Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Policies - Why the Are Important and What You Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:00In these high performing credit unions that I mentioned, you can go
- 0:02through the board packet and you can pretty much figure out what they're
- 0:05trying to do and how they're doing it just from a single board packet.
- 0:09Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:15I hope you enjoy.
- 0:17Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:20Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:23your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:26The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:29Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:31If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:34team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:39and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:41com.
- 0:42So find out more.
- 0:44Hey everyone.
- 0:44I'm Mark Treichel and thanks for joining me today for another
- 0:47episode of with flying colors.
- 0:50Today, I'm joined by a member of my team, Todd Miller, and we're going to discuss
- 0:54the role and elements of good policies.
- 0:58Todd, before we jump into the role and elements of good policies at
- 1:02credit unions, for those of you who may not have heard your past episodes
- 1:05or may not know you yet, could you give a little bit of your background?
- 1:08Sure.
- 1:09I was with NCUA from November of 1987, all the way to June of 2021.
- 1:15When I retired, it was a very enjoyable career.
- 1:19I enjoyed it a lot.
- 1:20Learned a lot.
- 1:21I was at the various roles.
- 1:24I, um, Bill, during my M career, I was examiner.
- 1:27Of course is what I started right out of college.
- 1:29I was a problem case officer.
- 1:30I spent 10 years as a regional capital market specialist.
- 1:33And the last 10 years of my career, I was the director of special
- 1:36actions in the Western region.
- 1:38Dealing with troubled credit unions.
- 1:39Dealing with troubled credit unions, where you got to see some challenges.
- 1:43No doubt.
- 1:43It's, it's interesting.
- 1:44So we had three jobs, the same examiner, problem case officer
- 1:47and director of special actions.
- 1:49Also, I was on the, on the West coast.
- 1:50I guess it was your region, but you know, the regions merged together,
- 1:54And you started, it didn't dawn on me until you just said it, you
- 1:57started a year after me, and you worked exactly one year more than me.
- 2:00So our tenure is, I think you might have one more month on that.
- 2:03I, so anyway, I digress.
- 2:05All right.
- 2:06So policies, what are they?
- 2:08What makes them good?
- 2:09What's their role and what's their element?
- 2:11So we're going to talk about policies.
- 2:13And so what, based on, you know, you just described what your background is.
- 2:17So something in your background, something that you saw.
- 2:20Made you want to discuss this as a topic, Todd, what was that?
- 2:24Well, there's a number of things is why I wanted to discuss this as a topic.
- 2:29If you go back and look at what we do, we help credit unions pass their exams.
- 2:33And of course, a lot of the exam issues are policy related and underlying
- 2:37that is we expect boards to have the general direction and control of their
- 2:42credit union and how do boards carry out their duties, basically they do
- 2:48that through their written policies.
- 2:50And secondarily, they also do it through their business
- 2:53plan and their strategic plan.
- 2:55Those are the two primary ways that boards kind of carry out their duties to
- 3:00have that general direction and control.
- 3:02We talked about, as a director of special actions, I dealt with troubled criteens.
- 3:06Well, I also had 20 some years of dealing with what I would call very
- 3:10high performing credit unions as well.
- 3:13And there's some very consistent characteristics in these high
- 3:16performing credit unions.
- 3:17One, they have very strong corporate cultures and its policies and
- 3:22strategic plans is how they build those corporate cultures and
- 3:26how they convey that to staff.
- 3:28I always thought it was very interesting in the high performing credit unions.
- 3:31You could go way down to Branch managers and tellers sit in the
- 3:35lunchroom, talk to loan officers, every employee in these high performing
- 3:39credit unions was on the same page.
- 3:40They knew what was in the strategic plan.
- 3:43They knew what they were supposed to be doing.
- 3:45They knew why they were supposed to be doing it.
- 3:47They were all very efficient organizations.
- 3:49They all had very strong policies.
- 3:52Across the organization, and it's a characteristic of high
- 3:55performing credit unions.
- 3:56Their staff know what they're supposed to be doing, why they're supposed to be doing
- 4:00it, how they're supposed to be doing it.
- 4:02And that's all conveyed to them through written policies, that strategic plan.
- 4:08That business plan, you know, you, you reminded me of something.
- 4:101 of my employees and Albany used to say that the regional office ran
- 4:14itself and it ran itself because it had good policies, procedures and
- 4:17structure and corporate culture.
- 4:19And you get that when you have that all in place, you can just see
- 4:23how you can be a high performer.
- 4:24So that that's a correlation to a regional office that applies to
- 4:28the credit union world as well.
- 4:30So, well.
- 4:31Go ahead, maybe just another piece to that.
- 4:33Maybe another way to paraphrase that and describe it is it's
- 4:37transparency across the organization.
- 4:40And we're going to digress just a 2nd, because I can, and
- 4:43I have the mic at the moment.
- 4:45But even if you look at my 35 years at their time, when
- 4:49employee morale was better.
- 4:51Higher lower, I mean, it was generally good the entire time, but there was
- 4:54times when it was better and those.
- 4:57Years when it was better than others, it was always years
- 5:00where NCOA was more transparent.
- 5:01The level of transparency from the top to the bottom was better.
- 5:05And I think NCOA over the years is they tried to improve that.
- 5:08You know, they have that national supervision policy manual now, and I
- 5:11think they actually work at being a more transparent organization over time.
- 5:15Yeah, and you know, and transparency goes to expectations when someone
- 5:19when you're transparent and people know what your expectations are.
- 5:22People always desire to achieve expectations.
- 5:24And if you have the structure in place.
- 5:27It allows everybody to excel.
- 5:28So great point.
- 5:29All right.
- 5:29So specific to policies, what exactly are we going to dig into today, Todd?
- 5:34Well, I think we'll break this down into kind of just three pieces.
- 5:38We'll talk about why you should have policies.
- 5:41I'll give you some just general thoughts on policies and how to execute them.
- 5:45And then last and probably the most important piece.
- 5:49We'll talk about common elements to good policy, and I don't care if
- 5:52you're writing a policy that's related to personnel, a lending policy, an
- 5:57ALM policy, a compliance policy.
- 5:59Policies have some common elements, and if you make your policy
- 6:04statements consistent throughout the organization, you'll just end up with.
- 6:08A more transparent and effective organization, and we'll talk about
- 6:12some of those common elements to a good policy statement.
- 6:15Very good.
- 6:16So, Todd, why does the credit union need to have a set of comprehensive policies or
- 6:21set another way even an individual policy that covers a particular specific topic?
- 6:27And what's the purpose?
- 6:29There are many, many reasons for this, and I'm just going to list them.
- 6:32It's not going to be all inclusive.
- 6:34We could probably spend an hour going through just why
- 6:36you should have a good policy.
- 6:38There's always hot, but number 1, they're required by regulation.
- 6:42And if you go through the regulations, you're By regulation, credit unions
- 6:46have to have specific policies.
- 6:48They need a lending policy.
- 6:49They need an interest rate risk policy.
- 6:52They need a liquidity policy.
- 6:54Those are mandated by regulation.
- 6:56If they're into a member business loan, they need a member business loan policy.
- 7:01If they're buying participations, the regulation requires they
- 7:04have a participation policy.
- 7:05So, first off, They're required by regulation.
- 7:09Kind of a corollary to them being required by regulation is good policies
- 7:13ensure compliance with the law.
- 7:15There's a plethora of regulations out there that you have to follow from hiring
- 7:21all the way to non discrimination in your lending, everything in between.
- 7:26Um, but another purpose of policy, just ensure your staff know what those legal
- 7:30requirements are and you comply with law.
- 7:33Policies are a good training tool.
- 7:34You know, when you hire a new employee, how do you get them
- 7:37familiar with the organization and what they're supposed to do and what
- 7:40the organization's expectations are?
- 7:42So policies are a good training tool.
- 7:45One of them you mentioned earlier, when we were talking about NCUA,
- 7:48policies are there to set expectations.
- 7:51You communicate that corporate culture, their values and mission.
- 7:56And that corporate culture is really important.
- 7:59And there's a lot of benefits to a strong corporate culture.
- 8:02Organizations with strong corporate cultures, they tend to be more efficient.
- 8:06They have lower employee turnover.
- 8:08Your employees tend to be happier.
- 8:09They know what expectations are and they meet them.
- 8:11Makes for a more pleasant work environment for all your employees.
- 8:15There's fewer compliance failures and service quality to your members
- 8:20just tends to be much higher when you have good written policies.
- 8:23Second piece of that, or a continuation of that is, they set standards for
- 8:28behavior and conduct and performance for both employees and management.
- 8:32And this is really important, is that people know how they should behave
- 8:36and they should have standards.
- 8:38And this is kind of an important one for management.
- 8:40If you expect your employees to follow policies, you need to make
- 8:43sure as management and executives that you're following themselves.
- 8:46From a board perspective, good policies, keep management accountable.
- 8:51And from a human resource perspective, it helps you defend against lawsuits and
- 8:57it lets employees know where to get help in terms of if they have any questions
- 9:03about employment or about any aspect of their job, policies, let them know
- 9:07where they need to go to get answers.
- 9:09So that's just some general reasons and the purposes for having
- 9:13policy and Good policy statements.
- 9:16There's a lot there to unpack Todd.
- 9:18And as you were going through it.
- 9:20I'm going to highlight 1 of the topics you mentioned, which is it's good to have 1,
- 9:24because they're required by regulations and where the rubber meets the road.
- 9:29You and I were chatting with the.
- 9:30Credit union the other day, and we were having a discussion.
- 9:34The credit union had a draft examination report.
- 9:37They thought that perhaps some things didn't need to be in a document
- 9:41resolution and that perhaps they could be in an examiner finding.
- 9:45And as they brought that up.
- 9:48You know, you pointed out to them that the items that were in the
- 9:51resolution were there because they were violations of regulations.
- 9:56And you didn't think and you thought that that's probably
- 9:58where they should be because they were a violation of regulation.
- 10:02Anything you want to, I'm assuming you agree with that, but anything
- 10:04you want to add to that thought.
- 10:06No, I'm not going to add to it.
- 10:07I agree that place, there was like, I think it was four violations of
- 10:11regulation and policies are so important.
- 10:14You just shouldn't, credit unions shouldn't get themselves into where you
- 10:16have multiple violations of regulations.
- 10:19And if you have good policy statements and good training programs to
- 10:23educate your staff on those policy statements, you're not going to end
- 10:26up with regulations of violation.
- 10:28Very good.
- 10:29So you've touched on some of the reasons or purposes for good policy
- 10:33statements, and you also mentioned that we're going to discuss, discuss
- 10:38common elements of a good policy.
- 10:40Before we dive into that, are there any other general thoughts before
- 10:44we get into specific policy elements that you'd like to chat about?
- 10:47I do.
- 10:48I have a couple things before we get into basically the common
- 10:52elements of a good policy.
- 10:54These are just some things that I've learned over my.
- 10:57Years of experience with N.
- 10:59C.
- 10:59U.
- 11:00A.
- 11:00I didn't read these in a book.
- 11:02They're just my observations.
- 11:03We're not a management consultant.
- 11:05These are just kind of my views.
- 11:07Implementation.
- 11:08It needs to happen from the top down.
- 11:10And I mean, the board needs to be clear in setting expectations.
- 11:15Um, a lot of times they do that with that strategic plan and business plan.
- 11:19They do that in their policy statements as well.
- 11:22Um, you want to have a high performing.
- 11:24Thank you.
- 11:25Organizations, your executives need to set a good example, and
- 11:29they need to abide by policies if they expect staff to do so as well.
- 11:34So, lead from the front, sound policies are implemented from the top down.
- 11:39Policies need to be readily accessible by staff.
- 11:42It's hard to expect your staff to comply with policies if
- 11:45they don't know what they are.
- 11:46So within your organization, have them in your library, make
- 11:49them easily accessible to staff.
- 11:51And if you're a loan officer, your lending policies probably
- 11:54should be in writing in your desk.
- 11:56Have staff meetings, go over them periodically, but they
- 12:00should be easy to find for staff.
- 12:02And so make them accessible, spend some time training on them, communicate
- 12:07them throughout the organizations.
- 12:09Policies need to be kept current.
- 12:11And we find this a lot with our clients and exam work and organizations grow
- 12:17and their policies get outdated.
- 12:19They don't grow with the organization.
- 12:21So if you're going to have a good policy program, You should
- 12:26have review dates put in there.
- 12:28Let's look at these periodically.
- 12:29Let's make sure we keep them current.
- 12:31A new regulation comes out.
- 12:33Read the regulation.
- 12:34Is that consistent with current policies?
- 12:36They need to be kept current on the other side of the coin.
- 12:40While employees should be educated on policy.
- 12:44They should also know that there's consequences for not following policies.
- 12:47Well, expectations are important.
- 12:49Training is important.
- 12:51There does need to be consequences if policies are not followed.
- 12:55You'll have a breakdown in the organization if there isn't
- 12:58consequences for not following policy.
- 13:00Policy exceptions should be documented and reported.
- 13:03A lot of people write policies and you can never write a policy that's
- 13:07going to cover every situation that will come up with a member.
- 13:10So there are going to be times where there's exceptions to serve a member
- 13:15or help out an employee or whatever it may be, but policy exceptions
- 13:19need to be documented and reported.
- 13:20If you get into the situation where You're having more exceptions are
- 13:25a lot of exceptions to policy.
- 13:28It's time for the board and management sit down and say, is that policy appropriate?
- 13:33We're having to go through and create a lot of exceptions to
- 13:36policies to serve our members.
- 13:38Well, maybe our policy needs a little bit of revision.
- 13:40Todd, that last comment, you remind me of a line from a song,
- 13:44which is, it's a one time thing.
- 13:46It just happens a lot.
- 13:48And if it happens too much, like you said, maybe it's time to reevaluate the policy
- 13:54when the exception becomes the norm.
- 13:56Let's tweak that.
- 13:56The other thing I want to say, when you talked about it coming from the top down,
- 14:00it reminded me of, you know, the NCA security system in the central office.
- 14:05This is kind of an abstract reference, but I would occasionally forget my badge.
- 14:09And I would walk into work because I live close to the office.
- 14:12And I remember the first time after I had been executive director and
- 14:15I forgot my badge and I had to let the guard would let me in and I saw
- 14:20in the look of his eye, it was like, well, Mark really needs to have me BS.
- 14:24I need to escort him up the elevator.
- 14:26And before he even hesitated, I said, I know you need to come with me.
- 14:31You know, I wanted to let him know.
- 14:33That I was going to follow the rule and when we got on the elevator and
- 14:37there were other folks in the building and they saw that I had to follow the
- 14:39rules as executive director, you can really set the tone at the top by every
- 14:46action you take in the credit union, whether it's policy or procedure.
- 14:50So I thought of that example, when you started talking about the
- 14:53importance of compliance from the top.
- 14:56So, all right.
- 14:57With that background, let's get into what the key elements that
- 15:01are common to all policies.
- 15:02You mentioned interest rate risk, you mentioned liquidity, you
- 15:06mentioned commercial lending.
- 15:07If you got that, there are key elements that are going to be in every policy.
- 15:12Let's walk through that Todd.
- 15:13I will.
- 15:14And this is the corporate culture thing too.
- 15:16When you sit down and write your policies, you put all these elements
- 15:19in there and it should be consistent how you write your policies.
- 15:22These across the organization, you just see that in high performing
- 15:26credit unions, there's a format to these, but I'll go through what I
- 15:31see is some of the common policy elements that should be in any policy.
- 15:35If I kind of back it up the way I would summarize it is your policy
- 15:39should really describe your risk management process in the organization.
- 15:43So, common policy element, purpose and objectives of the policy.
- 15:47Let's tell.
- 15:48The organization and our staff, why do we have this policy?
- 15:51And what are we trying to accomplish with this policy?
- 15:53Kind of the second common element that I would say that you'll
- 15:57find in good policy statements is they establish accountability.
- 16:02Who's responsible to identify, measure, monitor, control risk
- 16:06with respect to that area.
- 16:08And there will be some internal controls laid out within the policy.
- 16:12And this is part of the accountability.
- 16:15You separate risk taking from reporting.
- 16:18It's just good accountability.
- 16:20You separate the person who's making decisions from who's
- 16:22reporting on the outcomes.
- 16:24It's a good internal control.
- 16:26Another common element to good policies is the board will communicate its
- 16:31risk appetite within those policies.
- 16:33I'll call it a risk appetite statement.
- 16:35Just kind of some examples of things that fall under that whole
- 16:40category of Risk appetite statements.
- 16:43You'll have organizational wide balance sheet limits.
- 16:46Well, X percent of net worth will go into commercial loans.
- 16:50X percent of net worth will go into indirect loans.
- 16:52X percent of net worth will be to grade D borrower, C and D subprime loans.
- 16:58You'll have interest rate risk limits.
- 17:00You'll have liquidity limits.
- 17:01Whatever the policy is dealing with.
- 17:04You'll have some balance sheet wide limits.
- 17:07There should be limits on individual authority within a policy.
- 17:10Individuals at this level are authorized to do X.
- 17:13Individuals at this level are authorized to do Y.
- 17:17If we get to this point, it will take a committee or
- 17:20multiple people to approve that.
- 17:23There should be limits on individual authority.
- 17:25There should be limits on how that authority is delegated downstream.
- 17:29So you can authorize a CFO to purchase investments up to 2 million blocks.
- 17:34Well, you should specify what can he let his subordinates do.
- 17:37That should be laid out, you know, how much can an individual with policy, the
- 17:42authority delegated downstream limits need to be real, not just guidelines.
- 17:48And over my years, lots of credit, they like to put guidelines and policies.
- 17:54You get into higher performing organizations, there's not
- 17:56guidelines and policies.
- 17:58There's hard limits and policies.
- 18:00Guidelines might lead you up to a limit, but limits need to be real.
- 18:05I think you need to be wary of guidelines that create some
- 18:09wishy washy corporate culture.
- 18:10Limits get fuzzy.
- 18:12You can have guidelines, but they need to be backed up with real.
- 18:16Hard limits on the back end.
- 18:18Limits need to be triggered before risk profiles change significantly.
- 18:23You'll see a lot of credit unions, a lot of organizations, they'll have
- 18:26the green, yellow, red thresholds as a way to point out policy.
- 18:31Hey, when we get to that yellow, let's slow down.
- 18:35The other thing is, is.
- 18:37And I see this as a weakness, and it happens in many credits.
- 18:40There will be a regulatory limit, and they will make that their policy limit.
- 18:44When I'll just give you an example, you know, we have a regulatory limit
- 18:48that you can have 20 low income credits can have 20 percent of their
- 18:52deposits from non member, and you'll see people write that in their limit.
- 18:56But they're at zero.
- 18:57There needs to be something trigger when they go from zero for 10
- 19:01years to 5 percent or 10%, it's not an effective policy limit.
- 19:06If it's doesn't create some warnings as you change your risk profile.
- 19:10Another one is investment.
- 19:12I see when I was a capital market specialist, there was a lot of
- 19:16Cardenas wrote investment policies.
- 19:17Their policies authorized everything in the regulation from
- 19:20repurchase transactions to high risk, private label, mortgages.
- 19:25In a lot of cases, cardians have never ever bought those instruments.
- 19:28They will never ever buy those instruments.
- 19:31They don't understand half of those instruments.
- 19:33Things like that should not be in your policy.
- 19:35Your policy should be real.
- 19:37It should reflect the risk appetite and they should identify if your risk
- 19:43profile is changing along the way.
- 19:46So they should be unique.
- 19:47Those risk limits should be unique to each credit union.
- 19:50The next one is probably what I would call maybe one of the most
- 19:55important aspects of a sound policy.
- 19:58And that's a system of reports based on a risk assessment.
- 20:02Reporting, I'll summarize it this way.
- 20:04It needs to demonstrate management's compliance with policy or turn it around.
- 20:09Management needs to demonstrate compliance with policy in
- 20:12all aspects of the reporting.
- 20:13So, if you have a policy limit, there needs to be reports on that.
- 20:17You have early warning indicators within your policy.
- 20:21There needs to be reports on that.
- 20:23Now, reporting doesn't always mean every single thing goes to the board.
- 20:28But within the organization, there needs to be reporting to
- 20:31some level of responsibility.
- 20:34I'll just throw something out.
- 20:35A lot of credit unions are involved in indirect lending.
- 20:39For example, most places track dealer delinquencies.
- 20:42There are necessarily need to tell your board.
- 20:46What the delinquency level is of every indirect dealer, they should know
- 20:50delinquency overall, maybe delinquency for an indirect lending program, but at dealer
- 20:54level, they don't need to know that.
- 20:56But certainly your loan committee and your loan officers or chief lending officer.
- 21:01They should know what that delinquency is at a dealer level.
- 21:04That's a key risk indicator.
- 21:06So that reporting doesn't necessarily need to be the forward level, but
- 21:11there needs to be a system of reports that provide your early warning
- 21:15indicators, a demonstration with our compliant and demonstrate compliance
- 21:19with the credit risk appetite.
- 21:21Whatever that might be, there should be reporting on risk limits.
- 21:25If you have organizational wide risk limits, there should be reporting on that.
- 21:29All those limits that are a percentage of net worth.
- 21:32I would argue those are limits that should be reported all
- 21:35the way to the board level.
- 21:36It's kind of interesting.
- 21:37And this is a little sidetrack, but I've seen several high performing credit unions
- 21:42They have a compliance report, and it's interesting where you see it in the board
- 21:46packet in those high performing credeans.
- 21:48You see it close to the front.
- 21:49It's not on page 300.
- 21:51It's on page 3 or 5 or 7.
- 21:54It's somewhere close to the front in those high performing credeans
- 21:57because they take it seriously.
- 21:59And a lot of times there are strategic plan elements on
- 22:01that type of compliance report.
- 22:03As well, policy exceptions, they need to be reported.
- 22:07We kind of talked about it a little bit earlier on general thoughts.
- 22:11If you get too many exceptions, it's time to review your policy.
- 22:15Another thing with Reporting and compliance with policies.
- 22:19I think it's important for boards, especially that your reporting
- 22:23process shows trends over time.
- 22:26It doesn't show what your limit was this month.
- 22:29It shows where we're at this month.
- 22:31It shows where we were at last month, a quarter ago, a year ago.
- 22:36Whatever the case may be, I think for boards, they have a huge amount of
- 22:41common sense and they might not be experts at any one thing, but I think
- 22:46most board members will, if they look at a trend and they see things changing,
- 22:51it will prompt them to ask a question.
- 22:53And even for management.
- 22:55It's good to know what direction you're moving and how fast you're moving.
- 22:59It's not just where you are, but where have you been and where are you going?
- 23:03You kind of need those headlights down the road.
- 23:05So trend reporting is very, very important in my mind.
- 23:09And I think for board member, it's probably more important than
- 23:13even knowing where we're at today.
- 23:14It's where have we been?
- 23:16Where are we at directionally?
- 23:18Where are we going?
- 23:19I think you need all three of those.
- 23:21Types of reports and monitoring, and that should be written down within your policy.
- 23:28You should define this reporting process very clearly in each
- 23:31of your policy statements.
- 23:33And then last, we talked about the final thing is there should
- 23:37be a systematic review day.
- 23:39Not every policy needs to be reviewed every year.
- 23:42By regulation, there are certain policies that do need to be reviewed
- 23:46every year, but there should be some ownership within the organization and
- 23:49a specific review date for all policy.
- 23:52Even in CUA, we go through all our regulations every three years.
- 23:55In theory, we go through them every three years.
- 23:57Anyway, I don't know why I'm saying we, we're retired.
- 23:59We're not part of any more habit, I guess, but that review date is important.
- 24:04And, you know, I think a lot of When they get findings, you
- 24:10just see it quite frequently.
- 24:11They're going to hard.
- 24:12They're working every day.
- 24:14We're at 500 million.
- 24:15All of a sudden you turn around.
- 24:16Now we're at a billion 5 and policies haven't changed, but
- 24:20we've got all these new programs and different things going on.
- 24:22And it's important as an organization grows that.
- 24:26Those policies grow with them.
- 24:29The examiner say they want it appropriate to your complexity
- 24:32and it just needs to so set up a process to review them periodically.
- 24:37So they grow with you.
- 24:38That's a lot you through at the audience a lot you through at me,
- 24:42Todd, I'm going to highlight a couple of things and then I'm going to have a
- 24:45couple of follow up kind of questions for you before we wrap up here.
- 24:49But.
- 24:49You know, your last, second to last point on trends and a point in time, to
- 24:53me, the word that jumped out is context.
- 24:55I need to have context.
- 24:57I like to see things over time.
- 24:59Is it growing?
- 24:59Is it shrinking your point that just knowing a number today
- 25:03can pretty much be irrelevant.
- 25:05If you don't know what's the goal, what's allowed and where have
- 25:08we been and where are we going?
- 25:11And I think you really said it.
- 25:12Well, that providing that allows.
- 25:15The board members to understand and provides them the opportunity
- 25:19to ask better questions.
- 25:20And that can lead to a dialogue that can lead the credit union to a better place.
- 25:24So that's my take on trends at a point in time, jumping back to limits on individual
- 25:30authority, things that jumped into mind.
- 25:32There is when people violate that limit to authority, there's the
- 25:36potential that you could have bond claim and situations like that under
- 25:39the most Intense of those scenarios.
- 25:42Any thoughts relative to that side of things as it relates to
- 25:46limits on individual authority.
- 25:47Yeah, and I'm going to go back to something else.
- 25:49I said earlier to the tone from the top.
- 25:52If you have 1 employee violating limits in his own authority or her own authority.
- 25:58Other employees are going to see that and you're going to see
- 26:01that behavior occur through with other people in the organization.
- 26:05It's a morale killer when employees see management saying do this
- 26:10and they do something else.
- 26:12It's just not good for morale.
- 26:14A lot of times examiners find this because those employees that are unhappy
- 26:18and disgruntled about that will tell their examiners that this is going on.
- 26:22That happens a lot.
- 26:23But yes, bond claims are never good, and one of the things I mentioned in
- 26:27my general thoughts, there needs to be consequences for not following policies.
- 26:32The system tends to break down if there's not consequences for not
- 26:35following policy, and individual limits are a key part of it.
- 26:39And I'll just say, in dealing with our troubled credit unions and some of the
- 26:44credit unions that NCUA has had to pay out insurance funds to resolve, At the
- 26:50heart of those, it seems too many times there's individuals who just started out
- 26:54with violating their individual policy limits and it became a big problem
- 26:59that cost the insurance fund money.
- 27:01Well said, well said.
- 27:02So, so this is a kind of a two part question before we wrap up.
- 27:06As you were talking about board packages and what's included,
- 27:09what's excluded, I'm pretty sure in your mind you have a feeling of
- 27:14what an optimal board package is.
- 27:17You know, when you and I are talking to different clients or when we're,
- 27:20we're working trying to assist credit unions, oftentimes you'll say to me,
- 27:25I'd love to see the board package.
- 27:26Cause that again, that provides you context to best understand what's
- 27:30happening at the credit union.
- 27:32So along with that, separately, you and I had chatted about, there's
- 27:36probably going to be some future podcasts that come out of this podcast.
- 27:41Any, can you comment on either of those two statements I just made?
- 27:45Yeah, I just have a feeling Mark has shared a list of podcast
- 27:49ideas with a bunch of his staff and clients and other things.
- 27:53And I think you're going to see future podcasts potentially on
- 27:57individual policies, rather than general elements, what should be
- 28:01in an interest rate policy or what should be in a business loan policy.
- 28:04I can see that coming.
- 28:06Board packages are an interesting thing.
- 28:08A couple of times in my career, I'd sit down with groups of my
- 28:11own staff and say, Hey, what should be in a good board package?
- 28:15And board packages are very interesting because there's
- 28:19things the board wants to know.
- 28:22And then there's things they need to know.
- 28:23And you can't necessarily make them read it every month.
- 28:27But I will go back to you.
- 28:29It's important that management and executives give the board all
- 28:34the information they need to know.
- 28:36And maybe they won't read it every month, but maybe they read it every 3
- 28:40or 4 months or something of that nature.
- 28:43I think it would be very easy to spend a half a day sitting down with a
- 28:46board is what's in your board packet.
- 28:49And I think credit union board packets, a lot of times they, well, the examiner
- 28:53says, put this in there and they put it in there and someone else's,
- 28:56this should be in your board packet.
- 28:58They add another sheet in there and pretty soon this board packet is huge
- 29:02and they've never really went back at any given point in time as they've grown
- 29:05and said, what needs to be in there?
- 29:08You know, certainly if the board wants to know something, you
- 29:11need to put it in the rest of it.
- 29:12I would go back.
- 29:13Management needs to demonstrate compliance with policies and give them
- 29:18progress reports on that strategic plan.
- 29:20But board packages, it's a very interesting topic of what should
- 29:25be in there, and it reflects the nature of the credit union.
- 29:28And I'll just throw out an example.
- 29:31One of the problem credit unions I had at one point in my career.
- 29:35They were about 2 or 3 billion were sitting there.
- 29:38Of course, they ended up in special action.
- 29:40So they have negative earnings and all kinds of problems.
- 29:43And I think they had at that time, 42 branches in their cost accounting system.
- 29:4831 of their branches were losing money.
- 29:50And my comment to the CEO is don't you think your board members
- 29:54would maybe like to know that?
- 29:55Most credit unions, you know, they don't necessarily report all that
- 29:59branch profitability to the board.
- 30:01And there's probably not a necessity to, but at a strategic plan, occasionally,
- 30:07it's probably information that you should share with them sometime.
- 30:11It's a pretty significant fact when three fourths of your branches are losing money.
- 30:15And maybe your board members might want to know that.
- 30:17So it gets situational.
- 30:19Like all 42 branches were making money.
- 30:21Well, it probably wasn't something they would have needed
- 30:23to share with their board.
- 30:25So.
- 30:25Board packages are an interesting topic.
- 30:28When I was an RCMS and examiner, though, the first thing I would always do was
- 30:32just, I want to open a board packet.
- 30:34I would share it with every exam member on the team.
- 30:37In these high performing credit unions that I mentioned, you can go
- 30:40through the board packet and you can pretty much figure out what they're
- 30:43trying to do and how they're doing it just from a single board packet.
- 30:46It's very transparent in these high performing organizations, what's
- 30:50going on, and you can figure it out just looking at a board package.
- 30:53That's a good place to wrap.
- 30:54So the example of the branch offices, like you said, if more than half of them are
- 30:58losing money, that seems to fall into the category of the need to know you said,
- 31:02there's the want to know, and there's the need to know they need to know that
- 31:06so that they can take some actions to lead the credit union into the future.
- 31:09So another great episode, Todd, I appreciate you sharing your wisdom
- 31:13with the folks that will be listening.
- 31:15And that's it for today.
- 31:17I want to thank Everybody who listened for their time.
- 31:20I'm Mark Treichel, and I hope you join us again next time for With Flying Colors.
- 31:25Thank you for joining us on this episode of With Flying Colors, subscribe on
- 31:29your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 31:33of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 31:38If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 31:41out our services at marktreichel.
- 31:43com.