Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Patreon vs YouTube Membership
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. So in this episode, I just want to explain
- 0:03the differences between the YouTube membership program on YouTube and the patron membership program on
- 0:11Patreon, and I've taken some notes to keep me on track. So we
- 0:16started the YouTube membership program about a year ago, I think, and we've
- 0:20used this past year as a time to gather data, and during that time
- 0:26I experimented with different kinds of perks for the members. I also experimented with
- 0:31different amounts of time expenditure for myself to see what worked. I also asked
- 0:37for feedback and people provided their feedback, and me and my wife over time
- 0:42over this past year have occasionally sat down and thought about where we're at and
- 0:46what we want to do moving forward, and recently we established a pretty firm
- 0:52plan into the future, and I wanted to explain that to you all.
- 0:57So long story short, if you don't want to watch this full video,
- 1:00the plan is to continue doing what we have basically been doing for a while,
- 1:04which is that becoming a YouTube member will get you access to exclusive YouTube
- 1:10video content, and becoming a patron will get you access to exclusive audio podcast
- 1:15content. And the Patreon side, it's always been that way. Since twenty
- 1:19fifteen, since we started on Patreon with the YouTube side, I've kind of
- 1:25been trying to figure out what that is. But for a while now we've
- 1:27had this in place and we're going to continue with that plan. And so
- 1:32the rest of this video is just an explanation of how we got to that
- 1:36plan. And so originally, when I first heard about the YouTube membership program,
- 1:40I think a few years ago, I didn't really think it was in
- 1:45the cards for psychology in Seattle because we were already on Patreon, so it
- 1:49just seemed like a redundant thing. Also, I don't like having multiple accounts.
- 1:55I've always resisted since I started the podcast in two thousand and eight,
- 1:59reive I did opening every single account that we've had, Instagram, Facebook,
- 2:04all that kind of stuff. When I started the podcast two thousand and eight,
- 2:07I just wanted an RSS feed. I just wanted the audio podcast feed
- 2:10to go to your phone, your podcast catcher. And I didn't want a
- 2:15website. But people were yelling at me and saying you got to have a
- 2:20website. I was, Okay, I'll have a website, and then people
- 2:22are like, you got to start a Facebook account, and I'm like,
- 2:23how about you start one for me? And then someone started one for us,
- 2:28and then eventually we took it over Twitter. I went back and forth,
- 2:31finally shut that thing down, and even with YouTube, I didn't want
- 2:36to go on YouTube. But a student of mine in two thousand and nine
- 2:39said she liked the podcast, but she didn't like the way that you get
- 2:45podcasts. She said, you know, young people they listen to stuff on
- 2:47YouTube. And I thought, why would I upload audio podcasts to YouTube?
- 2:53That seems so strange, But she kept badgering me about it, and so
- 2:58I thought, okay, find she's younger, so maybe she knows. And
- 3:01so I started the YouTube channel just because of her, and you know,
- 3:06it seemed like something that was worth it over time. And so when I
- 3:10first heard about the YouTube membership program, I just thought, eh, you
- 3:14know, not for me, but many within the YouTube audience they would ask
- 3:20for it. You know, people would comment or email in and say,
- 3:23hey, you know, we would like to support what you're doing here,
- 3:27but we don't really want to go to Patreon because we're not really listeners to
- 3:30the audio podcast. We want to support what you're doing on YouTube, so
- 3:35you should have a YouTube membership program. But again I just thought, well,
- 3:38I don't know. I don't like multiple accounts. It just seems like
- 3:42a confusing thing. But some people in the audience started to sell me on
- 3:47the idea of having a YouTube membership program in addition to having the Patreon thing,
- 3:53because there were people on YouTube that wanted exclusive content on YouTube, and
- 4:00I'd never really considered that of making exclusive videos. I'm oriented towards deep dives
- 4:05on Patreon as something that's valuable to people that they'd be willing to pay money
- 4:12for. I never thought that people would want to pay money to have me
- 4:16watch a particular TV show or a particular documentary or something, and so that
- 4:21hadn't crossed my mind, but people were suggesting it. Also, some people
- 4:26within the YouTube community they wanted a smaller core community, like on Patreon.
- 4:31You know the audio podcast there's a much bigger audience than the patrons, right,
- 4:36But on Patreon there's a paywall there, so there's a smaller community,
- 4:42it's a more cozy community, and so on YouTube there were people that were
- 4:46saying, well, we want that not on Patreon, we want it on
- 4:50YouTube. We want to have a core YouTube community of psychology and Seattle,
- 4:57So that was another selling point. And so there were a few points.
- 5:00And by the way, thanks everyone for giving me this feedback. Also thank
- 5:03you to the patrons, because I wouldn't be here if it weren't for them.
- 5:09So in response to those requests, over the last number of years,
- 5:13we started to brainstorm what a YouTube membership program could look like. And the
- 5:19first thing that we came to was to think about the YouTube channel as almost
- 5:27like a different business than the audio podcast. I traditionally never saw it that
- 5:31way, because it was always an audio podcast that just happened to be on
- 5:35YouTube. But over the years, occasionally I would make a video that was
- 5:40not on the audio podcast. In the early days, it was rare that
- 5:44that would happen, but I would do that every once in a while.
- 5:46And then when the YouTube channel took off in its own right at the beginning
- 5:53of the pandemic, when I started watching that was blind then I was still
- 5:59in that mindset of like, well, it's still just an offshoot of the
- 6:01audio podcast, but it really isn't, right, It's a completely different thing,
- 6:09completely different content, different style. It's video. It's video oriented,
- 6:15right. It's hard to listen to that you have to see the clips,
- 6:19or it's better to see the clips. And so I was basically in denial
- 6:27of the fact that it was very much a different business or at least a
- 6:32completely different vibe, a completely different audience. And Stacey would tell me this
- 6:38sometimes she would say, you know, you might want to have the YouTube
- 6:43channel its own business, like a separate business account, that kind of thing.
- 6:47And I thought, oh, again, I don't like having multiple accounts.
- 6:51I don't like having multiple email accounts. I don't like having multiple bank
- 6:56accounts. Don't I get overwhelmed with stuff like I don't like It's almost like
- 7:00clutter in a way, and so I just want everything to be in one
- 7:02camp. And so I resisted that. And it is still just one business.
- 7:08It's just psychology in Seattle. But in a way, it is a
- 7:12completely different business. You know, on the audio side, it's a different
- 7:16vibe. I have my co hosts with me often, and that's very different.
- 7:21You know. Sometimes people from the YouTube side, they'll listen to an
- 7:26audio episode and I'll be surprised that in the comments section people will say,
- 7:31who's this Umbardo guy? And I'm thinking, who's umberdo He's been around from
- 7:36the beginning, he's part owner of Psychology. Who's Umbardo? How what are
- 7:40you talking about? But it's different audiences. It's a different group of people,
- 7:44different preferences, different experiences. And one of the ways that I started
- 7:48to think about it was that it's almost like two different restaurants. You have
- 7:54the podcast, the audio podcast that is more cozy. There's not as much
- 8:01traffic, but the people that come in are more regulars, they're more loyal.
- 8:07They might come every day, like Cheers the bar on Cheers, right,
- 8:13it's just a core group of people that come every single day, and
- 8:18it's more mellow on that side, and there's not a lot of foot traffic
- 8:22that walks by the restaurant and just randomly comes in. Then the YouTube channel
- 8:28is a different kind of restaurant where there are some loyal people, but there's
- 8:33a lot of passers by who are just walking and off the street and might
- 8:39just come to that restaurant once, or might even just walk in the door,
- 8:43look at the menu, go not for me, and walk out,
- 8:46and there's a lot more volume and the menu has to be more generally appealing.
- 8:52Probably, I don't know if that exactly scans, but you get my
- 8:54point, it's different, and to consider it all to be one restaurant is
- 9:01confusing to the audience and to me. Frankly. Now, some customers might
- 9:09like one restaurant and not the other, some might like both restaurants. Some
- 9:15might like one restaurant eighty percent of time and the other one twenty percent of
- 9:18the time. And thinking of it that way kind of helps me to figure
- 9:22out how to move forward. So one of the major areas that I kept
- 9:28coming back to when trying to answer this question as to whether or not the
- 9:31YouTube membership program would harm or benefit the audience was work life balance for myself,
- 9:37how do I allocate my time. If you've heard me talk about this
- 9:39in other episodes, you know that I've been struggling with that ever since the
- 9:43beginning of the pandemic. When the lockdown happened, I had extra time to
- 9:50do what I actually liked. The fact that I was working eighty hours a
- 9:54week because I wanted something to do wasn't anything to do. But of course,
- 10:01eventually we were able to not be under lockdown and do other things and
- 10:07see people and maybe go to a movie or something. And yet I was
- 10:11still working eighty hours a week. About seventy five hours a week and that
- 10:16was not going to work. But because I'm such a dedicated, loyal person
- 10:22when I make a commitment to something like that that I couldn't scale back.
- 10:30I thought while I committed, and even though the audience wasn't really asking me
- 10:33to do this, I thought, I thought, well, you know,
- 10:37I've already committed to this pattern of two reaction videos every day. Well again
- 10:43during the lockdown, that wasn't hard to do. Eventually it was way too
- 10:48much and people would say, Kirk, go ahead and slow down. We
- 10:52don't need you to drive yourself into an early grave, which incidentally like it
- 10:58could do that right toll on everything and anyway, So I thought maybe the
- 11:05YouTube membership program could help with that somehow. And the way that I thought
- 11:09it might be able to help was that as I scale back on YouTube,
- 11:13which you might have noticed that there are times outside of the Love is Blind
- 11:18seasons, I will publish two or three episodes a week instead of fourteen videos
- 11:24a week, And of course that's an addition to all the audio podcasts that
- 11:26we publish. So on a typical week over the last number of years,
- 11:31we would publish twenty episodes a week because there would be the fourteen or so
- 11:37reaction videos, there would be the five audio podcasts, and there would usually
- 11:41be some other stuff in there somewhere. That's a lot of content, and
- 11:46the content is edited a lot, and especially the audio podcast I'm spending a
- 11:52lot of prep time on that kind of stuff, so it, you know,
- 11:56it's completely unsustainable. And I thought, well, well when we scale
- 12:01back to on YouTube, because that was really the only thing I felt like
- 12:05I could scale back on it, and I resisted it for years. I
- 12:09don't want to, and so I would scale back other things, you know,
- 12:11like I closed a Twitter account, and I closed actually discord, and
- 12:16I closed other kinds of things that it was painful to do, but I
- 12:20just thought, I don't want to scale back on content. Eventually I had
- 12:24to scale back on content, and so I scaled back occasionally on YouTube to
- 12:30two or three episodes a week, and that helped. But what that does
- 12:35is that drastically reduces money and revenue and my ability to pay my bills.
- 12:41It certainly gives me a lot of anxiety about it. And so I thought,
- 12:46well, I wonder if the YouTube membership program could make up for some
- 12:50of that a little bit that in the same way that Patreon gave me this
- 12:54ability in twenty fifteen when I started Patreon, maybe what the YouTube membership program
- 13:01could do is I could spend my time tailoring my content to a core audience
- 13:07that was willing to support my ability to pay my bills, and to provide
- 13:16that very tailored content to a smaller group of people. Maybe that would give
- 13:24me the overall ability to scale back on time, but my overall ability also
- 13:28to pay my bills. If that makes sense. I hope that makes sense.
- 13:31So I wondered if that was possible also just giving me the ability to
- 13:39know what I should do with my time, because for me, if I
- 13:43was left to my own devices, I would watch all the shows you want
- 13:46me to. I would cover all the topics, I would do all the
- 13:50deep dives. But I've realized over the last few years that if I don't
- 13:54put major limits, if I don't impose limits on myself, I'll work myself
- 14:01into an early grave. I'll work eighty ninety hours a week. I mean,
- 14:05even the eighty hours a week I was still having to say, I
- 14:07would still have to have willpower say no, don't go down. That rabbit
- 14:11hole of content making because you need time to do other things. And I
- 14:18just love making. I just want to learn and experience and interact. I
- 14:22love doing this. So if you're up to me, i'd be doing it.
- 14:26But I have to limit myself somehow, and so one of the ways
- 14:30to limit myself is to make priorities. And one of the ways to make
- 14:35priorities is to say, well, who are the paying customers? So using
- 14:41the restaurant analogy, like a pizza restaurant, right, if I just went
- 14:46on the street or went online and said what sort of pizza should I offer
- 14:50this month as a special or something, and the dominant response is Hawaiian pizza,
- 14:56So then I make that a priority, and then I open my doors
- 15:01and no one buys the Hawaiian pizza. Well, that's important information for me
- 15:07to know, right, Because if you just ask everyone something, the data
- 15:11will reflect that you're asking everyone. But if you actually watch what people are
- 15:15willing to spend money for in your restaurant, that could be different. It
- 15:18might not be. It might be the same, but it might not be.
- 15:20And so when having a YouTube membership program, it would be along those
- 15:26lines. If I just ask everyone or I respond to requests. That's one
- 15:31set of requests, and that's important. I still value that greatly, but
- 15:35it's also interesting and important for any business to know, well, among the
- 15:41people that are that dedicated to your product that they're willing to pay money for
- 15:46it, what are they asking for? Right and over time, just to
- 15:52let you know that, I'm going to be listening to both audiences. I'm
- 15:54going to be listening to the overall YouTube audience and I'm also going to be
- 15:58listening to the membership audience and figuring out how to move forward. Like with
- 16:03Couple's Therapy, I was getting a lot of requests, but from a smaller
- 16:08group of people. When I put out a poll to everybody, they wouldn't
- 16:12request Couple's Therapy. But over the years, I would just continually get these
- 16:18requests, and when I started the YouTube membership program, I found that those
- 16:23people were the people that were requesting couples Therapy. So the only reason why
- 16:29I'm even allocating the time I love watching that show, But the only reason
- 16:33why I could justify spending the time watching that show is because the paying YouTube
- 16:41members were requesting it, right, So that gives me an ability to prioritize
- 16:48and figure out where I get the most bang for my bucks, so to
- 16:52speak. You know what I mean, And you know I hate bringing up
- 16:56the money aspect of it, but it's a major part of the conversation for
- 17:00me in that in order for me to even make this content, I need
- 17:04to be able to generate money from Psychology and Seattle, because I if that
- 17:11isn't the worst case scenario, say revenue just plummets for Psychology and Seattle,
- 17:15I have to go back to my regular career at the university and in my
- 17:19private practice, and I would be spending fifty six hours a week during doing
- 17:26that, and I would have, you know, only a little bit of
- 17:27time to make content. And so it's a symbiotic relationship. You know.
- 17:33The revenue makes it so I can make the content and make the content better,
- 17:37and I need to figure out how I can make that work so that
- 17:41everyone can kind of so it's a win win, right, I can win
- 17:47and the audience can win. Right. So I'm always trying to figure that
- 17:51out. So I hope you don't mind that I bring up the money ask
- 17:53because it's real. It's it's a real thing, you know. I semi
- 17:56retired from the university. I drastically shrunk my private practice over time, and
- 18:03I and my family are ninety nine percent dependent on you. So but you
- 18:08know, it's working out. It's not without its anxiety, but you know,
- 18:15things seem to be going okay. And as a part of my decision
- 18:18making process as to whether or not we would start the YouTube membership program,
- 18:22I had my history with Patreon to learn from in that in twenty fifteen,
- 18:29a listener actually suggested that I start on Patreon. I had never heard of
- 18:33Patreon at that point, and they suggested it. And again I didn't want
- 18:37to start another account, but I thought, well, I don't know,
- 18:38we'll give it a try. Plus I don't know if anyone wants to pay
- 18:41money for this kind of thing. We'll see, you know, maybe it's
- 18:44worth a shot. And so I gave it a shot, and you know,
- 18:47it worked out slowly but surely over time. And what I learned was
- 18:52that as people became patrons, I could scale back. In the beginning on
- 18:59my private practice, I never terminated with clients. I just waited for them
- 19:03to naturally terminate with me, and then I wouldn't replace them. So as
- 19:07I was making more money on Patreon, it would justify not taking on other
- 19:12clients because they would offset each other, right. And what that did was
- 19:17it gave me more time, and so I could allocate that time where the
- 19:21money was coming from, which was to make better audio podcast content. As
- 19:26I made better audio podcast content, more people became patrons and this feedback loop
- 19:32happened. Well, that was a very learning experience because it's that win win,
- 19:37right. I win because I'm getting this career shift that I want to
- 19:42do, and the audience is winning because they're getting more quality content. And
- 19:48it's a feedback loop that feeds its feeds on each other. Right. And
- 19:53with YouTube membership, it could be the same and it is kind of working
- 19:57out to be that way. So there's a built in mechanism of checks and
- 20:03balances where let's say hardly anyone becomes a YouTube member. Well, then that
- 20:08doesn't justify me pulling time away from other things an effort to do that kind
- 20:14of thing, and therefore it won't grow. It is growing, and it
- 20:18has been steadily growing, similar to how Patreon was growing over time, you
- 20:22know, slowly but surely, that kind of thing. And it's this way
- 20:27for me to understand where I should be pointing myself, because again, I
- 20:33want to do it all, but I need to limit myself. And how
- 20:37do I limit it? Sort of like with emails. When I respond to
- 20:41emails, I will prioritize patrons, and I'll prioritize upper tier, middle tier
- 20:47patrons, not because I want to exclude others, but I just can't answer
- 20:52all the emails. So I need some criterion to follow to no where to
- 20:57allocate my efforts, And it just seems like it makes sense to do that,
- 21:02you know, most of the time. And the same goes for content
- 21:06now with YouTube, and as more people become YouTube members, then that will
- 21:11inform me as to Okay, you know, in my month of work hours,
- 21:18how do I allocate that time? So it all makes sense. That
- 21:22makes sense. So if you're a patron, you might be thinking, well,
- 21:26how do we benefit from you starting this YouTube membership program? Isn't this
- 21:30just taking time away from the patron activities, the audio podcasts and the deep
- 21:36dives. And that's a viable question, and it was a question I was
- 21:40worried about, and I did not want that to happen, not only just
- 21:44because I don't think that would be very fair, but also I personally,
- 21:48personally just don't want that to happen. Well, what we found over time
- 21:55was it was actually the opposite. One of the things that I love doing
- 21:59and I have been struggling to have time to do, is to do deep
- 22:03dives for the audio podcast. I've talked about this before, but one of
- 22:07the things that I lament. You know how some people have like a bucket
- 22:08list, like, oh, I want to be able to do this,
- 22:11or travel to this country, are I want to climb this mountain? Well,
- 22:15for me, I don't really have anything on that list. All I
- 22:18have are just a bunch of deep dives that I want to do that I
- 22:23am sad that I know I won't live long enough to be able to do
- 22:27all of them. So I really like doing that kind of thing and I
- 22:33want to be able to do that. And so what I thought would happen
- 22:37and what is actually happening is as I'm scaling back on YouTube and having YouTube
- 22:42members and the income from that makeup for the income lost of scaling back on
- 22:48YouTube, overall, I'm spending less time on YouTube, even though the revenue
- 22:53loss isn't as severe as if I didn't have the YouTube membership program, if
- 22:57that makes sense. And so I have found that I have a lot more
- 23:03free time for the deep dives, also free time to finish my book on
- 23:07grief, and free time to do chores like put up Stacy's curtains, which
- 23:12I still have yet to do, which is on my list, or go
- 23:15for a walk or exercise or visit with my family or whatever. You know.
- 23:21So deep dives actually are increasing because of the YouTube membership program in part.
- 23:29And so Stacy and I, after thinking about this for a long time,
- 23:32we decided to launch the YouTube membership program about a year ago. And
- 23:36one of the things that we found was that the audiences were indeed very very
- 23:38different. When I would pull each audience, I would get a completely different
- 23:44set of requests. You know, on the YouTube membership side, I would
- 23:47get things like couples therapy or Taylor Swift documentary or the Little Mermaid that kind
- 23:53of stuff, Whereas on the Patreon side, I would get a completely different
- 23:57set of requests like the Neo Nazi deep dive or Jodi Arius or Josh Powell
- 24:06or Elon Musk or personality disorders. You know, that it was completely different,
- 24:11Like there was no overlap. You know, there's overlap between the two
- 24:14audiences, but their requests were completely different, so it really shows that it's
- 24:19two different restaurants and should be considered that way by me. But as we
- 24:23were doing the YouTube membership program, there were two problems. One was that
- 24:30I couldn't keep it straight as to where the exclusive content was going some of
- 24:36the time, and I would post patron stuff for YouTube members, and I
- 24:41would post YouTube member exclusive content for patrons sometimes because I just would forget or
- 24:49sometimes people would ask for it and I'd be like, oh, okay,
- 24:52but then other people are like, well, hey, how come we're not
- 24:55getting it? So that was one problem. The other problem was there was
- 24:59just a general constructive complaint, if you will, of people saying, hey,
- 25:03you know, I became a patron because you asked us to become a
- 25:07patron to support your channel on YouTube, and now I have to sign up
- 25:11on YouTube as well, Like that doesn't seem fair, And yeah, I
- 25:15get that, and that was one of the main reasons why I never started,
- 25:21or it took me so long to start the YouTube membership program. And
- 25:25if you have a situation where you sign up on Patreon only because of the
- 25:30YouTube channel and you want like a refund or a pro rated situation, email
- 25:37us and we'll figure out something. You know, you always want to go
- 25:41through the website. That's the only way that you know you can contact us,
- 25:45And we've already done things along those lines because it's just fair to do
- 25:48that, right. So in the end, we decided to continue with the
- 25:52policy of having the audio podcast exclusive content only for patrons and the video YouTube
- 26:00tube exclusive content only for YouTube members. And the reasons for this are for
- 26:07reasons. One is to allow me to provide tailored content to each audience instead
- 26:14of treating both audience as the same audience. It gives me the ability to
- 26:18tailor that. Also, it gives me the ability to know how to allocate
- 26:22my efforts and my time. Also, it will help to establish a more
- 26:29sustainable work life balance for myself. I want to be doing this until I'm
- 26:36unable to mentally or physically, which could be I don't know, hopefully in
- 26:41my eighties, who knows. I want to be doing this for a long
- 26:44time and I need to establish some kind of balance moving forward, and the
- 26:49way that I've been doing it that is not possible. So the YouTube membership
- 26:53program, I think is one measure to get me to that balance, and
- 26:59it seems to be actually working that way. The fourth reason to separate the
- 27:03content is to keep it clear and fair. Like I was saying earlier,
- 27:08I would forget sometimes or I would give in because I felt bad, and
- 27:15I would start sharing stuff across the two groups and there would be confusion and
- 27:19people would get upset. And if there's anything I know about these kinds of
- 27:23things is you have to be clear, and you have to be fair,
- 27:27and you have to stick to it. And the whole reason why I'm making
- 27:33this episode is because I was about to make some content, some exclusive content,
- 27:38and I was thinking, oh, you know, I should really share
- 27:44this with the other group, and so I started to do that, and
- 27:47then I was talking it over with Stacey and she's like, you can't do
- 27:49that because it's gonna be confusing to people and it's going to set this precedent.
- 27:56So I was like, yeah, that's right, Okay, all right,
- 27:59I need to figure this out for myself. Also, I need to
- 28:02tell people what the final policy is, because we've been playing around with it
- 28:07for a while. So I sat down to write like a quick outline to
- 28:11just insert at the beginning of one of these episodes, and the outline blossomed,
- 28:18and I thought, maybe I should just make an episode about this,
- 28:21because there's a lot to get into. And I thought, you know,
- 28:25I'll make this episode and then I hopefully won't have to talk about it again,
- 28:30because I was thinking, well, if I put it in an exclusive
- 28:33YouTube video or a YouTube video, then the audio podcast audience might not hear
- 28:40that, So I need to make sure I remember to mention it in an
- 28:44audio poda. How about just make one episode for everybody and that'll be that.
- 28:49Okay, So that's the end of that topic, and I want to
- 28:52talk about a tangential topic, which is that we have been filming our audio
- 28:59deep Dives and Bardo and we've been doing that because a lot of people want
- 29:03to see us as we're talking. But also I've gotten better at doing the
- 29:08whole thing, and I don't have a producer, and so I have to
- 29:12edit on the fly during the episode. You know, I have to control
- 29:15the cameras, I have to make sure everything is working, and then editing
- 29:18it is paining the ass, but I've gotten better, so we've started doing
- 29:22that, and so there will be the Patron section of the Patreon exclusive episodes,
- 29:29you know, the deep dives, and those will be video recorded and
- 29:33edited, by the way, but I haven't been posting them on Patreon.
- 29:37The reason for that, The main reason is that Patreon is really janky when
- 29:44it comes to video. Number one is they do allow video uploads, and
- 29:49they do allow those video uploads to be designated only for patrons. So it's
- 29:53like, well, why don't I just take the full video and just upload
- 29:56it to Patreon and have it made just so that patrons can see it.
- 30:00Well, we don't actually have that ability because Psychology and Seattle. We don't
- 30:06have that ability because when we signed up on Patreon in twenty fifteen, there
- 30:11was only one plan, and that plan did not offer video. And the
- 30:17percentage that Patreon takes out is they say it's like five percent, but really
- 30:23it's more like twelve or fifteen percent what Patreon takes from us. You know,
- 30:30the patrons give us X amount of dollars and then Patreon will take twelve
- 30:34fifteen percent something like that, even though they claim they only take five percent,
- 30:40and then they add on the credit card fees, which are only supposed
- 30:42to be like two or three percent, So I don't know how. I
- 30:45don't know how it balloons to twelve. Who knows. It's been that way
- 30:48since twenty fifteen, and I have looked into it before, and that's just
- 30:52how it is anyway. So the plan that we're under, we have been
- 30:57grandfathered in and allowed to keep that plan, but as a consequence, we
- 31:03don't have we don't have certain perks. One of those perks is the ability
- 31:07to upload videos. So in order to have the plan that uploads videos,
- 31:11we have to sign up on a different plan that would take maybe double the
- 31:17amount, and that would make it rough for us and for me to pay
- 31:21my bills just for one function of uploading videos to Patreon, which is a
- 31:29fairly limited function that we would be using now. Even though it would cost
- 31:34us extra money to do that, I did consider doing it for that reason
- 31:38because I really wanted the patrons to be able to watch the full videos.
- 31:42And so there was this period of time where Patreon was like, hey,
- 31:48even for those grandfathered people in, we're going to allow you temporarily to upload
- 31:53videos for your patrons, and so I thought, oh, well, let's
- 31:56give it a shot. So I think it was maybe during the Jody Area
- 32:00episodes, or maybe the Neo Nazi episodes. I'm not sure. I so
- 32:05oh, I'll start uploading the full video episode for the patrons. Well,
- 32:09their interface, Patreon, if you don't know their interface and their technology is
- 32:16so jacked up. There are so many problems. I won't bore you with
- 32:21the details. Stacey deals with a lot of the problems, but ask anyone
- 32:24that uses Patrioon, any creator, and they'll tell you, especially recently,
- 32:29that there have just been some atrocious changes to the UI and to the interface
- 32:32and to the technology. So when I would upload a video, it wouldn't
- 32:37work half the time, and even if it did work, it would take
- 32:40hours and hours to upload a video to especially you know, we might have
- 32:45a video, a Patron episode that could be two three hours long. That's
- 32:50a long video. I would set it and forget it and walk away and
- 32:53wake up the next day and it would be like fifty percent done, and
- 32:57so it was super janky. So in my head, I'm like, Okay,
- 33:01I'm going to double the fee that Patreon is taking from us to get
- 33:07this product that we only use every once in a while. The uploading of
- 33:10a video, and that product is a piece of crap. Now, in
- 33:16the future, I trust that Patreon will iron out those wrinkles and will likely
- 33:23offer to everyone the ability to upload videos. That's my guess. The alternative
- 33:30to using Patreon is to upload to YouTube, which works beautifully, and then
- 33:37you have the episode what they call unlisted, which means that only people with
- 33:42the URL can see it. And so then you upload the video to YouTube
- 33:47and then you make it unlisted, and then you take that URL and you
- 33:51put it in Patreon and bed the video and only Patreons would be able to
- 33:55see that post and then they could watch the full Patreon exclusive video on Patreon,
- 34:04but it's a video from YouTube. The problem with that is that YouTube
- 34:07has a policy about doing that. They say you can't do that because I
- 34:13think their reasoning is you can't use YouTube as basically like a server for a
- 34:19paywall that benefits someone else, so they have a policy against that. And
- 34:24I don't want to mess around too much with YouTube because I've heard of other
- 34:30channels, other content creators who have messed around with various different things, and
- 34:35YouTube will just delete their channel, and that is terrifying to me. I
- 34:43think it's just like delete Because of that reason, we at this point can't
- 34:50really viably upload full videos to Patreon, and therefore the video episodes that Berto
- 34:59and I are doing dives, you can watch the free portion of those episodes
- 35:04on YouTube, and then you have to listen to the rest of the episode
- 35:07on Patreon. I know that's not ideal. I don't think this is the
- 35:12way it's going to be in the future, but it is the way that
- 35:15it is now. And the way that I think about it is that in
- 35:17the past, Umberto and I wouldn't even make video And so for the old
- 35:22school audio podcast listeners, it's the same. They're still listening to Mbardo and
- 35:28I talk. Occasionally there'll be a video clip that we'll watch, but it's
- 35:30not very frequent, and I'm always mindful of explaining what's in the video to
- 35:36people that might be listening to the audio podcast, because that's my priority,
- 35:39is the audio podcast. We just happen to be videotaping it. It's not
- 35:44going in the direction of YouTube. It's just like it just happens to be
- 35:49videotaped for the few people that care to watch it instead of just listen.
- 35:53All right, So that's the end of my outline. So some closing thoughts
- 35:58are that I want to re assure the patrons that nothing really changes for the
- 36:02patrons. My dedication to the patrons, my dedication to the audio podcast has
- 36:08not changed at all. If anything, I now have more time to dedicate
- 36:15to Deep Dives and to the audio podcast. I don't know if people have
- 36:19noticed that, but I have. Personally. We're going to publish our Josh
- 36:22Powell episodes pretty soon. I spent a lot more time on that series than
- 36:28I would have normally, so I feel really good about that. The other
- 36:31thing I want to say is I really love making reaction videos. If I
- 36:36had my brothers, I would do it all day long, but I can't.
- 36:42So the balance is such that moving forward, I think what I'm gonna
- 36:46do is I'm going to continue doing what I've been doing this year. In
- 36:50twenty twenty four of when Love is Blind is on, then I'll go full
- 36:53hog and I'll be very detailed, and I'll post two videos a day as
- 36:59far as I can, and during that time there'll be a lot more activity,
- 37:04you know, comments, reaction videos and me in the comment section,
- 37:07and you know, just a lot of activity, a lot of time spent
- 37:12a lot of it's very gratifying. When the season six Lowest Blind came out,
- 37:15I had had already six weeks from the beginning of twenty twenty four of
- 37:21scaling back the YouTube channel, which gave me time to do chores and be
- 37:25able to think, and I found that when season six started I had a
- 37:31tremendous amount of enthusiasm and energy for it. As evidence, I think by
- 37:37all those episodes on the borderline abuse that I made, I don't know if
- 37:40I would have done that if I was burnt out slightly the way I was
- 37:45before, So I'm still dedicated to do that. Season seven is supposed to
- 37:51come out later this year, and I'm really looking forward to that, and
- 37:54I don't have any plans to scale back on that. But in between,
- 38:00it's going to be two or three episodes free episodes per week, plus I'm
- 38:06trying to have at least one YouTube member episode a week as well, and
- 38:12maybe as there's more YouTube members maybe that'll increase. I don't know. It's
- 38:16hard for me to commit. I'm still trying to figure out what the schedule
- 38:21for the YouTube members membership exclusive videos will be, but that's just where we're
- 38:24at right now, and so that you know all those things are the plan,
- 38:30and I just want everyone to know that. The other thing I want
- 38:34to say is thank you if you're watching this to this point, thanks for
- 38:40listening, because I really want people to know what's in my head and I
- 38:47don't want there to be confusion, and I hope that it makes sense as
- 38:53to why we're doing this. Also, I want to thank people for becoming
- 38:59a YouTube member and or becoming a patron. It means the world to me.
- 39:04I can't even tell you how transformative those people have been in my life.
- 39:09The patrons in particular, because it's been nine years, wow, almost
- 39:14nine years on Patreon, and some people have been patrons for nine years.
- 39:20They've been patrons that the entire time, which I mean, it just gives
- 39:23me chills that people would actually give me money to do this kind of thing,
- 39:30pay my bills for me so that I could spend my time doing this,
- 39:32and I'm living the dream. This is what I wanted to do.
- 39:37I love being a therapist. I love being a professor, and I did
- 39:40that for twenty five years and I now want to prioritize making content. It's
- 39:47the next chapter, you know, the way that I think about it is
- 39:50like when I started out in my career, I was primarily a therapist,
- 39:54and I was working with a very small number of people, the client,
- 40:00and trying to affect change in that way. Then later in my career,
- 40:05I was more focused on being a professor, And that's kind of zooming out
- 40:08a little bit, right because I'm helping a lot of therapists to help a
- 40:13large number of clients. Then now in my career, I'm zooming out even
- 40:17further and talking to the Internet, which is a large group of people,
- 40:22right, And it just feels like it makes sense in terms of the progression
- 40:29of my life. And I really love doing this and I wouldn't be able
- 40:35to do it at all if it weren't for patrons and the YouTube members and
- 40:38really just everyone clicking on. You know, every time you click on a
- 40:40video or you listen to an audio podcast, you know, every ad that
- 40:45is in the episode, we get a tiny little bit of money, you
- 40:49know, like half a penny or something something like that, and that all
- 40:52helps as well. And people that will be kind to me. That gives
- 40:57me the energy. People that you know, over time, there will be
- 41:00moments where I will feel hurt by a comment or two or an email or
- 41:07three, and I will wrestle with that, and if it gets to be
- 41:12a certain level, then I'll start to talk about it in a video or
- 41:15an audio podcast. And like in my marriage, or in my friendships or
- 41:21in my family, I have found that when I am vulnerable, which is
- 41:23hard for me because I'm more on the avoidance side, things go well for
- 41:28me because one, I'm focusing on my needs, but I'm also signaling to
- 41:34people that I can be hurt and that I am hurt, and then that
- 41:38will provoke people's empathy. Even though they might not agree with me, they
- 41:44care because they're human beings, and so they will reach out and then I
- 41:47will feel healed. I'll feel secure and safer, and it gives me the
- 41:52fuel. And so when people are like that with me, it gives me.
- 41:57You know, there's a lot of ways one can support and help me
- 42:00to make all this content. The emotional side is just as important as the
- 42:05monetary. On the monetary side, you know, also everyone that emails in
- 42:08and suggests things or ask questions for the audio podcast or whatever, like it's
- 42:15it's just I'm living the dream, like I said, every day I wake
- 42:19up and I think, I can't wait to just work. It's so great.
- 42:24It's so meaningful and fulfilling. It's not always easy, but it's so
- 42:28fulfilling and fun. And I get to hang out with friends, and I
- 42:34get to interact with people all over the world, and I get to do
- 42:39various different things. It's a great it's a great thing. So I just
- 42:44want to thank y'all and everyone out there. Please take care of yourself because
- 42:47you deserve it. You really, really do.