Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 155: What it takes to become French in 2026 with Charli James
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Lindsay Trermuda. Nearly 12 years ago, I became a
- 0:14French citizen. From beginning the paperwork to
- 0:17getting the letter in the mail, it took a year and a half when
- 0:20all was said and done. Since then, a lot has changed.
- 0:23For one, newly minted citizens aren't alerted by snail mail
- 0:27anymore in most places, but mostly the criteria for
- 0:30nationality have gotten stricter.
- 0:32That's particularly true as of January 1st.
- 0:35Given how many Americans in particular are looking to move
- 0:38to France. I thought it was time to dig
- 0:39into the process, how it's gotten harder and why, at least
- 0:43for everyone except George Clooney.
- 0:45And to do so brought on my friend and friend of the show,
- 0:49France 24 journalist and new French citizen Charlie James.
- 1:10What you just heard comes straight from Charlie James's
- 1:13recent naturalization ceremony. So I guess the 1st order of
- 1:16business is Fadi citation. A Massey Lindsay Yeah, it was so
- 1:20glamorous. I mean, it's not meant to be a
- 1:23parade. It's not a, it's not a gala
- 1:26event. Well.
- 1:26Fancy people get to have theirs at the Elysee with Emmanuel
- 1:29Macron. Oh.
- 1:30You mean George Clooney? Yes.
- 1:32People like George Clooney, the rest of us.
- 1:34It's in a slightly shabby room at an administrative building.
- 1:39But did it feel special? Did it feel like you were?
- 1:45It felt a little bit like a culmination.
- 1:47I think if anything it was a capstone on oh this is the last
- 1:51time I have to go in a building like this and a prefecture.
- 1:54For a while, at least. For a while, yeah.
- 1:56And I'm not going every couple of years or every year like you
- 1:59had to, you know, when you first arrive and start the whole
- 2:01process. And so that in and of itself is
- 2:05exciting and a blessing. It is.
- 2:07It is, But you have been here, what, 8 years?
- 2:12Eight years? Yeah.
- 2:12You have two children. A French husband.
- 2:15But that is not ultimately how you approach this process, is
- 2:19that correct? Like you had been here enough
- 2:22time also to apply as an individual who has worked and
- 2:27and been contributing to society because there are multiple ways
- 2:30we can apply for citizenship. Right, right.
- 2:32So I actually started the process through marriage and
- 2:35then during the process I became eligible just on my own.
- 2:39And so they switched my statue, they switched my the way that I
- 2:44was going at this. And so I did, for example, I
- 2:47mean, the only thing that really changes is when you do the
- 2:51interview, you do it all by yourself instead of also with
- 2:54your spouse. But yeah, I honestly, I wasn't
- 2:59in like a huge hurry to do the citizenship.
- 3:03I had two small children. And it wasn't something that I
- 3:06was like, I got to get this done now.
- 3:08But when the war in Ukraine started, my husband was really
- 3:14concerned. And he, I think, I think
- 3:16Europeans think about war on the continent differently than
- 3:21Americans. We haven't had war on our soil
- 3:23for a long time. And so the fact that this was so
- 3:26nearby, he said. I just want our family to have
- 3:31one common nationality so that all of us are protected through
- 3:361 country. And so it was really important
- 3:38to him and that's kind of why we kick started the the process.
- 3:42And that makes a lot of sense. And, and ultimately you're
- 3:44heading in that direction anyway.
- 3:46You, you're, you've laid down roots, you're raising your
- 3:48children here. You met your husband in the US,
- 3:51and so you've also. Got here, we've got here.
- 3:53Oh right, so you met here, but then I moved.
- 3:55Him to the US. Right.
- 3:56And so you've been through the green card process for him over
- 3:59there, which is an interesting dual experience, I think for you
- 4:03to be able to compare the two systems and processes, but your
- 4:07experience getting nationality. And our my dutiful audio
- 4:12producer, Matt Jordan, who is working on this episode right
- 4:15now, has also become French in the last handful of years.
- 4:19And his process was also a little different from mine.
- 4:21And so I think what can be kind of confusing to people who are
- 4:25about to embark on this or who want to know, if I move to
- 4:28France and put in enough time and want to contribute to
- 4:32society and want to become French, what is that going to
- 4:34look like for me? Well, everyone has sort of a
- 4:36different answer. What what was the journey like
- 4:41in terms of paperwork? I think that is something that
- 4:44hasn't really changed, right? You have to get a lot of
- 4:46documents that come from the US within a certain time frame.
- 4:51They need certain stamps, more official stamps than just the
- 4:55official nature of the Organism that's issuing them.
- 4:59What did you find the most challenging in organizing
- 5:03yourself for this process? Right.
- 5:05I mean, I think by the time you're doing citizenship here,
- 5:09you're used to the bureaucracy being quite a hassle.
- 5:12But it is true that just figuring out the timing and all
- 5:16the paperwork and, you know, they give you a list of here's
- 5:19what you need. And then of course, they ask for
- 5:21more things in the meetings. But for me, from start to
- 5:27finish, it was a little over a three-year process.
- 5:30Three years. Yeah.
- 5:32Well, it took me a year once I submitted to get my appointment
- 5:36for an interview. And then once I had the
- 5:38interview, it took me 16 months to get an answer.
- 5:41So most of that was just waiting around for the next step.
- 5:44There's a huge backlog. They don't have enough people
- 5:46processing. But I've also heard within the
- 5:49same amount of time, you know, in the last handful of years,
- 5:52some people have had an kind of arbitrarily accelerated process
- 5:57for reasons that are unknown. It's a black box.
- 5:59They told me when I was done with my interview.
- 6:01You'll have an answer in a year and then a year goes by and
- 6:05every month I'm, you know, calling and checking the website
- 6:07for they have a little timeline that follows and you can't
- 6:11really get any information, can I just.
- 6:13Tell you at least you had a website.
- 6:15Yeah, mine was the days of you may e-mail this person who may
- 6:18never respond to you. I got my notice in the mail in
- 6:23an an envelope that looked tampered with.
- 6:26To be honest, I thought it was just some like Bill or some, you
- 6:29know, solicitation. And then it's like, hello,
- 6:32you're French. But I can tell you all this kind
- 6:35of steps I I had to go through and then we can talk about what
- 6:37change, what's changing now this year.
- 6:40Yeah. So you have to get basically
- 6:42every document that's ever related to your life from birth
- 6:46certificate to I had to do the marriage certificate, obviously
- 6:49mine from New York where we got married and then here where we
- 6:52also had we didn't have a ceremony, but we got it like
- 6:55transferred and recognized by France.
- 6:58My parents information everything had to get special
- 7:03stamps called Aposteel and then also translated and.
- 7:08You're creating the FBI background check.
- 7:10Background check where a lot of people go and do it in the
- 7:12states because you can go and do it at post offices and other
- 7:16places like that. I got mine done here in the
- 7:19lobby of a Co working space by a woman.
- 7:22Yeah same. It was like no one here in Paris
- 7:25for. Probably the same.
- 7:26Woman. The only woman who does it.
- 7:28Yeah. So that was an interesting part.
- 7:31And then cuz I, you know, I work here.
- 7:34So all of my work documents, everything related to my
- 7:37children as well. And then just, you know, proof
- 7:40of utilities and where you live and all of that.
- 7:44So it's a lot of documents and everything has to be have like 3
- 7:47months of validity within each other.
- 7:51So you're, you have to get this this birth certificate in all
- 7:55these documents and it can't pass three months old from when
- 7:58you got it. So the timing of just trying to
- 8:00get everything in when it's all valid is very tricky.
- 8:06However, you're also forgetting your language results, right?
- 8:09Because I'm not saying you're forgetting.
- 8:11Of course you didn't forget. It's a.
- 8:12It's a memorable part of the problem.
- 8:14Right. You have to go and get a
- 8:16language test, which I did when I had infant and a 2 year old.
- 8:21So I was running on like one brain cell.
- 8:24All every brain cell I had went into passing this language test.
- 8:28But I had already had to do it for the 10 year visa that I had
- 8:31before. So I knew what to expect to
- 8:33going in. But yeah, you go to these
- 8:37special testing centers that you have to pay for, get an
- 8:39appointment, and then you take a multiple choice written test.
- 8:45And then you have to like write some emails and things like that
- 8:48as well. And then you go in and you do an
- 8:50oral portion where you're just one-on-one in a room with
- 8:52someone and they tell you to pretend you're in some sort of
- 8:56scenario and you role play. The second one I remember they
- 9:01told me I was going into a pet shop and buying a pet.
- 9:04Really. And I was obviously never a
- 9:07situation that I'd been in before.
- 9:10So it was, it was a little surprise, but apparently I did
- 9:14fine. But yeah, they want you to kind
- 9:16of role play a real life situation and then they, you
- 9:19know, judge how well you did. So maybe it's not the
- 9:22opportunity to say that you shouldn't buy pets in a pet
- 9:24store. Right.
- 9:25Initially I was like, well, I disagree with the premise of
- 9:27this, you know, I did. Oh my God, I would have.
- 9:30I would have been like bonus. Points in my head I was like, I
- 9:32disagree with the premise of this but.
- 9:35I in. In real life I was like, yeah,
- 9:37I'll have a dog please. So poor.
- 9:41Cats, huh? Then you wait and see what kind
- 9:44of results you get if you pass. If you don't pass, then yeah,
- 9:48you have to take it again and again and pay every time.
- 9:50So there's a cost for that as well.
- 9:52And then you have to pay just to submit what they called stamps
- 9:56here. They're fiscal.
- 9:56Stamps, yeah, fiscal stamps just to submit.
- 10:00And so, yeah, it's a time intensive and it's not as nearly
- 10:04as costly as the process in the US, but it's not nothing.
- 10:08Well, and then you and I didn't have this, this step for various
- 10:13reasons. I imagine it's because I
- 10:14initially came on a student visa, then transferred it to a
- 10:18one of them, you know, being part of a family, being married.
- 10:21But I did not have to take the civics test and you did.
- 10:24So that's another cost. No, the civics test just
- 10:26started, so we can talk about the the new things that have
- 10:31started. If you want the civics, there
- 10:33was always a civics portion in terms of like you had to learn.
- 10:38So when did you get asked those questions?
- 10:40And in the interview, and I didn't, you see what I mean?
- 10:43My questions were about as detailed as do you live a French
- 10:47life, which can be interpreted in 100 different ways?
- 10:50And I'm sitting there with my husband and I'm like, well, I at
- 10:52one point had been doing volunteer work for an
- 10:54organization. So I talked about that.
- 10:56I said we speak in French at home.
- 10:58I work in a company where all the meetings are in French.
- 11:02You know, you can sort of that was a you could freestyle that
- 11:05one. And they asked me those
- 11:06questions too. They wanted to know am IA part
- 11:10of any organizations that I work for a French company.
- 11:15The situation with my kids school, what kind of school they
- 11:18went to and my friends with the other parents.
- 11:20What language do I speak with the other parents?
- 11:23My husband's work. So they did ask me, why do you
- 11:25want to be French? That's the classic question, of
- 11:27course, of just why which? What's your motivation for this?
- 11:31And I bet they they people get themselves into trouble with
- 11:36that question because they might think it's an opportunity to be,
- 11:39you know, brutally honest. But if your answer is just to
- 11:42facilitate, you know, a smoother daily life, I don't know that
- 11:47that's, you know, that that can get you in trouble.
- 11:49Yeah. I.
- 11:51People say things that I think they think will fly.
- 11:55And actually, if you're not basically saying you're, you're
- 11:58dedicated, you're dedicated to building a life here because of
- 12:01the values or because, you know, you're, you want your children
- 12:03to be brought up in the amazing, you know, social foundation of
- 12:08this country. Like you need to have more than
- 12:10just a basic good. Reason and because the main
- 12:13thing that they're you obviously need to be able to say what the
- 12:17bestie is and who the Prime Minister is and things like
- 12:21that. They want you to get those right
- 12:23but they really want to know how well are you integrated exactly?
- 12:26Are you living a French life or are you just living your
- 12:31American life here in France and doing the bare minimum to
- 12:35actually incorporate yourself in society?
- 12:40So yeah, they liked that. I'm a member of the French Press
- 12:43Association. They obviously like that I have
- 12:46French children and that I speak French with my in laws and at
- 12:52work and things like that and have friends.
- 12:55I mean honestly, not a ton, but have friends that I speak French
- 12:59with as well because they don't want people just coming here and
- 13:02kind of taking the nice parts and not doing the work to
- 13:06contribute to society. So does George Clooney
- 13:09contribute to? Does he do the work?
- 13:11According to the French government, he does.
- 13:15He's very special. So for your listeners who
- 13:18haven't heard George Clooney and his wife and children, his wife
- 13:21who does speak. Fluent French.
- 13:23She's because she's Lebanese. She's Lebanese, so she's
- 13:25probably she's English Lebanese. And he became a French citizen
- 13:30two days before the new regulations went into effect.
- 13:34Fancy. That what a coincidence.
- 13:37So I was kind of surprised because I didn't even know they
- 13:40have a house in the South of France and they bought an old
- 13:45domain, like an old vineyard and apparently spend quite a bit of
- 13:49time there. I knew he did commercials.
- 13:52With Jean du Jardin, Yeah, Yes, yes, yes.
- 13:54But I didn't actually know that he lived here.
- 13:58I associate him with. Italy right with.
- 14:00Italy and not France, but it was big news here when he and his
- 14:06wife and kids became French and people didn't really like it
- 14:11that he admittedly speaks terrible French.
- 14:14He says his French is horrible, that he's using Duolingo to try
- 14:18to improve it and is taking lessons, but so far no luck.
- 14:22But that apparently wasn't a requirement for him because
- 14:26shocking, you know, rich and famous people, the same rules
- 14:30don't always apply to them. But he the French government
- 14:35says that he meets all the legal requirements and contributes to
- 14:40France's cultural prestige. And so there's a special route
- 14:44for athletes, famous people, especially rich people.
- 14:50The statute says that someone can be granted citizenship by
- 14:53the Interior Ministry if they contribute through their
- 14:56distinguished service to France's influence and the
- 14:59prosperity of its international economic relations.
- 15:04Soft power. But the French minister says
- 15:08he's he's happy that Clooney is a French citizen and that France
- 15:12is lucky to have him. Oh, and and what about all the
- 15:16other people who have to jump through incredible hoops?
- 15:20Are they not happy for them? So I think it was the timing of
- 15:22this. I think that if it didn't come
- 15:24right on the heels of these new changes to the language and the
- 15:29interview and the civics test coming into effect, people might
- 15:32have been like, oh, isn't that a fun story that he's French?
- 15:37But the fact that two days after he was granted citizen, it got
- 15:41much harder forever. Let's talk about that because
- 15:44that's the big change right now is that for almost everyone it
- 15:50is going to be harder to not only achieve citizenship, but
- 15:54even the requirements for getting long term permanent
- 15:57residency is getting harder as well.
- 16:00Right. Every level bumped up 1.
- 16:02So for citizenship it used to be B1, now it's B2.
- 16:07What does that mean for people who aren't aware of these
- 16:09language levels? So B2, it's the same level that
- 16:12you have to hit to go to a French university.
- 16:15It's considered intermediate, advanced.
- 16:17You're supposed to be able to talk on a wide variety of of
- 16:23topics without making mistakes. It's estimated to take 2000 to
- 16:273000 hours. Oh my gosh.
- 16:29To reach this level. So it's not easy, but then it's
- 16:36the same for if you're applying for a 10 year visa, it used to
- 16:39be a 2, now it's B1. And if you're applying for a
- 16:42short term visa, a year or two, it used to be a one, now it's a
- 16:462. So everything just got bumped
- 16:48up. So there's there's three things,
- 16:50three main changes of how things got harder.
- 16:52It's the language requirements. The second thing is a new 40
- 16:55question civics exam that you go and take at a testing center and
- 17:00then a stricter interview process.
- 17:03And who is conducting those interviews?
- 17:05So you at the prefecture at the. Prefecture.
- 17:08So I think this is meant to address a variation of how hard
- 17:15these interviews have been depending on where you're taking
- 17:18them. And also, we should add a caveat
- 17:21that it has been relatively smooth for certain people of
- 17:26certain backgrounds and countries of origins.
- 17:29And you and I both know plenty of people who either through
- 17:33their work or their language skills, more than meet the
- 17:36criteria but have been dismissed or given extra sort of hurdles
- 17:43to jump over because they're from a country you know?
- 17:47Or maybe it's really hard to get your parents birth certificate
- 17:50or you come from a country that the French government doesn't
- 17:53even recognize the country that issued your birth certificate,
- 18:00or there's an active war or there's a hostile government.
- 18:04And so it coming from America, it's obviously going to be much
- 18:09easier for me to get all of my documents than it is or someone
- 18:14coming from a country where it's an active war zone or where
- 18:18there's been a huge government regime change, or maybe they
- 18:22just don't have the same kind of record keeping.
- 18:25Exactly. Where maybe their parents
- 18:28weren't issued a birth certificate when they were born.
- 18:30And so all of these things can contribute to maybe people not
- 18:36even taking on the process, right?
- 18:38Well, and if you don't feel like if there's a person you can
- 18:40speak to for these specific scenarios that clearly are
- 18:44out-of-the-box and out of the, you know, the neatly defined
- 18:48parameters that the prefecture, you know, workers are trying to
- 18:52follow, you know, it can lead to, you know, just a clash.
- 18:56Even if someone does want to try the process, It's that, oh,
- 18:58you're, you know, the system is bugging, you're not, and you're
- 19:02not meeting XY and Z, you know? They just want to check the box.
- 19:06Do you have this? Do you have that?
- 19:08But it's not as easy for every, It's not that straightforward
- 19:11for every person. And I've heard both anecdotally
- 19:15and from friends of mine that went through the process that
- 19:18you're treated quite differently in these interviews, Sure, based
- 19:21on where you're coming from, what you look like and your, you
- 19:27know, maybe your family or fiscal situation.
- 19:30And so I think that the, they didn't say this, but I think
- 19:33that the memo that went out last year telling the prefectures,
- 19:39which are like the administrative building,
- 19:41government administrative buildings that handle visa and
- 19:45nationality requests that they have to be stricter in these
- 19:49interviews. I think it was to try to
- 19:51standardize the process because before my interview, I went and
- 19:55talked to as many people as I could that have been through the
- 19:57process of, OK, what was your experience?
- 19:59What can I expect? And I was hearing wildly
- 20:01different answers. Everything from, oh, you just go
- 20:04in there and it's like a chat for 15 minutes.
- 20:06They hardly even ask you anything.
- 20:08To people who said that, you know, they were in there for an
- 20:10hour getting grilled. And the people were really rude.
- 20:14Yes. And also.
- 20:15You know, just to give you an example, back in 2013 when I had
- 20:19my application in and I had the first interview, I then got
- 20:22summoned by myself to the Ministry of the Interior for an
- 20:26interview. I had no idea going in.
- 20:28I had, I had spoken to people who had had gone through the
- 20:31process in a similar fashion to myself and they didn't have to
- 20:34do that. And so it was very confusing and
- 20:36a bit scary. You were using said for his
- 20:38nationality. No, but you know what?
- 20:40What it was is they, you know, they walk you through the
- 20:42process. They wanted to talk to me.
- 20:43They wanted to have a real conversation with me.
- 20:46I think it's another way to test language skills.
- 20:49But they also went through all my documents.
- 20:51And I was really concerned because I didn't get my parents
- 20:53divorce certificate. I thought it was sort of unclear
- 20:56at the time whether that was necessary.
- 20:59And so they start going through my file and they said, so your
- 21:01parents are still together. And I said, actually, no.
- 21:04Is that, you know, should I have gotten that document?
- 21:07And they're like, no salva. But I was, I had this moment of
- 21:10like intense fear. I was like, I'm going to get
- 21:12screwed because I didn't get that document because no one
- 21:15could confirm whether I needed it.
- 21:17You know what I mean? You needed the marriage
- 21:18certificate. For things in my interview that
- 21:21they that wasn't on the list, random things like, yeah,
- 21:24utility bills and things like that.
- 21:27But I had it because I knew from my 10 year visa process that
- 21:30they will ask for whatever they want.
- 21:32So bring every document with your name on it in French that
- 21:36you have. But just to say you're right,
- 21:39the standardization is a way to make the process a bit clearer.
- 21:43However, there are also political reasons for doing
- 21:45this. Right, obviously.
- 21:48Well, my interview process I think was a little harder than I
- 21:52expected based on just what people told me.
- 21:55And it was a mix of civics questions and personal
- 22:01motivation questions, why I want to be French, asking about my
- 22:06family, how I've integrated myself, who I speak French with,
- 22:11etcetera. But there were a lot of civics
- 22:13questions too. I went back and looked at my
- 22:15notes. You have a couple of examples.
- 22:17From what they asked me, yeah. So they asked me, they asked me
- 22:22to name 3 presidents since de Gaulle, not including the
- 22:25current one. They asked me the rights and
- 22:28responsibilities of French citizens.
- 22:30They asked me about the motto What's Lisete and do I agree
- 22:34with it, Which was yeah, Which was the only time where maybe I
- 22:38wasn't 100% in my interview. Who's the Prime Minister?
- 22:44What Republic are we in and who established it?
- 22:46So these are. I studied before.
- 22:49I don't think I would have passed it if I didn't study
- 22:52before. Well, and didn't you share
- 22:54something with me that there was a this test was given to French
- 22:57citizens and two of them failed, You know, I.
- 23:00Mean. Well, that was the the language
- 23:01test. Yeah, that was the language
- 23:04test. So there's a France television.
- 23:07It's like a French broadcaster here.
- 23:09And when they announced the changes last year, they sent 10
- 23:13native French speakers, 10 French citizens to go take the
- 23:17test to see how they would do. Five of them failed the written
- 23:22part, but because they did so well on the oral part, they,
- 23:26they mix the results and so they ended up passing.
- 23:29But two people straight out failed.
- 23:31And these are these are Francophone people.
- 23:35And there's been cases of people from Belgium, people from the
- 23:40Congo who are native French speakers failing these language
- 23:43tests. I mean, like, I don't understand
- 23:45what I did wrong here, right? I'm a native French speaker, but
- 23:50this is another thing that advocates say puts certain
- 23:55people at a disadvantage because there are people who are very
- 23:58well integrated who speak French, who maybe don't have a
- 24:02the same formal education background or who just are bad
- 24:06at taking tests. And it's very test heavy.
- 24:10So now you have the language test and you have this 40
- 24:13question civics test. It's multiple choice.
- 24:16You take it on a computer, OK, But it's a separate, a whole
- 24:20separate process, right, that they've added and it costs
- 24:23anywhere from 70 to €200 to take it depending on where you go
- 24:29because it's not by the government, it's these private
- 24:32test centers that do these and the language tests.
- 24:35And so this is another obstacle in terms of cost and just in
- 24:41terms of being able to study and be good at passing a test.
- 24:47So the question is, what is the real goal of people becoming
- 24:51citizens? Is it integration?
- 24:55Because maybe this isn't the best way to judge whether
- 24:58someone is truly integrated. Because maybe you could be
- 25:01someone who's not as well integrated, but you have the
- 25:04money, the time, the resources to be able to pass all of these
- 25:07tests. Or you have people who are
- 25:10working here contributing, maybe don't have the same resources
- 25:15and won't be able to pass these tests.
- 25:17So is it that we want people to truly be integrated, or is it
- 25:21that we want certain kinds of people?
- 25:24Sure. This is the this is the become
- 25:26citizen, of course. So this is the question that's
- 25:28at play in the United States and many countries that are trying
- 25:31to control or change their immigration and citizen
- 25:38naturalization process. It's like who?
- 25:40Who do we want to become citizens?
- 25:43I'm curious. And you know, you don't have to
- 25:45have the answer to this, but do you know of any other countries
- 25:47that don't follow this sort of format for citizenship?
- 25:50I mean, the US, we know there are tests.
- 25:52There's a civic test. I imagine there's a language
- 25:56test. Perhaps not, but there's still
- 25:58this issue of a written exam across the world.
- 26:02No, right? Well, when we hear in the US
- 26:04stories of how, you know, native born citizens can't pass the
- 26:09civics test there as well or don't know what percentage of
- 26:13Americans don't know who the vice president is.
- 26:15And it's this like shocking number.
- 26:18From what I know looking into the EU, they all have some kind
- 26:22of process. It varies in terms of how many
- 26:25years you have to live there. Some countries don't have
- 26:29language requirements. Some Scandinavian countries
- 26:32don't have language tests, for example.
- 26:35But France isn't the only place that in Europe that is making it
- 26:40harder. This is this reflects a Europe
- 26:42wide shift to the right in terms of politics.
- 26:47It's that we're seeing, you know, 1/4 of the European
- 26:50Parliament is now right wing, far right.
- 26:53So this is not a France only phenomenon we haven't talked
- 26:57that much about like the why behind.
- 27:00Well, and I do want to, I do want to get to that.
- 27:02Obviously it's politically motivated.
- 27:03But I have to say there is a point at which it is
- 27:07unacceptable to believe that if you are from a Western country,
- 27:13a prosperous Western country, and you have the means, yeah,
- 27:18you need to be able to pass a language test.
- 27:20You're not in a country where the dominant language is
- 27:22English. And I'm not, I'm not against
- 27:24these at all. I think it should be hard to
- 27:26become a citizen. It is a huge right?
- 27:28But you spend some time looking online and you see some, you
- 27:33know, particularly Americans, Brits who takes, you know,
- 27:37sincere issue with some of this and or, or, or think that, you
- 27:43know, time spent is sufficient. But again, it goes back to your
- 27:48question of integration. And are you just trying to live
- 27:51your, you know, American or British life with a French
- 27:54backdrop, or are you actually contributing in some way beyond
- 27:58having children? And, you know, and I think these
- 28:00are valid questions. However, it's also weaponized
- 28:04and, you know, used as a political tool.
- 28:06Right. It's how do you judge that
- 28:07though? And who is this going to harm
- 28:10and exclude? And is that by design?
- 28:14Is it by design that it's going to exclude people who are
- 28:18horror, who by and large are black or brown and maybe don't
- 28:26just don't have the same resources and tail as old as
- 28:29time that, you know, elite, the elite are going to have special
- 28:32privileges. But this goes back to what I
- 28:35said about what's the real goal. Is it having people who are
- 28:38integrated, people who love France and who are a part of the
- 28:42fabric of French society? Or is it about having people who
- 28:46can afford to study and pass all of these tests?
- 28:51And there are a lot of people and advocates who say these new
- 28:57restrictions, these new guidelines aren't working in
- 29:01service of making sure that people who are truly integrated
- 29:06are the ones that are becoming citizens and not just the people
- 29:09who have the resources to be able to check all the boxes.
- 29:14It's interesting because these measures were also part of Bruno
- 29:18Rotayos sort of swan song, right?
- 29:21He he was the interior minister last year.
- 29:24It's hard to keep up with all the interior minister.
- 29:27He was a protection minister. He was particularly on the more
- 29:31extreme side of Mack Holmes administration and that was his
- 29:38last act basically. And so here we are.
- 29:41And given the unknowns of the next 18 to 24 months, we're
- 29:45about to head into, in a month from now, we're heading into the
- 29:48municipal elections all over the country, which may or may not be
- 29:54an indicator of what's to come next year.
- 29:57Probably it will. People are sort of checked out
- 29:59though with the municipals, which is not a good thing.
- 30:01Local elections really do matter.
- 30:03But next year is the big test of where we're going as a country.
- 30:08And so all of this plays into that.
- 30:10Right. So no, right, IO he, like he
- 30:14said, responsible for the changes, but he said that these
- 30:16need to happen because French nationality should be earned and
- 30:19not merely granted, and that in the past the process has been
- 30:23too lenient. He said quote, one must be
- 30:26worthy of becoming being French, we must be very demanding.
- 30:30Except for George Clooney. Unless you're George Clooney, of
- 30:33course. But I mean, just to set the
- 30:35stage, most French people still support skilled migration
- 30:40programs, family reunification based on citizenship and
- 30:46immigration, and humanitarian protection for refugees,
- 30:49bringing people here as refugees or for asylum.
- 30:54And actually immigration rates here in France are low compared
- 30:57to a lot of our neighbors and other Western countries.
- 31:00Germany. Germany, Belgium even we take in
- 31:04a third percentage wise of what Belgium takes in Canada as well.
- 31:10And so it's really become a major political issue here.
- 31:14I mean, you look at the the National Front now the National
- 31:18Rally Party after its rebranding.
- 31:21Immigration has been at the core of its agenda since the 1980s
- 31:25when it was founded by Marine Le Penny's dad.
- 31:29But but there was really a turning point during the refugee
- 31:33crisis in 2015 when, you know, we saw the wars in in Syria and
- 31:39Afghanistan and Iraq. You know, it's sending hundreds
- 31:42of thousands of migrants to Europe and a lot of countries
- 31:45really struggling to deal with this influx of people.
- 31:49And it created a big like political moment for these right
- 31:54wing parties who capitalized on people's fears or anger,
- 32:01resources going towards helping these people and used it as a
- 32:05political message. But we see in some ways it's the
- 32:10same as what we see in the United States too.
- 32:12You know, there's been this rise of support for right wing
- 32:15parties who promote immigration as being dangerous or unwanted.
- 32:20There's been a creation of a right wing media ecosystem here
- 32:23in France that didn't used to exist as well that now pushes
- 32:27these messages. And there's been a rise in
- 32:30conspiracy theories as well, same as that we see in the US of
- 32:33invasions of migrants or replacement theory.
- 32:36And a lot of the messaging that you hear from far right parties
- 32:39is about quote, UN quote because you can't see my face, quote,
- 32:44keeping France for the French and this idea that we have to be
- 32:49really strict about who comes in and who gets to become French
- 32:53because otherwise there will be a loss of French identity.
- 32:58And so that's the message that the far right has really pushed.
- 33:02They're very consistent. I we can say that they're very
- 33:05consistent with their message and getting it out there.
- 33:08You mentioned the far right media landscape, which is
- 33:11probably within Europe, the most developed here as a as a
- 33:16parallel to what goes on in the USI would say France is probably
- 33:19the most ahead of the game in that way.
- 33:21And that's not for any reassuring reason.
- 33:24And we have a billionaire class that is also propping this up,
- 33:28Vincent Bourdois being the media conglomerate, the billionaire
- 33:33owner of C News and plenty of other right wing stations.
- 33:37And so this is our real fear moving forward is that we're
- 33:41going to have a scenario that isn't unlike what happened in
- 33:43the US. And, you know, we have
- 33:45colleagues, you and I, Cole Stangler, for example, who has
- 33:50written a book about this in French.
- 33:52You know, what happens when all signs point to a similar Trump
- 33:57like takeover, maybe not with a figure like that, but just to
- 34:00say we are not impervious to all of these ills.
- 34:07And in fact, we're probably ripe for this to actually happen.
- 34:12So when you're someone who's coming here and trying to get
- 34:15permanent residency and hope for citizenship, doing that with
- 34:19this in the background means hoping that they don't make it
- 34:24even more challenging. What's a pull?
- 34:26It's a way for politicians to signal to the French public,
- 34:32look, we're doing something about this.
- 34:35It's a lot easier to put in new language requirements for
- 34:38citizenship than it is to actually tackle A migration
- 34:42crisis. And.
- 34:44You know the. The roots of why this is
- 34:46happening. Or how about have an actual
- 34:50functional plan for integration? I think they love to assume.
- 34:55The administrations have loved to assume that just by being
- 34:59here and engaging in society that that is somehow a
- 35:02sufficient form that like no one else has to help foreigners
- 35:07integrate. But in fact, there's a lot left
- 35:10to your own right, so the your own will.
- 35:14The OFII, which is the French like immigration office that
- 35:19handles immigration like it was through them that I had to take
- 35:24my. I don't think you had to do
- 35:26this, but I had to take integration classes.
- 35:28When I first. Came here because I came on a on
- 35:31a marriage visa and yeah, I spent two days in classes
- 35:36talking of the first one was principally about French history
- 35:39and studying all the kings and everything.
- 35:41And then the second one was just about cultural values where they
- 35:45talk. It was a lot of emphasis.
- 35:46I remember Laicite because I had some issues with that.
- 35:51Well, it's the French. Version of separation of church
- 35:54and. Secularism.
- 35:55But it, it really means on paper, it's a nice ideal, which
- 35:59is that you're free to, you know, practice your beliefs at
- 36:02home in private, but in the public space and the public
- 36:06sector, you cannot the, the, the French state comes first.
- 36:11So you're. Not really nice on paper.
- 36:13In practice, it doesn't actually works here because it's a
- 36:17country with such strong Catholic roots.
- 36:21People don't always adhere to it or you see certain groups that
- 36:24are targeted to, you know, not be able to wear things at school
- 36:28or at work. Yeah, but I mean, there are
- 36:30there are laws that the law says that, you know, if you're in a
- 36:34public hospital or you are in a public school, you can't wear
- 36:37any overt religious signs. So in theory that would also
- 36:40apply to a giant cross or a keep up.
- 36:43However it is really it in practice feels like an attack on
- 36:47Islam. And that's in the.
- 36:50Because I'm learning this and then I'm seeing well, but wait,
- 36:53there's there's crush like nativity scenes being put up at
- 36:56the Mary or like, why is there a Christmas tree at my daughter's
- 37:01crush, then it which is run by the government at her nursery?
- 37:04I mean, fair questions, Charlie. So it just doesn't always
- 37:08compute. But anyway, so they there's a
- 37:10lot on Lycete, there was a lot on the importance of working in
- 37:14France. And then there was a lot on how
- 37:19you can't have multiple lives, you can't beat your wife, things
- 37:25like this. And some of it just felt
- 37:29targeted to certain at certain communities and people.
- 37:34So it was, it was an interesting introduction to the country
- 37:37because I had to take it pretty soon after I arrived.
- 37:40But anyway, so the OFII, they handle all of all of this.
- 37:44They have cut services for language tests as well.
- 37:48So it used to be that because you have to take language tests,
- 37:52they test you when you arrive to see what your what level you're
- 37:56at and then they will offer you classes to improve.
- 38:01And these used to be in person classes.
- 38:04Now they have taken these and turned it into a online learning
- 38:08platform except for people who literally speak no French, like
- 38:12cannot write or speak a word of French.
- 38:14Everyone else, it's now an online learning platform and not
- 38:17classes in person, which the OFII says, well, this works
- 38:22better for people who maybe don't live in a big city where
- 38:25so they don't have to travel to the classes.
- 38:28OK, for certain people, but also learning a language is really
- 38:31hard and without that in person practice.
- 38:34So they're at, they're raising the standards and how hard it is
- 38:39while at the same time cutting the resources to be able to
- 38:42reach those standards. So again, if you have time,
- 38:46money, the ability to dedicate resources to this goal, you're
- 38:52going to be able to do it. But if you don't, they're making
- 38:54it even harder to attain that. So what do you think?
- 38:59Listeners should feel OK, because I'm, I know from the
- 39:05emails I get from the discussions I have from friends
- 39:07of ours who live here who hope to eventually qualify for
- 39:12citizenship and go through that process, they might be scared
- 39:15stiff now. They might think, well, maybe
- 39:17it's not worth it. But I guess I'm, I'm, I'm
- 39:20wondering what is your, I don't know what is what, what would
- 39:25you hope listeners take away from this?
- 39:29That they just need to do some of their the the work or that
- 39:32they need to realize that the system is not going to be
- 39:36unfortunately the same for everybody.
- 39:39You know, I'm tempted as an American to, you know, you want
- 39:41to end on a happy note. But it is, I'm not going to lie,
- 39:45it's discouraging. And I in many ways feel like I
- 39:49got in under the wire because the civics part I wouldn't be
- 39:54worried about because I had to do that anyway from as part of
- 39:58my interview. I studied a lot for that.
- 40:01And from what I've heard just reading on Reddit and like what
- 40:04these exams are like, it doesn't look extremely, extremely hard
- 40:09if you do the work and study. But the language, I mean B2 it's
- 40:14it's high. And if you are coming here.
- 40:19Under certain circumstances, I mean, I came here in my 30s, did
- 40:23not speak French and I felt like it was, I worked for every verb
- 40:30conjugation. It's different coming here when
- 40:33you're, you know, 19 as a student or when you have more
- 40:37time, but you know, with two kids and a full time job.
- 40:40And it, it was a challenge for me to reach all of these, to go
- 40:45through this whole process and, and check all the boxes.
- 40:47And so it is discouraging for even our friends who have lived
- 40:52here for a long time and haven't gone through the process yet,
- 40:55that now it's become just that much harder.
- 40:59And for people, for listeners who are thinking like, Oh, well,
- 41:02I'd love to move to France and get away from the US or even
- 41:07just, you know, see their future here.
- 41:10Yeah. I think you're just going to the
- 41:12language. I think you're just going to
- 41:14really have to make a lot of effort.
- 41:17That's got to be your your primary focus, I think.
- 41:20Well, because it's not only the language test.
- 41:21You have to go through the interview entirely in.
- 41:23French, Yeah, I mean, you need to.
- 41:25All the paperwork is in French and so I had my husband to help
- 41:28me, which was a huge leg up. But you're still having to go
- 41:33through the whole process in French too, so it's not like you
- 41:35can just study to pass the test. You do have to really be able
- 41:39to. Communicate So what about for
- 41:40retirees who are of a certain age, there is a a little bit of
- 41:45a grace for. So not for nationality.
- 41:48For nationality even 65 or over, you have to pass the language
- 41:52test for the visa. For the 10 year visa or the
- 41:54shorter visas, they don't make senior citizens pass the test,
- 41:59and there's some other small exceptions for people coming on
- 42:05through the asylum process, but for citizenship everyone has to.
- 42:11So this is just what it means to live in a globalized world
- 42:17that's also trying to close in on itself in some ways.
- 42:20And the idea of protecting what it means or doesn't mean to be
- 42:24of a certain state or country. And the for the far right swing
- 42:31is still swinging and. Yeah.
- 42:34I mean we can hope that maybe based on the results and I mean
- 42:38it's it's been less than two months that these new standards
- 42:43have been put in place. We can hope OK, maybe if the
- 42:47result it's not turning out the way that is actually best for
- 42:51the Republic that they will change it or roll things back.
- 42:55But in my experience covering French politics, covering just
- 43:02the, you know, story of immigration, that doesn't often
- 43:06happen or any people roll things back once they're in place, it's
- 43:09really hard to turn, turn back the clock.
- 43:12And also, I remember when we were discussing you coming on
- 43:15the show, I had found an article from France 24, actually from
- 43:202011, saying the rules were going to get under.
- 43:23Sarkozy. Right under Sarkozy, so.
- 43:26This is. Part of a long process of the
- 43:32state evaluating their standards and the process and actually
- 43:37work. We've been talking about
- 43:38citizenship, but for undocumented people who are
- 43:41currently working and paying taxes in this country because
- 43:44hello, yes, undocumented people do pay into the system.
- 43:49It's getting harder and harder for them to get regularized.
- 43:52It's it's entirely possible that France will find out same way
- 43:56that many countries have that immigrants help the economy and
- 44:01that when you either make it harder for people to come here
- 44:06or to work here or to stay here, that it's going to hurt, hurt
- 44:12their economy. And this is a big reason why
- 44:14Germany allowed so many people in is because they realized we
- 44:19need more people here in Germany to work, to take on a lot of
- 44:23jobs that they're either aren't enough, you know, native born
- 44:27Germans to take or that they don't want to take or unwilling
- 44:31to take. And so it's possible that France
- 44:34will also see, oh, OK, this isn't working out for us and we
- 44:40need to make some changes. The way that the political tide
- 44:44is turning right now, I wouldn't bank on that.
- 44:47I wouldn't bet my money on that happening right away soon, But
- 44:51it is possible that that could happen.
- 44:54Well, Charlie, I have to say I'm glad we have another voter among
- 44:57us in this room. I'm going to vote for the first
- 45:00time and this is super exciting. You got, you know, next month
- 45:03you got 2 Sundays to devote to this.
- 45:06It's important. And I think the more people
- 45:10understand what being French, you know, does mean, it means
- 45:14also showing up. And you know, I think some of us
- 45:17newer citizens are more engaged than the people who were born
- 45:21into the system, obviously, who think nothing matters, Think we
- 45:25we can all agree based on both election cycles in recent in
- 45:30recent years between the US and France that showing up does
- 45:34matter. And if you care about what
- 45:36happens in either place, it's time to make your voice heard.
- 45:39So I'm glad you will get to make your voice heard.
- 45:42Well, if France has a bigger culture of showing up and going
- 45:45out in the streets and making noise against the government,
- 45:49that you're prepared to make noise.
- 45:51I mean, I go to that. I've been to lots of protests as
- 45:55a journalist. I do not protest on my own
- 46:00usually just because as a journalist I, I stay, try to
- 46:04stay a little more politically neutral.
- 46:06Of course, journalists, we all have our our own beliefs.
- 46:11But my role as a journalist for France 24, any of the outlets
- 46:16that I've that I've worked for is to cover the news, not
- 46:20necessarily be a part of the news.
- 46:22So that is how I contribute. While you've also contributed by
- 46:27illuminating this discussion, thank you for bringing so much
- 46:32clarity, enthusiasm, and and facts.
- 46:37Really. Thanks, Lindsay.
- 46:41That's the show for today. If you're listening on Spotify,
- 46:44be sure to check out the poll related to this episode by
- 46:47scrolling down in your app. There are more exciting
- 46:49conversations to come this season, so I hope you'll
- 46:52subscribe or share the show with a friend if you've been enjoying
- 46:55what you've heard so far. As always, you can find more
- 46:58from me at lindsaytrermuda.com and at the New Paris Dispatch on
- 47:02Sub Stack at Treinto.