Latest / Brains & Bots / The Ed Tech Delusion
Transcript
- speaker-1: Good morning, good afternoon, good evening, wherever you are. Welcome to Brains and Bots, a podcast brought to you by the National Association of Scholars. I'm Lila Nourakish and I'm a senior fellow for international affairs and academic integrity. Brains and Bots, or BNB, is focusing on technology and education, on how education contributes to human flourishing and where education may fall into this system. Our first guest is Dr. Jared Horvath. Who is a neuroscientist, educator, and a best-selling author who specializes in human learning and brain development? He's the creator of the Learning Blueprint, an international award-winning program helping educators and students understand how learning actually works. Jarrett has conducted research and taught at Harvard University, Harvard Medical School, and at the University of Melbourne, and has worked with more than a thousand schools around the world. He is the author of six books. including the new as the digital delusion, which is the topic of today's conversation. This is the wonderful book by the way. Jared currently serves as the director of Alamy Global, an organization dedicated to bring cutting edge brain and behavioral science to educators, students and communities. Jared, we are so happy to have you join today. Welcome. speaker-0: Thank you so much for having me on. This will be great. speaker-1: Yeah, so excited. So without further ado, let's start our conversation. you organized the opening of your wonderful book, The The Digital Delusion, around five myths, that education is broken, multimedia enhances learning, free choice leads to better learning, and children learn best on their own. And intelligent tutors make children more intr intelligent intelligent. which myth has shaped more school policy in your view? And who do these claims remain persuasive despite the evidence that you present in your book? speaker-0: Yeah, it's it's I think depends on kind of what angle you're going at, but there was a very big and there still is a very big progressive education movement going on that basically argues children learn best with minimal guidance. That if you simply give them access to information and freedom, they will figure things out. And that's gotta be one of the most pernicious myths still going around. And I mean this is countries are still doing that, states are still following that. And the idea is basically that, or the problem with that is when left to your own devices, very few people will ever progress without what are called self-regulated learning skills. So SRLs, those are kind of the underlying framework needed to drive your own learning, to guide your own evolution. If you want to call it anything, you just call it metacognition. Metacognition is key to driving your own learning. Most people do not have it. Where do we develop it? We historically have developed it in a K through 12 generalized education. That means when you replace that kind of education with a free-for-all, you lose the skills. You no longer impart the skills kids need to make the free-for-all meaningful. And what you get is just a bunch of people regressing to that which they already know. Which isn't a shock to any teacher, really. I mean, if you if you've ever given a project or an assignment to your kids and you're like, all right, pick your own topic, you know, do what you want to do, you already know what everyone is gonna do. The kids who like sports are gonna do sports. The kid who likes horses is gonna do horses. The kid who likes films is gonna make a film. When we are thrown into the unknown, when we're presented with chaos, too many options, we do not expand, we do not grow, we do not seek for novelty, we regress to that which is safe, what we which we already know. So it's believe it or not, that whole self-guided learning movement, surest way to make sure kids basically just plateau. And so that's one of those things where I think there's a big battle in education between progressive education and quote. traditional, which I just would call learning. And I think that's that's still playing out very heavily in a lot of places. speaker-1: It's very interesting actually. When when I read your book it r resonated with me that you talked about struggle and how much it contributes to actually learning. and learning doesn't have to be entertaining, it has to be a struggle through which we are developing. So I this whole movement seems to be completely contrary to struggle, right? speaker-0: And I I think there's this there's this belief that any discomfort should be immediately alleviated. That if a kid feels uncomfortable, that we need to make them feel comfortable without realizing that no, it's it's just like going to the gym. If you alleviate all discomfort at the gym, that means you didn't work out. I mean, that means you put your stair stepper on two and you just had a good old time. It is the discomfort, which is the sign that you are progressing past your current boundaries. Now, can that discomfort go too far into chronic stress? Absolutely. But that's much more rare than people think, and we can handle that as a completely different subject rather than saying in order to avoid chronic stress, we will avoid any element of stress or or friction whatsoever. That was swinging the pendulum too far the other direction. speaker-1: So where is the balance in in effort and and stress in education and which is the stress that's actually not helping learning? speaker-0: So it's good whenever you enter into active learning mode, your brain will tap into a secondary energy source. So your brain, by and large, runs on sugar, on glucose. It gets glucose from your blood. But anytime you're in that struggle spot, your brain can't get enough glucose out of your blood to do that. So it taps into a secondary energy source called astrocytic glycogen. This is basically sugar that's already stored in your brain. Now, the joke is you really only have about three to four hours of that per day. So if you're assuming in a one hour class, maybe 20 minutes of that is new material, is is struggle, hard work, then you're seeing, yeah, over the course of a day, you're blown about two and a half hours of that astrocytic glycogen. All that is fine. Once you get up into trying to do six, seven, eight hours of hard learning every single day, that's when the body just starts to burn out. You don't have enough chemicals for that. That's when chronic chronic stress and learning goes down. So I think we've been pretty good. Is it's When we talk about like what's the what's that good kind of limit, just go back to the nineties, into the early knots. Schools were doing just fine, mate. We weren't broken, we were killing it. And we just had this really good mix of each class starts with a warm up, we're gonna do some hard learning, we're gonna do some practice, we're gonna end with a cooldown, have your break, let's do it again for the next class. speaker-1: That's that's a great point actually. And it it reminds me to my own learning you know experience back in the nineties and in the early two thousands, where we you know like learning was about reading and rereading and highlighting and telling it back, trying to explain it to your friends or your parents. and that was really a struggle because it not only took time but it was it was effortful. and it it also reminds me to what Mihai Chicks and Mihai Hungarian American psychologist said about the the stage of flow, that that is really a happy place for you, where you are you know succeeding in a process. So you are not concentrating on the result but on the way leading there. And actually I think it's very true for for for learning. And I was wondering how it relates to what you what you say about effortful learning and If if you can explain a little bit, I think it would be great. speaker-0: Yeah, so it's in in I love that. The concept of flow state is very interesting. So if you are learning something brand new that is just we're coming out of the blue, I'm gonna teach you how to fix the engine of a car, say. Like that's something I don't know how to do. That's astrocytic glycogen. You cannot get into flow state during that mode because your brain is working too hard to simply take in new information. But once you have the basics of something, And now you can move to what we're going to call deliberate practice, where okay, I've got the basic skill. Now I'm just gonna push it a little bit better. I'm gonna make myself a little bit faster. I'm gonna make it a little bit easier. That's when you get into flow state. So the the the point by which we're locking down, taking in and locking down new ideas, new skills, that's super effort. But then the point at which those skills are in, and now we're just locking them down, automating them, making them really good, that no longer requires that extra energy. You can get into flow state during those practice stages. That's when your brain uses glucose. Let that ride all day, every day. That is one of the best modes you can be in to consolidate learning. So flow isn't good for new learning. It's really good for consolidating experienced learning. But I mean, that's where now they start to play. And then eventually, once you lock that down. You don't even need flow anymore because now you're just coasting. Every time you see that skill, it's just autopilot. Your body's like, I already know this. You're good to go. And that's kind of a good snapshot of the movement of learning from surface learning into deep consolidation into automaticity at the end. speaker-1: That's really interesting. how does technology and education contribute to this or how it affects speaker-0: no. it looks like it should be fine. I mean, by all means, it's just information. It looks like it should be good. If tech can be said to be good at anything, it would be at that stage of deep consolidation where you're drilling skills and you're practicing them into automaticity. Now, the problem with most tech-based things are, I mean, there are dozens of them, it's kids do not view tech n as A learning tool. It's an if if a screen only existed in the classroom and that was the only place I'd ever seen it, maybe we could get away with saying, Yep, you've got 50 minutes where you need to drill math on this screen, and they might be able to sustain it. But the second the computer entered the home, and more importantly, the pocket, kids stopped seeing it as a learning tool. It became a tool for entertainment. 2,500 hours. Every single year they use these machines to entertain themselves, to flip between different tabs, to watch funny things, to do this. Now, whenever they see it, it's Pavlov's dog. They immediately see a screen and go, cool, let's have some fun with this. And we sneak in and say, No, I need you to learn. I need you to drill math problems. Well, most kids can only make it about six minutes before they start going into what they know how to do with that machine, which is fun. So unfortunately, just due to pure training, if you I'm some people say it takes 10,000 hours to master any skill. Sweet. By that definition, it takes kids four years after being introduced to tech to master one thing, flitting around on this screen, which is the one thing I can't have you doing if I now want you to learn from that screen. So believe it or not, that's one of those those things where it's like technically doing math problems should help. Why doesn't it help on a screen? Because most kids can't sustain their focus long enough to do a meaningful amount of them before going and doing something else. speaker-1: Does it mean that our brain associates screen time with entertainment and not with learning? speaker-0: Hundred percent. And it it was basic it was it was built to do that. It's called the attention economy, is they don't even hide that anymore. The way tech makes its money now is by keeping your eyes on a screen, more specifically a program for as long as it can. And they've learned the best way to do that is to continuously rapidly change what's happening. Keep shocking your system so you keep coming back for what's more. So instead of a 20-minute video on YouTube, you're watching 30-second videos. Go to the next one, go to the next one. Now, that is a great way to sustain attention because you're basically just tricking the system into a safety mode of saying, if I don't see what's going to happen next, I might die. What's going to happen next? But that kind of attention is very different than the kind of attention we need for learning, which is slow, sustained, and effortful. So if you want to get kind of really nerdy on this, the type of engagement that tech has been built to engender. Is what we're going to call ventral network engagement. It's a part of your brain that's just constantly paying attention to the world, trying to figure out if something's going to kill you. The type of engagement you need for learning is dorsal network engagement. That is personal, self-driven, sustained engagement. The two are very different. Not all engagement is created s equal. So the type of engagement that screens have, so people see, my kid was on a screen for three hours. That must be awesome. Nope. That's very different than the type of engagement I need to learn. speaker-1: That's that's super interesting and it reminds me to a study about which I read in the psychology magazine a few years ago. I'm a lawyer, so I might not be able to explain it in a very professional way from a psychological perspective, but the study was conducted under COVID and when people were in home office and they started to work from their bed in their pajamas. And they were complaining that they are not resting enough you know after sleeping in their bed. And the study actually concluded that it's because our brain associates the bed with with restful activities like sleeping. So if you're working from your bed, your brain starts to associate it with work and that's not really restful. So that might cause the the confusion for your brain. Is that similar when it comes to kids and and technology? speaker-0: Absolutely. That's where we see all human beings, we we tie our learning, our thinking to the context we're in. We use contextual cues basically to tell us what we need to be doing. And once this tool that was outside in the real world started to enter the classroom, we started to act shocked that kids would use it to play video games without realizing, no, that's all they do outside the classroom is play video games on this. Why would they think it's any different now that it happens to be in a classroom? So that's just a very good argument to say. We need to lock the context of a classroom back down. What you do outside of this school, do your thing. But in these four walls, you will only ever see these kinds of things. You will only ever allow to behave in these kind of ways. And in that way, we can retrain kids to build back up their attentional muscles, to build back up their memory and understanding simply by making it clear that this context is different than any other and there's a way you have to act here. speaker-1: So can education be fun? speaker-0: of course. I d it always is. Learning is not fun. Education is fun. So the it's it's people say is working out fun. No, heck no. When you're actually doing the lifting, it's not fun. But the second you're done and you look in the mirror and you flex, it's like, that was fun. The process itself is effort. But the context within which it happens and the growth you see because of it, that's the fun stuff. And this is why I love schools. For as much as we like to pretend that school is like that clip from Ferris Bueller, where some dude just stands there and says Bueller, Bueller. No school actually looks like that. What you're gonna do in any class, if you think back to it, is you're gonna do some hard learning, but a big chunk of your time is gonna be application and depth. You're gonna work on a project that allows you to apply that learning. You're gonna have to give a debate on a topic which forces you to think about it. You're gonna have to work with your peers. All of that is the fun stuff. The consolidation and application stuff is wickedly fun. It's the the learning stuff is hard. And so that's where I think most people think: can we skip the learning and go right into the consolidation? Well, can you touch the bottom of the pool without touching the surface of the pool? The answer is gonna be no. So anytime you try and strip away that stuff that's more work, you actually s get rid of any ability for it to become fun later. There's just nothing to have fun with after. speaker-1: Is there any levels or age where technology could be introduced in schools? And if yes, what do you think which is the age or level of education where it is okay to use technology in the classrooms? speaker-0: That's interesting. It's never gonna align with age. With that said, I can pretty comfortably say no elementary school, primary school kid needs tech. That that's never made sense to me. But a good rule of thumb when it comes to tech is when you don't need technology, is when you can now safely introduce it. So if your kids can do math, they understand arithmetic, now we can bring in a calculator. If your kids know how to formate, format a five-paragraph essay. Now we can bring in a word processor. Develop, see, we we made this big mistake where we mistook the tool for the skill. The tool is not the skill. The tool is simply the means by which you demonstrate or apply your skill. The skill is the skill. But when we teach kids exclusively on computers, we're thinking that the skill is somehow learning to use the machine to edit. No, no, no. You need to understand editing. You need to understand math. You need to understand science first. And then use the machine to demonstrate, bring those skills to life. So I think a good rule of thumb when we think when do we bring it in is always when your kids don't need it. That's when you bring it in. When they have the skill, now we're safe. With that said, we also, as we get older, we have to differentiate between curriculum and pedagogy. So sometimes curriculum is what we teach, pedagogy is how we teach. Curriculum would say we need to teach kids how to type. That is a literal skill that you will need a computer to do, or we need to teach kids how to code. Some like I'm trying to think of skills that would require a computer. In that case, you're making a curriculum argument. Cool. We need a typing class. Well, sweet. In that instance, we have a computer lab where you go take your typing class. Just like we have a music room where you go learn the oboe, and we have a gym where you learn basketball. It doesn't now, the problem is people have made that argument. We need to teach about tech. They have somehow morphed that into the argument we need to teach all skills through tech. And that's the best way to learn both. That's a pedagogy argument, and now you're making a mistake. When you tell me I have to teach math through tech, you've now stepped on my feet as a teacher and said and never listened to me to say, no, I know the best way to teach math, and it ain't through that screen. So I think you could also get away with saying we can teach about tech without then necessitating every class incorporate tech to teach skills through it. speaker-1: Yeah, I think it's a very useful differentiation between the cu curriculum and the pedagogy. many miss that point actually. I focus on higher education policy and I I see the forever dilemma. Should we allow students to use AI or not? and should we teach them how to use it? And the one one problem is that professors don't know how to use it, so it's hard to expect them to teach it. The other is yes, out there in the labor market they might be might need, depending on the profession, they might need some AI skills. But the question is, you know, how to incorporate it and AI is also constantly changing and developing. So by the time you teach them something, it might be outdated. so there's a lot of problems with this. speaker-0: And isn't that, I mean, that's the same argument as saying I you I can show you curricula where in the last hundred years people have said if you do not teach kids Morse code, they will be unable to communicate in this world. If you do not teach kids how to use a wireless radio transceiver, they will not succeed in this world. And of course, they're always wrong. Why for that exact purpose? If you try and guess what the tool of tomorrow is going to be by teaching the tool of today, You're gonna leave your kids struggling because they will have learned what to do last year with no clue what to do this year. So surely the better move is to teach kids how to learn and to think. Now they can adapt to any tool that comes their way. AI is the greatest example. AI comes down and everyone's saying, We gotta teach kids AI, we gotta teach kids AI. Mate, who uses AI? Adults. Who taught us? Nobody. How did we learn? Because we know how to think and learn. So if we avoid that process, that's what a general K through 12 education has always been. It's not I'm training you how to do a tool, it's I'm training you how to think through knowledge. That's gonna give you something to say. So take like AI, think of how stupid that is. What is AI? It's a box you type words into. Do you really think we need to devote months of curricular time to a box you type words into? Surely the important thing is what are you typing in that box? And that ability is gonna come from depth. Of knowledge and understanding, not from any training in a classroom. So by all means, I like when people talk about AI, very rarely do I use the word ban. Although to be fair, school is one giant ban. We ban clothes, we ban what you can say, we ban how you can move, we ban everything. But I rarely say ban when it comes to tech, but I do with AI because what's the point? AI is basically like, imagine inventing a tool that's gonna go lift weights for you. The job gets done. But you get no benefit of that job. And so now we get to say, what is the point of university? Is it to graduate? Well, cool, then use AI all you want to. Or is it to learn? And if it's a learning institution, then you can't use a tool that circumvents that. So a good rule of thumb as you think about AI going forward, I tell I'll tell people is AI is a tool that experts use to make their lives easier. But the tools that we use as experts to make our lives easier. Are never the tools a novice should use to learn how to become an expert. The only reason the tools work for us as experts is because we already have so much background knowledge that we can vet it and drive it. When I type in something and it spits something out, I can immediately go, yep, that's right, we're good to go. Or no, that's wrong. What is that all about? I am driving the tool. I'm just making my life easier because I don't feel like doing it all by hand out here. But a novice doesn't know enough stuff. They don't know the skills, they don't know the knowledge. So they can't drive the tool. The tool drives them. They type something in, the best they can do is copy it, paste it, hand it to somebody else. Through that process, they will not have learned facts, they will not have learned processes or skills. They will have just learned dependence on the tool. Now, is that what you want? Do you want a generation of graduates who are dependent on a tool? Or do you want a generation of graduates who know enough stuff to make tools meaningful? I was like, I sorry to to pound this home. I just think it's so dang important. Gimme a hammer. Do you think I don't know how to use a hammer? Mate, I can use a hammer with the best of them. Problem is, I got nothing to use it for. If you said build a wall, I'm like, I don't know how to do that. I know the tool, but I don't know what to do with it. Now give that to someone who understands craftsmanship and drafting and engineering. Do you think they're gonna use the hammer better than me? No. You pick it up, you swing it. They just have more stuff to say and do with it. So it wasn't the tool that was important, it was the knowledge that was important. So surely that's where we need to be focusing our inf our our time in school. speaker-1: What are the skills that needs to be taught, not just because of AI, but in general, what are the most important wider skills school has to teach to kids that cannot be done? speaker-0: I would say don't worry about skills. Knowledge, knowledge, knowledge, knowledge, knowledge. The more they understand skills, we tend to think skills are separate from knowledge. Like I've got skills over here, I've got knowledge over here, bring the two together, we're good to go. In truth, skills emerge from knowledge. They are not separate to it. They literally spring forth from your knowledge. So, in a very real sense, this means the kids who know more stuff will be more creative, will be more critical. We'll be better able to communicate. We'll have more to talk about. So we'll be more sociable. All of these higher order skills that we're saying the next generation needs, in order to develop them, you do not explicitly focus on them. You don't have a class on creativity. You continue to teach and learn, and you simply give them opportunities to apply their learning in a way that will now be creative. So my favorite example of this is the PISA exam. So this is a test given by the OECD to hundreds of thousands of ninth graders across the world every couple of years. And it tests them on reading, science, and math. Now, in 2018, they did something funny. They also included measures of creativity: creative ideation, innovation, divergent, convergent thinking, and all this stuff. Now, one country killed everyone when it came to knowledge: reading, science, math, Singapore. They always kill everyone. They are number one across the board. And everyone knows that because they have the most rigorous education system in the world. So no surprise there. Guess who killed everyone on measures of creativity? speaker-1: Singapore. speaker-0: By a country mile. They were so far ahead of everyone else. And everyone's like, how did they do that? Guess who was number two knowledge? Japan. Number two, creativity. Japan. When you lined up knowledge and creativity, all the countries tested aligned at 0.92, basically perfect. I could tell you how creative you're gonna be by how much you know. That just shows that these higher order skills emerge from our knowledge. You don't jump into creativity. And then because you can look stuff up, you can use your creativity. It's you know a lot of stuff, therefore you can now be creative with it. And so that's where I I'd say when we talk about skills of the future, just keep focusing on learning like we've always done. We'll be fine. speaker-1: That's that's very interesting. Especially because so many worried that with AI, you know, the the base information, how AI is trained is determining the answers it it gives. And obviously it can be manipulated if, you know, like let's say that probably AI models are not working the same way and not giving the same answers in North Korea and in the United States. Probably the training base is very different. So that's that also goes back to the knowledge problem, right? That if you have knowledge you can decide whether it's accurate or not, what the answer is it's giving you. speaker-0: You nailed it. Somebody said, only use AI below your knowledge. If you can't vet what it's saying, don't trust a thing it says. Cause we we did this in a classroom with kids. We said, here's a basic simple question about the brain. Like, I forget what we were talking about, but like, where's the motor strip in the brain? How do you image it? Something like that. We had every kid type that into Chat GPT at the same time. 20% of them came back with so wildly different answers that we're like, whoa. So even in the same model, you gotta remember these things aren't encyclopedias. They're just guessing. They're just token guesses. They're giant fill-in-the-blank machines. And sometimes they'll go on some path where if we weren't all doing that together, no kid would have seen just how bad it did for 20% of our kids. And those kids would have learned something totally wonky. So unless, exactly as you said, unless you can vet it, don't use it. speaker-1: You wrote a lot about multitasking and attention. could you explain what's the problem with multitasking in the classrooms and speaker-0: So what is attention? Attention, easily conceived of is a giant filter. Is there's way too much stuff coming in our brain at any one moment. We can't consciously take it all in. So attention kind of serves as our filter where we determine what's relevant, makes it into our awareness, what's irrelevant, gonna get blocked out. Now, the problem is, is you only have one attention filter slot in your brain. It's a little nugget here behind your left eye. So this means if you ever try and do two things at the same time consciously, you cannot do them simultaneously. The best you can do is start one, take your filter out, change it for the new filter, jump to this task. Take that filter out, go back to the old one, jump to this task. So we no longer talk about multitasking in research, we talk about task switching because your brain has to make that jump. Now, as your brain makes that jump between tasks. Now, again, I'm talking about conscious tasks. So if you're driving a car while singing along to the radio, You are consciously focused on singing. You don't know you're driving. That's an autopilot. And you know that because as soon as you need to find a parking spot or a house number, the first thing you're gonna do is turn off your radio, focus back on your driving. So we're talking about conscious focus on two tasks. Every time you have to swap out your attention filter, your brain goes black for about 0.2 of a second. We call it an attentional blink. You process nothing. So you're gonna start to go slower. The more you multitask, your speed just starts to drop. Because you start losing these periods of time. Also, every time you swap out your attention filter set, you have these periods where the two filters bleed together accidentally, and you get what's called rule set mixing. And what's gonna happen there is accuracy is gonna go down. You're gonna say something over here you meant to say over here. You're gonna write something over here that you actually meant to write over here. Third thing is the more you swap out your attention filter, for whatever reason, I don't know that anyone knows why this happens. Your hippocampus, which is our brain's primary memory network, starts to shut down. And your striatum, a secondary memory network, which is largely subconscious, kicks on. So in a very odd way, and again, we don't know why, when you're multitasking, your brain starts to take that information in less consciously, more as a subconscious pattern, which means you might learn stuff, but you'll never be able to actually access any of that stuff because your brain didn't treat it. As a primary memory, it treated it as something else. So, good rule of thumb. When you multitask, I call it the single worst thing you can do for learning and memory. You'll go slower, your accuracy will drop, your memory will tank. Now, what is the one thing kids do all the time on tech? Multitask. What is the one thing tech begs them to do? You gotta think about it. We are a serial processor. The human brain can do one thing at a time. Computers are parallel processors, they can do a hundred things at a time. And the problem is, is when we use that machine, we try to act like a parallel processor ourselves. If it can do 10 things, I'm going to try and maintain 10 things at once, which is the worst thing for our learning and memory. So that's why, man, just go back to a book, a pen and paper, where your only choice is read it or don't read it. And there's no real multitasking going on there. speaker-1: That's that's very interesting and it it also reminds me to my experience with writing. back in back in Hungary where I am from, in the schools we were making notes with our hands. And then I studied in Finland for one semester and everyone was taking their laptop to the school. So I was taking my laptop too. I didn't want to be you know left behind. so I took my laptop and I realized that okay, now I'm typing super fast to write down everything that's happening, but I have no c no clue what what was actually happening because I was just a typewriter. And then I needed to look back my notes. And while I was writing with my hand, I remember the rest of the things that I wrote down. So it's really interesting how how it works. And it reminds me to the multitasking example. and and of course how we use technology and how we are not. So I I don't know. I remember you were also writing about this in your in your book. So maybe speaker-0: Yeah, no, you it's and this goes back to the kind of friction thing is note-taking. A lot of people think note-taking is something you do while you're learning. No, note-taking is the learning. That is the act of transforming knowledge and putting it into your own script in an organized way that makes sense to you. That's the learning. Now, the joke is exactly as you said, is when we type notes, most people can type about as fast as people speak, or they're tempted to try to. So instead of taking notes, we just go into dictation. If I heard a word, I'm gonna write a word. If I heard it, I'm gonna write it. Think about a courtroom stenographer. Now, when you take notes like that, the only thing of importance is the sound and the order of the word. Did I hear it? Did I write it? The meaning of the words is irrelevant. You haven't done any transformation, you haven't done any depth, it's just words. So that's why whenever I see a kid taking copious amounts of notes, I always ask them, I say, Hey, what did we learn today? And they will flat out tell you, I don't know, I have to go read my notes. So What's the great way to make sure we're transforming our thinking if you take notes with a pen and paper? exactly as you found out, you can't write every word down. Because we write so much slower than other people speak, you now have to parse meaning. You have to decide what's important, what's not, how does that tie to this? And when you write something down, you've already done work with it. That's the learning portion of it. So by all means, like if you if classrooms did nothing different but exchange typed notes for handwritten notes, learning will go up just because of the thinking you're forced to do in order to get those notes done. So you you just stumbled right into a very good example of all this. speaker-1: Can we bring this back into trend, handwriting in schools? speaker-0: heck w well to be fair, when have schools ever cared about trends? I mean, we still have in in I worked in Australia for twelve years. They still had school uniforms that are like from the fifties. So I'm not sure that they care about trends, but by all means, I mean look, if if I I hate to man, I hate to say it, but if all your friends jumped off of a bridge, would you do it too? This is one of those examples where just because everyone is doing something, that doesn't mean it's good for the outcome we're trying to achieve. And the one or two kids who are going the other way who are saying, you know what? I'm gonna do I'm gonna read an actual book. I'm gonna write my notes with pen and paper, they will learn better, comprehend better, develop faster than kids do any other thing. So maybe they will be called nerds. I don't know. Go to town. But I'd rather be, and maybe this is easier for us as adults, but I I think back to my childhood. When you're 15, you don't think anything in the world is gonna be as as important as what happens in front of those lockers in the hallway. And then you hit 45 and you realize. I don't even remember what the heck happened in front of the. I am so glad I never gave a darn about what anyone else was doing or thinking. I was doing what I knew was best for my learning. And now as an adult, I get to reap those benefits. So off you go. Which by the way, I think I think I'll point that out too. Sorry, I just like to whenever I start talking tech and learning and stuff, one of the big questions kids always ask is why do we have to learn this? Like math. Why do I have to learn it? If I have a calculator, why should I have to learn it? And I One of the things we've done in the past is we try and kind of invent some future where it's meaningful. Like, imagine you're on a desert island and you only have coconuts, you gotta be able to do math then. No kid buys that. That's nonsense. The true answer has always been and will always be: it's because learning compounds. You don't learn A because A is gonna be useful to you all day, every day. You learn A because you can't learn B until you have A locked down. And you don't learn B because that's gonna form the basis of your identity. You learn B because you can't learn C until you've learned B. Because learning compounds. Best predictor of algebra is how automated do you have arithmetic? Best predictor of trig, how automated do you have algebra? What we're doing is we're building up till you get to a level where now you are learning stuff you're gonna do every day, where this will become your life, your future, your identity. And the joke is, is most people when they hit 30 and they figure all this out, they think back and they go, why didn't my school teach me that? Like, why wasn't I taught this from the very beginning? And the joke is you couldn't be taught that from the very beginning. Had we not walked slowly into this moment, you never would have understood any of that. Had we started there, this would have all been a wash. So that's another one of those where it doesn't matter what your friends are doing, you don't have to fit in. We know how learning works. We have this going for a reason. Engage with it. And you will get to a point where it all makes sense to you. I promise you. You just gotta engage with speaker-1: What's the role of teachers in this whole process? speaker-0: Teachers are a lot of people, especially with AI, they're kind of coming out saying, we don't need teachers anymore, because AI knows stuff. If you generally think teachers matter because of what we know, then the internet would have made us obsolete. The encyclopedia would have made us obsolete. We're way more important than that. So one learning mechanism is what we call affective empathy, which basically says human biology can synchronize. Human biology can resonate with other forms of biology, well, other human biology, in a way that boosts understanding and comprehension. So, in a very real sense, when a student and a teacher start to resonate during a lesson, and I promise you, you felt that, in that moment, you are no longer learning from your teacher, you are thinking like your teacher. You're now in their head, you're making the exact same cognitive moves they are, your understanding deepens exponentially. Now, as anyone can attest though, what is one of the best ways to break Any biological synchrony, bring out a phone. You ever been at a dinner table and everything's cruising and everyone's having a great time? As soon as somebody pulls out a phone and a screen interfaces, you can almost feel this physical click off around that entire table. It's like everyone just goes, screens kill that synchrony. So, in a very real sense, one of the best drivers of learning we we will always have is the teacher, not just for what they know, but literally for who they are. Biologically, human beings have evolved to learn from other human beings better than any other animal we've ever seen. And screens simply circumvent that biological ace in the hole that we've always been using throughout school. speaker-1: Yeah, that's that's a great point actually and it reminded me to a recent dinner with a friend who is about eighty years old and she's not really using her phone. It's really funny because we had dinner and she complimented me for not checking my phone in the last two hours and she was so surprised that I was able to focus on her for two hours without, you know, searching for my notifications. And I didn't know it's such a big deal, but she explained that whenever she takes out her nephews and nieces they don't have five minutes without their phone and she finds it very disrespectful but afraid to point it out because then they are not going to meet her anymore. So so it's it's it's probably it's a it's a very big problem in today's age that people are always on their phones and how AI companionship contributes to this when it comes to kids, it's it's a very alarming trend as I see that speaker-0: I don't know why anyone would think that that's going to be a good move. It was like I I remember when smartphones were kind of new. And like around 2012, 2014, the data started to come out that kids who use smartphones more were suffering more from mental and emotional problems. And the argument at the time was, well, we can't ban the phones because you could also use the phone as a therapist to make you feel better. So it was like, okay, on one hand, I'm showing you that your tool is causing harm. On the other, you're saying, yeah, but in a different circumstance, it could help them alleviate the harm I just caused them. Surely getting rid of the tool, now we've alleviated the harm and we have no need for the cure. It's the same thing with AI. When people are like AI psychosis, yeah, but you could use AI as a therapist. You mean to treat the problems that your AI caused me? Why not just get rid of the AI and now, hey, we've solved it. So it's just We're going in that cycle of just trying every new tech compounds problems and we try and solve that problem with more tech. And maybe it's just time to go back to recognizing humans, we can solve our own problems. I mean, I again, I don't mean to soapbox, but we we have gotten so good at displacing human beings. We have taken ourselves off of any pedestal and we have put tech on a pedestal and we assume we are weaker versions of it. That tech is like the ideal human being. Without realizing, no, man, if you look back at history, what human beings are capable of doing without any digital technology is absolutely gobsmacking. So I was just in Italy. So the aqueducts, the Coliseum, the entire city of Venice, go to New York, the vast majority of the skyline of New York, refrigeration, the rail network, the atom bomb, going to the moon. These are all things human beings did without a single digital computer in sight. In fact, we invented digital computers. That's how good we are. So, what happened that we now think we're at this stage where human ingenuity is dead. We don't have enough power. We need the computer to answer it for us. I was watching an interview with the ChatGPT dude the other day, Sam Altman, and they said, your data centers are going to contribute to global warming. And he says, yes, in the short term, but the AI will then tell us how to solve global warming. So that's why we need to do it now. I'm like, dude, what? Your faith in your tool is so much bigger than your faith in human beings that you would risk all of our lives. So this could give us an answer of how to avoid doing what you're doing right now? Just stop doing it, man. I mean, this is so as much if we take away nothing else, please remember just how powerful humans are. powerful our knowledge, our ability is when we're given time to cook. And we gotta give ourselves that time to cook. We will come up with some bad ideas, we'll come up with some clunkers, but my God, we'll come up with some absolute gold in the meantime if we just stop thinking computers are the only answer, right? speaker-1: Is anything AI can supplement? speaker-0: In terms of learning? speaker-1: In terms of anything in education or in learning? speaker-0: Well AI is a production tool. So I could see it supplementing things in a business spot where the process is irrelevant, the outcome is the only thing that matters. But in education the process is the only thing that matters. The outcome is irrelevant. So I would say no. Anytime it's gonna s jump into the process, get rid of it. It's not gonna be helpful. speaker-1: you say in your book that you are not anti tech but pro education. I wonder if there are any AI related skills that you know, schools can have mustering. I understand that you said that knowledge what matters, not skills, but I was wondering if there are any skills that are a must to have in this age with AI. speaker-0: No gosh. I b but trying to predict that is silly. Remember when everyone had to do coding because you wouldn't survive without coding? Then AI came along and said, now you don't have to code. And now we're saying actually you do have to code around the AI. No, I I I am not as enamored with this tool as everyone else seems to be in this world. I I do not think it's that powerful. I don't think it's that meaningful. I I actually don't know very many use cases for it. So when people say we see a future where the workplace is heavily AI, I just don't. I do which point to one field which is actually gonna benefit from AI outside of tech. Probably coding, maybe medicine, but they've already tried it in medicine and it's failing miserably. It's not helping them. Maybe basic research, but in which case, so so what? Like as a researcher, if AI was gonna help me, you didn't need to train me to do that. I needed to know what questions to ask as a researcher. So having AI wouldn't have changed what I needed to learn to become a good researcher. Made made my research easier. I yeah, I'm just not sold. I'm sorry. I I could very easily envision a future in the next five to ten years where AI as we know it now is basically collapsed. And it just is really a self-contained tool that people buy, a stack that certain companies buy to help productivity rather than being this internet based. Worldwide thing that everyone touches. speaker-1: You have a s an action toolkit in the in the book for for parents and for communities. I actually really like that. and I was wondering how should schools been build a genuine partnership with parents and how to treat parents? Because oftentimes it may seem that schools are not really treating parents as partners, you know, and the school boards and and so on. And you know, do you see do you see a possibility to Have a partnership between schools and parents and if yes, how? speaker-0: Absolutely. I think this is one of those rare moments where we're all gonna have to come together. It was like smartphones, right? When when there is a problem that is so big both inside and outside of schools, that usually triggers kind of a coming together of teachers, parents, and administrators. Smartphones was the last big one where outside of school it was bad. Inside of school, it was bad. The data was coming out that it ain't good for anyone. And that's when teachers and parents and students all came to g and and administrators came together and said, What do we do? Do we just ban it full out? What do we do with this? I think tech is now the thing. The data is so clear that learning is going so quickly in the wrong direction. And we can draw it back to mechanisms of this device that you can't really tell parents. When parents come in and say, We want less screen time for our kids, administrators can't really sit there and go, Well, you just don't understand learning like we do. Because in this in instance, nothing good is happening from it. So I think there are definitely going to be times. And I'm one of those rare people who say there does there should be a line between school and home. As parents, you don't have carte blanche to tell us how to do our job. you have to trust us to do what's best for your kids. But in this instance, what we've been doing has been very, very bad. And we recognize it, you recognize it. So get a coalition. Teachers will be your greatest allies if you're a parent. Get 10 parents together, go to a meeting, say, we want to see data that tech. Has been helping learning. We want to know how much our kids are on tech and how much that has benefited their growth and development. If your school does not have that data, and I'm pretty much guaranteeing you now they won't, that's when you can say, Well, then we need to work on this. This is this is a problem you can't keep ignoring. We have to deal with this. And most said, I'm shocked how many administrators are on board already with this. Just in the last couple of months, how many have said we didn't even know it was that bad? So we got to do something. So by all means, get your team, get your coalition, trust your schools. We'll We'll go there with speaker-1: Yeah, NES is is a membership organization of you know, professors and scholars and we often hear from our members that they feel that their profession is not worthy anymore, that you know, being a professor is not valued as it used to be. And part of the equitation here is is tech itself and you know, we can learn it online for free. Why should we go to do a university course or Why should I wait for you to respond when I can get an answer from AI in thirty seconds? so I think they will be very happy to hear that their role is still still valued and you know it's it's maybe just a temporary phenomenon what they experience. speaker-0: I think it'll it'll it'll have to swing back. And I'm I work in universities too. So I totally I always say, man, if you've worked in a university longer than 10 years, you've seen the drop in the incoming class. I mean, I'm not I'm not calling anyone out or anything, but the the the type of student we're getting now is very different than the type of student we were getting a decade ago. And I wouldn't say it's for the better. But you're right, one of the biggest counters to that is overconfidence. Is For as much as the kids coming in now don't have the basics, they have the confidence in themselves that I have yet to like we just I did not see that a decade ago. And I think that comes from the tech, from believing that simply accessing information is somehow the same as knowing that information. And then what is the the story we're telling around the world? Is that it? You have a new iPhone with a camera, you are now a photographer. No, you're not. You're just a kid with a camera. Surely there's more to this than simply having the tool. And I think we're getting fed up with that kind of tech argument. So I was, believe it or not, I was working at a school down in Australia where, and it wasn't a university, it was a K through 12 school. So it was a senior year kid. I was talking to the principal. The parent came in and just started berating the principal. Basically, everything you just said, like we're paying this amount of money. What are you doing for my kid? I need you to do this. We could just get this on A. What do you what AI? What are doing? And to his credit, the principal just sat there and listened. And I felt so awkward just sitting in that room like, okay. but at the end of when the tirade was done, the principal looked up at him and said, Are you finished? Which you know you screwed up. When somebody says the are you finished? you know that's bad because you're like, all right, hit me. And he said, Okay, you don't pay us money because we're Burger King. Like you can have it your way. You're paying us money because we're a five-star restaurant. We know what's best and how to work it. And you trust us to do that. And if you don't trust us, if you think AI is better, take your kids, take your money, get out of the school, go away. We don't need you. And it was like, just this beautiful moment of somebody stepping back into their profession and saying, dude, no, if you if you genuinely think AI is more important than going to a university, then use it. And I'll see you in 20 years. Maybe you're right, maybe you're wrong. Who knows? But if you're gonna be here, respect this institution, respect what we are doing, respect the The work we have put into our craft enough that I'm not just gonna give your kid information. I'm gonna make sure your kid understands what all this means and what the next step is. You don't want it, go away. And maybe, maybe we gotta do more of that at university. Maybe accept less kids, get fewer tuition. Maybe we won't have as much money as we did 10 years ago. But at least we're gonna be standing back on our laurels and saying this is a place of learning. This is a this is an institution of development and a search for the human truth. This is not a place where you get a degree so you can get a better job. At least not anymore. speaker-1: Yeah, that's that's very true, especially in a world where we see all those influencers being, you know, hyped up through social media who would be never never be famous without without these platforms. And they are making a lot of money. So it can be an example for kids that why should I go to university and learn? Why should I finish school when I can be an influencer and making money through advertisements and talking stupid things and get a voice. So it can be a very alarming trend. speaker-0: In we in we I'm working on a documentary now on genius. where does it come from? Is it born? Is it made? And one of the key things with genius is every society gets the genius they cultivate. And it's basically what are you paying attention to? That's where your genius is gonna come out of. And what are we paying attention to? Influencers in tech and film. That's like the only three things the US ever pays attention to. When was the last time you saw the Nobel ceremony on TV in the US? When was the last time you saw any scientist? Have their own show on any we just don't pay attention to this stuff. And we're shocked when our kids then grow up wanting to be famous. That's their goal. Well, that's the genius. And they're gonna come up with genius ways to be famous because that seems to be the only thing we care about in this culture. Whereas if a culture decided, you know what, we're just gonna stop paying attention. We're not paying attention to that. We're gonna start paying attention to, I don't know, poetry. And we're gonna start elevating poetry and That's gonna be on every top ten bestseller list. Watch when the next generation of kids wanna be poets. They just wanna live up to what we are telling them is important. And exactly as you said, we've kind of over the last 20 years built this world where we're focusing their attention on stuff that's you're gonna be the best at making YouTube clips. Not sure how meaningful that is in the scheme of things. speaker-1: That's a great point. I have one more question to you and that's about what what do you think what are the three most important steps we could do as a society to keep the society virtuous and to have a pro-learning environment? Yes. speaker-0: Reanalog schools. School should be analog and it should be contained. Within those four walls, there are a certain set of behaviors, a certain set of tools we can use that will be different than everywhere else. You walk into a hospital, you know you're in a hospital. You walk into a church, a library, you know you are there. Schools need to be the same. When you walk into those str places, those contacts should be so organized that you know it's time to learn. So I think one thing, go back to analog when it comes to learning. second, bring back the breadth of a K through 12 education. Keep art, keep gym, keep civics. It's all good stuff. Don't just focus on STEM, don't just focus on things that might get kids jobs someday. Focus on breadth of knowledge, a more classical kind of form of education. I think is gonna be a great way to do it. and I think third, this is gonna sound horrible. Stop paying attention to people who develop tech. They don't know anything besides tech. They don't know learning, they don't know development, they don't know well-being, they don't know psychology, they know tech. Why have we let tech developers run the conversation about everything else in this world? We let tech developers tell us what politics should look like, what laws we should have in place. What schools should be doing, what matters. We watch TED Talks. TED Talks are just techies telling us how to live our lives. Stop paying attention. The next time a big tech guru says anything, let it go in one ear, let it go right out the other. Unless they're talking to you about the specs of their tech, do not let them dictate our society anymore. We can figure out what's best for medicine. We can collectively figure out what's best for education. We don't need some some guy who made a screen one inch bigger. Now pay attention to me. Shut up. So I think the third step is we gotta stop this tech worship. You gotta gotta stop paying attention to these people, to their products. Go back to society. What do we care about? What do we genuinely care speaker-1: Thank you so much, Jared. I I think it's a lot of fruit for toads, for sure. speaker-0: No, thank you. And thank you so much for for chatting and and going deep into this stuff. speaker-1: This was Jarvet Kuni Horvet for today. thank you very much for joining us and listening to Brains and Bots. as you know, the National Association of Scholars is a membership organization, so feel free to go to our website and join our community if you want to receive more of these content. Thank you very much. Have a great rest of your day.