Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Federal EV Fees Incoming?, $50B EV Hangover, Uber Bets Big on Rivian
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Thursday, March 19th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. Kyle Mounts here, back in the seat.
- 0:07Today we're talking about federal EV fees, a $50 billion EV hangover, and Uber betting big. On Rivian. Uber and Rivian. Unlikely- Wow... fellows. Unlikely. [laughs] It's so interesting. Feel good to be home?
- 0:25It feels great to be home. I like, I mean, if you didn't notice, if you watch the show and you don't listen to it, you knew that I was in one of those, like, work- workspace phone booth things. Little cubicle. Yeah.
- 0:37So by the time you get about eight minutes into a podcast, and I'm a little high energy, right?
- 0:43[laughs] You start to get those, like, weird, not sweats, but you feel like you're about to be sweating profusely, and you, you're just wondering how to get to the end of the 15.
- 0:52[laughs] So it's nice to be [laughs] this open office. Not to mention you probably just ran or rode a bike for a while, so your body's already cooling down. Already. Uh, uh, you know. Yeah, it's fine. It's fine.
- 1:01That's the routine. That's the routine. Hey, tomorrow on the show, uh, we're gonna go, go live at 9:15 AM Eastern. We have John Bozzella, president of Alliance for Automotive Innovation.
- 1:11We're gonna talk about the op-ed he had in the Auto News, in Automotive News this week about, uh, what, what he sees as a very clear path for China to bypass US OEMs. We're gonna get his comments on it- [whistles]...
- 1:22on the show tomorrow morning at 9:15, so make sure you don't miss it. Um, also, we have a webinar coming up next week with our friends at MIA. Um, you need to...
- 1:31Look, these are some of the smartest, uh, most fun to be around people, too. Yes. People in the industry. We're gonna talk about and talk through the three roles that AI should be playing in your dealership.
- 1:41So this is the stuff that every dealer can take advantage of right now. You can join the webinar. It's next Wednesday at 2:00 PM.
- 1:49You should go to asotu.com right now so you can just sign up for it so you get the notifications and you remember, or you get the recording if you can't be there.
- 1:57Everyone's asking the same question, "How should I be using AI?" We're gonna answer some of these questions in the webinar. So go to asotu.com, sign up for the webinar, and we'd love to see you there.
- 2:07Answering questions like a boss. That's, that's what we should be doing. Uh, and, uh, I mean, we'd be remiss right now if we didn't mention ASOTU CON. Just go to asotucon.com. Go to ASOTU CON.
- 2:18Tickets are coming in every day. We really, really- Ah... want you to be there. It's just flying right now. Got some fun announcements coming up, too. So many fun announcements.
- 2:23Hey, want to thank our sponsor of the show today, Hey Greenlight. You know in spy movies when there's always someone in the earpiece, like, telling the agent what to say, like, "Turn left. Stop. Duck under the desk.
- 2:33Ask him about the briefcase," that kind of thing. That's basically Wingman from Hey Greenlight.
- 2:38It's a live call teleprompter that helps your team open stronger, handle objections better, and confidently land the appointment. Yeah, your reps close the deal.
- 2:46They just sound a lot smarter when [laughs] they're doing it. [laughs] If you want more consistent performance without hiring more people, check out heygreenlight.com. Such a cool product. Love it.
- 2:56Human in the loop, man. Human in the loop. That's, that... Feel like that's a great band name waiting to happen. Oh, that is- I come up with one every once in a while.
- 3:07I feel like we need to have the Human in the Loop band play at the Year of the Human- All right... ASOTU CON. We're gonna, we're gonna get Ben Hadley on this right now. Ow. No, Ben- Oh.
- 3:15That's the name of Ben Hadley's band. Human in the Loop. Forget it. All right, I'm texting him right after this show. Do it. Done.
- 3:23[laughs] I'm, I'm just gonna, I'm just gonna be the guy that doesn't do anything in the band, you know? That man is about to lose himself in some Suno for the la- next week.
- 3:29[laughs] I'm just telling you, right after that text, it's over. Let's talk about some news.
- 3:33A growing wave of state and EV fee proposals, state and federal EV proposals would charge electric vehicle owners two to three times what the average gas car driver pays in federal fuel tax every year. What?
- 3:46House Transportation Committee Chairman Sam Graves introduced a federal $200 EV fee, more than double the $95 average gas car driver pays in federal fuel taxes each year.
- 3:58The fee is a flat charge with no connection to actual road usage, meaning a grandmother driving 3,000 miles pays the same as a daily commuter logging 25,000 miles.
- 4:0636 states already impose EV fees that result in EV owners paying more than gas drivers, uh, contribute through their taxes. Texas charging $400 up front, plus $200 anyway. Makes sense, the oil coun- the oil state.
- 4:21Uh, Oregon offers a little fairer model, charging EV drivers 2.3 cents per mile proportional to actual road use, similar to how, you know, gas taxes would function. Use the gas when you drive the miles.
- 4:32Critics point out the federal gas tax hasn't increased since 1993, and that a single penny increase would generate roughly twice the revenue of the proposed fee to put $200 on the EV drivers.
- 4:42Nathan this morning was like, "Have we really gone from EV credits to EV fees in, like, five months?" That, that, that was my first- [laughs] Uh, I read this, and I was like, man, what a switch.
- 4:52[laughs] Um, you know, the... I, I can't imagine being the Fed and, and looking at EVs coming in- Not great timing... and going. Yeah, well, and not just that- I will say that...
- 5:02but, you know, we, the, a lot of tax money comes from the f- comes from the gas pump. Yep. Right?
- 5:10Federal, federal and state tax money, and all of a sudden you get out of the gas pump and it's all electricity costs, and where's the, where's that tax revenue gonna come from? Uh, you know. But-
- 5:23I, I- What, what a way, [laughs] what a way to drag down the, uh, drag down the perspective of owning an EV- I know... when you're like, "Eh, what?" You know. OEMs, too.
- 5:31Like, you think about all these automakers claiming billions and billions of dollars of losses because of all the, the shenanigans that they had to go through to kind of keep up with the federal incentives and all of that, and now they're already trying to, like, lick their wounds and figure out the new strategy, and now it's, like, an EV fee for EV drivers.
- 5:50Um, I think the timing couldn't be worse on even talking about this or rolling this out, obviously. Even talking about it.
- 5:54Oil prices, I think at $109 a barrel, 119 this morning, um, and with no end in sight to, to the conflict or the shortage. So, um, this is just some shenaniganery.Shenanigan.
- 6:06[laughs] What a word I should-- I can't believe I got that out. I just, it just happened. [laughs] Yeah. That was a tough one to say. Speaking of EVs. Stop. And a tough thing to say. Segway time.
- 6:15I mean, here's, here's some more things. Here's the thing. Automakers unwinding all of their EV bets c- at a combined cost approaching $50 billion. We just said that.
- 6:23A stark reminder of how aggressively the industry moved and how quickly it shifted beneath them. Ford leading the charge with $20 billion, um, EV-related write-downs through 2027.
- 6:34The F-150 Lightning and a pair of three-row electric crossovers. They gone. I love my F-150 Lightning, by the way. I've said that before. It's such a cool truck.
- 6:41Stellantis preview- previewed £22 billion, uh, pounds euros in charges, the latest single write-down covering canceled vehicle programs, EV supply chain restructuring, and the end of a battery joint venture.
- 6:53GM and Honda round out the list. GM topping $7 billion, um, Honda projecting $1.9 billion. Analysts saying- [laughs]...
- 6:59the write-downs don't single a full, a full retreat, but everybody's retooling for smaller, more affordable EVs, with Ford targeting, they're saying, a $30,000 midsize truck by next year.
- 7:09Uh, GM relaunching the Bolt, we covered that, uh, at around $30,000, which makes- Well, relaunching then removing one year later. We'll see. We'll see. Such an interesting thing. Yeah. They're like, "No, no, no.
- 7:18We're relaunching now, but we're gonna take it away." We'll see what happens.
- 7:21Uh, IC car analyst Karl Brauer puts it, "There has been an overestimate-- uh, overinvestment and certainly obviously too aggressive of a timeline."
- 7:31Well, yeah, and, and we a- we've all talked about this for the last four years with the EV tax credits and how, you know, all of this 2030, uh, uh, goals and, and move to 100% EV were unfounded in consumer behavior.
- 7:46But n- now we're paying the price for it. My question, and our question is, is, are we paying too hefty of a price? Are we retooling too quickly? Uh, because is, is, uh, uh...
- 7:56In my perspective, the market's gonna be ready for these EVs, and we're not gonna be, uh, ready to supply them. Uh, and that's actually more dangerous than what we were going, uh, through before.
- 8:06Uh, especially with, you know, y- y- there's so many reports, even this morning, uh, we had in our, in our daily email, which if you don't get, you can go to asotu.com and find that.
- 8:16But, uh, th- when, when you look at, like, there's gonna be so many used EVs in the market because of coming off lease, they're gonna go into new market areas that maybe people didn't own these vehicles before. Mm-hmm.
- 8:28And so your, your vision for owning an EV is gonna go a lot higher. Uh, I just don't know if we're gonna be able to supply it.
- 8:35I would love to see the under $30,000 ones because they know that's what's gonna have to compete with China. Um, but- I don't know. We were saying yesterday-... $50 billion... let's go Vinfast. I think you got a shot.
- 8:47Take your shot. [laughs] Speaking of taking the shot. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] There's a little partnership action. Big shot by Uber.
- 8:54They are betting $1.25 billion on Rivian to power their next robo taxi push, with plans to deploy up to 50,000 autonomous R2s across 25 cities by 2031. This is the R2, of course. It's been a while.
- 9:08The deal includes an initial $300 million investment and commitments to purchase 10,000 autonomous R2s, with options for 40,000 more starting in 2030.
- 9:18Uh, so, uh, that, that's obviously, like, pushing that out just a bit.
- 9:22Rivian's R2 robotaxis will launch exclusively on Uber's platform starting in San Francisco and Miami in 2028, then expanding across the US, Canada, and Europe.
- 9:32The deal follows Rivian's $5.8 billion Volkswagen software partnership and adds to Uber's growing roster of AV deals with Lucid, Zoox, Stellantis, and Nvidia. Rivian shares jumped roughly 10% on the news- Mm. [laughs]...
- 9:45a welcome boost as the company prepares to launch R2 consumer sales this spring. Uber CEO Dara, long name, uh. [laughs] Dara Khosrowshahi.
- 9:56"That vertical integration, combined with data from their growing consumer vehicle base and experience managing the complexities of commercial fleets, gives us conviction to set these ambitious but achievable targets."
- 10:09I mean, I'll always think the R2 is one of the coolest car names ever just because it reminds me of Star Wars every time I say it. Beep boop, beep boop. But it makes sense that everybody's squatting up, right?
- 10:17You see Tesla- Yeah... is like, "Nope. We're going it alone. We're making the cars. We're developing the software. We're even building the chips, and watch us do this thing that every..."
- 10:25Everyone else, if you're not doing all of those things, the option is you find the partner that you can go to war with- Yeah... which is, uh, which is a great strategy.
- 10:33And Uber and Rivian seem like two brands that are compatible. Um, I like how VW becomes part of the mix through their software partnership.
- 10:40There's als- obviously a lot of learnings that are gonna go there and come back, I think, into the franchise dealer networks and the vehicles that they sell. So I mean, everyone, you know.
- 10:48These things are always like, "Okay, sounds great." Stock goes up. We're not, we're not looking at, you know, we're deploying these things and by 2031, it's 2028 before we see the first ones.
- 10:57The R2 hasn't even been released yet, right? No. Like, you can't even buy one. So- Soon. They, I mean, they're saying late spring, so we'll see. I know.
- 11:03But it's still, it's like everything, it's like you're, you're betting on all these things that are gonna stack up and- So many bets... you know, a lot of money changing hands.
- 11:10It's a great way to move $300 million of investment money, though. Yeah. [laughs] I mean, as Uber, you gotta be looking at Tesla, and you gotta be looking at Waymo and- Oh, for sure...
- 11:17and trying to figure out how to recover some of that lost, uh, lost incentive.
- 11:21So, uh, there's no reason why they shouldn't be trying to pick a partner, and Rivian's the most logical choice, at least on the US side, from a vehicle price and, uh, like volume- Size...
- 11:31that they already have in the market. Yeah. 'Cause you gotta map these cities, and you gotta figure out how to drive within them, so- Mm-hmm... uh, uh, I'm, I'm, I'm looking forward to this race- Yeah...
- 11:39'cause you know me. I'm like, "When's my next autonomous vehicle?" Yeah. [laughs] I still gotta get in one. I still haven't been in one yet. Look, we hope you have an amazing day.
- 11:47We hope you're paying attention to what's going on there, but most importantly, paying attention to the changes you can make and you can control today in the store. Go to asotukan.com.
- 11:55Join the other people who are doing the same. [upbeat music]