Latest / Bloomberg Law / Weekend Law: SCOTUS, Crypto Fight & Musk Ultimatum
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: In the Conservative justices drive to curb federal regulators. They're
- 0:14Speaker 2: considering overturning a forty year old precedent, which would mean
- 0:18Speaker 2: a major legal shift that would crimp agency power over
- 0:22Speaker 2: everything from workplace conditions and drug safety to climate change
- 0:27Speaker 2: and cryptocurrency. Four of the conservative justices have previously signaled
- 0:32Speaker 2: opposition to the Chevron doctrine, which requires judges to defer
- 0:36Speaker 2: to agencies when they offer a reasonable interpretation of an
- 0:40Speaker 2: ambiguous statute. Here's Justice Neil Gorsuch. Does the judge addicate
- 0:45Speaker 2: that responsibility and say automatically whatever the agency says wins?
- 0:51Speaker 2: But the three liberal justices argued against the shift of
- 0:55Speaker 2: power to judges, emphasizing that agencies have expertise that judges
- 1:00Speaker 2: don't have. Here's Justice Elena Kagan.
- 1:03Speaker 3: You know, the best option is to listen carefully and
- 1:07Speaker 3: to defer if it's reasonable and if it's consistent with
- 1:11Speaker 3: everything that we know that Congress has said. To defer
- 1:14Speaker 3: to people who actually know things about these things, but
- 1:17Speaker 3: you know, to people who understand the way particular questions
- 1:21Speaker 3: fit within a broader statutory and regulatory scheme.
- 1:25Speaker 2: The decision may depend on the votes of Chief Justice
- 1:28Speaker 2: John Roberts Injustice Amy Coney Barrett, who voiced concerned about
- 1:32Speaker 2: illegal upheaval if Chevron is reversed, alluding to the more
- 1:36Speaker 2: than fifteen thousand court cases that have cited Chevron.
- 1:40Speaker 1: So maybe nothing happens immediately to those cases. But isn't
- 1:44Speaker 1: the door then opened for litigants to come back and say, well,
- 1:48Speaker 1: stationary source really means X or you know, broadband or
- 1:52Speaker 1: whatever the specific term was in brand X. So isn't
- 1:55Speaker 1: it inviting a flood of litigation? Even if for the
- 1:58Speaker 1: moment those holding states.
- 2:00Speaker 2: In the three and a half hours of oral arguments,
- 2:03Speaker 2: there was very little discussion about the facts of the
- 2:06Speaker 2: two cases where fishermen are challenging a National Marine Fisheries
- 2:10Speaker 2: Service rule that herring fishermen pay for the government monitors
- 2:14Speaker 2: who track their fish intake, a regulation that was suspended
- 2:18Speaker 2: last year. Joining me is constitutional law expert Harold Krant,
- 2:22Speaker 2: a professor at the Chicago Kent College of Law. The
- 2:25Speaker 2: Chevron doctrine, by the way, champion by conservatives when it
- 2:29Speaker 2: was established in a case that cut back on regulations,
- 2:32Speaker 2: but now vilified by them, tell us how it's used
- 2:36Speaker 2: in practice, what the practical application is.
- 2:40Speaker 4: The preprol application of Chevron is enormous. It allows a
- 2:43Speaker 4: structured way for courts to determine whether to uphold agency
- 2:48Speaker 4: interpretations of statutes, whether it's in wool making or in
- 2:51Speaker 4: a case and judication. And so if the statute is
- 2:55Speaker 4: vague a reasonable size for a truck or in the
- 2:59Speaker 4: famous case of run itself but to stationary source, a
- 3:02Speaker 4: court will have to decide whether Congress has been clear.
- 3:06Speaker 4: And if Congress has been clear, that's the end of
- 3:08Speaker 4: the matter, and the court's interpretation will hold. The agency
- 3:12Speaker 4: can appeal to if it disagrees, up to the Supreme Court.
- 3:14Speaker 4: But in many cases the courts are left with doubt.
- 3:17Speaker 4: I mean, what is a reasonable investigation? What is an
- 3:20Speaker 4: adequate measure? And they're not certain how to interpret it,
- 3:24Speaker 4: and so then the court will defer to any kind
- 3:27Speaker 4: of reasonable agency interpretation. That of course gives agencies more power,
- 3:33Speaker 4: and it gives agencies the ability to change their interpretation
- 3:38Speaker 4: of regulations as social or political conditions evolve, and that
- 3:41Speaker 4: has enormous significance both for business and for individuals regulated
- 3:45Speaker 4: by the government.
- 3:47Speaker 2: Many of the conservative justices have expressed opposition to Chevron.
- 3:53Speaker 2: Why are they so opposed to Chevron just.
- 3:56Speaker 4: As I oppose, I think for two different reasons. The
- 3:59Speaker 4: first is, in all other contexts, judges make the final
- 4:02Speaker 4: call as to what Congress meant in passing statutes. So
- 4:06Speaker 4: if there's ambiguity, courts have the final say. That's what
- 4:09Speaker 4: courts do, and courts think that they're better at it,
- 4:12Speaker 4: and that's their special function. So under Chevron, the courts
- 4:16Speaker 4: have to share this special function with agencies who they
- 4:19Speaker 4: view as sort of unelected bureaucrats or politicians. So that's
- 4:23Speaker 4: an affront to judicial respect. I think that's one argument.
- 4:26Speaker 4: The other argument or reason them is that this particular
- 4:29Speaker 4: court is very skeptical of administrative agencies and administrative agencies power.
- 4:34Speaker 4: They love presidential power, they don't like the power of
- 4:37Speaker 4: the bureaucrats beneath him. And there's no question but that
- 4:41Speaker 4: agencies under both Republican and democratic administration have more authority
- 4:46Speaker 4: and more influenced if the Chevron Document is applied accurately.
- 4:50Speaker 2: The liberal justices defended Chevron and the status quo, just
- 4:54Speaker 2: as Elena Kagan gave some practical examples like should courts
- 4:58Speaker 2: defer to an agency these expertise as to whether a
- 5:01Speaker 2: cholesterol lowering products should be classified as a dietary supplement
- 5:06Speaker 2: or a drug. So, I mean those arguments seem to
- 5:10Speaker 2: make sense when you consider you know on the ground
- 5:13Speaker 2: level what agencies are deciding.
- 5:16Speaker 4: In addition to that, there's long been a debate about
- 5:19Speaker 4: what Congress intends. There's been studies that suggest that Congress
- 5:22Speaker 4: is comfortable with Chevron, understand Chevron, and indeed would want
- 5:26Speaker 4: the agency to fill in statutory gaps or clarify statutory
- 5:30Speaker 4: language as opposed to the court. Why because agencies are
- 5:34Speaker 4: seen as Congress's partner in trying to look at safe
- 5:38Speaker 4: drug policy, or try to understand immigration policy, or try
- 5:40Speaker 4: to understand how to regulate the airway. So Congress indeed
- 5:43Speaker 4: would prefer or intend for courts to help them interstitially
- 5:47Speaker 4: by trying to clarify ambiguous language, as opposed to the court,
- 5:51Speaker 4: which doesn't have the same kind of expertise some kind
- 5:54Speaker 4: of flexibility in trying to figure out what statutes mean.
- 5:57Speaker 4: So I view from that perspective, Chevron is and be
- 6:00Speaker 4: consistent with separation of powers. Conservative justices like antonin Scalia
- 6:04Speaker 4: used to applaud it because it reflects Congress's intent that
- 6:09Speaker 4: the two entities, Congress and agencies are really working together
- 6:12Speaker 4: to accomplish a similar mission.
- 6:15Speaker 2: Did it seem like there were four Justices Clarence Thomas,
- 6:19Speaker 2: Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Samuel Alito who were ready
- 6:24Speaker 2: to completely jettison Chevron.
- 6:27Speaker 4: My guess would be that the four justices you mentioned
- 6:29Speaker 4: were clearly opposed to Chevron, but it's not clear whether
- 6:33Speaker 4: there is a majority of justice who want to overturn
- 6:38Speaker 4: Chevron outright, Whereas Justice Barrett and two Justice Roberts were
- 6:43Speaker 4: more on the fence in terms of what kind of
- 6:47Speaker 4: response to the court you take. Should the Court go
- 6:49Speaker 4: all the way and over rule Chevron or should they
- 6:53Speaker 4: just limit Chevron even further than previously limited by the
- 6:57Speaker 4: major question socrament and as was definitely marked upon in
- 7:00Speaker 4: oral argument, And if Chevron's overturned, that would cause a
- 7:04Speaker 4: great deal of instability, because the question would then be,
- 7:07Speaker 4: what about all these cases have been decided in reliance
- 7:10Speaker 4: upon Chevron? Does that mean that they will have to
- 7:13Speaker 4: be reopened to determine whether courts want to rethink? What
- 7:17Speaker 4: is the correct interpretation to give to the statute that
- 7:22Speaker 4: was challenged.
- 7:23Speaker 2: Yeah, I'm Barrett express concerns about the disruptive consequences of
- 7:27Speaker 2: overturning the precedent.
- 7:29Speaker 5: Yeah.
- 7:30Speaker 4: So one of the things that litigators don't remember today
- 7:33Speaker 4: is what life was like before Chevron. And the problem
- 7:36Speaker 4: that arises is when the agency makes an interpretation, it
- 7:40Speaker 4: can be challenged in many different circuits around the country,
- 7:44Speaker 4: and then oftentimes different district court judges will interpret ambiguous
- 7:48Speaker 4: statutory language differently, and so you will have the prospect
- 7:51Speaker 4: again if Chevron's overturned, of having a disarray seven different
- 7:56Speaker 4: or three different interpretations of one statute that are in
- 7:59Speaker 4: force in different circuits, and that makes planning and makes
- 8:02Speaker 4: even stability for businesses very difficult. That's the kind of
- 8:05Speaker 4: a cacophony that was discussed in oral argument, and I
- 8:09Speaker 4: think it's very real. It happened before Chevron, and one
- 8:12Speaker 4: of the advantages with Chevron was trying to get the
- 8:14Speaker 4: uniformity of approach to limit the splits among the circuits
- 8:18Speaker 4: and the delay in trying to get an interpretation approved, and.
- 8:23Speaker 2: Just noting that in these cases both the DC circuit
- 8:27Speaker 2: and the first circuit sided with the federal government affirming
- 8:31Speaker 2: lower court decisions. So this wasn't a case where the
- 8:34Speaker 2: justices had to take it. It was a case where
- 8:36Speaker 2: four of the justices, and I think we probably know
- 8:39Speaker 2: which four took it to change things up right, I think?
- 8:42Speaker 4: So what's intriguing about the case too? This was a
- 8:46Speaker 4: policy that was adopted by the Trump administration and defended
- 8:49Speaker 4: by the Biden administration. You know, would suggests it's a
- 8:52Speaker 4: good vehicle for Chevron because it's not a case that
- 8:56Speaker 4: looks more republican, it looks more democratic. This just looks governmental.
- 9:00Speaker 4: And Justice did have an interesting comment that just like
- 9:04Speaker 4: if we get rid of Chevron, businesses will be advantaged,
- 9:08Speaker 4: but at the same time, so may immigrants, veterans, and
- 9:12Speaker 4: social security claimants because all of those individuals who litigate
- 9:16Speaker 4: against the government have the burden of trying to persuade
- 9:20Speaker 4: the court that the statutory language has been attributed incorrectly
- 9:25Speaker 4: by the agency. But they can do that more readily
- 9:27Speaker 4: if Chevron doesn't exist, because otherwise they have to overcome
- 9:30Speaker 4: the presumption that the agency's interpretation is correct. And if
- 9:34Speaker 4: Chevron were totally overturned, then if these theoretically and it
- 9:39Speaker 4: would be true in some cases that individuals would have
- 9:42Speaker 4: more advantage in litigating against the government, But of course,
- 9:45Speaker 4: at the same time, so wol businesses.
- 9:47Speaker 2: This is one of the most important cases of the term.
- 9:50Speaker 2: Thanks so much. How that's Professor Harold Krent of the
- 9:53Speaker 2: Chicago Kent College of Law coming up next. A judge
- 9:57Speaker 2: grounds the Jet Blue Spirit merger, and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 10:02Speaker 2: The proposed merger of Jet Blue Airways and Spirit Airlines
- 10:06Speaker 2: won't be getting off the ground. A federal judge blocked
- 10:09Speaker 2: the three point eight billion dollar deal, saying it would
- 10:12Speaker 2: hurt competition and travelers who rely on Spirit's low fares.
- 10:17Speaker 2: While the decision means Jet Blue will continue to be
- 10:20Speaker 2: relegated to second tier status behind the industry's big four carriers,
- 10:25Speaker 2: the consequences for Spirit may be dire. Joining me is
- 10:28Speaker 2: Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation analyst Jenniferree, just how big a
- 10:33Speaker 2: win is this for the Biden administration, which has been
- 10:36Speaker 2: aggressive in antitrust enforcement.
- 10:39Speaker 6: Now, I guess I would classify it as a big
- 10:42Speaker 6: win on the M and a challenge front, But in
- 10:44Speaker 6: terms of this specific case, I don't necessarily see it
- 10:48Speaker 6: as surprising or a big win, because this just seemed
- 10:51Speaker 6: like an anti competitive deal from the beginning, and it
- 10:53Speaker 6: seemed like it should have been an easy case for
- 10:56Speaker 6: the Department of Justice to win. So it's not a
- 10:58Speaker 6: great feat in other ways that they succeeded in court,
- 11:01Speaker 6: but just generally, I think in stopping any kind of
- 11:04Speaker 6: consolidation and in kind of furthering the aggressive push to
- 11:08Speaker 6: stop consolidation and to stop a lot of deals. In
- 11:11Speaker 6: that way, it's a big win.
- 11:13Speaker 2: So why did the judge decide against the merger?
- 11:16Speaker 6: You know, I think what this really came down to
- 11:19Speaker 6: is the fact that there are flights that Spirit flies
- 11:22Speaker 6: where Jet Blue doesn't. So it's odd because most deals
- 11:25Speaker 6: will come down to where they compete, but I think
- 11:27Speaker 6: this came down to where they do not compete because
- 11:29Speaker 6: Jet Blue was very clear about plans to take those
- 11:32Speaker 6: Spirit flights, retrofit the planes to the Jet Blue model,
- 11:35Speaker 6: and probably therefore raise the fares and lower capacity because
- 11:39Speaker 6: the seats would be bigger and there would be fewer passengers.
- 11:42Speaker 6: And for those routes, there's no way from an antitrust
- 11:45Speaker 6: perspective that you can fix those higher prices for routes
- 11:48Speaker 6: where they compete. They could sell the route to a
- 11:51Speaker 6: Legiant or two frontier that might continue to compete as
- 11:54Speaker 6: a very low, unbundled fair option. But now what you're
- 11:58Speaker 6: doing is taking Spirit, which is considered an ultra low
- 12:01Speaker 6: cost carrier and offers these very low unbundled fares. You're
- 12:04Speaker 6: taking them out of the market for certain routes altogether.
- 12:07Speaker 6: And there are absolutely consumers that depended on those low
- 12:10Speaker 6: fares for those particular routes and they would be hurt
- 12:13Speaker 6: by this deal. And that's what the judge ultimately decided.
- 12:16Speaker 2: So does this mean then that Jet Blue will continue
- 12:19Speaker 2: to be at a disadvantage to the four biggest airlines
- 12:22Speaker 2: pricing power and bigger fleets with no real path to grow.
- 12:27Speaker 6: You know, I guess it does. And Jet Blue argued, look,
- 12:30Speaker 6: we need to combine with Spirit in order to grow.
- 12:33Speaker 6: That's really the only way nowadays to grow as an airline.
- 12:36Speaker 6: And if we grow, we can compete more vigorously against
- 12:40Speaker 6: the legacy airlines like Delta, United American in Southwest and
- 12:43Speaker 6: that would be a good thing for consumers. That's pro competitive.
- 12:46Speaker 6: And the judge actually agreed with that that this would
- 12:49Speaker 6: help Jet Blue if it could combine with Spirit help
- 12:51Speaker 6: it to grow, increase its map, and better compete with
- 12:55Speaker 6: some of the bigger airlines. But it wasn't enough. It
- 12:57Speaker 6: wasn't enough to overcome the harm to the consumers that
- 12:59Speaker 6: I just talked about. And I think that's why, in
- 13:02Speaker 6: a way, yes, the decision does tend to relegate Jet
- 13:06Speaker 6: Blue to its position sort of as a second tier.
- 13:09Speaker 6: But one of the things that happened here June that
- 13:11Speaker 6: was pretty effective is that what the Department of Justice
- 13:14Speaker 6: argued is that look, in this kind of second tier
- 13:17Speaker 6: place that Jet bluestits now, it's kind of a maverick, right,
- 13:21Speaker 6: it does something called the Jet Blue effect. It really
- 13:24Speaker 6: competes hard against the legacy airlines, and when it enters
- 13:27Speaker 6: a route or the route ST's in, it forces these
- 13:29Speaker 6: airlines to bring down their prices. And what they argued is, look,
- 13:32Speaker 6: if they buy Spirit, they're telling you they'll better compete
- 13:35Speaker 6: against the legacies, but in fact they're really just going
- 13:38Speaker 6: to become just like one of them. They're going to
- 13:40Speaker 6: be bigger, they're going to be in a position that's
- 13:43Speaker 6: more similar to the legacy airlines. They're going to take
- 13:45Speaker 6: on a huge amount of debt, from buying Spirit, and
- 13:48Speaker 6: they're going to need to keep their prices up, So
- 13:50Speaker 6: instead of actually continuing to exert this competitive pressure, they
- 13:54Speaker 6: just become like the legacies and they increase their prices.
- 13:58Speaker 2: The market appeared to like the news for Jet Blue.
- 14:00Speaker 2: Jet Blue stock rows almost five percent after the news.
- 14:05Speaker 2: Is that, you think because the company won't have to
- 14:07Speaker 2: shell out billions of dollars and be saddled with a
- 14:11Speaker 2: discount carrier.
- 14:12Speaker 6: I think so. I mean, first, it was a very
- 14:14Speaker 6: large amount of debt they would have taken on to
- 14:16Speaker 6: finish this acquisition. That's the first thing. Their debt debt
- 14:20Speaker 6: ratio would have been much worse than it's been in
- 14:22Speaker 6: the past. And they themselves aren't really doing all that
- 14:25Speaker 6: well right now. You know, all the airlines are struggling
- 14:27Speaker 6: a little bit with air traffic controller shortages and airline shortages,
- 14:31Speaker 6: and there's some engine problems for some planes, and you know,
- 14:33Speaker 6: everybody's recovering after COVID. And then at the same time,
- 14:37Speaker 6: what they're paying for Spirit now seems like an overpayment
- 14:40Speaker 6: given what Spirit is worth today. So I think many
- 14:42Speaker 6: analysts actually saw getting out of this deal is a
- 14:45Speaker 6: good thing for Jet Blue, for Spirit.
- 14:48Speaker 2: Not so much. It shares we're cut in half Tuesday
- 14:51Speaker 2: and their worst loss ever. And if Spirit doesn't survive,
- 14:56Speaker 2: doesn't that mean the judges analysis was wrong or at
- 14:59Speaker 2: least was not press the end.
- 15:01Speaker 6: Well, I think what happened here is that Spirits lawyers
- 15:04Speaker 6: could have made a more full throated flailing firm or
- 15:07Speaker 6: failing firm defense. Within the guidelines that the agencies used
- 15:11Speaker 6: to assess the deal, there is a defense to an
- 15:13Speaker 6: otherwise anti competitive deal called a failing firm defense or
- 15:16Speaker 6: a flailing firm defense, And it was sort of suggested
- 15:19Speaker 6: in trial that Spirit's not doing well. They're struggling financially,
- 15:23Speaker 6: they don't expect to make money next year, they don't
- 15:26Speaker 6: know when they'll be in a better financial position going forward,
- 15:29Speaker 6: and some of the issues they're having were outlined, and
- 15:31Speaker 6: the judge said, look, you know, they didn't really meet
- 15:34Speaker 6: the elements they need to meet. Legal cases have set
- 15:36Speaker 6: out the precedent, set out what has to be proven
- 15:39Speaker 6: in order to establish that defense, and the companies just
- 15:42Speaker 6: didn't do it. They didn't meet that defense, and that's
- 15:44Speaker 6: why the judge rejected it. And I sat through most
- 15:47Speaker 6: of the trial, and I tend to agree. I don't
- 15:49Speaker 6: think that they provided the evidence they needed to provide
- 15:52Speaker 6: that would have allowed the judge to say, Okay, I'll
- 15:55Speaker 6: let an otherwise anti competitive deal go forwards because of
- 15:58Speaker 6: the fact that Spirit might actually wonder if we don't
- 16:01Speaker 6: allow the deal to close.
- 16:02Speaker 2: In a joint statement, Jet Blue and Spirit said they're
- 16:05Speaker 2: evaluating their next steps as part of the legal process.
- 16:10Speaker 2: So that means will they appeal or won't they appeal exactly?
- 16:14Speaker 2: And what do you think about their chances on appeal?
- 16:16Speaker 6: You know, I think their chances aren't great, and it's
- 16:19Speaker 6: because this was really a question of interpreting the evidence,
- 16:23Speaker 6: the testimony by the experts and the documents, and ultimately
- 16:28Speaker 6: deciding which arguments were stronger and more valid than others.
- 16:31Speaker 6: And that kind of a decision is given deference by
- 16:34Speaker 6: an appellate panel because it needs to be shown that
- 16:37Speaker 6: it was clearly erroneous, and that's hard to meet. So
- 16:40Speaker 6: I do think an appeal would probably be an uphill
- 16:42Speaker 6: climb for the airlines. And time is a little bit
- 16:45Speaker 6: tight too, because it could take five to six months,
- 16:48Speaker 6: let's say, from notice of appeal to decision, and they
- 16:50Speaker 6: do have a merger end date of July twenty fourth,
- 16:53Speaker 6: so the timing's a little tight there too.
- 16:55Speaker 2: Could this ruling spell trouble for Jet Blue's rival, well
- 17:00Speaker 2: Alaska Airlines and its acquisition of Hawaiian You know, I.
- 17:04Speaker 6: May be in the minority here, but I don't actually
- 17:07Speaker 6: think it makes any difference, And I'll tell you why,
- 17:10Speaker 6: because I always thought that that deal would probably get
- 17:13Speaker 6: challenged by the DOJ. They just simply think that the
- 17:16Speaker 6: airline industry is already too consolidated, and if they go
- 17:20Speaker 6: in with that position, they may be more interested in
- 17:23Speaker 6: trying to challenge this deal in court than allowing it
- 17:26Speaker 6: to go through. So I've always thought that there was
- 17:28Speaker 6: a chance of that. I think that that deal's much
- 17:31Speaker 6: easier to fix than this deal is, because really that's
- 17:34Speaker 6: just a straightforward combination of two competitors that overlap for
- 17:39Speaker 6: I understand, a pretty small number of routes overall, and
- 17:43Speaker 6: then they can divest those routes to other carriers, which
- 17:45Speaker 6: is generally the way stairline mergers have been remediated in
- 17:49Speaker 6: the past. And I think that if they can divest
- 17:51Speaker 6: a sufficient number of routes to the right buyers, it
- 17:55Speaker 6: seems to me they have a very good chance of
- 17:57Speaker 6: winning in court with jeb Blue and Spirit. You had
- 17:59Speaker 6: this whole other problem of these routes where they didn't compete,
- 18:03Speaker 6: where it was only Spirit flying the route, but it
- 18:05Speaker 6: was now going to become Jet Blue and the prices
- 18:07Speaker 6: we're going to go up. So they had a different
- 18:09Speaker 6: problem then will exist with the Hawaiian Alaska combination.
- 18:13Speaker 2: This is the second time in less than a year
- 18:16Speaker 2: that Jet Blue has lost a federal anti trust challenge?
- 18:20Speaker 2: Is it time to just give up?
- 18:22Speaker 6: I would have said it was time to give up
- 18:24Speaker 6: before they end said the merger agreement with Spirit. I
- 18:27Speaker 6: don't think it's really any big surprise that that deal
- 18:30Speaker 6: was challenged and that the DOJ won it in court.
- 18:33Speaker 6: And I still wonder sometimes whether the whole reason for
- 18:37Speaker 6: entering that agreement was just to stop Frontier and Spirit
- 18:40Speaker 6: from merging. That's the very skeptical side of me.
- 18:42Speaker 2: I guess lawyers are supposed to be skeptical.
- 18:45Speaker 6: So exactly I'm supposed to approach this skeptically. You know,
- 18:48Speaker 6: I think it's pretty clear that they'd have a tough
- 18:51Speaker 6: time buying up another airline. You know, at the very
- 18:54Speaker 6: least they would be challenged and have to fight it
- 18:56Speaker 6: in court and try to win in.
- 18:58Speaker 2: Court something they haven't been very good so far. Thanks
- 19:01Speaker 2: so much, Jen. That's Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation analyst Jenniferree
- 19:06Speaker 2: Coming up next. Coinbase and the SEC face off in court.
- 19:10Speaker 2: I'm June Grosse. When you're listening to Bloomberg, Wrick, I.
- 19:13Speaker 7: Got Pink, then I got Peggy.
- 19:15Speaker 1: I got pep and Pad in the same week, Board
- 19:18Speaker 1: Vanessa catched something ten beanie baby.
- 19:21Speaker 7: Now what McDonald's.
- 19:22Speaker 5: Your kids can get teeny beanie babies in a happy meal.
- 19:25Speaker 2: Remember the beanie baby craze, the stuffed animals that became
- 19:29Speaker 2: a sensation in the early nineties and then became collectibles. Well, surprisingly,
- 19:35Speaker 2: beanie babies were part of the oral arguments in a
- 19:38Speaker 2: federal case that's key to the SEC's goal of regulating
- 19:42Speaker 2: the crypto market. Coinbase, the largest US crypto exchange, is
- 19:46Speaker 2: trying to get a judge to throw out the SEC's
- 19:49Speaker 2: lawsuit accusing it of selling unregistered securities, and its lawyer
- 19:54Speaker 2: said buying cryptocurrency on exchange is more like collecting beanie baby.
- 20:00Speaker 2: He's then investing in stocks or bonds. Joining me is
- 20:03Speaker 2: securities law expert Robert him a partner at Tartar Krinsky
- 20:07Speaker 2: and Drogan Bob. What's at stake in this case.
- 20:10Speaker 7: There's a lot of stake in this case, particularly for
- 20:13Speaker 7: Coinbase as well as the broader crypto industry. Here, the
- 20:17Speaker 7: judge has to decide whether the cryptocurrencies that traded on
- 20:20Speaker 7: the coinbase platform are securities under the statutory definition and
- 20:25Speaker 7: the rules that the SEC enforces, or whether they come
- 20:28Speaker 7: outside of that statutory framework. And it's really going to
- 20:31Speaker 7: have a fundamental impact on whether crypto exchanges can operate
- 20:35Speaker 7: in the United States and under what rules and how
- 20:38Speaker 7: much regulation they're going to be subject to.
- 20:40Speaker 2: So is the question whether crypto assets constitute an investment
- 20:45Speaker 2: contract or something else.
- 20:47Speaker 7: Yes, under the statute, which was enacted in nineteen thirty three,
- 20:51Speaker 7: So going back a long time, there's a definition of
- 20:54Speaker 7: securities in one of the categories is called an investment contract,
- 20:59Speaker 7: and that term is designed to be almost to catch
- 21:01Speaker 7: all within the statute because it specifically says stocks and
- 21:05Speaker 7: bonds and then it says investment contracts. So the litigation
- 21:08Speaker 7: that the SEC brought against Coinbase is really designed and
- 21:12Speaker 7: the judge has to decide whether the crypto assets that
- 21:15Speaker 7: were trading on the coin based platform fell within this
- 21:18Speaker 7: category called investment contracts, and Coinbase's entire argument is that
- 21:24Speaker 7: on the secondary market, there really is no contract in
- 21:27Speaker 7: place where purchasers of these digital assets and tokens would
- 21:32Speaker 7: have some contractual right to profits from the blockchain or
- 21:36Speaker 7: the company that the crypto relates to, And the sec
- 21:40Speaker 7: is arguing, well, that's too much of a specific, narrow definition,
- 21:43Speaker 7: and that generally speaking, the court should go off of
- 21:46Speaker 7: what they seemed to be the expectations of the people
- 21:49Speaker 7: buying these tokens and whether or not they have an
- 21:52Speaker 7: expectation of profit, regardless of whether it's in the form
- 21:56Speaker 7: of a written contract or not.
- 21:57Speaker 2: And why did beanie babies come up?
- 22:00Speaker 7: Coinbase made an interesting analogy in court compared the digital
- 22:03Speaker 7: assets and the crypto to beanie babies, you know, the
- 22:06Speaker 7: phenomena in the eighties and nineties, and collectibles is a
- 22:09Speaker 7: broader category, and Coinbase's point is that there's a lot
- 22:13Speaker 7: of different things that people invest in with the expectation
- 22:15Speaker 7: of a profit, including beanie babies, including baseball cards, and
- 22:19Speaker 7: not all of those things are securities. So just because
- 22:22Speaker 7: someone has the expectation that one day their purchase will
- 22:25Speaker 7: be more valuable in the future, does not convert that
- 22:28Speaker 7: over to a security And the SEC seemed to have
- 22:31Speaker 7: a little bit of a problem coming back from that argument,
- 22:33Speaker 7: because the SEC is taking a very broad view of
- 22:36Speaker 7: what constitutes security and what comes under its jurisdiction. And
- 22:40Speaker 7: I think those arguments from coinbase were really resonating with
- 22:43Speaker 7: the trial judge because she was concerned that she doesn't
- 22:46Speaker 7: want to overly broaden the definition of security and include
- 22:50Speaker 7: these things like collectibles and other things that are clearly
- 22:53Speaker 7: intended to be outside the statute.
- 22:55Speaker 2: I was surprised that beanie babies came up in the
- 22:58Speaker 2: oral arguments and the judge really seem to focus on
- 23:02Speaker 2: the idea of collectibles.
- 23:05Speaker 7: Well, it is a good analogy, and this is one
- 23:07Speaker 7: of the centerpieces of Coinbase's argument is that the SEC
- 23:10Speaker 7: is taking an overly expansive view of its own jurisdiction
- 23:14Speaker 7: and over the types of instruments it has regulatory authority
- 23:18Speaker 7: over and under our system, Congress has to pass a
- 23:22Speaker 7: statute and delegate specific powers to the SEC of what
- 23:25Speaker 7: it can and can't regulate, and Coinbas's whole argument is
- 23:29Speaker 7: that these crypto assets are not covered in the statute
- 23:32Speaker 7: and therefore the SEC has no ability to regulate them
- 23:36Speaker 7: until Congress chooses to amend the statute. And so Coinbase
- 23:40Speaker 7: brought up the example of collectibles and beanie babies and
- 23:43Speaker 7: saying that once you go down the slippery slope of
- 23:46Speaker 7: going outside of what really is defined in the statute,
- 23:49Speaker 7: almost anything that people buy, like a collectible, could be
- 23:53Speaker 7: a security. And the judge was particularly concerned about that
- 23:56Speaker 7: because she was concerned about opening the doors to a
- 23:59Speaker 7: lot more litigation and specifically mentioned class actions where these
- 24:04Speaker 7: class action lawyers could seize on a ruling in the
- 24:07Speaker 7: SEC's favor on this point and try to argue almost
- 24:09Speaker 7: anything could be a security and start suing companies that
- 24:12Speaker 7: create and promote collectibles.
- 24:14Speaker 2: So tell me what you think of the SEC argument
- 24:16Speaker 2: from Patrick Costello that securities differ from purchases of collectibles
- 24:22Speaker 2: like baseball cards or beanie babies. When they buy this token,
- 24:25Speaker 2: they're investing into the network behind it. One cannot be
- 24:29Speaker 2: separated from the other.
- 24:30Speaker 7: Well, I really don't think that the SEC's argument is
- 24:34Speaker 7: all that meritorious and that particular point, because when you
- 24:37Speaker 7: look at collectibles and you look at beanie babies, the
- 24:40Speaker 7: people and the companies that create, for instance, the Beanie Babies.
- 24:43Speaker 7: You know, they're very astute in terms of releasing special
- 24:47Speaker 7: edition beanie babies or limiting the supply or having particular promotions.
- 24:53Speaker 7: So it's not just like Beanie Babies took off on
- 24:56Speaker 7: their own, so to speak. A lot of thought and
- 24:59Speaker 7: marketing and other things that you could consider to be
- 25:02Speaker 7: kind of an enterprise. You know, we're in place. So
- 25:04Speaker 7: the SEC's attempt to distinguish a collectible's market from a
- 25:08Speaker 7: securities market really wasn't persuasive in that instance. But I
- 25:11Speaker 7: think the SEC's broader and stronger argument is that the
- 25:15Speaker 7: Securities Act of nineteen thirty three, even though it's old,
- 25:19Speaker 7: has a lot of flexibility built into it and has
- 25:22Speaker 7: been able to be adopted to new types of investment
- 25:25Speaker 7: products over the years, like real estate investment trust and
- 25:28Speaker 7: complex sorts of financing instruments. And the SEC's argument is
- 25:32Speaker 7: that that was exactly what this Act is designed to do,
- 25:36Speaker 7: and that crypto fits within that sort of category of
- 25:39Speaker 7: a new financial investment, that it is comfortably within the
- 25:43Speaker 7: concept of an investment contract.
- 25:45Speaker 2: And do you agree with our Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation
- 25:49Speaker 2: analyst Elliott Stein, who predicts the judge will back Coinbase
- 25:53Speaker 2: and dismiss the SEC suit.
- 25:55Speaker 7: Yeah, I do think that there's a very high likelihood
- 25:58Speaker 7: of that happening. And I think the judge could do
- 26:01Speaker 7: is say that trading on the secondary market, like what
- 26:05Speaker 7: happened on the coinbase platform, is not a security because
- 26:09Speaker 7: people are trading among themselves, and the blockchain companies don't
- 26:13Speaker 7: get that money. They're just you know, aftermarket purchasers that
- 26:16Speaker 7: are buying and selling among themselves and still keeping those
- 26:20Speaker 7: investor protections for when those tokens are initially issued, like
- 26:24Speaker 7: for instance, an initial coin offering. You know, those could
- 26:27Speaker 7: be securities because the company is getting the money from
- 26:30Speaker 7: that offering, they're using it to build out a platform,
- 26:33Speaker 7: they're using it to make the product more valuable. So
- 26:36Speaker 7: it's a much stronger case to say that that's a
- 26:38Speaker 7: security than the aftermarket trading. And I think the other
- 26:42Speaker 7: really good point that Coinbase brought up was that the
- 26:45Speaker 7: SEC allowed Coinbase to go public just three years ago.
- 26:49Speaker 7: So Coinbase filed their forms with the SEC, described a
- 26:53Speaker 7: business model the platform was operating, and the SEC approved
- 26:57Speaker 7: the IPO three years ago. So how can the SEC
- 27:00Speaker 7: come back three years later after approving the IPO and say, well,
- 27:04Speaker 7: your business was an illegal enterprise, you know, all along,
- 27:08Speaker 7: going back to twenty nineteen when you first started it,
- 27:10Speaker 7: even though we approved it to be offered to the public.
- 27:13Speaker 7: When twenty twenty one.
- 27:14Speaker 2: The question of whether digital tokens our securities has divided courts.
- 27:19Speaker 2: So another Manhattan Federal Judge, an Alisa Torrez, ruled in
- 27:23Speaker 2: July that exchange sales of Ripple Labs token weren't subject
- 27:28Speaker 2: to SEC jurisdiction, while Manhattan Federal Judge Jed Rakoff, I
- 27:32Speaker 2: think he just sits a floor apart from her, that
- 27:35Speaker 2: same month reached the opposite conclusion in the SEC's case
- 27:39Speaker 2: against Terrorform Labs. So how much influence will the decision
- 27:43Speaker 2: here by Judge.
- 27:44Speaker 7: Polkav Well, that's a really good point, June, because there
- 27:48Speaker 7: are a lot of decisions coming out of the Manhattan
- 27:50Speaker 7: Federal Court as well as other courts that are contradictory
- 27:53Speaker 7: and judges taking different approaches. And the judge in the
- 27:57Speaker 7: Coinbakes case, whatever way she ultimately the rules is going
- 28:01Speaker 7: to be one more decision in that mix. It's not
- 28:03Speaker 7: going to be a definitive answer either way, and I
- 28:06Speaker 7: suspect that at some point, either the appellate courts in
- 28:09Speaker 7: New York or even the Supreme Court is going to
- 28:12Speaker 7: have to issue a decision on this point because there
- 28:14Speaker 7: have been contradictory rulings. But ideally, as the judges pointing out,
- 28:18Speaker 7: this is more an issue for Congress in terms of
- 28:21Speaker 7: trying to pass a legislative framework for crypto that defines,
- 28:25Speaker 7: you know, what people have to do, how to regulate it,
- 28:28Speaker 7: which agency should be responsible for it. Because right now
- 28:32Speaker 7: you have this SEC, you have the CFTC, which regulates commodities,
- 28:37Speaker 7: and other agencies at the state level. We're all kind
- 28:40Speaker 7: of seert jurisdiction over crypto and it's very harmful for
- 28:43Speaker 7: the industry and it's hindering innovation and development because there
- 28:47Speaker 7: really is not a clear regulatory framework. So ideally Congress
- 28:51Speaker 7: would act, but I don't have high hopes for that
- 28:53Speaker 7: in this political climate.
- 28:55Speaker 2: Unfortunately, I have to agree with you there, Bob, Thanks
- 28:57Speaker 2: so much. That's Robert him a partner Tartar, Krinsky and
- 29:01Speaker 2: Drogan Coming up next, elon Musk's ultimatum to the Tesla board.
- 29:06Speaker 2: I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 29:11Speaker 1: All right, it's been an incredible year. The SpaceX team,
- 29:16Speaker 1: I think is the best space team that has ever
- 29:19Speaker 1: been as severled on face the Earth by far.
- 29:21Speaker 2: There was applause for Elon Musk at SpaceX last week.
- 29:25Speaker 2: It completed a record ninety six missions to space last
- 29:28Speaker 2: year with usually positive headlines. Not so much so for
- 29:33Speaker 2: the rest of Musk's life, with his divisive political and
- 29:36Speaker 2: cultural comments, his drug use reported by The Wall Street Journal,
- 29:41Speaker 2: and his focus split as he continues to run SpaceX
- 29:44Speaker 2: X Corp, Twitter, and other ventures in addition to Tesla. Yet,
- 29:49Speaker 2: despite all this, Musk is leaning on Tesla's board to
- 29:53Speaker 2: give him another massive stock award that would nearly double
- 29:57Speaker 2: his current shares. In a series of posts on X,
- 30:01Speaker 2: the Tesla chief executive says he would be quote uncomfortable
- 30:05Speaker 2: growing Tesla to be a leader in AI and robotics
- 30:08Speaker 2: without having twenty five percent control and then the not
- 30:12Speaker 2: so veiled threat. Unless that is the case, I would
- 30:15Speaker 2: prefer to build products outside of Tesla. Joining me is
- 30:19Speaker 2: business law professor Eric Tally of Columbia Law School. Eric,
- 30:23Speaker 2: is this a real threat?
- 30:24Speaker 5: It's really hard to tell. And first of all, I
- 30:26Speaker 5: guess it's kind of interesting that Elon Musk decided to
- 30:29Speaker 5: take his case for a raise. I guess not to
- 30:33Speaker 5: the Tesla board, but to the viewers of his ex
- 30:36Speaker 5: slash Twitter feed, to essentially make his case in the
- 30:40Speaker 5: court of public opinion, which is kind of a bizarre thing. Now,
- 30:43Speaker 5: it may well be the case that mister Musk has
- 30:45Speaker 5: already put forward this request and not having it received
- 30:49Speaker 5: as well as he would want it, but it's kind
- 30:51Speaker 5: of an interesting thing to decide. To you, he's going
- 30:53Speaker 5: to crowdsource people's opinions about whether he should have his
- 30:55Speaker 5: ownership stake increased to twenty five percent. Now, the guy
- 30:59Speaker 5: is an iconoclast who has a huge following all over
- 31:03Speaker 5: the place. Some of the following follows him into the
- 31:06Speaker 5: stock markets as well. So I think if you're sitting
- 31:08Speaker 5: on the board of Tesla, you probably don't want Elon
- 31:12Speaker 5: Musk becoming sour and sort of unhappy about his situation
- 31:16Speaker 5: at Tesla. Yeah. By the same token, there's a real
- 31:19Speaker 5: sense in which the types of reasons that mister Musk
- 31:23Speaker 5: gave in his fairly long tweet they don't really quite
- 31:27Speaker 5: pass the smell test. The main one that he gave
- 31:30Speaker 5: was that he needs that level of control so that
- 31:33Speaker 5: he has enough influence and power to help direct things
- 31:37Speaker 5: at Tesla. He's only sitting at thirteen percent now, which
- 31:41Speaker 5: by the way, is an amount that he brought himself
- 31:43Speaker 5: down to, having shed a bunch of his Tesla shares
- 31:46Speaker 5: so that he could afford his Twitter acquisition. And he
- 31:49Speaker 5: doesn't feel like he has the influence he wants. And
- 31:51Speaker 5: I don't really know of anyone who actually believes that.
- 31:54Speaker 5: You know, it's obvious to me that most retail investors
- 31:58Speaker 5: and almost certainly that board is hanging on every single
- 32:02Speaker 5: word that Elon Musk set so to claim that, you know,
- 32:05Speaker 5: if I don't have twenty five percent, I'm not going
- 32:07Speaker 5: to have enough influence. It just doesn't add up to me.
- 32:11Speaker 2: Is this a great time to be pressuring Tesla? With
- 32:15Speaker 2: the carmaker off to the worst start to any year
- 32:18Speaker 2: it's been a public company?
- 32:20Speaker 5: Yeah? How do I put this? Definitely this is a
- 32:22Speaker 5: terrible time to be pressuring Tesla. But you know, if
- 32:25Speaker 5: anyone could do it, possibly it is mister Musk first
- 32:27Speaker 5: and foremost realized that everyone like myself who teaches corporate
- 32:31Speaker 5: law has been sitting and waiting for a decision involving
- 32:35Speaker 5: mister Musk's own compensation package that was awarded to him
- 32:39Speaker 5: five and a half years ago that ended up paying
- 32:42Speaker 5: him almost sixty billion dollars worth of Tesla stock. We
- 32:45Speaker 5: don't know how that decision is going to come out
- 32:47Speaker 5: of Chancellor McCormack's chambers. Suppose she comes back and she says, yeah,
- 32:51Speaker 5: the shareholders have a point here. That may mean that
- 32:53Speaker 5: the cash flowers have to go in the reverse. He's
- 32:55Speaker 5: got to give back some of the value he's already
- 32:57Speaker 5: been paid her shares that he's received. So it's already
- 33:00Speaker 5: of a sketchy time to be saying, oh, let's just
- 33:02Speaker 5: reload this same package, or maybe even a richer package,
- 33:05Speaker 5: when we don't even know what the legal status of
- 33:07Speaker 5: the existing one was going to be. Second, one of
- 33:10Speaker 5: the things that has become clear is that the electric
- 33:13Speaker 5: vehicle space is both getting crowded by new entrants and
- 33:17Speaker 5: foreign competition, and you know, it's kind of an inflection
- 33:20Speaker 5: point about how heavily people are going to be diving
- 33:23Speaker 5: into additional purchases of electric vehicles. That's going to make
- 33:27Speaker 5: Tesla probably face even more of an uphill battle. It
- 33:30Speaker 5: So you've got this CEO who's saying I want you
- 33:32Speaker 5: to basically double my stake in the company, or else
- 33:35Speaker 5: I'm going to start directing business outside of Tesla. It's
- 33:38Speaker 5: not a great look and it's not a great moment
- 33:41Speaker 5: for that to happen.
- 33:42Speaker 2: Thanks Eric, Best, Professor Eric Tally of Columbia Law School,
- 33:46Speaker 2: And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 33:49Speaker 2: Remember you've ben always get the latest legal news by
- 33:51Speaker 2: subscribing and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 33:55Speaker 2: and at Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, slash Law. I'm
- 33:59Speaker 2: June gram So, and this is Gloomberg