Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: On Topic - The Ten Suggestions
Transcript
- 0:06AV Super Friends On Topic is an
- 0:08independent production wholly owned and
- 0:09operated by AV Super Friends, LLC.
- 0:12For the highest quality recording of all
- 0:13of our shows, visit AVSuperFriends.com.
- 0:19This is AV Super Friends On Topic,
- 0:21a thirty-minute monthly roundtable focused
- 0:23on a single topic.
- 0:24This discussion will be opinionated,
- 0:26to the point,
- 0:26and saturated with our well-known blend of
- 0:28painfully won expertise and deeply
- 0:30ingrained immaturity.
- 0:38For March, twenty twenty six.
- 0:40Yes, I said March.
- 0:40Deal with it.
- 0:41It's the best sounding and most regularly
- 0:43scheduled podcast in higher ed.
- 0:45This is the AV Super Friends on topic.
- 0:47Episode number sixty eight.
- 0:50That's over five and a half years of
- 0:52this.
- 0:53man broadcasting live across four time
- 0:55zones no scratch that we dropped we lost
- 0:58somebody today broadcasting live across
- 1:00three time zones across that time zone
- 1:02though wait a minute no it is four
- 1:04me and jamie are on the same time
- 1:06oh you are okay so jamie's a scofflock
- 1:08it still applies
- 1:09Broadcasting live across four time zones,
- 1:11it's spring, because it's March, remember.
- 1:13Theater of the mind,
- 1:14where the snow is melting,
- 1:15the budgets are tightening,
- 1:16the classroom tickets are blooming faster
- 1:18than the campus flower beds.
- 1:20And it's time to shake off our winter
- 1:22firmware and step boldly into spring
- 1:24refresh season.
- 1:25So from preventive maintenance to project
- 1:27planning,
- 1:27from frozen loading docks to fully booked
- 1:29install calendars,
- 1:30we're thawing out the technology and
- 1:32turning up our springtime momentum.
- 1:34I'm Chris Dector.
- 1:35It's time for another Friday afternoon
- 1:36podcast adventure with the AV Super
- 1:37Friends.
- 1:38And let's say hello to today's panel of
- 1:40AV Super Friends, which is this one.
- 1:47Oh,
- 1:47got to delete this because it's not that,
- 1:48Jamie's not here, sorry.
- 1:49Our first panelist ensures that every new
- 1:51AV over IP deployment blooms beautifully
- 1:54in April before immediately being clogged
- 1:56by multicast storms and metaphorical
- 1:57ragweed.
- 1:58He's a director of emerging technologies
- 2:01and seasonal pollen mitigation from
- 2:03Corvallis, Oregon.
- 2:03Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolowczynski.
- 2:05Yes, the colors are always blooming here.
- 2:08So we have somebody doing shading on all
- 2:11of our rooms all the time on every
- 2:13system.
- 2:13Just turn the gamma up a little bit.
- 2:16Exactly.
- 2:17Our next panelist champions the annual
- 2:19rediscovery of rooms that, quote,
- 2:21worked fine in the fall and now require
- 2:24emergency irrigation in the form of new
- 2:26DSP configs and a reboot ritual.
- 2:28He's an assistant provost for strategic
- 2:30sprouting and deferred maintenance
- 2:31awakening from Greensboro, North Carolina.
- 2:33Say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:34Yep, I reboot every room every spring,
- 2:37just like clockwork.
- 2:39Whether it needs it or not.
- 2:41And our final panelist leads the annual
- 2:43migration from we'll fix it in summer to
- 2:46why is this still broken in March while
- 2:48aligning capital requests with pollen
- 2:50forecasts and fiscal optimism.
- 2:52He's a vice president of Vernal Refresh
- 2:54Cycles and Strategic Thawing from Bowling
- 2:56Green, Kentucky.
- 2:56Say hello to Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 2:59It's not right.
- 3:00It's really VP of run to fail.
- 3:03What the hell is, what's Vernal mean?
- 3:05Sounds like an uncle's name.
- 3:07Like Uncle Vernal.
- 3:07That's Vern.
- 3:08Hey, Vernal.
- 3:10Like Uncle Vernal drank too much.
- 3:12You didn't like study Latin in school at
- 3:14all?
- 3:14So, okay.
- 3:15I mean, a little bit.
- 3:16I was Catholic for a little bit.
- 3:17All right.
- 3:17For a little bit.
- 3:19For a little bit.
- 3:20I'm still Catholic.
- 3:22I haven't read Latin since like third
- 3:24grade, I guess.
- 3:27I don't know.
- 3:27Well, anyway, speaking of being Catholic,
- 3:29let's lean into that.
- 3:30On today's show,
- 3:31we're going to discuss our top ten
- 3:33commandments of AV.
- 3:35But first, a little bit of housekeeping.
- 3:36So, first of all,
- 3:37if you're listening to this as a recorded
- 3:38MP three,
- 3:39while you're crawling through a ceiling,
- 3:40replacing a failed HDMI extender,
- 3:42just know that we do stream live on
- 3:43Fridays at about three fifteen Eastern
- 3:44twelve fifteen Pacific or whenever Mark's
- 3:47seasonal allergies subside.
- 3:49And of course,
- 3:49we were all late today because we had
- 3:51a meeting right before this and that ran
- 3:52long and then we're in all sorts of
- 3:54planning retreat.
- 3:56For two hours.
- 3:57It was a treat.
- 3:58Yes, that's right.
- 3:59You can catch us live on YouTube,
- 4:00LinkedIn, and Twitter,
- 4:01and when the pollen count is high,
- 4:02the takes are hotter,
- 4:04and occasionally we'll even take your
- 4:05calls,
- 4:06which I don't have set up right now.
- 4:07Deal with it.
- 4:09Spring is all about renewals, new growth,
- 4:11fresh start,
- 4:12so maybe this season's the season that you
- 4:13finally follow us on the socials.
- 4:15Go search for AV Super Friends on YouTube,
- 4:17LinkedIn, Twitter, and Blue Sky,
- 4:19and we see you out there posting stuff,
- 4:21so give us a follow, too.
- 4:23While you're out there decluttering your
- 4:24office,
- 4:24please consider planting the seeds of
- 4:26chaos by sharing this podcast with your
- 4:27coworkers, your local integrator,
- 4:29your procurement office,
- 4:30that one faculty member who still insists
- 4:32that VGA is more reliable.
- 4:34They're not wrong.
- 4:35And anyone else who might need a little
- 4:37sunlight in their signal chain.
- 4:39If you'd like to help this show to
- 4:40keep blooming,
- 4:40you can support us by using the donation
- 4:42link in the show notes or at the
- 4:43top of the website there.
- 4:45Your contributions help keep our mics hot,
- 4:47our opinions honest,
- 4:48and the snark organically sourced
- 4:51sometimes.
- 4:52And finally,
- 4:55we are turning over new leaves,
- 4:56but we're never crossing the stream,
- 4:57so keep an eye on what we're doing
- 4:59here.
- 4:59Thank you for your support.
- 5:00We couldn't do this without your support.
- 5:03Yay.
- 5:04All righty.
- 5:04We did it.
- 5:05What, do you want more clapping?
- 5:06It's like four people clapping there.
- 5:10That's about right.
- 5:12All right,
- 5:13so let's go to this month's topic,
- 5:17which is...
- 5:24So, Justin, this was your suggestion.
- 5:26Yeah.
- 5:26So just so everyone knows,
- 5:27we have an editorial calendar for the
- 5:29entire year except March.
- 5:31It literally says TBD.
- 5:33There is no plan for March.
- 5:35We change it up every year.
- 5:37And Justin, this was your suggestion.
- 5:38You were like, well, Hey,
- 5:39let's talk about this.
- 5:40So Justin go, what are we talking about?
- 5:41It's the vernal season, Justin.
- 5:43So what do you have?
- 5:44Use your vernal Catholic Latin.
- 5:46So being on a campus with a hill,
- 5:49sometimes you find yourself walking around
- 5:50thinking a lot.
- 5:51And I was thinking one day about all
- 5:53the problems I had and I was,
- 5:54you know,
- 5:55we ought to do a show about the
- 5:57ten commandments of AB.
- 5:59So here we are.
- 6:01So we talked about how to do it.
- 6:03I'm curious,
- 6:03why did that anecdote need to have a
- 6:04hill?
- 6:05Yeah,
- 6:05because every campus I've been on has a
- 6:07hill.
- 6:08Because all religions need death.
- 6:09We're the hill-toppers, thank you.
- 6:12I just mean you're on top of the
- 6:13hill.
- 6:13You're just at the top of the hill.
- 6:15We are known for our hills.
- 6:16And I bet you there's a lot of
- 6:17universities in Texas that are not on
- 6:19hills.
- 6:19Is that a thing?
- 6:19But maybe some are.
- 6:21The hill-toppers is like straight up
- 6:22because you're known for hills?
- 6:25Wyoming's not on a hill.
- 6:27No, there's a mountain.
- 6:28Mountains.
- 6:30Baby hills.
- 6:32Our campus is more like that.
- 6:35Most camps are more like this.
- 6:36Yes, because when they built the town,
- 6:38they were like, hey,
- 6:38there's a flat spot over there.
- 6:39That's where we should build the town.
- 6:42This guy from Kentucky was like,
- 6:43top of the mountain!
- 6:45Top of the hill.
- 6:45Hill toppers.
- 6:47Anyway, so everybody started debating,
- 6:50well,
- 6:50how are we going to get through the
- 6:51show?
- 6:52There's so much to talk about.
- 6:53Ten Commandments, like
- 6:55just listed Ten Commandments.
- 6:56You just come up with ten items.
- 6:59So I came up with quite a few
- 7:00here.
- 7:01Yeah, I just just in five minutes,
- 7:03I came up with this.
- 7:04So I know they're supposed to come up
- 7:06with two or three.
- 7:06You want me to read all of mine
- 7:08and just go through your list?
- 7:10What defines let's define a command?
- 7:12What defines your top ten commandments?
- 7:14These are things you know,
- 7:14commandments are things that you shall or
- 7:17shall not do in any circumstance at this
- 7:20point in our AV careers.
- 7:23It's just you shouldn't or should do these
- 7:25things.
- 7:25You should not or maybe should or
- 7:26sometimes maybe you do.
- 7:27It just explicitly... It depends.
- 7:30If you should or should not in each
- 7:32commandment.
- 7:33So it's not always thou shall.
- 7:35It's sometimes thou shall not.
- 7:37Unless you shall.
- 7:39Or shouldn't.
- 7:41General AV words of wisdom.
- 7:44These are just general words of wisdom.
- 7:48General suggestions.
- 7:50Suggestions, not commandments.
- 7:52The most strongest beliefs that Justin has
- 7:55as of today in line with AV.
- 7:57Now, this is fluid.
- 7:58It could change tomorrow.
- 7:59I was going to say, it sounds fluid.
- 8:00How many of these are based on today's
- 8:02commandments or tomorrow's?
- 8:07as follows today's commandments are
- 8:08tomorrow's problems let's just let's
- 8:10realize that possibly but not necessarily
- 8:13so just because i clipped this i want
- 8:14to run it anyway because it's funny and
- 8:16it cracks me up would you clip what
- 8:18i what i say go all pay heed
- 8:21the lord the lord jehovah has given unto
- 8:32you these fifteen ten ten commandments for
- 8:33all to obey
- 8:35Okay.
- 8:36Sorry, you said Ten Commandments.
- 8:37That's the first thing that came to mind
- 8:38was the Mel Brooks classics.
- 8:39So these are not in any specific weighted
- 8:42order whatsoever,
- 8:43but genuinely you have very strong beliefs
- 8:46about these.
- 8:46Yes.
- 8:47Like I always try to follow these things.
- 8:50except i know i see someone on your
- 8:53list that you do not follow yeah i
- 8:56can't yeah we just gotta get we're not
- 8:57gonna have times and we gotta get in
- 8:58here somewhere so i want to know what
- 9:00those are larry how do you know we'll
- 9:02get there i'm i'm curious if we could
- 9:03this could go many different ways today we
- 9:05might just do you want me to just
- 9:07know do you want me to pause and
- 9:08talk about each i would say pick pick
- 9:10one and we'll go around one let's go
- 9:11there and usb
- 9:16I don't think any of us disagree with.
- 9:17Okay,
- 9:19that was the one that was when he
- 9:20came down reading an order.
- 9:24Mouse and keyboard are farther away from
- 9:26your computer than move the computer.
- 9:28It's called wireless keyboard and mouse.
- 9:30That's an IT thing.
- 9:31That's a nightmare.
- 9:33Okay,
- 9:35that's a different group on your campus.
- 9:36Okay, so what's up?
- 9:38I want to know we don't want to
- 9:39rattle off.
- 9:40We're talking about USB in the
- 9:43the naughty list kind of not from cameras,
- 9:45not from other high bandwidth USB sources,
- 9:48correct?
- 9:49Stop doing that.
- 9:50Yeah,
- 9:50you're saying don't use USB as a
- 9:53replacement for the appropriate transport
- 9:56by extending USB through some bootleg,
- 9:58you know, IT nonsense.
- 10:00If it's not an SDI or Cat.Six type
- 10:03cable, you're in trouble.
- 10:04That I agree with.
- 10:06That's not extending USB.
- 10:10Because it's not the cat six is the
- 10:12problem.
- 10:13It's the
- 10:15TXRX sides that become issues.
- 10:17Yeah.
- 10:17All right.
- 10:19So is it because it's going to go
- 10:21wrong, just generally,
- 10:22thou shalt not do it because you're not
- 10:23going to have a good time?
- 10:23It's been a pain.
- 10:24It's been quite a bit of a pain.
- 10:26Well, if a friend of the show,
- 10:28Joe Cornwell, was here,
- 10:29he'd tell us USB was not designed for
- 10:30that.
- 10:31USB was designed to talk to local
- 10:32peripherals connected to a computer.
- 10:36It's not made to go long distance.
- 10:37And yes,
- 10:38you can make it go long distance,
- 10:40but there's all sorts of things.
- 10:41Because now you're way outside the spec of
- 10:42what that protocol is supposed to do.
- 10:44You run into all sorts of nonsense support
- 10:46issues.
- 10:47I want to know what Larry thinks that
- 10:48I do on this list because I'm shocked
- 10:50at that.
- 10:50We'll get there.
- 10:51We're going to get there.
- 10:52Can I just rattle these off real quick?
- 10:54No, no, no.
- 10:56Larry, go.
- 10:58Thou shall not use two screens when one
- 11:00will do.
- 11:01And what that means is you simplify the
- 11:03functionality for the end user even if
- 11:05they don't want to.
- 11:06You got to understand what they think they
- 11:10want to do.
- 11:12And then also understand the cognitive
- 11:13load of what that's going to take them
- 11:15to do.
- 11:15And they're not going to be able to
- 11:16do that in the middle of a class.
- 11:17And so simplify the system in such a
- 11:20way that they can actually accomplish
- 11:22teaching.
- 11:23And most of the time, Larry,
- 11:24I'll back you up on this.
- 11:26It breaks your viewing angle standards.
- 11:29Yeah,
- 11:29like there are lots of reasons to simplify
- 11:32and not do stuff like what if I
- 11:34add another screen?
- 11:36Oh, yeah.
- 11:36Like a third screen in the middle.
- 11:37That's half the content here.
- 11:39Well,
- 11:39just look up to the side of one
- 11:39of them.
- 11:40Eight of them circling the room?
- 11:41At an angle.
- 11:42Yeah.
- 11:43Mark eight screens.
- 11:43What's going on there?
- 11:45So I want to lean into the discomfort
- 11:47of this a little bit.
- 11:49Is there a correct environment where Val
- 11:51can have two screens?
- 11:52Yes.
- 11:53Conference rooms can work,
- 11:55depending on the shape of the furniture.
- 11:56That was probably the least on my list,
- 11:58but OK.
- 11:59Because if I'm laying it out, they design.
- 12:01Let me redact that statement.
- 12:03Can thou do this in a typical learning
- 12:06environment successfully, Larry?
- 12:08Maybe,
- 12:08depends on the shape of the room and
- 12:10furniture.
- 12:10But if two displays can cover the entire
- 12:13audience in the same manner and everyone
- 12:15can see the content.
- 12:17Equally.
- 12:18You can have two screens up there,
- 12:19but it's very limited because most people
- 12:21don't design classrooms that way.
- 12:23I've come across a couple.
- 12:25But Justin,
- 12:26let me give you an alternative here.
- 12:28I teach in the College of Business.
- 12:29I need two screens because two is better
- 12:31than one.
- 12:32I have two monitors at my computer.
- 12:33Therefore, I need two computer screens.
- 12:35I think we all see that.
- 12:36We see this a lot.
- 12:36I think we'd all agree.
- 12:37You need to change rooms.
- 12:38I don't disagree.
- 12:39I'm just saying this seems to be something
- 12:40from the College of Business for whatever
- 12:42reason.
- 12:42They're like, we need two screens in here.
- 12:44Why?
- 12:44Well, because that'd be two.
- 12:47no i was actually going to bring tease
- 12:49this out how much time we have in
- 12:50this there seems to be this like
- 12:51disconnect between like screen real estate
- 12:54and two pipes exactly and it's like
- 12:57there's this modality people get and
- 12:58they're like no i need two pipes worth
- 13:00of real estate but what if i give
- 13:02you the same thing no no i need
- 13:04two things my response is it always gets
- 13:07into that well what about powerpoint in my
- 13:08notes that's usually the hill this falls
- 13:10apart you don't want to show the class
- 13:12your notes so it's okay
- 13:13right so my point is always do you
- 13:16want to disservice half the room you want
- 13:19to i say that to the faculty i
- 13:21was like you were doing this i don't
- 13:25like them they can't see it and they're
- 13:28like and they usually say oh i never
- 13:31never thought of it that way of course
- 13:33we'll keep one and like okay then that's
- 13:35what we're gonna make a real small one
- 13:36over in the corner i need all the
- 13:38whiteboard space i'm not going to
- 13:39sacrifice any of that second monitor
- 13:42But that is for you to use and
- 13:44not to be broadcasting that.
- 13:45Can I turn it around so the students
- 13:47can view it?
- 13:48I'd love that.
- 13:48They do that a lot.
- 13:49I don't give a shit.
- 13:50You can try.
- 13:52Until they rip tables out of stuff.
- 13:53Yeah, it ain't going to work very well.
- 13:55So we're not doing two screens just
- 13:56normally across the board.
- 13:58Nothing that makes them route something
- 13:59else from a separate touch.
- 14:00I only do it if it makes sense
- 14:02from a visual acuity perspective.
- 14:04Okay.
- 14:06There's a lot there, but okay.
- 14:07Mark, what's coming off your list here?
- 14:10Thou shall design for serviceability.
- 14:14It is non negotiable.
- 14:17Which means that's on my list to kind
- 14:18of the same.
- 14:20No,
- 14:20I think it's important because it's a good
- 14:22concept.
- 14:22I'm not disagreeing with understand that
- 14:25this this is not necessarily what am I
- 14:26going to design my pin down?
- 14:27I'm gonna read this thing.
- 14:28But when you view options and
- 14:30opportunities and manufacturers come to
- 14:31you,
- 14:32do you understand what that means to your
- 14:34serviceability?
- 14:35Does the impact of
- 14:36your staff how does it tie into your
- 14:39ecosystem all that just because it does
- 14:40something on paper does not necessarily
- 14:43make ensure that's going to translate to
- 14:45what you need from a serviceability
- 14:46standpoint we all have ecosystems pick
- 14:49your whatever it is does this work well
- 14:51outside of what just the specs say do
- 14:53your people know how to do it are
- 14:55they trained to do it under skill like
- 14:57have that in the back of your mind
- 14:58not just
- 14:59Well, it says it can do it.
- 15:00And it's got the right number of eyes
- 15:02and the right amount.
- 15:02Oh, so it should work.
- 15:05That's kind of where we see a lot
- 15:06of that friction with like consultants all
- 15:07time.
- 15:07Well, they're like, well,
- 15:08just says it can do this, like,
- 15:10but it doesn't fit my service ecosystem
- 15:12doesn't fit my capacity of my students,
- 15:13my technicians, all those things.
- 15:15So I think it's imperative that all
- 15:17designs be viewed through that
- 15:19serviceability lens,
- 15:20I think it's too critical and
- 15:22It's too much risk if you don't.
- 15:23So is that because you're talking
- 15:25serviceability and standardization all in
- 15:27one shot,
- 15:27your standards should follow the same
- 15:30suit, right?
- 15:30They should become written in a way that
- 15:33speaks to how you're servicing and
- 15:35supporting the space,
- 15:36not just because it has the whiz bang
- 15:38thing.
- 15:39Can you actually do this?
- 15:40So if you say yes to this,
- 15:42what does it mean for you?
- 15:43Can you afford saying yes to this product
- 15:45or this service?
- 15:47yeah i i almost had the same thing
- 15:49like i had like treat yourself as treat
- 15:53your future you as the most important
- 15:55client system that you put in has to
- 15:57be serviceable and it also has to be
- 16:00standardized like you don't put a piece of
- 16:02equipment in until jamie has tested it on
- 16:05his system for a year yes once jamie
- 16:08has figured out how many times it's going
- 16:09to fail and what the remediation path is
- 16:11then you can use it yes now shall
- 16:14not test equipment
- 16:16no battle shall not test equipment on your
- 16:18network tested on jamie's okay so that i
- 16:23mean do you well let's i mean do
- 16:25you agree disagree with this i mean i
- 16:27agree it's just like i'm going through
- 16:28mine you've stepped on like three of mine
- 16:30with just one there so but that's that's
- 16:32on brand for me yeah he's kind of
- 16:34broad sweeping in his commandments
- 16:36Well, I think, to me,
- 16:38I would have started off with that.
- 16:39I disagree with the way you,
- 16:40and I think it's just your phrasing.
- 16:41I disagree that we design,
- 16:44that standards are based on serviceability
- 16:47as a primary.
- 16:47Standards should be based, in my opinion,
- 16:48standards should be based on experience of
- 16:50teaching and learning.
- 16:50Is that not the service that we're trying
- 16:53to deliver anyway?
- 16:54I don't know.
- 16:55I think it's both.
- 16:56I think it's both.
- 16:57I think there's a happy medium here.
- 16:58To me, that's a support ability,
- 16:59and that's your staff's ability to
- 17:01maintain.
- 17:02But if the system goes down,
- 17:03then teaching and learning gets
- 17:05interrupted as well.
- 17:05It's compromised.
- 17:06So it's got to be both.
- 17:07You have to do both.
- 17:08Yeah, it's a balance.
- 17:09And I think you're right to say, OK,
- 17:11it looks like this from this perspective,
- 17:12and I'll say that from that perspective.
- 17:13I think just generally,
- 17:15and I think this is probably more of
- 17:18an issue for different universities and
- 17:19schools that are relying more heavily
- 17:21about outside integrators,
- 17:23understanding the impact for a design that
- 17:25is not your own on your abilities.
- 17:27You're walking right all over knowledge
- 17:29work to just swinging your arms around.
- 17:32I've been singing.
- 17:34Chris, what is one of yours, sir?
- 17:37I got it.
- 17:37So so far,
- 17:38I've marked off like four on my list
- 17:40that you just I'm just being efficient.
- 17:42Apparently,
- 17:42you just you want one commitment.
- 17:43Do what I say.
- 17:45This is one paragraph.
- 17:47All right.
- 17:49Damacy,
- 17:50this one's what Larry talked about, too.
- 17:51I guess I'm gonna delete
- 17:52This one.
- 17:54You can always steal one.
- 17:56Go to Justin's list.
- 17:57He has an infinite list there.
- 17:59I got a good list.
- 18:00I'm going for the one I know Mark
- 18:01don't do.
- 18:04I know.
- 18:04It's sitting right in front of me.
- 18:05It's one of my options,
- 18:06and I'm bad at it, so go ahead.
- 18:08Thou shalt document everything.
- 18:10Exactly.
- 18:10That's the one.
- 18:12I'm looking right at it on my list.
- 18:13I was like, oh, I couldn't say that.
- 18:14Documentation loves uptime.
- 18:16Always save final signal flows,
- 18:17your IP schemes, your firmware versions,
- 18:20your as-builts.
- 18:22And so the note here,
- 18:23the note that I like,
- 18:24the way I phrased this was,
- 18:25if your documentation is go ask Steve,
- 18:30you're like one person leaving away from
- 18:33just utter chaos.
- 18:34Unless Steve is your AI bot,
- 18:36that may work.
- 18:38That's not what that means, and you know.
- 18:41Now, you raise a good point.
- 18:42If everything is properly documented,
- 18:43you have that,
- 18:44and the AI bot has access to it,
- 18:45and you can say, oh,
- 18:45go ask the Steve bot.
- 18:46Maybe.
- 18:48I think we're all...
- 18:50guilty of not fully documenting i'm i'll
- 18:53tell you where my weak point is is
- 18:55as built going back and those tweaks you
- 18:58make during installation of going back and
- 19:01and updating my drawings for that it's
- 19:02hard to find time to do that so
- 19:04here's the weird part yes i'm guilty of
- 19:08not having documents for a thing but
- 19:11I also believe thou shall not waste time
- 19:13over documenting common things that
- 19:14everybody should be doing all the time
- 19:15anyway.
- 19:16I disagree with that.
- 19:16Yeah.
- 19:17I don't.
- 19:18I agree with Mark on that one.
- 19:19And so there are certain things of
- 19:21standards.
- 19:21What are common things that you didn't
- 19:23know?
- 19:23If I'm going to build the same type
- 19:25of room over and over and over and
- 19:26over again,
- 19:27then it would be fully documented.
- 19:28The argument for that is,
- 19:30which I address in my class,
- 19:32if you want to take a class on
- 19:33this.
- 19:33And when is this class, Justin?
- 19:35first three days.
- 19:36If I wanted to take this doc class,
- 19:37where would I sign up?
- 19:39You want to keep those things documented
- 19:41to some degree as a standard because in
- 19:44theory, you have new employees coming in,
- 19:46new student workers,
- 19:47and that information can transpose to
- 19:50other people more easily versus, well,
- 19:53I mean,
- 19:54ninety percent of our department knows how
- 19:56to do something.
- 19:56So, eh, F it.
- 19:58I'm not saying it doesn't exist in
- 20:00documentation, but at the same time,
- 20:02I'm not saying that
- 20:04we know what our general things are,
- 20:07right?
- 20:08Saying we cannot move forward until we
- 20:10have this exactly spelled out to be the
- 20:11same thing we've done over and over and
- 20:12over again.
- 20:14Okay.
- 20:14Yeah.
- 20:15I don't agree with keeping that as a
- 20:16gatekeeper for not doing something like an
- 20:18excuse, but like,
- 20:20like you should be working towards
- 20:21documenting everything if you don't like,
- 20:23I think the general consensus is we want
- 20:25to document as much as we can.
- 20:26And I'll just say, Mark hates schematics.
- 20:29No, I don't.
- 20:30Yes, you do.
- 20:32With a passion.
- 20:33No, come on.
- 20:33You're talking about... I love to hate it.
- 20:36That's not design.
- 20:37That's not what that is.
- 20:37No, no, no.
- 20:38That's just documentation.
- 20:39I know that you get to systems where
- 20:41you have to and you're like,
- 20:42I know this has to be done,
- 20:43but man,
- 20:44I really don't want to do this shit.
- 20:46I don't think...
- 20:46I don't necessarily hate them.
- 20:48I hate the process of having to sit
- 20:49down and commit gobs and gobs of hours
- 20:51to doing things that
- 20:54Is it part of the,
- 20:54do we need them?
- 20:55Yes.
- 20:55Do I like to have that identity of
- 20:56having to do them all?
- 20:57No.
- 20:57Yeah, I'm with Mark on that.
- 21:02I mean, it's just like doing taxes.
- 21:03Do you want to do taxes all the
- 21:04time?
- 21:05I love doing taxes.
- 21:06You just don't.
- 21:07Right.
- 21:09All right, Justin,
- 21:10what's next on your list?
- 21:13Thou shall abide by all five X safety
- 21:15factors.
- 21:16So I'm tired of people hanging shit.
- 21:19with stupid things.
- 21:20The toggles on the box says two hundred
- 21:23pounds.
- 21:24Drywall screws are just fine.
- 21:26And part of this is, you know,
- 21:29and I guess I have nine commandments here,
- 21:32but one of them is bow shall support
- 21:35drop ceiling speakers independently of the
- 21:37ceiling grid.
- 21:37I'm sick and tired of looking at new
- 21:39ceilings that are
- 21:41concave like what the hell y'all doing
- 21:43it's a good to reflect better my business
- 21:45we bid on something and then i go
- 21:47back and look at some asshole that didn't
- 21:50do any safety factor stuff that i bid
- 21:53in my job that increased cost that like
- 21:56you can't get away with that like why
- 21:58are you talking about the integrators who
- 21:59did work on my campus before i got
- 22:01here because that's me it's infuriating to
- 22:04me it's it's it's a bad
- 22:07Did you guys ever go into a room
- 22:08and find a projector on the grid and
- 22:09the whole ceiling's like leaning down
- 22:11towards it?
- 22:11Yeah.
- 22:13It's like,
- 22:14how did you get away with that?
- 22:15How's the building inspector... Like,
- 22:16how's the client not worried about killing
- 22:19people?
- 22:20I'm interested.
- 22:21Is that in your scope to check?
- 22:25It's... Hell yeah.
- 22:27I mean, if you were designing it,
- 22:28but if you were to like...
- 22:30have something handed off.
- 22:32This becomes like a whole project process.
- 22:34If you walked into a space,
- 22:36let's just assume that you found out that
- 22:37a newly furnished building- Like College
- 22:39of Business, for instance?
- 22:40Whatever it is,
- 22:41whatever new college building du jour,
- 22:45if you walked in,
- 22:47would you take ownership on remediating
- 22:48that?
- 22:49Or would you say, nope,
- 22:49if you touch it legally- We're talking
- 22:51about it.
- 22:51I'm going to walk over to that building
- 22:54with a ladder,
- 22:54and my first thing I'm doing is popping
- 22:56my head above that ceiling going,
- 22:58this shit's got to get fixed,
- 22:59all of it.
- 23:02And that's part of us owning that system
- 23:06and being accountable for that system.
- 23:09If I'm not doing my due diligence,
- 23:11if I take over a system and I
- 23:14know the integrators are doing a subpar
- 23:16job,
- 23:17I'm going to have a commitment that I
- 23:19want to go right after you on this
- 23:20one when we're all said and done.
- 23:21Okay.
- 23:22But there's no way I'm trusting that
- 23:24person to do their job right.
- 23:26And so I've got to check off on
- 23:27all that shit.
- 23:28This might be a dovetailing on that one
- 23:30or maybe the same thing.
- 23:32But thou shall not let business process
- 23:35get in the way of doing what is
- 23:37correct.
- 23:41example if your general identity for the
- 23:45organization which you work for is av and
- 23:47there's an av problem thou shalt remediate
- 23:50that problem not wait for some legal
- 23:52definition as to when you can or cannot
- 23:54do it you're gonna have to i'm not
- 23:57sure what's the scenario on this you all
- 24:00know what's right and wrong something's
- 24:01broken if you get to a point you
- 24:02say oh well we didn't install it somebody
- 24:04else did
- 24:06and there's a class at risk because it's
- 24:07not working,
- 24:08go in there and try to fix it.
- 24:10We can't do it.
- 24:11Is that a thing?
- 24:12Yeah, we're not doing it.
- 24:15The project's not even done.
- 24:17It's not even signed off on at all.
- 24:20If there are classes in there on behalf
- 24:23of the university and it is not generally
- 24:25able to go in there and fix it,
- 24:27it's still under contract.
- 24:28It's been not done for a year.
- 24:30Like at some point.
- 24:32Who's signing off on it?
- 24:34I wasn't going to do this one.
- 24:35I had a note to it.
- 24:36I was like,
- 24:36I'm going to just say it anyway.
- 24:37The university as a whole is not allowing
- 24:41us to go in there to work on
- 24:42anything.
- 24:45I still believe in the best interest of
- 24:48the organization that you go remediate
- 24:50that.
- 24:51Successful learning outcomes would dictate
- 24:53that you go fix it.
- 24:54With what time and what money.
- 24:56And our schedule's already full.
- 24:59When you win.
- 25:02Right now.
- 25:02Stop the documentation and go fix it.
- 25:05get in there we didn't put it in
- 25:08we don't have any schematics we don't have
- 25:10any passwords we have no ip addresses we
- 25:12have we haven't even set foot in the
- 25:15building yet okay pause there would you
- 25:18know what you need to do if you
- 25:19were going to go in there yeah and
- 25:22what the fuck are you waiting for go
- 25:24get it done time time you know it's
- 25:27gonna it's gonna take a week to fix
- 25:29one room mark
- 25:33I'm thinking about this.
- 25:34When you do that,
- 25:35when classes are going on, Mark,
- 25:38a week to fix the breaks between classes.
- 25:42We just had winter break, dude.
- 25:43That was several weeks.
- 25:44You can make substantial progress in ten
- 25:46minutes.
- 25:46We were already booked on other projects
- 25:48over other EDU classes.
- 25:53Okay.
- 25:53I only wanted to get in there because
- 25:54it was a good opportunity to do so.
- 25:56It was a good opportunity.
- 25:58I mean, I just don't understand.
- 26:00Larry, what's another one for me?
- 26:02Well,
- 26:02you stole my last one on my list,
- 26:05so I was going to steal one on
- 26:06Chris's list that's really good,
- 26:08but I'll let him keep it.
- 26:09I misread yours here and thought it was
- 26:11way more interesting, but okay, go ahead.
- 26:12Wait, what?
- 26:12That was insulting.
- 26:16I'm going to just say I thought the
- 26:17word was furniture when I was scrolling
- 26:19past.
- 26:19Oh, okay.
- 26:22So rather than steal Chris's...
- 26:24You can steal from my list.
- 26:26I can steal from your list?
- 26:27Because I really like the four K,
- 26:28five K, eight K nonsense.
- 26:30Okay, that's fine.
- 26:31Okay, I'm going to steal that one then,
- 26:32because I really like it.
- 26:34Thou shall not chase resolution idols.
- 26:39Nobody can see it anyway.
- 26:40It doesn't matter.
- 26:41Like do not put four K, five K,
- 26:43eight K anywhere outside of very,
- 26:46very unique applications.
- 26:48Yes.
- 26:48If you're in an igloo.
- 26:49Yes.
- 26:50If you're touching the wall.
- 26:52Yes, yes, yes.
- 26:53But outside of that,
- 26:56ten ADP is the max everywhere.
- 26:58Seven twenty all day.
- 27:00Yeah.
- 27:00Do I hear four eighty?
- 27:02I'd go four ADP black burst rumors that
- 27:04are four eighty.
- 27:06Otherwise, you're just wasting money.
- 27:08NTSC gets it done.
- 27:11By the way, Larry,
- 27:13I think that's the reason why they're not
- 27:15done yet is for K.
- 27:18It would not surprise me.
- 27:19For K for K.
- 27:22seat yeah i'm not what's that mean justin
- 27:25they're not done yet because of four k
- 27:28are they waiting are there support i'm
- 27:29going to cost them four thousand dollars
- 27:31per room they did not have a very
- 27:33they did not have a very well thought
- 27:35through edid plan with all the devices and
- 27:37things they had to configure and so
- 27:42they're forcing four k through a ten
- 27:44eighty monitor and they're wondering why
- 27:45it's not working where did you guys find
- 27:47it if you know this why don't you
- 27:49tell them and get it fixed
- 27:52We have.
- 27:53We told them.
- 27:54They're asking us, and we told them,
- 27:56and they're like,
- 27:56we put in Crestron and fixed it.
- 27:58I'm like, yeah, you put in scalers.
- 28:01We don't put in scalers like that should
- 28:03be the eleventh commandment.
- 28:05Thou shall not actually,
- 28:05that's a good point that putting,
- 28:08putting a hardware scaler at the end of
- 28:10your signal chain does not fix your
- 28:11inability to set up an eat chain.
- 28:13No.
- 28:14And that's exactly what this integrator
- 28:15did and said,
- 28:16we should have used Crestron instead.
- 28:17I'm like use their use Crestron's D ten
- 28:21and E ten series.
- 28:22And let's see what the hell happens until
- 28:24you need to, you're not,
- 28:25now you're not doing apples and apples
- 28:26here.
- 28:28So that's a whole other thing.
- 28:29Now shall not use scalers is my limit.
- 28:31That is a good one.
- 28:31I like that one.
- 28:32I like that one.
- 28:33That one's better than... Chris,
- 28:34what did you get?
- 28:34By the way, so I,
- 28:37as you all know, inherited a campus.
- 28:38Many, many, many, many, many, many, many,
- 28:40many, many RMC scalers out there.
- 28:44I did find a room that had a
- 28:47seven-twenty P and ten-eighty I capable
- 28:49cameras, the older PTZ cameras,
- 28:52ten-eighty I.
- 28:54which is the one place so far you
- 28:56could legitimately say I want a hardware
- 28:58scaler there, and it didn't happen.
- 29:00So, we'll see.
- 29:04Thanks, guys.
- 29:04Anyway, can I read one?
- 29:05No, I haven't gotten mine yet.
- 29:06It's going to get a bunch of extra
- 29:08credit ones in here.
- 29:08Let's see.
- 29:09Where's the one I was trying to find?
- 29:14Ah, thou shalt protect audio above all.
- 29:20You can make do with bad video.
- 29:21Video forgives.
- 29:22I just have a heart attack right now.
- 29:24Video forgives, audio does not.
- 29:26Bad lighting can be annoying,
- 29:28but bad audio is fatal.
- 29:30uh if you have to choose you sound
- 29:33over an awesome picture is this that's
- 29:36primarily in like teaching and learning is
- 29:37this like specifically geared towards like
- 29:40collaboration and conferencing yes yes so
- 29:44i i agree with that but come on
- 29:46chris that's such a little hanging fruit
- 29:47okay you want to know that's like saying
- 29:50the a is relevant in a and b
- 29:52Okay, wait, I got one for Mark.
- 29:53Here's one for Mark.
- 29:54How about this?
- 29:54I'll sneak another one in here.
- 29:55Go for it.
- 29:56Because that last one was so bad it
- 29:57didn't count.
- 29:58It was good.
- 29:59I liked it.
- 30:00Thou shalt avoid over-automation.
- 30:05Just because you can auto-switch,
- 30:08auto-mix, auto-sense,
- 30:09auto-track your cameras, auto-detect,
- 30:13motion-sensor lights,
- 30:14doesn't mean you should.
- 30:16Complexity increases support.
- 30:18Larry brought up complexity increases
- 30:20cognitive load.
- 30:21And sometimes, this is just for Mark,
- 30:23sometimes the best control system is fewer
- 30:26decisions.
- 30:27That's exactly what I'm doing.
- 30:30But I read all that, like,
- 30:31continue to do my automated system.
- 30:36But sometimes because of their screen on
- 30:39the display, so like,
- 30:41there's a happy medium there.
- 30:43Yeah,
- 30:43but it's only for certain types of spaces,
- 30:44right?
- 30:44Okay, Justin, now get us right.
- 30:46You want me to do some more?
- 30:48Yeah,
- 30:48do one of them that you don't follow
- 30:49track of where we are.
- 30:51Let's like thou shalt remodel,
- 30:55read manuals.
- 30:56I know you don't do that.
- 31:00Nobody reads the manuals.
- 31:03What the hell do you think I'm...
- 31:05I'll get number five, Justin.
- 31:06Go there.
- 31:08Thou shalt not use a touch panel when
- 31:10a button panel will suffice.
- 31:12Agreed.
- 31:12And I kind of want to hit comma
- 31:15and also say don't use a button panel
- 31:16when nothing will suffice because I've
- 31:18done a few rooms that don't have an
- 31:20interface.
- 31:20What if it was automated?
- 31:22You walked in, plugged in,
- 31:23and it just worked?
- 31:24What if you walked in and you just
- 31:25have to wave your arms and things just
- 31:26happen?
- 31:27Yeah.
- 31:27Or say, monitor on.
- 31:32What if you just stayed home and just
- 31:33joined remotely?
- 31:34Plug and play to tech stuff.
- 31:35Pretty simple.
- 31:36It's all wireless now.
- 31:41Let's see.
- 31:41Dallas will not use chassis-based matrix
- 31:43switches.
- 31:44Oh, there we go.
- 31:46Except for if you're going to use stacked,
- 31:48sixteen or above more.
- 31:50It has to be matrix into matrix with
- 31:52sixteen by.
- 31:53But you're running four outputs in your
- 31:55quad box and your quad boxes?
- 31:58Yeah, yeah.
- 31:58I want to see all of those.
- 32:00If you're going to do it, go bold.
- 32:03Thou shalt abide by audio coverage
- 32:05uniformity standards.
- 32:07It's an easy one.
- 32:10Okay.
- 32:12Read the next one.
- 32:13Read the next one.
- 32:15Thou shall abide by discus.
- 32:17Now I will say that sometimes I can't
- 32:20abide by this.
- 32:20Exactly.
- 32:22Based upon skilling heights.
- 32:24But it's well communicated.
- 32:26But I always,
- 32:28it's number two on my list right after
- 32:30audio coverage uniformity in my designs.
- 32:32So could we use all of these to
- 32:33design the ultimate worst room?
- 32:36Really quick here.
- 32:37We got multi-display USB extension,
- 32:39eight K three foot tall images.
- 32:42Could we make the worst scenario room
- 32:45ever?
- 32:45That would, I got,
- 32:48I got one of my list just for
- 32:50Justin here.
- 32:50What is it?
- 32:51He's going to love this one.
- 32:53Thou shalt not let vendors design nice
- 32:55strategy.
- 32:58I agree with that.
- 32:59Because vendors will design and build
- 33:02projects.
- 33:02Those are big words.
- 33:04Okay, well,
- 33:04so vendors will design and build projects.
- 33:07You're interested in systems and
- 33:08standards.
- 33:09So they'll come in and do their own
- 33:12thing that's not aligned with either of
- 33:14those,
- 33:14and they get their check and they peace
- 33:16out.
- 33:17Yeah, I'm pretty sure I agree with that.
- 33:19How many did we get?
- 33:20I don't know.
- 33:21We're like in the twenty-seven range.
- 33:23Yeah, at this point.
- 33:23Thou shalt use sixteen by nine.
- 33:26I think that's just a legal requirement
- 33:27these days.
- 33:28Yeah.
- 33:30There's not really any other options.
- 33:31How shall we label cables?
- 33:35I think I'm including all the eleven
- 33:37commandments that I had.
- 33:38Yeah.
- 33:38I think you got it.
- 33:41um yeah i have the label cables thing
- 33:42on here as well um if you just
- 33:44might note that like you don't know what
- 33:46hdmi three is a year from now so
- 33:48labeling that with a human readable but
- 33:50i'm pretty sure it's not going to be
- 33:51analog audio it's probably going to be
- 33:53something to do with video so at least
- 33:54you know my favorite is when you see
- 33:56the handwritten labels with a question
- 33:58mark
- 34:00this is probably this question no it says
- 34:02it says confidence monitor question mark
- 34:03you're like what what's supposed to do you
- 34:07feel confident about this no uh does
- 34:11anybody else have one that they want to
- 34:12bring up because otherwise we'll wrap up
- 34:13and roll out here i have one i'm
- 34:14going to mention here at the end but
- 34:15it's it's a it's one i i violate
- 34:18all the freaking time but what is it
- 34:21thou shalt test with real content
- 34:25a laptop your laptop with a default
- 34:28windows background is not a test of an
- 34:31appropriate test for your your video
- 34:33systems no i don't know oh we're all
- 34:39guilty of that one the whole nine thousand
- 34:40spec check it off over document it yeah
- 34:45every room forget this out what size it
- 34:47is
- 34:49Okay.
- 34:51Well, any last minute things?
- 34:52A network-based one,
- 34:53but I don't know if it's really relevant
- 34:54or not.
- 34:54The network is part of your...
- 34:55I have one about life cycle, but...
- 34:57I have a life cycle one as well.
- 34:58Design for life cycle.
- 34:59Thou shalt.
- 35:03Thou shalt appropriately commission before
- 35:05declaring victory.
- 35:05That's a good one.
- 35:09All right, well,
- 35:10I think we get the gist of it.
- 35:11All right, well, there's your,
- 35:13I don't know how many that was.
- 35:14That's a lot.
- 35:16There was probably like seventeen in
- 35:17there.
- 35:19Or eighteen commandments.
- 35:21The things you got to do maybe most
- 35:22of the time,
- 35:23unless you knowingly violate them,
- 35:24which we all do.
- 35:25Yeah, if you want.
- 35:27If you feel like it this week.
- 35:29All right, any last thoughts?
- 35:30nope maybe all right well safety is
- 35:32important be safe out there good point
- 35:34safety third safety third after lunch all
- 35:39right okay well do this and we'll uh
- 35:42we'll come back we'll be back next month
- 35:43with more stuff uh head over to
- 35:44avsuperfriends.com for uh more shows of
- 35:47this type of discussion
- 35:52with yet another episode of AV
- 35:54Superfriends On Topic.
- 35:55You can contact us with questions,
- 35:57topic ideas,
- 35:58or general complaints at
- 35:59avsuperfriends.com.
- 36:08Nice work, everyone.
- 36:09Sharp broadcast.
- 36:11Really good.
- 36:11Everyone on the floor as well.
- 36:13Really a lot of hustle.
- 36:14I liked it.
- 36:15The opinions expressed by the AV
- 36:17Superfriends are solely those of the
- 36:18individuals and do not represent their
- 36:20respective institutions, organizations,
- 36:22companies, or clients.