Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Admissibility of Expert Witness Testimony with Eve A. Brackmann
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Invisibility of Expert Witness Testimony.
- 0:07I'm Lori Krip -Martin, Certified Family Law Specialist
- 0:10and the Vice Chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:13Litigation Section. And I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:16today's speakers, Eve Brachman. Eve Brachman
- 0:19is a senior partner at Munich Wilson Mandela
- 0:22LLP. She serves as lead counsel and jury and
- 0:26bench trials in all California state and federal
- 0:29courts, and she is well known for her effective
- 0:32private arbitration work. Her real estate practice
- 0:35covers high stakes litigation for casino developers,
- 0:40shopping center owners, mortgage companies, and
- 0:44big box retailers. Her business litigation practice
- 0:48covers disputes. in venture partnerships, manufacturing
- 0:52and distributor disputes, contract related lawsuits,
- 0:56fiduciary duty, unfair competition, defamation,
- 1:01trade secret, and anti -slap lawsuits. Eve also
- 1:05has significant experience with high -stake homeowners
- 1:08association disputes, as well as cannabis related
- 1:12matters. And now let's get started. Eve, off
- 1:16to you. Laurie, thank you so much for that amazing
- 1:20introduction. I appreciate that. And I feel really
- 1:23honored and happy to be here today to dive into
- 1:27this really important and evolving topic, admissibility
- 1:31of expert witness testimony. It's been evolving
- 1:34in both federal and California state court for
- 1:37some time now. And it's really important. Another
- 1:41thing I love about this topic is that it spans
- 1:44so many different areas of practice everywhere.
- 1:47that we have a trial we have the potential for
- 1:51a need for expert witness testimony. And then
- 1:54we have to understand the standards around admissibility
- 1:58of that testimony. That's criminal, civil, all
- 2:03areas of civil, you know, from torts, medical
- 2:06malpractice, things I do like commercial real
- 2:09estate litigation, construction litigation. We
- 2:12even have, I have a high stakes homeowners association
- 2:16matter going on right now in Orange County. in
- 2:19that case. A lot of different practitioners need
- 2:25to understand the missibility of expert witness
- 2:28testimony. And some lawyers approach this topic
- 2:32like they're competing in the bachelor. They
- 2:35want to be the only one that gets the rose, and
- 2:37they want to keep everyone else from getting
- 2:39a rose. And that is one approach. But I do think
- 2:42we have a In our profession, we have a more noble
- 2:47responsibility and noble role than that. We want
- 2:50our clients to have a fair trial. And we want
- 2:52to make sure that the court and the trial of
- 2:55fact are being advised only on reliable expert
- 2:59opinion, not junk science. And so that's really
- 3:03kind of what's at the core of all of this. And
- 3:06if you've ever had to go against and oppose an
- 3:09expert that was clearly just parroting council's
- 3:13comments, I think you can understand how it feels
- 3:16to really want to make sure that that kind of
- 3:21thing doesn't get into our trials and doesn't
- 3:23prejudice unfairly prejudice our clients. So
- 3:26also for young lawyers, if you're feeling a little
- 3:29AI anxiety lately and that low key fear that
- 3:33your job might get taken over by a robot that
- 3:35drafts faster and sites better than you, I understand.
- 3:40But here's the thing, AI still cannot. not yet,
- 3:44cannot think on its feet in a courtroom. And
- 3:46in federal court, yes, Rule 702 and Daubert motions,
- 3:51those challenges are usually briefed and often
- 3:53decided on the papers, sometimes with a hearing
- 3:58where you can orally argue. But that's largely
- 4:02a paperwork war in federal court. And especially
- 4:05as we'll get to with the Rule 702 amendments,
- 4:08the judge becomes The judge has, as of 2024,
- 4:13become truly a gatekeeper in federal court more
- 4:16than ever. But in California State Court, it's
- 4:19different. Yes, we have motions in Lumine. But
- 4:22I have to say, in my experience, I haven't seen
- 4:25a lot of experts excluded prior to trial. Usually,
- 4:30these objections to expert witness testimony,
- 4:33particularly Sanchez objections, they're hearsay
- 4:36objections, they're evidence. evidentiary objections
- 4:39that hit in real time when you're right in front
- 4:42of the jury. And it can even happen. You could
- 4:45get sandbagged. It can happen with little or
- 4:47no warning. So forget motions and lemonade. This
- 4:50is trial by fire in California State Court. And
- 4:53the lawyer, any lawyer that can think fast and
- 4:56speak smart in that setting is irreplaceable,
- 5:00at least as of 2025. So that's the good news.
- 5:04And as the great Mikhail Baryshnikov once said,
- 5:08fundamentals are the building blocks of fun or
- 5:11something like that. And actually, I have a bonus
- 5:14point question for everyone. What 1980s movie
- 5:18featured Baryshnikov alongside Gregory Hines,
- 5:21one of my favorite movies of all time? And what
- 5:25field of expertise would those two characters
- 5:31played by Baryshnikov and Hines likely be qualified
- 5:35to testify about? You can answer in the Q &A.
- 5:40And the first person to get the right answer
- 5:43to both parts of that question or both questions,
- 5:46I will personally, if you would like, buy you
- 5:48a coffee here at Watt Plaza, where our office
- 5:50is in Century City, at Starbucks. We have a Starbucks.
- 5:55Of course, feel free to drop any questions you
- 5:57have in the chat and I'll answer as many as I
- 5:59can. And if I don't answer, if I don't know the
- 6:03answer, I promise, unlike AI, I promise not to
- 6:05hallucinate. I'll just say I don't know. So let's
- 6:08dive in. Let's look at the next slide, please.
- 6:16So this is just sort of a little bit of what
- 6:18we just touched on. And the next slide, please.
- 6:24Yes. So this session, in this session, we'll
- 6:28walk through the legal standards for expert testimony
- 6:31in US courts, California -specific issues under
- 6:35People v. Sanchez, That was a 2016 case that
- 6:39changed everything about admissibility of expert
- 6:41witness testimony in California State Court.
- 6:45Challenges and strategies for admissibility.
- 6:48Case studies and practical tips. I will share
- 6:50some personal anecdotes if we have time, some
- 6:55personal stories. Trial lawyers love to tell
- 6:58war stories. I promise none of them are open
- 7:00or pending cases. Speaking of which, ethics.
- 7:06in expert witness testimony. There's some important
- 7:10things to touch on when it comes to your expert's
- 7:14testimony with regard to ethics and emerging
- 7:18trends. There's some new emerging trends, particularly
- 7:21I mentioned AI, a lot of new ways to present
- 7:26expert testimony that go far beyond the ELMO.
- 7:31Let's see if anyone was able to answer. I don't
- 7:33see The answer to my question. Oh, yes. Here's
- 7:38the Q &A. Okay. Let's see. Yes! Kristen Dale.
- 7:44Oh, no. Yes, that was the first one. Kristen
- 7:47Dale. White Nights was the movie. It was a 1985
- 7:50movie featuring Gregory Hines and Mikhail Baryshnikov.
- 7:55Dance would absolutely be a topic that they could
- 7:59opine about. They were both experts in the field
- 8:02of dance. I would submit that they could also
- 8:06potentially be experts about Cold War politics.
- 8:09So if you want to know why, watch the movie.
- 8:12I'm sure you can find it on Netflix. Yes, it's
- 8:17who else got it right? Some folks tried to answer
- 8:21but didn't get it. Rina Pedroza also got the
- 8:26right answer. So Rina and Kristen, I would, even
- 8:32though Kristen got it first. If you want to come
- 8:35have coffee at Watt Plaza at Starbucks, just
- 8:37email me. We'll set it up. I'll definitely have
- 8:4110 minutes to have coffee with you, if you'd
- 8:43like. All right. So let's go to the next slide,
- 8:48please. This is the learning objectives that
- 8:54we just discussed. By the way, I provided you
- 8:58a copy of this PowerPoint presentation. The slides
- 9:02are all in the materials. Also in the materials,
- 9:05there's a rule 702 handout. I'll walk through
- 9:07it with you in a few minutes, a few slides later.
- 9:12Also, just because I like to be able to watch
- 9:15a CLE without having to take a bunch of notes
- 9:17and I don't want to watch it again. It's always
- 9:20nice to be able to get the speaker's notes. I
- 9:22have a slide by slide just bullet point notes
- 9:25for you as well as some references in the written
- 9:28material. So there's three things in the materials
- 9:30I've provided. I really hope that's helpful.
- 9:33It is kind of a big topic and we only have, you
- 9:35know, till 1 30. So yeah, and if you have any
- 9:39follow -up questions, please always feel free
- 9:41to email me my email that is in the Okay. So
- 9:46we talked about learning objectives. Let's go
- 9:49to the next slide and let's talk about legal
- 9:51standards for expert testimony in the US. By
- 9:57the way, also speaking of AI, I don't know if
- 9:59you know this, probably the younger lawyers who
- 10:01tend to be more tech savvy, I think, than us
- 10:06folks who've been practicing since the early
- 10:102000s. You can have AI create your slides these
- 10:14days for PowerPoint, just saying, and that goes
- 10:16for creating expert materials as well. Okay,
- 10:20so slide four, legal standards for expert testimony
- 10:23in the U .S. Federal rule of evidence 702 governs
- 10:27expert testimony, and it was amended in 2023.
- 10:32effective January 1, 2024, but it was such a
- 10:35big deal that there's even a case that referenced
- 10:38the coming amendment back in 2023, and we'll
- 10:41talk about it a little bit. But it was amended
- 10:45to clarify the court's gatekeeping role. So let's
- 10:48spend a few minutes here because Rule 702, as
- 10:51recently amended, fundamentally reshapes how
- 10:54we think about expert admissibility in federal
- 10:57court. First, the amendment clarifies that it
- 11:00is the proponent's burden to prove. By a preponderance
- 11:05of the evidence, the expert testimony is admissible.
- 11:09That means judges don't get to punt questions
- 11:12about foundation or methodology to the jury in
- 11:14federal court the way that they do in California
- 11:16court still. The court has to find it, the court,
- 11:21the judge has to find it more likely than not.
- 11:23that the expert's testimony meets each requirement
- 11:26of Rule 702 before it gets in front of a jury.
- 11:30And there aren't any wait issues unless and until
- 11:34Rule 702 threshold is met as amended. As I mentioned,
- 11:39you have this handout, FRE 702 handout. What
- 11:42I put in here is sort of a color coded version
- 11:46of the amendment. So you can see highlighted
- 11:48in blue what was added. And then you can see
- 11:51there was some language that was stricken, and
- 11:53that's redlined. And what was added was, at the
- 11:59beginning of the rule, that this was original.
- 12:03A witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge,
- 12:07skill, experience, training, or education may
- 12:09testify in the formative opinion or otherwise
- 12:12if, and then in the old rule, the if standards,
- 12:17or A through D, came right after that. they inserted
- 12:21the proponent demonstrates to the court that
- 12:24it is more likely than not that and then the
- 12:28standard. So that's where this new standard where
- 12:31the proponent has the burden of proving by preponderance
- 12:36of the evidence that the expert meets these four
- 12:39standards. And we'll talk about those four standards
- 12:42too. And then indeed the four standard The language
- 12:46was tweaked a bit. Instead of the expert has
- 12:49reliably applied the principles and methods to
- 12:52the facts of the case, super important in itself,
- 12:58they struck expert has reliably applied, and
- 13:02it's the expert's opinion reflects a reliable
- 13:04application of. That's a very semantic change,
- 13:10and I think there's a lot of discussion about
- 13:13what that means. There certainly is pages and
- 13:16pages of discussion in the advisory committee
- 13:19notes from 2023 that explain why they made these
- 13:24changes. And so if you're curious about those
- 13:26notes, they're right here in the handout. And
- 13:29then also, I put a few recent applications to
- 13:32the rule 702 amendment, just some case studies
- 13:36that you might want to look up, some real interesting
- 13:39ones. And the one that I referenced earlier,
- 13:43Before the December 2023 amendment took effect,
- 13:47the Fourth Circuit in Sardis, the overhead door
- 13:50corp, cited it favorably and noted that the amendment
- 13:55echoes existing law and confirms the indispensable
- 13:58nature of the district court's gatekeeping rule.
- 14:02And then in 2022, still prior to adoption of
- 14:07the 2023 amendment, the Ninth Circuit also cited
- 14:14the rule. So you should take a look at that.
- 14:19Okay. Then the other thing that's in this handout,
- 14:26I looked up on Westlaw for you. At last night,
- 14:32so it's totally current, or maybe two nights
- 14:34ago, there are 10 citing references here. All
- 14:39of the cases that have cited rule 702 in the
- 14:43Supreme Court and the Ninth Circuit, since we're
- 14:46in the Ninth, since January 1st, 2024, there's
- 14:49only 10. So obviously, as we mentioned, this
- 14:53is a very evolving area of law. But those 10
- 14:57cases, I haven't read them all, but I'm sure
- 14:59we'll all be reading them together soon. Not
- 15:02together, but all of us will be reading them
- 15:05soon. Expert testimony is no longer presumptively
- 15:12admissible. And then each element of rule 702
- 15:16must be satisfied on its own. The expert must
- 15:18be qualified. Their testimony must aid the trier
- 15:22of fact. It must be based on sufficient facts
- 15:26or data. It must be the product of reliable principles
- 15:29and methods. And importantly, it must reflect
- 15:32a reliable application. This is category D. of
- 15:37those methods to the facts of the case. And the
- 15:39last one is where a lot of, in my experience,
- 15:42that's where a lot of experts falter is applying
- 15:45those methods to the facts of the case. In that
- 15:50handout, I provided some case examples, as we
- 15:53mentioned. In Ray Paraquat, the court excluded
- 15:56an epidemiologist's meta -analysis as unreliable
- 16:02under rule 702. In Anglaiza, the Sixth Circuit
- 16:06cited the amendment when excluding a cardiologist
- 16:09who cherry -picked studies. In acetaminophen,
- 16:16ASDAH, ADHD, multiple causation experts were
- 16:21excluded because they didn't apply their methods
- 16:24reliably to the facts. Practical implications.
- 16:28If you're offering an expert, especially in federal
- 16:31court, you need to come in with a bulletproof
- 16:33record, lay foundation in your expert report,
- 16:36use language tracking rule 702, and be ready
- 16:39to argue methodology, not just credentials. If
- 16:42you're opposing an expert, this amendment is
- 16:44your sword. Challenge the reliability of the
- 16:47application, not just the conclusions, but the
- 16:50reliability of that application to the facts
- 16:52of the case. Let's go to the next slide, please.
- 17:02That's the rule 702 -2023 update. We just discussed
- 17:06that. Next slide, please. Yes, here we go. California
- 17:11standards and Sanchez. Oh, sorry. I messed up.
- 17:16No, prior slide. My bad. Let's talk about Daubert,
- 17:22Frye, and Rule 702. And let's take a moment to
- 17:27step back and understand how we got here. Expert
- 17:30testimony plays a powerful role in both civil
- 17:34and criminal trials, as we mentioned. And it
- 17:37can explain complex science, economics, medicine,
- 17:41or data in ways a jury or judge couldn't otherwise
- 17:43understand or grasp. I had a case once that involved
- 17:48a retention basin, and the whole dispute was
- 17:52about the rate of seepage through a cement retention
- 17:55basin in a shopping center. And I learned the
- 18:00hard way that expert testimony has to be really
- 18:06understandable for the jury and the court. I
- 18:09think in federal court, more than ever, we need
- 18:12to make it understandable. We really need to,
- 18:16experts really sometimes can be in their ivory
- 18:19tower. They're not used to having to explain
- 18:21things in ways that are understandable to lay
- 18:25people. So as practitioners, obviously that's
- 18:30something that the trial lawyer needs to understand
- 18:32how to do. And again, with the court being the
- 18:36gatekeeper, it's more important than ever to
- 18:39understand how to make that understandable to
- 18:41the judge. So how do we know the expert we're
- 18:46hearing from is using real reliable science or
- 18:48are they just making it up? And that's where
- 18:51these standards come in. The Frye standard was
- 18:56from the Frye case was from 1923, the good old
- 19:00days. Frye v United States and this standard
- 19:03came out of the DC circuit. and it held for a
- 19:07long time. That was the standard for a long time.
- 19:09And that standard was that expert testimony is
- 19:12admissible only if the scientific, excuse me,
- 19:16the scientific technique or principle is generally
- 19:19accepted in the relevant field. So it's the general
- 19:22acceptance standard. It's a conservative standard.
- 19:27If the method is new or novel, you might have
- 19:30a tough time in a fry type. jurisdiction and
- 19:35the focus is entirely on the method not the expert
- 19:38and not how they applied it and not the results.
- 19:41This isn't the standard anymore in California
- 19:43or in in federal court in under you know the
- 19:49the Daubert and rule 702 standards but this is
- 19:53how we kind of this is where it came from this
- 19:55is the origin. So the Daubert standard from 1993
- 20:00Daubert v. Merrill Dow actually changed everything
- 20:03in federal court in 93. The Supreme Court held
- 20:07that Fry had been superseded and that general
- 20:10acceptance is no longer the only or even the
- 20:13primary test. Instead, the judge has a more active
- 20:19hands -on role as the gatekeeper, even under
- 20:21Daubert, not even counting the more recent amendment
- 20:25to 702. They have to ensure the testimony is
- 20:28both reliable and relevant to the facts of the
- 20:30case, and the court provided a non -exhaustive
- 20:34list of factors to guide that inquiry. Has the
- 20:39theory or technique been tested? Has it been
- 20:41peer reviewed and published? Is there a known
- 20:44or potential error rate? Has it gained some level
- 20:48of general acceptance in the relevant scientific
- 20:50community? So when you're doing your expert motions
- 20:55in federal court, it's really important to look
- 20:57not just at the language of rule 702, but at
- 21:00Daubert and perhaps even cases, a lot of cases
- 21:04have come. down the line from Dalbert, it's really
- 21:07important to understand, you know, like the,
- 21:12and we're not gonna, we don't have time today
- 21:14to go into the details of it, but it's important
- 21:17for you to understand, you know, really this
- 21:19whole body of case law. So anyways, general acceptance
- 21:23still matters from FRI, but it's just one piece
- 21:26of a larger puzzle. The 2023 amendment to rule
- 21:29702 reinforces the Dalbert framework in a very
- 21:32explicit way. I was just looking to see if anyone
- 21:38had questions. Feel free to put your questions
- 21:39in the Q &A. I will try to answer them as we
- 21:42go. And I'll try to leave a little time at the
- 21:45end, like 1 .25. I'll try to finish by then so
- 21:49you can ask any questions. So the 2023 Amendment
- 21:55to Rule 702 reinforces Daubert in an explicit
- 21:59way, as we discussed. So Daubert isn't just philosophical
- 22:04anymore. part of the code, and that's where the
- 22:08Frey -Daubert evolution really ties in. Under,
- 22:11you know, 702, the method must be reliable like
- 22:15Frey, the application must also be reliable like
- 22:19Daubert, and the court is the gatekeeper of all
- 22:22of that. So in short, it's not just academic.
- 22:25The choice of standard can change the outcome
- 22:28of a case, especially when your expert is relying
- 22:30on emerging science or industry -specific models.
- 22:36So let's go to the next slide. Let's talk about
- 22:40California specific standards. California state
- 22:43courts ordinarily don't do Daubert type motions.
- 22:47Motions in the limine are usually decided, you
- 22:50know, and often decided on the first day of trial
- 22:53in housekeeping. And so, you know, you don't
- 22:57know what's going to happen until you get to
- 22:58trial. And a lot of times, the motion to eliminate
- 23:03is not going to exclude an expert from testifying
- 23:06at trial. Sometimes it will. I've even seen,
- 23:09it was a long time ago, once I've seen a summary
- 23:12judgment motion granted based on expert opinion.
- 23:17But that type of thing is very rare in California
- 23:22court. Usually, you're in court in front of a
- 23:24jury while you're dealing with the California
- 23:27standards. Usually the battle, like I said, it
- 23:32occurs right in front of the jury. And the most
- 23:34important thing actually that happened in 2016,
- 23:37and it was basically a 10 on the Richter scale
- 23:40for those of us doing things like construction
- 23:43defect litigation. and other technical types
- 23:47of matters. I had been practicing since 2004,
- 23:50or I have been practicing since 2004. So in 2016,
- 23:55I was already pretty set in my ways. I had learned
- 23:57from my mentors how to do trial and what's admissible,
- 24:01what's not admissible. I even had by then experts
- 24:05that I... typically relied on in certain cases
- 24:09especially especially in construction cases which
- 24:12tend to be very expert specific and when Sanchez
- 24:16came down I called them up and we had a chat
- 24:19and their minds were blown they couldn't believe
- 24:21it and one of the experts I won't say who it
- 24:23was said you wouldn't believe it Eve we actually
- 24:27got excluded just like recently in court as a
- 24:31result of Sanchez and I couldn't believe it I've
- 24:33never heard of it before. My guy got on the stand
- 24:39and was ready to testify and it was, objection
- 24:45hearsay, objection hearsay, objection hearsay,
- 24:49sustain, sustain, sustain. That was it. The expert
- 24:51was very well prepared but had nothing to talk
- 24:54about. That was back shortly after the Sanchez
- 24:59opinion came down and that judge had been kudos
- 25:03to that trial lawyer who had properly briefed
- 25:06the judge on what Sanchez meant, which we'll
- 25:09get into in a minute, and prevailed at trial
- 25:13as a result of understanding how this case -specific
- 25:16hearsay thing works. So when I say it was a 10
- 25:21on the Richter scale, those of us listening who
- 25:23were practicing at the time probably share my
- 25:25recollection that it was really a big deal. And
- 25:28we had to try to understand it, and we still
- 25:30are trying to understand it. So the key issue
- 25:33is whether hearsay in Sanchez is whether hearsay
- 25:36cited by an expert is case specific. By the way,
- 25:40this case also underscores the broad applicability
- 25:44of this topic that we were talking about earlier,
- 25:46because Sanchez was a criminal case. It had to
- 25:49do with gang crimes and an enhanced sentence
- 25:54for specific things for gang affiliation in a
- 26:00violent crime. But Sanchez rocked the world in
- 26:05the civil litigation world as well. So really
- 26:09these are things that span all different practice
- 26:13areas. So before Sanchez, California evidence
- 26:16code sections 801 and 802 were interpreted to
- 26:20allow experts to disclose to the jury hearsay
- 26:23evidence that supported their opinions, even
- 26:26if that evidence wouldn't have been independently
- 26:29admissible. Many people, me included, thought
- 26:33that was unfair. It was frustrating. You can
- 26:35just get this hearsay in the back door or the
- 26:38side door because the expert heard it. How does
- 26:41that make it fair to present that hearsay evidence
- 26:45to the jury? It seems prejudicial. We were all
- 26:49used to hearing, hey, this isn't offered for
- 26:51the truth. it's just to help the jury to understand
- 26:54how the expert formed their opinion. But jurors
- 26:58are human. As courts later admitted, jurors were
- 27:01treating those hearsay statements as true and
- 27:04using them to decide critical issues. So in effect,
- 27:07experts were walking in the front door with their
- 27:11opinions and smuggling hearsay evidence through
- 27:14the back. So enter Sanchez. Sanchez shuts that
- 27:18that door. In that case, a gang expert testified
- 27:21about police reports, out -of -court statements,
- 27:25and gang database entries, none of which were
- 27:28independently admitted into evidence. The Supreme
- 27:31Court said, that's hearsay, that's a problem.
- 27:35So when any expert relates to the jury, sorry,
- 27:40a key quote from that case, at page 686 of that
- 27:44case, when any expert relates to the jury, case
- 27:48specific out of court statements and treats the
- 27:51content of those statements as true, the statements
- 27:54are hearsay and not invisible. So the result
- 27:58was Mr. Sanchez's gang enhancement was reversed.
- 28:02So the rule posts Sanchez. Now in California.
- 28:10If it's general background information, it's
- 28:12fine. Experts can talk about. learned treatises,
- 28:16foundational science, published research, things
- 28:19generally accepted in their field. I've even
- 28:21seen a post Sanchez case where unlike the gang
- 28:26database, which was hearsay, a court found that,
- 28:31and you should be able to see that in. in my
- 28:34references, a court found that a database of
- 28:38drugs that had been compiled through scientific
- 28:41testing and methodology was general background
- 28:45information. That wasn't case -specific hearsay.
- 28:48So it's not just every database is not admissible.
- 28:52A database based on community discussions about
- 28:55who's in a gang and who's not in a gang, that's
- 28:57hearsay. Database based on scientific compilation
- 29:01of information. background information that is
- 29:04fine to rely upon. So there can be a very fine
- 29:08distinction. Case specific facts must be independently
- 29:12admissible or the expert cannot disclose them
- 29:15to the jury on direct examination. It's not enough
- 29:20that the expert relied on it. You have to get
- 29:22hearsay in through an exception. via a stipulation
- 29:27or make it not hearsay, have someone come into
- 29:29court and testify as to the facts. Otherwise,
- 29:32it's out and so is your expert. And the old limiting
- 29:36instruction strategy is dead. The court made
- 29:39it clear in Sanchez, no amount of judicial gymnastics
- 29:42or dance moves can cure the prejudice. Practical
- 29:48examples, let's say your expert wants to discuss
- 29:51a doctor's diagnosis from a medical record, a
- 29:54crash report from a responding officer, a witnesses
- 29:58out of court statement from a declaration, financial
- 30:03analysis based on bank statements. Unless that
- 30:08underlying information is admitted into evidence
- 30:11through an exception, your expert cannot say
- 30:14it out loud. and they can't base their opinion
- 30:17on it. So let's talk about Sanchez in discovery
- 30:23and case prep for a moment. It's no longer something
- 30:28that you can fix at trial. So it requires identifying
- 30:33case -specific facts early in your case, tracking
- 30:38admissibility of each layer. of hearsay. There
- 30:41can be multiple layers of hearsay that needs
- 30:44to independently be admitted before the expert
- 30:47can opine and use that for their opinion. Get
- 30:51those depositions to lock in foundational testimony
- 30:55so that if you're doing you know pre -trial motions
- 30:59you can reference the testimony in the deposition
- 31:03on which that expert is relying. Business records
- 31:07and so that you can make sure the testimony especially
- 31:09if it's a an unfriendly witness, that testimony
- 31:12is coming into evidence. Business records exceptions
- 31:16are always something important to consider. Thoughtful
- 31:20stipulations were appropriate, but if you understand
- 31:27Sanchez and you have properly prepared your case
- 31:30and the other side hasn't and they want you to
- 31:33stipulate to waive Sanchez, don't do it. Make
- 31:37them put their case on properly why well because
- 31:41it helps you win yeah but also because you're
- 31:44doing your job as um as as an ethical and professional
- 31:50lawyer making sure that junk science isn't getting
- 31:54into the case and that the trier effect is being
- 31:58properly advised and your client's not being
- 32:00unfairly prejudiced by unreliable expert opinion
- 32:04um if your expert Bottom line, if your expert
- 32:09plans to rely on it, make sure it's admissible.
- 32:12Let's look at the next slide. Common admissibility
- 32:19challenges. Lack of proper qualifications. Let's
- 32:25say your case involves mold damage to a commercial
- 32:29property. You hire a contractor with expertise
- 32:33and experience in mold remediation. but no formal
- 32:38environmental science background. If your opponent
- 32:41moves to exclude it, they might succeed, especially
- 32:44if the court finds the expert lacks the qualifications
- 32:47to interpret test results or give causation opinions.
- 32:51So make sure your expert has the right academic
- 32:53licensure and professional background specifically
- 32:56tied to the issue at hand. A general, wow, I've
- 32:59seen this before, isn't necessarily going to
- 33:01cut it. And when we talk about ethics a little
- 33:05bit later in the program, in a few minutes. I'm
- 33:10going to share with you what I find to be, for
- 33:12me, a helpful way to vet experts early in the
- 33:16case. It helps not only with admissibility, but
- 33:19making sure that you really are adhering to ethical
- 33:22standards when you're picking experts and preparing
- 33:26them. Improper methodology. If your expert does
- 33:31biomechanical calculations to determine how your
- 33:34client's spine was injured in a low -speed collision,
- 33:36but they don't provide error rates or peer -reviewed
- 33:39sources and the technique isn't widely accepted
- 33:42in the field, that's a Daubert or admissibility
- 33:46landmine. a little practice tip. You don't just
- 33:51need the right method. You need it applied in
- 33:54a consistent, documented, and peer -reviewed
- 33:56way. Inadequate foundation. If an engineer bases
- 33:59their opinion about structural failure on a visual
- 34:03inspection, but they don't review the blueprints
- 34:05or conduct testing or gather load data and the
- 34:08opposing side challenges the foundation, they
- 34:11could very well win on that. So practice tip.
- 34:15Always ask, what does the expert know and how
- 34:18do they know it? How do they know it, right?
- 34:21A missing link in the factual chain is grounds
- 34:24for exclusion. You have to have a very clear
- 34:27admissible chain of underlying facts. Relevance
- 34:32or hearsay problems. Your expert relies on a
- 34:34treating physician's comment from an unadmitted
- 34:37medical record. For instance, this was clearly
- 34:42caused by the prior surgery. The doctor notes
- 34:45that in their notes. That's hearsay. Unless you
- 34:48admit the record or depose the doctor and have
- 34:50the doctor testify, your expert can't rely on
- 34:53it and can't say it. So if a case -specific fact
- 34:57is critical to your expert's opinion, make sure
- 34:59it's independently admissible or your expert
- 35:02cannot testify to it. I can't underscore having
- 35:05lived through both the old days pre -Sanchez
- 35:08and really pre -Rule 702 changes. and sort of
- 35:16how things have evolved, having personally lived
- 35:18through it, it is a sea change in our industry,
- 35:22or in our practice, about what experts are allowed
- 35:26to do. I started the first two years of my career,
- 35:29I did just construction defect litigation in
- 35:31the heyday of that residential, I don't do residential
- 35:35anymore, don't call me for residential. But that
- 35:39first two years, and I did ton of expert stuff
- 35:42as a young associate, that was like what? you
- 35:45know, what I was tasked with handling. And those
- 35:49experts, they would just, it would be, it was
- 35:51so loosey -goosey in California State Court about
- 35:53what they could opine on, what they could bring
- 35:55in, what they could say. And then when Sanchez
- 35:58hit, I mean, everything has really changed. And
- 36:00I think it's for the better. Personally, I think
- 36:03it's for the better for the reasons we talked
- 36:04about. We don't want junk science in our courts.
- 36:06We want everyone providing reliable expert witness
- 36:09testimony. And we don't want you know, we don't
- 36:13want the jury to be bamboozled with inadmissible
- 36:16hearsay in the guise of, oh, well, you know,
- 36:19the expert relied on it. So I personally think
- 36:21these are good changes and I think they make
- 36:23us better lawyers and they make our system of
- 36:26justice better. Okay, let's go to slide nine.
- 36:30Mitigating risks. This is what I was talking
- 36:34about before. Vet your experts orally. Get that
- 36:38expert on the phone when you get the case and
- 36:41you realize I'm going to need a valuation expert.
- 36:44I'm going to need a damages expert. I'm going
- 36:46to need a, you know, an expert on, you know,
- 36:49spinal robotics. Get them on the phone and, you
- 36:54know, vet multiple experts unless of course,
- 36:56you know, you've got certain experts that you
- 36:59regularly use because you just know that they're
- 37:01reliable and they do a good job. That's, you
- 37:03know, that's different. But, you know, you might
- 37:06want to vet just multiple different experts and
- 37:09see what different people are saying so that
- 37:11you as the lawyer can get multiple different
- 37:14opinions and understand who really has a reliable
- 37:18opinion here. And how am I going to do this case,
- 37:22right? This comes down to ethics that we'll talk
- 37:25about later too. Am I going to do ABC in the
- 37:30case or am I going to go this way, X, Y, Z? A
- 37:33lot of times what your expert has to say shapes
- 37:37what you're going to do in the case. It shapes
- 37:39the kind of discovery you're going to conduct.
- 37:41A lot of times it shapes whether you feel inclined
- 37:43to settle early and advise your client that you
- 37:47have some really tough hurdles in this case,
- 37:51or are you going to... Fight hard, go to the
- 37:54mat, and feel confident about going to trial.
- 37:58And when you get to trial and you've vetted your
- 37:59expert early and you've worked with them throughout
- 38:01the case, you don't have to have those surprises.
- 38:05Cardinal rule of trial work, you don't want any
- 38:07surprises at trial. I know all the trial lawyers
- 38:10that regularly do trials are raising your hands
- 38:13in agreement, right? No surprises at trial, unless
- 38:16you're surprising the other side. But you don't
- 38:19want to be surprised. And so getting those, vet
- 38:21those experts early, review their methodology
- 38:24and ensure it fits the case. We have better research
- 38:27tools as lawyers, as laypeople to vet research
- 38:30than ever. I mean, it's not just the internet
- 38:33anymore. We have AI research capabilities through
- 38:37Westlaw that are, you know, really state of the
- 38:39art. We have all kinds of ways to do research
- 38:42and vet those experts. And, you know, again,
- 38:46make sure you don't have any surprises. later.
- 38:49Anticipate Daubert and Sanchez objections. Talk
- 38:51with your colleagues about it on the case. Talk
- 38:55with the expert about it. You know, what could
- 38:57be objectionable? Put yourself in the other guy's
- 39:00shoes, the other lawyer's shoes, and say, if
- 39:03I were them, what would I be objecting to? Consider
- 39:07mock testimony to stress test the expert, especially
- 39:11if it's an expert you haven't used before. Then
- 39:13do it before you have to disclose experts. If
- 39:16this is someone that's just not going to be able
- 39:17to properly explain things and get that methodology
- 39:21and its application to the facts of the case
- 39:23across to the judge and the trier of fact, wonderful.
- 39:27Make them a consulting expert and find someone
- 39:29who understands how to explain it in court. Rely
- 39:33on scientific method. I was a hard science major.
- 39:38I was a biology major at USC. Fight on. And I
- 39:44learned scientific method, obviously, as a science
- 39:47major. Not all lawyers, a lot of lawyers are
- 39:50much better than I will ever be at things like
- 39:53economics and history, so on and so forth. So
- 39:55we all have our areas that we kind of grew up
- 39:57in. And not everyone really got a great grasp
- 40:02on scientific method in their school days. It's
- 40:09not that hard to learn. So if you haven't ever
- 40:12really delved into scientific method, I'm telling
- 40:15you, it can really be a game changer. And I have
- 40:17used it as a game changer in the area of expert
- 40:20testimony. So if you go do homework after this
- 40:23on anything, just Google scientific method if
- 40:25you're not familiar with it. Many people probably
- 40:27are and maybe. But it's just a huge help. And
- 40:30I'll get into it a little bit more in a couple
- 40:33slides. But let's talk about strategy. Whether
- 40:37you're trying to get your expert in or keep the
- 40:39other side's expert opinion out, this is one
- 40:43of the most persuasive tools you can use, scientific
- 40:47method. And the reason it's so persuasive and
- 40:50helpful is because courts love structure. Judges
- 40:53love reliability. And scientific method is by
- 40:56design a repeatable, logical, evidence -based
- 40:59process. It starts with the foundation that the
- 41:03truth of the matter is. We can never know anything
- 41:05for sure. That's kind of counterintuitive, isn't
- 41:08it? We're trying to find a method that helps
- 41:10us to explain why our opinion is right. We're
- 41:13starting with the foundation that we can never
- 41:16know anything for sure, for certain. But that's
- 41:20the reality. We can't know anything for sure.
- 41:23Descartes might disagree. He would say, I know
- 41:28that I exist because I can think, right? But
- 41:31really, that is just a theory. I think, therefore,
- 41:34I exist. It's a theory. And if you go through
- 41:39the whole process of getting to that through
- 41:41Cartesian theory, you'll see he started with,
- 41:44and I don't want to get too deep into the philosophy
- 41:47here. I won't. I promise. But he starts with
- 41:52testing some hypotheses. He forms a hypothesis.
- 41:58In fact, he. forms a null hypothesis which is
- 42:01I'm going to prove the opposite of what I think
- 42:04is true and if I can't prove it then I'm supporting
- 42:08my true hypothesis and transitioning it into
- 42:13a theory. So scientific method is how we go about
- 42:18that. If you can explain the steps of going from
- 42:20a hypothesis and testing it either as a null
- 42:23hypothesis or through accepted methods of computer
- 42:27modeling or whatever it is and then you get to
- 42:30a point where you've supported that reliably
- 42:34supported that hypothesis it becomes a theory
- 42:37and that is something that your expert that theory
- 42:40of the case the theory of causation the damages
- 42:44theory those are all expert opinions that are
- 42:47then admissible in um or quick like whatever
- 42:52cliff note version on that method, you ask a
- 42:55question or identify a problem, you form a hypothesis,
- 42:58you gather data, you test the hypothesis using
- 43:01consistent accepted methodology, you analyze
- 43:04the results, and then you draw a conclusion that
- 43:07can be replicated or peer reviewed. Not you,
- 43:11but your expert. And sometimes experts aren't
- 43:17familiar with that, and they, in my experience,
- 43:20they welcome you offering them that structure
- 43:23or walking through those steps, it gives them
- 43:25a feeling of confidence as well. It's really
- 43:28almost magical. Let's see. Here's an example.
- 43:33Your environmental expert tests multiple soil
- 43:36samples, runs them through an industry standard
- 43:39protocol, shows their results with reference
- 43:41to published EPA guidelines, and explains why
- 43:44the presence of toxins rules out a natural cause.
- 43:47That's good science and a judge will recognize
- 43:50it as such. You can also use it to exclude your
- 43:54opposing expert opinions if they can't stand
- 43:56up to the rigors. Flip it. You can use the absence
- 44:00of a scientific method to exclude your opponent's
- 44:04expert. Did they form a hypothesis or did they
- 44:06start with a conclusion? Did they test alternative
- 44:09theories or ignore contradictory data? Remember
- 44:12the cherry picked case that we referenced earlier?
- 44:17ignoring contrary data is a big pitfall. Did
- 44:20they use published acceptable methods or did
- 44:22they just invent their own? And did they replicate
- 44:25their process or could it be replicated? Could
- 44:27they explain how it might be replicated or are
- 44:29they just winging it from experience? These are
- 44:32all ways to flesh out junk science that somebody
- 44:35else is offering that you'd like to exclude.
- 44:40Bottom line, if they don't follow a repeatable
- 44:42logical method, whether it's scientific method
- 44:45or some other repeatable acceptable logical method,
- 44:48you have a basis to challenge that expert opinion.
- 44:53Here's another example. The opposing biomechanics
- 44:55expert says your client couldn't have been injured
- 44:57in a low -speed impact, but they didn't test
- 45:00vehicle damage. They didn't calculate force vectors.
- 45:04They didn't consult peer -reviewed research.
- 45:06They just eyeballed it. That's not science. That
- 45:09is speculation, and you should be able to exclude
- 45:11that. Here's a little pro tip. Speaking the court's
- 45:19language, right? Here's some phrases that you
- 45:22could use. This expert's opinion is not the result
- 45:25of scientific method or reliable application
- 45:28of methodology as required by Rule 702, Your
- 45:32Honor. Whether you're defending or attacking
- 45:36an expert, that phrase, this expert's opinion
- 45:39is not the result of scientific method or reliable
- 45:43application of methodology as required by the
- 45:46rules. Whether you're defending or attacking
- 45:49an expert, that phrase frames the court's gatekeeping
- 45:52duty and signals that you understand the rules
- 45:56and that you're following them to the court.
- 45:58That's very helpful. Okay, let's go to the next
- 46:04slide, examination strategies. Oh, here's a question
- 46:06before we get there. Can the state of mind exemption
- 46:10allow case -specific hearsay? For example, appraisers
- 46:13rely on comparable data from specific transactions
- 46:17to inform their value opinions. This is recognized
- 46:20methodology, but case -specific comps inform
- 46:23their own state of mind regarding their own value
- 46:26opinions. Could the state of mind exemption allow
- 46:28the admissibility of the comps? Okay. So I think
- 46:32what you're asking is whether comparable data
- 46:40is a hearsay problem for experts, maybe under
- 46:45Sanchez. This isn't my particular field, but
- 46:48we use comps too in real estate all the time.
- 46:51And I haven't had any trouble getting comps admitted.
- 46:55So the comps come from a database. Okay, now.
- 47:00It's not like a gang database. It's also not
- 47:04a medical data database. So the gang affiliation
- 47:08database is Sanchez. That's excluded. That's
- 47:12hearsay. Later cases have said things like medical
- 47:17information in a database is reliable. It's hearsay,
- 47:22but it's not case -specific hearsay. Those cobs
- 47:25are hearsay, but they're not case -specific hearsay.
- 47:29They're in a database of information. So I would
- 47:32argue that just like real estate comps, these
- 47:34sound like similar comps from a database. So
- 47:44you're asking about specific transactions, comparable
- 47:47data from specific transactions. So if it's from
- 47:51a database that is based on reliable information,
- 47:56I think you don't have a Sanchez problem. So,
- 48:01but if you want to chat more about it, I'll be
- 48:03happy to delve into a little more if you want
- 48:05to email me. I think it's fascinating question
- 48:08and happy to dive into it a little bit more or
- 48:12if anyone else. Yeah. If anyone else has input
- 48:17as to that question, I'll be happy to read it
- 48:19in the Q and a and repeat it to the group. Okay,
- 48:23let's talk the next slide was examination strategies.
- 48:28Again, feel free to put your questions in there.
- 48:31I'm happy to answer them, and I've built in time
- 48:35to do that. I think we have 12 slides, so we're
- 48:38getting pretty close to the end of the slides,
- 48:42although I wouldn't mind going through some of
- 48:44the 702 notes as well if we have extra time,
- 48:48but totally up to you. Okay, examination strategies
- 48:51for experts. Oh, okay, someone says, My comps
- 48:59are Cedar Beauchamp. Thank you, Francisco Sanchez
- 49:03for your question. That was an interesting question.
- 49:06Cedar Beauchamp says, my comps are often confidential
- 49:08and cannot submit them as evidence. If you can't
- 49:12submit your comps as evidence, I don't care if
- 49:14you're in federal court or state court, you are
- 49:17not going to be able to get an expert opinion
- 49:19based on inadmissible evidence. That is absolutely
- 49:23clear. So I'm not sure what you would do about
- 49:27that. So that is an interesting situation. You
- 49:32didn't mention your area of practice. But okay,
- 49:38examination strategies. On direct, you want to
- 49:42tell a cohesive story. You want to build the
- 49:44expert's credibility. And you want to emphasize
- 49:47the already admitted evidence as you walk through
- 49:49how they form their opinion and what their opinion
- 49:52is. So you want to just go step by step through
- 49:55the method they used, okay. And just one piece
- 49:59at a time. And you want to make sure, at this
- 50:02point in the trial, when you're on direct, that
- 50:05you've gotten all the evidence in that that expert's
- 50:08going to rely on. Sometimes judges are nice enough
- 50:11to let you recall witnesses or see if you can
- 50:14get some evidentiary evidence in. Don't forget,
- 50:18as you're going through the fact witnesses, get
- 50:21those exhibits in. You know, we're just the most
- 50:26basic things, right? Just making sure you got
- 50:28it in evidence and that by the time your expert
- 50:31is testifying, the jury, the finder of fact,
- 50:34if it's the court, the court is really familiar
- 50:37with those key pieces of evidence that are going
- 50:39to, it's like building a wall. You're building
- 50:41a brick wall and your expert sits on top of that
- 50:43wall. You want to build a nice strong wall. MLS
- 50:48comps, highly reliable due to realty board rules.
- 50:51Warren, this is a comment by Warren Worth. Thank
- 50:54you, Warren. By the way, if you don't want me
- 50:56to say your name when you do the comment, just
- 51:00say, please don't say my name and I won't. Otherwise,
- 51:02I'm going to say who the question was from. Warren
- 51:04Worth. MLS comps. Highly reliable due to the
- 51:07Realty Board rules where agents do need to provide
- 51:09accurate info promptly and also use. by almost
- 51:13all brokers, 100 % agree with you. I have not
- 51:15had any trouble. I haven't found a single judge
- 51:20that has felt like MLS comps are inadmissible
- 51:26hearsay in terms of what an expert can rely on.
- 51:32This is the kind of non -case -specific hearsay
- 51:36database that experts can rely on. And again,
- 51:40see? it's a fine, it can be a very fine, a very
- 51:45fine call. And I think state court judges tend
- 51:48to be more reluctant to exclude than federal
- 51:54court judges, but Sanchez does help to get some
- 51:57of that inadmissible hearsay keep it out. Okay,
- 52:02cross -exam, we talked about direct and kind
- 52:04of how to build that wall. Your expert sits on
- 52:06the wall. You want to make sure you've got, you
- 52:08know, everything in place before you're calling
- 52:13your expert to testify. Cross -examination. The
- 52:17goal on cross -examination of an opposing expert
- 52:19is to expose bias, assumptions, improper assumptions,
- 52:23and flaws. So I always, some people disagree
- 52:27with me. I think that trials are won and lost
- 52:30based on cross -examination, not just of experts,
- 52:32but fact witnesses. And it's really your opportunity
- 52:36to shine as a litigator and to show your preparation
- 52:40because you are thinking on your feet again never
- 52:42to be replaced by a machine as far as well never
- 52:45say never but um but you're not attacking the
- 52:48person you know I think the most effective expert
- 52:52cross -examination is very um very cordial and
- 52:56professional um and you're just dissecting that
- 52:59opinion based on all of the different factors
- 53:02that apply methodology application to the facts
- 53:05how did they get through what are the missing
- 53:09links in the chain. That's really the fun part.
- 53:12I think that's the fun part of dealing with expert
- 53:15testimony. Three attack zones, bias. Is this
- 53:19a career expert who always testifies on one side
- 53:22or the other? Had they testified in 40 asbestos
- 53:25cases and never found in favor of a defendant?
- 53:32So kind of in line with that, this happens. Frequently,
- 53:40I would say not frequently, but from time to
- 53:42time, the expert has given the opposite opinion
- 53:45in a different case where they have published
- 53:47a treatise or an article that says the opposite
- 53:50of what they're saying. I mean, that kind of
- 53:53goes, I think, hand in hand with bias. I'm not
- 53:55sure what you'd call it, but just self -contradictory.
- 54:00Unsupported assumptions. So what assumptions
- 54:02underlie this expert's opinion? Did they assume
- 54:04that their client was going 60 miles per hour
- 54:07when the data says 25? Well, you know, that's
- 54:11going to change the opinion, right? So you want
- 54:14to expose that. Flawed methodology. Did they
- 54:16fail to test alternative theories? Did they rely
- 54:19on a method that lacks peer review? Did they
- 54:21cherry pick their data? So use tight, closed
- 54:24-ended questions. uh here's some examples that
- 54:27fact came from a hearsay police report correct
- 54:30came from this police report which is hearsay
- 54:32okay you didn't review the treating doctor's
- 54:35deposition before forming your opinion did you
- 54:37you didn't read that deposition you haven't published
- 54:40on this subject in 15 years right so the goal
- 54:45is to create some doubt uh again without sounding
- 54:49disrespectful and let the jury fill in the gaps
- 54:53uh on redirect Rebuild and clarify after CROSS.
- 54:57If your expert took some hits on CROSS, don't
- 55:00waste your redirect. And make sure that you address
- 55:04everything. You'd be surprised what stands out
- 55:07in, you know, the jurors or the judges' mind.
- 55:11It might be different. So take copious notes
- 55:13and make sure you cover everything. Three rules,
- 55:17three cardinal rules only address what was raised
- 55:19on CROSS. Reinforce the experts process. Let's
- 55:23go back, you know, you're on redirect. Let's
- 55:24go back to the data you used. What was your source?
- 55:28Clarify any misleading impressions. If opposing
- 55:31counsel put words in their mouth, twisted an
- 55:33answer, walk it back with dignity, walk it back.
- 55:38Take your time and make sure you cover that base.
- 55:41And sometimes, sometimes that redirect can reinforce
- 55:46your expert's opinion even more than what you
- 55:49were able to do on direct. So clean redirect
- 55:54can really be very powerful. Here's a practical
- 55:58illustration. This expert has investigated over
- 56:02100 construction failures, including subsidence
- 56:04under shopping centers exactly like this one.
- 56:07She applied a soil compaction model peer reviewed
- 56:10in the Journal of Geotechnical Engineering. Here's
- 56:13how she reached her conclusion. Cross, you didn't
- 56:15test the site personally, did you? You relied
- 56:18entirely on the report of a subcontractor, right?
- 56:21And that subcontractor wasn't deposed in this
- 56:23case, correct? On redirect, you might say, can
- 56:27you explain why that subcontractor's report was
- 56:29standard in the field and why it was reliable
- 56:31in your analysis? Of course, at this point, you
- 56:33might have a real Sanchez problem, depending.
- 56:39Let's go to the next slide, please. Practical
- 56:45tips, collaborate with your expert from the beginning.
- 56:48Don't wait until trial to think about admissibility
- 56:51and understand both the law and the courtroom
- 56:53dynamic. Enough said. Let's go to slide 13. I
- 57:00am down to the last few minutes. Are there any
- 57:02questions before I get to the next slides or
- 57:05I will just finish up with the next two slides
- 57:07and we'll be done. Okay, ask now or forever hold
- 57:11your peace. Let's just take a quick detour into
- 57:15ethics. Number one, no contingency fees for experts.
- 57:20You cannot pay a testifying expert a contingency
- 57:23fee. They must be independent sources of analysis.
- 57:26Number two, don't coach the conclusion. You can
- 57:32prepare your expert for direct and cross. You
- 57:34can help them understand rule 702 or Sanchez,
- 57:37but you cannot tell them what to say or edit
- 57:39their opinions to fit your narrative. Again,
- 57:42back to the original. Start early. Find out early.
- 57:47Here's another bonus question. I have two minutes.
- 57:50Don't be like Cinderella's stepsisters trying
- 57:54to shove that big foot into a shoe that doesn't
- 57:57fit. Start early and make sure the shoe fits.
- 58:01Here's the bonus question. In the original Grimm's
- 58:05fairy tale, Cinderella's slipper was not made
- 58:08of glass. If you can tell me what the original
- 58:11material for her slipper was, I will, again,
- 58:14I will buy you a coffee at Starbucks here at
- 58:16Watt Plaza. First person. Original Grimm's fairy
- 58:21tale material of Cinderella's shoe. A third thing
- 58:25about ethics with experts. Consulting versus
- 58:29testifying experts. Very important to understand.
- 58:31You do not have to disclose what your consulting
- 58:35expert and you discuss that's work product, it's
- 58:40sometimes privileged, you don't have to disclose
- 58:43that unless and until you disclose them as your
- 58:47testifying expert and then everything you've
- 58:49discussed with them is fair game even if your
- 58:52client was copied. So if you want to have private
- 58:56conversations with expert consultants that you
- 59:00and you feel like what you've discussed with
- 59:02them isn't helpful for your case, and you don't
- 59:05want to use that, and you don't want to disclose
- 59:07it, do not designate them as an expert, as your
- 59:12testifying expert. Okay. Emerging trends. Can
- 59:21we see the next slide, please? Nobody knows the
- 59:25original Cinderella slipper material, I'll tell
- 59:27you before I get cut off, which happens in like
- 59:3060 seconds. It was feathers, not glass, feathers.
- 59:36Okay, emerging trends. Increased use of animations,
- 59:40simulations, and virtual reconstructions. using
- 59:44a lot of really great technology. So something
- 59:46you want to look into and I might say it can
- 59:48be very helpful not only at trial but also at
- 59:51mediation to present your expert testimony in
- 59:55a really interesting and dynamic way. So I'll
- 59:57just leave you with that. I wanted to say thank
- 1:00:00you so much for letting me present on this topic.
- 1:00:03I wish you all a wonderful rest of your day.
- 1:00:06It is 1 30 and I see no more questions. So thank
- 1:00:11you. And if you want a cup of coffee, email me,
- 1:00:14hit me up, and we'll make that happen. Thank
- 1:00:16you.