Latest / Newcomer Pod / The End of Quiet Quitting (w/Aki Ito)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. Welcome everyone to dead cat.
- 0:14Tom dirt on here at joined by Katie better.
- 0:16Eric is away this week at the great European tax incentive
- 0:20known as web Summit so it's another one of those
- 0:23freewheeling off-the-cuff Katie and Tom episodes anything can
- 0:27happen. But no we got structure this
- 0:29week. We could Tired.
- 0:31That's true. At it from any of our jobs.
- 0:33This could be the last time you see Kitty and I we got structure
- 0:36this week, though. Because as our guest, we have in
- 0:38the room akihito who is my colleague at Insider Aki is a
- 0:44features reporter senior Tech correspondent and features
- 0:47reporter. She's doing the deepen,
- 0:50assiduous work of examining are very broken, very complex, very
- 0:54troubled, psyche of work culture and she's written a ton of
- 0:58really good stories about it. And as far as dead cat is
- 1:02concerned, it's just a topic that we come back to maybe the
- 1:05most frequently on the show. It's then we explore the most
- 1:08because it takes the least amount of expertise to talk
- 1:10about it. That's true.
- 1:11We're all working. That's true.
- 1:14You have to read the fewest numbers of articles about it,
- 1:16except for Aki's because we all work.
- 1:19We all find ourselves hating our jobs at different times and
- 1:23recognizing that other people hate their jobs.
- 1:25Nobody wants to work anymore, that has been like the great
- 1:28realization from the pandemic. Even though we all still do it
- 1:31and Aki and sort of been on the Forefront of examining, what has
- 1:35been going on in the last few years.
- 1:37And we'll talk about this later in the episode, but she wrote an
- 1:40article about coasting culture that ended up being the
- 1:43inspiration for quiet quitting, and I would say you are directly
- 1:48or indirectly responsible for that whole discourse, that whole
- 1:53cycle, where we talked about quitting.
- 1:54Yeah, I'm sorry, I'm sorry in advance.
- 1:57Yeah. Well, you're all responsible for
- 1:59the term but we can talk about Later.
- 2:01So first of all, arguing you already said something, but
- 2:02welcome to dead cat. Thank you so much for joining.
- 2:04Yeah, good to be on. Hey guys aren't you want to talk
- 2:07about? Just your desire and decision to
- 2:09cover the work culture. Beat how long have you been on
- 2:13it at Insider or elsewhere? You know, I think I've been
- 2:16writing about work in some capacity for a really long time
- 2:21because I started out as an economics reporter and Tokyo at
- 2:25Bloomberg. You know and I think work is
- 2:27like a big part of the job market, but you know.
- 2:30First, I covered it from kind of, like, a macro economics
- 2:32perspective, about the job market.
- 2:35And then when I moved to the states and 2012, I was writing a
- 2:39lot of stories about kind of the intersection of technology.
- 2:43And the job market held Tech was changing the job market in one
- 2:46way or another. So that involved a lot of
- 2:48stories about work in the late 2010's.
- 2:52Maybe around like 2018, I started like a YouTube
- 2:56documentary series about people in jobs that didn't Cysts may be
- 3:01like a generation ago was called Next jobs and so that was
- 3:05probably, like, the closest I've done on like specific jobs and
- 3:11kind of more workplace issues. And then I came to Insider in
- 3:152021 and you know, from the beginning, I started as a
- 3:19workplace reporter so that's kind of my trajectory got it and
- 3:23we say jobs that didn't exist a generation ago, but do now we're
- 3:26talking about social media manager podcast, Host.
- 3:30Let's see. What, what else do you put in
- 3:33that group? Well, I think my favorite
- 3:35episode we did two seasons of it.
- 3:37My favorite episode took me to Rwanda which was really cool and
- 3:42I got to profile. This guy who was a drone
- 3:45delivery operator. So he helped these like
- 3:49autonomous drones, you know, fly blood to these really remote
- 3:54past battles or rural Rwanda was kind of saving people's lives
- 3:58that way. Yeah.
- 4:00Those kinds of jobs fascinating, okay?
- 4:02So I would put in the same category of importance as
- 4:04podcast host so I so what did you see as you started it
- 4:10Insider and got on this run of doing stories about the way our
- 4:14relationship with work has changed.
- 4:16I mean, what did you sort of see at?
- 4:18Let's say, 20, 20 21, when you began at insiders heard of
- 4:21writing these stories, what was happening?
- 4:23Well, I think, you know, from the beginning of my time at
- 4:26Insider, I did want to write about this changing relationship
- 4:29to Work and mostly because my relationship to work changed a
- 4:34lot over the course of twenty twenty quite dramatically.
- 4:37And you know, I wanted to find a way to write about it.
- 4:39That wasn't just this like self-help.
- 4:42I don't know. Confessional, first person as a
- 4:44kind of thing. So I spent like most of 2021
- 4:47just thinking about it trying to find a way into it.
- 4:50And finally, in the fall of 20 21, I was able to convince my
- 4:55Editor to let me write like a big piece about it.
- 4:59And yeah, but We published that sa and January of this year and
- 5:04was that the essay about coast and culture that was before
- 5:07coasting culture. This piece was called how
- 5:09America got addicted to work. It was kind of like, I know like
- 5:15Aaron Griffith has been on the show before and like, you know,
- 5:18like the awesome stuff that she wrote back in when was it like
- 5:212018, 2019 about puzzle culture, right?
- 5:25How ya like it was not going to last forever, wasn't
- 5:28sustainable? Yeah, yeah.
- 5:30Yeah. I feel like you know she and and
- 5:33Helen Peterson and it may be also Derek Thompson at the
- 5:36Atlantic we're really early and kind of identifying this like
- 5:39crazy Devotion to work, especially, you know, Among Us
- 5:43like the millennial generation. So I kind of wanted to take a
- 5:47step back and this essay that I wrote that I published in
- 5:51January thinking about kind of like going back to like the
- 5:54history like looking at like 150 years of American work, history
- 5:59and arguing. That it didn't really start out
- 6:01this way. You know, we have this image of
- 6:04America's like the Protestant work ethic country but you know,
- 6:07people actually very much value Leisure at the beginning of the
- 6:121900s there was this huge push you know organized by the unions
- 6:16to give us more Leisure Time and make us work less and that
- 6:20continued until about 1980. You know, American work hours.
- 6:24Continue to decline and Decline and decline for a long time.
- 6:28Americans actually worked a lot less than your P.
- 6:30Instead, but something happened around 1980, you know?
- 6:33And look at us today, we work about 4:00 less than Germans do,
- 6:40which is a crazy statistic, 04:00 more than Germans more.
- 6:44Okay. Yeah, yeah.
- 6:46Yeah. What was it about the 80s?
- 6:48I'm currently reading Reagan, land.
- 6:50The Rick pearlstein history book, which is about, you know,
- 6:53I mean, he's part of his whole series about the rise of the
- 6:55conservative movement, but that looks specifically, you know,
- 6:58the rise and Andrew love Ron. Reagan and him being
- 7:01specifically, like an appendage of the whole business community
- 7:05and kind of the rise of corporate America.
- 7:07Having far more direct control over political levers, but also
- 7:11just social issues. I mean, what happened in the 80s
- 7:14that you saw in your reporting that made for this dramatic
- 7:18shift towards us being work-obsessed groans?
- 7:21I think a big part was, you know, definitely Reagan.
- 7:24So, you know, on the one hand, the first thing was that the
- 7:29returns to To overworking got a lot greater because you know,
- 7:33rich people weren't paying as much in taxes.
- 7:36And so before, like, the government would have taken
- 7:38everything anyway. So it wasn't worth, you know,
- 7:40working crazy hours but suddenly now it was worth it for people
- 7:44who are earning High wages. So that was one thing.
- 7:47Another thing was that, you know, work became a lot more
- 7:50precarious even for White Collar professionals.
- 7:53So before you could really assume that you would have this,
- 7:56like, lifetime job security as long as you were at, like, You
- 8:00know, midsize company, but you didn't have that guarantee
- 8:04anymore with globalization and the rise of them in a.
- 8:08And so, as a result, you know, I think a lot of Americans felt
- 8:12compelled to overwork as a way to make themselves
- 8:15indispensable. So, I think those economic
- 8:18forces were really big. I'm very curious about when you
- 8:22saw this idea of work and meaning start to emerge, where
- 8:28work should be meaningful. You'll wear, it should be our
- 8:31passion where it should and so many ways.
- 8:34Replaced, some of the leisure activities that you had
- 8:37mentioned earlier, that things like unions were trying to carve
- 8:41carve out the time and space for for workers.
- 8:44And when did our jobs become meaningful.
- 8:47Yeah. I mean, it definitely isn't the
- 8:49way that Americans talked about work, even back in the 50s or
- 8:53the 60s. I think it really did start to
- 8:56emerge as a result, as almost, like, kind of like a
- 8:58rationalization. For working so hard.
- 9:01It was like we work so hard and as a result, we, you know, had
- 9:07to find a quick, a reason why we were doing this.
- 9:09That made it seem more noble than it actually was.
- 9:13It's like a self-justification, right?
- 9:15Yeah. Like at the end of the day, if
- 9:16I've missed spending time with my family and Miss spending, you
- 9:19know the personal growth that I might be able to achieve through
- 9:22Leisure activity or other kinds of you know more self oriented
- 9:26activities. You're like what I must be doing
- 9:28it for a reason otherwise I should be really Rest right now.
- 9:30Yeah, I think the decline in like Community Leisure is also a
- 9:34big part in this too. You know, we used to have all
- 9:38these Civic organizations and places to congregate as a group,
- 9:42you know, we had religion, organized religion.
- 9:45All of that has disintegrated over the years and so are being
- 9:49form of leisure today is Netflix, right?
- 9:51You know, you're just watching TV, maybe on a phone.
- 9:54You know all alone and there's nothing really rewarding about
- 9:58that. So yeah you have all these
- 9:59studies. Actually paying people at random
- 10:02times of the day, like, are you happy right now?
- 10:04Are you not, how are you feeling?
- 10:06And they find that when people are working, they actually
- 10:09report higher scores of well-being than when people are
- 10:13at home, which is ironic because you would think that it would be
- 10:17the other way around. But yeah, work is the more kind
- 10:21of communal, you know, challenging thing that we do in
- 10:24our lives today and Leisure is just, you know, sitting on her
- 10:27couch watching TV, which is It rewarding.
- 10:31So, yeah, I think like that Leisure picture plays, like, a
- 10:33big role in this too. It's interesting too.
- 10:36Because, you know, this researchers are saying, are you
- 10:38feeling, basically contentment or fulfillment?
- 10:40Because I think those things are a little bit different from
- 10:41happiness, especially in like, the American definition of
- 10:45Happiness, which are so particular.
- 10:47I think that if you asked, you know, somebody from France or
- 10:50somebody from China, like, if happiness is a goal, they would
- 10:54look at you. Like, you have five heads, but,
- 10:55um, but there's also like such a connection between Willis,
- 11:00you've worked very hard. You're allowed to take more
- 11:02expansive and expensive vacations.
- 11:05And so I'm getting it like there's this quote, and I'm
- 11:09going to butcher a little bit, but I was rereading goodbye to
- 11:13all that. And Joan Didion is writing an
- 11:15essay about the wealthy people of Newport Rhode Island.
- 11:18And she states flatly happiness is a consumption ethic, and one
- 11:24of the things that happened during the 80s was we became
- 11:27increasingly a consumer culture. I mean, was Be starting to
- 11:30happen in the post-war period. Of course, well son, I've seen
- 11:33madman to, but I think that in the 80s you saw that become
- 11:37exceedingly. Supercharged, the idea of
- 11:39consumerism, like, Beyond an Embrace of it, the idea that
- 11:43that's who we are. As people, the term itself,
- 11:45consumerism was developed in the 60s and 70s, like, it's all a
- 11:48result of like this. Post-war America economic.
- 11:51We all have toasters, we all have washer and dryers, you
- 11:54know, sort of like, we can live this Amazing Life, As Americans
- 11:57specifically, with. Also like In the very patriotic
- 12:00about it. And so I think that she's kind
- 12:03of seeing into the future in some ways.
- 12:05This idea that we would create an entire ethic around
- 12:09consumption and I wonder how that has changed how we see work
- 12:13and how we see satisfaction. Yeah, I think that's exactly
- 12:16right. Like you know the more we
- 12:18consume the more money we need and in order to get that money
- 12:22we have to work harder. So yeah, I think there's
- 12:25definitely a vicious cycle going on there.
- 12:28And if you look, you know, at the time Trends of different
- 12:31Industries as they've risen and Fallen both in value but also
- 12:36prominence. And like our culture.
- 12:38It's interesting to see Tech fit into all of this because if you
- 12:41look at the 80s and when finance and Wall Street were the most
- 12:45desired jobs in America, these were like the captains of
- 12:47industry. There was also like very much a
- 12:49hustle culture. These people were working at all
- 12:52hours and it was, you know, part of being a successful executive
- 12:56in the finance world, was the fact that you are dedicated To
- 13:00do your job, you have no family life, all of that, and that
- 13:03became very unattractive. At a certain point, you saw a
- 13:06lot of people in the industry. Either getting burnt out or just
- 13:08disillusioned and then Tech is sort of there.
- 13:12I mean, in a way that we consider it Tech in in kind of
- 13:14the Facebook era, do you know Web 2.0 period where these
- 13:18companies were all very Mission driven that they began talking
- 13:22about, you know, Google's don't be evil or whatever, Steve Jobs
- 13:27applied to Apple and why it was such an important company.
- 13:29And they it kind of beat that into the head of their employees
- 13:32that you were a good person because you worked for this
- 13:34company and so you could kind of.
- 13:36So you can we talk about this so much on this show but like,
- 13:38subsume your personal mission and personal identity into that
- 13:41of the companies. I mean, what's your take on
- 13:43that? Like how did you sort of see
- 13:45Tech specifically fit into addiction to work and people's
- 13:50self definition being connected to the place that they work?
- 13:54I think Tech really took the hustle culture that already
- 13:58existed That time to the extreme, and I feel like I
- 14:02really felt it myself. I got sucked into it myself
- 14:05because I moved to San Francisco from Tokyo in 2012.
- 14:10So, this was the, I think it was, like, the year that
- 14:12Facebook went public. And, you know, I think, in the
- 14:162010s there was this, like real sense that, you know, Tech was
- 14:19not only extremely lucrative, you know, but that it was really
- 14:23altruistic to. And everybody around me was not
- 14:27only earning, very nice salaries.
- 14:29But, uh, So changing the world and, you know, you didn't really
- 14:32talk about your salary because, you know, you pretended that
- 14:36changing the world was the more important thing that you were
- 14:38doing. Do you think people still
- 14:40believe that companies and people who are employees?
- 14:43Do you think that's something that they still think about or
- 14:45still strive for? I don't know.
- 14:47I think a lot of that bubble has popped.
- 14:50I think, you know, not just because of the pain demek, which
- 14:53made a lot of people, reevaluate their relationship to work but
- 14:57also just because of the changing tenor of In a news
- 15:00coverage of tech companies. Right now, we think of tech
- 15:03companies has good, you know, mostly evil but we didn't just
- 15:07like any other company like, right sure she's even more
- 15:10concerning. It's not even that it's evil
- 15:12because that would be interesting is that it's boring
- 15:14ass just like Starbucks or Walmart.
- 15:16Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 15:17Yeah. As fundamentally, you know,
- 15:20profit-seeking corporations and that's not really how we saw
- 15:23tech companies. I think back in the 2010s, like
- 15:26I think back then when we saw Facebook as you know, the
- 15:29company that Was you know connecting the world and you
- 15:32know Google is a company that was organizing the world and the
- 15:35information of the world and yeah, you know I don't I would
- 15:39venture a guess that most tech employees don't really know kind
- 15:44of have that illusion and choir. It would be strange if they did.
- 15:48I feel, you know, I'm sure things in there are some that I
- 15:51believe do but they would come off as even more Kool-Aid,
- 15:54drinking, you know, dead-eyed Psychopaths.
- 15:56If they set it now than they may have ten years ago, even when
- 15:59Mark Zuckerberg. Rhetorically just sort of given
- 16:01up on all that and then like we're here to make some money
- 16:03and a diverse. We're not going to put in any
- 16:05safeguards or really give a shit at all about how people feel or
- 16:08what happens to them. They are I mean right, okay,
- 16:10feels very blunt which is I think partly why the matter
- 16:12versus a concept is so unappealing to people because
- 16:15you're not really promising a better world, a more interesting
- 16:19environment which you can interact with your co-workers or
- 16:22your friends. You're basically like helping
- 16:24him create a new platform that he could monetize and be first
- 16:27in so that you know the company can.
- 16:29Stave off the rise of copycats and tick-tocks and anything that
- 16:33may have, you know, pulled away from their dominance.
- 16:35Yeah, you're just getting them or pixelated version of the
- 16:38current world, right? That the he can make better you
- 16:40know more money on that he built industry on top of.
- 16:42But anyway, let's zoom in a bit on the pandemic specifically
- 16:45because like you said you started covering this in 2021.
- 16:47So we're in this kind of nether region where we've been working
- 16:52remotely for, you know, a year or so our connection to our job
- 16:57in a relationship to our jobs is very different because we're
- 16:59all, Home, I mean, what did you see developing as time went on
- 17:04and we settled into our remote work lifestyle and began may be
- 17:08reassessing the way that we work at our relationship to our
- 17:11company's. Yeah.
- 17:12I think there are a couple friends there.
- 17:14I think probably the most important thing is that because
- 17:17we were no longer going into the office which seemed like such an
- 17:21important like such a central pillar of the way.
- 17:24We live our lives that put everything else up for grabs to
- 17:28and I think that Did our relationship to work how we
- 17:31think about our jobs? I also think that you know in a
- 17:34remote environment like your relationships with your
- 17:37co-workers aren't as important. So people started to realize
- 17:41that I think like, you know, they were too dependent on work
- 17:45for their social lives that they wanted to build more
- 17:47relationships outside of their jobs, especially if they were
- 17:50going to stay remote and then I think just kind of a humongous
- 17:55disruptions of the pandemic and the tragedy of it to made People
- 18:00do a lot of kind of deeper, you know, more philosophical
- 18:03thinking. Give them some time to think
- 18:06about whether they were living their lives in a way that
- 18:09fulfilled them. And if they work how they wanted
- 18:12to live it a little bit differently and how did coasting
- 18:15culture, which was sort of your next big Insight on the way that
- 18:20we work. How did that fit into things?
- 18:22So it, I mean, does it, does it flow directly from this period
- 18:25where we said? Yes we witnessed this giant
- 18:28tragedy and Hundreds of thousands and 1 million people
- 18:31that have died because of this disease.
- 18:33Our relationship with our co-workers is now severely
- 18:36limited because we don't see them in person.
- 18:38We don't see our bosses in person.
- 18:40You know, we don't have the commute aspect that gave us
- 18:43routine. Did that sort of lead in towards
- 18:45a disillusionment with work and then ultimately people saying,
- 18:48maybe I shouldn't be working that hard in the first place and
- 18:51I can find other meaning in my life.
- 18:54Yeah. Is there a way you could have
- 18:55written this as more of a how-to manual as well?
- 18:59It's funny you say that because like, you know, I was interested
- 19:03in this topic because I underwent this, you know, kind
- 19:06of re-evaluation myself and I wanted to figure out for the
- 19:10coast in culture story, my initial kind of impetus for
- 19:13writing, that story was I just wanted to talk to people who had
- 19:17figured out a new way forward that wasn't hustle culture
- 19:19because I was trying to figure that out myself.
- 19:22So yeah, I just try to find people who were working a lot
- 19:26less than they used to be and trying to see if, you know, Oh,
- 19:29they were able to be successful with that, you know, to not only
- 19:33keep their jobs but oh, so be happy with that decision to work
- 19:37less as you talk to these people, that made that decision.
- 19:40What was the rationale? I think that independent MC.
- 19:43They decided they made the realization that they had
- 19:47devoted to much of their lives to work, and they wanted to make
- 19:52work less Central in their lives so they could make room and time
- 19:55for things outside of their lives.
- 19:57Whether it was, you know, their family, their House their
- 20:00friends Community. Civic activities, were they
- 20:05happier though? I mean, it's one thing to make
- 20:07the decision and rebalance, the things that you're involved
- 20:11with. But did you find that these
- 20:12people asking for, you know, anyone out there who might have
- 20:14made this decision or wants to like the people that, you know,
- 20:18pushed things more in that direction?
- 20:20Are they seeing the benefits that they thought they were
- 20:22going to? I think the people I spoke to
- 20:24for that story where a lot happier they found more time
- 20:29too. Do the things that they found,
- 20:31they enjoy a lot more than work. But, you know, I think it's an
- 20:35astute question that you ask because it does come in like
- 20:38kind of two steps, right. The first step is to work less.
- 20:40So you have more time to do everything else.
- 20:42But the second step is actually to find those other things that
- 20:46you find actually fulfilling. Because, you know, if you're
- 20:48using that extra time in your day to, you know, watch more
- 20:51Netflix, for example, you know, that's probably not going to be
- 20:54rewarding for most people and, you know, that might actually
- 20:58lower your well-being as a Well, I think that's the part that I'm
- 21:02still trying to figure out to, you know, to try to fill my
- 21:06newly, created time with things that actually do.
- 21:10Bring me more fulfillment than just work itself, right?
- 21:13Because you know if it's about building Community or finding
- 21:17meeting outside of work that takes work as well.
- 21:20Like these things, it's not like it's like if you create a vacuum
- 21:23if by removing the thing that had been there and the
- 21:25expectation is like all the good stuff will just flow into it and
- 21:28it doesn't just Back like it, you know, the idea of meeting
- 21:32people that you live around, going out to a art museum or
- 21:36whatever the hell would find meeting for you.
- 21:38Like those are all things that would require work.
- 21:40You gotta get off your ass and do it, and it's not something
- 21:44that, you know, will just naturally fill in.
- 21:46So I imagine that there are people out there that just sort
- 21:49of like assumed that, you know, meaning and goodness would just
- 21:54enter their lives because they removed something that had been
- 21:56problematic beforehand and probably found very quickly That
- 22:00it just didn't happen like that and that's likes is literally
- 22:02just there, right? Yes.
- 22:03Go from you know the dining room table that you're working at 10
- 22:06steps over to the living room and suddenly you found yourself
- 22:09filling your time with that. Yeah, I mean work is just there
- 22:11to I think that's what makes it so difficult, you know.
- 22:14Usually if you put in more time and more effort than you do get
- 22:17rewarded for it as a result, whether that's you know,
- 22:20professional recognition from your peers or that's actually a
- 22:23higher salary whereas, you know, pursuing these things outside of
- 22:27work. Yeah, comes in fits and starts.
- 22:29It's a lot of experimentation and a lot of things that don't
- 22:33end up being fun. So I think it's less of a sure
- 22:36bet in that way. And I think that makes it hard
- 22:39for people to, I'll say that. Like, one thing that I've
- 22:42actually noticed now that I'm working fully remotely now and I
- 22:45used to back when I was at Bloomberg, I went into the
- 22:47office every single day. I found that like working
- 22:50remotely has helped me kind of like maintain energy, even at
- 22:56the end of the day to do something else.
- 22:58And like, I'm pretty Did I think so?
- 23:00Like, you know, back when I was going into the office every day,
- 23:03by the time, I came home by, like 7:00, like, all I wanted to
- 23:06do was, you know, not talk to anyone.
- 23:09Maybe, I don't know, maybe I would talk to my wife at the
- 23:11time or something, but like, you know, mostly like, I didn't feel
- 23:15up to like, hanging out with my friends because I was so
- 23:17exhausted. And by the time, Friday night
- 23:18rolled around, like, all I want to do was watch TV because I was
- 23:21so exhausted. And, you know, Saturday, I would
- 23:24spend like, just the day recovering and maybe Sunday I
- 23:27would feel social enough to do something but But now like I
- 23:30actually, you know, spend a lot of my evenings hanging out with
- 23:34people, you know. I took a pickleball like
- 23:36everybody else. All right?
- 23:39All right, I hope it's been everything.
- 23:52You you were excited, but interestingly to you're given
- 23:55the opportunity to choose with whom you're going to spend
- 23:59those. Those hours of your time, we are
- 24:02actually with other people. And that choice is not something
- 24:04we've had for a long time. Yeah, right.
- 24:07There's also, I think, you know, work itself, once you've kind of
- 24:11figured it out, not that it's ever easy.
- 24:13And I could say this, you know, as journalists it's it's a
- 24:15different difficult challenge every day and you find new ways.
- 24:18All we do is pick up the phone, write things down, pick up the
- 24:21phone, I think that it is literally the same thing, every
- 24:23second. Okay, it is actually the sad
- 24:25thing. So we can we find new ways of
- 24:26being rejected them Yeah, there's so many shades of
- 24:33finding yourself, dispirited and reject it by doing what we do.
- 24:38My favorite is, oh, yeah, I'd love to talk to you.
- 24:41I'll call you right back. Right.
- 24:43Never never again. Right.
- 24:45At the same time I was I was brought up only to say that the
- 24:49job remains interesting because the questions are almost because
- 24:52they're always. Yeah.
- 24:53And the people are different and it's you're dealing with, you
- 24:56know, people's personalities and individual emotions and
- 24:59motivations. Looks like that but I think in
- 25:02general once you get fairly good at your job you kind of know the
- 25:06actions that you need to take more or less to succeed in it
- 25:09and there's a success and expertise with repetition.
- 25:12Whereas when you're talking about, developing your personal
- 25:14life or building up Hobbies, I think there's a lot more
- 25:16rejection and instability almost or lack of certainty.
- 25:21With those things that can be hard in its own way, right?
- 25:23I mean, you've got to organize with other people to meet up.
- 25:26You got to find a thing to do, you know, you may not have a
- 25:29good time. I'm you may like you know invite
- 25:31everyone out to go to I don't know a concert and actually it
- 25:34sucked and you're like wow if I had just stayed home and just
- 25:38watch Netflix that might have been more fulfilling for me.
- 25:40At least I could somehow all corralled together in the
- 25:43workplace. Nobody's putting themselves out
- 25:44there and saying, let's all get together.
- 25:46We're just trapped there so we make rest of it and sometimes
- 25:49it's fun. This is a very dark view of the
- 25:51world. You know, researchers actually
- 25:54psychologists like make the differentiation of hard Leisure
- 25:58and easy leisure. That might not actually be like
- 26:01the actual terms that they use, but hard Leisure is, you know,
- 26:04stuff that's actually challenging that requires you to
- 26:07build out your skill. You know that takes a little bit
- 26:10of failure and then easy leader is just, you know, I don't know,
- 26:14like, taking up a hobby that you don't take very seriously or
- 26:18maybe just going out to drinks with a friend, or something like
- 26:21that. And they say that you where does
- 26:23pickle vehicle? I think it would depend on the
- 26:26person, but I'm very competitive.
- 26:28So, for me pickleball. All wood.
- 26:30Would you go hard? It's hard because you're the
- 26:32circus. I get really into it, you know,
- 26:34and I practice and I watched the YouTube videos to like perfect
- 26:37my serves. And um, yeah.
- 26:40So I think for me, it would be hard Leisure but I'm sure for a
- 26:43lot of people, it would be easily, sure.
- 26:45Yeah. There is like a
- 26:46self-consciousness around doing things with other people that we
- 26:49forget about. Especially if you so much of
- 26:52your social life was the workplace.
- 26:54It was served up to you. And I think that's something
- 26:56that we're trying to struggle with to even as Re-enter the
- 27:00world may or may not be going back to the office.
- 27:03It's like, how do we have the social interactions?
- 27:06We've been craving when there are all these risks rejection
- 27:10people not having the time people unsure, whether or not
- 27:14they're still close to the people.
- 27:16They thought they were close with.
- 27:18And then of course, the idea that we could still get polluted
- 27:21sort of like, hanging out your background like yeah.
- 27:24Yeah, right. Yeah.
- 27:25How much did they do? They matter in the first place?
- 27:28What about quiet quitting as A term because my understanding of
- 27:31the progression here is that you write this piece about coasting
- 27:34culture. It makes its way through the
- 27:37world of people who read Insider stories.
- 27:39But also just really pay attention to workplace and work
- 27:42culture Trends and then it becomes a tick tock Trend that
- 27:46some social psychologist or whatever reads the peace and
- 27:50says, oh, I've been noticing this a lot too.
- 27:51And I categorize this Behavior as quiet, quitting.
- 27:55And then that becomes a meme and everyone's talking about it on
- 27:58Twitter for a couple of weeks. Maybe giving you credit for it.
- 28:01Maybe not explain to me the trajectory from that piece that
- 28:04you wrote on coasting culture and this term that we all now
- 28:08know. Yeah.
- 28:09So what happened was after my story published, there's a
- 28:13career coach on Tick, Tock and YouTube, who talked, about a job
- 28:17that didn't exist to generation ago.
- 28:19Go on. So here, if Don my story and
- 28:24actually talk to him about this a few weeks ago, he said he
- 28:27didn't like spend that much time like thinking about About the
- 28:30name. But he just kind of
- 28:31spontaneously came up with it by combining a few of the words
- 28:35that were in my headline, I guess.
- 28:37And he called it quiet quitting. And then, I guess a bunch of
- 28:40take stalkers kind of jumped on that and made it even more
- 28:44viral. And it was kind of building and
- 28:46virality on Tick Tock for a few months and then it broke out
- 28:50into the mainstream and late August or so, when Outlets, like
- 28:54the Wall Street Journal started, talking about it.
- 28:57So I did not come up with the term.
- 28:58Yeah, I called it coasting. We're realizing around it to
- 29:01right. There were like people that were
- 29:02very upset. Oh yeah, currently found it to
- 29:05be deeply troubled. Well, you know, I think this
- 29:07says something about the internet there are multiple
- 29:10stages. I think of this, and, like the
- 29:12outrage cycle at first, you know, people were just like,
- 29:16wow, look at this thing that like, young people are talking
- 29:18about on Tick Tock and then like all the executives came in there
- 29:22like what the fuck is this? Like, you know, young people are
- 29:25so lazy. Like don't do this.
- 29:27Always true. Goodbye, John This is what's
- 29:31wrong about the world today. And then from there, all the
- 29:34young people came out, and they were like, why are we even
- 29:37calling this quiet quitting when it's just doing your job?
- 29:41What's the quickest? That's that's so late.
- 29:43If you're doing the bare minimum.
- 29:44That is actually the job that is actually the job exactly.
- 29:47You're fulfilling job, exactly. Yeah.
- 29:48So, there's which is sort of like reclaiming that Trend use
- 29:51the identified as starting the 80s of people being
- 29:54incentivized, to what we thought, then of over are great
- 29:58and to As such, I mean, I remember in the 80s they were
- 30:01like Time Magazine cover stories about workaholism and like
- 30:05whether or not this is going to destroy America and you could
- 30:07argue about it was it was definitely seen it as an
- 30:11aberration ran. And then by the time we got to
- 30:14your quiet quitting story. It was people recognizing that
- 30:18actually. Perhaps, it isn't every man.
- 30:19Yeah, I feel like the, I hate this word, but I feel like the
- 30:23discourse would have been a little bit better.
- 30:25Had they gone with the term coast and culture rather than
- 30:29Whether they had to put it on his like recently, but actually,
- 30:37it's as good as it's ever. Been free speech is back.
- 30:41It's apparently it's bad for business.
- 30:43Free speech is back. We've saved it.
- 30:45Actually we can talk about Elon a little bit here because I do,
- 30:49we'll see. We'll see if we're having a good
- 30:50time to know, we know, but I'm having a good time so let's not.
- 30:55But you know, it coasting culture to me.
- 30:59And even that in its of itself, I think probably implies a
- 31:02little bit of a boss Centric attitude, which is that you just
- 31:06heard of coasting along you're taking up time, you're not
- 31:08really helping the company and that and of itself, you know
- 31:11like it's not a positive thing. I doubt you spent that much time
- 31:14thinking whether or not this had you know employer or employee
- 31:17facing. No I did I did.
- 31:20Yeah you did. I did spend a lot of time and I
- 31:23did like the term coasting culture either.
- 31:25I just couldn't come up with anything better and I think that
- 31:28does go to show up And of the limitations of our language now
- 31:31like because I wrote it my story like these people aren't lazy or
- 31:35you know, unambitious or shiftless, they're just done
- 31:38letting their employers, squeeze Free Labor out of them.
- 31:41So it was a very like kind of pro-worker story, you know, but
- 31:44there's no like actual word in the English language that could
- 31:48make that seem like a good thing because we're so steeped in
- 31:51Hustle culture. Now I think I think the thing I
- 31:54like about quiet quitting, even though I do agree that it's a
- 31:57flawed term in its own way. Is, you know, it's essentially
- 32:01about quitting a philosophy and I like, kind of that rejection
- 32:05of the way that we used to live our lives.
- 32:08I don't know. There's something really, you
- 32:10know, kind of refreshing and a little bit bad ass about it, I
- 32:14think. Yeah I mean when you explain it
- 32:16like that it makes a lot of sense but I was a little bit
- 32:20late like a half-step late to the trend and so when the term
- 32:23itself was making its way around whatever Twitter.
- 32:26So me when I first saw I assumed it meant people.
- 32:29That were leaving their jobs and work like an Irish goodbye.
- 32:34But for quitting, right? He just stopped showing up and
- 32:37like they just their bosses found out after paying them
- 32:41several like oh shit would be an amazing like Tom hasn't been
- 32:45here why we've been sending him a real quietly by the way?
- 32:48If that's a trend. Yeah, if that's a trend that's
- 32:51fucking awesome. Like that's a real power, you
- 32:53know, power to the people move but yeah, I think I had the
- 32:56reaction that a lot of whatever Millennials of my generation.
- 32:59It, which was that, like, oh, that's not quitting at all,
- 33:02you're just still working, you're just not working as hard.
- 33:04And I think that begat, you know, maybe some of the backlash
- 33:07to the backlash or whatever. But I thought that the bosses
- 33:10reaction to it was very interesting because I saw these
- 33:13op-eds. I think Peggy, Noonan or someone
- 33:15at the Wall Street Journal wrote one of her kind of whatever kind
- 33:19of lazy pieces on it and there were other kind of and you it
- 33:22was funny for her because I don't believe she's ever
- 33:24employed people. Like she's never really been a
- 33:27boss that she was just kind of rejecting.
- 33:29I saw it. As her writing that op-ed is
- 33:30like a sort of a defense of the Reagan assist culture that she
- 33:34did help kind of lead when she was you know Reagan's speech
- 33:36writer which was like no no no your work is extremely
- 33:39important. You need to be someone who finds
- 33:41meaning in the same way that Jim.
- 33:43I think she was like referencing the office and how like you know
- 33:46if it weren't for work culture Jim never would have found Pam.
- 33:50It's like lady. These people aren't real think
- 33:55of all the office sitcoms that we've enjoyed through our lives,
- 33:58that never would have come to fruition.
- 33:59And had we not had a workplace Centric society which it's not
- 34:03for email. You know, the couple in You've
- 34:06Got Mail, never would have found another think about.
- 34:08Yeah, that Ryan and Tom Hanks would have never connected had.
- 34:11They not only communicated through, you know, dysentery
- 34:14anyway, but I should bring back a lot.
- 34:18Well, I think about my dad so doesn't AOL email address.
- 34:20So that's the the Boomers will be there for it.
- 34:24Oh, let's talk about the Boomers for a bit.
- 34:26So so if it is a generational aspect to it, It.
- 34:29I mean you were really writing about Millennials and maybe some
- 34:32gen Z people that were kind of the leads of this trend.
- 34:35I mean, for the boss generation that, you know, the Boomers and
- 34:39maybe some gen-xers, their reaction was largely, you know,
- 34:42rejecting it because they saw it as laziness.
- 34:45I think, you know what I wanted, I thought it applied to all
- 34:48generations, but particularly for Millennials because I think,
- 34:52you know, we spent a long time, we spent like many years in the
- 34:55work place, initially just so grateful to have jobs at all.
- 34:59I think Anne and finding fulfill and a thinking that we were
- 35:04finding fulfillment there. Yeah.
- 35:08It was really interesting that I think happened like you know
- 35:15kind of in the later stages of the pandemic with the really hot
- 35:18job market that made us realize like actually like we don't have
- 35:23to be so grateful to have jobs at all.
- 35:25Like we could have any job we want and we can demand raises
- 35:28and I think I think part of that was oh, so you know we can
- 35:31demand to have an actual work-life balance.
- 35:34I think back in like the early 2010's a lot of commentators
- 35:37actually thought that we Millennials would be like the
- 35:40work-life balance generation and that turned out to be totally
- 35:44untrue because, you know, of the economic climate that we started
- 35:49working in things were so bad that we actually didn't demand a
- 35:53work-life balance at all. If anything, we were just, you
- 35:55know, happy to work ourselves to death and I think that's like
- 35:59one of the Days in which gen Z is different.
- 36:02Now I think younger workers because they're coming into the
- 36:05workplace in this time when they have like a tremendous amount of
- 36:10bargaining power just because of the way the job market is right
- 36:13now you know they're demanding things that I think for me as a
- 36:1735 year old feels a little like, Oleg, are you sure you want to
- 36:21be that vocal? Like is it okay to ask that from
- 36:24your boss? But I know that a lot of my
- 36:26younger colleagues have no qualms about that because You
- 36:29know, they have a fundamentally different view of, you know,
- 36:33their relationship to their employer.
- 36:36I think that's very much shaped by, you know, kind of their
- 36:39early years in the work place. And I wonder if that's one of
- 36:42the things that sort of like, psychologically pave the way for
- 36:44an Embrace of unions, like it doesn't feel like unions no
- 36:47matter what was going on in the labor market.
- 36:50We're really going to find a foothold and Corporate America
- 36:54at a time when you had a generation grateful to have him
- 36:58that I kind of convinced. It's After a finding fulfillment
- 37:00through this work and it was making meaning and changing the
- 37:04world in positive ways. It's like really hard to have a
- 37:07union, which implicitly says there needs to be a wall between
- 37:10the employee and the employer and that this is, you know, a
- 37:13potentially very unbalanced relationship and so you need to
- 37:16band together in order to sort of even out the scales, but if
- 37:20we now have a generation that looks at work with more
- 37:23skepticism and that is not willing to do things really
- 37:29We're a generation before would have said we're just
- 37:31opportunities to advance and learn and grow.
- 37:35This generation sees a potential exploitive suddenly, it does
- 37:39feel like you have the psychological room for unions.
- 37:42Even when the jobs are paying. Well, yeah, right.
- 37:44Well and we had sort of two parallel tracks going on right
- 37:47now within, you know, Blue Collar work and you know the
- 37:50email jobs because you know you're seeing this trend of
- 37:55people at service and Retail unionizing, right all the
- 37:59Starbucks. That have formed unions the
- 38:01Trader Joe's at a form unions. Some Apple Stores, you start to
- 38:05see you like Union, like movement happening.
- 38:06So that's going on at the blue-collar level and then
- 38:09within, you know, the white-collar level, whatever you
- 38:11want to call these jobs, service economy versus our color.
- 38:14Sure. Yeah.
- 38:15Like office jobs, you're having various Trends in which people
- 38:19are sort of wrestling with how protected they are the
- 38:21relationship. They want to have with their
- 38:22jobs, whether it's the quiet, quitting phenomenon, whether
- 38:25it's people. I mean, you starting to see, you
- 38:27know, like newsrooms obviously there's a push to have Reunions
- 38:30there, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette is on strike,
- 38:33that's right. Yes, and then there's, you know,
- 38:36like the Google Union was a thing that didn't really get all
- 38:38that far, but you know, that was the kind of similar sort of
- 38:41trend people trying to figure out how they can work among
- 38:44their fellow co-workers to redirect or find more meaning
- 38:47and the jobs that they have more control in the jobs that they
- 38:49have. I mean, what do you think about
- 38:51that? Like are these the same things
- 38:52as it? Is it the same phenomenon, the
- 38:54unionization happening at the blue-collar level and the sort
- 38:57of dissatisfaction or unrest happening at the white.
- 38:59Our jobs. I think there are some similar
- 39:02threads, you know, both for, you know, blue collar workers and
- 39:06for white collar workers. It's been a very, very good job
- 39:09market and I think that that gives workers, you know, on both
- 39:13ends of the income scale, kind of more, I think both like in a
- 39:17more confidence. I think to demand, what they
- 39:19want, you do not have to worry so much about their job security
- 39:23when it comes to organizing, but I think we're like blue collar
- 39:27workers. A big part 2 was also the
- 39:29physical. Physical dangers that they had
- 39:31to put themselves in during the pandemic, especially when you
- 39:34know, PPE supplies for solo. Of course, we as, you know, kind
- 39:38of professional office workers, you know, didn't encounter that
- 39:43we were very safe. So, there's probably a little
- 39:46bit of a difference as well, but yeah, I think I'll be really
- 39:49curious to see like, where this like, momentum for unionization
- 39:53goes in the next few years. Like, I mean, with the economy
- 39:57turning, I don't know. If it's the momentum is going to
- 40:01continue. I hope it will.
- 40:02But yeah, we'll see and even as the economy turns you know and I
- 40:07think that the last time this happened in 2008, one of the
- 40:09things that we have today that's in a more exacerbated state that
- 40:13it was in two thousand eight and nine is this ginormous visible
- 40:17extreme wealth Gap. And so you know in 2008-9 is the
- 40:22economy, went down the toilet, we saw Wall Street, take a hit,
- 40:29And Executives, be raked over the coals, but then we did not
- 40:34see accountability, or a loss of wealth.
- 40:36In fact, most of the CEOs involved become wealthier than
- 40:38ever been in the subsequent year.
- 40:40So, now, as it's happening, you know, 15 years later, you have a
- 40:44public remembering, how little the wealthiest Americans.
- 40:48And that case, most responsible for the downturn had to pay in
- 40:52any way. And now we're seeing this huge
- 40:55wealth Gap. So, when we talk about a
- 40:56downturn, it feels like an only uneven downturn and it doesn't
- 41:01even seem realistic call it a downturn for so much of
- 41:03corporate America or especially investors or people who have
- 41:07access to huge amounts of private capital.
- 41:10And so even though the economy could get worse, I do wonder if
- 41:16people will continue to try to find ways to address the fact
- 41:20that this might not feel fair to them and if you Nance will
- 41:23continue to be wondering, all right?
- 41:25I mean, I think like right now though the blue collar job
- 41:28Market is still very, very good if anything you know the layoffs
- 41:33are very concentrated and the tech sector right now where
- 41:36workers are paid very well. So yeah, it does feel like a
- 41:40different Dynamic than your typical recession, you know?
- 41:43And I wonder how that's going to end up playing out over the next
- 41:47year. Well, if you look at the
- 41:49rationale that a lot of companies had four layoffs
- 41:51stripe, had layoffs yesterday shop.
- 41:54If I had layoffs, yesterday, Amazon is cut a lot of its More
- 41:59like extraneous. What they are using extraneous
- 42:01Workforce then Twitter but Twitter is obviously a usually
- 42:05sweet. Yes, their argument is largely
- 42:09that they overshot their growth expectations, that they sort of
- 42:13bought the bullshit that during the pandemic, as things were
- 42:16really taking off and equities were skyrocketing Good Times,
- 42:19we're never going to end and they should hire to meet that
- 42:21demand. And from Amazon, to all the
- 42:24other companies that I just mentioned the cold grips of
- 42:26reality that what they were riding on was actually.
- 42:28Really unrealistic set in and they had to restructure their
- 42:32guidance and their Workforce to meet where the business actually
- 42:35is, but like you're saying it doesn't feel like the same sort
- 42:38of recession type are business just fell off a cliff.
- 42:41We need to lay a ton of people off so that we can save all of
- 42:45our costs. And mostly just seem like a huge
- 42:46projection issue which isn't a problem in.
- 42:49These are still people being laid off, but the kind of, you
- 42:52know, challenging Workforce Unemployment skyrocketing that
- 42:55we would see in a typical recession.
- 42:57I don't quite see it there yet. Yet.
- 42:59And so I don't know what that's going to mean, in terms of, you
- 43:01know, the culture that's been built up over the last year.
- 43:04Yeah, I mean, I think for now most economists think that this
- 43:07is going to be a pretty mild recession at least for us here,
- 43:11in the US unemployment is going to go up, but probably not by a
- 43:16whole lot. So as long as it stays that way,
- 43:19I think it'll be, you know, relatively painless compared to
- 43:23a lot of the other recessions that we've had in the past, but
- 43:27I don't know. We'll see instead.
- 43:28Go to prognosticate these things and if it were easy, I'd be very
- 43:32rich in terms of the stuff that you've written about.
- 43:36I mean, what do you see? You know, having an impact on
- 43:41quiet quitting? I mean you wrote a piece like a
- 43:43week or so ago where you talked about how layoffs will or will
- 43:47not change a lot of the stuff that we've been talking about
- 43:49it. Like it like it, my head.
- 43:50I sort of Saw think, you know, everything going for my quiet,
- 43:53quitting to like quiet, shitting your pants that you could be
- 43:56laid off. That is not gonna that's not
- 44:00that is not going to take off. No, I'm sorry.
- 44:03You want to get that one trending.
- 44:04That that was not gonna got to talk right now and take a quiet
- 44:07shitting period. Um, I'm gonna try though, okay.
- 44:12You know what, let's see, let's see.
- 44:14I'm gonna take them away. So if I come back in, this thing
- 44:17is huge. I'll be really disappointed.
- 44:19I wasn't there to watch. Are you guys going to pay money
- 44:21for your blue truck? Is that something you're going
- 44:22to do? I do eight dollars.
- 44:25Is the current price. Yeah.
- 44:26And I feel like, I don't know, I'd rather have my nuts.
- 44:28Like, I don't know, well, I would say like a dollar is about
- 44:32the most. I would pick up a check.
- 44:33That's about as much as Worth to me a dollar.
- 44:35Yeah, I do adults. My boss is pay, then I'd be
- 44:38happy for that but I don't think I would pay myself.
- 44:41Oh yeah. No it's so funny like would the
- 44:44New York Times pay for us all to have blue checks?
- 44:47That's a huge expense, that seems insane.
- 44:49But especially with all the reporters.
- 44:52I mean, that's like 1,000 something reporters.
- 44:54You know, every month. Yeah.
- 44:55And you've got like, Yeah, I don't know.
- 45:00I mean, I love to see like the New York Times about a hundred
- 45:03bucks a month. 100,000 100,000, the New York Times today
- 45:12one-time eight million dollar write down in order to ensure
- 45:15the reporters remain verified on Twitter but also not just
- 45:18reporters the New York Times itself.
- 45:20Like we have all these accounts like the time right now, the
- 45:22times business account, the times Tech Team account, they'll
- 45:24have blue checks. So it would be like, do not give
- 45:28the White House, a blue check. Like, do we have to use taxpayer
- 45:30dollars? Wow, make sure that like the
- 45:33White House account, the still verified and it's a government
- 45:37contract, if you think about it, right?
- 45:39Yeah. It's like, you know, there fuk
- 45:40like, I would immediately start a Twitter account that was like
- 45:43out white house but it's bubbling wh@ith buse just kind
- 45:48of I mean, like no, I waited that's verified as the actual
- 45:50White House. I hope I wouldn't do that to all
- 45:53my boss is no but I mean, who you can see where that would be
- 45:56fascinating, if the I have to count were no more war, not held
- 46:01apart in terms of its veracity from like, all the White House
- 46:04Coffee, count accounts that will spring up, you describe that as
- 46:08interesting. I described that as free speech
- 46:11and and the Bastion of free speech that we're trying to
- 46:13defend on this letter. Letter letter letter tried.
- 46:17Just I'm up for whatever. I'm done.
- 46:20Criticizing any strategic decision.
- 46:22I think they should just go ham and, and kept everything should
- 46:25be on the table. Can you get a blue?
- 46:27Check your, you know. So presumably a candidate can
- 46:30have a blue check. What about a person who just had
- 46:32a very similar name to the candidate?
- 46:34Can they pay for the blue check and then you've got like, you
- 46:37know? Yeah.
- 46:38Probably Trump but then you, you have like Donald Trump or you
- 46:43have right Donald Trump. Yeah, you know, Joey didn't I
- 46:49think the way the checks are supposed to work now is that
- 46:53it's the people that currently have checks that if they don't
- 46:56pay, they'll have it. And I don't know if new like any
- 46:59is it that anybody that would sign up for the subscription to
- 47:02everybody here, which is gonna be exactly you want spent
- 47:05talking about is like democratizing the check, right?
- 47:08So, presumably, that does have that anyone can apply for it by
- 47:11making it into a financial hierarchy.
- 47:13Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
- 47:17So, I mean, like, if my name were Joe Biden and I were just
- 47:20another job, I did, I'd buy a check so fast or if I was my
- 47:25name were Donald Trump. I'd be like.
- 47:27So bad. Yeah.
- 47:31Now is my moment especially and policy.
- 47:34Yeah. Doesn't doesn't come back to the
- 47:35platform because he's sticking out with truth social.
- 47:38So there's only one. Real Donald Trump or Donald
- 47:40Trump Donald J. Trump is on da WN Trump.
- 47:44I think that would actually work almost as well.
- 47:45If you guys are ever thought about like it's hot, baby named
- 47:49conservative, female babies. We don't know that.
- 47:52It's not gonna take a little while to that data.
- 47:54Yeah, we'll look back as Spike and Dawn's.
- 47:57Aw n last popular in like the 70s or something.
- 48:01So in our last section here, I did want to ask a bit about the
- 48:04most recent story that you wrote because there was a really
- 48:06interesting paragraph that I want to read here and it kind of
- 48:08maybe sets the stage for where we are right now in the job
- 48:11market or work life relationship.
- 48:12So I'm going to be from your story here.
- 48:14Even as the great resignation turns into plain old
- 48:17resignation, I don't think hustle culture is ever coming
- 48:20back. America's addiction, overworked
- 48:22wasn't just about the hours, we put into our jobs, it was about
- 48:25looking to our careers to provide our Lives with meaning
- 48:28and Define our identities. Free temporarily from the
- 48:30shackles of hustle culture. Millions of Americans have
- 48:33glimpsed a new way of ordering their lives, and here's a quote
- 48:36here. I don't think that people can
- 48:38forget this re-evaluation that they've done.
- 48:40Jessica kriegel Chief scientist of workplace culture at the
- 48:42consultancy culture. Partners told me another job of,
- 48:45pretty sure didn't exist a generation ago but anyway, we're
- 48:49never going back to pre-pandemic Norms.
- 48:51So I mean it's all fairly clear in that paragraph but that's
- 48:55sort of where you think it stands even if we do.
- 48:57Enter some sort of a mild recession, the kind of great
- 49:00reset that. I think a lot of bosses were
- 49:02hoping for after the pandemic. And you've seen this with like
- 49:05Zuckerberg, you know, admonishing his employees for
- 49:08asking about meta days and all this other shit that I know
- 49:11bosses wanted. Yeah, that's right coasters.
- 49:15The quiet coasters, actually. You know, I there's clearly a
- 49:18desire among the employer class to reverse the trend that you've
- 49:22been writing about. But you don't think it's
- 49:24possible. You don't think our brains will
- 49:25suddenly have to be reformatted back to hustle.
- 49:27Culture in a way that really benefitted a lot of bosses or
- 49:30yeah, I don't think so. And I, you know, this is
- 49:32interesting to me because this story came out of a follow-up
- 49:36conversation that I had with this guy who I sit down a Miss
- 49:40Lee called Justin in my original coasting culture story.
- 49:43And in this most recent follow-up story, he's a
- 49:47recruiter, you know, he had skilled his hours down to, you
- 49:51know, as little as maybe 30 hours a week before he used to
- 49:54work like you know, 60 70 hour weeks.
- 49:57And he was really happy with that for a while, but in the
- 50:00late summer, he started to notice that things were shifting
- 50:04and the job market for recruiters is genuinely bad now
- 50:07because if you were, people are hiring now.
- 50:10So, a lot of some of his colleagues were getting laid off
- 50:12his performance reviews were getting harder.
- 50:14And so he's now back to working about 50 hours a week.
- 50:19Now kind of lost a little bit of his Swagger, you know.
- 50:22And at first I was kind of disappointed and I was like oh
- 50:24like you know what? Just yeah.
- 50:27Trend. But he was saying that, you
- 50:29know, even for him, it's see the pickle ball racket.
- 50:32Just like the freaks. Those are the people that that
- 50:45was hard for sure. Plus like, that was like I got a
- 50:51workout and lonely. It's like just me.
- 50:54Yeah, so he's back to working 50 hours.
- 50:57Is a week, so he's up these hours.
- 50:59But he said that he's no longer kind of like relinquishing his
- 51:02soul, the way that he used to, he doesn't think about work
- 51:06outside of work anymore. He doesn't talk about work with
- 51:08his friends, he does it, you know, kind of Hawk has like
- 51:12these companies like internal leaderboard.
- 51:14He doesn't need to be on top anymore.
- 51:15He just doesn't like, kind of think of himself, first and
- 51:18foremost, as a recruiter, the way that he used to.
- 51:21And that change in his mindset, he said was permanent.
- 51:25And you can tell that it's permanent because he said that
- 51:27That as soon as the economic recovery comes and things are
- 51:30safe for him again. He's going to scale those hours
- 51:33back down to 30 hours a week. And so, yeah, I think in that
- 51:37way, hustle, cultures done. But right now, it's probably a
- 51:40little too risky to be a quiet quitter.
- 51:44I think, especially in the tech industry, so I don't know.
- 51:47Maybe you need to like look like you're working hard again, but I
- 51:52don't think that changes kind of the rethink that a lot of
- 51:55Americans have had during the pandemic.
- 51:57Yeah. So it goes from quiet, quitting
- 51:59to perform. Well I'm gonna say that if
- 52:04you're in a job with a lot of meetings you see a lot of
- 52:06performative working and that was true before director.
- 52:09Oh yeah. I think that's core to the
- 52:10American working experience. I mean, I think a lot of his
- 52:13working culture has really been about telling the person next to
- 52:16you, that you're working really hard.
- 52:18It's really the person above you.
- 52:19It was really interesting to see during the pandemic when there
- 52:22was not as much performative working because, you know, you
- 52:25couldn't walk over to your boss's desk and just be used.
- 52:27A performative how people who weren't performative workers
- 52:31seem to do like really well during the pandemic, right?
- 52:35And we're all working from home, you know, they seem to really
- 52:37shine because suddenly their work, everyone was just there.
- 52:42One was more judged on the merits of what I was rather than
- 52:45whether or not, they'd put in the face time, which I right
- 52:48fascinating. Totally.
- 52:49And I think also fascinating was like, the initial realization by
- 52:53Bosses that when things did go remote, they were like, well,
- 52:56efficiency isn't really down all.
- 52:57Much. It's not like we're getting less
- 52:58out of people that sounds like a slightly separate conversation
- 53:01just because people were so depressed and working because
- 53:04they couldn't stop. I mean I think that's was like a
- 53:06little bit different and might have helped fuel this desire to
- 53:10quiet quit. Yeah.
- 53:11Well that's possible or less. It was part of the larger Trend
- 53:14but I think you know the question was were they right
- 53:17that efficiency did or didn't go down?
- 53:18Because when you saw you know earlier this year as the economy
- 53:21began to like slightly shit the bed there was I'm really trying
- 53:26to get quiet shitting Big working.
- 53:29I think it's there. It's just so unsavory.
- 53:32I'm so, so so so fundamentally icky.
- 53:35But Continuum you keep his room. Yeah.
- 53:39I'll keep quiet. Shitting that there was suddenly
- 53:43like this massive realization on the part of bosses.
- 53:45They're like actually we've been coasting.
- 53:47There's been a lot of people that really aren't pulling their
- 53:49weight around here and you know, maybe it was true or maybe it
- 53:52was just like the macro effect starting to hit their business
- 53:56and them trying to reclaim a little Control over their
- 53:58workers lives and have a little bit that that that was lost when
- 54:01things went remote and maybe people's did start kind of not
- 54:04being as performative in a way that bosses really liked.
- 54:08I don't know. I guess we'll find out later
- 54:09hashtag quiet shitting, but anyway, yes, yes, I think, let's
- 54:15let's I'm gonna say this. Yeah, that's what I meant.
- 54:19Let's is probably not that. I think you, if you would like,
- 54:21you may, I would say, let's revisit this topic, six months
- 54:26or so occupy. Going to have you back.
- 54:28We're going to talk about how quiet sitting epidemic has
- 54:31finally crested as the economy has returned to normal and and
- 54:36we've entered a new stage. What do you think?
- 54:38The next one's going to be called?
- 54:39Let's say quite shitting out of it.
- 54:41What do you expect? And you give us a new term.
- 54:43We had Taylor Lorenz on a couple months ago and Eric was trying
- 54:45to get like what's the next term you're going to drop on fighting
- 54:48or discourse? What do you sort of seriously?
- 54:50No I mean my editors asked this all the time because you know
- 54:53they want me to write more and yeah but Sing read the article,
- 55:02coasting culture bitches. I don't know what if you're
- 55:06down. All right, about it and then you
- 55:07can have me back on again. Awesome.
- 55:09I like it. I like that answer.
- 55:11Alright yeah. Alright, thanks.
- 55:12Thank you. Thanks for joining.
- 55:13This is great. Yeah, thanks.
- 55:15This is awesome. I
- 55:29Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 55:31Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 55:29Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 55:31Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.