Latest / Secrets of the Centuries / Dawn of Sumer: Cradle of Mesopotamian Civilization (7000-2000 BC)
Transcript
- 0:00Okay, so let's unpack this. Right. Imagine it's
- 0:04about 5 ,000 years ago. Okay, I'm there. You
- 0:07are holding a single -use mass -produced coffee
- 0:10cup. Yeah. You are totally stressed out about
- 0:13making sure your monthly recurring taxes are
- 0:15paid on time to this, like, highly centralized
- 0:18government. Right, which sounds very modern.
- 0:21Exactly. And you're dealing with this bloated,
- 0:24inherently corrupt bureaucracy. Oh, yeah. But...
- 0:27you aren't standing in modern -day New York or
- 0:29London. No. You're standing in the scorching,
- 0:33completely flat, like mud of ancient Mesopotamia.
- 0:37It's wild, right? It is. It just completely shatters
- 0:40the timeline we tend to hold in our heads about
- 0:42human progress. Totally. Because we have this
- 0:44bias, you know? We think of ancient people as
- 0:48fundamentally different from us. Like they're
- 0:50just simpler or something. Right, like they're
- 0:51just living purely day to day, rubbing sticks
- 0:54together. Yeah. But when you actually look at
- 0:56the raw data from this era and the source material,
- 0:59you realize they were dealing with administrative
- 1:01bloat. Spreadsheets. Yes. Supply chain issues.
- 1:05Class warfare. All of it. And that is exactly
- 1:08the mission of today's deep dive into the source
- 1:10material. We're working from this incredibly
- 1:12dense fact packed transcript that breaks down
- 1:15the complete and concise history of the Sumerians
- 1:17and early Bronze Age Mesopotamia. It's a fantastic
- 1:21source. It is. And the goal here for us. and
- 1:24for you listening, is to map out this wild transition.
- 1:27Yeah. We're going to trace the mechanics of how
- 1:30humanity went from living in these tiny, quiet
- 1:33farming villages to suddenly - Just exploding.
- 1:36Right, building sprawling, hyper -bureaucratic,
- 1:38warring megacities. And that transition is what's
- 1:41crucial to understand here. OK. Because we aren't
- 1:44just looking at the fact that a civilization
- 1:46magically materialized out of the desert. Like
- 1:48aliens built it or whatever. Right. None of that.
- 1:51We need to dissect the why and the how. The mechanics.
- 1:54Exactly. How does the physical reality of a muddy
- 1:58floodplain literally force a group of egalitarian
- 2:01farmers to, you know, invent specialized labor?
- 2:05And taxation. Taxation. And eventually the whole
- 2:08concept of a king. So whether you are prepping
- 2:11for your next trivia night... or you're just
- 2:13insanely curious about the literal roots of human
- 2:16society, stick with us. Yeah, it's a great ride.
- 2:18We're going to connect the dots from the very
- 2:20first wooden plow to the very first empire. But
- 2:24to even begin understanding who the Sumerians
- 2:26were. Oh, right, the discovery. Yeah, we actually
- 2:29have to jump forward in time to the 1800s. Which
- 2:31feels so counterintuitive. It does, but we have
- 2:33to look at how we even found out they existed
- 2:35at all. Right, because for thousands of years,
- 2:39humanity had just completely forgotten them.
- 2:41Complete amnesia. It is essentially the ultimate
- 2:45linguistic detective story. The amnesia of history
- 2:47is a very real thing. Yeah. So in the early 19th
- 2:50century, you have these European archaeologists
- 2:53scouring the Middle East. Right. Mostly modern
- 2:56-day Iraq and parts of Iran. Exactly. And their
- 2:59framework for ancient history was entirely dictated
- 3:02by the Bible and Greek historians. Like Herodotus.
- 3:06Like Herodotus, yeah. So they were out there
- 3:08actively looking for the legendary cities they
- 3:10already knew about. They wanted to find Babylon.
- 3:12They wanted to find Nineveh. They were basically
- 3:15looking for the people who built the Tower of
- 3:17Babel. Exactly. And as they started uncovering
- 3:20these massive ruins in the desert, they kept
- 3:22finding clay cylinders and bricks and these boundary
- 3:26stones. Covered in writing. Right. Covered in
- 3:29these mysterious wedge -shaped markings. The
- 3:32famous cuneiform script. Yes, cuneiform. Now,
- 3:36finding a dead language is one thing, but translating
- 3:40it... Without a key. Usually impossible. Totally
- 3:43impossible. You need a Rosetta stone. Like a
- 3:45bilingual text. Right. And they actually found
- 3:47the ancient equivalent of one. Oh, wow. They
- 3:50discovered these trilingual inscriptions carved
- 3:53into sheer rock faces. To carve right into a
- 3:56cliff. Yeah. At sites like Persepolis and Behistun
- 3:59in Iran, you had the exact same royal decree
- 4:02written in three distinct, completely unknown
- 4:05scripts. OK. So through just a monumental effort
- 4:09of comparative linguistics, scholars managed
- 4:12to crack one of the scripts. Right. Which turned
- 4:14out to be Old Persian. Which was huge. Because
- 4:17Old Persian has ties to known languages, so they
- 4:19could reverse engineer the grammar. And the vocabulary.
- 4:22Correct. So once they understood the Old Persian
- 4:24text, they used it as a decryption key for the
- 4:28other two scripts on that rock face. Smart. Very
- 4:30smart. And one of those turned out to be Elamite
- 4:33and the other was Akkadian. Though at the time
- 4:36they just called it Babylonian. Yeah, exactly.
- 4:39I am just trying to visualize the moment in those
- 4:4119th century university libraries. Oh, it must
- 4:44have been electric. Right. They crack Acadian.
- 4:46They realize it's a Semitic language, meaning
- 4:48it has structural cousins. Like modern Hebrew
- 4:52and Arabic. Exactly. So suddenly, they can read
- 4:55these ancient tablets. They must think they've
- 4:57just solved the entire puzzle of the ancient
- 4:59Middle East. Oh, they absolutely thought they
- 5:01had. Job done. Right? Job done. Let's pack it
- 5:04up. Translating the Akkadian texts became this
- 5:07relatively straightforward, albeit, you know,
- 5:09tedious process. Sure. But as they translated
- 5:12more and more of these royal Babylonian and Assyrian
- 5:15records, this bizarre anomaly kept popping up
- 5:19in the text. A glitch in the matrix. A total
- 5:22glitch. The scribes kept referring to a specific
- 5:25phrase. They kept writing Sumer and Akkad. Wait.
- 5:30Yeah. The rulers were constantly styling themselves
- 5:32as the King of Sumer and Akkad. Okay, so the
- 5:36archaeologists know what Akkad is. Right. That's
- 5:38the Semitic culture they literally just decoded.
- 5:41Exactly. But they have to be looking around going,
- 5:43what on earth is a Sumer? The confusion was profound.
- 5:47I mean, they had no idea. Where do you even start?
- 5:50Well, the breakthrough didn't come from finding
- 5:52a physical signpost in the desert that said,
- 5:55you know, welcome to Sumer. Right. It actually
- 5:57came from the mechanics of the writing itself.
- 5:59How so? Linguists started looking closer at the
- 6:02cuneiform script, the physical wedges pressed
- 6:05into the clay, and they realized that this writing
- 6:08system was incredibly clumsy when it was applied
- 6:11to the Akkadian language. OK, wait, what do you
- 6:14mean by clumsy? How can a font be clumsy? Well,
- 6:17it's not just a font, right? It's a syllabary.
- 6:20Semitic languages, like Akkadian, are heavily
- 6:24reliant on consonant roots, so the vowels change
- 6:26to denote tense or grammatical function. Right,
- 6:29okay. But cuneiform was clearly designed for
- 6:32an agglutinative language, where words are formed
- 6:35by just stringing together unchanging syllables.
- 6:37Oh, I see. So using cuneiform to write Akkadian
- 6:41was like trying to write English using only Chinese
- 6:43characters. That sounds terrible. It is. You
- 6:46can force it to work, but it's incredibly inefficient,
- 6:49and it clearly wasn't designed for it natively.
- 6:51Oh, wow. OK, so it's like hacking into an ancient
- 6:54hard drive. You decrypt the password, you open
- 6:57the folders, and then you realize the software
- 6:59running the files was actually built by an entirely
- 7:02different, much older operating system. That
- 7:04is a perfect mechanical analogy, yes. The script
- 7:07didn't belong to the Babylonians. It was a hand
- 7:10-me -down. Exactly. It belonged to a completely
- 7:13unknown, much older people, the Sumerians. That
- 7:18has to be just an existential shock to the system
- 7:21for these Victorian scholars. Oh, totally. Like
- 7:23they're sitting there in their tweed jackets,
- 7:25so confident they have the timeline of human
- 7:27civilization mapped out back to the Babylonians.
- 7:29Yeah. And suddenly the linguistic math literally
- 7:32proves they missed an entire foundational layer
- 7:35of human history. They uncovered a ghost civilization.
- 7:38A ghost civilization, wow. And it forced a total
- 7:42rewrite of the timeline. I mean, it pushed the
- 7:43dawn of recorded history back by millennia. Which
- 7:46is huge. It's massive. And linguistically, the
- 7:49discovery was staggering, too. When they finally
- 7:51started isolating and translating the Sumerian
- 7:54language itself, they realized it is what linguists
- 7:56call a language isolate. Meaning it has no family
- 7:59tree. None. Zero. Like at all. Not at all. It
- 8:02is not related to Semitic languages. It is not
- 8:05related to Indo -European languages. Wow. It
- 8:07has no known linguistic relatives, living or
- 8:10dead. Anywhere on earth. It just sits entirely
- 8:13alone. Okay, so this language isolate didn't
- 8:15come from the Babylonians and it has absolutely
- 8:18no ties to anything else Yeah, where did the
- 8:20people who spoke it actually physically come
- 8:22from? Because you don't just spawn a complex
- 8:25civilization in a vacuum, right? You need a starting
- 8:27point exactly to figure that out We have to look
- 8:29at the environmental pressure cooker that shaped
- 8:31them long before writing even existed We have
- 8:34to talk about the mud. We have to talk about
- 8:36the mud You really cannot separate the Sumerians
- 8:39from the mud Mesopotamia translates from Greek
- 8:41as the land between rivers. The Tigris and the
- 8:44Euphrates. Exactly. We are talking about the
- 8:46southern region of modern -day Iraq. Right. And
- 8:49this land is incredibly flat. It is essentially
- 8:51a massive deposit of rich, highly fertile silt
- 8:54created by thousands of years of constant, unpredictable
- 8:58flooding from those two rivers. Just premium
- 9:00agricultural -grade mud. The best. But it's also
- 9:03a blistering desert environment, right? Oh yeah.
- 9:06Extremely hot. So it's not exactly the easiest
- 9:08place to set up a farm. No, it's an environment
- 9:10of extremes. I mean, it receives very little
- 9:13rainfall and the rivers flood violently in the
- 9:16spring. Which is bad timing for crops, right?
- 9:17It is actually the worst time for the crop cycle.
- 9:20So if you just grow seeds in the ground, they
- 9:23will either bake in the sun or wash away in a
- 9:25torrential flood. So how did anyone survive there?
- 9:27Little and build a mega city. What was the first
- 9:29step? Well, it definitely didn't happen overnight.
- 9:31OK. Small scale farming had been developing in
- 9:34the wider, more forgiving areas of the Fertile
- 9:36Crescent for thousands of years. Sure. But in
- 9:39central Mesopotamia, between roughly 6 ,500 and
- 9:415 ,000 BC, we start to see the arrival of early
- 9:45groups like the Samara culture and the Halaf
- 9:47culture. And these groups are basically setting
- 9:49the table. They really are. The Samara culture
- 9:52begins digging the very first basic irrigation
- 9:55canals. Game changer. Absolutely. They realize
- 9:57that if they can control the water, if they can
- 10:00hold it back during the spring floods and release
- 10:02it slowly during the blistering summer, the soil
- 10:04is so rich that the agricultural yield is just
- 10:07astronomical. Wow. Meanwhile, the halaf culture
- 10:10is developing sophisticated pottery and establishing
- 10:13long distance trade networks. OK, so they're
- 10:15trading. What are they trading? They are importing
- 10:18things like obsidian and bitumen, which is a
- 10:21naturally occurring asphalt used for waterproofing.
- 10:23I see where this is going. Yeah. You have one
- 10:26group figuring out how to weaponize the water
- 10:27for farming. Right. And another group figuring
- 10:29out logistics and trade. Exactly. But these still
- 10:32aren't our ghost people, right? These aren't
- 10:34the Sumerians. Not yet, no. The immediate predecessors
- 10:36to the Sumerians are a group we call the Ubaidians.
- 10:40The Ubaid culture. Right. Which emerges around
- 10:425500 BC. We don't really know their exact origins.
- 10:46Likely they were migrants moving down into the
- 10:49southern marshes looking for virgin soil. Okay.
- 10:52But they take the irrigation techniques of the
- 10:54Samara and the trade networks of the Halaf and
- 10:56they scale them up. They optimize it. Yes. And
- 11:00the ultimate result of this Ubaid period is a
- 11:02settlement that the later Sumerians themselves
- 11:04viewed with absolute reverence. The city of Eridu.
- 11:08Yes, Eridu. The historical records we're looking
- 11:10at mention that the Sumerians believed Eridu
- 11:12was literally the first city ever created by
- 11:15the gods. Yeah, the origin point. And archaeologists
- 11:18have actually found evidence that the site might
- 11:20have been inhabited as far back as 8 ,000 BC.
- 11:24It's staggering. That is 10 ,000 years ago. The
- 11:28Sumerian King List, which, by the way, is this
- 11:30fascinating ancient text that blends myth, propaganda,
- 11:34and actual historical lineage. Like a royal resume.
- 11:37Right, exactly. It opens with a very clear statement.
- 11:41After the kingship descended from heaven, the
- 11:43kingship was in Eridu. Wow. So to the ancient
- 11:47mind, civilization itself was birthed in this
- 11:50specific spot. They believed it was the earthly
- 11:52home of the god Enki. Now Enki's a fascinating
- 11:56deity in the sources. Oh, very. Because the texts
- 11:59describe him as the god of fresh water, of science,
- 12:02of crafts, and crucially, as a friend and protector
- 12:05of mankind. Which makes total sense when you
- 12:07look at the geography of Eridu back then. Right.
- 12:10To me, it's just a dust bowl. But back then,
- 12:13the Persian Gulf extended much further inland?
- 12:15Yeah. So Eridu is situated right on the edge
- 12:17of these massive, teeming freshwater marshes.
- 12:21It was an ecosystem of overwhelming localized
- 12:24abundance. Just packed with resources. Exactly.
- 12:27You had endless fertile mud for growing barley,
- 12:30you had massive reed beds for building materials,
- 12:33and just an inexhaustible supply of fish and
- 12:36waterfall from the marshes. Now, the narrative
- 12:38often frames this as a kind of ancient Eden.
- 12:40Right. But I kind of have to push back on this
- 12:43paradise concept. OK, let's hear it. Because
- 12:46we are talking about a swamp in a 115 degree
- 12:49floodplain. True. Swarming with mosquitoes where
- 12:52the rivers could arbitrarily rise and wipe out
- 12:55your entire mud brick village in an afternoon.
- 12:57Also true. So was it really a paradise or did
- 13:00they just have incredibly good PR because they
- 13:03were the ones who figured out how to dig ditches?
- 13:05Well, I think you have to adjust your baseline
- 13:07for what constitutes a paradise. OK, fair. If
- 13:10you are a nomadic hunter gatherer or a pastoralists
- 13:14constantly moving your flocks across the harsh,
- 13:17arid steppes. Right, you're struggling. Your
- 13:19life is defined by caloric uncertainty. You are
- 13:22always one bad drought away from total starvation.
- 13:25Okay. Yeah, that is a very fair point. So if
- 13:28you wander down into the southern delta and you
- 13:30find a marsh where you can literally just scoop
- 13:32fish out of the water with a basket. Yeah. And
- 13:35where throwing seeds into the mud yields a harvest
- 13:3750 times what you planted? To you that is heaven.
- 13:40That is paradise. The mosquitoes and the heat,
- 13:43those are a small price to pay for absolute caloric
- 13:45security. It's basically the ancient equivalent
- 13:47of finding an oasis that never runs dry. Exactly.
- 13:51You aren't going to leave just because it's humid.
- 13:53Precisely. And this localized abundance is actually
- 13:56the mechanical engine that drives the creation
- 13:59of religion and bureaucracy. Wait, how so? Because
- 14:03human civilization didn't start because a visionary
- 14:05architect drafted a blueprint for a metropolis,
- 14:08it started with the immediate, practical need
- 14:11to manage and make sense of this abundance. Walk
- 14:14me through that. How does scooping fish out of
- 14:16a swamp turn into a religious institution? Well,
- 14:19look at the archaeology of Eridu itself. At the
- 14:23very bottom level of the ruins, dating back thousands
- 14:25of years, archaeologists didn't find a massive
- 14:28stone pyramid. What did they find? They found
- 14:30a tiny, humble mud brick room. It was less than
- 14:34eight square meters. That's tiny. Very small.
- 14:37And it had a small altar and a stand for ritual
- 14:40offerings. And the excavations showed layers
- 14:42of ash and fish bones on that altar, right? Yes.
- 14:45So they were literally just giving thanks for
- 14:47the fish? It's a fundamental human instinct.
- 14:49You experience a bounty you didn't create, and
- 14:53you feel the need to offer a portion of it back
- 14:55to the entity you believe provided it. In this
- 14:58case, the freshwater that sustained them personified
- 15:01as the god Enki. Exactly. But here is the mechanical
- 15:05shift. As the town grew, the offerings grew.
- 15:09Oh, I see. You suddenly have a surplus of fish
- 15:12and grain and reeds being brought to this central
- 15:15shrine. And someone has to manage that massive
- 15:17pile of fish. Exactly. You need full -time caretakers
- 15:21for the shrine. The priests. These are your first
- 15:23priests. And as the centuries passed, they rebuild
- 15:26the shrine on the same sacred spot over and over.
- 15:30Every time they rebuild it, they make it a little
- 15:32larger, elevating it on a mud brick platform
- 15:35to protect it from the floods. And so over millennia,
- 15:38that tiny eight square meter room evolves into
- 15:40those massive towering step pyramids we know
- 15:43as ziggurats. Exactly. The religious institution
- 15:46organically birthed itself as the communal organizing
- 15:48principle for resource management. Which sets
- 15:51the stage perfectly for the tipping point. Yes.
- 15:54Because Eridu was prosperous. Maybe a few thousand
- 15:56people at its absolute peak. A very successful
- 15:59town. Right. But it wasn't a megacity. No. To
- 16:02see the true explosion of urban density, we have
- 16:05to move forward into the fourth millennium BC.
- 16:07We have to look at what historians call the Uruk
- 16:10Phenomenon. Ah, the Uruk Phenomenon. Yes. This
- 16:13is where the scale of human existence completely
- 16:16fractures its old boundaries. OK. Between 4 ,000
- 16:19and 3 ,100 BC, the city of Uruk balloons to a
- 16:22size that was previously completely unimaginable.
- 16:25How big are we talking? We are talking about
- 16:27a population of roughly 25 ,000 residents living
- 16:30inside a single urban zone. I am genuinely trying
- 16:35to wrap my head around the logistics of that.
- 16:37It's a lot. Because today, 25 ,000 people is
- 16:40a quiet suburb. Right. But if you were a Bronze
- 16:42Age farmer whose entire concept of human society
- 16:45is like 50 people living in a cluster of mud
- 16:48huts. Yeah. Walking over ridge and seeing a sprawling
- 16:51city of 25 ,000 people must have felt like landing
- 16:53on an alien planet. Absolutely. How are they
- 16:56not all just starving in their own filth? The
- 16:59logistics of feeding and organizing that many
- 17:01people seem impossible for that era. It would
- 17:03be impossible under the old village system of
- 17:06egalitarian farming. Right. And it's during this
- 17:08chaotic period of extreme growth that scholars
- 17:11believe a new linguistic group fully integrated
- 17:13with the local Ubaidian population. Who were
- 17:16they? These people called themselves the Sagiga,
- 17:19which translates to the black -headed people,
- 17:21and they called their land Kangir. The Sumerians?
- 17:24Yes, the Sumerians. And to your point about the
- 17:26logistics of survival, the only way 25 ,000 people
- 17:30can live together without starving is through
- 17:32extreme social stratification and the division
- 17:34of labor. Because you can't have everyone farming.
- 17:36Exactly. You can no longer have every single
- 17:39family growing their own food, weaving their
- 17:41own clothes, and making their own tools. The
- 17:43system would just collapse. So you have to specialize.
- 17:45You have to specialize, and you have to establish
- 17:47a hierarchy. At the top, you have the high priests,
- 17:50who act as the intermediaries for the gods. Below
- 17:52them, you have a burgeoning noble class of administrators.
- 17:55The bureaucrats. The bureaucrats, yes. Then you
- 17:58have your specialized laborers, your full -time
- 18:00potters, weavers, metalworkers, and fishermen.
- 18:02Okay. And sadly, at the very bottom of this new
- 18:05pyramid, you have the introduction of institutionalized
- 18:08slavery, usually prisoners of war or debt slaves.
- 18:11Right. Which is brutal. But let's focus on those
- 18:14specialized laborers for a second. OK. Because
- 18:17when you have full -time potters churning out
- 18:18goods for 25 ,000 people, you completely lose
- 18:22the concept of, like, artisanal craftsmanship.
- 18:24You do. You essentially get the birth of mass
- 18:26production. You do. And the archaeological record
- 18:29provides a brilliant, tangible example of this.
- 18:32The beveled rim bowl. The beveled rim bowl. I
- 18:36love these things. Because when you look at the
- 18:39earlier Ubaid period, they were making this beautiful,
- 18:42intricately painted delicate pottery. Beautiful
- 18:45stuff. But in the Uruk period, the archaeological
- 18:48layers are absolutely choked with these incredibly
- 18:50ugly, rough, unpainted clay bowls. They are everywhere.
- 18:54It's basically the ancient Sumerian equivalent
- 18:56of a single -use coffee cup, or incredibly cheap
- 18:58Tupperware. That analogy holds up perfectly,
- 19:01but I'd actually take it a step further. Okay.
- 19:03It's not just that they were cheap, it's how
- 19:06they were made. If you need 10 ,000 bowls a week,
- 19:09you can't have artisans sitting at a potter's
- 19:11wheel, carefully shaping each one. Right, that
- 19:14takes way too long. So how'd they do it? Archaeologists
- 19:17believe they essentially use the earth itself
- 19:20as a mold. Really? Yeah. They would dig a standardized
- 19:23hole in the ground, press wet clay into it, let
- 19:26it dry, and pop it out. Wow. It was a crude industrialized
- 19:31assembly line process. That is wildly efficient.
- 19:34But why did they need so many standardized bowls
- 19:36in the first place? Because the core function
- 19:38of the city had fundamentally changed. Uruk operated
- 19:41as a massive redistribution engine. OK, how did
- 19:46that work? Well, the patron deity of Uruk was
- 19:48Inanna, the goddess of love and war, and the
- 19:51agricultural surplus of the entire surrounding
- 19:53region was brought to her massive temple complex,
- 19:56the Iyana, as taxation. Paid in grain, wool,
- 19:59and beer, right? Exactly. The priests managed
- 20:02this immense hoard of wealth, and in return they
- 20:04redistributed a portion of those goods back to
- 20:06the populace. Mostly to the laborers working
- 20:09on city projects, right? Right, in the form of
- 20:11daily rations. So those ugly beveled rim bowls,
- 20:15they weren't dining ware. They were standardized
- 20:18volumetric measuring cups for grain rations.
- 20:21So an individual wasn't getting a customized
- 20:23family heirloom bowl to eat from? No. They were
- 20:26basically being handed standardized caloric unit
- 20:28container 4B. Pretty much. It's the world's first
- 20:32massive welfare and redistribution state. It
- 20:34was a highly managed economy. Yeah. But this
- 20:37brings up the most critical mechanical problem
- 20:39of the Uruk period. What's that? If you are a
- 20:42priest and you are trying to manage the incoming
- 20:44taxes from a thousand different farms and the
- 20:47outgoing daily rations for thousands of specialized
- 20:50laborers. Oh, boy. Human memory is going to fail
- 20:52you by lunchtime on day one. Yeah, you absolutely
- 20:55cannot run a society of 25 ,000 people on oral
- 20:58tradition. You cannot. If a farmer claims he
- 21:01already paid his grain tax and the priest remembers
- 21:03differently, how do you resolve that without
- 21:05violence? You need a receipt. You need an objective
- 21:08external system of record -keeping. Which means
- 21:10writing wasn't invented to record epic poetry.
- 21:13No. Or to capture the depths of the human soul.
- 21:16It was essentially invented to be the world's
- 21:18most stressful Excel spreadsheet. That is the
- 21:20profound philosophical shift we have to recognize
- 21:22here. The written word? arguably humanity's greatest
- 21:25invention, was birthed purely out of the desperate
- 21:29need for accounting, taxation, and bureaucratic
- 21:32control. Let's get into the mechanics of that,
- 21:34because they didn't just invent cuneiform overnight,
- 21:36right? The records show it was a gradual hardware
- 21:39and software upgrade. Yes, it started very simply.
- 21:42Before writing, they used physical clay tokens
- 21:45shaped like the commodities they represented.
- 21:47Like a sphere for grain, a cylinder for an animal.
- 21:50Exactly. And they would seal these tokens inside
- 21:53a hollow clay ball called a bula to serve as
- 21:56a tamper -proof contract. OK. But eventually,
- 21:59someone realized they didn't need the physical
- 22:02tokens inside. They could just take a read and
- 22:04draw a picture of the token on the outside of
- 22:06a flat clay tablet. Oh, that's clever. And that
- 22:09gives us Proto -Cuniform, around, what, 3 ,300
- 22:12BC? Yes. Proto -Cuniform consisted of over 700
- 22:16pictographic signs. And it was highly literal.
- 22:20Literal how? You want to record a delivery of
- 22:22cattle. You draw a literal picture of a cow's
- 22:24head. You want to record barley. You draw a stock
- 22:27of barley. But a spreadsheet composed entirely
- 22:30of nouns is pretty limiting. How do they express
- 22:33actions, like verbs? That's where the conceptual
- 22:36leap happens. They started combining these literal
- 22:39pictures to convey abstract ideas. Oh, okay.
- 22:44The classic example from the tablets. If you
- 22:46draw the pictograph for a human head, And right
- 22:49next to it, you draw the pictograph for one of
- 22:51those beveled rim ration bowls. Head plus bowl
- 22:55equals the verb to eat. Exactly. It's the dawn
- 22:58of conceptual writing. That is so cool. But as
- 23:02the bureaucracy expanded, the physical act of
- 23:04drawing curved lines in wet clay with a pointed
- 23:07stylus proved incredibly tedious. The clay would
- 23:09bunch up. It was slow. So they needed a hardware
- 23:11upgrade. They changed the tool. Instead of a
- 23:14pointed stylus used for dragging, they cut a
- 23:17reed. to have a triangular wedge -shaped tip.
- 23:20Okay. Instead of drawing curves, they simply
- 23:23press the wedge directly into the clay, leaving
- 23:25a distinct geometric mark. Ah, and this is true
- 23:29cuneiform. From the Latin cuneus, meaning wedge.
- 23:32It was incredibly fast, it was permanent once
- 23:35baked in the sun, and the abstract combinations
- 23:38of wedges perfectly accommodated the one syllable
- 23:42structure of the Sumerian language. Okay, I get
- 23:44that they have a highly efficient written ledger
- 23:46now. Yeah. Clay is soft before it's baked. It
- 23:50is. I have to ask, how do you prevent a corrupt
- 23:53priest or a shady merchant from just taking their
- 23:56thumb, smoothing out the wet clay, and changing
- 23:59their tax debt from 100 bushels of grain down
- 24:01to 10? That's a great question. Because they
- 24:04didn't have passwords. They didn't have encryption.
- 24:06That is a very real mechanical problem. And their
- 24:09solution to it was elegant. The cylinder seal.
- 24:13OK. What exactly is a cylinder seal? Imagine
- 24:15a small tube of stone, maybe an inch or two long.
- 24:19An artisan would carve an incredibly intricate,
- 24:22unique scene into the surface of this cylinder
- 24:24in reverse. In reverse. Yes. So when a scribe
- 24:28finished a clay tablet, or when an official sealed
- 24:31a storeroom door with a lump of wet clay, they
- 24:33would take this stone tube and roll it across
- 24:36the wet clay. And it leaves a continuous raised
- 24:39relief pattern. Exactly. OK. It functioned as
- 24:42a tamper -proof security tag and a personal ID
- 24:45badge all in one. Wow. Because the carving was
- 24:47so intricate, it was nearly impossible to forge.
- 24:50If someone tried to smooth over the clay to alter
- 24:52a number, they would destroy the seal impression.
- 24:55Instantly flagging the document as tampered with.
- 24:57Exactly. OK, so the bureaucracy is fully weaponized.
- 25:01They have spreadsheets, they have mass production,
- 25:03they have tamper -proof security. They're a machine.
- 25:06But bureaucracy, no matter how perfectly optimized,
- 25:08has a glaring Fatal vulnerability. Right. You
- 25:12can only hoard so much grain, beer, and copper
- 25:14in a centralized temple before someone else from
- 25:17another city or from the mountains decides they
- 25:19want it. That's the reality of surplus. Yep.
- 25:23And an Excel spreadsheet cannot stop an invading
- 25:25army. And that vulnerability fundamentally changed
- 25:28the power structure of Sumerian society. OK.
- 25:31Initially, these megacities were run by the high
- 25:33priests, often titled the N. But being a pious
- 25:36priest who knows how to appease the water god
- 25:38or read sheep entrails, that does not mean you
- 25:41know how to organize a phalanx or manage military
- 25:44supply lines. When a thousand angry raiders show
- 25:47up at the city gates, reading a hymn to Inanna
- 25:50isn't going to save the grain silos. Precisely.
- 25:53As populations continued to boom throughout the
- 25:55region, the fertile land between these city states
- 25:57became incredibly scarce. Until they started
- 26:00bumping into each other. Exactly. Minor disputes
- 26:02over irrigation canals turned into organized
- 26:05armed conflicts. The cities desperately needed
- 26:07secular, charismatic military leaders to protect
- 26:10them. Which brings us to the rise of Kings. Yes.
- 26:14The historical text mentioned a few titles that
- 26:15emerged during this time. You have the NC, which
- 26:19functions sort of like a governor. Right. But
- 26:21my absolute favorite title from the source material
- 26:23is The Lugal, because the literal translation
- 26:26of Lugal is just great man. It's wonderfully
- 26:29direct, isn't it? It really is. The Lugol was
- 26:32the warlord, the man who could successfully lead
- 26:35the city's forces in battle. Initially, this
- 26:37was likely a temporary emergency power granted
- 26:40by the priesthood during a crisis. Like a Roman
- 26:42dictator. Exactly like a Roman dictator. But
- 26:45human nature dictates that once emergency powers
- 26:47are granted, they are very rarely returned. Funny
- 26:50how that works. By 2900 BC, at the start of what
- 26:53we call the early dynastic period, kingship is
- 26:56everywhere. It has become permanent, and more
- 26:58importantly, it has become hereditary. This shift
- 27:02from the priest to the Lugal feels like a massive
- 27:04psychological turning point for humanity. It
- 27:06really is. It is the realization that the primary
- 27:09existential threat was no longer the natural
- 27:11world. It wasn't the unpredictable floods or
- 27:14the lions anymore. The biggest threat to human
- 27:17survival was now other highly organized humans.
- 27:19Yeah. To protect themselves, these cities started
- 27:22building massive defensive walls. Uruk built
- 27:25a wall nearly six miles long. Six miles of mud
- 27:27brick. Yeah, it's a massive undertaking. And
- 27:31inside those walls, the Lugal now shared power,
- 27:33often in a very tense negotiated balance with
- 27:36the entrenched priesthood. And to fully grasp
- 27:38how that power dynamic worked, we have to look
- 27:41closely at the gods themselves. The Pantheon.
- 27:44Yeah, because the Sumerian pantheon is massive.
- 27:47And they are nothing like the modern concept
- 27:49of infallible, all -knowing, morally perfect
- 27:52deities. Not at all. The Sumerian gods were deeply,
- 27:56terrifyingly human in their behavior. Well, the
- 27:58records show you had An, the sky god. You had
- 28:01Enlil, the supreme god of the air in the massively
- 28:04important city of Nippur. Right. You had Inanna
- 28:07in Uruk. Enki in Eridu. Utu, the sun god. And
- 28:12the texts describe them taking human form, eating,
- 28:15drinking, and having extremely petty, volatile
- 28:18emotions. They really did. They were jealous.
- 28:20They held grudges. They threw tantrums. They
- 28:23read like highly armed reality TV stars. It's
- 28:26easy to view that as primitive mythology, but
- 28:29there is an incredibly brilliant psychological
- 28:31and political utility to having gods with bad
- 28:33tempers. Wait, really? How so? Think about it
- 28:36from the perspective of a ruling Lugal. Your
- 28:39mandate to rule relies on the perception that
- 28:41you are competent and favored by the heavens.
- 28:44Okay, sure. But ancient life was inherently unstable.
- 28:48What happens if a plague wipes out a third of
- 28:50your city? What happens if a massive flood destroys
- 28:52the harvest or you lose a catastrophic battle
- 28:55to a neighboring city? If the people blame your
- 28:57leadership, you get overthrown. Exactly. But
- 29:00if the gods are known to be temperamental and
- 29:02unpredictable, you have the ultimate political
- 29:04cover. Oh? You don't have to admit that you're...
- 29:07economic policies failed or your military strategy
- 29:11was flawed, you can publicly declare, well, Enlil
- 29:14was in a terrible mood today because we didn't
- 29:16offer enough barley at the Spring Festival. Wow.
- 29:19That is incredibly cynical. It works, though.
- 29:22Don't look at me. Inanna just woke up on the
- 29:25wrong side of the ziggurat. Exactly. It entirely
- 29:28deflects the blame away from the secular ruler.
- 29:31And simultaneously reinforces the power of the
- 29:33temple. Because the only solution is to double
- 29:35down on the rituals. It's a perfect closed -loop
- 29:38system for maintaining authority during a crisis.
- 29:41That's wild. But when you have these aggressive
- 29:44militaristic kings who view themselves as the
- 29:46earthly enforcers of these petty aggressive gods,
- 29:50you are inevitably going to get border wars.
- 29:52Which brings us to a conflict that the historical
- 29:55records detail extensively. Oh yeah, Lagash and
- 29:58Uma. It might be the world's first recorded multi
- 30:01-generational war, like a micro -scale world
- 30:04war between two highly developed rival city -states,
- 30:07Lagash and Umma. The conflict between Lagash
- 30:10and Umma is a fascinating case study in early
- 30:12geopolitics because it demonstrates how quickly
- 30:15a purely economic dispute escalates into a holy
- 30:17war. Okay. These two city -states were neighbors,
- 30:20and right between them lay an incredibly fertile
- 30:22tract of irrigated land called the Gou Adena.
- 30:25And both cities claimed it, obviously. Both cities
- 30:28needed it to feed their growing populations.
- 30:30The tensions got so high that a powerful king
- 30:33from a third neutral city, Misalem, the king
- 30:35of Kish, came in to act as an arbitrator. Oh,
- 30:38an ancient UN. Sort of, yeah. He surveyed the
- 30:41land, drew a literal line in the sand, and set
- 30:44up a physical boundary stone to enforce the treaty.
- 30:46So they actually tried diplomacy first. They
- 30:48did. But I'm guessing it didn't last. It didn't.
- 30:52The texts tell us that a ruler of Ooma named
- 30:54Ush acted haughtily, ripped the boundary stone
- 30:58out of the ground and marched his army into the
- 31:00Guadana. ripping up the physical treaty. That
- 31:02is a massive escalation. Lagash fought back,
- 31:06eventually led by a king named Eonatum, and we
- 31:09actually have a surviving physical monument of
- 31:11Eonatum's victory known as the Stella of the
- 31:13Vultures. The Stella of the Vultures? Yes. It
- 31:16is a massive carved limestone slab that shows
- 31:19the gruesome aftermath of the battle. It literally
- 31:22depicts vultures carrying away the severed heads
- 31:24of the soldiers from Uma. I've seen pictures
- 31:26of that Stella. It is brutally graphic propaganda.
- 31:30Very much so. But the war didn't end there, did
- 31:32it? No. Uma didn't give up. Generations later,
- 31:35another Uma ruler named Urluma escalated the
- 31:38tactics. He didn't just attack. He systematically
- 31:41diverted the irrigation water away from Lagash's
- 31:44canals. Which is devastating. He burned the replacement
- 31:47boundary stones and even hired foreign mercenaries
- 31:49to supplement his forces. Wow. Ultimately, though,
- 31:52Urluma was defeated and killed by Lagash. Okay.
- 31:55I have to stop here and ask a critical question
- 31:57about the sources we are relying on. Okay, go
- 32:00for it. Because the translated tablets we have
- 32:02seem to repeat this exact same narrative over
- 32:04and over. Lagash was the victim. Lagash was just
- 32:07defending its rightful territory. Uma was the
- 32:10treacherous villain who kept breaking the rules.
- 32:12And Lagash heroically won. Right. Are we just
- 32:15swallowing Lagash's state propaganda? That is
- 32:18exactly the critical lens you need to apply to
- 32:20ancient history. History is famously written
- 32:23by the victors. Right. Or more accurately in
- 32:26Mesopotamia, It is written by the side whose
- 32:28clay tablets happened to survive the millennia.
- 32:31So we are missing a whole chunk of the story.
- 32:34We are almost entirely lacking Uma's perspective
- 32:36on this conflict. Right. Because what if that
- 32:38original treaty drawn up by the King of Kish
- 32:40heavily favored Lagash? It very well might have.
- 32:44What if the boundary line essentially cut Uma
- 32:45off from their primary water source and Uma was
- 32:49actually fighting a desperate war against an
- 32:51unjust economic stranglehold? It is highly probable
- 32:54that Uma viewed themselves as freedom fighters,
- 32:57resisting an oppressive neighbor. That makes
- 32:59so much sense. But what is truly groundbreaking
- 33:01about the texts we do have from Lagash is the
- 33:04rhetorical framework they use to describe the
- 33:07war. How so? The inscriptions on the stellas
- 33:10don't just say, Eonatum, king of Lagash, fought
- 33:12Orluma, king of Uma. What do they say? They explicitly
- 33:16state that Ningirsu, the patron god of Lagash,
- 33:19went to war against Shara, the patron god of
- 33:22Uma. Oh, wow. The elevator to border dispute
- 33:27over a barley field into a cosmic battle between
- 33:30deities. Exactly. This is the absolute dawn of
- 33:34holy war rhetoric, and it is a stroke of political
- 33:37genius by the Lugal. Why? Because if you tell
- 33:40a farmer he needs to leave his family and risk
- 33:42getting a bronze spear through the chest just
- 33:45so the king can collect more taxes from the Gu
- 33:47-Idena field... He might desert. Right. But if
- 33:50you tell him that the enemy has insulted the
- 33:52god Ningirsu and that he is marching in a divine
- 33:55army to enforce the will of heaven... You ensure
- 33:58absolute fanatical loyalty. Yes. You aren't dying
- 34:02for mud. You're dying for the cosmos. Exactly.
- 34:06It's a method of mass psychological mobilization
- 34:08that empires have used ever since. So while Lagash
- 34:12and Uma are busy bleeding each other dry over
- 34:14this patch of irrigated dirt... Other cities
- 34:17in the Sumerian network are amassing staggering,
- 34:21frankly unimaginable levels of wealth. Yes. The
- 34:24economy is booming elsewhere. I want to pivot
- 34:27our focus to the city of Ur. This is the city
- 34:30famously referenced in the Bible as the birthplace
- 34:32of Abraham. Right. But what a British archaeologist
- 34:36named Sir Leonard Woolley found there in the
- 34:371920s. Sounds like something out of a dark fantasy
- 34:40novel. Woolley's excavation of what we now call
- 34:43the Royal Tombs of Ur is one of the most significant
- 34:46and unsettling archaeological discoveries of
- 34:49the 20th century. Okay, tell me about it. He
- 34:52dug into a massive cemetery dating back to roughly
- 34:552600 BC. He uncovered over a thousand standard
- 34:59burial pits, but the absolute centerpieces of
- 35:02the site were 17 elite, incredibly lavish royal
- 35:07tombs. The inventory of the grave goods from
- 35:10the historical records is mind -bending. It's
- 35:13unbelievable. Solid gold helmets, intricate lapis
- 35:16lazuli jewelry, full golden chariots, liars with
- 35:21bullheads made of gold, and beautifully crafted
- 35:24wooden board games. It was a level of opulence
- 35:26that rivaled the pharaohs. But the gold wasn't
- 35:29the most shocking part of the discovery. No.
- 35:31It was the bodies. The bodies. Inside these sealed
- 35:35tombs arranged meticulously around the central
- 35:37burial chamber of the king or queen were dozens
- 35:40of other skeletons. Who were they? These were
- 35:44attendants, musicians, chariot drivers, and fully
- 35:48armed guards. And they were all dead. They had
- 35:52been killed or had killed themselves to accompany
- 35:55the royal figure into the afterlife. The great
- 35:58death pit of Ur. I read that there were over
- 36:0270 bodies in one tomb alone. Yes. I have to understand
- 36:05the mechanics of this. How did they die? Were
- 36:08they a cult? Did they willingly drink poison,
- 36:12believing they were getting a VIP ticket to an
- 36:14eternal paradise? Or were they brutally forced
- 36:17into these pits and slaughtered? It is one of
- 36:20the most chilling debates in Mesopotamian archaeology.
- 36:24Woolley originally theorized that they walked
- 36:25into the pit willingly, drank poison from small
- 36:28cups found near the bodies. and peacefully lay
- 36:31down to die. Based on what? He based this on
- 36:34how neatly the bodies were arranged and the lack
- 36:37of obvious struggle in the skeletal remains.
- 36:40But modern science has something to say about
- 36:42that, right? It does. Recent CT scans of some
- 36:45of the surviving skulls from the tombs revealed
- 36:47evidence of blunt force trauma. Oh, God. Someone
- 36:51struck them in the back of the head with a heavy
- 36:53spike. And furthermore, there's evidence that
- 36:56the bodies were baked. or treated with a rudimentary
- 36:59mercury compound to preserve them. So they were
- 37:02murdered, embalmed, and posed like macabre dolls.
- 37:06It appears so, yes. And what's vital to understand
- 37:09is that this practice, what anthropologists call
- 37:12mass retainer sacrifice, is an extreme anomaly
- 37:15in Mesopotamian history. Oh really? Yeah, we
- 37:18don't find this happening consistently in later
- 37:20periods. It seems to have been a highly localized,
- 37:23relatively short -lived phenomenon specific to
- 37:25the early dynastic rulers of Ur. Thank goodness
- 37:28it didn't catch on. But what does that specific
- 37:31terrifying anomaly tell us about the political
- 37:34reality of Ur at that exact moment in 2600 BC?
- 37:38It demonstrates a terrifying zenith of absolute
- 37:40unchecked royal power. Right. The Lugol of Ur
- 37:44had elevated his status to such a staggering,
- 37:47quasi -divine height above the common people
- 37:49that human life itself was commodified. Just
- 37:52another resource. The lives of his closest courtiers
- 37:55and elite guards were treated functionally no
- 37:57different than a golden bowl, a lapis dagger,
- 38:00or a board game. A human being was just another
- 38:03piece of high -value inventory you pack in your
- 38:05suitcase for the journey to the netherworld.
- 38:08That is a profoundly grim realization. It shows
- 38:11how fully the bureaucracy had consumed the individual.
- 38:14It does. But it's worth noting that not every
- 38:17city expressed power through death pits. True.
- 38:19Take the city of Nepal, for example. Nippur didn't
- 38:22have a massive army and it didn't conquer its
- 38:24neighbors, but it wielded immense power. Why?
- 38:28Because it was the home of Enlil, the supreme
- 38:30god of the pantheon. So, Nippur was basically
- 38:33the ancient Vatican. That's a very apt comparison.
- 38:36Nippur remained fiercely neutral during the constant
- 38:39wars between cities like Lagash and Uma. Okay.
- 38:43Kings from all over Sumer would send lavish gifts
- 38:46in tribute to the temple in Nippur. Because gaining
- 38:49the blessing of Enlil's priesthood provided the
- 38:51ultimate political validation. It's a brilliant
- 38:54racket. It really is. You don't need a standing
- 38:57army if every king in the region is terrified
- 38:58of being excommunicated by your priests. Exactly.
- 39:02But speaking of absolute power, whether it's
- 39:05golden death pits or religious extortion, it
- 39:07inevitably leads to absolute corruption. Oh,
- 39:10always. And that corruption sets the stage for
- 39:13what has to be the world's first recorded populist
- 39:15uprising. Let's look back at Lagash in the 24th
- 39:18century BC. Right. So Lagash had fallen on very
- 39:21hard times since the glory days of Iannatum.
- 39:24The old military dynasty had somehow been ousted
- 39:27and the priesthood had essentially executed a
- 39:30quiet coup. Interesting. They installed one of
- 39:33their own as the ruler. The result was a catastrophic
- 39:36unchecked blending of church and state where
- 39:39the elite priests controlled both the secular
- 39:41government and the temple's vast economic machinery.
- 39:45The records we have outlining the corruption
- 39:47under a ruler named Lugalanda are infuriating
- 39:51even today. Oh, they are. It was late -stage
- 39:53bureaucratic extraction. Lugalanda personally
- 39:56seized massive tracts of public land for himself.
- 39:59Typical. But the taxes were the worst part. They
- 40:02taxed absolutely everything. They taxed the fishermen
- 40:06for fishing. They taxed the shepherds for shearing.
- 40:08They taxed weddings and, shockingly, they levied
- 40:11massive taxes on funerals. Funerals? If you wanted
- 40:14to bury a loved one in the sacred ground, the
- 40:17temple demanded a cut of your personal wealth.
- 40:19It got so severe that the texts describe ordinary
- 40:22impoverished families being forced into debt
- 40:24traps. Yeah. They had to literally sell their
- 40:27own children into slavery just to pay off their
- 40:30tax debts to the temple. It's a society on the
- 40:32verge of total collapse from internal rot. which
- 40:35is the classic precursor to a revolution. Right.
- 40:39After six years of Lugalanda's tyranny, a man
- 40:42named Urukagina overthrows him. And Urukagina
- 40:46is a fascinating historical figure because he
- 40:48doesn't just seize power for the sake of power.
- 40:51What does he do? He frames himself explicitly
- 40:53as a populist reformer. He presents himself as
- 40:56the champion of the poor, chosen by the god Nen
- 40:59-Gursu to clean up the corruption. And he institutes
- 41:02sweeping legal changes. The sources point out
- 41:05that this might be the very first written code
- 41:07of laws in human history. It is widely considered
- 41:10to be the first, though we don't have the actual
- 41:12physical law code tablet itself. Right. We just
- 41:14have other documents bragging about the laws
- 41:16he passed. Correct. But the references we have
- 41:19show a systematic dismantling of the oligarchic
- 41:22corruption. Give me some examples. He boasts
- 41:24that he fired the corrupt tax collectors. He
- 41:27banned officials from seizing the boatman's boats
- 41:30or the shepherd's sheep. He outlawed the exorbitant
- 41:33funeral taxes, and he claimed to have cleared
- 41:36the debts of the impoverished. It's like an ancient
- 41:38antitrust lawsuit. Yeah. Your kagina comes in,
- 41:41breaks up the corrupt monopolies, forgives the
- 41:44debt, and tries to build an equitable society.
- 41:47It sounds like a massive triumph for the common
- 41:48man. It does. But this is ancient history, and
- 41:53no good deed goes unpunished. What actually happened?
- 41:56The tragedy of Uruka Gina is that while he was
- 41:58busy restructuring the internal economy and focusing
- 42:01heavily on domestic social justice, he took his
- 42:04eye off the borders. The old corrupt system of
- 42:07Lugalanda was terrible for the poor, but it was
- 42:10highly efficient at extracting wealth, which
- 42:12probably funded a very robust standing army.
- 42:15So Uruka Gina's reforms likely disrupted the
- 42:17state's military funding. He weakened his own
- 42:19defenses. And right next door... Right next door,
- 42:23a ruthless king named Lugal Zigezi had just taken
- 42:26control of Uma, Lagash's ancient bitter rival.
- 42:29Perfect timing. Lugal Zigezi looked at Lagash,
- 42:32saw a society undergoing painful structural reforms
- 42:35with a weakened military, and executed a violently
- 42:38hostile takeover. He didn't just beat them in
- 42:40a skirmish. The records say Lugal Zigezi invaded
- 42:44and burned the city of Lagash to the ground.
- 42:46Completely destroyed it. It destroyed the temples,
- 42:48slaughtered the defenders, and completely ended
- 42:50Uruka Gina's utopian experiment. We actually
- 42:53have a surviving lament from a scribe in Lagash,
- 42:56who is just utterly devastated, cursing Lugo
- 42:59Zigezi, praying that his personal goddess makes
- 43:01him bear the mortal sins of destroying the city.
- 43:04It is a heartbreaking document, but it highlights
- 43:07a timeless, brutal geopolitical dilemma. Absolutely.
- 43:11How does a nation balance the ethical pursuit
- 43:13of a just, equitable domestic society? with the
- 43:17harsh, expensive reality of maintaining foreign
- 43:20military deterrence. It's the eternal question.
- 43:24And Urukagina failed that balancing act. His
- 43:27just society was eaten by a ruthless neighbor.
- 43:31And Lugalza guess he didn't stop with Lagash,
- 43:33did he? No, he went on an absolute tear. He conquered
- 43:37city after city until he claimed dominion over
- 43:40all of Sumer. He bragged on a vase inscription
- 43:43that his rule stretched from the lower sea the
- 43:45Persian Gulf, all the way to the upper sea, the
- 43:48Mediterranean. Which is almost certainly a massive
- 43:51exaggeration for propaganda purposes. Oh, definitely.
- 43:55But Lugalzagesi absolutely believed his own hype.
- 43:59He thought he had permanently won the Game of
- 44:01Thrones in Mesopotamia. He thought he was invincible.
- 44:04Until he got completely steamrolled by a man
- 44:06who didn't just play the game, but flipped the
- 44:09entire board over. Let's look at the arrival
- 44:12of Sargon of Akkad, Sargon the Great. Sargon
- 44:16represents a complete paradigm shift in the history
- 44:18of human governance. The most important thing
- 44:20to understand about Sargon is that he was an
- 44:23outsider. He was not a Sumerian. He was an Akkadian
- 44:26from the northern region, meaning he spoke that
- 44:29Semitic language we discussed earlier. He didn't
- 44:31come from the ancient entrenched Sumerian noble
- 44:33families. The records show we don't even know
- 44:36his real birth name. No. He literally named himself
- 44:39Sharukin, which translates to legitimate king.
- 44:42Right. I'm sorry, but if you have to forcefully
- 44:44name yourself the legitimate king, you are 100
- 44:47% a usurper. It is the ultimate political tell.
- 44:51And his origin story, which was heavily propagandized
- 44:54later, is straight out of myth. Let's hear it.
- 44:57The autobiographical legends claim his mother
- 44:59was a high priestess who secretly gave birth
- 45:01to him, placed him in a sealed woven basket,
- 45:04and cast him adrift on the Euphrates River. OK,
- 45:07stop me if you've heard this one before. It's
- 45:10the Moses story. It's the exact Moses archetype,
- 45:13written down centuries before the biblical Moses
- 45:15narrative. Wow. The legend continues that the
- 45:18basket was discovered by a humble gardener drawing
- 45:20water from the river. The cardinal raised Sargon
- 45:23as a commoner, teaching him the value of hard
- 45:26work. It's the perfect populist backstory. I
- 45:29wasn't born in a palace. I worked the dirt just
- 45:31like you. Exactly. But somehow. This humble gardener's
- 45:35son rises through the ranks of the royal court
- 45:37in the northern city of Kish, eventually becoming
- 45:40the cup bearer to the king. Let's pause on the
- 45:43role of the cup bearer because it sounds like
- 45:45a lowly servant job just pouring wine. It's not.
- 45:48Right. In a Bronze Age court where poisoning
- 45:51is the preferred method of regime change, the
- 45:54cup bearer is the one person the king has to
- 45:56trust with his life. It implies extreme intimacy
- 46:00with absolute power. It's a position of immense
- 46:03strategic leverage. And we don't know exactly
- 46:06how it happened, whether the king of Kish died
- 46:08or Sargon orchestrated a coup. But Sargon ends
- 46:11up in command of Kish's army. And while Lugal
- 46:15-Zgezi is down south, bloated with arrogance
- 46:18and trying to consolidate his newly conquered
- 46:20Sumerian cities, Sargon marches south with a
- 46:23highly disciplined, modernized force. And he
- 46:26absolutely crushes him? He defeats Lugal -Zgezi
- 46:29in battle. captures him alive, places him in
- 46:32a literal wooden neck stock, and drags him, humiliated,
- 46:36to the gates of Enlil's temple in Napor. Wow.
- 46:39Proving to the entire world that the gods have
- 46:41abandoned the Sumerian warlord and chosen the
- 46:43Akkadian upstart. Exactly. In 2334 BC, Sargon
- 46:48creates what historians widely consider the world's
- 46:51first true empire. Now, conquering a bunch of
- 46:55cities is one thing. But holding them together
- 46:57when they all hate you is another. How did Sargon
- 47:00actually manage this massive new territory? He
- 47:03managed it by completely dismantling the old
- 47:05legacy systems. He didn't just ask the conquered
- 47:08Sumerian nobles for tribute and leave them in
- 47:10charge. He broke their power. He confiscated
- 47:13the massive land holdings of the temples and
- 47:15the old elite and redistributed that land to
- 47:17his own fiercely loyal Akkadian commanders. You
- 47:20replaced the entire management here? Yes. And
- 47:23culturally, he made a massive shift. He made
- 47:25Akkadian the official language of the empire's
- 47:27administration. Sumerian was relegated to a secondary
- 47:30status. And what about the religion? To control
- 47:33the religious narrative, he installed his own
- 47:36daughter Enheduanna as the high priestess in
- 47:38the immensely powerful city of Ur. Enheduanna
- 47:41is amazing. The records note she is literally
- 47:44the first named author in all of human history
- 47:47whose works we actually possess. She wrote these
- 47:49incredibly powerful hymns. She was a brilliant
- 47:52political and theological operative for her father,
- 47:55synthesizing Sumerian and Akkadian gods to unify
- 47:58the populace. Smart. But Sargon's greatest stroke
- 48:01of political genius was spatial. He didn't rule
- 48:04his new empire from Uruk or Ur or Kish. He built
- 48:08a brand new capital city from scratch, Agade.
- 48:11I always wondered about that. Why spend the resources
- 48:15to build a new city in the dirt? When you just
- 48:18conquer the largest, wealthiest, most established
- 48:20cities in the world, why not just move into the
- 48:23palace at Uruk? Because if you move into the
- 48:25palace at Uruk, you are immediately suffocated
- 48:28by the entrenched, centuries -old networks of
- 48:30local nobles, priests, and bureaucrats who secretly
- 48:33resent you. Oh, that makes sense. You are playing
- 48:37on their home turf. By building Agade, Sargon
- 48:41bypassed the old money and the legacy corruption
- 48:43entirely. He created a blank slate. It's the
- 48:47ancient equivalent of a startup disrupting a
- 48:49legacy industry. He built his own platform. Exactly.
- 48:53He forced all the lucrative trade routes, all
- 48:55the tax caravans, and all the ambitious administrators
- 48:57to come to his city. He explicitly leaned into
- 49:00his humble gardener origins to bypass the snobbery
- 49:03of the Sumerian elites. Creating a new meritocracy
- 49:07based entirely on loyalty to the Akkadian crown.
- 49:09It was wildly successful. Sargon's empire was
- 49:13an absolute powerhouse. He ruled for decades,
- 49:15passed it to his sons and eventually to his grandson,
- 49:18Naram Sin, who expanded the borders even further
- 49:21and literally declared himself a living god.
- 49:24The Akkadian Empire seemed invincible. But, as
- 49:27with all things in history, it couldn't last.
- 49:30Because even the greatest, most heavily armed,
- 49:33bureaucratically perfect empires are entirely
- 49:35dependent on something they cannot control. The
- 49:39weather. the weather. That is the ultimate humbling
- 49:42reality of human history. You can have the sharpest
- 49:45bronze spears and the most efficient tax spreadsheets,
- 49:48but if the environment turns against you, the
- 49:50system shatters. The records show that by around
- 49:542193 BC, this invincible Akkadian empire collapses
- 49:58into total fragmented anarchy. It does. The Sumerian
- 50:04King List has this darkly hilarious, almost panic
- 50:07-stricken line describing the chaos of the time.
- 50:10Who was king? Who was not king? It captures the
- 50:13absolute dissolution of central authority perfectly.
- 50:17Right. It's the ancient equivalent of waking
- 50:19up, checking the news during a massive constitutional
- 50:21crisis, and realizing nobody is actually steering
- 50:25the ship. Exactly. But what actually brought
- 50:29down the empire? For a long time, the texts blamed
- 50:32an invasion by a group called the Gutians. Right.
- 50:36The Gutians were a fierce semi -nomadic mountain
- 50:38people from the Zagros range to the east. Okay.
- 50:41The surviving Akkadian and Sumerian texts describe
- 50:43them as savage barbarians who swept down into
- 50:46the plains and destroyed the capital, Agade.
- 50:49But modern archaeology and climatology have given
- 50:52us a much deeper, more systemic answer, haven't
- 50:55they? Yes. The Gutians were just the final symptom
- 50:59of the disease. The root cause was a severe prolonged
- 51:03period of climate change. A mega drought. Yes.
- 51:07Soil samples from the region indicate a massive
- 51:09abrupt climatic shift that caused severe drought
- 51:12and reduced the flow of the rivers. Wow. Now,
- 51:15think about the mechanics of Sargon's empire.
- 51:18It was a massive centralized bureaucracy that
- 51:21relied on a constant flow of agricultural surplus
- 51:24from the provinces to the capital to feed the
- 51:26army and the administrators. Right. No rain means
- 51:30no barley. No barley means the capital can't
- 51:32distribute rations. When the central government
- 51:35stops handing out food, the soldiers desert.
- 51:37And the provincial governors realize they have
- 51:39no reason to send their dwindling local supplies
- 51:42to a powerless king in Agade. The economic engine
- 51:45seizes up. The provinces rebel. The empire hollows
- 51:48out from the inside. And then the Gutians just
- 51:50walk into the ruins. Exactly. They exploited
- 51:53the weakness. But what's fascinating is that
- 51:56the Gutians, according to the archaeological
- 51:58record, didn't really know how to run a sprawling
- 52:01urban bureaucracy. So what did they do? They
- 52:04didn't leave much of a physical footprint. No
- 52:06grand temples, no massive walls. They seem to
- 52:09have operated more like a mafia, extracting tribute
- 52:12from the surviving cities, but largely leaving
- 52:15the local administration to run itself. Which
- 52:18leads to a really interesting psychological shift
- 52:20in how leaders presented themselves. During this
- 52:23chaotic Gutian occupation, a ruler named Gudea
- 52:26comes to power in the city of Lagash. Gudea is
- 52:29fascinating. And he completely changes the PR
- 52:32strategy. Gudea is a brilliant study in reading
- 52:35the room. If you look at statues of Sargon or
- 52:38Naromson, they are depicted as muscular, towering
- 52:42conquerors crushing their enemies underfoot,
- 52:44holding weapons. Right. But Gudea commissions
- 52:46statues of himself sitting peacefully, hands
- 52:49clasped in prayer, with a literal architectural
- 52:52blueprint resting on his lap. He doesn't call
- 52:54himself a warlord. He calls himself a shepherd.
- 52:58Because when the world is terrifying, unpredictable,
- 53:00and wracked by famine and barbarian raids, The
- 53:04populace doesn't want an aggressive warmonger
- 53:06who is going to provoke another conflict. No.
- 53:08They want a shepherd. They want a caretaker.
- 53:12Gudea focuses entirely on civic stability, digging
- 53:15canals and rebuilding temples to appease the
- 53:18gods. It was exactly what the culture needed
- 53:20to survive the Dark Age. But the Sumerians were
- 53:23an incredibly proud people with a deep legacy.
- 53:26They weren't going to let these Gudean mountain
- 53:27raiders dominate their homeland forever. Definitely
- 53:30not. And that leads us to the Sumerian comeback.
- 53:32The Renaissance. What I can only describe as
- 53:35the ultimate triumph of the bureaucratic machine.
- 53:38Oh, the Ur III period. The expulsion of the Gudians
- 53:42begins with a king named Utu -Hugal of Uruk,
- 53:45who finally organizes a coalition force and drives
- 53:48the occupiers out of Sumer. Okay. But it's his
- 53:50son -in -law, a man named Ur -Nammu, who truly
- 53:54capitalizes on the victory. In 2112 BC, Ur -Nammu
- 53:58founds the third dynasty of Ur, which historians
- 54:00refer to as the Ur III period, or the Neo -Sumerian
- 54:04Empire. And Ur -Nammu hits the ground running.
- 54:07Mm -hmm. He doesn't just build an army, he builds
- 54:09a legal framework. He issues a law code, one
- 54:12that actually survived physically on clay tablets,
- 54:15unlike Ur -Kagina's earlier code. That's right.
- 54:18And when you read the translations of these laws,
- 54:20it is shocking how relatively modern they feel.
- 54:23It completely defies our stereotypes of ancient
- 54:26justice. We are conditioned by later codes like
- 54:29Hammurabi's to expect brutal eye for an eye retaliation,
- 54:33physical mutilation for crimes. Right. But Ornamu's
- 54:36code is fundamentally different. It's basically
- 54:38a highly structured list of financial penalties.
- 54:41Exactly. If you knock out another man's eye in
- 54:44a brawl, the state doesn't blind you. The state
- 54:46mandates that you pay the victim half a mina
- 54:49of silver. Interesting. If you sever someone's
- 54:52foot, you pay a specific weight of silver. It
- 54:54is a system of restorative justice focused on
- 54:57economic compensation and maintaining social
- 55:00order rather than blood vengeance. It's incredibly
- 55:02pragmatic. But the real peak of this era, the
- 55:06absolute zenith of Sumerian civilization, happens
- 55:09under Ur -Nammu's son, Shulgi. Shulgi is quite
- 55:13the character. This guy rules for nearly half
- 55:15a century, and his ego is off the charts. He
- 55:18literally declares himself a living, breathing
- 55:20god. while he's still alive. He did. He commissions
- 55:23hymns where he calls himself a ferocious lion
- 55:26and brags that he can run faster than a gazelle.
- 55:29Shulgi possessed an ego that rivaled the pharaohs.
- 55:31He expanded the empire's borders significantly.
- 55:35But beneath the divine posturing and the military
- 55:37campaigns, Shulgi's true lasting achievement
- 55:40was entirely administrative. It was paperwork.
- 55:42It was the most intense, micromanaged paperwork
- 55:45the ancient world had ever seen. The Earth restate
- 55:48under Shulgi is arguably the most highly centralized
- 55:51bureaucratic society in all of antiquity. How
- 55:54much paperwork are we talking about? Archaeologists
- 55:56have translated approximately 100 ,000 administrative
- 55:59clay tablets from this specific period alone,
- 56:02and there are likely thousands more sitting unread
- 56:04in museum basements. 100 ,000 spreadsheets. I
- 56:08can barely manage my monthly budget, and they
- 56:10are tracking the granular economics of an entire
- 56:13empire on wet mud. They tracked absolutely Everything.
- 56:17We have tablets detailing the exact daily caloric
- 56:21rations for specific classes of weavers. We have
- 56:25records of individual sheep transfers, manufacturing
- 56:28quotas for copper tools, and precise agricultural
- 56:30yields down to the bushel. But collecting data
- 56:33is useless if you don't use it to optimize the
- 56:36system. And Shulgi's administrators used this
- 56:39data to invent something profoundly clever to
- 56:41manage the empire's taxation. It's called the
- 56:44Bala system. The balla system, which translates
- 56:47to exchange or rotation, is a logistical masterpiece.
- 56:51Think about the mechanical problem of taxing
- 56:54a massive empire. OK. If you tell every province
- 56:57to pay their annual grain tax at the exact same
- 56:59time, say, right after the harvest, what happens?
- 57:02You get a traffic jam of epic proportions. Thousands
- 57:05of caravans arrive at the capital simultaneously.
- 57:08You don't have enough silos to store the grain.
- 57:10It rots in the street. And your scribes die of
- 57:12exhaustion trying to tally it all in one week.
- 57:15Precisely. It's a logistical nightmare. So Shulgi's
- 57:19bureaucrats decentralized the collection. Under
- 57:21the Bala system, different provinces were assigned
- 57:24specific months of the year to pay their portion
- 57:26of the tax burden based on their regional wealth
- 57:28and production capabilities. I absolutely love
- 57:30this because instead of an annual tax nightmare,
- 57:33they essentially invented MRR, monthly recurring
- 57:35revenue, for a Bronze Age empire. That's a great
- 57:38way to look at it. Province A pays in January,
- 57:41Province B pays in February, and so on. It guarantees
- 57:43a steady, predictable, manageable cash flow and
- 57:46supply line for the state every single month
- 57:48of the year. It is exactly like MRR, but we should
- 57:52add a layer of historical realism to that analogy.
- 57:55Right. Unlike modern software subscriptions,
- 57:57this MRR was enforced at the end of a bronze
- 58:00spear. If Province B decided they didn't want
- 58:03to make their February grain payment, Shulgi
- 58:05didn't just cancel their premium account and
- 58:07send an email. He sent the Imperial Army to burn
- 58:10their fields. That is a very fair point. Compliance
- 58:13was not optional. But the Uri 3 dynasty didn't
- 58:16just innovate economically, they innovated culturally.
- 58:20The records show they engaged in this massive
- 58:22state sponsored project of weaponizing nostalgia.
- 58:26They did. You have to remember, the region had
- 58:28just suffered through centuries of Akkadian dominance,
- 58:31where the Sumerian language was marginalized,
- 58:33followed by the chaos of the Gutian occupation.
- 58:36Right. Ur -Nammu and Shulgi wanted to legitimize
- 58:39their rule by connecting themselves to the ancient,
- 58:41pure roots of Sumer. So they artificially resurrected
- 58:45the Sumerian language. They made it the official
- 58:47language of government and literature again,
- 58:50even though Akkadian was likely still the primary
- 58:52spoken language of the common people. Oh, interesting.
- 58:55They commissioned state scribes to collect and
- 58:57write down the old oral legends. This is when
- 59:00we get the earliest written versions of the Epic
- 59:02of Gilgamesh. They were actively constructing
- 59:04a shared fabricated cultural purity to unify
- 59:08a fractured populace. They were trying to make
- 59:10Sumer great again. It's a brilliant political
- 59:13strategy. You build an incredibly efficient economic
- 59:16machine and you wrap it in the comforting, glorious
- 59:20nostalgia of the ancient past. It worked well
- 59:23for a time. It seems like a society that has
- 59:26figured everything out. But despite all the brilliance,
- 59:31despite the MRR and the epic poetry, the Oir
- 59:343 empire suffers from the ultimate imperial hubris.
- 59:38They genuinely believed they could build a wall
- 59:41to keep the changing world out. Let's talk about
- 59:44the Amorites and the end of an era. The Amorites
- 59:47were nomadic, Semitic -speaking tribes migrating
- 59:49eastward from the Levant, essentially modern
- 59:52-day Syria. And the urbanized, highly -structured
- 59:55Sumerians, sitting securely behind the walls
- 59:57of their megacities, looking at their 100 ,000
- 1:00:00tax records, absolutely despised these nomads.
- 1:00:04The surviving texts are incredibly xenophobic.
- 1:00:07They describe the Amorites as uncultured savages
- 1:00:09who know no grain, who eat raw meat, and who
- 1:00:13don't even have the decency to bury their dead
- 1:00:15properly. The Sumerians view them as the antithesis
- 1:00:19of civilization. So faced with this influx of
- 1:00:22migrants looking for better grazing land and
- 1:00:24opportunities, King Shulgi attempts a massive
- 1:00:27engineering solution. The wall. He builds a wall.
- 1:00:31And not just a city wall. He attempts to build
- 1:00:34history's first true regional border wall, stretching
- 1:00:37across the narrowest point of the floodplain
- 1:00:39designed specifically to keep the Amorite tribes
- 1:00:41out of the Sumerian heartland. A literal border
- 1:00:44wall. How long did it work? It failed, as almost
- 1:00:49all static border walls in history do when faced
- 1:00:51with massive demographic shifts. You cannot physically
- 1:00:55wall off a mass migration that is driven by underlying
- 1:00:58economic or environmental necessity. So what
- 1:01:01did they do? The emirates simply walked around
- 1:01:04the ends of the wall where it met the rivers,
- 1:01:06or they slowly infiltrated over decades. By the
- 1:01:09time we reach Shulgi's successors, specifically
- 1:01:12a king named Ebi -Sin, Around 2004 BC, the situation
- 1:01:17has completely deteriorated. Completely. The
- 1:01:19Amorites haven't just bypassed the wall. They've
- 1:01:22settled down inside the borders. They've taken
- 1:01:25over smaller towns. And that destroys the bureaucratic
- 1:01:28machine. When Amorite tribes control the provincial
- 1:01:31roads, the local governors can't or won't send
- 1:01:33their bala tax shipments to the capital at Ur.
- 1:01:36The MRR dries up. And when the capital stops
- 1:01:39receiving grain, the highly centralized state
- 1:01:41rapidly collapses. Inflation skyrockets. The
- 1:01:45army fragments. It is the classic tragic irony.
- 1:01:48You build a massive, expensive wall. You stare
- 1:01:52at it, convinced it's keeping you safe. And while
- 1:01:55you were entirely focused on the wall, the world
- 1:01:58changes. And someone else sneaks in through the
- 1:02:01back door. Precisely. And while King Ibbeson
- 1:02:04is desperately trying to hold his crumbling state
- 1:02:06together against internal Amorite pressure, the
- 1:02:09fatal blow comes from the outside. Who was it?
- 1:02:12An old rival sees the weakness. Kindatu, a powerful
- 1:02:15king from Elam, which is in modern -day Iran,
- 1:02:18marches an army across the border, completely
- 1:02:21bypasses the useless Amorite wall, and sacks
- 1:02:24the great city of Ur. Oh, wow. They burn the
- 1:02:27temples, loot the treasury, and carry King Ibesen
- 1:02:30away in chains. And that specific event, the
- 1:02:32fall of Ur in 2004 B .C., marks the definitive
- 1:02:35political end of the Sumerian state. They never
- 1:02:38rise to independent power again. Never again.
- 1:02:41And their language dies out too, right? The records
- 1:02:44indicate that by 1800 BC, basically nobody was
- 1:02:47speaking Sumerian in the streets anymore. It
- 1:02:49only survived as a dead scholarly language for
- 1:02:51temple scribes, much like Latin in the Middle
- 1:02:54Ages. Yes, Sumerians ceased to be a living, breathing
- 1:02:57language. I have to ask, from a historical perspective,
- 1:03:00how does an entire culture just die? How do the
- 1:03:04people who invented writing in cities just vanish?
- 1:03:07That is the greatest secret of ancient history.
- 1:03:10They didn't vanish. The physical people didn't
- 1:03:13evaporate into thin air. They assimilated. OK.
- 1:03:16The conquerors and the conquered blended. The
- 1:03:19new Babylonian civilization that eventually rose
- 1:03:22from these ashes was a complete vibrant hybrid.
- 1:03:25It absorbed the Sumerian agricultural techniques,
- 1:03:28their complex pantheon of gods, their advanced
- 1:03:31mathematics, including our 60 -minute hour, and
- 1:03:34their cuneiform writing system. And they blended
- 1:03:36all of that with Akkadian and Amorite culture.
- 1:03:39Yes. So the culture didn't die, it evolved. It
- 1:03:43left its foundational, invisible DNA behind in
- 1:03:46everything that followed. Exactly. Which brings
- 1:03:50us to the end of this incredible arc. Think about
- 1:03:53the journey we just mapped out. From a tiny,
- 1:03:56eight square meter mud brick shrine where egalitarian
- 1:04:00farmers offered fish bones to a water god in
- 1:04:03the marshes of Eridu. Yeah. all the way to the
- 1:04:06100 ,000 spreadsheets of a self -proclaimed god
- 1:04:09-king managing a brutal, highly -taxed empire
- 1:04:13in it were. The Sumerians essentially beta -tested
- 1:04:16the concept of human civilization for the rest
- 1:04:19of us. They ran the first experiments on urbanization,
- 1:04:23statecraft, and economics. They gave us the wooden
- 1:04:26plow. They gave us mass -produced tupperware
- 1:04:29in the form of beveled rim bowls. They gave us
- 1:04:32the concept of centralized accounting. the 60
- 1:04:34second minute, and the written word itself. So
- 1:04:38why should you, listening to this deep dive,
- 1:04:41care about people who lived in the mud 5 ,000
- 1:04:44years ago? Exactly. Because the next time you
- 1:04:47look at an itemized receipt from a grocery store,
- 1:04:50or you stress over paying your monthly taxes
- 1:04:52to a centralized government, or you check your
- 1:04:55calendar to see what month it is, you are actively
- 1:04:58participating in a mechanical system designed
- 1:05:00by the blackheaded people millennia ago. And
- 1:05:04that realization leaves us with a profound, almost
- 1:05:07unsettling question to consider. Let's hear it.
- 1:05:11Sumerian died as a spoken language, but its cultural
- 1:05:14DNA survived in the Babylonians, the Assyrians,
- 1:05:17the Greeks, and eventually through a long unbroken
- 1:05:19chain in us. Right. It forces you to wonder,
- 1:05:235 ,000 years from now when our current spoken
- 1:05:26languages are completely dead and our modern
- 1:05:28empires are just... dust and archaeology. What
- 1:05:31invisible, everyday pieces of our current lives
- 1:05:34will still be secretly running the civilizations
- 1:05:36of the remote future? That is definitely something
- 1:05:39to chew on. Thank you so much for joining us
- 1:05:42on this deep dive into the source material. Keep
- 1:05:44digging, keep questioning the narrative, and
- 1:05:46we will catch you on the next one.