Latest / Why the Mongol Empire Split Apart So Quickly — Fexingo History / Berke's Choice: Faith and Feud in the Mongol West
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about the Toluid Civil War and how Khubilai and Ariq Böke split the east, but there's another fracture that happened almost at the same time, and it's one that really shaped the Islamic world. I'm thinking of Berke Khan and the Golden Horde versus Hulegu and the Ilkhanate. Luna: Berke — he was the one who converted to Islam, right? Lucas: Exactly. Berke was a son of Jochi, so he was from the eldest branch of Chinggis Khan's line, and he ruled the Golden Horde from Sarai on the Volga. But what's fascinating is that he was the first Mongol ruler to formally embrace Islam. That happened around 1252, before he even became khan. He converted through a Sufi sheikh, maybe, and it was a genuine personal conviction, not just political. Luna: So he was Muslim before Möngke sent Hulegu west? Lucas: Yeah, and that's the key. When Möngke Khan ordered Hulegu to march on the Ismailis and then Baghdad, Berke was already uncomfortable with the idea of destroying the Abbasid caliphate. He reportedly said something like, 'He has destroyed all the cities of Islam and has killed the caliph. If the eternal God supports me, I will call him to account for all this innocent blood.' Lucas: So you have this deep personal and religious divide between two cousins. Hulegu, who was a Tengri, and Berke, who was a Muslim. And then you have the political reality that the Golden Horde had its own ambitions in the Caucasus and Azerbaijan, which were right on the border of Hulegu's new territories. Luna: It was like a powder keg. Lucas: It was. And it exploded in 1262, when Berke sent his general Nogai to raid the Ilkhanate's territory, and Hulegu retaliated. There were two major battles, one near the Terek River in the Caucasus, and the Mongols of the Golden Horde actually won the first one, but then they were caught crossing the frozen Terek and Hulegu's forces smashed them. It was a brutal, back and forth campaign. Luna: And this was all happening while Khubilai and Ariq Böke were fighting for the throne? Lucas: Exactly. So the Mongol world was fracturing on multiple axes at the same time. You have the Toluid Civil War in the east, and you have this Jochid-Toluid conflict in the west. And the two conflicts actually fed each other. Berke, for a time, was leaning toward Ariq Böke, partly because he was annoyed that Hulegu had thrown his support to Khubilai. Lucas: But what's really interesting is how Berke's faith led him to do something that would have been unthinkable just a generation earlier. He formed an alliance with the Mamluks, the slave-soldier dynasty in Egypt that had actually defeated Hulegu's forces at the Battle of Ain Jalut in 1260. Luna: Wait, the Mongols allied with the Mamluks? The same Mamluks who fought them? Lucas: Yep. It was a classic case of 'the enemy of my enemy is my friend.' The Mamluks were Sunni Muslims, and they had just beaten the Mongol army, which was a huge shock to the whole empire. Berke reached out to the Mamluk sultan, Baybars, and they started exchanging embassies. There was even talk of a joint campaign against Hulegu, though it never really materialized. Lucas: But the alliance itself was symbolic. It meant that a Mongol khan was willing to cooperate with a Muslim power against another Mongol khan. That was a massive ideological shift. The Chinggisid ideal was that the whole world should be under one Mongol umbrella, but here you have a grandson of Chinggis who's willing to work with outsiders to tear the empire apart. Luna: It must have been a huge deal for the Mamluks. Lucas: It was. For the Mamluks, it legitimized their survival and gave them a powerful ally. And it effectively drew a line across the Middle East: the Ilkhanate in Iran, Iraq, and Anatolia, and the Golden Horde in the Kipchak steppe and the Caucasus. That line held for decades, and it helped the Mamluks survive against repeated Ilkhanid invasions. Lucas: But here's the thing — Berke didn't live to see the full consequences. He died in 1266, during a campaign against Hulegu, who died the same year. So the two cousins who started this war both died before they could settle it. The conflict continued under their successors, but it never really reached a decisive end. Luna: So it was a stalemate. Lucas: Pretty much. And that stalemate was a turning point. It meant that the Mongol Empire was not going to reunite under a single ruler. The Golden Horde remained independent, the Ilkhanate remained independent, and even when Ghazan later converted to Islam in the Ilkhanate, it was too late to repair the damage. The division was permanent. Lucas: And there's a smaller detail that I love. When Berke converted, he reportedly refused to eat pork and forbade his subjects from slaughtering animals in the traditional Mongol way — cutting the throat without draining the blood. He wanted Islamic halal practices instead. That was a huge break from the Yassa, the traditional Mongol law code, and it shows how seriously he took his faith. Luna: That must have caused friction with the more traditional Mongols. Lucas: Absolutely. There were some in the Golden Horde who were not Muslim, and they didn't like the new laws. But Berke was firm. And you know, it's interesting because this religious tension was happening all across the Mongol world. You had Khubilai favoring Buddhism, you had the Ilkhanate eventually going Muslim, and you had the Golden Horde going Muslim too. But they took different paths and they took them at different times, and that's part of why the empire couldn't hold together. Lucas: So when we look back at the Mongol Empire, we usually think of Chinggis Khan's conquests and the Pax Mongolica. But the fractures that really mattered were often personal and religious. And Berke's choice to embrace Islam, and to let it shape his politics, was one of those fractures that made the empire splinter. Luna: It's almost like religion became a weapon. Lucas: It did. And it was a weapon that Berke wielded deliberately. He used his faith to rally support against Hulegu, and he used the alliance with the Mamluks to put pressure on the Ilkhanate from two sides. It was a brilliant strategic move, even if it meant breaking the ideal of Mongol unity. Lucas: And if you're enjoying these deep dives into the Mongol world, you know, we've been going through these episodes for a while now. And honestly, the reason we can keep making them is that a small group of listeners chips in a few bucks a month through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's not a huge thing, but it covers the hosting and my coffee supply. Luna: Yeah, and it really helps us keep doing the research and production. No ads, just people who like the show. Lucas: So if that's something you want to support, the link is in the show notes. But back to Berke — there's one more thing I want to mention. He never actually fought Hulegu in person. The battles were fought by his generals, like Nogai. So the war was more like a proxy conflict, with the Mamluks doing a lot of the fighting against the Ilkhanate on the ground. Luna: So Berke was more of a strategist than a warrior in this case. Lucas: Right. And that strategy was pretty effective. By the time he died, the Golden Horde had secured its hold on the Caucasus and the Mamluks were a permanent check on Ilkhanid expansion. The Ilkhanate never managed to break through into Syria and Egypt, and that's partly because of Berke's pressure from the north. Lucas: So Berke's legacy is a bit complicated. He's a hero to some, because he defended Islam and stood up to Hulegu. But he's also the guy who helped split the Mongol Empire. And that split, more than anything else, determined the shape of the Middle East for centuries. You can draw a line from Berke's defiance to the later history of the region — the rise of the Mamluks, the eventual fall of the Ilkhanate, the emergence of the Ottomans. The Mongol Empire was never going to stay united after that. Luna: It's crazy to think that one man's conversion could change so much. Lucas: It really is. And it just shows that these big historical shifts often come down to individuals making choices that seem personal at the time but have massive consequences. Berke's faith, his anger, his political calculations — they all came together to create a rupture that no later khan could heal. Lucas: So that's the story of Berke and the fracture he caused. Next time we'll look at another piece of the puzzle, maybe the role of the Yam system in the empire's collapse, or the strange story of the Mongol embassy that ended up in Europe. There's always more.