Latest / Q&A: Social Security Disability Today / When you decide to sue the Social Security Administration
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning everyone. Good morning, and it is me Anthony Reads, and
- 0:04I'm here to talk to you a little bit about what happens if you decide
- 0:09to sue the Social Security Administration. Here's where it gets a little tricky.
- 0:13Most of you, if you've been applying for Social Security disability benefits, are
- 0:17probably familiar with the administrative process. That means you've probably been sent forms,
- 0:22you probably had to go to see doctors. You've also probably been denied a
- 0:27few times, and so you're probably used to dealing with Social Security. So
- 0:32that process in itself usually takes about two years. In its entirety, it
- 0:37means you've applied for the benefits, you've gotten denied once, maybe twice.
- 0:41You go before here before a judge. That didn't work out, so then
- 0:44you appeal to the Appeals Council. Then that doesn't work out. Then you
- 0:48get this letter that basically tells you you have a right to file a civil
- 0:52action. Some people don't understand what does that mean. Well, basically,
- 0:57what it means is that you're going to sue Security Administration. Now, soci
- 1:02Security Administration at one point in time had the distinction of being the most sued
- 1:07organization in the country, which is not too surprising based on the share volume
- 1:11of cases that come through. But let me tell you what usually happens,
- 1:15because a lot of times people are like, what happens to my case?
- 1:18What happens to my old case? And my money? What happens? What
- 1:19happens? And I'm like, Okay, here's how it usually shakes. Usually,
- 1:23when you get denied by a judge at that point in time, most
- 1:26people will then apply file a new application. While that new application is pending,
- 1:30the old one goes through the Appeals Council, and then finally we get
- 1:34to this level where if the Appials Council denies you, you have a right
- 1:37to sue the Social Security Administration. What usually happens at that point is you
- 1:42have to go into federal court and basically the federal courts wherever you're located at
- 1:46the time, whether it be it doesn't matter, because there's a federal court
- 1:49in every state in the Union. And then what happens is you file a
- 1:55complaint with the court. You have to basically server. You're basically serving the
- 2:00Attorney General, the United States attorney who's going to be arguing the case,
- 2:04and the commissioners soid security, and then what will happen is they will file
- 2:08an answer and then provide a what we call a transcript of what happened at
- 2:15the lower level, what happened before the judge that's going to usually have the
- 2:19application all of the medical records and non medical records that the judge had before
- 2:24them when you had your hearing. Then what happens is your attorney or yourself
- 2:30be representing yourself, will then write a legal brief describing what the judge did
- 2:36wrong. Here's where people sometimes lose sight of it. When you're in federal
- 2:40court. The judges there are not making a determination of whether you're disabled or
- 2:46not. That's not what they're doing. They're deciding whether or not the judge
- 2:50made an error of law that would justify them sending the case back to the
- 2:57judge to do it again. Hear me when I say the judge, when
- 3:00they're at the federal court level, they're not there to decide whether you're disabled.
- 3:06They're there to determine whether or not the judge who heard your case at
- 3:09the administrative level got the law wrong. If they got the law wrong,
- 3:14they're gonna send it back to the judge to look at again. Now,
- 3:17one or two things will usually happen. In this particular instance, you're usually
- 3:22going to have either the judge is going to agree with the Commission of soci
- 3:27Security Administration that the judge down at the lower level got it right. At
- 3:30that case, the only thing you have left is to appeal up to the
- 3:35Circuit Court of Appeal. And then that's a whole different level. And then
- 3:38if you lose there, you can try to go to the Supreme Court.
- 3:40They don't always take cases, they choose which ones to take. That's a
- 3:44whole different beast altogether. If you win at the federal court level, then
- 3:49what happens is it gets sent back to the judge. If you file the
- 3:53new application, maybe you've gotten approved on a new application. Then what happens
- 3:57is that those two applications, the old one and the new one, will
- 3:59get solidated into one big application. Is what they'll look at. Now,
- 4:04here's the one thing I tell people all the time, and when it's at
- 4:06the federal court level, a couple of things. One you cannot rush to
- 4:12judge. You know, It's amazing how many times when you're an administrative level
- 4:15you'll send documents saying I'm about to be foreclosed, I'm about to be bankrupts,
- 4:18I'm about to be evicted, and I need you to speed this up.
- 4:20And the Social Security Administration has procedures in place that allows it the luxury
- 4:27and the ability to be able to expedite claims. At the federal level,
- 4:31there is no rushing a federal court judge, not like not like the administrative
- 4:35level. The administrative level, those federal judges have certain guidelines that can follow
- 4:41to determine whether or not it's a case that can be expedited. At the
- 4:45federal court level, you're not looking at that same luxury. The second thing
- 4:48you need to be aware of is that while your case is pending, you
- 4:53can file a new application, So just in case you hadn't done that when
- 4:57you got denied by the judge the first time, you can still file a
- 5:00new application. Third, if you get approved at the federal court level,
- 5:04it has to go back to the same judge. If the same judge has
- 5:09not had a chance to hear the case twice, the regulations require that that
- 5:14judge be given the same opportunity. So it's not one of those things if
- 5:16you had a judge that you thought was bad. You were like, well,
- 5:18can we get a new judge? You, no, you can't.
- 5:20The reg say that every judge has at least two chances to get it right,
- 5:26and then it'll go back back. Then it'll go back. Now here's
- 5:29the final thing that a lot of people ask me. Well, let's say
- 5:30the judge at the federal level sends it back, that same judge denies it,
- 5:33and it gets denied again by the appeals council. Can you appeal it
- 5:38back in the federal court. Yes, you can. That's the one thing
- 5:42that's nice about the regulations. It's not at bar. It doesn't mean like
- 5:46if the federal court judge denies you at the federal court level, sends it
- 5:48back to the federal and then a straight up level and you get denied,
- 5:51you're done. No, you still have the ability to what we call exhaust
- 5:57your appeals, meaning you can appeal as long as you can. So it's
- 6:00finally decided. Now it's a wrap. Let's shut it down. You're down.
- 6:03So keep those things in mind. One other point I want to bring
- 6:06up is the fact that once you get into federal court, the appeals process
- 6:12is slow. Were you just kind of put that out there. For those
- 6:15of you who are like, could it be slower than the administrative process?
- 6:18It's not designed to be slower, but the reality is is that it does
- 6:21take a while. So I want you not to freak out when you're like,
- 6:25well, what's going to happen now? After both sides have argued their
- 6:29case before the court, the judge will then make a decision. You just
- 6:31have to wait. I know you hate that you've heard it all through the
- 6:34administrative process about that lovely phrase hurry up and waiting, But unfortunately hate to
- 6:39be the bare or bad news. You got to do that here too.
- 6:42But keep in mind one thing, the administration and the process is designed to
- 6:46give you the ability to fight as much as you possibly can, so please,
- 6:49by all means, take advantage of it if you feel that you have
- 6:53a valid claim. My name's Anthony reads everybody. Hopefully that helps you out
- 6:58if you're thinking about suing the Social Security Administration. For more, check out
- 7:01my blog www dot legalbet dot Anthony Reeves dot com, or you can check
- 7:06me out at the Theeves Lawfirm www dot reesfirm dot com, dedicated to representing
- 7:12the disabled and the discriminator