Latest / Newcomer Pod / Beware the "Tech Industrial Complex"
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Eric Newcomer. And I am Madeline Rinbarger.
- 0:04And this is the newcomer podcast.
- 0:10Each week, Eric and I discuss the VC deals and the drama that
- 0:14went down. Let's do it.
- 0:16Here we go. This episode is presented by
- 0:19Breck's The Financial Stack that founders and VCs can truly bank
- 0:23On. Imagine what your founders could
- 0:25do with their runway if they had a banking solution that had no
- 0:29minimums, no transaction fees, and 20 times the standard FDIC
- 0:33protection. Plus they could earn an industry
- 0:36leading yield while maintaining access to funds whenever needed.
- 0:40Brex simplifies financial services for start-ups so they
- 0:43can focus on building. Connect your portfolio to the
- 0:46financial stack that one in three US venture backed
- 0:48start-ups already use. Check out brex.com/banking Dash
- 0:55solutions. Welcome back to the show.
- 0:58Lots happening in tech this week, although it feels like all
- 1:02of a sudden between the DealNews it just got completely switched
- 1:05around with the Biden announcement this week about the
- 1:08tech industrial. Comp yeah, it was like a drive
- 1:11by shooting presidential address.
- 1:14You know, all of a sudden we have plenty of going on in
- 1:16Silicon Valley and then the administration is like, Oh yeah,
- 1:19the my Eisenhower style warning about what's going on in America
- 1:23is about the oligarchs in the tech industry and the techno
- 1:26industrial complex. I mean, it's, it's crazy to hear
- 1:30when if you think about like, you know, Eisenhower warning
- 1:32about the military industrial complex and that's, you know, a
- 1:35thing of history books. And so now we're watching.
- 1:37It's like, wow, is, is tech this bad?
- 1:40What? What was your reaction?
- 1:42I mean, yeah, it's it's interesting too, also because of
- 1:45tech's, you know, increasing involvement within defense
- 1:48world. But that's an aside for another
- 1:49day. I would say my initial reaction
- 1:52was it was quite peculiar. I mean, partially, I have to
- 1:57think that some degree, you know, the tech people, a lot of
- 2:01tech leaders coming out and either endorsing Donald Trump or
- 2:05remaining silent in this election when they had
- 2:07historically been larger Democratic donors, or at least
- 2:10that was the public perception maybe played a part in this.
- 2:13It felt maybe a little personal on a couple accounts but I feel
- 2:17like. Really easy.
- 2:19Easy to be wary of the tech industrial complex when, you
- 2:23know, Elon Musk opening up his pocketbook might have lost you
- 2:27the election, right? I mean, it's very personal to
- 2:30Biden in that this the tech set did a lot to, you know, I mean,
- 2:36Elon was literally what, paying for the Trump ground game.
- 2:39So clearly it was very personal to the election.
- 2:43It feels personal and it also feels like a shift in the
- 2:48attitude of government towards the tech sector.
- 2:50I mean, we hear it newcomer, very pro tech, pro innovation.
- 2:54It seems historically like that's one of the end all be
- 2:57alls of why people come to America and American identity
- 3:00and valleys, right And. Wow.
- 3:01The real. Texas girls coming out over
- 3:03here. I know my my individualism
- 3:07programming. Just immediately shot to the.
- 3:09Front for this one, but seriously doesn't like a shift
- 3:13in how the government is approaching tech, or at least
- 3:16one side of the government, before a new party takes control
- 3:20of the White House. Right.
- 3:21Yeah. I mean, you know, I'm on both
- 3:23sides of this. On the one hand, right after the
- 3:26election, I said, you know, I didn't vote for Trump.
- 3:29I think it's going to be a disaster.
- 3:31But the best possible outcome is that tech gets its talons in
- 3:36Trump world. I still think that's true.
- 3:39Like I think to me, tech sort of a tech administration is the
- 3:44best case scenario. Everyone wants their friends in
- 3:48tech in. The right exactly right their.
- 3:50Enemies in tech they don't want in the administration.
- 3:52Right. But I mean, I just think the
- 3:54general tech ideology of inevitably it's about sort of
- 3:58growth, pro GDP, sort of loose regulation on tech, sort of very
- 4:04free market. Like that's better to me than,
- 4:07you know, the sort of nationalist version of Trump
- 4:13that's all about sort of rounding up immigrants and
- 4:16tariffs. Like that's clearly sort of in
- 4:19contrast to the tech version. And then, you know, we could
- 4:22have sort of a neo con administration out of nowhere.
- 4:25That would be worse to me too. So if if if the options are sort
- 4:29of extreme tech favored capitalism, sort of nationalism
- 4:35and protectionism or a return to neoconservative Republicans, I
- 4:41would pick the tech set. That's still true.
- 4:45Absolutely. Well, if you're picking out of
- 4:46those three, that's easily. That's the path.
- 4:49Those are the paths, right? Am I missing one or like?
- 4:51No, not at all. And our government's about to
- 4:54get a lot more efficient seems too.
- 4:55So in some ways, when talking this week to people over at JPM
- 5:00Healthcare, I meant a lot of people mentioned that the new
- 5:04regulatory environment could really be favorable in part for
- 5:07biotech development, health development.
- 5:09And that's one thing that this new government set has really
- 5:12set out to cut back a lot of red tape within a lot of federal
- 5:15agencies, which no doubt would be helpful for innovation in
- 5:17these sectors. I mean, the, the oligarchs idea,
- 5:20I am deeply troubled by the idea.
- 5:22You know, Trump's putting, what, Jeff Bezos, Mark Zuckerberg,
- 5:26Elon Musk on stage with him as if they're like cabinet members.
- 5:31I don't like the sort of pay for play that's been.
- 5:33Happening. Around this, you know, that's
- 5:35one part that I will say like it does seem like a lot of these
- 5:38tech people have been really quick to go ahead and I won't
- 5:43say kiss the ring. You know, that's literally what
- 5:45it feels like. Yeah, donate right ahead of
- 5:48inauguration, like signaling with their money, hey, we're
- 5:51going to be your friend. Which to me feels like a little
- 5:54bit more ominous. And, you know, ominous, the
- 5:56inauguration donating obviously is always a thing.
- 5:59I think what's more troubling is because it's like they're going
- 6:02to mar a Lago. It feels like very like, yeah, I
- 6:05mean, it's kiss the ring. It feels very sort of mobster
- 6:08esque, which is you have to sort of pay your, do not pay your
- 6:12dues. You have to sort of, you know,
- 6:14yeah, you just have to kiss up to the leader, pay your yeah,
- 6:17you have to pay your respects to the great leader.
- 6:20And it feels like sort of proximity to him personally.
- 6:23I mean, semaphore basically had a piece saying, you know, it
- 6:26used to be we'd track all the, you know, business, money and
- 6:29politics, like looking, reading the tea leaves.
- 6:32And now it's the opposite where everybody's just like, yeah,
- 6:34obviously I'm kissing up to Trump.
- 6:37That's that's the name of the game.
- 6:38And then you pair that, you know, Ezra Klein's podcast just
- 6:43did something about how the Republican Party has moved from
- 6:46being, you know, an ideas type party or a party really ruled by
- 6:52a shared coalition of people trying to get some policy agenda
- 6:55to a personal party, one run by Trump and where it's really
- 6:59about that guy. And so I think tech has been
- 7:03uncomfortable. It's become a cult of
- 7:04personality. In some ways, tech's caught on.
- 7:07They're like fine, Yeah, all right, I want.
- 7:10What we'll do is. Amazon to be the most important
- 7:12company. And if it's not me, it's going
- 7:14to be Zuck. And so we're all going to kiss
- 7:16the ring. It's, you know, classic sort of
- 7:18collection action problem. And that's that's how we get
- 7:20sort of, yeah, the destruction of democratic norms.
- 7:23So to that degree, I agree 100% with Biden that they're
- 7:27oligarchs. That's terrifying.
- 7:30But then he just he sorry, I just lost my ran.
- 7:34I mean, he he's hitting on he's attacking profits, which is a
- 7:37classical classic, like caricature of Democrats.
- 7:39Like profits are the worst thing in the world when it's like
- 7:42profits reflect businesses successfully delivering things
- 7:45people want. And then he just like throws AI
- 7:48and it like he's shitting on AI and worried about that and
- 7:52social media, it's just like a kitchen.
- 7:53It felt very haphazard. It was sort of like a take
- 7:56choose your own adventure of grievances.
- 7:59Right, right. He doesn't seem the sharpest.
- 8:02You know, it's not necessarily that.
- 8:04Yeah, it feels an airtight argument.
- 8:07I think we can note where there are some causes for concern and
- 8:10also view the concept of the tech industrial complex being
- 8:14portrayed as much of A boogeyman as the military industrial
- 8:17complex was, is to be somewhat of a false comparison.
- 8:21Right well, to be an extreme Silicon Valley booster, the key
- 8:24element of Silicon Valley is that you know, it encourages new
- 8:28entrants. So it's it's there, you know
- 8:30there's a power center and certainly there are these VCs
- 8:33that stay in the mix and are power brokers.
- 8:36But it is like really searching for the next person with a great
- 8:38idea to thrust into the heart of everything, right?
- 8:42If you think of the new hot company, is is always like the
- 8:45most important piece of it. The problem with the defense
- 8:48industrial complex is that it was a lot like the government.
- 8:51There's a lot of protectionism. It's slow.
- 8:53It's sort of X extracting things against American interests where
- 8:57Silicon Valley is really a machine of people trying to say
- 9:01who's got the best new thing. Let's immediately pump them to
- 9:04the center of all our money and the culture.
- 9:07And so, yeah, I guess I'm just saying Silicon Valley is good in
- 9:11a way that the defense complex isn't.
- 9:15Counterpoint to you, Eric, how would you feel about the startup
- 9:18part of Silicon Valley versus the big tech part of Silicon
- 9:20Valley? Because it seems like also a lot
- 9:22of these fights have been picked with, you know, the Googles and
- 9:24the Microsoft's of the world rather than the innovation
- 9:26economy. I mean, people in the
- 9:29administration were, you know, this is much more active
- 9:32antitrust administration. We'll see what happens, but
- 9:34it'll probably let less so in the future, and there'll be more
- 9:36exits. But, you know, Gary Tan spoke
- 9:39pretty highly of Lena Khan over at YC because, you know, it
- 9:43leads to antitrust enforcement, leads to more little tech
- 9:46flourishing. Right.
- 9:47I mean, big tech is very company specific.
- 9:51Google, Microsoft, backbone of America represents everything
- 9:56great about what we're doing. Amazon pretty good, important to
- 10:01the, you know, logistics and getting us everything.
- 10:05Facebook somewhat soulless. I don't know.
- 10:08I'm never going to be able to book anybody from them if I say
- 10:11that. But no, I mean, you know, not
- 10:14the medic guest. Come back, Mama is good.
- 10:16But I just have to say, like, I mean, you even look at like the
- 10:20Facebook product. It's just like shameless, you
- 10:22know, I I just don't. And then Mark Zuckerberg went on
- 10:25Joe Rogan and he's shitting on Apple for never coming up with a
- 10:28new idea. It's like Apple delivers me the
- 10:31best device, best thing I hold built by anyone to date, whereas
- 10:36Mark Zuckerberg is like taking advantage of the fact that I
- 10:39look at Facebook every once in a while to, like, put a bunch of
- 10:42shit in front of me. Yeah, I, I I just think, yeah, I
- 10:46don't know. Zuck is not the bastion of
- 10:48principles. He's the most opportunistic here
- 10:50and just sucking up to Trump every couple years.
- 10:53It's like I'm going to totally reinvent myself.
- 10:56Yeah. So company specific views of of
- 10:59the big tech ones here. The the last thing I'll say is,
- 11:02you know, I we always want to cover politics less and they
- 11:05keep dragging us back in. I think if Kamala had won, we'd
- 11:08gotten away with it. But we will be keeping you up to
- 11:12date just. When we thought we were out.
- 11:15We will be keeping you up to date on your favorite oligarchs
- 11:20malevolence, so stay tuned. Moving on, Eric, you had this
- 11:26great story of the behind the scenes of the bench fall and
- 11:29return. Eric, what even is bench?
- 11:32What is this Canadian company you fell into?
- 11:36Yeah, not a company I'd heard of a month ago.
- 11:40You know the companies? Old founder Ian Crosby basically
- 11:44after bench went kaput, tweeted out the story of how the board
- 11:49removed him and basically said I hope this is a lesson to all
- 11:52VC's not to remove your founders.
- 11:55It's only going to be a disaster and something every VC wants to
- 11:58be on board with. So you saw a lot of people being
- 12:01like who did this to you? And like Amjad Mossad at Replit
- 12:05was like, these are the VC's never to take money from and
- 12:08just very simple, satisfying narrative that people want to
- 12:13see play out on Twitter. And I, you know, played my small
- 12:16part tweeting out pitch book with the list of board members.
- 12:20And that got people being like, oh, you know, I wasn't even on
- 12:23the board then. And so then.
- 12:25Oh no, you. You were a factor in the witch
- 12:27hunt. Era right, exactly.
- 12:28So then it's like all right, let's what actually happened
- 12:31here? Was this as simple a story?
- 12:33And you know it wasn't. What did you find in your
- 12:36reporting? I mean, people should go read
- 12:38the story on newcomer.co to get the full picture, but what
- 12:42what's your biggest take away around the merits of being
- 12:44founder friendly or not? And what happened with Bench?
- 12:47You know, Bench was a substantial company, about 35
- 12:50million in revenue doing an accounting business.
- 12:53You know, they basically figured out how to do it, a services
- 12:55heavy business pretty well, you know, using some technology.
- 13:00Then they raised a substantial Series C at the peak, you know,
- 13:04in 2021, 30 million in equity and like 30 million in debt.
- 13:08And then they spent a lot of it, Ian Crosby spent a lot of it
- 13:12trying to build like a banking business and new ideas, not a
- 13:15lot of it seemingly to make the core bookkeeping business more
- 13:20scalable. And so all of a sudden, the
- 13:21business is losing a lot of money on products that it hasn't
- 13:25even launched without necessarily a plan for how
- 13:28they're going to raise more money that they might need
- 13:30eventually. And so that freaked out the
- 13:33board. You know, the board sort of
- 13:35pushed him out. And then at the same time, his
- 13:38executives sent a letter to the board sort of complaining about
- 13:41him and asking for an investigation into him.
- 13:44So it was just sort of the perfect storm of, you know,
- 13:48classic perfect. Storm and almost and almost pile
- 13:51on, if you will, to the founder. Here these stories are always
- 13:54more complicated than could be boiled down on Twitter, but yeah
- 13:58I mean, I think it's an open question I mean you read the
- 14:00story do you did you come away pro founder or yeah what was
- 14:04your point of view I'm. Going to take the case for being
- 14:07founder friendly on this one, because we know what happened to
- 14:09bench after they pushed the founder out, right?
- 14:12It basically collapsed and they had a willing buyer, but it was
- 14:16not the exit that VCs dream of. So that's I'm going to put stake
- 14:20my claim here for that case that being founder friendly and to
- 14:24go, you know, to focus on sort of a very pro founder posture in
- 14:28this case actually made a difference, made a difference in
- 14:33the future of this company. The fact that they did not do
- 14:35this. Yeah, I don't know.
- 14:37In your own reporting, you can take another stance.
- 14:40I mean, replacing the founder always has this sort of anything
- 14:44could be the alternative world and then often it's terrible.
- 14:49I think the key thing is if you are a founder that wants to stay
- 14:53at your company, generate profits or at least grow revenue
- 14:58substantially and improve profit margins, you know, like at the
- 15:02end of the day, like board will put up with bad behavior if
- 15:05you're delivering like business results.
- 15:07But if they're you're angering your executives, your strategy
- 15:12seems sort of wild and you're not your core business isn't
- 15:16throwing off a bunch of money, then you know, you don't have
- 15:19anything like revenue, revenue growth, profits.
- 15:23Those are the things that 'cause people to ignore questionable
- 15:27sort of behavior and sort of people who piss people off.
- 15:30If you don't have those things, all of a sudden it's like you
- 15:33should be a nicer person to these executives.
- 15:35And that's, that's sort of my view.
- 15:37It's like, sure you can like, you know, the, you know, the
- 15:39Uber is my sort of case study. And it's just like, man, you
- 15:43burned so much money and then you didn't let your early
- 15:47investors really take a lot of money off the table.
- 15:50If you just let, you know, Benchmark, just sell their stake
- 15:53and walk away, then maybe you don't have the mutiny anyway.
- 15:56So these investors? Are I see your point here?
- 15:58I see your point here. Yeah, strong, strong opinions
- 16:02loosely held on my part. I'm, I'm always generally pro
- 16:04founder. But when like you, to your
- 16:06point, if the actual core part of the business is no longer
- 16:09functioning, what are investors supposed to do at that point or
- 16:13not function? The actual core part of the
- 16:14business is off the path and you don't see the revenue that you'd
- 16:18want and you don't see the profits that you want because
- 16:20you're working on these other projects.
- 16:22That to me seems like a point where it makes sense that people
- 16:25would want to intervene, because if you're not landing on what
- 16:28you've promised to do, how that path may not be the way that the
- 16:31business should be going. But if I want to flip this side,
- 16:34it's like the founder gets sort of these intangible things about
- 16:38the business. They have a really visceral
- 16:40sense of what they're good at and what the business is capable
- 16:44of. And so they can steer it towards
- 16:47new ideas and sort of things that are going to deliver sort
- 16:50of a level of creativity that a traditional business wouldn't.
- 16:54And that's what you're betting on with a startup.
- 16:56And if you get rid of the founder, you're sort of just
- 16:59going to be a regular company. And so you're never going to
- 17:01deliver sort of the exceptional returns the venture capitalists
- 17:06want. So we can both see both sides of
- 17:08it and like I. I It's a nuanced position.
- 17:12And it's funny with this specific one, I mean, I will
- 17:14say, like, I mean, clearly that Crosby brought in executive
- 17:18coaches to try to improve the relationship with executives in
- 17:23some ways. And that was a negative
- 17:26experience, you know, that it went poorly.
- 17:28And so it's like if that had gone well, you know, there are
- 17:31there are things where it's like if they could have found a way
- 17:33to to sort of improve that, you know, there are little things.
- 17:37And and, you know, even some of the executives that I talked to
- 17:40sign the letter regret that he was sort of like totally ousted
- 17:44from the company. You know, it might have been the
- 17:46kind of thing where it's like bringing Aceo who can make it
- 17:49seem a little more normal or bring in a new CEO, but you're
- 17:53the chair and you're still the visionary.
- 17:55And also like this this guy, a lot of people praise him Ian,
- 17:59for being like a visionary, you know, And so in some ways it's
- 18:03very natural that the visionary CEO plays more of a chair role.
- 18:08So, you know, I it really seems like they should have navigated
- 18:12to that and this letter maybe it.
- 18:14Seems like there were to jump in.
- 18:16It seems like there were avenues that they could have taken that
- 18:18weren't entirely just 0 sum ousting the the the founder of
- 18:22the company from the company. He didn't have to keep leading
- 18:25the company, but they made the call to fully remove him in a
- 18:28way that led to a lot of spite and animosity and ultimately
- 18:31seemed to be not productive. But if you get this intense
- 18:34letter from executives, you already sort of want the guy to
- 18:37go and you're going to have to do in a complicated
- 18:40investigation where you might, you know, I then you're like,
- 18:44whatever, like let's let's manage this guy out.
- 18:48I know. So it's it's a tough it's a
- 18:51tough one. I have a lot of empathy for
- 18:53everybody around employer.com, you know, is scooping up the
- 18:57remnants and I think they're going to be potentially buzzy
- 19:00with a number of acquisitions. I also think sort of sadly for
- 19:06Bench, there's this trend now, which is like service heavy
- 19:10businesses can be sort of smoothed out with AI.
- 19:14And so I think investors are actually somewhat excited about
- 19:17things like bookkeeping at the moment because you can throw
- 19:20language models at them to try and really extend bookkeepers
- 19:23across a lot of customers, which is what Bench was trying to do.
- 19:27So it is sort of the classic, maybe, you know, wrong time,
- 19:30right idea. And then Crosby, you know, he's
- 19:33at Mercury. He's actually working as part
- 19:36of, you know, a banking startup on accounting.
- 19:38So he sold his company to Mercury.
- 19:40So it's always he's doing what he wanted.
- 19:43So I just feel bad for the he's. Doing what he set out to do
- 19:46right yeah I just you know I feel bad for the employees that
- 19:49get sort of caught up in this right that we're working on this
- 19:52mission and don't have as clean of an exit as maybe the founders
- 19:55or executives will out of this right moving on from 1 startups
- 19:59lows we can move to another startups highs with our deal of
- 20:02the week with rush capital coming in any sphere the makers
- 20:07of cursor the popular coding assistant that's powered by
- 20:11generative AI raised 100 and. 5 million in new funding Co led by
- 20:15Thrive Capital and A16Z and Benchmark additionally
- 20:19participated in the round as well.
- 20:21A really big round for what won our newcomer Superlative for
- 20:25Product of the Year, right? Yeah, No, no bigger honor.
- 20:30No, the buzziest. You're actually building.
- 20:32Buzziest product in Silicon Valley right now?
- 20:35Probably that in granola. AI have got to be two of the
- 20:38buzziest AI products at the moment.
- 20:41But as we've covered in the newsletter, coding assistants
- 20:44had a really big wave earlier last year with a lot of VC sort
- 20:48of staking their claim into which ones that they thought
- 20:51were going to be the Microsoft Copilot upender Cursor seems to
- 20:55be in the lead right now just based on user chatter and based
- 20:58on venture interest. But we will see.
- 21:01There's always room for more entrance in the space.
- 21:03It's pretty, it's pretty saturated.
- 21:05And leads, as we've seen in this AI era, can have the lead and
- 21:09then be immediately usurped by a new up and Comer.
- 21:12It's, it's hard to be at the top for very long.
- 21:14Everyone's always nipping at your heels a little bit.
- 21:16So congratulations to any sphere for the funding.
- 21:21There's a subplot in that Anthropic, I think Cursor is
- 21:25like running through Anthropic. So like it's great business for
- 21:28Anthropic too. And it'll be interesting to see
- 21:31who really benefits more. Is it like Anthropic sort of
- 21:34genius, or is it Cursor's product that's more valuable and
- 21:39that that'll play out over time? Well, that's our show.
- 21:42We covered everything from politics to startup failures to
- 21:46startup wins. It's all of Silicon Valley in
- 21:49one episode. Run the gamut.
- 21:51All right. See you guys next week.