Latest / Film And Whiskey / Independence Day / Willett Pot Still Reserve Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 1996, director Roland Emmerich and star Bill Pullman
- 0:04gave the world an explosive foray into Third Kind Encounters
- 0:08and how awesome America can truly be.
- 0:12In 2024 we try one of the most contentious bourbons on the
- 0:16market. The film is Independence Day.
- 0:19The whiskey is will it pot still reserved.
- 0:22And we'll review them both. This is the film and whiskey.
- 0:27Podcast Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:47Podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:50glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:52I'm Brad G. And Brad, there has never been a
- 0:56better time to be an American. Because today we are talking
- 1:00about perhaps the most American movie ever made, 1996's
- 1:04Independence Day, a film that for a time, and that time, you
- 1:09know, in parentheses. That time is when I was seven
- 1:11years old, but for a time was my favorite film ever made.
- 1:16I believe it, man. It's it's a hell of a movie.
- 1:18It's so good, dude. It's so good and it's also so
- 1:23bad. And I don't think I've ever
- 1:25watched this movie through the critical lens that I watch
- 1:29movies on this podcast. And I turned it on this time and
- 1:32I was like, oh, this is like truly bad at parts.
- 1:36And also, I am having a complete blast watching this movie.
- 1:40It's so good. I'm glad that you've come to
- 1:43that place, Bob, otherwise this may have been.
- 1:46A. Very contentious episode.
- 1:51The I think that we're just going to be on opposite ends of
- 1:54the bell curve. Like if you're if you're in like
- 1:57the 70th percentile of people who love this movie, I think I
- 2:01might be in like the 30th, 40th where I'm like the the parts
- 2:05that work in this movie I do enjoy and they're they're
- 2:09ridiculous and over the top and funny.
- 2:12But a solid 50 to 70% of this film could have been left on the
- 2:17cutting room floor. I'll tell you what, man.
- 2:21I think you're being very generous because if you truly
- 2:23believe that 70% of the movie should have been cut, that that
- 2:27signals a pretty bad movie to me.
- 2:29It could have been a short film. All right.
- 2:33Well, as we get into our episode today, I just want to say if
- 2:35this is your first time joining us, don't leave yet.
- 2:38I'm going to praise Independence Day, as we all know it should be
- 2:41done. You never know, Bob, that that
- 2:43might drive some people away. That's.
- 2:45True. Well, you can hear Brad talk
- 2:46about the 30% that worked. If this is your first time
- 2:50joining us, welcome into film and whiskey.
- 2:52What we do here is we talk about movies and we talk about
- 2:56whiskey. And this season we are, we're
- 2:58changing things up a little bit. Not that we're replacing films
- 3:01or whiskey, but typically we look at movies that are
- 3:04considered classics of books. And wine books and books.
- 3:09Typically we look at movies that are considered classics of their
- 3:12genre. And I mean, perhaps Independence
- 3:15Day is considered a classic of some genre, but this year what
- 3:18we're doing is we're going year by year from 1988 to 2019 and
- 3:24looking at the highest grossing films of those years.
- 3:27Now Brad, remind me, is Independence Day actually the
- 3:30number one highest grossing film of 96?
- 3:34I don't believe it is. See.
- 3:36I thought it might have been because I.
- 3:37What? Let me look.
- 3:38OK. OK.
- 3:39And while you look, I'll keep vamping, but every now and then
- 3:42we run into this situation where we're not actually watching the
- 3:44highest grossing film because we've already reviewed that.
- 3:47But we are looking at huge blockbuster money makers.
- 3:50And Independence Day in a lot of ways kind of exemplifies the
- 3:55summer blockbuster of the 1990s. This movie was a money printing
- 4:00machine and I feel like it's one of those movies that it didn't
- 4:04really have much of A footprint at the Oscars or anything like
- 4:07that. But everyone in America saw this
- 4:10movie, and I remember it being just absolutely everywhere when
- 4:14we were kids. So I'm excited to dive into this
- 4:16one. Brad, what are you getting on
- 4:18this one? Well, the IMDb is only showing
- 4:22domestic, it's not showing foreign take.
- 4:25So according to IMD BS 1996 Worldwide Box Office, this is
- 4:30the number one grossing film we did it with with 306,000,000,
- 4:35followed by Twister and Mission Impossible.
- 4:39What a freaking year. Yeah, Jerry Maguire at 4.
- 4:43Ransom at five, 101 Dalmatians at six.
- 4:46Look at that. Well, we had a good top five at
- 4:47least. Never heard of Ransom?
- 4:52It's a Mel Gibson movie where he, his kid gets taken and he
- 4:55kills a lot of people. It's freaking great.
- 4:57OK, yeah, it sounds like there's a a theme here.
- 5:01Have you seen Twister? I've not seen Twister.
- 5:04They're making a sequel to it. I just saw the commercial during
- 5:07the Super Bowl. It has Glenn Powell.
- 5:08I'm I'm very excited for Glenn Powell.
- 5:10I was tornadoes Glenn Powell's your like your your rags to
- 5:15riches hope story for a new superstar movie star.
- 5:19I know he had to overcome looking like that to become the
- 5:21movie star that he is now. Speaking of sequels, I have very
- 5:26important news for you, Bob. No, what's that, Brad?
- 5:30I have finally gotten around to watching the film you've begged
- 5:34me to watch for three years now. I watched Deniz Dune.
- 5:42You know what else is even bigger news?
- 5:45In the last three days, I too have watched Deniz Dune.
- 5:50Have you now? Are you getting ready for Dune?
- 5:52Two I am, yeah. There's a there's a screening
- 5:54coming up in like a week. I'm very, very excited for it.
- 5:56I wanted to refresh myself. Interesting movie Brad, because
- 6:00I saw it in the theater and it was like mind blowing.
- 6:03I saw it on the small screen and I was like I I really like when
- 6:08film makers take sci-fi seriously and you can tell the
- 6:12scope and the scale of this movie is massive and the the
- 6:16shot composition is designed for a 40 foot wall with an image
- 6:21projected on it. It doesn't quite translate as
- 6:25well on the small screen. I I came out of this one like
- 6:28that was like a 7/7 and 1/2 and I when I saw it in the theater,
- 6:31I was like, that's an 8 1/2. Yeah, that's exactly where I
- 6:34was. I I, I I want to see Dune 2 in
- 6:38theaters. It also made me want to read the
- 6:40books. It it gave me just enough to
- 6:42make to pique my interest. I think the biggest problem with
- 6:46Dune was just that they got caught into the trap of world
- 6:51building and they didn't lean into what Lord of the Rings does
- 6:55and help you fall in love with the characters and.
- 6:58And I think that was my biggest problem with it is like Oscar
- 7:02Isaac is busy dying and I'm kind of like like I don't, I don't
- 7:06really care about him at all. Like, all of the characters in
- 7:09this movie are unlikable and the action is great.
- 7:13And like, the the world building is pretty cool.
- 7:16Like there's these creepy witches and there's a bunch of
- 7:19different houses and there's an unseen emperor that's apparently
- 7:22going to be played by Christopher Walken which led to
- 7:26no end of ridiculous imitations of what the emperor would be
- 7:31saying as Christopher Walken. But yeah, it was a good time.
- 7:37Had a good time with friends overall was somewhat unimpressed
- 7:41with the film as a whole. But it it's a Denny like the the
- 7:46floor for that film is A7. And like you said in theaters.
- 7:49I can easily go, yeah, that's that's an 8 to 9 out of 10 movie
- 7:54in theaters. Well see Brad, The thing is when
- 7:57you talk about how that movie failed to do world building,
- 7:59right, you forgot to mention that the alternative to a world
- 8:03building movie is a movie where aliens come and just blow up
- 8:06your world. And that's what we have today.
- 8:08And that's why Independence Day hot take better than dude that.
- 8:15I feel like that is a hot take. It is also not my take, but I
- 8:20think that means that it is time for us to get into our first
- 8:23segment of the day, which we call Brad explains.
- 8:26Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 8:29ticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and hear your take with
- 8:32this little segment that we call.
- 8:34Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 8:37podcast where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 8:41just seen, often for the first time.
- 8:43Brad, this was your first time with Independence Day, right?
- 8:46Sure was, yeah. You were talking about the bell
- 8:48curve of enjoyment. I also think you're on the other
- 8:51end of the bell curve for me in terms of age at which you first
- 8:54watched this movie. Oh yes, and therefore the
- 8:57effectiveness of this movie. Yes.
- 9:00You also, you also gave me like an education of 250 plus films
- 9:06before I watched this. So if there's if there's anybody
- 9:10to blame for me being a little bit mad on the movie, it's your
- 9:14fault. It's.
- 9:15Ultimately, me. Yeah.
- 9:16Yeah. Now, you were talking a bit ago
- 9:18about sequels. This movie did get a sequel back
- 9:20in, oh gosh, I don't know, 20/14/2017.
- 9:24It was so forgettable that I have no idea when it came out.
- 9:27And I never saw that movie. So when you brought up sequels,
- 9:30I was like, wow, did you go watch the sequel to this movie?
- 9:35Because you would have outdone me on doing your homework on
- 9:37this film. I sure did not did it was Will
- 9:40Smith in that. I don't believe so.
- 9:42I think I know Jeff Goldblum was, but OK, but not the big
- 9:46Willie. Yeah, I will say my biggest
- 9:48surprise about Independence Day one, the the original, because I
- 9:53didn't even know there was a second one.
- 9:55My biggest surprise was that I I feel like I always had the image
- 9:59of this movie, that this was like a Will Smith blockbuster
- 10:04when in all reality he was just kind of one cog in the machine.
- 10:08Well, one piece of the puzzle. I I was very surprised by how
- 10:12little he was in the film. Well, it's time for you to
- 10:14explain that machine and the cogs within it, because you have
- 10:18one minute on the clock to spoil this film and go.
- 10:24So there weren't any aliens. And then there were and they
- 10:28wanted to kill everybody and we couldn't stop them.
- 10:32But then then Jeff Goldblum can do some crazy math stuff, and
- 10:36now we can stop them and we blow them up because they suck and
- 10:40we're awesome. And why are we awesome, Brad?
- 10:43Because we're America. That's right.
- 10:46All right, that's good enough. Let's jump into the movie
- 10:51itself. So I want to start just kind of
- 10:52from the beginning and work through this thing in the order
- 10:56that it is presented to us. So it starts with an image of
- 10:59the moon. You see the memorial that Neil
- 11:04Armstrong set up, and then all of a sudden a shadow creeps
- 11:07across the face of the moon. And what a freaking great way to
- 11:10start this movie. Incredible opening like.
- 11:14First off, you failed to mention that the opening like titles
- 11:18explode. As every film in the 90s did.
- 11:23Yeah, I was going to say there's no hiding what this movie is
- 11:25about. No, it's about watching.
- 11:27Get blown up, Brad. So OK, the movie starts with
- 11:31this, this moon thing. And very, very quickly it gets
- 11:34into the meat of the movie. Like you, you have the aliens
- 11:37showing up in these giant fireballs in the sky and
- 11:41starting to position their ships over major cities around the
- 11:45world. And we are introduced to a few
- 11:48groups of people in different cities.
- 11:50So you've got the Jeff Goldblum character in New York City.
- 11:53He is like the main tech guy at a cable company in the 90s.
- 11:57You've got Will Smith and his girlfriend and her son out in
- 12:01California. Will Smith is is it an Air Force
- 12:04pilot? Like he's like he's.
- 12:07Continually refer to him as a Marine.
- 12:08A Marine? He's a Marine pilot.
- 12:10Got it, Got it. OK, so he's, he's off base, but
- 12:13he's watching this whole thing unfold over the, you know,
- 12:16skyline of Los Angeles. And then you've got Bill Pullman
- 12:19and his circle in Washington, DC Bill Pullman is the president of
- 12:23the United States. And boy, oh boy.
- 12:26Also, just clearly say he is very obviously banging his
- 12:31assistant that like Jeff Goldblum is nervous about them
- 12:35having an affair. Like they're very obviously
- 12:38having an affair. He was right to be nervous.
- 12:40Is that what we're saying? Yes.
- 12:42Yes. OK.
- 12:45So I was going to end my little thing about, you know,
- 12:48triangulating all these three things by saying, boy, oh boy,
- 12:51is it crazy how much these three groups of people overlap
- 12:54throughout this movie. And I'm going to be honest with
- 12:57you, man, I think that the 1st 30 to 35 minutes of this movie
- 13:03are almost perfectly plotted and set up and and like,
- 13:07rhythmically they move you through each of these groups of
- 13:10people. Like, I started watching this
- 13:12movie and I had to turn it off for a couple hours and I
- 13:14stopped, like right about the 3035 minute mark.
- 13:17And the aliens had not yet blown anything up.
- 13:19But I was like, they, they're really doing a good job of
- 13:22building the suspense and the dread and the sort of ominous
- 13:25thing going on here. And I'm learning about these
- 13:28characters. And I will say that just in the
- 13:31next 15 minutes, like, you know, the aliens are going to blow
- 13:35something up because Jeff Goldblum tells you the countdown
- 13:38is on and then he tries to get in touch with his ex-wife, who
- 13:41we find out is the press secretary at the White House or
- 13:45something thereabouts. Who's totally not sleeping with
- 13:49the? President Not sleeping with the
- 13:50president, but wink, wink. And so then you get this side
- 13:54quest where Jeff Goldblum has to go to Washington, DC because he
- 13:57wants to save his wife and also tell the president about all
- 13:59this stuff. And I will say, like, as soon as
- 14:03that side quest starts, the next 15 minutes of the movie almost
- 14:08could have just been cut out, dude.
- 14:09Like. But what are you talking about,
- 14:10Bob? You get Judd Hirsch being the
- 14:13most Jewish Jew that has ever been a Jew.
- 14:16Like, offensively so. Yep.
- 14:19But also OK, so like the like, the aliens start blowing stuff
- 14:23up. I paused it 42 minutes and 40
- 14:26seconds, which is like a good chunk of the way into the movie.
- 14:30Yeah, I would say it is a really long movie.
- 14:33And I think if you cut out 30 minutes and you put that back
- 14:37about 15, get the aliens blowing stuff up 30 minutes, then I
- 14:41think you have a hell of a movie.
- 14:42And that's what I'm saying. Like, I actually thought that it
- 14:45was perfectly plotted up till 30 minutes and from 30 to 42 it it
- 14:51lost me. And I'm a guy who is like very
- 14:53firmly in the Independence Day camp.
- 14:55It lost me and I was like I made a mental note because I knew.
- 14:59I knew in my mind Brad's going to think this drags here and
- 15:02you're if you know whether you did or not, I'm going to tell
- 15:05you Brad, you are right, it does drag.
- 15:07Thanks, man. I appreciate when you tell me
- 15:10that I'm right for things that I never even.
- 15:12Told that I just assume about you, yeah.
- 15:17Yeah, I I struggled a little bit with pacing throughout the
- 15:20entire film. I I think there's definitely
- 15:22moments where you spend time with characters that I just
- 15:25don't care about. I also think that they they give
- 15:30you just enough time in the opening sequences of the film
- 15:33with certain like secondary characters that end up dying off
- 15:38just enough to get you to like them.
- 15:40And specifically, I am thinking of Harvey Fierstein, who plays
- 15:45Marty The Who has probably the most distinct voice in Hollywood
- 15:50history. Oh yeah, like as soon as you
- 15:53hear his voice, you're like, oh, I know him.
- 15:54I don't know what his name is. I I mean, I just had to look it
- 15:57up. But he is probably my favorite
- 16:01character. I wish they had killed everyone
- 16:02else off. Like they could have killed Jeff
- 16:04Goldblum off and I would have been fine.
- 16:06Keep. Harvey Fierstein alive and I
- 16:09just want to see like a Cloverfield style.
- 16:12Somehow he gets a hold of a handheld Cam and like records
- 16:16his experience of Independence Day.
- 16:20But overall, they keep the right people alive and by the time you
- 16:26get to the the ending action, you're kind of ready for
- 16:31everything to be over. And so that last bit of action
- 16:35really flies through. But you're right.
- 16:37The middle 4050% of the film, it's it's a lot, man.
- 16:44There's a lot of cheesy, cheesy acting, bad dialogue.
- 16:47Well, and I'm trying to think of exactly how to like format the
- 16:50way we talk about it. But I think the 1st place I want
- 16:53to start is, you know, in this first third of the movie,
- 16:55because the movie is divided up into July 2nd, July 3rd, July
- 16:584th. And each of those days has a
- 17:00very distinct flavor to it in terms of what kind of movie this
- 17:03is trying to be. And so the first day is very
- 17:08much your like 1970s disaster movie, which we've never really
- 17:13talked about a movie like that on this podcast, Brad.
- 17:15But there was a huge genre in the 70s.
- 17:19There's a movie called Airport that kind of kicked things off.
- 17:21And then you had like The Poseidon Adventure in The
- 17:24Towering Inferno. They were all these movies where
- 17:27like something horrible happens and we got 45 A to B list actors
- 17:33to be in this movie. And you're going to watch people
- 17:35that you know and love burn to death.
- 17:37And you never know, like who's who's next.
- 17:39And that be like would Flight of the Phoenix fall into that
- 17:42category? Probably a little bit.
- 17:44But like these were more built around like a giant, you know,
- 17:48disaster happening where every everybody mostly dies.
- 17:52Yeah, I. Remember seeing the The Poseidon
- 17:55when I was a kid and and loving that movie.
- 17:57So I think in that vein, this movie is like really paying
- 18:00homage to that. I don't know like the extent to
- 18:04which it succeeds at that, but I think the like the secondary and
- 18:08tertiary characters, I think this script does a really good
- 18:12job of setting them up with minimal exposition to make you
- 18:18like them. Like the Harvey Fierstein
- 18:19character, I really liked him. But then like some of the
- 18:23primary characters, it's like they go overboard with the back
- 18:26story and I think that's like like the Jeff Goldblum
- 18:29character. I just, I'm going to be honest
- 18:32with you, man. Like I just don't care that
- 18:33much. Like and you could have
- 18:34accomplished what you want to accomplish with like 4 less
- 18:37scenes in that first 45 minutes. Oh, all you needed was the
- 18:41opening scene with him, him playing chess with his dad,
- 18:44right? But even like the.
- 18:46Incredible scene. Even if you want to continue the
- 18:48my wife works for the president now.
- 18:50You didn't have to have like 5 scenes of them on their little
- 18:54road trip talking about like, what it means to be a man and
- 18:57regret. And like, just like I want to
- 19:00watch aliens blow things up, let's please move this along.
- 19:03Yeah, no, 100%, that's that's what I'm saying.
- 19:05Like the chess scene was great. It was sweet and established
- 19:09what their relationship is with each other.
- 19:11I I also don't feel like you needed the like Green Earth
- 19:15Warrior message coming out of Jeff Goldblum's mouth like that
- 19:20felt like an extra 12 seconds every time he does that.
- 19:22Stick and it added up. They were trying to get their
- 19:24product placement in because he was like standing next to a
- 19:27fruitopia vending machine like. And like having cans of
- 19:31Coca-Cola everywhere. Yeah, it was not my favorite
- 19:36because it added up to a solid 4 or 5 minutes of screen time of
- 19:39him recycling things. Yeah, OK.
- 19:41I I could have had that time back to do other things with my
- 19:44life. So I say all that about the
- 19:47characters that get set up well, because there is a fourth group
- 19:50of characters that I have not talked about at all yet and they
- 19:53don't like they. They seem very set apart from
- 19:56the rest. And that is Randy Quaid as crazy
- 20:00town drunk who flies a biplane and crop dusts and his.
- 20:04Was abducted by aliens 10 years ago.
- 20:07Abducted by aliens, the town crackpot, and his three children
- 20:11who are riding across, you know, the the deserts of California in
- 20:15an RV and they really want this to be Comic Relief.
- 20:21And then they want him to have a redemption arc at the end of the
- 20:23movie and it does not work. The only part of this character
- 20:29that works, and folks, you know, forgive me for spoiling a nearly
- 20:3230 year old movie here, is when he sacrifices himself at the end
- 20:35of the movie and they let him go out, still being crazy, like
- 20:40it's not overly sentimental. He's just shouts Hello boys, I'm
- 20:46back. And then you get what is no
- 20:49exaggeration, one of the 10 best explosions in the history of
- 20:53films when that freaking ship blows up.
- 20:56It's great, but I don't need Randy Quaid in any more of the
- 21:01movie than just that one part. No, it should have been the
- 21:03president. The president should have
- 21:05sacrificed himself for the good of the world.
- 21:09And they all draw around the memory of this great hero.
- 21:12He's you know top three president of all time.
- 21:14Like that's that's the Come on Bob.
- 21:17You and I should start writing scripts I.
- 21:18Know now if we're going to talk about the ending of this movie
- 21:21and whether it works, we have to get there.
- 21:23So July 2nd, the aliens arrive. Everybody's freaked out, Will
- 21:27Smith reports to Base. The president is putting stuff
- 21:29on lockdown and try not to get people freaked out.
- 21:31Jeff Goldblum's driving to Washington to have domestic
- 21:34drama inside the White House with his ex-wife.
- 21:37And then the aliens attack. And the most iconic sequence of
- 21:42this movie starts where that building in Los Angeles blows up
- 21:46the Empire State Building, blows up, the White House blows up.
- 21:49It freaking rules. Oh yeah, it is.
- 21:53And like, I'm going to be honest with you, Brad, there's only a
- 21:55few stretches of this movie where some of the effects look
- 21:59hokey. I will say that the actual like
- 22:02attack of the aliens, it holds up tremendously well almost 30
- 22:07years later. Yeah, that that's probably one
- 22:09of the few special effects area that looks great.
- 22:12I thought that the shot of the Statue of Liberty and like the
- 22:18surprisingly prescient burnt out husks of the two towers.
- 22:24That shot was incredible. Like, talk about a devastated
- 22:29America. That's it in one shot.
- 22:32And they just, they nail it. And so there there's so much of
- 22:35that initial attack that like, you can tell where they put the
- 22:40budget in this movie. And it wasn't on the script
- 22:44writers. I do want to talk just for a
- 22:48minute since we're we're on topic now.
- 22:50Like this is a pre 911 movie in which an invading force knocks
- 22:56out national landmarks and wreaks destruction and kills
- 23:00thousands of people. And in this movie it's millions.
- 23:02But. Which which also leads to peace
- 23:05in the Middle East. True.
- 23:07So at the end of the film, the Iraqis and I think the British.
- 23:13They're all working together, man.
- 23:14Yeah, they're working together, man.
- 23:15It's great. So a pre 911 movie where this
- 23:18happens and I was thinking oh like this seems very unique
- 23:21right? But actually, that's not the
- 23:23case. Like in in the 90s, there was a
- 23:25lot of movies where buildings were getting knocked over, and
- 23:28even like Godzilla, you know, the crappy 90s remake of that.
- 23:31But I don't think there's any more.
- 23:37I don't know what's the analogous thing to 911 than
- 23:41Independence Day in 90s cinema. We'll see a little bit of that
- 23:43in Armageddon, the beginning of that movie, in a couple weeks
- 23:46here. It's really interesting man.
- 23:48And it's it's it's weird to watch with a post 9/11 lens
- 23:52because I feel like when stuff like this happens now, you know
- 23:56there's a lot of superhero Movies Now where they will
- 23:59destroy a city in the final fight of the movie.
- 24:01And a a criticism of that genre is always like you.
- 24:05You can't just flippantly kill thousands of people anymore in a
- 24:09post 911 world like it just reads it.
- 24:11It feels icky, right? And I think we were, we didn't
- 24:16feel icky about this in the 90s because it hadn't happened in
- 24:18real life yet. But there is a part of me that
- 24:21wonders, like, does America's response to 911, is it inflected
- 24:27with movies like this where somebody attacks us and we
- 24:32immediately attack back and like, that's what America does?
- 24:35Do you know? Like, it's just it's very weird
- 24:37to think about what actually ends up unfolding in real
- 24:40history as a result of, or maybe not a direct result of, but, you
- 24:44know, in the wake of movies like this that came before it.
- 24:48Yeah, I mean it. It's fascinating because there
- 24:50there are a lot of films still to this day that represent
- 24:54America as like a trigger happy reactionary nation.
- 24:58Like I'm even thinking about the the monster universe.
- 25:01Like if you watch the first Godzilla from like I don't know
- 25:0420/13/2014 like Godzilla comes and our our first response is to
- 25:11new kid like like that's the immediate response.
- 25:14So I think you still see that in media.
- 25:18I was curious about the fact that they don't actually portray
- 25:22America's trigger happy in this film.
- 25:24No, no like. For the longest time, the
- 25:26president is trying to communicate they.
- 25:28I mean, I don't know if this is an homage, but it seems like an
- 25:32homage to close Encounters of the Third Kind.
- 25:35When they send up the helicopter with the.
- 25:37Yeah, like the light displays and trying to communicate.
- 25:40And I I do like that the the director and scriptwriters are
- 25:44like, we're not messing around with, like are we here for
- 25:48diplomatic relations The first time they try to communicate
- 25:52with the aliens, the aliens shoot them down without mercy
- 25:56like the like there's nothing in there.
- 25:59And and even later in the film when they kind of quasi talk to
- 26:03an alien man in a sequence that kind of reminds me of of Alien
- 26:10right when the. Anyways, when they talk to him
- 26:13there, it's like there's no nothing going on there.
- 26:16We are here to destroy your world end of story.
- 26:20And they make it so obvious that they need to retaliate that they
- 26:24retaliate. Right.
- 26:24And that's the thing that. Is an interesting take.
- 26:27And because they portray America as so justified in doing it too.
- 26:32You know what I mean? Like.
- 26:33Right. We had no other choice, right?
- 26:36So anyway, I don't want to go down that road or open that can
- 26:38of worms, but it's a it's an interesting document now post
- 26:41911. Yeah.
- 26:42Oh, and I will say like, watch it.
- 26:45It's always interesting to watch, to examine cultural
- 26:48artifacts partially just for our own emotional response.
- 26:51Like when I'm watching this and I see the burning husk of 911 of
- 26:56911. When I see the burning husk of
- 26:58the two towers in the scene following the devastation of New
- 27:01York. Like I got a little emotional.
- 27:03Bob 100%. I I remember being 11 years old
- 27:07and seeing the twin towers collapsing.
- 27:12Like there is a part of me that was like crap this is this is
- 27:15bringing something up. I yeah.
- 27:17Anyways. So the you know, there's a fade
- 27:20to black on July 2nd. After all these cities get
- 27:23absolutely annihilated, we fade up on July 3rd.
- 27:25There's going to be a counter offensive.
- 27:27We're going to send some fighter pilots up there and see what
- 27:29damage we can do. And this is really where, like
- 27:32the bulk of the movie's exposition starts.
- 27:34Because the first third is like, we don't know anything about
- 27:38them and we're operating solely based on fear and survival
- 27:40instinct. And the second day of the movie
- 27:44is where the is where the movie really drags.
- 27:47Brad like I that middle third there's some great sequences.
- 27:50Like I I think that everything that happens with Will Smith is
- 27:53well done, like the the fighter pilot stuff, the chase through
- 27:56the canyons, punching an alien in the face and saying welcome
- 27:58to Earth. This is a star making
- 28:02performance for for Will Smith and he was, you know, perhaps
- 28:06the biggest actor on TV outside of Bill Cosby with The Fresh
- 28:09Prince. He does Bad Boys in 1995.
- 28:13That's a big hit. But he like, he had not cemented
- 28:16his movie star credentials. And then this movie comes out
- 28:19and you're right, dude. Like it's remembered as a Will
- 28:22Smith movie. He is not even like, I don't
- 28:26even think he's in the movie as much as Bill Pullman is.
- 28:29No. And so, like, it says a whole
- 28:31lot about the charisma that my guy was bringing to the screen
- 28:35in 1996, that not only do we remember it as a Will Smith
- 28:39movie, but it just absolutely catapults him into the A list
- 28:44pretty much immediately. Yeah, yeah.
- 28:47I mean, at the end of the day, Bill Pullman as an actor is
- 28:52somebody that I've never heard of, Bob so.
- 28:55He's, I mean, he's been in a lot of movies, but he was never
- 28:58like, outside of this, his biggest role ever is probably
- 29:03like he was the lead in Spaceballs, like the Mel Brooks
- 29:06movie. He is.
- 29:08That's that's funny. I didn't make that connection.
- 29:12And and like, I feel like, you know, we, we haven't really
- 29:15talked about performance as much.
- 29:16So let's sprinkle some in here. Bill Pullman, when I was a kid,
- 29:20I was like, that's a president. And now I watch it and I'm like,
- 29:24that's a guy trying to do a Clint Eastwood gruff voice.
- 29:28And I don't know why he's doing that voice the whole movie.
- 29:31And I don't know that this is a good performance.
- 29:34Yeah, it's not a great performance.
- 29:36It would honestly be probably my least favorite performance from
- 29:40the main kind of characters in the film, if not for the fact
- 29:44that he, like, transforms into like, I don't know, like Jack
- 29:49Nicholson and A Few Good Men and just gives a speech to beat all
- 29:54speeches at the end of the film. All right, go ahead.
- 29:56No, we'll get there. We'll get there.
- 29:58We're on Day 2 right now, so. Oh, I'm sorry.
- 30:00Yeah, so Will Smith's whole thing happens.
- 30:03What What's going on in this part of the movie, too is like,
- 30:06it's it's kind of your classic trilogy.
- 30:08They're trying to do a whole trilogy in one movie, like
- 30:11something happens at the end of the first movie that leaves you
- 30:14wanting more. In the second film, our heroes
- 30:17are like truly laid low. And you think that we're laid
- 30:20low after the first day where all of our cities are bombed.
- 30:23But then on the second day we try nuking the ship and nothing
- 30:26works. You know, we get this extended
- 30:29sequence in Area 51, which really that whole sequence kind
- 30:33of sucks, But like you get a great tip into horror for a
- 30:37minute where a live alien communicates the intentions of
- 30:43the aliens to the president and then through the vocal.
- 30:46Cords of a dead human being? Yeah, it's incredible.
- 30:50And then the that section of the movie ends with personal loss,
- 30:54like the the the president's wife dies, the first lady dead
- 31:00on July 3rd. Can I can I please just comment
- 31:03on that for one please? Please.
- 31:07Please the The president's wife dies.
- 31:09Why? Because the plot needs her.
- 31:12She needs to die. Yeah, that's exactly why.
- 31:14That's like literally what the Doctor says.
- 31:18He's like, isn't there anything you can do?
- 31:20And the Doctor just kind of shrugs his shoulders and he's
- 31:22like, well, she doesn't have plot armor, so.
- 31:27If she maybe if she'd gotten here sooner.
- 31:29Yeah, but like, what's wrong? She just didn't get here sooner.
- 31:32Yeah, exactly. So she dies.
- 31:36You have a a cute kid saying is mommy sleeping?
- 31:40The the waterworks are on Brad but not.
- 31:42Just a cute kid. A cute kid who has been in
- 31:45another movie in the film and whiskey history.
- 31:48Oh, who is this? She her name is Mae Whitmore.
- 31:53I believe she is in Scott Pilgrim versus the.
- 31:58World. Oh yeah, yeah, Yeah.
- 32:00Is that Mae Whitman? I think it's Whitman.
- 32:02That's her. Yeah, that's Mae Whitman, man.
- 32:04That's the president's daughter, man.
- 32:06She's like kind of a minor character in a bunch of films.
- 32:10OK, we're running long here, so let's let's put day three after
- 32:14the break. But before we wrap this up here,
- 32:17I want to talk about why I think the middle section of this movie
- 32:21sucks so much, Brad. And it is because this is where
- 32:24they start forcing these characters stories to overlap.
- 32:29Randy Quaid meets Will Smith and Vivica A Fox meets the First
- 32:33Lady, and Jeff Goldblum and the President are already hanging
- 32:37out. And it's like, do we need every
- 32:39one of these groups of people to have multiple layers of
- 32:42interaction in each other's lives?
- 32:44Because it kind of just seems like we're doing Crash but with
- 32:48aliens for a while and that does not work.
- 32:51Like, I don't, I don't care about the human drama here.
- 32:54Like, aliens blow stuff up, we blow up the aliens.
- 32:58That's the that's needs to be the plot here.
- 33:00I was thinking like a is it New Year's Eve, the the movie where
- 33:04there's like 80 different stars in it and they all have
- 33:07overlapping lives? That that's kind of what I was
- 33:09thinking as I as I watch this. I was like, oh, it's a it's a
- 33:13action New Year, New Year's Eve. But crucially, with aliens.
- 33:18With aliens, Aliens that if I'm being honest the the the inside
- 33:24aliens aren't great. The alien that kills all the
- 33:28people in the in the lab the. Exoskeleton.
- 33:33Right, one of the. Coolest designs, yes.
- 33:35And I think that if there's a scene that we could talk about,
- 33:38it is this scene where so Will Smith punches an alien in the
- 33:41head and it is unconscious for hours apparently.
- 33:45He's got a hell of a right. Hook until they get him down
- 33:47into the operating room and they are cutting off this like
- 33:50exoskeleton that the aliens use. And you start to see, you know,
- 33:54the fingers are moving and it's one of the great horror tropes
- 33:59of like you are trapped in a room with a thing that's going
- 34:02to kill everybody in the room. Like this is the doc ock in
- 34:05Spider Man 2 kind of a thing. And boy oh boy, the IT It is
- 34:10completely out of left field because the rest of the movie
- 34:12does not have this tone at all. But I will say it's still
- 34:16effective. Sure is, man.
- 34:18And even like when the rest of the group comes to the lab and
- 34:22the lab is covered in smoke and you can't see anything, the
- 34:26cameras like slowly zooming and like pushing in on the on the
- 34:30window and I'm like, Oh yeah, one of the dead bodies is going
- 34:33to get shoved up against the window and it's going to happen
- 34:36right about now. Oh crap.
- 34:40It still gives you. Yeah.
- 34:43All right, man. I think we're in a good spot to
- 34:44press pause. This is a fun episode so far.
- 34:47I really love talking about this movie, but I'm ready to dive
- 34:50into more contentious ground. So let's talk a little bit about
- 34:53this. Will it pot still?
- 34:55What do you say I'm? Sorry, pot.
- 34:56Still pot. Still.
- 34:57I'm ready, Bob. Let's do it.
- 35:05All right. So today we are checking out.
- 35:07Will it pot still reserve? Brad, I've already mentioned it
- 35:12a couple times. I've said that this is a
- 35:13contentious whiskey. I guess I'll just put it
- 35:15straight to you. Were you aware that this was a
- 35:18contentious whiskey and like, what do you know about it?
- 35:23I would say yes, I I know that the vibes on this whiskey are
- 35:26are really harsh. And when I say vibes, I mean
- 35:30like genuinely people's thoughts that this is something people
- 35:34either seem to really love or really hate.
- 35:38And I always had the impression that it was an expensive
- 35:42whiskey, and maybe that's because I had heard about it
- 35:45three or four years ago. I I mean, I'll spoil the value.
- 35:49Not my score, but it's a it's about a $50 bottle of whiskey.
- 35:53Yeah, and it doesn't really did experience a spike during the
- 35:56the peak of the bourbon boom. But then there is enough ill
- 36:01will towards this whiskey out there that like it market
- 36:04corrected itself. It's like one of the few ones
- 36:07that has kind of come back down into a reasonable range.
- 36:10Yeah. And I I don't know, do you know
- 36:12if it's like really hard to find even though it's at 50 ish on
- 36:16the secondary? Yes or no.
- 36:17I mean, I I think that this is like as available as regular
- 36:22Buffalo Trace. OK.
- 36:23You know what I mean? Like it's kind of allocated, but
- 36:25not really. Yep.
- 36:27So this is from obviously the Willett distillery.
- 36:31Willett started making this I believe back in 2008.
- 36:33It was originally introduced as a single barrel whiskey and then
- 36:37in 2011 or 2012 they kind of on on the hush hush swapped out the
- 36:43labels to say small batch. They said that at no point where
- 36:46the batch is any larger than 12 barrels, so it's a true small
- 36:49batch whiskey. This was not something that was
- 36:51being distilled by Willett because Willett didn't distill
- 36:54whiskey for a long, long time and so it was always a fun game
- 36:57people played to try to figure out where this whiskey came
- 36:59from. Most people thought it was from
- 37:01Heaven Hill. I do have it on very good
- 37:04authority, Brad, that this is actually being made 100% by the
- 37:09Willett Distillery now that they have their operations up and
- 37:11running and that it does in fact use a pot still in its
- 37:15distillation. So one of the big knocks on this
- 37:17whiskey, because if you've ever seen the bottles, the bottle of
- 37:20whiskey is shaped like a pot. Still, it is a very cool, albeit
- 37:24gimmicky bottle. Yeah, I I don't care if it's
- 37:28gimmicky. It's a really cool.
- 37:29It's cool. Yeah.
- 37:30Like I I have nothing against it.
- 37:32I just for a long time people said we don't actually know if
- 37:35there's a pot still involved in the production of this whiskey
- 37:37or if they just put it in a bottle shaped like a pot still
- 37:41and then called it pot still whiskey.
- 37:43That's involving a pot still. It's a pot still replica.
- 37:46Made of glass? Sure.
- 37:47Yeah, made of glass that holds the whiskey.
- 37:50But again I can say as far as I know 2024 it is being 100% made
- 37:56by Willett and it it does use a pot still in the distillation
- 37:59process. So on that note, let me say
- 38:02this. It's 94 proof.
- 38:04We do not know the exact mash bill on it, but it's suspected
- 38:08to be will. It's weeded mash bill.
- 38:11Brad, I'm pretty excited to dive into this.
- 38:12It's been years since I've tried this thing.
- 38:15Yeah, I I tried it at some point with, I believe, my friend who
- 38:20gave this to us, Wes. So thank you, Wes.
- 38:23Thanks, Wes. Yeah, what a guy.
- 38:26I'm excited as well. My notes on it honestly are very
- 38:29interesting. I I landed at an interesting
- 38:31place and I'm excited for us both to get there.
- 38:35For me, the nose was decent, it was satisfactory.
- 38:40It didn't blow me away. I got some vanilla cake, kind of
- 38:46like a a really dark Raspberry, and and then like I'm going to
- 38:51use a different phrase because I don't want to use this phrase.
- 38:54I'll let you take over it. I do have a.
- 38:56Treatment. I'm going to call it Dusty
- 38:59Attic. That's that's the note I got on
- 39:03the nose. Overall, a decent nose.
- 39:06I'll give it a 7 out of 10. My first note, Brad, that I
- 39:10wrote down was the Will It freaking funk.
- 39:14Not just the will it funk. Dude, I don't know how they do
- 39:17it because, like, for so long they were sourcing this whiskey
- 39:20and now they're making it themselves and their whiskey
- 39:22still smells exactly the same. Like about season 6 or so.
- 39:27Season five, maybe. We finally pinpointed what the
- 39:29funk is, and it's not actually funk.
- 39:31It's like rose petal. There's a ton of rose on this
- 39:35and it's here, man. It's here in spades.
- 39:37But there was also this really weird note that I got underneath
- 39:40it, and it was like burnt paper. It wasn't like char, it wasn't
- 39:45ash, it wasn't cigarette or tobacco or anything.
- 39:47It's like when you accidentally, like, catch a piece of paper on
- 39:51fire. There's a very specific smell to
- 39:54the way that burns. Is this a common occurrence for
- 39:56you, Bob? You know, listen, man, when I
- 39:59get top secret messages, you got to burn those things with fire.
- 40:03All your Mission Impossible messages that self destruct.
- 40:06So it was just a really weird thing to have underneath those
- 40:08layers of rose, and I couldn't tell if it was tipping me off to
- 40:11something bad coming. But in a vacuum, it wasn't a bad
- 40:15nose. It was just like, I'm going to
- 40:17take note, you know what I mean? So I'll give it a 7 out of 10 on
- 40:21the nose. The pallet here, I got a really
- 40:25interesting note of I I don't know if you've been overseas
- 40:29much, Bob, I haven't. But the one time I was, they had
- 40:32cherry juice in Ukraine, and it was incredible.
- 40:37And I got a very distinct vibe of like a really fresh, juicy
- 40:43cherry juice. There was some Coca-Cola notes.
- 40:48There's a little bit of like a salted caramel.
- 40:50I got some some like really salty peanuts.
- 40:55All of that might make it sound like I liked this whiskey.
- 40:59I was just OK with it. I was too.
- 41:01I came, yeah, I came to a 6 1/2 out of 10 on the on the palate.
- 41:04I did too. Yeah.
- 41:06It's. Interesting and unique.
- 41:09I just don't know if I like it or not.
- 41:11I think the most controversial thing I'm going to say about
- 41:13this whiskey on this review is that almost every category was
- 41:17middle of the road for me. I neither loved it nor hated it.
- 41:19And for a whiskey to be so divisive, I was really expecting
- 41:24super bold, prominent flavors. And for me, I'm actually kind of
- 41:28envious that you picked up on so much because you know, Brad, I I
- 41:32just got over a cold like a week ago and now I'm like Oh my gosh,
- 41:36should I be COVID testing because I didn't taste any of
- 41:38these things that Brad tasted. In fact, for me, I was like this
- 41:42has a surprising lack of flavor when compared to other Willit
- 41:46products. Like it was kind of non existent
- 41:49flavor wise at the front of my palate and it wasn't until the
- 41:52middle and the back part of my palate that I started picking up
- 41:54anything. It, you know, I feel like the
- 41:57mouthfeel and the experience of drinking.
- 41:59It was really pleasant and it drank like an expensive whiskey,
- 42:01like it. It grows really nicely.
- 42:04It builds on the palate. There's good spice here.
- 42:06The alcohol is never harsh, but it like, it leaves a nice little
- 42:09layer of like a prickly effect when you go to swallow.
- 42:13But it just reminded me of Noah's Mill, which I love so
- 42:16much. But if you took all of the
- 42:18sweetness out of Noah's Mill, it had some char to it.
- 42:21It wasn't bitter, it was just kind of like kind of bland
- 42:24compared to other Willett products that I've had.
- 42:27On my second sip I got a little bit of like a almost like a
- 42:30blended Scotch kind of flavor. It definitely didn't taste like
- 42:34a weeded bourbon to me like at all.
- 42:37So I just gave it a 6 1/2 and then on the finish, like I said,
- 42:40it has a nice chest burn like a really good oak base.
- 42:44It's perfectly fine and I think it would make a really good
- 42:48cocktail because it has everything you need like that a
- 42:51whiskey needs to announce itself with in a mixed drink, but just
- 42:56it doesn't have flavours to stand up on its own.
- 42:58It's almost like a super high quality mixer, so I gave it a 6
- 43:021/2 there as well. That's so funny, man on on my
- 43:05finish, the first note I took it, it took me a little bit to
- 43:09get to it, but it reminded me of like the egg white that we put
- 43:14in the whiskey sour. And not that I like ever, like
- 43:18just eat or drink. Just egg whites.
- 43:21But for some reason that's what I couldn't get out of my my
- 43:24brain. Like that specific texture of an
- 43:28egg white mixed in with your your whiskey sour.
- 43:31That's what I was getting there. There was black pepper, there's
- 43:36tobacco. It got kind of ashy for me after
- 43:39it sat on my my palate for a little bit.
- 43:41I actually think I liked the finish better than anything
- 43:44else. I gave it a 7 1/2 on the finish.
- 43:48Balance wise, I give it a six out of 10 Bob.
- 43:51It's just such a weird mix of flavours and I don't think it's
- 43:55bad. It's just so strange I I don't
- 43:58know if I love it or hate it. I.
- 44:01I actually gave it a 7 1/2 on the balance I like, which is
- 44:04higher than any of the individual categories.
- 44:06But I think it's actually quite nicely balanced.
- 44:09It's just it's it's nicely balanced for what it is, which
- 44:12is a cocktail with a really good backbone, but or a cocktail, a
- 44:18whiskey with a really good backbone but with like no
- 44:21accoutrements like it. It is like a solid highish proof
- 44:28whiskey with no flavor. And it's kind of that throughout
- 44:33the whole experience I was like you know what if this is your
- 44:36thing, it does that pretty well. So that was a 7 1/2 for me.
- 44:40And then we get to value. Now Brad, you've already kind of
- 44:42tipped your hand a little bit about value in the state of
- 44:45Ohio. This is selling for $57 a
- 44:48bottle. It's a little bit cheaper out of
- 44:50state like in a you know, non price controlled regions.
- 44:54At 57 this is probably going to be my lowest score.
- 44:58I think this is only like a 5 1/2 for me Brad, it's a cool
- 45:01bottle, but the whiskey inside of it, it's non age stated.
- 45:04It's not, it's not purported to be any older than like five
- 45:08years. Some people are arguing that
- 45:10it's like 8 to 10 year. I don't think that's true.
- 45:13And I just don't think that like at 94 proof that there's really
- 45:16anything that you're paying for here to justify 57 dollars
- 45:20outside of the bottle. Yeah, I I'm with you.
- 45:23I I'm going to give it a 5 out of 10 actually for value at
- 45:28almost $60.00. There's just a lot of other
- 45:32things to spend your money on. I I mean I I will say like this
- 45:36is a fascinating whiskey. I I I think it's very
- 45:39interesting and it deserves some level of buzz around people
- 45:44loving and hating it. But overall like I'm coming to a
- 45:4832 out of 50. Like it's not my favorite
- 45:51whiskey. It is not bad.
- 45:53It's well made. It's definitely not going to be
- 45:57everybody's cup of tea. If I had to guess, I would
- 46:00imagine that like 25 to 30% of people who drink this actually
- 46:05really like it. I'm at a 33 out of 50, so I'm
- 46:08really close to you. And for the second week in a
- 46:10row, I'm going to say by the Noah's Mill, which is almost the
- 46:15exact same price and a whiskey that I truly love and just water
- 46:18it down to 94 proof because I think it's better than this.
- 46:22And so, like, you know, that doesn't sound like a ringing
- 46:25endorsement. We're coming to a 32.5 out of 50
- 46:28or 65 out of 100. We're just below the 35 out of
- 46:3350 threshold where we usually start recommending stuff.
- 46:37I'm not going to recommend this, but it's not because I'm opposed
- 46:40to it. You know what I mean?
- 46:41Like, I feel like people are going to see that we said, oh,
- 46:43we don't recommend will it pot still.
- 46:45And they'll be like, aha, I knew it, you know, but like, it's
- 46:48fine. It's a fine whiskey.
- 46:50I think the the big differentiation point for me is
- 46:53the price. Like if it was cheaper, I'd
- 46:56probably tip into the 35 range. Yeah, honestly, if it was $10
- 47:00cheaper, like if this was like a 45 to $50 whiskey, I'd say yeah,
- 47:05this is a really unique and interesting whiskey for under
- 47:08$50.00. But 50 definitely is a wall when
- 47:13it comes to purchasing whiskey that I have to really like
- 47:17something to spend over half of $100 on it.
- 47:21So yeah, I'm just going to go buy a bottle of Quinta Ruben or
- 47:26Wild Turkey rare breed at this point over something like this.
- 47:29All right, man. Well, we're going to leave
- 47:31Willett Pot still behind us. We're going to get back into
- 47:33talking about Independence Day, the greatest film ever made.
- 47:36What do you say? Obviously, yeah, I'm ready,
- 47:38dude. Let's get to it.
- 47:43All right, that was Willet Pot still reserved.
- 47:46Brad, I'm not going to do any fancy segways.
- 47:48I'm going to ask you this. Should we finish talking about
- 47:51the movie and then do 2 facts and a falsehood?
- 47:53Or should we keep the people in suspense and do our game?
- 47:57Let's do our game, Bob. They They deserve to to linger a
- 48:01little longer. All right.
- 48:02Well, that means it is time for two facts and a falsehood.
- 48:05Brad is going to try to stump your ball.
- 48:10Two all right And what is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 48:16and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me
- 48:19with three items as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 48:23which is a complete lie and fabrication.
- 48:25And I have to annihilate it the way that the aliens try to
- 48:28annihilate us in this film. Brad, I am sitting pretty.
- 48:32I I think I'm at like 6:00 and 2:00 on the season.
- 48:37Yeah, you you're nailing it, man.
- 48:39I don't. Also, how are we 8 movies in?
- 48:42Well, this is this is movie 9. Yeah, that's insane.
- 48:45I know, man. It's crazy.
- 48:47I'm not really worried about whether I win or lose today,
- 48:48Brad. I am in a position of
- 48:50pompousness today. So.
- 48:53Pompousness. Pomposity.
- 48:55So hit me with your two facts and a falsehood.
- 48:58Fact #1. Filming took place in the summer
- 49:01of 1995, and unexpectedly, production was delayed for a few
- 49:05days when filming in the Los Angeles airport because it had a
- 49:09bomb threat from none other than the Unabomber Ted Kaczynski Fact
- 49:14#2. The production team came up with
- 49:16two primary designs for the large alien warships, and
- 49:20director Roland Emmerich liked them both so much that he
- 49:23decided to keep them, one becoming the massive warships
- 49:26scattered across the planets and the other becoming the mother
- 49:29ship that Will Smith and Jeff Goldblum had to fly into.
- 49:32Fact #3 Will Smith's line while dragging the alien back to the
- 49:36base. What the hell is that Smell Was
- 49:39completely unscripted. The Great Salt Lake flats, where
- 49:42the scene was shot has an issue where when the wind is just
- 49:47right, it can kick up the smell of millions of decaying brine
- 49:50shrimp from the nearby lake. Brad, these are three really
- 49:55good facts and or made-up facts because they all sound pretty
- 50:00pretty reasonable. I I'm going to be honest with
- 50:03you dude. I think that the design of both
- 50:05the little alien fighter jets and the city wide size ships are
- 50:10really, really cool. I've always hated the design of
- 50:14the mothership. It looks like a big flee like
- 50:16it's just floating through space with his little legs.
- 50:19I don't like it. So I kind of want #2 to be false
- 50:24just because I want to on that a little bit #3 see.
- 50:30I don't know. Did would Will Smith have been
- 50:32improvising? I don't know.
- 50:35Brad, you got me today. I got you, man.
- 50:38I'm going to say one is. Do you think that Ted Kaczynski
- 50:41was threatening the Los Angeles airport?
- 50:44I mean, I'm going to be surprised.
- 50:45He was threatening a lot of people.
- 50:48I think that one sounds the most plausible.
- 50:50I I think one is a fact just because it is like, why would
- 50:54you make up a fact about the Unabomber?
- 50:55It has nothing to do with this movie.
- 50:59So it's either two or three. And it just depends on did Will
- 51:02Smith improvise? I'm going to say I'm going to
- 51:10say two is the falsehood, Brad, But I think he might have gotten
- 51:12me today. Bob, you are on a hell of A roll
- 51:16like America in Independence Day.
- 51:18You are firing on also. Oh, it was too.
- 51:21It was too Wow, that was the falsehood, man.
- 51:24Yeah, so apparently the lakes have all of these, like, brine
- 51:29shrimp that like live in the lakes.
- 51:32But as they die, they they decay into like the silt.
- 51:37And if the wind hits just wrong, it like just spreads this
- 51:42reeking smell. And Will Smith had no idea about
- 51:46it and he just, you know, on one of the takes as he's dragging
- 51:50this alien across across the salt flats, he just casually
- 51:54goes, what the hell is that smell like?
- 51:58As a more serious question to somebody.
- 52:01And they're like, oh, this is perfect, Let's keep that in
- 52:03there. All right, man, let's get back
- 52:07into talking about the movie itself.
- 52:09So there's a fade in on July 4th after Mommy sleeping now, OK?
- 52:14And we're we're back at it. Everyone has been emotionally
- 52:17devastated. Jeff Goldblum is drinking
- 52:21himself into a stupor because he doesn't care anymore and the
- 52:24world's going to end And and then Judd Hirsch comes in and
- 52:27and says like, oh you're going to catch cold down there and and
- 52:30he goes, he goes, wait, say that again.
- 52:33I hate when characters do this but he does the say that again.
- 52:36What you're going to catch cold. He goes yes, like OK and and we
- 52:41are off on a mission to infect the light years traveling alien
- 52:48mothership with a virus from Windows 95.
- 52:52Yep. And boy oh boy, if there is
- 52:54anything 90s about this movie, it is the idea that, you know,
- 52:59no one knows what antivirus software is yet.
- 53:02Definitely not the aliens. Definitely not the aliens.
- 53:04They don't need that stuff, man. So OK, I want to talk about that
- 53:09plot line and get your thoughts on that, because there's good
- 53:11stuff that happens on July 4th, but there's also like, look,
- 53:15it's a movie about aliens attacking Earth.
- 53:17And even I was like, this is implausible, you know what I
- 53:20mean? Yeah, yeah.
- 53:21I mean, it's that element of you set your heroes up with an
- 53:27impossible task and then you give them a way to accomplish
- 53:30the task. The key in any film is whether
- 53:34it's, you know, Lord of the Rings, Frodo being able to throw
- 53:37the ring into the Into Mountain Doom.
- 53:40You know, whether it's Star Wars them able to blow up the Death
- 53:43Star, Like the way in which they defeat the impossible odds has
- 53:49to feel plausible. Like like like it came about in
- 53:54this this moment of ingenuity and at the end of the day like
- 53:58to believe even that the initial premise they use radio
- 54:03communication that we could hack into is ridiculous.
- 54:09Like they they flat out say these aliens communicate through
- 54:15like sight like psychic means, and yet for some reason they're
- 54:19transmitting radio broadcasts and not only are they doing
- 54:24that, we can like reverse engineer it to destroy their
- 54:28Shields. OK, cut.
- 54:31Oh OK yeah. These super psychic like world
- 54:35destroying aliens who have destroyed thousands of worlds
- 54:38beforehand. They also rely on radio
- 54:41technology. Got it?
- 54:43Sure. Yep.
- 54:44I mean, have you also considered that these are not Americans and
- 54:47so they're just not as intelligent as we are?
- 54:50That's true. I hadn't thought about that.
- 54:51I mean, that's the message of the film here, Brad.
- 54:53Although, like, wouldn't they have been the Americans of their
- 54:56original planet? I believe they're the British of
- 55:00their original planet, obviously.
- 55:03All right, here's another nitpick.
- 55:05Now that we're talking about the plausibility of this Alien
- 55:07movie, you know how, like, it always positions The ships
- 55:11always position themselves directly over their target, And
- 55:13the target is like, in the dead center of where the ship is,
- 55:16'cause it has this laser beam that comes down at the end of
- 55:19the film. The ship has moved to, like,
- 55:22directly over this military base that all of our heroes are far
- 55:26underground in. And then they blow the ship up
- 55:29and the ship falls to Earth. Like, you're still, you're still
- 55:33very much trapped there, right? Like, I don't know.
- 55:35How do you get out of that situation?
- 55:37No, they're totally fine. But don't think about it.
- 55:41I totally didn't think about it myself.
- 55:43That question never came up. Never came up one time.
- 55:46It's very obvious that they're going to be just fine.
- 55:48Honestly, as they blew it up the final time, I thought that they
- 55:51were going to do like some sort of like it just like implodes on
- 55:56itself and burns up into nothingness.
- 55:59But no, they they show it falling to the ground and I was
- 56:02like, hot what? OK, sure, why not.
- 56:07So the the climax of this movie is what I am going to refer to
- 56:11as a double Star Wars. And this is after a guy we
- 56:14follow on YouTube, Brad named Ryan George who does the pitch
- 56:17meetings. He had this extended thing in
- 56:19the Top Gun Maverick pitch meeting where he talks about how
- 56:22they have to do a Star Wars because the end of the movie is
- 56:25just, it's just A New Hope. And this movie we're doing a
- 56:29double Star Wars. We have Jeff Goldblum and Will
- 56:32Smith going into the mothership to upload a virus and they have
- 56:38to get back out and then blow the ship up.
- 56:40And on Earth you have the president of the United States
- 56:43saying, hey, I'm going to go fly this mission to blow up this big
- 56:47citywide destroyer. And so they're doing a Star Wars
- 56:51'cause they have to find, you know, the equivalent of, like,
- 56:54the vent hole from A New Hope. And it's freaking great, man.
- 56:59The end of the movie is so preposterous, and I love it so,
- 57:02so much. And it all kicks off when Bill
- 57:05Pullman has his presidential moment.
- 57:07And I had the text of this this speech pulled up.
- 57:10I'm not going to say it, but when my guy goes into, like
- 57:15second gear and he's like, you know, Independence Day, July 4th
- 57:20will no longer be an American holiday, but it will be a
- 57:22holiday where, like the whole world says.
- 57:24And then he just kicks it up a notch and he does.
- 57:26We will not go quietly into the night.
- 57:29And I'm like, dude, I was like, yes, like I I have seen this
- 57:34movie 35 times and my wife is sitting across the room for me.
- 57:38She's like, I've never seen this.
- 57:39And I said you came in at the perfect time because America is
- 57:43about to kick so much ass. You don't need to know.
- 57:46Anything has happened previously and I realized halfway through
- 57:50this speech that it is so moving that I was like tearing up as an
- 57:55American. And my wife notices me having an
- 57:59emotional response to Bill Pullman's alien speech.
- 58:04And I'm be honest with you, I am not ashamed.
- 58:06It is so good, Brad. Yeah, it's incredible.
- 58:09Like, as I was doing my research, for two facts and a
- 58:12falsehood, the the crew, weirdly this feels strange.
- 58:16They weren't actually instructed to applaud at the end of the
- 58:19speech. It was supposed to be like in
- 58:21the script. It was just a like go back to
- 58:24work, you know, maybe a little more energized.
- 58:27They actually just spontaneously burst into applause as the
- 58:31speech ended. And for good reason, because
- 58:34Bill Pullman was half dead throughout the film and he comes
- 58:38to freaking life and just delivers an incredible speech
- 58:42here. It's so good, and I love that at
- 58:44that part of the movie too. They're like, we don't have
- 58:47enough people to fly planes. Anyone who thinks they can fly
- 58:50can fly a plane now and then they like cut to the the crowd
- 58:53of people he's talking to and they look like it looks like the
- 58:56production team just went into like every bar in the area and
- 58:59pulled guys out. And but, like, it works so well
- 59:02for what they're trying to do because like that's what America
- 59:05looks like. Let's be honest here.
- 59:07Like there's just scraggly looking dudes with beards.
- 59:10And then Bill Pullman gives them the speech and they they're all
- 59:13drunk and they all immediately burst into cheers.
- 59:16It's incredible. And Randy Quaid is picked a hell
- 59:20of a day to. Quit drinking.
- 59:23OK man. Before we get into our last
- 59:25segment of the day, I want you to give me 30 seconds on the
- 59:29last 30 minutes of the movie. How does it work for you?
- 59:34What holds up? What doesn't hold up?
- 59:36Is it the best part of the movie or?
- 59:38No, there's elements of it that are great.
- 59:42The the speech is great. I think the final shot of the
- 59:46alien ship getting blown up is great.
- 59:49I I think that the tension of it as it like opens up and starts
- 59:52to shoot, it's it's giant laser beam is great.
- 59:57But overall, I think that they struggle a lot from the CG of
- 1:00:02the day for the fact that I I kept, and this was kind of my
- 1:00:06note throughout all of the technical aspects of the film.
- 1:00:10Every time they had a scene of like a spaceship attacking the
- 1:00:15the F sixteens or you know, getting into dog fights,
- 1:00:18whatever, I just kept thinking to myself, man, Star Wars did
- 1:00:23this better in 77, like like Return Return of the Jedi did
- 1:00:28this better and that was like over a decade before this.
- 1:00:33And I think that was my big issue.
- 1:00:35I just don't think they did the fight scenes very well.
- 1:00:40And if you're gonna do it an alien versus human sci-fi film,
- 1:00:46you gotta nail the dog fighting and you you have to really nail
- 1:00:50the the feeling of terror as enemy alien ships fill the sky
- 1:00:57and I just don't think that they nailed that.
- 1:01:00So that's that's my biggest let down for the end of the film.
- 1:01:03You don't like it when Bill, when Bill Pullman says come on
- 1:01:06boys, let's plow the road and then they just start firing
- 1:01:09machine guns. It's great, dude, you.
- 1:01:12I just don't think you're a lover of cinema.
- 1:01:14I think is what we're finding out today.
- 1:01:16I don't think I am. I hate it.
- 1:01:17That's why I've been doing this podcast for so long.
- 1:01:20All right, man. It's time for our last segment
- 1:01:22of the day, which we call. Let's make it a double.
- 1:01:25We're near the end of the episodes of Things Listening to
- 1:01:28the Film and Whiskey show. Let's favorite another film with
- 1:01:31this one, even if it's struggling.
- 1:01:32It's a final segment of the day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:01:35Let's make it a double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 1:01:38movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 1:01:41feature. Brad, I have not given one
- 1:01:44second's thought to this, so I'm going to let you go first.
- 1:01:48I actually have what I think to be a absolute perfect pairing
- 1:01:52for this movie. It is another film that has
- 1:01:56preposterous battles, really terrible dialogue, many not
- 1:02:02memorable characters and just some kick ass fight scenes.
- 1:02:08I am going to recommend 2013's Pacific Rim 'cause that would
- 1:02:14just be the most humans are the best and everybody else can go
- 1:02:19kick rocks movie pairing that I could imagine.
- 1:02:23I have absolutely no idea what to pair this movie with, I
- 1:02:26think. Yeah, I mean, do you want some
- 1:02:29recommendations? No, I think I'm going to go, and
- 1:02:31it's like a really lame one, but I'm going to go with Return of
- 1:02:33the King. I think that's like the obvious
- 1:02:35one here, because you get. Whoa, whoa, whoa.
- 1:02:38How is Return of the King the obvious?
- 1:02:41Fair. Here's how.
- 1:02:43Here's how It's obvious. It's obvious because there's
- 1:02:46like 2 movies that I think of that are also in the like
- 1:02:50Rousing the troops with a speech and it's Braveheart and it's
- 1:02:53this or and you know, it's Return of the King.
- 1:02:57I don't really want to rewatch Braveheart anytime soon.
- 1:02:59It's fine. It's a fine movie.
- 1:03:01I will also say if I can give one really hot take, I think
- 1:03:05this is a better speech than William Wallace's speech in
- 1:03:08Braveheart. And here's why.
- 1:03:12William Wallace's speech is like maybe three sentences long.
- 1:03:16We just like the way he delivers.
- 1:03:18They may take our lives, but they will never take our
- 1:03:20freedom. Is a great line.
- 1:03:21Reading the speech as a whole, not persuasive.
- 1:03:25I'm not, you know, like if you break it down on a literary
- 1:03:27level, I think Bill Pullman wins the day.
- 1:03:30And that's why Aragorn gets my nod, because he does a great job
- 1:03:34with his speech. And also we get to watch, you
- 1:03:38know, horrific looking creatures fall at the hands of man.
- 1:03:42And I'm, I'm cool with it, dude. So Return to the King is my
- 1:03:44pick. Anytime you have to start a
- 1:03:47sentence with, it's obvious, because it clearly isn't
- 1:03:53obvious. Yes, it's obvious to everyone
- 1:03:56but you, Brad I. Perhaps.
- 1:03:59Oh man, Bob, I I'm ready to give this movie a final score.
- 1:04:03I don't know if you're going to be happy with this.
- 1:04:06I liked this movie, but I very much so did not love this movie.
- 1:04:11I came to like a 6 1/2 out of 10 here.
- 1:04:15I think that's kind of like, objectively how good this movie
- 1:04:18is. I am both operating from a place
- 1:04:21of. I saw this as an American child
- 1:04:24in the 90s. Yeah.
- 1:04:25You did. And also like, I kind of want to
- 1:04:28give it A7. I'm not going to give it a 7.5
- 1:04:31to fudge the numbers here, but I I will give it a 7.
- 1:04:34Because last week we both gave Goldeneye A7.
- 1:04:37And like Goldeneye may or may not have more filmmaking merits
- 1:04:42than this movie, but I think, like, the action sequences are
- 1:04:45incredibly well done in this film.
- 1:04:47And I'm just being frank, I had a way better time watching this
- 1:04:50movie than I had watching Goldeneye.
- 1:04:52Like Goldeneye really had some serious whiplash tonally
- 1:04:56throughout the Yeah, but. Did this movie have a tank?
- 1:05:00I don't. I don't think this movie had a
- 1:05:02tank, Bob. That's true.
- 1:05:04They are at least each other's equivalent.
- 1:05:06So I'm going to give this A7. You gave it a 6 1/2.
- 1:05:08That takes us to a 6.75 on what is known around the world as the
- 1:05:14greatest film ever made. So it's it's pretty pretty hot
- 1:05:17take from us today. Yeah, it's the the BFI top film
- 1:05:21sight and sounds it's it was at the number one of the is it the
- 1:05:26AFI? Yeah, yeah.
- 1:05:28Yeah, #1 dethroned. Citizen Kane.
- 1:05:31Yeah, it sure did. All right.
- 1:05:34We want to know what you think of Independence Day.
- 1:05:36Have you watched it as an adult? Have you watched it recently?
- 1:05:40Have you been able to take off your childhood child of the 90s
- 1:05:43glasses to watch this movie? You can find us on all of our
- 1:05:46social media accounts, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok,
- 1:05:51YouTube at Film Whiskey. Or you can jump onto the
- 1:05:55Discord. We are on there every single day
- 1:05:57talking to you guys, fans of the Film and Whiskey Podcast.
- 1:06:01If you'd like to join the conversation, there is a link to
- 1:06:03our discord at the end of every single one of our show notes.
- 1:06:06Next week Brad, we are staying in the Will Smith camp to watch
- 1:06:10a movie that has really grown in people's estimations over recent
- 1:06:13years and crucially, a film that is like 98 minutes long and that
- 1:06:18is 1997's Men in Black. 98 falls within the 90 minute film,
- 1:06:25right? I think so.
- 1:06:26It's a rounding error. Let's go.
- 1:06:29Right. Join us for Men in Black next
- 1:06:31week. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:06:33I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.