Latest / James O'Brien Daily / How deep does racism run in Reform UK?
Transcript
- 0:02This is a global production.
- 0:06Hello and welcome to another installment of my daily podcast, full of the best bits of news, discussion and discoveries from my LBC show.
- 0:18It is domestic politics that draws our attention once again.
- 0:22I kind of fascinated by what's going on at the moment with regards to Reform uk.
- 0:30I appreciate that.
- 0:31If you are.
- 0:32Are uncomfortable listening to evidence of what they are, who they are, what they.
- 0:36What they stand for, because you've been drawn to them, then I just would cautiously remind you that you're uncomfortable with what you're becoming.
- 0:43You're not uncomfortable with hearing journalism or consuming journalism.
- 0:51You're uncomfortable with what you are.
- 0:54And that's great.
- 0:55And this is really important.
- 0:57I remember when Steve Bannon said you should.
- 0:59You should embrace the accusation of racism, but the fact that you're not ready to embrace it yet is brilliant because it means that you are not a bigot.
- 1:07It means that you are capable of changing your mind.
- 1:10You're capable of shame.
- 1:11You're capable of knowing you are becoming something really, really ugly.
- 1:16And this is the fascinating thing about the research that ITV have done, because what happens when all of these candidates and counselors and senior politicians and junior politicians, what happens when they think they are in private is that
- 1:31they make it clear they don't have any shame.
- 1:34It's a weird.
- 1:34I mean, it's almost a spectrum, isn't it?
- 1:37So you're messaging me to say, don't talk about this.
- 1:40You know, change the record or whatever it might be.
- 1:42You're kind of scared of your own reflection in the mirror or disgusted by your own reflection in the mirror.
- 1:48And then you've got the people who would be very outspoken and bigoted and racist in private.
- 1:55They're just frightened of the public reaction that they are not disgusted by what they see in the mirror.
- 2:01Do you see the difference?
- 2:02Is this worth exploring a little further?
- 2:05So you're still listening to this program despite being drawn towards Nigel Farage's bigotry.
- 2:12And that means that somewhere deep inside, you know that what you're becoming or what you're doing or the path that you're going down is wrong.
- 2:22If you've signed up for the party and you are publicly pretending not to hold the views that you express privately, you've gone much further down, down that path, haven't you?
- 2:31You've gone much, much further down that path.
- 2:34You.
- 2:34You are not ashamed or disgusted by the reflection that you see in the mirror.
- 2:39You are simply wary of the reaction you will get when other people see your real face.
- 2:44So, so you pretend not to be these things, you pretend not to be those, not to hold those views.
- 2:53And then, because you're probably, although by no means definitely not the sharpest knife in the drawer, you, you have a new colle offered to go canvassing with you, and your mask immediately drops.
- 3:07Your mask immediately drops.
- 3:09You immediately start saying things and expressing views that you.
- 3:16That you know are toxic to right thinking people, but which you are really committed to, that you really, really hold.
- 3:26So, I mean, there it is in a sense, Nigel Farage's defense, as ever, is that it's not his fault.
- 3:32Nothing is ever his fault.
- 3:34If Shaggy wasn't black, Nigel Farage would probably have him as his favorite popular music artiste.
- 3:41Because it wasn't me.
- 3:41It was never me.
- 3:42It wasn't me.
- 3:43I didn't do it.
- 3:44It wasn't me.
- 3:45And claiming that it's impossible to vet people over things that they haven't said yet, while completely ignoring the fact that they have failed completely to respond properly to things that people actually have said.
- 3:58Including his own communications director calling for a candid candidate called Chris Parry to be suspended after indulging in incredibly racist abuse of David Lammy.
- 4:12And that's the point, isn't it?
- 4:13That's the thing I'm a little bit confused about today is that, I mean, I'm witnessing.
- 4:18Look, some of the Farage apologists and cheerleaders are just pretending that none of this is happening.
- 4:23You could probably turn your telly on or turn your radio on.
- 4:26And some people who are in the business of tickling his toes won't be talking about it at all.
- 4:30And again, that's kind of a good thing because at least they're not lying or pretending that there's nothing to see here, here.
- 4:36But it's another spectrum, isn't it?
- 4:39So in the same way that some people are still a little bit ashamed of what they see in the mirror when it's held up in front of them.
- 4:45And some people aren't.
- 4:46They're just worried about what the reaction of the public would be.
- 4:49So it is in the media that some of the Farage apologists and the farish cheerleaders will simply not talk about it at all because it makes them feel a bit uncomfortable or because it would involve a little bit
- 4:59of self examination.
- 5:00It would involve a little bit of honesty.
- 5:03So let's just not talk about it.
- 5:05No, let's not talk about it at.
- 5:06All.
- 5:08Versus actually defending him or saying these are, these are just bad apples or these are the consequences of unfair journalism.
- 5:17So spectrums everywhere on this story.
- 5:20And yet the thing that I find really bizarre and the thing I feel a bit embarrassed about actually, is that it's all so obvious.
- 5:28I mean, who honestly thought that a political organization led by Nigel Farage would not attract hideous racists and misogynists?
- 5:36Who, who, I mean, put your hand up.
- 5:40Who only remember the fellow who got in touch yesterday saying, I can't believe you keep calling reform racist.
- 5:45I support reform and I'm not racist.
- 5:47Just a quick look at his message history to this studio and he was complaining, he was expressing a hope that no foreigners ever come to Cornwall.
- 5:54Not illegal immigrants or refugees or asylum seekers or people forced to come here via unsafe routes, but literally foreigners.
- 6:02And then, and then I don't know whether it was tongue in cheek or not, but then also literally stating, I can't possibly be racist because I've got a black friend.
- 6:10You have to hope that's tongue in cheek.
- 6:12But spoiler alert, some people are still living in 1973.
- 6:17So the spectrums are there.
- 6:20And, and the denials, as ever with Farage, are both mealy mouthed and disingenuous or downright dishonest because of course, the accusations involve plenty of evidence of people saying things that they were made aware of and seek to excuse
- 6:35or, or ignore.
- 6:37Sweep under the carpet.
- 6:39And there's a couple of things we're going to get stuck into the clips from the ITV News investigation shortly.
- 6:45There's a couple of things that I think really merit closer examination and it's this idea that any of this is surprising.
- 6:59That's where I'm feeling a little bit embarrassed.
- 7:02It's as if you remember when we were looking for Tories who weren't obsessed with Brexit.
- 7:08I'm wondering where they go now.
- 7:10Do you know, I think I've been holding in my mind, out of decency and kindness, I've been holding in my mind the possibility that you could stick across in a box for this fellow and not be comfortable or
- 7:24sympathetic with the racism that he represents or the racists that he obviously attracts and has done for his entire career.
- 7:32The idea that you could be looking at a political party that is absolutely obsessed with small boats, despite the fact that they're plummeting this year.
- 7:43Absolutely obsessed with immigration, despite the fact that it's come down at a rate of knots.
- 7:48Absolutely obsessed with the number of people coming to this country who are, for example, from former Commonwealth countries or who are of color.
- 7:58And completely forgetting that just 10 years ago your man said this I take.
- 8:04A very strongly pro Commonwealth view.
- 8:07I think it was very bad and wrong of us to turn our backs on the Commonwealth in favor of a European political project.
- 8:14And we've made a bad mistake.
- 8:16So now what we do is if you've got a qualification and you come from India or you come from parts of Africa, you now find it very, very difficult to get into this country.
- 8:27Despite the historical strong.
- 8:31You're still anti immigration.
- 8:32So I don't, I won't have that.
- 8:34You are anti immigration.
- 8:35You scaremongering and inflammatory in your campaign that have gone against people that look non white British people going to stop about their identity and nationality in this country.
- 8:49That is what I really want to know.
- 8:51It's extraordinary.
- 8:52Right there he is calling for more non white immigration and what is his literal political platform now what is it?
- 8:58You tell me what, what has he ever stood for except racism of different hues?
- 9:03Back then it was Eastern Europeans.
- 9:04It's people with names like Novak that he wanted to get rid of, that he didn't want to have in this country, claiming that he wanted more people from India and Africa to come here.
- 9:12You literally heard that right?
- 9:15More people from India and Africa.
- 9:18So how has he ended up attracting people who.
- 9:20Or defending people that are incredibly racist about someone like David Lammy, who was born in South London.
- 9:26It's almost like a kind of knot that we've never successfully untied because we are dedicating too much time and energy to thinking that it's complicated.
- 9:35It's really not.
- 9:36Any party led by Nigel Farage has attracted racists and bigots on an extraordinary scale since the very, very beginning.
- 9:45You know, the man that founded Ukip accused him of routinely using the N word in conversation.
- 9:51Of course, there were no microphones there.
- 9:53So when journalists want to investigate what these people say in private, they go in with microphones and guess what the reaction is.
- 9:58To complain about the microphones.
- 10:00It's absolutely extraordinary that we're all sitting here.
- 10:03Well, no, because we're not all sitting here today marveling at how blatant it is and how commonplace it is and how really you just have to follow one of these people around for five minutes with a, with a
- 10:14hidden camera and they will say something absolutely hideous, something that would get you sacked from most jobs.
- 10:18Indeed, I think one of them has been suspended from his job in the prison service already.
- 10:22And yet the point here is what they say in private, what they all seem to say and believe in private.
- 10:31And who gets to be surprised by that?
- 10:33You've got your hero, your leader, literally calling 10 years ago for more immigration from Africa and India, and now portraying more immigration from Africa and India as being the end of British civilization as we know it or part
- 10:45of some sort of great replacement theory.
- 10:47It's the absence of honesty that I can't stop focusing on.
- 10:51This absolute absence of honesty, because you show me this man today and then stand him next to the man from 10 years ago calling for more immigration from Africa and India.
- 11:06You tell me what the hell is happening here, what the heck is going on and why so many people are falling for it.
- 11:12We'll look shortly at the latest tranche of evidence, not just of racism, because as I tire of telling you, where racism goes, misogyny very quickly follows.
- 11:21Unfortunately for Sarah Poachin, the MP who is uncomfortable with seeing brown and black faces on television, she apparently never clocked the fact that if you get into bed with racists, then you will wake up with a misogynist.
- 11:35And I think Farage is great genius, and I use the word advisedly, is to wink at them.
- 11:41In fact, there's kind of evidence of that in the ITV stuff that was broadcast last night.
- 11:47How can Nigel Farage publicly claim to.
- 11:50I mean, they even claim they've done more to keep the Far Right out of British politics than anybody else, which is.
- 11:55I mean, it's comical to a tragic degree, but that's what they do.
- 12:00So they all think that Nigel.
- 12:02They all know that Nigel agrees with them, but he's just a little bit better than they are at never quite giving it away.
- 12:08That, at least, is the view of Ian Frost, the former chair of Reform's Chester branch.
- 12:16So what's the vetting process?
- 12:19Vetting process.
- 12:20This is the first stage.
- 12:22He meets with the chair of a reform branch in Chester and tests the reaction when he mentions his support for Tommy Robinson.
- 12:29I previously got an account where I've been like, some sort of support, like Tommy Robinson might be.
- 12:34Tweeted some stuff like that.
- 12:35Now I don't.
- 12:36What were they?
- 12:37Accounts on Twitter and.
- 12:39Well, apps, isn't it?
- 12:42If they're there, I can find them.
- 12:43Delete them all.
- 12:44Really Delete them.
- 12:45Right, Okay.
- 12:45I think Tommy Robinson is outdone to.
- 12:48Yeah, yeah, right.
- 12:49And I think the bulk of what he says I agree with.
- 12:52Right.
- 12:53All but politically, he's toxic.
- 12:56And what Nigel Prage has learned over.
- 12:5830 years of being in politics is we've got to play the game a little bit.
- 13:02Anything where you've got things.
- 13:05Tommy Robinson or anything like that.
- 13:07Okay.
- 13:07I would Delete the account and I'd.
- 13:09Start again with no red flags raised.
- 13:13He's encouraged to apply.
- 13:15You might become a counselor, you might then want to go the mp.
- 13:18Yeah.
- 13:19So social media.
- 13:21Yeah.
- 13:21Then apply.
- 13:22I join on the group.
- 13:24Any questions, give me a call.
- 13:25Brilliant.
- 13:26All right.
- 13:26Lovely.
- 13:27Ian Frost told us he thought the reporter was a genuine candidate and gave him the benefit of the doubt.
- 13:35He said it's not fair to judge people on a single conversation.
- 13:38And that for unrelated reasons, he has now left Reform uk.
- 13:42Oh, bless.
- 13:43That's the thing, isn't it?
- 13:45You know, there it is, someone saying, I want to be a candidate.
- 13:47Someone senior in the party saying, well, you better delete your far right affiliations out and pretend you're not like that.
- 13:52And crucially, what Nigel has learned over 30 years of being in politics is we've got to play the game a little bit.
- 13:58There's another one who said something like, you don't tell them what you're going to do.
- 14:00You just wait until you're in power and then you do it.
- 14:03Hey, who gets to be surprised by this stuff?
- 14:05Who gets to be surprised?
- 14:07And it goes right to the top as well, because this is Farage talking to his own communications director about a mayoral candidate who everybody wanted to sack in defense of some of Farage's colleagues.
- 14:18Everyone else in this room wanted to sack him for being hideously racist about David Sammy, a British politician, but.
- 14:25But not Nigel.
- 14:26Apologize to Lamb.
- 14:28Yeah, that's what he's doing.
- 14:29If David Lamb is taken, he's not.
- 14:31Too happy with it.
- 14:32No, I'm sure.
- 14:33But we just need to do it and move on.
- 14:34Yeah, I agree.
- 14:35Turn him out properly.
- 14:37Yeah.
- 14:37Attached him.
- 14:38Just showing a bit of.
- 14:41Bit of sock.
- 14:42I'm sorry.
- 14:42It's probably a good thing.
- 14:43Yeah, yeah.
- 14:45He's the rear app.
- 14:46That's the problem.
- 14:50But later, Reform's director of communications said Chris Parry should have been dismissed.
- 14:56It's up to me.
- 15:00Who decides if.
- 15:01These people stay or goes at night.
- 15:09It was a concerted effort to try.
- 15:11And get rid of him somehow.
- 15:12He cleans and then we head back to Makerfield, where the former candidate Alex Lomas revealed just how rigorous the vetting process is.
- 15:27ITV's Undercover Reporter is in Greater Manchester, where Reform are campaigning in the Makerfield by election.
- 15:33I usually have in my pocket, but.
- 15:34I don't want to bend them all.
- 15:35He meets Alex Lomas, who says he's twice failed Reform's vetting process to be a party candidate.
- 15:42First time he applied, he said, we can't because you use the word excessively.
- 15:46Oh, no.
- 15:47In case that.
- 15:48Loads of videos.
- 15:49The second one was a Tommy Robinson post.
- 15:51Oh, what was that?
- 15:52He's sharing all the time.
- 15:52Robson balls.
- 15:53Too far right.
- 15:54Tommy Robinson is banned from joining Reform uk.
- 15:57But despite being rejected, Lomas says he then got a phone call a few days later.
- 16:02Basically, on the second application, I got declined on the Friday.
- 16:05Yeah.
- 16:06I got an email through on the Tuesday.
- 16:07And you're participating.
- 16:08I said, you better check with your.
- 16:10Paperwork, mate, because I just failed it on Friday.
- 16:11Now he's saying, I passed it, I've not changed anything.
- 16:14And I got a phone call a few days later.
- 16:16I always stand for Reform uk.
- 16:20Thank you.
- 16:20Thank you.
- 16:21They failed.
- 16:21He would then lay back in on Tuesday anyway.
- 16:23Yeah, but they needed someone to stand.
- 16:26They basically just wanted to say, we.
- 16:27Are standing at a candidate in every single ward in Oldham.
- 16:31Yeah.
- 16:31In May, Alex Lomas did stand for Reform in Oldham in the local elections and came second, losing by just 200 votes.
- 16:41And just because I think it's worth it, you can go back 12 years to get a bead on just how sincere or honest or trustworthy Nigel Farage is being when he talks about how important it is to vet
- 16:57candidates for his party.
- 16:59It was a different party.
- 17:00I think it was a different party.
- 17:02But two or.
- 17:03But one, it's hard to keep track, isn't it?
- 17:04But one thing is always true.
- 17:06Whatever the party is called, it's always full of racists.
- 17:09This is him talking to me, actually.
- 17:11I think in.
- 17:12In 2014.
- 17:14My argument, James, is this.
- 17:15Wherever we have found people who have had extreme, racist, unpleasant views, we've unceremoniously got rid of them.
- 17:23Furthermore, I've tried to protect the party by making absolutely clear that anybody that had previously been a member of the BNP or organizations like that cannot even join as a member.
- 17:33And to hold up the views of a handful of people as being representative of ukip, frankly, isn't the truth.
- 17:39I mean, you gotta feel sorry for the fellow, right?
- 17:40I mean, it just keeps happening to him.
- 17:42It's almost as if he's walking through a garden that is full of rakes lying flat on the.
- 17:48On the pole.
- 17:48And everywhere he puts his foot, there's a rake that just springs up and smacks him in the face.
- 17:52That's for.
- 17:53That's what, 12, 14, 12 years ago, you're having exactly the same conversation and making exactly the same claims.
- 17:59And now we've got footage, we've got recorded footage of people who have publicly expressed profoundly far Right views being encouraged by Nigel Farage's army to.
- 18:09To delete their messages and sign up for the party anyway.
- 18:12And that line, the line, I think that's most important of all, what Nigel has learned over 30 years of being in politics is we've got to play the game a little bit.
- 18:21So there it is.
- 18:22Fair play to ITV News for this extraordinary investigation.
- 18:27You sort of find yourself wondering why nobody's bothered doing it before.
- 18:31And don't forget to tune in on Sunday evening, when I suspect that they haven't even released the worst stuff yet or the best stuff.
- 18:38I supp.
- 18:38I suppose, depending upon your perspective, I suspect that we're going to be seeing stuff on Sunday evening that is even more damning.
- 18:43And you can predict with absolute certainty that there will be two.
- 18:472 Responses from Reform.
- 18:49They will try and claim to be the victims and they will try to claim that there is nothing to see here.
- 18:55They will simultaneously try to say, poor us, poor us, poor us.
- 18:59And how dare journalists do.
- 19:01Do journalism.
- 19:03So it's been on the news two nights running now on itv and the documentary from which all of this reportage is drawn will be on Sunday evening.
- 19:14So, I mean, it is.
- 19:15And remember, I mean, they've only got a finite number of journalists.
- 19:18It's almost as if every single rock they've looked under has thrown up racists and.
- 19:23Or misogynists.
- 19:24And who here can honestly say that they are surprised?
- 19:27And that's the bit I want to get into, really.
- 19:30I'll read you this first, actually, I'm friends with the wife.
- 19:32This is unsigned.
- 19:33Of a reform counselor.
- 19:34She's tried not to tell anyone, anyone who's in reform.
- 19:36When he was a conservative counselor, everybody knew.
- 19:39She knows it's something I wouldn't approve of.
- 19:42She's explained to me that she isn't racist and she couldn't be because she works with Asian nurses.
- 19:46And then she tells me how lazy they all are.
- 19:48There's no part of her that ever saw anything wrong with what she was saying.
- 19:51And 10 years ago she would never have said this.
- 19:56So I think that we want to ask a couple of questions now, one of which is, I mean, the reform person in your life, the reform voter or the reform supporter in your life.
- 20:13And you're not going to believe me when I tell you that I want some people to answer no to this question.
- 20:19I want yes as well, but I want some people who answer no to this question.
- 20:24The reform supporter in your life, are they racist?
- 20:28So we don't need to do undercover Journalism.
- 20:31I don't need to strap a secret camera to my lapel or hide a microphone in my handbag.
- 20:36I can just ask you, because it's your mum that we're talking about, or your friend or your dad or your uncle.
- 20:41And that line there breaks my heart.
- 20:44She's saying things she never would have said 10 years ago.
- 20:47There is a reason why people are doing that.
- 20:50Someone has given them permission.
- 20:51Oh, indeed.
- 20:52Adam picks up this point.
- 20:53James Farage is giving the permission structure.
- 20:56Just like Trump banging the drum for racism.
- 20:58Mrs.
- 20:59May didn't stand up to Trump's racism.
- 21:01Farage went to Mar a Lago to kiss the ring of the Grand Wizard.
- 21:04Freedom of speech is a ridiculous conscript.
- 21:06Go to any town in the UK and within two minutes you will see a person of color.
- 21:10They are part of our society, full stop.
- 21:13So, and the other line you'll hear is, this is how everybody talks down the pub.
- 21:17This is how everybody speaks in private, which is just not true.
- 21:21There's probably three Responses to what's going on now?
- 21:24Claim we're the victims, blame the journalists, and then, despite the fact that it contradicts everything that's gone before, claim that they're just saying what everybody else says.
- 21:33So the reform just simply put, you can, you know, I don't need too much detail on who or what they are, but you know, someone, and I think, think it would be even more powerful if you love someone
- 21:45and they support Nigel Farage.
- 21:48Are they racist?
- 21:50Time for a short break now.
- 21:51Afterwards, the best callers in the business.
- 22:02George is in Leeds.
- 22:03George, what would you like to say?
- 22:05Hello, James.
- 22:05Hello, George.
- 22:07Yeah, I had a lodger who lived with me for quite some time.
- 22:11He was actually my friend from many years ago, back from when we were, you know, very young, 16, 15.
- 22:20He was an avid reform supporter.
- 22:23He had lots of kind of Christo fascist views.
- 22:28What does that mean?
- 22:28Christo fascist?
- 22:29Is it.
- 22:30Is it kind of.
- 22:31He kind of justified his racist views and speech with the fact that, you know, we needed Christianity to rise up and defeat Islam and all that type of stuff.
- 22:41He was a real kind of Trump supporter, MAGA supporter.
- 22:44When did it start?
- 22:46I think when he went away abroad to other countries and came back a different person.
- 22:52I just didn't recognize him anymore.
- 22:55And the last 10 years, I mean, how, how do you police or how do you navigate that?
- 23:02Because he's your friend, he's living in your house at one point.
- 23:06Yeah, I'll ask one cheeky question.
- 23:07I have to throw him out in the End.
- 23:09And what was the breaking point?
- 23:10What was the kind of just him.
- 23:12Trying to impose those views on me and kind of force them down my throat all the time, inviting or wanting to invite, you know, Reform Party members around to my house, which I just didn't want, obviously don't want
- 23:24those sort of people to kind of be around my house.
- 23:26I don't agree with their views or their opinions.
- 23:29Yeah, just kind of very big, almost.
- 23:32Not always outwardly race.
- 23:35But he'd been given permission to be of that opinion that, you know, Islam was bad, Muslims were bad and, you.
- 23:40Know, what did he.
- 23:41What did he hope to do about that?
- 23:43What was his sort of.
- 23:44Did he have a plan on.
- 23:45On how we were going to have, I mean, fewer Muslims coming to this country or fewer Muslims living in this country, by the sounds of it.
- 23:52Did he have.
- 23:53He didn't justify the violence against things like the mosques and things like that, but when I mentioned that there'd been attacks on mosque mosques, he was kind of almost, well, you know, there's worse things that could happen, you
- 24:03know, and it's kind of like, oh, really?
- 24:05That's really.
- 24:06So, yeah, we ended up clashing quite, quite badly.
- 24:08And you asked him to no longer live in your house?
- 24:10Absolutely.
- 24:11Where is he now, do you know?
- 24:13No idea.
- 24:14No, I don't think he went abroad again.
- 24:15Do you think he might be at church?
- 24:18He does go, yes.
- 24:20Yeah, he does.
- 24:22Whether I feel that his values are truly Christian, I'm not quite sure.
- 24:25It doesn't matter what we think.
- 24:27He should share them with the priest.
- 24:28Priest.
- 24:29That would probably be the best thing to do.
- 24:31Or indeed with members of his congregation who might be of color.
- 24:35Thank you, George.
- 24:36I mean, it's tricky, isn't it, the navigation, the negotiation of these things.
- 24:40But a lodger and an old friend is a lot easier to cut out of your life than a mum or even a partner.
- 24:4710:38 and I would like to hear all of those examples.
- 24:50The idea that this documentary is unrepresentative seems to me to be ridiculous, and that if you were to secretly record your friend or your family member who is a fan of Nigel Farage, they would be coming out with
- 25:03stuff indistinguishable from what the bigots who were recorded by ITV came out with.
- 25:08Ian is in Sheffield.
- 25:09Ian, what would you like to say?
- 25:11Hi, James, thanks for having us on.
- 25:13I've listened to you a long while.
- 25:14So, yeah, no good speak to you.
- 25:16I'm third generation, so on my dad's side, we came over on the Windrush, my dad has recently basically remarried and his new partner of a few years have really just started getting into reform and post a lot of
- 25:30reform anti immigrant rhetoric online.
- 25:34And it does, it causes huge issues with our family to the point where we've had to say if you, if you keep doing this, then you're no longer going to be welcome in our house, which has caused a
- 25:44big problem within our own family.
- 25:45I mean, we're a working class family.
- 25:47We all work.
- 25:48I've worked in some really male orientated environments and worked at sea.
- 25:51Well, according, according to Richard Tice, mate, you hear this stuff all the time.
- 25:55Time we don't.
- 25:56And this is it.
- 25:57And this is the huge insult.
- 25:59The huge insult.
- 26:00I mean, I can't say the word that we'd call it, but it runs with punts.
- 26:03Yeah.
- 26:04If someone was to say something about a woman and then compare it to your daughter in a sexual manner, it would be disgusting.
- 26:10You just.
- 26:11There are limits.
- 26:11And the fact that he thinks that that's okay.
- 26:13And I was listening to some of your colleagues yesterday and some of the reform voters that are coming on there and trying.
- 26:17Why don't they ring me?
- 26:18Why don't they ring me?
- 26:20Because they know that they'll, they'll have.
- 26:22To explain a couple of simple questions.
- 26:24What do you actually stand for?
- 26:26How do you feel about old saying he wanted more African and Indian immigrants back in 2016?
- 26:31So tell me what they were saying.
- 26:32I was busy yesterday, but they were.
- 26:35Just really struggling to condemn some of the things that those councillors were saying.
- 26:39And it is, it's indefensible.
- 26:41And I'm just.
- 26:42How dare you suggest it's indefensible?
- 26:44It's only their own press office who described it as indefensible and their job being to defend it.
- 26:48So it's going to divide, isn't it?
- 26:50And this is the thing.
- 26:51I don't know how to defuse this thing.
- 26:54I don't know how to defuse this thing.
- 26:56Because you're going to claim A, that this is completely unfair and it's appalling invasion of, of privacy and B, they're only saying what everybody thinks anyway.
- 27:08They can't both be true, can they?
- 27:10It's not.
- 27:10It's not, you know, so why are they not saying it openly and publicly?
- 27:15Because they're too ashamed.
- 27:17So what, you hope they were ashamed?
- 27:19Yeah.
- 27:19You would hope that.
- 27:20Well, that's my spectrum.
- 27:21Spectrum, you know, people getting cross with me for talking about it are still capable of being ashamed.
- 27:25The people who are Being recorded, saying this stuff in private, are not remotely bothered about being ashamed.
- 27:31They're just bothered about being outed, if you like, as racists in a society that happily still rejects racism most of the time.
- 27:39Are you going to fall out with your dad as a consequence of this?
- 27:42I mean, we're trying not to.
- 27:43I mean, it's a really difficult situation, but it is an education thing.
- 27:48I mean, I think that she's acting with the best interests at heart without realizing that what she's doing is, is causing harm.
- 27:54And it's such a strange being a mixed raised family and then to have somebody come in and just badmouth immigrants.
- 28:02What's your dad's ethnicity, if you don't mind?
- 28:05No.
- 28:05So on my dad's side, it's.
- 28:07We're all English.
- 28:07Yes.
- 28:08My grandad came over on the Windrush, so he's from Jamaica.
- 28:11So your dad is half West Indian or.
- 28:15Right, okay.
- 28:16And then your mum was white is why.
- 28:18Yes, so.
- 28:20So your dad is actually one of the people that his own wife is complaining about, but she doesn't mean him.
- 28:25No, I mean very much.
- 28:27He almost detracts himself.
- 28:28Oh, it doesn't apply to me.
- 28:30And it's.
- 28:30And I've had to explain to him, it's like, yes, yes, it does apply to you.
- 28:33Not only does it apply to you, but it applies to me and it applies to your, your grandchildren.
- 28:38Because he doesn't seem to understand that the anti immigrant rhetoric applies to all immigrants.
- 28:43They say it's just the people on the boats, but let's, you know, we're not politicians here.
- 28:46Let's be honest.
- 28:47They just mean anyone who's not white.
- 28:48Well, that's what these clips demonstra.
- 28:50They mean David Lammy and they defend the man who means David Lammy.
- 28:54That's got nothing to do with small boats.
- 28:55So he can still run for mayor after saying, David Lammy's got no business being in this country because he's black.
- 29:02Exactly.
- 29:03And when I walk down the street, you know, people see my skin color, will see my daughter's skin color.
- 29:07And I don't have a sign above my head that says this is one of the good ones.
- 29:10Or a clock that ticks back to when you first arrived or when your granddad first arrived.
- 29:17Yeah, it's weird.
- 29:18I mean, you.
- 29:20What do you know what annoys me, Ian?
- 29:22What annoys me is that you and people like you will be putting all of the effort and all of the generosity and trying to build these bridges and trying to keep these relationships alive.
- 29:30Because you love your mother, you love your dad and possibly you love your stepmother as well.
- 29:34But, but they won't be putting any effort into it at all.
- 29:37And in their other ear this poison will constantly be poured and, and I don't think we are hearing anything in these recordings that we're not seeing on the, on the, on the websites and the Facebook pages of the
- 29:49kind of people that are drawn to this pseudo politics.
- 29:53But it's going to be up to you, isn't it?
- 29:55To pour oil on the water and try to keep things sweet until you perhaps reach the point where you can't do it anymore.
- 30:01And that's the unfortunate situation.
- 30:03I mean I am sort of quite happy that I know that a lot of the activity online is bots and I think that emboldens people.
- 30:08People think that there are more of them than there actually are.
- 30:11And that's the question, you know, so back in the day you'd have some guy in the corner of the pub who'd shout and scream something and people are shut up John, don't worry about it.
- 30:18But when people go online and they're supported by BO and obviously the Internet brings people together, they are able then to find like minded people and then this grows and then the misinformation that gets spread.
- 30:28And I had an argument with them recently and.
- 30:30Oh, don't give me the facts.
- 30:32Oh, welcome to my world.
- 30:33Oh, there you go.
- 30:35It was fun.
- 30:36Yeah.
- 30:36And that's it, isn't it?
- 30:37Because there's something really comforting or nourishing about the feelings even if they're based on, on, on non existent statistics.
- 30:45And that's where the I don't mean you thing comes from.
- 30:47I'm sorry for what you're getting going through, I really am.
- 30:49What's the plan for Christmas, if you don't mind me asking?
- 30:52Well, we just continue as normal.
- 30:54I mean, you know, we're at that stage where do we invite them?
- 30:57Do we not because of the offense.
- 30:59I know some family members have already said that they're not welcome.
- 31:02Yeah.
- 31:03And it's.
- 31:04And I feel, I feel sorry for my dad.
- 31:05I said I don't think she's doing it out of badness, but I don't think she really realizes.
- 31:10And a lot of my friends or ex friends didn't realize what they were doing because I had to point it out to them.
- 31:15I was like, I understand you may have legitimate concerns over migration.
- 31:19Yeah, right.
- 31:19I don't believe, believe they're real, but you've got a legitimate concern.
- 31:24However, what you're doing is that you're.
- 31:26You're standing next to people that are extreme and you're racist because you happen to share one opinion.
- 31:33Again, very generous after each other.
- 31:35And.
- 31:35And they're also putting a target on your back.
- 31:37I think that's what, again, if anyone really needed it, spelling out.
- 31:40That's what these clips make clear.
- 31:42You know, it's not just new arrivals or refugees who've crossed on small boats.
- 31:47It's David flipping Lammy.
- 31:48It's everybody who isn't white.
- 31:50It's the black faces on television.
- 31:52It's the black faces on the pavements that Robert Generic walked down in Birmingham.
- 31:56So by support, even if you allow them the defense, the fig leaf of legitimate concerns, which I am increasingly persuaded has been quite a big mistake by the.
- 32:05The decent side of the country, even if you allow them their legitimate concerns, they are still painting targets on your back.
- 32:12Back.
- 32:13They are.
- 32:13They are.
- 32:14And.
- 32:14And my families.
- 32:15And that's.
- 32:15That's really what's changed the situation.
- 32:17And that's what I say.
- 32:18Do you realize what you're doing will hurt your grandchildren?
- 32:21Because I've grown up through the 80s and experience races and things like that, and it sort of went away.
- 32:26And over the last few years, it really does seem to have made a bit of a comeback.
- 32:29I don't want my daughter to experience the same things.
- 32:32And that's the argument I say to my friends and family members that may be going down this path.
- 32:38It's like not thinking about me, thinking about your friends.
- 32:41Don't look at what you see online.
- 32:42Look at your friends who come from immigrants.
- 32:44Look at your friends who are immigrants.
- 32:45Are they these people going off committing murders?
- 32:48I'm not saying that immigrants don't.
- 32:49Of course they do.
- 32:50Every demographic commits murders.
- 32:52There's some horrible stories around at the moment that we're probably not, but we shouldn't talk about.
- 32:57There's one story in particular in Stockport that is unthinkably hideous.
- 33:03And yet I don't think there'll be any protests or marches or masked men descending upon streets where they're not welcome as a consequence of the.
- 33:12The crimes that men have been convicted of in those cases.
- 33:15Ian, thank you.
- 33:15Good luck.
- 33:16I don't know how patient I'd be in the same situation that you're in.
- 33:20I hope I'd be as patient as you, but there comes a point where patience is pointless.
- 33:26This is nice from Steve.
- 33:28I'm a reform supporter, and the reason I won't call is that you are a skilled debater and I'm not.
- 33:33You'd destroy me, belittle me and call me racist and I wouldn't be able to get any of my points across.
- 33:37That's okay, mate, you can write them down.
- 33:39I am not racist.
- 33:41I align with reform more than any other party.
- 33:43I hate a lot of the abhorrent comments on the news the other day, but nevertheless, the party and what they stand for align with my views.
- 33:49I want to stop the relocation of Africa and Asia to Europe.
- 33:54That's it.
- 33:55And I don't even have to be a skilled debater to point out to you that the man who leads the party that you claim you support despite not being a racist, you just want to stop people coming here
- 34:04from Africa and India literally campaigned during Brexit on replacing European workers with workers from Africa and India.
- 34:14Laura is in Sheffield.
- 34:15Laura, what would you like to say?
- 34:16Morning, James.
- 34:17Hello.
- 34:19Hopefully I can help you out with what's it like to have somebody like that in your life.
- 34:23Not so much.
- 34:24Good on the, what you can do about it because I'm kind of hoping that listening to this this morning, I might get some ideas.
- 34:31Yeah, we might move on to that in the next hour.
- 34:33I don't know what the answers are, but somebody might.
- 34:35And it's more likely to be somebody who's come back out of the swamp, isn't it, than someone who can sort of adv on helping people out of the swamp.
- 34:42But go on.
- 34:43Yeah, sure.
- 34:44So I've had a best friend for about 20 years, been through absolutely everything together and I'm very, very close to her and her mum.
- 34:54When I met my friend and her mum, her mum was a labor supporting, mirror buying, quite left leaning person and the difference in her in the last 20 years is it's, it's unbelievable.
- 35:11So she, she's 70.
- 35:14They came up this summer and we were sitting in the garden and I actually, I actually asked them to come inside because I, I just, the thought of any of my neighbors hearing what she was saying just, it
- 35:27was just awful.
- 35:29What would she say?
- 35:30I mean obviously I know I can trust you to sort of.
- 35:33Yeah.
- 35:33To tailor it.
- 35:34Yes.
- 35:35I mean it's, it's obviously like the, the race thing is.
- 35:37That is the number one thing.
- 35:38It's all about el.
- 35:39Immigrants and the fact that, you know,.
- 35:42Where do they live?
- 35:43Again, I don't even like repeating it.
- 35:45Fair enough.
- 35:46Do they live in an area of high immigration?
- 35:48No, that was, that was one thing I said to her when she was saying about the boats.
- 35:51They live in Nottingham Right.
- 35:52And I said, oh, that's a big problem.
- 35:54Is it in Nottingham?
- 35:55Yeah.
- 35:56Boats.
- 35:56Boats arriving on the docks of the,.
- 35:58The river then, does she?
- 36:01No, but that's, that's the thing that.
- 36:02They've been given permission to articulate.
- 36:06Yeah.
- 36:07And the other thing is, even when I try to go push back on some of this, you hit a great.
- 36:12Well, I don't want to talk about it.
- 36:13I don't want to talk about it.
- 36:14We'll end up falling out.
- 36:15I don't want to hear it.
- 36:16So you can't even kind of try and reason with them and maybe make them see another side.
- 36:21They don't want to see another side to their, their beliefs.
- 36:24I, I genuinely think with her, it was Covid.
- 36:28It was sitting in the house, it was getting a mobile phone and it has just gone.
- 36:32I think she's just fallen down.
- 36:33This algorithm of absolute hate.
- 36:36And any sort of problems in her life is directly then applied to, you know, I mean, we went out, James, to a lovely.
- 36:44Anyone who knows Sheffield, there's a lovely place called Longshore.
- 36:46Beautiful, stately home.
- 36:48Me and my friend took her out there and we went and sat down, we got a nice cup of coffee and a local school turned up from somewhere in Sheffield that obviously had a slightly higher than normal Asian
- 36:59population.
- 37:00I just saw a load of school kids turning up to come on a school trip.
- 37:03Trip.
- 37:04Soon as those.
- 37:05The kids turn up, she was bristling.
- 37:07Oh, here we go, you know.
- 37:09You know, and it was.
- 37:10I was so uncomfortable because I thought, she's gonna say something, you know, something's gonna happen.
- 37:14Blimey.
- 37:16How's your friend coping with it?
- 37:17And what's it.
- 37:17Doing it to your friendship with her?
- 37:19Well, this is the thing we've.
- 37:21I've, I've had to try and step back.
- 37:23My friend isn't.
- 37:24She always just says, I'm not really political.
- 37:26So whenever we, we talk about anything, she just kind of steps back.
- 37:29I think she's quite embarrassed, but obviously it's her mom, so what's she gonna do?
- 37:35And I think she's.
- 37:37It's.
- 37:37I mean, as I say, it's 20 years.
- 37:39Best friend I've ever had.
- 37:40And I'm at the point now where the last time she came up, I.
- 37:43I said to my partner, first of all, I said, can you take the kids out?
- 37:46Because I don't want my kids hearing any of this.
- 37:48Yeah.
- 37:48So I wouldn't even let her be around my children.
- 37:50And I think for me, that was the kind of the final straw.
- 37:52I thought If I can't have her in my garden and I can't have around my kids, why is she my life?
- 37:57You know, and, and that sounds awful for someone that's been there for 20.
- 38:01Years, but you see, you're doing, you're doing what the other lad did, is it?
- 38:04You're the one doing the, doing the, doing the suffering.
- 38:07You're the one being generous.
- 38:08Hasn't crossed her mind that when she comes to sit in your garden, maybe she shouldn't say things that she must know by now you find deeply offensive.
- 38:15Yeah, well, that there's like, there's no filter, though.
- 38:17That's the other thing I find odd.
- 38:19So she, she doesn't even need to be secretly recorded.
- 38:23So I mean, she's just going, she's going all in on it wherever.
- 38:26And I think these people are as well.
- 38:28But this is just the first time anybody's had a microphone near them.
- 38:31And, you know, you can't imagine, because some of these people, these journalists have only been there like an hour and they start with the racism immediately.
- 38:38They're doing it all that.
- 38:39Crikey, are we kidding?
- 38:40They're doing it all the time.
- 38:41This is how they talk all the time.
- 38:43And you have to presume if Richard Tice thinks this is how all people talk all the time, that this is how he talks all the time as well, or the people around him talk all the time, albeit with
- 38:52slightly more privately educated accents.
- 38:55Yeah, and I think like you were saying there to the other guy that also the other guy was saying that, that now they're on a forum where everything they say or everything they think, there's loads of people backing
- 39:05it up.
- 39:06And the more that they click on those things, the more, the deeper and deeper they go.
- 39:09And I think that when they, when they, you know, it's almost like being part of a club, isn't it?
- 39:13You know, and they feel, but it's, I mean, obviously we're talking about the racism side today, but it's everything.
- 39:18Yeah, we don't, we don't believe in autism, we don't believe in vaccinations.
- 39:22Like, you know, I kind of glance at stuff online just to see how sort of bad it is and it is just paradox.
- 39:29Does she think that Michelle Obama is a man?
- 39:32Oh, I don't know if we had that one yet.
- 39:34We haven't touched on American politics.
- 39:36It's very, very local.
- 39:37Yeah, well, clearly, I'm sorry for what you're going through.
- 39:40I'm grateful to you for sharing.
- 39:41Time for a short break.
- 39:42Now.
- 39:42But when we get back, we'll be moving our focus to another huge story from today's news agenda.
- 39:56I'm beginning to wonder whether education is new area for me.
- 40:01It's the new obesity.
- 40:03It's the.
- 40:03The new area where I am most in need of having a little bit of a rethink and a little bit of a review of some of my opinions.
- 40:10And I will do.
- 40:11And I will continue to do so, usually with your help, but I.
- 40:15I think I'm right today when we turn our attention next to the Education Secretary's announcement that the ability to articulate yourself clearly should be assessed as part of GCSE exams.
- 40:27It's a word.
- 40:28I was only relatively recently introduced to this.
- 40:31It's, it's, it's, it's not oratory, it's oral C.
- 40:34Is it oral C or auracy?
- 40:36So I told you I'd only relatively recently been introduced to it.
- 40:38It's oracy, isn't it?
- 40:41It's got the same root as oral, which comes from the Latin word aura.
- 40:46O R A, I think, meaning mouth.
- 40:48If you have any idea how much it cost my parents.
- 40:52So that I could say with a modicum of confidence what the Latin derivation of a word.
- 40:56Word is.
- 40:58But.
- 40:58And it's Lucy Powell who has gone for it.
- 41:02And, and the importance of being able to articulate yourself.
- 41:07Now, this may sound a little bit melee mouthed on my part, but I don't necessarily want to get bogged down in the detail of the policy because I don't think that we've actually got it yet.
- 41:16It's.
- 41:16It's a central thrust.
- 41:18Talking to the confederation of school trusts, she said, both in content and in assessment.
- 41:22Speaking, listening and communicating will be a core part of every child's education from primary to GCSE and beyond.
- 41:30And I've been thinking about this now for a couple of days because I.
- 41:37Well, first of all, let's have a look at what the Daily Mail has to say.
- 41:39The Daily Mail has gone even more bonkers than usual.
- 41:42Dumb and dumber.
- 41:43Education Secretary told children will be the losers.
- 41:46As she says, speaking skills will be as important as reading and writing.
- 41:50In New Plan stands for gcse.
- 41:53So the Daily Mail are furious at the idea that children and some adults need help talking.
- 42:00How can anybody object to the idea that in 2026, the way that you can explain yourself in spoken word is incredibly important?
- 42:17More important, perhaps than ever.
- 42:22More important perhaps than ever.
- 42:23Why do I say that?
- 42:25Well, this is what I've been thinking about loads so there's two phone ins here.
- 42:29One is going to be experience based and the other is going to be a little bit of social commentary.
- 42:33We're going to be looking at this together because, you know, I love the written word, but I also love the spoken word.
- 42:41As you've probably gathered over however long a period of time you've spent listening to me, and because of my education, I would.
- 42:50I understand where the Daily Mail is coming from, by the way.
- 42:52It's.
- 42:52It's frightened men desperately trying to protect the only world they know.
- 42:58And of course, they are newspaper journalists.
- 43:00So the idea that talking is somehow as important or more important than writing is, is terrifying to them.
- 43:07But you know who.
- 43:08Hands up.
- 43:09Now, if you send voice notes instead of text.
- 43:12Texting.
- 43:13Do you send voice notes instead of texting?
- 43:15You do, Keith, don't you send voice notes instead of texting?
- 43:19Not to me, because I don't read them.
- 43:21I don't know why.
- 43:22I've got a real problem with voice notes.
- 43:24I just sort of can't quite get into the habit of it.
- 43:28But I appreciate that people do it.
- 43:30First of all, we complained about text speak, didn't we?
- 43:33Lol.
- 43:34And then we moved on to voice notes.
- 43:38The Internet now is.
- 43:41Is the forefront of media, new media.
- 43:46And the ability to write has absolutely nothing to do with the ability to communicate in most of the modern forms.
- 43:54It's.
- 43:55It's extraordinary when you think about it, that anybody could object to this.
- 43:59What is in 2026?
- 44:01What is more important?
- 44:04Being able to express yourself in print or being able to express yourself in person?
- 44:09Now, one problem is, of course, that if you can't express yourself in person, then you will never be able to express yourself in print.
- 44:16Unless you are cripplingly shy people who literally write beautifully but just sort of.
- 44:22Their palm stops sweating and their head fills with noise at the very thought of speaking publicly.
- 44:29So we may move into that territory a little later.
- 44:34But the.
- 44:36There's a phone in here.
- 44:39About what it's like to not be able to talk.
- 44:46Well, but I realized a little bit too late that that is quite an odd subject for a radio phone in to be a about.
- 44:57Can I.
- 44:57Should we just do it?
- 44:58Should we just open up the phone lines and see what happens on this one?
- 45:01Chloe's in Berkhamstead.
- 45:02Chloe, what would you like to say?
- 45:04Hi, James, I thought I'd do you a solid.
- 45:06I'm someone who's.
- 45:08Who's not very good at speaking out loud.
- 45:11You're doing all right so far, mate.
- 45:13I'M I'm really, really nervous.
- 45:15Honest, honestly.
- 45:16But yeah, it's like chit chat, anything important.
- 45:20If I'm having to debate someone, I just kind of freeze up and feel like I can't articulate myself.
- 45:27I guess it's like confidence in.
- 45:29Is it?
- 45:30And it's always been there.
- 45:32I would say so.
- 45:33Yeah.
- 45:33It's definitely something as an adult I've become more aware of.
- 45:37Like I read a lot, I can write my thoughts down, but I can't say them out loud.
- 45:43But people listening to this now and I'm not being sort of silly, people listening to this now won't believe you.
- 45:51Maybe.
- 45:51Yeah, I guess that's something I hear.
- 45:54It must be a personal opinion thing.
- 45:55I don't know.
- 45:56It could be a confidence thing.
- 45:57And you're actually a lot better than you think think you are.
- 45:59Like me and dancing.
- 46:01You might be right.
- 46:02I wish I'd done debate at school.
- 46:04I think that in all schools would be super valuable.
- 46:08Yes.
- 46:08I mean and debate is kind of like gear five really of auracy, you know, simply being able.
- 46:14I mean, I'm thinking more about the kids in class who would be nervous a.
- 46:19Of reading out loud because.
- 46:21And that can often be dyslexia.
- 46:23That of course now does get caught and addressed a lot more.
- 46:25But the.
- 46:28But.
- 46:28But the kids who.
- 46:29Who dread being asked the question because they're frightened of answering.
- 46:32That was me.
- 46:33Yeah, for sure.
- 46:34That's me and my daughter.
- 46:37As well.
- 46:38I think you're describing anxiety to me rather than a lack of articulacy.
- 46:42You know, you might be right.
- 46:43So that's why you confused.
- 46:45That's where you should get help for.
- 46:47For your little girl and for yourself as well.
- 46:49Just deal with the anxiety side of it and you'll be.
- 46:52There was a kid at my school who had a really bad stutter.
- 46:55Right.
- 46:56And the headmaster used to get him to sing and if he sang and this is probably terrible.
- 47:01I don't know, I haven't kept up to date with the latest developments.
- 47:03But if he sang, he was completely fluent.
- 47:06So that was actually what I did.
- 47:08Are you joking?
- 47:09Seriously, it does help.
- 47:11Yeah, it's funny.
- 47:12And briefly, how do you think it's held you back what you're describing?
- 47:17I think when it comes more recently I've seen it manifest in more important topics.
- 47:23Whether it's around speaking to friends about Palestine or like sort of global events.
- 47:27And people who are really good at debating will shut me down very quickly so I can't get my opinion across.
- 47:33Well, that is frustrating.
- 47:34Yeah, that's really frustrating.
- 47:36I guess practice makes perfect.
- 47:38I don't want to.
- 47:39I don't want to patronize.
- 47:40It's language, isn't it?
- 47:41It is language, but I mean, you just come on national radio, I don't want to frighten you, but I'm sure you realize this has got an enormous audience, this show, the biggest in the history of UK commercial radio,
- 47:52for now at least.
- 47:52Although all conscious of gravity and you've absolutely smashed it, you've done brilliantly well.
- 47:57So hopefully that could be a little building block or a brick in the wall of, of increased confidence.
- 48:02And you've given us a topic.
- 48:04Chloe, I told you there was a phone in there somewhere.
- 48:06Not only did you have the confidence to ring into the show, you had the confidence to ring into a show that actually hasn't really got a topic running through it.
- 48:13And you've given us a topic which is how do you know the difference between confidence and articulacy?
- 48:17Where does confidence end in articulacy begin?
- 48:21You know, I don't think I lack either.
- 48:24I can't, I can't lie.
- 48:25But I couldn't tell you what I would sound like if I was confident and not articulate.
- 48:31There's a reason why we get politicians to do my holiday cover.
- 48:34There is a presumption that they will be confident and articulate enough to.
- 48:39To do what many other people, normal people, we might say would be, would be terrified of.
- 48:44Sam's in New Milton.
- 48:45Sam, what would you like to say?
- 48:47Hello, James.
- 48:47Hello.
- 48:48Am I on?
- 48:49Wow.
- 48:50Okay.
- 48:50Yeah, yeah.
- 48:51First time call, a long time listener.
- 48:54Welcome.
- 48:55And yeah, just.
- 48:58Yeah, I'm not very good at talking, as you can tell.
- 49:01It's just.
- 49:02Thank you.
- 49:03Can I just say, I know I should thank you for calling in because that's an incredible thing that you've done.
- 49:09Thank you.
- 49:10Yeah, you, you.
- 49:11It's your fault, this you've made me bring in because I'm like, like, oh, I'm awful.
- 49:16So.
- 49:17Yeah.
- 49:17What?
- 49:18It's just the fear, like, I don't know.
- 49:20I can't explain it.
- 49:22You just haven't explained it.
- 49:23It's, it's, it, it's, it.
- 49:25Am I on speaker?
- 49:26This is so annoying for you because you've got.
- 49:30Take me off speaker.
- 49:31Take me off speaker so I can hear you more clearly in my ear and everybody, everyone else can hear you as well.
- 49:36Describe the fear to me.
- 49:38What, where is, where is the fear and what does it look like or feel deep within?
- 49:43You know, in the stomach, in the pits, somewhere.
- 49:47And where did it begin?
- 49:48When can you first remember having it?
- 49:50School.
- 49:51Yeah.
- 49:52Primary school.
- 49:54I had a teacher, he was a brilliant teacher, but he was like, right, we're all going to do impressions.
- 49:59And he was like, do an impression of me.
- 50:02And I was like.
- 50:02In my head, I was like thinking, yeah, okay, okay, I've got this.
- 50:04I've got this.
- 50:06Stood up, everyone's looking at me, staring, and I just froze and was like, I don't know.
- 50:12And that's it.
- 50:13You think that.
- 50:14You think that's where it began because until that point, you were confident enough to stand up and go first or to dive in on it.
- 50:20And then something happened.
- 50:22It's like a rabbit caught in the headlights.
- 50:24Literally.
- 50:24Yes.
- 50:25And from then on, there's just anything in the role play a group thing, like, oh, horrible.
- 50:32And.
- 50:32Yeah.
- 50:33And yet here you are, absolutely smashing it.
- 50:37You're bouncing a ball around the court, you're about to slot it into the basket.
- 50:40How is it?
- 50:41How do you think it might have help held you back in life?
- 50:43I mean, what.
- 50:43In what moments have you really wished that you could do it better?
- 50:48I think just like even at college as well, you present something or you.
- 50:52You write part of an essay and you have to sort of explain it.
- 50:55I wish I was good at that because that would just.
- 50:58Then, I don't know,.
- 51:01A little bit easier.
- 51:02And have you ever tried to be better at it or have you just sort of made decisions based upon avoiding those kind of.
- 51:08I think I have.
- 51:09I think I have.
- 51:09I've sort of chosen a path to deliberately dodge or all that stuff.
- 51:13You wouldn't have rung me today if you didn't know deep in your bones that this was a reversible condition.
- 51:18Yeah.
- 51:18Would you?
- 51:19Right.
- 51:19You wouldn't have done.
- 51:20How are we going to reverse it?
- 51:21How are we going to reverse it?
- 51:22I don't know how we go.
- 51:23I'm not going to give you.
- 51:23I'll give you some exercise.
- 51:25I'll give you some exercise.
- 51:26Yeah.
- 51:26Why don't you ring in again?
- 51:28Seriously.
- 51:28We'll keep it.
- 51:29We'll keep an eye on it.
- 51:30And so then we can track how much easier it gets and how much easier you find it.
- 51:34How are you feeling now, on a scale of 1 to 10?
- 51:36I've calmed down a little bit, you see.
- 51:39So, hey, this.
- 51:42This is the start of something maybe.
- 51:43I don't know.
- 51:43And I think it.
- 51:44I mean, we both think it's really important, the ability to communicate verbally with people.
- 51:49We're going to take a short break now then, you will help me illuminate this conversation with your thoughts.
- 52:03Joe is in Borehamwood.
- 52:05Joe, what would you like to say?
- 52:07James, hi.
- 52:08Thank you so much for taking my call.
- 52:10I feel like you have created the phone in for me, and I'm so grateful that I'm actually able to call in.
- 52:18I mean, my heart's been pounding the whole time I've been on hold.
- 52:20It's only me.
- 52:22That's what I'm telling myself.
- 52:24That's what I'm telling myself.
- 52:26So, I mean, I am in absolute awe of people that are, that can articulate themselves clearly, use all the big words and just sound really on point.
- 52:38And for that reason, I've actually been listening to LBC for the last 10 years.
- 52:42I listen probably to everybody, even the ones whose views don't align with my.
- 52:47Don't mention any names.
- 52:49It's just embarrassing.
- 52:50No, absolutely not.
- 52:51I mean, I value everybody's input, to be honest.
- 52:53It's good to have views from all sides, and sometimes I really want to call in and challenge some of those views, but I feel like I don't have the confidence.
- 53:02Confidence for a debate quite to that level.
- 53:06Even though all the ideas and words are in my brain and they exist, I, I feel them, I see them, I can't get them out of my mouth.
- 53:13Yeah, and the more, the more adrenalized you are, so the more you've got your kind of heart in your mouth, the harder it becomes because you're doing quite brilliantly now.
- 53:23And I'm not, I'm not patronizing you or, or exaggerating.
- 53:26You are doing brilliantly now.
- 53:28You sound calm, you sound collective deep.
- 53:30Breathing for the last 20 years.
- 53:32But if you'd rung in to tell me that I'm a disgrace and that, you know, I, I'm, I, I, I am a.
- 53:38Hang on, let's get it back out again.
- 53:40A far left.
- 53:41Rent a gob.
- 53:43It's a far left Liar.
- 53:45Rent a gob.
- 53:45Posh boy.
- 53:46Then your emotions would be running a tiny little bit higher and you would struggle to get the words out.
- 53:52I would, I made, I may just burst into tears, actually, to do something like that.
- 53:56So that's why I don't bother.
- 53:57I mean, English is not my first language.
- 53:59My first parents spoke to me in Italian from, from day dot.
- 54:03And we went to Italy, spent lots of time there before pre, before school age.
- 54:08So when I came back, I didn't speak a word of English and they threw me into school.
- 54:11And I think that was quite a lot of trauma for me because.
- 54:15So you turned up at school on your first day and you couldn't speak.
- 54:19Isn't that interesting that both of you was it.
- 54:21I think the last caller was Steve.
- 54:23The memory he had of thinking he was going to stand up and start doing an impression of someone and it would all go fine.
- 54:30And then suddenly it was like, ah, and he can trace it back to there.
- 54:33And you tracing it back as well to something that happened really early on.
- 54:37Yeah, it really hurt me, actually.
- 54:39I think it didn't really hurt me.
- 54:41I was 10 years old.
- 54:42So you can imagine by that point, you know, my language should have been, you know, a certain level and it really wasn't.
- 54:48And I just remember absolute fear when it came to having to read out in class all the way through school.
- 54:55Do you still have fluent Italian?
- 54:57Are you still fluent in Italian?
- 54:58Yeah, I mean, thankfully I am.
- 55:00It's.
- 55:00It's not amazing.
- 55:01I mean, it's been a long time, but I speak it all the time.
- 55:03And in fact, I, I was so traumatized by not being able to speak English on my first day of school that when my children were born, my husband, their dad, wanted me to speak to them in Italian and
- 55:14I absolutely refused.
- 55:15I said, no, these kids are going to have the best English they can possibly have.
- 55:20And now at age 26 and 22, they have been telling me for the last 10 years how upset they are that they don't have a second language.
- 55:28That's how much it affects.
- 55:31That's an incredible thing, isn't it?
- 55:33They almost feel that you're trauma and I would call it trauma.
- 55:37I can't imagine.
- 55:39Yeah, your trauma has deprived them of their, of their birthright in a way, because they should be bilingual.
- 55:44They should be, yeah, they should be bilingual.
- 55:45And I, I kick myself every single day.
- 55:48Tell the lazy so and so.
- 55:49It's never too late.
- 55:50They probably, they do classes at the embassy, for heaven's sake, stop moaning and.
- 55:53Get on with it.
- 55:54I bet they're train.
- 55:56They're desperate.
- 55:57They're desperate to speak Italian and I, I feel terrible for that.
- 55:59But at the time I just wanted them to go in being the kids that can speak the best English.
- 56:04So I didn't, I didn't stop talking to them.
- 56:06What would the benefit.
- 56:10What could school have done differently?
- 56:11Because I don't think anybody really contributing to this conversation is going to think, oh, no, this is terrible.
- 56:16How dare they be putting more effort into helping people to.
- 56:19School could have helped.
- 56:20Right.
- 56:21School, I think, did their best to be honest.
- 56:23With you, what can you do?
- 56:24It was.
- 56:24It was the mid-80s.
- 56:25I think it's more down to my parents.
- 56:28My mum spoke flu fluid English.
- 56:30She.
- 56:30She had been here since the age of 12.
- 56:32There was no excuse, really.
- 56:34I think they were just lazy.
- 56:38Sorry, Mum, if you're listening, we've gone.
- 56:40From, oh, I'm too nervous to ring into, I'm just gonna slag my mum off in front of him.
- 56:46People can hear me.
- 56:46James, I just think I'm talking to you.
- 56:49I.
- 56:49I actually listen to you and everybody else speak.
- 56:53And one of the reasons is not just to, you know, keep abreast of what's going on, but it's actually to learn to your producers that when you do your monologue, honestly, I love it.
- 57:05I just sit there and think, wow, if only I could do something like that.
- 57:09I actually have learned a lot listening to all of you guys.
- 57:12And that's.
- 57:12Well, what you're learning really is just.
- 57:14It's just A, that it's possible and B, that a lot of it is confidence.
- 57:18You can't be what you can't see, or in your case, you can't.
- 57:20You can't be what you can't hear.
- 57:22And now you're hearing it.
- 57:23So, so, so you're doing it.
- 57:24But this is in your second language, effectively a contribution that if people didn't know what the topic under discussion was, they would not in a million years have been able to guess.
- 57:34This is a phone in for people who don't think they're very good at talking and they'd be like, well, what the heck is Joe doing doing on it then?
- 57:42Yeah, but I mean, it's just, it's the skill.
- 57:45I can't even say the word that you said earlier.
- 57:47Oral C.
- 57:49No, I get it wrong as well, though.
- 57:50You see, I got it wrong as well, but I just keep plowing blindly on without looking in the rear view mirror.
- 57:55Oracy.
- 57:56Oracy.
- 57:57I think I'll tell you what, Monday's monologue, Joe, that.
- 58:01That's for you.
- 58:01All right, thank you.
- 58:03Thank you so much, James.
- 58:04The first ever dedication, but I think we've done.
- 58:08I hope it's a nice subject.
- 58:11That's what it's about.
- 58:12Of course.
- 58:13Analysis and evaluation galore.
- 58:15Thank you for listening and thank you of course, to all of today's contributors.
- 58:19We're back on Monday from 10 on LBC or right here shortly afterwards.
- 58:23Have a fantastic weekend.
- 58:25This has been a global production.