Latest / Leaders In Payments / Jonathan Silver, CEO & Len Covello, CTO at Engage People | Episode 349
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker 1: Welcome to the Leaders in Payments podcast, where we talk to C-level leaders from across the payments landscape.
- 0:06Speaker 1: We'll be discussing the products and services that impact the payment space today, as well as trends and predictions for the future of payments.
- 0:14Speaker 1: We will also hear stories from our guests about their journeys to the top.
- 0:18Greg Myers: Hello everyone and welcome to the Leaders in Payments podcast.
- 0:21Greg Myers: I'm your host, greg Myers, and today's special guests are Jonathan Silver, the CEO of Engage People, and Len Covello, the Chief Technology Officer of Engage People.
- 0:31Greg Myers: So, jonathan, len, welcome to the show.
- 0:33Greg Myers: Hey, greg, thanks for having us.
- 0:35Greg Myers: I'm happy to be here.
- 0:35Greg Myers: Great to be here, greg.
- 0:37Greg Myers: Jonathan, I'm going to lead off with you, but, len, feel free to jump in.
- 0:40Greg Myers: Jonathan, you were on the show a couple of years ago, so maybe remind our audience about Engage People's technology and sort of how your loyalty network works.
- 0:51Jonathan Silver: Sure.
- 0:51Jonathan Silver: As we discussed a couple of years ago, and all we've really done over the last couple of years is continue to expand and grow our network.
- 0:59Jonathan Silver: And so we have a vision of enabling members in loyalty programs to use their points as a form of payment at checkout.
- 1:07Jonathan Silver: And the goal is to democratize the usage of your points, to free them up and to create a better engagement.
- 1:16Jonathan Silver: And so what we've built is a set of rails, basically, where people can go to a retailer, tap their card and on the POS it'll say, hey, do you want to use your points for that transaction?
- 1:27Jonathan Silver: And so, look, it's difficult to do, but we've had great response, great uptake.
- 1:34Jonathan Silver: It's been really exciting.
- 1:36Greg Myers: Okay, Lynn, anything you'd like to add to that?
- 1:38Len Covello: I think John hit the nail on the head.
- 1:39Len Covello: It's one of those things and, greg, you'll notice in payments is what appears to be the simplest solution or kind of the easiest thing.
- 1:46Len Covello: There's definitely a lot going on in the background, so, while it's taken us some time to get there a lot of hard work, a lot of great partners and that ease of use or that frictionless transaction that you're seeing with our implementations out there we learned a lot about payments over the years, I'll say that, and I feel there's still a lot more to learn.
- 2:04Greg Myers: Okay, great, so Jonathan, back over to you.
- 2:07Greg Myers: So what is the business case for Pay With Points as a payment option?
- 2:13Jonathan Silver: So there are three constituents in the Pay With Points network.
- 2:16Jonathan Silver: There is the loyalty program, there's the member of the program and then the partner or the retailer that's accepting the points as a form of payment.
- 2:25Jonathan Silver: And so there, is a different value proposition for each three of those constituents.
- 2:30Jonathan Silver: For the member it is very much around driving a better member experience and getting better value for their points.
- 2:38Jonathan Silver: So that drives a higher engagement score, higher utilization.
- 2:43Jonathan Silver: In our credit card program we see an increase in the spend on the card from the members who use Pay With Points and an increase in retention, so there's a really good member benefit From the financial institution.
- 2:57Jonathan Silver: There is the member benefit, so higher engagement, higher spend as well, as we can actually derive the incremental value that they get from Pay With Points just in driving further utilization of cards.
- 3:16Jonathan Silver: in addition, to reduction of liability and if there aren't any cost per point savings.
- 3:20Jonathan Silver: So there is a very, very strong financial ROI on enabling paper points.
- 3:26Jonathan Silver: And then for the retailer they now get access to new customers.
- 3:31Jonathan Silver: We see an increase in spend from members who can use their points at a retailer and an increase in basket size, and it's at a lower transaction cost.
- 3:42Jonathan Silver: So there's a huge benefit to the retail partner in this network as well.
- 3:46Greg Myers: All right so, len, let's go over to you.
- 3:49Greg Myers: So you released a survey recently that found 84% of consumers would in fact use loyalty currency as a payment option in the future if it was offered by their credit card provider.
- 4:01Greg Myers: What do you feel is driving that demand?
- 4:03Greg Myers: I mean, 84% is a pretty high number.
- 4:06Len Covello: No, it is.
- 4:06Len Covello: I think the demand comes from a number of things.
- 4:09Len Covello: We've gone through some interesting I'll call it financial times the last number of years, starting with the pandemic and just the economy in general.
- 4:18Len Covello: So this is one of those things with inflation that's helping consumers kind of subsidize a payment.
- 4:23Len Covello: You can look at it as a discount.
- 4:25Len Covello: There's always been this connotation of loyalty that those points are kind of free money.
- 4:30Len Covello: We have the proverbial asterisks around that or quotes around that.
- 4:34Len Covello: So consumers are seeing that.
- 4:36Len Covello: And now when you're looking to transact for something, whether it's an everyday spend or an aspirational item, is that that cost is coming down for the consumer.
- 4:45Len Covello: So really what we see consumers using this as is not just a surprise and delight but an opportunity to drive down the cost on their everyday spend.
- 4:53Len Covello: And looking at a number like that 84% it's understandable on why people want to see those savings and why they want to use an additional currency out there that they have access to.
- 5:03Greg Myers: All right, Len, let's stick with you.
- 5:04Greg Myers: What makes Pay With points a differentiator compared to other alternatives like a buy now, pay later, which you see almost everywhere these days?
- 5:14Len Covello: I think the easiest thing to say is this is a stable currency.
- 5:18Len Covello: It's a currency that's out there.
- 5:19Len Covello: You have access to it.
- 5:20Len Covello: It's funded, so that currency is funded ultimately by the loyalty program, so there's no risk with it.
- 5:26Len Covello: The BNPL opportunity for consumers is a way to kind of take your payments and spread them out or kind of defer that payment out, but the consumer is still on the hook for the full value of the transaction.
- 5:38Len Covello: There's been other alternative payments out there.
- 5:40Len Covello: Crypto gained some steam a few years ago as possibly an alternative payment, but that had volatility with it.
- 5:50Len Covello: This is really almost like you're opening up another piece of your wallet and finding that money that you'd put away.
- 5:53Len Covello: When you take out a suit jacket that you hadn't worn in a few months and you've got that money there.
- 5:56Len Covello: That currency again is fully stable.
- 5:59Len Covello: It's ready to be used and, with Access Plus in the market today, it's used in real time.
- 6:06Len Covello: So this isn't a conscious effort that I'm going to go to the loyalty program and redeem for something and wait for that to arrive, or it's not a statement credit.
- 6:12Len Covello: This is a real-time ability to use that currency.
- 6:15Greg Myers: Yeah, and it seems like it's I don't know.
- 6:16Greg Myers: There's something that some excitement around it.
- 6:18Greg Myers: Right, it's like, oh, wow, I've generated all these points.
- 6:20Greg Myers: Wow, I've generated all these points, I need to spend them.
- 6:23Greg Myers: It just feels like there's an excitement factor to it.
- 6:26Len Covello: You're 100% right.
- 6:27Len Covello: It's bringing that back to loyalty.
- 6:29Len Covello: I'll steal John's thunder but we always talk about how loyalty kind of created this relationship and that was the point of it earlier on, when someone redeemed for an item and they got that reward.
- 6:38Len Covello: And then we saw this shift just in the industry in general, people moving to gift cards as a redemption option and that broke the relationship up from the program sponsor, the loyalty program and ultimately that reward of the redemption that the consumer had.
- 6:53Len Covello: So you'd earn a number of points you'd redeem for typically a gift card, because you didn't have that choice or that selection and you didn't know what you wanted.
- 7:00Len Covello: Put that in a drawer or you put that somewhere else and then ultimately you shopped a few months later and that relationship was gone.
- 7:06Len Covello: You didn't know what you wanted.
- 7:07Len Covello: Put that in a drawer or you put that somewhere else and then ultimately you shopped a few months later and that relationship was gone.
- 7:09Len Covello: You didn't kind of give the attribution to where it needed to come from.
- 7:10Len Covello: And that's come back with pay, with points.
- 7:12Len Covello: Now I know that when I'm tapping, when I'm checking out and I can use my points, I know exactly where that's coming from.
- 7:18Len Covello: It's building that bond back with the consumer and the loyalty program.
- 7:21Greg Myers: Okay, jonathan, over to you.
- 7:23Greg Myers: So we're coming off of Prime Day and Amazon is one of your big partners.
- 7:27Greg Myers: So how can using points help shoppers maximize sort of that user experience with Amazon?
- 7:36Jonathan Silver: So if you can explain what Len was talking about, if you think about a member experience historically because if I wanted to go redeem my points on Amazon, I would have to go back to the loyalty sponsor site, redeem a gift card, get an e-gift card via email, then go to Amazon, and so it's a disjointed experience.
- 7:55Jonathan Silver: What Access Plus does is create a single, one-stop inflow experience for a member.
- 8:02Jonathan Silver: So when you are on Amazon's website and there's a bunch of technical stuff in the background where we've linked your cards ahead of time, and so you show up to purchase an item and at checkout it just says hey, do you want to use your points for this?
- 8:18Jonathan Silver: Right in line, single transaction, single process.
- 8:21Jonathan Silver: And so when you think about a member uptake, we are seeing approximately one in four members of a loyalty program redeem with pay, with points, on an average of 3.9 times a year.
- 8:37Jonathan Silver: So it's a huge impact and a huge amount of engagement and member utilization.
- 8:43Jonathan Silver: And so then when Amazon runs its Prime Days, they have this huge spike in sales and we see I can't really share the data, but it's north of six, seven times increase for those days of point utilization and what we do see
- 9:02Jonathan Silver: and we're still doing a lot of research on this and getting feedback, but what we get anecdotally from members is they're waiting and prime day happens, and now they're getting an incremental benefit.
- 9:11Jonathan Silver: They're going hey, I'm getting the savings on Prime Day plus, I'm getting it even either for free or further reduced, and so people are waiting for it, and so what we'd like is the convergence of the largest e-commerce retailer in the world.
- 9:24Jonathan Silver: That's driving consumer behavior, and our members are jumping on board and actually enhancing that experience.
- 9:31Jonathan Silver: Look, it's been unbelievable from member utilization.
- 9:36Jonathan Silver: Hopefully it's great for Amazon, but we also know for our financial institution partners.
- 9:39Jonathan Silver: They get as excited as everyone else about seeing the engagement and the utilization during those days.
- 9:47Greg Myers: Sure.
- 9:47Greg Myers: So I guess the days of having loyalty points and then you have to go to this third-party website and you get to choose from travel and all these different options, and I guess those days are kind of gone.
- 10:00Greg Myers: Now, right, it's more instant gratification and it's the ability to use points on what you're buying today, as opposed to sort of leaving the retailer's site to go to this other marketplace or whatever.
- 10:12Greg Myers: I assume those days are pretty much gone.
- 10:14Jonathan Silver: They're going.
- 10:15Jonathan Silver: They're not gone yet.
- 10:16Jonathan Silver: But if you think about a member behavior, if I decide I need to go and buy a TV, I'm going to go to my favorite retailer to do that.
- 10:25Jonathan Silver: So unless we're doing a lot of marketing around, hey, you've got to come here and see this offer.
- 10:31Jonathan Silver: It's not part of people's consciousness.
- 10:33Jonathan Silver: Travel's a little bit different, because travel's a conscious decision.
- 10:36Jonathan Silver: They're large ticket items.
- 10:38Jonathan Silver: I'm going to do it once a year, once every couple of years, but for the everyday spend and the frequent transactions, it doesn't cross my mind to go.
- 10:46Jonathan Silver: I need to go and buy something.
- 10:48Jonathan Silver: Let me go back and see what's available on the website.
- 10:52Jonathan Silver: Where you do go, hey, I'm going to buy something, I'm going to get it on Amazon and, by the way, I'm going to have it this afternoon or tomorrow morning and now we can tap into that and further enhance and drive both loyalty and the member experience.
- 11:06Greg Myers: So, jonathan, you also have a partnership with the company Velocity Logic that's allowing BP gas stations to accept loyalty at the pump, which I think is a fascinating use case, so can you tell us more about that?
- 11:19Jonathan Silver: Sure.
- 11:19Jonathan Silver: So right now there's a huge focus on a lot of feedback from members around being able to use their points for everyday spend and, with inflation and everything we've been through over the couple of years, gas and grocery are the number one and number two item that everybody says to us.
- 11:36Jonathan Silver: That's where I want to use my points, and so we launched with BP and we are rolling out to numerous other gas stations over the next three to six months.
- 11:46Jonathan Silver: But the idea was allowing you to use your points to get a reduction in the price per gallon, and so a member would go out, they would insert their credit card to pay and it would say to you for X number of points do you want to save 50 cents a gallon?
- 12:01Jonathan Silver: Member said yes, and we actually rolled back the price at the pump and the response has been phenomenal.
- 12:09Jonathan Silver: We are getting a massive uptake on the offer.
- 12:13Jonathan Silver: It's running at about five or six times higher than we expected to go from an uptake point of view.
- 12:19Jonathan Silver: We are seeing multiple utilizations.
- 12:22Jonathan Silver: We see members coming back every couple of weeks to reuse the solution and reduce the price of their gas, and the number one feedback we get from members and from clients is well, where are the rest of them, when are the rest of the gas stations?
- 12:35Jonathan Silver: And so we are rolling out into four or five other major chains over the next couple of months.
- 12:41Jonathan Silver: So, Steve, you'll see those press releases and those announcements coming out shortly.
- 12:47Greg Myers: All right.
- 12:47Greg Myers: Well, this question is for both of you, but, Len, let's start with you.
- 12:50Greg Myers: What other opportunities are you seeing in the retail space?
- 12:55Len Covello: I think it's the integration of the pay-with points into the broader strategy for the retailers themselves.
- 13:00Len Covello: One of the things that's really important to us when we're talking about the implementation of this is trying to understand the broader strategy for that specific retailer and then the loyalty program as well.
- 13:11Len Covello: You don't want this to be disjointed.
- 13:12Len Covello: Once a consumer has an account with a specific retailer, our APIs can service up your points balance.
- 13:18Len Covello: They can service up that redemption piece.
- 13:20Len Covello: So now, as a consumer, if I'm in a mobile app or I'm on the website, think about, as you're scrolling through and you're searching for items, being able to show the value or the discount you have directly while looking at that product.
- 13:33Len Covello: So we talked about the TV during this call.
- 13:36Len Covello: If you're looking for a TV, we can show that discounted in real time for the consumer.
- 13:42Len Covello: So I still think there's a tremendous amount of opportunity on the marketing side and, ultimately, the consumer experience.
- 13:48Len Covello: Here.
- 13:49Len Covello: I think the payments piece is obviously the fundamental rails to make this magic happen, but exposing this to the retailers.
- 13:56Len Covello: We're excited to see what they'll do with it and what their UI and UX teams will do with this overall experience.
- 14:02Greg Myers: Okay, jonathan, in that same kind of vein.
- 14:04Greg Myers: We talked about Amazon, obviously so e-commerce, and then you talked about gas stations and everyday spend.
- 14:10Greg Myers: What other kind of retail environments are you seeing that are really starting to adopt this?
- 14:17Jonathan Silver: Yeah, so as we're rolling out over the next three-year plan of implementation, it's focused on specific areas further gas, everyday spend, groceries.
- 14:28Jonathan Silver: We're also now in conversation to integrate into POS and.
- 14:33Jonathan Silver: SMBs and small businesses so that you walk into the local coffee shop and you're all used to the screen that says you know, tap your card, do you want to go to it?
- 14:42Jonathan Silver: And the next screen will be do you want to use your points for this?
- 14:44Jonathan Silver: And so what it's allowing small businesses is the opportunity to get access to this huge base of members.
- 14:51Jonathan Silver: You know, today we have 40 million Businesses the opportunity to get access to this huge base of members.
- 14:55Jonathan Silver: Today we have 40 million active members.
- 14:56Jonathan Silver: We'll be over 140, 150 million in about a year.
- 15:01Jonathan Silver: So it's a huge base of consumers.
- 15:03Jonathan Silver: And so those are the two areas of focus for us Big chains, big footprints, and then a wide, long tail of small merchants Across the board.
- 15:09Jonathan Silver: For all of the merchants, what we're also now starting to get to is linking offers back and overlaying an offer with your redemption, so the ability to go to and say, hey, this person spends $100 a month with us.
- 15:21Jonathan Silver: Hey, if you spend $200, he has bonus points or a cashback and still use your points at checkout.
- 15:28Jonathan Silver: And so it's becoming very much a full circle way of the 360 view of how do I drive more engagement, how do I get members utilizing my location versus my competitor and driving better value for everybody along the way.
- 15:44Jonathan Silver: Beneficial of this beyond the financial institution and the retailer is the member who's getting a lot more value for their points and for their loft, and the retailer is the member who's getting a lot more value for their points and for their loft.
- 15:53Greg Myers: All right, so Len over to you.
- 15:54Greg Myers: So where have you found the most success in terms of implementing your strategy and fostering adoption?
- 16:04Len Covello: I'll go back to what I mentioned around the brands or the retailers that are really focused on the best way to use that experience.
- 16:08Len Covello: We talked about BP.
- 16:10Len Covello: It's a really elegant experience.
- 16:12Len Covello: I tap, I've got that offer coming to me in real time and I can use it accordingly.
- 16:17Len Covello: People have tried pay with points in different iterations in the past and there's been friction to this.
- 16:23Len Covello: It's been a post-transaction decision where you'll get a message, sms, text on your phone.
- 16:28Len Covello: Do you want to use points, yes, no, or consciously going in and looking at your transactions and applying your points later on.
- 16:34Len Covello: So it's really the consumer experience where we see the best adoption and the best implementations of this, and it's great.
- 16:41Len Covello: The partners we've been able to work with, some of the biggest brands in the world, are coming to the table, and they're coming to the table not with a let's implement this and see how this goes.
- 16:50Len Covello: It's a broader strategy of how they want this to be successful.
- 16:52Len Covello: So I would say again, really focusing not just on using those points, but how you're going to use those points as part of the transaction is where we see just fantastic adoption and great implementation.
- 17:04Greg Myers: Okay, so this question is for both of you, but, lynn, let's just stick with you.
- 17:08Greg Myers: Where do you see this heading in, say, the next two to three years?
- 17:11Greg Myers: Where's this loyalty space headed?
- 17:13Len Covello: This will be ubiquitous.
- 17:14Len Covello: I mean, john talked about the democratization of points.
- 17:17Len Covello: It'll be expected by consumers.
- 17:19Len Covello: It'll almost be odd if you're not able to use that currency in all your day-to-day transactions.
- 17:24Len Covello: Again, going back to the extremely stable funded currency that's available to consumers when I go to buy coffee, when I'm looking to book travel and all the transactions in between, when I'm heading off to the store, can I use this currency to send payments to other people?
- 17:43Len Covello: There's going to just be a lot of ways where people look at this currency not as that free money that was sitting on the side that I tapped into every few months or if not longer, but a currency that I expect to have available to me at all times.
- 17:56Len Covello: So that's where this is going, and nothing drives adoption bigger than consumer expectation and consumer demand, and we're seeing that.
- 18:03Len Covello: And again, I think we'll be on a chat in the not-too-distant future talking about how this is available everywhere.
- 18:09Greg Myers: Okay, Jonathan, your thoughts on that.
- 18:11Greg Myers: Where is this headed in the next few years?
- 18:13Jonathan Silver: Yeah, so exactly what Leonard said this will become ubiquitous, and then the next piece will be how do you use this to engage a member?
- 18:21Speaker 1: And so the ability to.
- 18:22Jonathan Silver: You know, everyone's connected on their phone, but the ability to put an offer inside of their wallet for them to go and say, oh, here's something special for me, to use my points and having those geotagged offers customized down to a specific segment of the population, offers customized down to a specific segment of the population we'll start to see the loyalty programs becoming closer to their end goal, which was how do I create a unique experience for a member that's relevant to them?
- 18:47Jonathan Silver: And the tools, the ubiquity of using your points as a form of payment and overlaying that with an offer will actually allow us to get to that original vision, which was I'm going to make this part of your everyday life and so you're going to become so intertwined with my loyalty program you're never going anywhere else.
- 19:07Greg Myers: So Len question for you how will loyalty points continue to impact payments?
- 19:13Len Covello: I think adoption of ideas and strategies by other fintechs out there.
- 19:18Len Covello: The fintech space has been incredible over the last number of years.
- 19:21Len Covello: You've seen these companies take legacy systems and just have a different spin on that, and the innovation we see from that is incredible.
- 19:30Len Covello: So we almost feel at Engage, this kind of I won't call it an obligation, but kind of this position to attend these payment events and speak at these events to let people know what's coming.
- 19:41Len Covello: And then we're excited.
- 19:42Len Covello: John and I have the fortunate opportunity to talk to companies saying what if we did this, or could we use your rails to do that?
- 19:49Len Covello: So I think we're going to see a lot of innovation Again.
- 19:51Len Covello: It's almost imagine a new currency being added to the world and with that comes everything that we see in payments.
- 19:57Len Covello: How are we moving that currency across borders?
- 20:00Len Covello: What are the other cool things we can do with that currency?
- 20:03Len Covello: Recurring payments, paying bills We've seen companies like Built transform an industry just with what they've done.
- 20:10Len Covello: And I'd argue some of the things we're going to see we're not even sure what they are yet.
- 20:14Len Covello: It's really some bright-minded startups out there that'll see what we're able to offer with our network and our rails and just build upon that.
- 20:22Greg Myers: Okay Well, jonathan Lynn, we've covered a lot of ground, obviously, about the company and what you guys are doing, some of your partners and the innovative stuff that they're working on and that you guys are helping them with.
- 20:33Greg Myers: So is there anything else you'd like to cover before we wrap up the show?
- 20:37Jonathan Silver: This is exciting.
- 20:38Jonathan Silver: It's changing an industry and it's allowing our clients and our partners to actually deliver value, and so it's an exciting time to be in the middle of all of this and, as Leonard said, it's going to evolve rapidly but it is going to become ubiquitous and glad to be part of this growing trend.
- 20:57Greg Myers: Len any final thoughts.
- 20:59Len Covello: Just echoing that it's a journey.
- 21:00Len Covello: It's one of those things that, when you look back, it took longer than you expected from the initial idea.
- 21:06Len Covello: I remember John talking about this earlier on on how to use that payments at checkout but we're there.
- 21:12Len Covello: We're in this incredible, exciting time of just huge adoption.
- 21:15Len Covello: The advantage we sit in the world today in fintechs is that things come to market very quickly and we're able to deploy things quickly.
- 21:22Len Covello: So it's just a really exciting time for us and, I think, for the industry as a whole.
- 21:27Len Covello: So it's a transformation in loyalty and we're seeing some great stuff from a lot of companies.
- 21:31Len Covello: So, again, just an exciting time.
- 21:34Greg Myers: Okay, great.
- 21:35Greg Myers: Well, thank you both so much for being here.
- 21:37Greg Myers: I know your time is very valuable, so thank you again for being on the show today.
- 21:41Jonathan Silver: Great Thanks for having us.
- 21:43Greg Myers: Pleasure Great, and to all you listeners out there, I thank you for your time as well.
- 21:46Greg Myers: Until the next story.
- 21:49Speaker 1: Thank you for joining us this week on the Leaders in Payments podcast.
- 21:52Speaker 1: Make sure you visit our website at leadersinpaymentscom, where you can subscribe to the show and where you'll find our show notes.
- 21:59Speaker 1: If you enjoyed listening, please share on your social channels as well.