Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Attachment Repair Part 1
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information please visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov work that's www.mit.edu OU P dot org.
- 0:17Welcome everybody. This is I love you keep going.
- 0:20It's February 23rd 2023, 7:35 p.m.
- 0:25Pacific time. And I thought I would talk about
- 0:29attachment or a tonight. We generally think of tatran is
- 0:34these three domains. The attachment system
- 0:38exploration system and the collaborative relationship
- 0:41system because different attachment outcomes are based on
- 0:46different conditioning. You might look at this as a set
- 0:50of skills that secure functioning requires in order
- 0:54for you to be able to function in that way.
- 0:58Mr. This requires a high degree of mentalizing and mentalizing
- 1:03is we talked about that in terms of the phonic abatement approach
- 1:07and early attachment and then views that establish in mid
- 1:11childhood and then the way that you are able to resolve
- 1:16conflicts in relationships, when you get past puberty into your
- 1:20adult life. So these three areas in which
- 1:25attached and conditioning comes online, and then, Specific
- 1:29patterns in relationships. In the development of different
- 1:34attachment strategies that we could also talk about it as an
- 1:37emotional regulation. Development were lack of
- 1:40development that also defines this.
- 1:43So we are all born essentially Auto regulators and then if
- 1:48somebody comes reliably enough, we reorient to external
- 1:52regulation. And if that external regulation
- 1:55is reliable enough, we move into a place of developing
- 1:59collaborative relationships. And then learning the capacity
- 2:04to emotionally regulate ourselves independent of the
- 2:08regulator, which then supports our ability to begin to explore
- 2:13things that are meaningful to us.
- 2:17If that process is interrupted and anyway, along the way, it
- 2:22tends to drop us into different kinds of attachment functioning.
- 2:26So one year in the order regulator stage, if nobody comes
- 2:30to pull you out of that into the external regulation system, you
- 2:36become a dismissing adult. This would be an indicator of
- 2:40neglect, nobody comes to take care of you in a good enough way
- 2:43that you learn to orient toward other people.
- 2:47Well. If the person comes reliably
- 2:51enough to reorient you to an external regulation strategy but
- 2:55not reliably enough that you enter into a collaborative a
- 2:59relationship then you become a preoccupied adult and only if
- 3:05they come good enough that you begin to move into a learn the
- 3:09nature of collaborative relationship systems.
- 3:12You move into the area of secure functioning Without that, of
- 3:18course, there's an effect on the exploration.
- 3:21So we often talk about attachment is this Dynamic
- 3:25relationship to exploration? When the attachment system goes
- 3:29off, you're compelled to come back and seek protection from
- 3:33somebody who can keep you safe, which deactivates the
- 3:36exploration system, once you feel connected and safe,
- 3:41attachment system shuts down in that kicks off.
- 3:46The exploration system so that you can then go out and find out
- 3:49the things that you need to know.
- 3:51The collaborative, relationship is independent of those two
- 3:54things. And that's something that you
- 3:56learn to do or you don't learn to do.
- 4:01In dismissing adults, what you have is a childhood of neglect.
- 4:07So there isn't that support in the attachment relationship.
- 4:12That doesn't mean that the exploration system isn't
- 4:17developed in dismissing people. It is but we tend to talk about
- 4:22that in terms of primary and secondary exploration.
- 4:26In primary exploration, it is the doing of the activities that
- 4:30you derive, meaning from and in secondary exploration.
- 4:34It's really about Gathering the time energy and resources.
- 4:37sources that you could, then use for a primary exploration
- 4:44Dismissing people in childhood. So the child category is anxious
- 4:49avoidant because nobody comes, they need to really defend, they
- 4:55really need to fend for themselves.
- 4:59It is in the day, enter into a collaborative system where they
- 5:02negotiate getting their needs met.
- 5:03Its that their needs are not really considered.
- 5:07And in order to get what they want, they have to go out and
- 5:10take it. So they don't enter into
- 5:11collaborative relationships because the experience of
- 5:15neglect is so painful for children.
- 5:18They really begin to suppress an awareness of the attachment
- 5:22system and suppress awareness of their emotions as a way of
- 5:26coping with that. So in a strongly dismissing
- 5:30adult, they have very little sense of emotion felt in the
- 5:35body, they don't see themselves as collaborative.
- 5:39They see Life as a series of transactions, they know what
- 5:43they need or they think they know what they need, and they're
- 5:47forgetting. It is to gather resources that
- 5:49they can then transact. The kind of care that they want.
- 5:53That's characteristic of Preoccupied adults.
- 5:58The child category for that is anxious ambivalent.
- 6:03Usually are inhibited from exploring one of the reasons
- 6:08that works is because their attachment system is activated.
- 6:12And so it deactivates their exploration system because the
- 6:16this is from the caregivers are unpredictable and unreliable,
- 6:20they become hyper activated in the attachment side, which
- 6:24deactivates the exploration side and they also become focused on
- 6:29the other person and become hyper-vigilant terms of
- 6:34monitoring them so that they can feel a sense of safety and
- 6:38having their needs. But they typically learn not to
- 6:43seek separation from their caregivers because they need
- 6:49that external source of Regulation.
- 6:55Only insecure people do it. Do you have the experience of
- 6:59developing a collaborative relationship and also have the
- 7:02experience of learning how to emotionally, regulate yourself
- 7:05independent of regulator but because it's a collaborative
- 7:09relationship, you're able to come back seek proximity and
- 7:13regulation from somebody when you need it, then when you don't
- 7:16need it here, then free to go and explore it.
- 7:19Because the caregiver is for secure kids are available.
- 7:25To them, they don't worry about whether or not they're going to
- 7:28be able to be regulated because they have access when they need
- 7:31it. But all making sense so far.
- 7:36The one category we haven't talked about is disorganized
- 7:39disorganized in children and adults.
- 7:43Jake, you had a question. Yes, I just wanted to ask the
- 7:49way that you described collaboration there.
- 7:51It almost seems like it's akin to attachment says collaboration
- 7:58like the skill of getting attachment needs met or can you
- 8:04elaborate on what it is a little bit and the collaborative.
- 8:09System. You take care of the other
- 8:13person in the way that they want to be taken care of and they
- 8:16take care of you in the way that you want to be taken care of.
- 8:20And the way that you learn to do, that is by a collaboration,
- 8:23they explain to you how they need to be taken care of and you
- 8:26take on learning how to do that. You explain to them how you need
- 8:30to be taken care of. And they take on being willing
- 8:33to do that in, developing the skill to do it.
- 8:37And then you're able to take on that responsibility and take
- 8:41care of them whether they're able to in all situations
- 8:45reciprocate. This means that if you become
- 8:49sick and are unable to meet your obligations in in that moment in
- 8:54taking care of the other person doesn't mean you lose the care
- 8:57of the other person because their responsibility to take
- 9:00care of you is ongoing. And then when you get better, of
- 9:03course, you return to taking care of them, or if they get
- 9:06Sick of they're unable to take care of themselves for a period
- 9:10of time. Your responsibility to take care
- 9:12of them is still active, you still engage in that.
- 9:16That's the nature of collaboration.
- 9:21Christian. So it sounds like collaboration
- 9:26presupposes. To secure attachments or at
- 9:31least in the context of that particular relationship.
- 9:34Yeah, the willingness to do that.
- 9:37Would mean that you recognize the value of the having that
- 9:42available to you, as well, and because insecure relationships,
- 9:46there's a mutual component to it.
- 9:49The, the expectation is that, that's what would happen.
- 9:52The thing about this is that it's not always equal my
- 9:56grandmother. When I asked her about why we
- 9:59always got the same thing. When we were kids she said that
- 10:03we were trying to be fair so my my I would often get the same.
- 10:07It Is My Two Brothers, identical, right?
- 10:10There would be three of them. We would each have one and my
- 10:13grandmother explain that to me, is they their desire to be fair?
- 10:18To which I responded. So what you're really saying is
- 10:20none of us ever had our needs met because we weren't one size
- 10:25fits. All right, and there was no real
- 10:27consideration of each of us. There was just the same gift for
- 10:31the Three Brothers family system.
- 10:36So in a collaborative system, you would really take into
- 10:40account what might be enjoyable for somebody in terms of the
- 10:43gift-giving and each person is different.
- 10:47So each person's gift might be different.
- 10:49Does it mean they have to be, but that's very different than
- 10:52one size fits all in an attempt to be fair that making sense.
- 10:58Jake. So in the pathway towards
- 11:04attachment repair, does I've heard some people describe that
- 11:09secure functioning is something that is more available than
- 11:14secure attachment and they suggested that maybe people
- 11:18should be working towards secure functioning first and it sounds
- 11:22like the way you're describing. It collaboration is just like
- 11:26the main piece of secure functioning.
- 11:29Does that make sense? Sense.
- 11:30When I just said, I think that it is possible to learn the
- 11:35skill set of secure functioning and then move, begin to move
- 11:39your relationships in the direction of secure functioning
- 11:42and that's actually a great idea.
- 11:43Because then you have more secure functioning relationships
- 11:46to support you. As you do, the deeper work of
- 11:49brooding, the native attachment system, and moving it toward
- 11:52earned security. But it's also true that you
- 11:54don't need to do the Deep work to uproot the native attachment.
- 11:58If you're able to find But who will collaborate with you on
- 12:02developing a secure relationship from the Native attachment
- 12:07strategies that each of you have?
- 12:10So I think that we met a group worked with Stan Tack and in
- 12:14terms of his couples model, which is the model where you
- 12:18move toward secure functioning relationship without doing the
- 12:22work of uprooting. The Native attachment strategy
- 12:25and shifting into secure functioning.
- 12:29The thing though about that is that it works better for people
- 12:33that are on the organized side of attachment rather than
- 12:35disorganized side of Aunt. And so most of the models for
- 12:40that that I'm familiar with really are talking about people
- 12:44who are organized dismissing and preoccupied, people coming
- 12:48together and working out a more secure functioning way of being
- 12:54in that relationship. So that the preoccupied person
- 12:58doesn't burn out and have to depart from the relationship.
- 13:01So what the dismissing person gets out of that is a more
- 13:05together, more regulated, preoccupied partner.
- 13:08And that is able to stay in the relationship over a long period
- 13:11of time and have a basic level of their needs met.
- 13:15But doesn't mean that it's the relationship itself.
- 13:18Shifted to secure function. I notice that stand patents
- 13:26principles for secure relationship seemed a little
- 13:29bit, like transacted, seems like a lawyer's type of agreement,
- 13:35those sort of thing. It's seems.
- 13:38I'm just saying it seems different than what you're
- 13:40doing, as long as there's a mutuality and a collaborative
- 13:45basis. It is different from
- 13:47transactional, the main way that I would understand that is, In a
- 13:53collaborative relationship system.
- 13:55If the person that you're in relationship to, for some reason
- 13:58is incapacitated temporarily your obligation to take care of
- 14:04them. Does not end with that, whereas
- 14:06in a purely transactional relationship, use Supply and I
- 14:10pay. And if you can supply, even
- 14:13though you're in firmed and that's the deal is off.
- 14:16So, the purely transactional relationships, don't operate
- 14:20very well. If one person is able to provide
- 14:22Divide their side of the exchange.
- 14:26Christian. So it sounds like the quote
- 14:31unquote, fake it till you make it model would work as long as
- 14:37if there's a dismissive person in the relationship.
- 14:40They would have to be willing to take care of the other person
- 14:44and be there for whatever bids for intimacy or whatever kind of
- 14:48needs are expressed. And then the preoccupied person
- 14:52would need to be able to express their needs authentically.
- 14:55And if that could be done, then, presumably.
- 14:59That secure that collaborative relationship could become a
- 15:02basis for internalizing that idea of security for the people.
- 15:05But they have to be able to go against their tendency to not
- 15:10want to do those things. But usually when you work with
- 15:13that model, what you do is you approach the dismissing person
- 15:17because they're good at exploring and they can see their
- 15:21self-interest clearly and so that if you could explain to
- 15:24them that it's in their self-interest to take better
- 15:28care of their partner because their partner won't burn out and
- 15:32be in better shape to take care of you and the way that you want
- 15:34to be taken care of, that makes sense.
- 15:38So then they're willing to take care of their partner to the
- 15:42point that their partner is in good shape to take care of them
- 15:44and they can see that as something that they value.
- 15:48So you're when you're talking to a dismissing person in that way,
- 15:51you're always coming from the point of view of what they're
- 15:54going to get out of it, which is the way that they're oriented,
- 15:59and then, with a preoccupied person, you're you're having
- 16:03them Express their authentic needs more often so that they
- 16:07actually we can feel valued and taking care of their
- 16:10relationship and be more willing to participate in the
- 16:13relationship in a way that actually is, it is useful for
- 16:18the dismissing person, but also better for the preoccupied
- 16:21person. So there a moment where the
- 16:24priests wear the dismissive person, Where the taking care of
- 16:31the other person? Is not thought of as like an
- 16:35explicitly transactional thing, where they've internalized it,
- 16:38and that they actually see what I'm saying, where it can be
- 16:41transactional, and you explain to someone that is for your
- 16:43benefit. But at some point, I would think
- 16:46of the secure functioning as having been internalized or it's
- 16:51not such an explicitly transactional thing.
- 16:53I don't think that if you don't intentionally do the Deep work
- 16:57of uprooting, your native attachment strategy, that it
- 16:59changes that much. Okay.
- 17:02What you're really doing is learning a way of being in
- 17:04relationship to somebody else that works for both people.
- 17:08Under the conditions that they normally understand that, what
- 17:11you'll find in those kinds of negotiations is that the
- 17:15dismissing person can see it clearly and be willing to do it
- 17:18much before the preoccupied person is willing to do it
- 17:22because what you are expressing their is that the preoccupied
- 17:25person has to be willing to come forward and express their
- 17:28authentic needs with their mostly operating and pretend
- 17:31mode. And for them to actually see
- 17:34that they have to overcome the resistance to being authentic
- 17:38and to present their actual needs.
- 17:39And then to be willing to receive, it is actually harder
- 17:43for them to do than it is for dismissing person to see the
- 17:46value of taking care of their partner.
- 17:49In a way that their Partners in better shape to take care of
- 17:52them. They get that and they usually
- 17:54get it pretty fast. Oh, yeah, if I give them a
- 17:58little bit of what they want, they're not always hectoring me
- 18:01about it, they're not always intruding on me.
- 18:04I actually get the person who I like being with easier, and it
- 18:07doesn't cost me that much, whereas, with the preoccupied
- 18:11person, because they're so conditioned to be inauthentic to
- 18:16move into direction of authenticity, it's harder.
- 18:20So they actually have a harder time with negotiating.
- 18:23I kind of secure functioning the if you can't explore well,
- 18:33dismissing people, explore well, then it's hard to sometimes.
- 18:36Find out what it is that you actually you need in a
- 18:38relationship that would make it work, better for you.
- 18:43And so there's a still more for preoccupied person to do to be
- 18:47able to come into balance there. Then there is her disposition
- 18:50person to do. so, the topic of tonight was repair So now that
- 19:07you have a sense of this modeling of attachment, how then
- 19:13do you begin to repair it? And if we look at this through
- 19:16the Buddhist frame, you have the capacity to sense the object
- 19:20that can be sensed when there's contact consciousness of the
- 19:23sensory experience arises. It's that evaluated for urgency.
- 19:28I like to say, does it need immediate attention?
- 19:30Does it not matter if we get to it, if it is their time to have
- 19:34a pleasant experience reason? I Talk about this in this way is
- 19:38because the brain processing time has been evaluated and it
- 19:41is pretty good science. The Urgent material, always
- 19:45jumps the head of the queue for processing and requires half the
- 19:49intensity and about 3/8 of a second to jump.
- 19:52The queue to be attended to a pleasant experience.
- 19:57Needs twice the intensity and a half, a second of duration,
- 20:01before it arises as something to be considered in the queue for
- 20:05process. Seing.
- 20:07Once it reaches the head of the queue, it's evaluated against
- 20:12the perceptual database. So the conditioned response or
- 20:15the that record of the history of the things that we experience
- 20:19and how we responded to them is then compared to this unattached
- 20:24and undifferentiated on fixated sensing experience.
- 20:28And if there's a meaning in it in the perceptual database,
- 20:31that's close enough to the sensing moment, the meaning of
- 20:36Patches and it fixates or becomes conceptual reality.
- 20:43So this is very different than the Western idea, but Aristotle
- 20:46really thought that we take in everything that's around us and
- 20:51we create an internal working model, that is basically an
- 20:55accurate reflection of what is outside of us.
- 20:58Epicurious, 300 years later. Suggested, that if you were in a
- 21:02strong emotional state, that could affect the interpretation
- 21:07of the creation of the working model internally, that it was
- 21:10still largely accurate. In the Buddhist sense.
- 21:14Of course, we're taking in data, creating a working model of
- 21:19what's happening and then projecting that outward.
- 21:23So that we live in these interpretations of the
- 21:27environment around us that our mental Creations, mental,
- 21:31formations of what's, actually there, that making sense the
- 21:36difference. So what is an internal model?
- 21:38And one is a projection that we operate in my Periods of this is
- 21:44really very much in the Buddhist idea of this that we create
- 21:49these understandings of what's actually happening.
- 21:52We project them outward and we operate as if that's what's
- 21:56there. We do not take the systematic
- 22:00survey of what's out there and then create an internal working
- 22:04model, we gather data and then we create a world based on that
- 22:09data and we as if that world is what's there, Makes sense.
- 22:14So if your air conditioning is different markedly or not from
- 22:18somebody else, you're creating reality.
- 22:22That's different from the other person's reality and this is,
- 22:25this seems to be a parent in pretty much every interaction
- 22:29with every person in every moment that there's an
- 22:33interaction. This is where I'm coming from.
- 22:36Where are you coming from? This is how it appears to be.
- 22:40How does it appear to you? Since we don't create?
- 22:43Date the same experience, but making sense.
- 22:48So then, when we talk about attachment conditioning, of
- 22:51course you're creating a perception of the world.
- 22:55That's based on your conditioning and because you've
- 22:58had the kind of conditioning that creates these different
- 23:00kinds of mapping, we can begin to recognize the pattern of how
- 23:05the child and the conditions. The child faces tend to sort
- 23:09tends to distort the creation of the experience of reality.
- 23:14If you have good enough mentalizing which secure people
- 23:16tend to do, you can understand that you are creating a version
- 23:21of reality, that's informed by by the experiences you had.
- 23:26And you can recognize that not everybody has that experience.
- 23:32And you can form a response to it and push it out into the
- 23:37world and then track actively hide that reaction to the
- 23:42present moment that you expressed his landing on the
- 23:45person that you expressed it too.
- 23:47And if you know somebody well enough, you can begin to
- 23:49understand their response to that.
- 23:54Meaning that they're assigning to it and then understand their
- 23:58reaction to that their expression to you in response to
- 24:02what you've said to them or Express to them, that making
- 24:06sense that exchange back and forth.
- 24:10You don't mentalize well enough to be able to do that.
- 24:13Then your capacity to understand the differences between people's
- 24:19perceptions, people's conceptual reality, it becomes a, it
- 24:24becomes your reality of which they're responding to in the
- 24:29same way that making sense. So we talked about and can
- 24:32evaluate that on a scale of one to nine.
- 24:36It's an exponential scale. So, Buddy to mentalize has a
- 24:40tattoo. Is it twice?
- 24:41A1, somebody to three is it four times somebody 24 16 times and
- 24:45so on up, so the secure people mentalize in a six to nine
- 24:53range, which is much higher than insecure.
- 24:57People dismissing people in the four to five range of
- 25:00preoccupied. People in the 3 to 4 range.
- 25:02That's organized. And then disorganized people I'm
- 25:07nerve 3. We didn't talk about what forms
- 25:12disorganized people. But what forms disorganization
- 25:16in a child is that the caregiver is the source of fear.
- 25:23So that when their attachment system goes off and it propels
- 25:27them to seek proximity to the caregiver when the caregiver is
- 25:31the source of fear. It throws the system into chaos,
- 25:36you keep your being compelled to seek proximity to the person who
- 25:40is frightening you for the fight, or flight system
- 25:44activates, at the same time as the attachment system and they
- 25:47have they essentially cancel each other out.
- 25:51So the disorganized child is not able to make sense of what to do
- 25:55in the moment that they need to seek proximity to a protector
- 25:59because there are protector is the source of the threat or the
- 26:03fearfulness that makes sense. And because of that, they tend
- 26:07to mentalize at a very low level, they aren't able to track
- 26:12all of the things that are necessary to track to be able to
- 26:15respond in a secure way. So their tendency that is to
- 26:20withdraw from Um, or disconnect from relationship because it
- 26:23hasn't been a source of safety and support.
- 26:31So we talked about the working, the repair, as in a three
- 26:35pillars approach, we need an approach that will add new data
- 26:39entries into the perceptual database, so that the body-mind
- 26:43can grab secure or secure oriented entries the database so
- 26:49that you can create a secure model of the world and not a
- 26:52world, that's associated with the actual conditioning that you
- 26:56had. So we use the ideal parent
- 26:59figure protocol. Tatian for that.
- 27:02Based on the Maha, mudra practices of the Tibetan Bon
- 27:06lineage of Buddhism which is where you visualize ideal parent
- 27:12figures that respond to your needs as a child, and a totally
- 27:16ideal and secure way. So that when you come into the
- 27:20present moment and want to form an understanding of what this
- 27:26moment is, you can grab one of these entries and create Eight a
- 27:32modeling of the present moment that's coming from a secure
- 27:35place which then allows you to create a nuclear response to
- 27:41what's happening and then also to be able to interpret what's
- 27:44happening in the exchange of information and communication
- 27:48with somebody else in a way that's secure.
- 27:53Now, you might be thinking, I'm going to do these Dopey
- 27:56visualizations and that's going to fix this.
- 28:02And it is true in the beginning. These rickety little
- 28:06visualizations that you do create these artificial entries
- 28:12into the database. The imagination is there so that
- 28:16you can fill were created. Understanding of it's not
- 28:21unique, it's funny. We've just had a pandemic with a
- 28:24virus that is this thing, this word that I'm trying to think of
- 28:27it. It's not coming.
- 28:30Now, there it is. We have the imagination.
- 28:35Which is meant to help us create a response to novel situations
- 28:38where there's no entry in the database, right?
- 28:41We every time we have a new experience, it's novel and we
- 28:44don't have a history of responding to it.
- 28:46And so we have to imagine what kind of response will have to
- 28:49it. So part of this process is that
- 28:53using that capacity, that's an eight into The Human Condition,
- 28:57vital part of it to create these new interpretations, these new
- 29:02possibilities of how to respond. The conditions of the present
- 29:06moment. What happens though, overtime is
- 29:10when you use one of these imaginary entries and you create
- 29:15a response to the present moment and you take the action in the
- 29:18present moment, you're creating a real experience.
- 29:21That is then also remembered and said over time the you no longer
- 29:26have to rely on the imagination. That you gained from doing the
- 29:31protocol, you have an actual experience of life that having
- 29:36made secure, Responses to the present moment, creates database
- 29:41of security that making sense, Jake.
- 29:46So you're looking for people that engage with this first have
- 29:51what you just said, there's a secure response to the present
- 29:54moment experience. That's the kind of first sign of
- 29:58attachment repair that that it's set in that you're looking for
- 30:02is some people learn the skills of having a secure response to
- 30:06the present moment of it, okay? And so then after they develop
- 30:10that skill and become more familiar with it than their
- 30:14relational life just emerges, Of that and then becomes actual
- 30:18secure attachment design. So, it starts with the
- 30:25imagination. We have these capacities to
- 30:28imagine, and in childhood, particularly with difficult
- 30:32conditioning. It's possible that we can pinch
- 30:36off or restrict the imagination. And so, part of the process is
- 30:40also repairing those. I like to call them pinches
- 30:44these restrictions in imagination.
- 30:47You open them up again. So you have the capacity to
- 30:49imagine often times in childhood when we can't get the thing.
- 30:53Things that we need. We can't get the things that we
- 30:56want. We restrict our ability to
- 30:58imagine having them because it's too painful to go to want them
- 31:03to not be able to get them over and over again.
- 31:07If the pinch is remain in place, when you become an adult, you
- 31:11don't imagine the things that you really want because you
- 31:14don't think that you can get them.
- 31:16So even if the possibility in your adult life arose, where you
- 31:20could have these things that you've always wanted, you don't
- 31:23imagine that you can have them in so you don't take them.
- 31:27So here what we do is begin to open up the imagination so that
- 31:31we can re-engage in really knowing the things that we find
- 31:36meaningful. And Suing them without that
- 31:40imaginary barrier that says that they're not for us that we can't
- 31:43have. Christian.
- 31:49Georgia. Do you think that it seems
- 31:51pretty clear to me that at some point you have to start doing?
- 31:55You have to start taking secure actions in the real world.
- 31:59You think that if you're doing say the ipf work and you're
- 32:05building up secure your weaving together, secure attachment and
- 32:08then you're still engaging in either insecure relationships or
- 32:12behaviors that you depended on for a long time.
- 32:16And you're traveling that at the same time or.
- 32:19And so you need to really make a clear choice too.
- 32:24Think about what kind of think about the collaborative aspect
- 32:27or think about how your behaviors in real life, reflect
- 32:29that. Or do you think it's some point,
- 32:31even if you are engaged in those behaviors, you will reach a
- 32:35point in your security where it will be in, comprehensible to
- 32:38keep doing that and you'll naturally turn away from those
- 32:41that does my question make sense, it does.
- 32:45So, I really talked about this in terms of the self experience.
- 32:50We all have these self experiences.
- 32:52These it's a kind of organizing of the experience of things
- 32:56consciously and that doesn't change that much.
- 32:59The perception of the self doing these things remains fairly
- 33:05consistent. I find the same way that you can
- 33:08imagine. That you were just like you are
- 33:09now when you were five years old because the self experience
- 33:13doesn't change. What?
- 33:14Even though the experience of being five was completely
- 33:17radically different than it is, It doesn't seem like that and
- 33:22then what you'll notice is there is no conscious decision to make
- 33:27the secure choice. You just make the secure choice
- 33:31and so what you notice is if you keep track of it as you're just
- 33:34responding differently than you used to respond with no
- 33:38conscious processing of, oh I'm going to do it secure now.
- 33:42That doesn't happen. You just do the secure thing.
- 33:45And then if your mentalizing it well enough you go oh that's
- 33:49completely out of character from the way that I used to do it.
- 33:52There's no conscious processing to get that.
- 33:55It's just the unconscious decision processing that enters
- 33:59Consciousness after it's been made and you're insecure and
- 34:03you've chosen securely rather than in the insecure way that
- 34:07you did or the disorganized way that you did before.
- 34:10Which I think is one of the cool things about you seem to
- 34:15yourself to be the same as you've always been and yet you
- 34:19choose entirely differently than you used.
- 34:25Make sense. Jake.
- 34:31Yeah, that really does make sense and I can really see how
- 34:34the stages of change theory really fits into that.
- 34:37Finally, but what about that period between when you first
- 34:43imagine the possibilities and actually take a conscious
- 34:47decision in before you have this automatic secure response, there
- 34:52must be a lot of falling down. There must be like a lot of
- 34:55mistakes. What about that stage?
- 34:57You just conveniently skipped over that way.
- 35:00The reason That your conscious self experience is, there is to
- 35:03let yourself in, on this hope I'm really trying to be
- 35:06authentic. And I realize I've just said
- 35:09something that's completely inauthentic.
- 35:12Then you have to repair as fast as you can.
- 35:17So each time, you notice that automatic flow of expression,
- 35:22did not produce the secure thing.
- 35:25You need to repair it as fast as you can UPS.
- 35:28This is, of course, generating mentalizing, which is the second
- 35:31pillar, you are constantly monitoring and you want to be
- 35:34spontaneous at the same time where you're completely
- 35:38spontaneous or you allow these things to erupt and then Monitor
- 35:42and when you notice that you've engaged in something that is
- 35:45inauthentic you then respond with you, authentic expression.
- 35:52And then the more you do that, of course, the sooner you get
- 35:55there until it is automatic. But what we're really going for
- 36:01here, when you get into the deep change, is that you just
- 36:06spontaneously automatically insecure Expressions rather than
- 36:11having to constantly Monitor and correct that making sense.
- 36:19So we learn to mentalize and we use meditation in our approach,
- 36:23to develop mentalizing. So, this is the bed of a pasta.
- 36:27NE approach that we do. We have a question.
- 36:29What if it never feels safe to be authentic?
- 36:31What is the reason that it wouldn't feel safe?
- 36:38Is it because you're in a relationship with somebody who
- 36:41doesn't feel safe and then you have to pretend or are you never
- 36:46in a place where you feel safe enough to risk it, but this is
- 36:50where you want to scaffold that with the support of people who
- 36:54may also be doing the war to risk it in small things.
- 36:58The move from inauthenticity to authenticity is quite
- 37:02challenging for most people partly depends on how difficult
- 37:08it was to learn to be inauthentic.
- 37:11And how harsh the training was we don't easily come into a
- 37:16place as children of expressing ourselves in authentically.
- 37:20It's a harsh and bitter training that we undergo in order for
- 37:24that to happen and depending on how hard it was, there's a lot
- 37:29of resistance to becoming authentic and you can be so far
- 37:32down the rabbit hole of it authenticity that you don't
- 37:34recognize that you're being inauthentic but let's say you do
- 37:38have that Insight that you do know that you're being
- 37:41inauthentic. If you push in to do.
- 37:46So let's say in Consciousness, arises the authentic response to
- 37:51the situation of the present moment.
- 37:53And if you were to express that, fearfulness of Abandonment
- 37:56arises, And then the in Atlantic thing, arises is the mind that
- 38:01you could express instead of the authentic thing.
- 38:03And if you express that and immediately relieves the
- 38:06abandonment Terror and the delusion in the Buddhist sense
- 38:11of the term is that's actually benefiting the relationship,
- 38:16because you don't feel abandonment here.
- 38:18But a little while later, you're angry, because you haven't been
- 38:21able to express yourself authentically and your authentic
- 38:24need has not been met because you haven't been able to
- 38:27express. Is it?
- 38:28So you're angry at the person. Be coming from a place of
- 38:32deprivation in the relationship, you're not connected, you don't
- 38:36feel safe because you are inauthentic.
- 38:41And you don't know whether if the authentic expression were
- 38:44made the person would stay with you or they wouldn't if you push
- 38:49into the authentic expression. Of course it intensifies.
- 38:53The abandonment are. And if you can hold on to that,
- 38:57Vacation, here's sideswiped by a wave of terrible Sadness.
- 39:03The terrible sadness is this recognition.
- 39:06That actually, you could have been authentic not necessarily
- 39:11in your childhood. You probably got that that your
- 39:14authentic expression in the family system, you grew up in,
- 39:17was it tolerated? But if you've been out of that
- 39:20family system enough, you have some autonomy, you could have
- 39:25been expressing yourself more. Ali and you did it.
- 39:28And so you begin to recognize that actually you've abandoned
- 39:32yourself, which is the origin of the terrible set and that for
- 39:36preoccupied people who tend to do this.
- 39:43And that you could have had the things that you wanted along the
- 39:47way. Had you been willing to ask?
- 39:50That's the terror, the origin of the terrible sadness.
- 39:53So one of the reasons it doesn't feel safe to move into
- 39:57authenticity from inauthenticity is because you're going to have
- 40:01to endure the abandonment Terror and you're going to have to
- 40:03endure the terrible sadness. And so often in our adult lives
- 40:10It isn't that the authenticity is the problem.
- 40:13It's that we can't bear the abandonment Terror and the
- 40:16sadness. And so we stay away from it.
- 40:19So you have to be willing to push into it little by little
- 40:23that you get acclimatize to allowing the abandonment tear
- 40:28and allowing the terrible sadness until you get onto the
- 40:31other side of it and you can make it authentic expression.
- 40:35That no longer activates the abandonment Terror the terrible
- 40:39sadness. I often use the metaphor of mine
- 40:43that old PC game Minesweeper. It's a grid and You Touch under
- 40:49one square and sometimes half the board will open up and you
- 40:52touch on another squared. It's totally surrounded by
- 40:55mines. That would sink your ship.
- 40:59Since you have to go very carefully.
- 41:00So it really is based on your actual conditioning, how easy it
- 41:03is to move out of in authenticity into authenticity,
- 41:07it is however, completely worth doing and once you begin to try
- 41:11to do it and make progress and it is, you see immediately the
- 41:14benefits of it. You don't worry, you're not
- 41:17fearful about being abandoned because you've expressed
- 41:22yourself authentically in the people that you're connected to
- 41:25see you the way that you are and have chosen to stay.
- 41:29Christian. George decides that for people
- 41:35that are real people Pleasers. So I guess really preoccupied
- 41:38sometimes when they set a boundary, they can actually feel
- 41:44really guilty and become really self lacerating but to me that's
- 41:48them being authentic. So how does that?
- 41:51Does that fit into your sort of formulation with the terrible
- 41:53sadness? Because it seems to be a
- 41:54different kind of reaction too. I guess being authentic or maybe
- 42:00I don't know if I question quite make sense, it does.
- 42:04So when the attachment system goes off, It's meant to propel
- 42:09you to seek proximity to somebody who will protect you
- 42:12and value you. And if you have a good enough
- 42:15caregiver, that's what happens. If you have an unreliable,
- 42:20unpredictable caregiver, who could respond in that good way,
- 42:23respond in a bad way, or a dangerous way or not, be
- 42:27findable to respond in any way. When the attachment system goes
- 42:31off. Its fearful, that's the
- 42:33experience. but you sometimes have in combination to that
- 42:39fearfulness a rejecting aspect where the caregiver is not only
- 42:45involved you in their mind States and in their care, but
- 42:49they're very rejecting of your expressions for authentic need
- 42:55and kids who have that experience, tend to have guilt
- 42:59when they attempt to sit set a boundary because they're trying
- 43:02to take care of their authentic deeds and they They've been
- 43:06shamed in a way about being selfish about putting their
- 43:11needs ahead of the needs of the caregiver.
- 43:13And that's the thing that creates the sense of guilt in
- 43:17setting up your boundaries with dismissing people.
- 43:20Of course it's different, the attachment system goes off and
- 43:24because they're profoundly neglected, they have the
- 43:28experience of sadness because there is nobody to connect to.
- 43:32So their attachment system goes off in their face.
- 43:35With nobody, that creates a sense of sadness.
- 43:39But if they are also rejected which can happen to in either
- 43:43case that that experience of rejection rather than being
- 43:47guilt becomes shame. So guilt is about really what
- 43:52you do and shame is the whole your whole being is not value.
- 44:05Make sense. So, with the mentalizing
- 44:10training, what we're doing is using meditation to develop
- 44:15emotional regulation skills, so that you can hold these more
- 44:19intense emotions, and also began Bill to mentalize.
- 44:22So that we use the insights, I'd really to develop the capacity
- 44:26to mentalize so that you can track all of these things
- 44:29happening at the speed that they're happening.
- 44:33And then, the heart practice is really to be able to regulate
- 44:37emotions in the experience of in relationships.
- 44:42One of the things about insecure disorganized people is they
- 44:45don't regulate emotions, very well.
- 44:48So, it's hard for them to operate at an emotional level,
- 44:51that secure adults would expect. It's to dis regulating for them
- 44:56to be in the intensity of emotion that secure functioning
- 45:00relationships except is a matter, of course.
- 45:02Course. So they become excluded from the
- 45:06experience of secure relationships because of And
- 45:11then the third pillar is the psychoeducation around how
- 45:14collaborative relationships function.
- 45:16So we do an education around the Dynamics of secure functioning
- 45:21relationships and what skills you may have and what skills you
- 45:24don't have so that you can learn the skills that you don't have
- 45:28Jake. I was just wondering if you
- 45:31could say something a little bit more about the last sentence.
- 45:34You said that secure functioning relationships take.
- 45:37As a matter of fact, he's kind of intense emotion.
- 45:40All experiences and that basically in people with
- 45:44insecure attachment or disorganized attachment, is that
- 45:47understood this regulating for them?
- 45:49Could you explain that a little bit more what you just said?
- 45:52So, secure, functioning relationships, the relationship
- 45:56is not on the table, that is to say, once you settle into a
- 46:01secure functioning relationship, you never really consider that
- 46:04the relationship is in Jeopardy. If there's a conflict in the
- 46:07relationship so that you can engage in Emotional
- 46:11negotiations, emotional expression.
- 46:15And this can be both positive and negative and because there's
- 46:20a real sense of security in the relationship can hold as a
- 46:24container, these intense experiences because insecure and
- 46:29disorganized people never really settle into that level of
- 46:33security in the relationship. What often happens when the
- 46:38emotional dysregulation of Of that intensity of it experience
- 46:42happens. The immediate solution is to
- 46:45shut down the emotional experience by threatening the
- 46:48relationship. So if you don't do what I'm
- 46:53asking you to do, then I'm out of here.
- 46:57Those kinds of ultimatums are very typical of insecure
- 47:00disorganized relationships, whereas in a secure
- 47:03relationship, the relationship itself is never on the table and
- 47:07you don't make ultimatums to your partner.
- 47:09You're collaborating with each other to get the relationship to
- 47:13work. So they stay open longer than
- 47:15the emotional. Intensity can be greater but the
- 47:18relationship is never threatened in the negotiation never Still,
- 47:23that's really because they even intense emotions aren't so dis
- 47:30regulating that people would want to walk away from the
- 47:33relationship. And also, if it does get too
- 47:36intense their ways of D escalating and tabling that it
- 47:40can be discussed at a later time making sense.
- 47:48It's quite a difference. What it's kind of
- 47:52counterintuitive to from insecure perspective of what
- 47:56insecure minded person. Might think a secure
- 47:59relationship is like, it's not that there's never any conflicts
- 48:02that there's space to negotiate, a win-win solution to the
- 48:06conflict. So that each party is satisfied,
- 48:09whereas in the power dynamics of insecure disorganized
- 48:12relationship often one party is winning in one party is losing
- 48:17and then They because the abandonment are so great.
- 48:21They temporarily accept losing position, but they can't hold it
- 48:24for very long. So the issues keep coming up
- 48:27over and over again in a relationship and it's
- 48:29essentially the disappointment that you can't come to a
- 48:32solution that's acceptable to both people.
- 48:35That topples, the relationship, whereas and insecure functioning
- 48:38relationship, the discussions are ongoing and tell a win-win
- 48:42is the is established and neither party would accept their
- 48:48Feeling that they were in a losing position in a
- 48:51negotiation, because that would be non collaborative.
- 48:56Anyway, I think we can continue talking about this next time,
- 49:00but let's do a little bit of meditation practice.
- 49:07I'm ringing the bell. So any comments or questions
- 49:12about the meditation practice? Christian, Georgia been sick all
- 49:22week and I haven't meditated until today and it occurred to
- 49:26me that I might have actually missed an opportunity that
- 49:29there's actually a lot of sensation that's very particular
- 49:32to being sick. That can be interesting from a
- 49:34meditation perspective. Yeah, sometimes the
- 49:39concentration isn't good when the body is sick and so really
- 49:43the lesson is Kodama tea with no concentration.
- 49:47That's one of the interesting things that you can then be
- 49:52totally scattered and in a body that doesn't feel good and at
- 49:56the same time in Equanimity whereas often before the
- 50:00experiences of equanimity of also been accompanied by these
- 50:04high concentration States in this real Clarity so yeah it can
- 50:08be useful in that way. I was in more like torpor but it
- 50:11was pretty sweet. Good equitably with torpor.
- 50:18That's a good thing. Jake, I found that a really
- 50:24great and effective and Powerful series of meditations.
- 50:28I'm good. Is that, is that kind of a full
- 50:33range of techniques that you use for inside mentalizing training.
- 50:38Its it is also noting, rest States and flow States.
- 50:43So that's just the first part. But that's really a lot of
- 50:48techniques. Like you just fit in like a
- 50:50whole, many bunch of steps to 120 minute practice.
- 50:55And that was the first time that we've meditated doing Insight
- 50:58that I've been able to follow along with all of them and
- 51:01really get a lot of benefit from it.
- 51:04So I just wonder. Would you do you normally when
- 51:07you teach meditation, would you teach all of the steps of your
- 51:10Insight practice over a period of two weeks or something
- 51:14because like in the Mojave Tradition or in the Burmese
- 51:18traditional take at least minimum three weeks, just to
- 51:22learn like pretty much half as many steps as Earth not even as
- 51:26many like a third of as many steps as you just introduced in
- 51:3020 minutes. What I normally do is teach I'll
- 51:34do a session of see hear feel is planes here field and then I'll
- 51:39do an expert exploration and detailed exploration of see
- 51:42space. Detailed exploration of here
- 51:45space detail. Exploration of fuel space.
- 51:50And then go back in to see hear feel.
- 51:52And then do the focus in Focus out, do some training in that
- 51:59and then add on to that the rest States and then do some training
- 52:04in that and then add on to that the flow States.
- 52:09So there's not the training of Insight Meditation that you want
- 52:13people to use to work towards the 16 stages of insight as
- 52:18well. We'll use that same.
- 52:20Series of practices. I'm the this particular vision
- 52:24is meant to develop mentalizing, so that's why I do it in the
- 52:30order that I do. What would you do?
- 52:32Like, how do you decide to transition a series of meditate?
- 52:36When you structure a course of meditation, you oriented towards
- 52:40improved mentalizing, or do you oriented towards the goals of
- 52:44Buddhist Awakening? I have a different progression
- 52:46for the Buddhist Awakening than from the mentalize.
- 52:50ER, So in the first it see hear feel again.
- 52:55And then for the first stage of the 16 stages, the second stage
- 53:00is it's also see her feel but mapping onto paying attention
- 53:04mainly to mind. So the first stage is Nama Rupa
- 53:08and and developing a sensitivity to the sense case.
- 53:11The second stage is conditionality.
- 53:14So you're looking at mind and the conditioning around what you
- 53:18pay attention to. And then the third stage, is the
- 53:22first pass at the three characteristics of the three
- 53:26marks of existence, and the self experience is really where I
- 53:30introduce the focus in Focus out because the focus in cluster is,
- 53:34mainly self oriented. In the focus out, cluster is the
- 53:37world, then we move into impermanence which is the flow
- 53:44States. So, the introduction of flow And
- 53:48then dukkha is the investigation of craving a version
- 53:53unconsciousness or Equanimity. So then they're the focus.
- 53:56There is on Equanimity we're in a body, old age sickness and
- 53:59death. I went to the barber today for
- 54:03the first time in 10 years to get a haircut because I've had a
- 54:06crew cut for 10 years and I decided I was going to go for
- 54:09something else. And Barbara's whipped the mirror
- 54:14past the back of my head. So I can't really see it, but
- 54:17this guy just really held it there.
- 54:19I could see. Oh my God, I'm seeing the back
- 54:22of my head for the first time in 10 years and it's like there's
- 54:26no hair there, funny old age, sickness and death.
- 54:36Imagine seeing that when you're in your 30s, know, I know,
- 54:40because that's what they started.
- 54:42Move with the beer really fast. They show you the front, they
- 54:44show you the sides. Just Zips right by.
- 54:49So hilarious, all these years, I've been rubbing the back of my
- 54:53head thinking that there was hair there.
- 55:02So then after the third Sager to the fourth stage, which is
- 55:05arising and passing, so that's where you're really getting into
- 55:08the just don't go on techniques so that you really begin to pay
- 55:11attention to the gonz of each arising and passing and then
- 55:15that moves you into the focus on Flow, where the first the
- 55:21barriers between the sentence case to dissolve, and then the
- 55:23barriers between inside and outside dissolve, then you're in
- 55:27dissolution. No, the different progression.
- 55:36You have a far more detailed teaching them what they teach
- 55:40and monasteries and Asia. Did you realize that they
- 55:43basically just push you along through the state and through
- 55:45your practice, through the bodily based practice and say,
- 55:47okay, now you're at stage one right now, it's stage two, but
- 55:52they don't really unless you find someone with particular is
- 55:56very rare that people have like all this worked out.
- 55:59So maybe you should be teacher class November I did when I was
- 56:05in Burma, I guess. 2019 looking for a meditation center to bring
- 56:10our group to. I went to the hoop box enter and
- 56:13I met a monk and he had power center and the monk that I was
- 56:19given a monk so that he could practice his English with me
- 56:22because he was being trained to be a translator and he took me
- 56:26all over the monastery. It was quite a lovely day but he
- 56:30had been doing breath counting for five and a half years and
- 56:34they were yet satisfied with the state of Johna that he could get
- 56:38into and that he wasn't being offered any insight practice at
- 56:41all and We had a hearty laugh about the nature of patients in
- 56:46the west where that simply would not fly.
- 56:48All right, we're out of time, thank you for coming, really
- 56:51appreciate your practice, we have some level level one coming
- 56:54up in a couple of weeks. If you're interested in that on
- 56:57Saturday mornings, it's on the website.
- 56:59We have a level-two coming up in April.
- 57:02We've added a meditation in addiction class in May so take a
- 57:06look at that. The retreat, a new tractors
- 57:09still happening. So if you're in Europe and want
- 57:11to come to that, Please do. I offer this teaching freely but
- 57:15I do hope that you'll make a donation.
- 57:16If you can there's a link on the website to do it.
- 57:19Any amount is appreciated and help support me.
- 57:21And also the work of met a group is doing and we make the space
- 57:24available for anybody. If you're not resource, thank
- 57:28you for coming, really appreciate it and we'll see you
- 57:30soon. Thank you George.
- 57:32I