Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Operational Risks in Credit Unions - What We See in 2025
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trifle with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:02This is another short take where we will talk about operational risks, cyber
- 0:07communication, strategies for cyber legacy system conversion, nightmares, uh, core
- 0:13conversions, and other operational risks that occs talking about we're seeing
- 0:18with our clients, et cetera, et cetera.
- 0:20Thanks for listening.
- 0:24Treichel: Next up the general topic in the, uh, the risk report
- 0:27was operational risks being elevated across multiple fronts.
- 0:32Any thoughts on that broad topic?
- 0:36Bauer: Yeah, the only thing I wanted to add or talk on is cyber right?
- 0:41Cyber risk.
- 0:42We spent a lot of time obviously developing our incident response plan.
- 0:47And I think that is so key for every credit union is to have a incident
- 0:51response plan that is ready and tested.
- 0:55And probably the most important part of that is just your communication plan.
- 1:00So you take the, we took the approach that we're gonna have a
- 1:03cyber incident, something's gonna happen, we're gonna get hacked, we're
- 1:08gonna have some kind of exposure.
- 1:11Um, so we took that approach in developing our incident re response
- 1:15plan, and, uh, we spent a lot of time.
- 1:19All the different aspects involved with that.
- 1:21But, but the hard part, I think at the end and is it's not the technical part
- 1:26of, of cyber, but it's communication.
- 1:27How do you communicate to all the stakeholders, to your board, to
- 1:30your staff, and most importantly, how do you communicate this
- 1:33to your, to your membership?
- 1:35'cause that's so critical because you can, if you mess that up, then
- 1:40you could have a huge reputation risk 'cause social media will explode.
- 1:44And you're gonna have bigger issues.
- 1:45So that to me is the most important part of dealing with with cyber.
- 1:50And then obviously having proper cyber insurance in
- 1:54place, understanding your risks.
- 1:56Um, you might have to have multiple cyber policies to get the coverage you want.
- 2:00But that to me is so key for, uh, for accrediting today.
- 2:05Treichel: Great points, Steve.
- 2:08Todd.
- 2:10Miller: Just kinda one thing they point out in the risk report along
- 2:13this line and operational risk, they talk about legacy technologies
- 2:18creating competitive disadvantages.
- 2:21Well, we, we've seen this with a couple of our clients.
- 2:24You know, they try and upgrade systems so they can keep up with the rest
- 2:29of the world and they end up having conversion issues and members lose
- 2:33access to payment systems and they get accounts that can't be reconciled.
- 2:39And so while all these upgrade paths are very important, it's
- 2:44like you need to have good plans and testing before you go through
- 2:47conversions of some of these older.
- 2:49Legacy systems, the cost of doing a conversion improperly is
- 2:54pretty significant and sometimes it drags you for a couple years.
- 2:59Back to Dennis's whole thing about having a plan for when something like
- 3:03this does happen, you know, you had the big credit union in the news last
- 3:07year on the West coast where members couldn't access their funds for where
- 3:11to drag on for a week or more, more.
- 3:14Um, you know, those are pretty significant risks.
- 3:18NCUA has been really good about how they handle this with credit unions.
- 3:23They have their information security officers, they rarely write doors,
- 3:28but they're really good about findings and they issue a lot of findings.
- 3:32And I think their whole attitude is amongst their information security
- 3:37officers is they are there to help you and improve your security profile.
- 3:42Um, that's generally the course of action they take.
- 3:45Some of this gets back to a cost thing.
- 3:48Again, what can you afford?
- 3:50So I would just say, you know, for the cranes out there, when you get multiple
- 3:53findings in your information security, ask your examiner, prioritize them for you.
- 4:00Because some of the stuff is very expensive and you know what
- 4:05has to be done today versus.
- 4:07What kind of residual risk can I take if I don't spend that money, for six months?
- 4:13So ask them to prioritize.
- 4:16I don't think operational risk and cybersecurity risk will ever
- 4:22leave the top three or four risks from our regulators ever again.
- 4:27And the AI fraud tools, there's, you can go on the dark web and find
- 4:32AI tools to help you commit fraud.
- 4:35So it's just gonna be an ever growing kind of a race to the top or race to the bottom
- 4:42depend if you're a criminal or a credit.
- 4:45You trying to keep criminals out.
- 4:47Plan on spending money in this area.
- 4:49Treichel: Forevermore, Steve?
- 4:53Farrar: No, I think we covered it.
- 4:54'cause I, I had wr written down and Todd covered it was you that we, you
- 4:58know, are surprised that, you know, the conversion issue has become.
- 5:03Something that's, uh, when it rears its head, it is just so ugly.
- 5:08Yep.
- 5:09Bauer: Yeah, that's one thing.
- 5:11We did a pretty much a wholesale change back in 2018 through 2022.
- 5:17Right.
- 5:17We upgraded core digital debit card.
- 5:21Right.
- 5:21We did a lot in a in a three year period of time.
- 5:23But just the core itself, I mean, take the time to do the necessary data cuts.
- 5:30I think we did three or four, um, before we were, we were comfortable.
- 5:35Before we moved to our core, we, so then when it came to, uh, conversion
- 5:39weekend, it went without, incident.
- 5:41Um, and then o other thing I've seen out there is you credit unions
- 5:45purchase a new a new, uh, core system, and they don't necessarily know a
- 5:50hundred percent what they purchase.
- 5:51It's, it's too much.
- 5:52Um, they don't have the expertise.
- 5:54So I think understanding exactly what, what you're getting into before, um, you
- 6:00know, what's all involved, particularly at the end as, as far as generating the
- 6:04necessary reports that you need, how the report writers work how the accounting
- 6:09function's gonna work, how that's gonna maybe integrate with a third, uh, a
- 6:13third party type of accounting system.
- 6:16Making sure that's all tested.
- 6:17So that's so key.
- 6:18Taking as, as Todd and Steve said taking your time and spending
- 6:21the money to do it right.
- 6:23And if you've gotta overspend a little bit to get it right I think it's well
- 6:26worked out so you don't have issues with your membership at the end of the day.
- 6:30Treichel: As someone once said, if you don't have time to do it right,
- 6:32you don't have time to do it over.
- 6:34Miller: Exactly.
- 6:36Treichel: All right.
- 6:37Fraud schemes targeting traditional payment methods and otherwise, Dennis, I