, foundations, pensions, family offices are
- 24:03approaching Bitcoin? So, so I start on that one.
- 24:09Do you want to come in after us, Daniel?
- 24:12So I think there's three key reasons why pension funds,
- 24:19endowments and charities are looking at.
- 24:22And in fact, you could include companies in there as well are
- 24:25looking at Bitcoin potentially. Now, it is still a relatively
- 24:30small percentage of those institutions that he's seriously
- 24:33looking at Bitcoin. It's a Bitcoin allocation, but
- 24:39you know, they are there and they are increasing.
- 24:41So those three reasons would be first of all diversification so
- 24:46that these, you know, that's following on for the munching
- 24:48premium and the black hole argument there.
- 24:51Inflation protection, you know, having a hard asset for the
- 24:56reasons that we all know can help to reasons a lot of people
- 25:00know because they use property and gold As for similar reasons,
- 25:05so protecting them against potential inflation in the
- 25:07future. And then thirdly, the asymmetric
- 25:11risk profile and return profile. So it's that ability to only
- 25:18have a small allocation. Typically, we might be talking
- 25:22about 2% to 4% of a portfolio, whereas it's got.
- 25:28So you're only going to lose 2 to 4%, but you could gain many
- 25:32multiples of that. So that's those are I think the
- 25:37key three key reasons. One factor that comes in on the
- 25:41asymmetric return profile is that that's all very well, but
- 25:46we warn everyone that it's going to be volatile in the meantime.
- 25:50So the way to mitigate that is to make sure you've got a long
- 25:55enough time horizon to bear that risk.
- 26:00And that means that Bitcoin is not appropriate for, well, in
- 26:04the UK, maybe half of the defined benefit pension schemes
- 26:08that we've got here, but that also means then it could be
- 26:11appropriate for the other half. Yeah, I think Sam's way of
- 26:18looking at this is really important because he's got a way
- 26:23of nuancing and saying upfront that Bitcoin is not right for
- 26:27every portfolio allocation. One of the points Sam made on
- 26:32another podcast was if you're a pension fund which has one year
- 26:35left to run, then you don't want to get Bitcoin because you might
- 26:39be in the wrong part of the market and it goes down.
- 26:42So Bitcoin is a great asset to hold, I would say for four years
- 26:46minimum, because if you've held it for four years minimum, if
- 26:50you look at the four year moving average, it's always going up
- 26:53and to the right. So that's a sort of the time
- 26:56frame. And with some of the
- 26:58conversations that I've been having have included family
- 27:01offices who have a multi generational time frame.
- 27:04So it's the perfect asset, for example, for family offices with
- 27:07a longer time horizon, which you're looking at.
- 27:09How do I be a custodian of intergenerational wealth?
- 27:14To give you an idea, I was in Amsterdam recently and I had a
- 27:17private meeting with the principals of 21 family offices
- 27:22and all of them were interested in investing in Bitcoin.
- 27:26But most of them believed they couldn't.
- 27:29And the reason they believed they couldn't was they had an
- 27:32impact investing mandate which said that we want to do things
- 27:35which are not only going to be financially sustainable, but
- 27:39also socially and environmentally sustainable.
- 27:42And they had some concerns that Bitcoin didn't tick those boxes.
- 27:47So my presentation was presenting the results of my due
- 27:51diligence as an investor, as a climate tech investor and as an
- 27:54impact investor, talking to other impact investors and
- 27:58saying, look, I can give you a reassurance that not only does
- 28:01it tick this box, but I have good reason to believe and the
- 28:06data backs us up, that it's going to be the most prudent ESG
- 28:09investment over the next 10 years.
- 28:10In fact, most of these funds have a challenge right now in
- 28:15that they don't have a lot of great options, which are both
- 28:19going to give them a healthy risk return profile, fit the
- 28:23asset allocation requirements of that fund.
- 28:26And at the same time, they're going to tick that ESG box
- 28:29really strongly. Now, half of them, they want to
- 28:32tick that box because they have genuine values that align to it.
- 28:36And others, it'll be frankly optics.
- 28:39They want to be seen to be doing the right thing.
- 28:41But in both cases, they need to have a reassurance that Bitcoin
- 28:45is going to be taking those boxes strongly.
- 28:48Long story short, at the end of that presentation, every single
- 28:51person, not only did they no longer have an ESG concern, but
- 28:55they could see that it was possibly the best performing ESG
- 28:59asset simply from an ESG point of view that they could possibly
- 29:02invest in. So there's a lot of reeducation
- 29:04to do as well. And this is fairly common.
- 29:06What happens when you have a nascent, because Bitcoin is not
- 29:09only an asset class, it's also a technology.
- 29:11So it's quite unique in that respect.
- 29:13My background is in tech entrepreneurship.
- 29:15So I look at it from a technology adoption lens and I
- 29:19look at how technologies get adopted over time and how you've
- 29:23never really had an asset or a technology where retail have
- 29:28been able to invest in it. And the institutions have
- 29:31actually been shut out for about 15 years.
- 29:33So this is quite unique. So it flips a lot of things in
- 29:37its head completely. And now finally, institutions
- 29:40are having a chance to be involved.
- 29:42Now the reality is that any nascent technology always has
- 29:45quite a lot of volatility to it on a given day because it's a
- 29:48reflection of the of the emotions of the marketplace.
- 29:51It's just that at a company such as Facebook or such as Google,
- 29:55it wasn't until it went public that you got to see the
- 29:58expression of that volatility. Now, Bitcoin is still relatively
- 30:02early on, so it has a lot more volatility in it, which is again
- 30:06why if you're looking at a longer term horizon, that
- 30:09volatility starts to iron out over the long term.
- 30:12If you look over that four year moving average, it's always up
- 30:16and to the right. Brian, maybe just throw you a
- 30:20little bit on the spot. Can you highlight a little more
- 30:23of the the notion that I think we all agree here that there's
- 30:26nothing probably more ESG than Bitcoin, but how you would
- 30:29describe it from your private banking and and research days
- 30:32that Coinbase is articulating to investors why that is?
- 30:36Yeah, I mean, it's a, it's a fascinating 1 because I think,
- 30:39you know, I was, I was trying to make this argument as you know,
- 30:43as early as 2-3 years ago when really the a lot of the FUD and
- 30:48and misinformation about Bitcoins energy usage was
- 30:51extremely prevalent, way more prevalent than it is today.
- 30:54And I think, you know, thanks to to folks like Daniel who have
- 30:57really been out and, and telling the truth and the real story
- 31:01here. I would also say Alex Gladstein
- 31:04has done a great job of this, but to, to break it down, you
- 31:08know, you could just go through the, the components of ESG,
- 31:11right, environmental, social and governance.
- 31:13The environmental 1, you know, is, is you have to look past
- 31:18effectively, OK, this thing is, is using a ton of energy.
- 31:20So maybe on on the surface of a, you know, very cursory
- 31:23understanding of what's happening, you could say, OK,
- 31:25use a lot of energy that's bad. But when you dig a little bit
- 31:29deeper into, you know, why and how it's using the energy it,
- 31:34for one, it's actually critical to the functioning of the
- 31:37network. And what Sam was alluding to
- 31:40earlier around this, this the mechanics of proof of work and
- 31:43how, you know, effectively, if you're going to create a new
- 31:45form of money, there should be some sort of tied to the
- 31:49physical realm of, you know, you need to expel energy in the
- 31:53physical reality in order to create new units of this thing.
- 31:56Very similar to, you know, if you just think of, of Bitcoin
- 32:00mining as a synthetic form of gold mining, very similar idea
- 32:03there, right? You have to pull the gold out of
- 32:05the earth. You have to expel energy via
- 32:08these Bitcoin mining ASIC machines in order to create new
- 32:11units. So that's, that's sort of the
- 32:12first stage of, of understanding here is like, OK, this is
- 32:15fundamental to the thing existing.
- 32:18And then you take a step further and say, well, how is it
- 32:20actually doing it? And and then it, it, you come to
- 32:23the realization that for the first time in human history,
- 32:26there's no such thing as stranded energy, IE we can now
- 32:30monetize energy in a location agnostic manner never before
- 32:34possible in human history. Pretty remarkable.
- 32:37And so then what you start to understand is, is overtime
- 32:41bitcoins just going to use more and more otherwise wasted or
- 32:44stranded energy? And you're already seeing that
- 32:46play out over the past several years because the, the, you
- 32:50know, the main input in terms of a, a Bitcoin miners balance
- 32:54sheet and profitability is their input cost.
- 32:56And that main, the main input cost cost to consider is the
- 33:00price of energy at which you're, you're mining.
- 33:02And so naturally what happens over time is, is you know, these
- 33:06miners will seek out lower and lower cost of energy.
- 33:08And in many cases, those are sources of energy that would
- 33:13have otherwise not been profitable or feasible to get to
- 33:17a grid, get to a population or or city center.
- 33:20And so they are generally wasted or stranded.
- 33:23And so that is a amazing dynamic that, you know, most people,
- 33:27again, if you're just looking at it at the surface level, use a
- 33:30lot of energy bad. We'll know.
- 33:32Let's look a little bit deeper. How is it using the energy?
- 33:35It's doing it in a very unique way that actually can't be done
- 33:38with any other technology if you want to move to the the social
- 33:43side of things. This one is a little bit more
- 33:45straightforward in my mind. And I think, you know, kind of
- 33:48remarkable that this was ever a question whether or not big
- 33:52Bitcoin was good in terms of the social dynamics.
- 33:54But, you know, there are billions of people around the
- 33:58world who are entirely unbanked or under some level of financial
- 34:02repression. And if they have access to the
- 34:05Internet and a smartphone, they can access this open,
- 34:08permissionless network and they can protect themselves from
- 34:12hyperinflation or debasement of their local currency.
- 34:15So that one's pretty straightforward.
- 34:17This is good for humanity. It gives people a open monetary
- 34:21network that they otherwise wouldn't have had.
- 34:23And then on the governance governance side, it's sort of
- 34:25this just elegant understanding of, yeah, this is an open
- 34:29network with, you know, it's a set of rules without rulers.
- 34:32That's sort of the ultimate form of governance in the sense that
- 34:35you don't have to trust fallible humans in terms of maintaining
- 34:38this thing. It's math, it's code, and it's
- 34:41the shared distributed piece of software that is, that is really
- 34:46the ultimate form of governance. But I, I want to hand it to
- 34:49Daniel because he's done a fantastic job of articulating
- 34:52these points over the past couple years.
- 34:54And so, yeah. Anything you want to add to
- 34:56that? You said it well, in terms of
- 34:59the social side, there's been 19 documented use cases of Bitcoin
- 35:05and most of them impact people who are currently in the global
- 35:08S So again, it flips things on its head.
- 35:11Normally we're used to a technology such as mobile phone
- 35:14technology impacting the W 1st and then when we've sucked the
- 35:18profit premium out of it, and then we think about other parts
- 35:20of the world. Bitcoin has been adopted as a
- 35:23store of value in the West, absolutely, but it's been used
- 35:26as a method of transacting predominantly in the global S
- 35:30where previously you couldn't to get remittance payments to your
- 35:33family across borders without middle men in the middle.
- 35:37It's just phenomenal how it's been used on the environmental
- 35:40side. What's interesting is that the
- 35:44media has latched onto this. It uses a lot of energy, which
- 35:47is absolutely true. But the really important thing
- 35:51to recognize is that that does not mean it's bad for the
- 35:55environment. In fact, if you look at the
- 35:57consensus of the environmental movement, or maybe not the
- 36:00consensus, but I'd say 75%, you kind of have the split.
- 36:04And people often think that the environmental movement is
- 36:06degrowth. They want to use less energy.
- 36:08That's actually a false notion of the environmental movement.
- 36:11There are definitely some people in the environmental movement
- 36:14who believe we should use less energy, fewer resources.
- 36:17However, most of the environmental movement, the
- 36:20other 75% of pragmatists say people like Saw Griffiths who
- 36:23wrote the book Electrify, who said that there's no way we're
- 36:27going to have a green energy transition and create more
- 36:30supply of renewables on the grid if we don't have demand for it.
- 36:33So the worst thing you could possibly do is to try to limit
- 36:36our energy consumption because then there's no demand.
- 36:39Who's going to set up a new bakery business in a street
- 36:42where people are buying less bread?
- 36:43It's not going to happen. So similarly, people aren't
- 36:45going to set up more renewable. Generation of people are using
- 36:48less energy. So what becomes important there
- 36:51is the form of energy that they are using.
- 36:54And there's been a lot of peer reviewed research lately that's
- 36:57shown that because Bitcoin is incredibly flexible as an energy
- 37:00user, it's able to use renewable energy that otherwise would have
- 37:04been wasted, would have been spilled into the ground.
- 37:07Because it was produced in the middle of the day in the case of
- 37:09soul, when nobody wanted it. Or in the case of wind, it was
- 37:12produced in the middle of the night when no one wanted it.
- 37:15And Bitcoin can soak that up. And that means the renewable
- 37:18generator is more profitable. And what does any prudent
- 37:21business operator do when they get more profit and their
- 37:25business, which means more solar, more wind.
- 37:28So it has this flywheel effect. And then the other great thing
- 37:31about it is because it can very easily ramp up and ramp down.
- 37:35The biggest concern that grid operators have and why you get
- 37:38these huge interconnection queues, I believe in the UK,
- 37:40they're spanning out to you want to get new solar and wind on the
- 37:43grid. Sometimes you're given a date in
- 37:45the 2000 and 50s. And the reason for that is that
- 37:48these grid operators cannot handle more intermittent power
- 37:52sources. So if the sun goes behind a
- 37:55cloud, you've lost your power. Well, what happens if you've got
- 37:58peak demand at that time or if the wind stops blowing, as it
- 38:01has in Germany right now, and the grid operators are freaking
- 38:04out because they don't have enough power on the grid?
- 38:06You have to have consumers of energy.
- 38:08You have to have two things. Number one, you have to have
- 38:10what's called a gas peaker plant, which can fire up very
- 38:13fast and supply more power. Or you have to have consumers of
- 38:17energy, which can very quickly ramp down their energy
- 38:19consumption. And so the paradox has been as
- 38:23we've put more variable renewable onto the grid, we've
- 38:26also had to put more gas pica plants onto the grid as backup,
- 38:29which is generating fossil fuel. And they idle through the year,
- 38:33releasing carbon dioxide into the atmosphere just for those
- 38:3610% of the year when there's peak demand.
- 38:38And they can counterbalance the variability of renewable energy.
- 38:42Well, now with Bitcoin mining, you don't have to do that.
- 38:44You don't need those gas pica plants anymore.
- 38:46In fact, in Texas, this is exactly what had happened.
- 38:49For three years, Berkshire Hathaway had been proposing 8 to
- 38:52$10 billion of new gas pika plants.
- 38:55But the grid operator discovered Bitcoin mining, which meant they
- 38:57could just ramp down the consumption of energy.
- 39:00They didn't need them. So it's been absolutely
- 39:02incredible. Once you look into the nuances
- 39:05beyond it uses too much energy, you start to see these amazing
- 39:10completely accidental ways that the cost.
- 39:13Bitcoin miners are the only people in the world who 80% of
- 39:17their budget, the operational budget is electricity.
- 39:20They are positively incentivized to cheat this cheapest sources
- 39:23of energy to seek the cheapest sources of energy in the world.
- 39:26And they are generally going to be renewable energy, which has
- 39:29been what's driving it to be the most renewable and most
- 39:33sustainable using energy user in the world today with more than
- 39:3850% coming from sustainable sources and rising by 4% plus
- 39:43every year. Yeah, well.
- 39:46This is probably an episode on itself.
- 39:48Well, one last thing, just a reference on the, the, you know,
- 39:51ESG argument is it 1 discounts the utility of Bitcoin, meaning
- 39:56like there is no utility value, which fundamentally a sort of
- 39:59value and economic activity coordinated from it has some
- 40:04value. And we can make the case it
- 40:05could be all the value when you when you break it down, it ties
- 40:08into the monetary premium that we discussed here.
- 40:10And if you don't necessarily need to produce more houses
- 40:12because of that, well, then there's that side of the energy.
- 40:15But then there's also this thing that the one that's probably the
- 40:17most relevant here is nobody talks about AI and data center
- 40:21usage. They talk about Bitcoin usage.
- 40:24And what effectively happened is to Brian's point, because
- 40:27there's no such thing as straining energy.
- 40:28And Bitcoin miners and the data center operators of that
- 40:32recognize that they are this like Canary in the coal mine and
- 40:35energy markets to find the cheapest source of energy.
- 40:37We're now the AI data centers are effectively, I don't know,
- 40:41Co opting is the right word, but they're they're purchasing,
- 40:43they're Co locating and they're ultimately becoming the most
- 40:47more profitable or or they're switching off from mining to
- 40:51actually powering GP us, which now pushes the Bitcoin mining
- 40:55miners to go find another cheaper source of energy to the
- 40:58point that's renewable or to stranded gas and other sources
- 41:01of energy. So it's, it's the most perfect
- 41:04energy access point that the market hasn't restarting to like
- 41:09recognize. So that's, I think, a part that
- 41:11goes under score, yeah. The other, the other way I would
- 41:14describe it just at a very high level is like it, it just it
- 41:18makes us more efficient as a species in terms of how we're
- 41:22leveraging all the different sources of energy that we have
- 41:25available to us. If we can, you know, instantly
- 41:29monetize on location something a source of energy that otherwise
- 41:33would have been wasted or stranded and not profitable to
- 41:36get to a grid. So at a very high level, all
- 41:38else equal, like it makes us more efficient as humans and
- 41:41should over time be sort of deflationary in the sense of
- 41:45we're just getting better at using all of the available
- 41:47energy sources on Earth. Yeah.
- 41:53And Daniel, I believe you gave a presentation before about
- 41:57Bitcoin being the world's best ESG assets.
- 41:59So I'd encourage we can include that in the show notes, but I
- 42:01can encourage anyone who wants to take a deeper dive into the
- 42:05topic to check that out as well. Feel like Daniel and Brian, you
- 42:09both very much, very well articulated the point there and
- 42:13would encourage people to check out that presentation.
- 42:15And and Sam want to pivot back over to you as well to talk a
- 42:19little bit more about your decision making process at
- 42:22Cartwright because you had described 33 characteristics as
- 42:28why institutional investors are honing in on Bitcoin as an
- 42:32investable asset class. And the three were
- 42:34diversification, inflation protection and asymmetric return
- 42:38profile. So when you were starting to
- 42:41evaluate Bitcoin in your seat as a pension consultant, were any
- 42:48of these three characteristics more important than the others?
- 42:50Or were any three more urgent than the others as it related to
- 42:53helping your pension schemes navigate these changing
- 42:56investment landscape? And then from there, maybe we
- 42:59could talk a little bit more about the manager research
- 43:03process and the process that your team went through as it
- 43:06related to trying to seek out Bitcoin exposure for for your
- 43:10pension schemes. And maybe also maybe afterwards
- 43:17I could given Daniels on the call, I could touch briefly on
- 43:21how pension trustees in particular think about the ESG
- 43:28situation and how they incorporate that within their
- 43:31within their investments. So out of those 3, the most
- 43:37relevant 1 I think was the asymmetric return profile.
- 43:41And that's because you want to take an idea to a client that
- 43:46they can see the benefit. Now there's always risks with
- 43:49anything, but they can see that the reward is worth taking for
- 43:54the risk. And so accepting that there's
- 43:58some volatility in the price, but it's got this asymmetric
- 44:03return profile is then makes it very attractive.
- 44:06But then you need to sense check it.
- 44:08And that's where the diversification comes in because
- 44:12I think, you know, sometimes there is a concern, well, we
- 44:16don't want Bitcoin because it's too volatile.
- 44:20OK, Well, we're not talking about putting everything in
- 44:22Bitcoin. We're talking about putting a
- 44:24small percentage in Bitcoin. So let's not focus on, we don't
- 44:29focus on a particular equity you invested in and and worry about
- 44:33that volatility. We consider the portfolio as a
- 44:35whole. And so you, you reduce that
- 44:40analysis and of course, everything then makes a lot more
- 44:42sense and is more sensible. So, so that, that's probably
- 44:48that the you mentioned then I think Jackson, the, the process
- 44:52that we went through to which, which process did you mean?
- 44:56Did you mean the process to advise on the Bitcoin allocation
- 44:59or something else? Yeah.
- 45:00So the the process once once you understood and the team had
- 45:05decided that Bitcoin had a role within the pension portfolios,
- 45:09what was that process like for you to start evaluating managers
- 45:13and what were the most important characteristics and I guess
- 45:18selection criteria that you thought through as a team?
- 45:22Well, so it was. So we also do a lot of research
- 45:26and a lot of different asset classes and fund managers.
- 45:30And as I think Michael might have alluded to earlier, we
- 45:35spend, you know, if we take an equity manager, global equity
- 45:38manager, we spend a lot of time thinking about, you know, what's
- 45:41their, what's their worldview, what's their process, their
- 45:44philosophy of tube, when do they buy, when do they sell
- 45:48different, different equities? Is there a bias within the
- 45:50portfolio portfolio? You've got all these kind of
- 45:52things that you're thinking about and then there's a bit of
- 45:55a sense check at the end you're making sure.
- 45:57Well, are their custody arrangements OK?
- 45:59OK, yeah, they've got they've got good custody arrangement in
- 46:01place, that's fine. Whereas for researching on ramp
- 46:09it, we spent about the same amount of time doing it all.
- 46:13But of course most of the issues were not relevant at all.
- 46:15So we could put them to completely to one side and
- 46:18really deep dive on on the custody.
- 46:21And obviously that's extra important because it's an asset
- 46:25class which clients are not used to.
- 46:28So it's actually was really important that we went the extra
- 46:30mile or extra 100 miles on the custody side because we had to
- 46:36be, you know, we had to be ticking every box to give them
- 46:40the reassurance, reassurance for a new asset class.
- 46:44So that was, that was, you know, a fascinating process to go
- 46:50through. I think the other key aspects
- 46:52that was important to us was having a firm that was willing
- 46:57and keen to work with us. You know, it makes things so
- 47:00much easier. You know, there's always things
- 47:03that come up, aren't there, that you think, well, you know, could
- 47:05we do this? Could we do that?
- 47:06And maybe the answer's yes and maybe the answer's no sometimes.
- 47:11But the point is, it's about that working relationship and
- 47:14being able to pick up the phone and then have those
- 47:16conversations. That's incredibly important.
- 47:19Yeah. And maybe Sam to add to that.
- 47:21So the founding of the firm, we had experienced building
- 47:23infrastructure at this point now for close to half a decade.
- 47:26At the time it was you know called 2 1/2 three years and we
- 47:29looked at the market and generally in a newer market or
- 47:32existing market you see the leaders and you assume that they
- 47:34have it all figured out. And in 2022 we realized that
- 47:37wasn't the case and we looked at GBTC at the time this is pretty
- 47:41ETF's and we looked at this product that had over 600,000
- 47:45bitcoins. So it was objectively providing
- 47:47product allocators exposure, but at the same time understanding
- 47:51the space, we looked at it as not the best product from some
- 47:54of the things that we were founded on that I think you can
- 47:57share more than my understanding you guys found valuable, which
- 48:00was the custody and the the counterparty risk, the in kind
- 48:05redemption. So Bitcoin is a unique asset
- 48:07that you can take delivery. And you've talked about
- 48:09previously, I think on our last podcast that we did about your
- 48:13experience with the GFC and the recognition that when they're
- 48:16when counterparty risk goes bid, that the fact that you want to
- 48:19be able to take delivery or hedge out those bets and and
- 48:21moving the asset. And then the education, which
- 48:24was a big component because historically allocators of all
- 48:29shapes and sizes have been exit liquidity in the space.
- 48:31They chase the momentum and then they go with asset managers.
- 48:33They don't really understand what's happening.
- 48:35And when that volatility inevitably ensues, you need
- 48:38somebody to be able to sit in the trenches with you to
- 48:40describe what's happening. And so that was how our firm was
- 48:43founded. And I think that was a lot of
- 48:44the things that we found were most valuable to you and was was
- 48:48really exciting because at the end of the day, you know,
- 48:50pensions consultants are the most sophisticated investors in
- 48:53the world. And we built this product and
- 48:55this firm for those investors with the market catching up.
- 48:58It's why we focus so heavily on education and this podcast as an
- 49:02example. Yeah, no, that's, that's
- 49:03brilliant. And I agree entirely.
- 49:05All those things were important. Two that particularly stood out
- 49:09from that list are the the counterparty risk and being
- 49:16Bitcoin only. So just to add a little bit more
- 49:18detail on each of those. So counterparty risk or
- 49:22exposure. So this is to do with, it's in
- 49:26many ways it comes back to the diversification point in that a
- 49:32big sort of part of that diversification associated with
- 49:38Bitcoin is that you can hold it without a bearer asset.
- 49:41As we know, you can hold it without counterparty risk.
- 49:45So why wouldn't you? It doesn't really make any sense
- 49:49to not do that. And that flows in some of you
- 49:54guys. Some great examples there,
- 49:55Michael, But you know, that leads to ruling out single
- 49:59points of failure. It comes down to, you know,
- 50:03working with someone who's not tempted.
- 50:04Well, if we lend it out, we can get a bit more yield or any of
- 50:08that nonsense. Well, it's got it's place, but
- 50:11it's not got it's place for institutional investment when
- 50:14all they want is an allocation to Bitcoin.
- 50:17So those that was important and the Bitcoin only was important
- 50:22as well because again, it's about ruling out distractions.
- 50:25So it's not getting distracted by trying to earn some yield by
- 50:28taking on some counterparty risk.
- 50:31It's not. It's ruling out distractions
- 50:33about other cryptocurrencies which are not moneytheyre.com
- 50:39companies or you know, technology companies or scams.
- 50:43So it just simplifies things dramatically and means you've
- 50:48got a nice clean allocation with no counterparty risk.
- 50:52And it just makes life so much easier when you're explaining it
- 50:55to to people on why they should invest in this way.
- 51:00Does your Bitcoin custody setup keep you up at night?
- 51:03Maybe you still have coins sitting on an exchange Worried
- 51:05about hackers? Or maybe you've set up your own
- 51:08self custody but don't feel safe with your Bitcoin savings
- 51:10stashed on a little plastic device in your desk drawer.
- 51:14Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp and our multi institution
- 51:17custody solution. Here's how it works.
- 51:20On Ramp creates a dedicated multi sig vault just for you. 3
- 51:24separate institutions each hold a key on ramp bit go and coin
- 51:28cover, but none can move funds unilaterally.
- 51:31Instead only you have control over your coins with on ramps
- 51:36multi institution custody. You'll sleep better at night
- 51:39knowing your Bitcoin is stored with best in class security on
- 51:42chain with fault tolerant multi sig.
- 51:45If you believe your Bitcoin is going to be worth a lot someday,
- 51:48don't jeopardize that future by exposing your coins to hackers
- 51:51on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks in the real world, or perhaps
- 51:55most importantly, the risk that you might screw something up
- 51:58with a highly technical self custody set up on ramps.
- 52:02Multi institution custody eliminates single points of
- 52:05failure, reduces your personal attack surface and technical
- 52:08burden, and provides access to financial services that allow
- 52:12you to confidently secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance
- 52:15planning, insurance backed warranties for all balances and
- 52:18transactions, low cost trading, and more.
- 52:22Bitcoin is a once in a species asset, secure it right.
- 52:25Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com. It's a critical thing to
- 52:28highlight even a bit further too in the sense that Bitcoin is
- 52:33about it maybe one point eight, $1.9 trillion asset today and
- 52:39it's about 60% of the broader digital asset market, which so
- 52:44that comes out to, I don't know, 3 1/2 trillion or so.
- 52:47But the point being that custody has been a pain point for the
- 52:52industry of it of it's entire existence.
- 52:55So for Bitcoins about 16 years and then since then over the
- 52:58past decade or so the proliferation of other digital
- 53:02assets. And in that time, there's been
- 53:04about $600 billion of losses of capital, permanent losses.
- 53:08And that's due to having a counterparty that is not acting
- 53:14in your best interest or may not have security that's up to snuff
- 53:17or has some some sort of single point of failure.
- 53:21And this is really important to highlight as we're speaking to
- 53:24institutional allocators, because when we think about
- 53:27custody and Sam, it ties into your point with if you're
- 53:29looking at, you know, an equity manager, right, you want to
- 53:32understand their alpha in the market as it relates to where
- 53:36they focus, you know, region wise, maybe sector specificity,
- 53:43what is their underlying strategy?
- 53:44Are they long only? Are they, you know, long, short
- 53:48market neutral, etcetera. If they're in the alternative
- 53:50space and none of that really matters in the Bitcoin space
- 53:54because you want to have exposure to the underlying
- 53:56assets. So then the question becomes
- 53:58then, well, what does matter? And I really wanted to emphasize
- 54:01the point on custody because with traditional assets, Sam,
- 54:06you kind of mentioned that custody, it's still important,
- 54:08but it's not a defining characteristic of the due
- 54:11diligence process, if I understand it correctly.
- 54:13I don't want to put words in your mouth.
- 54:15And the reason being is because these custody of other assets is
- 54:19effectively record keeping, right?
- 54:20You have records kept at the custodian.
- 54:22They're likely backed up in several different places and you
- 54:25lose the record, you, you haven't lost the asset.
- 54:28You know that that record is, is kept somewhere else.
- 54:31And it doesn't mean that the, the company no longer exists or
- 54:34the the piece of property is no longer there.
- 54:37Whereas with Bitcoin, the custody is critically important
- 54:40because if the keys are managed improperly, it's likely resulted
- 54:45in a permanent loss of capital. And it might have been before we
- 54:49hit record, but we were talking about the idea that if you are
- 54:52an institutional allocator, you can be wrong about an idea
- 54:56potentially and have, you know, a quarter percent or 1% of your
- 54:59portfolio go to 0 or, or experience a significant draw
- 55:02down. And you could be wrong about the
- 55:05investment thesis. But you what you don't want to
- 55:06be wrong about is the underlying custody or the exposure that
- 55:10you've gotten access to that asset class, right?
- 55:13Meaning you wouldn't want to lose your Bitcoin because you
- 55:16picked the wrong counterparty, whereas you might be OK with
- 55:20losing 1/4 percentage of your portfolio on the underlying
- 55:23investment thesis. Is that how you think about it
- 55:25as well? And Daniel, I'd offer that up to
- 55:27you as you're just given conversations that you have,
- 55:29you've been having with family offices and other institutional
- 55:32allocators. Yeah, Sam, do you want to go
- 55:35first? Yeah.
- 55:36I mean, you're spot on, Jackson, right?
- 55:38So that having that counterparty risk removed is essential and
- 55:45also the transparency that can go along with it.
- 55:48So the Bitcoin address in which it is held.
- 55:55So I've given that address to the trustees in question, and
- 56:02they love the fact that it's transparent.
- 56:04In fact, it's more transparent than any other asset they've
- 56:06got. So it's that's one of the great
- 56:09things about Bitcoin. You think, well maybe if it's
- 56:11just as good as everything else and then suddenly it's 10 times
- 56:14better and you think, Oh well OK, really underlines that new
- 56:19technology really takes off when it's 10X better than what is
- 56:23already in place. Yeah.
- 56:28The thing I'll add, just bringing in the family offices
- 56:30is one of the big considerations they have is inheritance is
- 56:34transfer of intergenerational wealth.
- 56:36And so that's actually quite a messy process just even in the
- 56:40traditional Fiat system. And so if you can almost address
- 56:442 issues at once, you address the custody issue, but you also
- 56:48address the wealth transfer issue together at one time, it
- 56:53can turn a potential perceived problem with Bitcoin into an
- 56:57even better solution for a lot of people who are looking to
- 57:00answer that question and to whom that question is tremendously
- 57:03important. So I've seen family offices,
- 57:06they're very interested in the question of what happens with
- 57:09that intergenerational wealth transfer with the custody of the
- 57:13assets. So I think what you're creating
- 57:15together and when I found out about on ramp, I'm like this is
- 57:17actually an ideal solution for family offices as well.
- 57:21That's exactly right. We, we were just got back the
- 57:24team on this call, we were visiting Dallas family offices,
- 57:27institutions that we had historically met with since, you
- 57:30know, 2020-2021 that hadn't had allocations.
- 57:32And it kind of got in emboldened in the sense of, you know, we
- 57:37used to talk for very often about, well, why is the asset
- 57:39have value? Why isn't it going to 0?
- 57:41And I, I basically reframed it. So like, if we want to talk
- 57:44about value and, and you know, scarcity, like that's a
- 57:47conversation. We'll set up a different call.
- 57:48I want to explain why it's not $10 trillion and it's breaks
- 57:52down what we're both Sam and Daniel both have references.
- 57:55You have this notion of you know, Jackson said six, 600
- 57:58billion. Our slide I can pull up has 400
- 58:00billion just because of the the price of bitcoins appreciation
- 58:03recently. But the point being is from the
- 58:07very simple perspective, Daniel like a patriarch of a family
- 58:10office and we experienced this intimately.
- 58:13They cannot get their exposure of 50 to $100 million because
- 58:16they both, this is just a real example.
- 58:18They father, son fly together and what happens if they have
- 58:22to, they can't trust a third party because you can't put that
- 58:24amount of capital because they're managing their families
- 58:25wealth. And so if they mess up the
- 58:27custodian, well then they lost the asset.
- 58:30But then they can't manage these private keys because if they go
- 58:33down and like they can't tell anybody about the private keys
- 58:35from an inheritance perspective because well, then that defeats
- 58:37the purpose of setting up the the security model.
- 58:40So these are just small examples that have kept individuals out
- 58:43of this asset. And once you solve for that, you
- 58:46allow for its appreciation. And so just for anybody watching
- 58:49these, there's two really good slides here that describe what
- 58:52we're talking about. This is the old slide that has
- 58:53the the $400 billion that is now 600 billion given bitcoins, you
- 58:58know, close to $2 trillion market cap.
- 59:01And then what we're describing on custody and Daniel's
- 59:04referencing is really this notion of multi institution
- 59:06custody, which inserts techno is governance effectively into the
- 59:10protocol requiring multiple institutions to validate with
- 59:14the asset manager or the end client depending how it's
- 59:17constructed to move the asset. This has never really existed in
- 59:21Bitcoin. It's nothing that's technically
- 59:22changed. It's more of the legal
- 59:23governance that's built on top of it.
- 59:26And it's part of where cartridge working with us, I think Daniels
- 59:28been interested and where we're seeing so much traction in the
- 59:31market because as the price gets to six figures, you can't
- 59:34actually afford to be on the slide anymore.
- 59:37So people just will stay out of the market rather than put
- 59:39material allocations because the alternative has effectively
- 59:42been, you know end up on this slide.
- 59:45And so now you can start to get folks in.
- 59:49But the one of the key thoughts here is we're still so early
- 59:54that this is asymmetric information like that.
- 59:56The reality is most people will look at the ETFs and think of
- 59:59them as the most sophisticated products.
- 1:00:01In reality, over a course of, you know, 15 years, we've seen
- 1:00:04centralized custody has not, you know, boded well for the
- 1:00:07underlying holders. You know, we hope it'll be
- 1:00:10different, but we can't plan for that when it comes to, you know,
- 1:00:13an asset that is, you know, holding 2 trillion and
- 1:00:16eventually $10 trillion, if not greater.
- 1:00:18And so that's kind of why we structure these products in this
- 1:00:20way. Yeah, it's it's exactly right.
- 1:00:22And I think you're just going back to what that slide really
- 1:00:27demonstrates with those the losses is, you know, effectively
- 1:00:32the 1st 16 years of bitcoins history.
- 1:00:35You, you didn't mess it up via the thesis, right?
- 1:00:38The thesis Bitcoin as money continues to be validated.
- 1:00:43That's not how any investor has lost money in this, in this
- 1:00:46asset class. The only way people have screwed
- 1:00:48up is via custody. And that whole 400, now 600
- 1:00:52billion are all a function of some version of a single point
- 1:00:56of failure. And so the reality is for the
- 1:00:591st 16 years, custodying Bitcoin without a single point of
- 1:01:03failure has been extraordinarily difficult, if not impossible.
- 1:01:07Whether you're doing self custody yourself, you, you
- 1:01:10yourself, the end client, then become the single point of
- 1:01:13failure or you're trusting a single entity that's a single
- 1:01:16point of failure. And really what we are just
- 1:01:19trying to pioneer and and sort of incept into the the market
- 1:01:24structure is there's a way to build fault tolerance and
- 1:01:28redundancy into the the protocol governance as as Michael alluded
- 1:01:33to. And so that is just objectively
- 1:01:37a better way forward in the sense that you can eliminate a
- 1:01:40single point of failure, which is again the only thing that has
- 1:01:43tripped people up in this asset class historically.
- 1:01:46And and that speaks to just the unique custodial nature of the
- 1:01:50asset in that you cannot afford to screw up the custody because
- 1:01:55it's just gone forever. It's finite and you can't
- 1:01:58recreate new Bitcoin. So, so it's just, it's very
- 1:02:02different than any other asset class.
- 1:02:03And for that reason you have to think about it differently.
- 1:02:07Sorry, boy, I was just going to say it's one of the thing that's
- 1:02:09tripped people up and that's their emotions and panic selling
- 1:02:14or particularly. And then that underlines going
- 1:02:21in with eyes open and making sure that decisions are made in
- 1:02:25a methodical way, which is what we can help with.
- 1:02:29That's exactly right. I think one thing that ties not
- 1:02:33that we have to go back to, but to the social side of the ESG is
- 1:02:36the democratizing nature that technology has, right?
- 1:02:40I think it's kind of a funny statement, but the presidential
- 1:02:42election posted, you saw Trump with like Elon and a few other
- 1:02:45people all holding this device that we all have, right?
- 1:02:48The most powerful, you know, influential people use the same
- 1:02:50device that we use in the same way where you think about
- 1:02:53sovereigns or pensions or large pools of capital would have had
- 1:02:56armed guards and all the things associated withholding hundreds
- 1:02:59of 1,000,000 billions of dollars in assets.
- 1:03:02This form of custody is is technology in the same way that
- 1:03:05a pension can leverage it is the same way as individuals like me
- 1:03:08and you can can leverage it. And there's this democratizing
- 1:03:10nature of sparking all your wealth and getting that like
- 1:03:12industrial grade security that you never saw for somebody to
- 1:03:16hold 1,000,000 of the same as 100 billion, if not a trillion
- 1:03:19dollars. So it's very powerful in that
- 1:03:22respect. And and to Daniel's point,
- 1:03:24market structure around inheritance tax advantage
- 1:03:26accounts and insurance have all been missing from this.
- 1:03:30And in an actual like way that makes sense.
- 1:03:34And these are things that multi institution solves for.
- 1:03:37Yeah, having people like Sam seems too modest to say this,
- 1:03:41but I'll say it on his behalf is tremendously important because
- 1:03:45if you extend out what it means, getting your emotions too
- 1:03:48involved, there's three big mistakes you can make.
- 1:03:50One is trying to time the market or panic sell.
- 1:03:54The second is that you think, oh, what's this call nascent
- 1:03:57altcoin slash NFT? Let me diversify into that.
- 1:04:00And you get wrecked. And then there's a third issue,
- 1:04:04which is you, you start trying to trade on leverage.
- 1:04:07I've made all three mistakes and a lot of people in Bitcoin have
- 1:04:12in their first cycle and they've lost money and then they've
- 1:04:14learnt that they're probably better off to do what some OG or
- 1:04:18some prudent advisor told them to do in the 1st place, which
- 1:04:21was to hold the asset and not sell it for a long period of
- 1:04:24time. And so it may sound like simple
- 1:04:26advice, but it's actually hard won advice.
- 1:04:29And it's tremendously important to have people like Sam who can
- 1:04:32say from experience this is the way to preserve wealth over a
- 1:04:35long period of time and to guide them through the processes
- 1:04:38because there are distractions. And in the media in particular,
- 1:04:42Bitcoin and crypto gets conflated all the time.
- 1:04:45Even within the Trump administration, it gets
- 1:04:47conflated and people think they're the same.
- 1:04:49They're absolutely diametrically opposed.
- 1:04:50The only thing that they have in common is they use the same
- 1:04:53technology base. But beyond that, the assets are
- 1:04:56different. The technology is different, the
- 1:04:57ESG profile is different. Everything is completely
- 1:05:00different about them. And so it's really important to
- 1:05:02understand those distinctions. That's a critical point, Daniel.
- 1:05:06And just to go a little bit further on it, it, I think
- 1:05:12there's an increasing recognition that Bitcoin is
- 1:05:14different from crypto. But I totally agree with you
- 1:05:17that there's still a lot of conflation and it ends up being
- 1:05:21detrimental to allocators because they're thinking about
- 1:05:24Bitcoin and the rest of the crypto space as these very
- 1:05:29speculative, not that speculative is inherently a bad
- 1:05:32thing, but they view them as speculative with no sort of
- 1:05:35value underlying it. And they view them all as the
- 1:05:38same thing, right? So naturally people gravitate
- 1:05:40toward maybe a top 10 weighted, you know, market cap weighted
- 1:05:44exposure to digital assets or they want to allocate to venture
- 1:05:49funds that are investing into Icos and and other things,
- 1:05:53right? And, and there's a difference
- 1:05:55there though that Bitcoin is and Sam, I want to and Daniel, I
- 1:06:00want to hear both of your takes on this.
- 1:06:02Bitcoin exists as its own monetary network.
- 1:06:04So if you think about the traditional financial system,
- 1:06:08you have equities and bonds, currencies, real estate, and
- 1:06:12they're all in some way tied more in some more than others,
- 1:06:15tied to this existing banking rails and Fiat currencies.
- 1:06:18And then you have this other technology that exists totally
- 1:06:22outside of that system. And it ties into Sam, your point
- 1:06:26about the great financial crisis and having the optionality to,
- 1:06:30you know, with gold particularly having the ability to take that
- 1:06:33bear instrument and then have access to a form of money or an
- 1:06:36asset or a form of capital outside of the banking system.
- 1:06:40And I think we're starting to get to a point now where there
- 1:06:42is that broader recognition within institutional circles and
- 1:06:47within investment committees where particularly after the
- 1:06:502022, the Russia sanction of assets and now these heightened
- 1:06:56geopolitical tensions that we've seen in 2022 three and 24.
- 1:07:00I do think that the, IT is becoming more clear to
- 1:07:03allocators, still not clear as it should be.
- 1:07:06But you know, we're getting to the point where folks are
- 1:07:08getting more educated in the space and they're starting to
- 1:07:10view Bitcoin as a more risk off strategic asset allocation where
- 1:07:14they're viewing the rest of the space to be more again,
- 1:07:17speculative or risk on or almost like a, you know, a lottery, a
- 1:07:21lottery ticket within a portfolio that's maybe 25 bits
- 1:07:23or a percentage of their portfolio.
- 1:07:26Any thoughts there? Yeah.
- 1:07:30I don't think we're there yet in terms of making that difference
- 1:07:36clear between Bitcoin and everything and everything else.
- 1:07:42I think we're getting there. But I mean, so for example, I
- 1:07:48was having various different debates or discussions on
- 1:07:52LinkedIn when we announced, when we announced what was it about 3
- 1:07:56weeks ago that first allocation to a pension scheme.
- 1:08:02And there's still a lot of confusion there.
- 1:08:05And they said, well, what about this, that or the other?
- 1:08:06And they said, well, that's, I mean, that's not Bitcoin.
- 1:08:09So you're talking about a complete.
- 1:08:11So there's still this element of two people talking past each
- 1:08:14other, but every opportunity I get, and I'm sure every
- 1:08:19opportunity you get as well, it's always mentioning Bitcoin
- 1:08:23is not the same as crypto or some other similar phrase.
- 1:08:27And the message is slowly getting there, I think, but it's
- 1:08:32still going to take some time. There's still, well, it comes
- 1:08:35back to what I was saying earlier, a lot of people haven't
- 1:08:37spent much time on this topic. And therefore that's one of the
- 1:08:42first things that hopefully people couldn't.
- 1:08:44In fact, when I speak to someone for the first time, they say,
- 1:08:47oh, this is interesting about your crypto exposure.
- 1:08:50I say, no, it's not, it's not crypto, it's Bitcoin.
- 1:08:53And in fact, if they're just learning, so if they're engaged
- 1:08:56and they would look, so I want to learn more, I say, OK, well,
- 1:08:58the first thing is I'll give you a shortcut of two years and tell
- 1:09:01you that Bitcoin is not crypto and hopefully, hopefully take
- 1:09:07that on board and that they will then accelerate their learning
- 1:09:09process. But yeah, there will still be
- 1:09:12some casualties along the way, I'm sure.
- 1:09:14Yeah, I think that's, that's the, that's the first and sort
- 1:09:18of primary route that we get sort of this divergent in terms
- 1:09:23of understanding Bitcoin versus everything else.
- 1:09:25It's it's just literally people taking the time to dig a little
- 1:09:30bit deeper than their, you know, existing sort of cursory view.
- 1:09:34The other component I I've been thinking about is more just like
- 1:09:38the market's going to tell us over time.
- 1:09:40Part of that is like what Jackson referenced earlier, like
- 1:09:43Bitcoin dominance, you have slowly just grinding upwards at
- 1:09:4660% of the market and growing. And then the other component too
- 1:09:51more recently is like, well, you know, the the corporate adoption
- 1:09:55and now sort of the nation state level adoption is occurring for
- 1:10:00a very specific asset, Bitcoin. You know, that sort of those
- 1:10:04upper tiers of these new forms of adoption is not occurring for
- 1:10:10the long tail of crypto assets. So that in and of itself is a
- 1:10:14market, you know, signal from the market in terms of new
- 1:10:17adoption that Bitcoin is fundamentally different than
- 1:10:21everything else and represents this sort of pristine collateral
- 1:10:26reserve type asset. Whereas if I'm being very
- 1:10:30generous about the rest of crypto, it's speculative tech
- 1:10:35plays more or less, which is is just fundamentally different
- 1:10:37than a long term sort of sound money reserve asset.
- 1:10:43And so I think that that, you know, while it's seems slow in
- 1:10:47real time like that, it is definitely shifting just in
- 1:10:50terms of the signals that we're getting from the market that
- 1:10:54these things are very different. There's a common theme that's
- 1:10:57come up three times so far, which has been investment of
- 1:11:00time and that's where the alpha is.
- 1:11:04The alpha doesn't exist by taking a very blunt view of an
- 1:11:09asset class, the alpha gets exposed when you get start to
- 1:11:13get an out of focus view and you bring it into sharp focus in the
- 1:11:16same way that we look at energy and we think, well that doesn't
- 1:11:19sound good. You put it into sharp focus.
- 1:11:21You realize that certain types of energy consumption are
- 1:11:24environmentally net positive. Similarly, you look at
- 1:11:27cryptocurrency and you think that includes Bitcoin.
- 1:11:30But when you look into it deeper and you go hang on a minute,
- 1:11:32Bitcoin has no founders. It had no ICO.
- 1:11:34It has a fixed cap supply of 21 million.
- 1:11:37It has the Lindy effect, which is working over 15 years.
- 1:11:40It has 60% market dominance. It's the only thing that nation
- 1:11:44States and corporate treasuries and family offices and pension
- 1:11:47funds and sovereign funds are looking at.
- 1:11:49That makes it fundamentally different, to give you another
- 1:11:52analogy. But what often happens is that
- 1:11:55things get conflated together before people get an intelligent
- 1:11:58understanding. So in another market, we saw
- 1:12:01this exact same thing play out as what happened in
- 1:12:04cryptocurrencies. So we have a fund right now that
- 1:12:09invests in Bitcoin mining companies who are using landfill
- 1:12:13gas as their energy source and we provide the infrastructure
- 1:12:16financing and we also get some juice on the top because we also
- 1:12:19in carbon credits because it's reducing carbon emissions
- 1:12:22because methane is 84 times more warming to the planet than
- 1:12:25carbon dioxide over a 20 year period.
- 1:12:27Now you may have heard that over the last couple of years the
- 1:12:31price of carbon on voluntary markets crashed.
- 1:12:34And there's a very specific reason that it crashed.
- 1:12:36And that's that a lot of people were behaving fraudulently.
- 1:12:40And what they were doing is they were registering these schemes
- 1:12:42in forest based carbon credit schemes.
- 1:12:44And they were saying that it was mitigating a certain amount of
- 1:12:47carbon emissions per year. And either the numbers were
- 1:12:49wildly overestimated or they were trying to claim projects
- 1:12:53which were not legitimate projects because they the
- 1:12:56projects were there anyway and they didn't need carbon credits
- 1:12:58in order to justify their existence.
- 1:13:01And there was a big expose of that.
- 1:13:02And what happened is the entire carbon market, voluntary markets
- 1:13:05crashed and then people looked a little bit more deeply and there
- 1:13:09was still a demand for carbon credits.
- 1:13:11And people said, well, hang on, there must be some other
- 1:13:13alternative. There must be a way for
- 1:13:14verifying whether these carbon credits are genuine, whether you
- 1:13:18can measure them or not. And people discovered, yes,
- 1:13:20there are, there are technology based credits as well.
- 1:13:23And that's things and that played into our hands because if
- 1:13:26you're looking at carbon credits that come from a landfill as
- 1:13:28opposed to from a forest, you can use telemetry to show
- 1:13:32exactly minute to minute exactly how many methane emissions that
- 1:13:36it's avoiding and therefore how many carbon equivalent emissions
- 1:13:39it's avoiding. So what happened to the markets
- 1:13:41then is then you've got this bifurcation where the forest
- 1:13:43based carbon credits are still trading low because people had
- 1:13:47lost faith in them as an instrument.
- 1:13:48But people's face rose in this particular type of carbon credit
- 1:13:53that was measurable up-to-the-minute and you could
- 1:13:55tell. So science based credits they
- 1:13:57called and they're now trading at a 50% premium.
- 1:14:00And the same thing happened with a couple of years ago with FTX
- 1:14:03collapsing and everything else collapsing.
- 1:14:06That brought down Bitcoin for the same reason that it was
- 1:14:10tarred with the same brush and people didn't understand it was
- 1:14:12different. And then people started to go
- 1:14:13hang on. FTX was nothing to do with
- 1:14:15Bitcoin. In fact, the founder of FTX, Sam
- 1:14:18Bachman Freed, hated Bitcoin and railed against it and funded
- 1:14:21politicians to speak against it. He didn't like, he said in the
- 1:14:24Financial Times two years ago, that Bitcoin has no future as a
- 1:14:28payments network, right? So this had nothing to do with
- 1:14:30Bitcoin. This had to do with the
- 1:14:31fraudulent behaviour of one person who is running an
- 1:14:34exchange. And as people started to
- 1:14:37understand that was not Bitcoin, then you saw Bitcoin start to
- 1:14:40rise, but the other forms of cryptocurrency did not rise.
- 1:14:44If you look at how Bitcoin is trading relative to Ethereum
- 1:14:47over the two year period, it's trading up and up and up and up.
- 1:14:50And I think that's because there's this increasing market
- 1:14:52sophistication which is starting to distinguish, but there is
- 1:14:55still more work to done to be done.
- 1:14:57And that really points to the importance of investing some
- 1:15:01time to understand these nuances because that's where you gain
- 1:15:04that offer. Yeah.
- 1:15:07What we've seen is everything that you guys just described
- 1:15:10that takes the time, but it also takes multiple people's time in
- 1:15:13these organizations. And these facts are objectively
- 1:15:17true. There's no shortage of research
- 1:15:18that if anybody spends the time, comes to the same conclusion.
- 1:15:21And what ends up happening is something that that I just like
- 1:15:24really felt viscerally. Is that 21 million is a very,
- 1:15:28very small number when you, when you really break down kind of
- 1:15:32the, the fact to Sam's point that nobody's really here yet
- 1:15:36from an institutional perspective, it's still so very
- 1:15:38early that they're still trying to figure out like the, through
- 1:15:41the fog of war, what's happened in digital assets And how do I
- 1:15:44just get my bearings so I don't end up in this, you know, FTX
- 1:15:48situation. And it takes so much consensus,
- 1:15:51so much committees like sitting in these large pools of capital
- 1:15:54that we're still so amazingly early.
- 1:15:55And that 21,000,000 number is so very small, especially when
- 1:15:59again for we, we know this, but maybe new listeners or
- 1:16:02institutional listeners that like 4 to 5 million of those
- 1:16:04coins will never be seen again just by nature of losses.
- 1:16:10And most of the rest of the 20 million, no one wants to sell
- 1:16:12them. That's exactly right.
- 1:16:18So gentlemen, maybe as we're kind of coming up on the tail
- 1:16:22end of the conversation, be curious to hear any viewpoints
- 1:16:25on what could accelerate or what could potentially decelerate
- 1:16:31Bitcoin adoption for institutional investors,
- 1:16:34businesses, family offices, high net worths into 2025.
- 1:16:38Are there any specific catalysts that you could see either
- 1:16:42positive or negative? Are there certain catalysts that
- 1:16:45have happened in the past weeks or months that you think are
- 1:16:49worth emphasizing further? Just curious to hear outlook as
- 1:16:53it relates to the investment case for Bitcoin for these types
- 1:16:55of allocators. So, OK, so a couple of things
- 1:17:03that spring to mind. So, well, actually, I guess, I
- 1:17:07guess the first one maybe covers both, because the first one is
- 1:17:12we've talked about the human emotions around Bitcoin now the
- 1:17:16Bitcoin network, just, you know, the whole TikTok next block meme
- 1:17:22and the Bitcoin network just continues every 10 minutes or so
- 1:17:26to, to confirm those transactions.
- 1:17:29So nothing changes there. What changes?
- 1:17:32What impacts the price is the human emotions around whether
- 1:17:37it'll succeed, will it not succeed, how much will it
- 1:17:39succeed, etcetera. And that I think will be the key
- 1:17:45determinant of whether we see, you know, what the next year has
- 1:17:50in store in terms of in terms of the price.
- 1:17:54Do we see human beings be more receptive to to and institutions
- 1:18:02in particular to this as an asset class and are they going
- 1:18:07to be more willing to dip their toe in the water?
- 1:18:11So I mean, none of us know the answer to that.
- 1:18:13I mean, in our own way, we're all trying to to encourage that
- 1:18:19for the right reasons, but we don't really know.
- 1:18:22I think, I think there's, I think there's the other example
- 1:18:26I was going to just mention was that when I was last on your
- 1:18:31podcast, I think it was February this year from memory.
- 1:18:36So I think I said then, which is always a bit risky because
- 1:18:42you're trying to predict the future.
- 1:18:44But I think I said given what we're seeing in the market, and
- 1:18:48this is markets generally, not not Bitcoin specifically.
- 1:18:53And in terms of where we are thinking about things from an
- 1:18:55Austrian economics point of view, which tells you nothing
- 1:18:58about timing, does tell you that we're on shaky ground as far as
- 1:19:03the economy is concerned. Then maybe we'll be having a
- 1:19:07recession in 12 to 18 months. I remember saying that.
- 1:19:11So thankfully we're not yet at the 12 or 18 months because it
- 1:19:14hasn't happened yet. And of course things can change
- 1:19:18like the, you know, I don't know you, you'll know better than me
- 1:19:21what impact the Trump administration could potentially
- 1:19:24have next year. But I think, you know, we are
- 1:19:28still on rocky ground economically.
- 1:19:30And therefore if we do get a big hit to markets, I think that'll
- 1:19:36particularly after the COVID one in 2020, I think that will mean
- 1:19:41that people look around again and think, OK, what's worked,
- 1:19:43What hasn't worked. And what would be interesting is
- 1:19:48if we see Bitcoin as a risk on assets due to its lack of
- 1:19:52counterparty risk rather than a risk.
- 1:19:56So risk off asset rather than risk on asset as it has been in
- 1:20:00the past. But yes, there's a couple of
- 1:20:02examples there. I think the other thing that's
- 1:20:06really going to drive adoption amongst institutionals is
- 1:20:09exactly what you're doing already, and that is by solving
- 1:20:13these custody issues and by getting the first CAB off the
- 1:20:16ranks, the first ever pension fund in the world that's had a
- 1:20:193% asset allocation. There's been other pension
- 1:20:22funds, but it was much smaller. This is the largest percentage
- 1:20:25allocation ever. Then others are more willing to
- 1:20:30follow because one of the big hesitations has been looking
- 1:20:33around at your peers and going, well, no one else is doing it.
- 1:20:35And that's no longer an objection now.
- 1:20:37And so people are going to be leaning in.
- 1:20:39And I know Sam, you've had a lot of inquiries, right?
- 1:20:41And I'm sure they're only going to continue.
- 1:20:46So that's tremendously important.
- 1:20:47And for example, now three years ago, Micro Strategy was the only
- 1:20:53company in the world that had Bitcoin on its corporate
- 1:20:55treasury. Now there are more than 60
- 1:20:57companies who have Bitcoin on its corporate treasury.
- 1:20:59So I see a very similar trajectory for pension funds,
- 1:21:02for sovereign funds, for family offices, where as soon as you
- 1:21:05have that first one who gets involved, others will follow.
- 1:21:08And unlike corporate treasury, it's actually easier to have
- 1:21:13Bitcoin on your corporate treasury with the board
- 1:21:14structures with public listed companies is pretty hard for
- 1:21:18institutional investors to get Bitcoin as an asset is
- 1:21:21relatively, it's not straightforward, but relative to
- 1:21:24the process of a pub Co going through getting Bitcoin on its
- 1:21:26corporate treasury is actually easier.
- 1:21:28So I think we'll see that follow much faster, particularly now
- 1:21:32that we've had the first one who is allocated a significant level
- 1:21:36and now we've got 3 pension funds in total around the world
- 1:21:39already just within six months who have allocated.
- 1:21:43That's what I quite like. About this is that historically
- 1:21:47Bitcoin has been a grassroots movement.
- 1:21:49It's been, you know, your your typical man on the street, woman
- 1:21:54on the street who was bought first, the retail investor
- 1:21:57rather than institutions. And there's something quite
- 1:22:00elegant about that. And interestingly, we're seeing
- 1:22:03the same thing with institutions.
- 1:22:05It is the smaller institutions that are more nimble and able to
- 1:22:09take these decisions quicker and understand the issues quicker
- 1:22:14that can take advantage of this before, you know, before the big
- 1:22:18firms come along. I.
- 1:22:20Think it's a great point, both Daniel and Sam that you made
- 1:22:23about the comparison between the work that you've done at
- 1:22:27Cartwright and recommending a 3% allocation, which is really a
- 1:22:31demonstration of again the time conviction and understanding of
- 1:22:35Bitcoin and it's difference against the broader digital
- 1:22:38asset space. And really viewing Bitcoin as,
- 1:22:41as you mentioned, an asymmetric return profile, a risk off
- 1:22:45investment within a portfolio versus some of the other larger
- 1:22:49institutional adoption that we've seen, particularly in the
- 1:22:52US, Just because that's what I would know better than other
- 1:22:54markets is typically see 10 basis point allocations or 50
- 1:22:58basis point allocations. And I'd imagine those will grow
- 1:23:01over time as a percentage of portfolio.
- 1:23:03And we'll certainly see more people follow that lead.
- 1:23:06But I think that speaks to the leadership at Cartwright, right?
- 1:23:10And Sam, you and the team understanding Bitcoin very
- 1:23:14deeply and because of that able to understand the merits not
- 1:23:18only from a reward perspective, from the absolute performance
- 1:23:23that Bitcoin can generate, but also from a risk adjusted basis.
- 1:23:26There's a ton of data that you can back into now that
- 1:23:29demonstrates that a 135, even 10% allocation can enhance the
- 1:23:34risk adjusted return of a portfolio that's predominantly
- 1:23:38comprised of traditional assets. So I think we will see larger
- 1:23:41allocations. It is just a function of
- 1:23:43institutional investors, you know, starting to have a more
- 1:23:47gradual exposure. And it also is likely that maybe
- 1:23:51these pension plans don't have people who are as convicted on
- 1:23:55the investment thesis of Bitcoin and haven't done as much work
- 1:23:58and had it not as much time in the market as as the two of you
- 1:24:02have. Yeah.
- 1:24:03The other, the other thing I wanted to highlight is just
- 1:24:07zooming out a bit and reflecting on just how much sort of the
- 1:24:13Overton window has shifted within the past, call it two to
- 1:24:16four years. You know, Daniel, you sort of
- 1:24:20alluded to this. Nobody in the institutional
- 1:24:21world wants to to put themselves out there 1st and do something.
- 1:24:25So it was always going to be this sort of gradually then
- 1:24:27suddenly type adoption from these these different cohorts.
- 1:24:32But just just, you know, thinking where we're at today in
- 1:24:36terms of both at the federal and the state level, we have
- 1:24:39multiple proposals for, you know, the United States
- 1:24:43government to be accumulating Bitcoin as a reserve asset.
- 1:24:47Like, just think about that fact relative to where we were four
- 1:24:50years ago when a lot of the institutional crowds main sort
- 1:24:53of worry about Bitcoin was that the government was going to ban
- 1:24:57it. It's like, OK, well, what if the
- 1:24:59government's not buying it? Like how does that, how does
- 1:25:01that change your priors on this thing?
- 1:25:04So I think it is important, you know, to just zoom out and
- 1:25:07contextualize how far we've come in terms of literally just the
- 1:25:10narrative shift and really what that enables in terms of air
- 1:25:14cover for institutional allocators to actually, you
- 1:25:18know, make some moved into the space.
- 1:25:19It's just a totally different environment than it was even 2
- 1:25:22four years ago. Well, gentlemen, appreciate the
- 1:25:28two of you carving out time. Daniel, first start with you.
- 1:25:32Do you want to give a hand off to folks where they can get in
- 1:25:35touch with you to learn more about the work you're doing?
- 1:25:37And then Sam will ask you to do the same.
- 1:25:41You have a newsletter which is called the Bitcoin ESG Forecast
- 1:25:47for obvious reasons. I substack newsletter.
- 1:25:50They can find me on Twitter slash X at DS Baton.
- 1:25:54Those are the best two places and my investment Bitcoin mining
- 1:25:58company infrastructure fund is Chapter 4 capital.com.
- 1:26:05So the best place, best place to get hold of me is either through
- 1:26:08our website cartwright.co.uk or I'm on LinkedIn so you'll be
- 1:26:14able to find me there. Excellent.
- 1:26:17Well, Daniel and Sam, thank you both for the time today.
- 1:26:20Really insightful conversation. We'll have to do it again soon.
- 1:26:23Thanks for joining us, guys. Thank you.
- 1:26:25Thank. You thanks for listening to this
- 1:26:29week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:26:31valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:26:33rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:26:36All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:26:38notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:26:41reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 1:26:43entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:26:46investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:26:49your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:26:52Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:26:56one of our private client advisors.