Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Entertainment Tax Today: Catalogs, Compensation & Compliance
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Entertainment Text Today Catalogues,
- 0:06Compensation and Compliance. I'm Philipp Beran,
- 0:09Chair of the BHBA Taxation Law Section. The tax
- 0:13section is sponsored by Hochmann, Salk and Torscher
- 0:16Perez. The Hochmann, Salk and Torscher Perez
- 0:18BC advantages experience and eye for innovation
- 0:21and a genuine dedication to clients, their families
- 0:24and their business. In addition to their national
- 0:26practice and civil... civil tax and criminal
- 0:29tax controversy and related litigation in federal
- 0:32and state court. The firm is also active in white
- 0:35collar defense. I'm delighted to introduce our
- 0:39speakers, Bob Jason, Shane Nix and Jonathan Kalinsky.
- 0:43Bob Jason is a partner at MKSFBLLP and an internationally
- 0:48recognized tax expert who advises high profile
- 0:52clients and companies across entertainment, technology
- 0:55and sports. A frequent national lecturer and
- 0:59long -time contributor to leading tax publication,
- 1:02he brings deep expertise in compensation planning,
- 1:05startups and complex transaction. Jane Nix is
- 1:09the partner of the Tax Department Entertainment
- 1:12Transaction Practice at Wilkie, Farr and Gallagher
- 1:15LLP, advising companies and high -profile talent
- 1:19on complex transactional tax matters across the
- 1:22entertainment industry. Recognized by billboard
- 1:25and variety for his impact in the field, he serves
- 1:28as a trusted advisor on acquisition, restructuring,
- 1:32and copyright related issues, while also bringing
- 1:34the worlds of entertainment and technology, bridging
- 1:39the worlds, sorry. Jonathan Kalinsky is principal
- 1:43at Hoffman's Hawk and Torscher Press, who focuses
- 1:46on complex civil and criminal tax controversies,
- 1:49sensitive offshore disclosure matters, and federal
- 1:51and state issues for individuals, entities, and
- 1:53fiduciaries worldwide. A former IRS trial attorney
- 1:57and US tax court attorney advisor, he brings
- 2:00extensive experience handling examination appeals
- 2:03and high stakes tax disputes. And now let's get
- 2:07started. Bob, I'll hand it over to you. Thank
- 2:10you, Philip. And welcome, everybody. I'm Bob
- 2:14Jason. I'm going to moderate this presentation
- 2:17this afternoon. We're gonna start with Shane
- 2:20Nix, who along with Jonathan Kalinsky are two
- 2:25of the most talented tax advisors in anywhere.
- 2:30And I'm very, very pleased to be moderating this
- 2:33panel with them. I'm gonna hand it over to Shane
- 2:36and we'll proceed from there. So Shane, go right
- 2:39ahead. Hello, everyone. So I'm going to start
- 2:43today and what I'm going to generally cover is
- 2:46some common topics that come up in the entertainment
- 2:48industry. Starting first with production, company
- 2:53financing, talent services, music catalog sales,
- 2:59issues that arise with copyright, reversion issues,
- 3:04security expenses. And then I'm going to turn
- 3:06it over to Bob regarding endorsement deals. And
- 3:09along the way, Jonathan. or Bob may chime in
- 3:14and add some color to some of the topics that
- 3:17I'll be going through. So first, going on to
- 3:20the first slide, a common topic that arises in
- 3:25film finance is... Section 181 and so to give
- 3:29some context to to section 181 and what it actually
- 3:32does the the general default rule historically
- 3:36is that when you create an intangible asset that
- 3:39your costs have to be capitalized into the tax
- 3:41basis of that asset and You can't start depreciating
- 3:45that asset until it's placed in service which
- 3:47for purposes of 181 is the initial release or
- 3:51broadcast so when it's when it's first released
- 3:54for commercial benefit and monetizing the underlying
- 3:57asset. Now where 181 becomes useful in practice
- 4:02is that particularly for independent films that
- 4:06are being produced like through a partnership
- 4:09LLC, for example, what happens is that in industry
- 4:15practice, sometimes people do not want to, sometimes
- 4:20people do not Hi, Shane. It looks like you're
- 4:30muted. It looks like something happened with
- 4:32the camera. Oh, sorry. Yeah, apologies for that.
- 4:36Yeah, what I was saying was that the purpose
- 4:40of the 181 election is to accelerate cost recovery.
- 4:47So you might have an LLC as a production entity
- 4:51that's taxed as a partnership. To bring in investment
- 4:55tax -free, into the partnership is really done
- 4:58one of two ways. It's either by capital contribution
- 5:02that you give the investor equity in the LLC
- 5:07in exchange for that or as a true bona fide debt
- 5:11for income tax purposes. As an industry practice,
- 5:14however, sometimes the way that films are structured
- 5:17in terms of financing is that the LLC will enter
- 5:21into an investor agreement with the particular
- 5:24investor And the invest in that context for tax
- 5:29purposes, that's not treated as debt because
- 5:31it doesn't meet all of the various criteria to
- 5:34be treated as debt for federal income tax purposes.
- 5:37And if they're not getting an actual equity interest
- 5:41in the LLC, it's not gonna be treated as a tax
- 5:43free contribution. So the next question is, well,
- 5:45if it's not debt or equity, what is it? And under
- 5:48these investor agreements that are commonly used,
- 5:51ultimately, what it really is for income tax
- 5:54purposes is that the LLC is effectively selling
- 5:57a right to receive future proceeds in the film,
- 6:00which would be a currently taxable transaction.
- 6:04And how that's reported on a tax return is up
- 6:08to the underlying accountants. But typically,
- 6:10from a peer general tax perspective, that's taxable
- 6:14income upon receipt. if you're under the default
- 6:17rule where you have to capitalize your production
- 6:20expense, then unless you release the project
- 6:23in the first year when you receive that cash
- 6:26investment, then you're going to have taxable
- 6:30income without a corresponding deduction to offset
- 6:32that income. So where section 181 comes into
- 6:35play is that if the LLC is eligible for section
- 6:38181, when that income is received, as long as
- 6:43that income is spent in the same year that it's
- 6:45received, 181 allows the LLC to deduct expenses
- 6:50as and when incurred rather than requiring those
- 6:53expenses to be capitalized and then depreciated
- 6:56over a 10 -year period. So to qualify for Section
- 6:59181, 181 was enacted to encourage investment
- 7:03in the U .S. So the general requirement is that
- 7:0675 % of the above -the -line costs for services,
- 7:12which would be to directors, production personnel,
- 7:15writers, etc. 75 % of those costs need to be
- 7:20for compensation for services that are performed
- 7:22in the United States. So if you meet that requirement,
- 7:27then the entity LLC, who's the owner of the underlying
- 7:30production, i .e. the copyright, has to make
- 7:33an election on its tax return, which is made
- 7:36in the first year that the principle production
- 7:41has started, you have to make the 180 election
- 7:43with respect to that tax return year. And historically,
- 7:48181 has included qualified film and TV productions,
- 7:51which would have this, you know, the 75 % compensation
- 7:55requirement that I just mentioned. And there's
- 7:58also live theatrical performances that can qualify
- 8:00as well. That work usually typically comes more
- 8:04so in my experience outside of New York. So historically,
- 8:07I've done a little bit of uh the live production
- 8:10181 planning but for the most part it's been
- 8:14in the film and tv context now interestingly
- 8:17as part of the one big beautiful bill act that
- 8:20was passed in july section 181 was amended to
- 8:24include uh qualified sound recordings which allows
- 8:28the nlc to you know deduct costs as and when
- 8:33incurred up to 150 000 per tax year with respect
- 8:37to sound recordings Now, 181 was amended, but
- 8:42interestingly, it was not extended. So effectively,
- 8:47181 is set to expire before, you know, by any
- 8:51productions that would commence after January
- 8:541st, 2026. Section 181, however, is on a House
- 9:00bill that's being considered in Congress, but
- 9:04presumably has been delayed given the government
- 9:07shutdown. um that that just you know the government
- 9:10just reopened up recently so we'll see how soon
- 9:13that gets passed if at all um historically prior
- 9:17to the tcja which was the 2017 tax act 181 was
- 9:22always passed as part of the year -end extenders
- 9:26bill. So during the year, people were working
- 9:28under the assumption that 181 is not available
- 9:31because it had already expired. And then as part
- 9:33of the year -end extenders bill, 181 get passed
- 9:36retroactively and then now all of a sudden people
- 9:38could plan. So that framework defeats the purpose
- 9:42of tax planning because it's always been passed
- 9:45in retrospect. Other than as part of Biden's
- 9:49tax bill, 181 was passed prospectively through
- 9:54the end of January, 2026. And so people along
- 9:57the way have been able to plan for their film
- 10:00productions. Can you move to the next slide,
- 10:02please? So under the TCJA, one of the additional
- 10:13provisions that have been enacted is that under
- 10:16bonus depreciation, which allows for the taxpayer
- 10:21to qualify to deduct 100 % of the capitalized
- 10:28cost. So this is also an exception to the general
- 10:31rule that you have to capitalize your costs and
- 10:33then you have to wait until it's placed in service,
- 10:36wait till the project's placed in service, which
- 10:37could be a number of years later in practice
- 10:40because of the timing in terms of when productions
- 10:43get. or the time needed to produce a film and
- 10:47also with the writer's strikes and the actor
- 10:50strikes that happen, anything can, you know,
- 10:52occur along the way that might end up pushing
- 10:55out the slated date for the release. And so what
- 10:59bonus depreciation does is that under the TCJA
- 11:04in 2017, qualified property was defined to include
- 11:11qualified property under Section 181, which is
- 11:13qualified film and TV productions, qualified
- 11:17live theatrical performances, and now qualified
- 11:20sound productions. So as you see on this slide
- 11:23is basically a summary of now bonus depreciation
- 11:28is going to be permanent after the One Big Beautiful
- 11:31Bill Act going forward. prior under the TCJA,
- 11:35it was 100 % depreciation up until I think 2023,
- 11:39and then it started to phase out. So instead
- 11:41of getting 100%, you got 80 % in 23, 60 % in
- 11:4624 and so on, such that at the end of this year,
- 11:49bonus depreciation was gonna go away, but it's
- 11:51now been extended permanently. Now that still
- 11:53doesn't, if you go to the next slide, that still
- 11:58doesn't solve, some of those investor issues
- 12:02that I raised earlier because a key distinction
- 12:06between bonus depreciation and 181 is that 181,
- 12:09you get to deduct expenses as and when incurred.
- 12:13With bonus depreciation, you still have to capitalize
- 12:15your costs, and then you can take the bonus,
- 12:18which is 100%, but you can't take it until it's
- 12:21placed in service. So you still have to wait
- 12:22until the initial release or broadcast in order
- 12:24to take 100 % of the bonus depreciation. One
- 12:29of the articles that I referenced on my prior
- 12:31slide, which in the materials is a link to the
- 12:33actual article, it explains what the issue is
- 12:36in production between 181 and bonus depreciation.
- 12:41One other key distinction between 181 and bonus
- 12:44depreciation is that under section 181, you can
- 12:47only, if you qualify and you make the election,
- 12:50It's on a project by project basis. So for a
- 12:53film or TV production, it's for that specific
- 12:56film or TV production. A sequel would be a new
- 12:58production that you can make a 181 election on.
- 13:02For a TV series, you can only make the 181. Each
- 13:06episode in the series is treated as a separate
- 13:09production, and you're limited to making 181
- 13:13for the first 44 episodes of a series. But if
- 13:17you don't have 181, you still have the timing
- 13:20investment. What you see on this slide is just
- 13:23an illustration of the structuring. So what you
- 13:27see here is like a preferred equity interest.
- 13:29That would be where the investor is actually
- 13:31getting admitted to the LLC as a member. So it's
- 13:34a tax -free contribution of capital that will
- 13:38be used to produce the film. There's an indirect
- 13:42ownership by the investor through the LLC interest
- 13:45so that when the production LLC in this example,
- 13:49makes a 181 election. Any losses that are generated
- 13:52from that election, as and when those expenses
- 13:55are incurred, can flow up directly to the owners,
- 13:59including the investors. And that's a robust
- 14:02way to structure a 181 election. On the right
- 14:07there, where you see a ride -along investment,
- 14:08that's what's a common structure, where you just
- 14:11have this investor agreement, but there's no
- 14:14equity, and it's not treated as debt. raises,
- 14:18you will see in practice that sometimes people
- 14:20will say, you know, they will argue that you
- 14:23don't have to own the production in order to
- 14:26make a 181 election. That is just patently false.
- 14:31The regulations require that you have to own
- 14:34the production in order to make the 181 election.
- 14:37So the investor is not going to be able to get
- 14:39the benefit of 181 or bonus because they do not
- 14:41own directly or indirectly the underlying production.
- 14:45There is case law that would that suggests that
- 14:47an investor could qualify for the income forecast
- 14:51method, which would mean that they would deduct
- 14:54their investment over a 10 year period based
- 14:57on their projected income, which for some productions
- 15:01that might be in the first one or two years.
- 15:03And so effectively you might be getting still
- 15:05an accelerated deduction by nature of the underlying
- 15:08facts rather than law, depending on the projections
- 15:12of the income. Moving on to the next slide. And
- 15:18I'm going to skip through a lot of these next
- 15:20slides to the next topic. This just covers a
- 15:23lot of stuff that I already talked about. And
- 15:26there's a summary here of the differences between
- 15:30the default method, which is the income forecast
- 15:32method. And that would apply to foreign productions.
- 15:35It may also apply to US productions. But bonus
- 15:40depreciation is effectively, I believe you would
- 15:43just. you know, reported as bonus depreciation
- 15:46if you're a qualified production. You don't have
- 15:49the 15 million dollar limit that you have with
- 15:52181. So you can really, if it's a qualified U
- 15:54.S. production, you can really take everything
- 15:57immediately as and when it's placed in service.
- 16:00So if it's a qualified U .S. production, more
- 16:02likely you're going to be, if you're not eligible
- 16:04for 181, you're going to be reporting under bonus
- 16:07depreciation. But foreign productions are going
- 16:09to be under the income forecast method, which
- 16:11requires that you wait until you place it in
- 16:13service, and then you have to deduct it over
- 16:1510 years based on your income projections. On
- 16:20the next slide, this is just a summary of considerations
- 16:24that we'll kind of skip through, but you can
- 16:26use for reference. Going on to the next topic.
- 16:30Shane, before we move on, I just wanted to offer
- 16:34my two cents from a controversy perspective on
- 16:37181. We've seen some activity by the IRS in this
- 16:43area. There are some investors who have done
- 16:48leveraged 181 deals where they would put in some
- 16:53cash in exchange for a note. Uh, and there has
- 16:57been, uh, some IRS audit activity. So that's,
- 17:01uh, I think a topic that is still developing,
- 17:04um, and one that, uh, is to be continued to see
- 17:10where that heads, but, um, the IRS, uh, has looked
- 17:15at several of those deals. Yeah. And there is
- 17:18a case I'm actually writing an article right
- 17:20now that should be released in December, um,
- 17:22that there's a case that came out in appellate
- 17:25ninth circuit that I think the inference is that
- 17:29it was arising from 181 but it goes to the points
- 17:31that you're making about putting in a note where
- 17:34you have it's an unsecured note etc. So that's
- 17:37something to keep in mind people may be trying
- 17:39to plan around that. The next topic since we're
- 17:43cutting down I want to make sure that Jason Bob
- 17:46Jason has enough time to go through his materials
- 17:50as well. The next topic just to do it 15 second
- 17:54overview is just loan out companies. That's that
- 17:57alone out company is what you'll hear that it's
- 17:59an industry term of art. It's basically that
- 18:03any any talent, particularly in the film and
- 18:05TV space, they're going to use a C Corp or Nest
- 18:08Corp to engage their services with the studio.
- 18:12And that's largely because studios will whether
- 18:16or not you're treated as an employee for under
- 18:18the income tax rules. By default studios will
- 18:22tend to treat individual engagements as an employment
- 18:26relationship which then requires withholding
- 18:30on compensation paid and it also jeopardizes
- 18:34legitimate business expenses given that miscellaneous
- 18:38itemized expenses of employees are no longer
- 18:40deductible. So I'll skip I'm going to skip through
- 18:44this content and go to California SP422, which
- 18:50Jonathan, if you want to cover that. Yeah, Bob,
- 18:54do you want to? I guess I'll just do it now since
- 18:58we're here. Go ahead. Okay, perfect. So if you
- 19:05could go back a couple of slides. Back one more,
- 19:08back one more. There we go. So the area of loanouts
- 19:14became somewhat contentious. About a year or
- 19:18so ago, you may have read in the trades that
- 19:24the EDD, California EDD was looking into the
- 19:28issue of loanouts, particularly the use of MPPSC's
- 19:33Motion Picture Payroll Production Company. These
- 19:37were the companies who pay, by and large, all
- 19:43of the entertainment industry. And the EDD was
- 19:48calling into question the payment of loan outs.
- 19:52And the particular topic that they were looking
- 19:55at is essentially proposing to disregard the
- 20:00loan out and say that the performer was the direct
- 20:05employee of the MPPSC. And this would be under
- 20:10code section 679 of the CUIC. from the EDD's
- 20:18perspective, the way they looked at it was they
- 20:24can maybe understand above the line, actor, director,
- 20:28writers having loan outs. But in practice, as
- 20:33the loan out issue evolved over time, it was
- 20:37being widely used below the line in areas that
- 20:40you previously didn't. And so they also found
- 20:45significant non -compliance among the loan outs.
- 20:49And instead of going after each individual loan
- 20:52out, they decided, isn't it easier if we just
- 20:56use 679 to go after the MPSC's, the payors. Within
- 21:03that area even, I think what you saw was it was
- 21:08not the big studios who would pay certain loanouts
- 21:14that may not be registered, may not have certain
- 21:17issues. These would be independent studios that
- 21:21may come or go by the year, by the month, that
- 21:25had issues with compliance, that were entering
- 21:29into agreements with entities that typically
- 21:32would not have been entered into by a major studio.
- 21:35And the job of the MPPSC is essentially to just
- 21:40pay out the funds as they're earned by the individual
- 21:43by the loan out. If you were an individual with
- 21:47no loan out you were being paid directly by the
- 21:51MPPSC and you're being treated as an employee
- 21:54of that MPPSC. That's the 679 and this was legislation
- 21:58that went back to when Arnold Schwarzenegger
- 22:01was governor and was seen as cleaning up an issue
- 22:05that had been a problem that was a very entertainment
- 22:08industry favorable section to make things simplified.
- 22:15The MPPSC's typically would pay the loan outs
- 22:19directly and because they're paying an entity,
- 22:21there is no 1099. It's up to the loan out to
- 22:26pay their owner, the performer as an employee.
- 22:31where there was abuse was that loan out was not
- 22:36always registered with the EDD, was not paying
- 22:39payroll taxes. And during the pandemic and the
- 22:43strikes, you saw a lot of unemployment claims
- 22:46being filed listing the MPPSCs as the employer.
- 22:52And so what happened was you had obstructed claims.
- 22:56The EDD would say yes. we think this person is
- 22:59an employee, and then we determine them to be
- 23:02an employee of the MPPSC, you audit, and that's
- 23:06how this issue came to a head. So the EDD relied
- 23:13on an old case from 1975 called Cooperman, and
- 23:18then Code Section 679. What ended up happening,
- 23:22and I was involved in this process, The legislation
- 23:28along with several parts of the entertainment
- 23:32industry came up with, and in conjunction with
- 23:37EDD, with legislation that was passed, and that's
- 23:41SB 422. What that does, next slide please. Next
- 23:50slide, you can skip a couple. To SB, yeah, there
- 23:53we go. So that was signed by Governor Newsom
- 23:58in September of last year, and basically codifies
- 24:02the loan out. And remember, this is within California,
- 24:07but specifies that a loan out company is the
- 24:09employer of the employee owners. So think of
- 24:13your actor, your director, and in reality, a
- 24:18lot of below the line workers have adopted a
- 24:21loan out. for themselves, and we can get to some
- 24:25reasons why that might be, but it is the loan
- 24:28out that is the employee, the employer, and the
- 24:32worker, the owner who is the employee. It is
- 24:35not the MPPSC. Specifically, the legislation
- 24:40says we are not overruling Cooperman, and this
- 24:44is not intended to limit UI benefits. So the
- 24:48way to do it is if you have a loan out, and you're
- 24:52in a period of unemployment, you file a claim,
- 24:55you file that claim and say that your loan out
- 24:58is the employer. To do so, you have to be registered
- 25:02with the EDD. Register with the EDD. If you're
- 25:05loan out, if you have clients whose loan outs
- 25:07are not registered with the EDD, because of this
- 25:12law, the EDD is going to have no choice but to
- 25:15start looking directly at the loan outs, not
- 25:18the MPPSC. The other important thing I want to
- 25:23highlight here is that loanouts are corporations
- 25:26or LLCs classified as corporations for federal
- 25:30tax purposes, not partnerships. If you have a
- 25:34partnership, you technically don't qualify as
- 25:37a loan out and should not be paid by the MPPSC
- 25:42as a loan out. Beginning next quarter, first
- 25:48quarter of 2026, the MPPSCs are required to start
- 25:52filing reports to send into the EDD the payments
- 25:58to the loanouts and then the identification information.
- 26:03So this sets up a system very similar to if somebody
- 26:09receives a W -2 or a 1099, the IRS knows what
- 26:12you've got. If that doesn't fall on your tax
- 26:15return, they've got this matching system that
- 26:18is usually how most audits end up. That's going
- 26:22to happen here. If the MPPSCs report certain
- 26:26loan outs and those loan out companies don't
- 26:30report, aren't registered, expect to see audits,
- 26:35even if these are one -person companies, the
- 26:39EDD is essentially left with no choice. One of
- 26:43the issues here, though, I can envision is going
- 26:45to be if a loan out makes a million dollars but
- 26:49pays wages of, say, 200 ,000, you're inherently
- 26:55going to see a mismatch here. That's not necessarily
- 27:00a problem. That's a very common setup. but it
- 27:05may result in some questions being asked. And
- 27:11we'll just have to see how this issue evolves.
- 27:15Also note that, again, this is only California.
- 27:19So other states where we have not seen this issue,
- 27:24but that doesn't mean you won't see it in the
- 27:28future. Yeah, we'll just have to see how this
- 27:34plays out. Mike, so we'll make a comment, Jonathan,
- 27:38on the viability of loan out corporations generally.
- 27:42This is an issue that was extremely concerning
- 27:46years ago in the era when loan out corporations
- 27:52really took off and became very popular and the
- 27:55IRS took the position, and maybe they still believe
- 27:59it, that loan out companies are just shams that
- 28:05you don't need, and that the only purpose of
- 28:08loan out corporations is for the tax benefits
- 28:10to the individual. And those tax benefits are
- 28:14substantial, but I have not seen in the relatively
- 28:20recent past any wholesale attacks on loan out
- 28:25corporations. So my view remains that loan out
- 28:30corporations are here to stay. There may be attacks
- 28:34on them from time to time, like California. But
- 28:39generally speaking, they are a very incredibly
- 28:42valuable planning tool for talent. Yeah, and
- 28:46just adding on to that, the case that I mentioned
- 28:48in a couple previous slides, Sergeant V Commissioner
- 28:50from the sergeant yeah yeah from the 90s um the
- 28:54takeaway there um is in my in my view is that
- 28:59the two requirements there's a code section 269
- 29:03cap a that gives the irs discretion to ignore
- 29:06an entity for tax purposes if it's being used
- 29:09solely for tax avoidance purposes um in in the
- 29:12sergeant case the taxpayer end of winning the
- 29:14the sergeant case dealt with hockey players that
- 29:17were using loan out companies which now we we
- 29:20know that you know in is an industry practice
- 29:22athletes are generally treated as ww2 employees
- 29:25now but the sergeant case still applies for other
- 29:28you know film and tv and other areas where loanouts
- 29:31are still in existence but the two general requirements
- 29:33on takeaway in my mind from sergeant is that
- 29:36you have to have the corporation has to have
- 29:38control over the talent's activity and you have
- 29:42to follow corporate formality. So a key component
- 29:46to the loan out company, and Bob's written an
- 29:48article on this in the recent past, is to have
- 29:51an employment agreement in place. And my two,
- 29:55I think the important pieces that are gained
- 29:59from the employment agreement is it establishes
- 30:01contractual control over the talent, which is
- 30:03one of the requirements from from Sargent and
- 30:06also it establishes additional corporate formalities
- 30:10because what does corporate formalities mean?
- 30:13In practice, you'd look to the statue and it's
- 30:15like, are you having board meetings, et cetera,
- 30:17et cetera. But in this context, the talent is
- 30:20wearing all hats. They're the officer, they're
- 30:23the director, they're the employee, they're the
- 30:25shareholder. So it's hard to establish what would
- 30:28traditionally be viewed as corporate formalities.
- 30:30And a proper employment agreement sets forth
- 30:33you know, a formula in terms of how to determine
- 30:36compensation versus a distribution, et cetera.
- 30:39So that's an important point here as well in
- 30:42terms of having the loan out respected. Great.
- 30:46OK. Shane, is there anything else on your list
- 30:51that you want to talk about? I might just cover
- 30:55for maybe five minutes the music piece here and
- 30:59then I can turn it back to you. Great. So I'll
- 31:04make the music catalog. There's obviously a ton
- 31:07of music catalog activity and there's not a whole
- 31:12lot of available case law in terms of how certain
- 31:16gray areas are treated in terms of character
- 31:19of game. So I'm going to just touch on that for
- 31:22a minute and then also just raise a couple of
- 31:25the points that come up and that is when you
- 31:28have a sale how do you treat the the repayment
- 31:32of any advances that are unrecouped. And that
- 31:35ultimately is going to boil down to how you originally
- 31:38treated the advance. If it was treated as debt,
- 31:41rightfully or wrongfully, you're probably going
- 31:45to have additional gain now. But if it was treated
- 31:48as an advance payment of a royalty, which it
- 31:51typically is the proper treatment, and you would
- 31:53have picked that income up in the prior year,
- 31:56when you make the repayment in the year of the
- 31:59sale, in terms of the unrecouped advance amount,
- 32:02there's a corresponding deduction under this
- 32:05claim of right doctrine. So those are two points
- 32:08just to keep on the radar. In terms of character
- 32:10of gain, going to the next slide, I'm not gonna
- 32:14go into the detail here. The point is that in
- 32:19practice, you'll see people seeking opinions
- 32:22or sometimes people not really looking into all
- 32:26of the underlying issues to evaluate whether
- 32:28or not you have capital gain, but to get to a
- 32:32reporting position under the IRS standards, you
- 32:35have to have a certain comfort level when you
- 32:38make the filing. And rather than getting into
- 32:42the detail on this slide and the next slide,
- 32:44this is really intended to be an issue spotting
- 32:47point that the analysis should be covering, why
- 32:52is it not a work for hire? I've seen opinions
- 32:54where people just say, well, We don't we don't
- 32:59think that the the law that you know governs,
- 33:02you know treatment of work -for -hire payments
- 33:04is applicable anymore It was you know, or it
- 33:06was applied incorrectly with no further analysis.
- 33:09That's not going to be a sufficient You know
- 33:11reasoned opinion likewise the substitute for
- 33:14ordinary income doctrine That is a U .S. Supreme
- 33:17Court doctrine that has never been overruled
- 33:19and it's been applied as recently as, from my
- 33:22recent research, as 2011, possibly later. I've
- 33:25seen that doctrine just completely ignored and
- 33:28just say, oh, it hasn't been applied in a while,
- 33:31let's ignore it. Going to the next slide, you
- 33:34also, there's a bunch of different. components
- 33:36under section 1221 that need to be addressed?
- 33:39Is it inventory? Is it a self -created intangible?
- 33:42Is it depreciable business property? So these
- 33:44slides are really just intended to make sure
- 33:46that when you're looking at this type of analysis
- 33:49that you're thinking through all of the various
- 33:51issues. I'm going to skip the next topic, taxation
- 33:56of copyright reversion. I provided a link to
- 33:59an article that I wrote in 2020 that kind of
- 34:02gives some framework as to how this might be
- 34:04analyzed. And then I'll also skip security expenses.
- 34:09If we have time at the end, we can come back
- 34:10to it. The main point that I just want to flag
- 34:13is that in the IRS audit manual, which is typically
- 34:16where an auditor is going to be looking, they
- 34:19don't address section 132, which is a legitimate
- 34:22way that security expenses effectively can be
- 34:25deducted. That is current law. That's, you know,
- 34:30that's binding law. It's in the statute. The
- 34:33IRS audit manual just says that security expenses
- 34:36are inherently personal and that they're only
- 34:40deductible if the talent is going to an event
- 34:44like an award ceremony where there's paparazzi.
- 34:48So there's more to the story, but an auditor
- 34:50is looking at the audit manual, and they may
- 34:54not be familiar with Section 132 and applicable
- 34:58case law, which I mentioned on the next slide,
- 34:59Munson v. Commissioner. So that's just things
- 35:02to keep in mind because I don't think the IRS
- 35:04is adequately addressing this topic in their
- 35:07audit manual. So, Bob, thanks for the additional
- 35:11time there, and I'll turn it back over to you.
- 35:13Sure. Great job, guys. One of the things that
- 35:18Shane's slides show is that there are many, many
- 35:24topics to be covered here, each of which really
- 35:27deserves its own special presentation. So this
- 35:31is just an overview, unfortunately, but I think
- 35:34there are some great topics here for future conversation.
- 35:38I'm going to talk about one particular issue,
- 35:40and I'm going to talk about it only because it
- 35:44comes up all the time, and it's a very practical
- 35:47issue, and that is that talent likes equity.
- 35:53When our talent clients do endorsement deals,
- 35:57they want stock. or membership interests, or
- 36:01stock options, or something other than cash.
- 36:06Why? A lot of this harkens back, because this
- 36:10wasn't that popular, until the tech boom, which
- 36:18made a lot of people very rich. The talent focus
- 36:22on that. They don't focus on the fact that there
- 36:25was a tech bust following the tech boom. Now
- 36:28they see all these tech bros making billions
- 36:32and maybe even trillions of dollars. And they
- 36:34think this is the way to get rich. So when a
- 36:37company wants to endorse one of our talent clients,
- 36:41there's usually a discussion of equity. And here's
- 36:43how it generally comes up. Talent manager comes
- 36:47to us and says, I got a great deal for our talent
- 36:52client. This new startup company is very interested
- 36:58in the client. It's called AI Robotics, whatever,
- 37:03and they want to give our talent client 1 % of
- 37:08the company. I'm telling you, this is how these
- 37:10things always start, 1 % of the company. So we
- 37:13talked to the talent client who's very excited
- 37:15about this, but we have no idea what 1 % of the
- 37:18company means. If it's a corporation, does that
- 37:22mean 1 % of all of the stock of the company?
- 37:26What if there's preferred stock? Maybe it just
- 37:27means one percent of the common stock. Maybe
- 37:30it doesn't mean equity at all. Maybe it means
- 37:33phantom equity like stock appreciation rights
- 37:36or phantom stock. We don't know what it means.
- 37:40So we go back to the company and we say, what
- 37:43exactly are we talking about here? The company
- 37:46says, okay, we're going to give your client a
- 37:50thousand shares of stock Each worth $1 ,000.
- 37:55So your client is gonna get a million dollars
- 37:58in stock. I'm using stock at the moment. We'll
- 38:02talk about other kinds of equity in a moment.
- 38:09And so the manager's excited because he got his
- 38:12client or they got their client a million dollars
- 38:16of equity. The manager's thinking about their
- 38:19own commission on that. But the problem, of course,
- 38:22is that I say, of course, I know we have the
- 38:25entertainment industry section listening to this.
- 38:29So I'll remove the words, of course, and say,
- 38:33when a talent is paid for providing services,
- 38:39that is compensation income, which is taxable
- 38:42upon receipt generally as ordinary income. So
- 38:48what we've done here is, yeah, we've gotten our
- 38:51talent client a million dollars, but it's a million
- 38:54dollars in stock. And if the talent lives in
- 38:58a high tax state like New York or California,
- 39:03there's going to be maybe a $500 ,000 tax obligation
- 39:07on that million dollars. I have been seeing these
- 39:12issues for a long time. And one thing which I
- 39:14can say with confidence is that talent does not
- 39:19like to pay anything in these endorsement deals.
- 39:23The talent could say, I think that the stock
- 39:26of AI robotics is gonna hit a trillion dollars
- 39:31one day, but they will not write a check today
- 39:34to pay the tax on the stock that they received.
- 39:38So we have to have further conversations. One
- 39:42conversation that always comes up is, Okay. Actually,
- 39:46the stock of this company, according to the company,
- 39:49is worth almost nothing. Nominal value. Why is
- 39:55that? Well, this company is pre -revenue. The
- 39:59fancy term for saying it doesn't make any money.
- 40:01It has no gross receipts. It has no property.
- 40:06It just has a bunch of very expensive engineers
- 40:08running around trying to create some property.
- 40:12So the company owner will say, all right, look,
- 40:14it's worth $10 this stock. It's not worth a million
- 40:18dollars. It's worth $10. Now, you could just
- 40:22say, OK, it's only worth $10. The company is
- 40:27telling us it's worth $10. That's a pretty great
- 40:30tax result. But if you're wrong, your client,
- 40:35the talent, is going to have to pay a lot of
- 40:38tax. The fact that the company told you that
- 40:40this is what the value is does not help you.
- 40:44It may help you on penalties, but you're still
- 40:47going to ultimately have to pay that tax. What
- 40:49you have to do is you've got to go to the company
- 40:51and say, what's the basis for your evaluation?
- 40:58Have you had any rounds of financing that might
- 41:01set a value for the company? Have you done any
- 41:06valuations? A very common kind of valuation that
- 41:10these companies will do is something called a
- 41:13409A valuation. 409A is a terrible tax code section,
- 41:18horrible, that basically requires if you grant
- 41:25stock options to an employee, the exercise price
- 41:30of that option cannot be less than the value
- 41:33of the stock. So, companies get these valuations
- 41:38because the tax consequences of being wrong on
- 41:41this issue are really terrible for the talent.
- 41:46So the company will get a valuation that says,
- 41:52it's okay, we can issue stock options at this
- 41:54price. It could be that this particular company
- 42:00really has no indicia evaluation. that you can
- 42:05point to. Sometimes we'll just ask them to get
- 42:08evaluation so that we have no surprises on this
- 42:13one. But if we go back to our basic example of,
- 42:18let's suppose that the stock really is worth
- 42:20$1 ,000 a share. We don't want to pay tax on
- 42:24a million dollars, so what do we do? We have
- 42:27to restructure this in some fashion. a first
- 42:33go at it is, okay, instead of stock, how about
- 42:38stock options? A stock option is a contractual
- 42:43right for someone to buy a share of stock at
- 42:47a particular price today. So in our example,
- 42:51if we're assuming that the client's gonna get
- 42:54shares of stock worth $1 ,000 each, we could
- 42:58certainly have them instead issue to our client
- 43:02a stock option with an exercise price of $1 ,000
- 43:07per share, more on that in a moment. And what
- 43:10have we achieved? Well, in the grant of stock
- 43:14situation, the talent has to pay tax on the stock.
- 43:20But if you structure a stock option properly,
- 43:23the grant of the option is not taxable, it's
- 43:26tax free. So you've solved that problem. by just
- 43:30changing the form of the equity. Now, the difference
- 43:34between an option and stock happens on the cash
- 43:38out portion of the transaction years down the
- 43:41road when the stock is either or options are
- 43:44either sold or exercised. Any monetization of
- 43:48a stock option is ordinary income. In contrast,
- 43:53if you sell stock, it's almost invariably capital
- 43:56gain. So, this is the trade -off here. The trade
- 44:00-off is if you take stock, you have to pay tax
- 44:03upfront, but everything else is capital gain.
- 44:08If you get an option, the option is tax -free
- 44:12on grant, but the exercise of the option is ordinary
- 44:20income. There are other ways of skinning the
- 44:25cat here. there are things that are referred
- 44:28to as phantom equity. It's not really equity.
- 44:31You don't own an interest in the company like
- 44:34stock or stock option. It's simply a compensation
- 44:38program that is designed to pay the talent something
- 44:42that is equivalent to the value of the stock
- 44:45or the appreciation of the stock at some point
- 44:48in the future. So a great example is phantom
- 44:53stock. Instead of giving the talent stock, which
- 44:56is taxable today, we give the talent a right
- 45:00to receive the value of a thousand shares of
- 45:04stock at some point in the future. That's laid
- 45:08out. At that point in the future, the talent
- 45:13has ordinary income, no tax at grant, and the
- 45:18talent is perfectly fine. Again, the talent really
- 45:23doesn't care upfront about the distinction between
- 45:26capital gain and ordinary income. They just want
- 45:29cash and they don't want to pay tax until they
- 45:32get the cash. Okay. I'm going to just finish
- 45:34with one related topic. And this topic deserves
- 45:41a whole seminar. This whole thing deserves a
- 45:42whole seminar in and of itself. But let me just
- 45:44finish quickly with this. The challenge that
- 45:48we have that we have found is that there's a
- 45:53trade -off either way we've structured these
- 45:55things. Either the grant is tax -free upfront,
- 46:00like a stock option or phantom stock, but you
- 46:03have to pay ordinary income at the back end,
- 46:05or it's taxable upfront, like the grant of stock
- 46:09and its capital gain at the back end when the
- 46:12stock is sold. Wouldn't it be great if there
- 46:15were some compensation structure that would allow
- 46:19you talent to receive equity upfront tax free
- 46:24and cash at the back end at capital gains rates.
- 46:28That is the holy grail of compensation planning
- 46:32and it exists. It exists if the issuer is or
- 46:37can be structured to be an LLC because there
- 46:41is a type of membership interest in an LLC. It's
- 46:44called a profits interest, which is a terrible
- 46:47name for it. because a profit's interest to the
- 46:50entertainment industry is an interest in an income
- 46:53stream. This profit's interest is a membership
- 46:58interest in the LLC. And it has certain characteristics
- 47:03that basically assure that the interest is only
- 47:06an interest in profits to come and not current
- 47:10value. And if you structure it properly, the
- 47:14grant of the profit's interest is tax -free.
- 47:17while the back -end payments can actually be
- 47:21capital gain. That is the holy grail. I wish
- 47:24I had more time to elaborate on this and the
- 47:27other issues, but I want to reserve sufficient
- 47:30time for Jonathan to finish his presentation.
- 47:34So I'm going to end it here and hand it back
- 47:37to Jonathan. No, no, we'll go back to Shane.
- 47:39I'm done. I'm done. Oh, OK. We'll go to Shane.
- 47:43And if anybody has questions, feel free to submit
- 47:47questions through the Q &A function. Yeah, it
- 47:52looks like we have about nine minutes. How much
- 47:55time we have left? Nine minutes? Yeah. OK, so
- 47:59if there are any questions, I'll continue on
- 48:03with the security expenses, just to give a little
- 48:07more color there. And then if people have questions,
- 48:11I can kind of pause, because I think the gist
- 48:13there is that there is a framework to deduct
- 48:17security expenses if you have the right facts.
- 48:25OK, so yeah, with respect to security expenses,
- 48:31there's a code section, section 132, that deals
- 48:36with fringe benefits. being provided to the employee
- 48:43of the company. And this applies whether it's
- 48:49a company with 100 employees and it also applies
- 48:52even if it's a loan out company that has one
- 48:54employee, i .e. the shareholder talent. One of
- 48:58the fringe benefits that's provided for in the
- 49:01statute is a working condition fringe. In a working
- 49:06condition, the general rules that when a tax,
- 49:08so just to give some historical context, there
- 49:12was a vast disparity in terms of how taxpayers
- 49:16were treating fringe benefits. And fringe benefits
- 49:21obviously is generally something that your employer
- 49:26might provide you in the form of cash or property.
- 49:29um that you get the benefit of and so from an
- 49:33income tax perspective you're receiving some
- 49:35value and up until um the 80s there wasn't there
- 49:41wasn't a lot of formal guidance there was not
- 49:44no statutory guidance and the IRS had proposed
- 49:47regulations in the 70s um and there was a moratorium
- 49:51put on releasing those regulations until there
- 49:55was comments received by by treasury and people
- 49:58had a had time to comment on that. Now in the
- 50:0170s there was two PLRs that were issued where
- 50:05executives at a company had deducted certain
- 50:08security expenses and that included one fact
- 50:12pattern was that there was a U .S. executive
- 50:18and someone at their foreign branch, an executive
- 50:21in their foreign branch, was injured or maybe
- 50:25shot. There was some tragic event that happened
- 50:28that made this executive nervous about his own
- 50:32circumstances and he he claimed a deduction for
- 50:36um for security expenses and they ended up getting
- 50:39a private letter ruling and the IRS said that's
- 50:41not deductible that's personal in nature and
- 50:44that's probably where the IRS gets its commentary
- 50:48in the audit guide from I'm assuming um that
- 50:51in those instances it was It was personal in
- 50:54nature. And my takeaway factually, which obviously
- 50:57PLRs don't always go into a lot of analysis,
- 51:01factually, the facts in that case in terms of
- 51:04the threat that the executive was concerned about
- 51:08was too attenuated. He wasn't experiencing a
- 51:12direct imminent threat of anything with him personally.
- 51:16But I've represented entertainers who have had
- 51:20people you know, burglarizing their property,
- 51:23knowing that someone's there because, you know,
- 51:26maybe they're looking for memorabilia or that
- 51:28person might be a music artist that has a recording
- 51:32studio at his home and has valuable recordings
- 51:34there that haven't yet been released. There's
- 51:38been people that have shown up on the premises
- 51:40with an imminent threat with a knife or otherwise,
- 51:45you know, saying things like they're going to
- 51:47kill their kids or whatnot. And you just get,
- 51:49there is real threat of that and so under the
- 51:53regulations that were released in the 80s under
- 51:56section 132 the value of the fringe benefit is
- 51:59taxable income under section 61 as gross taxable
- 52:03income and a fringe benefit though is is effectively
- 52:07a compensatory payment so structurally how this
- 52:10how this works under the 132 framework is that
- 52:13the loan out company would have taxable income
- 52:17from the studio. In my example, let's say it's
- 52:19$100. So there's $100 of gross taxable income.
- 52:24The provision of property or cash that would
- 52:27otherwise qualify as a working condition fringe
- 52:30under the statute, that would be deductible at
- 52:34the company level as a compensation expense under
- 52:37section 162. And under section 61, the talent
- 52:42or shareholder has taxable income, that's compensatory
- 52:45income. But importantly, Section 132 is not a
- 52:49deduction section. It's an exclusionary provision.
- 52:53So if you qualify under Section 132, yes, the
- 52:57talent shareholder has taxable compensation from
- 53:00the fringe benefit. But if you qualify under
- 53:05Section 132, that income is excluded. So it has
- 53:07the net effect of a deduction, but it's not really
- 53:11a deduction at the individual level. So that's
- 53:14the general framework. And under the regs, under
- 53:17132 -5, it provides for what you need to qualify
- 53:22for security expenses as a working condition
- 53:25fringe. And first and foremost, if you have an
- 53:29overall security program in place, which would
- 53:31include trained bodyguards and chauffeurs, private
- 53:35travel, you have to have all of this stuff to
- 53:37have an overall security program in place with
- 53:3924 -7. you know, business reason to have that
- 53:43security in place. But you can also have a bona
- 53:48fide business, or you have to have a bona fide
- 53:50business oriented security concern that is the
- 53:54catalyst for that overall security program. If
- 53:57you can move to the next slide, I'll wrap this
- 53:59up and check to see if we have any questions
- 54:02before we wrap up the presentation. So on the
- 54:06next slide, If you get an independent, if the
- 54:10company gets an independent security report done
- 54:15by, you know, there's companies out there that
- 54:17have. uh individuals that have experience with
- 54:20security historically they might have been in
- 54:22police force they might have been special ops
- 54:25in the military um but they'll do a formal analysis
- 54:28and evaluate under your facts and circumstances
- 54:31what do they recommend as an independent consultant
- 54:34to protect the employee and and once you get
- 54:37that report if it if it meets all the requirements
- 54:39um that will satisfy the the the overall security
- 54:44um um program test that otherwise is needed outside
- 54:51of having this independent report. So typically
- 54:53if talent is planning or has the need for security
- 54:57for certain specified factual circumstances,
- 55:03the typical approach is to get an independent
- 55:05study to rely on when structuring into 132. Now,
- 55:09interestingly, just to wrap this up, There is
- 55:13an old tax court case from 1929. While it is
- 55:16old, it has been cited in the 2000s, so it's
- 55:24still viewed as good case law. What's interesting
- 55:26about that case is that it wasn't in the context
- 55:29of a fringe benefit. It was a sole proprietor
- 55:32who was a farmer, and he had fired some employees.
- 55:36They became disgruntled and started vandalizing
- 55:38his property. Someone took a shot at him with
- 55:41a a rifle or maybe back then it was a musket
- 55:44um because it's a fairly old case um but the
- 55:47important point there is that the IRS challenged
- 55:50the deduction and said that at least a part of
- 55:53this all our portion of this is personal and
- 55:55should not be deductible and because of the imminent
- 55:57threats on his person on his personal residence
- 56:01um it was still upheld as a valid deductible
- 56:05expense for a sole proprietor outside the realm
- 56:07of 132, because under 132, that wasn't enacted
- 56:10until the 80s. And that included security patrol
- 56:14over his personal residence when only his wife
- 56:17was home when he was out. And it also included
- 56:20security with him on personal trips to New York
- 56:23City. So that's just an example. It is somewhat
- 56:27of a gray area because there isn't a whole lot
- 56:29of case law outside of this Munson case, and
- 56:32otherwise you're looking at 132. But it's just
- 56:35to go to say that the IRS manual just blankly
- 56:40saying that security expenses are not deductible
- 56:42isn't the full story, and you have to really
- 56:44look into this. I want to add something. So I
- 56:46have a currently documented case in the tax court
- 56:50where this is security expenses are one of the
- 56:54issues and the taxpayer had threats made and
- 57:01the issue there was there is no security study
- 57:05that was done in light of that and the government
- 57:10is calling into question whether the security
- 57:13was provided 24 -7 or whether there were certain
- 57:16flights that may have been international flights
- 57:19that there were the security wasn't there. That's
- 57:24one of the issues there. But one of the resources
- 57:29that I've looked at is if you look at the public
- 57:32filings of almost all big companies, Apple, Tesla,
- 57:37Netflix, there's going to be a note in their
- 57:43compensation section about security that is provided
- 57:48to certain executives and And you may find out
- 57:52that they've treated it as compensation as opposed
- 57:56to considering it a fringe. And so that's one
- 58:01of the issues in the case that I have, and we'll
- 58:03see how it goes. But again, and it's, I wouldn't
- 58:08say directly related to entertainment, but it's
- 58:10something that you definitely see in the entertainment
- 58:14industry as well. Okay. Well, thank you guys.
- 58:19Great job. Thank you to our audience for listening
- 58:23in and watching this seminar. I'm sure I speak
- 58:27for the others by saying if anyone has any questions
- 58:31after this event, feel free to reach out. We'll
- 58:33be happy to discuss them. So we're going to sign
- 58:37off now. Thank you very much and enjoy. Thanks,
- 58:41Bob.