Latest / CIC’s Small Business Intelligence / How Small Businesses Can Use AI as a Productivity Engine (and Thought Partner), Episode 26
Transcript
- Hello, and welcome to Small Business Intelligence by Community Investment Corporation, the podcast where we analyze the latest news headlines and address the all-important question of: what does this all mean to you as a small business owner? We'll share our insights in this regard so you can be better prepared for what might happen in the days, weeks, and months ahead.
- I'm Joe McCaffrey, a business advisor with CIC, and my co-host for this podcast is Louis Silva, the president and CEO of the Community Investment Corporation.
- Always good to see you, Louis.
- Likewise, Joe.
- Here we are closing in on the end of September, which means summer is almost officially over.
- I think this week is the last day of summer.
- Today's the last day of summer.
- Today is? Oh, okay.
- Yes.
- All right.
- So, uh, if the weather prognosticators are correct about El Niño, uh, we can expect to have a milder but wetter winter, which hopefully means less snow to shovel.
- That would be nice.
- I still have piles of snow in my yard from last winter.
- I snapped two shovels last year because of all the snow removal.
- I'd like to not repeat that this year.
- I'm kidding, of course- Yeah about the snow piles, but there was...
- It was an unusually hot summer.
- Uh, we had, we had the hottest summer on record, I read.
- So, uh, uh, enough about...
- talk about the weather.
- We have more important and interesting things to talk about today.
- So who's in the studio with us today? We have Luke here, as always, and like last time- Hello.
- Hi, Luke.
- Hey, Joe.
- And, and like last time, Matthew Krieger is joining us, this time in person, to continue our discussion about small business technology.
- Welcome back, Matt.
- Thank you.
- Hey there.
- Uh, let me tell you a little bit about Matt.
- Matt is the CEO of Cobert Incorporated, which is a Connecticut-based manufacturing company.
- Matt is also a fellow SCORE mentor, CIC educational consultant, and a personal friend of mine.
- Matt has spent his entire career in tech-related roles.
- He's one of my go-to people when it comes to any kind of tech-related questions, particularly those pertaining to AI.
- So in preparation for today's discussion, as I did last time, we went through the news articles that we collected from the last month, and, uh, we spent almost the entire hour last time with Matt talking about AI, and I hope we'll be able to get to some other topics today.
- But the hottest news right now is about, you guessed it, it's about AI, artificial intelligence, and the news isn't very good.
- So let's pick up where we left off last time talking about AI.
- But what I wanna do is make sure we get to the other topics, particularly data privacy and cybersecurity.
- So, so as I said, the latest news has mostly been negative.
- I wrote a blog post about AI Armageddon that will be coming out shortly, discussing what small businesses should be doing in this period of uncertainty.
- You know, we need to face the fact that AI is here.
- It isn't going away.
- It's only gonna get bigger and better.
- So that's just, you know, just nothing we can really do about that.
- So despite all the recent negativity about AI, CIC still believes that AI is a great productivity asset that small businesses should adopt, particularly for competitive reasons.
- If your computer...
- I'm sorry, if your competitor is using AI and you aren't, they will likely have a competitive advantage over you, which will eventually translate into reduced profitability and potentially loss of market share.
- So as a small business owner, getting left behind should be your greatest concern about AI, I would say.
- Uh, so with that in mind, we'll, we'll get right into the discussion.
- So Matt, first, uh, question Uh, that was actually Lewis's question.
- You wanna take the first question? Yeah, Matt, I'm, I'm curious, you know, you, you're a score mentor, you work with some of our CICs micro, um, loan clients, and given that AI is all the rage these days, um, what are people mostly concerned about when they seek out your type of assistance? Um, what are their concerns? How are they looking to leverage AI? Are folks thinking about using it to replace your workforce? Tell us, tell us what you're seeing out there.
- I think there's a couple of things people think about.
- One is, um, what is my opportunity? Um, how do I sort of actualize the opportunity of AI versus what I just hear in, in the news? How do I make it work for me? What does it mean for me? And, um, the answer that I typically give is, um, it-- try not to follow the hype.
- Um, try not to follow the leapfrogging of the technology, which is sort of a natural thing.
- Uh, try not to chase Try not to chase, uh, w-what is reported as the newest capability.
- Um, look at the productivity opportunities, look at the time-saving opportunities, look at the opportunity to remove friction points in everything that you do, whether it is your sales, whether it is your payables, whether it is your marketing, uh, whether it is data analysis, whatever it is.
- So initially, when people ask about AI, I ask them to identify friction points in operating their business, and maybe they come back and they say, "Hey, I have a friction point, uh, entering data into a project tracking system.
- It's very time intensive, it's very labor intensive."
- Uh, and I say, "Okay, let's look at how to, uh, sort of automate that."
- Now, it's important that when business people, small or otherwise, look at AI, um, that they not try to jam AI, uh, as the solution into every problem.
- AI is, um, uh, you know, people tend to think about AI as the hammer and everything else as sort of the nail.
- Um, a better way to look at things is to look at your friction points, ask if standard non-AI, old, boring technology can solve the problem.
- In many cases, particularly a small business, um, they're not even using basic technology tools.
- Let's, let's assume they've explored that for a minute, uh, and, and that they're looking for, uh, actual, you know, things that fit into AI.
- So what opportunities fit into AI? Um, in cases where data is, is messy and you need to make sense of it, AI is very good at synthesizing information.
- If you have handwritten data, AI is very good at recognizing that information and transforming it into, uh, rich text.
- Um, if you have, uh, spreadsheets that contain data, uh, many people are hamstrung on how to analyze that data because they don't have the technical skill.
- They're not an Excel expert, a Google Sheets expert.
- The ability to ask questions of AI in order to generate, um, uh, analysis of that data is a powerful concern.
- I mean, in short, to anybody, but particularly, particularly small business, you know, AI is, i-is an intent-driven system.
- Previously with Standard technology, you have to implement the mechanics of a system.
- You have to worry about how things work.
- You have to connect Excel to something or your financial application to something.
- With AI, you, you express your intent.
- This is the goal I want to accomplish.
- I want this data out from here and into here.
- And, uh, AI is very good at establishing the outcome as opposed to burying you in the mechanics.
- So, uh, just to come around, long story short, whether it is, um, writing proposals, responding to customer emails, asking questions of your data, uh, these are all things that you can dip your toes in the water with, uh, AI.
- Y- you're a small business owner.
- How have you leveraged AI in your, your day-to-day? Don't give me any proprietary e- examples, but, you know- Sure how has it solved some minor issues? Yeah, I mean, we've locate-- we've, um, uh, loaded, for example, all of our product marketing sheets into an AI knowledge base, uh, that allows very easy search both by customers and by us internally to get product specifications, um, um, to get product technical information, product capabilities, again, through natural language, right? So typically, when you have, uh, individual documents, you would scan the documents for, um, uh, information, and you would search by keyword.
- Well, now I can ask questions where the answer may actually be located somewhere in this database.
- I don't know where.
- I can focus on the, the what do I wanna know, as opposed to focusing on, on the mechanics.
- Uh, another area where we've done something very similar is, is, um- Uh, locating tons of technical documentation, uh, into AI and having the same type of knowledge base.
- Um, another, another opportunity along the same lines, not to beat this example to death, but, uh, any business has a ton of relevant business information that is trapped inside email.
- And email is an unstructured tool, it is traditionally very difficult to get information out of because you're limited by traditional search.
- If you feed email into the same type of repository that I'm talking about, now you can synthesize information, um, uh, a-across emails, uh, and again, expressing your intent to get a certain inf-- a piece of information, um, emails now become that source as a be-- as opposed to a keyword search.
- Uh, another example we've done is, um, loading, loading meeting transcripts.
- Um, personally, I, I don't take a lot of meeting notes anymore.
- I let the transcripts do the work.
- Typically, what I may do is if we're discussing something interesting during a meeting, I'll sort of put a flag on, on like the timestamp and, uh, or, or I'll, you know, indicate what the topic is that I wanna know something about.
- And after the meeting is over, I will ask questions of the transcript.
- Uh, I will ask for a synthesis of the transcript and get the to-do list and the answers that way.
- So I'm listening more now as, uh, as, uh, as opposed to, you know, to note-taking.
- And then the other example I gave, uh, I use a lot.
- We have these, uh, bills of materials for the machines that we manufacture.
- The bills of materials are typically across many unstructured spreadsheets.
- So when I want to know, uh, how many or what is the cost of a given component or set of components across many extra Excel spreadsheets, again, I can now ask questions in natural language in a way that sort of abstracts me from the details around how that spreadsheet, uh You know, is, is created.
- And then finally, I will use AI as, as a, as a thought partner.
- Um, the, you know, the more you use a ChatGPT or a Claude, the more memory and context these tools build around you.
- They record-- They, they have knowledge of your previous conversations.
- So, um, unlike speaking with an individual who gets tired and sort of forgets things, I can go back to the AI, and I can pick up a conversation around a given topic, add context since that time, uh, and essentially bounce off that AI questions and opportunities, uh, i-in, in a thought partner way.
- And one of the useful things is to, is to take my same business information and put it in the perspective, get a, a marketing take versus a technical take versus a, um, sort of a business development take on that same information.
- And when you have these three or four personas, you know, you get some interesting perspectives, whereas before you might have paid somebody to do that.
- So if this all sounds interesting and exciting, it's about to get real here in a minute because we actually are going to do exactly what you were talking about- Mm-hmm where I'll let you do the setup on this, Matt.
- We took some, some CIC data, and, uh, we, we put it all together, and we're going to, uh, have a conversation with a, with an AI agent here.
- So why don't you set-- do the setup for this one.
- Right.
- So, so you guys have done, uh, uh, 23? 25.
- 25 episodes so far.
- So Luke provided me, um, with 25 text transcripts.
- I loaded them into a, a ChatGPT project.
- A ChatGPT project is nothing more than a logical grouping of files and sources and sheets, and any other data that you want to add.
- Uh, other, by the way, analogous tools are, uh, NotebookLM, otherwise known as Gemini, uh, Notebook or Claude Projects.
- Most of the tools have this concept of a, of a project bundling.
- So we loaded these, uh, transcripts into a project.
- We gave a little bit of context around.
- This is the CIC Small Business Intelligence Podcast.
- And one of the questions that I asked the podcast, uh, or the project last night Which we could do now if you guys are okay with it.
- Yeah, let's do it.
- Is I said, okay, you know, Louis and, and, and, um, and Joe and Luke have discussed, uh, or made multiple predictions over the years.
- Maybe not informally, but, you know, maybe not formally, but maybe you said, "Hey, I suspect this will happen or that will happen."
- We could say, you know, give us the top three, um, uh, predictions that they made and tell us how these things actually turned out.
- We like to say we don't make predictions on this podcast.
- We try to anticipate things.
- Anticipation.
- So, so, so if, uh, uh...
- H- how would you want to word that question? I want to put it in, in wording that's, uh- You could ask it, you can term it in, in, in, uh, terms of a prediction.
- Yeah, you could ask it that.
- Okay.
- So, so let's do that.
- So what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna turn on, uh, ChatGPT voice mode.
- Okay.
- Okay? So over the, uh, 25 podcast episodes, Joe and Luke and Lewis have talked about, uh, many, many topics, and they have, of course, made predictions formally or informally around things that would happen in the real world.
- So I'd like you to call out, um, the top three areas where they made a prediction that ended up panning out and, uh, if you could very briefly and very concisely summarize how that happened.
- I just need some top-level information on these three.
- Okay.
- Yeah.
- Hang on.
- I'm just going to go I'm, I'm getting nervous Just a sec Hey, thanks for your patience.
- I've got a solid snapshot here now.
- First, on tariffs and pricing.
- They warned of tariff pass-through and margin pressure, and, uh, what later happened was inflation in imported goods and small firms adjusting prices just as they described.
- Second, the K-shaped consumer economy.
- They had talked about a split where lower income households pulled back while higher income consumers stayed strong, and later, spending and credit stress patterns broadly followed that line.
- Third, AI changing staffing.
- They anticipated leaner teams and role reshaping, and that showed up as businesses piloted AI to automate routine tasks and rethink entry-level hiring.
- Give me the top three where they were incorrect or the results haven't yet panned out, but I'd prefer you look at circumstances where the events have indeed panned out, but they were, uh, incorrect.
- Let me check This is like our report card, Lewis I know.
- I like it.
- I'm surprised interest rates weren't a topic of discussion, but I suspect we got it wrong.
- Okay, so three calls stand out.
- One, they said tariffs would force the Fed to raise rates, but in twenty twenty-five, the Fed actually cut rates three times.
- So that timing was off.
- Second, they forecast a really nice recovery and a high-note finish for twenty twenty-five, but growth slowed sharply late in the year.
- Third, they expected consumer prices to gradually come down, but inflation stayed sticky instead.
- Got it.
- I'd like you to answer one more question for me, which is obviously from the transcripts, you understand the themes and the topics that were discussed.
- Can you extract three themes from all of the discussion that may not have been directly discussed, but nonetheless are contained in the transcripts if you synthesize the information across them? Interesting.
- Let me take a pass.
- Okay.
- Across the episodes, three underlying themes emerge.
- First, small businesses carrying more systemic risk than before.
- They're absorbing policy swings, cost volatility, and making micro calls that used to be buffered by larger institutions.
- Second, the economy that matters is hyper-local to the customer.
- The national numbers matter less than the specific customer mix you serve.
- That's the subtext behind the K-shape discussion.
- Third, adaptability itself becomes a form of capital.
- The ability to change pricing, tech, suppliers, and staffing quickly.
- That speed is becoming a separator between those who survive shocks and those who benefit from them.
- I'll, uh, I'll ask one final question here, which is if we wanted to take the content as discussed over the twenty-five episodes and repurpose that content, let's say in blog posts, give me three to five, um, headlines of what those blog posts could be that would reflect, again, sort of a synthesis or a repurposing of the existing content in a way that doesn't just duplicate what was talked about, but adds new value.
- Let me think.
- These are good questions Here are five synthesis-driven headlines I'd go with.
- One, the small business owner is becoming the economy's shock absorber.
- Two, there is no longer one consumer economy: how to navigate the K-shaped marketplace.
- Three, adaptability is the new working capital: AI, pricing, and staffing.
- Four, why good economic news can still feel bad on Main Street.
- And five, twenty-five episodes, twenty-five signals: what small businesses should be watching next.
- That last one could be a really fun signature piece using your own series as a lens rather than simply a recap.
- She's making work for me.
- So, so let me- Wow let me just map that, let me map that for a minute to a small business.
- So if you as a small business person do what we did here, rather than loading podcast transcripts, you load your, um, uh, technical documentation, your, uh, marketing information, your customer, um, uh, your anonymized, uh, customer interactions, your, um Uh, uh, marketing and advertising leads, your any internal documentation, uh, over any period of time, you could imagine as a small businessperson how you could get some intelligence out of that in a way which really wouldn't have been possible previously.
- For sure.
- Are you s- are you asking us that, or is, are you...
- Are we out of, are we out of chat mode? We're out of chat mode.
- I'm- Oh, okay talking to you.
- I'm trying to map it toward- Hmm something that the small businessperson could immediately do with that.
- Oh, for sure.
- I mean- Makes a lot of sense you know, you were, you were talking earlier about the, um, you know, the types of things that, that you load into it, like emails and, and meeting transcripts.
- I'm not on a Zoom call anymore where there's somebody who's not, d- doesn't have their, their Note Tracker running.
- Right.
- So there's a lot of, there's a lot of data here, and I guess is it structured or unstructured? Not quite sure which category it fits in, but it doesn't matter because you can still feed it all into AI- Right and it'll, it'll help you decipher it and tell you what it all means.
- Yep.
- And what's really cool is that we've been doing the podcast now for almost two years, so we've fed into it almost two years of transcripts.
- Yep.
- And I, you know, a lot of these conversations, I forget what, what you and, you know, Lewis and I talked about in the early days and stuff, but AI doesn't.
- Right.
- You know? So this is, this is really what it's all about.
- I mean, this is where it really turns into, like you said, you know, using it as a thought partner- Mm-hmm you know, to, uh...
- And asking questions.
- I mean, everything that you asked it was in natural language.
- It was like you were asking me the question or Lewis or anybody else.
- It was...
- That's, that to me was really what it was all about.
- You can just talk to this like you'd talk to a regular person.
- Right.
- You know? But that's, I think, what, uh, what makes it so interesting.
- And of course the quality of what you're gonna get out is, is dependent upon what you put into it.
- And you do wanna...
- You did mention, you know, an- anonymizing, you know, customer information and that sort of thing.
- You wanna be careful with what you share.
- But, um, you know, those are the sort of things.
- This is where you get value from...
- You've got all this data and this information sitting around.
- What are you doing with it? Mm-hmm.
- You can extract strategic intelligence value from it.
- You, you make a good point.
- I wanna say two things.
- When, when you talk about, uh, every meeting has, uh, you know, everybody's running a transcript tool- Yeah I, I would guess that the vast majority of those transcripts are, uh, sitting stale.
- They are.
- Yeah.
- Okay.
- I bet you they are.
- Uh, number one.
- So that presents an enormous opportunity in my opinion to, uh, to my data.
- The second thing that presents an enormous opportunity is all, all of this historical data that you've got, whether it's structured or unstructured, which has been sitting there, you maybe have not even accumulated that data intentionally, it just, it just adds up, now becomes mineable data.
- Um, I'm thinking of like email.
- Like that's a treasure trove of, of information.
- Exactly.
- There's great stuff in there.
- Exactly.
- Yeah.
- And, uh, and that, that becomes...
- So, so you now have access to information or to intelligence, I should say, uh, it- for which you always had the data, but you could never extract, extract anything of it.
- Right.
- That, that's, that's the game changer I think is that.
- I'm just thinking about the time lapse that just transpired here, right? Like- Yeah two years' worth of data, two years' worth of transcripts.
- It would've taken a normal individual hours, days- Yeah, months weeks to, to extract five potential blog postings, right? We did this in a matter of minutes.
- So just thinking about that component in and of itself, I mean, it's pretty impressive.
- It's pretty amazing.
- Yeah.
- I wanna, I wanna make one comment too because someone's always bound to say something about this.
- They say, "Well, how do you know, how do you know it's right, and, uh, that the AI is, uh, is right?" And, uh, you know, sometimes you know it's right, sometimes you don't.
- Uh, most of the tools that we are working with can, um- Provide citations back to the original source If you ask it, it'll do that, yeah If you ask it, it'll do that, or it'll do it, you know, naturally.
- That's one of the things actually that, uh, uh, Gemini Notebook is, is very, very good about, is it, it's what they call source grounding, which is where the, the universe of, uh, of answers that the AI could give is, is sort of bounded by your knowledge base because that's where you want the answers from.
- And then when it does give you an answer, it cites the sources from which it pulled the information and allows you to do a sanity check Mm-hmm.
- No, I, I think that the, uh, the responses that it gave us, uh, were, were right on.
- I mean, Lewis and, and, and Luke and I were looking at each other and nodding our heads, like, "Yeah, that's, that's exactly, we remember those," you know? So it, it, um, you know, we, we didn't, I, I didn't have any questions as far as any of the things that it said.
- It's like, "Oh, is that accurate?" Did you, Lewis? No, I'm actually kind of shocked though that it didn't pick up on things that I thought were m- prevalent throughout our discussions, one of them being interest rates, right? Yeah.
- Yeah I mean, that was, uh...
- I couldn't think of an episode that didn't go by where we didn't touch on what's gonna happen with interest rates.
- Seems like we always talk about that, yeah Right? Um, so that's, you know, that's another example where, you know, AI may not always get 100% of the, the topic at hand correct Yeah, and you'll have a lot of...
- I mean, you know, you know, o- one of the, um, challenges with AI, whether it's, uh, you know, whether it, uh, you know, we, we've, we've all talked about AI sort of behaving in a, a sycophantic-type way.
- We also see AI sometimes sort of chasing what you want.
- For example, if you asked a follow-up question about why wasn't interest rate content more prevalent in the answer, the AI, you know, might say, "Oh, that's a really good point I neglected to-" It always compliments you like that.
- Yeah Right.
- I, I neglect...
- No, "But I neglected to prioritize this," and there is indeed, you know, that theme.
- And there's a number of techniques where you can, uh, uh, focus the AI on trying to get more, uh, correct answers earlier in the process, but I think that's a, that's a work in progress, is, is the AI sort of triangulates to what it thinks you want as opposed to, uh, giving information that's truly based on the facts But also, thinking about this as a conversation, like if you and I were having this conversation without, without the, uh, you know, the AI agent involved, you know, I would have follow-up questions and, and say, "Well, what about this, man? What-" Mm-hmm I mean, that would be a normal course of a conversation that, that humans would have.
- You can have that same conversation.
- Uh, we could have asked it Lewis's interest rate question as a follow-up- Right and it would've gotten back to us, and that would've spawned even more questions maybe.
- And this is the thing, you can have an endless conversation with this, uh, with this, you know, computer essentially telling you the things that you need to hear.
- Mm-hmm That's the, that to me is the most amazing part of it, you know? It, it's, it's ongoing.
- It'll, it'll keep ans- answering your questions as long as you keep ask- asking them You know? So it's funny how you learn something every single time, uh, you know, AI comes about.
- I- the, the, the prod- the project scenario that you talked about, that was to me like a, why wouldn't I create a project for every little specific thing that I'm working on and let build in the knowledge surrounding that particular issue and have it sort of, um, work within itself to solve a problem All right, so here's something else that's pretty cool that we can do.
- So I, I know from speaking with small business owners that the primary reason why they're reluctant to jump into the AI pool, so to speak, is because they haven't yet figured out how AI can help their business.
- And that's what this last exercise was intended, was to really start getting people thinking in the, in a certain direction.
- These are the sort of things that you can do with it.
- So let's look at a few types of businesses and talk about the specific sort of things that AI can do to make the business better.
- Now, we can have this conversation, or we can bring the AI agent back into the, the equation because they've gotten all the perspective from all the news articles and whatnot from the last almost two years.
- How do we wanna handle that? Do we wanna just have the conversation ourselves, or do we wanna- I think we've spent enough time with, uh- Okay, let's do that then the personality ChatGPT pilots.
- So one of the more popular types of businesses that I work with is health and wellness businesses.
- And, uh, in fact, uh, Score is doing a health and wellness expo coming up.
- It's a digital expo.
- It's free.
- Uh, it's on October 20th from six, uh, 6:00 PM to 8:00 PM.
- And we're gonna be talking about business development strategies for people in the health and wellness, uh, sector.
- So again, work with a lot of businesses in this area.
- So what sort of things could AI do to help them in their business? What, what types of applications could, could we use for them? Right.
- So I, I asked this question of, uh, of one of the AIs after you brought it up because- Okay I, I'm not that familiar with health and wellness.
- But, um, one of the answers that, uh, makes sense is tailoring educational content or wellness plans toward an individual based on their needs or their specifics.
- Um, again, taking into account that we want to protect, uh, PII, personally identifiable information, or, or other, um, you know, and obs- also observe other, uh, you know, for example, HIPAA or other compliance factors.
- But certainly synthesizing a personalized wellness plan is a scenario where you could see AI, um, helping out.
- Another opportunity is, and this is not specific to health and wellness, um, customer service, right? Um, FAQs.
- Generating, um, again, customer-specific, contextually relevant, uh, responses to customer service, uh, inquiries.
- You could see easily a situation where, uh, a customer, if this is appropriate, is chatting with a health and wellness customer service chatbot, uh, or something, you know, which perhaps is sort of emulating the health and wellness coach and getting, you know, real-time, contextually relevant, um, information about, about their own, um, their own cases.
- Uh, certainly health and wellness or, or any discipline, you know, we have drafting social media, drafting newsletters, posts, um- This is, uh, I think to me, content creation, while probably the most common use of AI, uh, is also one where you wanna be careful.
- There's an exponential growth of, you know, AI slop on the internet today.
- Uh, you know, I, I, I sort of-- I didn't make this up, but there's this notion that as something becomes easier and cheaper to create, the value of that thing, you know, tends towards zero.
- Yeah.
- And certainly is the, is the case here too.
- Um, uh, sales proposals, uh, is, is another one, you know, where, um, uh, sort of personalized, uh, information could, could become very meaningful to, you know, to a health and wellness business.
- Okay.
- That all sounds very interesting.
- What about, um, what about, like, a daycare business? We work with a lot of daycare businesses.
- Mm-hmm.
- What do you think about that? I...
- So I would suggest that, um, o- a daycare's big...
- One of a big challenges of a daycare, I would imagine, would be scheduling.
- Okay.
- Would that, would that be a reasonable assumption? Um- Um so you're talking about staff scheduling.
- Staff scheduling, capaci- uh, capacity management.
- Yeah.
- Um, you know, I, I, I actually don't- Could be tours.
- Could be tours for potential.
- It could be tours for potential.
- Um, I would imagine that an interesting opportunity would be providing the AI with, uh, historical staffing information, uh, based on the number of kids and sort of come up with a more recommended capacity management plan- Mm-hmm um, you know, if that's something that, um, um, that would benefit daycare.
- But I, I think one of the common elements here and, and something that all businesses could, should consider, again, is e- every business has a very similar set of back-end processes, right? They all have to, uh, uh...
- They, they all have vendors.
- They have AP.
- They have AR.
- They have to manage a, a CRM system.
- Um, these things are, are, are sort of table stakes in my opinion to look at the productivity enhancements of AI or any technology for that matter, um, but we're here talking about AI in order to increase their productivity on and, and reduce friction.
- One of the things that is, I think, to be determined is how all these businesses will use AI to grow top line, you know, revenue, and, and that isn't clear to me yet.
- Um, I have...
- Because that's the million-dollar question ultimately- Right is, right? At some point soon, every business will be AI-enabled, whether they do it purposely or the software tools they use, you know, will come with these things that are embedded.
- But I'm, for example, I have a SCORE client who is, uh, ha- has a, uh, a counseling...
- It's, it's sort of an AI native startup, um, which counsels, uh, a- a- abused women And the, the model that they have is to let the, uh, woman speak with and be counseled by an avatar, so a, a, a talking face that embodies the knowledge of the practice and also the knowledge of that individual person, with the idea that the entrepreneur's, uh, research has shown that, you know, some people are-- they feel more comfortable talking with y- you know, with an AI avatar than just a text chat.
- So you say, "Well, why wouldn't they just talk to the therapist or to the counselor directly?" Well, they would, but this allows scale, right? This allows more scale.
- This allows essentially more than 40 hours a week for the entrepreneur to provide counseling type services.
- So this is one of these AI native type startups where, uh, if it, it-- if this works out, this provi- provides potentially a very transformative opportunity- Okay you know, to, to the entrepreneur.
- And then, uh, last example is food service.
- We work with a lot of restaurants and, you know, bars and different things like that where, where they serve food.
- That's, uh, that's another very popular business.
- So where could you see AI being used in a business like that? So I think, I think again, uh, I think capacity planning is another one.
- My understanding about food ordering for many small restaurants is that it's a, it- it's a very analog sort of back of the napkin type, type exercise.
- Now, there's a little bit of, um pre-work that would need to be done here in order to get an AI-assisted, um, boost.
- For example, right, you have to actually get that data into some sort of system and out just, you know, out of somebody's head.
- But I think there's an opportunity there to, um, do better job on, uh, food inventory management and planning, not letting fresh foods get stale because they don't have a lot of, um, you know, enough, enough customer ordering activity.
- That's, that's one example, Joe- Mm-hmm that, uh, I should see-- that I could see.
- I think another opportunity, again, not unique to food service businesses, is doing deeper research on markets or locations.
- Um, one of the things we do in SCORE very frequently is we recommend...
- I always forget the name of this, but the, uh, libraries provide a service that allows a newly formed business to get comparables, um, whether it's revenue or margins or location information for a given type of business.
- So I'm a pizza shop, I'm in downtown Norwalk, and I wanna know, you know, what a competitive gross margin is going to be because I'm gonna need to prove I'm competent to get a loan from a bank or from CIC, you know, or, or whoever it is.
- Um, th-this type of information, this type of sort of contextually relevant business-specific information may now be available through what they call deep research, which is, uh, tools offered by the, um, all-- I think all the AI, uh, toolmakers offer deep research, which is the ability to go deeper on the web, synthesize, bring back information in the form of a more comprehensive report that otherwise wouldn't have been available Yeah, I'm thinking also, uh, staff scheduling might be another, uh, you know, good way to help you figure out...
- You know, the, the one thing about food service companies is they have a, they have a ton of data that they can get from their, uh, their, their point-of-sale systems.
- You know, uh, if they're using Toast or some- Toast is probably the, the more popular one.
- There is a ton of information in there that you could use.
- And, uh, like I said e- earlier, you know, putting this information into a, into a, into a, you know, an AI engine and asking it to help you analyze it, ask questions about it.
- What are my best-selling products? What are my best days of the week where I'm, you know, doing, you know, whatever? I mean, there's a whole bunch of stuff that you can really start to glean from that.
- Um, and that-- those are, those, those are good uses of AI.
- Yeah.
- Figuring out, you know, telling you things about your business that you didn't previously know.
- That you didn't know.
- I'll tell you, I'll tell you one other use case, uh, you know, may be relevant, for example, for a guy like you, Luke, right? You build websites.
- Uh, you, you, you maybe make other software solutions.
- The idea to have AI-generated software, AI-generated websites, let's say for prototypes.
- Um, previously, to test something with a customer, to get in front of them a design, to get in front of them a, uh, you know, a working website prototype took real time and real technical skills and real design skills.
- Um, now you can generate those things in prototype format, uh, and get very, very quick results, put them in front of the customer, reduce cycle times.
- Ultimately, the people doing those things should still have good technical skills.
- Mm-hmm.
- But the ability to sort of reduce time to market by creating software, um, you know, uh, on the fly, I think is a really good opportunity.
- Joe, you and I have a CIC, you know, uh, TA client who is in the, um Uh, food service and beverage business, and he used, uh, Claude to generate internal apps for managing his own inventory process and for communicating infor- uh, that inventory information to other folks on his team.
- This is a software solution that he created by iteratively prompting, I believe, Claude.
- And again, all he expressed was his intent.
- He's not a technology person.
- He didn't code this thing.
- Hmm.
- He said to the software, "This is what I want to accomplish," and he iterated over the course of several hours to create something that was very powerful for him.
- Yep.
- Yep, for sure.
- So, um, you know, that was, uh, that's a great example of what it is that we're talking about.
- So these are the sort of things that, again, we try to, we try to help people with in their business and, you know, help them come up with some, uh, some, some unique ideas.
- But sometimes the client, you know, things that they do on their own, we, uh, we find out some, uh, some pretty interesting things as well, and that's a good example in that case.
- But, um- Joe, in the, in the batch of technology articles you, uh, you analyzed over the last 30 days or so on the, uh, on the topic of how certain industries are leveraging AI, um, one of the articles that stuck out to me, given that we get involved in many ground-up construction projects, was this article on AI cutting construction costs, potentially cutting construction costs by 17 to 20% and timelines by 22 to 25%.
- What was fascinating about that article was that, and I didn't realize this statistic, but roughly 75% of construction projects ex- experience cost overruns, and that eq- equates to about $30 to $40 billion in cost overruns every single year.
- Huge.
- Yeah.
- It's massive.
- And, and The, the, the use case for AI in this particular scenario was, uh, essentially it could help reduce, um, inefficient use of skilled labor, waiting to rework documentation, coordinating problems, scheduling conflicts, right? We talked about scheduling with daycare, um, drawing reviews, et cetera.
- These are all the ways in which this particular article called out the use of AI for the construction industry to, uh, look to hone in on those cost overruns.
- And we see it all the time.
- Uh, and it also gave us a couple of, uh, pointers on what lenders could t- potentially use AI to understand the risk behind a ground-up construction project.
- Pretty fascinating.
- Yeah.
- It's, uh, that- that's another good, uh, good example, and, and you did some more research on...
- You took that question, and you did some additional research on it through, uh, through AI, I guess, through Google Gemini or whatever.
- That's, that's where you got the more expanded, uh, information from.
- Correct? Yeah, absolutely.
- And, um, you know, specifically, I wanted to understand, well, hey, you know, if we're experiencing these cost overruns locally- Mm-hmm me, being in the business of lending to these end users, what do I have to worry about? And it, and it, sure enough, it's, it, it, it honed in on that construction cost overruns tend to lead to appraisal gaps.
- We're seeing this real time every single day.
- Yep.
- Um, and, uh, delayed completion could extend my draw period for my borrower, right? So it increases the cost that a borrower might have to succumb to, uh, interest-wise, uh, that they didn't necessarily pencil out at the beginning of the project.
- So, um, for me as a lender, I'm using that data to say, okay, from a cash flow perspective, how long do I need to br- carry this interest-only period out further to, um, to anticipate this particular type of cost overrun, and can the business afford to do that? Right.
- Right? So yeah.
- I mean, when I do projections with clients, I always tell them, things will always take longer and cost more than you think they will.
- So I encourage them to build that into their sensitivity model and test, you know, what happens if it's six months later, what happens if it's 20% cost overrun, and see what the picture looks like, because it may turn out that the project is no longer financially viable under those circumstances.
- So, you know, I guess this is a, a word of caution to people in these situations.
- I had this conversation with one of our staff here at CIC this morning.
- You know, when you're in the business of making projections, you're always gonna be wrong.
- Sure.
- You know, it's a matter of you wanna be wrong a little and not a- Mm wrong a lot, right? Right.
- But inevitably, you know, it's really hard to make some of these predictions because you just can't tell in many cases what things are gonna be, and, and there's factors beyond your control.
- We talk about that a lot on this podcast.
- And, uh, you know, it's really hard to anticipate and, uh, and to account for those things.
- But like I said, you know, best case, worst case, you know, most likely case scenarios, if you're, if you're not testing the sensitivity of your financial projections, you know, you might be putting yourself into a situation where only like, you know, the best outcome is, is, is gonna, you know, is gonna work for you.
- And if that's the case, that's really not a good way to go into a project.
- Yeah.
- And it, it also harkens the importance of understanding why contingencies are so important.
- And, and I don't mean contingencies from a cost perspective, but contingencies in terms of your plan potentially not working out as you intend- you originally intended it for.
- Yeah.
- Yeah, like I said, I mean, you know, what was, what was formally a, a viable project could turn into a nightmare because now it's no longer...
- You know, you're losing money on it, and nobody wants to lose money, right? So, you know, these are the sort of things that you can try to anticipate in advance and, uh, and just test it.
- Like I said, test the sensitivity and see where it, see where it comes out at, so.
- You know, Lewis, the, the way that you used AI to ask that question I think is, i- is, is important potentially for the listeners.
- Because when people say, you know, I, I indicated at the beginning, one of the barriers is people don't know where to go.
- They don't know where to get going.
- Um, ask the AI, right? Right.
- I'm a, I'm a pizza business.
- I'm, I'm, uh...
- Here's my details.
- I'm constantly struggling with, uh, uh, with, with cashflow.
- Um, uh, you know, my vendors, uh, my, my sauce and dough and, um Um, cheese vendors have me over a barrel.
- You know, what are some things I should be thinking about here? Uh, hey, AI, uh, what do you need to know from me to help me answer that question better, right? Use AI as the idea generator.
- And to get that dialogue going, you just have to ask one simple question.
- So you don't need to know ahead of time how it's going to solve a problem.
- You just need to know enough to ask it.
- Yep.
- So here's another personal, uh, you know, um, example of how I use AI at, uh, at, at CIC.
- So I've mentioned before, we do the economic analysis summary, which has all of the articles and everything that we collect.
- I'm about ready to release the new one.
- There's n- almost...
- I think there's over nine hundred articles in the past month, which is an absolutely incredible.
- Uh, so that'll be coming out soon.
- So that's one way that we use AI.
- The other way that I use AI is I have a lot of que- a lot of discussions with people, and they're always asking me questions about, "I need-- I got a business.
- I'm thinking of getting, you know, you know, getting some money.
- Where can, you know, how do I get money?" Blah, blah, blah.
- I'm having these conversations with a lot of different people, mostly through Score.
- And, uh, so you know what I try to...
- You know, I try to help them and explain to them how, you know, community lending works and the difference between us and a bank and all that other kind of good stuff.
- But at the end of the day, there's a lot of things that, that play into the decision as to whether or not you're going to get a loan based on your personal financial profile.
- So what I did was I put together a template that ha- asks a whole bunch of questions about your personal finances, the business, et cetera, et cetera.
- And what I do is I take that information, I anonymize it, so it's not gonna be tied back to you, and I put it into GPT, and I say, "Hey, tell me what the prospects are for this person to get a loan.
- And if, if the prospects aren't good, tell me what they need to do in order to improve their chances."
- And you'd just be blown away at what it tells you.
- It's like, "Oh, well, they need to, you know, save up more money.
- They need to improve their credit score.
- They need some experience in the industry," whatever the case may be.
- You know, I'm just absolutely blown away every time that it does this.
- And another conversation we had this morning here at CIC was, you know, using AI to help us vet the, the, the assumptions that go into the financial projections.
- You know, these are the sort of things like that we are g- you know, using, uh, AI in, in our business, but it could be equally applicable to other folks in other industries as well.
- We don't- Yeah you know.
- These, these are just examples.
- But, you know, like you s- I love your que- y- what you were just saying.
- Ask, ask ChatGPT or Claude or whoever it is you're using, "How can you help me in my business?" That's a great way to get started.
- Right.
- Ask that first question.
- You know, that's a really good way to kick it all off, so.
- Okay, any, uh, final thoughts on this topic or we'll move on? Uh, I wanna say one more thing on that.
- If, if the casual observer here, um, might say that we are cheerleading AI, I would say if somebody said that, it wouldn't be terribly wrong.
- I, I, I wouldn't, I wouldn't dispute that.
- Right? And, and something I would say is, is, you know, we're, we're talking about opportunity today.
- Yeah.
- Right? Um, everything has a downside, right? Mm-hmm.
- And yet need to be aware of those risks.
- And I'm not gonna cover every one of those risks right now.
- We know about trusting AI and double-checking and not uploading your data, uh, which is personal.
- But I wanna call out one thing which I think every business person ought to be conscious of, which is when you use AI, you risk, um, uh, sort of outsourcing your brain power to something else.
- So, uh, I know that when I am using AI to do research or put together a spreadsheet or do some analysis, uh, it is, it is very hard.
- You really need to be conscious about y- you're driving the bus.
- It's very easy to sort of let your brain atrophy while the AI does the work.
- Yeah.
- It's, it's, it's alluring, right? If, if you can take an elevator, you're not gonna carry the box up the stairs.
- Yeah.
- And if you can take an elevator and you don't carry the box up the stairs, you're gonna have to figure out a way to get your exercise elsewhere.
- Yep.
- And this is a very similar thing.
- So that's why it's very hotly debated, what is the role of AI in especially the early, uh, you know, K through 12 schooling process or even in college, high school, whatever it is.
- We saw some articles on that, yes.
- When, when you use AI, you will naturally rely on AI and sort of give a pass to some of the other muscles that you would normally exercise, and I think it's really important to, to think about that because you don't wanna, you don't wanna have that thing atrophy.
- True.
- I mean, you know, in going back to the example I just gave of the, uh, the template that I use for helping people, uh, you know, for screening, uh, you know, pre-screening on, on loan applications and stuff, it's, uh, it's for the purpose of, you know, I got tired of telling people the same things.
- You know, how many times can I say to somebody, "You need to fix your credit score.
- You need to save more money," whatever.
- I mean, I was just telling people the same thing over and over again, so I didn't really see that as me relaxing my, my mental muscles d- by using that.
- But it ends up really enlightening the, uh, the person on the other end of it where they, they see all these things like, "Wow, I never knew that.
- I never would have, I never would've known that."
- Right.
- You know? So- I would say, I would say what you gain in, in resourcefulness- Yeah you potentially, uh, lose in the exercise- Of exercising mental muscles Yeah, yeah And what you want to be is resourceful and exercise your brain- Right and not just take the...
- And for me, that's a very conscious exercise.
- I really have to be intentful with that, intentional.
- Yeah, I mean- I would...
- Oh, sorry.
- Go ahead.
- No, I was also gonna add that I, we find All the time that the output of a collaborative session where we're using our brain power and we're working with Claude or ChatGPT or Gemini for the purpose of research or, um, fact-finding or content creation or scheduling or planning or proposals.
- The output of a very collaborative session where we're using our brains and the AIs are using their brains is always infinitely better than a softball approach- Mm-hmm to tell me how to do this or give me a version of this that reduces our, you know, the, the effort on, on our end, fi- on firing synapses on gray matter and on what the, the AI then come to expect from this exercise with me or with us as an agency.
- The more we are not challenging, but working together, the, the better, the higher the bar for, for the output.
- So, um, I think in that case, you exercise your own thinking and you're using the AI.
- I'm not saying this is always the case.
- Of course, sometimes we, you know, take the easy road.
- But I th- I know based on our own experience, when you're working together, thinking together, which sounds a bit future, Paul- You know, Joe's AI Armageddon article.
- Um, there is, there's a, there's an opportunity for, for real benefit there.
- Well, the final product is enhanced.
- Is it- Yeah.
- I mean, that's- Vastly I feel the same way.
- Vastly enhanced, you know? That's, uh, that's, that's how I look at it as well.
- Well, the, the one-- And the last thing now my, my actual synapses are like, "Okay, cool.
- We get to think? Let's do that."
- I, I, I, I feel that we, yeah, we really are able to...
- If you're a, an, a solopreneur or an entrepreneur or a small business owner, your business is inherently small, so your opportunity to collaborate with somebody else depends on their schedules or can you get together? Did you schedule a Zoom? Is...
- So if you have an idea or you want to ask AI intelligent questions and get a response or have a collaborative brainstorm, whether it's virtual or it's you're talking to your AI, th- there is a really wonderful opportunity to get feedback that's not just blowing smoke.
- Challenge me.
- Give me the, the, what am I not thinking about? You know, to Matt's point, ask the hard questions.
- Is this- That's the best question you can ask yeah, is this the rookie approach? What's harder? What are the downsides of a- of taking this road? Give me 10 obvious cons for taking this approach tomorrow.
- What are the financial downfalls? What ultimately could be the benefit of doing this? Am I crazy? Talk to me.
- Tell me honestly.
- Give me some deep research.
- The, the real chance there, the real opportunity is to be willing to be wrong, just like any entrepreneur or solopreneur.
- Let's fail fast and move on.
- Let's...
- But give me good feedback.
- And as we all know, when you have an idea or you're, you're testing something Just like the way you tested Chat's knowledge of the CIC podcast, give us some synthesis.
- Like, the ability to go back in time or to get contextual feedback and input about an idea that's not just your idea.
- Has anybody else had this idea? Is there something that's part of this categorically? Has-- Is there a patent for this particular idea? Are there other companies that exist out there that are doing this? If so, name three.
- Send me their links to their websites.
- Tell me what I could be doing differently.
- You know, that when you start to source all of that stuff factually and you're using your own brain and the tools at hand, I think that this is a lights out opportunity to, uh, to level up.
- Yeah.
- I think one of the most important things, and this is certainly the case for startup businesses, pre-startups, you're going through the, you know, you're not quite even to the proof of concept phase.
- You're just really just, you know, vetting the idea, um, you know, with friends or on paper or whatever, you know, is asking that question: What am I missing? You know, because oftentimes it's not like what you did about what you knew.
- It's what you didn't know that you didn't think about until it was too late and, you know, some big cost comes up that you didn't anticipate or something like that.
- Those, those are the really the more important things, and AI is great for helping you figure those things out, you know, that you might not have ever been able to figure out those on your own.
- You know, it's gonna challenge you in that way.
- And even-- It's like, challenge me.
- Tell me, you know, what am I missing here? That's a great discussion to have with AI about, about anything that you're thinking about doing, so.
- Um, okay, let's, uh, let's move on to, you know, one of the other criticisms of technology in general, and particularly with AI, is regarding socialization.
- So in this post-COVID era, people have become less social.
- Some would even say isolated.
- Um, I hear this in conversations with clients.
- I even experienced it myself, to be honest.
- This is one of the reasons why we decided to launch this podcast almost two years ago.
- We recognized the change and decided we needed to meet people where they were, which was in the digital realm.
- And people in general are spending more time at home, including working and in smaller and less frequent social gatherings.
- Whether technology has created or enabled this phenomenon is debatable.
- The reason why it happened isn't material.
- The fact is, it's the new reality.
- So let's think about what opportunities and challenges does this create for small businesses.
- So think about like, um, you know, like a, a brick and mortar.
- Your retail traffic is probably gonna be down.
- Maybe people are buying more stuff online.
- Um, what other things can we think about? Home delivery, uh, of, of products or services.
- Quick serve.
- Everybody wants everything yesterday, right? Uh, what kind of-- What k- what else comes to mind when you guys think of what I just said? Well, about anything.
- About just the change in just the, the whole socialization thing, how it's changed the, the level of socialization, you know, between humans, uh, as a result of, you know, all the technology enhancements that we have.
- Whether it's phones or, or Zoom.
- I mean, every- you know, nobody knew...
- Hardly anybody knew about Zoom before COVID hit, and now everybody is like, "Everybody's using Zoom."
- Overusing Zoom, I think.
- Let's go back to just a simple telephone call.
- We don't need to see each other, you know? Well, I definitely think as a small business owner, it changes how you have to anticipate your business opportunities, right? If you're, if you're focused on face-to-face interaction, given what you just described, how we've become sort of less social, how do we adapt? And, you know, I think AI is a perfect way to give you some, some resources on how you might need to pivot, right? I, uh, Matt, the ChatGPT agent, clearly said that adapting and pivoting is creating an opportunity for generating capital, right? And I think that's exactly w- you know, what you're touching on, Joe.
- It's you have to be willing to adapt in this new world that we're all living in to continue to be successful in what you're doing.
- Yeah, I'm, I'm thinking too about, like, you know, people are spending more time at home, so they want to improve their home environment.
- Inside more than outside.
- I know looking around my neighborhood and stuff, people are more focused on the inside of their house than the outside 'cause that's where they spend most of their time.
- Weather, the weather has become even more of a factor, particularly if it's, if it's less than ideal.
- Um, you know, when people go out, they want experiences.
- We've heard and seen articles.
- We've talked about that a lot.
- You know, alcohol consumption is down.
- THC is up.
- Um, you know, interactive classes are more popular.
- You know, things like, um, you know, I have a client who, uh, who's looking to do a, um, you know, like a pottery type, uh, type business and stuff.
- You know, they're looking for technology to make their life easier.
- Children and pets are now a much bigger priority- Yeah than they even were before.
- Those sort of things.
- Y- yeah, so, you know, it's funny.
- I'm, uh, I'm laughing because, um, in the, in peak pandemic or, you know, in this post-COVID world, if you will, what's the one thing that people did most, um, personally? It was to enjoy their home, to enjoy their backyards, right? Right.
- To, to kinda get comfortable with their own space.
- And I'm laughing because in the middle of the pandemic, there was one transaction that I did with a client that stuck out to me, and it was, it was fascinating because as we were all, we were all living this, I found myself enjoying my backyard, enjoying my deck more, and what was the one thing that- people were doing, especially in that particular transaction.
- This particular business recognized that people hated being bitten by mosquitoes.
- And so this particular franchise became so successful almost overnight because people recognized that, "Hey, I need to spray my backyard against mosquitoes so that I can stay home and be with my family and enjoy my backyard."
- Yep.
- So that was a clear scenario where, hey, someone pivoted and recognized that there was an opportunity, and boy, did they capitalize, and they've become a very successful franchise, so.
- And, and this is the whole purpose- Yeah of throwing out these things, because there's ideas here, folks.
- I'm not, I don't have the answers.
- I'm just, I'm just kinda just trying to get you to think, right? I, I...
- You know, so Joe, y- your example of, uh, you know, people staying home more.
- Yeah.
- Right? So if you're a business, again, a brick-and-mortar business, and your business model sort of depe- y- you never even Would, you know, people are out.
- They were at a mall.
- Like, what's a mall now? But people were out.
- You know, they were walking into pizza shops.
- They still do, but it's sort of less.
- So you relied on foot traffic, but you never even contemplated that.
- It was just there.
- So now you have to say, uh, w- you have to be intentional about what your value add is, and how do you get to those people? Otherwise, you risk, you know, going out of business.
- I would suggest that there probably are new business opportunities that have emerged or that will emerge that specifically give people something that they feel is lacking, which is, you know, one-to-one interaction, the socialization.
- Uh, many people, um, d- d- don't lack...
- Uh, sorry, they don't feel they lack that.
- They're probably net not as healthy, uh, you know, m- uh, cognitively as a result of that or mentally.
- But I would suggest that services which specifically capitalize or give people that in-person interaction could be, could be super hot again.
- Yeah.
- But look- I agree we've seen a complete destruction of, um, uh, you know, of malls and, and so much retail exactly because of this.
- And, and again, the whole purpose for bringing this up is that these are the sort of thoughts and discussions that I don't believe are happening enough in, in particularly with a lot of small businesses, is looking ahead, picking yourself, y- you know, picking your eyes up from the, from the day-to-day, here-and-now responsibilities of running a business and, and looking off to the horizon and saying, you know, "What, what do I see happening? What's...
- Where are the new opportunities? Where are they coming from?" And stuff.
- So this is kind of the whole purpose of having this discussion and what's behind, you know, the podcast.
- We, we touched on this in a recent blog post, you know, about, uh, working, you know, in the birt- business versus working on the business, and this falls under the category of working on the business, thinking about the future of your business.
- Yeah, I wanted to say one more thing.
- I love what Matt just added about a return to kind of, like, community or in person or...
- I, I was having this conversation with my brother, and he works for a big, um, online company with a lot of digital interactions.
- And, you know, we both came up, we were born in the '70s, we both came up- In the '80s with video stores and CDs and Sam Goody and, like, all that stuff, you know, records and concerts and a lot of the stuff that existed pre, you know, pre-internet, pre-social media, certainly pre-artificial intelligence to the extent that we're all experiencin'- experiencing and enjoying it.
- Anyway, we were talking about, from a retail perspective, how we get bummed out when we walk into a place and you gotta place your order on the tablet.
- Yeah.
- And there are a lot of places that have elevated the AI to the extent that they are using it to take your order or to perform some por- portion of the in-person experience.
- And some of these larger, uh, companies are finding that that is not working to build their business.
- And my brother and I were talking about why that might be, and then we were waxing, you know, deeply into the, um, reduced experience that is a digital experience in person.
- Um, uh, so if you go to Starbucks and you order your coffee at the counter, they still put your name on it, and they'll call you out, and you feel like you were seen and heard, and then you have your coffee if you like Starbucks.
- If you order in advance, you...
- They put it on the counter.
- You can go in and you pick it up, and you don't have to see anybody.
- If you go through the drive-through, you have some modified, you know, middle ground experience.
- But for these...
- Uh, Joe, I was thinking about your question.
- It took me a minute, but I was thinking about retail experiences, and they have to be just that.
- They have to be experiences.
- You have to, if it's a clothing store, well, most people can get that clothing online, so are you making it? How is it special? Is the shopping experience special? Can somebody get a cappuccino while they're there? Are you playing music? Do you have some interactive version of that experience on site? Is there a trunk show? Is there free parking? Is there...
- Like, what is the thing that will get people to come out? And can they buy those things online if they're not local? How do you curate something that's really meaningful, and how do you honor whether you're a digital business or you're an analog business? I mean, businesses have to be some hybrid version of both, but my point, if there's a point here, is that an in-person retail experience needs to feel like an in-person retail experience, and we've drifted from what that means to people.
- If the retail Owners can sort out what that experience looks like, promote it digitally in the right way, that's the bridge.
- They can get people out.
- It's just some happy magic there.
- I'm gonna add one thing to what you said.
- I think that people have a tendency toward, uh, give it to me right now, immediate satisfaction, and efficiency.
- And you are fighting against that as a business owner trying to reach an audience, unless your business is to offer efficiency and immediacy, which, you know, so many, for example, retail and food service businesses are.
- I would say the exception today is, to your point, Luke, businesses that want to create real in-person experiences.
- Those businesses, I would guess, will continue to be the exception and not the norm, but they have to create, to your point, something very special.
- Because if you wanna get somebody to do something that is not the most efficient way, that is not the path to, uh, immediate self, you know, gratification, you must be doing special, something special on top of that to get them in Agreed.
- All right.
- Uh, I'm looking at the clock.
- And guess what? Guess what we didn't get a chance to talk about? Data privacy, cybersecurity.
- Next time.
- Business continuity.
- Next time.
- Uh, yeah.
- Well, it's an evolving conversation, right? So- Oh, I know.
- Yeah.
- Looking ahead, technological advancements, AI regulation.
- Really wanted to dive into that one.
- Uh, but, you know, I think- Tune in next time for AI regulation.
- Oh, yeah.
- That sounds real exciting.
- Well, you know, no, this is a great discussion.
- Luke, you're one of my barometers because whenever, whatever you You're here all the time when, when we do these podcasts and, uh, and, and, you know, we always talk after we go offline and everything.
- You say, you know, "I...
- You guys gave me ideas."
- We give you ideas today? Yeah, tons of ideas.
- You can see when my synapse is really, like, de-det- tuned in and turned on.
- I think there's a lot to talk about and, you know, maybe we can take some specific CIC clients next time, or I...
- There's certainly more to talk about, and it continues to evolve.
- I mean, who knows what will happen tomorrow in terms of AI legislation, rules, bumpers, boundaries.
- Like, there, there's a lot here to unpack, and the nice part about this as it relates to small business intelligence and CIC is that there is a very, um, obvious connection between small business owners like myself, like Matt, like you guys running CIC, like all the CIC clients, and anybody who's listening.
- This is...
- You, you could still w- work for a big business and have...
- find lots of commonality here.
- This is about being human, um, in 2026 and beyond and what it means to participate in our capitalist economy on either side.
- I think there's lots to take away, so.
- You know, the whole purpose of this podcast is to get people thinking.
- Thinking is good.
- We wanna get people thinking, so, you know, we- Think more.
- If you found this podcast to be, uh, to be helpful, interesting, please share the link with your colleagues and friends if you think they could benefit from hearing the content.
- And also don't forget, in addition to the podcast, we have, um, other informational resources, uh, for our small business lenders, including our economic summary report.
- Latest one on that, like I said, hopefully will be out this week.
- Blog posts and analysis templates, which you can find on our website at ciclending.com.
- So be sure to join us next time as we once again discuss strategic intelligence that will enhance the value of your small business.
- I'm Joe McCaffrey.
- I'm Louis Silva.
- I'm Matthew Krieger.
- I'm Luke Scott.
- Thank you for tuning in.
- Three, two, one