Latest / Interfaiths / Interfaith Dialogue as a Spiritual Exercise
Transcript
- 0:00I want you to try a thought experiment with me.
- 0:01Just for a second. Close your eyes. Imagine you're
- 0:05not. Well, you. You don't have a name. You don't
- 0:08have a job to get to. You're an animal. Okay,
- 0:11I'm with you. Where are we going with this? Let's
- 0:13say a hawk riding a thermal current over a huge
- 0:17canyon. Or maybe a wolf. moving through a snow
- 0:21-covered forest. The classic way to start thinking
- 0:23about phenomenology, right? Trying to imagine
- 0:26the welt, the self -world of another creature.
- 0:29Exactly. Now, how do you see the world? The poet
- 0:32Rainer Maria Rilke had this... really specific,
- 0:35beautiful answer. He said that animals see the
- 0:38world with whole eyes. He called it the open.
- 0:40The open. Yeah. So when that hawk looks down,
- 0:43it doesn't see landscape or property lines or,
- 0:45you know, potential prey resources. It just sees
- 0:47what is. There's no separation, no filter between
- 0:50the observer and the observed. A hawk and the
- 0:52wind are like part of the same single event.
- 0:54Precisely. It sounds peaceful, doesn't it? But
- 0:56then Rilke just pivots. He turns the camera on
- 0:58us. Humans. And he says our situation is actually
- 1:01tragic by comparison. Oh, so he says our eyes
- 1:05are turned back upon themselves. We don't just
- 1:09see the world. We analyze it. We categorize it.
- 1:11We encircle it with concepts. And here's the
- 1:14line that just floored me. Rilke says we seek
- 1:17to snare the world, setting traps for freedom,
- 1:20setting traps for freedom. Wow. That is a. Devastating
- 1:25line. It really is. And it stuck with me reading
- 1:28the material for today's deep dive because it
- 1:30feels like that's exactly what we do, especially
- 1:32when we try to understand other people. We build
- 1:34these these intellectual cages. Right. We trap
- 1:38them. We trap them in our categories, secular,
- 1:40religious, modern, traditional. And we pat ourselves
- 1:43on the back thinking we understand them. But
- 1:45we just caught a shadow. We aren't seeing them
- 1:47with whole eyes. And that sets the stage perfectly
- 1:49for what we're getting into today, because we
- 1:51are in a way. questioning the very tools we use
- 1:54to understand the other. I mean, we live in this
- 1:57information age. We have more data about other
- 1:59cultures, other religions, other belief systems
- 2:02than any generation in human history. You can
- 2:04pull up Wikipedia right now and get a five -minute
- 2:06summary of Shinto rituals or Sufi poetry. Instantly.
- 2:11But the question is, are we actually understanding
- 2:14the people behind that data? Or are we just trapping
- 2:18them in our own neat little framework of reason?
- 2:20Are we building a secular cage? That is the big
- 2:23question. We are diving into a really fascinating,
- 2:27definitely controversial, and I'll say it, a
- 2:29pretty difficult paper. It's titled, What If
- 2:31Anthropology Were a Spiritual Exercise? by the
- 2:34anthropologist Khaled Farhani. It was published
- 2:37in Current Anthropology in 2026. And we should
- 2:39say, we're not just looking at the paper itself,
- 2:41but at the explosion of debate it caused. I mean,
- 2:44scholars from... Tel Aviv to Columbia to Cambridge
- 2:47all jumped in on this. And just to clarify for
- 2:50everyone listening, while this paper is technically
- 2:52about anthropology, the academic study of humans,
- 2:55it's really about something much, much broader.
- 2:57Oh, absolutely. It's about how any of us encounter
- 3:00people of faith in what we call a secular world.
- 3:02It's about that huge divide between the religious
- 3:05and the secular and asking if we can ever really
- 3:08cross it. Specifically, we're going to dig into
- 3:10a new framework Ferrani proposes called the Antheistic.
- 3:13Don't worry, we will definitely explain what
- 3:15that means. But the mission here is to see how
- 3:17this changes the game for interfaith understanding.
- 3:20Because, let's be honest, a lot of what passes
- 3:22for interfaith dialogue can feel a bit, well,
- 3:27superficial. Superficial is a good word. Or...
- 3:32Cosmetic. Cosmetic is a polite way to put it.
- 3:34Yeah. It often stays right there on the surface
- 3:36of information exchange. I believe X, you believe
- 3:39Y. Isn't that nice? Let's agree to be civil.
- 3:41Have some coffee and cookies. Exactly. Farhani
- 3:44is pushing for something far more radical. He's
- 3:46asking, how do we move from just swapping facts
- 3:50to genuine spiritual formation? How do we stop
- 3:53analyzing people and actually start letting them
- 3:55change who we are? So to get there, we first
- 3:58have to understand the trap, the cage Rilke was
- 4:00talking about. Ferroni starts his argument by
- 4:02diagnosing what he sees as a deep sickness in
- 4:05modern thinking, especially in the university.
- 4:07He says we are trapped in sovereign secular reason.
- 4:10Okay, that's a mouthful. Let's break that down.
- 4:12Yeah, let's unpack that because it sounds like
- 4:14a heavy philosophy lecture. What is sovereign
- 4:17secular reason? The key word is sovereign. Think
- 4:21of a king. A sovereign is supreme, absolute,
- 4:24answering to no one. Okay, got it. Sovereign
- 4:27secular reason is the belief that the human intellect
- 4:30is the king. It's completely self -sufficient.
- 4:33It operates, as the philosopher Immanuel Kant
- 4:36might say, without the guidance of another. Meaning
- 4:39it only relies on itself. On logic, observation,
- 4:42that kind of thing. Exactly. It doesn't need
- 4:44a God. It doesn't need a spirit, a muse, or a
- 4:47revelation to help it understand the world. It
- 4:49believes it has all the tools it needs right
- 4:52inside its own toolbox. So it's the idea that
- 4:55I can figure everything out just using my brain.
- 4:57I don't need any outside, you know, divine help.
- 5:00Specifically, you don't need revelation. You
- 5:02don't need divine speech. In this framework,
- 5:05when reason looks at religion like, when a sociologist
- 5:07studies a church service reason, treats God or
- 5:10prophecy as objects to be studied. Like a rock
- 5:13or an insect. Precisely. They're cultural artifacts.
- 5:17We can analyze why you believe in God. We can
- 5:19analyze the social function of prayer in your
- 5:21community. But we never for a moment entertain
- 5:24the possibility that God might actually be real.
- 5:27Or that the prayer is actually... You know, talking
- 5:29to someone. Right. It's like studying a group
- 5:32of people who believe in Santa Claus. You could
- 5:34write a very serious academic paper about the
- 5:37economic impact of Santa Claus rituals, but you
- 5:40never for a second think Santa's actually going
- 5:41to come down your chimney. Exactly. You maintain
- 5:44what's called methodological atheism. And Ferrani's
- 5:47whole point is that this creates a secular cage.
- 5:50It's a form of myopia, a blindness. We can analyze
- 5:54people. We can write these brilliant ethnographies
- 5:56about them, but we cannot truly meet them. Because
- 5:59we've already ruled out the most important part
- 6:01of their reality. We're cut off from the divine
- 6:03possibilities that their lives represent. We're
- 6:06setting Rilke's traps for the world, but we aren't
- 6:09experiencing it. We are safe, but we are blind.
- 6:12But hold on. Isn't that just science? I mean,
- 6:14for science to work, doesn't it have to be objective?
- 6:17If I'm studying a chemical reaction, I'm not
- 6:19going to ask if the chemicals are having a spiritual
- 6:21experience. Why is it a cage instead of just
- 6:24a good, solid method? And that is the billion
- 6:27-dollar question. For chemicals, sure, no one's
- 6:30arguing that. But Furani, and a whole line of
- 6:34thinkers he draws upon, would say that when you
- 6:37apply that exact same method to people, Especially
- 6:40people for whom God is the primary organizing
- 6:43reality of their lives. You are fundamentally
- 6:46missing the point. You're describing the container
- 6:48but ignoring the contents. You're describing
- 6:51the shell and ignoring the ghost in the machine.
- 6:53By ruling out the divine from the get -go, you're
- 6:56ruling out the very thing that makes their world
- 6:58make sense. So you aren't being objective. You're
- 7:01actually being deaf to a specific and crucial
- 7:04frequency. Okay, so if the problem is this secular
- 7:07cage where everything gets interpreted through
- 7:08this one godless lens, what's the solution? Ferani
- 7:12proposes something he calls a spiritual exercise.
- 7:14Now, when I hear that phrase, I immediately think
- 7:17of yoga or maybe a silent Jesuit retreat. What
- 7:21does he mean in this academic context? He's borrowing
- 7:24this term from a French philosopher named Pierre
- 7:27Hadot. Hadot was a giant in the study of ancient
- 7:30philosophy. He looked back at the Greeks, the
- 7:32Stoics, the Epicureans, the Platonists, and he
- 7:35had this huge realization. Which was? That for
- 7:38them, philosophy wasn't just sitting in a classroom
- 7:40debating logic puzzles. It wasn't about getting
- 7:43tenure or publishing papers. It was a way of
- 7:45life. It was practical. It was something you
- 7:47did. It was transformative. A spiritual exercise
- 7:51in this sense means a metamorphosis of the self.
- 7:55It's not just thinking hard about a topic from
- 7:57a distance. It's about training yourself to,
- 7:59and this is a direct quote, die to your individuality
- 8:02and plunge into the totality of life. Plunging
- 8:05into the totality of life. That sounds a lot
- 8:07more exciting than writing a dissertation. It
- 8:09is. The goal isn't to accumulate knowledge like
- 8:11you're collecting trophies for a shelf. The goal
- 8:14is to liberate yourself from your own small ego
- 8:16and access what he calls the mystery of the presence
- 8:19of the universe. So it's a fundamental shift.
- 8:21It's a huge shift from an intellect that tries
- 8:24to conquer knowledge, to grab it, own it, cite
- 8:27it, to an intellect that prepares itself to receive
- 8:30knowledge. That is such a crucial distinction.
- 8:34Conquering versus receiving. It feels like the
- 8:37difference between being a hunter and, I don't
- 8:39know, maybe a satellite dish or a gardener. That's
- 8:43a great analogy. One is aggressive, right, going
- 8:45out to kill and capture. The other is attentive,
- 8:48patient, waiting for something to arrive or to
- 8:50grow. The hunter sets the trap. The receiver
- 8:54opens the door. And Farani is asking, what if
- 8:58anthropology, the study of humans, wasn't just
- 9:01a job you do from 9 to 5? What if it was a spiritual
- 9:04exercise where you risk fundamentally changing
- 9:07who you are by truly immersing yourself in the
- 9:09reality of the other? What if the anthropologist
- 9:11has to undergo their own metamorphosis just to
- 9:14be able to see what's really there? That's the
- 9:15question. And that leads us to the core concept
- 9:17of this entire deep dive. It's the jargon word
- 9:20of the day, folks. The atheistic. The atheistic.
- 9:23Furani coined this term. And you have to listen
- 9:26carefully because it sounds like atheistic, but
- 9:29it is definitely not that. It also sounds a bit
- 9:31like pantheistic, but it's not that either. No,
- 9:34it's something unique. It's a linguistic bridge
- 9:36he's trying to build. It comes from two Greek
- 9:38roots. Yeah. Anthropos. Meaning human. And theos.
- 9:41Meaning God. So human God. Ferani defines the
- 9:44atheistic as an intermediate, atopic space. A
- 9:48topic, meaning no place. Right. It's not a physical
- 9:51location you can put on a map. It's not a church.
- 9:53It's not a lab. It's a perceptual space, a state
- 9:55of mind where human reason and divine intelligence
- 9:58get actually meet. Okay, hold on. This sounds
- 10:01very theological. Do I have to believe in a specific
- 10:03God to enter this atheistic space? Do I have
- 10:06to be religious? If I'm a hardcore secular humanist
- 10:08listening to this, am I just... disqualified?
- 10:11It's a great question. And Ferroni is very careful
- 10:13here. He says, no, you don't have to be a monotheist.
- 10:15You don't have to sign up for a specific creed
- 10:17or go to a specific building on Sundays. But,
- 10:20and this is the big but, he says it requires
- 10:22an agnostic assent to the existence of a divine
- 10:25order. Agnostic assent. That's a fascinating
- 10:29phrase. It feels like a contradiction. Usually
- 10:31agnosticism is about not assenting. It's about
- 10:34saying, I don't know. Right. But here it's like
- 10:36saying, I don't know for sure, but I'm going
- 10:38to say yes. to the possibility. It's an act of
- 10:41intellectual hospitality. It's a space where
- 10:44reason stops being indifferent to revelation.
- 10:47So it admits that maybe just maybe human reason
- 10:50isn't the only intelligence in the universe.
- 10:53It admits that revelation isn't just a cultural
- 10:55myth to be analyzed, but a potential source of
- 10:57real truth. Ferani also calls this the daemonic
- 11:01space. Daemonic? Like demons? That sounds a little
- 11:04terrifying. Guggles, in the ancient Greek sense,
- 11:07not the Hollywood horror movie sense, the daemon
- 11:09was a spirit, an intermediary between gods and
- 11:12humans. Socrates talked about his daemon as a
- 11:15divine voice that guided him. Oh, okay. So think
- 11:18of this space as a laboratory where reason admits
- 11:20it's fragile. He calls it an aporia generator.
- 11:24Aporia, meaning a puzzle you can't solve. Yeah.
- 11:26A logical dead end. Exactly. A logical impasse.
- 11:30A roadblock for pure logic. The atheistic space
- 11:34deliberately leads to puzzles that reason alone
- 11:38cannot solve. And that's the whole point. Why?
- 11:41What's the goal of that? Because it forces the
- 11:44human intellect to pursue what Ferrani calls
- 11:46its homecoming. It's about realizing it has a
- 11:49home in the divine and trying to listen for that
- 11:52signal, even if it can't fully decode it yet.
- 11:54So instead of shutting out the spooky stuff or
- 11:57the divine stuff because it doesn't fit our neat
- 11:59scientific model, we deliberately open a door.
- 12:02We create this meeting place, the atheistic,
- 12:04where we can listen to what he calls voices that
- 12:07are near yet emanate from a place beyond. It's
- 12:10like tuning an old radio. You're trying to find
- 12:12a frequency you didn't even believe existed.
- 12:14And you have to be very quiet and very patient
- 12:16to even hear the static. And this is where it
- 12:18gets really practical for our listeners who care
- 12:20about interfaith dialogue. Because usually when
- 12:22we enter a dialogue, we keep our secular shields
- 12:25up. We say, that is your truth, this is my truth,
- 12:28and we're just comparing cultural notes from
- 12:30a safe distance. But in the atheistic space,
- 12:32you drop the shield. You enter a common ground
- 12:35where no one owns the territory. We are both
- 12:38standing in the mystery together, looking up.
- 12:41It sounds risky. It sounds like you have to be
- 12:43willing to be fundamentally wrong about your
- 12:45own worldview. It is. It's perilous. But Ferani's
- 12:48argument is that it's the only way to truly understand.
- 12:52If you stay safe in your fortress of reason,
- 12:54you never really meet the person who lives outside
- 12:57the walls. To help us visualize this, to make
- 12:59it less abstract, Ferrani doesn't give us a textbook
- 13:02definition. He gives us biographies. He introduces
- 13:05three guides. And none of these people were traditional
- 13:08anthropologists. They didn't have PhDs in the
- 13:11field or write for academic journals. But Ferrani
- 13:13says they did the work of this deep immersion
- 13:15better than most academics ever could. They're
- 13:18such fascinating figures, three lives, three
- 13:21totally different paths, but they all converge
- 13:23on this idea of an atheistic encounter. They
- 13:26show us what this spiritual exercise actually
- 13:28looks like in practice. They really do. Okay,
- 13:31let's meet guide number one, Simone Weil. The
- 13:33threshold dweller. That's a great name for her.
- 13:36Simone Weil was a French philosopher, a mystic.
- 13:40an activist in the early 20th century, a giant
- 13:43of 20th century thought, but a very, very strange
- 13:45one. She was Jewish by birth, but was intensely
- 13:48drawn to Christianity, right? She wrote these
- 13:50beautiful, profound essays about the Christian
- 13:53mystics. She did. She even had mystical experiences
- 13:56of Christ. But, and this is the absolute key
- 13:59to understanding her, she famously refused baptism.
- 14:02She refused to officially join the Catholic Church.
- 14:05Which seems so contradictory on the surface.
- 14:07If she loved Christianity so much, why not go
- 14:09all the way? Because she wanted to stay at the
- 14:12intersection. That was her word. She said her
- 14:14vocation was to belong at the intersection of
- 14:17Christianity and everything that is not Christianity.
- 14:20Wow. She felt she had to remain on the threshold
- 14:22of the church so she could be in solidarity with
- 14:24the outsider, with the heretic, with the unbeliever,
- 14:27with the vast majority of humanity that wasn't
- 14:29Christian. She felt that by joining the club,
- 14:32she would be separating herself from the rest
- 14:34of the world she loved. That is a profound act
- 14:37of solidarity. It's almost like she didn't want
- 14:40the comfort of being in siege. She chose to stay
- 14:43out in the cold with everyone else. It went further
- 14:46than just labels. It was physical. During World
- 14:49War II, when she was living in safety in England,
- 14:51she refused to eat more than the meager rations
- 14:54that were being given to people in Nazi -occupied
- 14:56France. She literally starved herself to death.
- 15:00Out of solidarity. She did. And that's what makes
- 15:02her such a powerful guide. This is not just participant
- 15:05observation. This is dying with your subjects.
- 15:08And her key concept for us is attention. Attention.
- 15:12And sounds so simple. Pay attention. We tell
- 15:14our kids that all the time. Pay attention in
- 15:16class. But for a while, attention was a spiritual
- 15:18discipline of the highest order. It wasn't just
- 15:21focus. It wasn't just concentrating on a math
- 15:23problem. She wrote, and this is an amazing line,
- 15:26studies are nearer to God because the attention,
- 15:29which is their soul. The soul of studies is attention.
- 15:32For her, true attention meant suspending your
- 15:34own thought, actively emptying your mind, leaving
- 15:38the soul, as she put it, empty and ready to be
- 15:40penetrated by the object. Ready to be penetrated
- 15:43by the object. That is the exact opposite of
- 15:45the trap Rilkes was talking about. It's not about
- 15:48grabbing the world. It's about letting the world
- 15:49grab you. It's making yourself a blank slate.
- 15:52Exactly. It's a radical, vulnerable openness.
- 15:55And think about what that means in an interfaith
- 15:58context. When you listen to someone of another
- 16:01faith, are you analyzing them? Are you mentally
- 16:05forming your counter -argument? Are you categorizing
- 16:08them? Or are you just quiet? Or are you emptying
- 16:11yourself so completely that their reality can
- 16:14actually enter you? That's Weil's lesson. True
- 16:17understanding requires an empty soul. You have
- 16:20to shut up, not just with your mouth, but with
- 16:22your mind. Okay, that's a high bar. Let's move
- 16:24to guide number two, Martin Buber. The Bridge
- 16:27Builder. Buber was a Jewish philosopher born
- 16:30in Vienna who eventually moved to Jerusalem.
- 16:32And likewise, he was a fascinating outsider.
- 16:34He wasn't quite a political Zionist. He wasn't
- 16:36orthodox in his religious practice. He always
- 16:39stood in between different worlds. And his big
- 16:41famous concept is I -thou. Even people who haven't
- 16:44read philosophy have probably heard of I and
- 16:46thou. Yes. Buber's whole philosophy is that all
- 16:50life is meeting. He makes this crucial distinction
- 16:52between I -it relationships and I -thou relationships.
- 16:56Okay, what's the difference? In an I -it relationship,
- 16:58I treat you as an object, a thing. You are a
- 17:02means to an end. You're a waiter who brings me
- 17:04coffee, a voter who gives me power, a research
- 17:07subject who gives me data for my book. I experience
- 17:10you, but I don't truly meet you. But I -thou
- 17:12is different. I -thou is a genuine encounter.
- 17:15I meet you not as a collection of traits, but
- 17:17as a whole unique universe. And Buber believed
- 17:20that in every true I -thou encounter between
- 17:23two people, there is a glimpse of the eternal
- 17:26thou. which is his word for God. And this wasn't
- 17:29just abstract armchair philosophy for him. He
- 17:31was living this in Jerusalem during incredibly
- 17:33turbulent times, the lead up to 1948 and beyond.
- 17:36He was actively trying to build bridges between
- 17:38Jews and Arabs, between Israelis and Palestinians,
- 17:40when everything was actively falling apart. He
- 17:43was. He saw the sociologist or the anthropologist
- 17:46not as a spokesperson for a group, but as a partner
- 17:49with God and the world. He believed Revelation
- 17:52wasn't just something that happened once on Mount
- 17:54Sinai thousands of years ago. He said revelation
- 17:57whispers to us in the course of every ordinary
- 18:00day. The divine presence is here now in our meetings
- 18:04with each other. Exactly. The divine presence
- 18:07dwells among us. So for Buber, dialogue is an
- 18:10existential demand. It's not just a nice thing
- 18:12to do. It's a fundamental way of being alive.
- 18:14If you aren't doing it, you aren't fully human.
- 18:16If you aren't truly meeting the other, you're
- 18:18just bumping into objects in the dark. Well said.
- 18:21Which brings us to guide number three, and he's
- 18:24arguably the most adventurous of the bunch, Muhammad
- 18:26Assad. The desert wanderer. Assad's life story
- 18:30is just incredible. He was born Leopold Weiss
- 18:32into a Jewish family in what is now Lviv, Ukraine.
- 18:36Grew up in Vienna. He was a journalist, a traveler.
- 18:38He goes to the Middle East in the 1920s and just
- 18:41feels this irresistible pull, this urge to wander.
- 18:44And he ends up converting to Islam and writing
- 18:48one of the most famous and respected English
- 18:50commentaries on the Quran. He goes from Leopold
- 18:52Weiss to Muhammad Assad. A massive, total transformation.
- 18:57And his key concept for us is surrender. Islam,
- 19:01of course, means surrender. It does. And his
- 19:03own story of conversion is so telling. He didn't
- 19:06sit down with a spreadsheet and logically deduce
- 19:09that Islam was the most correct religion. He
- 19:11describes faith coming to him like a robber who
- 19:14enters a house by night. That is a wild image
- 19:17for finding religion, a robber. It implies a
- 19:20kind of violence or at least a complete lack
- 19:22of control, an intrusion. It implies he was overtaken.
- 19:25He was defenseless. He didn't find faith. Faith
- 19:27found him. It broke in. And this connects directly
- 19:30to his view of knowledge. He spent years living
- 19:33with Bedouins in the Arabian Desert. And he deeply
- 19:35critiqued the Western way of trying to conquer
- 19:37knowledge. He called it intellectual rape. Yikes.
- 19:40Those are very strong words. But he meant that
- 19:42we try to force the world to give up its secrets,
- 19:45to grab what we want from it. Incredibly strong.
- 19:47He argued that to bridge a cultural distance,
- 19:49you shouldn't try to conquer the culture. You
- 19:51have to surrender our senses to it. You have
- 19:54to let the desert strip away your Western defenses.
- 19:56You have to let the cultural distance overwhelm
- 19:58you, not the other way around. So we have Vile
- 20:00emptying her soul, Buber meeting the Thao, and
- 20:03Asad surrendering his senses. All three of them
- 20:06are talking about lowering the defenses of that
- 20:08sovereign self. They're all talking about a kind
- 20:11of profound vulnerability. Precisely. They are
- 20:15the living models for what Firani wants anthropology,
- 20:18and by extension, all of us, to become. They
- 20:21show us that to really know the other, you have
- 20:23to risk the self. You can't stay safe on the
- 20:25shore and still understand the ocean. So Frani
- 20:28takes these lives, these models, and he tries
- 20:30to systematize them into a new way of doing things.
- 20:33He breaks this down into five facets of transforming
- 20:35the practice. If we really want to adopt this
- 20:38atheistic approach, what do we actually do differently?
- 20:41Right. It's one thing to have these inspiring
- 20:43biographies. It's another thing entirely to have
- 20:45a method. So let's walk through these five facets
- 20:48because they provide a kind of roadmap for this
- 20:50spiritual exercise. Okay. Facet number one, method.
- 20:54He talks about immersion as a way of life. Currently
- 20:58in anthropology, immersion is a tool. It's something
- 21:02you do for fieldwork. You get a grant. You go
- 21:05live in a village in the Amazon or a neighborhood
- 21:07in Cairo for a year. You take notes. You try
- 21:10to behave like a local. And then you pack your
- 21:12bags. You go home to your comfortable university
- 21:13office and you write your book. Exactly. It's
- 21:16a project. It has a start and an end date. It's
- 21:18a 9 -to -5 logic, essentially. You dip in and
- 21:21you dip out. It's professional. You don't bring
- 21:23the jungle home with you, usually. Verani argues
- 21:25that for the atheistic seeker, immersion has
- 21:28to be a logic for living. It's 224 -7. It's existential.
- 21:34Think of Weil again. She didn't just study the
- 21:36working class. She became a factory worker. She
- 21:39wanted to disappear into the crowd, to love them
- 21:41as they are. So the shift is that the researcher
- 21:44doesn't just produce a text and ethnography as
- 21:48the end product. They consciously reorient their
- 21:51entire life. The product is the life that they
- 21:54live. It's a total commitment. The research never
- 21:56really ends. It sounds exhausting, to be honest.
- 21:59It sounds like there's no off switch. But I get
- 22:01the point. OK, facet number two, form of knowledge.
- 22:05He calls this revelatory thinking. This goes
- 22:08right back to Assad's robber. In the secular
- 22:10academy, we believe we construct knowledge. We
- 22:13build theories like we build houses. We stack
- 22:16the bricks of data. We apply the mortar of analysis.
- 22:19And we have a structure. A nice solid theory.
- 22:21Farhani says we need to learn the art of letting
- 22:23go. We need what he calls docility. Docility.
- 22:27That word usually has a negative connotation
- 22:29like being a doormat or a passive sheep. But
- 22:32here it takes on a different meaning. It means
- 22:34being teachable. Being quiet enough to hear.
- 22:37It's about listening to the unsaid and unsayable.
- 22:40It requires silence and patience. We are waiting
- 22:43for the truth to speak to us rather than interrogating
- 22:45the truth until it confesses. It's a shift from
- 22:48active construction to active reception. It's
- 22:51admitting that maybe the truth is shy, and if
- 22:54you shout at it with your theories, it's not
- 22:56going to come out and talk to you. I love that.
- 22:58The truth is shy. That's perfect. Okay, facet
- 23:00number three, object of knowing. What are we
- 23:03actually studying with this new method? This
- 23:05is a direct critique of Emile Durkheim, one of
- 23:08the founding fathers of sociology. Durkheim famously
- 23:11and reductively equated God with society. Right.
- 23:15The idea that when people are worshiping God,
- 23:17they're really just worshiping the collective
- 23:19power of their own social group. God is just
- 23:22us, shouted really loudly. Exactly. So sociologists
- 23:25study the social and they think they've successfully
- 23:28explained away the divine. Ferani says no. Stop.
- 23:31Do not confuse the social with the divine. That
- 23:34is a massive category error. So what are the
- 23:36new objects of study? The new objects of study
- 23:38in this spiritual exercise are things that exceed
- 23:41our human categories. God. Evil. Death. Existence
- 23:45itself. The big stuff. The scary stuff. The stuff
- 23:48that sovereign reason tries to ignore or explain
- 23:51away as just cultural constructs or psychological
- 23:54phenomena. Frani calls it the quandary puzzle
- 23:57menace of the unreasonable. We have to be willing
- 24:00to face the fact that some things are beyond
- 24:02our tidy social explanations. We have to look
- 24:04at evil not just as a social dysfunction, but
- 24:07as a real menacing force. We have to look at
- 24:10existence as a miracle, not just a biological
- 24:13fact. Facet number four, location. Where does
- 24:16all this happen? And here, Ferrani gets a little,
- 24:18well, so spicy. He has some harsh words for the
- 24:21university. Devils. He does not pull any punches
- 24:23here. He, along with his guide Martin Buber,
- 24:26is deeply skeptical of the modern academy. Buber
- 24:28called academic scholarship drudgery. He was
- 24:31terrified of becoming a university lecturer and
- 24:33losing his spiritual vitality. Ferrani goes even
- 24:36further. He describes the university as a place
- 24:38of intellecticide. Intellecticide. The murder
- 24:41of the intellect. That is a pretty harsh accusation
- 24:43for a tenured professor to make about his own
- 24:46workplace. It is. He argues that the modern university
- 24:49is obsessed with security. It's modeled on the
- 24:52market. It's about production, grants, safety,
- 24:55rankings, avoiding lawsuits. And he asks this
- 24:58really provocative question. Can the university
- 25:01serve manna and manna, spiritual nourishment,
- 25:04or can it only serve? mammon money and markets.
- 25:08And he connects this directly to the current
- 25:10political moment, doesn't he? He mentions the
- 25:12inability of universities to protest genocides,
- 25:15and he's specifically referencing the war in
- 25:18Gaza. He does. He sees the market modeled university
- 25:21as fundamentally cowardly. It cannot speak truth
- 25:24to power because it's too beholden to that power
- 25:26for funding and prestige. It's staffed by what
- 25:29he calls security minded people. So the location
- 25:32of this spiritual exercise might have to be on
- 25:35the margins of the institution or at least in
- 25:36constant tension with it. You can't just be a
- 25:38comfortable academic. You have to be a bit of
- 25:40a rebel. Which brings us to the final one, facet
- 25:43number five, the knowing subject. That's us.
- 25:45That's the person doing the studying. How do
- 25:48we change? This is the culmination, the transformation.
- 25:51The seeker must acknowledge their own fragility.
- 25:54They have to admit they are dependent. The subject
- 25:56becomes a vessel. The outcome isn't just that
- 25:59you see the world differently or that you publish
- 26:01a new paper. The outcome is that you become somewhat
- 26:03different. You are the experiment. You are not
- 26:06just a brain in a jar analyzing the world. You
- 26:09are a soul in the world being changed by it.
- 26:11That's it. Exactly. So we have this really robust,
- 26:15really demanding framework, the atheistic. Now
- 26:17I want to pivot and apply it very specifically.
- 26:20What does this mean for our listeners who are
- 26:22trying to navigate a world full of different
- 26:24religions, different beliefs? We have a source
- 26:27here, a blog post summary titled, What if interfaith
- 26:30dialogue were a spiritual exercise? explicitly
- 26:34applies Verani's ideas to this field. And this
- 26:38is where the rubber really meets the road. If
- 26:40we apply this atheistic lens to the way we do
- 26:42interfaith dialogue, we see three huge challenging
- 26:45shifts. And these are shifts that really challenge
- 26:48the way most of us think about getting along
- 26:50with our neighbors of different faiths. Let's
- 26:52take them one by one. Shift number one, from
- 26:55information to formation. We touched on this,
- 26:58but let's go deeper. Most interfaith work, as
- 27:01we said, is informational. Here is my holy book.
- 27:04Here is yours. Here is my holiday. Here is yours.
- 27:08I don't eat pork. You don't eat beef. It's safe.
- 27:10It's polite. It's about correcting misconceptions
- 27:13and building tolerance. It's basically a show
- 27:15and tell or a Wikipedia exchange. Did you know
- 27:18that in my religion, we do this? And that has
- 27:21value. Let's be clear. We need to know those
- 27:23facts. But Farhani's framework implies it's not
- 27:26enough. The dialogue must be formational. It
- 27:30must be about changing who you are. The challenge
- 27:32becomes, are we willing to let the other's reality
- 27:35make a genuine claim on us? What does that look
- 27:38like in practice? It means when I sit down with
- 27:40a Buddhist, I'm not just listening to learn about
- 27:42the Four Noble Truths. I'm willing to let their
- 27:45understanding of suffering fundamentally challenge
- 27:47my own comfort and my own attachments. When I
- 27:50sit with a Muslim, I'm willing to let their discipline
- 27:53of daily prayer expose my own spiritual laziness.
- 27:55So it's moving from that's interesting to that
- 27:58convicts me. It's letting the other person be
- 28:01a mirror that shows you your own flaws, your
- 28:03own gaps, your own spiritual poverty. Correct.
- 28:06It transforms dialogue from a polite coffee chat
- 28:09into a spiritual workout. It's supposed to be
- 28:12hard. Okay, shift number two. This feels like
- 28:15the hardest one for... modern secular people
- 28:17taking revelation seriously it is absolutely
- 28:20the most dangerous one in normal secular dialogue
- 28:24we bracket truth we have this unspoken agreement
- 28:27we say that is your truth and this is my truth
- 28:30we act like we're in a museum looking at different
- 28:32paintings we can appreciate the art without believing
- 28:35it depicts reality we can say oh what a beautiful
- 28:37myth that is But the atheistic approach says
- 28:40you have to get out of the museum. You have to
- 28:42grapple with the possibility that the other is
- 28:44holding a piece of divine truth. Exactly. Remember
- 28:47Muhammad Assad? When he picked up the Quran,
- 28:49he wasn't appreciating it as great Arabian literature.
- 28:52He was facing the terrifying possibility that
- 28:54this was divine speech. The risk here is real
- 28:57and it is total. This framework implies that
- 29:00genuine dialogue might reconstitute your identity.
- 29:03What do you mean by that? I mean, you might convert.
- 29:06Or you might be so radically transformed in your
- 29:09own faith that you become unrecognizable to your
- 29:13old self. It takes all the safety rails off.
- 29:16If I really truly listen to you with that why
- 29:19-like attention, I might not come back as the
- 29:21same person. I might realize that you are right
- 29:24and I am wrong about the fundamental nature of
- 29:26the universe. That is the price of admission
- 29:29to the atheistic encounter. If you aren't willing
- 29:32to risk your own worldview, you aren't really
- 29:34engaging. You're just observing from a safe distance.
- 29:36You're still in the cage. Which brings us to
- 29:38shift number three, the atopic meeting place.
- 29:42This is the idea of the common ground. But it's
- 29:46not a common ground where we water everything
- 29:47down to the lowest common denominator, some kind
- 29:50of vague, we're all spiritual mush. Right, not
- 29:52that. It is a space of that agnostic ascent we
- 29:55talked about. We don't have to agree on doctrine.
- 29:57You can be a Christian. I can be a Jew. Someone
- 29:59else can be a Muslim. But we must agree that
- 30:03there is divine order worth listening to. We
- 30:06meet in that shared humility. We meet in the
- 30:09powerful agreement that we are not the center
- 30:11of the universe. It's like we both agree to look
- 30:14up at the sky, even if we see totally different
- 30:17constellations. We just agree that the sky is
- 30:19there and it's bigger and more mysterious than
- 30:22both of us. That is a beautiful way to put it.
- 30:24We share the awe. even if we describe the source
- 30:27of that awe differently. Now, this all sounds
- 30:29very noble, very poetic. I'm almost ready to
- 30:32sign up for the Antheistic Club, but this is
- 30:35a deep dive, and we don't just accept things
- 30:37at face value. Ferroni's paper received some
- 30:39very serious, very sharp pushback from other
- 30:42scholars in the field. Oh, absolutely. And these
- 30:44critiques are really important because they poke
- 30:46holes in this potentially romantic vision. They
- 30:48ask the tough, necessary questions. They do.
- 30:51The responses published in Current Anthropology
- 30:54were pointed. They raise critical questions about
- 30:57privilege, about violence, and about the very
- 31:00definition of what it means to be spiritual.
- 31:02Okay, let's get into it. Critique number one
- 31:04comes from Yasmin Moll, an anthropologist at
- 31:07the University of Michigan. She points out a
- 31:09divide between the religious and the spiritual.
- 31:12And Moll makes a very grounded, practical point.
- 31:15She essentially says, look Khalid, many of us
- 31:18anthropologists are already religious people.
- 31:20They pray. They go to mosque or church or synagogue.
- 31:23They do anthropology to pay the bills. They don't
- 31:26need their academic discipline to be their church.
- 31:28Right. She's basically saying, I have a rich
- 31:30spiritual life. Thank you very much. I don't
- 31:33need my fieldwork to provide my fullness of being.
- 31:35I have a prayer rug for that. Exactly. Why burden
- 31:38the job with the monumental task of saving your
- 31:41soul? But she goes deeper. She offers a correction
- 31:44on Farhani's reading of Muhammad Asad. She argues
- 31:47that Assad didn't seek agnostic assent or wonder.
- 31:50He sought certitude, he found Islam, and he was
- 31:53sure about it. He wasn't just hanging out in
- 31:56the atheistic space enjoying the mystery. He
- 31:58bought the house. He moved in. Right. She suggests
- 32:01Farhani might be romanticizing the seeking part,
- 32:04the wandering, the questioning over the finding
- 32:07part. For many, many religious people, the goal
- 32:10isn't to wander forever in a beautiful mystery.
- 32:13The goal is to arrive at the truth with a capital
- 32:16T. So Maul is asking if this atheistic space
- 32:19is just a projection of a liberal, academic kind
- 32:22of spirituality that values the question more
- 32:25than the answer. It's a great point. It's easy
- 32:28to love the question when you don't have to commit
- 32:30to an answer that might demand things of you.
- 32:32Okay, a very strong critique. Critique number
- 32:35two comes from Elaine Oliphant and Joel Robbins.
- 32:38They bring up the problem of the divine. This
- 32:41is the dark side argument. Ferrani talks about
- 32:43the divine, about revelation as this source of
- 32:45oneness. connection and transformation. It all
- 32:48sounds lovely. But Oliphant and Robbins remind
- 32:50us, revelation isn't always benign. Not at all.
- 32:53History is absolutely full of violent revelations.
- 32:55God told me to smite you. God told me this land
- 32:58is mine and you and your people have to leave.
- 33:00Yeah, hearing voices from beyond isn't always
- 33:02a recipe for world peace. Sometimes it's a recipe
- 33:05for a crusade or a genocide. Exactly. If we open
- 33:08the door of reason to revelation, how do we distinguish
- 33:12between the wister of the divine and a dangerous
- 33:14delusion or a malicious call to violence ferrani
- 33:18talks about the need for discernment but robbins
- 33:21points out he doesn't really explain how we discern
- 33:23what's the test and they also point out a glaring
- 33:26exclusion in his examples ferrani's models vile
- 33:30buber assad are all abrahamic they're all monotheistic
- 33:33they deal with a big god what about everything
- 33:37else right what about ancestors what about nature
- 33:40spirits what about polytheism oliphant asks does
- 33:43Does atheism exclude an indigenous worldview
- 33:45of the spirit world because it's too focused
- 33:47on a divine order or revelation in the Jewish,
- 33:50Christian, or Muslim sense? If my reality is
- 33:53populated by forest spirits, do I fit in Farani's
- 33:56club? That's a heavy critique. If we're trying
- 33:58to escape the secular cage, are we just jumping
- 34:01into a slightly larger monotheistic cage? Are
- 34:03we just trading one Western -centric bias for
- 34:05another? It's a real danger. They warn that we
- 34:08can't ignore the violent history of Christian
- 34:10and European concepts of religion and the divine
- 34:13being imposed on other cultures. We have to be
- 34:16incredibly careful not to universalize a specific
- 34:19kind of God talk. And then we have critique number
- 34:22three from Omer Ibrahim. This one hits on the
- 34:25very real issues of power and privilege. And
- 34:28Ibrahim asks the deeply uncomfortable question,
- 34:31who gets to surrender? who can actually afford
- 34:34to dissolve their ego right if you're a tenured
- 34:37professor at a prestigious western university
- 34:39maybe it feels romantic and liberating to surrender
- 34:42your ego but if you are marginalized if you're
- 34:46oppressed if your ego is attacked every day then
- 34:48effacing your ego might sound a lot like just
- 34:51giving up the little power you have Precisely.
- 34:53He warns that this call for ego effacement can
- 34:56be a colonial trick. It's easy for a privileged
- 34:58scholar to talk about surrendering to the other.
- 35:00But for a colonized subject, survival might require
- 35:03the exact opposite. Asserting the self, building
- 35:06up the ego, not dissolving it. He asks whose
- 35:09temporality we're operating on. Is the researcher's
- 35:11spiritual journey happening at the expense of
- 35:13the people being studied? It's the eat, pray,
- 35:16love problem, isn't it? Am I using your culture,
- 35:19your reality, as a kind of exotic backdrop for
- 35:22my own personal enlightenment project? It's a
- 35:24potent and necessary question. Ibrahim reminds
- 35:27us that spirituality doesn't happen in a political
- 35:30vacuum. It happens in a world of very real power
- 35:32dynamics. So Farhani gets hit with these critiques
- 35:35from all sides. Elitism, exclusion, romanticism,
- 35:39naivete about violence. Does he just roll over?
- 35:41No. He writes a defense, a rebuttal. And this
- 35:44is where the context gets incredibly... real
- 35:46and raw. He is writing from Tel Aviv and Jerusalem
- 35:49during what he calls the Al -Aqsa flood, the
- 35:52war in Gaza that started in October 2023. And
- 35:55this context is inescapable for him. He frames
- 35:57his entire response using the metaphor of the
- 35:59flood. The biblical flood, Noah's flood. Yes.
- 36:02He asks how that ancient story names our current
- 36:05time, a flood that is washing away truths and
- 36:07untruths alike. What does he say? He says we
- 36:26desperately need big universal stories. He argues
- 36:29that in the face of what he calls the disintegrating
- 36:31powers of capitalism and war, small local stories
- 36:35aren't enough. If we just retreat into our little
- 36:37tribes, our little identities, we will be crushed
- 36:40by the massive machinery of war and markets.
- 36:43So for him, universalism isn't the oppressor.
- 36:46It's the life raft. In his view, yes. He says
- 36:49we need big stories, a universal vision of humanity
- 36:52and the divine to counter the big destructive
- 36:54force. that are tearing the world apart. And
- 36:57then, addressing Ibrahim's powerful point about
- 36:59power, Farhani argues that the atheistic can
- 37:01be the lot of the defeated. It isn't just a luxury
- 37:04for the privileged. How so? How does that work?
- 37:06He suggests that the spirituality of the oppressed
- 37:09is a real and powerful thing. He says that this
- 37:12atheistic mode, this radical openness to the
- 37:15divine, might actually work better for those
- 37:18who are crushed, for those who are, in his words,
- 37:20working and thinking from lost, unpromising places.
- 37:24For them, it is a way to survive. the siege.
- 37:26The siege. That leads to his final powerful provocation.
- 37:30He says the university and sovereign secular
- 37:32reason itself are a siege on the human intellect.
- 37:35They're surrounding us, blockading us, starving
- 37:38us of meaning. And he closes by quoting the great
- 37:40Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish who wrote, by
- 37:43taking this journey you can besiege your siege.
- 37:46Besiege your siege. That is an incredible image.
- 37:48It means turning the tables on your captor. It
- 37:51means that by opening up to the divine, by refusing
- 37:54to be trapped in the pure material secular world,
- 37:56the intellect frees itself. It breaks the blockade.
- 38:00It pursues its divine possibilities even, and
- 38:02especially amidst dark times. It is an act of
- 38:06intellectual and spiritual resistance. So, we
- 38:09have traveled all the way from Rilke's secular
- 38:12cage through Furani's atheistic space, guided
- 38:16by Veal, Buber, and Assad. We've faced the tough
- 38:20critiques, and we've looked at the profound implications
- 38:22for how we talk to one another. We've seen how
- 38:25this one idea challenges the academy, challenges
- 38:28interfaith dialogue, and ultimately challenges
- 38:31us personally. It has been quite a journey. Yeah.
- 38:34And it really does leave us with a lot to chew
- 38:36on. I think the biggest takeaway for me and maybe
- 38:38for you listening is about this idea of the courage
- 38:41to be transformed. It's about realizing that
- 38:44knowing things isn't enough. You have to risk
- 38:46being someone new. Yes. And that true knowledge,
- 38:50this kind of knowledge comes with a real cost.
- 38:52It costs you your certainty. It costs you your
- 38:54defenses. It costs you the illusion of control.
- 38:57So here's my final question to you, the listener.
- 38:59The next time you find yourself in a conversation
- 39:01with someone who sees the universe in a fundamentally
- 39:04different way than you do, maybe they're from
- 39:06a different faith maybe they have no faith at
- 39:07all ask yourself this are you analyzing them
- 39:10are you just collecting data points for your
- 39:12mental map of the world or you being attentive
- 39:15or are you willing to let their reality truly
- 39:18enter you are you willing to be in a sense besieged
- 39:21by their truth because maybe true understanding
- 39:24isn't just about safety or tolerance maybe it's
- 39:27about the profound risk and the profound reward
- 39:30of being changed and on that note We'll leave
- 39:33you to your own spiritual exercises. Thanks for
- 39:35diving deep with us.