Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP188: The Real Life Buffalo Bill
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Hi Tanya, Hi Talia, how are
- 0:35you doing this week? I'm doing fantastic. Sweet, I hope everybody else
- 0:40is doing fantastic. And thank you guys all for tuning in to us.
- 0:43This is a story. It's a serial killer, which I love. Yes,
- 0:47I read so much about him over the years. I read an entire
- 0:51like three page book. I recognize this serial killer for years and he's one
- 0:57of the worst. And now I'm gonna tell y'all about I'm gonna share it
- 1:02with all of us. Yeah, but before I do, I hit the
- 1:04subscriber follow button on whatever you app you're listening to, because that really helps
- 1:08us. Forgive me. I got some allergies going, so there's always something
- 1:12I went on. I know I have bad allergies, so I'm a little
- 1:15nasily, but you're ready. Yeah, Okay, this is about Gary Heidnick.
- 1:22Do you know all about it? You know that you don't know I
- 1:25am in for a tree, right, you know it's so horrible. It's
- 1:29so horrible. Let me give you a little background, Okay. Gary Heidnick
- 1:33was born November twenty second, nineteen forty three in East Lake, and that's
- 1:37a suburb of Cleveland, Ohio. His parents Michael and Ellen. They were
- 1:42abusive parents, and he had a really hard childhood. He was the oldest
- 1:49of two children, so it was only him and he had a younger brother
- 1:53named Terry. Basically, Terry and Gary were all each other had growing up.
- 2:00Both Michael and Ellen the parents. They were known to be violent and
- 2:04they eventually divorced. When they did, Gary and Terry went to live with
- 2:08their mother, and she remarried. It didn't take her long after the divorce
- 2:13to find somebody else. They lived with her for four years, so they
- 2:16were young, okay when this happened. When the children were old enough to
- 2:20go to school, they ended up moving in with their father, who was
- 2:23also remarried. The two boys were basically raised by their father and their stepmother.
- 2:29Their father was really emotionally abusive as well as physically. Michael would beat
- 2:36his children every chance he got, and Gary suffered from urinary incontinence, so
- 2:43he often wet the bed, which caused a beating. I'm sure check mark
- 2:47serial killer check he wet the bed. When this happened, his dad would
- 2:53force him to hang the wet sheets out of the window of his own room
- 2:58so the neighbors could see, just to embarrass him. One time Gary was
- 3:02forced to hold up the wet, urn soaked sheets by his ankles from the
- 3:08window. What I did, like hold them there. Michael would even go
- 3:15as far as painting a bulls eye on the backside of his son's pants,
- 3:20and then he would kick the bulls eye when he was at home like target
- 3:24practice. Yeah, that's so sick. And sometimes he would make Gary ware
- 3:30the wet pants to school if he had soaked them earlier. Needless to say,
- 3:35Terry and Gary were scared shitless of their father, and they were scared
- 3:39to even pick up things around the house because God forbid, if they ever
- 3:44dropped anything, especially something that maybe it was like a glass, he would
- 3:47just kick the living shit out of them, massively abusive. Any reason would
- 3:53set him off, exactly. One time, Gary fell out of a tree
- 3:57when he was extremely young, so his head was shaped a little bit odd
- 4:02and the injury seemed to affect his brain. He had an IQ of one
- 4:06hundred and forty eight. Oh wow. Yeah, he was extremely intelligent and
- 4:12he did well in school. But there's just something off with Gary. He
- 4:17didn't have a lot of friends. He refused to interact with people, and
- 4:21he couldn't make eye contacts. Even if someone spoke to him, he couldn't
- 4:26look him in the eye. And you know, often now it's a sign
- 4:30of autism or something, but we're talking about in the nineteen fifties, he
- 4:34wasn't friendly and this was believed to be resolved of just the abuse he suffered
- 4:41at home. At the age of fourteen, Gary developed a fascination with a
- 4:45military and asked his father if he could go to military school. Wow,
- 4:48who asked Gary? Yeah, he was enrolled in the private, all male
- 4:55Stoughton Military Academy and that's located in Virginia, the school closing in nineteen seventy
- 5:01six due to mismanagement issues, but just so you know, it was successful
- 5:05for about one hundred years. Gary studied there for two years but ended up
- 5:11leaving before he graduated. He ended up going back to a public school and
- 5:15then he trapped out at the age of eighteen, he joined the United States
- 5:19Army and he would serve for a little over a year. He was an
- 5:24excellent student while there, according to one droll sergeant, so after completing his
- 5:29training, Gary applied for a few jobs that included the military police force and
- 5:33jobs with specialist roles, but he was rejected. In nineteen sixty two,
- 5:39Gary was transferred to San Antonio, Texas so he could be trained as a
- 5:44physician or a medic. Really so he's very intelligent, but socially somewhat awkward.
- 5:51He excelled at this and then he was later transferred to a military hospital
- 5:56in West Germany. He obtained his certification after only being there for a few
- 6:00weeks. Prior to that, he got a ged because he had to get
- 6:04a GED before he could get the certification. Shortly after he got a certification,
- 6:10that's when Gary showed some signs that maybe all wasn't right in his head.
- 6:16He reported himself in August of nineteen sixty two, stating that he was
- 6:23experiencing disneyness, blurred vision, severe headaches, vomiting. The doctors evaluated him
- 6:30and diagnosed him with a flu, but the doctors also thought something's not right
- 6:36with Gary neurologically. He was prescribed antipsychotics and that was to treat what they
- 6:45believed was schizophrenia because he was hallucinating. Oh no. Later that same year,
- 6:51Gary was transferred to a military hospital in Philadelphia, and this is where
- 6:56he was officially diagnosed with schizo personality disorder. After his diagnosis, Gary wasn't
- 7:04able to serve in the military. You can, you know, you know
- 7:06you can't, but he was given a full pension for his mental incapacity.
- 7:13According to some reports, Gary was extremely unhappy working in a hospital in Germany,
- 7:16so he pretended to have mental illness so that he could get honorably discharged
- 7:23for medical reasons. Because so he can get a pension because he's super I
- 7:30mean a hundred and forty eight. That's no joke. So I'm as smart
- 7:32as you and me kidding, No, yeah, babe. His pension was
- 7:39set at one hundred percent so he could receive full benefits after it was discharged.
- 7:45To play a devil's advocate. One of Gary's friends was there when Gary
- 7:49was initially diagnosed and he said that the mental breakdown was one hundred percent legitimate.
- 7:57In nineteen sixty four. After being just ar from the military, Gary
- 8:01began studying at the University of Pennsylvania, which is a very good school,
- 8:05very good school. He did lead the university. Shortly after, he enrolled
- 8:11to pursue a nursing job at the Veterans Administration in Coatesville, Pennsylvania. So
- 8:18he's working in a healthcare center. Basically, it was a doctor's office for
- 8:22veterans and their families. Gary didn't last very long there because he was fired
- 8:26for poor contact and poor attendance. He was really rude to and he would
- 8:35show up, you know, when he felt like it, and sometimes he
- 8:39wasn't even scheduled, and he'd be like, Hey, I'm here to work
- 8:41and they're like, no, Gary, you're not scheduled. Andy, but
- 8:43I don't want to work and they'd be like, no, Gary's time to
- 8:45go home. That's weird. I mean, I'm paraphrasing. How basically that's
- 8:50how it went. About three years later, he began a nursing job at
- 8:54the Elwyn Institute, and that's a nonprofit organization located in Delaware count in Pennsylvania.
- 9:01This organization provided care for adults and children who suffered from intellectual and developmental
- 9:07disabilities. Gary ended up spending a lot of time in psychiatric hospitals because he
- 9:11attempted suicide on more than one occasion. Remember I told you about his brother
- 9:16Terry. Yes, Terry also suffered from the same thing. After their mother,
- 9:22Ellen was diagnosed with bone cancer. And I told you Ellen was an
- 9:26alcoholic and for years she just drank and drank. She ended up committing suicide
- 9:33on Mother's Day, oh, nineteen seventy one, by drinking mercuric chloride.
- 9:39What it's one of the chemicals used in embalming. Oh my god, what
- 9:45the hell? Like, how do you? How do you? I don't
- 9:48know. It sounds like it would be I don't know. It just sounds
- 9:52like that would be just rolled up to a funeral home, was like,
- 9:56Hey, can I have someone I don't know? I don't know. Gary
- 9:58was seven at the time that happened. And Terry would later tell the Philadelphia
- 10:03Inquirer and this is an eighty seven about his own suicide attempts, and what
- 10:09stuck out the most is a comment he made about both Gary and him having
- 10:16schizophrenia. According to Terry, they both suffered from schizophrenia, both attempted suicides.
- 10:22They didn't own a happy childhood. So he thinks the diagnosis is correct
- 10:28and he has it too. Yeah, and he has it two. Wow,
- 10:31at the age of twenty eight. Are you ready for this? Yeah?
- 10:35Gary from his own church. Oh no, yes. It was in
- 10:39October of nineteen seventy one. It was the United Church of the Ministries of
- 10:43God. He had taken a trip to California and this is where he discovered
- 10:48his religious awakening. There he was known as Brother Bishop and at the time,
- 10:54Brother Bishop had a congregation of five followers five one being his brother Terry
- 11:00and one being his girlfriend. At the game. Under the church's name,
- 11:05Gary opened a bank account and then he got something with Merrill Lynch and put
- 11:09fifteen hundred in the account to start. Later the account would surpass five hundred
- 11:16thousand dollars. That's about five point five million dollars today. The amount of
- 11:24funds in this account really relates and demonstrates Gary's ability to manipulate personally and his
- 11:31skills in the stock market. Damn, because he would invest the money.
- 11:37Someone in his congregation said that he had a Cadillac and rules Royce and that
- 11:43he would drive around in a camper and sleep on the streets of southwest Philly,
- 11:48but that can't be completely verified. In nineteen seventy six, Gary was
- 11:54arrested in charge with carrying an unlicensed firearm. It was a pistol, and
- 12:00he was charged with aggravated assault. He shot a person who was offering a
- 12:05rental property to Gary. He wanted to go look his property. There's this
- 12:09guy's like, yeah, you know, here's the property. And Gary got
- 12:11upset and took this pistol shot at the guy, raised his face. He
- 12:16didn't end up serving any time for this, though this is nineteen seventy six.
- 12:22I mean, shit happens. What the landlord, potential landlord? I
- 12:26don't know what shit happened. Gary still had a tough time interacting with normal
- 12:31human beings when he was younger, as I said, but he met a
- 12:35woman named Gail Linkow and he was dating her. Eventually they would have a
- 12:41son together, Gary Jr. Unlucky kid, I know. Unfortunately their son
- 12:46would be putting a foster home due to the instability of Gail and Gary.
- 12:54Gary was working at a mental institution because I told you he he's got his
- 12:58own congregation going. But his big thing is to work with mentally challenged people,
- 13:05and he had a resume to support his ability to work there. While
- 13:09he was at one another mental institution, he met another woman and her name
- 13:13was Aunt Janette Davidson, and they began a relationship. She was another patient.
- 13:20So he's taking advantage of these women. Yeah, Anne, Jeanette suffered
- 13:24from diminished mental capacity. She was illiterate. Her IQ was forty eight forty
- 13:33eight. He's definitely taking advantage of her. She had a sister there named
- 13:37Alberta, and Alberta was a patient too. Gary seemed to like an Jeanette,
- 13:43and the two of them ended up having a daughter together on March sixteenth
- 13:48of nineteen seventy eight, and they named her Maxine. Just like Gary Jr.
- 13:52Maxine would get put into the foster care system because mom's a patient in
- 13:58the mental hospital and dad is fucking nuts. H just be honest, like
- 14:05seriously, Gary, Like you're having sex with the patients at a Montel hospital
- 14:11and he's still a church leader. Oh no, but this isn't the entire
- 14:16ship show. He's brother bishop. Yes, you're right. Gary was really
- 14:22desperate to start his own family, even though he had two kids seriously.
- 14:26Yes, he really wanted to have kids, he just didn't make the best
- 14:30choices. No, that's putting it nicely. In nineteen seventy eight, Gary
- 14:35signed Alberta out of the mental hospital for a one day pass. Oh,
- 14:41she thought she was just being taken out for the day. It's one day
- 14:45passed, but no, Gary took her to his home and he made her
- 14:48a prisoner and his basement. While in prison in basement, he raped her
- 14:56and he satomizer. It took ten days for the police to find Alberta.
- 15:01And remember that's the sister of man Jeanette's to find her. She was shackled
- 15:07to pipes what in the basement? She was terrified, covered in her own
- 15:11blood. Immediately taken to the hospital and after I mean she'd been raped and
- 15:16sadomized for ten days straight, she contracted ganaria. What Gary gave her ganaria.
- 15:24He was arrested and charged with kidnapping, rape, false imprisonment, interfering
- 15:30with the cousty of someone who's been committed, unlawful restraint, and involuntary deviant
- 15:35sexual intercourse. The case didn't go to trial until November, and he was
- 15:41found guilty. Do you know what they did. They put him on probation.
- 15:45No, they didn't put him behind bars. Okay. Gary was given
- 15:48three years in I think it's called a Taska Darrow, which is a quote
- 15:52unquote prison for the mentally ill. He was originally sentenced for three to seven
- 15:58years, but that was overturned on an appeal, and after three years he
- 16:03was released and he was under supervision of a state sanctioned mental program. So
- 16:10they're supposed to watch Gary. Yeah, while Gary was serving his time.
- 16:15During this time, Anne Jeanette somehow vanished and she was never seen or heard
- 16:21from again, and it's believed Gary had something to do with that. In
- 16:26nineteen eighty four, Gary bought a rowhouse, kind of a cheap house in
- 16:30a so nice area where they're all kind of very close together rouse in Philadelphia,
- 16:38Pennsylvania. This house, Tanya, Oh my god, this house would
- 16:41turn into one of the most notorious And when I say this, I mean
- 16:45horror shows of the most evil things that could happen to a human being in
- 16:49Pennsylvania. And when I say, I say, I swear to God,
- 16:52I mean it. What happens there is so fucking bad. Tanya. Oh
- 16:56no, let's start out slowly, Okay, from his home. He ran
- 17:02a church. Oh god, he's still got his church. Got his church.
- 17:06It's kind of like a cult. And he would advertise the church to
- 17:08any neighbors who would give his creeps the time of day. The neighbors.
- 17:15Some of the neighbors went along with it because the church expanded and it wasn't
- 17:19no longer five followers. There are many more that joined to listen to Brother
- 17:26Bishop, Brother Bishop. And then Gary gets married. What Gary used a
- 17:30matrimonial service to correspond with the woman who lived in the Philippines, So it
- 17:37was like it was like a match service to get married, like a male
- 17:40order. Brad. Yes, okay, that's what I'm trying to say,
- 17:42yea, even though it's not very nice. Her name was Betty, Oh
- 17:47Betty, poor Batty. She just wanted a better life, I know.
- 17:49The two wrote letters back and forth, and then Gary proposed a Botty.
- 17:56She arrived on some family visa probably nine one thirty or fiance visa, because
- 18:03I've done them. Yes, Betty arrived in Philadelphia in September of nineteen eighty
- 18:08five, and they tied the knot on October third. Yes, Gary was
- 18:15not what you would consider to be a good husband. Stop really yeah,
- 18:18I mean Betty, like you said, she was coming to America. She
- 18:22thought she was meeting the man of her dreams and hoping for a better life.
- 18:26But what she got was the exact opposite. The marriage went down the
- 18:33tubes rapidly. Betty found him in bed having sex with multiple women. She
- 18:38was upset. Eventually he made her watch what and he forced her to have
- 18:45sex with these women as well because she was abused every day. She was
- 18:48abused during her short marriage Gary, Betty said she was raped multiple times by
- 18:52him and beaten. In nineteen eighty six, Gary was arrested for assault,
- 18:57indecent assault, spousal rape, an involuntary deviant sexual intercourse. So good for
- 19:06Batty. I mean, this is eighty six. I know that's what I
- 19:10was thinking too, Pennsylvania. I know, with all these charges, you
- 19:15would think that maybe because he is you know this history, he writes,
- 19:21put away, maybe in a prison. But no, Batty dropped the charges.
- 19:26Oh Batty, Well, she didn't show up for the preliminary hearing and
- 19:30Gary was free to walk away. Oh. I mean he not only beaten
- 19:36rape Betty, but he would deprive her of food. It's just fucking sick.
- 19:41I dude, I hate people. Come on, I know this is
- 19:45only the beginning. Yeah, oh yeah. She did eventually get pregnant because
- 19:51at some point after even though she didn't show up for the preliminary hearing,
- 19:56she did file a child suport claim against him, so that would make it
- 20:00Gary's third child. After his short lived marriage to Betty, that's when he
- 20:04began kidnapping women and using them as sex slaves. Oh crowd. He later
- 20:11on would blame the fact that Betty had left him and you know, yeah,
- 20:17it made his blood boil, so he had to make up for it
- 20:19somehow. He particularly targeted women of color and sex workers. And I'm gonna
- 20:26tell you about the first victim as soon as we get back from them commercial
- 20:32break. The first of his victims was a woman named Josephina Rivera. She
- 20:42was twenty five at the time she disappeared. Gary kidnapped her on November twenty
- 20:48fifth of nineteen eighty six. She was a sex worker. He offered twenty
- 20:52dollars to have sex with him, and she agreed to go to his house.
- 20:56He had already plans for what he was going to do with her.
- 21:00After they both got to his house, he hit her, he raped her,
- 21:04and then he chained her up in the basement. The basement wasn't an
- 21:10ordinary basement, man. Gary dug a hole in the basement floor, and
- 21:17just so you know, he would throw women in this hole to stay.
- 21:22It was pretty deep. Oh yeah, it was a deep hole. Yeah,
- 21:26it wasn't as deep as Silence of the Lambs, but it was deep
- 21:30where they couldn't climb out. Yes, they could not climb out. Gary
- 21:33put muffler clamps around Josephina's ankles and put nuts on the clamps, you know,
- 21:41so she absolutely can't Yeah, to ensure she couldn't get free. And
- 21:45then he would also use crazy glue on them. He did not want her
- 21:48to be able to get free. And when you're using in crazy glue,
- 21:52you can't just undo the clamps easy either. When Josephina was secured in the
- 21:56hole, it's so bad. Gary put plywood over the opening of the hole
- 22:02and he placed huge bags filled with dirt on top of it. So she's
- 22:07in pitch black, pitch black scar Yeah, it's probably freezing in there too,
- 22:11Yeah, in the basement. Yeah, I mean, it's Philadelphia yeah,
- 22:14it's horrible. Where Josephina was chained wasn't wasn't very big. Like I
- 22:18said, It's deep, but it wasn't really all that big. She had
- 22:22to bend herself like a pretzel to fit in there. So again, it's
- 22:26not like Silence of the Lambs, where there was room and lots of room.
- 22:30I mean, once he put the boards on top, she had to
- 22:33like bend down. When he wanted to use an abuser, he would pull
- 22:37her out of the hole by her hair. He'd beat her with a stick
- 22:41and rape her, and then he would throw her back in the hole.
- 22:44Every time she heard him approaching, obviously, she would freak out. Josephina
- 22:49was sure she was going to be murdered and then no one would ever discover
- 22:52what happened to her body. After two days in captivity, she came to
- 22:56the realization of why she was actually kidnapped. Josephina was told by Gary that
- 23:03she was to produce lots of kids from home. No. Yes, He
- 23:07told her that he had kids already, but the state kept taking them away,
- 23:12and he said to her quote, well I got away now of having
- 23:17kids, so nobody can take them away, and you're just the start.
- 23:19You're gonna have my baby down there, but not just you. I want
- 23:25to get ten girls here so you all can have my kids and he won't
- 23:32want to have a baby, farmer, what's he gonna do with these tens?
- 23:36These women are in holes? Like I mean, this is is not
- 23:38well thought out thing. What the hell? Josephina couldn't believe this was actually
- 23:45happening, and this was some plan that he wanted and believed he could go
- 23:51through and it would succeed. But she was a bit relieved that he didn't
- 23:56want her, right at least he's not going to kill her. He needed
- 23:59her a lot. Gary was trying to enslave these ten women to create what
- 24:03he thought was the perfect race. All of his victims were black women,
- 24:07and he strongly believed that the races would eventually be mixed and then there would
- 24:12be only one race about a hundred years in the future if he just mixed
- 24:18it all. He believed that white people should absolutely mix with black people and
- 24:23vice versa, and again, this was a way to have the perfect human
- 24:29being. He also thought that tall people should procreate with short people, and
- 24:33that short people should never procreate with other short people because society needed to have
- 24:40taller people. Gary is not well, this geneticist, So let's talk about
- 24:45his next victim. On December third, he kidnapped Sandra Lindsay when she was
- 24:51only twenty four years old. She was mentally disabled. She was kidnapped on
- 24:56her way to a grocery store. He ended up convincing her to come to
- 25:02his home, and then when she got there, he chained her up,
- 25:06just like he did Josephina. While the two women were together. And when
- 25:11I say chained up, so there's this hole in the basement, but there's
- 25:14also he's got other places to chain them. And sometimes he would squeeze two
- 25:19women in that toll that I already said was small. Sometimes he would just
- 25:23chain them up. So these two women were together and Gary would rape them,
- 25:27and he would make each woman watch the other woman be ripe, and
- 25:33you know, it's really messed up. Is the reason why Sandra came to
- 25:36Gary's home was because she was a member of this church. Oh no,
- 25:41and I told her she was mentally only a few weeks later, December twenty
- 25:47second, he kidnapped another woman. She was a nineteen year old single mother.
- 25:51Her name was Lisa Thomas. Lisa was lured by Gary while she was
- 25:56walking and it was really cold out. He offered her a ride. She
- 26:00accepted it. He bought Lisa some food because she was down and out in
- 26:04her luck, and he drove her back to his house and offered her come
- 26:08to my house. We'll have a glass of wine. And he seemed like
- 26:11a really nice guy. And she was having a hard time that glass of
- 26:15wine. He slipped her some drugs in it and made her unconscious, and
- 26:21then he raped her. And when she woke up, she was chained up
- 26:23in the basement next to Josephina and Sandra. When she became conscious, Gary
- 26:30came down and he offered them all some sandwich as he made. Oh here
- 26:34made ladies some food. What a nice man. On January one of nineteen
- 26:41eighty seven, this is like boom, boom boom, Deborah Dudley was kidnapped.
- 26:45Deborah was feisty and Gary was taken aback when she started defending herself.
- 26:51As she was brought to the basement, she would talk back. She would
- 26:55also defend the other women in the basement. Through the next few days,
- 26:59so she was eating more and she was putting the hole more than the other
- 27:03women. Gary was often humiliated by her because she did talk back, and
- 27:07it really pissed him off. And you like, don't want to piss a
- 27:11crazy fucking psycho off, right, He began making the captives eat dog food
- 27:18instead of bringing them sandwiches and forcing them to have sex with each other.
- 27:25We gave Gary the idea to feed his victims dog food was because every now
- 27:30and then he would allow the women to watch a little TV that he brought
- 27:34down, and some were able to watch it, others were putting what he
- 27:37called a time out. One time, while watching TV, one of them,
- 27:41one of the captives I don't I don't know which one, was watching
- 27:45a dog food commercial. And keep in mind, they're not fed very much,
- 27:49and she said that looks good enough to eat, because I mean,
- 27:52they were pretty much always starving. They were at his mercy. So that's
- 27:56when Gary decided, okay, dog food is. Since thinks it's good enough
- 28:00to eat, I'm gonna give her dog food. Eventually, Debrah was murdered.
- 28:06He was sick of her defying him, so he put her in the
- 28:10pit, chained up, and he filled a pit with water in front of
- 28:15the other girls. He forced Josephina to stick a live wire yeah in the
- 28:23chains an electrocuted Debra to death. The amount of torture these women went through
- 28:30cannot be explained. They were naked, chained, beaten, rate for ste
- 28:37have sex with each other, starved, and the pit was just, you
- 28:41know, the worst thing. And Debrah was putting that pit for a while.
- 28:44I mean when he put him in a pit, we're not talking about
- 28:45an hour. Sometimes it was days. And so yeah, he filled it
- 28:51with water and then made the other woman, Josephina, electrocute Debra. After
- 28:57Debra's death, Gary made some changes. He purchased a portable toilet and he
- 29:03allowed the women to use tampons. He also began allowing them to Bathe really
- 29:07not because he cared about them, but he wanted them clean. They were
- 29:10getting I mean they it's getting getting gainey. Yeah, and he wanted them
- 29:15clean when he would rape them. Now that he murdered Deborah, he had
- 29:19to replace her, so he kidnapped another victim, Jacqueline Askins, And this
- 29:25is on January eighteenth, nineteen eighty seven. Jacqueline was only eighteen years old
- 29:30at the time of her kidnapping. When she was kidnapped. There was a
- 29:33single toilet down in the basement where Gary kept his captives. There was no
- 29:38plumbing for the toilet. It's just gross, and it's just gross. That's
- 29:41why he ended up getting the portable one. The women would whimper, of
- 29:45course when they heard Gary comming, because they knew someone was going to be
- 29:48beaten and someone was going to be raped, and they were tortured. They
- 29:52were all tortured and want to tell you about it because it's coming up.
- 29:56It's just it's so bad. He didn't like how the women were now crying
- 30:03and I mean they have PTSD and they're they're in shock. Oh they want
- 30:07He wanted them to be happy he was coming. This is bad. Yeah.
- 30:11He gouged out their ear drums with a screwdriver what so that way they
- 30:15couldn't hear him coming and start whimpering. Oh my god, it's bad,
- 30:22it's bad, it's so bad. There are many times when the women misbehaved
- 30:30and they would be severely punished. Sandra was caught trying to take the plywood
- 30:36from over the covering of the pit. She's trying to escape. This made
- 30:41him so angry. Tanya so angry that he hung her by her wrists from
- 30:47a beam. He hung her there for a week? What a week?
- 30:52A week? Oh, it must have been so painful. Before this even
- 30:56happened, she was already sick. She had some sort of infection and she
- 31:00had a fever. I mean, so she's weak. She was given only
- 31:04pieces of bread to eat while hanging each day. Eventually she was removed from
- 31:11the beam. But that's because she died. Oh no, yes, When
- 31:15he realized she was dead, he took her lifeless body from the beam,
- 31:19brought it upstairs and I can't this is going to be this is real,
- 31:23gruesome, guys. He dismembered her with a power saul. Then he boiled
- 31:30her flesh. He put it in a food processor, mix it up with
- 31:36dog food. Oh no, don't tell me, please, don't stop.
- 31:38He fed the food to his dogs. No, but remember he also fed
- 31:45dog food to his captives. He fed Sandra to the remaining victims as well,
- 31:51And actually he did the same with Deborah Sports. Both women had been
- 31:57boiled and what a sec food processor and fed to the other women. How
- 32:07did I not know this story? I don't know the survivors because there are
- 32:10survivors later stated they'll never forget the smell of boiling flash. And when he
- 32:17fed Deborah and Sandra to the other women mixed with that dog food, they
- 32:25did know that what they were eating. But you can't judge them there starving.
- 32:31They're starving and if he did, if they didn't eat it, who
- 32:35knows what he would have done to them. They just watched a woman being
- 32:38hanged for seven days until she died, So like judging is, it's not
- 32:45okay. He cooked on one of the women's ribs in the oven. He
- 32:50cooked that both of the heads on the stove, and the smell was really
- 32:54bad, and the neighbors called the police. I'm gonna so the police came
- 33:00because that's how bad it is, and the police knocked on his door.
- 33:05They questioned Gary. He said that he burned a roast and lost track,
- 33:10just lost track of time, and he burned a roast. The women,
- 33:14as I said, they'd been starred and they either had to eat or die
- 33:20from starvation. That's how much he didn't feed them. Wow, And that
- 33:23was basically all they were given during their captivity was some bread, dog food,
- 33:30and dog food mixed with other victims. One of the survivors would later
- 33:35say, quote, if it wasn't for me eating her or eating dog food,
- 33:39I wouldn't be here today. God, what a fucking choice. I
- 33:45don't know. Oh my god. And then like I said, if you
- 33:51don't do it, it's bad. That's really bad. On top of all
- 33:59the rape and torture, he made Josephina beat the others while he watched.
- 34:07But see, Josephina was I don't know how to say it, but trying
- 34:10to play a game. She was trying to get on his good side with
- 34:14the hope that she could escape and save everybody else. So she did what
- 34:22she had to do in the hopes of eventually her being able to get out
- 34:27and save everybody. Not because she really enjoyed it, that's my opinion.
- 34:31I read a lot about it, that's my opinion. So Josephina's made it
- 34:36beat the other girls, and he would watch, and she started paying attention,
- 34:40and she began to really figure out how Gary worked. She was really
- 34:46good at judging what motivated him and what didn't, and she was extremely motivated
- 34:53to get the hell out of this hell hole and live. So she studied
- 34:58him basically his everyday pad and Gary had told her his dreams of one day
- 35:02having ten children, and she dreamed of escaping. But she didn't obviously tell
- 35:07him that. She knew Gary wanted a true connection with someone, even though
- 35:13Gary's all shaved the fuck up, so she played into it. He treated
- 35:17obviously everybody horribly. But one of the weaknesses she noticed in Gary is that
- 35:23Gary really wanted the women to give a fuck about him. He wanted them
- 35:30to view him as a person. Josephina thought that is why he got so
- 35:35pissed off whenever the women would try to escape like Sandra, or talk back
- 35:40to him or hurt his feelings. It really that was like what triggered him.
- 35:47He just wanted to be loved. He just wanted to be loved to
- 35:51Leaf. Yeah, how come they didn't love him? Josephina was completely repulsed
- 35:57by him, but she decided the best way to survive was to try to
- 36:01be his friend. She began to do everything that he asked of her,
- 36:06and as I said, this was beating and torturing the other women. She
- 36:09would always validate his feelings and make him believe that she understood why he was
- 36:15doing what he did. This paid off Josephina was allowed to go upstairs.
- 36:21Oh yes, she was granted more privileges, and on one point she was
- 36:24allowed to cook from Wow. The two would watch movies together. Oh,
- 36:29this poor woman, But as soon as the movie was done, she would
- 36:34be sent back to the hole. Really, so she's getting some punishment even
- 36:39though she's getting to him like he would punish her. Josephina could have escaped.
- 36:45I mean, she was unchained and allowed upstairs, but she thought,
- 36:51if I take off running, he will go and kill the other women before
- 36:55I have a chance to save them. She was really nice of her.
- 37:00She knew that he would immediately go down to the hole and kill the other
- 37:05women without a second thought, and to her, she just couldn't do it.
- 37:10So she continued to play the game and gain more and more of his
- 37:14trust, and it worked. She played the game so well, in fact,
- 37:17Tanya, that she was eventually able to convince Gary to take her home
- 37:22what to visit her family so she could say her final goodbyes and just be
- 37:28with Gary and have all those babies. Wow. She told Gary that she
- 37:31was going to be with him forever. She just needed one last goodbye to
- 37:36her family and Gary being fucking stupid. Said okay, that's crazy, and
- 37:43he took her back to the city close to where she lived, and he
- 37:45parked at a gas station that was in a couple blocks of her family's home.
- 37:52The reason why he parked there, that was Josephina's idea. She said
- 37:55she didn't want her family to be able to identify his car, and she
- 38:00didn't want him to get any trouble. Oh, that was smart because of
- 38:04her disappearing and all that. So he parked, She got out, and
- 38:08he told her she gets fifteen minutes. She nodded, okay and calmly walked
- 38:15away. When she got out of his sight, she went to the closest
- 38:19pay phone and dialed nine one one Wow. She called the nine one one
- 38:23operator and said that five other women had been kidnapped and said to the dispatcher
- 38:30that if Gary was able to get away, the rest of the captives would
- 38:35be murdered. On March twenty three, in nineteen eighty seven, Gary was
- 38:39arrested while he was in the car at the gas station waiting for Josephina to
- 38:45come back the wild Wow. What I didn't tell you is that earlier that
- 38:50day he'd kidnapped another woman that same day, twenty four year old Agnes Adams.
- 38:57Luckily she was laid freed. Yeah, the police came and they ended
- 39:05up freeing all the women that were still left Brother Bishop's Church. They were
- 39:10pretty upset by all this. They were so dementa Tanya, I mean,
- 39:15it just shocked everyone. It is horrific. He was in a rowhouse too.
- 39:22How does this neighbors not know what's going on? They were in the
- 39:24basement, them, they were in the basement. One person stated it was
- 39:31one of the most heineous crimes I've ever heard of. It's a memory that
- 39:35I'll never forget, and the thought of it is still with me to this
- 39:37day. I will never forget the coverage of what the police found inside.
- 39:43The police gat us search weren't and when the agents entered, they discovered the
- 39:47remains of two deceased women, parts of their body in a freezer inside containers
- 39:53labeled dog food. Oh my god. On the stove, they discovered a
- 40:00severed head still inside a pot. Are you fucking kidding me? No.
- 40:06They also found three women chained up in very bad shape. They were naked,
- 40:10beaten, blooding, and malnourished. But free. Yeah, you're gonna
- 40:15hate this, Tanya. Okay. Gary's trial began in June of nineteen eighty
- 40:20eight, and you know what his defense was. The women were already there
- 40:23when he moved into the house. Shut the fuck up. What? Yes,
- 40:30he had a lawyer. Yes, they went with this. Yes.
- 40:35When Gary told his attorney about feeding the dead victims to the girls, his
- 40:39attorney, his name was Charles Prudo Junior, made a sick joke by asking,
- 40:44quote, what seasoning did you use? Oh? No, that guy
- 40:49really has no soul. What the fuck is that? I don't know,
- 40:52some public defender that couldn't get a real chick defense public defenders. Yeah.
- 40:58In the end, Gary ever admitted to actually doing anything wrong, and they
- 41:02did try the insanity defense, but because Gary's IQ was so high, they
- 41:07said he knew right from wrong, even though he was schizophrenic, his mother
- 41:13was not well, and his brother was insane. Gary had an explanation for
- 41:16every evil thing he did, and he remained completely calm during the process.
- 41:22His attorney had suggested to him that he not bathed for months and not from
- 41:29his beard and let his mustache grow out to really give the appearance that he
- 41:34was insane. In the end, though, Gary was convicted of two counts
- 41:37of first green murder, five counts of abduction, and four counts of aggravated
- 41:43assault. This was a Keppel murder case, so he was sensed to death
- 41:47by lethal injection. His execution was scheduled for April fifteenth, nineteen ninety seven,
- 41:52but there was last minute an appeal that was filed and it was regarding
- 41:57Gary's mental competence. On July sixth, nineteen ninety nine, Gary was executed
- 42:04by a lethal injection and he was the last person to be put to death
- 42:07in the state of Pennsylvania. Wow. The DA never pressed charges on Josephina
- 42:14for being involved with the murder of Debra since she was the one that saved
- 42:19in the end, and to them, that was the sickest type of torture
- 42:23anybody could habitually be forced to kill somebody else. It's just so sad.
- 42:28When Gary was executed, the remaining victims were invited to attend. Jacqueline did
- 42:32attend, so did Sandra and Deborah's family. Sandra's sister said quote, I
- 42:37went to the execution, but it was too calm and serene for me.
- 42:40I'm thinking execution is something like turn around and let me shoot you. Instead,
- 42:45they just stuck a needle in his arm. He never looked at us,
- 42:47never acknowledged us, never said he was sorry. He didn't say anything.
- 42:52He didn't even look at our direction. Do you want to know what
- 42:55the last meal was? Yeah, you can read it, because we like
- 42:59to know that prior to him dying he had. His last meal is two
- 43:02slices of cheese, pizza and some coffee. That's it. Yeah, I
- 43:07guess he wasn't all that fucking hungry, Tanya. Crimes of what Gary did
- 43:12were so fucked up in Amena they actually inspired Hollywood writers to think of the
- 43:16role of Buffalo Bill in the movie Silence of the Lamps. Yes, there
- 43:22was a quote later from Jacqueline, one of the survivors, when she was
- 43:25interviewed, and in regards to Josephina, she said, quote, she killed
- 43:30Debbie and we all could have gotten out of their live. There was a
- 43:32lot of stuff she did that she didn't have to. I just thought she
- 43:37took on her serial killer ideal too. She was the oldest, she was
- 43:39supposed to protect us, even though she was in a bad situation. She
- 43:43was supposed to protect us. Quote. I don't think that's fair to Josephina.
- 43:47I wasn't there. I don't know. I know she ended up seeing
- 43:52what she did. I know. I'm not blaming josephina I there are so
- 43:54many more, Like when you read three hundred pages of a book of the
- 44:00constant torture an abused that these women went through. It's seriously one of the
- 44:05worst cases. You can imagine a pit an abasement, any like that being
- 44:12fed and humans broke their ear drums with the fucking screwdriver. I don't Yeah,
- 44:17it's bad, so bad. Oh, t Lea, this is just
- 44:22messed up. Yeah, that is the story of Gary Hyde. I'm glad
- 44:27he's dead. Yeah, although I know the family really didn't get any satisfaction
- 44:31from it. But wow, thanks for that to Leah. That was fucked.
- 44:36I appreciate you guys taking them time to listen there. Like I said,
- 44:39there was even more details that I just laughed out because I think I
- 44:45shared enough. But if you haven't done so already, please hit the subscribe
- 44:49slash follow button on your favorite app. It seems so wrong to say that,
- 44:52I know, seems so wrong. And you can also if you saying
- 45:00the word enjoy, if you enjoy listening to this. We have our Patreon,
- 45:05Paige. You can go to it's patreon dot com slash T and T
- 45:07and those are the letters T and T crimes and you can get one episode
- 45:14every week that's exclusive for our paid subscribers. And you also get episodes like
- 45:20this ad free and you can get the same on your Apple podcast by subscribing
- 45:23to us. You can also go to our website, Crimes and Consequences dot
- 45:28com and listen. And we have Facebook and Instagram at Hardcore True Crime.
- 45:34Haven't been doing much on that lately because we're busy, busy people. Yeah,
- 45:38but we're gonna get to that Sunday, we will soon promise. Yeah,
- 45:43life's just got a lot going on going on. I think this is
- 45:46everything you think. So yeah, well, thank you everybody for honestly listening
- 45:52to this. I hope you guys have a great Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday,
- 45:54Thursday, Friday, Saturday, or Sunday, whatever day it is exactling
- 46:00until our next episode. Just don't kill each other. Bye,