Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 239:10-16. Oaths: When Binding, Multiple, Nazir, Unintentional

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 239:10-16. Oaths: When Binding, Multiple, Nazir, Unintentional · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:01
  Hey, good morning Resh lammetet Saif yudd shamaka Vero shanishpa
• 0:09
  V almar anika motka harehu ASA. OK, So here if a person hears
• 0:15
  his friend make a shavua and he says I'm going to be just like
• 0:18
  you. So the Shahana Paskins, it's ASA
• 0:21
  pashas is Amin Hatara. And some of the posts can point
• 0:25
  out even with malchus. In other words, there's no
• 0:28
  difference. Before we had a case, you were
• 0:31
  saying kamuhu on when a person made a nether on a hefez so that
• 0:38
  were a shivuah and he was like he was duplicating on the on the
• 0:42
  object. So that that didn't work.
• 0:45
  Mikara, you know Mikara didn't or at least not from Malkas and
• 0:49
  korban. But you saw a ICA here, it's
• 0:53
  mamash A shivuah. OK, you're aleph shivua
• 0:58
  Shahutsiya belasha neder. OK, so this we touched upon what
• 1:03
  happens if a person makes a shivua and he says it in the way
• 1:07
  usually you word a neder kegon shalmar.
• 1:11
  Yes. Like he says akhilat Ki Karzai
• 1:15
  shivua. So he says this.
• 1:18
  It's he doesn't say it's it's asur.
• 1:20
  He doesn't say it's like a like a korban.
• 1:22
  He says kishivua. So this is a shivuah.
• 1:26
  It's aser as it's aser median shivuah.
• 1:29
  And even though he worded it more like a Nader has worded has
• 1:35
  in power of a as a din as a shivuah and binding.
• 1:40
  And just as a short recap from Rayshavov.
• 1:44
  Hey, and we just had it in Rayshlammat Dalid.
• 1:48
  Basically, it happens to be a Mahlokat if we say that that a
• 1:54
  Neder Balashan Shivua is a neder or Shiva balashan neder if it's
• 1:59
  a shivua. And so that's a mahlokas
• 2:04
  Mahlokas postgame I'm showing him and the Sholkhanara Green
• 2:10
  brings down both opinions and he says certainly it's aser either
• 2:15
  midorisa midinjados. It has, it has, it's equal.
• 2:19
  It's as if it is, or it might just be me darabanan me based on
• 2:24
  the Shalala hargiel. Kind of like a canas and some
• 2:27
  rishonium also make a distinction.
• 2:29
  They don't say it by another 'cause it's all about a Heifetz,
• 2:33
  but they do say it by a Shiva. But it's more about on the
• 2:37
  person. So there's a distinction and
• 2:39
  therefore it might be different. Anyways, that's a Mahoka
• 2:41
  rishonium, but we certainly see we it.
• 2:43
  It is aser if the shalkhanar has a mind, there isa darabanan.
• 2:48
  It's not 100% clear, but according to everybody, he he
• 2:53
  would be higher if for a person makes a neither or a svua, even
• 2:59
  if it's whatever election it is to do a mitzvah or or sedaka.
• 3:05
  I know that's just OK. You'd bet alma hareni Nazir.
• 3:09
  OK, we're going to touch upon Nazir us today, he says.
• 3:15
  Person says I'm going to be a Nazir and then again he says
• 3:18
  Arani Nazir. He says it twice.
• 3:20
  I'm becoming a making myself a Nazir.
• 3:23
  OK, so Khalushanahem. So the den is we're going to see
• 3:28
  it in contrast to Nadarian and Shavuas.
• 3:32
  We do say that Nazir is Khal an an Azeros and therefore, but
• 3:40
  sorry, lean hog stay Nazeros if you earn.
• 3:44
  So if you say that that you're a Nazir twice, that's two nadarium
• 3:48
  of or two Naziris and they're rather and so you're high of 1
• 3:53
  after another another words 30 days plus 30 days, right.
• 3:57
  If you specify a certain amount of time, then that's what the
• 3:59
  Naziris is for. If you don't specify, we say
• 4:03
  Stam Naziris is shloshin young think we said Stam chavua and
• 4:08
  neder is generally going to be forever on that item or on
• 4:12
  yourself until you put a expiration date or you do atara.
• 4:15
  But for naziris we say Stam is only 30 days.
• 4:21
  So then he says even if a person says the shock points out to her
• 4:25
  Iranian Nazir Hayom just today or Leo Mekhad, he still has to
• 4:30
  be a Nazir for 30 days because he don't get less than 30 days.
• 4:36
  And we Paskin Naziris is not less than 30 days.
• 4:39
  And we also paskin that Naziris is Khal al Naziris.
• 4:43
  In other words, they're both binding you and you just add the
• 4:46
  two times together. Better be very careful.
• 4:48
  Don't tell yourself a Nazir. I meant a Nazir.
• 4:51
  Wait, wait. Yeah, you can't do it for 32
• 4:54
  days or twice that it has for life.
• 4:57
  You're high of a carbon after 30 days.
• 5:00
  The with the shock points out is a little kitser.
• 5:02
  Kitser helchus nazeros. Everyone agrees it's nohig
• 5:06
  bifinea bite, Vishalo bifinea bite.
• 5:09
  So it doesn't matter if the base of Migdash is built or not,
• 5:14
  nowadays it's always binding. Bain the arts Bain the
• 5:18
  Hutzlarts. It doesn't matter if you're in
• 5:19
  Israel or anywhere in the world, it's binding.
• 5:23
  Now the Rahman has an interesting opinion.
• 5:25
  Kofin otola alot la Erezizer El that if you're in Nazer, because
• 5:31
  all the lands of Hutzlarts have, we consider heirs amim Tamim and
• 5:36
  so therefore or Tamaeus or whatever it is.
• 5:38
  So therefore we have to he has to move to Erezizer El now Eve.
• 5:43
  But while he's in Hutzlaritz, he's still binding to be a Nazir
• 5:46
  in the meantime, still has to move.
• 5:48
  It's a separate issue, but it's still binding for him, right?
• 5:52
  Naziris goes on wine, not to become tummy to dead to dead
• 5:56
  people and and not to shave. And all the details that come
• 6:02
  with Naziris are not discussed here.
• 6:05
  Those all apply in Hutzlaritz as well.
• 6:09
  But as long as you're in Khutz Laureitz, you're Naziris time
• 6:14
  doesn't begin. You're still in Nazir and you're
• 6:17
  30 days don't the count doesn't begin until you move to Eretz
• 6:22
  Yzreil, the rivit argues and he says nowadays there's no
• 6:25
  difference. And even in Eretz Yzrel we're
• 6:28
  we're basically keep Tumantara the same as they do in Khutz
• 6:31
  Laureitz, right? We're not so careful.
• 6:33
  So therefore everybody is considered Tumas Mace wherever
• 6:37
  we are. That's the that's the
• 6:39
  assumption. And so therefore there is no Kyo
• 6:42
  to move to Eretz Yusrell. It doesn't help.
• 6:44
  And then he also points out that there is a difference of
• 6:47
  Nazira's Shimshan says the shock points out according to the
• 6:50
  round bomb, there'll be no reason to move to Eretz Yusrell
• 6:53
  or need to move to Eretz Yusrell because Nazira's Shimshan goes
• 6:58
  on wine and shaving. It's not about being Tammy.
• 7:01
  And so therefore it doesn't that there is no, according to the
• 7:05
  Rambam, he believes there's no Kiev to move.
• 7:07
  Then he also says there is Shaila Venezeros.
• 7:11
  You could also do Kanhilo Ataras Nadaram that we're referring to
• 7:15
  that we're used to also for nazeros, Shailas nazeros.
• 7:20
  OK, is that all? He also points out Hilchos
• 7:25
  Nazeros if a person makes it a woman makes it so then
• 7:30
  according, you know, long as the age and whatever applies, there
• 7:33
  is hafara for a husband and a a father for to to be made for
• 7:40
  Nazeros. And he also points that out, but
• 7:42
  not by Nazeros Shim sham. They have no no binding on that.
• 7:47
  OK, no, no jurisdiction on that. Fine, let's go to Yid Gilmour,
• 7:51
  back to Shibuos. EIN shivua khala al shivua,
• 7:55
  right? So in contrast to what we just
• 7:57
  said by Nazeros, we say like this and we're going to say the
• 8:00
  same thing by Nadar coming up, EIN shivua khala al shivua 1
• 8:06
  Shivua cannot be khal on another Shiva shiim Ammar shivua Shiloh
• 8:11
  khalki karza person says the words Shivua shilo khalki karza.
• 8:14
  I'm not going to make, I'm making a shivu.
• 8:16
  I'm not going to eat it, right? Preferably.
• 8:19
  I mean, it's worse if you stay with Hashem's name.
• 8:20
  Fine, Shavua Shaloha kikar. They say it twice.
• 8:24
  I'm not going to. I'm making a shavua that I'm not
• 8:26
  going to eat this role in Hashiniya khala.
• 8:29
  So the second one doesn't apply yet.
• 8:32
  It's not khal yet. In other words, the second
• 8:35
  shavua was hovering in the air, but it doesn't land.
• 8:38
  It doesn't have where to land because we don't.
• 8:39
  One can't land on top of the other.
• 8:42
  And if a person eats that kikar is only going to be high of how
• 8:45
  many. Loving the one for the first
• 8:48
  Shavua, however be shown a person does Atara shavuas on the
• 8:55
  first one, so then Khala Hashmiya, the second one that
• 8:59
  was hovering in the air lands it applies and he's still going to
• 9:02
  be high of that love on the second shavua.
• 9:06
  Interesting case. Yeah, the post can point out
• 9:09
  it's in the Shah quotes from the Maharam.
• 9:11
  What happens if a person makes a Neda or a Shavua depending on
• 9:16
  how it's worded. Basically it's like this.
• 9:19
  People say it as a shuva. Basically a person makes, if a
• 9:23
  person makes, let's say a shuva, if I am going to do something,
• 9:30
  so then I'm going to have to make, I'm going to have to pay
• 9:33
  every time. Says every time I do something,
• 9:36
  he's trying out and he has a bad habit.
• 9:37
  He wants to break a habit. So every time I do this, now I
• 9:41
  have to pay, pay money to somebody, right?
• 9:45
  So then I'm giving myself this knas.
• 9:48
  So he basically makes it as a Shuva for every time he does it.
• 9:52
  So then there's a whole there's a question.
• 9:54
  What can he do or how does he do it?
• 9:56
  And there's no real terror. So don't do this.
• 9:59
  Basically the two stabbed him. Is it could be you can't get out
• 10:02
  of it because we learned you could only do a Tara after its
• 10:09
  call. And if you said you're going to
• 10:12
  be, you're going to now you're going to make yourself obligated
• 10:15
  to to pay. It's going to be Khal, the
• 10:18
  obligation to pay every time you do something.
• 10:20
  Then every time you do something, now you have a it's
• 10:24
  kilo, a new, a new Shiva is Khal on you or, and it lands again.
• 10:31
  And therefore, and you can't until it lands, you can't do
• 10:35
  Atara. So do you look at it?
• 10:37
  I don't know. Yeah, so, but it's but it's like
• 10:43
  Infinity. Never really, there's no end.
• 10:46
  You can never get rid of the next one.
• 10:48
  Every time you get rid of the first one, the next one is
• 10:51
  called. It's like, do you, do you say
• 10:53
  it's like, you know, there's Infinity window mirrors or
• 10:55
  whatever it is, Is it just forever?
• 10:57
  You just have to keep on asking Atara.
• 10:59
  Or do you say since it was all in one statement, it's keilu 1
• 11:03
  shivua and it can all be, but you don't undo one.
• 11:07
  They all fall apart. Or as the Archer Shulkhan put
• 11:11
  it, you say it's kind of like neder shukhtar shukhtar mixato
• 11:15
  hutar kulo. So anyways, that's a question,
• 11:19
  no clear answer. So don't do that.
• 11:22
  OK? You dial it.
• 11:25
  Amar shuvuha shukhal basar extreme young.
• 11:28
  OK, so if a person makes a shuvuha not to eat meat for 20
• 11:32
  days, the Khazar vilmar shivua shaloh al basar shnaim
• 11:38
  estremiel. So now he goes and he says wait,
• 11:43
  OK, sorry, first he says 1 shivu, I'm not going to eat meat
• 11:46
  for 20 days. And then he says, now I'm not
• 11:48
  going to eat meat for 22 days. So what's the halacha?
• 11:52
  Is that a shivua on top of a shivua?
• 11:55
  In other words, is that going to be, is the second one going to
• 11:59
  be Khal altogether? And if it is, are you now higher
• 12:02
  for 22 days or is it 20 + 22 and now you're higher for 42 days?
• 12:09
  For sure it's gonna be half because it's Kolo, right?
• 12:12
  So it's for sure Kolo, but it's Kolo.
• 12:15
  It's the most, most if Kolo. Same thing, right?
• 12:18
  So therefore it's for sure going to be Kol.
• 12:21
  How many days? And if you said 2020, we're
• 12:23
  going to say it's a big, it's a big Mahloka in the Rushonia
• 12:26
  Manposki. OK, let's read inside.
• 12:29
  Yeshua Misha Omer. Yeshua Misha Omer.
• 12:31
  So he quotes one opinion. Misha Omer Norm often I don't
• 12:37
  want to say usually I don't know.
• 12:39
  Yeshua Misha Omer means there's one opinion and he does not
• 12:43
  agree with it. Many times.
• 12:45
  We're going to see it perhaps both today if we got there.
• 12:47
  Yeshua Misha Omer. Well, if he's quoting more than
• 12:50
  one opinion, that's the general rule.
• 12:53
  If he quotes more than one opinion and one sieve and he
• 12:56
  says Yeh Shamisha Omar, that usually means that's one opinion
• 12:59
  who he does not agree with, Lahalaka.
• 13:01
  If the shalkhanar only quotes one opinion and it's Yeh
• 13:05
  Shamisha Omar and that's the whole, see if then usually he
• 13:09
  only found one opinion or he only quotes one opinion in the
• 13:12
  base Yosef and that is Lahalaka. So that's exactly, it's
• 13:16
  consistent here. Like always we're about to get
• 13:19
  to the next case if we get there yeshu me shomer shahsar babasar
• 13:23
  shnaim the Arabahim young. So there is one opinion in the
• 13:26
  Rishonim or a opinion that says it's 42 days.
• 13:30
  You add them because it's right. You say, OK, fine, that's
• 13:35
  because you add an extra days. So you you meant to add them in
• 13:39
  total, the Eno near Ali and he says I don't disagree with this
• 13:43
  doesn't make sense. Ella Eno asar, the basar Ella
• 13:47
  Shnaim, the estremium only 22 days.
• 13:51
  OK, because you added All right, let's keep reading in the in the
• 13:56
  Rama. I'll just point out the taz.
• 13:59
  I mean, this is the halakha according to the Shah and seems
• 14:03
  clearly the I think also the the Taz is Mahmer.
• 14:07
  He says 1 should be a mahmir in this case for 42 to be Koshish
• 14:12
  for that opinion. OK, I don't know 'cause as you
• 14:16
  know, because Nadaram is the reisa Stam Nadaram mahamar.
• 14:20
  But you usually say that only when it's a real.
• 14:22
  So when you end up with the Suffolk.
• 14:24
  But if if you have a clear opinion based on the Surya and
• 14:29
  the Rishonian, we we don't say that every question that comes
• 14:31
  up in the entire past 40 Simani and we don't find we don't end
• 14:35
  off with every question for every Michael because we shown
• 14:38
  him as a so anyway, I don't know Haga vedavka bomosif Beneder
• 14:44
  Shani shoneder Risha now that's only the Ramar qualifies is
• 14:50
  because you added first you said 20, then you said 22.
• 14:54
  So therefore when you add you have to it's, we assume it's
• 14:58
  included the 1st 20, but you also obviously meant to add 2
• 15:03
  more days, right? So then we say like this.
• 15:05
  So then if it's on the same day, you say 20 then 22.
• 15:09
  So then that's when you add two more days and the total is 22
• 15:13
  about if on the same day a person says certainly one after
• 15:22
  another, perhaps the same day, keep reading.
• 15:25
  If it says twice Estream, I'm making another for Shibuya for
• 15:29
  Estream Yom and then again for Estream Yom.
• 15:31
  Then the fact that he repeated it, he obviously meant to add
• 15:35
  another 20. We'll see.
• 15:38
  The the Sholkhanarov seems to disagree with this and that and
• 15:41
  the the shock disagrees with it. But it's anyway Mark Lucas, if
• 15:49
  you want, if one has to only keep the 1st 20 or if one has to
• 15:53
  keep 40, the Rama holds to keep 40 the inkhein Najro Najro
• 16:00
  Alamali. If so, why did he say his same
• 16:03
  another twice? Not to repeat himself.
• 16:05
  He obviously meant to add 20 + 20 the inkhein Najro Alamali.
• 16:10
  So he's after about 40 days, right?
• 16:13
  The shock disagrees. And and same with the the Shah
• 16:16
  Kanarak, the Philo emotive Al Nidro.
• 16:20
  If you said 20 plus and then again, you made another, another
• 16:28
  22. So if it's on the same day, so
• 16:31
  then you only have to be, you only have to keep 22.
• 16:34
  But if you did it on a different day, right, Sunday, you said 20
• 16:39
  on Monday you said 22. So then why?
• 16:42
  So then that 20 days already started Harishonim, vyakharka,
• 16:49
  nadar SH name shanayam vastremium and then you make
• 16:52
  another Nader for 22 days. So then in minion arishon Ole la
• 16:57
  klau then the 1st 20 days don't count at all.
• 17:00
  Vyasa, rabasa, shanayam, arbaimyam and then you'd be ASA
• 17:04
  for 40 days and one should be. Doesn't sound like he
• 17:11
  necessarily holds of it. MI ikar I didn't MI svara but he
• 17:16
  says it's possibly true. We've shown him say so and
• 17:20
  therefore he says 1 should be Mahmir.
• 17:22
  Shah argues with this. Again the Grah and the Shah
• 17:26
  disagree, but the the Araka Shahan is Mahmir.
• 17:29
  Also in the ends that it's best just to be Mahmir and Duatara
• 17:33
  and you avoid the entire Mahlakis.
• 17:35
  Tedwav yeish Misha Omer. Here's the yeish Misha Omar I
• 17:39
  alluded to where the the shock points out that he gun he says
• 17:44
  it clearly. He he doesn't say Yesh Misha
• 17:47
  Omer because he doesn't agree with it.
• 17:49
  He agrees with it Lahalaka. But if you look in the base,
• 17:51
  he'll say if that's the only opinion that he either quoted or
• 17:54
  found and that was the run. But he also points out, you
• 17:57
  should know that this is also the opinion of Tosvas Rashi Rash
• 18:01
  Rashbanghule. OK Asia Misha Omar, this is the
• 18:04
  AL AQA show. IM Amar konam kikar zeh alai the
• 18:08
  hazer of Amar konam kikar zeh alai inohaya Vela aqas, right?
• 18:13
  A neder, Khal al neder as well. You're only going to be high of
• 18:17
  1 right? You said you said another and
• 18:19
  you said the exact same letter twice.
• 18:22
  So it's going to only the first one is khal and the second one
• 18:24
  is not. I believe the second one would
• 18:28
  be khal if you do hatara on the first one right?
• 18:31
  That's what we said before. OK, Ted Zion cave on Shenandra
• 18:37
  Chicago Sumatar. All right.
• 18:38
  We already learned Nidre Chicago's right.
• 18:41
  You said it by accident. You didn't mean to make that
• 18:43
  nether it was I'm completely the whole understanding of what you
• 18:48
  are making another about or The Tonight was all miss a
• 18:52
  misunderstanding. So it's not Khal.
• 18:53
  You don't have to do a Tara IM Nishba Shalo Khalki Karzai
• 19:00
  person makes a Shiva not to eat this world implony Amar de
• 19:06
  Varza. If Mr. X said something and
• 19:11
  we're talking about the person is positive or pretty positive,
• 19:16
  his complete Havana. Our assumption was that he
• 19:20
  didn't say it. Otherwise he would never make
• 19:22
  this Shiva, right? The shock points out if you're
• 19:25
  not, if he wasn't wasn't sure and if you you know or had no
• 19:29
  clue, no idea. So then that's a normal Shiva.
• 19:34
  You made it tonight and that's not a Chicago.
• 19:37
  Chicago is when there was a misunderstanding, not otherwise.
• 19:40
  If you didn't know and you still made the Shiva, you you knew you
• 19:43
  were making the Shiva without knowing and you you were going
• 19:46
  to find out later on if it's if it's a nice Mcleum or not.
• 19:50
  We're talking about a case where you were pretty sure he never
• 19:53
  said it, the Nimza Shamrol. And then lo and behold, he
• 19:57
  actually did say it. You thought he didn't say it and
• 19:59
  he did say it. So but you made the Ned there
• 20:02
  the Shiva on that assumption. So therefore.
• 20:05
  Motzerba kikar, you're allowed to eat it no problem, right?
• 20:07
  So we learned this by Nadarim. It's the same thing by Shivas.
• 20:11
  Bahrain imtala kikar be ekhad Shi Amar shivua Shiloh kikar zeh
• 20:18
  imokhal zeh. So too, if a person is taloi
• 20:23
  eating this, let's say this roll go for bread based on eating
• 20:28
  something else. OK, so this is only going to be
• 20:32
  usser if he eats something else. OK, Vishakha now then comes the
• 20:39
  akhla and he actually eats that other item, right?
• 20:42
  I'm going to make a shivua not to eat a roll of bread.
• 20:45
  This roll of bread if I eat a pink lady apple.
• 20:50
  All right, so I have this pink lady apple and as long as he
• 20:55
  doesn't eat that apple, he can eat the roll.
• 20:57
  But if he eats that apple, then he can no longer eat that roll.
• 21:01
  And then he goes the alkaline eats it Lokala alava shivua.
• 21:06
  Because when he ate the pink apple, the pink the apple he
• 21:09
  thought he was, he totally forgot about his shivua the only
• 21:15
  time. And that's all the shivua or
• 21:18
  another dish Gaga. That's not because again, either
• 21:24
  when you're when you say the chavua, it was by a mistake and
• 21:29
  a misunderstanding or when you do The Tonight it was on a
• 21:33
  misunderstanding or a mistake. You forgot about your chavua.
• 21:36
  Even that's called a Chicago. The Yaco loco shall tonight.
• 21:44
  OK, well, that's tequila. That's the next part.
• 21:48
  So you so we said you're not well, it's the same case, but
• 21:50
  you didn't eat it yet. You said you're not going to eat
• 21:53
  the we already said you're not high of on the key card when you
• 21:56
  ate it by mistake. Fine, now you make the exact
• 21:59
  same Chervua. I'm not going to eat this loaf
• 22:01
  of bread if I'm going to eat this out right, making sure not
• 22:06
  to eat the bread if I eat the apple.
• 22:09
  Now you come to the apple. We say we say like this, the low
• 22:14
  the Yahoo show tonight. You are allowed to eat that
• 22:18
  apple. You made a chevua on the bread.
• 22:21
  There is no chevua on the apple. The apple is a tenai for your
• 22:24
  chevua. You're allowed to eat the the
• 22:26
  apple. But now you're binding the the
• 22:30
  chevua is binding not to eat the bread unless you do a Tara so,
• 22:34
  but you are allowed to eat the apples.
• 22:37
  There's no Easter to eat the apple.
• 22:40
  We're not afraid that you might come to eat the apple by
• 22:43
  mistake, the bread by mistake. Now, if you eat the bread by
• 22:48
  mistake, that was a real shivua. There was no misunderstanding
• 22:52
  when you made the shivua, no misunderstanding when you did
• 22:55
  The Tonight. Now you're you're violating the
• 22:58
  shivua Bishkaga. That's a violation of a shivua.
• 23:01
  We we had this many times. OK, so you won't be high of a
• 23:04
  Corbin. I mean, you won't be high of
• 23:06
  malchus. Maybe a Corbin whenever it
• 23:07
  applies, whatever it is, but that's you could, but you could
• 23:12
  be in violation of a shivua or another Bishop.
• 23:15
  It there's no, we always said that so therefore and but we're
• 23:20
  not worried about that. You just have to be careful.
• 23:26
  However, there is an isser darabanan to eat the loaf of
• 23:29
  bread. If a person makes a shibuya not
• 23:32
  to eat a loaf of bread based and with a tanai of eating the
• 23:36
  apple. So it's not exactly whole yet.
• 23:39
  You're still allowed to eat the bread.
• 23:41
  But there's an isser darabanan of eating that bread because
• 23:45
  after you eat the bread, yeah, you might come to eat that apple
• 23:49
  and then Lema Freya, you'll violate the esser.
• 23:52
  So there is an extra safeguard on the esser, but there's no
• 23:57
  safeguard on The Tonight. It's almost like a Xerilexer
• 24:00
  type of thing so that we don't do.
• 24:06
  So don't eat the the piece of bread because you might end up
• 24:10
  eating that apple afterwards. Then I'm afraid you violated it.
• 24:14
  The EM alcohol shell tonight tequila.
• 24:17
  The EM alcohol shell tonight tequila bishogig butter
• 24:22
  bishniya. The EM alcohol bemezid Hayev
• 24:26
  alashniya. The shock just points out, even
• 24:29
  if you ate the we kind of just said it in that previous case,
• 24:32
  even if you ate the loaf of bread, you didn't eat the apple
• 24:36
  yet you ate the loaf of bread. That and you ate the loaf of
• 24:38
  bread by mistake. You still can't have that pink
• 24:41
  lady 'cause if you eat the apple, well, I'm afraid you're
• 24:43
  going to violate it. Remember, the misa isser can be
• 24:47
  done bishogig to be called a Gaga that you're not Kaya for
• 24:51
  It's only on when you said the Shiva and when you do The
• 24:55
  Tonight. So therefore, even if you eat it
• 24:58
  bishogig the isser, you can still be violating that isser if
• 25:01
  you then eat the apple. So OK, this last clause and this
• 25:05
  last line in the the the Michel Kanar, we said, we basically
• 25:09
  just said this out loud. If you eat The Tonight first,
• 25:13
  but you eat it, you eat the apple first by mistake.
• 25:17
  You forgot about your Shavua when you ate the apple.
• 25:21
  Can you now eat the loaf of bread?
• 25:22
  Mutter bashenia, you are allowed to eat the loaf of bread.
• 25:26
  Here. The bashenia means a loaf of
• 25:27
  bread. But if you ate the pink lady,
• 25:29
  the apple on purpose, and in other words, you knew that
• 25:32
  there's a shavua involved. So now, Kaya balashenia, you
• 25:35
  would be high if you eat that loaf of bread.
• 25:37
  Think we'll save the last seat for tomorrow?