Latest / The Vegan Report / Winning Canada, One Ally at a Time. With Liz, Edward, Debra, Mike & Irene | Ep. 58
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you are listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:06Today I want to show you what the world of politics looks like at its best.
- 0:13When it is embodied by hopeful, passionate and inspiring leaders who dare to dream of
- 0:20a more compassionate world.
- 0:23A rare kind of politics light years away from the small world of calculating cynical and
- 0:32power hungry politicians.
- 0:35Today we are talking to the candidates of the Animal Protection Party of Canada who
- 0:41share with us tales of their uphill battle against a system that keeps them locked outside
- 0:49the centres of power.
- 0:52Their names are Liz White, Edward Fraser, Deborah Wall, Irene Kay and Mike Peach.
- 1:01Welcome everyone, thank you so much for being here.
- 1:04So happy to see you all.
- 1:06Let me start with this icebreaker question.
- 1:08Can you please state your name and also talk about your vegan or animal rights hero?
- 1:16Yes, so I can start.
- 1:19My name is Mike Peach.
- 1:21I'm from St. John's, Newfoundland and I've been vegan and animal liberation activist
- 1:30for about 10 years now.
- 1:34So yes, I guess it's hard to say I'm a vegan or animal liberation activist.
- 1:42I'm a hero but there's a couple I like.
- 1:45I like Melanie Joy.
- 1:47I don't know if you've heard of her.
- 1:48She's a clinical psychologist and she's the one who came up with the term chironism to
- 1:55explain the belief system that most people in society get indoctrinated into from a
- 2:02young age which makes them prejudiced against certain species of animals considered food.
- 2:12So she explains how it's a learned behavior and all the parallels with other systematic
- 2:19forms of oppression and discrimination.
- 2:20She has a really good TED talk that I like.
- 2:23It's usually the first thing that I recommend people watch when I do street outreach.
- 2:28And then there's a couple other common ones that most people like.
- 2:31I like Gary or Obsky.
- 2:35There's Joey Karbstrong and Earthling Ed.
- 2:38I like Earthling Ed too.
- 2:40I want to try to figure out how to set up where they do the tables and then they just
- 2:46sit down and invite people to come chat with them.
- 2:48I think that's a good form of street outreach too.
- 2:51Wonderful.
- 2:52Thank you, Mike.
- 2:53I will add the link to her TED talk in the episode notes.
- 2:57Liz?
- 2:58So my name's Liz White.
- 3:00I'm the leader of the animal protection party of Canada.
- 3:04I started in the became an animal rights activist and in the late 1980s or early 1990s was at
- 3:17the Toronto Humane Society, got fired from there for having perhaps two radical thoughts
- 3:23along with some of the other people there, which was quite funny, but it allowed us to
- 3:28form animal alliance.
- 3:30And then in 2005, the Supreme Court ruled that the election elections act, Ken Elections
- 3:37Act needed to be amended to allow smaller parties to be able to actually form properly
- 3:44and participate in elections.
- 3:47And so in 2005, 2006, we formed the animal protection party of Canada.
- 3:52And so we've been around for about 18 years, I guess.
- 3:58The barriers in the act for small parties mean that they will never really be able to
- 4:07participate in a way that the party for the animals does, for example, in the Netherlands,
- 4:13where they actually are able to elect people to all levels of government, including the
- 4:18European Parliament.
- 4:20So we're looking at legislative changes and to the act.
- 4:28But of course, the act is controlled by the large parties who have their own interests,
- 4:32which is not to add any political parties to the mix.
- 4:36And so it'll be an uphill battle, but we're looking at some of the avenues to actually
- 4:41break down some of those barriers.
- 4:44Thank you, Liz.
- 4:45Irene?
- 4:46Yes, I'm Irene Kay.
- 4:47I'm in Burlington, Ontario, and I will be running as a candidate for the animal protection
- 4:53party when the next federal election rolls around.
- 4:57I have two heroes.
- 4:59One is Gary Francione, who I discovered when I very first went vegan.
- 5:06And I loved his argument that basically, if most people would agree that it's wrong to
- 5:16harm an animal unnecessarily, and that if you take that to its logical extension, because
- 5:24we don't need animals to live, we don't need to eat animals to live, then any killing of
- 5:30an animal is unnecessary.
- 5:32And his main argument, he's a legal scholar, and his main argument from a legal point of
- 5:37view is that as long as animals continue to be classed as property, then there's no
- 5:44– all animal welfare laws in the world are not going to help them.
- 5:49And as it stands now, most of the animal welfare laws do not cover the vast majority of farmed
- 5:55animals that we raise and slaughter for food.
- 5:59My other hero is Will Tuttle.
- 6:03And his famous book is World Peace Diet.
- 6:05Again, I read that 10 years ago when I first went vegan.
- 6:09I literally wept on every page because he writes so poetically and so movingly about
- 6:16the plight of animals, especially the plight of the female animals, because it's an exploit.
- 6:22Basically animal husbandry is exploitation of the female, the female chicken, the female
- 6:28pig, the female cow.
- 6:31And the most abused animal on the planet is the dairy cow.
- 6:35Thank you, Irene.
- 6:36Debbie, your turn.
- 6:37Thank you all, and I ran for the Animal Protection Party of Canada in 2021.
- 6:43I became the first Manitoba to represent the party.
- 6:47And I had my aha moment in 1978 when I was attending pre-vector classes at the University
- 6:56of Manitoba.
- 6:57And we went to the annual Aggie Bash, and I happened to see a little calf.
- 7:02And when I went over to say hi to them, they licked my face, and I realized, you're no
- 7:07different than a dog.
- 7:09And another thing I realized is that we as humans are capable of all kinds of mental
- 7:15gymnastics to justify all kinds of horrible things that we do to animals.
- 7:21But once something touches your heart, there's just no denying it.
- 7:25So that was a big lesson for me.
- 7:28And in terms of, and I've been involved in animal rights, liberation, protection in various
- 7:35forms since then.
- 7:37And I have to say my heroes are pretty much anybody who speaks up on behalf of the animals,
- 7:45because it's not an easy place to be swimming against what most of society is doing.
- 7:53Thank you, Debbie.
- 7:54And finally, Edward.
- 7:55Yeah.
- 7:56So, Edward Fraser, I'm running for the Animal Protection Party of Canada in High Park Parkdale
- 8:01in the upcoming election.
- 8:03I came to veganism in a bit of a strange way.
- 8:07I had been a vegetarian for many, many years, kind of justifying that as being good enough.
- 8:15And of course, realized, of course, it's not.
- 8:17But I saw some advertising on the subway here in Toronto for the Fur Bears Association
- 8:27out of BC.
- 8:29And I naively thought to myself, well, they don't actually use fur anymore.
- 8:35That's barbaric.
- 8:36Did a bit of research and realized, yeah, there is still a somewhat what's called thriving
- 8:42fur industry and of course, with Canada Goose and all of those other types of coats that
- 8:48it actually made quite a comeback.
- 8:49So that was kind of my way of understanding that there needed a lot more to be done.
- 8:54So I transitioned to veganism at that point.
- 8:58Activism and the sport of animal rights causes group from there.
- 9:03And yeah, it's come to realize that these sort of industries still exist.
- 9:09It's necessary work that groups like the Animal Protection Party of Canada and Animal Justice
- 9:15and so many other groups that are fighting for animal rights.
- 9:19And then I'll just say that it's those people who do the work with those groups that are
- 9:26my heroes.
- 9:27A lot of the people who are out there like Earthling had like Mike mentioned and bringing
- 9:33awareness to the cause.
- 9:35I had to give respect to those people, but it's so many of the people who are doing the
- 9:41grassroots initiatives, getting to know Mike a little bit virtually through the means we've
- 9:45done with the party.
- 9:47The respect I have for somebody like him, it's so easy for me to do in my neighborhood
- 9:52where it's accepting.
- 9:54I see vegan stickers all over the place.
- 9:56I have access to all sorts of restaurants and resources.
- 9:59I have a community here.
- 10:02Mike is swimming upstream, like Debbie said in his area, and to fight the fight in those
- 10:12sort of conditions, all the respective world.
- 10:16Thank you, Edward.
- 10:17So Mike, you wanted to react to what Irene said.
- 10:20Oh yeah.
- 10:21Yeah, she was talking about Gary Francillon.
- 10:26I thought I'd add him.
- 10:28I liked my list because I write his stuff and I like him too.
- 10:34There's a couple of other good books I could recommend just because I'm going to have to
- 10:41go on in a few minutes.
- 10:45There's one I really like.
- 10:46It's called Eternal Treblinka by Charles Patterson.
- 10:51I don't know if you guys have read or heard of this one.
- 10:55But he's a Jewish animal rights activist.
- 11:00It's sort of like the same idea as Alex Hirschhaft.
- 11:07He wrote that book and I found it really powerful.
- 11:10It talks about the sources of discrimination and oppression and those mentalities and how
- 11:19they sort of infect or poison everything in society.
- 11:26There's another good one I like.
- 11:30There's a couple of books called Dominion, but this one is called Dominion Power of Man
- 11:36and it's by this guy, Matthew Scully.
- 11:41This one is more directed for like arguing for animal rights from a religious perspective.
- 11:52So that's I always found because I'm not religious at all.
- 11:55Talking to religious people during street outreach is one of the more difficult cells.
- 12:03So trying to find common ground with them is kind of tough.
- 12:07I've noticed that religious people tend to be more likely to stop and watch and want
- 12:12to have a conversation with you when you're doing a cube of truth.
- 12:17And so I figured trying to come up with some good arguments to sort of meet them where
- 12:24they are.
- 12:27This book was good for me for that.
- 12:29So for anyone who wants to, you need help like to learn how to outreach with more religious
- 12:36people, specifically the Dominionist for the Christian people.
- 12:41Thank you for the recommendation, Spank.
- 12:44Those are two great authors that I truly love.
- 12:51Since you have to go soon, Edward mentioned how this is an upstream battle for you.
- 13:00Tell me more about that.
- 13:02It's so difficult about talking about animal protection, animal rights in Newfoundland.
- 13:10Yes.
- 13:11So the culture in Newfoundland is a little bit different than the rest of Canada.
- 13:16So Newfoundland used to be its own country until around World War II.
- 13:23Let me double check the exact year I used to have this memorized.
- 13:28Yeah, 1949 is when Newfoundland joined Canada.
- 13:33For them, they were their own country.
- 13:35So there's a lot of nationalistic pride specifically for Newfoundland.
- 13:41We have a separatist party and everything.
- 13:43And the culture, so they're very proud of their culture.
- 13:46And specifically though, being an island, it's very heavily based on fishing and hunting
- 13:54and the seal hunts as well.
- 13:57So that's a big part of most Newfoundlanders' identities.
- 14:01And they're always trying to, they're all obsessed with the fishery, trying to defend
- 14:06it.
- 14:07A lot of people, it's their full identity.
- 14:12It's exploiting and using animals as bait into the culture.
- 14:16And they're sensitive about it too.
- 14:20They feel like they're somehow persecuted by the rest of the world.
- 14:23They're misunderstood about it, like ignorant, towny people.
- 14:28Sort of.
- 14:29Anyway, the point is that you're considered, like for being a vegan here, you're almost
- 14:35considered a cultural traitor to the Newfoundland culture.
- 14:38Like you're directly fighting against the most important things in Newfoundlanders'
- 14:43identity and culture to go against the fishery and the seal hunt specifically.
- 14:49It's just a ridiculous, political issue.
- 14:52And that's all it is now.
- 14:53It's just, yeah, almost like the nonsense that you got going in the states, like where
- 15:01the Republicans and Democrats are like completely polarized.
- 15:04It's just random stuff.
- 15:07And you have to fall in line with one extreme or the other.
- 15:10I don't know.
- 15:11It's sort of like gun control or something.
- 15:15I don't know much about it, but I think Republicans are like, the worst evil ever is to take your
- 15:20guns away.
- 15:21But I'm not sure exactly, but it feels like that.
- 15:29So when we do seal hunt protests, it's just a lot more tense and the hostility is way
- 15:35higher than if we do a Cuban truth, Gritual slaughter, house footage, or do a vigil out
- 15:41in front of the country or been chicken death camp.
- 15:45It's like even though we're opposing all of animal agriculture, which obviously would
- 15:50include the seal hunt, they're less incensed by that than when we do seal on protest directly
- 15:56where you get people screaming at us and shouting or threatening violence, that kind
- 16:01of thing, or trying to call the cops and stuff.
- 16:05But yeah, so I guess it's like that.
- 16:10I feel the culture here is less progressive because the sort of little bit isolationist.
- 16:18And because of their history with the seal hunt and just hunting and fishing in general.
- 16:24So it's a very up here little battle here, but more so than other places I visited.
- 16:31I lived in Portugal for five years.
- 16:33And even though a lot of new fine culture is actually based on old Portuguese culture,
- 16:39because they were always sending the fishing boats over here.
- 16:42But they even have some similar dishes like the Jigs dinner we have here, which is traditionally
- 16:49they have like a dead piece of turkey or but a lot of vegetables like greens and turnips
- 16:59and they have gravy and stuff that's based on a Portuguese dish.
- 17:03But even so, it's like night and day with the animal rights community in Portugal is
- 17:08so much bigger and so much better organized and tight knit there.
- 17:14And they have like a lot of good events and demos all across the country.
- 17:20And they're more like they're more accepted.
- 17:22They have a political party as well called the pan.
- 17:26And they had recently won that like they have proportional representation as well over
- 17:35there.
- 17:36And they had the seats in Parliament.
- 17:39And like the party leader for pan was able to bring motions to ban bullfighting.
- 17:44And even though they didn't get past the bullfighting in Portugal very similar to the
- 17:49seal hunt here in terms of culture and their like obsession with cultural identity and
- 17:55stuff.
- 17:57So but he was able to bring that to Parliament and make some really good arguments like and
- 18:02we do but we did bullfighting protests over there too.
- 18:06And there was a lot more people at the bullfight protests than there would ever be at a seal
- 18:10hunt protest here.
- 18:13Even though it was like done outside of Coliseum's and they had people screaming at them and
- 18:17yelling and hostility.
- 18:19But they also had some supportive people.
- 18:21I don't know if you might imagine the southern United States.
- 18:26Fulturally like they're very conservative there and you would imagine that they're like
- 18:30pro hunting and very against animal rights more than like more liberal parts of the States.
- 18:39I feel it's like that the version of that in Canada is new from.
- 18:44I understand better.
- 18:45Yes.
- 18:46Thank you Mike.
- 18:48Thank you.
- 18:49Interesting.
- 18:50Yes.
- 18:51Thanks.
- 18:52Yes.
- 18:53Very interesting.
- 18:54I have lots of American listeners and I wonder if we could talk about the state of animal
- 19:07welfare in Canada.
- 19:08So maybe we could you could maybe give a mark to Canada like on 10 what would be Canada's
- 19:18great in terms of animal protection laws and you know compared to other countries maybe
- 19:27if you have experience living elsewhere.
- 19:31Like how would you describe Canada in terms of you know animal welfare and maybe we could
- 19:37start with Liz.
- 19:39Probably not very high between one and 10 one being bad and 10 being good.
- 19:50The biggest area is animal agriculture and as we experience people going into various
- 20:01places and documenting the immense cruelty that happens in these places in these private
- 20:08farms which are usually the big large farms and how little is done to rectify the situations
- 20:16in those places and then being faced with ag-gag legislation so that there's big penalties
- 20:23if somebody does go into a farm and document even if they document the extreme cruelty
- 20:30even if the film shows you know the enormous terrible cruelty that goes on with these animals.
- 20:38It's the people who get prosecuted and not the farmer and so you know when you talk about
- 20:45volume probably Canada isn't as bad as the United States because the farms aren't as
- 20:53large I mean some dairy farms in the States are 100,000 cows whereas in Canada you know
- 21:02they're not that large but you know I sat through a court case with where the Canadian
- 21:09Food Inspection Agency took Maple Dodge farms to court over cruelty to the animals that
- 21:14were being delivered to the slaughterhouse and so it was you know they kill almost half
- 21:26a million chickens a day and some of those are spanned hens and some of them come from
- 21:35very long distances including from the United States and so you look at these situations
- 21:41and you think that Canada really on the animal agriculture side has not done a lot.
- 21:48However I say under the Trudeau government and I say this cautiously they have passed
- 21:55legislation that would ban the use of animals in cosmetic testing and the products that
- 21:59are tested from elsewhere are now banned in Canada.
- 22:04That's pretty low hanging fruit you know I started working on that in 1990 and so you
- 22:11know it's taken until 2023 to get that legislation passed but they have done other stuff they've
- 22:16banned strict nine in Canada they've banned and they're in the process of looking at banning
- 22:21the trade in horses to Japan for for live slaughter so you know it isn't that things
- 22:28haven't happened it's just that the volume of cruelty is so large that these small advances
- 22:38are appeared to be really small so you know we still have lake old trapping we still drown
- 22:44beavers with connoisseur traps in and and lake old traps we still use for we still do
- 22:52horse racing we do all the various things we use animals for our own purposes and really
- 23:01that dynamic which is what we're trying to change has not changed a great deal yet but
- 23:08it's a it's a big fight.
- 23:10Thank you Liz.
- 23:12Debbie?
- 23:13Just to kind of pick up a little bit where on what Liz said there's this kind of little
- 23:17piecemeal approach to improving you know the protection of animals in our country Canada
- 23:25is actually notorious for having some of the poorest animal protection laws in the developed
- 23:31world and one of the issues is we have this whole big long list of what are called accepted
- 23:36activities and it's pretty much every possible use of animals that you can imagine that are
- 23:42exempt from our protection laws as long as standard codes of practice are followed so
- 23:49this is why you can euthanize big quotation marks around euthanize baby pigs by taking
- 23:56them by their hind legs and slamming their head into the concrete but if you did the
- 24:01same thing to a puppy or a kitten you would be charged with cruelty to animals and it
- 24:06makes no sense like our laws should be based on science and not emotion so it makes no
- 24:12sense that only the animals that we are emotionally attached to as our companion animals get a
- 24:19modicum of protection meanwhile science tells us that all animals are equally capable of
- 24:26suffering.
- 24:27So I think we would make a huge step forward if we got rid of those accepted activities
- 24:32and animals under the law are considered right now just to be property and there's a big
- 24:37push for the government to at least recognize them as sentient beings.
- 24:43Thank you Debbie.
- 24:45Edward, so what grade would you give Canada?
- 24:48Yeah, I'm a bit more of a pessimist.
- 24:51I'd give it is can you give an F minus?
- 24:55Is that possible?
- 24:57I mean I don't think Canada is alone in that.
- 25:01I mean I would think every country around the world gets a failing grade but what gives
- 25:10me hope is individuals and the fight and that you can make a small difference as an individual
- 25:19or a small group.
- 25:21Yeah, wide scale change is the goal but by not eating meat for one meal you're making
- 25:30a difference you're helping to save an animal's life.
- 25:33So while I don't I haven't seen in my 20 years of being kind of aware of these issues
- 25:40haven't seen a lot of political movements some tokenism stuff as Liz spoke about sure
- 25:47but yeah I mean that's why the critical areas and this is why I was motivated to get involved
- 25:55with the political party that's where change is going to be effective is at the political
- 26:01level and at the legal level and so if we can win court cases to change laws that's
- 26:12when people's opinions are going to change when people's widespread opinion change that's
- 26:17when political gains are made.
- 26:19So we're a ways off but that's why grassroots movement, grassroots activism and individual
- 26:28actions still matter.
- 26:30It's such a huge, huge issue and there's so much room to go it can feel overwhelming
- 26:38but every individual action even if you're not a vegan if you choose to go meatless for
- 26:46a week if you choose to buy a faux leather jacket instead of a leather jacket all these
- 26:54small actions by many many individuals add up to a big thing.
- 26:58Thank you Edward.
- 26:59Irene?
- 27:00As far as giving Canada a grade I agree we're way down the list but the thing is that all
- 27:13around the world going back to what Debbie was talking about when her encounter with
- 27:17the calf is that if you were born a dog in North America your prospects are way different
- 27:26than if you were a dog born in South Korea or China because there dogs are eaten.
- 27:34So all around the world we use animal every culture uses animals from nose to tail in
- 27:42all different and horrible ways.
- 27:46But one of my interests is transitioning factory farms to other uses and I came across
- 28:01something the other day that's happening in the states it's called the, it's been put
- 28:07forth by Cory Booker of course who's a vegan and also James McGovern and it's called the
- 28:15Industrial Agriculture Conversion Act in the US and it's giving looking for federal support
- 28:24for converting farms from animal agriculture and that I would love to see it's called
- 28:32transforming and you've probably heard the term but it's really taken my interest because
- 28:38it's the same as in the fossil fuel industry there's this big whoa oh my god all the oil
- 28:42workers are going to lose their jobs.
- 28:44Well they don't necessarily have to, they may lose that job but hey they can get another
- 28:50job in a green industry.
- 28:52Now whether they want to or not I don't know but again looking back historically when the
- 29:00internal combustion engine came along what happened to all the buggy whip makers?
- 29:06What about all the horseshoe, the blacksmith who did the horseshoes?
- 29:11Well guess what they found something else to do so that's something that I'm really
- 29:18looking forward to taking these farm buildings that are already there, taking these farmers
- 29:26who are up to their eyeballs in debt and beholden to the big chicken producers and enabling
- 29:34them to transition out of that and make use of their land and their buildings to more
- 29:42green and more healthy options.
- 29:45So thanks.
- 29:47Thank you Irene and I should say on a positive note that South Korea has passed a law to
- 29:53ban the slaughter and trade of dog meat but the ban will only take effect in 2027.
- 30:02Liz you wanted to react to Edward's point.
- 30:06I was just going to say that I think Edward paid a really good point and but I was going
- 30:16to say the thing that we need to do is to move Canada into a proportional representation
- 30:24voting system.
- 30:25The current system will not allow us to elect anybody to Parliament unless it's some like
- 30:33outlier somewhere that happened just to be in the right place at the right time.
- 30:39It's just not possible.
- 30:41Everything in the Canada Elections Act is stacked against us getting elected and so
- 30:48when you look at places like the Netherlands which has probably the largest vegan animal
- 30:56rights party party for the animals with representation throughout government levels that they have
- 31:04been able to pass much more progressive legislation and have even greater discussions about what
- 31:13changes need to be made.
- 31:14And in fact there's a revolt by the dairy farmers there because there's discussion about
- 31:21beginning to wrap up dairy farming practices.
- 31:26And so we would barely be able to have that discussion here.
- 31:32So I think we've been involved with the spring tide and fair voting BC who are now in the
- 31:40appeals court trying to get proportional representation.
- 31:44They'll be going to the Supreme Court and we intend to intervene there to see if we
- 31:50can actually get the Supreme Court to consider change.
- 31:53It's a big gift but I think it's really worth the fight and if even we get some better practices
- 32:00we might be able to make greater progress.
- 32:03I mean our wonderful candidates who run know that they're doing outreach and talking to
- 32:11people which I do as well when I run as a candidate but knowing that they are going
- 32:17to get elected and it takes a real strong committed person to take on that role and
- 32:25go out and talk to people and knowing that you're probably going to be bottom of the
- 32:31list when all of the politics that we talk about not only affects all the animals but
- 32:39affects us because of the contribution to the greenhouse gases which animal agriculture
- 32:46is huge.
- 32:47And quickly Liz, for those who don't know what is a proportional representation?
- 32:54It means that people who vote, every vote is counted.
- 33:01So it depends on the type of proportional representation.
- 33:05In Canada we've talked about the single transferable vote which is one way and the others we've
- 33:11talked about mixed member proportional.
- 33:14Both of those are much more inclusive of actually calculating how people vote and then how they're
- 33:23allocated to the final outcome of the election.
- 33:28And the provinces who have looked at proportional representation, I think British Columbia has
- 33:33been through it twice, Ontario at least once, have set the bar so high.
- 33:40You know it wasn't a 50 plus one vote, it was 60 percent and the vote, the latest vote
- 33:47in BC I think was about 58 or 59 percent.
- 33:50So it was very, very close but they were unable to make the higher levels.
- 34:00So I think the challenge is when politicians are in parliament they don't want to give
- 34:06it up.
- 34:07When they're out of parliament they talk about proportional representation as the Trudeau
- 34:11and other politicians and when they're in they think maybe not I want to hold on to my
- 34:15seat, I don't want to share it.
- 34:17Yes, it was a promise of the Trudeau first electoral campaign and I did vote for him
- 34:25because of that.
- 34:27I remember that very clearly.
- 34:29Edward, you wanted to add something.
- 34:32For those who are interested in getting a little more information on farming transition
- 34:37there was a really easily digestible news item on the NBC News Report, actually in the
- 34:44U.S. about a farmer who is using a grant for mercy for animals to change from a livestock
- 34:50farm to an organic vegetable farm and how amazing that's been for him and how that can
- 34:58be accomplished.
- 34:59So I'd encourage people to look that up because it shows what impact that can have on individual
- 35:07farmers and how that is a viable option for people who might be involved in the livestock
- 35:14industry now and hoping to get out of it.
- 35:17Thank you Edward.
- 35:18Debbie?
- 35:19I just wanted to add if anybody's really interested in learning more about proportional representation
- 35:24I would recommend going to Fair Vote Canada and you can do a real deep dive there and
- 35:30get involved with the movement to achieve a proper representation in the country.
- 35:36Thank you Debbie.
- 35:37I will add the link to Fair Vote Canada in the episode's notes.
- 35:42Liz?
- 35:43Just two quick things.
- 35:45First, I'm happy to share the links with the Fair Voting, BC and Springtide.
- 35:53They do regular reports about what money they're raising, how the court cases went, what the
- 35:59issues are that were being discussed, all that sort of stuff.
- 36:03So Rayanne, I'll send it to you and maybe you can add it in.
- 36:08The second thing is we have in Canada, in Quebec, I think, a farmer who's promoting
- 36:19vegan farming.
- 36:21And he's written a book.
- 36:24He's run a workshop just recently and he's amazing because he has incorporated the entire
- 36:35environment around his farm into the production of vegetables, which is what he does.
- 36:43This is veganic, but he doesn't use any animal fertilizer.
- 36:48So it's all minimally tilled.
- 36:50It's a really interesting thing.
- 36:51So I'll send you a link to his website and that's where the vegan farming issue began
- 37:01was in the Netherlands, around all that progressive thinking with Party for the Animals and others
- 37:07there.
- 37:08Thank you, Liz.
- 37:10I did not know about this farmer in the same province where I'm based.
- 37:15I would love to visit his farm this coming summer.
- 37:19Okay, so since we are on the topic of politics, let's talk about politics.
- 37:27Liz, this is your second time on the podcast and the first episode we recorded together
- 37:34was very impactful to me.
- 37:37It really made me rethink animal rights activism and what it should look like and the importance
- 37:48of politics in all of that, in that equation.
- 37:53So all of you, I'm under the presumption that all of you agree with that, that politics
- 38:02are a priority in advancing the cause of animal protection.
- 38:09So I guess I would like to hear your best argument for getting more involved in politics
- 38:19in every level of government as an animal rights activist, as a vegan.
- 38:29So who would like to start?
- 38:30Irene, maybe?
- 38:31Well, I confess I am a novice in the political arena.
- 38:37I guess I was on a call the other day and the speaker was talking about sort of from
- 38:54the highest levels of government down from the federal, provincial, local, municipal.
- 39:02And basically his argument was that especially at the higher levels, and I know Liz can speak
- 39:11to this much more eloquently than I can, but that at the higher levels, even say this
- 39:17bill in the states that Cory Booker is sponsoring, they're going to run into all kinds of stonewalling
- 39:25and they're actually kill committees where their job is to kill the bill, delay the bill.
- 39:36So all of these things happen at the higher levels.
- 39:38And this speaker was saying that where he works at a state level, he has forged relationships
- 39:51with politicians on the lower levels and his argument was even if you don't agree with
- 39:59what the person, like they may be a hunter, but they may not agree with trophy hunting.
- 40:06They may love, they may be a meat eater, but they love cats and dogs.
- 40:13And so if you can find any type of relationship with these individuals without alienating them,
- 40:20then you have a basis with which to move forward with your agenda.
- 40:28And so I'm taking that, like again, where I live, there's a huge meat packing plant,
- 40:36meat slaughterhouse.
- 40:3710,000 pigs a day are killed in Burlington.
- 40:43And yet I feel powerless.
- 40:46I don't know that I can actually stop this legitimate enterprise from, I mean, it's free
- 40:53country.
- 40:54They're a profit making organization.
- 40:57They provide jobs in the community.
- 41:00But the only way that I could possibly do anything with that would be if the city of
- 41:06Burlington makes some sort of law that outlaws that type of activity.
- 41:14So as I say, I'm not really terribly averced on this on the subject, but I'm passionate.
- 41:20So I'll let others speak.
- 41:22No, you're bringing some very pertinent points.
- 41:26I love, love, love that approach.
- 41:28I think we tend to antagonize and make an enemy out of hunters, out of farmers, out
- 41:37of the list goes on.
- 41:39Instead of looking at, like you said, ways of creating building relationships with those
- 41:45actors, with those people.
- 41:48Edward, you wanted to react.
- 41:50I think it's an excellent point.
- 41:54I've always taken an approach of killing with kindness.
- 41:57Of course, people can't see my quote marks on this audio podcast.
- 42:03But when you can reach people on a level and make them understand that, because for a standard
- 42:11person who, as my wife and I have often said it, when we were where we were pre-veganism
- 42:17was plugged into the matrix, it's hard to get out of that because our entire society
- 42:23is built on animal agriculture.
- 42:26But if you can make people realize that even a small difference can have a huge impact,
- 42:33they're more willing to make that.
- 42:34And then if you take that first step, making the second and third and fourth and fifth
- 42:38step is much, much easier.
- 42:40To answer your question about politics, you don't need to be a politician.
- 42:46And I would, of course, be reticent to call myself a politician even though I'll be running
- 42:50in an election.
- 42:53You can just be a professional pain in the ass.
- 42:57That's where I was at before aligning with the party.
- 43:01I would constantly be pestering my municipal and provincial and federal representatives
- 43:08to try to make change to what effect, debatable, even getting a response is sometimes difficult.
- 43:16But especially at the municipal level, I have a slaughterhouse that I unfortunately often
- 43:24smell at the stockyards, which is just on the border here of the Hyde Park, Parkdale,
- 43:31riding.
- 43:33And to me, I'm not going to be able to win that war probably on an animal rights or compassion
- 43:42basis, but the smell that it produces.
- 43:49I've talked to lots of people who are carnivores who say, what is that smell?
- 43:55And I'm always happy to let them know exactly what it is.
- 43:59And I think the vast majority of people would be in favor of shutting that down, or at least
- 44:08in their mind, moving it so that it wasn't a little nimbyism.
- 44:12Maybe I don't mind it if it happens because I still want my hamburger, but I don't want
- 44:16to smell.
- 44:17And if I can shut that down based on that, I don't care how it gets done.
- 44:22So taking alternative approaches to finding ways to get policy change on the municipal
- 44:28level can be an effective way.
- 44:31You have to try to reach people on their level, and you can't get people to go from zero to
- 44:41ten overnight.
- 44:42That's not going to happen for most people.
- 44:44If you can get people to just make small changes, I've always found that to be a much more effective
- 44:50way to get people to change.
- 44:53Yes, I absolutely agree, Edward.
- 44:57And even if you vote for a measure for that slaughterhouse to stop emitting that smell,
- 45:06and because of that measure, they need to renovate the building, we're talking about
- 45:12extra costs that either way from that margin of profit that this industry makes.
- 45:18So sure, that's also a victory.
- 45:21Demi?
- 45:22There's often a discussion as to where we should be focusing on individual change versus
- 45:28systemic change.
- 45:30And I think we need both.
- 45:32And running for the party to me is a way of working on systemic change.
- 45:37I've been a member of the animal alliance forever, and a member of the animal protection
- 45:45party of Canada since its inception.
- 45:48Liz had gone on a cross-entry tour.
- 45:50This was a pre-pandemic trying to recruit new candidates, and at the time I thought,
- 45:55you know, there's no way I have the time or the sources to actually fund.
- 46:01But then I learned about being a paper candidate, which essentially just gave your name on the
- 46:06ballot, and I thought, you know, I can do that.
- 46:09So I got my name on the ballot.
- 46:11But what it ended up getting into was a paper candidate test, which was on the ballot.
- 46:17I had people reach out to me to take part in some debates.
- 46:21I was part of a student forum.
- 46:23One of the high schools in my writing, they had asked all the parties to bring a lawn
- 46:29sign there, and they had the students investigate, like, research the party.
- 46:34So I was able to reach a whole lot more people in a way I have never done so before by being
- 46:42a paper candidate.
- 46:45And when the dust all settled after the election, I was last in my writing in terms of votes.
- 46:51But in the student election, I was third from last.
- 46:56So to me, that was a very interesting lesson that it's going to be the young folks who
- 47:02have more on the line in terms of things, climate change that are going to take more
- 47:07interest and hopefully move the needle forward to the animals here in Canada.
- 47:12Thank you, Debbie.
- 47:13Liz?
- 47:14I think in Canada, we do very little education about politics.
- 47:21We don't really talk about how politics works in Canada, what's different between the federal
- 47:27level, the provincial level, and the municipal level.
- 47:31Why are all three there?
- 47:34We're now having a discussion in Ontario about interference by the provincial government
- 47:38into municipal politics when we elect people at the city level.
- 47:44The provincial level is telling our politicians in the city level how to run the city.
- 47:50And so I think our party offers an opportunity for younger people who are, I guess, finding
- 48:02it difficult to look at the situation and wonder why change can't happen.
- 48:08People write to me all the time and say, I wrote to my politician about this, that,
- 48:13or other issue and nothing has happened.
- 48:16Because I think people think that they can simply write a letter or click on a petition
- 48:26or do whatever and the issue will be dealt with.
- 48:29So very few people that I know have actually met with their politicians have actually sat
- 48:34down and had a conversation with them.
- 48:37And you can agree to disagree with the person, but you can have a perfectly friendly talk.
- 48:44And I think our party provides people with the opportunity to actually do that and to
- 48:52actually begin to navigate the political system that we have, because it's very complicated.
- 49:00And it takes a long time to learn actually how to do that, to actually permeate the political
- 49:05parties on Parliament Hill.
- 49:08It's like storming the barracks.
- 49:11You can't, you know, it's very, very hard to get in to talk to people.
- 49:15So and most people are lovely and reasonable and want to hear you and maybe even want to
- 49:23help you.
- 49:25But if you can't get to talk to them personally, it makes it very, very difficult.
- 49:29So the, we, in the last, in the last, just the last point politically, we had to deal
- 49:36with the cosmetic issue ban on cosmetic animal testing, which is actually done federally
- 49:44because of the, of the testing and the cosmetics.
- 49:47So we were managed to put together a coalition of people, including the industry.
- 49:55And those were animal rights people, those were people who produced animal rights products,
- 50:00Lush and the Body Shop, and, and then we had a very sympathetic minister, the Honourable
- 50:07Jean-Yves DuClo, who allowed us access to it and participated in the whole process.
- 50:13And so it got done.
- 50:14But you know, it took 30 years to do it.
- 50:18So it just happened that those all aligned that made it possible.
- 50:23You have been a few now mentioning, you know, younger people and Liz, you also mentioned
- 50:32actions that people take online.
- 50:34And there was something I realized from looking at the animal protection party, you know, I
- 50:43looked at your social media, there are thousands of people, you know, following you, engaging
- 50:48with you on social media platforms, yet, you know, relatively to, to that following, there
- 50:56are very few, a few number of candidates, you know.
- 51:03So I wonder why, you know, why are we, why are those people captured by social media
- 51:11and not able to, you know, engage in a true meaningful way with the nonprofit they support
- 51:20in theory?
- 51:21Are you asking me?
- 51:23Sure.
- 51:24I mean, anyone.
- 51:25I don't want, I don't want to occupy the conversation, but no, go ahead.
- 51:31I think there are several reasons why.
- 51:34First of all, I think younger people are much busier than maybe some of us who some of us
- 51:42have retired, some of us are, you know, anyway.
- 51:46So I think it's because they're busy, they have to make enough money to support if they
- 51:53have a family and all that sort of stuff.
- 51:57Secondly, I think the barrier is, which is what I talked about is that most people don't
- 52:03understand that in order to make real change for animals, we have to talk to the politicians.
- 52:12They're the ones that make the decision about who dies, who lives, who is used in research,
- 52:18how they're used, what kind of extreme cruelty can be applied to them in what is considered
- 52:26an acceptable way by, by society.
- 52:31Most people don't know what is actually happening.
- 52:36And so, although they support an organization that does it, they may not want to be specifically
- 52:43involved.
- 52:44And that's why I look to like Pan in that we were talking about and Party for the Animals,
- 52:53because they have been able to garner a much younger group of people to actually run politically
- 53:00and, and I think it's, we have still have an uphill battle to make that change.
- 53:08And so it makes it much more difficult to attract people.
- 53:12I'm very, very, very glad that people are part of the organization, are supporting us
- 53:19in many ways, including in donations.
- 53:23But you know, they may not have decided that it's something they feel like they could really
- 53:29do.
- 53:30I would encourage them to do it because in the end, it can be lots of fun.
- 53:35I talk to all kinds of people.
- 53:37We have great arguments, you know, very friendly or, or agreements or whatever.
- 53:44And we get to talk about all kinds of things.
- 53:46We get to debate in front of all candidates meetings.
- 53:50We get to talk to a huge crowd.
- 53:51I went to one in Thornhill.
- 53:54The number of people there were about 350.
- 53:57I was the only odd ball there because I talked about things that nobody else would want to
- 54:02talk about.
- 54:03But anyway, a bunch of people in the crowd came up and said that they really enjoyed
- 54:07it and that they would give it some thought.
- 54:10So you, you realize that the outreach is very, very different.
- 54:14But I think, you know, the learning curve in terms of how politics works in this country
- 54:19is something that we really need to work on, particularly with younger people.
- 54:25So they realize the importance of running.
- 54:27Thank you, Liz.
- 54:28Edward.
- 54:29I mean, I think we could probably do an entire show or maybe even a 12 part series on, on
- 54:34youth and politics.
- 54:37But I think it comes down to a couple of things.
- 54:39I think when you're younger, you don't realize the true path towards change will come through
- 54:49political and legal roads.
- 54:54If you're passionate about something, because there's an instant gratification that comes
- 54:59through protesting things like vigils, things like that, that you don't get that from the
- 55:07political realm.
- 55:10But as you get older, maybe you get a little bit wiser, that you come to realize these
- 55:16things, at least that that's the way it was for me.
- 55:18And I suspect that is the way it is for a lot of people.
- 55:22But I would say to anybody who is listening, it can definitely seem intimidating.
- 55:30And I think in our current political climate, it's also very easily to get disillusioned
- 55:37by the process and to think it doesn't matter.
- 55:41But for me, just knowing that there was somebody out there who shared my vision, who shared
- 55:53my hopes, you know, void my spirits.
- 55:56And I think that people can appear even as a paper candidate for the party.
- 56:02So if you're passionate about animal rights, just be on the ballot, because just seeing
- 56:09that that name on the ballot makes a huge difference.
- 56:14It makes people realize that there are others out there who share those same views.
- 56:19And even if it gets one or two or three people to think, wow, what is this?
- 56:25I want to look into it more.
- 56:28It makes a big difference, because I know for me, I just when I was voting in the last
- 56:32election, it was provincial election, but I got thinking, well, there must be a party
- 56:37out there, and that's what led me to find this road.
- 56:40And you know, I wasn't expecting much, but when I dug in and looked at the party platform,
- 56:46I was blown away, blown away by how well presented it is, by how thoroughly thought
- 56:53out it is, how well worded it is.
- 56:56And so if you can get others just to make those connections by seeing a name on the
- 57:01ballot, doing a bit of research to reading more to getting more, it really does all those
- 57:06small steps can really build to something big.
- 57:09So I would encourage anybody who might be interested, you know, look into it a little
- 57:14bit.
- 57:15And if you're just appears a paper candidate, because it really can with with not a whole
- 57:21lot of effort make a very big difference.
- 57:23Yes, the unexpected consequences of just, you know, putting your name out there.
- 57:29And you know, I also loved what Debbie was saying about how this promoted the cause.
- 57:35And she got invitation to various places like schools.
- 57:40Irene.
- 57:41Yes, this is a little bit of an outlier comment, but one of the stand up comedians in the late
- 57:50night talk show was talking about the US Thanksgiving coming up.
- 57:54And he said, Oh, yes, and you'll, you'll gather with the family and that one person who suddenly
- 57:59went vegan, you know, made that kind of comment that ridicule comment about veganism.
- 58:07And I'm brought to mind about that quote that was attributed to my high McGonagy, but apparently
- 58:14it isn't actually his quote, but first they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they
- 58:20fight you, and then you win.
- 58:23And that's in terms of what, what, excuse me, what Liz was talking about, that this
- 58:30cosmetic change was like 30 years in the making.
- 58:34But yeah, first they laugh at you, then they ridicule you, then they attack you.
- 58:39And guess what?
- 58:41Then you make progress.
- 58:42So this is a long game.
- 58:44And unfortunately, you know, these things do take time, but what else are we going to
- 58:51do?
- 58:52And that's the common, that's the sentiment shared by most of the people who are in this,
- 58:56in this movement is if we, if we do nothing, then the animals will continue to suffer.
- 59:03We have to do what we can at whatever level we can to make life better for, for the whole
- 59:11world, but especially for the animals.
- 59:14Yes.
- 59:15And using, you know, business vocabulary, we're investing it into a future and to, you
- 59:23know, a future profit.
- 59:25And that profit is a world without animal exploitation.
- 59:28Liz?
- 59:29I guess the last thing I think I would say on this issue is that we have actually a pretty
- 59:36big community who are out there doing all sorts of different things, promoting the idea
- 59:42of veganism and animal eliminating animals from our culture of exploitation.
- 59:49So we, we need to find a way to incorporate all the actions of all those people into the
- 1:00:00political party.
- 1:00:02And I say that by way of, for example, the people who are out bearing witness to the
- 1:00:08pigs at fearmans and to the cows, the, the, called dairy cows at St. Helens near Edward
- 1:00:18that they collect data for us.
- 1:00:21They demonstrate, they can show what, what do the cows actually look like in the truck?
- 1:00:28How are the pigs actually doing in a temperature of 85 degrees in a, in a metal can with a
- 1:00:35bunch of pigs there?
- 1:00:37How is all that happening?
- 1:00:38We can use that information collectively to put into the party, offer and begin to approach
- 1:00:46government about those issues, which we've, we've now started to do.
- 1:00:50There's people who are collecting the condition of the cows that are going into Helens, which
- 1:00:54are pretty terrible with the CFIA and with the federal government.
- 1:00:59So we'll see if we can make some progress on that.
- 1:01:02But we have a big community and we need to find a way to connect everybody so that we,
- 1:01:09so that we work together on all of these issues.
- 1:01:12And that way we'll begin to magnify the kinds of things that we're talking about politically
- 1:01:19speaking.
- 1:01:20Yes.
- 1:01:21Great point.
- 1:01:23Which also brings me to the topic of the constituents, you know, the people who are going to vote
- 1:01:31for the, for the party and for this cause.
- 1:01:37Do we have an idea of the profile of those people?
- 1:01:42Do vegans, you know, are vegans active in politics?
- 1:01:46Should they be more, you know, are they the ones, you know, who go and vote?
- 1:01:52Are they the ones who will be behind you, you know, supporting you?
- 1:01:59I think that the problem is that the vegan community is very small in comparison to the
- 1:02:05entire population.
- 1:02:08So it's very difficult to actually specifically identify how many vegans live in, say, the
- 1:02:19riding that I ran in.
- 1:02:20I know that there are people there, but I wouldn't know how many, I wouldn't know where
- 1:02:25they are necessarily.
- 1:02:29So I think what we need to do is look at the whole riding.
- 1:02:34This is what we've done before, to evaluate how to move votes.
- 1:02:41What you want to do is evaluate ridings where the votes are swing.
- 1:02:48So this is a riding that doesn't necessarily vote liberal all the time or conservative
- 1:02:52all the time.
- 1:02:53And they, they switch back and forth and the margins are narrow.
- 1:02:58And so we've done a number of studies in communities where that happens.
- 1:03:06And what you find, if you can, if you're able to measure it, which is really important
- 1:03:09to do is that you can actually move votes from one party to another, and you can make
- 1:03:16the argument to move to the animal protection party of Canada, if not for, as a reason of
- 1:03:23being vegan, but for saving the planet for your kids or whatever the argument is.
- 1:03:28So we really need to understand how to move these votes and how to actually appeal to
- 1:03:37those people in the riding who are prepared to change their vote between elections or
- 1:03:44in, during elections.
- 1:03:46So it's, I think it's very difficult to actually figure out the, the vegan aspect of it.
- 1:03:53I know there are ridings like Parkdale and that have a lot of vegan resonance.
- 1:04:03And there are some in, in my writing, but most people don't know how many there are
- 1:04:08and where they live and whether they vote, how old they are, what their, you know, economic
- 1:04:14income is or whatever profile you might have on them are, they don't know anything really
- 1:04:21about them.
- 1:04:22And so I think it's very difficult to target because just specifically on that.
- 1:04:27Thank you, Liz.
- 1:04:28Debbie?
- 1:04:29I would encourage anybody listening to the podcast to please go to the animal protection
- 1:04:33party of Canada's website and see that it's not just strictly engaging vegan topics,
- 1:04:40you know, we have positions on things like education, for example.
- 1:04:44So it's not just that narrow sort of focus and it's estimated that perhaps like three
- 1:04:52parts of the population is vegan, but I think we also appeal to those who are, they're very
- 1:04:59much all the environment.
- 1:05:00You know, if you hear anything about the current catastrophe, the entire focus is on fossil
- 1:05:05fuels and nobody is really discussing the negative impacts of animal agriculture and
- 1:05:13chemicals far, far beyond just the amount of greenhouse gases that it contributes.
- 1:05:19It's like environmental degradation, habitat species laws, freshwater, water, pollution,
- 1:05:26ocean acidification, dead zones.
- 1:05:30It's leading to antibiotic resistance.
- 1:05:33It's checking off all the boxes for conditions that will lead to the next pandemic.
- 1:05:39And it's got like huge native human health impacts in 2019.
- 1:05:44Canada created the current Canada Food Guide, which was produced by scientists and scientists
- 1:05:51and three research and history influence.
- 1:05:56And it shows the diet that's optimum for our human health is one that's done it with whole
- 1:06:02plant foods.
- 1:06:04A lot of people would be surprised to know that billions of dollars continue to subsidize
- 1:06:10animal agriculture and we need to shift those subsidies and make those foods that keep us
- 1:06:16healthy, those whole plant foods, affordable and available to all.
- 1:06:22So we would result in drastically reduced healthcare costs.
- 1:06:28So there's all these other issues that come into play that people care about.
- 1:06:34Just like an animal rights issue, there's all these other factors that come in.
- 1:06:39This is very much a straight kind of system.
- 1:06:43And we need to make big changes if we want to keep this planet healthy for everyone.
- 1:06:49I think are attracted by that as well.
- 1:06:51Yes, really good point.
- 1:06:53Edward?
- 1:06:54I think as politics becomes more and more polarizing, I think people, well, I shouldn't
- 1:07:03say I think I hope people will start to look to alternatives.
- 1:07:08And I think that those alternatives will hopefully manifest in proportional representation
- 1:07:16because as we've all learned at all political levels, minority governments are aware actual
- 1:07:24change that the people want, get made.
- 1:07:29And proportional representation is like that on steroids.
- 1:07:32It's where every voice is heard.
- 1:07:35And that's why this party has invested so heavily in trying to affect that change is
- 1:07:40because really that's where the will of the people will be manifested.
- 1:07:47And even in small groups, and it's not just people who are interested in specifically
- 1:07:53this topic.
- 1:07:54It's people who are passionate about any number of things should be behind, should get fully
- 1:08:01behind proportional representation because in the current system, first past post, one
- 1:08:06group is going to, for the vast majority of times, going to hold all the power and a majority
- 1:08:12of the people within the population is not going to have their voices heard.
- 1:08:17Whereas in proportional representation, everybody gets a piece of the pie.
- 1:08:22So that to me is where not only for veganism and for animal rights, but for all causes,
- 1:08:30that's where you're going to see the real political change.
- 1:08:34So it is unfortunate that as we discuss the people in power, of course, are the ones who
- 1:08:39make the decision at the time and they never want to change because they go and stay in
- 1:08:42power.
- 1:08:43But I think, well, again, I say I think when I really mean hope, I hope that one day the
- 1:08:51people will eventually reach that critical line where they decide, no, we need to have
- 1:08:57our voices heard and we need to have all our voices heard and the best way to do that is
- 1:09:01through proportional representation.
- 1:09:03Yes, not just the politicians, the constituents too.
- 1:09:08I remember when, I think in the second electoral campaign when Trudeau was against the conservative,
- 1:09:16projections showed that if we had the proportional representation, he would have lost.
- 1:09:23And many liberals, I know, were happy actually that he did not implant those reforms, those
- 1:09:32democratic reforms, because that would have meant a victory for the conservative party.
- 1:09:40Debbie?
- 1:09:41Well, I just wanted to add that the Green Party is probably the most readily recognized
- 1:09:47as having the strongest position on the environment, but even they are not calling for a major
- 1:09:52transition in our food system.
- 1:09:55So it has been joked that the animal protection party of Canada is greener than greens.
- 1:10:01It's very true, very true.
- 1:10:04The reason why I bring the topic of constituents is partly because, you know, in light of the
- 1:10:12recent Republican victory in the US, I have realized that, and let me know what you think,
- 1:10:22but that the animal rights movement has not done a good job at gaining constituents like
- 1:10:33allies among conservatives.
- 1:10:36And, you know, I was thinking about what Mike said in the beginning of the podcast.
- 1:10:42He talked about how conservative the people were in Newfoundland.
- 1:10:50He also mentioned Mattius Colley, who is this, you know, very mainstream conservative.
- 1:10:58He was a speechwriter for many Republican presidents, and he's also an animal rights
- 1:11:05advocate, you know, a vegan, and who has written extensively on the conservative argument for
- 1:11:13veganism.
- 1:11:15And I feel like maybe we're missing on a whole pool of army of possible allies.
- 1:11:25And so what do you think?
- 1:11:27Do you think that we could be doing a better job at appealing to a more conservative audience?
- 1:11:34Yeah, who wants to take that, Debbie?
- 1:11:40I think we have to think about where these conservative folks are getting their information
- 1:11:45from, and it's certainly not from wonderful podcasts like yourself.
- 1:11:49And mainstream media is just not carrying this message.
- 1:11:54They are being funded by, you know, people who are paying for the ads, which tends to
- 1:11:58be counter-use of youth industries.
- 1:12:02And we have less resources to be able to capture that.
- 1:12:07We have, for example, here in Winnipeg, it can be very hard to get any kind of space
- 1:12:14on buses.
- 1:12:16If you manage to get any space on the buses, they really want to loot the message.
- 1:12:20So we have a uphill battle in terms of just getting the message out there to people who
- 1:12:26aren't hearing it.
- 1:12:27Thank you, Debbie.
- 1:12:28Liz?
- 1:12:29My message to everybody is we have no permanent friends and no permanent enemies in politics.
- 1:12:36So it very much depends on each situation.
- 1:12:40When I first got into going to Ottawa, I was put on a committee by the then agriculture
- 1:12:50minister to look at the issue of the import of puppies from the United States into Canada.
- 1:12:56And at that time, there were about 20,000 coming in.
- 1:12:59This is way back in the early 1990s.
- 1:13:02The minister was Bill McKnight.
- 1:13:04He was, by all accounts, a pretty hardcore conservative, but he loved dogs.
- 1:13:12And we sat on that committee with all of the importers and the people who were selling
- 1:13:18them and all that sort of stuff.
- 1:13:20Nobody wanted any changes.
- 1:13:21And I was the one person on the committee that was talking about an alternative.
- 1:13:28And he got so frustrated that he simply signed a directive to the border authorities that
- 1:13:35they were not to import any puppies that were genetically compromised or where there was
- 1:13:42an infection, the entire truck would have to be turned back.
- 1:13:46Now that had serious implications for the dogs on the trucks, the puppies.
- 1:13:51So we had to approach people at the border to see if we could get them properly handled.
- 1:13:57But it meant that the number of dogs coming across the border was dropped from 20,000 down
- 1:14:04to under 7,000 just in that one activity.
- 1:14:08So there are allies in every party.
- 1:14:12The question is, we don't have the same kind of resources as the agricultural community,
- 1:14:19and they affect many more riding, so it makes it much more difficult.
- 1:14:23But occasionally, if you don't fight with them, I'm trying very hard not to fight with
- 1:14:29some of the conservatives because I disagree with some of their other policies.
- 1:14:34But nonetheless, we have to talk to them.
- 1:14:36If Pierre Pollyev gets elected, we have to go through that party and find out who we
- 1:14:43can talk to.
- 1:14:44Who is it that we can get in and see?
- 1:14:46Who is it that we can actually ask to do even a private members bill to get it discussed
- 1:14:52on the legislature?
- 1:14:54So I think we just don't make enemies, and we probably don't have a lot of friends, but
- 1:15:02we need all of those capacities to actually make change.
- 1:15:07Yes, I completely agree.
- 1:15:11And more than in the higher level of politicians, even the constituents, those politicians are
- 1:15:19elected by people, and if we show that those people care about animals, they will be more
- 1:15:26inclined to listen to us.
- 1:15:29Edward?
- 1:15:30I think you make a really interesting point about the opportunities that are there to
- 1:15:34make gains within the conservative side because there are people who are religious, do tend
- 1:15:42to have conservative meanings.
- 1:15:48So there are opportunities there that can be reached, but I think one thing that we often
- 1:15:55lose sight of as people in the animal rights community is that we can make gains in our
- 1:16:09interests when we try to support other issues that might not be germane to this specific
- 1:16:16topic.
- 1:16:18So what I mean by that is that we're probably all privileged in our lives in that we're
- 1:16:24not fighting day to day to keep ourselves and our families afloat because when that's
- 1:16:32the case, as it is with a lot of people, a lot of people, and that number is growing
- 1:16:37because of the wage divide, you don't have a lot of time to fight for others because
- 1:16:43you're fighting for yourself.
- 1:16:45So when we prop up people, whether that be through universal basic income, other measures
- 1:16:51to make sure that people aren't scraping by, they have more time for things that they're
- 1:16:58passionate about.
- 1:16:59Because I think a lot of people, if they have their eyes open to what's going on, they're
- 1:17:07probably going to be more motivated to either take action or at least take steps.
- 1:17:15But when you can go to the grocery store and you can buy subsidized meat for cheaper than
- 1:17:21you can fresh vegetables, what are you going to buy when you're just trying to keep your
- 1:17:27family alive?
- 1:17:29So things that aren't specific to our cause, they're still within what we should be fighting
- 1:17:36for because they eventually lead to what will help our cause.
- 1:17:40And I think that sometimes that gets lost because, again, it feels so mountainous what
- 1:17:45we're climbing, what we're trying to achieve, but small gains in other ways can have big
- 1:17:50impacts on what we're trying to do.
- 1:17:54Thank you, Edward.
- 1:17:55It makes me think of recording, I mentioned how I work in the fundraising philanthropic
- 1:18:02world and a donation is classified as a luxury expense, actually.
- 1:18:11So when you donate to an organization, you're actually, it's a luxury, it's considered a
- 1:18:16luxury, which I find interesting in which it goes your point.
- 1:18:22Irene, we haven't listened to you answer for a moment now.
- 1:18:29Did you want to add something to this whole conversation?
- 1:18:33Well, as I said before, I'm a bit of a novice at this, so I can't speak so knowledgeably,
- 1:18:42but I am so much in favor of allyship, that this is the way we're going to get things
- 1:18:49done.
- 1:18:51Just a word about, I know we're talking about politics, but one of the, when you asked at
- 1:18:56the very beginning about who are our heroes and how do we get into this whole movement,
- 1:19:06I have changed my outlook from the Gary Francione abolitionist stand, which is, we have to end
- 1:19:15all animal use 100% around the world.
- 1:19:20But unfortunately, that's just not going to happen.
- 1:19:24And so my position now is, I think we're calling pragmatic veganism.
- 1:19:31And that is, if you take 100 people and 10 of them go completely vegan overnight, no
- 1:19:39animal use whatsoever.
- 1:19:41And the other 90 people take a more flexitarian report, they do meatless Mondays, they reduce
- 1:19:50their animal use of animals, who's going to make the most difference to the animals?
- 1:19:56Well, it's going to be the 90 people, not the 10.
- 1:20:00And we talk about luxury, we're the luxurious ones, we're the vegans who are happily vegan,
- 1:20:07and we don't have any type of mental conflict over it.
- 1:20:13The other 90 let them work through it.
- 1:20:18But they are our allies, they're not our opposition, they are our allies, and we need to encourage
- 1:20:26them in every way, including political.
- 1:20:31I was at the Burlington VegFest for the last several years, and Liz has been kind enough
- 1:20:37to sponsor me there, a booth.
- 1:20:39And I can't tell you the number of people who come up to the table and say, I didn't
- 1:20:45know there was a party.
- 1:20:47Wow, tell me more.
- 1:20:48Of course, I hand out the booklet and I talk them up and I get on the mailing list.
- 1:20:57But again, how does that translate into actually going into the voting booth and voting?
- 1:21:03And again, I think that happened in the States.
- 1:21:06Everybody was expecting, especially I as a feminist was expecting all the young women
- 1:21:10to turn out.
- 1:21:12They didn't turn out, and that was a great loss for the USM for the world.
- 1:21:18So I have a rambling comment there.
- 1:21:21Thank you, Irene.
- 1:21:23Yes, Edward?
- 1:21:25I just think that's so well said by Irene about allyship and being able to make difference
- 1:21:34through outreach.
- 1:21:35I see it firsthand as I was out recently with a group of friends.
- 1:21:42We were at a restaurant, not a vegan restaurant, just a regular restaurant.
- 1:21:46And one of the guys came in and he said, well, I guess I'm having the veggie burger.
- 1:21:50And I said, well, why is that?
- 1:21:52He said, well, I was on the subway and I saw a white one and another poster where you've
- 1:21:58got the pig juxtapose against the puppy.
- 1:22:00And he said, well, I can't eat a burger now.
- 1:22:04I got to have a veggie burger.
- 1:22:05So it shows that it works.
- 1:22:07Those things all work and all those small measures add up to big things because that
- 1:22:11was one less animal on a plate that night.
- 1:22:15It sounds cliche, but when I got into this, I thought to myself, if I can change just
- 1:22:20one person's mind or even change just one meal, then I'll have had a made a difference.
- 1:22:24And if you think if we can get people all across the country signing up to the party,
- 1:22:31and each riding eventually fingers crossed the goal, the amount of difference, all those
- 1:22:36small actions will make.
- 1:22:39It's really heartwarming to think of what that could eventually be.
- 1:22:43Thank you, Edward.
- 1:22:44And that makes me think I want to give a shout out to on behalf of animals, it's another
- 1:22:50podcast hosted by some very good friends.
- 1:22:57And in one episode, you know, they interviewed the lobbyist and he said an animal rights
- 1:23:03lobbyist and he said, you need to meet those politicians and constituents with confidence
- 1:23:12because our cause is a righteous cause.
- 1:23:15And I do feel that at my core, you know.
- 1:23:22So yeah, Mike, you're back.
- 1:23:25Welcome back.
- 1:23:26Just in time.
- 1:23:30Just in time for, you know, wrapping this up.
- 1:23:34Thank you everyone.
- 1:23:35Thank you so much for all of your, you know, insights for sharing your experience.
- 1:23:42Anything that you want to add anything before we end this recording.
- 1:23:50Last chance.
- 1:23:51Yes, baby.
- 1:23:52Oh, I think thank you for your interest in the party and inviting us onto your podcast.
- 1:23:59And the last word I want to leave for all your listeners is a quote by a wonderful
- 1:24:05artist, Megan, who was killed by a transport truck carrying pigs at a video.
- 1:24:12And she said, doing nothing does no good.
- 1:24:15So I encourage everybody to do they can no action for the animals is too small or too
- 1:24:21big.
- 1:24:22Thank you.
- 1:24:23Thank you.
- 1:24:24Thank you.
- 1:24:25Thank you.
- 1:24:26Thank you.
- 1:24:27Thank you.
- 1:24:28Thank you.
- 1:24:29Thank you.
- 1:24:30Thank you.
- 1:24:31Thank you.
- 1:24:32Thank you, Debbie.
- 1:24:33Mike.
- 1:24:34Yes.
- 1:24:35Yes.
- 1:24:36I was thinking of one more.
- 1:24:37Activists I'd like to include.
- 1:24:38So there was a.
- 1:24:39Buddhist monk.
- 1:24:40And philosopher named.
- 1:24:41Deacon.
- 1:24:42Who died a couple of years ago.
- 1:24:44And as far as like a philosophy goes, I would say I'm.
- 1:24:49He was a very nice guy.
- 1:24:53And I was a very nice guy too.
- 1:24:55And I think he was just like I, I like.
- 1:24:58Buddhist ideas.
- 1:24:59So he was one of my favorites.
- 1:25:03Like I use a lot of quotes from him as, as well.
- 1:25:05And I do outreach.
- 1:25:06Yeah.
- 1:25:07And he has, they've made a film about his life.
- 1:25:10I think it's called walk with me.
- 1:25:12I would recommend that as well.
- 1:25:14It's about mindfulness and.
- 1:25:16And stuff.
- 1:25:17he was a vegan as well and that was part of his non-violence philosophy.
- 1:25:25Thank you, Mike. As a Buddhist, I truly appreciate this comment. Yes, Irene?
- 1:25:31I just wanted to quote, give this quote from another, it was part of a talk that I was involved in
- 1:25:43and it basically says, although non-human animals should have some rights, the term
- 1:25:50rights can be emotive and negative, turning off listeners before you are even able to make your
- 1:25:55point. Think about gun rights, reproductive rights, civil rights. These terms can resonate or repulse
- 1:26:02depending on your audience. You cannot get your point across if nobody's listening.
- 1:26:08Thank you. Thank you, Irene, for this. Again, thank you so much, everyone. And I truly wish that,
- 1:26:15you know, success and lots of votes for this upcoming election. Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 1:26:23I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage more people
- 1:26:29to take action. Again, thank you so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.