Latest / Migraine Relief Code with Dr. Amelia Scott Barrett, MD / Hormone Replacement Therapy and Migraines: Insights and Benefits
Transcript
- 0:00Alright.
- 0:00Hello, everybody, and welcome to our conversation about menopause and migraines.
- 0:08As you all know, I am super excited for this conversation.
- 0:12Doctor Jennifer Rollins is here with us this evening to tell us about some recent updates on
- 0:18what's going on in the world of hormone replacement therapy for those of us who are in
- 0:23or around menopause.
- 0:25And we are gonna talk about what it means specifically for those of us with migraine.
- 0:30Specifically those of us who have migraine with aura, what are the risks, what are the benefits
- 0:35in terms of our our overall health, and and what is estrogen toxicity anyway?
- 0:40So we've got some, fascinating topics for you guys here this evening.
- 0:46We will start with our conversation, and then we'll just open it up to you guys.
- 0:51So if you wanna put questions in the chat as we go, what I'll do is kinda keep an eye on those.
- 0:58So, doctor Rollins, you don't have to do that.
- 1:00You can just concentrate on on your your, your thang.
- 1:04And, I'll keep my eyes on the questions in the chat and kinda try to group similar questions
- 1:09together.
- 1:10And if we can't quite fit it in while she and I are talking, we will for sure fit it in during
- 1:14the q and a after.
- 1:15Okay?
- 1:16Sound good?
- 1:18Alright.
- 1:19Sounds great.
- 1:19Rolling.
- 1:21Alright.
- 1:21Doctor Rollins, thank you so much for being here this evening to talk to us about menopause
- 1:27and migraines.
- 1:28And, you know, I think really the first question on my mind is that I know that we had
- 1:34the Women's Health Initiative, you know, I don't know, twenty ish years ago that told us
- 1:39that hormone replacement therapy increased our risk of breast cancer.
- 1:43And then there's been some new updated information recently that says, well, maybe not
- 1:50and maybe we should be on it.
- 1:52Can you just kind of walk us through how all that happened and where we're at now?
- 1:58What do we understand now about HRT, during, perimenopause and after?
- 2:05Sure.
- 2:05Yeah.
- 2:05I'm happy to.
- 2:06Thanks for having me here.
- 2:08So, yeah, so the Women's Health Initiative was published in February, so it's been about
- 2:13twenty four years since the study was published.
- 2:16And at the time, the the the way the study was grouped is that it had estrogen only, estrogen
- 2:24plus synthetic progesterone, which is called progestin, and then you had the placebo group.
- 2:29And so the study was actually stopped prematurely because they noticed there was an
- 2:33increased risk of blood clots and stroke, and then there was a concern for, breast cancer in
- 2:40the estrogen plus progesterone or progestin really because they were synthetics at the
- 2:44time.
- 2:45And it was actually, you know, I at the time, it was so well published, the information,
- 2:51like, in the media.
- 2:53Doctors actually found out through the media more than through we never got, like, a little
- 2:56email that's like, hey, by the way, this is coming out.
- 2:59Like, patients were just starting to come straight to us and saying, oh my gosh.
- 3:03I gotta get off HRT.
- 3:03I gotta get off HRT.
- 3:05And so the prescription rate at that time was somewhere around seventy percent of women were
- 3:10on hormone replacement therapy who are good candidates at the time, and it went down to
- 3:13about four percent very, very quickly.
- 3:17Wow.
- 3:17That
- 3:18is a dramatic impact.
- 3:20Oh my goodness.
- 3:20I didn't realize it was that big.
- 3:23Yeah.
- 3:23Yeah.
- 3:23And so that it just became very like, there wasn't a lot of, at the time, a lot of sort of
- 3:30information as to, like, wait.
- 3:32What is you know, it was just the largest study that had ever been done.
- 3:35I think it was, like, 12,000 women.
- 3:37It was a very well funded study by, the company, a prescript a pharmaceutical company.
- 3:43And so we kind of just almost used it as the bible, right?
- 3:47Oh, HRT is bad.
- 3:48Everybody should be off of hormone replacement therapy.
- 3:50It's potentially has an increased risk of breast cancer and blood clots of stroke, so you
- 3:54should be off of it.
- 3:56And then over and it's kinda has been the narrative.
- 3:58So if any any physician was trained in the last twenty three years, they were really kind of
- 4:02told the same narrative.
- 4:03And I'm sixteen years out of residency and I distinctly remember as an OB GYN, they said,
- 4:08well, you don't need to remember anything about, you know, hormone replacement therapy
- 4:11because you're never gonna prescribe it.
- 4:13So don't worry about it.
- 4:14It's it's not a thing you need to worry about.
- 4:16So and I'm an OB GYN.
- 4:19So at the time, I really didn't know much about that.
- 4:21And now in the last probably five, six years, there's been so much more attention on
- 4:26menopause and menopause care and, you know, people who are, you know, in their late forties
- 4:31and mid fifties have celebrities who are now aging who don't like it, who don't like to have
- 4:37positive, like, aging.
- 4:38Yeah.
- 4:39Yeah.
- 4:39Yeah.
- 4:39Right?
- 4:40You got these celebrities like Gwyneth Paltrow and Naomi Watts and Halle Berry and all these
- 4:46list of, oh my gosh, the lady with a great TV show that was eat on ET.
- 4:50I don't know why.
- 4:51Drew Barrymore.
- 4:52All those ladies who have, like, wait a minute.
- 4:54This is not okay.
- 4:55I'm not interested in in aging like this.
- 4:57And so the education to patients has made people go back to look at those studies in in
- 5:03the early two thousand and say, why would we why is this the the truth?
- 5:07Why do we believe this is the truth?
- 5:10And a lot of sub studies have been done from that and realized that the patient population
- 5:15was the average age of that patient that was in that study was in their, like, late fifties,
- 5:20early sixties.
- 5:21There
- 5:21were people who are starting on HRT in their forties, fifties, sixties, seventies, eighties.
- 5:26Like, everybody was in the same lump of patients.
- 5:29So that was one big fault of the study is they never distinguished between a 50 year old who
- 5:34was within ten years of menopause starting hormone replacement, a 60 year old, a 70 year
- 5:38old, like there was no distinction on those things.
- 5:41Really, when they went back to look at the estrogen, the estrogen only arm, the people who
- 5:45had hysterectomies that only got estrogen, they didn't get progesterone at all.
- 5:49Those women actually had a decrease in breast cancer.
- 5:52They actually had less breast cancer.
- 5:56So and they estrogen only?
- 5:58Estrogen only arm.
- 5:59It was the estrogen plus synthetic progestin arm.
- 6:03And remember the estrogen then was not bioidentical.
- 6:06It was synthetic.
- 6:07Right.
- 6:07So it is yeah.
- 6:08Premarin are are sort of classic.
- 6:10So, both of them were synthetic at the time.
- 6:13So so fault two of this study was that the progestin arm was the one that had the breast
- 6:18cancer risk, not the estrogen only arm.
- 6:20They actually had a protective effect on there.
- 6:23That that was never said.
- 6:25Yeah.
- 6:25That I did not know that.
- 6:26That is fascinating.
- 6:27Okay.
- 6:28Yeah.
- 6:28And then the third the third fault here is that we don't even use that regimen anymore.
- 6:33Like, none of us use that.
- 6:34Right.
- 6:35And that kind of, you know, synthetics have really kind of gone by the wayside, and so none
- 6:40of us are even using those therapies really anymore because, I mean, I don't know how many
- 6:44women in your community, but if you tell them, hey.
- 6:46I would love to give you this estrogen that's made from horse urine and it has 16 different
- 6:51metabolites of estrogen, they're gonna be like, no.
- 6:54Yeah.
- 6:55There's no idea.
- 6:56Though most of us don't do that anymore just because that's kind of come out of favor for
- 7:00the way that we sort of see the world and all those other things with sustainable, you know,
- 7:05sustainable medication.
- 7:06So so there was a lot of since then, people who've done many, many, many sub analysis on
- 7:12the Women's Health Initiative had realized that the the health of the patient is the most
- 7:17important part.
- 7:17Like, if you're 45 years old, it's much different starting a 45 year old on HRT than a
- 7:2275 year old.
- 7:24Old.
- 7:24Because by then, when they went through the menopause transition, their blood vessels have
- 7:28hardened and they've sort of become it becomes more of a risk than someone who's 70 starting
- 7:33them on oral estradiol versus someone who's 45 who still has very pliable, flexible blood
- 7:38vessels from a blood from a cardiovascular standpoint, so blood clots and stroke.
- 7:44Okay.
- 7:45From from the breast cancer, perspective, you know, there's been other studies like the
- 7:50nurses health initiative study that was done with 11,000 women.
- 7:54There's been a lot of European studies, and a lot and what they've realized is the synthetic
- 7:59progestin is where we're concerned about this increased breast cancer risk.
- 8:04And it's really been when you look at the even back then, it was an additional person per
- 8:1010,000 people.
- 8:11So we're not even talking about you know, you have that sort of relative risk and absolute
- 8:15risk question.
- 8:16We weren't even talking about a huge substantial increase, but whenever you, you
- 8:20know, when you're reporting something, it's always better to look more dramatic to say
- 8:24increased risk of, you know, breast cancer as opposed to sort of talking about one extra
- 8:29person per 10 per 1,000.
- 8:30So, so over time in the last twenty four years, for those of us to take care of menopause women
- 8:38is we've realized that the age of the patient is important as far as their health status, and
- 8:43then also are they at risk for any heart disease or breast cancer in the future, then
- 8:48those are the patients you sort of look a little bit more closely as is hormone
- 8:51replacement therapy an option for them or not.
- 8:53But most women are candidates for it.
- 8:56Yeah.
- 8:57And now there's so many more options for besides oral medications that even those risks
- 9:03go down even more because the patch, for example, has less heart disease risk than an
- 9:09oral medication.
- 9:10So there's a lot of things that have suddenly come come out in that twenty three years that
- 9:14we kinda jumped the gun on saying it's bad for everybody when that's not necessarily the case.
- 9:19Okay.
- 9:19So two follow ups for you on that.
- 9:22I have heard, and tell me if this is true or not, that the that increased risk of breast
- 9:27cancer went something like this.
- 9:28Like, it was four in ten thousand or a thousand or something like that, who were not getting
- 9:38HRT.
- 9:39It only went up to, like, five in a thousand or ten thousand of people who are on HRT.
- 9:43And that is that what you mean by that one
- 9:45That one extra person.
- 9:46Yep.
- 9:47Okay.
- 9:47So it's, like, technically, twenty five percent increase, but, like, really not much in terms
- 9:53of number of people.
- 9:55Gotcha.
- 9:56Okay.
- 9:57And then it sounds like the second thing you're saying is you really have to consider the risk
- 10:03of HRT as you're thinking about that, and that's cardiovascular risk, mainly risk of
- 10:10blood clots, stroke, heart attack, as well as breast cancer.
- 10:14Right?
- 10:15Yeah.
- 10:15Yeah.
- 10:15I mean, breast cancer is really I mean, to be honest, breast cancer is one in eight women.
- 10:19Right?
- 10:19I mean, this is a risk for everybody, really, because that's a high percentage.
- 10:23That's a lot.
- 10:24Yeah, exactly.
- 10:25So the the patients that we sort of steer away from an HRT would be more of someone who has
- 10:31high risk of breast cancer because they maybe have genetic reasons or, maybe they had a
- 10:37biopsy in the past and they're in that hyperplasia category.
- 10:41You know, like, they're they're at higher risk, and so those are the patients we may be a
- 10:43little more cautious related to hormone replacement therapy.
- 10:47But, the heart disease risk is really is more, you know, someone who smokes who's over the age
- 10:53of 35, they may have uncontrolled high blood pressure or uncontrolled diabetes, and they
- 10:57really need to work on the metabolic aspect of their health first before they get on an extra
- 11:02thing like hormone replacement therapy.
- 11:04Might be someone who we would kind of have a good informed consent conversation with.
- 11:08Yeah.
- 11:09Not to say they're not a candidate, but that we need to make sure that we're having a good
- 11:13informed consent about it.
- 11:14Okay.
- 11:15And then
- 11:16yeah.
- 11:17Exactly.
- 11:18One other thing you had mentioned is that you said the risk is actually lower with
- 11:23transdermal forms of estrogen, like a patch or something, as compared to a pill.
- 11:28Now that's important to this community of people with migraines because many of us have
- 11:33auras.
- 11:34And, of course, aura also increases your risk of stroke just a tiny bit.
- 11:40And so for it sounds like for us, you know, people who have migraine with aura, maybe the
- 11:46better decision then would be to take a patch.
- 11:49Is that correct?
- 11:50Or are there are there other forms of estrogen that we should ask our doctor about?
- 11:55Yeah.
- 11:56Yeah.
- 11:56So, yes, transdermal application would be better.
- 11:59Now there are FDA approved, you know, like EVA Mist is an is a transdermal estrogen you could
- 12:05spray on you.
- 12:05So there are DVgel is an estrogen gel.
- 12:09So there are FDA approved ones that are not necessarily a patch that are still transdermal.
- 12:15And then obviously you have compounding, right?
- 12:16You have compounding outside of the FDA prescribed, medication.
- 12:21So there are other transdermabocystipatch.
- 12:24Okay.
- 12:24And by compounding, you mean, like, the creams that are made by a special compounding
- 12:27pharmacy?
- 12:28Okay.
- 12:28Gotcha.
- 12:29And so do you have thoughts about what the best choice is for somebody who does have migraine
- 12:34with aura if they look at the pros and cons and decide, okay.
- 12:37I wanna do this.
- 12:40Any recommendations as to, you know, which for like, is any kind of transdermal okay?
- 12:45Are there certain forms of estrogen that are better than others?
- 12:47Should you go for an estradiol?
- 12:50Should you go for, like, the lower dose?
- 12:53Or what do you how do you think we should, ask our docs about this?
- 12:58Yeah.
- 12:58So there are three estrogens in the body.
- 13:00There's estradiol.
- 13:02This is the I'm 25.
- 13:04Life is awesome.
- 13:05Things are great estrogen.
- 13:07There's estriol, which is really only present when you're pregnant, and then if you happen to
- 13:11be on a biased cream that's compounded, that's estriol.
- 13:15Or say you get pick something up off a counter, it's gonna be estriol.
- 13:18And then there's estrone, which is the pro inflammatory fat estrogen that nobody wants.
- 13:24Okay.
- 13:24We don't we don't ever compound Nobody's gonna take that one.
- 13:27Nobody's like, yes.
- 13:28The one that's made in my fat.
- 13:30Let's sign up for it.
- 13:31Like, nobody does that.
- 13:32So it's really the estradiol, which is the 25, I feel awesome, life is great, invincible
- 13:39estrogen that most people use in the patch or the or the cream, like a Divigel or the, mist,
- 13:47those are all FDA approved estradiol.
- 13:50Okay.
- 13:51What I find with people with migraines is some of them are very sensitive to things, like very
- 13:57sensitive to medications.
- 13:59So sometimes I can't just give them an estradiol patch because they like, I almost
- 14:06need to, like, baby step it up a little bit with their estrogen.
- 14:08So sometimes I'm I have to, you know, give the caveat that I'm integrative medicine trained.
- 14:14So I do I'm not opposed to compounding in alternative medicine.
- 14:18I'm I'm I'm boarded in integrative medicine and functional medicine.
- 14:21So to me, that's, like, part of my toolbox for patients.
- 14:24So sometimes I have to do, like, a combo of a weak estriol and estradiol to kind of ease them
- 14:30into that because they're prone to migraine.
- 14:34So I have to be careful not to, like, hit them with what, you know, a 47 year old that doesn't
- 14:39get headaches with because it's miserable.
- 14:42So, you know, sometimes I do find those patients to be a little bit more sensitive.
- 14:46So I think there and it's not a one size fits all.
- 14:50There's certainly patients who do better with creams than they do with a patch or they do
- 14:55better with, a dosing every other day or only cycle specific.
- 15:00Like, there's it's there's a very personalized approach to those things because I've had
- 15:04patients who you barely give them a little tiny cream and they're like the happiest people in
- 15:08the world and then you give them like the other person, you give five levels of the patch and
- 15:12they're still miserable and you're like, wait a minute, how do I you guys, like, what's going
- 15:17on here?
- 15:17The physiology is something that you don't know until you start trying with patients.
- 15:22Yeah.
- 15:22That makes sense.
- 15:23And, you know, a lot of people in my community have had their genetic testing done so they
- 15:28know exactly how their body makes, you know, converts progesterone to testosterone and
- 15:33testosterone to estrogen and how their body makes toxic metabolites.
- 15:37So I think everybody here is like, yep.
- 15:39Yep.
- 15:40We're all gonna be different about that.
- 15:42Yeah.
- 15:43Yeah.
- 15:43It's true.
- 15:44I mean, I literally you know, we do blood test in in Western Medicine because we don't use a
- 15:48lot of, like, Dutch tests, for example.
- 15:50Yeah.
- 15:51I love the Dutch test, but they don't do it because it's not covered by insurance.
- 15:55And, but you can certainly see, like, someone could be on very small amount of cream and then
- 16:01their estradiol level is, like, 2,000, and you're like, what?
- 16:05How is this possible?
- 16:06And you can imagine that the pathways, if you know the Dutch and can picture it, it you can
- 16:10imagine that the pathway for them is different than the person that maybe has a normal 50
- 16:15estradiol by being on a on a cream.
- 16:17Like, they may be converting from testosterone or they may be, specifically shoving it all
- 16:23down that one pathway.
- 16:24You know, like, there's a lot of different ways to do it.
- 16:27Yeah.
- 16:27Yeah.
- 16:28Fascinating.
- 16:29Okay.
- 16:29So then knowing that there is a slightly higher risk of stroke, and, you know, we need to be
- 16:37kinda careful about dosing because it could worsen our migraines, What are the benefits?
- 16:42Oh my gosh.
- 16:43How much time do we have?
- 16:44So the benefits
- 16:46We wanna hear them all.
- 16:48I mean, so, you know, the patients that choose to do hormone replacement therapy even with
- 16:54migraines, they're, you know, they're coming to me saying, I can't sleep.
- 16:59I can't get to sleep.
- 17:00I can't stay asleep.
- 17:02I'm angry.
- 17:03I'm irritable.
- 17:04I hate my coworkers.
- 17:05I hate my husband.
- 17:07I, you know, my vagina's dry.
- 17:10My, you know, everything my skin has changed.
- 17:13I just don't feel like myself.
- 17:15Yeah.
- 17:15I don't feel like myself.
- 17:17This body is not mine.
- 17:18Somebody else's is body.
- 17:20So those patients have often tried to to dial in their nutrition, dial in their lifestyle, do
- 17:26the weights, do the supplements, do the things, maybe tried herbal therapy, and it's not doing
- 17:31it for them.
- 17:32It's not they don't imagine you know, we we now spend thirty years on average in menopause.
- 17:38Right?
- 17:38Yeah.
- 17:39So a third of our life is in this stage.
- 17:42That's a very big chunk.
- 17:43Yeah.
- 17:43Yes.
- 17:44So sometimes I say to patients, how do you want that thirty years to go?
- 17:48And and, you know, this may be completely resonate with people or may not resonate at
- 17:53all, but I sometimes think of this as, like, an epidural in labor.
- 17:56Right?
- 17:56You can have a baby without an epidural.
- 17:59It happens.
- 17:59It will come out.
- 18:00I promise.
- 18:02But do you want to?
- 18:04That's really the choice.
- 18:05Right?
- 18:05Like, in my mind, it's the choice.
- 18:07Like, how do you want that labor to go?
- 18:10How do you want that to go?
- 18:12And for some women, they've decided, you know, I think hormone replacement therapy makes sense
- 18:17for me because I want to live differently than I am, and I've tried these other things.
- 18:22Or maybe they've decided that's the way they wanna go.
- 18:25Yeah.
- 18:25And it's not and it's not for everybody.
- 18:27Some people don't need it.
- 18:29But for the women that do choose it, it's because they find out that they get the relief
- 18:33of being able to sleep.
- 18:35So I I describe to patients a lot of times each of those hormones kinda has a role.
- 18:38So progesterone is the hormone in your body that helps relax your brain to get you to sleep
- 18:42to stay asleep.
- 18:43It works with the GABA receptors in your brain to calm you down, to make you feel less
- 18:48irritable, anxious, annoyed.
- 18:51You have less apathy, like you feel calmer, and it helps in your joints to help less stiffness.
- 18:57You don't feel stiff or achy.
- 18:58You don't pull your neck when you walk out you know, try to get out of bed in the morning when
- 19:02you get into menopause.
- 19:04It calms the heart down so you have less heart palpitations.
- 19:07Those are all the effects of progesterone, and there's more, but those are kind of the big
- 19:11ones.
- 19:13Estrogen is the hot flashes, night sweats, memory.
- 19:16Why did I walk in this room?
- 19:17What's my neighbor's name?
- 19:18What's that kid I went to high school with?
- 19:21Dry skin, dry vagina, skin, urinary, more UTIs, more BB.
- 19:27All of that is estrogen, specifically, like, joint pain and bone pain.
- 19:32It's very much estrogen.
- 19:33Like, the frozen shoulder, the, you know, achiness, all estrogen and libido.
- 19:39Yeah.
- 19:41And then testosterone is focus, energy, building muscle mass, libido.
- 19:48Mhmm.
- 19:49So when there are patients that are coming, they usually come for symptoms and say, you
- 19:52know, I'm having these symptoms.
- 19:54What are the things that we can do to fix?
- 19:55And when we talk about HRT, it's really more symptom driven from where what we decide to
- 20:00give to them in particular.
- 20:02Does that make sense?
- 20:03Absolutely.
- 20:04So does HRT, newer data with bioidentical HRT, does it reduce your risk of heart attack?
- 20:13Yeah.
- 20:14So the there's a lot of new things.
- 20:16So in the way that we have it listed in sort of medicine as we say, okay.
- 20:21Estrogen is for hot flashes, for example.
- 20:23Mhmm.
- 20:23But what we know is that estrogen is vital for heart health, for bone health, for muscle
- 20:29health.
- 20:30Like, we have all these other parameters that we know that estrogen is very, very useful for.
- 20:36In fact, there was, I don't know if you've read, The Menopause Brain by Lisa Monscani, but
- 20:43that book is fantastic.
- 20:45It she's the first person ever to she's a neuroscientist to ever, get a marker.
- 20:51She can literally see on imaging of what where estrogen goes in the brain.
- 20:56Wow.
- 20:56It's super cool.
- 20:58And she was able to then show what her her theory is that we have twice the rate of
- 21:05Alzheimer's because women go through menopause, and that transition kick starts them that
- 21:12direction and inflammation and all the other things are a genetic setup for you.
- 21:17Right?
- 21:17And then now menopause kind of throws you over there into that category.
- 21:21So we have twice the rate of Alzheimer's and her idea was let's show the value of estrogen
- 21:26from a brain perspective of, you know, how does it help keep our brains healthy and prevent
- 21:32disease?
- 21:33And so that's a great book for those of the people who love the idea of what does estrogen
- 21:37do for the brain.
- 21:38And I think in the next five years, we're gonna get indications about why we would use estrogen
- 21:43for other things besides hot flashes.
- 21:46Symptoms.
- 21:47Yeah.
- 21:47Exactly.
- 21:47And I think that brain piece is so important.
- 21:50Obviously, migraine is a brain disease.
- 21:52If you keep your brain cells healthy, things are just gonna go better.
- 21:55You're gonna get fewer.
- 21:56Mhmm.
- 21:57Migraines, you're gonna get less of all the things that go along with migraine, whether
- 22:00that's brain fog or anxiety or depression or insomnia, you know, all of the things, that go
- 22:06along.
- 22:06So what helps people so often is to focus on keeping the brain healthy as a whole, and then,
- 22:12of course, your get your headaches get better as a byproduct.
- 22:15And so, it sounds like we have pretty good imaging data that estrogen is a part of keeping
- 22:20your brain cells healthy.
- 22:23Yeah.
- 22:23And, you know, there's a lot of other, studies in other countries about testosterone and its
- 22:29value in bone and muscle.
- 22:31Right?
- 22:31We lose muscle and bone as we age and the value of how testosterone can actually be, you know,
- 22:37and heart can be like a wellness for those sorts of things as we age.
- 22:43I think a lot more of that will come up too as people are putting more focus on menopause in
- 22:49general and what happens to people as they age.
- 22:52Interesting.
- 22:53Now I I think I is is, bone health related to estrogen as well, or is it really just
- 23:00testosterone?
- 23:01Nope.
- 23:02No.
- 23:02Estrogen helps with collagen.
- 23:04And so when you're talking about collagen for bone and bone turnover, right, bone needs to,
- 23:09like, need to break down the bad stuff and build the good stuff.
- 23:11So estrogen is key in that osteo class, osteoblast activity.
- 23:16So this is why when, you know, people are starting to have osteopenia, we tell them to do
- 23:20weight bearing exercises to put pressure and stress on the bones to turn over.
- 23:25But estrogen, when you're young, kinda like bosses the bone around and kinda like you need
- 23:30to be doing this.
- 23:31You need to have lubrication and fluid in your joints.
- 23:34You need to have collagen.
- 23:35Like, all that stuff is what estrogen does.
- 23:37I actually joke with my patients that I sort of talk talk about estrogen as, like, the bossy
- 23:41aunt in your family.
- 23:42Like Bossy.
- 23:43Everybody has one that, like, is in everybody's business.
- 23:46Right?
- 23:47And they know mine's aunt Lisa, and aunt Lisa knows I talk about her all the time.
- 23:50Like, she's the bossy aunt in my family.
- 23:52Like, she's up in everybody's business, and she knows everything about everybody.
- 23:56And there's an estrogen cell on every single there's an estrogen receptor on every cell in
- 24:01your body.
- 24:01So estrogen to me is like the bossy aunt Lisa.
- 24:04Like, she's involved in everything.
- 24:06So when she goes away, you know, the inmates go rogue.
- 24:10Wow.
- 24:10The inmates go rogue.
- 24:13Wow.
- 24:13Interesting.
- 24:13Do what they wanna do.
- 24:15Yeah.
- 24:15I did not know there was an estrogen receptor on every cell in your body.
- 24:18That's fascinating.
- 24:20Okay.
- 24:20Yeah.
- 24:21I mean, this is actually some of the stuff we're seeing now with women using estrogen on
- 24:24their face for we have estradiol and estriol receptors in our face.
- 24:27So now people are putting their vaginal estrogen on their face to improve their skin,
- 24:31which is awesome.
- 24:32There's some new data.
- 24:34Oh my god.
- 24:34Does that help?
- 24:35It's awesome.
- 24:36I do it really.
- 24:37Yeah.
- 24:39Yeah.
- 24:39That's good.
- 24:40So you can do yeah.
- 24:41You can do, like, a biased cream, and I always put it I mean, like, right now, I look too old
- 24:45because my light the light's bad in here, but you can put it on, underneath your eyes and a
- 24:48long you can put it anywhere on your face, really, but it's great because it does improve
- 24:52collagen, helps turnover, or helps your skin look a little bit more, youthful.
- 24:57So there's a lot of, like, products that are now, being sold by third parties for with
- 25:03estriol and estradiolinum.
- 25:05Oh my gosh.
- 25:06That's fascinating.
- 25:07Okay.
- 25:07That's a super useful tip too.
- 25:08I did not know that.
- 25:10Okay.
- 25:10And you can only take you can take you can take the estradiol vaginal stuff and do it if you
- 25:15want.
- 25:15If you want a old school, kick it old school on cheap.
- 25:17You can use this stuff if you want.
- 25:20That's very easy.
- 25:21Don't have
- 25:21to get another prescription.
- 25:22That's great.
- 25:23Okay.
- 25:24Love it.
- 25:26Okay.
- 25:26And one last thing.
- 25:27This whole issue of estrogen toxicity, they talk about it a lot in functional medicine.
- 25:32I never heard anything about it in regular MD school, but then again, I'm a neurologist, not
- 25:36an OB.
- 25:38Do do people talk about this estrogen toxicity being a big deal?
- 25:42Do you have to try to clear that stuff off?
- 25:45Should you be tested?
- 25:48Is the sixteen hydroxy really the one that's associated with cancer?
- 25:52How do we how do we frame all that?
- 25:55Yeah.
- 25:55So, you know, I think the one thing you have to realize is those are two different languages.
- 26:00Right?
- 26:00Western medicine, we don't use those terms.
- 26:03Terms.
- 26:03We don't look at metabolites of hormones.
- 26:06We don't kinda I don't wanna say don't care, but we don't use it as any for anything
- 26:11clinical.
- 26:12Right.
- 26:13In functional and integrative.
- 26:14And in fact, even in western medicine, we put people on HRT.
- 26:17We don't ever check their blood tests.
- 26:18We don't have we just sort of go, oh, it'll be fine.
- 26:21Yeah.
- 26:21Which I which I fundamentally disagree with anyway because I've many times found people
- 26:25with crazy high levels, and it was just a standard medication.
- 26:28So it's like, well, I think you should probably test for safety.
- 26:31Yeah.
- 26:32But, but, yeah, from then we were talking about functional medicine or integrative medicine.
- 26:38First of all, in OB, that didn't tell you any of that stuff.
- 26:42But in, you know, in functional medicine, what we under what we are about is, like, how do we
- 26:47get the body to heal?
- 26:49How do we use what we know about our body?
- 26:51How do we our uniqueness and our personalization, how do we make that help us
- 26:56with whatever goal we're doing for health?
- 26:58And so the metabolites or figuring out where those hormones go is important, especially if
- 27:04you're not going to use HRT because you wanna figure out what is the step I can do to to to
- 27:09to regulate my hormones better.
- 27:11But even with HRT, I often will do Dutch test.
- 27:14This is really the Dutch test we're talking about.
- 27:16And, because often patients will wanna know, well, what does this do this hormone do to my
- 27:21body?
- 27:22Like, how how does it how do I respond to it?
- 27:25And so, I think it can be very valuable to understand how does this hormone replacement
- 27:30therapy get respond how does it respond to my body, whether or not it's a good or bad
- 27:35pathway.
- 27:35And I do think that some of the, the reasons why this is used a lot even with hormones is
- 27:40because there's some people who are trying to study, like, breast cancer patients.
- 27:45And if we put them on Tamoxifen, are they truly being blocked?
- 27:49Like, is their estrogen actually truly being blocked?
- 27:52So there's some studies that are being done around, which I think is awesome, where they're
- 27:55using the Dutch to try to see maybe those patients are not actually being fully blocked
- 28:01and they're going down the bad pathway.
- 28:03And those are the people with maybe recurrences.
- 28:06Right?
- 28:07Like, they're, you know, they're like, it's going through and it's shooting this direction
- 28:10and not this direction, the green pathway.
- 28:12And so maybe potentially these drugs, while they're not a universal fit for everybody.
- 28:17So I think that's kind of cool stuff where people might in the future use it for
- 28:24understanding what's the right personal treatment for someone with breast cancer and
- 28:28how to see what's happening with their estrogen if they're, like, an ERP or a positive patient
- 28:32kind of thing.
- 28:33So could you maybe, start some HRT, if you know genetically that you are prone to making these
- 28:41toxic metabolites, start your HRT, wait a couple months, grab a Dutch, see where you're
- 28:45at, see what your metabolites are doing, and then maybe make quest decisions about dosing?
- 28:51Like, would that be a reasonable thing?
- 28:53You can.
- 28:54I mean, you can make decisions about dosing.
- 28:55You can also make decision on the type that you're taking.
- 28:58Right?
- 28:59Maybe maybe you're on a patch, and that's not working with your chemistry, and maybe you
- 29:04prefer a cream.
- 29:05I don't know.
- 29:05Like, there's there's ways you can do both the type, but also the dosing.
- 29:09Okay.
- 29:09So, yeah, maybe changing formulation.
- 29:11Okay.
- 29:11Cool.
- 29:12Got it.
- 29:13Or even if you're on say, for example, you're on an estrogen cream and you feel great on it,
- 29:17this is what you wanna do, you can still use the Dutch in some ways to do lifestyle changes,
- 29:22right, and to figure out, well, maybe I need to, you know, do something for liver support or
- 29:29I need more GI support or I you know, whatever it is from a lifestyle standpoint to dial that
- 29:32piece into.
- 29:34Mhmm.
- 29:34Got it.
- 29:35Okay.
- 29:36If you're open to HRT, it's something that you're wanting to do.
- 29:39I do think there's a ton of longevity benefits for using it.
- 29:43For sure, brain, muscle, bone, heart, skin, I mean, prevention.
- 29:49There was a very great study, believe it or not, funded by Medicare, which like never
- 29:53happens, where they literally literally took 65 year old women in Medicaid, like a population,
- 29:58and they just gave them vaginal estrogen and saw how many people did not go into the ER
- 30:00urgent care for UTIs.
- 30:01And saw how many people did not go into the ER urgent care for UTIs.
- 30:04And, ironically, it dropped by sixty percent, but it but it was, like, so drastic that they
- 30:10we should think of it sometimes, especially on, like, a vaginal thing of, like, prevention.
- 30:15I'm in, like, this prevention category because a lot of women get very sick with UTIs or or
- 30:20and and get end up being very, very sick.
- 30:23And so those are things that we might, in the future, see where it's more of a thought of
- 30:27prevention.
- 30:28You know what I mean?
- 30:29Yeah.
- 30:30Fascinating.
- 30:30Wow.
- 30:31That's really interesting data.
- 30:32Is the vaginal estradiol ring a transdermal HRT?
- 30:37Yeah.
- 30:37So that that's a vaginal option.
- 30:40So rings the ring is estring.
- 30:42It's a ninety day ring that you put in the vagina.
- 30:44So we don't really call that transdermal because derm we're thinking of dermis more like
- 30:49our skin.
- 30:49So estrogen cream, like Divigel or Evo Mist or a patch is more like transdermal.
- 30:56And then vaginal can be creams, suppositories, rings.
- 31:02Okay.
- 31:03So that's the local benefits only.
- 31:05You're not gonna get systemic benefits from any kind of a vaginal ring cream, anything.
- 31:10Okay.
- 31:10Got you.
- 31:10Okay.
- 31:11Yeah.
- 31:11In fact, you can actually have a breast cancer patient can take vaginal estrogen because
- 31:16there's no systemic risk.
- 31:17Yeah.
- 31:17And how do
- 31:18you feel about testosterone?
- 31:19It sounds like some of the benefits are energy, muscle building, libido.
- 31:24Anything else?
- 31:26Yeah.
- 31:26I mean, I I love testosterone.
- 31:28I think I I I have a hard time believing that at 25, it's great, but at 55, it's not great.
- 31:33I don't get that how it's natural in our body and it it's something useful.
- 31:37It suddenly becomes not useful just because there's no FDA approved medication for females.
- 31:41I just think that's quite weird.
- 31:43Yeah.
- 31:44When in The UK and Australia, they have a patch for testosterone.
- 31:48They've been trying to get companies have been trying to get testosterone for females since
- 31:52the eighties, but for some reason, there's this block, to getting it approved.
- 31:56So I think that testosterone has a lot more benefits than what we know because we just
- 32:02don't study it because there's no product.
- 32:06But
- 32:06I will tell you that there's actually a company trying to work on testosterone.
- 32:10I don't know why it would be intranasal because I don't know any woman that wants to snort
- 32:13testosterone, but, hey.
- 32:15You do you, buddy.
- 32:16You do me.
- 32:17So whatever.
- 32:19I'm sure it was a man running that company, but, like and so we'll see.
- 32:24But I think testosterone, for what I noticed with women, is that they focus energy in the
- 32:31afternoon.
- 32:32You know, I I I'm 47.
- 32:34I take testosterone, and I described to my husband that I love you, but I really like you
- 32:38now.
- 32:38Like like, you know, he swipes by me, and I'm like, hey.
- 32:43Hey.
- 32:43And before, I was like, I could care less.
- 32:46I'd rather go to sleep.
- 32:47Like Yeah.
- 32:48So, you know, there's sort of I think they're from a libido, what it does for libido
- 32:53specifically is it improves blood flow to the genitalia, which is something that women lose
- 32:58as we age, and then also it improves the brain's response for dopamine that says, oh,
- 33:03this was a rewarding activity.
- 33:04Do you remember?
- 33:05Like, this was actually so it works in the brain and locally to help for women for libido.
- 33:10I I do find, like I said, with, people who have migraines, that they you just have to be a
- 33:16little gentler on finding the option.
- 33:19You can't just sort of hit them at the high dose of HRT.
- 33:21You need to start always at the lowest, and you need to sort of give more time to see how they
- 33:27do.
- 33:27Yeah.
- 33:28And I'm guessing that giving more time helps with somebody who has problems.
- 33:31We've got a question here.
- 33:32I started HRT.
- 33:33It included testosterone, but my headaches increased in your daily.
- 33:36I'm guessing the answer is go a little slower and lower dose.
- 33:40Like you were saying, maybe start with a cream first, not a patch.
- 33:45Yeah.
- 33:46And some of it has to do with the reason what triggers your migraine.
- 33:49So, for example, if I have a patient who gets migraines because they don't sleep, whenever
- 33:52they don't sleep, well, then I'm gonna be focusing on their HRD really on progesterone to
- 33:56get them to sleep.
- 33:58Like, right, what are the migraine I mean, I had migraines for forever, and then I did Botox
- 34:02for migraines, and they went away, and it was amazing.
- 34:05Yeah.
- 34:05But but there are certain usually people have triggers that, that cause them to they they
- 34:11know their triggers.
- 34:12Right?
- 34:12So if it's like sleep, then progesterone.
- 34:15If it's cycle, then I think about estrogen.
- 34:17If it's, you know, whatever the triggers are, you sometimes have to focus first on that and
- 34:22go low and slow on those patients.
- 34:24So I often will, for example, start progesterone first, then I may add estrogen.
- 34:28You know, like, I sort of slowly do add these things so that I know that they're kind of not
- 34:34getting a migraine from that particular drug.
- 34:36Like, I would never start a migraine person, estrogen, progesterone, testosterone all at one
- 34:40time.
- 34:41Got it.
- 34:41Right.
- 34:41Right.
- 34:41Because you have to monitor what have that makes total sense.
- 34:44Yeah.
- 34:45And a question about that.
- 34:48If you are, say, already 70, doesn't make sense to start HRT at that point.
- 34:54So I would tell you from a Western medicine standpoint, they would say no.
- 34:58You should not do it.
- 35:00I will tell you that, have I done it?
- 35:02Yes.
- 35:04What I wanna know, I often will require that patient to get a coronary artery scan, like,
- 35:10what are their blood vessels look like from a cardiovascular standpoint just to understand.
- 35:14Are are we are we doing I mean, honest to be honest, like, some of sometimes some seven year
- 35:19olds are healthier than 20 year olds.
- 35:21That's fair.
- 35:22Fair.
- 35:22I mean, I've had some patients that I'm like, dang.
- 35:25You're healthier than my 25 year old in the, you know, in the in the practice.
- 35:29So I would definitely I always get a coronary artery scan just to make sure that there's no
- 35:33clots I mean, no, blockages in their coronary vessels.
- 35:37I will talk about lifestyle.
- 35:39We'll talk about what is the why now.
- 35:42Like, what are why are you considering it?
- 35:44I would say most of the people that are thinking about it from a standpoint in their
- 35:48seventies is because of the vaginal issues, UTIs, dryness, discomfort.
- 35:54And that local system I mean, local is very different than systemic for risk.
- 35:59So I don't have any problem on a 70 year old who's like, I want the cactus thing to go away.
- 36:04I'm like, let's do it.
- 36:05You know what I mean?
- 36:06Like, I'm I'm gay.
- 36:07Like, because there's very few risks.
- 36:09So, you know and that makes someone's quality of life a lot better.
- 36:12If they have incontinence, it will improve their incontinence.
- 36:15If they have dryness, like, there's a lot of benefits for local estrogen.
- 36:20So I don't have a problem dishing that out.
- 36:24I think when we're talking about systemic, we really wanna understand why did they go through
- 36:27the whole transition and why now.
- 36:30Like, what
- 36:31is the what's going on?
- 36:33And they could probably do progesterone to help with sleep and testosterone to help with libido
- 36:39muscle mass energy, those would be okay.
- 36:42Right?
- 36:42It's just the the the patch estrogen or the systemic estrogen that we would have second
- 36:47thoughts about.
- 36:48Am I understanding you correctly?
- 36:50Well, all of it's systemic if you're putting it on whether or not it's, oral or whatever, but
- 36:55the risk is, yes, are higher with estrogen versus progesterone or testosterone.
- 36:59Okay.
- 37:00But a lot of times, to be honest, those patients really only need a tiny bit.
- 37:04Like, I don't even think about patch.
- 37:06When I think about that, I think about even a tiny bit of cream goes a long way.
- 37:10You know?
- 37:10Because if you haven't had anything, a tiny bit goes a long way.
- 37:13Yeah.
- 37:14Whereas, like, a 45 year old, you can't give them a tiny bit of estrogen.
- 37:18They they are used to being having so much more.
- 37:20Okay.
- 37:21Does that
- 37:21make sense?
- 37:21Yeah.
- 37:22Those That's my personal but, you know, again, that conversation is for sure outside of
- 37:26western medicine because if you were 70, you walk into a standard OBGYN, they're gonna be
- 37:30like, no.
- 37:31Yeah.
- 37:32Yeah.
- 37:33Yeah.
- 37:34Hormone replacement therapy is not meant to bring you back to 25.
- 37:37Like, it's not meant to I mean, I'm I don't wanna burst anybody's bubble, but it's hard to
- 37:42get back to 25, like, even with hormone replacement therapy.
- 37:46So I mean, I'm 47.
- 37:47I mean, you know, I think I would pick, like, 40.
- 37:50I'm a little smarter then.
- 37:51Right?
- 37:51Like, 25, I see.
- 37:52I don't wanna be 25.
- 37:54That was med school.
- 37:55That was way too much work.
- 37:56Right?
- 37:57No.
- 37:57Maybe a little bit more mature.
- 37:59So here's an interesting one.
- 38:00What if somebody has estrogen levels that are already high in menopause having been tested
- 38:06genetically or with a Dutch?
- 38:08Should you skip the estrogen then and maybe just do progesterone and testosterone or take
- 38:12it based on symptoms?
- 38:16Yeah.
- 38:16So so a perimenopausal person is a perfect example of that.
- 38:19They're gonna have because they have the roller coaster on the way down, they're gonna have
- 38:23sometimes it's high, sometimes it's normal, sometimes it's low.
- 38:26And they'll tell you that.
- 38:26They're like, sometimes I feel great, sometimes I feel terrible, Like, I'm up and down.
- 38:31Like, I'm a, you know, I'm a mess.
- 38:33So, I can say that because it's literally me right now.
- 38:36So, you know, like so testing them, this is why Western medicine argues against testing because
- 38:42they say, Well, you could test somebody and three weeks later, it's like completely low and
- 38:46then three weeks later, it's normal.
- 38:47Like, what are you gonna do with that information?
- 38:49So I often don't use estrogen because if you're gonna add estrogen to somebody, you may
- 38:55potentially when they're high, make them even feel worse, Right?
- 38:58So if there's someone who say has still having cycles but having perimenopausal symptoms or
- 39:03even they may if you put them on estrogen, they may start having acne, their breasts are gonna
- 39:08bother them, they get heavier periods, they have all the high estrogen type symptoms.
- 39:12So I I usually go by, symptoms, but I also go by, like, what stage are they in their
- 39:19perimenopause journey.
- 39:20So there's three stages.
- 39:22You know, where are they likely to be?
- 39:24And I often counsel them saying, I don't think that you're ready quite for estrogen.
- 39:28If we are, then we can add it, but just here's the side effects if it's too much for you, if
- 39:32that
- 39:33makes sense.
- 39:33That that makes total sense.
- 39:34Yeah.
- 39:35Yeah.
- 39:35That seems like a really good way to handle that situation.
- 39:38Do I understand that the aura and HRT combo has a small risk for stroke?
- 39:42Yep.
- 39:42It does.
- 39:44Lower dose, estrogen and transdermal and bioidentical are always to reduce that risk.
- 39:51Am I right in saying that?
- 39:53Yeah.
- 39:54So estrogen in general, whether or not it's a birth control pill or estrogen, it's it there
- 39:58is a slightly increased risk for people with aura for, cardiovascular disease.
- 40:05The transdermal is the safer option compared to oral for sure.
- 40:09It's not a contraindication.
- 40:11So if you had aura, we don't say, oh, yeah.
- 40:12No.
- 40:12Never ever estrogen.
- 40:14Understand a little bit more about the neurological impact.
- 40:18Right?
- 40:18Because there are different peep people have different kind of symptoms or risk factors that
- 40:22we're talking about.
- 40:23But, yes, transdermal is definitely is, typically used more often than an oral option
- 40:28in that scenario.
- 40:30What do you think about think compounded, like, estrogen mimics?
- 40:35Soy, yam?
- 40:37Yeah.
- 40:38Do you think those do anything, or do you really just need the prescription stuff to get
- 40:41the job done?
- 40:43No.
- 40:43I mean, there are people who use plant bay well, first of all, bioidentical hormones are
- 40:48compounding or plant based in any way.
- 40:49I mean, a lot of medications are plant based, but they're they're plant based anyway.
- 40:53But if you're talking about, say, ProGest cream, which is made from wild yams, then,
- 40:58like, the kind you get over the counter Yeah.
- 41:02Then, yes.
- 41:04I mean, there I have lots of patients.
- 41:05I have PMDD patients.
- 41:07I have PMS patients.
- 41:08I have menopause patients who use it.
- 41:10It's there's no I'm not against anything, to be honest.
- 41:14There are people who it works great.
- 41:16Right?
- 41:16Like, I have patients who swear, like, it's the best thing ever.
- 41:20So I'm not if it works, great.
- 41:23Do I think that in general, progesterone compound or progesterone in general works
- 41:28better than yam?
- 41:30Yes.
- 41:31But that's just from patients who I see, right, in general.
- 41:34I see their them come back.
- 41:36But there are a lot of patients, especially younger patients, who are using it for cycle
- 41:39support or migraine support in their luteal phase that use ProGest Cream, and it works
- 41:45great for them.
- 41:46I just wanna say thank you so much for being here.
- 41:50We are, just so grateful to you for sharing your time and expertise.
- 41:55I appreciate you so much.