Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Lack of Jails Threatens Trials and BCNDP vs Constitutional Requirements
Transcript
- 0:13Adam Stirling: We're going to start today with a practice direction.
- 0:18Adam Stirling: What practice direction and what is this latest one about?
- 0:23Michael Mulligan: Sure.
- 0:23Michael Mulligan: So the uh courts, the Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, Provincial Court, the uh kind of the administrative uh judges can issue uh directions about things, sort of procedural things and rules about how things are to be conducted, when and how things should be scheduled, uh that sort of thing.
- 0:40Michael Mulligan: And this was one of those, and it just came out today, and it's one that looks like it's gonna have a pretty significant impact around the province.
- 0:48Michael Mulligan: The background of it, as explained in the notice, is that it uh uh is uh it involves the issue of uh what is to be done uh with people who are in custody for their trial.
- 1:01Michael Mulligan: They've been denied bail, they've been detained uh in communities where there is no correctional facility for them to be housed in uh for the purpose of their trial.
- 1:12Michael Mulligan: Uh and that issue becomes particularly acute for longer trials, which are often the case in the BC Supreme Court dealing with more serious matters, murder and so on there.
- 1:23Michael Mulligan: Uh and the uh in the past, what's happened in these uh sm locations, and there's a whole list of them here, eleven of them, Cranbrook, Dawson Creek, Fort St.
- 1:34Michael Mulligan: John, Nelson, Powell River, Prince Rupert, Revelstoke, Roslyn, Smithers, Terrace, and Williams Lake, is that uh they would, when it was the nearest correctional facility, is so far away that you can't drive there and back every day, um, particularly being an issue when you have trials that go on for weeks on end.
- 1:54Michael Mulligan: Um and in the past, what they did is they uh had arrangements to have uh people who are in custody housed in like local RCMP detachments or local police detachments, um, and that has been discontinued because the simply those local police forces are just not equipped to do that.
- 2:14Michael Mulligan: Um, and so that's been terminated.
- 2:17Michael Mulligan: Um that's been an issue, by the way, in uh Victoria in the region uh as well, and it arises here in the case of prisoners who are female uh because they we do not have a a correctional facility for women uh in Greater Victoria or on the island, they have to go over to the lower mainland, uh, or for children.
- 2:36Michael Mulligan: Uh the youth custody center here was shut down.
- 2:39Michael Mulligan: Uh and so um you've got uh the police department saying, look, we can't manage this.
- 2:45Michael Mulligan: Uh and so what the practice directive details is that the court sheriffs who are responsible for people who are in custody for their trial um have been chartering airplanes and flying the accused person back and forth to the pretrial facility daily.
- 3:03Michael Mulligan: Um and the as the court points out, that's not always available.
- 3:07Michael Mulligan: Uh and so there have been efforts to try to fix this, uh including as detailed in the this uh notice, for several months there's been a quote working group, close quote, uh made up of the provincial government officials and police uh departments and so on trying to find uh some solution to this, and it just hasn't come together at this point.
- 3:28Michael Mulligan: And so what the court has said is that there are going to need to be these uh uh pretrial hearings with judges uh to determine can they manage the trial for people who are in custody when there's nowhere to house the person that you can drive to and back uh every day uh in relation to where the courthouse is.
- 3:50Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the court has pointed out that at those hearings, the judge trying to manage that will need to decide whether and how that should be approached.
- 3:59Michael Mulligan: And the various solutions listed here are that the trial could be adjourned.
- 4:04Michael Mulligan: Uh that could have an impact on in some cases about whether there ever will be a trial, because a person has a right to a trial within a reasonable period of time.
- 4:11Michael Mulligan: Another possibility they raised is moving trials to other locations.
- 4:16Michael Mulligan: Sometimes that can happen, but it has other knock-on effects like witnesses that have to be transported all over the place.
- 4:22Michael Mulligan: Uh, and there's a legal presumption that trials are supposed to be in the community where the allegation is from, um, so that has problems.
- 4:30Michael Mulligan: Or another possibility is that the accused will be released from custody in order to allow the trial to proceed uh in that location and not with additional delay.
- 4:40Michael Mulligan: Um and so this just came out this morning, um, and we'll have to wait and see how it plays out, but it's clearly a problem.
- 4:48Michael Mulligan: Um uh and uh in these communities it's uh you know it's uh just very logistically difficult when there's no proper facility there.
- 4:57Michael Mulligan: Um and uh the police just aren't in the business of acting as jails uh for people who are you know maybe uh in there for weeks.
- 5:06Michael Mulligan: Police departments often have sort of uh basic like how holding cells where you could like hold somebody overnight, you know, for the purpose of a bail hearing the next day or you know, that sort of thing.
- 5:16Michael Mulligan: Uh but they're not equipped uh to operate as like a long-term jail.
- 5:21Michael Mulligan: Like many of them don't have things like no shower facility and no proper way to feed the people uh and so on.
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's gonna be, I mean, that's been an issue here locally, but um, you know, asking some small RCMP detachment with one cell in the back room or something to manage uh somebody in custody for weeks on end while they have a trial and no facilities for them is just really not uh workable.
- 5:45Michael Mulligan: It also means for the people, I think, in some circumstances, like let's say you had two cells in some small community, and one of them's taken up by a person who was having a uh a long trial, uh, it can also mean things like, you know, the other cell is uh somebody who's in there for being drunk in public or something, and so you end up with an accused person who's um got no shower facilities, can never go outside, and every night during their trial, they've got somebody who's you know sitting next to it, throwing up or yelling or whatever, and so really not uh a great facility for them.
- 6:15Michael Mulligan: And the police detachments have just decided, sorry, that we're we're just cannot be the uh you know the last resort, which is often how frankly police are treated, you know, when you don't have other uh proper services in place that sort of leave it to the police.
- 6:29Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh I think they've it looks like they've just had enough of that.
- 6:33Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest uh from the BC Supreme Court.
- 6:35Michael Mulligan: Uh and we'll have to wait and see which of those choices judges take up to make sure that uh these trials can proceed uh when there's just no adequate facilities to have the uh person in in custody.
- 6:46Adam Stirling: All right, let's take a break.
- 7:09Adam Stirling: How does all of that work and what is the latest on that?
- 7:12Michael Mulligan: So the latest on that is the decision, uh a trial decision uh brought challenging the constitutionality uh of changes the provincial government is trying to make to the uh how lawyers are regulated in the province.
- 7:27Michael Mulligan: Uh and it's a really interesting decision that came out yesterday.
- 7:30Michael Mulligan: Um and it it deals, first of all, with the sort of the one of the fundamental, the premise of this constitutional argument, uh, bearing in mind, of course, that when things are challenged in court, uh they are not a judge assessing whether what the government is doing is wise or a good idea or anything of the sort.
- 7:48Michael Mulligan: Uh all that all judges have the authority to do is to determine whether laws passed by the government are constitutional, which is to say permitted at all, right?
- 7:57Michael Mulligan: Sometimes the way I describe it is it's not a great way to make public policy by asking what you can possibly get away with and then doing just slightly less than what would be unlawful, right?
- 8:08Michael Mulligan: It's sort of like you know, you don't figure out how much medicine you should take by determining the amount that will kill you and then recommending you take just a little less than that, right?
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: We should uh do better.
- 8:16Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 8:17Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the premise of this litigation is brought by the Law Society of British Columbia and a host of other uh groups, including law societies from other places in the country and other groups that were interested in all of this.
- 8:30Michael Mulligan: The first sort of fundamental premise of this constitutional challenge um was arguing that the idea of an independent bar uh is a unwritten constitutional principle.
- 8:45Michael Mulligan: Um and that's a really interesting thing to think about, uh, because uh in Canada uh we have all kinds of const we have a written constitution, uh, but many of the things that we take for granted uh are not written down at all, right?
- 9:01Michael Mulligan: If if you just read the Constitution uh Act, the written part of it, you would think that the uh you know in British Columbia, the Lieutenant Governor just kind of does whatever they want, uh, and the governor general kind of runs Canada uh and uh you know all these politicians, what what are they, right?
- 9:17Michael Mulligan: Which is not how we operate.
- 9:19Michael Mulligan: Um much of how we operate, the sort of the very premise of our uh uh uh govern governing system, right, are these principles that are not written down, right?
- 9:32Michael Mulligan: You you don't have the lieutenant governor just disallowing legislation left, right, and center and doing whatever they want, right?
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: Uh and so one of the first things that the judge had to deal with in this case is is this concept of an independent bar, an unwritten constitutional requirement.
- 9:49Michael Mulligan: Um and to assess that, uh, the uh judge looked at sort of the history uh of that, pointing out things like, you know, for example, the law societies existed since 1874, shortly after the province came into force or came into existence, um, and looked at um things including like how has this been managed since, uh, and the the history of it, of course, goes back to even before uh British Columbia existed.
- 10:15Michael Mulligan: Like in the UK, uh the way barristers are regulated are by these things which are called the inns of court.
- 10:22Michael Mulligan: Over there we've got like Lincoln's Inn and the Inner Temple, the Middle Temple, and Gray's Inn, and they're these sort of organizations that um manage and discipline and set rules and uh so on for how barristers are to conduct themselves, and they're not a function of the government.
- 10:38Michael Mulligan: Um and it's really interesting and important, of course, because the things like you know, you we take for granted the idea of things like an independent judiciary, right?
- 10:47Michael Mulligan: You don't want the judge who's uh you know being told what to do by the government.
- 10:51Michael Mulligan: Uh and for that to have any meaning, you also have to have an independent bar, uh, because judges don't just roam through the streets looking for problems to solve, right?
- 11:00Michael Mulligan: Um and if you don't have an independent bar, the independent judiciary is pretty well meaningless.
- 11:05Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the judge found that indeed that is a constitutional principle, which is a requirement, and that can act as a constraint on what government is allowed to do.
- 11:15Michael Mulligan: It's not unfettered.
- 11:17Michael Mulligan: Now the judge then had to sort out, having found that to be the case, whether what the government is trying to do here um uh violates that.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: Uh and some of the things which were pointed to by the law society include the fact that the uh government, in this legislation called the Legal Professions Act, they added an S to the legislation, um, does things like it removes the uh basic uh object of the law society uh which currently exists, which is to uphold and protect the public interest and the legal rights and freedoms of all people in British Columbia.
- 11:51Michael Mulligan: And they've replaced that with things that are uh priorities for the current NDP government, like things like implementing UNDRIP, right?
- 12:01Michael Mulligan: The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People, for example.
- 12:04Michael Mulligan: And interestingly, on that score, uh it's not implementing the BC legislation, it's implementing directly the United Nations Declaration.
- 12:12Michael Mulligan: And so that's interesting, even if uh the BC version of that gets repealed or suspended, well, the way this is worded that it would still exist.
- 12:21Michael Mulligan: And then they've done other things like allowing them to uh appoint more of the people like the board of directors, they're called benchers that operate the law society, gives the government more authority to appoint more of them.
- 12:31Michael Mulligan: And then they also looked at another thing which is interesting that may not have got a lot of attention, that they've uh introduced this uh thing called a indigenous council.
- 12:41Michael Mulligan: Uh and the indigenous council and another thing called a transitional indigenous council uh has authority, approval powers over some of the rules that this uh the law society would be able make.
- 12:55Michael Mulligan: Uh and so it's basically the the provincial government is trying to um modify the law society in order to have it carry out its political objectives, right?
- 13:09Michael Mulligan: Um and uh broadly speaking, I must say one of the reasons why this is such a troubling piece of legislation um is it's uh indicative of a few other attempts along the same lines that we've seen in uh British Columbia, like for example, uh the effort to pass legislation uh in response to Trump to try to allow the uh uh government to pass rules without the going through the legislature, uh, or things that restrict property rights, uh, or uh efforts to change things like uh financing for uh political parties in a way that may advantage the current government, um, which uh and changes to other this and other um the sort of otherwise independent uh professional bodies that are uh sort of the the left-wing equivalent of what we've seen uh the right do in places like the United States or uh uh Hungary, for example, uh where, you know, for example, in the United States, again, they have all kinds of um sort of norms, they would call them there, in terms of things like you know how the president might conduct themselves, right?
- 14:18Michael Mulligan: Um and uh the current president in the United States uh has become uh master at sort of doing things uh that are not in accordance with those things, like in the legal regime uh attacking, making uh uh putting rules in place to punish law firms that have uh taken cases that the uh president doesn't like.
- 14:40Michael Mulligan: Uh or you see other things going on uh there in terms of uh things like um gerrymandering or redistricting, uh, or uh in places like Hungary over the past number of years, there were uh all kinds of changes made to uh advantage uh the uh right wing government that was in place there.
- 15:00Michael Mulligan: And what uh those things seem to be is you wind up with a sort of a government that concludes that uh their policies are so uh important and in uh that it's uh worth undermining some of the things that would act as restraints uh on their ability to do what they want.
- 15:19Michael Mulligan: Um and uh the Law Society in British Columbia is an example of that.
- 15:24Michael Mulligan: Um you know, many, many times uh what lawyers are tasked with uh doing uh is opposing uh what the uh government is trying to do in terms of whether it's some individual prosecution of somebody or the challenging laws or whatever it might be.
- 15:41Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh this this piece of legislation that changes to the Legal Professions Act um is in that same vein uh of trying to uh constrain uh the uh sort of uh elements in society that might uh resist uh what uh the government is trying to do.
- 16:01Michael Mulligan: Uh and so it's in that context that this case has come out, right?
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: Um and uh indeed the judge found uh that uh there are constitutional restraints on what the government is permitted to do, uh but as is a judge's task, it's not to decide whether uh those uh uh to this legislation is a good idea or not.
- 16:27Michael Mulligan: I think most people, if you ask them to think, should you have the regulator of lawyers tasked with implementing uh political goals of the current government?
- 16:37Michael Mulligan: I think most people would think about that and say that's really not a very good idea.
- 16:41Michael Mulligan: Um but you know, the the judge has to, as they're charged with doing, uh look at each of the various things uh that the uh provincial government is doing here, uh like uh trying to give themselves uh um more power to make rules, trying to give this uh indigenous transitional council uh authority to approve the initial rules that this law society would uh implement, um, or give, for example, this uh indigenous council the power to approve particular um things or the obligation to implement the UN undrip or each of those things individually, the judge here goes through and analyzes, well, does this seem to be um in violation of that uh constitutional obligation?
- 17:28Michael Mulligan: Uh and despite the argument from the current law society, uh that this amounts to a sort of the language used was a waterfall effect of numerous measures uh in this piece of legislation, which collectively, in the view of the current law society, um undermines uh the its independence uh in a way intended to advantage uh the current government and to deprive ultimately people of their ability to um get independent legal assistance.
- 18:02Michael Mulligan: And the judge concluded that ultimately, well, whether or not this is a good idea or not, it doesn't go so far as to be unconstitutional or unlawful.
- 18:11Michael Mulligan: Um now, I rather suspect this won't be the it's almost certainly not to be the end of it.
- 18:16Michael Mulligan: This will go on to the Court of Appeal and probably the Supreme Court of Canada, I guess just given how important uh those principles are.
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: Uh but just reading this decision, it's both interesting because it gives that historical perspective on how we got here and you know how constitutional principles work in Canada uh and why it is important uh that you have an independent judiciary uh and bar.
- 18:41Michael Mulligan: And of course, those things don't exist to advantage the judges, for example, right?
- 18:46Michael Mulligan: It's not important that you have an independent judiciary because somehow uh that helps judges.
- 18:52Michael Mulligan: Uh nor is it important that you have uh an independent bar because somehow that's good for lawyers.
- 18:57Michael Mulligan: It's important that we have an independent judiciary and an independent bar so that uh people are able to get uh assistance, legal assistance, and have an impartial forum to have disputes resolved, many of which involve the government.
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: Um and you know, the worry with these kinds of changes where you switch right into the legislation whatever the government of the day thinks is their most important priority, and you uh require a regulator of a legal profession to implement those things, just imagine being uh somebody who's on the other side of that, right?
- 19:34Michael Mulligan: If you're let's say you're the property owner in Richmond whose property is at risk of uh you know you may lose it, right?
- 19:41Michael Mulligan: And that may extend to other parts of the province.
- 19:44Michael Mulligan: You may well want to be able to hire a lawyer who's going to vigorously uh oppose uh some of those things.
- 19:51Michael Mulligan: What does that mean uh when the regulatory agency uh is charged with implementing uh the legislation that is at the core of that?
- 20:02Michael Mulligan: You know, that is really seriously troubling.
- 20:05Michael Mulligan: Uh and so this is a very bad piece of legislation, bad from the perspective of um living in a democratic and free society where you've got uh sort of independence of the uh legal profession and the judiciary so that people can have fair hearings into these things.
- 20:22Michael Mulligan: This is a terrible piece of legislation.
- 20:24Michael Mulligan: Uh but the at least the decision on the uh trial level is that uh whether it's good or bad, uh that uh it is allowed.
- 20:34Michael Mulligan: Uh and so we'll have to wait and see what the next step is, likely an appeal.
- 20:38Michael Mulligan: Uh but that's the latest out of the BC Supreme Court in terms of the uh provincial government's effort to change the law society to implement uh their priorities.
- 20:48Adam Stirling: All right, that's all the time we have for now, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 20:52Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you so much.
- 20:53Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 20:54Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 20:55Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.