Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Tech Companies Withdraw Guidance in a Selloff
Transcript
- Lucas: Let's start with what's happening right now: July 27th, 2026. Tech stocks are in a broad selloff. Tesla down 18.6 percent in five days, Meta off 7.8 percent, NVIDIA down 5 percent. If you're a post ipo company watching your stock drop like that, one of the first strategic decisions you face is whether to adjust or even withdraw your forward guidance. Luna: Withdrawing guidance feels drastic. Most companies give annual or quarterly revenue projections. Pulling them altogether signals something serious. Lucas: It does. But it's actually a well-established tool, and it's protected by the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act's safe harbor. That means if a company withdraws guidance because of genuine uncertainty, it can't be sued for forward-looking statements that turn out wrong. The key is that the withdrawal has to be timely and clearly communicated. Luna: So it's not just about avoiding a lawsuit. It's also about resetting expectations. Take a cloud software company that went public in 2024. Their stock had been sliding all year, and in Q2 they decided to pull full-year guidance entirely. Lucas: Right, and that's a perfect case. The company said 'we can't reasonably forecast the rest of the year given macro uncertainty.' The stock actually ticked up on the news because investors no longer had a target to anchor downside expectations. It removed a source of negative momentum. Luna: But isn't there a credibility risk? If you withdraw guidance too often, analysts start to question whether management knows its own business. Lucas: Absolutely. It's a signaling game. The market interprets a withdrawal as either prudence or confusion. Data shows that companies that withdraw guidance more than once in a two-year period tend to see a higher cost of capital. Analysts widen their estimate ranges, which increases volatility. So it's not a free move. Luna: So when does it make sense? Is it only when the macro shock is truly unexpected, like a tariff surprise or a sudden demand drop? Lucas: Exactly. The current selloff is mostly driven by rotation out of growth stocks and fears of a slowdown. If you're a post ipo company that's still unprofitable or burning cash, guidance becomes a huge liability. By withdrawing, you buy time to execute without the market penalizing every miss. Luna: But then you have to re-establish guidance eventually. How do companies navigate that transition? Lucas: They usually come back with a shorter horizon—say, one quarter instead of a full year. Or they provide a very wide range. The goal is to slowly rebuild credibility. Some companies even replace numerical guidance with qualitative statements, like 'we expect growth to be in line with the industry.' That's less precise but harder to fail. Luna: I remember a notable example from a few years ago: a high-profile fintech IPO that withdrew guidance during the 2022 downturn. They didn't reinstate it for five quarters. When they finally did, they also changed the metrics they reported, shifting from transaction volume to revenue. Lucas: Good point. That's a key move—changing the metric you guide on. It's a way to reset the narrative. For post ipo companies, the investor relations team has to work closely with legal to draft the withdrawal language. You can't just say 'we're done'; you need to explain why and what to expect next. Luna: And the timing matters. If you withdraw right before earnings, it looks like you're hiding bad news. Better to do it a few weeks earlier, after a major macro event or a big customer loss. Lucas: Exactly. If this episode is giving you something useful for what you're building or running, we hope you'll consider supporting the show. It stays ad-free thanks to listeners who buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Even a small contribution helps us keep these conversations independent and free of sponsor clutter. Luna: Yeah, it really does make a difference. We hear from people who say our episodes helped them think through an IR challenge or a capital markets decision. That's what keeps us going. Lucas: Back to guidance withdrawals: one more nuance. There's a difference between a withdrawal and a suspension. A withdrawal is permanent—you're done with guidance for that period. A suspension is temporary, often done during a quiet period or M&A. But the market treats both similarly. Luna: So the big takeaway for post ipo companies: guidance is a double-edged sword. In a selloff, withdrawal can be a circuit breaker, but it comes at a cost. Use it sparingly. Lucas: And if you do it, communicate clearly, lean on the safe harbor, and have a plan to reinstate. That's how you turn a defensive move into a strategic one.