Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 89
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder true crime cases five four, three, two, one one one
- 0:21one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you
- 0:31are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, So let's get
- 0:34started. A crime committed to collaps and cheers. The assault of Sheryl Anne.
- 0:47The town of New Bedford, Connecticut, is probably best known as the
- 0:51setting of the American classic Moby Dick. The fictional tale of a captain chasing
- 0:56down a monstrous white sperm whale was concocted by Herman Melville by drawing upon the
- 1:00town's history as one of the most prominent ports in the United States for those
- 1:04seeking out the oil within the sea going mammals. When you delve into the
- 1:11city's heritage during the early part of the nineteen eighties, one would find that
- 1:15nearly sixty percent of the city's population could trace their lineage back to Portugal.
- 1:21This was primarily attributed to the whaling captains who would recruit sailors to replace those
- 1:26who died or deserted after a voyage to the hunting grounds just outside of the
- 1:30western European nation. When the whaling industry collapsed and the textile boom came,
- 1:38the sailors flocked to the mills in search of jobs. But when the Great
- 1:41Depression hit, many of the thriving mills closed up shop in Massachusetts and left
- 1:46for the Southern States, where they could pay lower wages to their workers.
- 1:51By the nineteen eighties, things hadn't picked up much, and the city of
- 1:55New Bedford found itself with one of the highest percentages of people without a job
- 2:00in the entire state. Many people who found themselves down on their luck would
- 2:05attempt to drown their sorrows in a bottle. One such place they would congregate
- 2:09at was known as Big Dan's Tavern. Though the location is no longer standing
- 2:15today, it is remembered for the night of March sixth, nineteen eighty three.
- 2:22Despite the fact many people in the town of New Bedford were struggling,
- 2:24the life of Cheryl Ann Araujo had been particularly difficult. At twenty one years
- 2:30old, she had already been left to fend for herself by her parents.
- 2:34While she was growing up, the only person who would take the young girl
- 2:38in was her great grandmother and then later her grandparents. When Cheryl became pregnant,
- 2:45she decided to leave high school before graduating and move in with her then
- 2:49boyfriend. They had two more children. As the pair continued to bounce from
- 2:53job to job Without a steady income between the two of them, they barely
- 2:59kept their heads above water, and money was a constant strain on the relationship.
- 3:05Despite this, the two found a way to make it work right up
- 3:07until that fateful night in early March, when Cheryl went in search of some
- 3:12cigarettes. Earlier that evening, the family of five had been together celebrating the
- 3:19third birthday of their daughter. Just after nine p m. She planned to
- 3:23walk to one of the local shops to buy her smokes. Finding the two
- 3:28closest stores shuttered for the night, she made the two block trip to Big
- 3:31Dan's Tavern in hopes of finding a pack. Cheryl was definitely out of place
- 3:38in the dimly lit bar that was a popular haunt for the local fishermen.
- 3:42Despite this, she made her purchase and decided to stay for a bit to
- 3:46light up one of her much needed cigarettes while chatting up some of the locals.
- 3:52Alcohol was taking its toll on some of the male patrons, and they
- 3:55forced the mother of three to the floor and ripped her pants off before lifting
- 4:00her onto the surface of a pool table, where for ninety minutes she was
- 4:04raped and forced to perform oral sex on a number of the men. What
- 4:10may be the most terrible part of the incident may be that no one reacted
- 4:14to her screams as this went on for an hour and a half. Once
- 4:18the assault was finally concluded, she staggered, exhausted into the streets, where
- 4:25a group of shocked men saw the nearly nude Cheryl. She was understandably in
- 4:30hysterics, but they got enough of a story to know they had to take
- 4:33her to a nearby police station. After taking her statement, police responded to
- 4:39the scene. Inside they found business going on as it always did inside Big
- 4:44Dan's. Also inside, they were surprised to find at least two of the
- 4:48men Cheryl accused of raping her still drinking and having a good time. Sadly,
- 4:56it still didn't seem that many acknowledged the atrocity that had occurred just a
- 5:00short while ago. One witness to the crime actually was quoted, why should
- 5:05I care? Apathy wasn't the common theme, though. Within a week of
- 5:12the rape, forty five hundred people held a vigil outside of City Hall in
- 5:15support of Cheryl. Many were outraged that people would be willing to stand there
- 5:20and watch as a woman was being sexually assaulted. Big Dance Tavern didn't get
- 5:27off easy either. It was a commonplace for troublemakers to hang out, where
- 5:30fights and lude behavior were the norm. After the bar's owner gave up his
- 5:35license, the city demolished the building with a chainsaw within the week. As
- 5:41for the men, it took less than two days for four men to find
- 5:45themselves behind bars. Daniel Silva, Joseph Vieira, John Cordero, and Victor
- 5:51Raposo were charged with rape. The four posted bail, and Silva tried to
- 5:57make a run for the border, but due to an ex fired passport,
- 6:00he was arrested along with his three co defendants. Two weeks after the incident
- 6:06happened, the Boston Herald published an interview that had been conducted with two men
- 6:11who had been at the bar that night. Their story didn't completely line up
- 6:15with the one Cheryl had told the police. They claimed she had been kissing
- 6:19one of the suspects when the pair fell to the floor in what looked like
- 6:24a consensual attempt to have sex. The man had been too much in his
- 6:29cups to perform, and so he carried her to the pool table, where
- 6:32two other men who were at the bar forcibly began to have sex with her.
- 6:36At the point when the two men started to rape her is when they
- 6:41said Cheryl began to scream. When they were asked why they didn't help the
- 6:45woman, one said he believed it had been a free show, while the
- 6:48other only stated he wished he had in hindsight. The interview drew the attention
- 6:54of the local police, and the two men who'd given the interview were arrested
- 6:58on charges of accessories before the fact. Public reaction brought the firestorm surrounding the
- 7:04case to a whole new level. Not only was there an outpouring of support
- 7:10for the victim, but the entire Citi's Portuguese community was blamed for the rape,
- 7:15given the six men were of Portuguese descent. Most of this hatred came
- 7:19because of the initial statement that had been given by Sheryl the night had occurred.
- 7:24Scared and in a state of shock, she had told police she had
- 7:28been raped while a large group of people clapped and cheered her rapists. Later
- 7:32on in the trial, it would come out that Other than the six men
- 7:36facing charges, there were only three other men present, including one who'd been
- 7:42passed out in the corner at the time. The story, however, had
- 7:46grabbed national attention, as the original story had been published in papers across the
- 7:50country. Given the hideous nature of the crime, When it came time for
- 7:56the trial in February of nineteen eighty four, the racial stigmas had yet to
- 8:01fall away. It was dubbed the Portuguese rape Trial, something the district attorney,
- 8:07also a man of Portuguese descent, took great offense with in hopes of
- 8:11giving the accused a fair trial. The location was moved to Fall River Superior
- 8:16Court. Cameras were mounted inside the courtroom, where local and regional stations broadcast
- 8:22the entire thing. The prosecution began by calling Cheryl Anne herself to the stand,
- 8:28where she gave testimony about her attack. Details included her being dragged to
- 8:33the pool table while a man with beady eyes climbed on top of her while
- 8:39she screamed for help. All the while a man climbed on top of her
- 8:43and began to rape her. She told the court her head was slammed against
- 8:46the end of the pool table again and again as she begged for help.
- 8:52She also said the louder she screamed, the harder another man would pull her
- 8:56hair as this went on. The men who'd taken the battered Cheryl to the
- 9:01police station that night also were put on the stand. One man who found
- 9:05her said he'd never in his life seen a person more terrified. When the
- 9:11prosecution called the bartender who'd been working that night, he told the jury he
- 9:16had a bad feeling about Cheryl. The night of March third. He claimed
- 9:20she'd been laughing and talking with the man at the bar who'd surrounded her.
- 9:24He even went on to say that he wanted to call the police and have
- 9:28her removed. The defense, in cross examination asked him if this behavior had
- 9:33been so unusual that he believed she should be forced from the bar, and
- 9:37he simply stated yes. When Cheryl had been taken to the pool table,
- 9:43the bartender had asked one of the other people inside to call the police.
- 9:48After initially refusing, the man eventually tried to call, but had dialed a
- 9:52wrong number and refused a second attempt. Eleven days after the trial began,
- 9:58the defense was given the floor to make its case and poke holes in the
- 10:03prosecution's witnesses. Silva's attorney claimed that his client had been drinking much of March
- 10:09sixth before Cheryl approached him looking for drugs. He claimed the two of them
- 10:13had made each other's acquaintance before, and after some flirting, he took Cheryl
- 10:18to the pool table. He claimed there had been no begging or cries for
- 10:22help, that what happened between Silva and Cheryl had been consensual. He also
- 10:28claimed that the others who were on trial had gotten involved because they'd been drawn
- 10:33by the action. He went on to claim Silva had not had sex with
- 10:37Cheryl. As the trial went on, the defense teams attempted to make out
- 10:43Cheryl as a sexually promiscuous woman and a welfare case that was only bringing this
- 10:48up in hopes of making money. Despite the lawyer's repeated assaults, she remained
- 10:54steadfast in her claims. Thus, on March seventeenth, nineteen eighty four,
- 10:58just past one year since the day it occurred, Silva and Vieira were found
- 11:03guilty of aggravated rape. Five days later, the two other men, Cordero
- 11:09and Riposo, were also convicted of aggravated rape. The two men who'd given
- 11:15the interview and had been charged with accessory before the fact were acquitted due to
- 11:20lack of evidence. Reactions to the verdicts were mixed. Women's rights groups saw
- 11:24it as a victory, while those who were in support of the defendants were
- 11:28outraged by the jury's decision. The day after the final verdicts were read,
- 11:35a group of over five thousand people marched in support of the four men who
- 11:37had been convicted. Looking to protest the results of the trial, they made
- 11:43their way from City Hall all the way to the House of Corrections. The
- 11:48following day, almost twice the number turned out to support the four men,
- 11:52leading both of these marches where the two men who'd been acquitted. When it
- 11:56came time for sentencing, Vierrearah, was given six to eight years in prison,
- 12:01while the other three received nine to twelve. Following this announcement, a
- 12:07group of protesters who were there to support the convicted men yelled inflammatory remarks about
- 12:11both Cheryl and threats against the district attorney. For those in support of the
- 12:18victim, They scolded the defense's tactics. They claimed they were willing to destroy
- 12:22Cheryl's reputation in the community if only to get guilty men off for a crime
- 12:28they did commit. The only thing both sides agreed on from start to finish
- 12:33was that no one did anything to intercede that night. Despite the tragedy that
- 12:39cheryl Anne was forced to endure, it did have one positive outcome. Women
- 12:45in the city of New Bedford were galvanized by the outrage, which led to
- 12:48the creation of a new rape crisis center and a law that imposed a fine
- 12:52on any one who failed to report a felony. As for life after the
- 12:58incident, for cheryl Anne, things were not great. Despite the men who
- 13:03raped her going to prison, she was the constant victim of ridicule from the
- 13:07people in her hometown of New Bedford. When people would recognize her on the
- 13:11streets, some of them would hurl insults at her and throw garbage at her
- 13:16house when they walked by. Three days after the trial ended, she couldn't
- 13:20take the abuse any longer. She packed up two of her three kids and
- 13:24left for the state of Florida. The third child stayed behind in New England.
- 13:31Despite the move and new job with the same company, memories of that
- 13:35night at Big Dan's still haunted her. She was convinced people who were still
- 13:39angry at the four men's convictions were to track her down and kill her.
- 13:45One of her friends remembered while riding in a car with her, that Cheryl
- 13:48would just stare at the rear view mirror the entire time, as if expecting
- 13:52someone to be following her. This constant paranoia led to her drinking heavily to
- 13:58cope, which landed her in a rehab clinic once. Even after her release,
- 14:03she was still wound very tight. Unfortunately for her family, eleven days
- 14:07before Christmas arrived in nineteen eighty six, Cheryl lost control of her car on
- 14:13an icy patch of road and slammed headfirst into a utility pole, killing her.
- 14:18Luckily, both of her daughters, who were in the car with her
- 14:22at the time, survived. As for the four men convicted of the rape.
- 14:26Within three years of her death, all of them would be released from
- 14:30incarceration. Vieia in May nineteen eighty eight, Silva in May nineteen eighty nine,
- 14:37Riposo in July nineteen eighty nine, and Cordero in October nineteen eighty nine.